de la Puen e Pacheco, Ma io Albe o; A ias, Elkyn Lugo; To es, Jose
A icle
Op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s: an
expe imen al case s udy in Ba anquilla, Colombia
Cogen Economics & Finance
P o ided in Coope a ion wi h:
Taylo & F ancis G oup
Sugges ed Ci a ion: de la Puen e Pacheco, Ma io Albe o; A ias, Elkyn Lugo; To es, Jose (2024) :
Op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s: an expe imen al case s udy in Ba anquilla,
Colombia, Cogen Economics & Finance, ISSN 2332-2039, Taylo & F ancis, Abingdon, Vol. 12, Iss. 1,
pp. 1-15,
h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/23322039.2024.2391937
This Ve sion is a ailable a :
h ps://hdl.handle.ne /10419/321572
S anda d-Nu zungsbedingungen:
Die Dokumen e au EconS o dü en zu eigenen wissenscha lichen
Zwecken und zum P i a geb auch gespeiche und kopie we den.
Sie dü en die Dokumen e nich ü ö en liche ode komme zielle
Zwecke e iel äl igen, ö en lich auss ellen, ö en lich zugänglich
machen, e eiben ode ande wei ig nu zen.
So e n die Ve asse die Dokumen e un e Open-Con en -Lizenzen
(insbesonde e CC-Lizenzen) zu Ve ügung ges ell haben soll en,
gel en abweichend on diesen Nu zungsbedingungen die in de do
genann en Lizenz gewäh en Nu zungs ech e.
Te ms o use:
Documen s in EconS o may be sa ed and copied o you pe sonal
and schola ly pu poses.
You a e no o copy documen s o public o comme cial pu poses, o
exhibi he documen s publicly, o make hem publicly a ailable on he
in e ne , o o dis ibu e o o he wise use he documen s in public.
I he documen s ha e been made a ailable unde an Open Con en
Licence (especially C ea i e Commons Licences), you may exe cise
u he usage igh s as speci ied in he indica ed licence.
h ps://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0/
Cogen Economics & Finance
ISSN: 2332-2039 (Online) Jou nal homepage: www. and online.com/jou nals/oae 20
Op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic ofinance
p ojec s: an expe imen al case s udy in
Ba anquilla, Colombia
Ma io Albe o de la Puen e Pacheco, Elkyn Lugo A ias & Jose To es
To ci e his a icle: Ma io Albe o de la Puen e Pacheco, Elkyn Lugo A ias & Jose To es
(2024) Op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic ofinance p ojec s: an expe imen al case
s udy in Ba anquilla, Colombia, Cogen Economics & Finance, 12:1, 2391937, DOI:
10.1080/23322039.2024.2391937
To link o his a icle: h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/23322039.2024.2391937
© 2024 The Au ho (s). Published by In o ma
UK Limi ed, ading as Taylo & F ancis
G oup
Published online: 23 Aug 2024.
Submi you a icle o his jou nal
A icle iews: 675
View ela ed a icles
View C ossma k da a
Ci ing a icles: 2 View ci ing a icles
Full Te ms & Condi ions o access and use can be ound a
h ps://www. and online.com/ac ion/jou nalIn o ma ion?jou nalCode=oae 20
GENERAL & APPLIED ECONOMICS | RESEARCH ARTICLE
Op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s:
an expe imen al case s udy in Ba anquilla, Colombia
Ma io Albe o de la Puen e Pacheco
a
, Elkyn Lugo A ias
b
and Jose To es
c
a
Depa men o Poli ical Science and In e na ional Rela ions, Uni e sidad Del No e, Ba anquilla, Colombia;
b
Depa men
o Business Managemen , Co po acion Uni e si a ia Minu o de Dios, UNIMINUTO, Ba anquilla, Colombia;
c
Uni e sidad
De Suc e, Suc e, Colombia
ABSTRACT
This esea ch examines he de elopmen and e alua ion o an op imiza ion amewo k o
he s a egic deploymen o inancial esou ces in mic o inance ini ia i es in Ba anquilla,
Colombia. The amewo k inco po a es an a ay o a iables, including ma ke dynamics,
ins i u ional elemen s, p ojec a ibu es, and i m-speci ic ac o s, o op imize p ojec ou -
comes and long- e m iabili y. Wi h app oxima ely 3,500 mic o inance p ojec s cu en ly
ope a ing in he coun y, Colombia has a h i ing mic o inance sec o ha plays a c ucial
ole in p omo ing inancial inclusion and economic de elopmen . To ensu e a ep esen a-
i e sample o his s udy, 21 mic o inance p ojec s we e selec ed using s a i ied sampling
basedonkeycha ac e is icssuchassec o ,size,andyea so ope a ion.Theop imiza ion
amewo k de eloped in his s udy inco po a es an a ay o a iables, including ma ke
dynamics, ins i u ional elemen s, p ojec a ibu es, and i m-speci ic ac o s, o op imize
p ojec ou comes and long- e m iabili y. Comp ehensi e s a is ical echniques, such as
ac o analysis, p incipal componen analysis, ANOVA, and - es s, demons a e subs an ial
enhancemen s in c i ical pe o mance indica o s when he op imiza ion amewo k is
implemen ed. The expe imen al g oup, employing he amewo k, displays supe io in es -
men e u ns, educed loan de aul s, expanded bene icia y each, and ampli ied employ-
men gene a ion compa ed o he con ol g oup u ilizing con en ional alloca ion
s a egies. These ou comes co obo a e p io s udies emphasizing he me i s o da a-d i en
me hodologies o inancial esou ce alloca ion in mic o inance. The esea ch con ibu es
o he comp ehension o e ec i e capi al deploymen in mic o inance ini ia i es and o e s
ins i u ions a p ac ical ins umen o boos pe o mance, a ain inancial sus ainabili y, and
suppo po e y educ ion and economic g ow h. The indings ha e implica ions o mic o-
inance o ganiza ions, policymake s, and academics, unde sco ing he signi icance o inco -
po a ing a comp ehensi e se o a iables and in eg a ing social capi al conside a ions in o
mic o inance app oaches. Subsequen esea ch can expand upon hese disco e ies o u -
he in es iga e he e iciency o capi al alloca ion and de elop inno a i e s a egies o
s eng hen mic o inance p og ams.
