scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig) [lt] [de] [fr] [it] [es] [pt]

Predicaments of Legal Terminology Translation of EU-Georgia Association Agreement

Abstract

Straipsnyje nagrinėjamos terminų vertimo problemos ES asociacijos susitarime su Sakartvelu, pasitelkiant pavyzdžius iš Batumio Šotos Rustavelio valstybiniame universitete specialiai sukurto tekstyno. Nors ekspertai dėl aiškumo pataria vengti terminų variantiškumo (Strandvik 2012; DGT 2015; Bajčić, Martinović 2018; Kordić 2020), tyrime argumentuojama, kad variantiškumas ES tekstuose ne visada lemia nevienodumą kartvelų kalboje. Pavyzdžiui, angliški terminai counterfeiting (klastojimas), forging (klastojimas) ir false (klaidingas) kartvelų kalboje perteikiami vienu terminu გაყალბება [gaq’albeba], neprarandant tikslumo. Panašiai yra ir su terminais circumvention (vengimas) bei evasion (vengimas): abu jie verčiami kaip სანქციებისგან თავის არიდება [sank̕c̕iebisgan t̕avis arideba], išlaikant prasmę. Tai rodo, kad kvazisinoniminiai variantai anglų kalboje gali būti verčiami vienu kartvelišku atitikmeniu. Straipsnyje taip pat pabrėžiamas poreikis iki vertimo atlikti analizę ir nurodyti terminologinius išteklius, siekiant perteikti sąvokų skirtumus. Konvergencijos ir aproksimacijos painiojimas laikant jas sinonimais arba netinkamas Anti-Circumvention Mechanism (Kovos su vengimu priemonė) vertimas kaip Anti-Counterfeiting Mechanism (Kovos su klastojimu priemonė) parodo, kad kontekstinės analizės nepaisymas gali iškraipyti prasmę.

Read accessible full text

Predicaments of Legal Terminology Translation of EU-Georgia Association Agreement

Author: Khatuna Beridze
Year: 2025
DOI: 10.35321/term32-05
Source: https://journals.lki.lt/terminologija/article/download/2436/2483
Te minologija / Te minology
2025, ol. 32, pp. 1–14
Con en s link / Tu inio nuo oda
ISSN 2669-2198 (online / elek oninis)
Copy igh © 2025 Kha una Be idze. Published by he Ins i u e o he Li huanian Language. This is an Open
Access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion Licence, which pe mi s
un es ic ed use, dis ibu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal au ho and sou ce a e
c edi ed. // Išleido Lie u ių kalbos ins i u as. Šis s aipsnis y a a i os p ieigos, pla inamas pagal „C ea i e
Commons‚ p isky imo licencijos sąlygas, leidžiančias ne ibo ai naudo i, pla in i i a ku i u inį be kokioje
laikmenoje, nu odan au o ių i šal inį.
Recei ed: / Gau a: 2024-12-09. Accep ed: / P iim a: 2025-08-27. 1
PREDICAMENTS OF LEGAL TERMINOLOGY TRANSLATION OF
EU-GEORGIA ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT
Teisės e minijos e imo sunkumai ES i Saka elo asociacijos susi a ime
KHATUNA BERIDZE
Ba umi Sho a Rus a eli S a e Uni e si y
E-mail: [email p o ec ed].ge
ORCID ID: h ps://o cid.o g/0000-0001-5333-0722
Fields o esea ch: T ansla ion S udies, Co pus linguis ics, Legal e minology ansla ion, Li e a y
ansla ion, Pos colonial ansla ion heo y and p ac ice, Cogni i e linguis ics and ansla ion.
