scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Solving a possibilistic linear program through compromise programming

Abstract

In this paper we propose a method to solve a linear programming problem involving fuzzy parameters whose possibility distributions are given by fuzzy numbers. To address the above problem we have used a preference relationship of fuzzy numbers that leads us to a solving method that produces the so-called $\alpha$-degree feasible solutions. It must be pointed out that the final solution of the problem depends critically on this degree of feasibility, which is in conflict with the optimal value of the objective function. Then DM faces a bi-objective problem that we will solve through a Compromise Programming approach, whose solution lets the Decision-Maker express his own preferences about feasibility versus optimality. Our proposed method will be illustrated by a numerical example

Read accessible full text

Solving a possibilistic linear program through compromise programming

Author: Jiménez López, Mariano,Rodríguez Uría, Ma. Victoria,Arenas Parra, Mar,Bilbao Terol, Amelia
Publisher: Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya. Secció de Matemàtiques i Informàtica
Year: 2000
Source: https://upcommons.upc.edu/bitstream/2099/3575/1/07jimenez.pdf
sYbs m 7BP ]B8}Z$  
w
1(((
D
dxTdM;
7Bj%$  s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$ s _Bs8 qYBZY
]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
F$8? 9 N?B}9 
@
iBI?Z9 =?s z V sR  $jAsB V

@
*}B e{B B8?s V}j${sIs y = $%R$IsI Ij _s?R zsR{B 7}s$ 
Z}`$jB8oRYZR

*}B e{B B8?s ]Zs $s$%s = $%R$IsI I !%$IB 7}s$ 
8s$s8soR{${}IZ $B%$R
VARs{
y Y$R }s} b }B}BR s 8YBI B RBj% s j$ s }Bs88$  }BAj8
$ %Bj%$  PZ99k }ss8R bYBR }BRR$A$j$k I$R$AZ$B R s $% Ak PZ99k
Z8AR qB sIIRR Y sAB% }BAj8 b Ys% ZRI s }P { js$B T
RY$} BP PZ99k Z8AR Ys jsIR ZR B s RBj%$  8YBI Ys }BIZ{R Y
RBT{sjjI

TI PsR$Aj RBjZ$B R y 8ZR A }B$ I BZ Ys Y h sj RBT
jZ$B BP Y }BAj8 I} IR {$${sjjk B Y$R I BP PsR$A$j$k bY${Y $R
$ {B 4${ b$Y Y B}$8sj %sjZ BP Y BA`{$% PZ {$B  qY * Ps{R s
A$TBA`{$% }BAj8 Ys b b$jj RBj% YBZY s ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
s}}Bs{Y bYBR RBjZ$B jR Y *{$R$B Ts, -}RR Y$R Bb }P {R
sABZ PsR$A$j$k %RZR B}$8sj$k !Z }B}BRI 8YBI b$jj A $jjZRsI
Ak s Z8${sj -s8}j
kbBIRU
N$ s _Bs88$  3Z99k WZ8A ]B8}B8$R _Bs8T
8$  _BRR$A$j$k *$R$AZ$B  e-}{I $ %sj e-}{I %sjZ 3Z99k
Z8AR s ,$ 
V7 ]NV77y3y]Vqy!W
w
dd
D
U
(
g
(
,
(
g
1
3
d y BIZ{$B
N$ s }Bs88$ 
w
N_
D
$R Y B}$8$Rs$B {Y $JZ 8BR PJZ jk s}}j$I $
sjTbBjI }BAj8R s I YPB $ $R %k $8}Bs  B $ BIZ{ $ Y s}}Bs{Y
b sR}{R Ys sjjBb Y 8BIj B h $ B Y sj bBjI sR 8Z{Y sR }BRR$Aj
V k j$ s }Bs88$  8BIj }R $  sjTbBjI R$Zs$B R $ %Bj%R s jB
BP }ss8R bYBR %sjZR s sRR$ I Ak Y -}R s I $ Y {B % $B sj
s}}Bs{Y Yk s JZ$I B h- s -s{ %sjZ B Y sPB8 $B I }ss8R
<Bb% -}R B Y *{$R$B Ts,
w
*
D
PJZ jk IB B , Bb }{$Rjk Y
%sjZ BP YBR }ss8R yP -s{ %sjZR s RZRI YR s B jk Rs$R$T
{sj $ P { PB8 Y }sR Iss s I Y$ RsA$j$k $R IBZAPZj RB Y }BAj8:R
}ss8R s ZRZsjjk Ih I Ak Y *{$R$B Ts, $ s Z {s$ bsk B Ak
dx
dE
 F$8? 9 N?B}9 
z iBI?Z9 =?s  V sR  m V $jAsB
8s R BP js Zs Rs8  _ss8R qYPB $ $R ZRPZj B {B R$I Y
, BbjI BP Y -}R sABZ Y }ss8R sR PZ99k Iss
qY$R }s} {B R$IR N_ }BAj8R bYBR }ss8R s PZ99k Z8AR AZ Y
I{$R$B %s$sAjR s {$R} y Y$R ,$ I BP }BAj8R Y s bB ,k JZR$B RU
YBb B Ys Ij Y js$B RY$} Ab Y PZ99k jP s I Y {$R} $Y Ys I
R$I BP Y {B Rs$ R s I YBb B h I Y B}$8sj %sjZ PB Y PZ99k BA`{$%
PZ {$B  qY s Rb $R jsI B Y }BAj8 BP s ,$  PZ99k Z8AR
V %s$k BP 8YBIR PB {B8}s$  B s ,$  PZ99k Z8AR YsR A }BI
$ j$sZ
w
Gs  s I  >d1H
D
s I s ,$  8YBIR IB B sjbskR s b$Y
s{Y BY *$&  }B}$R Ys% A s}}j$I B `ZR$Pk s ,$  8YBIR
RZ{Y sRU I$R$ Z$RYsA$j$k
w
BBjs s I *s $ >1H
D
 s$B sj$k
w
Ws,s8Zs >MH
D

