scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Integrated life cycle assessment of a southern European house addressing different design, construction solutions, operational patterns, and heating systems

Abstract

The construction industry is responsible for a substantial fraction of materials and energy consumption, waste generation, CO2 and other pollutant emissions. Life cycle assessment (LCA) can be used to study and compare the environmental impacts of buildings under different scenarios. This study comparatively assesses the impact of several design options, envelope solutions and operational conditions on the energy life cycle (LC) of a single-family house in southern Europe (Portugal) taken as case-study. The following parameters are evaluated: location, orientation, building shape, windows placement and sizing, insulation level, exterior wall construction, operational pattern, ventilation level, heating system, and end-of-life (EoL) scenarios. The non-renewable primary energy (NRPE) results are presented for the total LC of the house. Afterward, the overall embodied energy is analyzed and the results are presented per component and LC process of the house, in order to assess the contribution of each component. Finally, different circular economy EoL scenarios are analyzed to assess their potential benefits. As buildings are typically unique, complex, and difficult to compare with each other, the results of this paper will contribute for future comparison purposes, in order to foster LCA studies devoted to Mediterranean houses.

Read accessible full text

Integrated life cycle assessment of a southern European house addressing different design, construction solutions, operational patterns, and heating systems

Author: Monteiro, Helena,Soares, Nelson
Year: 2022
DOI: 10.1016/j.egyr.2022.02.101
Source: https://estudogeral.uc.pt/bitstream/10316/100492/1/1-s2.0-S2352484722003481-main.pdf
A ailable online a www.sciencedi ec .com
ScienceDi ec
Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
www.else ie .com/loca e/egy
The 8 h In e na ional Con e ence on Ene gy and En i onmen Resea ch ICEER 2021, 13–17
Sep embe
In eg a ed li e cycle assessmen o a sou he n Eu opean house
add essing di e en design, cons uc ion solu ions, ope a ional
pa e ns, and hea ing sys ems
Helena Mon ei oa,∗, Nelson Soa esb
aLow Ca bon & Resou ce E iciency, R&Di, Ins i u o de Soldadu a e Qualidade, Po ugal
bUni e si y o Coimb a, ADAI, Depa men o Mechanical Enginee ing, Po ugal
Recei ed 22 Janua y 2022; accep ed 9 Feb ua y 2022
A ailable online xxxx
Abs ac
The cons uc ion indus y is esponsible o a subs an ial ac ion o ma e ials and ene gy consump ion, was e gene a ion,
CO2and o he pollu an emissions. Li e cycle assessmen (LCA) can be used o s udy and compa e he en i onmen al impac s
o buildings unde di e en scena ios. This s udy compa a i ely assesses he impac o se e al design op ions, en elope solu ions
and ope a ional condi ions on he ene gy li e cycle (LC) o a single- amily house in sou he n Eu ope (Po ugal) aken as case-
s udy. The ollowing pa ame e s a e e alua ed: loca ion, o ien a ion, building shape, windows placemen and sizing, insula ion
le el, ex e io wall cons uc ion, ope a ional pa e n, en ila ion le el, hea ing sys em, and end-o -li e (EoL) scena ios. The non-
enewable p ima y ene gy (NRPE) esul s a e p esen ed o he o al LC o he house. A e wa d, he o e all embodied ene gy
is analyzed and he esul s a e p esen ed pe componen and LC p ocess o he house, in o de o assess he con ibu ion o
each componen . Finally, di e en ci cula economy EoL scena ios a e analyzed o assess hei po en ial bene i s. As buildings
a e ypically unique, complex, and di icul o compa e wi h each o he , he esul s o his pape will con ibu e o u u e
compa ison pu poses, in o de o os e LCA s udies de o ed o Medi e anean houses.
© 2022 The Au ho s. Published by Else ie L d. This is an open access a icle unde he CC BY-NC-ND license
(h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Pee - e iew unde esponsibili y o he scien i ic commi ee o he 8 h In e na ional Con e ence on Ene gy and En i onmen Resea ch, ICEER, 2021.
