scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

The behaviour of I-129 released from nuclear fuel reprocessing factories in the North Atlantic Ocean and transport to the Arctic assessed from numerical modelling

Abstract

A quantitative evaluation of the fate of 129I, released from the European reprocessing plants of Sellafield (UK) and La Hague (France), has been made by means of a Lagrangian dispersion model. Transport of radionuclides to the Arctic Ocean has been determined. Thus, 5.1 and 16.6 TBq of 129I have been intro-duced in the Arctic from Sellafield and La Hague respectively from 1966 to 2012. These figures represent, respectively, 48% and 55% of the cumulative discharge to that time. Inventories in the North Atlantic, including shelf seas, are 4.4 and 13.8 TBq coming from Sellafield and La Hague respectively. These figures are significantly different from previous estimations based on field data. The distribution of these inven-tories among several shelf seas and regions has been evaluated as well. Mean ages of tracers have been finally obtained, making use of the age-averaging hypothesis. It has been found that mean ages for Sellafield releases are about 3.5 year larger than for La Hague releases.

Read accessible full text

The behaviour of I-129 released from nuclear fuel reprocessing factories in the North Atlantic Ocean and transport to the Arctic assessed from numerical modelling

Author: Villa Alfageme, María; López Gutiérrez, José María; Suh, Kyunk-Suk; Min, Byung-Il; Periáñez Rodríguez, Raúl
Publisher: Elsevier
Year: 2015
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2014.11.039
Source: https://idus.us.es/bitstreams/1391530f-42f4-411c-95d9-d4582e0d5ff6/download
The beha iou o
129
I eleased om nuclea uel ep ocessing
ac o ies in he No h A lan ic Ocean and anspo o he A c ic
assessed om nume ical modelling
M. Villa
a
, J.M. López-Gu ié ez
b
, Kyung-Suk Suh
c
, Byung-Il Min
c
, R. Pe iáñez
d,
⇑
a
Dp Física Aplicada II, ETSIE, Uni e si y o Se illa, Spain
b
Dp Física Aplicada I, EPS, Uni e si y o Se illa, Spain
c
KAERI, Daedeok-Dae o 989-111, Yuseong-Gu, Daejeon, Republic o Ko ea
d
Dp Física Aplicada I, ETSIA, Uni e sidad de Se illa, C a U e a km 1, 41013 Se illa, Spain
Keywo ds:
A lan ic Ocean
Iodine-129
Dispe sion
Lag angian model
A c ic Ocean
abs ac
A quan i a i e e alua ion o he a e o
129
I, eleased om he Eu opean ep ocessing plan s o Sellafield (UK) and La Hague
(F ance), has been made by means o a Lag angian dispe sion model. T anspo o adionuclides o he A c ic Ocean has been
de e mined. Thus, 5.1 and 16.6 TBq o
129
I ha e been in o-duced in he A c ic om Sellafield and La Hague espec i ely om 1966
o 2012. These figu es ep esen , espec i ely, 48% and 55% o he cumula i e discha ge o ha ime. In en o ies in he No h
A lan ic, including shel seas, a e 4.4 and 13.8 TBq coming om Sellafield and La Hague espec i ely. These figu es a e significan ly
di e en om p e ious es ima ions based on field da a. The dis ibu ion o hese in en- o ies among se e al shel seas and egions
has been e alua ed as well. Mean ages o ace s ha e been finally ob ained, making use o he age-a e aging hypo hesis. I has
been ound ha mean ages o Sellafield eleases a e abou 3.5 yea la ge han
o La Hague eleases.
1. In oduc ion
Nume ical models which simula e he dispe sion o adionuc-
lides in he ma ine en i onmen ha e been con inuously de el-
oped, since he pionee ing wo ks o P andle (1984) o he mos
sophis ica ed app oaches used, o ins ance, o p edic he ans-
po o Fukushima eleases in he Pacific Ocean (Masumo o e al.,
2012; Pe iáñez e al., 2014). Some models ha e also been de el-
oped o simula e he anspo o adionuclides eleased om he
Eu opean nuclea uel ep ocessing plan s o Sellafield (UK) and
La Hague (F ance) in A lan ic wa e s. These models ha e been
applied o a numbe o adionuclides like
137
Cs (P andle, 1984;
Gao e al., 2004),
90
S (Gao e al., 2004),
99
Tc (Ka che e al.,
2004) and
129
I(O e e al., 2009). We a e no men ioning he e
local-scale applica ions, o ins ance in he English Channel and
in he I ish Sea.
