scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig) [lt] [de] [fr] [it] [es] [pt]

Disappearance of the auxiliary verb esti in the Lithuanian passive

Abstract

The prototypical passive voice in Lithuanian is an analytical construction consisting of a passive past participle and the auxiliary verb būti ‘to be’. Nowadays, the conjugation of this verb in the present tense is regular, except for the suppletive form of the third person yra, an East Baltic innovation, and historically, its original form was esti. Although the development and uses of the verb yra are well described, its development as a passive auxiliary verb has not received enough attention. The paper aims to trace the disappearance of the form esti from the function of an auxiliary verb in the passive constructions based on Old Lithuanian texts from 1547–1816, represented by prints from three historical dialects of Lithuanian.

Read accessible full text

Disappearance of the auxiliary verb esti in the Lithuanian passive

Author: Paweł Brudzyński
Year: 2024
DOI: 10.35321/all91-05
Source: https://journals.lki.lt/actalinguisticalithuanica/article/download/2356/2426
 S aipsniai / A icles 117
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
Uni e si yo Wa saw
ORCIDid:o cid.o g/0000-0002-1850-0818
Fieldso  esea ch:His o yo Bal iclanguages,mo phology,
syn ax,seman ics, oice,modali y.
DOI:doi.o g/10.35321/all91-05
DISAPPEARANCEOFTHE
AUXILIARYVERBESTIINTHE
LITHUANIANPASSIVE
Pagalbinio eiksmažodžioes i išnykimasiš
lie u iųkalbosne eikiamosios ūšies
ANNOTATION
Thep o o ypicalpassi e oiceinLi huanianisananaly icalcons uc ionconsis ingo a
passi epas pa icipleand heauxilia y e bbū i‘ obe’.Nowadays, heconjuga iono  his
e bin hep esen  enseis egula ,excep  o  hesupple i e o mo  he hi dpe sony a,an
Eas Bal icinno a ion,andhis o ically,i so iginal o mwases i.Al hough hede elopmen 
anduseso  he e by aa ewelldesc ibed,i sde elopmen asapassi eauxilia y e bhas
no  ecei edenougha en ion.Thepape aims o ace hedisappea anceo  he o mes i
om he unc iono anauxilia y e bin hepassi econs uc ionsbasedonOldLi huanian
ex s om1547–1816, ep esen edbyp in s om h eehis o icaldialec so Li huanian.
 KEYWORDS:Li huanian (language), diach ony, passi e, pa iciple, auxilia y
e b.
ANOTACIJA
Lie u iųkalbosne eikiamosios ūšiesp o o ipasy aanali inėkons ukcija,suda y aiš
ne eikiamosios ūšiesbū ojolaikodaly ioi pagalbinio eiksmažodžiobū i.Daba inėje
lie u iųkalboješio eiksmažodžioesamojolaikoasmena imasy a aisyklingas,išsky us
suple y inę3-iojoasmens o mąy a,ku i– y ųbal ųkalbųino acija,ois o iškaipi minė
josbu usi o ma– es i.No s eiksmažodžioy a aidai  a osenage aiap ašy a,jo,kaip
ne eikiamosios ūšies pagalbinio eiksmažodžio, aidai ski a nepakankamai dėmesio.
S aipsnio ikslas– emian is1547–1816me ųsenosioslie u iųkalbos eks ais,ku iuos
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
118 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
ep ezen uoja ijų is o inių lie u ių kalbos a mių spaudiniai, a sek i o mos es i, kaip
a liekančiospagalbinio eiksmažodžio unkciją,išnykimąne eikiamosiosekons ukcijose.
 ESMINIAIŽODŽIAI:lie u ių kalba, diach onija, ne eikiamoji nuosaka, daly is,
pagalbinis eksmažodis.
1. INTRODUCTION
In o mula inguni e sals ela ed o hena u eo  hepassi e,onemus be
ca e ulbecausei maydi e ins uc u eand unc ion omlanguage olanguage
(Siewie ska1984;Shiba ani1985;Geniušienė2016).O cou se,i ispossible
oiden i yse e alcommon ea u escons i u ing hecanonicalpassi e oice
inEu opeanlanguages(Hol oe 2001:366).Howe e ,i isno easy o ind
uni e sals ha a ecommon oalllanguages.Theconcep o  hepassi e oice
i sel isusuallyassocia edwi hi sp o o ypical,pe sonaluse(Siewie ska1984:
28),whe e hesen encehasaco espondingcons uc ionin heac i e oice,i 
ispossible ode e mine hesubjec and hesubjec o  hepassi econs uc ion
co esponds o hepa ien o  heac i econs uc ion.Howe e ,in hispape , he
passi eisunde s oodb oadlyas heso-calledpassi e amily(Naue al.2020),
i.e.,se e aldi e en p edica i econs uc ionswi hapassi epa iciple,which
canbeg oupedbasedon o maland unc ionalpa ame e s,includingpe sonal,
impe sonal, ac ional, esul a i e o  modal cons uc ions. The p o o ypical
passi e oiceinLi huanianisananaly icalcons uc ionconsis ingo aso-called
passi epas pa iciple( -pa iciple)o passi ep esen pa iciple(m-pa iciple)
and heauxilia y e bbū i‘ obe’.Nowadays, heconjuga iono  his e bin he
p esen  enseis egula ,excep  o  hesupple i e o mo  he hi dpe sony a,
anEas Bal icinno a ion,andhis o ically,i so iginal o mwases i.
