Disappearance of the auxiliary verb esti in the Lithuanian passive
Abstract
The prototypical passive voice in Lithuanian is an analytical construction consisting of a passive past participle and the auxiliary verb būti ‘to be’. Nowadays, the conjugation of this verb in the present tense is regular, except for the suppletive form of the third person yra, an East Baltic innovation, and historically, its original form was esti. Although the development and uses of the verb yra are well described, its development as a passive auxiliary verb has not received enough attention. The paper aims to trace the disappearance of the form esti from the function of an auxiliary verb in the passive constructions based on Old Lithuanian texts from 1547–1816, represented by prints from three historical dialects of Lithuanian.
Full text
S aipsniai / A icles 117
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
Uni e si yo Wa saw
ORCIDid:o cid.o g/0000-0002-1850-0818
Fieldso esea ch:His o yo Bal iclanguages,mo phology,
syn ax,seman ics, oice,modali y.
DOI:doi.o g/10.35321/all91-05
DISAPPEARANCEOFTHE
AUXILIARYVERBESTIINTHE
LITHUANIANPASSIVE
Pagalbinio eiksmažodžioes i išnykimasiš
lie u iųkalbosne eikiamosios ūšies
ANNOTATION
Thep o o ypicalpassi e oiceinLi huanianisananaly icalcons uc ionconsis ingo a
passi epas pa icipleand heauxilia y e bbū i‘ obe’.Nowadays, heconjuga iono his
e bin hep esen enseis egula ,excep o hesupple i e o mo he hi dpe sony a,an
Eas Bal icinno a ion,andhis o ically,i so iginal o mwases i.Al hough hede elopmen
anduseso he e by aa ewelldesc ibed,i sde elopmen asapassi eauxilia y e bhas
no ecei edenougha en ion.Thepape aims o ace hedisappea anceo he o mes i
om he unc iono anauxilia y e bin hepassi econs uc ionsbasedonOldLi huanian
ex s om1547–1816, ep esen edbyp in s om h eehis o icaldialec so Li huanian.
KEYWORDS:Li huanian (language), diach ony, passi e, pa iciple, auxilia y
e b.
ANOTACIJA
Lie u iųkalbosne eikiamosios ūšiesp o o ipasy aanali inėkons ukcija,suda y aiš
ne eikiamosios ūšiesbū ojolaikodaly ioi pagalbinio eiksmažodžiobū i.Daba inėje
lie u iųkalboješio eiksmažodžioesamojolaikoasmena imasy a aisyklingas,išsky us
suple y inę3-iojoasmens o mąy a,ku i– y ųbal ųkalbųino acija,ois o iškaipi minė
josbu usi o ma– es i.No s eiksmažodžioy a aidai a osenage aiap ašy a,jo,kaip
ne eikiamosios ūšies pagalbinio eiksmažodžio, aidai ski a nepakankamai dėmesio.
S aipsnio ikslas– emian is1547–1816me ųsenosioslie u iųkalbos eks ais,ku iuos
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
118 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
ep ezen uoja ijų is o inių lie u ių kalbos a mių spaudiniai, a sek i o mos es i, kaip
a liekančiospagalbinio eiksmažodžio unkciją,išnykimąne eikiamosiosekons ukcijose.
ESMINIAIŽODŽIAI:lie u ių kalba, diach onija, ne eikiamoji nuosaka, daly is,
pagalbinis eksmažodis.
1. INTRODUCTION
In o mula inguni e sals ela ed o hena u eo hepassi e,onemus be
ca e ulbecausei maydi e ins uc u eand unc ion omlanguage olanguage
(Siewie ska1984;Shiba ani1985;Geniušienė2016).O cou se,i ispossible
oiden i yse e alcommon ea u escons i u ing hecanonicalpassi e oice
inEu opeanlanguages(Hol oe 2001:366).Howe e ,i isno easy o ind
uni e sals ha a ecommon oalllanguages.Theconcep o hepassi e oice
i sel isusuallyassocia edwi hi sp o o ypical,pe sonaluse(Siewie ska1984:
28),whe e hesen encehasaco espondingcons uc ionin heac i e oice,i
ispossible ode e mine hesubjec and hesubjec o hepassi econs uc ion
co esponds o hepa ien o heac i econs uc ion.Howe e ,in hispape , he
passi eisunde s oodb oadlyas heso-calledpassi e amily(Naue al.2020),
i.e.,se e aldi e en p edica i econs uc ionswi hapassi epa iciple,which
canbeg oupedbasedon o maland unc ionalpa ame e s,includingpe sonal,
impe sonal, ac ional, esul a i e o modal cons uc ions. The p o o ypical
passi e oiceinLi huanianisananaly icalcons uc ionconsis ingo aso-called
passi epas pa iciple( -pa iciple)o passi ep esen pa iciple(m-pa iciple)
and heauxilia y e bbū i‘ obe’.Nowadays, heconjuga iono his e bin he
p esen enseis egula ,excep o hesupple i e o mo he hi dpe sony a,
anEas Bal icinno a ion,andhis o ically,i so iginal o mwases i.