Keywo ds: End-o -li e; LCA; Li e cycle; Medi e anean house; Pa ame ic s udy; P ima y ene gy
1. In oduc ion
The ising e idence o clima e change associa ed o he human-induced g eenhouse gas (GHG) emissions
emphasizes he need o shi human ac i i ies owa ds a low-ca bon socie y. Buildings ha e a conside able sha e o
wo ldwide ene gy use, esou ces consump ion, and was e gene a ion, among o he en i onmen al haza ds. To mee
ca bon educ ion goals, a buil en i onmen wi h educed ene gy needs, lowe GHG emissions and educed was e is
∗Co esponding au ho .
E-mail add esses: [email p o ec ed],[email p o ec ed] (H. Mon ei o).
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.egy .2022.02.101
2352-4847/© 2022 The Au ho s. Published by Else ie L d. This is an open access a icle unde he CC BY-NC-ND license (h p:
//c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Pee - e iew unde esponsibili y o he scien i ic commi ee o he 8 h In e na ional Con e ence on Ene gy and En i onmen Resea ch, ICEER,
2021.
H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
equi ed [1]. Li e cycle assessmen (LCA) is a scien i ic me hodology ha can be applied o es ima e he po en ial
en i onmen al bu dens o buildings du ing he di e en phases o hei li e cycle (LC): om ma e ial ex ac ion,
p ocessing, building cons uc ion and use, ill hei end-o -li e (EoL). The e o e, LCA can help es ablishing mo e
sus ainable buildings, wi h mo e en i onmen ally iendly cons uc ion choices and p ocedu es. I can also be used
o compa ison pu poses, o example o compa e he en i onmen al impac s o al e na i e cons uc ion and/o
di e en ope a ional scena ios, such as di e en design, building en elopes, sys ems, ope a ional condi ions, and
EoL op ions.
In he las yea s, p io i y has been gi en o educe he ope a ional ene gy o buildings and o assess cos -e icien
ene gy- eno a ion measu es [2], since ope a ion is he longes LC s age o buildings, neglec ing somehow he
ela i e en i onmen al impac s associa ed wi h cons uc ion and EoL phases. Howe e , his end is shi ing, since
educing he ope a ional impac , may boos he ela i e impac s o cons uc ion and EoL phases when an in eg a ed
LCA s udy is pe o med [3]. Mo eo e , he colossal olume o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e (C&DW) calls
o a mo e ci cula economy app oach, and he need o con e ing building EoL ma e ials in o mo e sus ainable
inno a i e alue-added p oduc s. Indeed, one o he key a ge s poin ed ou by he Eu opean Union’s g een deal is
he educ ion o he impac s o esiden ial buildings [4]. This s udy aims a compa ing he impac o se e al design
solu ions, building en elopes and ope a ional condi ions in he LC ene gy o an independen house in sou he n
Eu ope (Po ugal), aken as a case-s udy. Fo ha pu pose, some da a published by he au ho s (de o ed o he same
house) and sca e ed in he li e a u e was compiled, compa a i ely analyzed and discussed in his a icle [3,5–7].
In a i s pape , Mon ei o and F ei e [7] e alua ed se en al e na i e ypes o ex e io walls and compa ed h ee li e
cycle impac assessmen (LCIA) me hods. In a second pape , Mon ei o e al. [6] e alua ed he LC non- enewable
p ima y ene gy (NRPE) imp o emen po en ial o he house by analyzing ou hea ing/cooling ope a ional pa e ns
(di e en schedules and se -poin s), ou hea ing sys ems (ope a ing wi h di e en ene gy sou ces), and al e na i e
elec ici y gene a ion mix scena ios. In ano he wo k, Mon ei o e al. [3] e alua ed h ee ypologies o ex e io
walls, six insula ion ma e ials, i e deg ees o insula ion and ou en ila ion le els. Mo eo e , insula ion hickness
ipping-poin s we e iden i ied o al e na i e ope a ional pa e ns and walls, conside ing six en i onmen al impac
ca ego ies. Recen ly, Mon ei o e al. [5] e alua ed he impac o h ee design pa ame e s on he p ima y ene gy and
en i onmen al pe o mance o he same house: building o ien a ion, shape and openings sizing.