IMPACT STATEMENT
This s udy demons a es he signi ican impac o an inno a i e op imiza ion model on
imp o ing he pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia.
Mic o inance p ojec s u ilizing he op imiza ion amewo k showed highe e u ns on
in es men , lowe de aul a es, inc eased bene icia y ou each, and g ea e job c ea ion
compa ed o hose using adi ional alloca ion me hods. These indings unde sco e he
po en ial o da a-d i en app oaches o op imize esou ce alloca ion in mic o inance,
o e ing a aluable ool o p ac i ione s o enhance bo h inancial sus ainabili y and
social impac . The s udy's esul s ha e impo an implica ions o policymake s and
mic o inance ins i u ions, highligh ing he need o suppo i e en i onmen s ha acili-
a e he adop ion o such op imiza ion models. This esea ch con ibu es o he g owing
body o e idence on e ec i e s a egies o enhancing mic o inance pe o mance, wi h
po en ial applica ions beyond Colombia o o he de eloping coun ies acing simila
challenges in inancial inclusion and po e y alle ia ion.
ARTICLE HISTORY
Recei ed 12 May 2024
Re ised 2 July 2024
Accep ed 31 July 2024
KEYWORDS
Op imiza ion amewo k;
mic o inance pe o mance;
expe imen al design;
s a is ical analysis; po e y
alle ia ion
SUBJECTS
Economics; Business;
Managemen and
Accoun ing; Indus y &
Indus ial S udies
CONTACT Ma io Albe o de la Puen e Pacheco [email p o ec ed] Depa men o Poli ical Science and In e na ional
Rela ions, Uni e sidad Del No e, Ba anquilla, Colombia
ß2024 The Au ho (s). Published by In o ma UK Limi ed, ading as Taylo & F ancis G oup
This is an Open Access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion License (h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0/), which
pe mi s un es ic ed use, dis ibu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal wo k is p ope ly ci ed. The e ms on which his a icle has been
published allow he pos ing o he Accep ed Manusc ip in a eposi o y by he au ho (s) o wi h hei consen .
COGENT ECONOMICS & FINANCE
2024, VOL. 12, NO. 1, 2391937
h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/23322039.2024.2391937
In oduc ion
In de eloping coun ies, mic o inance is an ins umen o ad ancing inancial inclusion and os e ing
economic g ow h. Mic o inance ins i u ions s i e o alle ia e po e y, encou age en ep eneu ship, and
s imula e economic de elopmen by ex ending access o inancial se ices, including loans and sa ings
accoun s, o indi iduals and small businesses ha a e o en excluded om adi ional banking sys ems.
The e icien alloca ion o capi al esou ces, which en ails conside ing a wide a ay o ac o s and op i-
mizing und deploymen o maximize inancial and social e u ns, is c ucial o he success and impac o
mic o inance p ojec s.
De eloping op imiza ion models o guide esou ce deploymen decisions and unde s anding he
de e minan s o e icien capi al alloca ion a e essen ial o enhancing he pe o mance and sus ainabili y
o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia, a ci y wi h a di e se economic landscape. This s udy
aims o add ess his need by cons uc ing and e alua ing an op imiza ion model ha akes in o accoun
ma ke condi ions, ins i u ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics, and company ac o s o imp o e capi al
alloca ion e iciency and p ojec ou comes in Ba anquilla’s mic o inance sec o .
The exis ing li e a u e on capi al alloca ion in mic o inance, which emphasizes he impo ance o con-
side ing a wide ange o a iables and employing da a-d i en app oaches o op imize esou ce deploy-
men , se es as he ounda ion o his s udy. By inco po a ing insigh s om p e ious esea ch and
adap ing hem o he speci ic con ex o Ba anquilla, his s udy seeks o con ibu e o he unde s and-
ing o e icien capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s and p o ide aluable insigh s o p ac i ione s,
policymake s, and esea che s in he ield.
To p o ide a clea and logical low o in o ma ion, allowing o a deep explo a ion o he opic and a
ho ough p esen a ion o he indings, he s udy was s uc u ed in a comp ehensi e manne . P e ious
esea ch on he key ac o s in luencing capi al alloca ion e iciency in mic o inance p ojec s was syn he-
sized in he li e a u e e iew sec ion, which also explo ed he po en ial o op imiza ion models o
enhance p ojec pe o mance, p o iding a solid heo e ical ounda ion o he s udy. To ensu e a di e se
ep esen a ion o economic ac i i ies and enable an assessmen o he op imiza ion model’s applicabili y
ac oss di e en business con ex s, he esea che s selec ed a sample o 21 companies om a ious sec-
o s in Ba anquilla, Colombia. S uc u ed su eys, semi-s uc u ed in e iews, and he analysis o inan-
cial s a emen s and p ojec pe o mance epo s we e in ol ed in he da a collec ion p ocess, allowing
o iangula ion o da a sou ces and enhancing he eliabili y and alidi y o he indings.
The s udy employed desc ip i e s a is ics, ac o analysis, p incipal componen analysis, ANOVA, and
- es s o iden i y key e iciency ac o s and assess he op imiza ion model’s impac on mic o inance p o-
jec pe o mance, compa ing ou comes be ween he expe imen al and con ol g oups.
