scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Does Provision of Smart Services Depend on Cooperation Flexibility, Innovation Flexibility, Innovation Performance or Business Performance in SMEs?

Abstract

Many manufacturers provide a lot of accompanying services to their products. However, not all of them supply smart services, because the move towards these is not easy, especially for SMEs, which often struggle with a lack of money, insufficient digital technologies or unskilled employees. The aim of this paper is to find out if smart service provision depends on cooperation flexibility, innovation flexibility, innovation performance and business performance in SMEs. To fulfil the research aim, quantitative research was carried out among 112 Czech electrotechnical SMEs. The findings show that the higher the rating companies give to working with external customers, the less chance they have of providing smart services. Thus, SMEs who value cooperation flexibility with external customers as less important are more likely to provide smart services. The higher rating companies give to product innovation flexibility, the higher the chance for providing smart services. Thus, we can expect companies who value product innovation flexibility more highly to more likely deliver smart services.

Read accessible full text

Does Provision of Smart Services Depend on Cooperation Flexibility, Innovation Flexibility, Innovation Performance or Business Performance in SMEs?

Author: Kaňovská, Lucie; Doubravský, Karel
Publisher: Budapest University of Technology and Economics
Year: 2021
DOI: 10.3311/PPSO.15709
Source: https://dspace.vut.cz/bitstreams/a884ce01-e51c-4438-b45a-0d7bbedf8cd0/download
64|h ps://doi.o g/10.3311/PPso.15709
C ea i e Commons A ibu ion b
Pe iodica Poly echnica Social and Managemen Sciences, 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021
Ci e his a icle as: Kano ska, L., Doub a sky, K. (2021) "Does P o ision o Sma Se ices Depend on Coope a ion Flexibili y, Inno a ion
Flexibili y, Inno a ion Pe o mance o Business Pe o mance in SMEs?", Pe iodica Poly echnica Social and Managemen Sciences, 29(1), pp. 64–69.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3311/PPso.15709
Does P o ision o Sma Se ices Depend on Coope a ion
Flexibili y, Inno a ion Flexibili y, Inno a ion Pe o mance
o Business Pe o mance in SMEs?
Lucie Kano ska1*, Ka el Doub a sky2
1 Ins i u e o Managemen , Facul y o Business and Managemen , B no Uni e si y o Technology, 2906/4 Kolejni, 612 00 B no,
Czech Republic
2 Ins i u e o In o ma ics, Facul y o Business and Managemen , B no Uni e si y o Technology, 2906/4 Kolejni, 612 00 B no,
Czech Republic
* Co esponding au ho , e-mail: kano ska@ bm. u b .cz
Recei ed: 07 Feb ua y 2020, Accep ed: 18 May 2020, Published online: 19 Oc obe 2020
Abs ac
Many manu ac u e s p o ide a lo o accompanying se ices o hei p oduc s. Howe e , no all o hem supply sma se ices, because
he mo e owa ds hese is no easy, especially o SMEs, which o en s uggle wi h a lack o money, insu icien digi al echnologies
o unskilled employees. The aim o his pape is o ind ou i sma se ice p o ision depends on coope a ion lexibili y, inno a ion
lexibili y, inno a ion pe o mance and business pe o mance in SMEs. To ul il he esea ch aim, quan i a i e esea ch was ca ied
ou among 112 Czech elec o echnical SMEs. The indings show ha he highe he a ing companies gi e o wo king wi hex e nal
cus ome s, he less chance hey ha e o p o iding sma se ices. Thus, SMEs who alue coope a ion lexibili y wi h ex e nal cus ome s
as less impo an a e mo e likely o p o ide sma se ices. The highe a ing companies gi e o p oduc inno a ion lexibili y, hehighe
he chance o p o iding sma se ices. Thus, we can expec companies who alue p oduc inno a ion lexibili y mo e highly o mo e
likely deli e sma se ices.
Keywo ds
se ices in manu ac u ing, sma se ices, SMEs, lexibili y, pe o mance, elec o echnical manu ac u e s, Czech Republic
1 In oduc ion
A lo o manu ac u e s wo k on he ans o ma ion o hei
angible p oduc s o p o ision se ices o sa is y hei cus-
ome s wi h be e complexi y. Accompanying se ices a e
able o suppo he company posi ion on he ma ke s and
a e one o he impo an sou ces o compe i i e ad an age.
