Chap e 7
Ci cula Ma e ial Usage
S a egies—P inciples
Paulo San os ,AimeeBy ne , Fe ha Ka aca , Paola Villo ia ,
Me cedes del Rio , Rocío Pineda-Ma os ,
and Genesis Camila Ce an es Puma
Abs ac The cons uc ion indus y signi ican ly con ibu es o global g eenhouse
gas emissions, aw ma e ial ex ac ion, and was e p oduc ion. Implemen ing ci cula
economy (CE) p inciples in his sec o could g ea ly educe hese impac s. Howe e ,
adop ion wi hin he indus y emains slow due o ba ie s such as limi ed knowledge
and expe ience. This chap e aims o assess and help o e come hese obs acles by
p o iding a comp ehensi e analysis o ci cula ma e ial usage p inciples and s a e-
giesincons uc ion.I alsohighligh soppo uni iesandenable so change,including
inno a ions and eme ging echnologies in ecycling, digi iza ion, obo ic sys ems,
new ma e ials, and p ocessing echniques. Fou case s udies illus a e he applica ion
o ci cula heo y h ough a Bio-Building, U ban Mining and Recycling (UMAR)
Expe imen al Uni , Open-spaced apa men , and an “Escuela Poli écnica Supe io ”.
The conclusions emphasize he need o s ong egula o y amewo ks, awa eness
ini ia i es, and in e na ional coope a ion. In eg a ing echnological ad ancemen s
P. San os (B
)
Ci il Enginee ing Depa men , ISISE, ARISE, Uni e si y o Coimb a, Coimb a, Po ugal
e-mail: [email p o ec ed]
A. By ne
O ice o he Vice P esiden o Sus ainabili y, Technological Uni e si y Dublin, G angego man,
I eland
P. Villo ia ·M. del Rio
Escuela Técnica Supe io de Edi icación, Uni e sidad Poli écnica de Mad id, Mad id, Spain
F. Ka aca
Depa men o Ci il and En i onmen al Enginee ing, School o Enginee ing and Digi al Sciences,
Naza baye Uni e si y, As ana, Kazakhs an
R. Pineda-Ma os
Depa amen o de Ingenie ía Ae oespacial y Mecánica de Fluidos, Escuela Técnica Supe io de
Ingenie ía Ag onómica, Uni e sidad de Se illa, Se illa, Spain
G. C. Ce an es Puma
ISISE, ARISE, Depa men o Ci il Enginee ing, Uni e si y o Minho, 4804-533 Guima ães,
Po ugal
© The Au ho (s) 2025
L. B agança e al. (eds.), Ci cula Economy Design and Managemen
in he Buil En i onmen , Sp inge T ac s in Ci il Enginee ing,
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-031-73490-8_7
175
176 P. San os e al.
like AI, obo ics, and blockchain is c ucial o op imizing was e managemen . Addi-
ionally, educa ion on ci cula p ac ices is i al. By os e ing global collabo a ion,
s anda dizing ci cula cons uc ion app oaches can lead o a mo e sus ainable and
esilien building indus y.
Keywo ds Ci cula economy ·Buildings ·Ci cula ma e ials ·S a egies ·
P inciples ·O e iew
One o he main was e lows in he Eu opean Union (EU) is cons uc ion and demo-
li ion was e (CDW), ep esen ing in 2018 a ound 36% o o al was e gene a ed [1].
Besides soils, conc e e, b icks, gypsum, wood, glass, me als, plas ic and sol en s a e
he mos o en CDW ound in he EU-27 coun ies [2], exhibi ing no only a high
esou ce alue, bu also a high po en ial o e-use and ecycling [1]. E en wi h high
inancial penal ies, illegal ly- ipping o CDW con inues o ake place (Fig. 7.1). In
his con ex , he EU has made he managemen o CDW a p io i y [3] and he Was e
F amewo k Di ec i e (WFD) 2008/98/EC [4] imposed a manda o y eco e y a ge
(70% eco e y a e o CDW in weigh by 2020). Included in hese eco e y ac i i ies
a e “ he p epa a ion o non-haza dous CDW o e-use, ecycling and o he ma e ial
eco e y, including back illing ope a ions” [1].
This chap e p esen s an upda ed e iew o ci cula ma e ial usage p inciples and
s a egies wi hin he cons uc ion sec o . Fi s , some basic concep s abou ci cula
economy and ma e ial usage a e p esen ed as an in oduc o y amewo k. Nex ,
he main p inciples o ci cula ma e ial usage a he design s age a e desc ibed.
A e , he ci cula ma e ial usage s a egies and p inciples in cons uc ion ac i i ies
a e p esen ed, including: ex ending li espan and end-o -li e s a egies, collabo a-
i e app oaches and business models, echnological inno a ions, main ba ie s and
enable s o ci cula ma e ial usage. Finally, o conclude his subsec ion, some bes
Fig. 7.1 Cons uc ion and
demo ion was e illegally
disca ded in he middle o a
o es
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 177
p ac ices ela ed o he p e ious heo e ical concep s abou ci cula ma e ial usage
in he building indus y, a e illus a ed using some selec ed case s udies.
7.1 Unde s anding Ci cula Economy and Ma e ial Usage
Sec ion
The ci cula economy (CE) is a model o p oduc ion and consump ion which ocuses
on e aining exis ing ma e ials and p oduc s as long as possible and educing was e
[5]. Ci cula i y aims o mo e away om he adi ional linea model o ‘ ake-make-
dispose’ whe e ma e ials a e ex ac ed, manu ac u ed in o p oduc s, and ul ima ely
disposed o . Ins ead, i ocuses on c ea ing a closed-loop sys em whe e ma e ials
a e con inuously eused, ecycled, o egene a ed o minimize he need o new
esou ces and educe he en i onmen al impac . In he buil en i onmen , he e is no
clea and accep ed de ini ion o a CE [6]. Howe e , a ci cula buil en i onmen can
be a sus ainable app oach which ca e s o he g owing needs o he sec o wi hou
causing addi ional de imen al impac s on he en i onmen .
The EU has ag eed o educe g eenhouse gas emissions by 55% by 2030 (o 1990
le els) and o become ca bon neu al by 2050 [7]. Al hough igu es luc ua e yea on
yea , he Ci cula Economy Ac ion Plan [8] a ibu es 50% o ex ac ed ma e ial and
35% o he EU’s was e gene a ion o cons uc ion. The sec o accoun s o 5–12%
o o al g eenhouse gas emissions h ough ma e ial ex ac ion, cons uc ion p oduc
manu ac u e, and building wo k. This includes cemen , aluminium, s eel, b ick and
glass p oduc ion which accoun o app oxima ely 9% o global ene gy ela ed CO2
emissions [9]. Con ounding his issue, 10–15% o building ma e ial is was ed du ing
cons uc ion and he majo i y o demoli ion was e is cu en ly land illed in he EU
[10]. Na ional cons uc ion and demoli ion was e (CDW) ecycling a es a y g ea ly
ac oss Eu ope, om 10 o 90% [11]. A CE has he po en ial o educe global CO2
emissions om building ma e ials by 38% by 2050 [12,13].
Acco ding o he Ellen MacA hu Founda ion [14] he h ee p inciples o a CE
a e: he elimina ion o was e and pollu ion, he use o ci cula p oduc s and ma e ials
and hi dly, he egene a ion o na u e. Wi hin hese p inciples, he e a e se e al
subca ego ies and concep s which will be discussed below.
7.1.1 Elimina ing Was e and Pollu ion
The i s p inciple aims o mo e away om a linea sys em whe eby aw ma e-
ials a e ex ac ed, consumed and e en ually h own la gely in o land ills and incin-
e a o s. In ci cula design, aw ma e ials use is minimized, and ma e ials can be
designed o emain in use o mul iple cycles by ollowing he R p inciples. The e
a e many e sions o he R p inciples o a CE which a e based on he o iginal 3;
178 P. San os e al.
Fig. 7.2 Ci cula i y hie a chy o p inciples in he p oduc chain wi h examples om cons uc ion.
Based on a able by Po ing e al. [19]
Reduce, Reuse, and Recycle. This can hen be subdi ided mul iple imes o make
o up o 14 and e en 22 Rs [15,16]. Reike e al. [17] iden i ied 38 “ e-” wo ds, as
lis ed nex by alphabe ic o de : “ e-assembly, ecap u e, econdi ioning, ecollec ,
eco e , ec ea e, ec i y, ecycle, edesign, edis ibu e, educe, e-en ision, e i ,
e u bish, e use, ema ke , emanu ac u e, eno a e, epai , eplacemen , ep ocess,
ep oduce, epu pose, esale, esell, e-se ice, es o a ion, esyn hesize, e hink,
e ie e, e o i , e og ade, e u n, euse, eu ilize, e enue, e e se and e i alize”.
Ten o he mos common include: Re use/Rejec , Re hink, Reduce, Reuse, Repai ,
Re u bish,Remanu ac u e,Repu pose,RecycleandReco e .Figu e7.2indica es he
hie a chy o hese, p io i ized om 1 o 10 based on maximizing esou ce e iciency,
minimizing was e gene a ion, and highes alue c ea ion and e en ion. Recycling
and eco e y a e anked lowes because o he loss o complex s a e and he need o
highe ene gy inpu s [18].
7.1.2 Use o Ci cula P oduc s and Ma e ials
Ci cula Ma e ials used wi hin cons uc ion can be la gely di ided in o wo g oups;
low o ze o-ca bon ma e ials such as wood and eused o eco e ed ma e ials wi h
minimal ep ocessing o anspo - ela ed emissions [20]. The echnical cycle and
he biological cycle suppo ci cula ma e ial use and a e illus a ed in Fig. 7.3.
The echnical cycle on he igh in ol es ma e ials such as me als, conc e e, plas-
ics, glass, o syn he ic composi es in building p oduc s. A he end o a s uc u e’s
li e, o cons uc ion p oduc s’ li e, hese ma e ials a e eco e ed om he demoli-
ion o decons uc ion p ocess, so ed and p ocessed be o e being ep ocessed o
eused in cons uc ion o o he applica ions. The inne loops in he Fig. 7.3 bu e ly
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 179
Fig. 7.3 Ci cula economy bu e ly diag am in e p e ed o he cons uc ion indus y by O enhaus
[22]
diag am applied o he cons uc ion indus y, e ain mos alue in he ma e ial o
p oduc . This is based on he mo e gene al ci cula economy bu e ly diag am [21],
in which he inne mos loop, ‘Main enance’, p olongs he li e o he ma e ial o
p oduc . This is ollowed by ‘Reusing’ and ‘Redis ibu ing’ which keeps ma e ials
in hei o iginal o m and displaces he need o manu ac u e new i ems o ex ac new
ma e ials. ‘Re u bishing’ and ‘Remanu ac u ing’ hen include some p ocessing and
he ou mos loop, ‘Recycling’, is a las eso when o he op ions a e no possible.