h ps://doi.o g/10.35321/ e m32-05
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ABSTRACT
The pape examines e minology ansla ion p oblems in he EU-Geo gia Associa ion Ag eemen us-
ing examples om a cus om-buil co pus a Ba umi Sho a Rus a eli S a e Uni e si y. While expe s ecom-
mend a oiding e m a ia ion o cla i y (S and ik 2012; DGT 2015; Bajčić & Ma ino ić 2018; Ko dić 2020),
he s udy a gues ha a ia ion in EU ex s may no always cause inconsis ency in Geo gian. Fo example, Eng-
lish e ms coun e ei ing, o ging, and alse con e ge in o one Geo gian e m, გაყალბება [gaq’albeba], wi hou
loss o accu acy. Simila ly, ci cum en ion and e asion bo h ansla e as სანქციებისგან თავის არიდება
[sank c iebisgan a is a ideba], p ese ing meaning. This shows ha quasi-synonymous a ian s in English can
be ende ed by one Geo gian equi alen . The pape also s esses he need o p e- ansla ional analysis and
e e encing o e minological esou ces o cap u e concep ual dis inc ions. Misuse o con e gence and app oxi-
ma ion as synonyms, o mis ansla ing An i-Ci cum en ion Mechanism as An i-Coun e ei ing Mechanism,
demons a e how neglec ing con ex ual analysis can dis o meaning.
KEYWORDS: legal ansla ion, e minological colloca ions, a ia ion, co pus-based, EU-Geo gia Associa ion
Ag eemen .
ANOTACIJA
S aipsnyje nag inėjamos e minų e imo p oblemos ES asociacijos susi a ime su Saka elu,
pasi elkian pa yzdžius iš Ba umio Šo os Rus a elio als ybiniame uni e si e e specialiai suku o eks yno.
No s ekspe ai dėl aiškumo pa a ia eng i e minų a ian iškumo (S and ik 2012; DGT 2015; Bajčić,
Ma ino ić 2018; Ko dić 2020), y ime a gumen uojama, kad a ian iškumas ES eks uose ne isada lemia
2
ne ienodumą ka elų kalboje. Pa yzdžiui, angliški e minai coun e ei ing (klas ojimas), o ging (klas ojimas) i
alse (klaidingas) ka elų kalboje pe eikiami ienu e minu გაყალბება [gaq’albeba], nep a andan ikslumo.
Panašiai y a i su e minais ci cum en ion ( engimas) bei e asion ( engimas): abu jie e čiami kaip
სანქციებისგან თავის არიდება [sank c iebisgan a is a ideba], išlaikan p asm . Tai odo, kad
k azisinoniminiai a ian ai anglų kalboje gali bū i e čiami ienu ka elišku a i ikmeniu. S aipsnyje aip pa
pab ėžiamas po eikis iki e imo a lik i analiz i nu ody i e minologinius iš eklius, siekian pe eik i są okų
ski umus. Kon e gencijos i ap oksimacijos painiojimas laikan jas sinonimais a ba ne inkamas An i-
Ci cum en ion Mechanism (Ko os su engimu p iemonė) e imas kaip An i-Coun e ei ing Mechanism (Ko os
su klas ojimu p iemonė) pa odo, kad kon eks inės analizės nepaisymas gali išk aipy i p asm .
ESMINIAI ŽODŽIAI: eisinis e imas, e minologinės kolokacijos, a ian iškumas eks yno duomenų
pag indu, ES asociacijos susi a imas su Saka elu.
