53
EURO CRISIS FROM GERMAN AND FRENCH PERSPECTIVES IN 2013
Robe K. MacG ego
F ee-lance w i e
Ká anská 274/13, 108 00 P aha 10
obe kmacg ego @yahoo.com
Abs ac
A e a e y sho ime o he “Golden Age o he Eu ozone” ha d imes ha e a isen o
Eu opean in eg a ion. They e ealed c acks in he e y ounda ions, and (un il hen) hidden
hough s and opinions o key playe s in he EU a ena. Recen emo ions and di e en le els o
a sense o obliga ion o deal wi h cu en p oblems seem o di ide ins ead o b ing oge he
he big DUO, he Eu ozone’s ac ion o ce, and e en he EU i sel . I should be no ed ha
Eu opean in eg a ion a e he Second Wo ld Wa was a p oduc o he combina ion o F ench
and Ge man ways o hinking. In 2013, i seems ha his pu pose-buil duali y is alling apa .
The aim o his pape is o esea ch and analyze se e al aspec s and elemen s o he F anco-
Ge man pola i y ela ionship o he Eu ozone scene y. Obse a ion and compa ison leads o a
numbe o su p ising esul s, which a e suppo ed by he da a.
Keywo ds: Eu ozone, C isis, In eg a ion, Expo , GDP.
In oduc ion
F ance and Ge many we e wo o he main a chi ec s o he a ious ea ies and acco ds which
g adually led o he o ma ion o he EU. Though ancien i als, as he wo ‘cen al powe s’ in
he alignmen s ha would become he EU, he F ench leade s, such as Mi e and and Gisca d
d’Es aing, we e able o ea hei is-à- is Schmid and Kohl as good iends. In he
p ospe ous imes ha p eceded he c isis o 2007, hey helped o m a mu ual admi a ion
socie y, F ench and Ge man leade s and o he unc iona ies wo king hand in hand wi h each
o he , he wo powe s conni ing o ‘se he agenda’ p io o any EU summi . Ye inlaid
di e ences, such as a i udes owa ds wo k and p omo ing p i a e en e p ise, be ween he wo
coun ies would end o ake on added emphasis when he EU ell in o ha d imes. How ha e
hese wo a ed since? The p oblem o he assessmen o he complex ela ionship o F ance
and Ge many (1) can be amed and de eloped wi h he employmen o he app op ia e
me hodology ocusing on he iden i ica ion, desc ip ion and analysis (2). The p esen ed da a
and p oblem sol ing sugges ions (3) dese ed an in e disciplina y discussion (4) which should
esul in a conclusion w apping he p esen ed hough s and pu ing hem in o a gene al se ing.
1 S a emen o a p oblem – assessing he ela ionship o F ance and Ge many
Wi h he 20 h cen u y ha ing been de as a ed by wo Wo ld Wa s, he Cold Wa , he
Dep ession, Fascism, Communism, and pe secu ion o he In elligen sia and Jews and
Ch is ians, leade s o exhaus ed ‘Middle Eu ope’ unde s andably el ha a spi i o
coope a ion, wo king oge he , could p e en u u e con lic s, “The Golden ule in ac ion”.
Thusly, o o e 50 yea s now, leade s in Ge many, F ance, I aly and o he coun ies ha e
been p oud o hei peace ul g ow h and co-exis ence, ollowing Ame ica’s jump-s a ing he
e-building p ocess h ough he Ma shall Plan.
As economies con inued o lou ish, he Eu opean Mone a y Union was in oduced by he
Maas ich T ea y 1991/1992, one o he p e-condi ions se by F ance o Wes Ge many's
uni ica ion wi h Eas Ge many. The ‘Eu o’ cu ency was in oduced in 1999, aking physical
o m in 2002. Besides being a symbol o poli ical uni y, i was p edic ed ha he common
54
cu ency would inc ease c oss-bo de compe i ion, lowe impo -expo cos s, and lead o
p ice s abili y, among o he bene i s. In addi ion, i was el ha he common cu ency would
help s imula e p og essi e con e gence be ween membe s a es.