The signi icance and use ulness o his esea ch on op imizing capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p oj-
ec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia, canno be o e s a ed. By de eloping and es ing a comp ehensi e op i-
miza ion amewo k ha conside s a wide ange o ac o s, including ma ke dynamics, ins i u ional
elemen s, p ojec a ibu es, and i m-speci ic ac o s, his s udy p o ides a aluable ool o mic o inance
ins i u ions o enhance hei pe o mance and sus ainabili y. The indings demons a e ha he applica-
ion o he op imiza ion amewo k leads o subs an ial imp o emen s in c i ical pe o mance indica o s,
such as in es men e u ns, loan de aul a es, bene icia y each, and employmen gene a ion. These
esul s unde sco e he po en ial o da a-d i en app oaches o op imize esou ce alloca ion and maximize
he impac o mic o inance ini ia i es.
Mo eo e , he esea ch holds signi ican implica ions o policymake s, p ac i ione s, and esea che s
in he ield o mic o inance. The insigh s gained om his s udy can in o m he design and implemen a-
ion o mic o inance p og ams, no only in Colombia bu also in o he de eloping coun ies acing simi-
la challenges. By highligh ing he impo ance o conside ing a comp ehensi e se o a iables and
in eg a ing social capi al conside a ions in o mic o inance app oaches, he s udy p o ides a oadmap o
enhancing he e ec i eness and sus ainabili y o mic o inance p ojec s. Policymake s can u ilize hese
indings o c ea e an enabling en i onmen ha suppo s he adop ion o op imiza ion amewo ks and
da a-d i en decision-making in he mic o inance sec o , ul ima ely p omo ing inancial inclusion and eco-
nomic de elopmen .
2 M. A. DE LA PUENTE PACHECO ET AL.
Fu he mo e, his esea ch con ibu es o he ad ancemen o knowledge in he ield o mic o inance
and capi al alloca ion e iciency. By demons a ing he applicabili y and e ec i eness o he op imiza ion
amewo k in he con ex o Ba anquilla, Colombia, he s udy ills a gap in he exis ing li e a u e, which
has p ima ily ocused on o he geog aphical egions. The obus me hodology employed in his esea ch,
including he use o s a i ied sampling, expe imen al design, and comp ehensi e s a is ical analyses,
ensu es he eliabili y and alidi y o he indings. This s udy se es as a ounda ion o u u e esea ch
e o s aimed a u he in es iga ing he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s and
de eloping inno a i e s a egies o s eng hen mic o inance p og ams. By building upon he insigh s
p o ided by his esea ch, schola s can con inue o explo e he complex dynamics o mic o inance and
con ibu e o he de elopmen o e idence-based p ac ices ha p omo e inclusi e economic g ow h
and po e y alle ia ion.
The discussion sec ion del ed in o he indings and hei implica ions, shedding ligh on how he
op imiza ion model, by conside ing a comp ehensi e se o ac o s including ma ke condi ions, ins i u-
ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics, and company ac o s, led o signi ican enhancemen s in he inan-
cial and social pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s. The discou se unde sco ed he po en ial
ad an ages o emb acing he model o a ious s akeholde s in he mic o inance ecosys em, such as
mic o inance ins i u ions, policymake s, and egula o y bodies, in e ms o d i ing supe io ou comes
and os e ing inancial inclusion and economic de elopmen .
The p ima y aim o he esea ch was o de elop and empi ically e alua e a model o he e icien
alloca ion o unds in mic o inance ini ia i es in Ba anquilla, Colombia, aking in o accoun a di e se
a ay o ac o s o op imize p ojec pe o mance and sus ainabili y. The ul ima e goal was o con ibu e
o po e y alle ia ion and economic g ow h in he egion h ough he e ec i e deploymen o inancial
esou ces in mic o inance p ojec s.
The li e a u e on mic o inance has ex ensi ely explo ed he po en ial o his inancial ool in p omo -
ing economic de elopmen and alle ia ing po e y. Nume ous s udies ha e highligh ed he posi i e
impac o mic o inance on a ious aspec s o bene icia ies’li es, such as income gene a ion, en ep e-
neu ship, and social empowe men . Howe e , he success and sus ainabili y o mic o inance p ojec s
hea ily depend on he e icien alloca ion o capi al esou ces. Ine icien alloca ion o unds can lead o
subop imal ou comes, such as high de aul a es, low p o i abili y, and limi ed social impac (He mes &
Lensink, 2011; Se ano-Cinca & Gu i
e ez-Nie o, 2014).
While se e al s udies ha e in es iga ed he ac o s in luencing he pe o mance o mic o inance ins i-
u ions, he e is a lack o esea ch on he de elopmen and applica ion o op imiza ion models o cap-
i al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s. Exis ing s udies ha e p ima ily ocused on he impac o
indi idual ac o s, such as ma ke condi ions, ins i u ional en i onmen , o p ojec cha ac e is ics, on he
e iciency o mic o inance ope a ions (Cull e al., 2011; Me sland & S øm, 2009). Howe e , he e is a
need o a comp ehensi e app oach ha in eg a es hese ac o s in o a uni ied op imiza ion model o
guide esou ce alloca ion decisions.
Mo eo e , he majo i y o s udies on mic o inance ha e been conduc ed in he con ex o Asian and
A ican coun ies, wi h limi ed esea ch ocusing on he La in Ame ican egion, pa icula ly Colombia.
Gi en he unique socio-economic condi ions and egula o y en i onmen in Colombia, i is c ucial o
examine he de e minan s o e icien capi al alloca ion and de elop con ex -speci ic op imiza ion mod-
els o enhance he pe o mance and sus ainabili y o mic o inance p ojec s in his egion.
