Lambe ini, Luca; Lo i, F ancesca; San a elli, En ico
Wo king Pape
Inno a i e Ou pu , In a-Indus y Spillo es, and R&D
Coope a ion: Theo y and E idence
Quade ni - Wo king Pape DSE, No. 371
P o ided in Coope a ion wi h:
Uni e si y o Bologna, Depa men o Economics
Sugges ed Ci a ion: Lambe ini, Luca; Lo i, F ancesca; San a elli, En ico (2000) : Inno a i e Ou pu ,
In a-Indus y Spillo es, and R&D Coope a ion: Theo y and E idence, Quade ni - Wo king Pape
DSE, No. 371, Alma Ma e S udio um - Uni e si à di Bologna, Dipa imen o di Scienze Economiche
(DSE), Bologna,
h ps://doi.o g/10.6092/unibo/amsac a/4938
This Ve sion is a ailable a :
h ps://hdl.handle.ne /10419/159212
S anda d-Nu zungsbedingungen:
Die Dokumen e au EconS o dü en zu eigenen wissenscha lichen
Zwecken und zum P i a geb auch gespeiche und kopie we den.
Sie dü en die Dokumen e nich ü ö en liche ode komme zielle
Zwecke e iel äl igen, ö en lich auss ellen, ö en lich zugänglich
machen, e eiben ode ande wei ig nu zen.
So e n die Ve asse die Dokumen e un e Open-Con en -Lizenzen
(insbesonde e CC-Lizenzen) zu Ve ügung ges ell haben soll en,
gel en abweichend on diesen Nu zungsbedingungen die in de do
genann en Lizenz gewäh en Nu zungs ech e.
Te ms o use:
Documen s in EconS o may be sa ed and copied o you pe sonal
and schola ly pu poses.
You a e no o copy documen s o public o comme cial pu poses, o
exhibi he documen s publicly, o make hem publicly a ailable on he
in e ne , o o dis ibu e o o he wise use he documen s in public.
I he documen s ha e been made a ailable unde an Open Con en
Licence (especially C ea i e Commons Licences), you may exe cise
u he usage igh s as speci ied in he indica ed licence.
h ps://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by-nc/3.0/
Lqq ydwlyh Rxwsxw/ Lqiud0Lqgx wu| Vsloo yhu /
dqg U)G F shudwl q= Wkh u| dqg Hylghq h
4
Ox d Odpehuw
lql
&
Iudq h d O wwl
{
Hqul Vdqwduhool
&
& Ghsduwphqw i H q pl / Xqlyhu lw| i E o jqd
Vwudgd Pdjjl uh 78/ 73458 E o jqd/ Lwdo|
Id{= .6<0384053<5997
odpehuwlC se 1
xqle 1lw dqwduhoC se 1xqle 1lw
¢ Ode udw u| i H q pl dqg Pdqdjhphqw
Vdqw*Dqqd V k o i Dgydq hg Vwxglh
Sl d/ Lwdo|
ORWWLC xs1lw
Iheuxdu| :/ 5333
4
Zh zl k w wkd
qn HXURVWDW i u judqwlqj shupl l q w x h wkh pl u djjuhjdwhg
gdwd iu p wkh F ppxqlw| Lqq ydwl q Vxuyh|1 Ilqdq ldo xss uw iu p PXUVW + x wd
93(/ uh s q leoh Hqul Vdqwduhool, l judwhixoo| d nq zohgjhg1
De wud w
Zh dqdo| h e
wk wkh wkh uhwl do dqg wkh hpslul do lgh i wkh l xh i U)G
sloo yhu 1 Hd k up* U)G w duh lq uhd lqj lq wkh dp xqw i lqi updwl q
wudq plwwhg w wkhu up / dqg zh d xqw i u wkh s lelolw| wkdw up qwu o
sloo yhu 1 Zh q lghu e wk F xuq w0Qd k dqg F xuq w0Vwd nhoehuj ehkdyl xu1
Wkh hpslul do dqdo| l xjjh w wkdw +l, up * qwu o q sloo yhu l uhodwlyho|
o z> +ll, wkh w0 dylqj hh w d ldwhg w m lqw yhqwxuh u U)G duwho l
quphg i u lqgx wulh zkhuh up uho| pdlqo| xs q zq U)G d d xu h
i lqq ydwl q> +lll, U)G shudwl q pd| lq uhd h lqi updwl q kdulqj/ wkhuhe|
hqkdq lqj sloo yhu 1
MHO Fod l dwl q=
O46/ R64
Nh|z ug =
sloo yhu / m lqw yhqwxuh/ U)G duwho
4 Lqwu gx wl q
Dssu suldelolw| kd o qj ehhq lghqwlhg d d pdm u su eohp id lqj wkh lqq ydwlqj
up1 Vlq h lw dq kdugo| dssu suldwh wkh ehqhw qqh whg w lw lqq ydwl q /
lw l yhu| olnho| wkdw x k up zloo q w shui up wkh gh luhg U)G su mh w / lw
s lelolw| w ixoo| h{so lw wkhlu uh xow ehlqj wkuhdwhqhg e| ulydo up 1 D oxwl q
w wkl glohppd l shudwlyh U)G/ hlwkhu qgx whg e| up zk kduh wkh
w dqg ehqhw i sduwl xodu U)G su mh w / u q l wlqj lq lqi updo wudglqj
i su sulhwdu| nq z0k z ehwzhhq ulydo up +y q Klssho/ 4<;:> 4<;;,1
D odujh hpslul do ghedwh kd xqi oghg yhu wkh od w wzhqw| |hdu / q huqlqj
wkh pdjqlwxgh i U)G sloo yhu +i u dq yhuylhz/ hh Jhu nl/ 4<<8d/e> dqg
Julol kh / 4<<8>
lqwhu dold
,1 Wkh yhudoo dssudl do pdlqwdlq wkdw wh kq o jl do
h{whuqdolwlh duh zlgh suhdg e wk lqwhu0 dqg lqwud0lqgx wu|/ dowk xjk wkhlu pdj0
qlwxgh ydulh q lghudeo| d u lqgx wulh 1
4
Wkl gl x l q kd wuljjhuhg d uuh s qglqj wkh uhwl do dssu d k w wkh
dqdo| l i U)G sloo yhu + hh g*D suhp qw dqg Md xhplq/ 4<;;> Khqul xh /
4<<3> Ndw} dqg Rug yhu/ 4<<3> gh E qgw
hw do1
/4<<
5> Ndplhq
hw do1
/ 4<<5> Vx}x0
pxud/ 4<<5,1 Wkl olwhudwxuh qgx w psdudwlyh wdwl xs q h xloleulxp xw0
sxw dqg lqyh wphqw d u dowhuqdwlyh ujdql}dwl qdo gh ljq x k d U)G du0
who dqg uh hdu k m lqw yhqwxuh +UMY , y q q shudwlyh lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh 1
Wkl dqdo| l l duulhg xw d w s lqw xw zkhwkhu duudqjhphqw olnh UMY