Thehis o yo henew,supple i e o mhasbeenex ensi elydocumen ed
(S ang1947:1970;Fo d1967;Os owski2017a;2017b;2021).The e bes i,
o iginallyanexis en ial e b,was eplacedby he e by aandnowse esonly
ahabi ual unc ion,simila o he o mbūna‘usuallyis’(Genialiausios min ys
es i pap asčiausios.‘Themos geniusideasusuallya e hesimples ones.’).The
o iginal o mo y ashouldbe econs uc edas*ī- -,asindica edby heOld
Bal icanddialec al o ms(Endzelin1922:556;Os owski2017b:167;2021
66–67).E ymologically,i isa o ma ionbasedon hes emo heanapho ic
p onouni-( obep eciseins .sg.*h₁i-h₁),and woloca i epos posi ions- and
*-.Ini ially,i wasalocal e b,which henacqui edanexis en ialmeaning
(as e idenced by ex s om he 16 h and 17 h cen u ies). This de elopmen
pa halignswi h he ypological da a on he ela ionshipbe ween loca ional
S aipsniai / A icles 119
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
andexis en ialsen ences(Lyons1967:390–396;Cla k1978:85–126;Yong,
Jie2013;Os owski2017b:168;2021:67).
While hee olu ionanduseso he e by aha ebeenex ensi elydocumen ed,
i se olu ionasapassi eauxilia y e bhasbeena ela i elyunexplo eda ea.
Thiss udy ills hisgapbyme iculously acing hedisappea anceo he o m
es i om he oleo anauxilia y e binpassi econs uc ions.The esea chis
basedonOldLi huanian ex s om1547–1816,which ep esen h eehis o ical
dialec so Li huanian.Thepape willdel ein o equencyda a,examining
hedis ibu iono indi idual o mso he hi dpe sono he e bbū i‘ o
be’incombina ionwi hpassi epa iciples.Thiscomp ehensi eanalysisaims
op esen ade aileduseo hesecons uc ionsand,c ucially, oexplain he
anishingo he o mes iin heauxilia y unc ion.
2. METHODOLOGY
The esul s p esen ed in he pape we e based on a co pus c ea ed o
hes udy,consis ingo OldLi huanian ex s om he e i o ieso a ious
his o icaldialec so heLi huanianlanguageandw i eno e almos 300yea s.
The ex swe eselec edbasedon hepublica ionso ZigmasZinke ičius(1987;
1988;1990;1998)as hemos ep esen a i emonumen so heOldLi huanian
language.Zinke ičiusw i esabou h eehis o icaldialec s: heWes e ndialec
used on he e i o y o P ussia and dialec s spoken in he e i o y o he
G andDuchyo Li huania(li h.Lie u os Didžioji Kunigaikš ys ė (LDK))– he
Cen aland heEas e n.1Thepe iodinwhich hesedialec scanbesaid oha e
exis edlas edapp oxima elyun il heendo he17 hcen u y.Inaddi ion o
ex s om hispe iod,somela e ex sha ealsobeenincluded.E en hough
i isakindo anach onism, o hes udy, hese ansla ionswe eincludedin
hedialec smen ionedabo e,basedon heo igino heau ho s,and he e o e
asana u alwayo de eloping helanguage heyused.Thissimpli ica ionwas
in ended o acili a e hedesc ip ionandcompa isono ex sand, hus, o ace
hede elopmen o hes udiedcons uc ion.The ablebelowshows hesizes
o indi idual ex s
1
Fulllis o w i ingsisa achedin heabb e ia ionsec ion.
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
120 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE1:co pussize
DIALECT TEXT Wo d by ex Wo d by dialec To al
P ussian
(wes )
1547MžK 7297
411255
(650170wi h
Quand ’sNT)
2398569
1573WP 183894
1579VE 40224
1579BB 166975
1612ZE 12865
1727KNT 238915
LDK
(cen al)
1599DP 419036
1222710
(1654968wi h
Bi ne is’and
Gied ai is’NT)
1660MP 201170
1653KN 171861
1660ChB 430643
1701B NT 228586
1816GNT 203672
LDK (eas ) 1644ŠPS 68982 93431
1647JE 24449
Ascanbeseen, henumbe o ex s omindi idualdialec sisno uni o m.
Themaingoalinc ea ing heco puswas odi e si y ex sso ha he esul s
ob ainedwe eas eliableaspossibleand oexcludepossibleindi iduallinguis ic
cha ac e is icso au ho s.Theonly ex om he19 hcen u y ep esen s he
Cen al a ian because heg ea es di e si ydis inguished hisdialec du ing
he s udy. The las p oblem conce ns he ep esen a ion o ex s om he
Eas e ndialec .Thisisbecause,asZinke ičiuss a es(1998:252–255), his
dialec is heleas ep esen edandde eloped.Fo his eason,al hough he
da a ombo h ex sp o idein e es ingin o ma ion, heya e heleas eliable
andimpo an o hes udy.Toelimina esigni ican nume icaldisc epancies
u he ,pe cen ageda awillalsobep esen edin heanalysisinaddi ion o
numbe s.