The biological cycle, o bio-loop, only includes ma e ials ha can be sa ely egen-
e a edin he biosphe e ia compos ing o anae obic diges ion suchas imbe , bamboo
o s aw. Ma e ials om he echnical cycle can end up in he biological cycle, once
hey can no longe make a p oduc . The inne loops o he le side o he bu e ly
diag am shows he ‘cascading p inciple’ which is he cascading use o enewable
esou ces, wi h se e al euse and ecycling cycles [23]. Fo he cons uc ion indus y,
hisismos applicable o imbe ,whichcouldbegini s i s p oduc li eassolid imbe
beams and end i s i h li e being incine a ed o ene gy eco e y [24]. Cascading
ensu es ha biogenic ca bon emains in he sys em o a longe pe iod o ime,
esul ing in lowe en i onmen al bu dens and can suppo o he indus ies such as
a ming ia eeds ock o soil e ilize [25].
180 P. San os e al.
7.1.3 Regene a e Na u e
Ci cula cons uc ion can con ibu e o he egene a ion o na u e by inco po a ing
s a egies ha suppo ecological es o a ion, biodi e si y enhancemen , and sus ain-
able land managemen p ac ices. The a o emen ioned biological cycle con ibu es
o biodi e si y and ecosys em heal h by p omo ing he use o enewable ma e ials
ha can be eg own and eplenished. Main aining ma e ials in use also con ibu es o
his p inciple as less land is equi ed o sou cing i gin aw ma e ials, which allows
mo e land o be e u ned o na u e.
While ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials hold g ea po en ial o sus ainable and
esou ce-e icien building p ac ices, he e a e se e al challenges ha need o be
add essed o acili a e widesp ead adop ion. The de ails o he challenges aced can
be speci ic o each s akeholde ’s ole. Howe e , hey can be b oadly g ouped as
economic, in o ma ional, ins i u ional, poli ical and echnical challenges [26] wi h
commonly encoun e ed subca ego ies lis ed in Table 7.1.
A key challenge in he sec o is he olume o exis ing buildings no designed
o decons uc ion, con aining oxic ma e ials, and lacking de ailed documen a ion
[28]. Reused ma e ials equi e addi ional ime and mo e quali ied labou , and he e
is a lack o ma ke mechanisms o aid eco e y [6]. A sys em needs o be de eloped
Table 7.1 Challenge a eas o a ci cula buil en i onmen compiled om e iew a icles [6,26,
27]
Challenge subca ego ies Challenge
Economic – Lack o g an s/unclea inancial case
– Lack o inancial aid, incen i es o sho - e m bene i s
– Low alue o ci cula ma e ials
– Cos o up on in es men
In o ma ional – Lack o esea ch, educa ion and in o ma ion
– Lack o awa eness, in e es and knowledge
– Lack o bes p ac ice case s udies and leade ship
Ins i u ional/s uc u al – Lack o s a egic ision and collabo a i e pla o ms
– F agmen ed supply chains
– Lack o ma ke mechanisms o eco e y
Poli ical – Lack o egula o y ins umen s/ egula o y p essu e
– Lack o ax ac ions
– Lack o ci cula ision
Technological – Lack o in eg a ed p ocesses, ools, and p ac ices
– Lack o an in o ma ion managemen sys em
– Complexi y o buildings
– Technology and in as uc u e eadiness
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 181
which suppo s he use o ci cula ma e ials which includes quali y assu ance, s an-
da diza ion, ce i ica ion and classi ica ion, mechanisms o anspo and s o age
and access o he ma ke [26,29].
Finances, o lack o inancial case, we e iden i ied as a leading ba ie o s ake-
holde s [6,10,27]. Fo ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials, his includes he high a ail-
abili y and low cos [27] o i gin aw ma e ial, he cos o decons uc ion, he wo k
in ol ed in p o iding he ma e ial o euse, he cos o ecycled/ eused ma e ials,
and he lack o ewa d o penal y [26].
Ins i u ional o in o ma ional challenges include he lack o guidance and ools,
and lack o knowledge [26]. S akeholde s h oughou cons uc ion alue chains in
Eu ope a e un amilia wi h how CE p inciples do o could ope a e in he buil en i-
onmen , wi h many unable o iden i y i s s eps in ini ia ing he ansi ion o a CE
[10].
Add essing hese challenges equi es collabo a i e e o s om a ious s ake-
holde s, including policymake s, indus y p o essionals, esea che s, and end use s.
O e coming hese ba ie s will pa e he way o a mo e widesp ead adop ion o
ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials, howe e he e is a need ini ially o p o ide e idence,
compile bes p ac ice examples and de elop guidance.
7.2 Design P inciples o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage
7.2.1 Designing o Ci cula i y
The e a e se e al p inciples wi hin he design s age o p omo e ci cula i y in building
cons uc ions. These p inciples can be clus e ed in o he ollowing poin s [30,31]:
– Design s anda dized p oduc s and ma e ials, using egula and simple modula
shapes o a oid was e.
– Design o dec ease he need o ex ac and p oduce i gin ma e ials.
– Design using eco e ed ma e ials: by de ec ing unused ma e ials om echnical o
na u al lows and ans o ming hem in o ci cula ma e ials which can be inco po-
a ed wi hin he p oduc ion o new ma e ials and p oduc s, p omo ing he design
o ma e ials wi h high ecycled con en .
– Design du able ma e ials so ha hey can p olong hei use in he building and
he e o e inc ease li e ime and delay he end-o -use cycle.
– Design conside ing he se ing p ocedu e o he ma e ials, so ha he ma e ials can
be easily disassembled: Ma e ials should be designed hinking ha , when placed
in a cons uc ion p ojec , hey should allow decons uc ion and p omo e euse and
ecycling. Fo example, using mechanical join s o a oid he use o binde s and
adhesi es.
182 P. San os e al.
7.2.2 Ma e ial Selec ion and Managemen
The cons uc ion sec o , in pa icula , plays a pi o al ole in ansi ioning owa ds a
less esou ce-in ensi e economy by maximizing he use and eco e y o esou ces
in building design and cons uc ion. Sus ainable ma e ial sou cing and e icien
ecycling echniques a e c ucial o achie ing a ci cula economy.
1. C i e ia o Selec ing Ci cula Ma e ials
The EU emphasizes he signi icance o applying ci cula economy (CE) p inciples
ac ossall economic sec o s, wi h a pa icula ocuson wa e and ene gyconse a ion,
was e p e en ion, ma e ial ecycling, p omo ion o euse and epai , and u iliza ion
o seconda y aw ma e ials [32].
CE in he cons uc ion sec o aims o maximize he use and eco e y o esou ces
and buildings, educing he en i onmen al impac . Thus, i is o impo ance ha
designs aim o ex end he use ul li e o buildings h ough ehabili a ion, using ecy-
clable ma e ials; and he usage o new indus ialized long-li e ma e ials based on
eco e ed and alued esou ces. Addi ionally, adop ing new indus ialized long-li e
ma e ials de i ed om eco e ed and alued esou ces can con ibu e o sus ainable
p ac ices [33]. By implemen ing hese ecommenda ions, he cons uc ion sec o can
play a pi o al ole in ansi ioning owa ds a less esou ce-in ensi e economy and
os e ing ci cula i y. This app oach aligns wi h he b oade objec i es o he CE,
such as educing was e gene a ion, conse ing esou ces, and p omo ing sus ainable
ma e ial use.
2. Sus ainable Ma e ial Sou cing
Rega ding he a ailabili y o aw ma e ials, c i ical aw ma e ials a e o pa icula
impo ance as hei g ea economic impo ance o he Eu opean Union (EU); e y
sensi i e o supply in e up ion; and being hei ex ac ion o a signi ican impac on
he en i onmen . C i ical aw ma e ials—e.g., li hium, a e o en p esen in elec onic
de ices. The cu en low ecycling a e o hese ma e ials means ha signi ican
economic oppo uni ies a e being los . Thus, he undamen al di ec ions ha he
ci cula i y s a egy mus ake a he Eu opean le el a e hose ha conside he need o
inco po a e hese ma e ials in o educ ion, euse and ecycling p ac ices. To achie e
au onomywi h espec o hesema e ials, heEUp oposes di e si iedand undis o ed
access o global aw ma e ials ma ke s, while seeking o educe ex e nal dependence
on hese ma e ials as well as he en i onmen al p essu es associa ed wi h hei impo
[32].
3. Ma e ial E iciency and Recycling Techniques
TheEUinsis son heimpo anceo incen i es o headop iono e iciencymeasu es
in he use o esou ces and o inc easing ecycling, eco-inno a i e pe o mance,
and in es men s in g een p oduc s and se ices [32]. To mo e owa ds an economic
model o ma e ial e iciency, economic p io i ies and li es yles mus be in line wi h
educing excessi e economic ma e ial dependence by applying he p inciples o
ci cula i y—i.e., educe and euse be o e ecycling [32]. Fundamen al aspec s o CE
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 183
Fig. 7.4 Impo an ecycle
poin s (Sou ce au ho s, based
on Si uación y e olución de
la economía ci cula en by
Mo a ó e al. [32])
ela ed o ecycling a e: (i) design o ien ed owa ds economy o ma e ials and ene gy,
use o ecyclable and enewable ma e ials, and easy disassembly and eplacemen o
ma e ials and componen s; and, (ii) ecycling and eco e y o non- eusable ma e ials
[33].
Was e p e en ion con inues o pose a majo challenge in all Membe S a es o
he EU, including hose wi h high ecycling a es [32]. The use o ecycled ma e ials
can con ibu e o pa ially co e ing he o al demand o ma e ials, hus educing he
ex ac ion o aw ma e ials. C ea ing e icien seconda y ma e ials ma ke s enables
highe alue ecycling cycles since mos ma e ials a e ecycled a e disassembly.
The p inciples a e ou lined in Fig. 7.4.