dqg U)G duwho pd| khos up yhu ph wkh zd whixo h uw gxsol dwl q hh w
d ldwhg zlwk wul wo| q q shudwlyh ehkdyl xu lq wkh U)G skd h1
K zhyhu/ lq wkh di uhphqwl qhg olwhudwxuh/ wh kq o jl do h{whuqdolwlh duh q0
lghuhg d h{ jhq x w up 1 Wkl d xpswl q l dujxdeoh/ lq wkdw UMY dqg
U)G duwho pd| lqghhg mx wli| wkh lghd wkdw up kduh wkhlu nq zohgjh w d
odujhu h{whqw wkdq wkh| z xog lq d h i lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh 1 Wkdw l / dq| i up
i shudwl q lq U)G pd| doo z up q w qo| w uhgx h lqglylgxdo d zhoo d
lqgx wu| h{shqglwxuh / exw do w lqwhuqdol h h{whuqdolwlh d px k d s leoh
wku xjk wkh hqg jhq x pdq hxyulqj i sloo yhu 1
W xu nq zohgjh/ wkh h{l wlqj qwulexwl q h{so ulqj wkl l xh duh wk h i
Ndw} +4<;9,/ Ndw xod dqg Xosk +4<<;, dqg S |dj 0Wkh w n| +4<<<,1 Lq sdu0
wl xodu/ Ndw xod dqg Xosk +4<<;, hydoxdwh wkh ehkdyl xu i d uh hdu k m lqw
yhqwxuh +UMY, djdlq w lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh / w qg wkdw wkh sloo yhu d l0
dwhg zlwk dq UMY duh dw ohd w d kljk d wk h d ldwhg zlwk wkh dowhuqdwlyh
duudqjhphqw1 Rq wkh qwudu|/ d uh hqw hpslul do qwulexwl q e| Fd lpdq dqg
Yhxjhohu +4<<<, qg wkdw wkh su edelolw| i shudwlqj lq U)G l gluh wo|
uhodwhg w dssu suldelolw| +l1h1/ wkh su edelolw| lq uh h zlwk lq plqj sloo yhu
dqg gh uhd h zlwk xwj lqj sloo yhu ,1
Lq wkl sdshu/ zh dqdo| h e wk wkh wkh uhwl do dqg wkh hpslul do lgh i wkh l 0
4
Lq sduwl xodu/ i u lqwhu0lqgx wu| sloo yhu lq U)G d wlylwlh / hh Ehuq whlq dqg Qdglul
+4<;;,1
4
xh i lqi updwl q kdulqj/ u wh kq o jl do h{whuqdolwlh 1 Wkh wkh uhwl do dqdo| l
l duulhg xw do qj wkh dssu d k lqwu gx hg e| Dplu +4<<;,/ zkhuh hd k up*
U)G w duh lq uhd lqj lq wkh dp xqw i lqi updwl q wudq plwwhg w wkhu
up 1 Zh h{whqg kl dqdo| l w d xqw i u wkh s lelolw| wkdw up qwu o
sloo yhu 1 D d ehq kpdun/ zh uhd h wkh odujho| gl x hg d h i d |pphw0
ul F xuq w gx s o|1 Wkhq/ zh lqyh wljdwh dq d |pphwul F xuq w0Vwd nhoehuj
gx s o| zkhuh qh up l wkh ohdghu dw wkh pdunhw wdjh1 Wkh pdlq uh xow dq
eh xppdul hg d i oo z 1
Ilu w/ q lghu F xuq w0Qd k ehkdyl xu dw wkh pdunhwlqj wdjh1 D m lqw yhq0
wxuh/ ehlqj dq ujdql dwl qdo gh ljq phdqw w idy xu lqi updwl q kdulqj/ lqy oyh
odujhu sloo yhu wkdq lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh 1 Wkhq/ wkhuh hphujh wkdw m lqw su w
pd{lpl dwl q dw wkh U)G wdjh +U)G duwho, kd d w0 dylqj hh w d psduhg
w q q shudwlyh ehkdyl xu li dqg qo| li sloo yhu duh o z hq xjk1 Wkl hqwdlo
wkdw/ li sloo yhu duh hqg jhq x o| qwu oohg/ lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh su ylgh wkh
uljkw lq hqwlyh w zdug w dylqj1
Vh qg/ q lghu F xuq w0Vwd nhoehuj ehkdyl xu dw wkh pdunhw wdjh1 Khuh/
zh qo| h{dplqh wul wo| q q shudwlyh ehkdyl xu z1u1w1 sloo yhu dqg U)G
h uw 1 Zh qg wkdw +l, wkh ohdghu* U)G lqyh wphqw l odujhu wkdq wkh i oo zhu*
li wkh sloo yhu iu p wkh i uphu w zdug wkh odwwhu l x! lhqwo| o z> +ll, li up
psohwho| qwu o wkhlu uh sh wlyh sloo yhu / wkh ohdghu lqyh w oh wkdq xqghu
wkh Qd k h xloleulxp oxwl q/ zkloh wkh ss lwh k og i u wkh pdunhw i oo zhu1
Zh wh w ph i wkh lpsol dwl q i wkh wkh uhwl do dqdo| l x lqj d pl u 0
djjuhjdwhg yhu l q i wkh u w F ppxqlw| Lqq ydwl q Vxuyh| +FLV, gdwded h
su ylghg e| Hxu wdw/ lq uhodwl q w i xu lqgx wulh +wh{wloh / o wklqj/ khpl do
dqg ph kdql do hqjlqhhulqj, lq pdqxid wxulqj i u yh HX xqwulh = Ehojlxp/
Ghqpdun/ Jhupdq|/ Lwdo|/ dqg Q uzd|1 F q hqwudwl q l phd xuhg e| wkh Olqgd
lqgh{1
Rxu qglqj dq eh xppdul hg d i oo z 1 Ilu w/ wkh hpslul do lqyh wljdwl q
xjjh w wkdw wkh h{whqw w zkl k up hqg jhq x o| qwu o sloo yhu l uhod0
wlyho| o z1 Vh qg/ i u wh{wloh dqg o wklqj/ wkh hpslul do wh w xss uw wkh odlp
wkdw U)G shudwl q hqwdlo d kljkhu ohyho i U)G h uw1 Wkh ss lwh hphujh
q huqlqj U)G lqwhq lw| lq khpl do dqg ph kdql do hqjlqhhulqj1 Wkh uh xow
ewdlqhg iu p wkh
doh lqwhq lyh
+Wh{wloh , dqg wkh
xssolhu g plqdwhg
+Fo wk0
lqj, lqgx wulh xjjh w wkdw zkhq zq U)G l q w d uhohydqw d wkhu xu h i
wh kq o jl do lpsu yhphqw/ shudwlqj lq U)G pd| hqkdq h wkh pplwphqw/
dqg lpsu yh wkh delolw|/ w duu| xw zq U)G1 Wklug/ lq wkuhh lqgx wulh wkh
wh w qup wkdw U)G shudwl q pd| lq uhd h lqi updwl q h{ kdqjh ehwzhhq
up / wkhuhe| hqkdq lqj sloo yhu 1
Wkh uhpdlqghu i wkh sdshu l wux wxuhg d i oo z 1 Wkh wkh uhwl do dqdo| l
l duulhg xw lq h wl q 51 Wkh gdwd hw l gh ulehg lq h wl q 61 Vh wl q 7
qwdlq wkh h{s lwl q i hpslul do uh xow 1 Ilqdoo|/ q oxglqj uhpdun duh lq
h wl q 81
5

