Taming he Space: Seman ic Modelling
using Linked Open Da a o Fuzzy Wobbling
Geospa ial Da a om he A chaeological
and Geosciences domains
Flo ian Thie y*
1,2
, Fiona Schenk
3,2
, S e anie Baa s
4
,
Alla d W. Mees
1
, Sophie C. Schmid
5,2
, Chia a G.M. Gi o o
6
,
Fabian F icke
7
1 Leibniz-Zen um ü A chäologie (LEIZA) – Mainz, Ge many
2 Resea ch Squi el Enginee s Ne wo k – Mainz, Ge many
3 Johannes Gu enbe g Uni e si ä Mainz (JGU) – Mainz, Ge many
4 Münzkabine , S aa liche Museen zu Be lin, SPK – Be lin, Ge many
5 F ee Uni e si y o Be lin – Be lin, Ge many
6 A chaeobiocen e | LMU Munich – Munich, Ge many
7 Ge man A chaeological Ins i u e (DAI) – Mainz, Ge many
* Co esponding au ho
Co espondence: fl[email p o ec ed]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
A BSTRACT
A chaeological and geoscien ific esea ch o en elies on spa ial da a whose
p ecision and eliabili y a y conside ably. Coo dina es de i ed om exca a ion
epo s, li e a u e, o mode n su eys equen ly embody agueness, ambigui y, o
conflic ing in e p e a ions. This pape add esses such wobbling geospa ial da a by
p esen ing a seman ic app oach ha embeds unce ain y di ec ly in o Linked Open
Da a (LOD). A he co e o his app oach lies he Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology
(FSL-O), which builds on PROV-O, SKOS, and GeoSPARQL o model en i ies, ac i i ies,
and agen s alongside explici p ope ies o ce ain y, p o enance, and
me hodological de ail. I s implemen a ion in he uzzy-sl Wikibase ex ends his
amewo k h ough a dedica ed schema o geoloca ion and coo dina e me ada a,
enabling he documen a ion o p ecision, me hods, sou ces, and ac o s. The SPARQL
Unico n Toolki u he suppo s isualisa ion by in eg a ing hese da a in o GIS
en i onmen s and gene a ing human- eadable HTML ou pu s. The me hodology is
demons a ed h ough in e disciplina y case s udies: Ogham s ones wi h mul iple
biog aphies be ween ancien findspo s and museum con ex s; Campanian Ignimb i e
deposi s se ing as La e Pleis ocene ch onological ma ke s; poo ly documen ed
numisma ic hoa ds om C o on; and Roman Samian wa e dis ibu ions. Each
example illus a es how unce ain y can be exp essed as s uc u ed,
machine- eadable in o ma ion, a he han being hidden o o e simplified. By
embedding uzziness in o LOD, his wo k enhances he FAIRness, anspa ency, and
in e ope abili y o a chaeological and geoscien ific da ase s. I con ibu es o
in e na ional deba es on how o esponsibly ep esen spa ial unce ain y and
p o ides a ounda ion o u u e ex ensions o on ology and Wikibase models ac oss
b oade cul u al he i age and scien ific domains.
Keywo ds: FAIR, Linked Open Da a, unce ain y, A chaeology, Ogham, Samian Wa e,
Geosciences, Campanian Ignimb i e, Wikibase
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
In oduc ion & Backg ound
A chaeological and geoscien ific esea ch is deeply elian on spa ial da a, ye he
p oduc ion and use o such da a a e a ely ee om unce ain y [1], [2]. Coo dina es
de i ed om his o ical sou ces, exca a ion epo s, field su eys, o seconda y li e a u e
o en con ain agueness, ambigui ies, o imp ecision ha complica e hei in e p e a ion
and euse [3], [4], [5], [6]. This si ua ion gi es ise o wha we e e o as “ uzzy wobbling
geospa ial da a”, loca ions ha shi depending on he sou ce, me hod, o in e p e a i e
amewo k employed [7]. Unless such unce ain y is explici ly eco ded, he esul ing
da a canno be conside ed anspa en , ep oducible, o eusable in he long e m.
This challenge aligns di ec ly wi h he FAIR P inciples [8], now widely ecognised as a
co ne s one o mode n esea ch da a managemen . Achie ing FAIRness equi es mo e
han simply publishing da ase s: he con ex o hei c ea ion, including he me hods and
assump ions unde lying geospa ial coo dina es, mus also be documen ed. Fo
a chaeological and geoscien ific da ase s, whe e si e loca ions may be ague o
dispu ed, his anspa ency is essen ial o ensu e us in he da a and o enable
meaning ul euse ac oss disciplina y bounda ies.
Figu e 1 - A dis ibu ed Knowledge G aph Scheme b inging oge he Linked Open
Da a and FAIR Digi al Objec s app oaches. Flo ian Thie y & And eas Noback, CC BY
4.0, ia Wikimedia Commons.
Linked Open Da a (LOD) [9], [10], [11] o e s a amewo k o add essing hese
equi emen s. By ep esen ing in o ma ion in g aph-based s uc u es using s anda ds
such as RDF, SPARQL, and GeoSPARQL [12], [13], LOD allows he e ogeneous da ase s o
be seman ically connec ed and en iched. This app oach has pa icula ele ance o
a chaeology, a discipline ha inhe en ly in eg a es di e se o ms o e idence, om
geological s a ig aphy and palaeoen i onmen al eco ds o a e ac ypologies and
ex ual sou ces. LOD enables he in eg a ion o such e idence wi hin he ede a ed
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
in e disciplina y knowledge g aph (FIKG, Fig. 1), while a he same ime enabling he
explici modelling o unce ain y and p o enance.