Among hese adionuclides,
129
I is a e y significan one since,
due o i s biophilic beha iou and e y long hal -li e
ð15:710
6
yea sÞ, can e en en e he ood chain and emain he e
much longe han o he sho -li ed iso opes. Thus, a numbe o
s udies conce ning he dis ibu ion and a e o
129
I eleases
om he Eu opean ep ocessing plan s in he No h A lan ic
ha e been published (Smi h e al., 2011; He e al., 2013; Michel
e al., 2012; Alfimo e al., 2004, 2013; Gómez-Guzman e al.,
2013).
Some models ha e simula ed he dispe sion o
129
I in he no h-
e n A lan ic Ocean (O e e al., 2009), as commen ed abo e. How-
e e , only he anspo pa hways by he main cu en sys ems
ha e been desc ibed. Fu he mo e, a quan i a i e es ima ion o
he
129
I in en o ies in di e en sub-basins and shel seas has ne e
been pe o med. The objec i e o his pape consis s o p esen ing
such de ailed calcula ions by means o a Lag angian dispe sion
model. Due o he Lag angian na u e o he model, i is possible
o know i a gi en pa icle, loca ed anywhe e in he domain, is
coming om Sellafield o om La Hague. Thus, his allows o e al-
ua e independen ly he a e o adionuclides eleased om each
nuclea acili y and he con ibu ion o each plan o he in en o-
ies in he No h A lan ic. Also, he inpu o he A c ic Ocean
has been e alua ed, quan i a i ely de e mining he ac ions o
Sellafield and La Hague eleases which en e in o his ocean. Mean
age o wa e ace s ha e been calcula ed o eleases om
Sellafield, La Hague and conside ing bo h simul aneously. The
age-a e aging hypo hesis, desc ibed below, has been adop ed.
The model is b iefly desc ibed in Sec ion 2. Resul s a e p esen ed
and discussed in Sec ion 3.
⇑
Co esponding au ho . Tel.: +34 954486474; ax: +34 954486436.
E-mail add ess: [email p o ec ed] (R. Pe iáñez).
2. Model desc ip ion
The model is a Lag angian dispe sion model in which a adionu-
clide elease is simula ed by a numbe o pa icles, each o hem
equi alen o a numbe o uni s (a oms o Bq). Lag angian models
p esen wo ad an ages o e Eule ian models, in which an
ad ec ion/di usion equa ion o mass concen a ion is sol ed.
Fi s , a ificial nume ical di usion is no in oduced; second, spe-
cific p ope ies may be assigned o each pa icle. Fo ins ance, a
‘‘clock’’ may be a ached o each pa icle, which is use ul o ob ain
wa e ace ages (Mi ó e al., 2012).
The h ee-dimensional pa h ollowed by each pa icle is com-
pu ed, u bulen di usion being modelled as a h ee-dimensional
andom walk p ocess. The densi y o pa icles pe wa e olume
Fig. 1. Model domain wi h loca ion o sampling poin s whe e measu ed
129
I concen a ions ha e been compa ed wi h model esul s. Blue boxes define some egions whe e
adionuclide con en s ha e been e alua ed. (Fo in e p e a ion o he e e ences o colou in his figu e legend, he eade is e e ed o he web e sion o his a icle.)
−50 −40 −30 −20 −10 010 20
50
55
60
65
70
75
Longi ude
La i ude
0.5 m/s
EGC
NCC
NAC
No h Sea
Cel ic Sea
Bal ic Sea
No h Cape
No wegian Sea
I mingue Sea
Fig. 2. Su ace cu en s calcula ed by JAMSTEC model o Janua y 2008 as an example. The main cu en s a e he Eas G eenland Cu en (EGC), No h A lan ic Cu en (NAC)
and he No wegian Coas al Cu en (NCC). Only one o each 25 ec o s is d awn.
uni is compu ed o ob ain adionuclide concen a ions o e he
domain a he desi ed imes and dep hs. Technical de ails may
be consul ed elsewhe e (Pe iáñez and Ellio , 2002; Pe iáñez and
Ca a aca, 2010), bu some indica ions a e gi en below.