Wi h he g owing impo ance o digi al echnology, man-
u ac u e s a e s a ing o o e sma se ices o hei cus-
ome s. Digi al echnologies assis companies o p oduce
and deli e "indi idual cus omized" p oduc s and se -
ices. Hence, cus ome s could be ope a ed on an indi id-
ual basis, which could imp o e cus ome sa is ac ion and
con o ming hei quali y expec a ions (Sade e al., 2019).
The p ocess o in eg a ing se ices o angible p oduc s is
called se i iza ion, and he in eg a ion o sma se ices
is called sma se i iza ion.
The issue o sma se i iza ion is speci ic o SMEs,
whe e he implemen a ion o sma echnologies is mo e
demanding due o he o en limi ed inancial and pe sonnel
capaci ies. Coope a ion be ween companies is e y impo -
an oday and is gaining in impo ance. Equally, he impo -
ance o lexibili y, which is mo e and mo e ecognized
as essen ial o building a sus ainable compe i i e ad an-
age in p oduc inno a ion, is inc easingly impo an .
To be able o be e unde s and he si ua ion in man-
u ac u ing SMEs in he ield o sma se ice p o ision,
his pape se s ou o asce ain i sma se ice p o ision
depends on inno a ion and coope a ion lexibili y and inno-
a ion and business pe o mance in elec o echnical SMEs
in he Czech Republic. The ca ego iza ion o SMEs in he
esea ch is in acco dance wi h he Wo ld Bank's de ini ion
o SMEs as en e p ises employing be ween 10–249 employ-
ees. The empi ical pa o he wo k is ocused on elec ical
enginee ing companies (CZ-NACE 26 and CZ-NACE 27),
which a e impo an ep esen a i es o he manu ac u -
ing indus y and a e subcon ac o s o many o he sec-
o s o he economy. In addi ion, he elec ical enginee ing
Kano ska and Doub a sky
Pe iod. Poly ech. Soc. Man. Sci., 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021|65
indus y is a global indus y, which means ha on he one
hand, many Czech companies can ha e cus ome s a ound
he wo ld, while on he o he hand, compe i o s can also
be global. As a esul , i is necessa y o cons an ly ocus
on esea ch and de elopmen , inno a e p oduc s, espond
o cus ome demand, look o p oduc ion sa ings and new
ends in he ield.
2 Li e a u e e iew
Many opposing e minologies a e used o sma se ices,
such as " elese ice" (Bo gmeie , 2002), " ele-main enance"
(Ga cia e al., 2004), " elema ics" (Cha e jee e al., 2001),
"e-se ice" (Rowley, 2006), "e-main enance" (Le a e al.,
2008) o some a ia ions, combina ions o adap a ions
using he e m " emo e", such as "RRDM (Remo e Repai ,
Diagnos ics and Main enance)" (Biehl e al., 2004).
Acco ding o Klein (2017), he e m "sma se ice" has
gained popula i y mo e ecen ly. Sma se ices ha
o e manu ac u ing se ices o hei p oduc s can also be
e e ed o as accompanying se ices using sma echnol-
ogies. Fo his pape , he e m "sma se ice" is used.
Also, a lo o de ini ions o sma se ices we e de el-
oped o e las yea s. Sma se ices can be pe cei ed
as one o he enable s o se i iza ion (e.g. G ubic and
Peppa d, 2016; Neu and B own, 2008) and a e he appli-
ca ion o specialized compe ences, h ough deeds, p o-
cesses, and pe o mances ha a e enabled by sma
p oduc s (Be e ungen e al., 2017). "Sma se ices a e
echnologically-media ed se ices ac i ely deli e ed
by he p o ide h ough accessing a emo e asse and
exchanging da a h ough buil -in con ol and/o eed-
back de ices" (Klein, 2017). Finally, as Allmendinge and
Lomb eglia (2005) decla e, "Soon, i will no be enough
o a company o o e se ices; i will ha e o p o ide
sma se ices.".
Sma se ices can also o e some aluable ben-
e i s o hei p o ide s and also o hei cus ome s.