PZ99k B j$ Z$R${ }R s$B
w
*jsIB zIsk s I z$js >;H s I qB  s I
B $RB  >ddH
D
 s I BAZR RR
w
OZs >d;H
D

y Y$R }s} b ZR s 8YBI
w
F$8 9 >H
D
Ys %$hR sjj Y sAB% }B}$R
s I Ys AR$IR $R {B8}Zs$B sjjk ^{$  B RBj% s N_ }BAj8 A{sZR $
}R%R $R j$ s$k
NBB,$  s Y }B}k BP }R $  Y }P { js$B RY$} $ j$ Z$R${
B PZ99k 8R s ,$  8YBIR {s A {jsRR$hI $ bB s}}Bs{YR !  BP Y8
sRRB{$sR Ak 8s R BP I$&  PZ {$B R s{Y PZ99k Z8A B s R$ j }B$  BP
Y sj j$  s I Y s Bsj {$R} BI js$B RY$} Ab PZ99k Z8AR $R
RsAj$RYI
qY BY s}}Bs{Y s ,R PZ99k Z8AR Ak 8s R BP s PZ99k js$B RY$} y
sjjBbR I{$R$B 8s,R B }R  Y$ }P {R $ s sIZsj bsk bY${Y $ s N_
}Bs8 }8$R ZR B Ys Ij b$Y I$&  IR BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R
s I b$Y sI B BA`{$% %sjZ $ sjjBbR ZR B jBB, PB s B IB8$ sI
Rs$RPk$  RBjZ$B 
!A%$BZRjk $P Y *{$R$B Ts, RsAj$RYR s Y$Y I BP Rs$RPs{$B BP
{B Rs$ R PB s RBjZ$B  Y PsR$Aj RBjZ$B R R A{B8R jRR s I {B RJZ jk
Y BA`{$% B}$8sj %sjZ $R bBR 7B Y * YsR B h I s Asjs {I RBjZ$B
Ab bB BA`{$%R $ {B 4${U B $8}B% Y BA`{$% PZ {$B %sjZ s I B
$8}B% Y I BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R
y BI B sIIRR Y sAB% }BAj8 $ YsR A RZRI PB8Zjs$  s
sZ-$j$sk A$TBA`{$% }Bs8 Ys b b$jj RBj% YBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs8T
8$  qY }s} {B {jZIR b$Y s Z8${sj -s8}j B {js$Pk Y }B}BRI
8YBIBjB${sj s}}Bs{Y
1 _BRR$A$j$R${ j$ s }Bs8
y s }%$BZR }s} >dH b }B}BRI B RBj% Y PBjjBb$  }BRR$A$j$R${ j$ s }BT
s8U $ $8$9 K
F
)K

0
?
RZA`{ B
?
;
w
K
,
K
K
D
)
+
?
;
{p
z
b
K
?

