ISSN: 2582-4686 SJIF 2021-3.261,SJIF 2022-
2.889, 2024-6.875 Resea chBib IF: 9.948 / 2024
VOLUME-5, ISSUE-11
136
THE INTERRELATION BETWEEN JOURNALISM AND MUSICAL CRITICISM
Rakhmano a Is a Mumino na
Depa men o Music Pe o mance
and Cul u e, Bukha a S a e Uni e si y
Abs ac
Musical c i icism and jou nalism a e wo closely in e connec ed socio-cul u al phenomena. Bo h
ields aim o illumina e, analyze, and communica e a is ic and social p ocesses o he public.
Jou nalism se es as a p o essional ac i i y o dissemina ing in o ma ion, conduc ing analysis, and
shaping public opinion, whe eas musical c i icism e alua es, in e p e s, and e eals he aes he ic and
ideological essence o music. The e o e, musical c i icism has de eloped as a specialized b anch o
jou nalis ic p ac ice.
Keywo ds: musical c i icism, jou nalism, media, cul u al communica ion, aes he ics, Uzbek music,
digi al media, musical jou nalism, a is ic analysis, mass cul u e.
The Role o Musical C i icism in Jou nalism
Th ough jou nalism, musical c i icism eaches he wide public. Mass media dissemina e musical
analyses, shape musical as e wi hin socie y, and in oduce new c ea i e igu es. E e y musical c i ic
en e s he jou nalis ic ield o sha e ideas wi h audiences — h ough newspape s, magazines, adio,
ele ision, and, in mode n imes, online media and social ne wo ks. Jou nalism hus se es as a
medium ha popula izes and con eys musical c i icism o he audience.
The in e ela ion be ween musical c i icism and jou nalism is p ima ily mani es ed in hei
communica i e na u e. Jus as a jou nalis in e p e s social phenomena, he c i ic analyzes musical
e en s. The di e ence lies in he ocus: jou nalism co e s social, poli ical, and cul u al p ocesses in
gene al e ms, while musical c i icism e alua es hem om an a is ic s andpoin . Howe e , bo h
sha e a key unc ion — in luencing public consciousness and shaping cul u al alues.
His o ical Fo ma ion and De elopmen
The in e ela ion be ween musical c i icism and jou nalism ook shape in he la e 19 h and ea ly 20 h
cen u ies. Ini ially, musical c i icism exis ed mainly wi hin academic o a is ic ci cles. Wi h he
expansion o he p ess, i e ol ed in o a ious jou nalis ic o ms. In Uzbekis an, jou nals such as
Sha q Yulduzi, O‘zbekis on Adabiyo i a San’a i, Yoshlik, Tea , and San’a played a signi ican ole
in in eg a ing musical c i ique in o jou nalism.
By he mid-20 h cen u y, specialized c i ical gen es such as “conce e iews,” “pe o mance
analyses,” “album commen a ies,” and “imp essions om musical e enings” appea ed in newspape s
and magazines. This ma ked jou nalism’s en y in o he musical ield. Radio and ele ision u he
s eng hened his ela ionship, o e ing pla o ms o c i ical p og ams and discussions. C i ics such
as A. Bobojono , R. Abdullae , M. Qodi o , T. Jalilo , and O. Yoqubo signi ican ly con ibu ed o
he ad ancemen o na ional musical cul u e h ough hei a icles and commen a ies.
Gen es and Fo ms o Musical C i icism in Jou nalism
Musical c i icism is exp essed h ough a ious jou nalis ic gen es:
• Re iew – analysis o a conce , album, pe o mance, o musical e en , assessing a is ic quali y,
pe o mance mas e y, melody, image y, and s age cul u e.
ISSN: 2582-4686 SJIF 2021-3.261,SJIF 2022-
2.889, 2024-6.875 Resea chBib IF: 9.948 / 2024
VOLUME-5, ISSUE-11
137
• Analy ical A icle – explo es b oade phenomena such as he de elopmen o mode n pop
music o he adi ions o na ional maqom a .
• In e iew – con e sa ions wi h compose s, pe o me s, o c i ics ha e eal he inne dynamics
o he musical en i onmen .
• Repo age – p o ides i id, di ec accoun s om conce s, es i als, o compe i ions, cap u ing
li e imp essions.
• Essay – a e lec i e, pe sonal, and philosophical piece abou a pa icula wo k o a is .
Thus, jou nalism se es as a pla o m o shaping and deli e ing musical c i icism o audiences. A
musical c i ic uses jou nalis ic gen es o each he public, he eby con ibu ing o he dissemina ion
o musical cul u e.
P o essional Simila i ies be ween C i ics and Jou nalis s
The p o essions o jou nalis s and musical c i ics sha e many common ea u es. Bo h ely on ac s,
e idence, analysis, e alua ion, and logical conclusions. Howe e , he c i ic’s wo k emphasizes
subjec i i y, aes he ic pe cep ion, a is ic hinking, and p o essional musical li e acy. E e y musical
c i ic, in a sense, mus be a jou nalis , while e e y cul u al jou nalis should possess musical
awa eness and analy ical skills.
A jou nalis ic app oach in oduces dynamism and ele ance in o c i icism. The jou nalis p o ides
immediacy and esponsi eness, while he c i ic o e s dep h and aes he ic in e p e a ion. Toge he
hey complemen each o he : he jou nalis is swi , and he c i ic is p o ound. In mode n imes, his
in e connec ion has p oduced a new hyb id o m — musical jou nalism.
