Zipf's law and random texts
Abstract
Random-text models have been proposed as an explanation for the power law relationship between word frequency and rank, the so-called Zipf's law. They are generally regarded as null hypotheses rather than models in the strict sense. In this context, recent theories of language emergence and evolution assume this law as a priori information with no need of explanation. Here, random texts and real texts are compared through (a) the so-called lexical spectrum and (b) the distribution of words having the same length. It is shown that real texts fill the lexical spectrum much more efficiently and regardless of the word length, suggesting that the meaningfulness of Zipf's law is high.
Full text
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 457698:7;=<?>A@ :CBDEGF7H <=IKJL1>NMN<=E"> ; OQPRDSNHT5.J;=@ <=:1MN@ U7;WVX7Y7H @T>NZ7@T:7[\B]DEGF78:1L ^"_a`cbedgfihkjml jonqpsrojtnpvuowyxRz{txRf | 4~}o |~| |q B4~eBe (A g\"W(9mWg(?2¡£¢¤¥ ¦§¨%© ª ¨ )(«a ¨ ¬ §¨ m("()( § (A2®¯¥agm°2±2¡£²(³(²a´ª±µ°¶(g § (¡£97 ¨·§ ¤¸" ¨ ¹£(" §º (A2 g7»·=»·9 |A B4 |~¼¾½G¿ J7ÀÂÁ Ã%ÄÅ (A2 g\"W(9mWg(=¡£¢¤¥ ¦§¨%© ª ¨ )(«a ¨ ¬ §¨ m("()( § (A2®¯¥agm°2±2¡£²(³(²a´ª±µ°¶(g § (¡£97 ¨·§ ¤¸Æ" ¨ ¹£ ¨ (g º (A g7»·=79»· Ã%ǪЧ m¢"È § ¨ )®¡ Ä ´(É(ÉmÊ("«(ªË"(a¡£¥ÌvÍÂg ¨ ³aÎ(Ï(² Ä ¡ ¦ Ð | <?;=<?@T6<=5.ÑÒSN<=;=<?@T6<=5578MN<®Ó | <=6(@T>N<=5.ÑÒSN<=61@ >Ô<?5578aMN<1Ó | 8a:757DEGÕ)MN<?I1MÖE"D157<=H >×Z7896<GY<?<=:KF7SNDFD>N<=5K8>×8:K<?I1F7HT8:78MN@TD:KØ·DSÖMNZ7<eFD9Ù<?SÖHT89ÙÚSN<?Õ H 8MN@TD:7>ÔZ7@ F.Y<=MÆÙ<=<?:.ÙDaSN5µØ·SN<=Û(X7<=:7;=LR8:75µSN8a:7Ü2ÝMNZ7<Þ>NDaÕ);?8aH HT<?5ß(@ F7Ø9à >kH 89Ù ¿á Z7<=LR[<=:7<?SN8aH HTL SN<?[a8SN57<=5"8>£:(X7HTH7Z(L1FDaMNZ7<?>Ô@ >£SN8MNZ7<=SMNZ78:"EGD(57<=HT>@T:"MNZ7<>NMNSN@ ;=M>N<=:7>Ô< ¿ :"MNZ7@T>£;?D:1MN<=I(MÝSN<=;?<=:1M MNZ7<?DaSN@ <=>ÖDØHT8:7[X78a[<G<=E"<=SN[<=:7;=<G8:75K<?6aDH XMg@TD:K8>N>ÔX7EG<GMNZ7@ >ÖH 89ÙÚ8> G2 ¨ a ¨ @ :7Ø·DaSNE"8aMN@ D: Ù@ MNZR:7DÂ:7<?