K
K,?

(

w
d
D
bY K

)
w
K

@
,
K


,333,
K

z
D
K
)>K
y
7i
H
E?z
K
K
)
w
K
K
@
,
K
K

,333,
K
K
E
D
 }R  PZ99k }ssT
8R bYBR }BRR$A$j$k I$R$AZ$B R s $% Ak PZ99k Z8AR
7Bj%$  s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$ s _Bs8 qYBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
d
!Z s}}Bs{Y $ Y }%$BZR }s} sjjBbI ZR B BAs$ s PZ99k B}$8sj RBjZ$B
$ Y BA`{$% R}s{ PB }BAj8
w
d
D
 y Y }R  bB, b }B}BR BAs$ $ 
s B PZ99k B}$8sj RBjZ$B $ Y I{$R$B %s$sAjR R}s{ B Y Rs8 }BAj8
qB IB Ys Y PBjjBb$  JZR$B R >H s$RU
d
D
<Bb {s b Ih  Y
PsR$A$j$k
BP s I{$R$B %{B - bY Y }ss8R
BP {B Rs$ R s PZ99k Z8AR2
1
D
<Bb {s b Ih  Y
B}$8sj$k
PB s BA`{$% PZ {$B b$Y PZ99k }ssT
8R2
7%sj sZYBR Ys% RZI$I Y$R }BAj8 7B8 BP Y8 Ak {B R$I$  B
B jk PZ99k }ss8R AZ sjRB Y PZ99k BsjR BP Y I{$R$B 8s, $ qs s,s
s I VRsk >d(H 7s,sbs >H !YR Ak ZR$  RB8 js$B RY$} BP {B8}s$RB BP PZ99k
Z8AR $ ]sI sR s I zIsk >nH 7s,sbs >H !Z s}}Bs{Y AjB R B Y
R{B I BZ} G ZR s PZ99k js$B RY$} B {B8}s PZ99k Z8AR I%jB}I Ak
F$8 9 >H Ys %$Pk BBI }B}$R RZ{YU I$R$ Z$RYsA$j$k s$B sj$k PZ99k
}R s$B s I BAZR RR qY$R 8YBI $R {B8}Zs$B sjjk ^{$  B RBj% s
N_ }BAj8 A{sZR $ }R%R Y j$ s$k BP Y }BAj8
PB }R $  Y }P { js$B RY$} BP PZ99k Z8AR Ys b b$jj ZR
b RYBZjI {sjj Y B$B R BP Y -}{I $ %sj s I Y -}{I %sjZ BP s
PZ99k Z8A <$j} >xH Ih R Y -}{I $ %sj BP s PZ99k Z8A K
y
 bY${Y
b$jj A BI
o{
w
K
y
D
 sRU
o{
w
K
y
D
)>
o
y
@
,o
y

H)
}8
@

W

d
y
w
_
D
Q_,
8
d
(
/

d
y
w
_
D
Q_
]
w
1
D
bY
W
y
w
_
D
s I
/
y
w
_
D
s Y jP s I Y $Y Ys I R$I BP Y 88ARY$}
PZ {$B BP Y PZ99k Z8A K
y
 V I Y -}{I %sjZ BP s PZ99k Z8A K
y

bY${Y b$jj A BI
o~
w
K
y
D
sRU
o~
w
K
y
D
)
o
y
d
L
o
y
1
1
w
n
D
yP K
y
)
w
y
d
,y
1
,y
n
,y
;
D
$R s s}9B$Isj PZ99k Z8A $R -}{I $ %sj s I
$R -}{I %sjZ {s A {sj{ZjsI %k sR$jkU
o{
w
K
y
D
)
}
y
d
L
y
1
1
,y
n
L
y
;
1
]

o~
w
K
y
D
)
y
d
L
y
1
L
y
n
L
y
;
;
w
;
D
*h $$B d
3B s k }s$ BP PZ99k Z8AR K
y
kK
K
b Ih  Y js$B RY$} BP
PZ99k }P {
-
w
K
y,
K
K
D
 YBZY Y PBjjBb$  88ARY$} PZ {$B >HU
-
w
K
y,
K
K
D
)
T

z

Z
(R$
o
y
1

o
K
d
c
(
o
y
!

o
K
A
o
y
!