Ad ec ion is compu ed sol ing he ollowing equa ion o each
pa icle:
d
d ¼qð1Þ
whe e is he posi ion ec o o he pa icle and qis he cu en
ec o a he pa icle posi ion and dep h, sol ed in componen s u
and
. T anspo due o e ical ad ec ion is masked by e ical
mixing due o u bulence, since e ical cu en s in he ocean a e
small. Thus, i is a common app oach o neglec e ical ad ec ion
in ma ine dispe sion modelling.
The maximum size o he ho izon al s ep gi en by he pa icle
due o u bulence, D
h
,is(P oc o e al., 1994; Hun e , 1987;
Pe iáñez and Ellio , 2002):
D
h
¼ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
12K
h
D
pð2Þ
in he di ec ion h¼2
p
RAN, whe e RAN is a andom numbe
be ween 0 and 1. This equa ion gi es he maximum size o he s ep.
1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2x 1012
Yea
Annual elease (Bq)
Sella ield
La Hague
Fig. 3. Annual
129
I eleases om Sellafield and La Hague ep ocessing plan s. This
in o ma ion has been compiled om López-Gu ié ez e al. (2004), Sellafield (2014),
A e a (2014).
Fig. 4. Measu ed
129
I concen a ions (mBq/m
3
) in su ace wa e s. No h Sea samples we e collec ed in 2005. The smalle numbe s a e sampling s a ion numbe s and he
la ge ones he co esponding measu ed concen a ions ( aken om Michel e al., 2012).
In p ac ice, i is mul iplied by RAN o ob ain he eal size a a gi en
ime and o a gi en pa icle. Simila ly, he maximum size o he
e ical s ep is (P oc o e al., 1994; Hun e , 1987; Pe iáñez and
Ellio , 2002):
D
¼ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
2K
D
pð3Þ
gi en ei he owa ds he sea su ace o he sea bo om. K
h
and K
a e he ho izon al and e ical di usion coe ficien s espec i ely
and
D
is ime s ep. A cons an ypical alue o 1:010
3
m
2
=s
(Ellio e al., 2001) has been used o K
. I has been es ed ha
model esul s a e li le sensi i e o his pa ame e . Ac ually, mos
o he
129
I emains in he su ace laye , as has been ound in o he
modelling s udies (O e e al., 2009). The Smago insky’s scheme
(Cushman-Roisin and Becke s, 2011) has been adop ed o desc ibe
he ho izon al di usi i y.
Radioac i e decay can also be simula ed by a s ochas ic me hod
(Pe iáñez and Ellio , 2002), al hough his p ocess is neglec ed
gi en he e y long hal -li e o
129
I (1.6 10
7
yea s) in compa ison
wi h simula ed imes (47 yea s). Al hough adionuclide adso p-
ion/deso p ion eac ions be ween wa e and sedimen s can also
be simula ed using a s ochas ic me hod (Pe iáñez and Ellio ,
2002), hese p ocesses a e also neglec ed he e since iodine is con-
se a i e in seawa e , hus emaining in solu ion.
The conside ed domain in he no h A lan ic ex ends om 50°W
o 25°E in longi ude and om 45.1°N o 75.1°N in la i ude (Fig. 1).
Wa e ci cula ion o he pe iod o in e es has been ob ained om
JAMSTEC (Japan Agency o Ma ine-Ea h Science and Technology)
global ocean model. I is OFES (Ocean global ci cula ion model Fo
he Ea h Simula o ).
1
A compa ison o model pe o mance wi h
da a in se e al egions o he global ocean (including he No h
A lan ic) may be seen in Masumo o e al. (2004) Ho izon al esolu-
ion is 0.1°and he e a e 54 e ical le els, wi h inc easing hickness
om he su ace owa ds he sea bo om. Mon hly mean ci cula ion
has been used. As an example, he su ace wa e ci cula ion o Jan-
ua y 2008 is p esen ed in Fig. 2. The No wegian Coas al Cu en
(NCC), flowing along he No wegian coas o he no h, is clea ly
seen. The Eas G eenland Cu en (EGC) flows sou hwa ds along
he eas G eenland coas . Finally, he No h A lan ic Cu en (NAC),
de i ing om he Gul S eam, is appa en in he cen al A lan ic
wi h a numbe o eddies and meande s.