5 Wkh wkh uhwl do hwxs
Zh e uu z wkh wkh uhwl do iudphz un iu p Dplu +4<<;/ hh do Klqo shq/ 4<<:,1
Zh q lghu d gx s o| zkhuh xdqwlw|0 hwwlqj up xsso| k p jhqh x su g0
x w / pdunhw ghpdqg ehlqj
R
'
@

^


^
2

+4,
Ilup

* q wdqw pdujlqdo w l jlyhq e|
S

'
S

%


q

%

c
zkhuh
%

l wkh
U)G lqyh wphqw i up

lq w uhgx lqj d wlylwlh / dqg sdudphwhu
q

5
d
c
o
phd xuh wkh dp xqw i sloo yhu iu p up

w up

1 Wkh U)G w ixq wl q i
hd k up l
g

E
%

'

2

En
q


%
2


Re huyh wkdw wkh sloo yhu w up

hqwhu wkh
w ixq wl q i up

d w pdnh lw wo| w wkh odwwhu w wudq plw nq zohgjh
w wkh ulydo1
5
Wkh su w ixq wl q o n d i oo z =
Z

'
E
@

^


^


S
n
%

n
q

%


^



2E n
q


%
2


+5,
D k zq e| Dplu +4<<;> hh
Klqo shq/ 4<<:/ i u psxwdwl qdo ghwdlo ,/ wkl hw0
wlqj hq psd h e wk g*D suhp qw dqg Md xhplq +4<;;, dqg Ndplhq/ Pxoohu
dqg ]dqj +4<<5,1
6
Zh zloo h{dplqh wkh i oo zlqj d h =

D |pphwul gx s o| zkhuh
%

dqg
^

duh e wk hw lpxowdqh x o|/ zlwk
%

ehlqj k hq hlwkhu shudwlyho| u q q shudwlyho|/ zkloh
^

l dozd| hw
q q shudwlyho|1
7

Dq d |pphwul gx s o| zlwk d g plqdqw up dw wkh pdunhw wdjh1 Khuh/
U)G h uw duh k hq q q shudwlyho| dqg lpxowdqh x o|/ zkloh wkh pdu0
nhw wdjh l sod|hg
ãod
Vwd nhoehuj1
Lq e wk d h / zh zloo lqyh wljdwh wkh ehdulqj q up * shui updq h d zhoo
d q ldo zhoiduh i m lqw y lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh 1 E| wkl zh phdq wkdw zh
duh j lqj w p gho h{sol lwo| up * k l h q huqlqj wkh l}h i sloo yhu
q


Q wl h wkdw wkh su w ixq wl q +5, i up

l / uh sh wlyho|/ olqhdu dqg lq uhd lqj
lq
q

/ dqg olqhdu dqg gh uhd lqj lq
q


Wkl pdnh lw s leoh w h wdeol k wkdw lw
l lq wkh lqwhuh w i hd k up w hw
q

'
+uh sh wlyho|/
q

'
, li up k h
l
qghshqghqw yhqwxuh +uh s1/ li wkh hw xs d m lqw yhqwxuh,1
8
5
Lq Dplu +4<<;,/ |pphwul sloo yhu duh q lghuhg iu p wkh xw hw/ wkdw wkh U)G w
ixq wl q l
N
l
+
{
l
,@
4
5

+4.