<=5RDØ<=I1F7H 8a:78MN@ Da: ¿ <=SN<"SN8a:757DEâMN<?I1MN>W8a:75RSN<?8aHMN<=I1MN>W8SN<G;=DEGF78SN<=5RMNZ7SNDX7[Z ÑÒ8Ó>ÔDÕ);=8HTH <=5mH <=I1@ ;=8H>ÔF<=;?MNSNX7Eã8a:75µÑTYÓMNZ7<57@T>NMNSN@TY7X7MN@ Da:ÞDaØ2ÙDSN57>¶Z78961@T:7[kMNZ7<>N8aE"<HT<=:7[MNZ ¿ M@ >>NZ7D9ÙA:mMNZ78MSN<=8HMN<=I(MN>U7HTHMNZ7<¯H <=I1@ ;=8H>ÔF<=;?MNSNX7EäE×X7;ZE"DaSN<¯<?åG;=@ <=:(MNHTLe8:5mSN<=[8SN57HT<=>N> DØ]MNZ7<WÙDSN5HT<?:[MNZÝ(>NX7[[a<?>ÔMN@ :7[GMNZ78Mkß(@TF7Ø9à >AH 89ÙqE"<=8:7@T:7[Ø·X7HT:7<?>Ô>A@ >AZ7@ [aZ ¿ æm*$&(+9ç*$#)*èéç&-#)è#%*+.*$ä&(ê-')!ç#%-*ë-ìm')*è!è&&(í2!#%&1+.*ëîî-î#)ç=& #)$&1*2ç#%ï(ç#%-*ä-ìm#%ç+µ!*#)ê&1+'GìÆ&(ç!&(+ð"ñ"*&v-ìmç=&t,.-+çµ-ò2ê#%-!+.#%+.ç=&t+çç#%+9ç=#)(' $#%+9ç=#)ò!ç=#)-*.-ì£ó"-$.ò!*$*(&(+7ðé-$µì&(í!&(*(0R$#)+ç#)ò!ç#)-*+Ö&(ô#)ò#)çW+ç#)/2#)*è\&(èõ !'%#)ç=#)&(+ðöªìAók-$+G#%*tK+9,.î'%&Âç&(ôç"&-$&1&($t$&(1&(+#)*è')0Cò20Cç&(#)GìÆ&(í!&(*(02ç& ÷ *-,.')#%ø(&1$~ù~ìÆ9&(í2!&(*10C-ì~Kó"-$v#)+Gµî-7ók&(e'%7óâ-ì~#%ç+G*/ú)ûüªý$&(+1#%ò&1$t#)*t#)ç=+ +9#%,.î'%&(+9çeìÆ-,þ+ ÿ ÷ ýù ý ÷ £ð)ù óe&(&qÿ ÷ ýùG#%+Rç=&C*-,.')#%ø1&($ ìÆ&(í!&1*(0¾-ìGqók-$ óe-+& */¾#)+ ýð Öí!#)ê7'%&1*2ç')02 +9!é&1è!'%#)çª0(*éò&.î&(+9&(*2ç&($ ÷ è#)*é#%*é#)ç+ +9#%,.î'%&1+ç ìÆ-,ù"+\vì!*1ç=#)-*é-ì×ç& ;=DSNSN<=>NFD:757@T:7["8aX7MNZ7DS ¿ Electronic version of an article published as Ferrer-i-Cancho, R.; Solé, R. Zipf's law and random texts. "Advances in complex systems", 2002, vol. 5, núm. 1, p. 1-6. DOI 10.1142/S0219525902000468 © 2002 World Scientific Publishing Company. https://www.worldscientific.com/doi/abs/10.1142/S0219525902000468
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 A»£¢9ªg ¨ A § 9a § mA» »£a ì&(í2!&(*10 t-ì.ók-$v*$ò&(1-,µ&1+ ÿ ÷ Aù ÷ £ð ù óe&1&Úÿ ÷ ùÂ#%+ ç&î-òò#)'%#)çª0 éók-$i+Cì&(í2!&(*10 ä#%*iÚ+,.î')&2ð e&+9&((-*$ ì-, #%+c(')'%&1$éç&C')&(ô#%('Ö+9î&((ç!, ú% üÖ-\ç&C#)*2ê&(+9& #)îì +c$#)+ç#%ò!ç#%-* ú üð e& &(ôî-*&1*2ç+e#)* Öíðð%*$vð .-ò&(0 ÷ +9&(& ì-e#)*+ç*(&oú £) ûü "! ÷ £ð ù *$ãç&1#%Kçª02î#%1'"ê7'%!&(+K& .*$ # ð %$ "-ç & ×í¶ðAð%C*$ãð &oç&o+9-õ (')'%&1$ ' #%îì +"'%7óR')ç-!èoç&ì-9,.&("#%+"ç&,.-+ç"(-,.,.-*o-*&2ð )( m&1&2ç&ç&(, ')7ó &(ì&(+kç-Rç&m+ç&(*èç=o-ìç=&m&(,.î#%#)('-ò+&(êç#)-*ççk+kò&1&(* ç&(+ç&($o#%*o$# +* &(&(*ç ')*è!è&(+.*$ä!ç-+ú)üªð -, +.ìÆ.+Cók&v/2*-7óR~$&1ç=#)'%&1$ä*$ä&1ô2ç&(*+9#%ê&v+9ç=!$0 + -*')0t+9-7óe*qç=çÞç&cê7'%!