Thehis o yo  henew,supple i e o mhasbeenex ensi elydocumen ed
(S ang1947:1970;Fo d1967;Os owski2017a;2017b;2021).The e bes i,
o iginallyanexis en ial e b,was eplacedby he e by aandnowse esonly
ahabi ual unc ion,simila  o he o mbūna‘usuallyis’(Genialiausios min ys
es i pap asčiausios.‘Themos geniusideasusuallya e hesimples ones.’).The
o iginal o mo y ashouldbe econs uc edas*ī- -,asindica edby heOld
Bal icanddialec al o ms(Endzelin1922:556;Os owski2017b:167;2021
66–67).E ymologically,i isa o ma ionbasedon hes emo  heanapho ic
p onouni-( obep eciseins .sg.*h₁i-h₁),and woloca i epos posi ions- and
*-.Ini ially,i wasalocal e b,which henacqui edanexis en ialmeaning
(as e idenced by ex s om he 16 h and 17 h cen u ies). This de elopmen 
pa halignswi h he ypological da a on he ela ionshipbe ween loca ional
 S aipsniai / A icles 119
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
andexis en ialsen ences(Lyons1967:390–396;Cla k1978:85–126;Yong,
Jie2013;Os owski2017b:168;2021:67).
While hee olu ionanduseso  he e by aha ebeenex ensi elydocumen ed,
i se olu ionasapassi eauxilia y e bhasbeena ela i elyunexplo eda ea.
Thiss udy ills hisgapbyme iculously acing hedisappea anceo  he o m
es i om he oleo anauxilia y e binpassi econs uc ions.The esea chis
basedonOldLi huanian ex s om1547–1816,which ep esen  h eehis o ical
dialec so Li huanian.Thepape willdel ein o equencyda a,examining
hedis ibu iono indi idual o mso  he hi dpe sono  he e bbū i‘ o
be’incombina ionwi hpassi epa iciples.Thiscomp ehensi eanalysisaims
op esen ade aileduseo  hesecons uc ionsand,c ucially, oexplain he
anishingo  he o mes iin heauxilia y unc ion.
2. METHODOLOGY
The esul s p esen ed in he pape  we e based on a co pus c ea ed o 
hes udy,consis ingo OldLi huanian ex s om he e i o ieso  a ious
his o icaldialec so  heLi huanianlanguageandw i eno e almos 300yea s.
The ex swe eselec edbasedon hepublica ionso ZigmasZinke ičius(1987;
1988;1990;1998)as hemos  ep esen a i emonumen so  heOldLi huanian
language.Zinke ičiusw i esabou  h eehis o icaldialec s: heWes e ndialec 
used on he e i o y o  P ussia and dialec s spoken in he e i o y o  he
G andDuchyo Li huania(li h.Lie u os Didžioji Kunigaikš ys ė (LDK))– he
Cen aland heEas e n.1Thepe iodinwhich hesedialec scanbesaid oha e
exis edlas edapp oxima elyun il heendo  he17 hcen u y.Inaddi ion o
ex s om hispe iod,somela e  ex sha ealsobeenincluded.E en hough
i isakindo anach onism, o  hes udy, hese ansla ionswe eincludedin
hedialec smen ionedabo e,basedon heo igino  heau ho s,and he e o e
asana u alwayo de eloping helanguage heyused.Thissimpli ica ionwas
in ended o acili a e hedesc ip ionandcompa isono  ex sand, hus, o ace
hede elopmen o  hes udiedcons uc ion.The ablebelowshows hesizes
o indi idual ex s
1
Fulllis o w i ingsisa achedin heabb e ia ionsec ion.
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
120 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE1:co pussize
DIALECT TEXT Wo d by ex Wo d by dialec To al
P ussian
(wes )
1547MžK 7297
411255
(650170wi h
Quand ’sNT)
2398569
1573WP 183894
1579VE 40224
1579BB 166975
1612ZE 12865
1727KNT 238915
LDK
(cen al)
1599DP 419036
1222710
(1654968wi h
Bi ne is’and
Gied ai is’NT)
1660MP 201170
1653KN 171861
1660ChB 430643
1701B NT 228586
1816GNT 203672
LDK (eas ) 1644ŠPS 68982 93431
1647JE 24449
Ascanbeseen, henumbe o  ex s omindi idualdialec sisno uni o m.