This s udy aims o add ess hese esea ch gaps by de eloping and es ing an op imiza ion model o
capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s, speci ically in he con ex o Ba anquilla, Colombia. By con-
side ing a wide ange o ac o s, including ma ke condi ions, ins i u ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics,
and company ac o s, his s udy seeks o p o ide a comp ehensi e amewo k o op imizing esou ce
alloca ion in mic o inance ini ia i es. The applica ion o his model o he di e se economic landscape o
Ba anquilla will o e aluable insigh s in o he e ec i eness o such op imiza ion echniques in imp o -
ing he inancial and social pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s. Fu he mo e, by ocusing on he
Colombian con ex , his s udy will con ibu e o he limi ed body o knowledge on mic o inance in La in
Ame ica and p o ide p ac ical ecommenda ions o p ac i ione s, policymake s, and esea che s wo king
in his egion.
COGENT ECONOMICS & FINANCE 3
The esea ch had limi a ions, such as i s ocus on mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia,
which may limi he applicabili y o he indings o o he geog aphical a eas o economic se ings.
Mo eo e , he s udy did no examine he long- e m impac o he model on he inancial sus ainabili y
and social each o mic o inance ins i u ions due o he limi ed ime pe iod o da a collec ion and
analysis.
The cen al esea ch ques ion was: How can a model based on key e iciency ac o s imp o e und
alloca ion and enhance he pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia? By add ess-
ing his ques ion, he s udy sough o ad ance he unde s anding o e icien und alloca ion in mic o i-
nance ini ia i es and p o ide p ac i ione s wi h a p ac ical ool o op imize esou ce deploymen and
achie e be e inancial and social ou comes.
Fu u e esea ch could in es iga e he applicabili y o he op imiza ion model in a ious geog aphical
con ex s, assess i s long- e m impac on mic o inance ins i u ions, and inco po a e ad anced analy ical
echniques o u he enhance he model’s e ec i eness.
Li e a u e e iew
Be o e del ing in o he p e ious esea ch ela ed o his s udy, i is essen ial o unde s and he g and
heo y ha unde lies he in es iga ion. This esea ch is g ounded in he heo y o capi al alloca ion e i-
ciency, which posi s ha he op imal alloca ion o inancial esou ces is c ucial o he success and sus-
ainabili y o economic en u es (Felds ein & Ho ioka, 1980; Tobin, 1984). The heo y sugges s ha
e icien capi al alloca ion in ol es di ec ing esou ces owa ds he mos p oduc i e and p o i able
oppo uni ies while minimizing isks and cos s (Fama, 1980; Jensen & Meckling, 1976).
In he con ex o mic o inance, he heo y o capi al alloca ion e iciency is pa icula ly ele an , as
mic o inance ins i u ions o en ope a e in esou ce-cons ained en i onmen s and se e ulne able popu-
la ions. E icien alloca ion o capi al esou ces is c i ical o mic o inance ins i u ions o achie e hei
dual objec i es o inancial sus ainabili y and social impac (He mes & Lensink, 2011). The heo y p o-
ides a amewo k o unde s anding he ac o s ha in luence capi al alloca ion decisions and he con-
sequences o ine icien esou ce alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s.
The applica ion o he capi al alloca ion e iciency heo y o mic o inance has led o he de elopmen
o a ious models and app oaches aimed a op imizing esou ce deploymen in his sec o (Se ano-
Cinca & Gu i
e ez-Nie o, 2014). These models ypically conside a ange o ac o s, such as ma ke condi-
ions, ins i u ional en i onmen , p ojec cha ac e is ics, and o ganiza ional a ibu es, o guide capi al
alloca ion decisions (Cull e al., 2011; Me sland & S øm, 2009).
By g ounding his esea ch in he heo y o capi al alloca ion e iciency, he s udy seeks o con ibu e
o he heo e ical unde s anding o e icien esou ce alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s. The de elop-
men and es ing o an op imiza ion model ha inco po a es key ac o s in luencing capi al alloca ion
decisions align wi h he p inciples o his g and heo y. The indings o his s udy a e expec ed o p o-
ide empi ical e idence suppo ing he applica ion o he capi al alloca ion e iciency heo y in he con-
ex o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia.
Ha ing es ablished he heo e ical ounda ion, he ollowing pa ag aphs will explo e he p e ious
esea ch ela ed o capi al alloca ion e iciency in mic o inance, iden i ying he gaps ha his s udy aims
o add ess and highligh ing he po en ial con ibu ions o his in es iga ion o he exis ing body o
knowledge.
The Colombian go e nmen has ecognized he impo ance o mic o inance in p omo ing inancial
inclusion and economic de elopmen , and has implemen ed a ious policies o suppo he g ow h and
sus ainabili y o he sec o . One no able policy is he ‘Banca de las Opo unidades’(Banking o
Oppo uni ies) p og am, which was launched in 2006 as a join ini ia i e be ween he Colombian go -
e nmen and he p i a e sec o (Banca de las Opo unidades, 2021). The p og am aims o expand access
o inancial se ices o low-income and ma ginalized popula ions, pa icula ly in u al a eas, by p o id-
ing unding and echnical assis ance o mic o inance ins i u ions (MFIs). Th ough his p og am, he go -
e nmen has sough o c ea e an enabling en i onmen o he de elopmen o he mic o inance sec o
and o p omo e he adop ion o bes p ac ices in e ms o inancial inclusion and social impac
(Minis e io de Hacienda y C
edi o P
ublico, 2019).
4 M. A. DE LA PUENTE PACHECO ET AL.
Ano he impo an policy de elopmen in he Colombian mic o inance sec o is he es ablishmen o
a comp ehensi e egula o y amewo k. In 2015, he go e nmen issued Dec ee 2555, which p o ides a
clea se o ules and guidelines o he ope a ion o MFIs in he coun y (P esidencia de la Rep
ublica de
Colombia, 2015). The dec ee de ines he legal s a us o MFIs, se s capi al and liquidi y equi emen s, and
es ablishes epo ing and anspa ency obliga ions. This egula o y amewo k has helped o p omo e
he s abili y and c edibili y o he mic o inance sec o , while also ensu ing ha MFIs ope a e in a manne
ha p o ec s he in e es s o hei clien s and con ibu es o he o e all de elopmen o he inancial
sys em (Supe in endencia Financie a de Colombia, 2020).