This pape p o ides a big pic u e o he wo k ca ied ou so a , summa izing p e ious esul s in an in eg a ed
way and compa ing he LC in luence o op ions a di e en le els. Indeed, se e al se s o al e na i e scena ios
ela ed wi h di e en design and ope a ional pa ame e s a e e alua ed (e.g., loca ion, building o ien a ion, building
shape, windows placemen and sizing, insula ion le el, ex e io wall ype, ope a ional pa e n, en ila ion le el,
HVAC sys em, e c.) and he NRPE esul s a e p esen ed o he o al LC o he house. A e wa d, he embodied
ene gy o he house is p esen ed pe p ocess and building componen in o de o e alua e he ini ial and ecu en
embodied impac o each componen . The po en ial bene i s o di e en ci cula economy EoL scena ios a e also
e alua ed.
2. Me hodology
2.1. Li e cycle assessmen and case s udy de ini ion
An independen house loca ed in sou he n Eu ope (40.2 No h, 8.4 Wes ) was aken as case s udy, based on
p e ious esea ch [3,5–7]. Inhabi ed by a household o ou people, he 133 m2building had ypical Po uguese
cons uc ion elemen s: b ick walls, conc e e s uc u e, aluminum windows. Fig. 1 shows he eas and wes ( on )
acades o he house. Following he LCA me hodology (ISO 14040/14044), a ibu ional LCA s udies ha e been
pe o med o he house du ing 50 yea s li e ime — unc ional uni . Aiming o compa a i ely analyze he
LC in luence o building op ions a di e en le els, he main pa ame e s conside ed in his pa ame ic s udy a e
p esen ed in Fig. 1. All he in o ma ion equi ed o he LC in en o y, embodied ene gy o p oduc ion, anspo ,
cons uc ion (A1–A5), main enance (B3–B4), and model simpli ica ions a e p esen ed in Re s. Mon ei o e al. [3,5,6]
and Mon ei o and F ei e [7]. LC esul s a e accoun ed o non- enewable p ima y ene gy om cumula i e ene gy
demand me hod.
To e alua e he LC impac o al e na i e building design decisions, se e al aspec s we e conside ed:
– Eigh building o ien a ions (s a ing om base case Wes –Eas and assuming a 45◦ o a ion among al e na i es)
assuming he windows a e placed in opposi e acades (as shown in Fig. 1).
527
H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
Fig. 1. Eas and wes acades o he e e ence house and main building op ions conside ed in he pa ame ic LCA.
– Di e en windows placemen : H1 Wi(Fig. 1) and H1 Wi-b, as explained in Re . Mon ei o e al. [5]. H1 Wi
scena io has i e openings placed in he on - acade and six openings in he back- acade, while H1 Wi-b
al e na i e has he same windows (numbe and a ea) as H1 Wi( o he same ia ea ac o ), bu place hem in
h ee acades: wo in he on , se en in he la e al, and wo in he back- acade.
– Fou window- o-wall a ios (WWR): 5, 10, 15 and 20% WWR. This means ha he in luence o inc emen al
window sizes (Wi,i=1, 2, 3, 4) we e analyzed o he windows placemen op ions e e ed. The base-case
building (Fig. 1) co esponds o a 5% WWR (Wi,i=1) wi h all windows o alizing 11 m2 acade a ea [5].
– Al e na i e building shapes: he compac base case (H1), a single-g ound loo house (H2), and a less compac
house wi h wo loo s (H3).
Mo e de ails abou his pa ame ic s udy can be ound in Re . Mon ei o e al. [5].
To assess he impac o he ex e io walls h ee cons uc ions we e e alua ed: double hollow b ick mason y,
ligh weigh conc e e block mason y, and wooden wall (wood ame and cladding). Mo e in o ma ion abou he
ex e io walls can be ound in Re . Mon ei o e al. [3]. Mo eo e , i e insula ion hickness (0, 3, 6, 9 and 12 cm),
and six insula ion ma e ials (XPS, XPS-CO2, co k, ock wool, EPS, PUR) we e e alua ed o he base b ick-wall
case house [3].