While many o he mic o and mac oeconomic goals we e a ained, i soon became ob ious
ha eal con e gence had no occu ed in all membe s a es, and ha e en he majo i y o
membe s a es we e bla an ly iola ing he EU s abili y and g ow h pac , which was insis ed
upon by Ge man inance minis e Theo Waigel. Though popula pe cep ion would place I aly,
Spain and G eece as he guil ies culp i s, F ance and Ge many we e also among hose caugh
iola ing hei own ules. How ha e he wo allies esponded?
2 Me hods
The bundle o Eu opean in eg a ion issues a ound he single-common cu ency and i s a ea
and e a, he Eu ozone and Eu o c isis, needs o be app oached and add essed wi h app op ia e
scien i ic me hods. These p edominan ly in es iga ing echniques mus be deployed in an
open-minded o m, as his s ongly in e disciplina y opic and s a ed p oblem canno ely jus
on con en ional ways o acqui ing and p ocessing in o ma ion. The e is an abundance o da a
and e idence, bu i is no always empi ically measu able and su icien ly objec i e. As a
ma e o ac , he key poin in he s udy o he Eu ozone (objec ) is he s andpoin o he
examine (subjec ), hus ine i ably he wo s onges playe s - F ance and Ge many - p esen a
di e en , o en ha d o econcile, analysis. In o he wo ds, he e seem o be wo leading se s
o hypo hesis, analysis and conclusions – he Hollandism s. Me kela ianism.
The ul ima e me hodological selec ion o he s a ed p oblem led o he employmen o
scien i ic p ocedu es o iden i ica ion and desc ip ion while using an abundance o esou ces,
including s ic ly academic pape s as well as p ess eleases and newspape a icles, along wi h
he obse a ion o he gene al economic se ing and a ailable economic da a. The analysis is
p edominan ly unc ional and compa a i e wi h analogy elemen s. Bo h induc ions and
deduc ions a e used as app op ia e.
3 Da a and p oblem sol ing
The poli ical and economic Eu opean in eg a ion was se in mo ion ollowing he Schuman
Decla a ion based on h ee ea ies in he 1950s, he T ea y o Pa is es ablishing he Eu opean
Coal and S eel Communi y (ECSC) and by he T ea ies o Rome es ablishing he Eu opean
Economic Communi y wi h a common ma ke (EEC) and he Eu opean A omic Ene gy
Communi y (Eu a om). The Eu opean Cou o Jus ice (ECJ) was among he ins i u ions
o med and ecognized by all o hem o all h ee communi ies. The ECJ was able o change
he T ea y o Rome es ablishing he EEC in o a cons i u ion and laid down he legal
ounda ions o Eu opean in eg a ion, especially in he economics ield. A d i ing ac o o
Eu opean in eg a ion was o s eng hen he economic coope a ion be ween Ge many and
F ance so as o p e en u u e con lic s in Eu ope [16].
The e ollowed a numbe o o he ea ies, including he T ea y o Maas ich es ablishing he
EU wi h a single ma ke o in e nal ma ke as well he expansion o he membe ship o 15.
Things seemed o be going well, wi h posi i e p ospec s o Eu opean in eg a ion. Ye he
u u e was no sanguine, bu o a ious easons many inside, as well as ou side, playe s
decided o o e look dange signs, o a leas did hei bes o minimize hem. The e o e,
ins ead o an in-dep h and ca e ul implemen a ion o ongoing legi ima iza ion o he
sup ana ional app oach and legi ima e moni o ing o he ue willingness and p e e ences o
he Eu opean ci izen y, an o e ly posi i e pic u e was pain ed, d owning ou any dissen . The
i e decades o Eu opean in eg a ion we e hus desc ibed as glo ious and success ul, he EU
55
p aised as i ally con ibu ing o p ospe i y, democ acy and secu i y in Eu ope and i s
enla gemen policy as a wonde ul ins umen o o eign policy. Ine i ably, i was decided
ha such a splendid achie emen should be delinea ed in a solemn cons i u ional o ma ,
making i mo e de ined, o icial, and illus ious (and also e lec ing on he glo ious leade s).
Thus, he p epa a ion o he Cons i u ional T ea y s a ed en husias ically bu hen became an
abo ed a emp o be subs i u ed by he e o m ea y o Lisbon signi ican ly changing he
Maas ich T ea y on EU (TEU) and he Rome T ea y on EEC, becoming he T ea y on he
Func ioning o EU (TFEU) [16].