Themaingoalinc ea ing heco puswas odi e si y ex sso ha  he esul s
ob ainedwe eas eliableaspossibleand oexcludepossibleindi iduallinguis ic
cha ac e is icso au ho s.Theonly ex  om he19 hcen u y ep esen s he
Cen al a ian because heg ea es di e si ydis inguished hisdialec du ing
he s udy. The las  p oblem conce ns he ep esen a ion o  ex s om he
Eas e ndialec .Thisisbecause,asZinke ičiuss a es(1998:252–255), his
dialec is heleas  ep esen edandde eloped.Fo  his eason,al hough he
da a ombo h ex sp o idein e es ingin o ma ion, heya e heleas  eliable
andimpo an  o  hes udy.Toelimina esigni ican nume icaldisc epancies
u he ,pe cen ageda awillalsobep esen edin heanalysisinaddi ion o
numbe s.
To indin heco pusdesc ibedin hepape cons uc ions,a o mulawas
usedconsis ingo :
1) hi d-pe sonauxilia y e by ao es i;
2)endingso  henomina i esingula andplu al o bo hgende s:
a.pas passi epa iciples( -pa iciple),
b.p esen passi epa iciples(m-pa iciple).
In heo y, heauxilia y e bcombinedwi h hepassi epa icipleis he
basiso  hepassi e.All o mulas ookin oaccoun  heo hog aphyusedby he
 S aipsniai / A icles 121
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
au ho sand he ac  ha  heauxilia y e bcouldbeinbo hpos posi ionand
p eposi ion o hepa iciples.Un o una ely, he esul sdono conside  o ms
whe e heauxilia y e bcouldbeina u he posi ion ela i e o hepa iciple.
Theob ained esul swe e henmanually il e ed:
TABLE2:Dis ibu iono auxilia iesinpassi econs uc ions
Pa iciple m-pa iciple -pa iciple
Auxilia y y a es i y a es i
o al 232 314 2251 210
546 2461
Ascanbeseen, he esul s o indi idualcons uc ionsdi e signi ican ly.
Cons uc ionswi h -pa iciplesdomina e,bu  hedis ibu iono  heauxilia y
e bincons uc ionswi hm-pa iciplesa ac smo ea en ion.The ollowing
sec ionswilldiscussade ailedanalysiso indi idualauxilia iesin hepassi e.
3. ANALYSIS
The ablesbelowp esen nume icalda aon hedis ibu iono y aandes i.
Table 3 shows he absolu e alues o  he occu ence o  indi idual e bs in
combina ionwi hm-pa icipleand -pa iciple.Theseda aa eg oupedin o
la ge en i iesacco ding o hecen u yanddialec  hey ep esen .Table4shows
hesameda aexp essedasape cen age alue.
TABLE3:To alnumbe o auxilia iesbydialec
DIALECT Cen u-
y
m-pa iciple -pa iciple
y a es y a es
P ussian
(Wes e n)
XVI 38 139 437 55 492
XVII 0 0 0 11 011
XVIII 45 0 45 243 3 246
LDK (Cen al)
XVI 58 15 73 559 32 591
XVII 8 263 271 490 67 557
XVIII 41 34 75 216 46 262
XIX 42 143 295 2 297
LDK (Eas e n) XVII 0 0 0 0 5 5

PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
122 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 4:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple -pa iciple
y a es =y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
XVI 97 3 100 89 11 100
XVII 0 0 0 100 0 100
XVIII 100 0 100 99 1100
LDK
(Cen al)
XVI 79 21 100 95 5 100
XVII 3 97 100 88 12 100
XVIII 55 45 100 82 18 100
XIX 98 2 100 99 1100
LDK (Eas e n) XVII 0 0 0 0 100 100
Alownumbe o occu enceso examples om heEas e ndialec o  he
G andDuchyo Li huaniawillbediscussedin henex sec ion.Howe e , o 
ob ious easons, heya e oos a is icallyinsigni ican .Thegene alpic u e ha 
mayeme ge om heabo eda asugges s ha es iasanauxilia ywasused
ma ginallyal eadyin he imeso  he i s w i en ex s,especiallyin hecase
o  hepassi ewi h he -pa iciple.Howe e ,adeepe analysiso indi idual
ex smayshowin e es ing ela ionshipsbe weenbo h o ms.The ollowing
pa ag aphswilldiscuss heuseo bo h e bsincombina ionwi h hepassi e
basedon he -pa icipleand hem-pa iciple.
3.1. -pa iciple
Acco ding oVy au asAmb azas(2006:353),ini ially,passi ewasbased
on heso-calledpassi epas pa iciple o medbyadding hesu ix- -and he
app op ia eending o hein ini i es em.Thispa iciplewasini iallyused o
c ea ede e baladjec i es(e.g.,bal as‘whi e’<bal i‘ owhi en’),ande en ually,
i became hebasis o  hepassi eandhasp obablyse ed his unc ionsince
p e-li e a e imes.In heoldes Li huanian ex s om he16 hcen u y, he o m
o  he hi dpe sono  heauxilia yismos lyy a.Howe e ,somecons uc ions
wi hes is illcanbe ound:
(1) 1579VEE:
…ghiſſai j a paʃki as nůgi
3.sg.m.de aux.p s.3 appoin .ps .pp.nom.sg.m om
Diewa ſudʒia
God.gen.sg judge.gen.sg
‘…heisappoin edbyGod-judge.’