&(+m-ì¯ç=&c&(ôî-*&(*ç=+m1*qê70tì-, -*&c+9,.î'%&cç-C*-ç&1 ú)ü¯*$¾&(ê&(*¾,.-&Kç*¾-*&µ$-,.#)*iú% % ûü¯#%+ *&1(&(+9+0qìÆ-Â&1ô2î'%#)*#)*èvç=&K+9,.& +,.î'%&2ð /. ¯#)è£ðm+9-7óe+eç& *-,.')#%ø1&($vì&(í!&(*(0 ê&(+9!+e*/ ÷ ù~*$ç=& '%&1ô2#)(' +î&((ç!, ÷ 0 £ùì- 1( &(,.*v&(')ê2#)'%')& 2 +Þ-ò20 43 Â#)/ð 100101102 f (frequency) 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 P(f) 100101102103104 r (rank) 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 P(r) A B -2.0 -1.0 @T[ ¿ ¿ SN<=Û1X7<?:;?LK6<=SN>NX7>kSN8a:7ÜvÑÒ4GÓ8a:75.H <=I(@T;?8aH>ÔF<=;?MNSNX7E Ñ 65 ×Ó¶DaØ<?SNEG8:.}\<?HT61@ HTH <®à >k}\DY1L ¼ @T;Ü Ñ 67)8 9:9 57@ ; <?SN<=:1M~ÙDaSN57>Ó ¿®á Z7<×578>ÔZ7<?5\HT@ :7<k@ :\4é>ÔZ7D9Ù>MNZ7<ר·SN<=Û1X7<?:7;=L6a<?SN>ÔX7>SN8:7ÜÂØ·DSÙDSN57>Z78961@ :7[ HT<?:7[aMNZ 1< Ý9ÙZ7@T;Ze@T>MNZ7<A896a<?SN8a[<AHT<=:7[MNZeDØÙDSN57>@T:e} <=H 61@TH HT<1à >YD1DÜ\ÑÒMNZ7<=SN<A8SN< 8 9:= 57@ ; <?SN<=:1M < aÕ)H <=MNMN<=S ÙDSN57>Ó ¿aá Z7<W<?I1FDa:7<?:1MN>A8SN<mÑÒ4GÓ ?>A@ 8:5.Ñ 65 ×Ó ?BC@ @ED FHG 8>A<?I1F<=;=MN<?5 ¿ ñk*&-òê2#)-!+tí2!&(+ç#)-* #)+&1$ò0ëç&(+9&-ò+&(ê7ç#%-*+o#)+7×&ç&10ëç=&&(+!'%ço-ì +-,.&C*-*Úç#)ê2#)'Ö(!+'Öî-(&1++ JIK, *20-ò+&(ê&($Ú&1è!'%#)çª0#)*Ú*ç!&C*&1&($+cï9+ç\ç- ò&+ç!$#%&1$ëò20ã,.&(*+.-ì*!')'e,.-2$&(')+7ðeñ"*&î-++9#%ò')&&(ôî')*ç=#)-*ë-ìç=& L #)îì +C')7ó (-,.&(+kìÆ-, cî!&1'%0µ*$-, î-(&(+9+7ð M, m* &('%0µè!,.&(*çÖè#%*+ç×*0K+9î&((#)'£(!+' &(ôî')*ç#%-*.ò&(0-*$.*$-,.*&(++Öók+Öç&e$#)+(-7ê&(90Rç=çÖ*$-, +&(í!&(*(&(+Ö-ì'%&1ç=ç&(+ ÷ #%*cóe#)\ç&Öò'%*/+î1&Öók+A,.-*èeç&1,ù&1î-$!1&($\ç& ¯&(ô2î-*&(*ç-ìók-$+ ú +N üð O, ++!,.&cç=çmç&c/&(0+m-ì¯ çª02î&1óe#%ç&(m&cçª0î&($qçm*$-,ðöªì¯ç&cò')*/v+î(& #)+m#)çmóG#)çqî-òò#%')#)ç0 'P *$q-*&c-ìWç=& AQ î-+9+#)ò')&c'%&1ç=ç&(+m&c#%çmóe#%çqî-òò#)'%#)çª0
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 R ÈN«¢ TS KU ]Ð V Ð¥ -W Ú~Ð~¥ TWTX WÍ ZY ¤ \[1Y ^] ÷ _`P ù bacQ ¾7ê#)*èK')'')&(çç=&1+"ç&+,.&î-òò#)')#%çª02ç&$#)+ç#)ò!ç#)-*o-ìók-$+k')#),.#%ç&($ ò0vò')*/v+î(&1+m1*ò&R+-7óe*ç- -ò&(0 d ×í¶ðð) ú eN üªð Of Þ&(ìð~ú ü~î-7ê2#)$&(+ &(1&(*çmî--ì óe&(*¾')'W(ç&(9+ 7ê&.ç&µ+9,µ&.î-òò#%')#)ç0ð!