Sma se ices a e mo e compe i i e, o e new sou ces
o e enue, highe ma gins, and conside able cos sa ings
(Küssel e al., 2000). They p o ide he oppo uni y o lea n
om cus ome s, es ablishing a basis o esea ch and de el-
opmen , sales o ma ke ing ac i i ies (Laine e al., 2010).
Sma se ices allow o de ec o ea ly p edic machine
ailu es o de ec i e p oduc s a ea ly s ages and can o e
ins an oo cause analysis as well as ins an ecommenda-
ions o p ope emedia ion (Sade e al., 2019). Po e and
Heppelmann (2014) summa ize hei posi ion: "Sma se -
ices o e exponen ially expanding oppo uni ies o new
unc ionali y, a g ea e eliabili y, much highe p od-
uc u iliza ion, and capabili ies ha cu ac oss and an-
scend adi ional p oduc bounda ies". Allmendinge and
Lomb eglia (2005) s a e ha companies p o iding sma
se ices ge mo e han 50 % o e enue and 60 % o ma -
gins om se ices han om p oduc sales.
Digi al esou ces can be a le e o inno a ion in SMEs
(Higón, 2012). They also change he way inno a ion is
managed (Yoo e al., 2009) and make companies mo e
ex o e ed (Tambe e al., 2012). Digi al esou ces ace
he adi ional spa ial cons ain s o companies which
a e connec ed o coope a ion in he ield o inno a-
ion (Del ou e al., 2018). Acco ding o Pagani (2013),
an inc easing in e es in business- o-business collabo a-
ion can be expec ed, based on se ices, which use sma
echnology and can change adi ional business ope a ions
and make collabo a ion a majo success ac o .
Flexibili y has become one o he mos use ul and nec-
essa y ools in oday's compe i i e ma ke s. Flexibili y
in manu ac u ing is widely ecognized as a c i ical compo-
nen o achie ing a compe i i e ad an age in he ma ke .
P oduc inno a ion lexibili y is inc easingly ecognized
as essen ial o building a sus ainable compe i i e ad an-
age in an inc easingly u bulen ma ke (Liao e al., 2010).
3 Me hodology
Fo a good unde s anding o he esea ch p oblem, he
quali a i e esea ch was unde aken in manu ac u ing
companies. The cu en esea ch is a ollow-up o he ea -
lie esea ch held in 60 manu ac u ing companies.
The ques ionnai e consis ed o se en pa s wi h sui able
ques ions. Coope a ion lexibili y was di ided in o ex e nal
coope a ion lexibili y wi h cus ome s, ex e nal coope a ion
lexibili y wi h supplie s and in e nal coope a ion lexibil-
i y. Inno a ion lexibili y was di ided in o inno a ion lex-
ibili y ela ing o p oduc and inno a ion lexibili y ela -
ing o accompanying se ices. Also, he ques ions ela ed
o inno a ion pe o mance and business de elopmen we e
included. The las pa o he ques ionnai e asked o gen-
e al in o ma ion abou he esponden s, including a eques
abou hei in e es in sma se ice p o ision.
The i ems ela ing o lexibili y we e based on
Tomáško á (2005), Liao and Ba nes (2015), Obeida e al.
(2016). The i ems ela ing o inno a ion pe o mance
we e based on Liao and Ba nes (2015) and Obeida e al.
(2016). Pe o mance is de ined as sys em o moni o ing
indi idual co po a e p ocesses on he way o implemen
he app op ia e changes in o ganiza ional cul u e, sys ems
66|Kano ska and Doub a sky
Pe iod. Poly ech. Soc. Man. Sci., 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021
and p ocesses (Milicho ský, 2015). Business pe o mance
i ems ypically measu e he use o ma ke ing pe o -
mance i ems (i ems 1–3) and inancial pe o mance i ems
(i ems 4 and 5). The i ems ela ing o p o ision o sma
se ice we e inspi ed by Bje ke and Johansson (2015),
Chaudhu i (2018), G ubic and Peppa d (2016).
A Like scale o m om 1 o 5 was used o he ques-
ionnai e, whe e 1 means "No, I don' ag ee" and 5 means
"Yes, I ag ee". All pa s we e es ed using C onbach alpha.