 S aipsniai / A icles 123
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(2) 1579VEE:
Pagi as eʃ waiſus ßiwa a awa
bless.ps .pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 ui .nom.sg womb.gen.sg poss.2.sg
‘Blessedis he ui o  hywomb.’
Obse a ions ela ed o hedis ibu iono  he hi dpe son o mso  he
e bbū ia egi enin he ablesbelow,whe e able5p esen sabsolu enumbe s
while able6–pe cen ageda a ega ding hedis ibu ioninindi idual ex s:
TABLE5:To alnumbe o auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT -pa iciple
y a es TOTAL
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 3 3
1573WP 237 27 264
1579VEE 61 20 81
1579BB 139 5 144
1612ZE 11 011
1727KNT 243 3 246
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 414 6 420
1660MP 145 26 171
1653KN 0 12 12
1660ChB 490 56 546
1701B NT 216 46 262
1816GNT 295 2 297
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 4 8
1647JE 0 1 1
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
124 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 6:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT -pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 100 100
1573WP 90 10 100
1579VE 75 25 100
1579BB 97 3 100
1612ZE 100 0 100
1727KNT 99 1100
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 99 1100
1660MP 85 15 100
1653KN 0 100 100
1660ChB 90 10 100
1701B NT 82 18 100
1816GNT 99 1100
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 100 100
1647JE 0 100 100
Theo e whelmingmajo i yo examplesuse heauxilia yy aas hede aul 
one.As expec ed,a g adual disappea anceo  hepassi e wi h he e bes i
can beno iced.Howe e , his p ocessdi e edsligh lybe ween hedialec s
o P ussiaand heG andDuchyo Li huania.Basedon heda a,i canbe
assumed ha  hecons uc ionwi hes iasanauxilia y e b inallywen ou o 
useinP ussiain he18 hcen u yand heLDKin he19 hcen u y.Acco ding
oAmb azas (2001:15), his isp obably ela ed o he de elopmen  o  he
passi ei sel ,whichwas i s  ullyg amma icalizedinWes e ndialec sand hen
g aduallyco e edsubsequen dialec s o heEas .Thisp ocessinsomeeas e n
dialec swasno  ullycomple edun ilmode n imes(Amb azas2001:15–16;
2006:365–366).Below, hecha ac e is icso  heuseo  hemen ioned e b
o msinindi idualdialec swillbediscussed.
3.1.1.P ussiandialec
Theoldes s udied ex  ep esen s heP ussiandialec ,anda  hesame ime,
heoldes Li huanianbookis heMa ynasMaž ydas’Ca echism.Du ing he
co pussea ch, h eeexampleso  hepassi ewi hanauxilia yin he hi dpe son
we e oundin he ex men ionedabo e,andin e es ingly,all heseexamples
a econs uc ionswi h he e bes i:
 S aipsniai / A icles 125
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(3) 1547MžK
…Baßniczie pado a es i Ch is ui
chu ch.nom.sg gi e.ps .pp. aux.ps .3 pn.da .sg
(4) 1547MžK
Szadis Dewa […] ap aschi as es i
wo d.nom.sg God.gen.sg desc ibe.ps .pp.nom.sg aux.p s.3
Tais zadeis
his.ins.pl.m wo d.ins.pl
‘Wo do Godisdesc ibedwi h hesewo ds.’
O cou se, heexamples ounda eno nume ousenough obeconside ed
s a is icallysigni ican .Howe e ,i iswo hno ing ha in he ex o Pos illa
om1573,only28yea sa e  heCa echism, hedominan  o mo  heauxilia y
is y a,andes ioccu sinonly10%o  o alexamples(27ou o 264).Howe e ,
despi e hiso e whelmingdisc epancy, he eisnoappa en di e encein he
useo  he wo o ms.Theycanbeusedbo hin esul a i emeanings(5a)and
(5b)andinac ionalmeaningswi hanexp essedagen (6a)and(6b):
(5) Resul a i e:
a. 1573WP
P iligin a es ka alis e dangaus ßmagu
equa e.ps .pp.nom.sg. aux.ps .3 kingdom.nom.sg hea en.gen.sg man.da .sg
ka eliu
king.da .sg
‘Thekingdomo hea enislikeun oace ainking…’
b. 1573WP
P iligin a i a ka alis e Dangaus ßmagu
equa e.ps .pp.nom.sg. aux.ps .3 kingdom.nom.sg hea en.gen.sg man.gen.pl
seiancʒiam gie ụ seklụ
sow.p s.ap.da .sg.m good.gen.pl.m seed.gen.pl
‘Thekingdomo hea enislikenedun oamanwhichsowedgoodseed…’
(6) Ac ional:
a. 1573WP
Diewas […] ege as es nog
God.nom.sg see.ps .ap.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 om
angelụ
angel.gen.pl
‘…Godwas[…]seeno Angels.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
132 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
beginningo  he18 hcen u y,es iwass illap oduc i eauxilia yusedina
ully- ledgedpassi e,while hepassi ewi hy a,al houghnume ous,wasless
de eloped.