Annual
129
I eleases om Sellafield and La Hague, p esen ed in
Fig. 3, a e in oduced om 1966 o 2012, which is he simula ion
pe iod. These eleases define he numbe o Bq (o a oms) co e-
sponding o each eleased pa icle.
3. Resul s and discussion
Model esul s ha e been fi s compa ed wi h a ailable mea-
su emen s o es i s pe o mance. Michel e al. (2012) p esen a
map wi h
129
I concen a ions in he su ace wa e s o he No h
Sea and English Channel o samples collec ed in 2005 (Fig. 3 in
hei pape , which is ep oduced in Fig. 4). The au ho s do no gi e
he exac loca ion o sampling poin s. Thus, a de ailed compa ison
canno be done. Howe e , he o e all calcula ed dis ibu ion
Fig. 5. Calcula ed
129
I concen a ions (mBq/m
3
) in su ace wa e s (mean alue o e
a su ace laye wi h hickness 100 m) o he No h Sea o yea 2005.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
129I (mBq/m3)
129I (mBq/m3)
Sample numbe
Measu emen s
Calcula ions
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Sample numbe
Measu emen s
Calcula ions
Fig. 6. Calcula ed (o e a 100 m hick laye ) and measu ed
129
I concen a ions
(mBq/m
3
) in su ace wa e s a poin s indica ed in Fig. 1 o samples collec ed in
2010 and 2012 (1–18; op panel. F om Gómez-Guzman e al. (2013) and López-
Gu ié ez e al. (2013)) and 1999 (19–31; bo om panel. F om Alfimo e al. (2004)).
1
h p://www.jams ec.go.jp/esc/ esea ch/A mOcn/p oduc /o es.h ml#ci e_no e-1.
pa e n o
129
I is in ag eemen wi h obse a ions. This calcula ed
dis ibu ion is p esen ed in Fig. 5. Su ace concen a ions a e
calcula ed as he mean alue o e a 100 hick su ace laye . The
hickness o he su ace mixed laye in he ocean ypically anges
om 25 o 200 m (Picka d and Eme y, 1982). Thus, we p o ide
concen a ions in he su ace as an a e age o e a 100 m hick
laye , which may be ep esen a i e o he mean alue o he
su ace mixed laye hickness.
Concen a ions abou 500 mBq/m
3
a e ob ained in he English
Channel, in ag eemen wi h Michel e al. (2012). A s ong concen-
a ion g adien is appa en in Denma k, wi h quickly dec easing
concen a ions as mo ing o sho e in o he No h Sea. This e ec
is also ound in Michel e al. (2012), al hough calcula ed concen a-
ions a e sligh ly o e es ima ed by he model. A simila pa e n is
ob ained along he UK eas e n coas . Howe e , his canno be seen
in he measu emen s o Michel e al. (2012) because samples we e
no collec ed close o he coas , bu ens o km o sho e. Since con-
cen a ions dec ease e y as as mo ing o sho e, p obably hese
high concen a ions calcula ed by he model along he B i ish coas
canno be app ecia ed in Michel e al. (2012). In he cen al No h
Sea, measu ed concen a ions gene ally a e o he o de o
10
1
mBq=m
3
. Model calcula ions a e in ag eemen wi h his
(Fig. 5). Measu ed
129
I concen a ions wi hin he I ish Sea a e no
o ally ep oduced by he model, which mus be due o he ela-
i ely low esolu ion o JAMSTEC cu en s. Spa ial s uc u e o cu -
en s may no be adequa ely ep esen ed in semi-enclosed basins
wi h na ow connec ions wi h he open ocean. The same si ua ion
occu s in he Danish S ai s, as will be shown below. Ne e heless,
he ocus o his pape is he open A lan ic Ocean, no shel seas.
Mo eo e , he I ish Sea is e y sensi i e o he discha ge iming.
Thus, modelled and measu ed esul s can be e y di e en he e,
depending o he sampling da e. Also, i mus be conside ed ha
mean annual discha ges a e being used in he model, which a ec s
model accu acy in he nea field.