év*$-, î-2(&1++\#%+\('%')&($é gCh)ijlkmon6p)irq?s?p:q/k ú +N ü2-~ ut ivwkxg t vwvwkiv%y t n6kiz{k ú eN ü2-~+#),.î')0 xbp)i|)h)gEvwk~}?v ú ü2,.-$&('ªð 3 Â&1+î#)ç&.-ì"ç=&.+9!î#)+#)*è+9!#)ç=ò#)')#%çª0-ì"*$-, ç&(ôç=+ç=&(0&.è&(*&('%')0&(è$&($ +k*!')'20î-ç=&(+#)+kççkóeç&(ê&(k&(ôî')*ç#%-*o+kç-RìÆ(&µú üªð M -R+-,.&m&(ôç&(*2ç7#)ç×+ ò&1&(*ã(-*(')!$&($ã*$ãóe#%$&(+î9&($ çç d #)îì +K'%7ó $-&(+K*-çRç&(')'k*0ç=#%*è ÷ &(')&(ê7*2ç7ù ò-!çe')*è!è& ú) üªð 101102 f (frequency) 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 P(f) 100102104106108 i (rank) 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 P(i) AB -1.0 @ [ ¿ ¿ SN<=Û1X7<?:;?LÂ6a<?SN>ÔX7>¯SN8:7Ü ÑÒ4GÓ8a:75cH <=I(@T;?8aH>ÔF<=;?MNSNX7E Ñ 65 ×Ó£DØ8m>NDÕ;?8aH H <=5cEGD:7Ü<=LÂHT8:7[X8[<\ÑT8 SN8a:757DE MN<?I1MÓØ·DSNEG<?5eY1L 8b ] 8 9 57@ ; <?SN<=:1MÙDaSN57>WÑ 9- MNDMN8aHÙDSÔ57>Ó ¿9á Z7<A8aH F7Z78aY<=MZ78> @ HT<?MNMN<=SN>KÑÒ8HTH~Z7896(@T:7[µMNZ7< >N8EG< F7SNDY78aY7@ HT@ MLÓ8:75tMNZ7< F7SNDY78aY7@ HT@ MLCDØWY7H 8a:7ÜC>NF78a;?< @T> @ 2 = ¿á Z7< <=I1FD:7<=:1M@ :CÑÒ4GÓ@T> >A@ ÙZ@ HT<¯:7DGFD9Ù<=SHT8Ùq>N<=<=E">AMND"U7MA@ :.Ñ 65 ×Ó ¿ !tK(-*1'%!+#)-*t(-,.&1+7#)*o-!"ê#%&1óc2ìÆ-, ç&Â,.#)+')&($#)*èµ(-,.î#%+9-*tò&(çªók&(&(* */o$#)+ç#)ò!ç#)-*+7ð&(*vç& ')&(ô#%1'¶+9î&((ç!,þ#)+eî'%-çç=&1$vìÆ-eç&\,µ-*/&10 ')*è!è&2 ç&"$# +* &1&(*(&1+¯ò&(çªók&(&1*K*$-, *$K*-*K*$-, +9&(í!&(*(&(+¯ò&(1-,.&"$,.ç#)2ð l. ¯#)èð1 +9-7óe+kç&m*-,.')#%ø1&($ ì&(í!&(*(0µê&(+9!+k*/.*$ ç&m')&(ô#)('£+9î&((ç!, ì-kR,.-*/&(0 ')*è!è& óe#)ç P *$ ' ûð % e&oìÆ-,.&(K+-7óe+ ð % e& ')ç=&1R+-!'%$ +9-7ó *ë&(ôî-*&(*ç Ú+Cî&($#)(ç&($ëò0 Öíð¯£ð Úò!ç.*-éî-7ók&(C$-,.#)*ë(*ëò& #)$&1*2ç#%ï&($*$v#)çG$# e* &1+eè&(ç=')0oìÆ-,þ#)ç=+Þ(-!*ç=&1îçe#%* d. W#%èððöªçeç=&1,.îç#%*è.ç=-.ç#)*/ ç&\+çç=#)+ç#)('+ç!1ç=!& -ìò-ç$#)+ç#)ò!ç#)-*+e#)+Þ(-,.î')&(ç&('%0o$# e* &1&(*ç®ð W-(ò!')0 è-7óeçi#)*i*$-, ç&(ôç=+o#%+ ì+ç&( ç*i#)*i&('Þç&(ôç+¾ú üªð Q û ')&($+Âç=-é r =£ r = \N ûo$# +* &(9&(*2ç õN')&(çç=&1ók-$+7ìÆì-, ç&Kò-!çµ rN \,.#)')'%#)-*ók-$+ -ìkç=&µ9*$-, ç&(ôç #%* '. ¯#)èvðöªì×+9,.î'%#)*è& c* &(1ç=+\&µ&1+î-*+9#%ò'%&.ìÆ- ç&.+!î#)+#)*è î'%-ç#)* . ¯#)èð 4$ cç&K')&(ô#%1'¯+î&1(ç!, óe#)ç Q o+9-!')$#%,.