INTRODUCTION
To ensu e he quali y o mul ilingual legisla i e ex s in he Eu opean Union, se e al
ini ia i es ha e been es ablished, including he Eu opean Commission’s Di ec o a e-Gene al
o T ansla ion, he JRC-Acquis co pus, and he IATE e minology da abase main ained by
he Di ec o a e-Gene al o T ansla ion o he Eu opean Pa liamen . Addi ionally,
heo e ical and empi ical s udies le e aging co pus me hodologies ha e add essed he
challenges o ansla ing mul ilingual legal ex s, leading o he de elopmen o a ious
ecommenda ions. The Eu opean Commission’s Di ec o a e-Gene al o T ansla ion has
implemen ed a quali y managemen amewo k o ensu e ha ansla ions mee he needs o
di ec clien s, pa ne o ganisa ions, and end-use s (DGT T ansla ion Quali y Guidelines
2015: 1). Howe e , despi e he a ailabili y o ad anced echnological ools, linguis ic
esou ces, and me hodological guidelines, challenges in ansla ing legal e minology ex s
pe sis ac oss all EU Membe S a es. Edi ing p ocesses ha e iden i ied common ansla ion
e o s, ca ego ised as inco ec ansla ions, inapp op ia e e minology, omissions,
edundancies, and issues ela ed o cla i y, g amma , spelling, and punc ua ion (S e aniak
2023: 366). In Li huania, he Go e nmen adop ed a esolu ion in 1999, which assigned he
T ansla ion, Documen a ion and In o ma ion Cen e o ansla e he acquis. The acquis,
consis ing o p ima y and seconda y binding legisla ion, and ep esen ing a conside able 95
olumes o ac s, oughly es ima ed a 60,000–70,000 pages o he O icial Jou nal (q d. om
he ‘Regula Repo om he qua Commission on Li huania’s P og ess Towa ds Accession’
2002: 130)
1
. Compa ably, as pa o he EU ascending p ocedu es, ansla ion o he
Geo gian-EU Associa ion Ag eemen , a i ied in 2014 by he EU Pa liamen , comp ises 750
pages by now. The ask o ansla ion o he EU-Geo gia Associa ion Ag eemen (AA) was
ini ially assigned o he ansla ion depa men a he Fo eign Minis y o Geo gia, and la e
e-assigned o he ansla ion depa men a he Minis y o Jus ice.
The p esen a icle is pa o a la ge -scale co pus-based s udy o he EU-Geo gia AA
o de elop a co pus-based ansla ion analysis and me hodology o he ansla ed Acquis, as
well as legal ex s (Be idze, Diasamidze 2025: 354). The objec i e o he pape is o ou line
1
A ailable a : www.eu opa l.eu opa.eu/mee docs/commi ees/empl/20021021/02-1406EN.pd .
3
he u gency o he e minological uni o mi y and unde sco e he c i ical need o a
consis en , uni ied and s anda dised app oach o legal e minology managemen in Geo gia,
as pa and pa cel o he na ion’s Eu opean in eg a ion e o s. To ensu e ac cu a e and
e ec i e implemen a ion o he AA, he pape examines how quasi-synonymous legal e ms
and e minological colloca ions in English a e ansla ed in o Geo gian and how
e minological a ia ions lead o seman ic inconsis encies/inaccu acies. The esea ch seeks
o de e mine o wha ex en e minological a ia ion, whe he in ol ing single e ms o
colloca ions, impac s he unc ional equi alence o ansla ed legal con en . The s udy
ecommends p e- ansla ional e m analysis, con ex ual in e p e a ion, and he consul a ion
o au ho i a i e e minological da abases (such as IATE) in mi iga ing concep ual and
seman ic di e gence.
THEORETICAL APPROACHES TO LEGAL TRANSLATION
L. Biel (2019: 25, 26) summa ises se e al ypes o linguis ic- ansla ional challenges
ha accompany he d a ing o EU ex s: ‚ he sou ce ex /language/cul u e, a ge
ex /language/cul u e, equi alence, ansla ion p ocess, quali y‛. EU mul ilingual ex s mus
be consis en in con en and e minology, ‚be ween each o he (which is e e ed o as
mul ilingual conco dance)‛ (S e aniak 2017:117), which means no only equi alence wi h
he o iginal ex , bu also conco dance be ween all e sions o he same ex in 23
languages. Koskinen calls equi ale nce ‚a p io i‛ ea u e o EU ansla ion (Koskinen 2000:
49, q d. in Biel 2019: 25). The o iginal i sel c ea es se e al di icul ies o he EU: when a
ex is w i en in he so-called o iginal language, i akes 5–10 s eps o align i wi h o he
language ex s. The p ocess is ca ied ou by cons an ly swi ching om language o
language, compa ing, making changes and ew i ing (see Doczekalska 2009: 360; Koskinen
2001: 293), and he inal documen may di e signi ican ly om he o iginal ex (Koskinen
2001: 293).