The le el o eliabili y o ex e nal coope a ion lexibili y
o cus ome s was 0.792, o ex e nal coope a ion lexibil-
i y o supplie s 0.812, o in e nal coope a ion lexibili y
0.814, o inno a ion lexibili y ela ing o p oduc 0.832
(p oduc inno a ion lexibili y), o inno a ion lexibili y
ela ing o accompanying se ices 0.890, o inno a ion
pe o mance 0.677 and o business pe o mance 0.673.
The le els o eliabili y we e good o all pa s o he ques-
ionnai e excep inno a ion pe o mance and business
pe o mance whe e he le el o eliabili y is ques ionable.
Manu ac u ing SMEs om he Czech Republic pa -
icipa ed in he esea ch, especially p oduce s o elec ic
equipmen and elec onic componen s. Manu ac u e s
pa icipa ing in he esea ch comply wi h he Czech indus-
y classi ica ion, namely CZ-NACE 26 (Manu ac u e
o compu e , elec onic and op ical p oduc s) and
CZ-NACE 27 (The P oduc ion o Elec ical Equipmen ).
The e a e 278 companies in CZ-NACE 26 and 575 compa-
nies in CZ-NACE 27 wi h 10–250 employees acco ding o
Czech S a is ical O ice. To ally he e a e 853 companies
(da a a e om Decembe 2019).
Small and medium manu ac u e s we e selec ed om
he Amadeus da abase. Mos ly manage s and di ec o s
we e con ac ed by email and asked o ill ou a ques-
ionnai e, which was web-based. Incomple e ques ion-
nai es we e disca ded. The da a was collec ed om
July o Oc obe 2019. The o al numbe o SMEs om
CZ-NACE 26 and om CZ-NACE 27 in he Amadeus
da abase was 730 (254 SMEs om CZ-NACE 26 and
476 SMEs om CZ-NACE 27). All 730 companies we e
con ac ed, bu 22 emails we e sen back immedia ely.
These companies ha e al eady ceased o exis o a e in liq-
uida ion o con ac emails we e missing and he compa-
nies we e no longe aceable. In o al, 112 ully comple ed
ques ionnai es we e ecei ed back. The ques ionnai e
e u n a e co esponds o 15.8 %. The da a analysis was
done by he so wa e package SPSS, Ve sion 17.
The pape is ocused on sma se ice p o ision and on
coope a ion lexibili y and inno a ion lexibili y in man-
u ac u ing SMEs. The ollowing esea ch ques ion was
p oposed RQ: Does P o ision o Sma Se ices depend
on coope a ion lexibili y, inno a ion lexibili y, inno a-
ion pe o mance and business pe o mance in SMEs?
Logis ic eg ession was chosen o ul ill he aim o he
pape . Logis ic eg ession is used o c ea e a model whe e
he dependen a iable is a ca ego ical a iable (sma se -
ice p o ision). Independen a iables (whe e i is possible
o moni o whe he hey ha e an in luence on he depen-
den a iable) can be bo h me ic and ca ego ical a iables.
4 Findings
The Resea ch Ques ion used bina y logis ic eg ession
o desc ibe he dependence o sma se ices p o ision
on quan i a i e esea ch a eas. The dependen a iable is
dicho omous (Yes, No). Independen a iables a e me ic
a iables:
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal - cus ome s,
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal - supplie s,
• collabo a i e lexibili y / in e nal, inno a ion lexi-
bili y by p oduc ,
• inno a ion lexibili y by accompanying se ices,
• inno a ion pe o mance and business pe o mance.
The ollowing Table 1 shows he signi icance o inde-
penden a iables measu ed by Wald's s a is ics.
Fi s o all, he iew was ocused on a cons an ha
has no logical in e p e a ion in he model. Based on he
p- alue o he signi icance es o he cons an , which is
highe han he selec ed signi icance le el o 0.05, he
cons an is s a is ically insigni ican ( doesn' ha e in o -
ma ion alue o his mode). The model is ec ea ed wi h-
ou a cons an . Thus, a new educed model is calcula ed,
see Table 2.