Wa e samples ha e also been collec ed a ound Iceland, in he
I minge Sea and in a ansec om Sco land o Iceland (Fig. 1)in
2010 (Gómez-Guzman e al., 2013) and 2012 (López-Gu ié ez
e al., 2013). A compa ison be ween measu ed and calcula ed
129
I
su ace concen a ions is p esen ed in Fig. 6. Gene ally speaking,
calcula ed concen a ions in he UK-Iceland ansec a e in good
ag eemen wi h obse a ions. The model unde es ima es concen-
a ions in some sampling poin s in he a ea o Iceland (poin s
13, 14 and 15). Salini y and empe a u e measu emen s indica e
ha No h A lan ic Wa e is p esen he e (Gómez-Guzman e al.,
2013). Thus, he o igin o his
129
I canno be a ibu ed o he
EGC, which e en ually could be anspo ing adionuclides om
he A c ic back o he A lan ic. Ins ead, some eddies o episodic
cu en s which a e no ep oduced by he mean mon hly wa e ci -
cula ion could be anspo ing pa ches o Sellafield eleases o his
a ea.
An o e es ima ion abou one o de o magni ude is appa en in
he I ish Sea sample, which may be due o easons men ioned
abo e. Howe e , model esul s ag ee wi h measu emen s in he
Cel ic Sea a ea.
Some p ofiles in he wa e column we e also measu ed in he
a ea o Iceland (Gómez-Guzman e al., 2013), showing dec easing
concen a ions wi h wa e dep h. The model does no calcula e sig-
nifican concen a ions down he wa e column. As commen ed
abo e, i has been ound in o he modelling s udies (O e e al.,
2009) ha mos o he
129
I eleased om Sellafield and La Hague
emains in he su ace laye . Thus,
129
I measu ed in deep wa e s
in he a ea o Iceland could be coming om he A c ic. The model
canno simula e his anspo om he A c ic back o he A lan ic
since he o me is no wi hin he conside ed domain ( he A c ic is
no included in JAMSTEC hyd odynamic calcula ions).
Samples we e also collec ed in a ansec om he No h A lan ic
o he Bal ic Sea in 1999 (Alfimo e al., 2004). A compa ison o
model esul s wi h measu emen s is also p esen ed in Fig. 6. The
model is o e es ima ing concen a ions in he Danish S ai s.
This may be due o he ela i ely coa se esolu ion o he model,
which does no ep oduce adequa ely he na ow s ai s and
passages in hese wa e s. This makes pa icles o emain apped
in he a ea. Ne e heless, he o e es ima ion is no la ge han a
ac o 5.
As an example, he calcula ed
129
I concen a ion in su ace
wa e o yea 2000 is p esen ed in Fig. 7. Radionuclides ollow
Fig. 7. Calcula ed
129
I concen a ions (mBq/m
3
) in su ace wa e s (100 m laye ) in yea 2000. The maximum o he colou scale has been se o 500 mBq/m
3
. (Fo
in e p e a ion o he e e ences o colou in his figu e legend, he eade is e e ed o he web e sion o his a icle.)

he well known anspo pa hways (O e e al., 2009; Po inec
e al., 2003). Thus, Sellafield eleases a el a ound Sco land and
en e he No h Sea. He e hey join La Hague eleases and hen
a el along No way coas wi h he NCC. Pa o he ac i i y p e-
iously en e s he Bal ic Sea. S ong g adien s a e ob ained ac oss
he NCC, which has al eady been ound in he case o
137
Cs, and is
also in ag eemen wi h p e ious
129
I simula ions (O e e al.,
2009). In addi ion, some o he Sellafield eleased adionuclides
a e anspo ed o he sou h, as has been ound o
137
Cs
(Po inec e al., 2003). Then pa o his ac i i y en e s he English
Channel and, om he e, he No h Sea.
A main con ibu ion o his wo k is o p o ide a quan i a i e
analysis on he a e o
129
I eleased om Sellafield and La Hague.
Fi s , he ac i i y in en o y in he A c ic Ocean has been e alua ed.