The need o explici modelling is especially e iden when spa ial in o ma ion is
ans e ed be ween communi ies and in as uc u es. Geoscien is s may desc ibe a
olcanic e up ion laye in s a ig aphic e ms. A he same ime, a chaeologis s may e e
o associa ed findspo s, and his o ians may only men ion he nea es se lemen wi hou
a sha ed seman ic model ha can cap u e he a ying deg ees o ce ain y, p ecision,
and spa ial e e ence; such in o ma ion isks emaining siloed, ambiguous, o e en
misleading. By con as , modelling unce ain y as pa o he da ase i sel enables a
iche and mo e hones ep esen a ion o he pas .
In ecen yea s, se e al ini ia i es ha e highligh ed he impo ance o documen ing
agueness and unce ain y in geospa ial da a, pa icula ly h ough seman ic
echnologies. The adop ion o on ology-d i en app oaches allows doub s and
imp ecisions o be ep esen ed in a s uc u ed, machine-ac ionable way, a he han
being elega ed o oo no es o omi ed en i ely. This ensu es ha subsequen use s –
whe he domain expe s, in e disciplina y collabo a o s, o compu a ional sys ems – can
in e p e he confidence, me hods, and limi a ions associa ed wi h each spa ial
s a emen .
This pape builds on hese de elopmen s by p esen ing a seman ic modelling
app oach o wobbling geospa ial da a. We ocus on he Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions
On ology (FSL-O), designed o cap u e agueness, unce ain y, and p o enance in
geo e e enced da a. Implemen ed wi hin a ede a ed ecosys em o Wikida a and
dedica ed Wikibase ins ances, FSL-O p o ides a amewo k o in eg a ing
a chaeological and geoscien ific da ase s while making explici he ci cums ances o
hei c ea ion. The pape u he demons a es how his model can be applied in p ac ice
h ough a se ies o in e disciplina y case s udies, anging om ea ly medie al Ogham
s ones o La e Pleis ocene olcanic deposi s and ancien numisma ic hoa ds.
By o eg ounding unce ain y as an in eg al componen o da a modelling, ou
app oach seeks no only o enhance he FAIRness o a chaeological and geoscien ific
da a bu also o p o ide a me hodological ounda ion o hei long- e m in e ope abili y.
In doing so, we aim o con ibu e o a b oade discussion wi hin he CAA communi y on
how bes o ep esen , in eg a e, and euse spa ial da a ha , by i s e y na u e, con inues
o wobble.
Me hodology: SPARQL Unico n & uzzy-sl On ology
The me hodological co e o his pape lies in he seman ic modelling o agueness
and unce ain y in geospa ial da a. While spa ial coo dina es a e ypically ea ed as
fixed and p ecise poin s in da abases, a chaeological and geoscien ific p ac ice e eals
a a mo e complex eali y. Loca ions may be de i ed om exca a ion epo s,
seconda y li e a u e, o al adi ions, o mode n field su eys, each wi h a ying deg ees
o p ecision and confidence. To make such a iabili y anspa en and eusable,
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
unce ain y i sel mus become pa o he da a model. In he ollowing, we p esen he
main ools and on ological amewo ks ha enable such modelling and isualisa ion: he
SPARQL Unico n Toolki , he Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology (FSL-O), and he uzzy-sl
Wikibase.
Figu e 2 - Scheme o “ uzzy-sl” modelling, based on PROV-O, wi h he classes
En i y, Ac i i y and Agen . Flo ian Thie y, CC BY 4.0.
The SPARQL Unico n Toolki [14], [15], [16], [17] p o ides he echnical in as uc u e
o isualising Linked Open Da a in GIS and o ans o ming machine-ac ionable RDF
in o human- eadable ou pu s. O iginally concei ed as a b oade FAIRifica ion ool, in his
pape , i s ole is es ic ed o wo key unc ions: he in eg a ion o LOD in o GIS
en i onmen s such as QGIS and he gene a ion o an LOD HTML documen a ion.
Th ough i s QGIS plugin, Linked Da a que ies can be pe o med di ec ly agains SPARQL
endpoin s, enabling he o e lay o unce ain o uzzy loca ions wi h o he spa ial
da ase s. Fo example, que ies o Ogham s ones, Campanian Ignimb i e findspo s, o
numisma ic hoa ds can be execu ed and displayed as clus e ed laye s in QGIS. The
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
same oolchain also enables he c ea ion o HTML pages ha ende RDF iples in a
na igable, human- eadable o m. In his way, he Unico n Toolki ac s as an in e ace
laye be ween he echnical modelling o unce ain y and i s use in e e yday esea ch
p ac ice.
Figu e 3 - uzzy-sl Wikibase modelling scheme. Flo ian Thie y, CC BY 4.0.