Table 1 Signi icance o a iables in he model
BS.E. Wald d p- alue Exp(B)
Ex e nal-
cus ome s –1.558 0.590 6.987 10.008 0.211
Ex e nal-
supplie s 0.261 0.330 0.623 10.430 1.298
In e nal 0.675 0.441 2.341 10.126 1.964
Flexibili y
by p oduc 0.801 0.486 2.719 10.099 2.228
Flexibili y
by accomp.
se ices
0.296 0.424 0.488 10.485 1.345
Inno a ion
Pe o mance –0.416 0.380 1.200 10.273 0.660
Business
Pe o mance 0.902 0.474 3.630 10.057 2.466
Cons an –2.726 1.591 2.937 10.087 0.065
Kano ska and Doub a sky
Pe iod. Poly ech. Soc. Man. Sci., 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021|67
Acco ding o he p- alues o he signi icance es s o he
indi idual eg ession coe icien s, i can be seen in Table 2
ha he only a iable ha ing a signi ican impac on sma
se ices p o ision is lexibili y in he ield o coope a ion /
ex e nal / cus ome s (p- alue < 0.05). Highe alues o
p- alues indica e he e a e high co ela ions be ween inde-
penden a iables (a mul icollinea i y p oblem). Fo his
eason, he dependence be ween he independen a iables
is de e mined by a co ela ion ma ix. The e a e s ong
dependences (g ea e han 0.9) be ween a iables inno a-
ion lexibili y by accompanying se ices:
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal-cus ome s,
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal-supplie s,
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal - cus ome s,
• collabo a i e lexibili y / in e nal and inno a ion lex-
ibili y by p oduc ,
• inno a ion pe o mance,
• inno a ion lexibili y by p oduc , business pe o mance
• inno a ion lexibili y by p oduc .
Fi s o all, he iew is ocused on he dependence o
inno a ion lexibili y by accompanying se ices:
• collabo a i e lexibili y / ex e nal
• supplie s on collabo a i e lexibili y / Ex e nal-
cus ome s.
New educed models a e calcula ed by emo ing he
ele an a iables o pai s o a iables om he o iginal
model. These educed models a e compa ed (R2 is aken
as a c i e ion). The bes model is p esen ed in Table 3.
The p oblem o he exis ence o a s ong dependence
o collabo a i e lexibili y / in e nal, inno a ion pe o -
mance, business pe o mance on inno a ion lexibili y
by p oduc is sol ed in he same way. New educed models
a e calcula ed by emo ing he ele an a iables o pai s
o a iables o iple o a iables om he o iginal model.
These educed models a e compa ed (R2 is aken as a c i-
e ion). The bes model is p esen ed in Table 4.
Table 4 shows wo a iables ha do no co ela e sig-
ni ican ly. Thus, he model desc ibing he p o ision o
sma se ices can only be desc ibed as shown in Table 4.
Bo h a iables in his model a e s a is ically signi ican
(p- alue < 0.05). Acco ding o he las column Exp (B),
which is he exposed coe icien o chance, he p o ision
o sma se ices can be in e p e ed by changing he p e-
dic o by one.
The highe he a ing companies gi e o wo king
wi h ex e nal cus ome s, he less chance hey ha e o
p o iding sma se ices. Thus, o companies e alua -
ing wo se coope a ion wi h ex e nal cus ome s, we a e
mo e likely o p o ide sma se ices. The highe he a -
ing companies gi e inno a ion o he p oduc , he highe
he chance hey ha e o p o iding sma se ices. Thus, o
companies e alua ing p oduc inno a ion, we can be mo e
likely o deli e sma se ices.
Looking a he esul s in e ms o whe he he busi-
ness sco e in each egion a ec s sma se ices p o ision,
i can be said ha he chances o p o iding sma se ices
o an en e p ise e alua ing coope a ion lexibili y / ex e -
nal / cus ome s a e age 2, is 0.439 imes highe han he
company ha e alua es lexibili y in he ield o collabo-
a ion / ex e nal / cus ome s on a e age 1. So i can be said
ha he inc easing e alua ion o lexibili y in he ield o
Table 3 Signi icance o a iables in he model
BS.E. Wald d p- alue Exp(B)
Ex e nal-
cus ome s –1.781 0.517 11.883 10.001 0.168
In e nal 0.699 0.414 2.844 10.092 2.012
Flexibili y
by p oduc 1.044 0.374 7.775 10.005 2.841
Inno a ion
Pe o mance –0.566 0.354 2.557 10.110 0.568
Business
Pe o mance 0.843 0.461 3.352 10.067 2.324
Table 4 Signi icance o a iables in he model
BS.E. Wald d p- alue Exp(B)
Ex e nal-
cus ome s –0.824 0.257 10.267 10.001 0.439
Flexibili y
by p oduc 0.970 0.308 9.958 10.002 2.639
Table 2 Signi icance o a iables in he model
BS.E. Wald d p- alue Exp(B)
Ex e nal-
cus ome s –1.849 0.568 10.580 10.001 0.157
Ex e nal-
supplie s 0.149 0.314 0.227 10.634 1.161
In e nal 0.620 0.428 2.102 10.147 1.860
Flexibili y
by p oduc 0.904 0.474 3.643 10.056 2.470
Flexibili y
by accomp.