To assess he in luence o he ope a ional condi ions, h ee di e en ope a ional pa e ns we e conside ed:
OP100, OP50 and OP25. The OP100 conside s con inuous indoo he mal com o condi ions 365 days a yea , wi h
empe a u e se -poin s be ween 20–25◦C (hea ing–cooling season). I also conside s 4 W/m2o in e nal hea gains
pe use ul a ea. The OP50 ep esen s an a e age occupancy o he house wi h a medium HVAC le el, equi ing
a ound hal o he OP100’s ene gy consump ion (simula ed). The OP25 ope a ional pa e n exempli ies a modes
occupancy and a low HVAC le el, compa able o s a is ical da a ( om Po uguese households), and i includes only
a qua e o OP100’s simula ed ene gy consump ion. The annual HVAC ene gy demand o he building al e na i es
we e ob ained using DesignBuilde 3.0, which uns on Ene gyPlus he mal dynamic simula ion. Mo e de ails on he
ope a ional pa e ns and ene gy simula ions can be ound in Re s. Mon ei o e al. [3,5,6]. Fou o al en ila ion le els
(0.3, 0.6, 0.9 and 1.2 ac/h) we e also conside ed in he pa ame ic s udy as explained in Re . Mon ei o e al. [3]. Six
loca ions we e also conside ed (Coimb a, B aganc¸a, ´
E o a, Po o, Lisbon and Fa o) as p esen ed in [8]. To e alua e
he impac o he hea ing sys em selec ion, ou sys ems and h ee elec ic gene a ion mixes we e conside ed as
epo ed by Mon ei o e al. [6]: esis ance hea e s, hea pump (ai –wa e ), na u al gas condensing boile and wood
pelle s boile .
Las ly, o assess he EoL s age impac , h ee EoL scena ios o C&DW we e modeled: EoL 1 (land ill); EoL 2
(ma e ial ecycling o seconda y cons uc ion wo ks eplacing g a el and back illing ma e ials); EoL 3 (ma e ial
ecycling o subs i u e bo h g a el/back illing ma e ials (50%) and cemen powde s (50%), and window and doo
elemen s eco e y and euse).
528
H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
3. Resul s and discussion
3.1. Join in luence o building en elope, design, and ope a ional condi ions
Fig. 2 shows he a ia ion on li e cycle NRPE o he house induced by he al e na i e cons uc ion, design, and
ope a ional op ions s udied. The a ia ion is coded in h ee colo s: black ba s esul om a ying bo h embodied
and ope a ional ene gy; ed ba s, p esen mainly an ope a ional ene gy a ia ion; blue ba s, depic ed a a ia ion due
o embodied ene gy. As can be seen, many cons uc ion and design pa ame e s a ec bo h ope a ion and embodied
impac (black), usually wi h ade-o s. Ne e heless, some ope a ional and design pa ame e s may hold iden ical
embodied ene gy and a ec di e en ly he ope a ional equi emen s ( ed).
Fig. 2. LC NRPE a ia ion o he base case house o he building en elope, design and ope a ional op ions assessed (black ba s esul om
a ying bo h embodied and ope a ional ene gy; ed ba s, p esen mainly an ope a ional ene gy a ia ion; blue ba s, depic ed a a ia ion due
o embodied ene gy).
Rega ding use s in luence, he simula ed hea ing and cooling loads o achie e a con inuous com o condi ion
(OP100), ep esen 43% o LC ene gy, being a abo e ypical ene gy equi emen s o Po uguese households. As
Po uguese dwelle s usually adap o widesp ead in e io com o condi ions compa ed o no h-Eu opeans, he
ope a ional equi emen s in a mild clima e can be be ween a qua e o a hal o OP100, which esul s in a educed
LC impac o ope a ional s age (16%–28%), e en wi hou changing he house embodied bu dens.