The s a uso  he o m es i haschangedo e  100yea s,and in Juozapas
A nul asGied ai is’ ex ,only wouseso i in hepassi econs uc ioncanbe
ound.In e es ingly,bo hexamples,simila ly oChylinskis’,a enega ions:
(22)1816GNI
a[Jog jums duo a i a zino pasłep inés ka alis es dangaus:]
o jemis ne es duo a
exclam 3.pl.m.da  neg aux.p s.3 gi e.ps .pp.n
‘[Because i  is gi enun oyou oknow hemys e ies o  hekingdomo 
hea en,]bu  o hemi isno gi en.’
b [Daug eypogi i ki u s ebukłu pada e Jezus po akimis moki iniu sawo,]
ku ie ne es i pa aszi i ose
which.pl.m neg aux.p s.3 w i e.ps .pp.nom.pl.m his.loc.pl
knigose
book.loc.pl
‘[Andmanyo he signs ulydidJesusin hep esenceo hisdisciples,]which
a eno w i enin hesebook.’
The e ylow equencyo es i(1%)maysugges  ha  he o misp obably
used o s ylis ic easons,andmos likelysomewhe ebe ween he18 hand19 h
cen u ies,es iasanauxilia y e bin he e i o yo  heLDK inally ellin o
disuse.
A  hispoin ,asmallsampleo  heeas e ndialec iswo hmen ioning–
namely ex sbyKons an inasSi ydasandJonasJakna ičius.Inbo h ex s,
only i eexampleso  hepassi ewi h he hi dpe sonwe e ound,andalluse
he e bes i.
(23)1644ŠPS
kayp ki i dá bay Diewo […]
as o he .nom.sg.m wo k.nom.pl god.gen.sg
eʃ i da i i nuog wiſu iiu
aux.p s.3 made.ps .pp.nom.pl.m om all.gen.pl.m h ee.gen.m
Pe ſunu T ayces S[ en osios]
pe son.gen.pl ini y.gen.sg holy.gen.pl.
‘Aso he wo kso  heGoda emadebyallHolyT ini y.’

 S aipsniai / A icles 133
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(24)1647JE
A wienas ig iu kad
exclam one.nom.sg om 3.pl.gen when
ißwido apćis i as es i [sug io su bałsu didʒiu
ga bindamas Diewu.]
ealize.ps .3 cleanse.ps .pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3
‘Andoneo  hemwhen ealized ha iscleansed,collapsedonea hand
p aisedloudly heLo d.’
Theabsenceo y a o msin hepassi ecouldsugges  ha  hep ocesso 
de eloping o mso  he hi dpe sono  hepassi e oices a edin heWes 
andmo ed o heEas and heEas e ndialec was helas  o ullyde elop
hepassi e.Thiswouldcon i mAmb azas’(2001:15–16)obse a ionson he
de elopmen o  hepassi e,bu un o una ely, hesampleis oosmall obe
ully eliable.Ne e heless,i showsace ain endencyandisas a ingpoin 
o  u he analysis.
3.2. m-pa iciple
Inaddi ion o he -pa iciple, heLi huanianpassi emaybebasedon he
so-calledp esen passi epa iciple(m-pa iciple), o medbyadding hesu ix
-m-andanending o hep esen  enses em.His o ically, hepa iciplewas
used oc ea eadjec i es(c .la . i mus, en.wa m),andnowadays,cons uc ions
usingi a echa ac e izedbyadu a i easpec .In his unc ion,i isaLi huanian
inno a ion. The same pa iciple is p esen  in La ian. Howe e , i  has no 
de elopedas hebasis o  hepassi eandins eadhasamodalmeaning.
In e es ingly,in heoldes  ex s om he e i o yo P ussia, hede aul 
auxilia y e bwasy a,andes iappea edla e ,mainlyin he e i o yo  he
LDK.Thedis ibu iono  hese o msisp esen edin he ablesbelow:
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
134 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 7:To alnumbe o auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 0 0
1573WP 10 0
1579VE 7 1 8
1579BB 30 0 30
1612ZE 0 0 0
1727KNT 45 0 45
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 58 2 60
1660MP 0 13 13
1653KN 0 5 5
1660ChB 7257 264
1701B NT 41 34 75
1816GNT 42 143
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 0 0
1647JE 0 0 0
TABLE 8:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 0 0
1573WP 100 0 100
1579VE 88 12 100
1579BB 100 0 100
1612ZE 0 0 0
1727KNT 100 0 100
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 97 3 100
1660MP 0 100 100
1653KN 0 100 100
1660ChB 3 97 100
1701B NT 55 45 100
1816GNT 98 2 100
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 0 0
1647JE 0 0 0
 S aipsniai / A icles 135
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
Thedis ibu ionmen ionedabo eseemspuzzling.Asal eadymen ioned,
passi ewas i s g amma icalizedin he e i o yo P ussia.Thisispa icula ly
impo an  akingin oaccoun  hepassi ewi h hem-pa iciplebecausei  i s 
eme gedinP ussiaandonlyla e sp ead o he e i o yo LDK,andacco ding
oAmb azas(2001:16),apassi eo  his ypehasno de elopedinsomeEas e n
dialec s o hisday,whichseem obecon i medby heda acollec ed o  his
s udy.Below,ananalysiso indi idualexamples oundin heP ussianandLDK
dialec swillbediscussed.