Pa icles in he A c ic a e defined as hose which lea e he model
h ough he no h and no h-eas open bounda ies. As commen ed
be o e, anspo o adionuclides back om he A c ic o he A lan-
ic canno be simula ed. Thus, esul s should be conside ed as an
uppe limi . Model esul s a e p esen ed in Figs. 8–10 o adionuc-
lides espec i ely eleased om Sellafield, La Hague, and conside -
ing bo h sou ces. No e ha , gi en he Lag angian na u e o he
model, di e en labels can be assigned o pa icles eleased om
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
2
4
6
8
10
12 x 1012
Bq
Ac i i y in A c ic Ocean
Cumula i e discha ge
In en o y in domain
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
% in he A c ic
Yea
Respec o cumula i e discha ge
Respec o in en o y in domain
Fig. 8. Top: o al in en o y o
129
I in he A c ic, Sellafield cumula i e discha ge and in en o y in he model domain o eleases om Sellafield. Bo om: ac ion o he A c ic
in en o y wi h espec o he cumula i e discha ge and o he in en o y in he domain.
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5 x 1013
Bq
Ac i i y in A c ic Ocean
Cumula i e discha ge
In en o y in domain
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
% in he A c ic
Yea
Respec o cumula i e discha ge
Respec o in en o y in domain
Fig. 9. Same as Fig. 8 bu o eleases om La Hague.
La Hague and Sellafield. Thus, a de ailed analysis may be ca ied
ou since he o igin o each pa icle in he compu a ional domain
is known.
Radionuclide in en o y in he A c ic inc eases mono onically
along he simula ion pe iod. Abou 48% o he o al eleases om
Sellafield a e wi hin he A c ic Ocean a he end o he simula ion
(2012). In he case o La Hague eleases his ac ion is sligh ly
highe (55%) since mos o he ac i i y is anspo ed o he eas ,
owa ds he No h Sea. Howe e , pa o Sellafield eleases a e
anspo ed sou h, o he Cel ic Sea. The e is a highe ac i i y inpu
o he A c ic Ocean han he ac i i y p esen wi hin he model
domain (abou 120%), as may be seen in Figs. 8–10. I can be con-
cluded ha 5.1 and 16.6 TBq o
129
I ha e been in oduced in he A c ic
om Sellafield and La Hague espec i ely un il 2012 (Figs. 8 and 9).
The o al supply o
129
I om bo h plan s o he A c ic in 1993 was
es ima ed o be P7 TBq (Ke shaw and Bax e , 1995). Bu his
figu e essen ially ep esen s 100% o he cumula i e discha ge o
ha ime, and seems o be la gely o e es ima ed. The calcula ed
in en o y in he A c ic o ha ime wi h he p esen model esul s
2.1 TBq (Fig. 10), which is 31% o he cumula i e discha ge om
bo h plan s un il hen. In he case o
90
S , which is also conse a i e
in seawa e , i was es ima ed ha 30% o he Sellafield elease was
anspo ed in o he Ba en s Sea (Ke shaw and Bax e , 1995).
In en o ies in he No h A lan ic, including shel seas (i.e., he
model domain), a e 4.4 and 13.8 TBq, coming om Sellafield and
La Hague espec i ely, in 2012 (Figs. 8 and 9).
The ac ions o adionuclides in di e en egions o he No h
A lan ic (wi h espec o he cumula i e discha ges) a e p esen ed
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
1
2
3
4
5x 1013
Bq
Ac i i y in A c ic Ocean
Cumula i e discha ge
In en o y in domain
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
% in he A c ic
Yea
Respec o cumula i e discha ge
Respec o in en o y in domain
Fig. 10. Same as Fig. 8 bu o eleases om Sellafield and La Hague oge he .
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
2
4
6
8
10
%
Cel ic Sea
English Channel
A lan ic
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
%
No way Sea
No h Sea
Bal ic Sea
Fig. 11. F ac ions o
129
I in se e al basins wi h espec o he cumula i e discha ge o eleases om Sellafield.
M. Villa e al. / Ma ine Pollu ion Bulle in 90 (2015) 15–24 21
in Figs. 11 and 12 o Sellafield and La Hague eleases espec i ely.
These egions a e indica ed in he map o Fig. 1. A ecen imes,
be ween 10% and 15% o he eleases a e p esen in he No h
Sea, Bal ic Sea and No way Sea, o bo h Sellafield and La Hague
eleases. In he case o La Hague, he in en o y in he English Chan-
nel is abou 3% o he discha ge, and in he Cel ic Sea and open
A lan ic i is negligible (Fig. 12). In he case o Sellafield, abou
2% o he discha ge is in he Cel ic Sea in 2012 and less han 1%
is p esen in bo h he English Channel and open A lan ic. This is
simila o p e ious esul s o
137
Cs: i has been ound (Po inec
e al., 2003) ha , on a e age, 1% o Sellafield eleases go h ough
he English Channel.