To indin heco pusdesc ibedin hepape cons uc ions,a o mulawas
usedconsis ingo :
1) hi d-pe sonauxilia y e by ao es i;
2)endingso henomina i esingula andplu al o bo hgende s:
a.pas passi epa iciples( -pa iciple),
b.p esen passi epa iciples(m-pa iciple).
In heo y, heauxilia y e bcombinedwi h hepassi epa icipleis he
basiso hepassi e.All o mulas ookin oaccoun heo hog aphyusedby he
S aipsniai / A icles 121
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
au ho sand he ac ha heauxilia y e bcouldbeinbo hpos posi ionand
p eposi ion o hepa iciples.Un o una ely, he esul sdono conside o ms
whe e heauxilia y e bcouldbeina u he posi ion ela i e o hepa iciple.
Theob ained esul swe e henmanually il e ed:
TABLE2:Dis ibu iono auxilia iesinpassi econs uc ions
Pa iciple m-pa iciple -pa iciple
Auxilia y y a es i y a es i
o al 232 314 2251 210
546 2461
Ascanbeseen, he esul s o indi idualcons uc ionsdi e signi ican ly.
Cons uc ionswi h -pa iciplesdomina e,bu hedis ibu iono heauxilia y
e bincons uc ionswi hm-pa iciplesa ac smo ea en ion.The ollowing
sec ionswilldiscussade ailedanalysiso indi idualauxilia iesin hepassi e.
3. ANALYSIS
The ablesbelowp esen nume icalda aon hedis ibu iono y aandes i.
Table 3 shows he absolu e alues o he occu ence o indi idual e bs in
combina ionwi hm-pa icipleand -pa iciple.Theseda aa eg oupedin o
la ge en i iesacco ding o hecen u yanddialec hey ep esen .Table4shows
hesameda aexp essedasape cen age alue.
TABLE3:To alnumbe o auxilia iesbydialec
DIALECT Cen u-
y
m-pa iciple -pa iciple
y a es y a es
P ussian
(Wes e n)
XVI 38 139 437 55 492
XVII 0 0 0 11 011
XVIII 45 0 45 243 3 246
LDK (Cen al)
XVI 58 15 73 559 32 591
XVII 8 263 271 490 67 557
XVIII 41 34 75 216 46 262
XIX 42 143 295 2 297
LDK (Eas e n) XVII 0 0 0 0 5 5
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
122 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 4:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple -pa iciple
y a es =y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
XVI 97 3 100 89 11 100
XVII 0 0 0 100 0 100
XVIII 100 0 100 99 1100
LDK
(Cen al)
XVI 79 21 100 95 5 100
XVII 3 97 100 88 12 100
XVIII 55 45 100 82 18 100
XIX 98 2 100 99 1100
LDK (Eas e n) XVII 0 0 0 0 100 100
Alownumbe o occu enceso examples om heEas e ndialec o he
G andDuchyo Li huaniawillbediscussedin henex sec ion.Howe e , o
ob ious easons, heya e oos a is icallyinsigni ican .Thegene alpic u e ha
mayeme ge om heabo eda asugges s ha es iasanauxilia ywasused
ma ginallyal eadyin he imeso he i s w i en ex s,especiallyin hecase
o hepassi ewi h he -pa iciple.Howe e ,adeepe analysiso indi idual
ex smayshowin e es ing ela ionshipsbe weenbo h o ms.The ollowing
pa ag aphswilldiscuss heuseo bo h e bsincombina ionwi h hepassi e
basedon he -pa icipleand hem-pa iciple.
3.1. -pa iciple
Acco ding oVy au asAmb azas(2006:353),ini ially,passi ewasbased
on heso-calledpassi epas pa iciple o medbyadding hesu ix- -and he
app op ia eending o hein ini i es em.Thispa iciplewasini iallyused o
c ea ede e baladjec i es(e.g.,bal as‘whi e’<bal i‘ owhi en’),ande en ually,
i became hebasis o hepassi eandhasp obablyse ed his unc ionsince
p e-li e a e imes.In heoldes Li huanian ex s om he16 hcen u y, he o m
o he hi dpe sono heauxilia yismos lyy a.Howe e ,somecons uc ions
wi hes is illcanbe ound:
(1) 1579VEE:
…ghiſſai j a paʃki as nůgi
3.sg.m.de aux.p s.3 appoin .ps .pp.nom.sg.m om
Diewa ſudʒia
God.gen.sg judge.gen.sg
‘…heisappoin edbyGod-judge.’
S aipsniai / A icles 123
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(2) 1579VEE:
Pagi as eʃ waiſus ßiwa a awa
bless.ps .pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 ui .nom.sg womb.gen.sg poss.2.sg
‘Blessedis he ui o hywomb.’