Legal ex s in Eu opean languages, including English, a e cha ac e ised by he
in luence o La inisms. This in luence o igina es om he ansla ion o Roman law
documen s om La in (G aziadei e al. 2005: 45) and con inues o shape he s ylis ic ea u es
o mode n legal ex s in hese languages (Biel 2014: 332–333; Ko dić 2020: 235–236). In
addi ion o La inisms, ansla ing legal ex s and e minology is complica ed by o he
ac o s, such as a ia ions in e minology ac oss legal and legisla i e documen s.
Biel (2023: 90) dis inguishes be ween he concep s: a ia ion, synonymy and polysemy
d awing on a de ini ion o a e m in he ISO e minology s anda ds (ISO 1087 2019: 3, 7),
s a ing ha a legal e m can be de ined as a designa ion – a linguis ic exp ession – which
ep esen s a concep , ha is a uni o knowledge, in he legal domain. In he ideal wo ld, a
concep is e oked by one e m only; ha is, he e is a one- o-one ela ion o o m and
meaning, known as uni oci y o mono e e en iali y. I is wo h no ing ha he e minology
ield nowadays p e e s he e m a ia ion and a ian o e synonymy (Biel 2023: 91–92).
When d a ing o ansla ing legisla i e ex s, expe s ecommend a oiding a ia ion o
4
e ms o enhance consis ency and cla i y (S and ik 2012: 39–40; DGT T ansla ion Quali y
Guidelines 2015: 11; Bajčić, Ma ino ić 2018: 212; Ko dić 2020: 241). The exis ence o
e m a ia ion in ex s is no a new linguis ic phenomenon. Fo example, Gambashidze
(1988) discussed how synonymy a ises when e e yday ocabula y is adap ed as e minology.
This esea che also highligh ed ha he bo owing o o eign wo ds o en leads o
synonymy, wi h in e na ional e ms coexis ing alongside na i e ones. Gambashidze (1988:
38–40) ad oca ed o he isomo phism o concep s in e minology and c i icised he
eme gence o lexical double s in language. Since he law pe mea es e e yday li e, legal
e minology o en o e laps wi h common ocabula y. Wo ds o igina ing om e e yday
language equen ly acqui e specialised legal meanings (Ko dić 2020: 235–236). Fo
ins ance, English legal ja gon o a single concep may include synonymous e ms like
iola ion, b each, in ingemen , and null and oid (Gozdz-Roszkowski 2013). This o e lap
be ween common ocabula y and legal e minology can lead o seman ic ambigui y, a
challenge also no ed in Geo gian (Ghambashidze 1986; A abuli 2016; Ma gali adze 2020).
S udies e eal he inc easing use o common wo ds as legal e ms.
Legal communica ion, like any specialised communica ion, ope a es unde a ious
cons ain s. F om an onomasiological poin o iew, lexemes a e synonymous and
equi alen i hey ha e he same deno a i e meaning. I is conside ed essen ial o combine
onomasiological app oaches ( ocusing on de ining concep s) wi h semasiological ones, and
s udy he meanings o synonymous e ms and common wo ds in speci ic con ex s (Heylen,
S eu s 2014: 96).