The model has been applied o calcula e he mean age o he
adioac i i y con en in he model domain. The concep o age is
widely used in ocean sciences o highligh he inhe en ime scales
o a sys em associa ed wi h he ad ec ion and di usion o ma e .
I has been used o wo main pu poses: o es ima e he en ila ion
a e o ocean basins and o in e ho izon al ci cula ion om ace
dispe sion. In he las case he age is defined as he ime elapsed
since a ace was eleased in he sea om a poin sou ce. As
desc ibed in de ail by Delee snijde e al. (2001), he age is a
Lag angian concep : one jus needs o a ach a ‘‘clock’’ o each pa -
icle. In ou case, he clock is ini ialized when he pa icle is
eleased om Sellafield o La Hague plan s. A he end o he sim-
ula ion, he ages indica ed by he clocks a ached o he pa icles in
he ocean a e ead. The ‘‘age-a e aging hypo hesis’’ (Delee snijde
e al., 2001) is applied o e alua e he mean age, which eads ha
he mean age o a se o pa icles (in ou case, pa icles which a e
wi hin each g id cell) is defined as he mass-weigh ed a i hme ic
a e age o he ages o he pa icles conside ed. The mass o each
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
%
Cel ic Sea
English Channel
A lan ic
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
%
No way Sea
No h Sea
Bal ic Sea
Fig. 12. F ac ions o
129
I in se e al basins wi h espec o he cumula i e discha ge o eleases om La Hague.
Fig. 13. Calcula ed
129
I mean ages (yea s) o e he model domain.
pa icle co esponds o i s adioac i i y con en in he p esen
applica ion. I mus be poin ed ou ha age is a di e en concep
om ansi ime, which a e well defined o his a ea [ o ins ance
in Po inec e al., 2003)] and a e no calcula ed again in his wo k.
Calcula ed mean ages o e he model domain a e p esen ed in
Fig. 13. Ob iously, ace age inc eases wi h inc easing dis ance
om he sou ce (Sellafield and La Hague). Mean age o ace s in
he No h Sea is abou 5 yea s, while i is la ge in he Cel ic Sea
(app oaching o some 10 yea s in he sou h). Mean age in he Bal ic
is significan ly longe (mo e han 20 yea s). This is due o he ac
ha pa icles, once hey en e he Bal ic, emain he e o a signi -
ican ime due o he limi ed wa e exchange wi h he No h Sea.
Ac ually, esidence imes es ima ed o he Bal ic ange om 11
o 30 yea s (Leppa an a and My be g, 2009). Mean age inc eases
along he NCC, eaching mo e han 10 yea s in he a ea o No h
Cape. In he open A lan ic Ocean, ace ages a e o he o de o
20 yea s.
Gi en he Lag angian na u e in he model, he o igin o each
pa icle is known. Thus, mean ages o eleases coming om
Sellafield and La Hague can be calcula ed sepa a ely. These a e
shown in Fig. 14. These pic u es a e also use ul o see in de ail
he di e en a es o Sellafield and La Hague eleases, al eady
ou lined in Fig. 7. The las s ollow a e y s aigh pa h owa ds
he NCC, al hough some is los in o he Bal ic Sea. Some o he
Sellafield eleases en e he No h Sea om he English Channel
and some om he no h (a ound Sco land). These wo ac ions
con ibu e di e en ly o he mean ages o Sellafield eleases in
he No h Sea. Pa icles coming om he English Channel ha e
mean ages a ound 8 yea s, while pa icles coming om Sco land
ha e mean ages abou 2 yea s. As a esul o he mixing o hese
wo ac ions o pa icles, mean ages in he sou he n NCC (a
60°N la i ude) is abou 9 yea s. On he o he hand, mean age in his
a ea o pa icles coming om La Hague is abou 5.5 yea s.
Consequen ly, mean ages o Sellafield eleases a e abou 3.5 yea s
Fig. 14. Calcula ed
129
I mean ages (yea s) o e he model domain. Top: Sellafield eleases. Bo om: La Hague eleases.