î-7ê& ÷ ç&1&K9&R-*'%0 t$# e* &1&(*ç o õN'%&1ç=ç&( ók-$+ù=ð \. ¯#%èð£t+9-7óe+ ççÂ*-çÂ-*')0qç&µìÆ&1í2!&(*10qê&1+!+ */ î'%-ç#),.î-7ê&(+Âò!ç')+-oç&R')&(ô#)('+î&(1ç=!,ð O -*&1ç=&(')&(++7ç&Kí2!'%#)çª0-ìÖç&K'%çç=&1 #)+m+9ç=#)')'~('%&19'%0v')-7ók&(mç*ç=çm-ìW &('~ç=&1ô2ç7ð O e&R*')0ç=#)(')'%0vî&($#)(ç&($&(ôî-*&(*ç=+ &c-ò2ê#%-!+')0tê7'%#)$q#)* . ¯#%èð]õN A$ Qò!çÞ*$-, ç&(ô2ç+m')#%/&cç&(+9&c&(ê&('A#)èq+,.î')#)*è +9&(*+9#%ç#)ê&1*&(+9+eóe&1*v1-,.î&1$vç-.&('ç&(ôç=+ð
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 9 A»£¢9ªg ¨ A § 9a § mA» »£a 100102104 f (frequency) 10-4 10-2 100 P(f) 100102104106 i (rank) 10-6 10-4 10-2 100 P(i) -1.16 A B @T[ ¿ ] ¿ SN<=Û1X7<?:7;=LÂ6a<?SN>ÔX7>¯SN8:7ÜCÑÒ4eÓ8a:75\HT<=I(@T;?8aH>NF<?;=MNSNX7E Ñ 65 ×Ó£DØ8m>NDÕ);=8HTH <=5cE"Da:7Ü<=LÂHT8:7[X78a[< ÑÒ8 SN8:57DE MN<?I1MӣطDSNEG<?5cY1L 8 7 Ö57@ ; <?SN<=:1M¯ÙDSN57>ÞÑ 91l MNDaMg8aHÙDaSN57>Ó ¿á Z7<"8H F7Z8Y<=M¯Z78> @ HT<?MNMN<=SN>KÑÒ8H H~Z78961@T:7[KMNZ7<\>N8EG< F7SNDY78aY7@ HT@ MLÓ8:75tMNZ7< F7SNDY78aY7@ HT@ MLCDØWY7H 8:ÜC>NF78;=< @T> @ 2 = ¿á Z7< <=I(FD:7<=:1M@ :CÑT4eÓ@T> >A@ 8:5MNZ7<WÛ(X78aH @TMÆLÞDaØ]MNZ7<WH <=I(@T;?8aH2>NF<?;=MNSNX7Eä@ MZ7@T[Z7<=SMNZ78:ÂÙ@ MNZ @ ¿ öªç ,.#%èç ò&.ç=-!è2ç ç&.,.-*/&(0')*è!è&.ók&.7ê&µ&1,.î')-70&1$é#%+\+#),.î')#)+ç#%2ð , m')' ')&(çç=&1+~7ê&×ç=&Ö+9,.&×î-òò#%')#)çª02aóe#%\#)+~*-çA&1')#)+ç#%ðaöªì]Þ*$-, ç=&1ô2çA#)+~è&(*&(9ç&($ óe#)ç=q')&(çç&(mî-òò#)')#%ç#)&(+m-òç#%*&($qìÆ-, -ò20 d3 Â#%/¶ç=&cìÆ&(í!&(*(0tê&(+9!+m*/tî')-ç ')-+&(+cç=&.+ç&(î+õN')#%/&.îî&(*(& ÷ +9-')#)$é')#%*&.#)* '. ¯#)è£ð , .ùkóe#%')&.ç&C'%&1ô2#)('Ö+î&(1ç=!, #),.î-7ê&(+ ÷ . ¯#%èð1 $ \ùð l -ç#)(&"ç=çç&"#),.î-7ê&(,.&(*ç(*K*-çò&kçç=#)ò!ç=&1$Rç-+,.')'%&1 ê-21ò!')0 ÷ ò-!ç\ð +N Þ,.#)'%')#)-*tók-$t#%*tç&Â!*2ò#%+&1$t(+&2ù~ò!çGK')&(++G9&(+ç#)(ç#%ê&Âók70 -ìï')'%#)*è.ç&\+î&1(ç!,ð , m*t$$#)ç#%-*'+-!9(&-ì$#%+9è&(&1,.&(*çk1-,.&(+"ì-, ç&*'%0+#)+"-ìAók-$o$#)+ç#)ò!õ ç#%-*+k-ì¶R(&1ç=#)* ')&(*èç~ð-*/&10µ')*è!è&(+"#%,.î'%0.ók-$ ')&(*èçoìÆ-'%')-7óe+"*o&(ôî-*&(*õ ç#%'$#%+9ç=#)ò!ç=#)-*è#)ê&(*ò20 ÿ ÷ ù ÷ _P ù w ÷ £ð ù óe&1&Âÿ ÷ b ù£#)+¯ç&"î-òò#)'%#)çª0c-ì£ók-$+WìÆ-,.&($Kò0 ')&(çç&(+7ð®öª*K1-*ç+9ç®®ók-$K')&(*èç #)+",.-$&1'%&1$oóe#)ço')-èõN*-,.'