o
K
A

w
o
y
A

o
K
!
D
R$ (
;
J
o
y
d

o
K
1
,o
y
1

o
K
d
o
dR$
o
y
d

o
K
1
k
(
w
x
D
bY
-
p
K
y,
K
K
Q
$R Y I BP }P { BP K
y
B% K
K

yP
-
p
K
y,
K
K
Q


 b I B $ Ak K
y


K
K
s I b Rsk Ys K
y
$R s Ys K
K
s
jsR $ s I

 GY
-
p
K
y,
K
K
Q
)
d
1
bRskYsK
y
s I K
K
s $ I$& 
dM
 F$8? 9 N?B}9 z iBI?Z9 =?s  V sR  m V $jAsB
*h $$B 1
V I{$R$B %{B
?
;
{p
z
$RRs$IBA

TPsR$Aj
B }BAj8
w
d
D
$PU
8$
i
@
,333,E
-
w
y
i
?,K
i
D
i
)

w
E
D
Ys $R B Rsk $P K
y
i
?


K
K
i
,

i
)d
,333,E
w

D
qYPB sP
w
x
D
b b$ Y PBjjBb$  -}RR$B U
J
w
d


D
o
y
E

L
o
y
E
@
o
?

o
K
E

L
w
d


D
o
K
E
@
w
M
D
qY R BP sjj

TPsR$Aj I{$R$B %{BR $R I BI Ak

w

D
 3B8 Ih $$B 1
Y PBjjBb$  }B}k $88I$sjk PBjjBbRU

@
c

p
w

@
D
V
w


D
w

D
k 8s R BP Ih $$B 1 b Ys% s RbI Y hR JZR$B U YBb B Ih 
PsR$A$j$k bY Y {B Rs$ R $ %Bj% PZ99k Z8AR
7$ {

$ I${sR Y PsR$A$j$k I BP s{Y {B Rs$  d


{s A $ T
}I sR Y I BP Z PsR$A$j$k $ d


$%R ZR s 8sRZ BP $R, BP %$Bjs$B
BP RZ{Y {B Rs$ 
qB s Rb Y R{B I JZR$B U YBb B Ih  Y B}$8sj$k PB s BA`{$%
PZ {$B b$Y PZ99k }ss8R b {B R$I Y PBjjBb$  }BAj8U
$ $8$9 K
F
)K
?
RZA`{ B U
?
;
w
,K
D
)
?
;
{p
z
b
?

K,?

(
i
w
d(
D
bY Y PZ99k }ss8R s B jk $ Y BA`{$% PZ {$B  V{{BI$  B Y
s ,$  8YBI $% $ Ih $$B d b {s Rsk YsU
*h $$B n
?
L
;
w
,K
D
$R Rs$I B A s
s{{}sAj B}$8sj RBjZ$B
B }BAj8
w
d(
D
$P $ $R %$hI YsU
K
?

@
b

K
?
L
,

?
;
w
,K
D
w
dd
D
3B8 Ih $$B d Y sAB% -}RR$B {s A b$ sR PBjjBbRU
o


?


o

0
?
L
@
o

0
?


o

0
?
@
L
o

0
?
L


o

0
?
L
@

d
1
w
d1
D
RB Ys
o

0
?
@
L
o

0
?

1

o

0
?
L
@
L
o

0
?
L

1
w
dn
D
qYPB PB8 JZs$B
w
n
D
s I Ih $$B n Y PBjjBb$  }B}BR$$B {s A
RsIU
_B}BR$$B d
?
L
;
{p
z
$R s s{{}sAj B}$8sj RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
d(
D
$P s I
B jk $P $ $R s B}$8sj RBjZ$B B Y PBjjBb$  {$R} j$ s }Bs8U
$ $8$9
o~
w
K

D
?
RZA`{ B U
?
;
w
,K
D
w
d;
D
7Bj%$  s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$ s _Bs8 qYBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
d
bY
o~
w
K

D
)
w
o~
w
K

@
D
,o~
w
K


D
,333,o~
w
K

z
D
D

V{{BI$  B Y$R RZj b 8sk RsAj$RY Y PBjjBb$  Ih $$B jsI B Y
$ $$sj PZ99k 8BIj
w
d
D

*h $$B ;
?
L
;
{p
z
$R Rs$I B A s

TB}$8sj RBjZ$B
B }BAj8
w
d
D
$P $ $R
s B}$8sj RBjZ$B B Y PBjjBb$  }BAj8U
$ $8$9
o~
w
K