4. Li ecycle Assessmen and Ma e ial Managemen
P oduc ion sys ems conce ning e icien use o ma e ials—gi en p io i y o ac i i-
ies allowing he de elopmen o CE p inciples om he beginning o he p oduc ion
p ocess phases, and no only in i s inal dimensions; i.e., ecycling and econ e -
sion o was e—would se e as ecommenda ions aimed a he change o economic
models and he ansi ion owa ds a less esou ce-in ensi e economy. E icien use
o ma e ials in p oduc ion sys ems is a c i ical aspec o he CE. I is essen ial o
p io i ize ac i i ies ha p omo e CE p inciples om he beginning o he p oduc ion
p ocess phases, a he han only ocusing on ecycling and econ e sion o was e in
i s inal dimensions.
190 P. San os e al.
7.3.2 Collabo a i e App oaches and Business Models
In his sec ion, some o he inno a ions in business models ha a e a ec ing he
cons uc ion sec o in a ou o CE applied o i s p oduc s a e collec ed.
1. Ci cula Supply Chains and Ne wo ks
Cu en ly, he con e sion o adi ional linea supply chains in o ci cula ones o
imp o e he managemen o na u al esou ces and educe he olume o was e
p oduced is included as one o he goals o he ansi ion o he cons uc ion sec o
owa ds CE [82]. The amoun o ma e ial los in demoli ion p ocesses is equi alen o
40% o he o al mass o aw ma e ials ex ac ed in p oduc ion, making he cons uc-
ion indus y one o he mos pollu ing indus ies globally [9]. In his sense, one o
he mos ambi ious a ge s included in CE is “closing he loop” in he lows o aw
ma e ials and esou ces used h oughou he li e cycle o cons uc ion p oduc s [42,
49,83]. Figu e 7.7 p o ides a schema ic o e iew o he ela ionship be ween he
s ages wi hin he supply chain and he s akeholde s.
In his gene al o e iew, a ansi ion owa ds CE in he building ma e ials supply
chain equi es a join e o o all pa icipan s included in he ne wo k [84]. The e-
o e, i is necessa y o inc ease anspa ency, a oiding possible weaknesses in he
chain and gaps in he ag eemen s. This would gene a e oppo uni ies o indus-
ial symbiosis and he in eg a ion o e e se logis ics in manu ac u ing p ocesses,
mo ing owa ds a edesign o cu en indus ial p ocesses and imp o ing coo dina-
ion be ween esou ces/in en o ies [49]. On he o he hand, he c ea ion o a well-
de ined ma ke o CDW would make i possible o inc ease consume demand o
hese ecycledp oduc s, mo ing owa dsag eensupplychain ha in eg a es he en i-
onmen al cos s de i ed om he p oduc dis ibu ion p ocess [26]. In addi ion, o a
ansi ion owa ds ci cula i y in he cons uc ion sec o , i is necessa y o eco e he
seconda y aw ma e ials gene a ed in demolished buildings a he end o hei use ul
li e and, in u n, o analyse hei iabili y o ecycling, eco e y o einco po a ion
Fig. 7.7 Fullsupplychaincycleands akeholde sin ol ed(Sou ce ownelabo a ionbasedon Cheng
e al. [82])
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 191
in he p oduc ion o new p oduc s [85]. A his poin , se e al au ho s ag ee on he
impo ance o educing and sepa a ing CDW a sou ce o imp o e i s managemen
p ocess [86]. Wi h his sepa a ion a he s a ing poin , he logis ical cos s and en i-
onmen al impac in e ms o CO2equi alen emissions de i ed om anspo o he
p ocessing plan would be educed, so ha bo h anspo jou neys and anspo ed
mass would be educed.
2. Sha ing Economy and P oduc -as-a-Se ice Models
Indus ial s a egies o alue c ea ion ha e changed adically in ecen yea s as a
consequence o globalisa ion and p og essi e echnological de elopmen [87]. This
e olu ion has a ec ed he cons uc ion indus y, which is e ol ing om p oduc
p ocu emen -cen ed hinking owa ds p oduc -se ice sys ems (PSS) [88]. In his
way, building p oduc manu ac u e s a e o ced o edesign hei manu ac u ing
p ocesses and complexi y inc eases in he ea ly s ages o de elopmen o accom-
moda e his new business model [89]. By o e ing p oduc -associa ed unc ionali y,
manu ac u e s a e obliged o ha e a deep unde s anding o how hei p oduc s beha e
a e con inuous use, which p o ides addi ional mo i a ion o imp o e he skills
associa ed wi h he enginee ing and p oduc design s ages h ough expe ience [90].
Howe e , as in o he indus ial sec o s, he e mus be a ecep i eness on he pa
o consume s when i comes o accep ing his p oduc and se ice model. In his
ega d, Fig. 7.8 schema ically shows he ex e nal and in e nal ac o s ound in he
li e a u e ha o a ce ain ex en condi ion he accep ance o his business model in
cons uc ion.
Se e al au ho s ha e wo ked wi h his business model ying o adap di e en
p oduc s o his “se i isa ion” p ocess. Examples a e linked o cons uc ion equip-
men [87], cons uc ion machine y [90], p e ab ica ed building componen s [91]
o building componen s [92]. Impo an ly, he p oduc -as-a-se ice model b ings
Fig. 7.8 In e nalandex e nalde e minan so p oduc -as-a-se icemodels(Sou ce ownelabo a ion
based on Cook e al. [89])
192 P. San os e al.
ad an ages om an en i onmen al poin o iew, conside ing he ull li e cycle o
he p oduc and i s subsequen eco e y possibili ies [93], as well as con inuous
imp o emen based on in o ma ion sha ing ha boos s he sus ainabili y o building
p oduc s [88].
Finally, and in ela ion o he p oduc -as-a-se ice business model, i is wo h
highligh ing how in ecen decades he collabo a i e economy has been encou aged
o p omo e sus ainabili y. This concep add esses he possibili y o using high-p iced
physical asse s wi hou he need o buy hem, educing was e due o obsolescence
o disuse [91]. Fu he mo e, hanks o he ad ancemen o in o ma ion and commu-
nica ion echnologies, i is possible o p omo e a mo e democ a ic o ganiza ion and
educe in o ma ion asymme ies in a ou o a CE in cons uc ion [94].
3. Ex ended P oduc Responsibili y
Ex ended p oduc esponsibili y (EPR) was i s de ined a he beginning o he
cen u y by Lindhq is as a s a egy o p o ec he en i onmen and is in ended o
ensu e ha any p oduc manu ac u e akes esponsibili y o i s en i e li e cycle,
inco po a ing he s ages o eco e y, ecycling, collec ion and disposal [95]. This
app oach would change he cu en p oduc ion model a ec ing he cons uc ion
indus y by egula izing and se ing he ules o he p ope managemen o cons uc-
ion and demoli ion was e in line wi h he Eu opean G een Deal guidelines [1]. This
app oachisal eadybeingadap ed o ce ainp oduc sa ound hewo ld,suchasEu o-
pean legisla ion o plas ic p oduc s [96], o ai condi ione s and washing machines
in Japan [97].
Howe e , inal cons uc ion p oduc s, unde s ood as ci il in as uc u es o build-
ings, a e complex and ailo -made en i ies in each design, which makes i di icul
o s anda dize and ace he p o o ypes p oduced o he ma ke [98]. In his sense,
i is possible o hink o an EPR localized o he main aw ma e ials used in he
elabo a ion o cons uc ion sys ems. Howe e , he use ul li e o hese is a ely less
han 50 yea s and i is di icul o manage he inal managemen o hese p oduc s
[98].
The e o e,as a as EPR isconce ned,i isnecessa y o examinecu en ini ia i es,
egula ions and p ac ices in he cons uc ion sec o o unde s and hei sui abili y and
abili y o add ess he issue o end-o -li e managemen o CDW [99]. Only in his way,
i will be possible o build a legisla i e amewo k o building and ci il wo ks, buil
on he “pollu e pays” p inciple, encou aging p oduce s o inco po a e CE c i e ia in
hei manu ac u ing p ocesses, p omo ing eco-design and suppo ing he ecycling,
eco e y and inal euse o cons uc ion p oduc s [100,101].
4. Public–P i a e Pa ne ships and Policy Implica ions
Public–p i a e pa ne ships (PPPs) a e a use ul ool in he cons uc ion sec o o
le e age public esou ces and p i a e managemen expe ise in mo ing owa ds a
ci cula and sus ainable economy [102]. These pa ne ships a e es ablished based
on a long- e m ela ionship o us , whe e esou ces, knowledge, skills and sha ed
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 193
Table 7.3 Ad an ages and disad an ages o public–p i a e pa ne ships in he cons uc ion sec o
(Sou ce Bao e al. [109])
Ad an ages Disad an ages
✓Public sec o s can alle ia e esponsibili y ✓Long nego ia ion pe iods
✓P i a e sec o s can mode a e in es men ✓Lack o lexibili y
✓Public sec o s can d aw on p i a e sec o expe ise ✓Inequali y o isk and e u n
✓Public–p i a e pa ne ship is s eng hened in he long
e m
✓Lack o anspa ency in Ag eemen s
esponsibili y o decision-making a e exchanged [103,104]. Howe e , hese pa -
ne ships a e no always a ou able and ha e se e al ad an ages and disad an ages
ha can be seen in Table 7.3.
While i is ue ha PPPs a e commonly accep ed in he de elopmen o acili ies,
including design, inancing and implemen a ion [105], such as he supply o d inking
wa e in la ge ci ies [106], in was e managemen o a CE he e is s ill a long way
o go. In he EU, p og ess is being made owa ds a policy amewo k o p omo e
such an ag eemen o educe he en i onmen al impac o he cons uc ion sec o
[107]. Howe e , his ansi ion is slow and o en no as e icien as desi ed and
making in as uc u e esilien will equi e a change o mindse on he pa o p i a e
managemen and las ing suppo om go e nmen s [108].
7.3.3 Technological Inno a ions o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage
CE cons i u es an impulse o imp o ing he p oduc i i y o he cons uc ion sec o
wi h a need o in es men in echnology and digi alisa ion. Acco ding o Fe e
e al. [33], he scale and e iciency o ne wo ks o ecycled, alued and eco e ed
cons uc ion ma e ials a e undamen al o he ollowing poin s ou lined in Fig. 7.9.