Öú))ü-G¯-#%+9+-*#)*t$#%+9ç=#)ò!ç=#)-*+cú üªð ) ×,.î#)#%1'+ç!$#)&(+ +-7ó ççÂç=&(&K#)+tçª02î#%1'¯'%&1*èç " c*$')-*èoç#%')+Â,.70îî&17ðöªìÖ'%'¯'%&1ç=ç&(+ 7ê&Kç&K+,.&Kî-òò#)')#%çª0,.-*/&(0')*è!è&(+Âî&1$#%1çççók-$+Â7ê2#)*ètç=&R+9,.& ')&(*èç 7ê&mç&+,.&mìÆ9&(í2!&(*102ð e&m$+&($o')#%*&m#)* A. ¯#)èð£ 1, Q+9-7óe+kç&$#)+ç#%ò!ç#%-* -ìók-$+m#%*&(')ê2#)'%')& 2 +Þ-ò0 43 Â#)/o7ê#%*è.ç&c+,.&\'%&1*èç=óe#%#)+Þ('%&1'%0 2#)îï*~ð öª*o(-*2ç+ç7ç&&(í!#)ê7')&(*çk#)* R,.-*/&10µ')*è!è&#%*oóe#)o')''%&1ç=ç&(+"7ê&ç=&m+9,.& î9-òò#%')#)çª0 #%+.!*#)ìÆ-,s$#%+ç#)ò!ç=#)-* *$äç=&t$#%+9ç=#)ò!ç=#)-* -ìm'%&(çç&(+.-ìm¾,.-*/&(0 ')*è!è&.óe#)çé&1')#)+ç#%C')&(çç=&1\ì&(í2!&(*1#%&1+\#)+cç=&.$+9&($Ú')#%*&.#)* . ¯#%èð , .ð $ "-çÚ& (')&(')0o*-ç #%îï*~ð $ "0t+9+!,.#)*è çç ¡ #)îì +m')7ó #)+m ç=9#%ê#%'~+çç=#)+ç#)('A&1è!'%#)çª02+-,.&c!ç-+m$&1õ (')#)*&($ç-.#%*(')!$&\#%çe+Þîçe-ìç&\ìÆ&(ç!&(+Þ-ì~')*è!è& -#)è#%*+7ðöª*+9ç=&1$2#)çe+Þò&(&(* !+9&($v+e.è#%ê&1*v+çç=#)+ç#)('¶ì(çeóe#%çv*-µ*&(&($vì-e&(ô2î'%*ç#)-*ãú)üªð¶ñ"!e-ò+9&(ê7ç#%-*+ $-C*-çeè#)ê& +9!îî-çeç-.ç#)+eê#)&(óRð
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 R ÈN«¢ TS KU ]Ð V Ð¥ -W Ú~Ð~¥ TWTX WÍ ZY ¤ \[1Y < 101102 f (frequency) 10-6 10-4 10-2 P(f) 101102103 r (rank) 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 P(r) AB -2.0 -1.0 @ [ ¿ 9 ¿ SN<=Û1X7<?:7;=L6<=SN>NX7>\SN8a:7ÜãÑÒ4GÓk8a:75HT<?I1@T;?8Hk>NF<=;=MNSNX7E Ñ 65 ÖÓ"DØ"8tEGD:7Üa<?LHT8:7[X78a[<µØ·DaSNE"<=5 Y1L 87<)8 G57@ ; <?SN<=:1MkÙDSN57>\Ñ 9r MNDMN8HÙDSN57>Ó ¿ B]Z78SN8;=MN<?S"F7SNDaY78Y7@ HT@ MN@T<?>GÙ<?SN<mDaY7MN8@T:7<?5CØ·SNDE }\<?HT61@ HTH <®à >k}\DY1L ¼ @T;Ü ¿á Z7<Þ578>NZ7<=5µHT@ :7<Þ@T:µ4ä>NZ7D9Ù>kMNZ7<ÞØ·SN<=Û(X7<=:7;=Lc6a<?SN>ÔX7>kSN8:7ÜRØ·DS×ÙDSN5>×Z78961@ :7[ HT<?:7[aMNZ H< Ý7ÙZ7@T;Z\@T>MNZ7<k896<=SN8[a<×HT<=:7[MNZ\DØ£ÙDaSN57>@T:\} <=HT6(@TH HT<1à >¯YD1DÜ ¿®á Z7<×SN8a:757DEMN<?I1MZ78a> ] = 8 = 7 57@ ¢; <=SN<?:1M %< aÕ)H <=MNMN<?SAÙDSN57> ¿(á Z7<W<=I1FD:7<=:1M@ :CÑÒ4GÓ@T> >A@ ÙZ7@TH <WMNZ7<W>ÔH DF<W@ :.Ñ 65 ×Ó]@ > ->A@ ) ¿ é&c7ê&\')+-C+9-7óe*qççÞ*$-, ç&(ô2ç+m')-+9&\ç& 4 #)îï*q+î&\#)*qç&cìÆ&(í!&1*(0 ê&(+9!+Ö*/Rî')-çWóe&1*.ók-$+Ö&G&1+ç#%1ç=&1$.ç=-\ (&1ç=#)*.'