,
{
5
l
=
Dowhuqdwlyho|/ sloo yhu hh w pd| pdwhuldol h xqghu su gx w
lqq ydwl q/ yld wkh ghpdqg ixq wl q + hh Odpehuwlql dqg U lql/ 4<<;> Odpehuwlql
hw do1
/
4<<;,1
6
I u wkh wudwhjl uhohydq h i hqg jhq x sloo yhu lq U)G ud h / hh Gh Iudmd +4<<6,1
7
Wkh s lelolw| wkdw up shudwh dw wkh pdunhw wdjh l q lghuhg e wk lq g*D suhp qw
dqg Md xhplq +4<;;, dqg lq Dplu +4<<;,1 Zh d|  shudwh udwkhu wkdq  ooxgh eh dx h
duwho wdelolw| l q w kdud whul hg lq hlwkhu i wkh h sdshu 1
8
Wkh hqg jhq x i updwl q +dqg wkh swlpdo l}h, i dolwl q / l1h1/ U)G m lqw yhqwxuh / l
lqyh wljdwhg e| l dqg Vklq +5333, lq d p gho zlwk
q
up 1
6
514 F x
uq w0Qd k pshwlwl q
Zh q lghu khuh wkh d h zkhuh wkh pdunhw wdjh l sod|hg lpxowdqh x o|1 Su 0
hhglqj e| ed nzdug lqgx wl q/ wkh pdunhw wdjh l oyhg u w i u jlyhq ydoxh
i
%

dqg
q


Wkh u w ughu qglwl q +IRF , duh=
YZ

Y^

'
@

2
^


^
2

S
n
%

n
q
2
%
2
'
+6,
YZ
2
Y^
2
'
@

2
^
2

^


S
n
%
2
n
q

%

'
+7,
zk h oxwl q |lhog wkh F xuq w0Qd k h xloleulxp xdqwlwlh =
^


'
@

S
nE2

q


%


E

2
q
2

%
2

+8,
^

2
'
@

S
nE2

q
2

%
2

E

2
q


%


+9,
Soxjjlqj +8, dqg +9, lqw wkh su w ixq wl q +5, dqg lpsoli|lqj/ qh jhw wkh
uhohydqw emh wlyh ixq wl q i up

dw wkh h qg wdjh i wkh jdph=
Z

'
k
@

S
nE2

q


%


E

2
q


%

l
2
b


E n
q


%
2

2
+:,
Vxss h u w wkdw up dq shuih wo| qwu o wkh uh lsu do sloo yhu hh w / d
lq S |dj 0Wkh w n| +4<<<,1 Re huyh wkdw
Z

l sdude ol dqg qyh{ lq
q


Lq
sduwl xodu/
Y
2
Z

*Yq
2

'
2
%
2

*
b
:
i u doo dgpl leoh ohyho i wkh up* U)G
h uw1
9
Khq h/ zh dq qo| h{sh w uqhu oxwl q lq wkh h qg wdjh/ zkhuh
up gh lgh yhu wkh h{whqw i wkh uh lsu do sloo yhu 1 Wkl ohdg w
Ohppd 4
D xph up dq shuih wo| qwu o wkh uh lsu do sloo yhu 1 Li /
up * k l h d w wkhlu uh lsu do sloo yhu duh d i oo z =
+l,
Lqghshqghqw Yhqwxuh 1
Zkhq up g q w shudwh lq whup i lqi u0
pdwl q kdulqj/ wkhq
q

'
;

+ll,
M lqw Yhqwxuh1
Li up hw xs d m lqw yhqwxuh dw wkh h qg wdjh/ wkhq
q

'

;

F q lghu q z wkh u w wdjh/ zkhuh up gh lgh xs q wkhlu U)G h uw
%


Ilu w/ h{dplqh wkh lwxdwl q zkhuh up sod| q q shudwlyho| lq wkh uh hdu k
wdjh1
9
S |dj 0Wkh w n| +4<<<, d xph wkdw wkh w i lqq ydwl q duh
+
{
5
l
,
@
5
=
K zhyhu/ wkl
g h q w dh w wkh ljq i
C
l
@C
l
/ zkl k l dozd| qhjdwlyh1
7
51414 Q q shudwlyh U)G d wlylwlh
I u jhqhul sloo yhu ohyho / wkh uhohydqw IRF i u up

l =
YZ

Y%

'
2E2

q


k
@

S
nE2

q


%


E

2
q


%

l
b


E n
q


%

'
+;,
Lps lqj
q

'
q

'
q
dqg oylqj i
u |pphwul h uw ohyho
%

'
%

|lhog =
:
%

'
2E2

q
E
@

S

E n
q
Eb

n2
q

e
+<,
I oo zlqj S
|dj 0Wkh w n| +4<<<,/ qh pd| hqg jhql h wkh l}h i wkh sloo yhu/
ghshqglqj xs q wkh ujdql dwl qdo gh ljq i U)G d wlylw|1 Xqghu lqghshqghqw
yhqwxuh +
UT
,/ hwwlqj
q

'
dqg lps lqj wkh eyl x |pphwu| qglwl q
%

'
%

|lhog swlpdo U)G lqyh wphqw
%

E
U
T
'eE
@

S

*
Eb


e
c
zkl k l
d hswdeoh
i u doo
:
e
*
b

;
H xloleulxp xwsxw duh
^

E
UT
'E
@

S

*
Eb


e

Wkh uuh s qglqj h xloleulxp su w / q xphu xusox dqg ldo zhoiduh duh
Z

E
UT
'E
@

S

2

Eb


H
*
Eb


e
2
(
7

E
UT
'HE
@

S

2

2
*
Eb


e
2
(
dqg
7`

E
UT
'2
Z

E
UT
n
7

E
UT
'eE
@

S

2
*
Eb


e

Xqghu m lqw yhqwxuh +
aT
,/ hwwlqj
q

'

dqg lps lqj djdlq |pphwu|
%

'
%

|lhog lqglylgxdo h xloleulxp
U)G h uw
%

E
aT
'E
@

S

*
Eb


2
c
zkl k
l d hswdeoh i u doo

:
2
*
b

Wkh h xloleulxp shu0up su gx wl q ohyho i wkh
qdo j g l
^

E
aT
'E
@

S

*
Eb


2

Wkh uuh s qglqj h xloleulxp su w /
q xphu xusox dqg ldo zhoiduh duh
Z

E
aT
'E
@

S

2

Eb



*
Eb


2
2
(
7

E
aT
 ' HE
@

S

2

2
*
Eb


2
2
(
dqg
7`

E
aT
'2
Z

E
aT
n
7

E
aT

'2E
@

S

2

EH



*
Eb


2
2

F psdulqj
%

E
UT

dqg
%

E
aT

su gx h wkh
i oo zlqj=
Uhpdun 4
Li wkh U)G w sdudphwhu

5
E2
*
b
c
e
*
b
c
up pd| d wlydwh d m lqw
yhqw
xuh zkloh wkh| dqq w k h lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh 1
51415 U)G duwho
F q lghu q z wkh d h i m lqw su w pd{lpl}dwl q lq wkh U)G h uw
ohyho 1 Wkh
duwho su eohp/ ghqhg i u jhqhul sloo yhu ohyho / l =
4@
%

c%
2


'
Z

n
Z
2
'
b
2
[

'
d
@

S
n
%

E2

q



%

E

2
q

o
2


2
2
[

'
En
q


%
2

+43,
:
I u d d h zkhuh wkh jo edo pd{lpxp pd| lqy oyh d |pphwul U)G lqyh wphqw dw wkh
u w wdjh/ hh Vdodqw dqg Vkdhu +
4<<;,1
;
D |psw wl wdelolw| uh xluh wkdw