Al e na i e cons uc ion op ions known o c i ically in luence he he mal pe o mance o buildings we e also
assessed, such insula ion hickness and en ila ion a es. Despi e he mal insula ion is usually conside ed one o he
key measu es o cu -down hea ing equi emen s, esul s show ha adop ing a lowe en ila ion le el (an ai - igh
house wi h 0.3 ac/h) has a highe in luence han inc easing he mal insula ion hickness abo e 6 cm o educe LC
NRPE. Resul s also depic ha high en ila ion le els ( o ins ance, 1.2 ac/h, due o use s) can easily hwa he
bene i o ha ing an adequa e he mal insula ion le el. In addi ion, he LC p ima y ene gy sa ings achie ed wi h
an inc eased insula ion le el (e.g., om 3 o 9 cm XPS) a e in e io o he educ ion a ained by using al e na i e
cons uc ion componen s such wooden walls, as a subs i u e o he base-case b ick walls. These esul s highligh he
impo ance o accoun ing he embodied ene gy, especially in new Medi e anean houses, ag eeing wi h o he LC
s udies [9,10]. Mo e speci ically, his wo k e eals ha he li e cycle impac o use phase he mal equi emen s may
be signi ican ly lowe han hose inco po a ed in building componen s. Thus, a building design s age, designe s
should conside he in luence o speci ic building componen s and hei ini ial and ecu ing embodied ene gy,
as a decision ac o , since i may ep esen 3 o 7 imes he he mal ope a ional ene gy (i OP50 wi h a hea
pump o a wood pelle s hea e a e selec ed, espec i ely). In buildings and clima e condi ions whe e he mal
ene gy needs ha e a po en ially small con ibu ion, he cu en building egula ions, which a e mainly ocused on
529
H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
ope a ional pe o mance, may miss ele an LC impac s and oppo uni ies o imp o emen owa ds a low ca bon
buil en i onmen .
Analyzing he impac o simple design decisions (house o ien a ion, window sizing and dis ibu ion, building
shape), he s udy shows ha hese may induce a li e cycle NRPE a ia ion ha exceeds he e ec o a ying he mal
insula ion om 3 o 9 cm. Thus, i he in luence o design op ions is dis ega ded om a LC pe spec i e, un hinking
design may o e shadow he po en ial use s age sa ings o using adequa e he mal insula ion and ai igh ness.
Indeed, simple design choices appea o be as signi ican as he en elope cons uc ion op ions and hence should be
simul aneously assessed.
Li e cycle NRPE is also shown o be highly in luenced by ope a ional condi ions: ope a ional pa e ns ( ep e-
sen ing al e na i e o ms o inhabi a building), HVAC sys ems, and he ene gy supply chain. Unde mild clima ic
en i onmen s and cul u ally low ope a ional pa e ns, designing he buildings o easonable ope a ional condi ions
ha ep esen he use s’ beha io a iabili y is impe a i e.
A new dwelling wi h elec ic hea ing o e en wi h a na u al gas condensing boile may be esponsible o a
highe LC NRPE han a less insula ed house using a wood-pelle s boile , despi e he new building imp o ed he mal
pe o mance and lowe inal ene gy needs. P e ious li e a u e also poin ed ou ha , depending on he hea ing sys em
adop ed, passi e buildings may ha e close o highe LC impac han s anda d o con en ional buildings [11]. Some
au ho s de ended ha he supply chain o ene gy sou cing hea ing equi emen s had a g ea e in luence on p ima y
ene gy han building cons uc ion op ions [12].
The esul s o his pape suppo p eceding s udies, ex ending hei each o a di e en clima ic and ope a ional
con ex . Typically, he cold clima e passi e dwellings p e iously analyzed a e designed o ha e con inuous in e io
he mal com o , being cha ac e ized by hick insula ion laye s, iple-glazing windows, and en ila ion sys ems
wi h hea eco e y. In con as , in his esea ch, he s udied building is a s anda d Po uguese new house, which
mee s he passi e house s anda d, due o mild sou he n Eu opean clima ic condi ions (i.e. Coimb a loca ion) and
cha ac e is ic Po uguese dwelle beha io (pa ial and in e mi en use o HVAC sys ems). Assessing di e en
Po uguese loca ions showed ha he ope a ional s age magni ude can be signi ican ly inc eased in cold-win e
and ho -summe loca ions such as B aganc¸a, bu i emained small in o he Po uguese loca ions (i.e. Coimb a,
Lisbon, Fa o, Po o).