A he cen e o his wo k, howe e , is he Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology (FSL-O), a
seman ic model specifically designed o cap u e wha we e e o as “wobbling
geospa ial da a.” FSL-O [18], [1] is buil upon h ee es ablished s anda ds: PROV-O, SKOS,
and GeoSPARQL ( Fig. 2 ). Following he PROV-O concep [19], i dis inguishes be ween
en i ies , ac i i ies , and agen s . A si e is ep esen ed as an en i y associa ed wi h a
geome y, which is c ea ed by a me hod unde s ood as an ac i i y, and his ac i i y is
a ibu ed o a pe son, he agen . This iadic s uc u e ensu es ha e e y coo dina e can
be aced back o he p ocedu e and au ho i y by which i was p oduced. C ucially, FSL-O
inco po a es explici p ope ies o eco d unce ain y. Each si e and i s geome y can be
desc ibed by wo co e a ibu es: sl:ce ain yDesc , a ex ual desc ip ion o confidence o
doub , and sl:ce ain yLe el , a con olled ocabula y anging om low o high, including
dubious. Si es may u he be linked o bibliog aphic e e ences ia sl:hasRe e ence o o
online esou ces h ough exac Ma ch p ope ies bo owed om he SKOS ocabula y.
Me hods, in u n, can be cha ac e ised h ough sl:hasSou ce and sl:hasSou ceType ,
which iden i y he unde lying da a sou ce and i s ca ego y, sl:ac i i yDesc , which
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
documen s he me hod in ee ex , and he al eady men ioned ce ain y p ope ies,
which ca y o e o he le el o ac i i ies. Toge he , hese p ope ies allow no only he
ep esen a ion o whe e a si e is loca ed, bu also he ci cums ances, e idence, and
confidence wi h which his loca ion has been es ablished. The esul ing RDF can hen be
ans o med in o HTML files h ough he SPARQL Unico n On ology Documen a ion
esea ch ool, ensu ing ha he on ology-d i en da a emains bo h machine-p ocessable
and accessible o human use s.
Figu e 4 - Example Wikibase " uzzy-sl" modelling o Ai/Aii: Ogham S one
Coumeenole No h (Q131) wi h cu en loca ion (Ai) and finding si e (Aii); B:
Campanian Ignimb i e Findspo Auel Maa AU3 (Q70); C: Campanian Ignimb i e
Findspo U luia Qua y (Q73). Flo ian Thie y, CC BY 4.0.
While FSL-O p o ides he concep ual amewo k, i s in eg a ion in o exis ing
communi y in as uc u es is essen ial. Wikida a, as one o he mos widely used
communi y-d i en knowledge g aphs, allows he modelling o spa ial in o ma ion ia he
p ope y P625 o geog aphic coo dina es. Howe e , such coo dina es can be en iched
wi h qualifie s and e e ences o cap u e unce ain y. Fo ins ance, he modelling o an
Ogham s one in Wikida a can dis inguish be ween i s ancien findspo and i s mode n
exhibi ion loca ion. Qualifie s such as de e mina ion me hod (P459), subjec has ole
(P2868), and s a ed in (P248) enable he documen a ion o whe he a coo dina e was
de i ed om geo e e encing, ob ained om a da abase en y, o obse ed on-si e. The
sou cing ci cums ances (P1480) qualifie can indica e whe he he in o ma ion was
ob ained h ough a di ec su ey. A he same ime, loca ion (P276) dis inguishes
be ween he di e en oles a place may play, such as a findspo , an exhibi ion enue, o a
gene al e e ence. Re e ences o ex e nal esou ces, such as OpenS ee Map node
iden ifie s (P11693), p o ide addi ional ancho ing o he coo dina e o collabo a i e
geospa ial eposi o ies. By combining hese qualifie s and e e ences, a Wikida a i em
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
can eflec bo h he ancien and mode n biog aphies o a si e, while making explici he
me hods and unce ain ies associa ed wi h each loca ion.
The mos de ailed implemen a ion o he on ology-d i en app oach is achie ed
h ough he uzzy-sl Wikibase, a specialised Wikibase ins ance dedica ed o modelling
unce ain geospa ial da a (Fig. 3). I s da a model dis inguishes be ween Geoloca ion
Me ada a (GLM), ep esen ed as s a emen s, and Coo dina e Me ada a (CM),
ep esen ed as qualifie s. GLM includes p ope ies such as ela edTo (P10), which
connec s a si e o ex e nal esou ces in he LOD cloud; hasRe e ence (P11), which
eco ds a li e a u e quo a ion o bibliog aphic sou ce; hasSpa ialType (P8), which
specifies ca ego ies like inhabi ed place, i e , ca e, maa , o supe olcano;
hasSpa ialCa ego y (P26), which si ua es he loca ion wi hin domains such as geology o
a chaeology; and loca edInTheAdminis a i eTe i o ialEn i y (P32), which links o
co esponding Wikida a i ems o adminis a i e uni s. These high-le el s a emen s
es ablish he basic con ex o a si e. The cu en en CM qualifie s hen p o ide
fine-g ained me ada a abou he coo dina es hemsel es. P ecision (P23) eco ds he
numbe o significan decimal places in he WGS84 coo dina e, he eby exp essing he
nume ical accu acy o he geo e e encing ( o example, ±0.0001° o he F anch hi
Ca e). Ce ain yLe el (P5) and ce ain yDesc ip ion (P13) mi o he FSL-O p ope ies,
allowing bo h a ca ego ical and ex ual accoun o confidence. Me hodUsed (P7) and
me hodDesc ip ion (P15) documen how he coo dina e was ob ained, whe he by
ex e nal eposi o y, li e a u e-based geo e e encing, o on-si e su ey. Ac ingPe son (P14)
iden ifies he indi idual esponsible o he geo e e encing ac i i y, while
sou ceTypeGene ic (P6) and sou ceTypeDe ail (P16) p o ide u he di e en ia ion o he
e idence base, dis inguishing be ween ex ual desc ip ions, pape s, o
communi y-con ibu ed sou ces such as OpenS ee Map. Finally, loca ionType (P24)
specifies he unc ional ca ego y o he loca ion – whe he i is a findspo , e up ion si e,
o museum display – while poin Type (P33) indica es he concep ual ole o he
coo dina e, such as a ep esen a i e poin , a place as a concep , o a na u al place. By
combining GLM and CM, he uzzy-sl Wikibase hus enables he explici eco ding o
bo h he con ex ual and me hodological dimensions o geospa ial da a (Fig. 4).