Obse a ions ela ed o hedis ibu iono he hi dpe son o mso he
e bbū ia egi enin he ablesbelow,whe e able5p esen sabsolu enumbe s
while able6–pe cen ageda a ega ding hedis ibu ioninindi idual ex s:
TABLE5:To alnumbe o auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT -pa iciple
y a es TOTAL
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 3 3
1573WP 237 27 264
1579VEE 61 20 81
1579BB 139 5 144
1612ZE 11 011
1727KNT 243 3 246
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 414 6 420
1660MP 145 26 171
1653KN 0 12 12
1660ChB 490 56 546
1701B NT 216 46 262
1816GNT 295 2 297
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 4 8
1647JE 0 1 1
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
124 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 6:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT -pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 100 100
1573WP 90 10 100
1579VE 75 25 100
1579BB 97 3 100
1612ZE 100 0 100
1727KNT 99 1100
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 99 1100
1660MP 85 15 100
1653KN 0 100 100
1660ChB 90 10 100
1701B NT 82 18 100
1816GNT 99 1100
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 100 100
1647JE 0 100 100
Theo e whelmingmajo i yo examplesuse heauxilia yy aas hede aul
one.As expec ed,a g adual disappea anceo hepassi e wi h he e bes i
can beno iced.Howe e , his p ocessdi e edsligh lybe ween hedialec s
o P ussiaand heG andDuchyo Li huania.Basedon heda a,i canbe
assumed ha hecons uc ionwi hes iasanauxilia y e b inallywen ou o
useinP ussiain he18 hcen u yand heLDKin he19 hcen u y.Acco ding
oAmb azas (2001:15), his isp obably ela ed o he de elopmen o he
passi ei sel ,whichwas i s ullyg amma icalizedinWes e ndialec sand hen
g aduallyco e edsubsequen dialec s o heEas .Thisp ocessinsomeeas e n
dialec swasno ullycomple edun ilmode n imes(Amb azas2001:15–16;
2006:365–366).Below, hecha ac e is icso heuseo hemen ioned e b
o msinindi idualdialec swillbediscussed.
3.1.1.P ussiandialec
Theoldes s udied ex ep esen s heP ussiandialec ,anda hesame ime,
heoldes Li huanianbookis heMa ynasMaž ydas’Ca echism.Du ing he
co pussea ch, h eeexampleso hepassi ewi hanauxilia yin he hi dpe son
we e oundin he ex men ionedabo e,andin e es ingly,all heseexamples
a econs uc ionswi h he e bes i:
S aipsniai / A icles 125
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(3) 1547MžK
…Baßniczie pado a es i Ch is ui
chu ch.nom.sg gi e.ps .pp. aux.ps .3 pn.da .sg
(4) 1547MžK
Szadis Dewa […] ap aschi as es i
wo d.nom.sg God.gen.sg desc ibe.ps .pp.nom.sg aux.p s.3
Tais zadeis
his.ins.pl.m wo d.ins.pl
‘Wo do Godisdesc ibedwi h hesewo ds.’
O cou se, heexamples ounda eno nume ousenough obeconside ed
s a is icallysigni ican .Howe e ,i iswo hno ing ha in he ex o Pos illa
om1573,only28yea sa e heCa echism, hedominan o mo heauxilia y
is y a,andes ioccu sinonly10%o o alexamples(27ou o 264).Howe e ,
despi e hiso e whelmingdisc epancy, he eisnoappa en di e encein he
useo he wo o ms.Theycanbeusedbo hin esul a i emeanings(5a)and
(5b)andinac ionalmeaningswi hanexp essedagen (6a)and(6b):
(5) Resul a i e:
a. 1573WP
P iligin a es ka alis e dangaus ßmagu
equa e.ps .pp.nom.sg. aux.ps .3 kingdom.nom.sg hea en.gen.sg man.da .sg
ka eliu
king.da .sg
‘Thekingdomo hea enislikeun oace ainking…’
b. 1573WP
P iligin a i a ka alis e Dangaus ßmagu
equa e.ps .pp.nom.sg. aux.ps .3 kingdom.nom.sg hea en.gen.sg man.gen.pl
seiancʒiam gie ụ seklụ
sow.p s.ap.da .sg.m good.gen.pl.m seed.gen.pl
‘Thekingdomo hea enislikenedun oamanwhichsowedgoodseed…’
(6) Ac ional:
a. 1573WP
Diewas […] ege as es nog
God.nom.sg see.ps .ap.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 om
angelụ
angel.gen.pl
‘…Godwas[…]seeno Angels.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
132 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
beginningo he18 hcen u y,es iwass illap oduc i eauxilia yusedina
ully- ledgedpassi e,while hepassi ewi hy a,al houghnume ous,wasless
de eloped.