TRANSLATION PROBLEMS IN THE ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT FOR
GEORGIA
Resea ch me hodology
To ca y ou he esea ch o he p esen pape , I used he esou ces o he co pus
analyse which I de eloped a he T ansla ion and In e disciplina y Resea ch Cen e o
Ba umi Sho a Rus a eli S a e Uni e si y (The co pus o he BSU T ansla ion and
In e disciplina y Cen e, www.co pus.bsu.edu.ge) speci ically o he co pus-based
ansla ion esea ch, including analyses and me hodology o he ansla ed Acquis, as well
as legal ex s. The cus om-buil unidi ec ional co pus comp ises EU-Geo gia AA, Ti les I–
IV and A icles 1–276 in bo h English and Geo gian. Legal e ms we e manually agged
du ing he ex ual ma kup s age using cus om XML ags de eloped o he pla o m
www.co pus.bsu.edu.ge, al hough he TagSe did no ollow s anda d ag assignmen
p o ocols. The p ocessing was conduc ed in h ee s ages: compa a i e analysis o pa allel
ex s, agging, and manual alignmen o English and Geo gian A icles in XML o ma . The
co pus is encoded in XML acco ding o TEI P4 s anda ds, wi h each language o ming a
sepa a e TEI body. The so wa e au oma ically aligns bilingual ex s and gene a es bilingual
lexicons o each XML ile. I also p o ides s a is ical da a on e m dis ibu ion, which
5
suppo s he pos -ex ac ion quali a i e analysis and he e alua ion o legal ansla ion
quali y.
Resul s and discussion
The ollowing analysis will ocus on speci ic examples. An example below, ex ac ed
(Figu e 1)
2
, is pa o he ansla ion analysis o he EU-Geo gia Associa ion Ag eemen
conduc ed a he Cen e o T ansla ion and In e disciplina y S udies a Ba umi Sho a
Rus a eli S a e Uni e si y. I illus a es he ins ance when e ms con e gence and
app oxima ion a e conside ed as ei he synonymous o quasi-synonymous, and ansla ed
wi h he same e m, as ound in Ti le II, A icle 3, Objec i es o Poli ical Dialogue, o he
ansla ion o he Geo gia-EU Associa ion Ag eemen .
Figu e 1. Sc eensho 1 om he co pus o he BSU T ansla ion and In e disciplina y Cen e,
www.co pus.bsu.edu.ge
Figu e 2. Sc eensho 2 om he co pus o he BSU T ansla ion and In e disciplina y Cen e,
www.co pus.bsu.edu.ge
The pa ag aph illus a es (Figu e 2) ha he ansla ion p o ides he e m
დაახლოება
[daakhloeba]
3
as he ansla ional equi alen o he English e m con e gence:
2
A ailable a : www.co pus.bsu.edu.ge.
3
Fo ansli e a ion o Geo gian I use Geo gian – Na ional ansli e a ion sys em, see:
h ps://www. ansli e a ion.com/ ansli e a ion/en/geo gian/iso-9984/.

6
To deepen poli ical associa ion and inc ease poli ical and secu i y policy con e gence
and e ec i eness.
გააღრმაოს პოლიტიკური ასოცირება და გაზარდოს პოლიტიკური
და უსაფრთხოების პოლიტიკის საკითხებზე
დაახლოება
და ეფექტიანობა.
gaaḡ maos poli iku i asoc i eba da gaza dos poli iku i da usap xoebis poli ikis
saki xebze daaxloeba da ep ek ianoba.
The e a e o he ins ances, including he e m con e gence and i s Geo gian
ansla ion as
დაახლოება
. All in all, he e a e 102 cases o he e m con e gence ansla ed
as daakhloeba in 390 a icles o he Body ex , excluding annexes. An exce p om he same
ex and i s ansla ion poin s ou ha he same e ms a e epea edly used in he sou ce and
ansla ion ex s, and daakhloeba is sugges ed as he ansla ional equi alen o he e m
con e gence, as he example om he co pus e i ies (Figu e 3):
(k) o p o ide all bene i s o close poli ical
associa ion (lg_ m) be ween he EU and Geo gia,
including inc eased secu i y policy (lg_ m)
con e gence o all ci izens o Geo gia wi hin
i s in e na ionally ecognised bo de s (lg_ m).