se ices
0.219 0.407 0.291 10.590 1.245
Inno a ion
Pe o mance –0.605 0.360 2.835 10.092 0.546
Business
Pe o mance 0.822 0.460 3.191 10.074 2.275
68|Kano ska and Doub a sky
Pe iod. Poly ech. Soc. Man. Sci., 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021
coope a ion lexibili y / ex e nal / cus ome s educes he
chances o p o iding sma se ices. I can also be seen
om he o he side, which means ha a company e alua -
ing lexibili y in ex e nal coope a ion - cus ome s on a e -
age 1, has 2.278 imes highe chances o no p o iding
sma se ices han an agency e alua ing coope a ion
lexibili y in ex e nal coope a ion - cus ome s on a e -
age 2. The chances o p o iding sma se ices o a man-
u ac u e ha e alua es inno a ion lexibili y o a p oduc
a e age o 2, a e 2.639 imes highe han a company ha
e alua es inno a ion lexibili y o a p oduc a e age o 1.
5 Discussion
To ul ill he esea ch ques ion s a ed abo e, logis ic
eg ession c ea es a model desc ibing he impac o some
a eas on sma se ice p o ision. The quan i a i e esea ch
ca ied ou con i med only wo a eas. The gene al model
o se en pa s looks like his:
log
.
π
παβ ββ
ββ
ββ
x
xxxxxx
xx
()
−
()
=+ ++
++
++
111 22 33 44
55
66 77
The esul ing model looks like his:
lo
g,
π
π
ββ
x
xxx
()
−
()
=+
111
22
speci ically:
log.
..
π
π
x
xxx
()
−
()
=− +
10 824 097
12
In e p e a ion is no ia he g aph bu able and chances,
see Table 4. The highe he a ing companies gi e o wo king
wi h ex e nal cus ome s, he less chance hey ha e o p o id-
ing sma se ices. Thus, o companies e alua ing wo se
coope a ion wi h ex e nal cus ome s, hey a e mo e likely o
p o ide sma se ices. The highe he a ing companies gi e
o inno a ion o he p oduc , he highe he chance hey a e
o p o iding sma se ices. Thus, o companies e alua ing
p oduc inno a ion, we can be mo e likely o deli e sma
se ices. This inding is in line wi h Biehl (2017) ha sma
se ices " aised high expec a ions o i s po en ial" and a e
widely used o desc ibe he company's inno a ion.
I we wan o answe he esea ch ques ion, "Does
P o ision o Sma Se ices depend on coope a ion lexi-
bili y, inno a ion lexibili y, inno a ion pe o mance and
business pe o mance in SMEs?", we ha e o say ha p o-
ision o sma se ices depends only on coope a ion lex-
ibili y / ex e nal / cus ome s and on inno a ion lexibili y
ela ing o p oduc . Only wo pa s om se en possible
a ec he sma se ice p o ision signi ican ly.
6 Conclusion
The indings o he esea ch show ha he p o ision o
sma se ices depends on coope a ion lexibili y / ex e -
nal / cus ome s and inno a ion lexibili y ela ing o p oduc .
Bo h a iables om se en possible in he abo e-men ioned
model a e s a is ically signi ican (p < 0.05). The p o ision
o sma se ices can be in e p e ed by changing he p e-
dic o by one. The highe he a ing companies gi e o
wo king wi h ex e nal cus ome s, he less chance hey
ha e o p o iding sma se ices. The highe he a ing
companies gi e o inno a ion o he p oduc , he highe
he chance hey ha e o p o iding sma se ices.