In addi ion o hese policies, he Colombian go e nmen has also implemen ed a ious ini ia i es o
suppo he capaci y building and p o essionaliza ion o he mic o inance sec o . Fo example, he
‘P og ama de Educaci
on Financie a’(Financial Educa ion P og am) p o ides aining and esou ces o
help MFIs imp o e hei inancial managemen p ac ices and be e se e hei clien s (Comisi
on
In e sec o ial pa a la Educaci
on Econ
omica y Financie a, 2017). Mo eo e , he go e nmen has collabo-
a ed wi h in e na ional o ganiza ions, such as he In e -Ame ican De elopmen Bank and he Wo ld
Bank, o p omo e knowledge sha ing and bes p ac ices in he mic o inance sec o (Depa amen o
Nacional de Planeaci
on, 2018). These e o s ha e con ibu ed o he s eng hening o he ins i u ional
capaci y o MFIs in Colombia and ha e helped o ensu e ha he sec o emains esponsi e o he e ol -
ing needs o i s clien s and he b oade economic de elopmen goals o he coun y.
The success and impac o mic o inance p ojec s in de eloping coun ies like Colombia hea ily ely
on he e icien alloca ion o capi al. The e iciency o capi al alloca ion in en e p ises has been iden i ied
as a signi ican de e minan o economic g ow h and de elopmen (Wang e al., 2022), emphasizing he
impo ance o unde s anding and op imizing his p ocess in he con ex o mic o inance p ojec s in
Ba anquilla, Colombia. Mic o inance se ices ha e he po en ial o p omo e economic g ow h and
educe po e y by imp o ing esou ce alloca ion, os e ing ma ke de elopmen , and acili a ing he
adop ion o be e echnologies (Bakh ia i, 2011).
Social capi al, which e e s o he ne wo ks, no ms, and us ha acili a e coope a ion and coo din-
a ion wi hin communi ies, has been ound o play a i al ole in enhancing he e iciency o mic o inance
ope a ions (Ikha e al., 2022; Ma cona o e al., 2016). This is pa icula ly ele an o he p esen s udy,
as i aims o de elop an op imiza ion model ha conside s no only inancial ac o s bu also social and
ins i u ional aspec s ha in luence he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s. The c e-
a ion and u iliza ion o social capi al h ough communi y-based de elopmen p ojec s can imp o e he
e ec i eness o mic o inance ini ia i es, as i helps o build us , educe in o ma ion asymme ies, and
acili a e collec i e ac ion.
Du ing pe iods o inancial in eg a ion, as obse ed in he 1990s, he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in
de eloping coun ies has been shown o imp o e (Mann, 2020), highligh ing he impo ance o well-
unc ioning inancial ma ke s and ins i u ions in acili a ing he e icien alloca ion o esou ces. In he
con ex o Ba anquilla, Colombia, unde s anding he ins i u ional ac o s ha in luence he e iciency o
capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s is c ucial o de eloping an e ec i e op imiza ion model.
Howe e , challenges such as co up ion can dis o his p ocess by educing he ma ginal e u n pe
uni o in es men (O’Toole & Ta p, 2014), emphasizing he need o anspa en and accoun able inan-
cial sys ems.
The de elopmen and applica ion o an op imiza ion model ha conside s ma ke condi ions, ins i u-
ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics, and company ac o s ha e he po en ial o signi ican ly imp o e
he inancial and social ou comes o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia. Halim e al. (2018)
emphasize he impo ance o adop ing a cus ome -cen ic app oach and employing s a egies such as
se ice ma ke ing mix and ma ke o ien a ion o enhance he pe o mance o mic o inance ins i u ions,
which aligns wi h he p esen s udy’s ocus on conside ing ma ke condi ions in he op imiza ion model,
as unde s anding and mee ing cus ome needs e ec i ely is c ucial o he success o mic o inance p oj-
ec s in Ba anquilla. The impo ance o a holis ic app oach o mic o inance op imiza ion is suppo ed by
se e al epu able sou ces, which highligh he need o conside a wide ange o a iables o ensu e he
success o hese ini ia i es.
Fu he mo e, he empowe men o women h ough mic o inance p og ams and communi y-d i en
de elopmen p ojec s has been iden i ied as a s a egy o enhance social capi al and imp o e esou ce
COGENT ECONOMICS & FINANCE 5
alloca ion (Ikha e al., 2022; Kaka & Abidin, 2014). The p esen s udy aims o con ibu e o he unde -
s anding o how hese aspec s in luence he e iciency o capi al alloca ion and p ojec pe o mance by
conside ing gende - ela ed ac o s and he ole o women in mic o inance p ojec s.
E o s o imp o e he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in en e p ises a e essen ial o d i ing economic
g ow h and de elopmen (Bushman & Smi h, 2002; Fon al o & De La Puen e, 2023). The p esen s udy
builds upon his p emise by de eloping an op imiza ion model ha conside s a wide ange o ac o s o
imp o e he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla, Colombia. By alloca -
ing capi al o alue-c ea ing oppo uni ies and wi hd awing i om alue-des oying ones, o ganiza ions
can enhance hei compe i i eness and sus ainabili y.
Mo eo e , Caballe o-Mon es e al. (2021) unde sco e he impo ance o conside ing ma ke condi ions,
pa icula ly he le el o compe i ion, when making egula o y decisions ha impac he mic o inance
indus y. This highligh s he need o align egula o y amewo ks wi h ma ke dynamics o ensu e op i-
mal ou comes, which is ele an o he ins i u ional ac o s conside ed in he p oposed op imiza ion
model o mic o inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla.