D
?
RZA`{ B U
?
;
w

D
w
dx
D
qYBZY Y$R 8BIj b Ys% RZAR$ZI Y $ $$sj PZ99k }Bs8
w
d
D
PB s {$R}

T}ss8${ j$ s }Bs8
3B8
w

D
Y BAs$ $  BP s A %sjZ B Y B}$8sj BA`{$% PZ {$B
$8}j$R s jRR I BP PsR$A$j$k BP Y {B Rs$ R qY Y *{$R$B Ts,
Z R $ B bB {B 4${$  BA`{$%RU B $8}B% Y BA`{$% PZ {$B %sjZ s I
B $8}B% Y I BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R qB BAs$ s Asjs {I RBjZ$B
B Y$R }BAj8 b$Y bB BA`{$%R $ {B 4${ b Ys% Isb Z} s sZ-$j$sk
A$BA`{$% }Bs8 sR RYBb $ Y PBjjBb$  R{$B 
n V A$BA`{$% }BAj8U Y }sk B& 8s$- s I
Y $Isj }B$ 
V{{BI$  B Y sAB% {B R$Is$B R b }B}BR s$R$  Y }BAj8
w
d
D
ss$
YBZY Y PBjjBb$  B Tj$ s A$BA`{$% }BAj8U
$ $8$9 K
F
w
?
D
)K
?
s-$8$9

RZA`{ B U
J
w
d


D
o
y
i

L
o
y
i
@
o
?

o
K
E

L
w
d


D
o
K
E
@
,

i
?

(
,
(



d
w
dE
D
qY R BP PsR$Aj RBjZ$B R BP 8BIj
w
dE
D
$R I BI Ak


*h $$B x
w
?

,

D
;
$R Rs$I B A s
_sB B}$8sj RBjZ$B
B
w
dE
D
$P Y
IBR B -$R s BY
w
?,
D
;
RZ{Y Ys
K
?


@
b

K
?
w
d
D
s I




w
dM
D
bY s jsR B  BP YR $ JZsj$$R $R R${
3B8 Ih $$B R ; s I x b IIZ{ Y PBjjBb$  }B}BR$$B U
_B}BR$$B 1
Vjj _sB B}$8sj RBjZ$B R
w
?

,

D
B }BAj8
w
dE
D
s


T
RBjZ$B R B }BAj8
w
d
D
s I {$}B{sjjk
_BBP
N
w
?

,

D
A s


TRBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
d
D
AZ B s _sB !}$8sj
RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
dE
D
 Y Y -$RR s BY
w
?,
D
%$hk$ 
w
d
D
s I
w
dM
D
bY s jsR B  BP YR $ JZsj$$R $R R${

dM(
 F$8? 9 N?B}9 z iBI?Z9 =?s  V sR  m V $jAsB
3B8
w
d
D
s I Y }B}BR$$B d b Ys%U
o~
w
K

D
?


o~
w
K

D
?
s I PB8
w
dM
D
?
;
w


D
 Y
?

$R B s B}$8sj RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
dx
D
s I
w
?

,

D
$R B
s


TRBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
d
D

V I {$}B{sjjk j
w
?

,

D
A s _sB !}$8sj RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
dE
D
AZ B s


TB}$8sj RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
d
D
 3B8 Ih $$B ; Y $R s BY
?
;
w


D
RZ{Y Ys
o~
w
K

D
?


o~
w
K

D
?
 PB8
w
n
D
b Ys% Ys K
?

k
@
b

K
?
s I
w
?

,

D
$R B s _sB RBjZ$B B }BAj8
w
dE
D

"
78sjj IR BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R {s B A s{{}I Ak Y *{$R$B T
s,
yP


$R Y 8$ $8Z8 I BP PsR$A$j$k BP {B Rs$ R Ys Y I{$R$B
8s, $R b$jj$  B sI8$ Y PsR$A$j$k $ %sj BP

$


$R IZ{I B





d
G P B Y$R b }BAj8 sR
w
dETA$R
D
U
BIj
w
dE
D
b$YU





d
qB RBj% Y }BAj8
w
dETA$R
D
YBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$  $ $R {RRsk
B BAs$ Y }skTB& 8s$- qB IB Ys b B}$8$R s{Y BA`{$% R}ssjk {sjT
{Zjs$  Y %sjZ s{YI Ak Y BY BA`{$% B Y B}$8sj I{$R$B %s$sAj
qY$R 8s$- sjjBbR ZR B JZs $Pk Y {B 4${ j%j Ab Y bB BA`{$%R y
BZ {sR b {s BAs$ Y bB BbR BP Y 8s$- Rs$  PB8 Y 8$ B s I
s PsR$A$j$k IRU