3.2.1.P ussiandialec
Asal eadymen ioned, hepassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleisaLi huanian
inno a ion ha  i s appea edon he e i o yo P ussia.In heoldes  ex –
Maž ydas’ Ca echism, he e we e no examples o  his ype o  use wi h an
auxilia y.I isdi icul  osayhowde eloped hiscons uc ionwasdu ing his
pe iod,andi mayno bea es ed.Howe e ,i canbeassumed ha i wass ill
no  ullyg amma icalizedasapassi e,and heoldes a es edexamplecomes
omVilen as’ ex  om1579,whe esomedi e en useso  hepa iciplecan
be ound:
(25)1579VEE:
Nëʃa Aga wandinamas j a A abioie
o  pn call.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 pn.loc.pl
kalnas Sinai
moun ain.nom.sg pn
‘Fo Moun SinaiiscalledAga inA abia.’
(26)1579VEE:
Wiʃʃi daik ai aw j a galimi
all.nom.pl.m hing.nom.pl 2.sg.da  aux.p s.3 can.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
‘All hingsa epossible oyou…’
(27)1579VEE:
… bagams apʃakoma j a Euangelia
poo .da .pl p each.p s.pp.nom.sg.  aux.p s.3 gospel.nom.sg
‘… o hepoo  hegospelisp eached.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
136 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
(28)1579VEE:
… ku ie nîg iô [Die o] j a
which.nom.pl.m om 3.sg.gen.m aux.p s.3
ʃiun emi
send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
‘…whicha esen byhim[ heGod]…’
Example(25)illus a es hea ibu i eo  esul a i euse,which ypically
ma ks he ini ial s age o  he passi e’s e olu ion (Bybee e al. 1994: 64;
Amb azas2001:12).Example(26)demons a esamodaluse.Examples(27)
and (28) ep esen  he ac ional passi e, which sha es he same meaning as
he con empo a y cons uc ion wi h he m-pa iciple – namely, du a i e o 
habi ual.C ucially,asshowninexample(28),i ispossible oexp essanagen 
in hecons uc ion,indica ing ha i isal eady ullyde eloped,muchlike he
passi ebasedon he -pa iciple.I iswo hno ing ha Vilen as’ ex is heonly
examinedP ussianDialec  ex  o ea u econs uc ionwi hes i.
(29)1579VEE:
… duk e mana ʃunke’ nůgi
daugh e .nom.sg 1.sg.poss.nom.  g ie ously om
Welna eʃ i wa ginama
de il.gen.sg aux.p s.3 ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
Ascanbeseen,i isa ull- ledgedac ionalcons uc ionwi hanexp essed
agen ,bu i is heonlyexampleo  his ypein heexamined ex s.The ex s
byB e kūnasandQuand ( heonlyones om he e i o yo P ussiawhe e
hecons uc ionoccu s)onlyuse hecombina iony a + m-pa iciple.Please
conside belowexamples:
(30)BB1579:
30 Mana Duk ie nůg Welino pik ai
1.sg.poss.nom. daugh e .nom.sg om de il.gen.sg g ie ously
i a mucʒijma
aux.p s.3 ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
(31)KNT1727:
Mano Duk e ſunkiey Wélno wa ginnama
1.sg.poss.nom.  daugh e .nom.sg g ie ously de il.gen.sg ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
 S aipsniai / A icles 137
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
Due o he sca ci y o  da a, i  is challenging o pinpoin  when he
g amma icaliza iono  hepassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleoccu ed.Howe e ,
i isundeniablyplausible ha by he16 hcen u y,in heP ussian e i o y,i 
wasal eady ullyde eloped,and om heou se ,i sde aul auxilia y e bwas
y a.Thisislikelylinked o he ac  ha when his ypeo cons uc ioneme ged
in helanguage, hepassi ebasedon he -pa iciplewasin he inalphase
o  g amma icaliza ion. In he 16 h cen u y, y a was he dominan  auxilia y.
Mos  likely, he newly eme ged passi e cons uc ion wi h he m-pa iciple
au oma icallyadop ed hemos  equen auxilia ydu ing hispe iod.
3.2.2.Cen aldialec
Basedon hep e iouslyp esen edda a ega ding he -pa iciple,i couldbe
assumed ha  hesi ua ioninLDKwasanalogous o ha inP ussia.Howe e ,
heda ap esen edinTables(7)and(8)seem ocon adic  his.Theoldes o 
heexamined ex s–Daukša’sPos yll–hasasimila dis ibu ion o he ex so 
P ussianau ho s,and heonly woexamplesou o 60useso  hem-pa iciple
a econs uc ionswi hes i:
(32)DP1599:
... numí elei kâ ais giwúmpiumṗi śiuncʒemi
dead.nom.pl some imes li e.all send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
es
aux.p s.3
‘…deadsome imesa esen  oli e.’