The Economic and Mone a y Union ( he EMU) was d eamed up du ing 1988-1989 by a g oup
o cen al banke s, p esaging he Maas ich T ea y o 1991. Banke s would come o ha e an
inc easingly in luen ial ole in he u u e, as he Eu opean Cen al Bank (ECB) would be
made up o 11 cen al banks cha ged wi h mone a y policy. Fo hose coun ies wishing o
join he EMU, ‘Con e gence c i e ia’, budge a y and mone a y s ic u es, we e es ablished.
The c i e ia ules applied o exchange a es, na ional deb , in la ion, in e es a es, size o
budge de ici s, wi h he UK and Denma k (o icially) and Sweden (de ac o) op ing ou .
A uni ied cu ency o Eu ope, less han 60 yea s a e he Second Wo ld Wa , was highly
signi ican , and also a sign o u he in eg a ion among he membe na ions. The aim o
g owing c oss-bo de ade, inc easing e iciency in inancial as well as goods and se ices
ma ke s and educing anspo a ion cos s and cos s o doing business seemed well wi hin
each. Ano he goal o he Eu o was achie ing p ice s abili y. Howe e , i should ha e been
clea o all ha he ‘g ea equalize ’ o a common cu ency would lead o he mo e e icien
and compe i i e manu ac u ing coun ies making in oads in o hose coun ies less well-
o ganised. The business eali y pu hese ideas, goals and expec a ions unde he ‘acid es ’,
and he un o una e ou come pushed he big EU duo in o con inued s ess. These wo close
allies ha e p esen ed di e gen o unes, wi h di e ing solu ions ... and his has his o ic oo s.
Two o he main p oponen s o he Eu o, Jacques Delo s, he F ench Head o he (in) amous
EMU and EU c ea ing Commission, and Helmu Kohl, Ge man Chancello du ing his
Commission ime, admi ed, a e he ac , ha hey each had a e y weak backg ound in
economics, and i (e en ually) showed. In e es ingly enough, i was he same Jacques Delo s,
who wo decades la e bi e ly s a ed ha he Eu o was lawed om he e y beginning and, in
e e ing o i s c ea o s, said “and now e e yone mus examine hei conscience” [17]. Thus,
acco ding o he o me a chi ec o he single cu ency, he Eu o was doomed om he s a
[12]. His sugges ion abou examining one's conscience has pe haps al eady been unde aken
by himsel [19].
The idea o a mone a y union wi h no eal iscal union has p o en o be ha owing. I was no
pu o a democ a ic o e o hose who would be mos impac ed, namely EU ci izens. As
Economis Roge Boo le w o e, he Eu o “...wasn’ willed by he people bu was a he h us
upon hem by hei leade s, wi hou su icien hough o p epa a ion. They ha e c ea ed a
mons e which h ea ens o des oy he Eu opean economy – and wi h i , o h ea en he
wo ld” [4].
Howe e , in he sho e m, he Eu o Zone’s goal o p ice s abili y, while a ge ing in la ion,
quickly gained accep ance in inancial and o eign exchange ma ke s, bond ma ke s apidly
became in eg a ed, leading o a igh ening oge he o go e nmen bond yields, he a ious
coun ies' a es ending downwa ds owa ds well- ega ded Ge many's le els. The dec ease o
he de ia ion o he con e gence o in e es a es in he las decade is shown in he g aph in
Fig. 1.
56
Sou ce: [2; 3]
Fig. 1: Con e gence o in e es a es
Appa en s abili y diminished cu ency isk, and inancial ins i u ions ound i inc easingly
easy o bo ow ab oad. This led, in u n, o inc eased lending o he cons uc ion indus y and
housing sec o , p ope y alues ( empo a ily) ose and deb inc eased. As he global inancial
c isis se in du ing 2007, howe e , bad bank deb s and la ge go e nmen al deb s we e
exposed.
“Rules a e made o be b oken”, said Gene al Douglas MacA hu . Al hough he Eu o
con e gence c i e ia se by he Maas ich T ea y, i.e. he equi emen s o en e he hi d s a e
o he EMU, include clea ly he deb c i e ion o 60% and he de ici c i e ion o 3%, bo h
F ance and Ge many ailed o mee hem and hus do no sa is y A .140 o he TFEU and he
S abili y and G ow h Pac (SGP). As a ma e o ac , bo h coun ies iola ed hem soon a e
he signa u e o he SGP in 1997 and he same goes o almos all he o he membe s o he
Eu ozone. These iola ions we e cons an ly epea ed and ne e esul ed in any punishmen ,
which only encou aged u he ansg essions [11]. “F ance has egula ly b oken he EU and
Eu ozone's 'golden ule' ha budge de ici s should no exceed 3pc o GDP annually, (wi h) a
nonchalance ha many belie e helped sow he seeds o he cu en deb c isis” [20].