(k) უზრუნველყოს, რომ საქართველოსა და
ევროკავშირს შორის მჭიდრო პოლიტიკური
ასოცირების (lg_ m) შედეგად მიღებული ყველა
სარგებელი, გაზრდილი უსაფრთხოების
პოლიტიკის (lg_ m) საკითხებზე
დაახლოების ჩათვლით, გავრცელდეს
საქართველოს ყველა
მოქალაქეზე, საერთაშორისოდ აღიარებულ
საზღვრებში (lg_ m).
Figu e 3. Ti le II, A icle 3
Apa om he abo e examples, including he con ex ual use o he e m con e gence
in he colloca ions: poli ical and secu i y policy con e gence, secu i y policy con e gence o all
ci izens o Geo gia, he o he example is con e gence on o eign and secu i y ma e s:
This will inc ease he e ec i eness o poli ical coope a ion and p omo e con e gence
on o eign and secu i y ma e s.
აღნიშნული გაზრდის პოლიტიკური თანამშრომლობის ეფექტიანობასა და
ხელს შეუწყობს
საგარეო
და
უსაფრთხოების
პოლიტიკის
საკითხებზე
დაახლოებას
.
Full pa ag aph o he example is p o ided om he co pus (Figu e 4):
7
Poli ical dialogue on all a eas o mu ual in e es ,
including o eign and secu i y ma e s (lg_ m)
as well as domes ic e o m (lg_ m), shall be
u he de eloped and s eng hened be ween he
Pa ies. This will inc ease he e ec i eness
o poli ical coope a ion (lg_ m) and p omo e
con e gence on o eign and secu i y
ma e s (lg_ m), s eng hening ela ions in an
inno a i e way.
პოლიტიკური დიალოგი საერთო ინტერესთა ყველა
სფეროში, საგარეო და უსაფრთხოების
საკითხებისა (lg_ m) და შიდასახელმწიფოებრივი
რეფორმის (lg_ m) ჩათვლით, მხარეებს შორის კიდევ
უფრო განვითარდება და გაღრმავდება. აღნიშნული
გაზრდის პოლიტიკური თანამშრომლობის (lg_ m)
ეფექტიანობასა და ხელს შეუწყობს საგარეო და
უსაფრთხოების პოლიტიკის (lg_ m) საკითხებზე
დაახლოებას, ურთიერთობების
გაძლიერებას ამბიციური და ინოვაციური გზით.
Figu e 4. Ti le II, A icle 3
In back ansla ion, he Geo gian e m daakhloeba co esponds o he English e m
app oxima ion, which ansla ion assumes as a a ian o he English e m. Howe e , in
IATE de ini ions, con e gence and app oxima ion deno e dis inc concep s and a e no
synonyms/ a ian s. Fo ins ance, in he IATE en y 3564197, hese e ms deno e di e en
concep s, ha ing di e en seman ic alue: ‚Commi ee on Economic In eg a ion, Legal
App oxima ion and Con e gence wi h EU Pol icies‛. The i le iden i ies he ole o he
s anding pa liamen a y commi ee wi hin he Eu ones Pa liamen a y Assembly, which is
esponsible o u he economic app oxima ion be ween he EU and i s Eas e n Eu opean
Pa ne s, suppo ing he socio-economic e o ms o he Eas e n Eu opean Pa ne s, as well
as ade and in es men libe aliza ion, leading o con e gence wi h EU laws and s anda ds o
es ablish a ne wo k o deep and comp ehensi e ee ade a eas. The unc ion o he
commi ee indica es aking a se ies o s ep-by-s ep p ocedu es aimed a achie ing common
poli ical goals, demons a ing again ha app oxima ion and con e gence a e wo dis inc
e ms and do no ep esen quasi-synonymous unc ional equi alen s. When ansla ing his
en y in o Geo gian, using only one e m daakhloeba would no longe su ice o con ey he
meanings o bo h App oxima ion and Con e gence. Hence, i s ansla ion shall be:
ეკონომიკური ინტეგრაციის სამართლებრივი
დაახლოებისა
და ევროკავშირის
პოლიტიკასთან
თანხვედრის
კომისია [ekonomiku i in eg ac iis sama leb i i
daaxloebisa da e oka ši is poli ikas an anx ed is komisia] ‘Commi ee on Economic
In eg a ion, Legal App oxima ion and Con e gence wi h EU Policies’. As es ed in he
conco dance , he e m n ( anx ed is is a case o m o he e m) is concep ually and
seman ically co esponding equi alen o con e gence. Simila ly, i s a ian
თანხვდომა
[ anx doma] can also be conside ed as a unc ional equi alen o he e m con e gence.