He mes and Hudon (2018) p o ide u he suppo o he comp ehensi e app oach aken in his
s udy h ough hei sys ema ic e iew o de e minan s a ec ing he inancial and social pe o mance o
mic o inance ins i u ions. Thei indings indica e he complexi y o ac o s in ol ed in mic o inance op i-
miza ion, sugges ing ha an e ec i e op imiza ion model should accoun o a wide ange o a iables
o d i e success.
Addi ionally, Chasanah e al. (2023) p opose a amewo k o pos -p ojec sus ainabili y e alua ion in
mic o inance, emphasizing he dual goals o social impac and inancial sus ainabili y. This dual ocus
aligns wi h he objec i es o he p esen s udy, which aims o de elop an op imiza ion model ha bal-
ances social and inancial objec i es e ec i ely o enhance he pe o mance and sus ainabili y o mic o i-
nance p ojec s in Ba anquilla.
The po en ial o da a-d i en and sys ema ic app oaches o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance has been
inc easingly ecognized, as hey o e a s uc u ed amewo k o op imizing capi al deploymen ac oss
di e se economic sec o s. By le e aging ma hema ical models and axioma ic p inciples, hese
app oaches ensu e ha esou ces a e alloca ed e icien ly, maximizing e u ns while managing isks
e ec i ely (Heidy Rico e al., 2024; Kalkb ene , 2005; Lugo-A ias e al., 2024). This aligns wi h he p esen
s udy’s objec i e o de eloping an op imiza ion model o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s in
Ba anquilla, Colombia, which conside s a wide ange o ac o s, including ma ke condi ions, ins i u-
ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics, and company ac o s.
The impac o mic o inance on po e y alle ia ion and en ep eneu ship is ano he key a ea o s udy
ha is ele an o he p esen esea ch. Ribei o e al. (2022) sugges ha while mic o inance can os e
de elopmen among i s clien s, a mo e holis ic app oach is needed o enhance ou comes and be e
unde s and he bene icia ies. This aligns wi h he comp ehensi e app oach aken in his s udy, which
conside s a wide ange o ac o s in luencing he e iciency o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s,
ul ima ely aiming o con ibu e o po e y alle ia ion and economic de elopmen in Ba anquilla.
Fu he mo e, he ole o social capi al in he e ec i eness o mic o inance canno be o e looked, as
Fang and You (2019) emphasize he impo ance o building and u ilizing social capi al o imp o e he
e ec s o mic o inance in e en ions. This insigh is pa icula ly ele an o he p esen s udy, as he
op imiza ion model conside s ins i u ional ac o s and social aspec s ha in luence he success o mic o-
inance p ojec s in Ba anquilla. By inco po a ing social capi al conside a ions in o he model, he s udy
aims o p o ide a mo e comp ehensi e app oach o op imizing capi al alloca ion and enhancing he
o e all impac o mic o inance ini ia i es in he egion.
Mo eo e , unde s anding he ole o in ellec ual capi al and i s in e ac ion e ec s on pe o mance
is essen ial o mic o inance ins i u ions seeking o enhance hei success. Kamukama e al. (2010)
emphasize he impo ance o iden i ying he in ellec ual capi al mix ha d i es success, enabling
ins i u ions o make in o med decisions ega ding capi al alloca ion s a egies. In he con ex o he
p esen s udy, his unde sco es he need o conside he in ellec ual capi al o he pa icipa ing
mic o inance ins i u ions in Ba anquilla when de eloping and e alua ing he e ec i eness o he
op imiza ion model.
6 M. A. DE LA PUENTE PACHECO ET AL.
The ela ionship be ween capi al alloca ion, inno a ion, and pe o mance in mic o inance is a c ucial
aspec o conside when de eloping op imiza ion models. B adley e al. (2012) highligh he media ing
ole o inno a i e p ac ices in he inancial, social, and human capi al-pe o mance ela ionships wi hin
mic o inance p og ams. This sugges s ha he p oposed op imiza ion model should ake in o accoun
he inno a i e p ac ices employed by mic o inance ins i u ions in Ba anquilla, as hey can signi ican ly
in luence he e ec i eness o capi al alloca ion and o e all p ojec pe o mance.
Resea ch me hod
The objec i e o his s udy was o analyze he e icien alloca ion o capi al in mic o inance p ojec s in
he ci y o Ba anquilla, Colombia, and o de elop an op imiza ion model ha could imp o e he pe -
o mance and sus ainabili y o hese p ojec s.
Mic o inance ins i u ions o en wo k wi h a di e se ange o small businesses and en ep eneu s
ac oss di e en sec o s o he economy. While mic o inance is ypically associa ed wi h p o iding inan-
cial se ices o low-income indi iduals o small businesses, hese ecipien s can be engaged in a ious
economic ac i i ies. The s udy’s app oach o including companies om di e en sec o s likely e e s o
he mic o inance ins i u ions o o ganiza ions ha p o ide mic o inance se ices, a he han he ecipi-
en s o mic o inance.
The esea ch aimed o iden i y he key ac o s in luencing capi al alloca ion e iciency and o assess
he applicabili y o he op imiza ion model ac oss a di e se ange o economic sec o s. By examining
he p ac ices and expe iences o 21 companies in ol ed in mic o inance p ojec s, he s udy sough o
p o ide insigh s in o he challenges and oppo uni ies associa ed wi h op imizing esou ce alloca ion in
his con ex .
This sample size was de e mined h ough a s a i ied sampling echnique, which aimed o ensu e a
di e se and ep esen a i e selec ion o companies in ol ed in mic o inance ini ia i es. The esea che s
chose his app oach o cap u e he he e ogenei y o he business landscape in Ba anquilla and o assess
he gene alizabili y o he op imiza ion model ac oss di e en economic con ex s.