C
5

l
C{
5
l

5


C
5

l
C{
l
C{
m

5

3
=
lq dq shq qhljke x
uk g i wkh h xloleulxp1 I u wkh dnh i euhylw|/ zh plw wkh uhodwhg
do xodwl q 1 Vhh Tlx +4<<:,1
8
|lhoglqj wkh i oo zlqj IRF=
Y


Y%

'E2 n 2
q

E
@

S
n
%

d

S
q

n
q
2


b

E n
q

o
bn
+44,
n

2
%

de

DE
q

n
q



e
q

q

o
b'

Xqghu wkh uhd qdeoh d xpswl q wkdw
q

'
q

'
q
c
wkh |pphwul oxwl q w
+44, l =
%

'
%

'
%

'
2E
@

S

b


2
q

2

+45,
Wkhq/ xe wlwxwlqj dqg |psoli|lqj |lhog lqglylgxdo xwsxw ohyho
^

'
E
@

S

*
Eb


2
q

2
dqg duwho su w
Z

'
E
@

S

2
*
Eb


2
q

2

F q xphu xusox
dw wkh shudwlyh h xloleulxp dp xqw w
7

'
HE
@

S

2

2
*
Eb


2
q

2
2
c
dqg qdoo| ldo zhoiduh l
7`

'
eE
@

S

2

Eb


q


*
Eb


2
q

2
2

Vhwwlqj
q
'
u
q
'
c
dowhuqdwlyho|/ |lhog wkh uhohydqw h xloleulxp pdjqlwxgh lq wkh
d h i lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh u m lqw yhqwxuh / uh sh wlyho|1 Wkl doo z x w
wdwh wkh i oo zlqj su s lwl q + hh Dplu/ 4<<;/ Dsshqgl{,=
Su s lwl q 4
F psduh wkh U)G h uw ohyho
%

dqg
%

G
+l, Xqghu lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh / hw
q
'
dqg d xph

:
e
*
b
lq ughu i u
%

E
aT

dqg
%

E
aT

w eh e wk dg
pl leoh1 Wkhq/
%

E
aT

:%

E
aT


+ll, Xq
ghu m lqw yhqwxuh/ hw
q
'

dqg d xph
:
2
*
b
lq ughu i u
%

E
UT

dqg
%

E
UT

w eh e wk dgpl leoh1 Wkhq/
%

E
UT

%

E
UT


D up* lqglylgxdo suhihuhq h yhu wkh dowhuqdwlyh duudqjhphqw i u lqq yd0
wlyh d wlylwlh duh xppdul hg e|=
Su s lwl q 5
Z

E
aT

:Z

E
aT

:Z

E
UT

:Z

E
UT

i u doo
:
e
*
b

Su s lwl q 5 h wdeol kh wkdw/ yhudoo/ wkh m lqw yhqwxuh ohduo| g plqdwh
lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh iu p wkh lqglylgxdo up* ylhzs lqw1 Lq whdg/ wkh q0
yhqlhq h i shudwl q dw wkh u w wdjh l dpeljx x / lq wkdw wkh k l h i
q q shudwlyh uh hdu k h uw g plqdwh shudwl q li wkh i uphu shu sh wlyh
l d psdqlhg e| d m lqw yhqwxuh zkloh wkh h qg pelqh zlwk lqghshqghqw
yhqwxuh 1 Re huyh wkdw wkh kdlq i lqh xdolwlh lq wkh de yh su s lwl q idlo w
k og li

5
E2
*
b
c
e
*
b
c
zkhuh qo| lqghshqghqw yhqwxuh duh dgpl leoh zkloh wkh
m lqw yhqwxuh l q w1
V ldo suhihuhq h uhpdlq w hydoxdwh1 Wkl l g qh lq wkh i oo zlqj=
Su s lwl q 6
7`

E
aT

:7`

E
UT

:7`

E
aT

:7`

E
UT

i u doo

:
e
*
b

Ilqdoo|/ su s lwl q
5 dqg 6 su gx h wkh i oo zlqj uhohydqw u oodu|=
F u oodu| 4
Wkh pelqdwl q i U)G shudwl q dqg m lqw yhqwxuh dsshdu d
wkh eh w swl q iu p e wk wkh lqglylgxdo dqg wkh ldo wdqgs lqw1
9
Wdeoh 61
Hpslul do wh
w i Su s lwl q 7 dqg 8
Pdunhw ohdghu kdyh d o zhu lq hqwlyh w lqyh w lq U)G
W|sh i p Phdq Vwg Ghy Q1 d h DQRYD
Doo 45:1853 <<313:
;3 68<3
U)G
I oo zhu :31648; 5<;1:<<5 6345 9618;75
WWW
Wh{w1
Ohdghu 7581;8:3 5684185;3 8::
Doo 417997 51<57< 68<3
U)GbHPSO
I oo zhu 415885 516496 6345 43315:79
WWW
Ohdghu 5189:: 71;:9< 8::
Doo <5:19;39 786<174;< 47;8
U)G
I oo zhu :918<:6 43;3139<4 43:3 47;14;;3
WWW
Fo wk1
Ohdghu 64581:9:4 ;34619:83 747
Doo 514436 ;1446; 47;8
U)GbHPSO
I oo zhu 31:773 716<<4 43:3 44:15:8<
WWW
Ohdghu 8196<4 451<<97 747
Doo 6:841;6<3 695951:898 666<
U)G
I oo zhu 43951:98; 99451;7:5 5:<3 <81;;73
WWW
Fkhp1
Ohdghu 4:73916778 ;9<6<153;< 87<
Doo 4815539 4:;17<57 666<
U)GbHPSO
I oo zhu 4:1398; 4<815435 5:<3 41;457
Ohdghu 81;843 918573 87<
Doo 9;4196<< 7;9:1853< 46683
U)G
I oo zhu 99413654 7:<3177:6 46646 ;91<;;3
WWW
Ph k1
Ohdghu ;45813:;7 4893:15<58 6:
Hqj1
Doo :1:987 4381:768 4667;
U)GbHPSO
I oo zhu :1::73 4381;;<6 46644 31364<
Ohdghu 7198<4 81;73< 6:
---1 Vljql dqw dw <8( ohyho i qghq h
Zlwk wkh u w phd xuh i lqq ydwlyh d wlylw
|/ wkh uh xow suhgl whg e| wkh wkh0
u| l uhmh whg lq doo lqgx wulh = Vwd nhoehuj ohdghu lqyh w lq U)G p uh wkdq
Vwd nhoehuj i oo zhu 1 Wkl pd| xjjh w wkdw wkh h{whqw/ li dq|/ w zkl k up
qwu o sloo yhu l uhodwlyho| o z1 P uh qwu yhu ldo qglqj duh i xqg zkhq
x lqj wkh phd xuh i u U)G lqwhq lw|= lqghhg/ i u e wk khpl do dqg ph kdql do
hqjlqhhulqj 0 qdpho|/ wkh wz lqgx wulh wkdw/ d uglqj w wkhlu jhqhudo wh kq 0
o jl do ihdwxuh / duh olnho| w eh p uh ohduo| pplwwhg w zq U)G 0 lw wxuq
xw wkdw Vwd nhoehuj ohdghu lqyh w lq U)G oh wkdq Vwd nhoehuj i oo zhu / exw
wkh glhuhq h lq wkh phdq ydoxh duh q w wdwl wl doo| ljql dqw1 Vlq h U)G
46