The s a uso he o m es i haschangedo e 100yea s,and in Juozapas
A nul asGied ai is’ ex ,only wouseso i in hepassi econs uc ioncanbe
ound.In e es ingly,bo hexamples,simila ly oChylinskis’,a enega ions:
(22)1816GNI
a[Jog jums duo a i a zino pasłep inés ka alis es dangaus:]
o jemis ne es duo a
exclam 3.pl.m.da neg aux.p s.3 gi e.ps .pp.n
‘[Because i is gi enun oyou oknow hemys e ies o hekingdomo
hea en,]bu o hemi isno gi en.’
b [Daug eypogi i ki u s ebukłu pada e Jezus po akimis moki iniu sawo,]
ku ie ne es i pa aszi i ose
which.pl.m neg aux.p s.3 w i e.ps .pp.nom.pl.m his.loc.pl
knigose
book.loc.pl
‘[Andmanyo he signs ulydidJesusin hep esenceo hisdisciples,]which
a eno w i enin hesebook.’
The e ylow equencyo es i(1%)maysugges ha he o misp obably
used o s ylis ic easons,andmos likelysomewhe ebe ween he18 hand19 h
cen u ies,es iasanauxilia y e bin he e i o yo heLDK inally ellin o
disuse.
A hispoin ,asmallsampleo heeas e ndialec iswo hmen ioning–
namely ex sbyKons an inasSi ydasandJonasJakna ičius.Inbo h ex s,
only i eexampleso hepassi ewi h he hi dpe sonwe e ound,andalluse
he e bes i.
(23)1644ŠPS
kayp ki i dá bay Diewo […]
as o he .nom.sg.m wo k.nom.pl god.gen.sg
eʃ i da i i nuog wiſu iiu
aux.p s.3 made.ps .pp.nom.pl.m om all.gen.pl.m h ee.gen.m
Pe ſunu T ayces S[ en osios]
pe son.gen.pl ini y.gen.sg holy.gen.pl.
‘Aso he wo kso heGoda emadebyallHolyT ini y.’
S aipsniai / A icles 133
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(24)1647JE
A wienas ig iu kad
exclam one.nom.sg om 3.pl.gen when
ißwido apćis i as es i [sug io su bałsu didʒiu
ga bindamas Diewu.]
ealize.ps .3 cleanse.ps .pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3
‘Andoneo hemwhen ealized ha iscleansed,collapsedonea hand
p aisedloudly heLo d.’
Theabsenceo y a o msin hepassi ecouldsugges ha hep ocesso
de eloping o mso he hi dpe sono hepassi e oices a edin heWes
andmo ed o heEas and heEas e ndialec was helas o ullyde elop
hepassi e.Thiswouldcon i mAmb azas’(2001:15–16)obse a ionson he
de elopmen o hepassi e,bu un o una ely, hesampleis oosmall obe
ully eliable.Ne e heless,i showsace ain endencyandisas a ingpoin
o u he analysis.
3.2. m-pa iciple
Inaddi ion o he -pa iciple, heLi huanianpassi emaybebasedon he
so-calledp esen passi epa iciple(m-pa iciple), o medbyadding hesu ix
-m-andanending o hep esen enses em.His o ically, hepa iciplewas
used oc ea eadjec i es(c .la . i mus, en.wa m),andnowadays,cons uc ions
usingi a echa ac e izedbyadu a i easpec .In his unc ion,i isaLi huanian
inno a ion. The same pa iciple is p esen in La ian. Howe e , i has no
de elopedas hebasis o hepassi eandins eadhasamodalmeaning.
In e es ingly,in heoldes ex s om he e i o yo P ussia, hede aul
auxilia y e bwasy a,andes iappea edla e ,mainlyin he e i o yo he
LDK.Thedis ibu iono hese o msisp esen edin he ablesbelow:
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
134 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
TABLE 7:To alnumbe o auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 0 0
1573WP 10 0
1579VE 7 1 8
1579BB 30 0 30
1612ZE 0 0 0
1727KNT 45 0 45
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 58 2 60
1660MP 0 13 13
1653KN 0 5 5
1660ChB 7257 264
1701B NT 41 34 75
1816GNT 42 143
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 0 0
1647JE 0 0 0
TABLE 8:To alpe cen ageo auxilia iesby ex
DIALECT TEXT m-pa iciple
y a es =
P ussian
(Wes e n)
1547MžK 0 0 0
1573WP 100 0 100
1579VE 88 12 100
1579BB 100 0 100
1612ZE 0 0 0
1727KNT 100 0 100
LDK
(Cen al)
1599DP 97 3 100
1660MP 0 100 100
1653KN 0 100 100
1660ChB 3 97 100
1701B NT 55 45 100
1816GNT 98 2 100
LDK
(Eas e n)
1644ŠPS 0 0 0
1647JE 0 0 0
S aipsniai / A icles 135
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
Thedis ibu ionmen ionedabo eseemspuzzling.Asal eadymen ioned,
passi ewas i s g amma icalizedin he e i o yo P ussia.Thisispa icula ly
impo an akingin oaccoun hepassi ewi h hem-pa iciplebecausei i s
eme gedinP ussiaandonlyla e sp ead o he e i o yo LDK,andacco ding
oAmb azas(2001:16),apassi eo his ypehasno de elopedinsomeEas e n
dialec s o hisday,whichseem obecon i medby heda acollec ed o his
s udy.Below,ananalysiso indi idualexamples oundin heP ussianandLDK
dialec swillbediscussed.