The selec ion p ocess in ol ed using he Ba anquilla Chambe o Comme ce da abase o ob ain eli-
able in o ma ion on company cha ac e is ics, including sec o , numbe o employees, annual e enue,
and mic o inance expe ience. The popula ion o companies was di ided in o s a a based on hese cha -
ac e is ics, and a p opo ional numbe o companies we e andomly selec ed om each s a um o be
included in he sample. This s a i ied sampling echnique ensu ed ha he sample was ep esen a i e
o he business popula ion in Ba anquilla. In he case o his s udy in Ba anquilla, he di e se sec o s
men ioned likely e e o he a ious economic ac i i ies ha mic o inance ins i u ions in he ci y sup-
po . Ba anquilla, as a majo po ci y and indus ial cen e in Colombia, has a di e se economic land-
scape. Mic o inance ins i u ions in he a ea may se e a wide ange o small businesses and
en ep eneu s ac oss di e en sec o s o he local economy. Fo example, hey migh p o ide loans o
small-scale manu ac u e s, a isans, local e aile s, se ice p o ide s, o en ep eneu s in he ci y’s g ow-
ing ou ism sec o .
The cen al esea ch ques ion guiding his s udy was: How can an op imiza ion model based on key
e iciency ac o s imp o e capi al alloca ion and enhance he pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s in
Ba anquilla, Colombia? To add ess his ques ion, he s udy hypo hesized ha he applica ion o an op i-
miza ion model ha conside s ma ke condi ions, ins i u ional ac o s, p ojec cha ac e is ics, and com-
pany ac o s will signi ican ly imp o e he inancial and social pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s in
Ba anquilla, Colombia, compa ed o adi ional capi al alloca ion me hods.
This hypo hesis is g ounded in he exis ing li e a u e, which has highligh ed he impo ance o e i-
cien capi al alloca ion o he success and sus ainabili y o mic o inance p ojec s (He mes & Lensink,
2011; Se ano-Cinca & Gu i
e ez-Nie o, 2014). The hypo hesis p oposes ha he applica ion o a comp e-
hensi e op imiza ion model, which akes in o accoun a wide ange o ac o s, will lead o imp o ed
inancial pe o mance and enhanced social impac in mic o inance p ojec s.
By compa ing he pe o mance o mic o inance p ojec s u ilizing he op imiza ion model wi h hose
using adi ional capi al alloca ion me hods, he s udy aims o demons a e he e ec i eness o he p o-
posed model in he con ex o Ba anquilla, Colombia. The s uc u ed hypo hesis clea ly con eys he
COGENT ECONOMICS & FINANCE 7
Fon al o, H. R., & De La Puen e, M. (2023). Explo ing he impac o s a egic leade ship on he sus ainabili y o ech-
nology-cen ic companies: An in-dep h case s udy om Colombia’s No he n Coas . Academic Jou nal o
In e disciplina y S udies,12(5), 308. h ps://doi.o g/10.36941/ajis-2023-0146
Halim, F., Abidemi, B., & Alshauibi, A. (2018). En i onmen al u bulence, se ice ma ke ing mix, ma ke ing o ien a ion
and mic o inance pe o mance: A concep ual model. Jou nal o Business and Social Re iew in Eme ging Economies,
4(1), 27–36. h ps://doi.o g/10.26710/jbsee. 4i1.360
He mes, N., & Hudon, M. (2018). De e minan s o he pe o mance o mic o inance ins i u ions: a sys ema ic e iew.
Jou nal o Economic Su eys,32(5), 1483–1513. h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/joes.12290
He mes, N., & Lensink, R. (2011). Mic o inance: I s impac , ou each, and sus ainabili y. Wo ld De elopmen ,39(6),
875–881. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wo ldde .2009.10.021
Ikha , M., Bane jee, S., Bandhopadhyaya, K., Tiwa i, M., & Deshmukh, P. (2022). A e women wi h mo e o ’social cap-
i al’mo e empowe ed? A c oss-sec ional analysis om u al wa dha, cen al india. Jou nal o Family Medicine and
P ima y Ca e,11(2), 472–479. h ps://doi.o g/10.4103/j mpc.j mpc_2495_20
Jensen, M. C., & Meckling, W. H. (1976). Theo y o he i m: Manage ial beha io , agency cos s and owne ship s uc-
u e. Jou nal o Financial Economics,3(4), 305–360. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/0304-405X(76)90026-X
Kaka, E., & Abidin, F. (2014). Po e y alle ia ion in he no heas nige ia media ion o pe o mance and mode a ing
e ec o mic o inance aining: A p oposed amewo k. Medi e anean Jou nal o Social Sciences,15(3), 425–437.
h ps://doi.o g/10.5901/mjss.2014. 5n27p62
Kalkb ene , M. (2005). An axioma ic app oach o capi al alloca ion. Ma hema ical Finance,15(3), 425–437. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1111/j.1467-9965.2005.00227.x
Kamukama, N., Ahiauzu, A., & N ayi, J. (2010). In ellec ual capi al and pe o mance: es ing in e ac ion e ec s. Jou nal
o In ellec ual Capi al,11(4), 554–574. h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/14691931011085687
Lugo-A ias, E., Lugo-A ias, J., Va gas, S. B., de la Puen e Pacheco, M. A., Bo e G anados, I., Ba aza He as, C., & T iana
He n
andez, D. (2024). De e minan s o he compe i i eness o wo ld palm oil expo s: A coin eg a ion analysis.