Inno a ion ecosys ems o boos e-indus ializa ion and sus ainabili y in he
cons uc ion sec o ad oca e he p omo ion and suppo o R +D+I (Resea ch,
De elopmen and Inno a ion) and knowledge ans e ins umen s on: echnologies
4.0; ecycling and eco e y o ma e ials and componen s which a e mo e complex
o ecycle (plas ics, composi es, was e); p oduc i i y imp o emen s in componen
manu ac u ing and eco e y (3D, obo ics, A i icial In elligence (AI), In e ne o
Things (IoT); new long-las ing ma e ials; and ma e ials aceabili y echnologies
(blockchain) [33].
1. Ad anced Recycling Technologies
Resou ce eco e y as business model and d i e o CE ocuses p ima ily on eco e y
o used ma e ials o ene gy om was e—e.g., ecycled s eel and ib es, and ecycled
agg ega es o hei use in cons uc ion o in o he sec o s; being indus ial and
194 P. San os e al.
Fig. 7.9 Fundamen als in ci cula ma e ial usage (Sou ce own elabo a ion based on Fe e e al.
[33])
ene gy symbiosis among complemen a y sec o s essen ial o he adop ion o he CE
p inciples [33].
In he con ex o cons uc ion, disassembly and ecycling bes p ac ices a e
employed o e alue he use o cons uc ion was e, which is o en conside ed “low
alue” ma e ial. Tes ing me hods o disassembly, ea men , and ecycling would
help o op imize he eco e y and euse o ma e ials, con ibu ing o he e icien
use o esou ces in he p oduc ion p ocess [33]. By implemen ing hese ad anced
ecycling echnologies, he cons uc ion indus y can educe was e, minimize he
ex ac ion o i gin esou ces, and p omo e a mo e sus ainable app oach o ma e ials
managemen . Fu he mo e, hese echnologies enable he ans o ma ion o was e
in o aluable esou ces, p omo ing he de elopmen o a CE. Recycled s eel, ib es,
and agg ega es can be u ilized in a ious sec o s, including cons uc ion; c ea ing a
closed-loop sys em whe e ma e ials a e con inuously eused and ecycled. This no
only educes he en i onmen al impac o esou ce ex ac ion bu also con ibu es
o he de elopmen o a mo e esou ce-e icien and less was e ul economy [110].
O e all, ad anced ecycling echnologies and esou ce eco e y play a c ucial ole in
d i ing he ansi ion owa ds a CE by maximizing he alue o was e ma e ials and
minimizing esou ce consump ion. By adop ing hese echnologies and p inciples,
indus ies can con ibu e o a mo e sus ainable and esou ce-e icien u u e.
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 195
2. In elligen So ing and Sepa a ion Sys ems
In elligen so ing and sepa a ion sys ems a e pi o al in ad ancing he p inciples
o he CE by enhancing he e iciency and e ec i eness o was e managemen and
esou ce eco e y p ocesses. These sys ems le e age cu ing-edge echnologies such
as AI, machine lea ning, compu e ision, and obo ics o accu a ely iden i y, so ,
and seg ega e di e se ma e ials. This enables hei app op ia e ecycling, euse, o
eco e y, he ebyp omo ingsus ainablep ac ices.Byau oma ing heso ingp ocess,
hese sys ems enhance he pu i y and quali y o eco e ed ma e ials, augmen ing
hei alue o subsequen euse o ecycling. Mo eo e , hey op imize esou ce allo-
ca ion by dynamically adjus ing pa ame e s, such as con eyo speed and senso
se ings, he eby maximizing e iciency while minimizing was e. These sys ems also
play a c i ical ole in de ec ing and elimina ing con aminan s, he eby imp o ing he
quali y o eco e ed ma e ials and mi iga ing he isk o c oss-con amina ion. Wi h
hei excep ional accu acy and speed in so ing, hey educe manual labou equi e-
men s, inc ease h oughpu capaci y, and enable he p ocessing o la ge olumes o
was e. Fu he mo e, in elligen so ing sys ems gene a e aluable da a pe aining o
was e composi ion, quan i y, and quali y [33]. This da a-d i en app oach acili a es
in o med decision-making, p ocess op imiza ion, and he de elopmen o no el ecy-
cling echnologies. By in eg a ing in o ci cula supply chains, hese sys ems acili-
a e he e icien eco e y and ein oduc ion o ecycled ma e ials, he eby closing
he loop in he CE. As echnology con inues o ad ance, hese sys ems a e poised o
makesigni ican con ibu ions o esou cee iciency,was e educ ion,andsus ainable
ma e ial u iliza ion.
3. Digi alisa ion and Blockchain Applica ions
The p omo ion o he gua an eed sys em o componen s and spa e pa s, digi al
aceabili y (Eu opean passpo ) and associa ed documen a ion a e equi emen s o
he deli e y o sus ainable and ci cula buil en i onmen [33]. Complemen a ily,
inancial aid o in es men s by indus ialized and sus ainable cons uc ion compa-
nies—e.g., modula design, BIM (Building In o ma ion Modelling), IoT digi aliza-
ion, 3D p in ing, cu ing obo ics, …—, and suppo o componen s’ banks and
ma e ial passpo s, a e p oposed as d i e s o o e s in public–p i a e collabo a ion
[33].
Rega ding ci cula i y o ma e ials, blockchain solu ion o ma e ials passpo
emb aces echnology agains he low anspa ency and aceabili y o he ma e ials
used—e.g., ib e pla es, s eels, coa ings, acades. Collabo a i e design and manu ac-
u ing (BIM, IoT, …) bene i by he a ailabili y o new echnologies which in eg a e
design, wi h p oduc ion and deli e y sys ems—JIT (Jus -In-Time) deli e y—a he
cons uc ion si e.
4. Robo ic Decons uc ion
Technological inno a ions in decons uc ion include ad anced ools and echniques
used o disman le and epu pose buildings and s uc u es in a mo e e icien , sus ain-
able, and p o i able manne . These inno a ions aim o educe was e, minimize en i-
onmen al impac , and imp o e sa e y du ing he decons uc ion p ocess. The use
196 P. San os e al.
o obo s o decons uc ion is a p omising app oach ha can imp o e e iciency
and sus ainabili y in he cons uc ion indus y. T adi ional demoli ion me hods ha e
signi ican isks and en i onmen al impac s, especially in conges ed u ban a eas
[111].In Japan, al e na i eme hods using Single-Task Cons uc ion Robo s (STCRs)
andsemi-au oma edon-si e ac o iesha ebeende eloped oadd esslegal,economic,
and ecological needs. Howe e , implemen ing adi ional indus ial obo s in a
decons uc ion en i onmen poses challenges, pa icula ly in e ms o human– obo
in e ac ion and collabo a ion. To o e come hese challenges, e icien human– obo
collabo a ion is conside ed in he design o decons uc ion STCRs. Addi ionally,
he applica ion o he Robo -O ien ed Design me hod can make he ope a ion o he
decons uc ion sys em mo e e icien . Building componen s should be compa ible
wi h obo ic applica ions, and connec o s and join s be ween componen s should
p o ide easy access o equipmen du ing he disassembly phase. The use o obo s
o decons uc ion can sa e ene gy, money, and ime while minimizing casual ies and
dis u bance o he economic en i onmen [111]. A amewo k o he e alua ion o
obo -assis ed, sys emized decons uc ion has been p oposed, which includes pe o -
mance indica o s ha can be adjus ed based on s akeholde pe spec i es. O e all,
he use o obo s in decons uc ion o e s a scalable and sus ainable solu ion o he
indus y.
5. Eme ging Ma e ials and Sus ainable Manu ac u ing P ocesses
Inno a ion in ma e ials, sus ainable design, and he de elopmen o al e na i e ech-
nologies ha equi e di e en ma e ials can help mi iga e supply isk. Solu ions
o educe he ecological oo p in and inc ease ma e ial eco e y o imp o e he
sa e y and compe i i eness o p oduc ion p ocesses a e wi hin each. Howe e ,
global scena ios con inue o p esen g ea e complexi y and compe i ion o na u al
esou ces [32]. The du a ion and oo p in s o ca bon dioxide (CO2), wa e and
ma e ial consump ion a e lowe in indus ialized sys ems, being he en i onmen al
impac o ci cula and sus ainable indus ialized cons uc ion suscep ible o di e en
modelling scena ios o ecycling pe cen age [33].
7.3.4 Ba ie s and Enable s o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage
Ex ensi e li e a u e has iden i ied ba ie s and enable s o de eloping a ci cula
economy in he cons uc ion sec o . Howe e , i is impo an o no e ha a ci cula
economy is a mul idimensional concep , and a close inspec ion o exis ing li e -
a u e e eals ha ba ie s and enable s ha e p ima ily ocused on he echnical
aspec s o ma e ials and p oduc s. Acco ding o a ecen s udy by Cha e e al. [112],
ba ie s o he de elopmen o a ci cula economy in he cons uc ion sec o can be
ca ego ized in o six dis inc ypes: economic ( e e ing o ma ke ba ie s), socio-
logical (pe aining o cul u al o psychological obs acles), poli ical, o ganiza ional
(in ol ing s akeholde s), echnological, and en i onmen al (conce ning ecological
impac ). Simila ly, Ababio and Lu [113] iden i ied i e ca ego ies o ba ie s: social
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 197
and cul u al, poli ical and legisla i e, inancial and economic, echnological, and
amewo k and heo y ela ed.
While esea ch on ba ie s o ci cula economy de elopmen has been ex ensi e,
s udies on enable s o he ci cula economy ha e ye o be conduc ed o he same
ex en .AbabioandLu [113]ha edepa ed om classi yingandlis ingenable sunde
speci ic ca ego ies and ins ead discussed hem unde b oade hemes. Gene ally,
enable s a e ela ed o echnology and inno a ion, policy, educa ion and awa eness,
as well as inancing and ma ke c ea ion. I is impo an o no e ha a comp ehensi e
unde s anding o bo h ba ie s and enable s is c i ical o p omo ing a success ul
ansi ion o a ci cula economy in he cons uc ion sec o . This pa o he epo
ocuses on he ma e ial usage- ela ed ba ie s o enable s add essed in he li e a u e.
They a e discussed unde ou ca ego ies.
1. Economic and Regula o y Ba ie s
Nume ous s udies ha e iden i ied insu icien and imma u e ma ke s, as well as a lack
o demand o eused and ecycled ma e ials, as he p ima y economic ba ie s o he
implemen a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices in he cons uc ion sec o [114–116].
These s udies also sugges ha he cons uc ion indus y is o en c i icized o i s
poo lexibili y in adop ing inno a i e p ac ices due o he pe cei ed isk o losing
p o i s [112,115].