The eal con e gence does no occu in all membe s a es. The eg ession modes, explana o y
a iable and dummy a iables a e s a is ically signi ican and o he pe iod o 1995-2010
sugges ha one o he slowes con e ging coun ies is Ge many [13]. In his espec , he
awa eness abou basic mac oeconomic da a abou F ance and Ge many is c i ical and hus is
ecapi ula ed in he ollowing ables, i.e. in Tab. 1 o F ance and in Tab. 2 o Ge many.
Tab. 1: O e iew o F ance GDP, go e nmen de ici /su plus and deb in he EU
2009
2010
2011
2012
GDP in million Eu o
1 885 763
1 936 720
2 001 398
2 033 648
Go e nmen de ici
- 142 223
- 136 779
- 105 392
- 98 196
Ra io o annual de ici o e GDP
- 7.5%
- 7.1%
- 5.3%
- 4.8%
Accumula ed go e nmen deb in
million Eu o
1 493 385
1 594 977
1 716 887
1 833 810
Ra io o accumula ed deb o e GDP
79.2%
82.4%
89.8%
90.2%
Sou ce: [2]
57
Tab. 2: O e iew o Ge many GDP, go e nmen de ici /su plus and deb in he EU
2009
2010
2011
2012
GDP in million Eu o
2 374 500
2 496 200
2 592 600
2 643 900
Go e nmen de ici
- 73 180
- 103 440
- 20 230
+ 4 090
Ra io o annual de ici o e GDP
- 3.1%
- 4.1%
- 0.8%
+ 0.2%
Accumula ed go e nmen deb in
million Eu o
1 768 919
2 056 089
2 085 181
2 166 278
Ra io o accumula ed deb o e GDP
74.5%
82.4%
80.4%
81.9%
Sou ce: [2]
4 Discussion
In o his maels om, bols e ed wi h Socialis e ou , wi h p omises o inc eased social
spending, a oiding aus e i y p og ams imposed by o he EU na ions and c ea ing mo e jobs –
a leas in he public sec o – came he sel -p oclaimed ‘no mal p esiden ’, F ancois Hollande.
F om he s a o his aking powe , he augu ies we e no p opi ious, as Hollande was
d enched by a sudden ain squall a his inaugu a ion, and la e ha day his je was s uck by
ligh ning as he was making his way o Ge many o mee wi h Angela Me kel. When he inally
a i ed a he Be lin ai po , again in a downpou , he go los on he ai ield's ed ca pe
e iewing he Ge man oops, and had o be guided i mly by M s. Me kel's g ipping his
elbow, a sign o hings o come.
Inasmuch as he leade s o Ge many and F ance had, o many decades, oge he mapped ou
wha he agenda would be p io o any EU summi , Me kel and Hollande we e a ed o wo k
oge he ...bu ha didn' mean ha hey had o like i , o espec each o he . Be o e he F ench
elec ion, i was ob ious ha mos EU leade s, Me kel included, hoped o he e-elec ion o
Hollande’s p edecesso , Nicholas Sa kozy, which did no bode well o Hollande’s u u e
ela ions wi h Me kel.
Ea ly on, M . Hollande began dis ancing himsel om aus e i y measu es. P io o he EU
summi in Oc obe o 2012, Hollande a emp ed o ambush M s. Me kel by o ming a
‘Medi e anean F on ’ o F ance, Spain, I aly and Po ugal o b eak Ge many’s hold on
policy. His e o s ailed ignominiously, Ge many was annoyed, and Me kel began
s eng hening ies o he UK's Da id Came on. Hollande and Me kel ough o e supe ision
o na ional budge s, and acco ding o a epo e p esen . “Such an open clash be ween he
F ench and Ge man leade s is a e a EU summi s, a sign ha Eu ope's landscape has changed
adically since M . Hollande ook powe .” [8].