The in e play o hese h ee ools—SPARQL Unico n o isualisa ion, FSL-O o
concep ual modelling, and he uzzy-sl Wikibase o implemen a ion – c ea es a
wo kflow ha ende s geospa ial unce ain y anspa en , eusable, and in e ope able.
Ra he han p esen ing a fixed o o e simplified ep esen a ion o he pas , his app oach
acknowledges he wobbling na u e o spa ial da a. I p o ides he means o documen ,
isualise, and c i ically engage wi h i . The ollowing case s udies will demons a e how
his me hodology can be applied o di e se da ase s, anging om epig aphic
monumen s and olcanic eph a laye s o numisma ic hoa ds and ce amic dis ibu ions.
Case S udies: Ogham, Campanian Ignimb i e & Samian Wa e
The me hodological app oaches ou lined abo e gain hei ull ele ance only when
applied o conc e e esea ch da a. In he ollowing, we demons a e how he modelling
o uzzy and wobbling geospa ial da a can be pu in o p ac ice ac oss a selec ion o
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
in e disciplina y case s udies. The examples highligh how FSL-O and he uzzy-sl
Wikibase allow o a anspa en ep esen a ion o unce ain y, how he SPARQL Unico n
Toolki acili a es isualisa ion, and how Linked Open Da a in as uc u es enable
in eg a ion ac oss domains.
Figu e 5 - Geospa ial modelling o Ogham S one CIIC 81 / Q74 / GARES/1 [20] a
UCC S one Co ido , no. IV. Flo ian Thie y, CC BY 4.0.
One o he longes - unning and mos illus a i e examples is he Linked Open Ogham
p ojec . Ogham s ones, e ec ed mainly be ween he ou h and se en h cen u ies CE in
I eland and pa s o B i ain, a e among he ea lies w i en monumen s o he I ish
language [21], [22], [23]. They p o ide no only linguis ic e idence bu also insigh s in o
kinship s uc u es, e i o ial o ganisa ion, and cul u al con ac s. Many s ones, howe e ,
ha e complex biog aphies: some emain in si u, o he s we e mo ed in o museums, and
many a e known only om an iqua ian epo s. The uzziness o hei spa ial e e ences
is hus in insic. Using he uzzy-sl Wikibase, Ogham s ones can be modelled wi h
coo dina es (P4) en iched by qualifie s and e e ences. Fo ins ance, he s one CIIC 81
(Q74
1
), ini ially ound a Ga anes in Coun y Co k, is documen ed bo h in i s ancien
findspo and in i s cu en loca ion in he UCC S one Co ido no. 4 (Fig. 5). The
exhibi ion si e espec i ely findspo can be qualified as P5: High / Low; P13: on-si e
su ey a exhibi ion a ea / GARES/1 [20]; P7: on-si e su ey / Geo e e encing; P14:
Flo ian Thie y; P6: on-si e su ey / Tex ual Desc ip ion; P16: on-si e su ey / Pape ; P15:
on-si e su ey a UCC Co k / ound in old documen s; P23: ±0.0001°; P24: Exhibi ion Si e
/ Findspo ; P33: Exhibi ion / Loca ion o a Place as a Concep . CIIC 81, espec i ely,
GARES/1 is also e e enced o o he esou ces in he FIKG, such as Wikida a
(Q130529871), Seman ic Kompakk (Q1262), Fac G id (Q10000294), OSM node
11071361392, and SMR ID CO074-148----. This dual modelling cap u es he spa ial
biog aphy o he s one and he di e en confidence le els associa ed wi h each
coo dina e. In p ac ice, hese s a emen s can be que ied ia SPARQL and isualised in
QGIS h ough he Unico n plugin, which enables bo h densi y maps and indi idual
ea u e explo a ion. The Ogham case demons a es how doub , mo emen , and
1 c . h ps:// uzzy-sl.wikibase.cloud/en i y/Q74 (all links las accessed 09.09.2025)
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
Discussion & Ou look
The esul s p esen ed in his pape demons a e how seman ic modelling can
ans o m he way a chaeological and geoscien ific da ase s a e documen ed,
compa ed, and in eg a ed. The ocus he e has been less on in oducing he gene al
p oblem o unce ain y – al eady well ecognised in bo h fields—and mo e on showing
how Linked Open Da a p o ides he me hodological means o deal wi h i in a s uc u ed
and in e ope able manne . By applying he Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology (FSL-O) and
implemen ing i in he uzzy-sl Wikibase, combined wi h isualisa ion h ough he
SPARQL Unico n Toolki , we ha e highligh ed a wo kflow ha cap u es no only
coo dina es bu also hei p o enance, confidence, and con ex .