(33)DP1599:
… anié ku ié lûdin iemus dâ omi
3.pl.nom.m which.nom.pl.m wi ness.ins.pl made.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
es ’
aux.p s.3
… hosewhoa emadewi nesses…’
Howe e ,al eadyayea la e ,inMo kūnas’ ex , he esul sa esu p ising,
and hedominan auxilia yises i,whiley awi h hem-pa icipledoesno 
appea a all:

PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
138 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
(34)1600MP:
a.[Pos illa LIETVWISZKA Tá áy es Iǯguldimás p ás ás Ewángeliu an koǯnos Nedelios i
Sʒwen es’ pe wisus me us]
ku ios págal budá sená Báǯnicǯioy
which.nom.sg.m acco ding way.acc.sg old.acc.sg.m chu ch.loc.sg
Diewá es skái omos
God.gen.sg aux.p s.3 ead.p s.pp.nom.pl.
‘[ThisLi huanianPos ilis hesimpleexplana iono  heGospel o e e y
Sundayandholiday h ough heyea ],whichacco ding o heold adi ionis
eadin heCong ega iono  heGod.’
Zinke ičius(1998:247)accusesMo kūnaso manymis akes,bu  hesame
canno besaidabou Bi ne iso S eponasJaugelisTelega– enownedlanguage
expe so  hei  ime(Zinke ičius1988:216–223).In he50yea solde  ex o 
Knyga nobažnys ės, heonlycons uc ionexp essing his ypeo passi eiss ill
es i + m-pa iciple.
(35)1653KN
35… ki a i ȧ dángus ku ion
o he .nom.sg.  be.p s.3 hea en.nom.sg which.ill.sg
wisi wie ni i pábȧni
all.nom.pl.m ai h ul.nom.pl.m and de ou .nom.pl.m Ʒmones
people.nom.pl
siunćiámi es i
send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m aux.p s.3
‘…di e en is heHea en owhichall ai h ulandde ou peoplea esen .’
Wha  his ype o  dis ibu ion o cons uc ionwi hes i can indica e?O 
cou se,i canbeassumed ha somewhe ebe ween he16 hand17 hcen u ies,
he e bes i eappea edonceagainas hede aul auxilia y o  hem-pa iciple,
bu  his seems unlikely. The eason o  such a la ge disc epancy be ween
Daukšaand heo he au ho s om heLDK,asal eadymen ioned,shouldbe
sough in heo igino  heau ho o  hePos ille.The e o e,i canbeassumed
ha Daukša’s ex ,whichisa ep esen a i eo  heCen aldialec ,wasa leas 
in luencedby heWes e ndialec in his espec ,whichseems obecon i med
bybo h heda a ega ding he -andm-pa iciples.
While he examples ci ed so a  ha e no  been nume ous, he ex  o 
Chylinskis’ Bible seems o con i m he hesis ha  in he e i o y o  he
LDK, hecons uc iono y a + m-pa iciplehasno ye beende eloped.In
hemen ioned ansla ion,ou o 266examples,onlyse encons uc ionsa e
combinedwi hy a.Fou a eusedwi h hepa iciplezynoma ‘known’andone
 S aipsniai / A icles 139
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
wi hwadynama ‘called’andno szaukiamas ‘no called’–sooneshouldconside 
hemaslexicalizeda ibu i eo modaluses a he  han heac ualpassi e.
(36)1660ChB
a… ana di wa ju liezuwe
ha .nom.sg.  ield.nom.sg 3.pl.gen.m ongue.loc.sg
wadynama i a Akeldama
call.p s.pp.nom.sg.  aux.p s.3 pn.nom
‘… ha  ieldiscalledin hei p ope  ongue,Aceldama…’
b [Jog nes zymus ziankłas pada y as i a pe jos,]
zynoma i a wisiemus ku ie giwena
know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 all.da .pl.m which.nom.pl.m li e.p s.3
Je uzalej
pn.loc.sg
‘[Fo  ha indeedano ablemi acleha hbeendoneby hem]ismani es  oall
hem ha dwellinJe usalem.’
Onlyoneexamplecanbein e p e edas heac ionalpassi e:
(37)1660ChB
[Be ep aszo jos wie oy, as nes ku sej abejoia ligus i a]
Wilniey ma iu, ku sej wa omas i a
wa e.da .sg sea.gen.pl which.da .sg mo e.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3
nog wejaus
om wind.gen.sg
‘[Bu le himaskin ai h,no hingwa e ing.Fo he ha wa e e hislike]a
wa eo  hesead i enwi h hewind…’
Mos examples(259)wi hapassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleinChylinskis’
ex  use he e b es i. Among hem, one can also ind cons uc ions wi h
hepa iciplesmen ionedinexamples(36)and(37),bu  he ea eonly6o 
hem.Theo e whelmingmajo i ya epassi econs uc ionsco esponding o
con empo a ydu a i eandhabi ualuseo  hem-pa iciple.