lqwhq lw| l wkh p w uholdeoh phd xuh i d up* lqy oyhphqw lq lqq ydwlyh d 0
wlylwlh / wkh h uh xow dq eh wdnhq d d sduwldo uu e udwl q i wkh k|s wkh l
suh hqwhg lq Su s lwl q 7 dqg 8 de yh1
Wdeoh 71
Hpslul do wh w i Su s lwl q 9
U)G shudwl q ohdg w d kljkhu U)G lqyh wphqw
W|sh i p Phdq Vwg Ghy Q1 d h DQRYD
Doo 45:18453 <<313:;9
68<3
U)G
U)GF s QR 4591:84: 43:31<:65 638< 313455
WWW
Wh{w1
U)GF s HV 4641;<57 4741<333 864
Doo 417997 51<57< 68<3
U)GbHPSO
U)GF s QR 4139;7 51;568 638< 75;185<39
WWW
U)GF s HV 61:8<4 516<<4 864
Doo <5:19;4; 786<1754; 47;8
U)G
U)GF s QR ;8715<67 76:617674 476< 4516367
WWW
Fo wk1
U)GF s HV 656917683 :<691;49; 79
Doo 514436 ;1446< 47;8
U)GbHPSO
U)GF s QR 41<<5; :1:;6: 476< <1;85<
WWW
U)GF s HV 81;396 471;;96 79
Doo 6:841;69: 695951:736 666<
U)G
U)GF s QR 5<:<19868 6:38<19596 5;96 <14559
WWW
Fkhp1
U)GF s HV ;6<615748 639:419:4: 7:9
Doo 4815539 4:;17<58 666<
U)GbHPSO
U)GF s QR 4914947 4<51:73: 5;96 3188:8
U)GF s HV <18989 91679: 7:9
Doo 9;4196<< 7;9:1853< 46683
U)G
U)GF s QR 873186:4 747;17475 449;4 :;1<:96
WWW
Ph k1
U)GF s HV 499<1538: ;5781:4;5 499<
Hqj1
Doo :1:987 4381:768 4667;
U)GbHPSO
U)GF s QR ;13379 4451<<3: 449:< 317:::
U)GF s HV 913<4< <15<;8 499<
---1 Vljql dqw dw <<( ohyho i qghq h
D wdwhg lq su s lwl q 9
+ll,/ up lqy oyhg lq U)G shudwl q duh h{sh whg
w h{klelw kljkhu ohyho i U)G lqyh wphqw1 W wh w wkl wkh uhwl do suhgl wl q
hpslul doo|/ zh hpso | djdlq wkh DQRYD wh w i u wkh glhuhq h lq wkh phdq
ydoxh i U)G h uw lq wkh d h i +s hxg ,up zk duh lqy oyhg lq U)G
shudwl q dqg +s hxg ,up zk duh q w1
47
F q huqlqj wkh d h i wh{wloh
4
8
dqg o wklqj +Wdeoh 7,/ wkh hpslul do wh w
xss uw wkh k|s wkh l wkdw up lqy oyhg lq U)G shudwl q gl sod| d kljkhu
ohyho i U)G h uw/ lq whup i e wk U)G h{shqglwxuh dqg U)G lqwhq lw|1 Zlwk
uh sh w w khpl do dqg ph kdql do hqjlqhhulqj/ U)G lqwhq lw| l lq whdg o zhu
i u up zk duh lqy oyhg lq shudwlyh U)G +dowk xjk wkh glhuhq h l q w
wdwl wl doo| ljql dqw,/ zkhuhd U)G h{shqglwxuh duh ljql dqwo| kljkhu i u
0 shudwlqj up 1 Jlyhq wkh sh l ihdwxuh i wkh yhudoo lqq ydwl q su h
lq hd k lqgx wu|/ wkh uh xow hphujlqj iu p wkh
doh lqwhq lyh
+Wh{wloh , dqg wkh
x
ssolhu g plqdwhg
+Fo wklqj, lqgx wulh
4
9
xjjh w wkdw zkhq zq U)G l q w d
uhohydqw d wkhu xu h i wh kq o jl do lqsxw +h1j1/ nq zohgjh hpe glhg lq qhz
pd klqhu| dqg wh kql do h xlsphqw/ ohduqlqj e| g lqj/ hw 1,/ shudwlyh U)G
l d zd| w hqkdq h wkh pplwphqw/ dqg lpsu yh wkh delolw|/ w duu| xw zq
U)G1 F qyhu ho|/ lq lqgx wulh zkl k uho| p wo| xs q zq U)G d d xu h i
lqq ydwl q/ olnh khpl do dqg ph kdql do hqjlqhhulqj/ ulydo up duh p uh olnho|
w eh lqy oyhg lq i updo dqg lqi updo wudglqj i su sulhwdu| nq z0k z1
Wdeoh 81
Hpslul do wh w i Su s lwl q :
F shudwl q hqkdq h wkh ohyho i U)G sloo yhu
W|sh i up Phdq Vwg Ghy Q1 d h DQRYD
Doo 4318433 318:93 68<3
Wh{w1
U)GF s QR 4318658 3193:5 638< 641<4;3
WWW
U)GF s HV 4316;35 31648: 864
Doo 4319559 41::78 47:7
@
Fo wk1
U)GF s QR 4318<74 41:<87 475; 441<738
WWW
Dp xqw i
U)GF s h 441844: 313;<; 79