In eg a ion o Musical C i icism and Jou nalism in he Digi al E a
The ise o digi al media has ele a ed he collabo a ion be ween musical c i icism and jou nalism o
a new le el. C i ics now exp ess hei ideas no only h ough p in media bu also ia online pla o ms,
blogs, podcas s, YouTube e iews, and Teleg am channels. Many young jou nalis s a e engaging in
musical analysis h ough social media, making c i icism mo e accessible and democ a ic.
Howe e , his end has also b ough challenges: declining s anda ds o c i ique, lack o a is ic
c i e ia, and he ise o subjec i e o p omo ional con en . The e o e, s eng hening he heo e ical
and e hical ounda ions o bo h jou nalism and musical c i icism, as well as aining p o essional
c i ics, has become an u gen necessi y.
The De elopmen o Musical Jou nalism in Uzbekis an
A e Uzbekis an gained independence, mass media expe ienced apid g ow h, which e i alized bo h
jou nalism and musical c i icism. Today, publica ions such as San’a , Tea , O‘zbekis on San’a i,
Yoshla O ozı, Da akchi, Oila Da asida, Zamin, Kul u a.uz, and Uza.uz egula ly publish analy ical
musical a icles. Tele ision and adio p og ams such as Musiqa Olami, Es ada Yangilikla i, San’a
Tongi, and Yosh Is e’dodla ha e also become impo an pla o ms whe e jou nalis s and c i ics
collabo a e.
Among he younge gene a ion, musical blogging, podcas s, and “ eac ion ideos” ha e eme ged as
new o ms o public c i icism. This in e ac i e s yle o communica ion has made musical c i icism
mo e popula and di ec , in eg a ing i deeply in o he b oade sys em o cul u al communica ion.
Conclusion
Musical c i icism and jou nalism a e no me ely ela ed — hey a e in e dependen . Thei coope a ion
ensu es ha a is ic alues a e communica ed, analyzed, and p ese ed wi hin socie y. In he mode n
ISSN: 2582-4686 SJIF 2021-3.261,SJIF 2022-
2.889, 2024-6.875 Resea chBib IF: 9.948 / 2024
VOLUME-5, ISSUE-11
138
digi al e a, his ela ionship has become e en mo e dynamic, opening new oppo uni ies o c ea i i y,
educa ion, and cul u al exchange. S eng hening p o essional s anda ds and os e ing a cul u e o
esponsible musical jou nalism emain key ac o s o he sus ainable de elopmen o Uzbekis an’s
musical a and media space.
Re e ences
1. Abdullae , R. (2010). The de elopmen o musical c i icism in Uzbekis an. Tashken : Fan.
2. Bobojono , A. (2005). Music jou nalism and cul u al communica ion. Tashken : San’a .
3. Mi zae , M. (2002). His o y and heo y o Uzbek music. Tashken : San’a .
4. Ta aso , V. (2010). Theo y o music. Moscow: Muzyka.
5. Kadi o , B. (2015). Founda ions o musicology. Tashken : Uzbekis an Na ional Conse a o y
P ess.
6. Saido , A. (2020). P oblems o con empo a y musical hinking. Tashken .
7. Le e e, P. (2012). Music c i icism and jou nalism: an in e na ional pe spec i e. London:
Rou ledge.
8. Is a , Rakhmano a, and Rakhma o Rus am. "MUSIC AND DRAMA THEATRE (ON THE
EXAMPLE OF THE BUKHARA MUSIC AND DRAMA THEATRE)." AMERICAN JOURNAL OF
EDUCATION AND LEARNING 3.7 (2025): 587-591.
9. Рахманова, И. М., and Мадина Тохтамуратовна Чориева. "ЧТО ЧЕЛОВЕК ПОНИМАЕТ
ИЗ МУЗЫКИ, ЕСЛИ ОН НЕ ГУМАНЕН?." Mul idisciplina y Jou nal o Science and Technology
5.3 (2025): 282-286.
10. Саидов, Джасур Шавкатович. "Педагогические и психологические особенности
формирования вокально-хоровых навыков у учащихся." Mul idisciplina y Jou nal o Science and
Technology 5.6 (2025): 473-477.
11. Bahodi o na K. S. METHODOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS OF AESTHETIC EDUCATION
OF YOUNG STUDENTS THROUGH MASS CULTURAL EVENTS IN THE CONDITIONS OF
NEW UZBEKISTAN //AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EDUCATION AND LEARNING. – 2025. – Т.
3. – №. 6. – С. 686-692.
12. Hami o a S. B. e al. Me hodological possibili ies o aes he ic educa ion o young s uden s
h ough cul u al e en s //Academic Jou nal o Science, Technology and Educa ion. – 2025. – Т. 1. –
№. 5. – С. 12-15.
13. Bahodi o na H. S. FORMS, TYPES OF CULTURAL EVENTS AND THEIR
ORGANIZATION //In e na ional con e ence on mul idisciplina y science. – 2025. – Т. 3. – №. 1. –
С. 92-94.
14. Хамитова С. Б. Синтез жанров народного искусства в направлении современных
массовых праздников и представлений //Mul idisciplina y Jou nal o Science and Technology. –
2025. – Т. 5. – №. 6. – С. 458-463.