B eaking us wi h he Ge mans was one o he leas o Hollande’s p oblems, howe e , as his
unpopula aising o he op le el o pe sonal income axes began o d i e weal h and he
weal hy (no jus Ge a d Depa dieu) om F ance, lessening he numbe o en ep eneu s and
hus losing job c ea ion oppo uni ies. When A icle 6 o his new ax law aised he op a e o
capi al gains ax om 34.5% o 62.2% (in B i ain i is 28%) i se o a i es o m o p o es
om businessmen, al eady s agge ing unde es ic i e labou laws. A icle 6 was labeled
‘economic illi e acy’ and a disas ous economic mis ake. In Sep embe , his budge called o
highe axes, bu no slimming o he ga gan uan s a e spending, wi h no plans o inc ease
expo s o encou age business, o o se F ance’s long e m loss o global compe i i eness. A
his poin , Ge many's inance minis e , Wol gang Schauble, asked a (Ge man) panel o op
ad ise s o examine possible e o m p oposals o F ance. In No embe , F ance was s ipped
o i s co e ed AAA s a us by inancial a ings agencies, unemploymen hi a 13-yea high,
while i s insis ence o main aining high F ench ag icul u al subsidies helped lead o he ailu e
o he EU o each an acco d on EU spending o 2014-2020. Hollande has only nibbled a he

58
edges o he de ici , cu ing 10 Billion Eu os in spending and aising axes (mos ly on he ich)
by 20 billion, he esul insigni ican o a 2 T illion Eu o budge .
When o me P esiden Geo ge W. Bush amously joked ha one o F ance’s p oblems is ha
he e is no F ench wo d meaning ‘en ep eneu ’, he hi he nail on he head. Al hough
Hollande has spoken abou s imulus spending, he has no unde aken much needed e o ms o
he es ic i e business en i onmen , mainly labou law.
“The F ench labou code has 3,650 pages and 200 pages a e added e e y yea . The Swiss
labou code has 70 pages and I do no hink Swi ze land is a less e icien economy o labou
ma ke ” says Hen i de Cas ies, CEO o Axa, a F ench Insu ance company which is one o he
la ges in he wo ld [6].
In F ance, when a company g ows in size such ha i needs mo e han 50 employees, 34
addi ional labou laws and es ic ions ake e ec , discou aging businesses om expanding.
This helps explain why he e a e in F ance ba ely 4,000 SMEs – Small and medium
en e p ises – p opo iona ely only hal o he o al ha exis s in ei he Ge many o G ea
B i ain [1]. Also, a mul i ude o many illogical ules and di ec i es c ea e ha oc o any
po en ial o g ow h, his du ing a e ible slump. Fo ced on business and p i a e indi iduals
wi h bu eauc a ic e ou , “They cos he 27 Eu opean Union coun ies an a e age o 3.7
pe cen o hei g oss domes ic p oduc a yea , mo e han $10 billion in he case o F ance,
and hold back an incalculable amoun o new in es men ” [7]. De Cas ies o Axa poin ed ou
ha wi h F ench public spending a 56 pe cen o GDP i is 10 pe cen age poin s mo e han
he a e age o he o he Eu ozone coun ies, he di e ence being 200 billion Eu os, one en h
o F ance’s 2 illion Eu o economy. “This 200 billion Eu os is aken ou each yea om he
people who know how o make money, c ea e jobs and os e g ow h o subsidize bene i s and
public p ojec s ha do no necessa ily ha e any signi ican a e o e u n, so i is no su p ise
ha he compe i i eness is no op imal” [6].
New ules o wheelchai access and i e p o ec ion h ea ens o shu down 80% o small
independen ly un ho els, mos o hem in cen u ies-old buildings which a e unable o enla ge
hallways o s ai s. A bu eauc acy, when i becomes sick o dys unc ional, is e med a
bu eaupa hy, and he F ench e sion has a la ou all i s own. In addi ion, he cu en global
pos -mode n socie y is ounded on communica ions and cu en success ul EU p ojec s, such
as TLD.eu o o he p ojec s in he sphe e o in ellec ual p ope y, a e concep ually based on
he echnical ha moniza ion and s ong delega ion o P i a e law subjec s [14]. These well
p o en co ec concep s should become an inspi a ion o he EU [15] and should p eoccupy
he minds o EU leade s and ac o s much mo e han he d i e o inc ease he numbe o pages
o a ious codes and egula ions o he eage ness o ha e supe mode n wide ele a o s in
medie al buildings.