In he cons uc ion sec o , adop ing CE p ac ices is me wi h a majo challenge—
he highe esou ce cos associa ed wi h decons uc ion compa ed o demoli ion.
Mo eo e , i gin ma e ials end o be less expensi e han ecycled ma e ials, while
ecycling cos s mo e han he disposal o CDW. Un o una ely, he ecen COVID-
19 pandemic has only wo sened hese challenges by s alling economic de elopmen
and inc easing he use o single-use ma e ials. The implemen a ion o CE p ac ices
in he cons uc ion indus y equi es signi ican in es men s, such as he enewal o
equipmen [116]. Mo eo e , ou da ed legisla ion and he lack o s anda dized guides
ega ding design and p ocu emen p ocedu es a e majo egula o y ba ie s o CE
de elopmen [112,117]. Addi ionally, a lack o go e nmen suppo and he absence
o suppo om public ins i u ions ha e been highligh ed as c i ical ba ie s o CE
adop ion [112,118].
In o de o p omo e he in eg a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices in he cons uc-
ion indus y, i is necessa y o adop new business models and me hods o e alu-
a ing asse s ha p io i ize ma e ial alue. Fo ins ance, long- e m in es men s can be
made o suppo he ci cula economy business case by u ilizing whole-li e cos ing.
Ano he oppo uni y p esen ed by he implemen a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices
is he abili y o ans o m he business model in o a p oduc -as-a-se ice con ac
(PSS), as no ed by Rizos e al. [119]. Enable s ha ha e been commonly iden i-
ied include design-build-ope a e-main ain con ac s and hei a ia ions, acco ding
o Ababio and Lu [113]. Fu he mo e, s akeholde s in he cons uc ion indus y
ha e epo ed ha implemen ing ci cula economy p ac ices can o e mo e lexible
wo king a angemen s, as To gau o e al. [117] epo ed.
198 P. San os e al.
2. Cul u al and Beha iou al Challenges
Cul u al and beha iou al changes can p esen signi ican obs acles o he adop ion
o inno a i e p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y. This sec o is known o i s
conse a i e na u e and esis ance o new ideas ha challenge exis ing a i udes,
cus oms, and belie s. Some o he cul u al issues ha hinde he adop ion o ci cula
economy (CE) and sus ainabili y p ac ices among cons uc ion s akeholde s include
a lack o awa eness, eluc ance, and isk a e sion. Mo eo e , he e is a p e e ence o
i gin cons uc ion ma e ials o e eused and ecycled p oduc s, which is ein o ced
by ing ained belie s ha ci cula economy p ac ices a e no easible [112,118].
Se e al s udies ha e in es iga ed s akeholde s’ pe cep ions o he adop ion o
CE p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y. The li e a u e e iewed in his sec ion
highligh s ha con ac o s a e hesi an o use e u bished and ecycled ma e ials in
hei cons uc ion due o conce ns abou a po en ial dec ease in he quali y o hei
p oduc s [27,112,118]. Cus ome s, on he o he hand, may no p e e buildings
cons uc ed using old ma e ials. Addi ionally, he quali y o eco e ed ma e ials is
o en pe cei ed as in e io o i gin ma e ials, u he uelling scep icism abou he
easibili y o CE p ac ices [117].
3. S akeholde Engagemen and Awa eness
In o de o acili a e he widesp ead adop ion o ci cula economy (CE) p ac ices
in he cons uc ion indus y, i is impo an o add ess he exis ing cul u al and
beha iou al ba ie s. This can be achie ed h ough a a ie y o means, such as educa-
ion,awa eness- aising, and cul u al change ini ia i es. By doing so, s akeholde s can
wo k owa ds c ea ing a mo e sus ainable and ci cula economy, which would no
only bene i he indus y bu also he en i onmen .
One e ec i e enabling ool o inc easing awa eness, changing a i udes, and
a ec ing beha iou s is dialogue [113]. This can in ol e open and hones commu-
nica ion be ween di e en g oups o s akeholde s, including indus y p o essionals,
academics, and go e nmen o icials. Th ough dialogue, s akeholde s can gain a
be e unde s anding o each o he ’s pe spec i es and wo k collabo a i ely owa ds
inding solu ions o indus y challenges.
Academic cu icula and p o essional wo kshops a e also impo an enable s o
cap u ing CE and i s ange o sus ainable p ac ices [113]. These educa ional oppo u-
ni iesp o ides akeholde swi h he equisi eideas and knowledge oadd essindus y
challenges. Addi ionally, hey help o ensu e ha indus y p o essionals a e equipped
wi h he skills and expe ise needed o implemen sus ainable p ac ices in hei wo k.
By in es ing in educa ion and aining oppo uni ies, s akeholde s can wo k owa ds
a mo e sus ainable and ci cula economy in he cons uc ion indus y.
4. Go e nmen al Suppo and Incen i es
The global cons uc ion indus y is acing a signi ican challenge in emb acing
ci cula p ac ices and business models due o he absence o adequa e policies,
laws, and amewo ks. The lack o go e nmen suppo , such as inancial aid o
ax incen i es, is making i less economically easible o in es in ci cula models,
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 199
and as a esul , discou aging hei adop ion. The absence o egula o y p essu e
and s ic laws also ails o es ablish he necessa y u gency o ci cula i y, and he
equi ed beha iou al changes in he cons uc ion indus y a e no aking place. This
is a p essing issue ha needs o be add essed so ha he cons uc ion indus y can
mo e owa ds a mo e sus ainable and ci cula u u e [27]. Sus ainable de elopmen
is becoming inc easingly essen ial, and as a esul , ci cula buildings a e gaining
popula i y. The main objec i e o ci cula buildings is o os e he idea o “building
as a ma e ial bank” [115], whe e he ma e ials used in he cons uc ion a e s o ed and
eused when he building’s li e comes o an end. Howe e , his can only be achie ed
i he e is a inancial incen i e o design buildings ha can be easily decons uc ed
and econs uc ed. I is wo h no ing ha ci cula buildings a e gene ally mo e cos ly
han adi ional buildings.
The ci cula economy in he cons uc ion indus y is a complex issue ha equi es
he in ol emen o all s akeholde s, including go e nmen s, in es o s, designe s,
cons uc o s, and use s. The ansi ion owa ds ci cula p ac ices equi es a signi i-
can change in mindse and app oach, as well as he adop ion o new echnologies
and sys ems. None heless, he bene i s o ci cula i y in he cons uc ion indus y a e
a - eaching, including educed was e and ca bon emissions, inc eased esou ce e i-
ciency, and imp o ed social and economic ou comes. The e o e, i is essen ial o
all s akeholde s o collabo a e and wo k owa ds a mo e sus ainable u u e o he
cons uc ion indus y.
7.4 Case S udies and Bes P ac ices
7.4.1 Case S udy 1—Gonsi Sóc a es Bio-building
(Ba celona, Spain)
Figu e 7.10 shows he Gonsi Sóc a es Bio-Building which was buil by Cons ucía
Company. They ollowed he Lean2C adle®ci cula cons uc ion me hodology
[120]. Almos all he building ma e ials (99%) we e cha ac e ized and i s compo-
nen s we e e iewed, and up o 50 ypes o ma e ials we e in en o ied. Among hese
ma e ials, 89% (8,400 ons) will no become was e a hei end-o -li e bu ha e a
ci cula way o be ein oduced in o he p oduc ion p ocess. Thus, when he use ul
li e o he building ends, hey can be eused, epai ed o ecycled in he way ha is
mos con enien a ha ime, allowing hem o p ese e g ea e alue o he nex
use [121].
206 P. San os e al.
conse ing esou ces, and os e ing inno a ion. Fu he mo e, in eg a ing hese p in-
ciples suppo s he b oade global sus ainabili y agenda, signi ican ly ad ancing CE
p ac ices beyond he cons uc ion sec o .
This chap e ela ed o implemen ing CE p inciples in he cons uc ion indus y
has e ealed c ucial insigh s o enhancing sus ainabili y and educing en i on-
men al impac . Howe e , he slow adop ion o hese p inciples is due o indus y-
speci ic ba ie s such as limi ed knowledge and expe ience. The e o e, a collec-
i e e o o educa e and dissemina e in o ma ion is essen ial o o e come hese
obs acles. Emb acing inno a ion o e s a p omising pa h o p omo ing ci cula i y.
Success ul case s udies o ci cula p ac ices can p o ide aluable insigh s o wide
indus y adop ion. De eloping obus egula o y amewo ks can incen i ize sus ain-
able p ac ices, and in eg a ing ad anced echnologies can op imize was e manage-
men p ocesses. Educa ion on ci cula p ac ices is i al, and global collabo a ion is
essen ial o s anda dizing uni e sally accep ed app oaches.
Re e ences
1. Moschen-Schimek J, Kaspe T, Hube -Hume M (2023) C i ical e iew o he eco e y a es
o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e in he Eu opean Union—an analysis o in luencing
ac o s in selec ed EU coun ies. Was e Manag Else ie L d 167(Decembe 2022):150–164.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2023.05.020
2. Gio gi S, La agna M, Campioli A (2018) Guidelines o e ec i e and sus ainable ecycling
o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. In: Bene o E, Ge icke K, Gui on M (eds) Designing
sus ainable echnologies, p oduc s and policies. Sp inge In e na ional Publishing, pp 211–
221. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-66981-6
3. Eu opean Commission (2019) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e—en i onmen . h ps://en
i onmen .ec.eu opa.eu/ opics/was e-and- ecycling/cons uc ion-and-demoli ion-was e_en.
Accessed 14 July 2023
4. Eu opean Pa liamen and o Council (2008) Di ec i e 2008/98/EC o he Eu opean Pa liamen
and o he Council o 19 No embe 2008 on was e, known as “Was e F amewo k Di ec i e”
(WFD), consolida ed ( e ised 7-5-2018). O J Eu Union
5. Eu opean Pa liamen (2023) Ci cula economy: de ini ion, impo ance and bene i s.
h ps://www.eu opa l.eu opa.eu/news/en/headlines/economy/20151201STO05603/ci cula -
economy-de ini ion-impo ance-and-bene i s?&a _campaign=20234-Economy&a _med
ium=Google_Ads&a _pla o m=Sea ch&a _c ea ion=RSA&a _goal=TR_G&a _audience=
impo ance%20o %20ci cula %20economy&a _ opic=Ci cula _Economy&a _loca ion=
IE&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI -6j yVgAMV 4poCR1L QBdEAAYASAAEgLUT_D_BwE.