Fu he mo e, he e minological dic iona y o he Geo gian Legisla i e He ald o e s
bo h ansli e a ion and ansla ion o he e m con e gence in a ious con ex s. The
ins ance o he ansli e a ion o con e gence as კონვერგენცია [kon e genc ia] yields no
8
u he examples, while he ansla ion o he colloca ion con e gence o a numbe sequence
as რიცხვითი მიმდევრობის კრებადობა [ ic x i i mimde obis k ebadoba] ‘collec i i y
o a nume ical sequence’ back ansla es he e m as concep ually and seman ically di e ing
a ian . I allows o e minological a ia ion o he La in e m and he mis ansla ed
Geo gian a ian daakhloeba ha exace ba es he p oblem.
The ollowing example (Figu e 5) is om A icle 2, pa ag aph 24, o Ti le IV o he
Ag eemen :
Acquis Eng. ST que y ile xml 4444
Ti le IV Sec ion 2 A icle 24
Acquis Geo. TT que y ile xml 4444
Ti le IV Sec ion 2 A icle 24
4. The impo o p oduc s o igina ing in Geo gia
lis ed in Annex II-C o his Ag eemen shall be
subjec o he an i-ci cum en ion
mechanism (lng_ m) se ou in A icle 27 o his
Ag eemen .
4. საქართველოში წარმოშობილი პროდუქტის
იმპორტი, რომელიც ჩამოთვლილია ამ
შეთანხმების II-C დანართში, დაექვემდებარება
გაყალბების საწინააღმდეგო მექანიზმს (lng_ m)
წინამდებარე შეთანხმების 27-ე მუხლის
შესაბამისად.
A icle 27
მუხლი 27
An i-ci cum en ion mechanism (lng_ m) o
ag icul u al p oduc s and p ocessed ag icul u al
p oduc s
1. The p oduc s lis ed in Annex II-C o his
Ag eemen a e subjec o he an i-ci cum en ion
mechanism (lng_ m) se ou in his A icle. The
a e age annual olume o impo s om Geo gia in o
he Union o each o hose p oduc s is p o ided in
Annex II-C o his Ag eemen .