In 2013, Hollande’s bad luck con inued, wi h he Cahuzac scandal, whe ein he budge
minis e , in cha ge o igh ing ax aud was ound o ha e been a ax auds e himsel ,
holding a sec e Swiss bank accoun , and is aced wi h jail. In addi ion, he minis e o
indus ial eco e y, A naud Mon ebou g, once again p o ed his un i ness o he job by
chasing away a 300 million dolla in es men om Yahoo, his coming jus a e p e en ing
Ti an In e na ional om ying o buy a ailing Goodyea F ench i e plan , o go along wi h
simila ailu es. A highly unpopula o cing h ough o Gay Ma iage has led o he la ges
s ee p o es s in 30 yea s, e lec i e as well o Hollande’s unpopula i y. In a mock elec ion, i
is es ima ed now ha he would ga ne bu 19% o he o e, wi h igh is Ma ine Le Pen ahead
wi h 23% and o me P esiden Sa kozy ne ing 34% [18]. Pe haps o ake he hea o
Hollande om he F ench ci izen y, in Ap il o his yea se e al o Hollande’s minis e s
began o make insul ing ema ks abou Ge many, aus e i y, and M s. Me kel, wi hou being
59
held accoun able o hei ema ks by Hollande. The Ge man esponse was o leak a memo by
some o M s. Me kel's coali ion pa ne s which labeled F ance as “Eu ope’s bigges p oblem
child” wi h a sick economy and a e o m package ha was, a bes , aimless. M s. Me kel hen
denied ha she knew o he epo o ag eed wi h i . As M s. Me kel migh say, “Touche!”
Why does Ge many igh so ha d o keep he Eu o, which has cos so many people in G eece,
Spain, Po ugal and o he coun ies hei jobs and u u es? Because i is in hei own bes
in e es . The Ge man “business and poli ical eli es know ha he Eu ozone p o ides Ge man
expo e s wi h a la ge ma ke o a he uncompe i i e coun ies ha buy hei goods...Me kel
mus explain ( o Ge man o e s) ha Ge many is paying in o he bail-ou unds no o
idealism bu ou o sel -in e es ” [10]. Ge many has been es aining i ’s domes ic
consump ion, in he ace o calls om he o he EU zone membe s o inc ease i , while i has
become an expo -d i en na ion. In No embe , 2012, he US T easu y depa men eleased a
damning c i icism o he e-occu ing ade su plus o Ge many, b anding i as a g ea e enemy
in his ega d han China. Ge many's cu en accoun su plus a ha poin was a 6.3% o
GDP, while China ( o a ious easons) was down o 2.6%, making Ge many he bigges
single sou ce o ade imbalance in he wo ld. The epo said ha he EMU egime o
Sou he n aus e i y was no being me by o se ing s imulus in he No h coun ies, hus
holding back global eco e y [9]. Bu as o me GM Chai man ‘Engine Cha lie’ Wilson
amously decla ed “Wha ’s good o Gene al Mo o s is good o he USA”, and wha ’s good
o Ge many is......good o Ge many. In e o GM, GM Eu ope’s Opel-Vauxhall has epo ed
losses o $1.8 billion in 2012, Fo d Eu ope los $1.75 billion, and Peugeo -Ci oen o F ance
los $2 billion. And Volkswagen? Volkswagen had p o i s o $15 billion [21].
Meanwhile, in F ance, as o May, 2013, public spending is now a 57% o GDP, while he
coun y’s public deb is nea ly 94%, and unemploymen has inc eased 11.5% in he one yea
since F ancois Hollande ook o ice. The Eu opean Commission, which has been g an ed new
EU powe s o en o ce needed e o ms in membe coun ies, has demanded F ance make
adical e o ms o i s bloa ed pensions and employmen laws so as o y o inc ease F ance’s
waning compe i i eness. This demand wen hand-in-hand wi h he Commission’s g an ing
F ance wo ex a yea s o each i s budge ’s de ici a ge s. “Ou message o F ance is pu ing
a g ea accen on s uc u al e o ms ha a e needed” said Jose Manuel Ba oso, head o he
Eu opean Commission, he EU’s execu i e body. “Cu ing public spending, es o ing
compe i i eness, opening up es ic ed ma ke s, e o ming he ax egime and loosening igh
labou ma ke egula ions” con inued Ba oso. This announcemen came on he same day ha
he OECD, club o la ge economies based in Pa is called o almos exac ly he same changes
o F ance [5].