The key me hodological con ibu ion o his wo k lies in b inging oge he h ee
elemen s: fi s , a o mal on ology (FSL-O) ha exp esses agueness and uzziness
h ough explici p ope ies such as ce ain y le el, ce ain y desc ip ion, and e e ences
o sou ces; second, a Wikibase implemen a ion ha ex ends his model h ough a
de ailed schema o geoloca ion and coo dina e me ada a, allowing use s o eco d
p ecision, me hods, and agen s; and hi d, an in eg a ion pa hway o communi y-d i en
in as uc u es like Wikida a and OpenS ee Map, whe e da a can be connec ed ac oss
disciplina y and linguis ic bounda ies. This combina ion mo es beyond adi ional
gaze ee s o da abases by embedding unce ain y di ec ly in o he da a model a he
han ea ing i as an ex e nal anno a ion.
The case s udies unde line he alue o his app oach. Ogham s ones exempli y he
complex biog aphies o a chaeological monumen s, as hey shi be ween findspo s and
museum con ex s. Campanian Ignimb i e deposi s demons a e how geoscien ific and
a chaeological da a can be in eg a ed when hei unce ain ies a e modelled explici ly.
Numisma ic hoa ds om C o on highligh he a ying g anula i y o spa ial desc ip ions,
om p ecise u ban loca ions o b oad egional e e ences. Samian si es illus a e how
e en well-es ablished esea ch da abases equi e ca e ul ea men o coo dina e quali y
and p ecision. In all hese cases, seman ic modelling enables esea che s o exp ess
di e ences in confidence, o ace me hods o da a c ea ion, and o connec o ex e nal
esou ces. The in e ope abili y o hese da ase s is enhanced p ecisely because
unce ain y is p ese ed as s uc u ed in o ma ion. The in eg a ion o he
a chaeome allic, ce amic, and cul u al-geog aphical case s udies u he illus a es how
he uzzy-sl app oach anscends disciplina y bounda ies. By applying he same
seman ic logic o da a o igina ing om me allu gy, egional a chaeology, and landscape
esea ch, hese examples demons a e ha unce ain y is no confined o a single da a
ype o scale. Ins ead, i mani es s as a uni e sal p ope y o a chaeological e idence,
which can be o mally ep esen ed and compu a ionally analysed h ough sha ed
on ological s uc u es. This ein o ces he po en ial o he uzzy-sl amewo k o ac as a
me hodological b idge be ween si e-based documen a ion, egional syn hesis, and
c oss-domain da a in as uc u es.
Wha se s his pape apa me hodologically is i s emphasis on Linked Open Da a as
he backbone o in e ope abili y. The use o RDF, PROV-O, SKOS, and GeoSPARQL
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
ensu es ha he da a p oduced can be que ied, linked, and isualised ac oss
in as uc u es. The explici inclusion o unce ain y in o his seman ic amewo k is
wha makes i dis inc i e. Ra he han o e ing ce ain y whe e he e is none, he
app oach allows da a o emain hones abou i s limi a ions while s ill being eusable.
This is pa icula ly impo an in in e na ional and in e disciplina y con ex s, whe e
esea che s om a chaeology, his o y, and he geosciences mus be able o e alua e no
only he da a i sel bu also he deg ee o confidence a ached o i .
Visualisa ion is ano he c i ical a ea o discussion. While modelling unce ain y
seman ically p o ides he ounda ion, esea che s also need in ui i e ways o see and
in e p e i . The use o bounding boxes, bu e s, o hulls makes uzziness isible in maps,
bu hese echniques equi e ca e ul calib a ion. Fo example, bu e s gene a ed in
WGS84 coo dina es isk p oducing dis o ions ha a e echnically co ec bu isually
misleading. The SPARQL Unico n Toolki add esses pa o his challenge by enabling
seman ically anno a ed da a o be pulled in o GIS en i onmen s whe e such
isualisa ions can be es ed, compa ed, and efined. In his sense, he oolki p o ides
no jus a display mechanism bu also an expe imen al en i onmen o de eloping
use - iendly ep esen a ions o unce ain space.
Looking o wa d, he nex s eps in ol e ex ending he on ology and he Wikibase
schema in esponse o u he case s udies. While he cu en model al eady
inco po a es en key p ope ies o coo dina e me ada a, addi ional a ibu es may be
needed o cap u e empo al agueness, di e en ypes o spa ial abs ac ion, o mo e
nuanced desc ip ions o me hods. Applying he model o new da ase s—such as
a chaeome allu gical e idence, la ge-scale cul u al landscapes, o addi ional ce amic
co po a—will help o iden i y such equi emen s. The modula i y o FSL-O and he
flexibili y o Wikibase make hem well-sui ed o his i e a i e efinemen .
Ano he a enue o de elopmen lies in alignmen wi h in e na ional s anda ds and
in as uc u es. Mapping FSL-O o CIDOC CRM and i s a chaeological ex ensions, o
linking Wikibase da a o global ini ia i es such as he Eu opean Collabo a i e Cloud o
Cul u al He i age (ECCCH), will ensu e ha uzzy geospa ial da a can pa icipa e in wide
ecosys ems. This is pa icula ly impo an o long- e m sus ainabili y: only i da a
models a e compa ible ac oss in as uc u es can hey be main ained and eused a
scale.