)


s I

) d V{{BI$  B Ih $$B ; Ys
8s R RBj%$  Y PBjjBb$  bB {$R} 8B BTBA`{$% }Bs8RU
s
D
_BAj8
w
dx
D
b$Y

)


 bYBR B}$8sj RBjZ$B
?

w


D
$%R Y PZ99k
Z8A K
F

w


D
)K
?

w


D
sR }BRR$A$j$k I$R$AZ$B BP Y {BR}B I$  B}$8sj
BA`{$% %sjZ
A
D
_BAj8
w
dx
D
b$Y

) d bYBR B}$8sj RBjZ$B
?

w
d
D
$%R Y PZ99k
Z8A K
F

w
d
D
)K
?

w
d
D
sR }BRR$A$j$k I$R$AZ$B BP Y {BR}B I$  B}$8sj
BA`{$% %sjZ
qYPB Y }sk B& 8s$- $R Y PBjjBb$ 
!A`$% 3Z {$B 3sR$A$j$k *
!A`$% 3Z {$B K
F

w


D


3sR$A$j$k * K
F

w
d
D
d
qY j8 R BP }$ {$}sj I$sB sj
w
K
F

w


D
,
d
D
PB8 Y $Isj }B$  bY${Y B}$T
8$RR Y bB BA`{$% PZ {$B R R$8Zjs BZRjk !A%$BZRjk Y $Isj }B$  $R
Z ss$ sAj ! Y BY Ys I Y R{Z Isk I$sB sj PB8R Y s $T$Isj
}B$ 
w
K
F

w
d
D
,

D

; ]B8}B8$R RBjZ$B R
qY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$  s}}Bs{Y B RBj% s 8Zj$BA`{$% B}$8$9s$B
}BAj8 $R AsRI B Y $Is Ys s s$B sj *{$R$B s, RYBZjI {YBBR Y
7Bj%$  s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$ s _Bs8 qYBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
dMd
_sB B}$8sj RBjZ$B  B s ss BP _sB B}$8sj R Ys $R sR B Y
$Isj }B$  qY }B$ R Ys %$hI Y }%$BZR }B}k s {sjjI {B8}B8$R
RBjZ$B R
y BZ {sR
w
}BAj8
w
dETA$R
D
D
 Y }B$ R BP Y BA`{$% R}s{ Ys% Y PB8
w
K
F
w
?
D
,
D
 b$Y K
F
w
?
D
)K
?
 Ys $R B Rsk Y hR {B8}B   $R s PZ99k Z8A G
Rsk Ys Yk s PZ99k }B$ R
qB h I Y {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B R $ $R {RRsk B Ih  Y I$Rs {
Q
E

Ab s{Y BA`{$% PZ {$B
W
E
s I $R $Isj %sjZ
W

E
 G bB, b$Y Y
8s
I$Rs {
Ab PZ99k Z8AR >EHU
Q
w
K
y,
K
K
D
)
/
o~
w
K
y
D

o~
w
K
K
D
/
w
d
D
3B8
w
d
D
b {s RsAj$RY Y PBjjBb$  }B}BR$$B U
_B}BR$$B n
V k {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B B Y PBjjBb$  {$R} }Bs8U
$ $8$9
o~
>K
F
w
?
D
H)
o~
w
K

D
?
s-$8$9

RZA`{ B
U
J
w
d


D
o
O
E

L
o
y
E
@
o
?

o
K
E

L
w
d


D
o
K
E
@
,

i
?