The IMF issued he same calls o e o ms om F ance wi hin he same week. Hollande's
esponse was no one o g a i ude, howe e , o he wo yea s ex ension, a he one o denying
ha he EU could ‘dic a e’ o F ance, and implying ha F ance migh ‘hun and peck’ e o m,
and a i s own (slow) pace. Howe e , inasmuch as Eu ope’s Commissione o economic and
mone a y a ai s, Ollie Rehn has implied ha he will use new EU powe s, such as ines and
o he penal ies, o o ce F ance o make needed e o ms, i may jus be mo e emp y e biage
om Hollande. Meanwhile, a F ench documen a y ilm abou Hollande, en i led Le Pou oi
(The Powe ) has po ayed him as a imid, ine ec ual, hen-pecked weakling, a aid o make
decisions, and losing he espec o hose wo king unde him. Hollande’s ecen
announcemen ha he Eu oc isis was o e will doub less be gi en all he espec due i s
sou ce.
Hollande’s app o al a ings a e he lowes in F ance’s his o y, hough pe haps a e Wa e loo
Napoleon’s migh ha e been wo se, had hey measu ed such hings in hose days.
60
Conclusion
The dynamics o he F ench-Ge man pa ne ship, so impo an o leading he EU, has b oken
down, e lec ing he o unes o he Eu o i sel . Was he alliance buil on a ounda ion o sand,
jus as he Eu o seems o ha e been? The ama eu ish a emp s o Hollande o show up Angela
Me kel simply damaged his c edibili y on he wo ld s age. F ance’s e usal o e o m i s
economy is conside ed as po en ially he bigges h ea o he con inuance o he Eu o, so i
may p o e ou ha Eu o skep ics will be oas ing Hollande in he u u e. Ye wi h co ec
leade ship, acing eali y and ge ing F ance’s own house in o de , he esul s could be
d as ically di e en , hough s ill wi h pe haps a ecogni ion om EU leade ship ha he eu o
expe imen has caused a mo e damage han i is wo h.
Li e a u e
[1] ALEXANDER, H.: Why e en Hollande’s backya d says F ance isn’ wo king. [online].
The Teleg aph, 24 h No embe , 2012. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/news/wo ldnews/ ancois-hollande/9700805/Why-e en-
Hollandes-backya d-says-F ance-isn -wo king.h ml>.
[2] ALLEN, T.: Eu o a ea and EU27 go e nmen de ici a 3.7% and 4.0% o GDP
espec i ely. [online]. Eu os a News Release - Eu oindica o s, 64/2013 - 22nd Ap il,
2013. [accessed 2013-06-11]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://epp.eu os a .ec.eu opa.eu/cache/ITY_PUBLIC/2-22042013-AP/EN/2-
22042013-AP-EN.PDF>.
[3] ANAND, M. R.; GUPTA, G. L.; DASH, R.: The eu o zone c isis – I s dimensions and
implica ions. [online]. In EconPape s. Janua y 2012. [accessed 2013-06-11]. A ailable
om WWW:
<h p://econpape s. epec.o g/sc ip s/ edi .p ?u=h p%3A%2F%2Fwww.esocialsciences.
o g%2FDownload%2F epecDownload.aspx%3F name%3DA20122610315_20.pd %26
ca ego y%3DA icles%26AId%3D4764%26 e %3D epec;h= epec:ess:wpape :id:476
4>.
[4] BOOTLE, R.: Eu ope has eached a wa e shed momen and leade s need o e ocus.
[online]. The Teleg aph, 7 h May, 2012. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/commen / oge boo le/9249466/Eu ope-has-
eached-a-wa e shed-momen -and-leade s-need- o- e ocus.h ml>.
[5] CARNEGY, H.: Hollande unde p essu e o speed up e o ms. Financial Times, 30 h
May, 2013, p. 2.
[6] CAVE, A.: F ance wo se o han 1970s: Axa chie . [online]. The Teleg aph, 1s June,
2013. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/ inancialc isis/10093809/F ance-wo se-o - han-
UK-in- he-1970s-Axa-chie .h ml>.