I would ce ainly be in e es ing o con inue esea ch
in o he indus ies and hen be able o compa e he p o i-
sion o sma se ices. The a icle limi may be in a sample
o manu ac u e s, a ge ing only one indus y and espon-
den s wi hin one coun y. The e o e, u he esea ch
will be di ec ed o o he indus ies o iden i y he mos
comp ehensi e iew o he p o ision o sma se ices o
indus ial manu ac u e s.
Acknowledgemen
E a Tomasko a con ibu ed in he esea ch, which was
held in 112 elec o echnical SMEs companies in he Czech
Republic in 2019.
Re e ences
Allmendinge , G., Lomb eglia, R. (2005) "Fou S a egies o he Age
o Sma Se ices", Ha a d Business Re iew, 83(10), A icle
Numbe : 131. [online] A ailable a : h ps://ha bo esea ch.com/
wp-con en /uploads/si es/8/2018/09/Ha a d-Business-Re iew_
Fou -S a egies- o -Sma -Se ices_Allmendinge -Lomb eglia.pd
[Accessed: 10 July 2019]
Be e ungen, D., Ma zne , M., Janiesch, C. (2017) "In o ma ion sys-
ems o sma se ices", In o ma ion Sys ems and e-Business
Managemen , 15(4), pp. 781–787.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s10257-017-0365-8
Biehl, M., P a e , E., McIn y e, J. R. (2004) "Remo e epai , diagnos-
ics, and main enance", Communica ions o he ACM, 47(11),
pp. 100–106.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1145/1029496.1029501
Biehl, S. (2017) "Design Guidelines o Sma Se ices: A S a egic-
logic Pe spec i e on Seeking Compe i i e Ad an age wi h
Digi ized Se i iza ion S a egies", Doc o al disse a ion,
Uni e si y o S . Gallen.

Kano ska and Doub a sky
Pe iod. Poly ech. Soc. Man. Sci., 29(1), pp. 64–69, 2021|69
Bje ke, L., Johansson, S. (2015) "Pa e ns o inno a ion and collabo a-
ion in small and la ge i ms", The Annals o Regional Science,
55(1), pp. 221–247.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00168-015-0712-y
Bo gmeie , A. (2002) "Telese ice und die Neue Ins i u ionenökonomie"
(Telese ices in mechanical and plan enginee ing: applica ions
and design ecommenda ions), In: Telese ice im Maschinen-
und Anlagenbau, Deu sche Uni e si ä s e lag, Wiesbanden,
Ge many, pp. 115–147. (in Ge man)
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-322-81064-9_4
Cha e jee, A., G eenbe g, J., Jones, M., Kaas, H. W., Wojcik, P. (2001)
"Telema ics: Decision Time o De oi ", Business S a egy
Re iew, 12(2), pp. 21–38.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/1467-8616.00172
Chaudhu i, A. (2018) "In e ne o Things, o Things, and by Things",
Aue bach Publica ions, New Yo k, NY, USA.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1201/9781315200644
Del ou , F., Le Gall, S., Le hiais, V. (2018) "The spa iali y o SMEs' coop-
e a ion o inno a ion in he digi al age: a mixed me hod s udy",
In: 4 h Geog aphy o Inno a ion Con e ence (GeoInno 2018),
Ba celona, Spain, pp. 1–14.