(
,




d
w
1(
D
$R sjRB s {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B B PZ99k }Bs8
w
dETA$R
D
 s I {$}B{sjjk
y BZ {sR b {s Ih  Y I$Rs { Ab s{Y BA`{$% %sjZ s I Y
{BR}B I$  $Isj %sjZ sR PBjjBbRU
Q
@
w
K
F
w
?
D
,
K
F

w


D
D
)
/
o~
w
K
F
w
?
D
D

o~
w
K
F

w


D
D
/
Q

w
,
d
D
)d


w
1d
D
VR Y BA`{$%R s 8sRZI $ I$&  Z $R $ $R {RRsk B YB8B $R
Y I$Rs {RU
Q
@
)
o~
w
K

D
?

o~
w
K
F

w


D
D
o~
w
K
F

w
d
D
D

o~
w
K
F

w


D
D

Q

)d


d



w
11
D
qB I8$  sjj }BRR$Aj {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B R b {B R$I Y PBjjBb$  I$RT
s { 8sRZRU
U

)
F
>
w
P
@
Q
@
D

L
w
P

Q

D

H
@
b

PB d

c
8s-
w
P
@
Q
@
,P

Q

D
PB

)
w
1n
D
GY
P
@
s I
P

s Y b$Y Ys }R  Y *{$R$B Ts,:R }PT
 {R b$Y sI B Y I$% { Ab s{Y BA`{$% %sjZ s I $R $Isj
%sjZ
V {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B $R Y B  bY${Y 8$ $8$RR
U

 qYPB b b$jj RBj%
Y PBjjBb$  {$R} 8B BBA`{$% }Bs8U
$ $8$9
U

RZA`{ B U
J
w
d


D
o
y
E

L
o
y
E
@
o
?

o
K
E

L
w
d


D
o
K
E
@
,

i
?

(
,




d
w
1;
D
dM1
 F$8? 9 N?B}9 z iBI?Z9 =?s  V sR  m V $jAsB
!A%$BZRjk Y RBjZ$B I} IR B Y {YBR 8${ k %sk$  } PB8 d B
 Y R BP {B8}B8$R RBjZ$B R {s A I8$ I
qB $jjZRs Y }B}BRI 8YBIBjBk s }BRR$A$j$R${ j$ s }Bs8 $R }B%$II
sR s Z8${sj -s8}j
x WZ8${sj -s8}j
N A Y PBjjBb$  s }BRR$A$j$R${ j$ s }Bs8UU
$ $8$9
w
d
,
1(
,
1d
D
?
d
L
w
1
,
n(
,
nd
D
?
1
RZA`{ B U
w
;
3
x
,
x
,
x
3
x
D
?
d
L
w
1
3
x
,
n
,
;
D
?
1

w
d;
,
1((
,
1(E
D
w
n
,
;
,
x
D
?
d
L
w
E
3
x
,

,

3
x
D
?
1

w
1n(
,
1;(
,
1x(
D
?
d

(
,?
1

(
w
1x
D
3B R$8}j${$k b Ys% RZ}}BRI Ys sjj $8}{$R }ss8R s $s Zjs
PZ99k Z8AR AZ s k BY PZ99k Z8AR {BZjI A $8}j8 I
N ZR sRRZ8 Ys Y 8$ $8Z8 I BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R Ys *
$R b$jj$  B s{{} $R

(
)(
3
; V{{BI$  B -}RR$B
w
dETA$R
D
b b$jj RBj% Y
}BAj8U $ $8$9
w
d
,
1(
,
1d
D
?
d
L
w
1
,
n(
,
nd
D
?
1
s-$8$9

RZA`{ B U
?
;
w

D
,
(
3
;



d
w
1E
D
qB BAs$ Y }sk B& 8s$- $ $R {RRsk B RBj% Y sAB% }BAj8 PB

)(
3
; s I PB

) d Y  s{{BI$  B }$s}Y 1 b b$jj RBj% }Bs8
w
dx
D
b$Y

)(
3
; s I PB

)dU
!3 3*
!3 K
F

w
(
3
;
D
)
w
d(;n
3
1
,
d(M
,
ddn;
3
M
D
(
3
;
3* K
F

w
d
D
)
w
dd;
3
M
,
d11E
,
d1
3
1
D
d
qY }$ {$}sj I$sB sj $R Y $Isj }B$ U
w
K
F

w
(
3
;
D
,
d
D

qY {B8}B8$R R $R BAs$ I RBj%$  Y PBjjBb$  }Bs8R b$Y 8${R
U

B Y {$R} }Bs8
w
1;
D
 N
P
d
)(
3
x s I
P
1
)(
3
x
D
U
s
D
b$Y 8${
U
d
 b Ys% Y }BAj8U
$ $8$9
U
d
)(
3
x
F
1(
?
A
Ln(
?
!