გაყალბების საწინააღმდეგო მექანიზმი (lng_ m)
სასოფლო-სამეურნეო პროდუქტებისა და
სასოფლო-სამეურნეო გადამუშავებული
პროდუქტებისთვის
1. წინამდებარე შეთანხმების II-C დანართში
მოცემული პროდუქტები ექვემდებარება ამ
მუხლით განსაზღვრულ გაყალბების
საწინააღმდეგო მექანიზმს (lng_ m) ამ
პროდუქტების თითოეული კატეგორიის
საქართველოდან ევროკავშირში იმპორტის
საშუალო წლიური მოცულობა მოცემულია ამ
შეთანხმების II-C დანართში
Figu e 5. Ti le IV A icle 2, pa ag aph 24
The example illus a es ha he e m an i-ci cum en ion mechanism is ansla ed as
გაყალბების საწინააღმდეგო მექანიზმი [gaq’albebis sa s’inaaghmdego mekanizmi]
which is back ansla ed as an i-coun e ei ing mechanism. Acco ding o he IATE sou ce
3575478, he e m ci cum en ion de ice is de ined as: any con ol de ice, so wa e,
9
componen o pa ha al e s he ene gy demand on a p oduc du ing any es p ocedu e,
esul ing in measu emen s ha a e un ep esen a i e o he p oduc 's ue cha ac e is ics ha
occu du ing no mal use unde compa able condi ions. Depending on i s unc ion, he e m
an i-ci cum en ion mechanism can be mo e accu a ely ansla ed as მანიპულაციის
საწინააღმდეგო მექანიზმი [manipulac iis sacinaaḡmdego mek anizmi] ha back ansla es
as an i-manipula ion mechanism, while ci cum en ion de ice can be ansla ed as
მანიპულაციის ხელსაწყო [manipuli ebis xelsacqo] ha back ansla es as manipula ion
de ice. Addi ionally, he IATE sou ce 141062 includes he e m an i-ci cum en ion
measu e, which can also be ansla ed as მანიპულაციის საწინააღმდეგო ზომა
[manipulac iis sacinaaḡmdego zoma] ha in English back ansla ion would be an i-
manipula ion measu e. The e m gaq’albebis sa s’inaaghmdego (an i-coun e ei ing) ails o
cap u e he o iginal meaning, which implies ha he law is ci cum en ed h ough
echnological in e en ion.
Theo e icians ad oca e o de e mining he quali a i e and quan i a i e
co espondence o sou ce and a ge e ms o hei equi alence wi hin a speci ic con ex ,
emphasising he impo ance o bo h con ex and pu pose when ansla ing e ms (de G oo
2006: 424–425). The e m ci cum en ion appea s in o he con ex s; o example, he IATE
sou ce 3628171 lis s sanc ions ci cum en ion and sanc ions e asion as synonymous a ian s.
These e ms a e de ined as: ‘A delibe a e a emp o emo e om a ansac ion o se ies o
ansac ions he pa icipa ion o sanc ioned en i ies, o indi iduals, o o conceal hese ac s’.
In his con ex , he Geo gian e m gaq’albebis / coun e ei ing would no longe se e as a
unc ional equi alen o ci cum en ion; ansli e a ion o he e m in o Geo gian as
სანქციების მანიპულაცია [sank c iebis manipulac ia], sanc ions manipula ion would be
mo e app op ia e. Using სანქციების გაყალბება [sank c iebis gaqalbeba] sanc ions
coun e ei ing would dis o he seman ic meaning and ail o p ese e he equi alen
meaning (Reiß & Ve mee 2014: 29) o he o iginal ph ase. Rega ding he e minological
a ian s: sanc ions e asion and sanc ions ci cum en ion, he e ms ci cum en ion and
e asion unc ion as con ex ual synonyms. In Geo gian hese a ian e ms a e ansla ed as
სანქციებისგან თავის არიდება [sank c iebisgan a is a ideba], back ansla ed as sanc ions
a oidance. T ansla ing bo h sanc ions ci cum en ion and sanc ions e asion as sank c iebisgan
a is a ideba esul s in a single Geo gian equi alen o wo dis inc English a ian e ms. I
one o he a ian e ms: sanc ions ci cum en ion and sanc ions e asion we e ansla ed as
სანქციების მანიპულაცია [sank c iebis manipulac ia] back ansla ed as manipula ion o he
sanc ions, i would esul in he eme gence o a ian e ms in Geo gian: sank c iebis
manipulac ia and sank c iebisgan a is a ideba. The e m e asion also appea s in con ex s like
ax e asion, o which he Geo gian language had an ea lie es ablished equi alen
გადასახადებისგან თავის არიდება [gadasaxadebisgan a is a ideba], back ansla ed as
ax a oidance, and, p esumably, he same Geo gian e m was ex apola ed on he wo
English a ian e ms.