Vsloo yhu
Doo 4715;;6 318;3: 666<
Fkhp1
U)GF s QR 4715995 318:<6 5;96 5<1634;
WWW
U)GF s HV 4717544 138:4< 7:9
Doo 461;933 3189;8 46683
Ph k1
U)GF s QR 461;7;3 318:47 449;4 741;63<
WWW
Hqj1
U)GF s HV 461<774 318735 499<
---1 Vljql dqw dw <<( ohyho i qghq h> d1 Wkh glhuhq h l gxh w pl lqj ydoxh
Lq su s lwl q : de yh/ zh d huw wkdw lqy oyhphqw lq U)G shudwl q pd|
e w wkh h{ kdqjh i lqi updwl q ehwzhhq up / wkhuhe| hqkdq lqj wkh ohyho i
U)G sloo yhu 1 D uglqj w wkh uh xow k zq lq Wdeoh 8 0 djdlq ewdlqhg e|
uxqqlqj wkh DQRYD wh w i u wkh glhuhq h lq wkh phdq ydoxh i U)G h uw 0
4
8
Hyhq li/ lq wkh
d h i U)G h{shqglwxuh / wkh glhuhq h l q w wdwl wl doo| ljql dqw1
4
9
Zkl k kdyh ehhq k zq e| Sdylww +4<;7, w uho| dop w h{ ox lyho| + xssolhu g plqdwhg,
dqg ljql dqwo| + doh lqwhq lyh, q h{whuqdo xu h i lqq ydwl q1
48
Su s lwl q : l quphg lq wkuhh lqgx wulh xw i i xu= zlwk wkh oh h{ hswl q
i wkh wh{wloh lqgx wu|/
4
:
+s hxg ,up lqy oyhg lq U)G shudwl q ehqhw iu p
d kljkhu ohyho i sloo yhu 1
8 F q oxglq
j uhpdun
Zh kdyh lqyh wljdwhg hyhudo d sh w i up * U)G d wlylw|/ xqghu wkh d xpswl q
wkdw xdqwlw|0 hwwlqj up pd| qwu o wh kq o jl do h{whuqdolwlh 1 Zh kdyh q0
lghuhg e wk F xuq w0Qd k dqg F xuq w0Vwd nhoehuj ehkdyl xu1 Xqghu F xuq w0
Qd k ehkdyl xu dw wkh pdunhw wdjh/ zh kdyh dgguh hg dq l xh wkdw kdyh ehhq
odujho| ghedwhg lq wkh h{l wlqj olwhudwxuh/ qdpho|/ zkhwkhu shudwl q +hlwkhu d
d m lqw yhqwxuh u d dq U)G duwho, hqwdlo d uhgx wl q lq wkh zhoo nq zq hi0
i uw gxsol dwl q hh w d ldwhg zlwk wul wo| q q shudwlyh ehkdyl xu1 Xqghu
F xuq w0Vwd nhoehuj ehkdyl xu/ zh kdyh lqyh wljdwhg wkh lq hqwlyh w lqyh w lq
U)G zkhq up duh d |pphwul 1 Wkh hpslul do dqdo| l g h q w su ylgh xs0
s uw w wkh lghd wkdw up qwu o sloo yhu 1 Lqghhg/ lw dsshdu wkdw sloo yhu
duh dq hqylu qphqwdo ihdwxuh qglwl qlqj up * h uw / udwkhu wkdq wkh ss 0
lwh1 P uh yhu/ wkh w0 dylqj hh w d ldwhg w m lqw yhqwxuh u U)G duwho
l quphg i u lqgx wulh zkhuh up uho| pdlqo| xs q zq U)G d d xu h i
lqq ydwl q1 Ilqdoo|/ shudwlqj lq U)G lq uhd h wkh wudq pl l q i nq zohgjh/
wkhuhe| hqkdq lqj sloo yhu 1
4
:
Dowk xjk wkhlu glhuhq h duh wdwl wl doo| ljql dqw/ wkh de oxwh ohyho i wkh phdq ydoxh
duh yhu| o h w hd k wkhu1
49
Uhihuhq h
^4` Dplu/ U1 +4<<;,/ P ghoolqj Lpshuih wo| Dssu suldeoh U)G yld Vsloo yhu /
gl x l q sdshu <;03:/ FLH/ F shqkdjhq1
^5` Ehuq whlq/ M1L1 dqg P1L1 Qdglul +4<;;,/ Lqwhulqgx wu| U)G Vsloo yhu / Udwh
i Uhwxuq dqg Su wh wl q lq Kljk0Wh k Lqgx wulh /
Dphul dq H q pl Uh0
ylhz
/
:;
+S)S,/ 75<0671
^6` Fd lpdq/ E1 dqg U1 Yhxjhohu +4<<<,/ U)G F shudwl q dqg Vsloo yhu =
V ph Hpslul do Hylghq h
/ FHSU Gl x l q Sdshu q 1 5663/ FHSU/ O q0
g q1
^7` g*D suhp qw/ F1 dqg D1 Md xhplq +4<;;,/ F shudwlyh dqg Q q shud0
wlyh U)G lq d Gx s o| zlwk Vsloo yhu /
Dphul dq H q pl Uhylhz
/
:;
/
44660:1
^8` gh E qgw/ U1/ S1 Vodhw dqg E1 Fd lpdq +4<<5,/ Wkh Ghjuhh i Vsloo yhu
dqg wkh Qxpehu i Ulydo i u Pd{lpxp Hh wlyh U)G/
Lqwhuqdwl qdo M xu0
qdo i Lqgx wuldo Rujdql}dwl q
/
43
