scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

A LINGUISTIC AND CULTURAL ANALYSIS: COMPARING IELTS, TOEFL, AND PTE

Author: Ashiraliyeva, Guljahon; Lapasova, Xurshida; Saydazimova, Durdona
Publisher: Zenodo
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17712168
Source: https://zenodo.org/records/17712168/files/144-147.pdf
PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF
SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH
Volume 02, Issue 10, 2025
144 PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH uni e salcon e ence.us
A LINGUISTIC AND CULTURAL ANALYSIS: COMPARING IELTS,
TOEFL, AND PTE
Ashi aliye a Guljahon Tux asin qizi
S uden o Uzbek Na ional Pedagogical Uni e si y
Email: [email p o ec ed]
Lapaso a Xu shida Yaxyo qizi
S uden o Uzbek Na ional Pedagogical Uni e si y
Email: [email p o ec ed]
Scien i ic Supe iso :
Saydazimo a Du dona Xabibullaye na
PhD, associa e p o esso
Uzbek Na ional Pedagogical Uni e si y
Depa men o he Theo y and Me hodology o English
Email: [email p o ec ed]
Abs ac : The ising impo ance o in e na ional educa ion and global mobili y has
in ensi ied he ole o English p o iciency es s. Among he mos widely accep ed
examina ions—IELTS, TOEFL, and PTE—each u ilizes a unique linguis ic, cul u al,
and me hodological app oach o e alua ing communica i e abili y. This a icle
p o ides a compa a i e s udy o hese exams, highligh ing di e ences in assessmen
philosophy, sco ing p ocedu es, and es s uc u es, wi h e e ence o es ablished
academic sou ces [1–5]. Pa icula a en ion is gi en o Uzbek lea ne s, whose
linguis ic backg ound, p onuncia ion sys em, and educa ional en i onmen
signi ican ly in luence hei es pe o mance. The analysis concludes ha he
e ec i eness o any exam depends la gely on he lea ne ’s indi idual cha ac e is ics,
cul u al exposu e, and p e e ed communica ion s yle.
Key wo ds: English p o iciency es s, IELTS, TOEFL, PTE Acadеmic, linguis ic
analysis, cul u al ac o s, assessmen philosophy, Uzbek lea ne s, AI sco ing, academic
communica ion, in eg a ed skillsю
Anno a siya: Xalqa o a’lim a mehna mig a siyasi imkoniya la ining o ib bo ishi
ingliz ili bo‘yicha xalqa o im ihonla ning o‘ nini yanada muhimlash i di. Eng
mashhu IELTS, TOEFL a PTE im ihonla i il ko‘nikmala ini baholashda u licha
ling is ik a madaniy yondashu la ga ega. Maqolada ushbu im ihonla uzilishi,
baholash amoyilla i a me odik a qla i solish i ilib, asosiy akademik manbala ga
ayaniladi [1–5]. Shuningdek, o‘zbek o‘qu chila ining one ik a g amma ik
PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF
SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH
Volume 02, Issue 10, 2025
145 PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH uni e salcon e ence.us
xususiya la i, o‘qu ja ayoni a eal kommunika i amaliyo ning ye ishmasligi
na ijala ga qanday a’si ko‘ sa ishi yo i iladi. Tadqiqo shuni ko‘ sa adiki, eng
sama ali im ihon anlo i o‘qu chining shaxsiy il aj ibasi, madaniy ayyo ga ligi a
im ihon o ma iga moslashu chanligiga bog‘liq
Kali so’zla : Ingliz ili im ihonla i, IELTS, TOEFL, PTE Academic, ling is ik ahlil,
madaniy omilla , baholash amoyilla i, o‘zbek o‘qu chila i, sun’iy in ellek baholash
izimi, akademik kommunika siya, in eg allashgan ko‘nikmala .
Аннотация: Рост международной образовательной и профессиональной
мобильности усилил значение экзаменов по английскому языку. Наиболее
распространённые тесты — IELTS, TOEFL и PTE — опираются на различные
лингвистические и культурные концепции оценки владения языком. В статье
проводится сравнительный анализ структуры, критериев оценивания и
методологических подходов указанных экзаменов, основанный на авторитетных
источниках [1–5]. Особое внимание уделяется узбекским обучающимся, для
которых фонологические особенности языка и специфика образовательной
среды заметно влияют на результаты тестирования. Сделан вывод о том, что
выбор оптимального экзамена зависит от индивидуальных особенностей,
культурного опыта и предпочитаемого стиля коммуникации.
Ключевыек слова: Экзамены по английскому языку, IELTS, TOEFL, PTE
лингвистический анализ, культурные факторы, принципы оценивания, узбекские
учащиеся, автоматизированное оценивание, академическая коммуникация,
интегрированные навыки.
In oduc ion: In mode n global socie y, English p o iciency es s se e as
s anda dized ga eways o highe educa ion, employmen , and mig a ion oppo uni ies.