d(n
3
x
d11E

d(n
3
x
3
L(
3
x
,
d


(
3
E
E
RZA`{ B U
>
w
d


D
x
3
1x L

;
3
x
D
H
?
d
L>
w
d


D
n
3
xL

1
3
x
D
H
?
1



1(n L
w
d


D
d
>
w
d


D
;
3
xL

n
3
x
D
H
?
d
L>
w
d


D

3
1x L

E
3
x
D
H
?
1



1;x L
w
d


D
1nx
(
3
;



d
,?
d

(
,?
1

(
w
1
D
7Bj%$  s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$ s _Bs8 qYBZY ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$ 
dMn
qY RBjZ$B $RU

)(
3
xM
?
d
d
)1
3
n
?
d
1
)dM
3
1K
F
d
)
w
d(M1
3
1
,
dd1
3
E
,
dd
3
(E
D
s I Y -}{I %sjZ BP K
F
d
$R dd1
3
E
A
D
b$Y 8${
U

Y }BAj8 $RU
$ $8$9
U

)
Q
RZA`{ B U
BIj
w
1
D
{B Rs$ R R
(
3
x
F
1(
?
A
Ln(
?
!

d(n
3
x
d11E

d(n
3
x
3

Q
(
3
x
,
d


(
3
E
E

Q
w
1M
D
qY RBjZ$B $RU

)(
3
d
?

d
)1
3
n
?

1
)dM
3
E
K
F

)
w
dd(
3
d;
,
ddx
3
E;
,
d1(E
3
d;
D
s I Y -}{I %sjZ BP K
F

$R ddx
3
E;
]B8}s$  YR RBjZ$B R b$Y Y $Isj }B$  b b$jj BAR% Ys Y B 
{BR}B I$  B
U

$R 8B Asjs {I Ys Y BY s I $ bBZjI A B&I B
Y I{$R$B T{  sR s RBjZ$B  yP Y I{$R$B T8s, IBR B {B R$I Y sAB%
RBjZ$B s{{}sAj $ 8sk A Y Rs$  }B$  BP s $ s{$% }B{RR
E ]B {jZR$B R
y Y$R }s} b Ys% }B}BRI s 8YBI B RBj% s j$ s }Bs88$  }BAj8
$ %Bj%$  PZ99k }ss8R bYBR }BRR$A$j$k I$R$AZ$B R s $% Ak PZ99k Z8T
AR y s }%$BZR bB, >dH b YsI RBj%I Y Rs8 }BAj8 BAs$ $  s PZ99k
RBjZ$B $ Y BA`{$% R}s{ AZ Bb b Ys% {B RZ{I s RBj%$  8YBI Ys
}BIZ{R {$R} B}$8sj RBjZ$B R $ I{$R$B R}s{
qB {B RZ{ Y sAB% 8YBI s }P { js$B RY$} BP PZ99k Z8AR $
YsR A ZRI qY$R jsIR ZR B Y RBT{sjjI

TI PsR$Aj RBjZ$B R s I Y
B Y s{{}sAjk B}$8sj RBjZ$B 
G Ys% RYBb Ys Y BAs$ $  BP s A %sjZ B Y B}$8sj BA`{$%
PZ {$B $8}j$R s jRR I BP PsR$A$j$k BP Y {B Rs$ R s I YPB Y
*{$R$B Ts, Ps{R s }BAj8 $ %Bj%$  bB {B 4${$  BA`{$%RU B $8}B% Y
BA`{$% PZ {$B %sjZ s I B $8}B% Y I BP Rs$RPs{$B BP {B Rs$ R
y Y$R }BAj8 Y I BP PsR$A$j$k BP {B Rs$ R A{B8R s b I{$R$B
%s$sAj
qB BAs$ s Asjs {I RBjZ$B B Y$R }BAj8 b Ys% RBj%I s ]B8}B8$R
_Bs88$  }BAj8 bY${Y sjjBbR Y *{$R$B Ts, B RsAj$RY I$%R T
JZ$8 R sABZ PsR$A$j$k %RZR B}$8sj$k qY$R R{Y8 JZ$R s {s$ $ T
s{$B b$Y Y *{$R$B Ts, $ BI B sI`ZR Y$R RZ{Z BP }P {R
AZ $ $R 8Z{Y 8B 4-$Aj Ys Y ZRZsj PB8Zjs$B R
qB RBj% Y sAB% ]B8}B8$R _Bs88$  }Bs8 $ YsR A {RRsk
B - I B _BRR$A$j$R${ _Bs88$  Y 8s$ RZjR B {jsRR${sj ]B8}B8$R
_Bs88$ 