In conclusion, he cen al con ibu ion o his pape is me hodological. By embedding
unce ain y in o Linked Open Da a h ough he combined use o FSL-O, uzzy-sl Wikibase,
and SPARQL Unico n isualisa ion, we ha e shown a conc e e pa hway o dealing wi h
wobbling geospa ial da a in a chaeology and he geosciences. The app oach is
in e na ionally ele an , in e disciplina y by design, and scalable h ough alignmen wi h
b oade in as uc u es. Fu u e wo k will ocus on expanding he on ology and p ope y
se s, in eg a ing u he case s udies, and efining isualisa ion s a egies. In his way,
he model no only acknowledges he inhe en uzziness o spa ial in o ma ion bu also
p o ides he ools o make i anspa en , in e ope able, and FAIR.
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
Acknowledgemen s
The au ho s would like o hank Ka s en Tolle and Sebas ian Gampe o hei ad ice,
as well as he CAA Ge many, SIG Da a D agon and NFDI4Objec s Communi y. The
au ho s acknowledge he use o language assis ance powe ed by a ificial in elligence
(Cha GPT, OpenAI) o s ylis ic edi ing and linguis ic efinemen . All con en and
a gumen s we e au ho ed and e ified by he au ho s hemsel es.
Da a, sc ip s, code, and supplemen a y in o ma ion a ailabili y
Thie y, F. e al. (2025). uzzy-sl Wikibase: h ps:// uzzy-sl.wikibase.cloud ;
Thie y, F., & Schenk, F. (2023). Campanian Ignimb i e Geo Loca ions [Da aSe ] a
h ps://gi hub.com/Resea ch-Squi el-Enginee s/campanian-ignimb i e-geo [49];
Thie y, F., & Baa s, S. (2023). C o on Geo Loca ions [Da aSe ] a
h ps://gi hub.com/Resea ch-Squi el-Enginee s/c o on-geo ;
Thie y, F. (2023). Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology [Da aSe ] a
h ps://gi hub.com/Resea ch-Squi el-Enginee s/ uzzy-sl-on ology [50];
Thie y, F., & Hombu g, T. (2025). SPARQLing Unico n QGIS Plugin [So wa e] a
h ps://gi hub.com/spa qlunico n/spa qlunico nGoesGIS [14], [15], [16], [17];
Hombu g, T., & Thie y, F. (2024). SPARQL Unico n On ology Documen a ion [So wa e]
a h ps://gi hub.com/spa qlunico n/spa qlunico nGoesGIS-on doc [14], [15], [16], [17].
Conflic o in e es disclosu e
The au ho s decla e ha hey comply wi h he PCI ule o ha ing no financial conflic s
o in e es in ela ion o he con en o he a icle.
Funding
This pape is pa o he DFG- unded NFDI ini ia i e, specifically he Resea ch Da a
In as uc u e o he Ma e ial Remains o Human His o y (NFDI4Objec s), DFG P ojec
numbe 501836407. Some wo ks we e unded by Wikimedia Deu schland, Fellow-
P og amm F eies Wissen 2020/21: “I ische Ogham S eine im Wikimedia Uni e sum”.
Re e ences
[1] F. Thie y, F. Schenk, S. Baa s, K. Tolle, and P. Thie y, ‘Modellie ung on Fuzzyness /
Wobbliness in Geoda en - Am Beispiel a chäologische und geowissenscha liche
Fundo e e enzen’, Tagungsband FOSSGIS-Kon e enz 2024 , ol. 2024, pp. 64–73,
Ma . 2024, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10571858.
[2] N. J. Ca , ‘Spa ial Unce ain y o Fea u es & Func ions (SUFF) Model’, Spa ial
Unce ain y o Fea u es & Func ions (SUFF) Model. Accessed: Oc . 21, 2024.
[Online]. A ailable: h ps://w3id.o g/su /spec
[3] F. Thie y, F. Schenk, and S. Baa s, ‘Dealing wi h doub s: si e geo e e encing in
a chaeology and in he geosciences’, A cheologia e Calcola o i , ol. 35, no. 2, pp.
97–106, 2024, doi: 10.19282/ac.35.2.2024.11.
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
[4] F. Thie y and F. Schenk, ‘Modelling o Unce ain y in Geo Sciences Si es’, Squi el
Pape s , ol. 5, no. 1, p. #4, Dec. 2023, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10255259.
[5] F. Thie y and F. Schenk, ‘How o loca e he Campanian Ignimb i e si e U luia based
on li e a u e? How o p o ide and publish his da a in a FAIR way?’, Squi el Pape s ,
ol. 5, no. 1, p. #5, 2023, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10262720.
[6] F. Thie y, F. Schenk, and S. Baa s, ‘Dealing wi h doub s: Si e geo e e encing in
a chaeology and in he geosciences’, Squi el Pape s , ol. 5, no. 1, p. #6, Dec. 2023,
doi: 10.5281/ZENODO.10291889.
[7] A. Züfle e al. , ‘Handling Unce ain y in Geo-Spa ial Da a’, in 2017 IEEE 33 d
In e na ional Con e ence on Da a Enginee ing (ICDE) , Ap . 2017, pp. 1467–1470. doi:
10.1109/ICDE.2017.212.
[8] M. D. Wilkinson, M. Dumon ie , Ij. J. Aalbe sbe g, G. Apple on, and e al., ‘The FAIR
Guiding P inciples o scien ific da a managemen and s ewa dship’, Scien ific Da a ,
ol. 3, p. 160018, Ma . 2016, doi: 10.1038/sda a.2016.18.
[9] S. C. Schmid , F. Thie y, and M. T ogni z, ‘P ac ices o Linked Open Da a in
A chaeology and Thei Realisa ion in Wikida a’, Digi al , ol. 2, no. 3, pp. 333–364,
June 2022, doi: 10.3390/digi al2030019.