3.2.1.P ussiandialec
Asal eadymen ioned, hepassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleisaLi huanian
inno a ion ha i s appea edon he e i o yo P ussia.In heoldes ex –
Maž ydas’ Ca echism, he e we e no examples o his ype o use wi h an
auxilia y.I isdi icul osayhowde eloped hiscons uc ionwasdu ing his
pe iod,andi mayno bea es ed.Howe e ,i canbeassumed ha i wass ill
no ullyg amma icalizedasapassi e,and heoldes a es edexamplecomes
omVilen as’ ex om1579,whe esomedi e en useso hepa iciplecan
be ound:
(25)1579VEE:
Nëʃa Aga wandinamas j a A abioie
o pn call.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3 pn.loc.pl
kalnas Sinai
moun ain.nom.sg pn
‘Fo Moun SinaiiscalledAga inA abia.’
(26)1579VEE:
Wiʃʃi daik ai aw j a galimi
all.nom.pl.m hing.nom.pl 2.sg.da aux.p s.3 can.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
‘All hingsa epossible oyou…’
(27)1579VEE:
… bagams apʃakoma j a Euangelia
poo .da .pl p each.p s.pp.nom.sg. aux.p s.3 gospel.nom.sg
‘… o hepoo hegospelisp eached.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
136 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
(28)1579VEE:
… ku ie nîg iô [Die o] j a
which.nom.pl.m om 3.sg.gen.m aux.p s.3
ʃiun emi
send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
‘…whicha esen byhim[ heGod]…’
Example(25)illus a es hea ibu i eo esul a i euse,which ypically
ma ks he ini ial s age o he passi e’s e olu ion (Bybee e al. 1994: 64;
Amb azas2001:12).Example(26)demons a esamodaluse.Examples(27)
and (28) ep esen he ac ional passi e, which sha es he same meaning as
he con empo a y cons uc ion wi h he m-pa iciple – namely, du a i e o
habi ual.C ucially,asshowninexample(28),i ispossible oexp essanagen
in hecons uc ion,indica ing ha i isal eady ullyde eloped,muchlike he
passi ebasedon he -pa iciple.I iswo hno ing ha Vilen as’ ex is heonly
examinedP ussianDialec ex o ea u econs uc ionwi hes i.
(29)1579VEE:
… duk e mana ʃunke’ nůgi
daugh e .nom.sg 1.sg.poss.nom. g ie ously om
Welna eʃ i wa ginama
de il.gen.sg aux.p s.3 ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
Ascanbeseen,i isa ull- ledgedac ionalcons uc ionwi hanexp essed
agen ,bu i is heonlyexampleo his ypein heexamined ex s.The ex s
byB e kūnasandQuand ( heonlyones om he e i o yo P ussiawhe e
hecons uc ionoccu s)onlyuse hecombina iony a + m-pa iciple.Please
conside belowexamples:
(30)BB1579:
30 Mana Duk ie nůg Welino pik ai
1.sg.poss.nom. daugh e .nom.sg om de il.gen.sg g ie ously
i a mucʒijma
aux.p s.3 ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
(31)KNT1727:
Mano Duk e ſunkiey Wélno wa ginnama
1.sg.poss.nom. daugh e .nom.sg g ie ously de il.gen.sg ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
S aipsniai / A icles 137
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
Due o he sca ci y o da a, i is challenging o pinpoin when he
g amma icaliza iono hepassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleoccu ed.Howe e ,
i isundeniablyplausible ha by he16 hcen u y,in heP ussian e i o y,i
wasal eady ullyde eloped,and om heou se ,i sde aul auxilia y e bwas
y a.Thisislikelylinked o he ac ha when his ypeo cons uc ioneme ged
in helanguage, hepassi ebasedon he -pa iciplewasin he inalphase
o g amma icaliza ion. In he 16 h cen u y, y a was he dominan auxilia y.
Mos likely, he newly eme ged passi e cons uc ion wi h he m-pa iciple
au oma icallyadop ed hemos equen auxilia ydu ing hispe iod.
3.2.2.Cen aldialec
Basedon hep e iouslyp esen edda a ega ding he -pa iciple,i couldbe
assumed ha hesi ua ioninLDKwasanalogous o ha inP ussia.Howe e ,
heda ap esen edinTables(7)and(8)seem ocon adic his.Theoldes o
heexamined ex s–Daukša’sPos yll–hasasimila dis ibu ion o he ex so
P ussianau ho s,and heonly woexamplesou o 60useso hem-pa iciple
a econs uc ionswi hes i:
(32)DP1599:
... numí elei kâ ais giwúmpiumṗi śiuncʒemi
dead.nom.pl some imes li e.all send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
es
aux.p s.3
‘…deadsome imesa esen oli e.’