Accessed 9 July 2023
6. Adams KT, Osmani M, Tho pe T, Tho nback J (2017) Ci cula economy in cons uc-
ion: cu en awa eness, challenges and enable s. P oc Ins Ci Eng Was e Resou Manag
170(1):15–24
7. Eu opean Commission (2019) COM/2019/640 The Eu opean g een deal. B ussels
8. Eu opeanCommission(2020)COM/2020/98Anewci cula economyac ionplan o acleane
and mo e compe i i e Eu ope. B ussels
9. Uni ed Na ions En i onmen al P og amme (2022) 2022 Global s a us epo o buildings
and cons uc ion: owa ds a ze o-emission, e icien and esilien buildings and cons uc ion
sec o , Nai obi
10. Acha ya D, Boyd R, Finch O (2018) F om p inciples o p ac ice: i s s eps owa ds a ci cula
buil en i onmen
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 207
11. Eu opean Commission (2020) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. h ps://en i onmen .ec.
eu opa.eu/ opics/was e-and- ecycling/cons uc ion-and-demoli ion-was e_en#publica ions.
Accessed 9 July 2023
12. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2022) Reimagining ou buildings and spaces o a
ci cula economy. h ps://ellenmaca hu ounda ion.o g/ opics/buil -en i onmen /o e iew.
Accessed 8 July 2023
13. Мa e ial Economics (2019) Indus ial ans o ma ion 2050: pa hways o ne -ze o emissions
om EU hea y indus y. Uni e si y o Camb idge Ins i u e o Sus ainabili y Leade ship
(CISL), Camb idge
14. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2018) Wha is a ci cula economy? h ps://ellenmaca hu oun
da ion.o g/ opics/ci cula -economy-in oduc ion/o e iew. Accessed 9 July 2023
15. Çimen Ö (2023) De elopmen o a ci cula building li ecycle amewo k: incep ion o
ci cula ion. Resul s Eng 17:100861
16. Çimen Ö (2021) Cons uc ion and buil en i onmen in ci cula economy: a comp ehensi e
li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 305:127180
17. Reike D, Ve meulen WJV, Wi jes S (2018) The ci cula economy: new o Re u bished as
CE 3.0?—Explo ing con o e sies in he concep ualiza ion o he ci cula economy h ough
a ocus on his o y and esou ce alue e en ion op ions. Resou Conse Recycl Else ie
135(No embe 2017):246–264. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec.2017.08.027
18. Mesa JA, Espa agoza I (2021) Towa ds he implemen a ion o ci cula economy in engi-
nee ing educa ion: a sys ema ic e iew. In: 2021 IEEE on ie s in educa ion con e ence
(FIE), 13–16 Oc 2021, pp 1–8
19. Po ing J, Hekke M, Wo elland E, Hanemaaije A (2017) Ci cula economy: measu ing
inno a ion in he p oduc chain. PBL
20. Ga g R (2022) He e’s how o c ea e a ci cula sys em o he buil en i onmen . In: Uni ed
Na ions clima e change con e ence COP27: wo ld economic o um
21. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2019) Ci cula economy bu e ly diag am. h ps://ellenmaca
hu ounda ion.o g/ci cula -economy-diag am. Accessed 9 July 2023
22. O enhaus LM (2022) Bu e ly diag am o ci cula buildings ( e sion 1). igsha e. h ps://
doi.o g/10.6084/m9. igsha e.21249573. 1
23. Eu opean Commission (2019) A sus ainable bioeconomy o Eu ope: s eng hening he
connec ion be ween economy, socie y and he en i onmen : upda ed bioeconomy s a egy.
Publica ions O ice o he Eu opean Union, B ussels
24. Technical Uni e si y Munich (2017) Cascading use o wood o ensu e sus ainabili y. h ps://
phys.o g/news/2017-12-cascading-wood-sus ainabili y.h ml
25. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2022) The biological cycle o he bu e ly diag am. h ps://ell
enmaca hu ounda ion.o g/a icles/ he-biological-cycle-o - he-bu e ly-diag am. Accessed
9 July 2023
26. Muna o MR, Ta a es SF (2023) A e iew on ba ie s, d i e s, and s akeholde s owa ds he
ci cula economy: he cons uc ion sec o pe spec i e. Clean Respons Consump 8:100107.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.cl c.2023.100107
27. Wuni IY (2022) Mapping he ba ie s o ci cula economy adop ion in he cons uc ion
indus y: a sys ema ic e iew, Pa e o analysis, and mi iga ion s a egy map. Build En i on
223:109453
28. Spa anda a L, We ne M, Kaminsky A, Finch L, Douglas K (2020) Accele a ing he ci cula
economy h ough comme cial decons uc ion and euse
29. Akinade O, Oyedele L, Oyedele A, Da ila Delgado JM, Bilal M, Akanbi L, Ajayi A, Owolabi
H (2020) Design o decons uc ion using a ci cula economy app oach: ba ie s and s a egies
o imp o emen . P od Plan Con ol 31(10):829–840
30. B own M, Hasels eine E, Ap ó D, Kope a D, Luca E, Pulkkinen K, Vula Riz anolli B (2018)
Sus ainabili y, es o a i e o egene a i e. Publica ions COST ac ion RESTORE CA16114,
wo king g oup one epo . h ps://www.eu es o e.eu/wp-con en /uploads/2018/04/Sus ainab
ili y-Res o a i e- o-Regene a i e.pd . Accessed 14 July 2023
208 P. San os e al.
31. Dumée LF (2022) Ci cula ma e ials and ci cula design— e iew on challenges owa ds
sus ainable manu ac u ing and ecycling. Ci c Econ Sus ain 2:9–23. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/
s43615-021-00085-2. Accessed 14 July 2023
32. Mo a ó J, Jiménez LM, Calle os-Islas A, De la C uz JL, Díaz LD, Ma ínez J, P-Lagüela E,
Penagos G, Pe nas JJ, Ro i a S, Sanz FJ, Tollin N, Villanue a B, Woischnik A (2021) In o me
COTEC – Si uación y E olución de la Economía Ci cula en España. Mad id: Fundación
Co ec pa a la inno ación. h ps://co ec.es/obse acion/economia-ci cula / 62c16db-5823-
deb4-7986-a786e5c3401c. Accessed 18 Aug 2023
33. Fe e J, He e ía N, Remón A, A mas R, Díez de Ri e a T, Ramos I, Sa o i T, Isla M, Mo a ó
J, Villanue a B, Ba alla J, Villa M (2022) P oyec o Economía Ci cula España – Acele ando
la T ansición en el Sec o de Cons ucción. h ps://www.accen u e.com/con en /dam/acc
en u e/ inal/accen u e-com/documen /Accen u e-EC-Espana-In o me-Sec o -Cons uccion.
pd . Accessed 19 Aug 2023
34. Ellen Maca hu Founda ion (2023) h ps://ellenmaca hu ounda ion.o g/. Accessed 8 July
2023
35. Cha e R, Lu W, Hall D (2022) The ansi ion o he ci cula economy o he cons uc ion
indus y: insigh s in o sus ainable app oaches o imp o e he unde s anding. J Clean P od
Else ie L d 364(June):132421. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.132421
36. Nußholz J e al (2023) F om ci cula s a egies o ac ions: 65 Eu opean ci cula building cases
and hei deca bonisa ion po en ial. Resou Conse Recycl Ad 17(Janua y). h ps://doi.o g/
10.1016/j. c ad .2023.200130
37. Se aki F, an Timme en A (2022) Dis up i e echnologies o a ci cula building
indus y. Build En i on Else ie L d 223(July):109394. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.builden .
2022.109394
38. Ta a es TM e al (2023) The bene i s and ba ie s o addi i e manu ac u ing o ci cula
economy: a amewo k p oposal. Sus ain P od Consump Else ie L d 37:369–388. h ps://
doi.o g/10.1016/j.spc.2023.03.006
39. Oluleye BI, Chan DWM, An wi-A a i P (2023) Adop ing A i icial In elligence o enhancing
he implemen a ion o sys emic ci cula i y in he cons uc ion indus y: a c i ical e iew.
Sus ainP odConsumpIns ChemEng 35:509–524.h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.spc.2022.12.002
40. Ma sh ATM, Velen u APM, Be nal SA (2022) Ci cula economy s a egies o conc e e:
implemen a ionand in eg a ion.JClean P od Else ie L d362(Oc obe 2021):132486. h ps://
doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.132486
41. Figge F e al (2018) Longe i y and ci cula i y as indica o s o eco-e icien esou ce use in
he ci cula economy. Ecol Econ Else ie 150(No embe 2017):297–306. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.ecolecon.2018.04.030
42. Ki chhe J, Reike D, Hekke M (2017) Concep ualizing he ci cula economy: an analysis
o 114 de ini ions. Resou Conse Recycl 127:221–232. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec.
2017.09.005
43. Mollaei A, Bachmann C, Haas C (2023) Es ima ing he eco e able alue o in-si u building
ma e ials. Sus ain Ci ies Soc 91:104455. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.scs.2023.104455.66
44. Zhuang GL, Shih SG, Wagi i F (2023) Ci cula economy and sus ainable de elopmen goals:
explo ing he po en ials o eusable modula componen s in ci cula economy business model.
J Clean P od Else ie L d 414:137503. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2023.137503
45. Haines-Gadd M, Cha nley F, Encinas-O opesa A (2021) Sel -healing ma e ials: a pa hway o
immo al p oduc s o a isk o ci cula economy sys ems? J Clean P od Else ie L d 315(May
2020):128193. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.128193
46. A a N (2023) Remanu ac u ing owa ds ci cula i y in he cons uc ion sec o : he ole o
digi al echnologies. In:Technologicalimagina ion in he g eenand digi al ansi ion. Sp inge
In e na ional Publishing, pp 493–503. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-031-29515-7_45
47. Van S ijn A, G uis V (2020) Towa ds a ci cula buil en i onmen : an in eg al design ool o
ci cula building componen s. Sma Sus ain Buil En i on 9(4):635–653. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1108/SASBE-05-2019-0063
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 209
48. Hosseini MR e al (2015) Re e se logis ics in he cons uc ion indus y. Was e Manag Res
33(6):499–514. h ps://doi.o g/10.1177/0734242X15584842
49. Ding L, Wang T, Chan PW (2023) Fo wa d and e e se logis ics o ci cula economy in
cons uc ion: a sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 388:135891. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.jclep o.2023.135981
50. An wi-A a i P, Ng ST, Hossain MU (2021) A e iew o he ci cula i y gap in he cons uc ion
indus y h ough scien ome ic analysis. J Clean P od Else ie L d 298:126870. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.126870
51. Ha J e al (2019) Ba ie s and d i e s in a ci cula economy: he case o he buil en i-
onmen . P ocedia CIRP Else ie B.V. 80(Ma ch):619–624. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p oci .