[10] T. Be ne s-Lee, ‘Linked Da a’. Accessed: May 31, 2024. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://www.w3.o g/DesignIssues/LinkedDa a.h ml
[11] F. Thie y and P. Thie y, ‘Linked Open Ogham. How o publish and in e link a ious
Ogham Da a?’, A cheologia e Calcola o i , ol. 34, no. 1, pp. 105–114, 2023, doi:
10.19282/ac.34.1.2023.12.
[12] N. J. Ca and T. Hombu g, ‘GeoSPARQL 1.1: Mo i a ions, De ails and Applica ions o
he Decadal Upda e o he Mos Impo an Geospa ial LOD S anda d’, IJGI , ol. 11,
no. 2, p. 117, Feb. 2022, doi: 10.3390/ijgi11020117.
[13] J. Abhaya a na e al. , ‘OGC Benefi s o Rep esen ing Spa ial Da a Using Seman ic
and G aph Technologies’, OGC Whi e Pape . OGC, Oc . 05, 2020. [Online]. A ailable:
h p://www.opengis.ne /doc/wp/using-seman ic-g aph
[14] F. Thie y, F. Schenk, and P. Thie y, ‘Das Resea ch Squi el Enginee s Ne wo k:
FAIRifica ion Tools und LOD-P ojek e aus de A chäoin o ma ik und den
Geowissenscha en’, A chäologische In o ma ionen , ol. 47, no. NWDVA 2024
Bochum: Digi ale A chäologie, pp. 115–140, Ap . 2025, doi:
10.11588/ai.2024.1.110394.
[15] F. Thie y and T. Hombu g, ‘SPARQLing Unico n QGIS Plugin’, Squi el Pape s , ol. 6,
no. 2, p. #5, Sep . 2024, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.13828632.
[16] T. Hombu g and F. Thie y, ‘SPARQL Unico n On ology Documen a ion’, Squi el
Pape s , ol. 6, no. 2, p. #2, Ma . 2024, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10780476.
[17] T. Hombu g and F. Thie y, ‘The SPARQL Unico n On ology documen a ion: Exposing
RDF geoda a using s a ic GeoAPIs’, Tagungsband FOSSGIS-Kon e enz 2024 , ol.
2024, pp. 82–90, Ma . 2024, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10570985.
[18] F. Thie y, ‘Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology’, Squi el Pape s , ol. 5, no. 2, p. #3, Dec.
2023, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10362777.
[19] ‘PROV-O: The PROV On ology’. Accessed: Dec. 05, 2023. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://www.w3.o g/TR/p o -o/
[20] CISP Da abase, ‘GARES/1 [CISP Da abase]’. Accessed: Sep . 09, 2025. [Online].
A ailable:
h ps://linkedopenogham.gi hub.io/cisp- eco e y/cisp/da abase/s one/ga es_1.h ml
[21] R. A. S. Macalis e , Co pus insc ip ionum insula um Cel ica um . Dublin: S a ione y
Office, 1945.
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
[22] D. MacManus, A Guide o Ogam . in Maynoo h monog aphs, no. 4. Maynoo h: An
Saga , 1997.
[23] S. C. Schmid and F. Thie y, ‘SPARQLing Ogham S ones: New Op ions o Analyzing
Analog Edi ions by Digi iza ion in Wikida a’, CEUR Wo kshop P oceedings , ol. 3110,
no. G aph Technologies in he Humani ies 2020, pp. 211–244, Ma . 2022, doi:
10.5281/zenodo.6380914.
[24] F. Schenk, U. Hambach, S. B i zius, D. Ve es, and F. Si ocko, ‘A C yp o eph a Laye in
Sedimen s o an Infilled Maa Lake om he Ei el (Ge many): Fi s E idence o
Campanian Ignimb i e Ash Ai all in Cen al Eu ope’, Qua e na y , ol. 7, no. 2, p. 17,
Ma . 2024, doi: 10.3390/qua 7020017.
[25] B. Giaccio e al. , ‘The Campanian Ignimb i e and Codola eph a laye s: Two
empo al/s a ig aphic ma ke s o he Ea ly Uppe Palaeoli hic in sou he n I aly and
eas e n Eu ope’, Jou nal o Volcanology and Geo he mal Resea ch , ol. 177, no. 1, pp.
208–226, Oc . 2008, doi: 10.1016/j.j olgeo es.2007.10.007.
[26] F. G. Fedele, B. Giaccio, and I. Hajdas, ‘Timescales and cul u al p ocess a 40,000 BP
in he ligh o he Campanian Ignimb i e e up ion, Wes e n Eu asia’, Jou nal o Human
E olu ion , ol. 55, no. 5, pp. 834–857, No . 2008, doi: 10.1016/j.jhe ol.2008.08.012.
[27] M. W. Mo ley and J. C. Woodwa d, ‘The Campanian Ignimb i e (Y5) eph a a C ena
S ijena Rockshel e , Mon eneg o’, Qua . es. , ol. 75, no. 3, pp. 683–696, May 2011,
doi: 10.1016/j.yq es.2011.02.005.
[28] T. Tsano a e al. , ‘Uppe Palaeoli hic laye s and Campanian Ignimb i e/Y-5 eph a in
Topli sa ca e, No he n Bulga ia’, Jou nal o A chaeological Science: Repo s , ol. 37,
p. 102912, June 2021, doi: 10.1016/j.jas ep.2021.102912.