Ga cia, E., Guyenne , H., Lapay e, J. C., Ze houni, N. (2004) "A new
indus ial coope a i e ele-main enance pla o m", Compu e s &
Indus ial Enginee ing, 46(4), pp. 851–864.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.cie.2004.05.019
G ubic, T., Peppa d, J. (2016) "Se i ized manu ac u ing i ms com-
pe ing h ough emo e moni o ing echnology: An explo a o y
s udy", Jou nal o Manu ac u ing Technology Managemen ,
27(2), pp. 154–184.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/JMTM-05-2014-0061
Higón, D. A. (2012) "The impac o ICT on inno a ion ac i i ies:
E idence o UK SMEs", In e na ional Small Business Jou nal:
Resea ching En ep eneu ship, 30(6), pp. 684–699.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1177/0266242610374484
Klein, M. M. (2017) "Design ules o sma se ices", Doc o al
disse a ion, Uni e si y o S . Gallen. [online] A ailable a : h p://
e di.unisg.ch/www/edis.ns /SysLkpByIden i ie /4607/%24FILE/
Dis4607.pd [Accessed: 12 No embe 2018]
Küssel, R., Lies mann, V., Spiess, M., S ich, V. (2000) ""TeleSe ice"
a cus ome -o ien ed and e icien se ice?", Jou nal o Ma e ials
P ocessing Technology, 107(1–3), pp. 363–371.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/S0924-0136(00)00727-5
Laine, T., Pa anko, J., Suomala, P. (2010) "Downs eam shi a a
machine y manu ac u e : he case o he emo e echnologies",
Managemen Resea ch Re iew, 33(10), pp. 980–993.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/01409171011083987
Le a , E., Iung, B., C espo Ma quez, A. (2008) "E-main enance: e iew
and concep ual amewo k", P oduc ion Planning & Con ol,
19(4), pp. 408–429.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/09537280802062571
Liao, Y., Ba nes, J. (2015) "Knowledge acquisi ion and p oduc inno a-
ion lexibili y in SMEs", Business P ocess Managemen Jou nal,
21(6), pp. 1257–1278.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/BPMJ-05-2014-0039
Liao, Y., Hong, P., Rao, S. S. (2010) "Supply Managemen , Supply
Flexibili y and Pe o mance Ou comes: An Empi ical In es iga ion
o Manu ac u ing Fi ms", Jou nal o Supply Chain Managemen ,
46(3), pp. 6–22.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/j.1745-493X.2010.03195.x
Milicho ský, F. (2015) "Financial Key Pe o mance Indica o s
in Enginee ing Companies", Pe iodica Poly echnica Social and
Managemen Sciences, 23(1), pp. 60–67.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3311/PPso.7810
Neu, W. A., B own, S. W. (2008) "Manu ac u e s o ming success ul
complex business se ices: Designing an o ganiza ion o i he
ma ke ", In e na ional Jou nal o Se ice Indus y Managemen ,
19(2), pp. 232–251.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/09564230810869757
Obeida , B. Y., Al-Su adi, M. M., Masa'deh, R., Ta hini, A. (2016)
"The impac o knowledge managemen on inno a ion: An empi -
ical s udy on Jo danian consul ancy i ms", Managemen Resea ch
Re iew, 39(10), pp. 1214–1238.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/MRR-09-2015-0214
Pagani, M. (2013) "Digi al Business S a egy and Value C ea ion:
F aming he Dynamic Cycle o Con ol Poin s", MIS Qua e ly,
37(2), pp. 617–632. [online] A ailable a : h ps://www.js o .o g/
s able/43825925?seq=1 [Accessed: 05 July 2019]
Po e , M. E., Heppelmann, J. E. (2014) "How Sma , Connec ed P oduc s
A e T ans o ming Compe i ion", Ha a d Business Re iew,
92(11), pp. 64–88. [online] A ailable a : h ps://www.gospi. /
IMG/pd /po e -2014-hb _how-sma -connec ed-p oduc s-a e-
ans o ming-compe i ionhb -2014.pd [Accessed: 10 July 2019]
Rowley, J. (2006) "An analysis o he e-se ice li e a u e: owa ds a
esea ch agenda", In e ne Resea ch, 16(3), pp. 339–359.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/10662240610673736
Sade , S., Hus i, I., Da óczi, M. (2019) "Indus y 4.0 as a Key Enable
owa d Success ul Implemen a ion o To al Quali y Managemen
P ac ices", Pe iodica Poly echnica Social and Managemen
Sciences, 27(2), pp. 131–140.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3311/PPso.12675
Tambe, P., Hi , L. M., B ynjol sson, E. (2012) "The Ex o e ed Fi m:
How Ex e nal In o ma ion P ac ices A ec Inno a ion and
P oduc i i y", Managemen Science, 58(5), pp. 843–859.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1287/mnsc.1110.1446
Tomáško á, E. (2005) "Měření žní o ien ace a její li na podniko ý
ýkon" (Measu ing o ma ke o ien a ion and i s in luence on busi-
ness pe o mance), Doc o al disse a ion, B no Uni e si y o
Technology. (in Czech)
Yoo, Y., Boland, R. J., Lyy inen, K., Majch zak, A. (2009) "Call o
Pape s-Special Issue: O ganizing o Inno a ion in he Digi ized
Wo ld", O ganiza ion Science, 20(1), pp. 278–279.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1287/o sc.1080.0416