%&1*èç=7óe#).#)+Ö*-çWç&e(+9& -ì¯9&('Aç&(ôç=+ð]öªçm#)+mç=!+(')&(mç=çm,.-*/&(0v')*è!è&1+mîç#%'~ê7'%#)$#)çª0v&(')#%&(+-*ç=&(#) ók-$ ')&(*èç $#)+ç#)ò!ç=#)-*~~óG#% ók&t7ê&tî-#)*2ç&($äç=-¾ò&t!*&('%#)+ç#)2ð e&(+&t&(+9!')ç+ ç!+ +!èè&(+ç ç=ç ìÆ!ç!9&Kç&1-#)&(+ -ì×'%*è!è&µ-#)è#)*¾+-!'%$¾ò&µò')&Kç-t&1ô2î'%#)*ç& -#)è#)*-ì~ç& 4 #%îì +Þ')7óR#%*+ç&($v-ì!+9#%*è.#%çe+Þ.è#)ê&(*(-*+ç#)*2ç7ð j ¤£r¥¦T§?¨u©«ª/¬-\®ª/¦¯l° é&.ç*/+ Hf Kð \f m-!++&1!é*$i cð#)')'%&(\ì-\&1'%îìÆ!'Ö(-,.,.&(*2ç+7ð e#)+\ók-/ók+\+!îõ î-ç&($ ò20µç&m*2ç K. £&Þöª*+ç#%ç!ç& ÷ f- mù¶*$Cè*2ç+k-ì¶ç&µ "&(*&('%#)çç×$&Kç')!*0 ÷ . ¯öªõN M /f. "eù*$vç&oö( T± ÷ $\N õÔû /f ~ùð r 4ª/²ª2³Jª/¦-£)ª/° ´¶µ~·A¸H¹ºK¹?»¼¾½w¼~¿bÀ)Á)Âc¼~Ã)ÄA¼~ÅMÆ?¼~Åd¼~Å)ǤÈ2¹É¼~Âc¼~ż~Ź?Ê-À¼~ÅMË̶Ë:¼~Ë̶ÍÎϽ¶Ì¶Å)ÐÀ)̶¿ËÌ6Ñ{¿¼~Å)ÇÑ{ÒÄÓ)½¶Î{Ô¿ÆM¿Õ ËÎ{ÄÖ¿ËÀ)Ç)̶Î{¿c¹×rØJÙMÚ¾Û2ÜJÝØ¾ÞHßÙÜJÛ)à«á+à«ÜJà«á+âãä\á+Û2åÙá+æ~àçá+è:æbéêëêìí¶µîî~ï?ððJñéµòòó¹ ´¶ð~·`ôr¹rõ¹ö¼~¿ËÌw¹»Î{½6½Ñ{À)ÂÍÎ{¿¼~Å)ÇCÄÒÅ)÷JÎøÆ½w¼~Å2ÐÀ¼~ÐÎ{¿c¹ù\ØJúûOÝ¢ãüáýàçþléµëµìéµòJòÿ¹ ´¶ê~· H¹/öÒÃ)Î{Åé ¹É¹ A¼~ÅrËÎ{ÐżJé/¼~Å)ǤÈ2¹ ¼Ír½¶Ì6ŹÉÏÀ)ÄÎ{Â̶ÑM¼~½%¼~ż¾½6ÆM¿Ì¶¿TÒ TÒÂÇ +ÂÎ MÀ)Î{Å)Ñ{̶Î{¿T̶м~ÂbËÌ )Ñ{̼~½T¼~Å)ÇCż¾ËÀ2Âc¼~½½¼~Å)ÐÀ¼~ÐÎ1ËÎ{ÔrË¿l¹ /ÚÜJè:àçÜJÝ¢æbéÿëµìí¶òÿ~ï?µ ?éµòòî¹ ´ · ¹ 1¹ 1¹ Ì6ÄÄÎ{Âcé ¹\º ÒÃ)½¶Î{ ¼~Å)Ç ¹ ½6ËÄA¼~Å)Ź Ò 1¼¾ÂÇ)¿ ¼HËÃ)Î{ÒÂÆÒ ÒÂǽ6Î{Å2ÐËà Ç2Ì6¿bËÂ̶Á)À)Ë̶ÒŹ×MØJÙMÚ¾Û2ÜJÝØ¾Þß-ÙMÜJÛ2à«á+à«ÜJàçáýâãä\á+Û2åÙMáýæbà«á+è:æbéµJí6òñ~ï?µ Oóéµòò ?¹ ´¶ÿ~· ¹øõ̹ ¼~Å)Ç2ÒÄËÎ{ÔMË¿Î{ÔrÃ2Ì6Á)Ì¶Ë ! {Ì6Ó "$# ¿bÕç½¼ % Õ«½6̶÷Î & TÒÂÇ ' +ÂÎ MÀ)Î{Å)Ñ{ÆÇ)̶¿ËÂÌ6Á2À)ËÌ6ÒŹ )(%*&*+*-, )ÚÜrÛ)æ . ÜJè:àçáýØJÛ)æØJÛ ( ÛcÞØJÚ¾úÜJà«á+ØJÛ ,/ JãbØJÚ¾þléêñëóìí¶µñ ?ð~ï?µñ ?ÿéMÉÏÒcÍÎ{ÄÁ?ÎøÂµòòðJ¹ ´¶ó~· ¹ 10 /Î{ÂÂÎ{ÂÌö¼~Å2Ñ~Ã)Òd¼~Å2Ç ¹2¸¹È:Ò½ 32 Îr¹ 14 TÒÂÎ{Ð̶ÄÎ{¿ ̶ÅAËÃ)Î 5 +ÂÎ rÀ2Î{Å)Ñ{ÆuÒ + TÒÂÇ2¿H¼~Å)Ç4ËÃ)Î ÒÂbÌ6ÐÌ¶Å Ò %Ñ{ÒÄÓ)½¶Î{Ô¡½¶Î{Ôr̶Ñ{ÒÅ)¿cí 76 rÌ¶Ó "# ¿Ï½¼ % 0ÂÎ{Ír̶¿Ì¶ËÎ{ǹ\×MØJÙMÚ¾Û2ÜJÝ\ؾÞßÙMÜrÛ)à«á+à«ÜJàçáýâãä\á+Û2åÙá+æbà«á+è:æbé ð ?µ¹r̶ÅCÓ)ÂÎ{¿¿c¹