[29] K. E. Fi zsimmons and U. Hambach, ‘Loess accumula ion du ing he las glacial
maximum: E idence om U luia, sou heas e n Romania’, Qua e na y In e na ional ,
ol. 334–335, pp. 74–85, June 2014, doi: 10.1016/j.quain .2013.08.005.
[30] S. Pö e e al. , ‘Disen angling Sedimen a y Pa hways o he Pleniglacial Lowe
Danube Loess Based on Geochemical Signa u es’, F on . Ea h Sci. , ol. 9, p. 600010,
Ap . 2021, doi: 10.3389/ ea .2021.600010.
[31] F. Thie y, A. W. Mees, and J. B. Kiesling, ‘Challenges in esea ch communi y building:
in eg a ing Te a Sigilla a (Samian) esea ch in o he Wikida a communi y’, AeC , ol.
34, no. 1, pp. 157–164, 2023, doi: 10.19282/ac.34.1.2023.17.
[32] M. Reddé and A. Mees, ‘Had ian’s Wall and i s Con inen al Hin e land’, B i annia , ol.
53, pp. 55–84, No . 2022, doi: 10.1017/S0068113X22000216.
[33] M. Flückige , E. Ho nung, M. La ch, M. Ludwig, and A. Mees, ‘Roman T anspo
Ne wo k Connec i i y and Economic In eg a ion’, The Re iew o Economic S udies ,
ol. 89, no. 2, pp. 774–810, Ma . 2022, doi: 10.1093/ es ud/ dab036.
[34] R. G ün hal e al. , ‘D as ic demog aphic e en s igge ed he U alic sp ead’,
Diach onica , ol. 39, no. 4, pp. 490–524, Aug. 2022, doi: 10.1075/dia.20038.g u.
[35] A. Childebaye a e al. , ‘B onze age No he n Eu asian gene ics in he con ex o
de elopmen o me allu gy and Sibe ian ances y’, Commun Biol , ol. 7, no. 1, p. 723,
June 2024, doi: 10.1038/s42003-024-06343-x.
[36] S. G unwald, ‘Riskan e Zwischensch i e: A chäologische Ka og aphie in
Deu schland zwischen 1870 und 1900’, in Massendinghal ung , B. Ho mann and
o he s, Eds, Leiden: Sides one P ess, 2016, pp. 111–147.
[37] E. He e a Mala es a and S. De Vale iola, ‘Ambiguous landscapes: A amewo k o
assessing obus ness and unce ain ies in a chaeological poin pa e n analysis’,
PLoS ONE , ol. 19, no. 9, p. e0307743, 2024, doi: 10.1371/jou nal.pone.0307743.
[38] H. Mülle -Ka pe, Die U nen elde kul u im Hanaue Land . Ma bu g: Elwe -G ä e und
Unze , 1948.
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
[39] Hessisches Landesam ü Bodenmanagemen und Geoin o ma ion,
‘Ve wal ungseinhei en Hessen. Geobasisda en’. 2025. Accessed: Ap . 03, 2025.
[Online]. A ailable:
h ps://gdk.gdi-de.o g/geone wo k/s /api/ eco ds/e72c607e-304d-49db-a a1-06 2
49a4466a
[40] R Co e Team, R: A Language and En i onmen o S a is ical Compu ing . Vienna,
Aus ia: R Founda ion o S a is ical Compu ing, 2025. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://www.R-p ojec .o g/
[41] A. Baddeley, E. Rubak, and R. Tu ne , Spa ial Poin Pa e ns: Me hodology and
Applica ions wi h R . Boca Ra on: Chapman and Hall/CRC P ess, 2015.
[42] S. Ga nie , N. Ross, B. Rudis, A. P. Cama go, M. Sciaini, and C. Sche e , i idis:
Colo blind-F iendly Colo Maps o R . 2021. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://CRAN.R-p ojec .o g/package= i idis
[43] R. J. Hijmans, e a: Spa ial Da a Analysis . 2025. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://CRAN.R-p ojec .o g/package= e a
[44] E. Pebesma, ‘Simple Fea u es o R: S anda dized Suppo o Spa ial Vec o Da a’,
The R Jou nal , ol. 10, no. 1, pp. 439–446, 2018, doi: 10.32614/RJ-2018-009.
[45] T. L. Pede sen, pa chwo k: The Compose o Plo s . 2020. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://CRAN.R-p ojec .o g/package=pa chwo k
[46] H. Wickham, ggplo 2: Elegan G aphics o Da a Analysis . New Yo k: Sp inge -Ve lag,
2016.
[47] H. Wickham, R. F ançois, L. Hen y, and K. Mülle , dply : A G amma o Da a
Manipula ion . 2023. [Online]. A ailable: h ps://CRAN.R-p ojec .o g/package=dply
[48] H. Wickham and M. Gi lich, idy : Tidy Messy Da a . 2023. [Online]. A ailable:
h ps://CRAN.R-p ojec .o g/package= idy
[49] F. Thie y and F. Schenk, ‘Campanian Ignimb i e Geo Loca ions’, Squi el Pape s , ol. 5,
no. 2, p. #2, 2023, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10361309.
[50] F. Thie y, ‘Fuzzy Spa ial Loca ions On ology’, Squi el Pape s , ol. 5, no. 2, p. #3, Dec.
2023, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.10362777.
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