2018.12.015
52. ebuydeal.com (2023) h ps://www. ebuydeal.com/en/buy-sell-second-hand/115/building-
ma e ials. Accessed 15 July 2023
53. seconduse.com (2023) h ps://www.seconduse.com/in en o y/ca ego ies/lumbe /. Accessed
15 July 2023
54. o o dc.com (2023) Ro o DC—decons uc ion and consul ing. h ps:// o o dc.com/shop/ca
ego y/doo -32. Accessed 15 July 2023
55. Oluleye BI e al (2022) Ci cula economy esea ch on building cons uc ion and demoli ion
was e: a e iew o cu en ends and u u e esea ch di ec ions. J Clean P od Else ie L d
357(Decembe 2021):131927. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.131927
56. Ghobadi M, Sepasgoza SME (2023) Ci cula economy s a egies in mode n imbe cons uc-
ion as a po en ial esponse o clima e change. J Build Eng Else ie L d 107229. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2023.107229
57. Ahn N e al (2022) Ci cula economy in mass imbe cons uc ion: s a e-o - he-a , gaps and
p essing esea ch needs. J Build Eng Else ie L d 53(May):104562. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/
j.jobe.2022.104562
58. Llana DF e al (2022) C oss Lamina ed Timbe (CLT) manu ac u ed wi h Eu opean oak
eco e ed om demoli ion: s uc u al p ope ies and non-des uc i e e alua ion. Cons Build
Ma e 339(No embe 2021). h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2022.127635
59. Cobî zan N e al (2020) Mic oscopical and mac oscopical analysis o eco e ed b icks o
assessing hei eusabili y in mason y buildings. P ocedia Manu Else ie B.V. 46:144–149.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p om g.2020.03.022
60. Ramos M e al (2023) Local scale dynamics o p omo e he sus ainable managemen o
cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. Resou Conse Recycl Ad 17(Feb ua y). h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j. c ad .2023.200135
61. dos Reis GS e al (2021) Cu en applica ions o ecycled agg ega es om cons uc ion and
demoli ion: a e iew. Ma e ials 14(7). h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma14071700
62. Sahoo P e al (2023) Seques a ion and u iliza ion o ca bon dioxide o imp o e enginee ing
p ope ies o cemen -based cons uc ion ma e ials wi h ecycled b ick powde : a pa hway o
cleane cons uc ion. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 395(June):132268. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.conbuildma .2023.132268
63. Be gonzoni M, Melloni R, Bo i L (2023) Analysis o sus ainable conc e e ob ained om he
by-p oduc so anindus ial p ocess and ecycledagg ega es om cons uc ionand demoli ion
was e. P ocedia Compu Sci Else ie B.V. 217(2022):41–51. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p ocs.
2022.12.200
64. Fe ández D e al (2023) Towa ds a mo e sus ainable en i onmen ally p oduc ion sys em
o he ea men o ecycled agg ega es in he cons uc ion indus y: an expe imen al s udy.
Heliyon 9(6). h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e16641
65. Za agoza-Benzal A, Fe ández D, San os P e al (2023) Reco e y o end-o -li e y es and
mine alwool was e:a case s udy wi h gypsumcomposi e ma e ials applying ci cula economy
c i e ia. Ma e ials 16(1):243. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma16010243
66. Za agoza-Benzal A, Fe ández D, A anes-Sánchez E e al (2023) New ligh ened plas e ma e-
ial wi h dissol ed ecycled expanded polys y ene and end-o -li e y es ib es o building
p e ab ica ed indus y. Case S ud Cons Ma e 18(Oc obe 2022):e02178. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.cscm.2023.e02178
210 P. San os e al.
67. So munen P e al (2021) An e alua ion o he moplas ic composi e ille s de i ed om
cons uc ion and demoli ion was e based on hei economic and en i onmen al cha ac e is ics.
J Clean P od 280. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.125198
68. Ahmed N (2023) U ilizing plas ic was e in he building and cons uc ion indus y: a pa hway
owa ds he ci cula economy. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 383(Decembe 2022):131311.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2023.131311
69. Özçelikci E e al (2023) Eco-hyb id cemen -based building insula ion ma e ials as a ci cula
economysolu ion ocons uc ionand demoli ionwas e.Cemen Conc Compos141(Janua y).
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.cemconcomp.2023.105149
70. Seco A e al (2018) Sus ainable un i ed b icks manu ac u ing om cons uc ion and demoli-
ion was es. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 167:154–165. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbui
ldma .2018.02.026
71. dos Reis GS e al (2020) Fab ica ion, mic os uc u e, and p ope ies o i ed clay b icks using
cons uc ion and demoli ion was e sludge as he main addi i e. J Clean P od 258. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.120733
72. Islam S, Islam J, Robiul Hoque NM (2022) Imp o emen o consolida ion p ope ies o
clay soil using ine-g ained cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. Heliyon The Au ho (s)
8(10):e11029. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e11029
73. GiannopoulouIe al(2023)High empe a u epe o manceo geopolyme sbasedon cons uc-
ion and demoli ion was e. J Build Eng Else ie L d 72(Feb ua y):106575. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.jobe.2023.106575
74. He X e al (2022) Recycling o plas ic was e conc e e o p epa e an e ec i e addi i e o ea ly
s eng h and la e pe meabili y imp o emen o cemen pas e. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d
347(June):128581. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2022.128581
75. Thwe Win T e al (2023) Use o polyp opylene ibe s ex ac ed om ecycled su gical ace
masks in cemen mo a . Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 391(Ma ch):131845. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2023.131845
76. Ál a ez M e al (2022) ‘Pe o mance cha ac e isa ion o a new plas e composi e ligh ened
wi h end-o -li e y es’ ecycled ma e ials o alse ceiling pla es. Ma e ials 5660. h ps://doi.
o g/10.3390/ma15165660
77. San os P, Ma eus D (2020) Expe imen al assessmen o he mal b eak s ips pe o mance in
load-bea ing and non-load-bea ing LSF walls. J Build Eng Else ie L d 32:101693. h ps://
doi.o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2020.101693
78. San os P e al (2022) Nume ical simula ion and expe imen al alida ion o he mal b eak
s ips’ Imp o emen in Facade LSF Walls. Ene gies 15(21):8169. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/en1
5218169
79. Paih e PL, Lalngaihawma AC, Saini G (2019) Recycled agg ega e illed was e plas ic bo les
as a eplacemen o b icks. Ma e Today P oc Else ie L d. 15:663–668. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.ma p .2019.04.135
80. Lamy-mendes A e al (2022) Ae ogel composi es p oduced om silica and ecycled ubbe
sols o he mal insula ion. Ma e ials 15(22):7897. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma15227897
81. Rod igues Pon inha AD e al (2023) The momechanical pe o mance assessmen o sus ain-
able buildings’ insula ing ma e ials unde accele a ed ageing condi ions. Gels 9(3):241.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/gels9030241
82. Cheng Q, Feng H, Ga cia de So o B (2022) Re amping cons uc ion supply chain p ocesses
wi h ci cula economy s a egies: a sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 335:130240.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.130240
83. Bocken NMP, Oli e i EA, Cullen JM, Po ing J, Li se R (2017) Taking he ci cula i y o he
nex le el: a special issue on he ci cula economy: aking ci cula i y o he nex le el. J Ind
Ecol 21:476–482
84. Rabnawaz R, Zhang X (2021) Mul i-s age ne wo k-based wo- ype cos minimiza ion o he
e e se logis ics managemen o ine cons uc ion was e. Was e Manag 120:805–819. h ps://
doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2020.11.004
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 211
85. Komko a A, Kabe G (2023) Op imal supply chain ne wo ks o was e ma e ials used in
alkali-ac i a ed conc e e os e ing ci cula economy. Resou Conse Recycl 193:106949.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec.2023.106949
86. Pallewa S, Wee asoo iyageda a M, Bo doloi S, Sa mah AK, Vi hanage M (2023) Rep o-
cessed cons uc ion and demoli ion was e as an adso ben : an app aisal. Sci To En i on
882:163340. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.sci o en .2023.163340
87. Ru ald R, Be oni A, Johansson C (2019) A ole o physical p o o yping in p oduc -se ice
sys em design: case s udy in cons uc ion equipmen . P ocedia 83:358–362. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1016/j.p oci .2019.03.099
88. Tseng ML, Lin S, Chen CC, Calaho ano LS, Tan CL (2019) A causal sus ainable p oduc -
se ice sys em using hie a chical s uc u e wi h linguis ic p e e ences in he Ecuado ian
cons uc ion indus y. J Clean P od 230:477–487. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019.