T ansna ional Co po a ions Re iew,16(3), 200063. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. nc .2024.200063
Mann, K. (2020). Does o eign capi al go whe e he e u ns a e? Financial in eg a ion and capi al alloca ion e i-
ciency1. In e na ional Jou nal o Finance & Economics,26(3), 3945–3971. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/ij e.1998
Ma cona o, D., Ba in-C uz, L., & Ped ozo, E. (2016). Lending g oups and di e en social capi als in de eloped and
de eloping coun ies. Re is a de Adminis ac¸~
ao Con empo ^
anea,20(6), 651–672. h ps://doi.o g/10.1590/1982-
7849 ac2016150050
Me sland, R., & S øm, R. Ø. (2009). Pe o mance and go e nance in mic o inance ins i u ions. Jou nal o Banking &
Finance,33(4), 662–669. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jbank in.2008.11.009
Minis e io de Hacienda y C
edi o P
ublico. (2019). Dec e o 2555 de 2010.
O’Toole, C. M., & Ta p, F. (2014). Co up ion and he e iciency o capi al in es men in de eloping coun ies. Jou nal
o In e na ional De elopmen ,26(5), 567–597. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/jid.2997
P esidencia de la Rep
ublica de Colombia. (2015). Dec e o 2555 de 2015.
Ribei o, J., Dua e, F., & Gama, A. (2022). Does mic o inance os e he de elopmen o i s clien s? a bibliome ic ana-
lysis and sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. Financial Inno a ion,8(1), 34. h ps://doi.o g/10.1186/s40854-022-00340-x
Rico, H., de la Puen e, M., Diego Rios Mahecha, J., & Pe ez, H. (2024). Social media, b and loyal y and he banking
indus y in Colombia. Inno a i e Ma ke ing,20(1), 31–39. h ps://doi.o g/10.21511/im.20(1).2024.03
Se ano-Cinca, C., & Gu i
e ez-Nie o, B. (2014). Mic o inance, he long ail and mission d i . In e na ional Business
Re iew,23(1), 181–194. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.ibus e .2013.03.006
Supe in endencia Financie a de Colombia. (2020). Ci cula Ex e na 007 de 2020.
Tobin, J. (1984). On he e iciency o he inancial sys em. Lloyds Bank Re iew,153(1), 31–39. h ps://doi.o g/10.
21511/im.20(1).2024.03
Wang, Q., Geng, C., Hai-Tao, E., & Song, J. (2022). Resea ch on capi al alloca ion e iciencies wi h ou -dimensional
ac o capi als om china’s in elligen manu ac u ing en e p ises. PLOS One,17(7), e0270588. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1371/jou nal.pone.0270588
Appendix A. Sample ques ionnai e
In oduc ion: We g ea ly app ecia e you willingness o ake pa in his in e iew. You expe iences and insigh s a e
in aluable o ou esea ch on capi al alloca ion e iciency in mic o inance p ojec s. Please eel ee o openly sha e
you hough s and opinions, as you esponses will be kep s ic ly con iden ial and used solely o he pu pose o
his s udy.
Gene al In o ma ion:
1. Can you b ie ly desc ibe you company’s in ol emen in mic o inance p ojec s?
2. Wha is you cu en ole in he company, and how long ha e you been in his posi ion?
Mic o inance P ojec Expe ience: 3. Wha we e he main objec i es o he mic o inance p ojec s you company has
unde aken in he pas h ee yea s? 4. How many mic o inance p ojec s has you company been in ol ed in du ing
14 M. A. DE LA PUENTE PACHECO ET AL.
his pe iod? 5. Wha ac o s did you conside when making capi al alloca ion decisions o hese p ojec s? 6. How
did you company decide o alloca e capi al o hese mic o inance p ojec s? 7. Did you ace any challenges o
obs acles while alloca ing capi al o mic o inance p ojec s? I yes, please elabo a e.
Ma ke Condi ions and Ins i u ional Fac o s: 8. In wha ways do ins i u ional ac o s, such as he egula o y en i -
onmen , poli ical s abili y, and inancial in as uc u e, a ec you company’s pa icipa ion in mic o inance p ojec s?
9. How do ma ke condi ions, such as economic g ow h, in la ion a es, and ma ke demand, in luence you com-
pany’s decisions o in es in mic o inance p ojec s?
P ojec Cha ac e is ics: 10. How do you de e mine he a ge popula ion o you mic o inance p ojec s? 11. Wha
a e he ypical loan sizes, epaymen e ms, and in e es a es o he mic o inance p ojec s you company has been
in ol ed in? 12. Based on you company’s expe ience, wha a e he key success ac o s o mic o inance p ojec s?
Company Fac o s: 13. Wha ole does managemen expe ise play in he success o you company’s mic o inance
p ojec s? 14. How does you company’s inancial heal h impac i s abili y o in es in mic o inance p ojec s? 15.
Wha lessons ha e you lea ned, and how has you company’s expe ience in mic o inance e ol ed o e ime?
Capi al Alloca ion Op imiza ion: 16. In you opinion, wha a e he po en ial bene i s o applying an op imiza ion
model o capi al alloca ion in you company’s mic o inance p ojec s? 17. How does you company cu en ly op i-
mize i s capi al alloca ion o mic o inance p ojec s? 18. Wha challenges o ba ie s do you o esee in implemen ing
an op imiza ion model o capi al alloca ion in you company? 19. A e you amilia wi h any op imiza ion models o
echniques o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance?
Fu u e P ospec s: 20. Wha imp o emen s o changes would you like o see in he way you company alloca es
capi al o mic o inance p ojec s? 21. How do you see you company’s in ol emen in mic o inance p ojec s e ol ing
in he u u e?
Conclusion: 22. Do you ha e any ques ions o conce ns ega ding his esea ch s udy? 23. A e he e any o he
aspec s o capi al alloca ion in mic o inance p ojec s ha you would like o discuss?
You ime and aluable insigh s a e g ea ly app ecia ed. Thank you o you pa icipa ion in his in e iew.
COGENT ECONOMICS & FINANCE 15