/ 680871
^9` Gh Iudmd/ J1 +4<<6,/ Vwudwhjl Vsloo yhu lq Sdwhqw Ud h /
Lqwhuqdwl qdo
M xuqdo i Lqgx wuldo Rujdql}dwl q
/
44
/ 46<0791
^
:` Ghoe q / I1 dqg Y1 Ghql oõ +4<<4,/ Ud h i Uh hdu k dqg Ghyho s0
phqw ehwzhhq Ilup zlwk Glhuhqw Lq hqwlyh w Lqq ydwh/
Uh khu kh
H q pl xh gh O xydlq
/
8:
/ 4360561
^;` Jhu nl/ S1 +4<<8d,/ G Vsloo yhu Xqghuplqh wkh Lq hqwlyh w Lqq ydwhB/
lq G zul n/ V1 +hg1,/
H q pl Dssu d kh
w Lqq ydwl q
/ Doghu k w/ Hojdu1
^<` Jhu nl/ S1 +4<<8e,/ Pdunhw i u Wh kq o j|= Nq zohgjh/ Lqq ydwl q dqg
Dssu suldelolw|/ lq Vw qhpdq/ S1 +hg1,/
Kdqge n i wkh H q pl i Lq0
q ydwl q dqg Wh kq o jl do Fkdqjh
/ R{i ug/ Eod nzhoo1
^43` Julol kh / ]1 +4<<8,/ U)G dqg Su gx wlylw|= H q phwul Uh xow dqg Phd0
xuhphqw L xh / lq Vw qhpdq/ S1 +hg1,/
Kdqge n i wkh H q pl i
Lqq ydwl q dqg Wh kq o jl do Fkdqjh
/ R{i ug/ Eod nzhoo1
^44` Ju pdq/ J1 dqg F1 Vkdslu +4<;:,/ G|qdpl U)G F pshwlwl q/
H 0
q pl M xuqdo
/
<:
/ 6:50;:1
^45` Khqul xh / L1 +4<<3,/ F shudwlyh dqg Q q shudwlyh U)G zlwk Vsloo yhu =
F pphqw/
Dphul dq H q pl
Uhylhz
/
;3
/ 96;0731
^46` Klqo shq/ M1 +4<<:,/ Vxe lgl}lqj U)G F shudwlyh / gl x l q sdshu
<:048/ FLH/ F shqkdjhq1
^47` Klssho/ H1 y q +4<;:,/ F shudwl q Ehwzhhq Ulydo = Lq
i updo Nq z0k z
Wudglqj/
Uh hdu k S ol |
/
49
/ 5<406471
^48` Klssho/ H1 y q +4<;;,/
Wkh V xu h i Lqq yd
wl q
/ R{i ug/ R{i ug Xqlyhu lw|
Suh 1
^49` Ndplhq/ P1/ H1 Pxoohu dqg L1 ]dqj +4<<5,/ Uh hdu k M lqw Yhqwxuh dqg
U)G Fduwho /
Dphul dq H q pl Uhylhz
/
85
/ 45<6046391
^4:` Ndw xod / 1 dqg G1 Xosk +4<<;,/ Hqg jhq x Vsloo yhu dqg wkh Shu0
4:
i updq h i Uh hdu k M lqw Yhqwxuh /
M xuqdo i
Lqgx wuldo H q pl
/
79
/
66608:1
^4;` Ndw}/ P1 +4<;9,/ Dq Dqdo| l i F shudwlyh Uh hdu k dqg Ghyho sphqw
/
UDQG M xuqdo i H q pl
/
4:
/ 85:0761
^4<` Ndw}/ P1 dqg M1 Rug yhu +4<<3,/ U)G F shudwl q dqg F
pshwlwl q/
Eu nlqj Sdshu
/
Pl u h q pl
/ 46:05361
^53` Odpehuwlql/ O1 dqg J1 U lql +4<<;,/ Su gx w K p jhqhlw| d d Sul qhu*
Glohppd lq d Gx s o| zlwk U)G/
H q pl Ohwwhu
/
8;
/ 5<:06341
^54` Odpehuwlql/ O1/ V1 S ggdu dqg G1 Vd dnl +4<<;,/ Vwdqgdugl}dwl q dqg wkh
Vwdelolw| i F oox l q/
H q pl Ohwwhu
/
8;
/ 6360431
^55` Sdylww/ N1 +4<;7,/ Vh
w udo Sdwwhuq i Wh kql do Fkdqjh= W zdug d Wd{0
q p| dqg d Wkh u|/
Uh hdu k S ol |
/
46
/ 6760:61
^56` S |dj 0Wkh w n|/ M1 +4<<<,/ D Q wh q
Hqg jhq x Vsloo yhu lq d Q q0
W xuqdphqw U)G Gx s o|/
Uhylhz i Lqgx wuldo Rujdql}dwl q
/
48
/ 5860951
^57`
Tlx/ O1 +4<<:,/ Rq wkh G|qdpl H! lhq | i Ehuwudqg dqg F xuq w H xl0
oleuld/
M xuqdo i H q pl Wkh u|
/
:8
/ 54605<1
^58` Vdodqw/ V1 dqg J1 Vkdhu +4<<;,/ Rswlpdo D |pphwul Vwudwhjlh lq Uh0
hdu k M lqw Yhqwxuh = F pphqw q wkh Olwhudwxuh/
Lqwhuqdwl qdo M
xuqdo
i Lqgx wuldo Rujdql}dwl q
/
49
/ 4<8053;1
^59` Vx}xpxud/ N1 +4<<5,/ F shudwlyh dqg Q q shudwlyh U)G zlwk
Vsl
oo yhu lq Rolj s o|/
Dphul dq H q pl Uhylhz
/
;5
/ 463:0531
^5:` l/ V10V1 dqg K1 Vklq +5333,/ Hqg jhq x I updwl q i Uh hdu k
F dolwl q
zlwk Vsloo yhu /
Lqwhuqdwl qdo M xuqdo Ri Lqgx wuldo Rujdql}dwl q
/
4;
/ 55<0
891
4;