"!#%$&(')#%*&(+ ,.-*/&1023 A»£¢9ªg ¨ A § 9a § mA» »£a ´¶î~· ¹ 1 ¹ 8 Ì6½¶½6Î{Âc¹%È:ÒÄÎÎ 9 ?Î{Ñ{Ë¿Ò -Ì6ÅMËÎ{ÂÄÌ6ËËÎ{ÅMË ¿bÌ6½¶Î{Å)Ñ{ÎM¹ 8: úã:Ú~áýèbÜJÛ×rØJÙÚ~Û2ÜJÝØ¾Þ '; æ~þlè </ JØJÝ¢Øåþlé î ?í¶êµµ~ï?êµ Oéµòÿî¹ ´¶ñ~· ¹ ¹ oÌ6½¶½¶Î{ ¼~Å)Çɹö\Ã2ÒÄ¿÷MÆr¹ 0 ̶Å)̶Ëc¼~ÂÆÄÒrÇ)Î{½¶¿Ò ½¼~Å)ÐÀ¼~ÐJΡÀ)¿Î{¿l¹ = wÅ ¹ > ¹\õ\À)Ñ{ÎMé ¹O»\À)¿Ãé¼~Å)Ç @? ¹ 1¼~½¼~ÅrËÎ{ÂcéJÎ{Ç2Ì6ËÒ¿cé A ÜJÛ 1B C ~ØØ D Ø¾Þ FE CÜJà G/ JãúÜJà«á+è~ÜJÝ H; -æbþlè </ rØJÝ Øå:þcérÍÒ½6À2ÄoÎKð¹ ̶½6Î{ÆMérÉ Î JI %ÒÂ÷éµòJóê¹ ´¶ò~·`È)¹)ÉH¼~Âc¼~ż~ŹÈ:Ëc¼~Ë̶¿ËÌ6ÑM¼¾½½w¼ K ¿ Ì6ÅA̶Š" +ÒÂÄA¼~Ë̶ÒÅ ¿bÑ{Ì6Î{Å)Ñ{ÎMé)½¼~Å)ÐÀ¼~ÐÎu¼~Å)ÇA¿ÆM¿ËÎ{Ä Ò Å¼~ËÀ)Âc¼~½ ÅMÀ)ÄÁ?Î{¿lí¿bÒÄÎu¿ËÂ̶÷r̶Å)пÌ6Ä̶½w¼~ÂbÌ6ËÌ6Î{¿l¹ ×rØJÙÚ~Û2ÜJÝØ¾Þ L 2èá+ã:Û2àçá M è4ÜJÛ 1BN( Û 1B JÙMæ~àçÚ¾á+ÜJÝ O ãæ~ã~ÜJÚè </ Jé ÿµí¶îêó~ï?îÿÿJéµòòð¹ ´¶µ ·`È)¹ÉH¼~Âc¼~ż~ż~Å)Ǹ¹T»¼~½¼~¿À)Á)Âl¼~Ã)ÄA¼~ÅrÆ?¼¾Å¹ = wÅ " +ÒÂbÄ ¼~Ë̶ÒÅËÃ)Î{ÒJÂÎ{Ë̶ÑKÄÒMÇ)Î{½¶¿Ì¶Å¿Ëc¼~ËÌ6¿bË̶ÑM¼~½ ½¶Ì6Å2ÐÀ)Ì6¿bËÌ6Ñ{¿TÕÓ¼~ÂËTÌwí &ÄÒMÇ)Î{½ +Ò P TÒÂÇ +ÂÎ MÀ)Î{Å)Ñ{̶Î{¿c¹ùÙÚ¾ÚãÛ2à QL )è:á+ãÛ2è~ãé/óêí¶ðóµ~ï?ðóòé?µòòð¹ ´¶µµ~·`È)¹ÉH¼~Âc¼~ż~ż~Å)Ǹ¹T»¼~½¼~¿À)Á)Âl¼~Ã)ÄA¼~ÅrÆ?¼¾Å¹ = wÅ " +ÒÂbÄ ¼~Ë̶ÒÅËÃ)Î{ÒJÂÎ{Ë̶ÑKÄÒMÇ)Î{½¶¿Ì¶Å¿Ëc¼~ËÌ6¿bË̶ÑM¼~½ ½¶Ì6Å2ÐÀ)Ì6¿bËÌ6Ñ{¿TÕ\Ó¼~ÂË-̶Ìwí ¤ÒÂbÇ R +ÂÎ MÀ)Î{Å)Ñ{̶Î{¿¼~Å2ÇHÃ)̶Î{Âc¼~ÂÑ~Ã2Ì6ÑM¼~½/¿ËÂÀ)Ñ{ËÀ)ÂbÎ Ì6ÅK½w¼~Å2ÐÀ¼~ÐÎM¹%ù\ÙMÚ¾ÚãÛ2à L 2èáýãÛ2èbã:éóêí¶ðòî~ï?ê ?óéµòòð¹ ´¶µð~·`È)¹rɼ~Âc¼~ż~ż~Å)Ç¡¸¹»¼~½¼~¿À2Á)Âc¼~Ã)ÄA¼~ÅMÆ?¼~Ź H ÒrÇ2Î{½6¿ 4 +ÒÂÓ?Ò TÎ{½¼ % &ÂÎ{½w¼~Ë̶ÒÅ)¿Ì6Å¡½¶Ì6Å2ÐÀ)̶¿ËÌ6Ñ{¿ ¼~Å2ǡ̶Š" +ÒÂbÄ ¼~Ë̶ÒÅC¿Ñ{̶Î{Å)Ñ{ÎM¹×MØJÙMÚ¾Û2ÜJÝØ¾Þß-ÙMÜJÛ2à«á+à«ÜJàçá+â:ãä\á+Û2åÙMáýæbà«á+èæ~éÿëµ~Õ¾ðìí6êJÿ~ï?óµéµòòñ¹ ´¶µê~· A¹ S ¹ÉÏÒ 1¼~÷¹ S Ã)ÎÁ¼~¿Ì¶ÑËÃ)ÎÂbÎøÓ2ÂÒrÇ2À)Ñ{ËÌ6ÍÎÂc¼¾Ë̶ÒHÒ Ï¼ T TÒÂÇéMËÃ)ÎÄ ¼~ÔM̶ÄÀ)ÄEËÃ)οbÌ U! {ÎÒ ËÃ)Î1½¶Î{Ôr̶Ñ{ÒÅ¹× WV %à G/ JãbØJÚ 3VQX á+ØJÝ YV +éð Oí6µîò~ï?µñJòéð ?¹ ´¶µ · A¹ ¹JÉÏÒ 1¼~÷é?ôr¹?»¹ HZ ?½¶ÒË÷r̶ÅéO¼~Å)Ǹ¹ ¹OôJ¼~Å)¿bÎ{Ź Ã)Î Î{ÍÒ½¶À)ËÌ6ÒÅÒ ¿bÆrÅMËc¼~Ñ{ËÌ6Ñ Ñ{ÒÄÄÀ)Å)Ì¶Õ ÑM¼~Ë̶ÒŹ [ ÏÜJàçÙÚãé W ?í ?òJÿ~ï ?òñéð O¹ ´¶µÿ~·`ôr¹ À)½¶Ç¼Í)¼¹ Ã)Î T +ÂÎ MÀ)Î{Å)Ñ{ÆH¿Ó?Î{Ñ{ËÂÀ)ÄÒ ËÎ{ÔM˼~Å)ÇÍÒMÑM¼~Á)À)½¼~ÂÆM¹O×rØJÙÚ~Û2ÜJÝOؾÞoß-ÙMÜJÛ2àçáýàçÜJà«á+â:ã ä\á+Û2åÙá+æ~àçá+è:æbéêëµìí¶êñ~ï?ÿ ?éµòòó¹ ´¶µó~· ¹lºK¹ 6 MÌ6Ó " b¹ A ÙMúoÜJÛ @C ~ã </ JÜJâ:á+ØJÙMÚÏÜJÛ 1B à \/ rãTûOÚ¾á+Û2èá ûOÝ¢ã1ؾÞÝ¢ãbÜJæ~àã %] TØJÚ¾à GV: ÛCá+Û2àçÚØ B JÙMèà«á+ØJÛCàçØ ^/ JÙ S. úoÜJÛCãbè~ØJÝ Ø:åþl¹ ¼ ýÅ)Î{ÂTÂÎ{Ó)ÂÌ6ÅMËcélÉÏÎ -I %ÒÂ÷é/µòJîð¹/µ~¿bË-Î{Ç)̶ËÌ6ÒÅí?ö¼~ÄÁ)Â̶Ç)ÐÎMé ^ í ÏÇ2Ç)Ì6¿bÒÅ)Õ ¤Î{¿b½6Î{ÆMéµò ?ò¹