IELTS, TOEFL, and PTE, despi e measu ing he same ou p ima y language skills,
a e g ounded in di e en linguis ic adi ions and cul u al pe spec i es [1]. Thei
assessmen amewo ks e lec a ied unde s andings o communica ion, in e ac ion,
and academic p epa edness. Fo Uzbek lea ne s, whose educa ional sys em p io i izes
g amma and eading o e communica i e luency, na iga ing hese exams equi es an
unde s anding o how es o ma s align wi h hei linguis ic backg ound [5].
Tes s uc u e: a linguis ic and cul u al compa ison. Iel s: Emphasis on Au hen ic, Real-
Li e Communica ion. Managed by Camb idge Assessmen English, B i ish Council,
and IDP, IELTS e alua es language h ough p ac ical communica i e asks [1].
Lis ening & Reading: Inco po a e mul iple English accen s and eal-li e ex ypes.
W i ing: Focus on analy ical and a gumen a i e w i ing a an academic le el.
PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF
SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH
Volume 02, Issue 10, 2025
146 PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH uni e salcon e ence.us
Speaking: Conduc ed ace- o- ace, assessing luency, cohe ence, in e ac ion, and
p agma ic skills.IELTS e lec s B i ish communica ion s yles p io i izing cla i y,
spon anei y, and in e pe sonal compe ence.
TOEFL: Academic In eg a ion wi hin an Ame ican Con ex . TOEFL is designed o
esemble No h Ame ican academic en i onmen s and lec u e-based lea ning s yles
[2]. In eg a ed asks: Requi e syn hesizing in o ma ion om a icles and audio lec u es.
Speaking: Reco ded esponses assessed by ce i ied a e s using Ame ican English
no ms. This exam a o s analy ical easoning, s uc u ed a gumen a ion, and
comp ehension o academic discou se. PTE Academic: Technology-D i en, AI-Based
Assessmen .
PTE uses ad anced au oma ed sco ing sys ems based on a i icial in elligence [3].
AI Sco ing: Ensu es consis ency bu aises conce ns abou de ec ing accen a ia ion,
s ess, o cul u al nuance [4].In eg a ed Skills: Many asks assess speaking and
lis ening simul aneously. PTE aligns wi h mode n digi al communica ion
en i onmen s, equi ing high compu e luency and apid ask-swi ching.
E ec i ness: a ma e o indi idual i . Iel s bene i s lea ne s con iden in in e pe sonal
con e sa ion and spon aneous speech in e ac ion [1].
TOEFL sui s s uden s who excel in academic-s yle lis ening, eading, and syn hesis o
complex in o ma ion [2]. PTE is ideal o echnologically p epa ed lea ne s who
pe o m well unde AI-based, as -paced condi ions [3]. Thus, he exams di e no in
di icul y bu in he ype o linguis ic compe ence hey p io i ize.
The Uzbek con ex : linguis ic and cul u al ac o . Uzbek lea ne s ace pa icula
di icul ies due o owel and consonan sys em di e ences be ween Uzbek and
English; g amma - ocused eaching me hods; limi ed exposu e o in e ac i e English-
speaking en i onmen s [5]. These ac o s especially in luence speaking, lis ening, and
in eg a ed skills asks. A cul u ally ele an p epa a ion app oach signi ican ly
imp o es ou comes.
Conclusion: This compa a i e s udy e eals ha IELTS, TOEFL, and PTE embody
dis inc cul u al and linguis ic o ien a ions in language assessmen . IELTS a o s eal-
li e communica ion, TOEFL e lec s academically in eg a ed asks in an Ame ican
s yle, whe eas PTE ep esen s echnologically ad anced, AI-based e alua ion models.
Fo Uzbek lea ne s, whose phonological s uc u e and educa ional backg ound di e
om English-speaking no ms, es pe o mance is closely ied o cul u al amilia i y
and p epa a ion ype. The e o e, he e is no single “mos e ec i e” exam. The op imal
choice depends on he lea ne ’s linguis ic s eng hs, p e e ed communica ion s yle,
echnological com o , and he expec a ions o he ins i u ion hey apply o. A cul u ally
PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF
SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH
Volume 02, Issue 10, 2025
147 PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS OF SCIENTIFIC AND INNOVATIVE RESEARCH uni e salcon e ence.us
in o med, lea ne -cen e ed p epa a ion s a egy enhances pe o mance and enables
Uzbek s uden s o success ully demons a e hei English p o iciency on any
in e na ional pla o m.
Re ences:
1. B i ish Council. (2023). IELTS Guide o Teache s. Camb idge Uni e si y P ess,
(pp. 12–45).
2. B own, J. D. (2018). Language Assessmen Al e na i es. Applied Linguis ics
Re iew, 39(2),( pp. 4–9, 45–67).
3. Educa ional Tes ing Se ice (ETS). (2022). TOEFL iBT Tes F amewo k. ETS
Publica ions, (pp. 8–33).
4. Ka imo a, N. (2021). English Language Tes ing in Uzbekis an. Tashken
Pedagogical Jou nal, 28(3),( pp. 112–125).
5. Pea son PLC. (2023). PTE Academic Sco e Guide. Pea son Educa ion L d.,( pp. 10–
29).