05.140
89. Cook M, Go be g A, Angus A, Longhu s P (2012) Recep i i y o he p oduc ion o p oduc
se ice sys ems in he UK cons uc ion and manu ac u ing sec o s: a compa a i e analysis. J
Clean P od 32:61–70. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2012.03.018
90. DongminZ,DachaoH,YuchunX,HongZ(2012)A amewo k o designknowledgemanage-
men and euse o p oduc -se ice sys ems in cons uc ion machine y indus y. Compu Ind
63:328–337. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.compind.2012.02.008
91. Li CZ, Chen Z, Xue F, Kong X, Xiao B, Lai X, Zhao Y (2019) A blockchain- and IoT-based
sma p oduc -se ice sys em o he sus ainabili y o p e ab ica ed housing cons uc ion. J
Clean P od 286:125391. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.125391
92. Ness D, Xing K, Kim K, Jenkins A (2019) An ICT-enabled p oduc se ice sys em o euse
o building componen s. IFAC 52:761–766. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.i acol.2019.11.207
93. K is ensen HS, Remmen A (2019) A amewo k o sus ainable alue p oposi ions in p oduc -
se ice sys ems. J Clean P od 223:25–35. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019.03.074
94. Thie e A, Koopman C, Hobson A, Kuipe C (2016) How he In e ne , he sha ing economy,
and epu a ional eedback mechanisms sol e he “Lemons P oblem”. Law Re 830. h ps://
eposi o y.law.miami.edu/uml / ol70/iss3/6
95. Lindhq is T (2000) Ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in cleane p oduc ion: policy p inciple
o p omo e en i onmen al imp o emen s o p oduc sys ems. Lund Uni e si y
96. Filho WL, Saa i U, Fedo uk M, Ii al A, Moo a H, Klöga M, Vo ono a V (2019) An o e iew
o he p oblems posed by plas ic p oduc s and he ole o ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in
Eu ope. J Clean P od 214:550–558. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2018.12.256
97. Jang YC (2010) Was e elec ical and elec onic equipmen (WEEE) managemen in Ko ea:
gene a ion, collec ion, and ecycling sys ems. J Ma e Cycles Was e Manag 12:283–294.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s10163-010-0298-5
98. Xu J, Ye M, Lu W, Bao Z, Webs e C (2021) A ou -quad an concep ual amewo k o
analyzing ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in o sho e p e ab ica ion cons uc ion. J Clean
P od 282:124540. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.124540
99. Campbell-JhonsonK, Calis oM, ThapaK, Lake eld D,Ve meulen WJV(2020) Howci cula
is you y e: Expe iences wi h ex ended p oduce esponsibili y om a ci cula economy
pe spec i e. J Clean P od 279:122042. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.122042
100. Fe ão P, Ribei o P, Sil a P (2008) A managemen sys em o end-o -li e y es: a Po uguese
case s udy. Was e Manage 28(3):604–614. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2007.02.033
101. Deu z P (2009) P oduce esponsibili y in a sus ainable de elopmen con ex : ecological
mode nisa iono indus ialecology?Geog J175(4):274–285.h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/j.1475-
4959.2009.00330.x
102. ZhangX,UllahYousa HMA(2020)G eensupplychaincoo dina ionconside inggo e nmen
in e en ion, g een in es men , and cus ome g een p e e ences in he pe oleum indus y. J
Clean P od 246:118984. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019.118984
103. Glasbe gen P (2011) Mechanisms o p i a e me a-go e nance: an analysis o global p i a e
go e nance o sus ainable de elopmen . In J S a Bus Alliances 2(3):19–206. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1504/IJSBA.2011.040886
212 P. San os e al.
104. Xie Y, Zhao Y, Chen Y, Allen C (2022) G een cons uc ion supply chain managemen :
in eg a ing go e nmen al in e en ion and public–p i a e pa ne ships h ough ecological
mode nisa ion. J Clean P od 331:129986. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.129986
105. Tang L,Shen Q,Cheng EWL (2009)A e iew o s udieson Public-P i a e pa ne shipp ojec s
in he cons uc ion indus y. In J P oj Manag 28:683–694. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.ijp oman.
2009.11.009
106. Munoz-Jo e J, Hinojosa S, Mascle-Allemand AL, Temp ano J (2023) A selec i i y index o
public-p i a e pa ne ship p ojec s in he u ban wa e and sani a ion sec o in La in Ame ica
and he Ca ibbean. J En i on Manage 335:117564. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jen man.2023.
117564
107. Aza ian M, Tadege A, Laed e O, Wondimu P, K is ian T (2023) P ojec owne ship in public-
p i a e pa ne ship (PPP) p ojec s o No way. P ocedia Compu Sci 219:1838–1846. h ps://
doi.o g/10.1016/j.p ocs.2023.01.481
108. Amp a wum G, Osei R, Tam VWY (2022) Explo ing he concep o public-p i a e pa ne ship
in building c i ical in as uc u e esilience agains unexpec ed e en s: a sys ema ic e iew.
In J C i In as uc P o 39:100556. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.ijcip.2022.100556
109. Bao Z, Lu W, Chi B, Yuan H, Hao J (2019) P ocu emen inno a ion o a ci cula economy o
cons uc ion and demoli ion was e: lessons lea n om Suzhou, China. Was e Manag 99:12–
21. ISSN 0956-053X. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2019.08.031
110. Eu opean En i onmen Agency (2023) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e: challenges and
oppo uni ies in a ci cula economy. h ps://www.eea.eu opa.eu/publica ions/cons uc ion-
and-demoli ion-was e-challenges. Accessed 24 Sep embe 2023
111. Lee S, Pan W, Linne T, Bock T (2015) A amewo k o obo assis ed decons uc ion:
p ocess, sub-sys ems and modelling. In: P oceedings o he 32nd ISARC, Oulu, Finland, pp
1–8. h ps://doi.o g/10.22260/ISARC2015/0093
112. Cha e R, Mo el CJ, Rakhshan K (2021) Ba ie s o implemen ing he ci cula economy in
he cons uc ion indus y: a c i ical e iew. Sus ainabili y 13(23):12989
113. Ababio BK, Lu W (2023) Ba ie s and enable s o ci cula economy in cons uc ion: a mul i-
sys em pe spec i e owa ds he de elopmen o a p ac ical amewo k. Cons Manag Econ
41(1):3–21
114. Hosseini MR, Chileshe N, Rameezdeen R, Lehmann S (2014) Re e se logis ics o he
cons uc ion indus y: lessons om he manu ac u ing con ex . In J Cons Eng Manag
3:75–90
115. Kan e s J (2020) Ci cula building design: an analysis o ba ie s and d i e s o a ci cula
building sec o . Buildings 10:77
116. Tleuken A, Tokazhano G, Jemal KM, Shaimakhano R, So e bek M, Ka aca F (2022)
Legisla i e, ins i u ional, indus ial and go e nmen al in ol emen in ci cula economy in
Cen al Asia: a sys ema ic e iew. Sus ainabili y 14:8064
117. To gau o B, Zhanabaye A, Tleuken A, Tu kyilmaz A, Bo ucki C, Ka aca F (2022) Pe o -
mance assessmen o cons uc ion companies o he ci cula economy: a balanced sco eca d
app oach. Sus ain P od Consump 33:991–1004
118. Bilal M, Khan KIA, Thaheem MJ, Nasi AR (2020) Cu en s a e and ba ie s o he ci cula
economy in he building sec o : owa ds a mi iga ion amewo k. J Clean P od 123250
119. Rizos V e al (2016) Implemen a ion o ci cula economy business models by small and
medium-sized en e p ises (SMEs): ba ie s and enable s. Sus ainabili y 8(11):1212
120. Ve a Co nejo SE (2018) P opues a de indicado es lean2c adle® en ases de uso
y decons ucción. Mas e hesis. Escuela de Caminos. Uni e sidad Poli écnica de
Ca aluña. h ps://upcommons.upc.edu/bi s eam/handle/2117/341616/TFM_SOLANGE_V
ERA.pd ?sequence=1&isAllowed=y. Accessed 14 July 2023
121. Cons ucía(2020)LaCons ucciónCi cula conLean2C adle®.h ps://www.cons ucia.com/
cons uccion-ci cula -lean2c adle/. Accessed 14 July 2023
122. Cons ucía (2020) Edi icio Sóc a es. h ps://www.cons ucia.com/edi icio-soc a es. Accessed
14 July 2023
7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 213
123. KPMG (2019) T ue Value de edi icios Lean2C adle®. Economía ci cula en el diseño a qui-
ec ónico, Cons ucía and eco in elligen g ow h, 2. h ps://www.picha chi ec s.com/2020/05/
20/economia-ci cula -en-el-disenoa qui ec onico-p -2/. Accessed 14 July 2023
124. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2019) Resou ce- espec ul cons uc ion— he case o he U ban
Mining and Recycling uni (UMAR). In: P oceedings o IOP con e ence se ies: ea h and
en i onmen al science (EES), ol 225, p 012049. h ps://iopscience.iop.o g/a icle/10.1088/
1755-1315/225/1/012049/pd . Accessed 14 July 2023
125. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2018) U ban mining and ecycling. h ps://www.nes -uma .ne .
Accessed 14 July 2023
126. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2018) U ban Mining and Recycling (UMAR) expe imen al
uni . Ma e ials. h ps://nes -uma .ne /#ma e ials. Accessed 14 July 2023
127. S oneCycling (2023) h ps://www.s onecycling.com/. Accessed 14 July 2023
128. Magna Glaske amik (2023) h ps://magna-glaske amik.com/. Accessed 14 July 2023
129. ReWall (2023) h ps://elemen al.g een/ ewall- ecycled-high-pe o mance- oo -and-wall-ma
e ials/. Accessed 14 July 2023
130. Robe sonGL(2021)Recyclingo asep icbe e ageca ons:a e iew.Recycling6(20).h ps://
doi.o g/10.3390/ ecycling6010020
131. Ul a ouch (2023). Denim insula ion. h ps://www.bondedlogic.com/ul a ouch-denim-insula
ion/. Accessed 14 July 2023
132. Di isa e (2023) h ps://di isa e.com/au ho s/2144897897-alex-shoo s-buildings. Accessed
14 July 2023
133. Packwall (2023) Boa ds. h ps://www.packwall.a /en/homepage/. Accessed 14 July 2023
134. RECOMA (2023) h ps://www. ecoma.com/p oduc /design-boa d. Accessed 14 July 2023
135. Repolyuse (2018) EU unded p ojec . Li e +.h ps://li e- epolyuse.com/.Accessed14July
2023
136. Yesy o ma (2023) SKY echos ecosos enibles. h ps://www.yesy o ma.es/sky- echos-ecoso
enibles/. Accessed 14 July 2023
137. Rod igo-B a o A, Cuenca-Rome o LA, Calde ón V, Rod íguez Á, Gu ié ez-González S
(2022) Compa a i e Li e Cycle Assessmen (LCA) be ween s anda d gypsum ceiling ile and
polyu e hane gypsum ceiling ile. Ene gy Build 259. h ps://www.sciencedi ec .com/science/
a icle/pii/S037877882200038X? ia%3Dihub. Accessed 14 July 2023
Open Access This chap e is licensed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion 4.0
In e na ional License (h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0/), which pe mi s use, sha ing,
adap a ion, dis ibu ion and ep oduc ion in any medium o o ma , as long as you gi e app op ia e
c edi o he o iginal au ho (s) and he sou ce, p o ide a link o he C ea i e Commons license and
indica e i changes we e made.
The images o o he hi d pa y ma e ial in his chap e a e included in he chap e ’s C ea i e
Commons license, unless indica ed o he wise in a c edi line o he ma e ial. I ma e ial is no
included in he chap e ’s C ea i e Commons license and you in ended use is no pe mi ed by
s a u o y egula ion o exceeds he pe mi ed use, you will need o ob ain pe mission di ec ly om
he copy igh holde .