[7] CODY, E.: F ance d owing in ules and egula ions, c i ics say. [online]. The
Washing on Pos , 16 h Ap il, 2013. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://a icles.washing onpos .com/2013-04-16/wo ld/38587923_1_ ules- ench-
egula ions>.
[8] EVANS-PRITCHARD, A.: EU leade s ag ee “ iscal acili y” plan wi h eye on budge
union. [online]. The Teleg aph, 19 h Oc obe , 2012. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable
om WWW: <h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/ inancialc isis/9619305/EU-leade s-
ag ee- iscal- acili y-plan-wi h-eye-on-budge -union.h ml>.
61
[9] EVANS-PRITCHARD, A.: Ge many displaces China as US T easu y’s cu ency
illain. [online]. The Teleg aph, 28 h No embe , 2012. [accessed 2013-06-11].
A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/cu ency/9709882/Ge many-displaces-China-as-
US-T easu ys-cu ency- illain.h ml>.
[10] GRANT, Ch.: The s a egic consequences o he Eu o c isis. [online]. Eu ope’s Wo ld,
18 h Oc obe , 2010. [accessed 2013-06-13]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www.eu opeswo ld.o g/NewEnglish/Home_old/A icle/ abid/191/A icleType/A
icleView/A icleID/21728/Thes a egicconsequenceso heEu oc isis.aspx>.
[11] HEIM, J.: Eu ope misses he Ma k wi h i s Fiscal Impac . [online]. In In e na ional
A ai s Re iew, 13 h Feb ua y, 2012. [accessed 2013-06-10]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www.ia -gwu.o g/node/383>.
[12] KIRKUP, J.: EURO doomed om s a , says Jacques Delo s. [online]. In The
Teleg aph, 2nd Decembe , 2011. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/ inancialc isis/8932647/Eu o-doomed- om-s a -
says-Jacques-Delo s.h ml>.
[13] KOVÁŘOVÁ, J.; ŠULGANOVÁ, M.: The eal con e gence o selec ed coun ies o he
Eu o Zone a e age economic le el. Scien i ic pape s o he Uni e si y o Pa dubice.
Se ies D, Facul y o Economics and Adminis a ion, 2012, Vol. 25, Iss. 3, pp. 113-124.
ISSN: 1211-555X.
[14] MacGREGOR PELIKÁNOVÁ, R.: And he bes op le el domain o Eu opean
En e p ises is … In e na ional and Compa a i e Law Re iew, 2012, Vol. 12, 2/2012,
pp. 41-58. ISSN 1213-8770.
[15] MacGREGOR PELIKÁNOVÁ, R.: Koncep y z oblas i duše ního las nic í coby
inspi ace p o e opskou in eg aci? Ac a MUP, 2013, Vol. 4, Iss.1, pp. 54-63. ISSN:
1804-6932.
[16] MacGREGOR, R; PACLÍK, M.: Eu opean in eg a ion Odyssey - he ship sails on …
bu whe e? In Jou nal on Legal and Economic Issues o Cen al Eu ope, 2013, Vol. IV,
Iss.1, pp. ISSN: 2043-0855X.
[17] MACKENZIE, C.: Eu o was lawed om he beginning: Jacques Delo s accuses
Eu opean leade s o doing ‘ oo li le, oo la e’. [online]. MailOnline. 3 d Decembe ,
2011. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/a icle-2069458/Eu o- lawed-beginning-Jacques-
Delo s-accuses-Eu opean-leade s-doing-li le-la e.h ml>.
[18] MOUTET, Anne-Elisabe h: M No mal has become he Pi i ul P esiden . [online]. The
Teleg aph, 2nd May, 2013. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/news/wo ldnews/ ancois-hollande/10033387/M -No mal-
has-become- he-Pi i ul-P esiden .h ml>.
[19] PACLÍK, M.: Eu oc isis. PEM, 2012, Vol.3, Iss. 2, pp. 24-30. ISSN: 1804-3550.
[20] Teleg aph S a . F ance mus e o m o he eu o will die. [online]. The Teleg aph, 29 h
May, 2013. [accessed 2013-06-14]. A ailable om WWW:
<h p://www. eleg aph.co.uk/ inance/commen / eleg aph- iew/10087934/F ance-mus -
e o m-o - he-eu o-will-die.h ml>.