(33)DP1599:
… anié ku ié lûdin iemus dâ omi
3.pl.nom.m which.nom.pl.m wi ness.ins.pl made.p s.pp.nom.pl.m
es ’
aux.p s.3
… hosewhoa emadewi nesses…’
Howe e ,al eadyayea la e ,inMo kūnas’ ex , he esul sa esu p ising,
and hedominan auxilia yises i,whiley awi h hem-pa icipledoesno
appea a all:
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
138 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
(34)1600MP:
a.[Pos illa LIETVWISZKA Tá áy es Iǯguldimás p ás ás Ewángeliu an koǯnos Nedelios i
Sʒwen es’ pe wisus me us]
ku ios págal budá sená Báǯnicǯioy
which.nom.sg.m acco ding way.acc.sg old.acc.sg.m chu ch.loc.sg
Diewá es skái omos
God.gen.sg aux.p s.3 ead.p s.pp.nom.pl.
‘[ThisLi huanianPos ilis hesimpleexplana iono heGospel o e e y
Sundayandholiday h ough heyea ],whichacco ding o heold adi ionis
eadin heCong ega iono heGod.’
Zinke ičius(1998:247)accusesMo kūnaso manymis akes,bu hesame
canno besaidabou Bi ne iso S eponasJaugelisTelega– enownedlanguage
expe so hei ime(Zinke ičius1988:216–223).In he50yea solde ex o
Knyga nobažnys ės, heonlycons uc ionexp essing his ypeo passi eiss ill
es i + m-pa iciple.
(35)1653KN
35… ki a i ȧ dángus ku ion
o he .nom.sg. be.p s.3 hea en.nom.sg which.ill.sg
wisi wie ni i pábȧni
all.nom.pl.m ai h ul.nom.pl.m and de ou .nom.pl.m Ʒmones
people.nom.pl
siunćiámi es i
send.p s.pp.nom.pl.m aux.p s.3
‘…di e en is heHea en owhichall ai h ulandde ou peoplea esen .’
Wha his ype o dis ibu ion o cons uc ionwi hes i can indica e?O
cou se,i canbeassumed ha somewhe ebe ween he16 hand17 hcen u ies,
he e bes i eappea edonceagainas hede aul auxilia y o hem-pa iciple,
bu his seems unlikely. The eason o such a la ge disc epancy be ween
Daukšaand heo he au ho s om heLDK,asal eadymen ioned,shouldbe
sough in heo igino heau ho o hePos ille.The e o e,i canbeassumed
ha Daukša’s ex ,whichisa ep esen a i eo heCen aldialec ,wasa leas
in luencedby heWes e ndialec in his espec ,whichseems obecon i med
bybo h heda a ega ding he -andm-pa iciples.
While he examples ci ed so a ha e no been nume ous, he ex o
Chylinskis’ Bible seems o con i m he hesis ha in he e i o y o he
LDK, hecons uc iono y a + m-pa iciplehasno ye beende eloped.In
hemen ioned ansla ion,ou o 266examples,onlyse encons uc ionsa e
combinedwi hy a.Fou a eusedwi h hepa iciplezynoma ‘known’andone
S aipsniai / A icles 139
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
wi hwadynama ‘called’andno szaukiamas ‘no called’–sooneshouldconside
hemaslexicalizeda ibu i eo modaluses a he han heac ualpassi e.
(36)1660ChB
a… ana di wa ju liezuwe
ha .nom.sg. ield.nom.sg 3.pl.gen.m ongue.loc.sg
wadynama i a Akeldama
call.p s.pp.nom.sg. aux.p s.3 pn.nom
‘… ha ieldiscalledin hei p ope ongue,Aceldama…’
b [Jog nes zymus ziankłas pada y as i a pe jos,]
zynoma i a wisiemus ku ie giwena
know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 all.da .pl.m which.nom.pl.m li e.p s.3
Je uzalej
pn.loc.sg
‘[Fo ha indeedano ablemi acleha hbeendoneby hem]ismani es oall
hem ha dwellinJe usalem.’
Onlyoneexamplecanbein e p e edas heac ionalpassi e:
(37)1660ChB
[Be ep aszo jos wie oy, as nes ku sej abejoia ligus i a]
Wilniey ma iu, ku sej wa omas i a
wa e.da .sg sea.gen.pl which.da .sg mo e.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s.3
nog wejaus
om wind.gen.sg
‘[Bu le himaskin ai h,no hingwa e ing.Fo he ha wa e e hislike]a
wa eo hesead i enwi h hewind…’
Mos examples(259)wi hapassi ebasedon hem-pa icipleinChylinskis’
ex use he e b es i. Among hem, one can also ind cons uc ions wi h
hepa iciplesmen ionedinexamples(36)and(37),bu he ea eonly6o
hem.Theo e whelmingmajo i ya epassi econs uc ionsco esponding o
con empo a ydu a i eandhabi ualuseo hem-pa iciple.