(38)1660ChB
a…[ eywanis e] nog Izaoka paszławinime jo
om pn.gen.sg blessing.loc.sg 3.sg.m.gen
paźadama i pas yp ynama es
p omise.p s.pp.nom.sg.  and en o ce.p s.pp.nom.sg. aux.p s.3
‘…[he i age]isp omisedand ein o cedbyIsaac’sblessing.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
140 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
bIz aeli ey pamuszami es nog Filis ynu
pn.nom.pl de ea .p s.pp.nom.pl.m aux.p s.3 om pn.gen.pl
‘Is aeli eswasde ea edbyPhilis ines.’
cPas yp ynamas es asabliwu api eyszkimu
ein o ce.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s. 3peculia .ins.sg.m e ela ion.ins.sg
‘Was ein o cedbypeculia  e ela ion.’
Asin hecaseo  he -pa iciple, he ea econs uc ionswi haho a i e
p e ix (39a) and a nega ion p e ix (39b). Howe e , hese a e jus  i e such
examples:
(39)1660ChB
aWiezliwis e jusu ’es pazys ama wisiem[us]
mode a ion.nom.sg 2.pl.gen aux.p s.3.ho know.p s.pp.nom.sg.  all.acc.pl.m
zmonem[us]
man.acc.pl
‘Le you mode a ionbeknownun oallmen.’
b… jeygu wel n’es wadojama
i  again aux.p s.3.neg edeem.p s.pp.nom.sg. 
ada bus pa do pagal apwe ynima
hen be. u .3 sell.ps .pp.n acco ding o es ima ion.acc.sg
awo
2.sg.poss
‘…i i isno  edeemed, heni shallbesoldacco ding o hyes ima ion.’
Thismayindica e ha  he e bes i,whichcouldha especialized unc ions
incons uc ionswi ha -pa iciple,is a he ade aul auxilia yin hecaseo 
an m-pa iciple.Thishypo hesismayalsobesuppo edby he ac  ha manyo 
heexamplescomeno  om he ex o  heBiblei sel bu  omin oduc ions
ochap e s ha a eno inspi edby hesou ceo  he ansla ionand e lec  he
idiolec o  heau ho himsel –and he e o e heac uallanguageo  heCen al
dialec o  hesecondhal o  he17 hcen u y.
Bi ne is’ ex , which is 40 yea s olde , he si ua ion changes, and he
dis ibu iono bo hauxilia iesa ealmos equal(45%–es iand55%–y a).
The eisnoappa en di e encebe ween heuseo bo h e bs,bu  hepassi e
wi hes iseemsmo eac ional.A  hesame ime,incombina ionwi hy a, he e
a emo elexicalizedo a ibu i e o ms.
 S aipsniai / A icles 141
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(40)1701BNT
a… duk ė mano sunkey mucʒijama
daugh e .nom.sg 1.sg.poss.nom.  g ie ously ex.p s.pp.nom.sg. 
es i nůg Welnio
aux.p s.3 om de il.gen.sg
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
b[G óma a] skai oma i a nůg wissû
book.nom.sg ead.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 om all.gen.pl
ʒmonû
man.gen.pl
‘Bookis eadbyallmen.’
(41)1701BNT
aTegul jumus wissiemus žinoma es i
shall 2.pl.da  all.da .pl.m know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3
‘Bei knownun oyouall…’
bNes žinoma i a jog Wießpa s
because know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 ha  Lo d.nom.sg
musu ißėjo iß plemês Iudos
1.pl.gen go.ps .3 om ibe.gen.sg pn.gen
‘Fo i ise iden  ha ou Lo dsp angou o Juda…’
This mayindica e ha  he u n o  he 17 h and 18 hcen u ies was when
hees icons uc ionbegan o allin odisuse.Gied ai is’ ex hasonlyone
cons uc ionwi h he e bes iou o 43.I can, he e o e,beassumed ha 
hiscons uc ionwasnolonge p oduc i ein he19 hcen u y.Al hough,as
in hecaseo  heP ussiandialec , heexac da eo  heg amma icaliza iono 
hecons uc ionwi hy acanno begi en,i mus ha eoccu eda  he u n
o  he18 hand19 hcen u iesa  hela es ,i.e.,o e 100yea sla e .Theda a
om heEas e ndialec a eindeed agmen a y.Howe e , heabsenceo  he
discussedcons uc ionin heexamined ex smaybea eason oclaim ha  his
cons uc ionmus ha ede elopedandbeeng amma icalizede enla e .
4. CONCLUSIONS
His o ically, he hi dpe sono  heLi huanian e bbū i ‘ obe’used he o m
es i,co esponding oo he Bal icandIndo-Eu opeanlanguages(c .P ussian
as ;Polishjes ,La ines ,Ge manis ,e c.).Howe e ,due o heseman icshi ,