(38)1660ChB
a…[ eywanis e] nog Izaoka paszławinime jo
om pn.gen.sg blessing.loc.sg 3.sg.m.gen
paźadama i pas yp ynama es
p omise.p s.pp.nom.sg. and en o ce.p s.pp.nom.sg. aux.p s.3
‘…[he i age]isp omisedand ein o cedbyIsaac’sblessing.’
PAWEŁBRUDZYŃSKI
140 Ac aLinguis icaLi huanicaXCI
bIz aeli ey pamuszami es nog Filis ynu
pn.nom.pl de ea .p s.pp.nom.pl.m aux.p s.3 om pn.gen.pl
‘Is aeli eswasde ea edbyPhilis ines.’
cPas yp ynamas es asabliwu api eyszkimu
ein o ce.p s.pp.nom.sg.m aux.p s. 3peculia .ins.sg.m e ela ion.ins.sg
‘Was ein o cedbypeculia e ela ion.’
Asin hecaseo he -pa iciple, he ea econs uc ionswi haho a i e
p e ix (39a) and a nega ion p e ix (39b). Howe e , hese a e jus i e such
examples:
(39)1660ChB
aWiezliwis e jusu ’es pazys ama wisiem[us]
mode a ion.nom.sg 2.pl.gen aux.p s.3.ho know.p s.pp.nom.sg. all.acc.pl.m
zmonem[us]
man.acc.pl
‘Le you mode a ionbeknownun oallmen.’
b… jeygu wel n’es wadojama
i again aux.p s.3.neg edeem.p s.pp.nom.sg.
ada bus pa do pagal apwe ynima
hen be. u .3 sell.ps .pp.n acco ding o es ima ion.acc.sg
awo
2.sg.poss
‘…i i isno edeemed, heni shallbesoldacco ding o hyes ima ion.’
Thismayindica e ha he e bes i,whichcouldha especialized unc ions
incons uc ionswi ha -pa iciple,is a he ade aul auxilia yin hecaseo
an m-pa iciple.Thishypo hesismayalsobesuppo edby he ac ha manyo
heexamplescomeno om he ex o heBiblei sel bu omin oduc ions
ochap e s ha a eno inspi edby hesou ceo he ansla ionand e lec he
idiolec o heau ho himsel –and he e o e heac uallanguageo heCen al
dialec o hesecondhal o he17 hcen u y.
Bi ne is’ ex , which is 40 yea s olde , he si ua ion changes, and he
dis ibu iono bo hauxilia iesa ealmos equal(45%–es iand55%–y a).
The eisnoappa en di e encebe ween heuseo bo h e bs,bu hepassi e
wi hes iseemsmo eac ional.A hesame ime,incombina ionwi hy a, he e
a emo elexicalizedo a ibu i e o ms.
S aipsniai / A icles 141
Disappea ance o he auxilia y e b es i in he Li huanian passi e
(40)1701BNT
a… duk ė mano sunkey mucʒijama
daugh e .nom.sg 1.sg.poss.nom. g ie ously ex.p s.pp.nom.sg.
es i nůg Welnio
aux.p s.3 om de il.gen.sg
‘…mydaugh e isg ie ously exedwi hade il.’
b[G óma a] skai oma i a nůg wissû
book.nom.sg ead.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 om all.gen.pl
ʒmonû
man.gen.pl
‘Bookis eadbyallmen.’
(41)1701BNT
aTegul jumus wissiemus žinoma es i
shall 2.pl.da all.da .pl.m know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3
‘Bei knownun oyouall…’
bNes žinoma i a jog Wießpa s
because know.p s.pp.n aux.p s.3 ha Lo d.nom.sg
musu ißėjo iß plemês Iudos
1.pl.gen go.ps .3 om ibe.gen.sg pn.gen
‘Fo i ise iden ha ou Lo dsp angou o Juda…’
This mayindica e ha he u n o he 17 h and 18 hcen u ies was when
hees icons uc ionbegan o allin odisuse.Gied ai is’ ex hasonlyone
cons uc ionwi h he e bes iou o 43.I can, he e o e,beassumed ha
hiscons uc ionwasnolonge p oduc i ein he19 hcen u y.Al hough,as
in hecaseo heP ussiandialec , heexac da eo heg amma icaliza iono
hecons uc ionwi hy acanno begi en,i mus ha eoccu eda he u n
o he18 hand19 hcen u iesa hela es ,i.e.,o e 100yea sla e .Theda a
om heEas e ndialec a eindeed agmen a y.Howe e , heabsenceo he
discussedcons uc ionin heexamined ex smaybea eason oclaim ha his
cons uc ionmus ha ede elopedandbeeng amma icalizede enla e .
4. CONCLUSIONS
His o ically, he hi dpe sono heLi huanian e bbū i ‘ obe’used he o m
es i,co esponding oo he Bal icandIndo-Eu opeanlanguages(c .P ussian
as ;Polishjes ,La ines ,Ge manis ,e c.).Howe e ,due o heseman icshi ,