The use s age NRPE o he house a ied abou 37%, solely due o he changes o he Po uguese elec ic
gene a ion mix (o e 5 yea s). Such wide a ia ion did no a ec he selec ion o he HVAC sys em wi h he lowes
NRPE (wood pelle s boile ), bu wi h he elec ic mix ha ing a lowe impac , using a esis ance hea ing sys em may
ha e simila NRPE o using a na u al gas boile . O he au ho s [11], s udied he e ec o he ene gy supply chain
and elec ici y p oduc ion mix in ope a ional esul s. They highligh ed ha besides hea ing needs, o he household
ene gy needs can highly in luence o al ope a ional impac , since hese ep esen a signi ican sha e o new houses
ope a ion. Lowe ing he LC impac o hese needs can be mos ly achie ed h ough ene gy-conscious use beha io ,
appliances e iciency and supply-chain imp o emen s.
3.2. Embodied ene gy and EoL scena ios
Fig. 3 shows he embodied ene gy pe cons uc ion componen pe li e cycle o p esen hei magni ude in e ms
o ini ial (cons uc ion A1–A5) and ecu en (main enance and epai B2–B3) embodied impac s, compa ed o
ope a ional ene gy use (B6) and o he al e na i e EoL scena ios (C1–C3) including he po en ial a oided bu dens
(D), when applicable.
NRPE esul s a e p esen ed o he whole house o e 50 yea s. Fig. 3shows ha he p ima y ene gy associa ed o
he house componen s (cons uc ion A1–A5, and main enance- epai B2–B3) was oughly 4.7 GJ/m2, om which
87% was equi ed o cons uc he house, p io i s use (A1–A5). These quan i a i e esul s a e align wi h he ange
ound on p e ious li e a u e: 3.1–7.6 GJ/m2[13,14]. The a io among use phase B2–B3 ac i i ies and he ini ial
embodied ene gy is small (15%), which is jus i ied by socio-economic d i e s and he way Po uguese dwelle s
inhabi and main ain hei buildings. In he con ex co e ed, main enance ac i i ies a e s ill mos ly co ec i e, as
poin ed ou by o he s udies [15].
The mos impac ul building cons uc ion elemen we e he ex e io walls (double hollow b ick), which we e
accoun able o abou 40% o he house ini ial embodied ene gy (A1–A5) and abou hal o ecu ing ene gy (B2–
B3). I is in e es ing o no e ha he embodied ene gy o ex e io walls was highe han he he mal use s age ene gy
530

H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
Fig. 3. House LC p ima y ene gy pe LC s age and cons uc ion componen .
o he house wi h OP50 (B6). O he signi ican cons uc ion componen s in e ms o ini ial embodied ene gy we e
by descending o de : he loo s (23%), he oo (16%), and he in e io walls (9%). These esul s a e aligned wi h
p e ious li e a u e o Medi e anean dwellings ha ound ha bo h ex e nal walls, and slabs ( loo s and oo s) we e
he elemen s ha a ec ed mos he house’s embodied ene gy [16].
The analysis o he EoL esul s shows ha land ill (EoL 1) is he wo s scena io. Demolish, anspo and land ill
mo e han 230 ons o C&DW ep esen s an addi ional LC NRPE o 8% (C1–C4). The wo scena ios assuming
ecycling (EoL 2 and EoL 3), ake ad an age o C&DW, p esen ing a ound 6% addi ional NRPE o demolish
and p ocess hese ma e ials o be ecycled (C1–C3). When conside ing a sys em expansion, ecycling a oids he
ex ac ion o p ima y ma e ials (such as g a el and back illing ma e ial) o se ing signi ican p ima y ene gy (i.e.,
a ne educ ion o 16% o A1–A5 in EoL 2 and 64% in EoL 3). O e all, he esul s show ha ci cula economy
solu ions, namely ocused in disman ling and euse building componen s (e.g., doo s and windows) and o use
mine al C&DW o p oduce seconda y agg ega es and powde able o eplace bu densome p ima y ma e ials (e.g.,
cemen ) should be p e e ed (EoL 3). Thus, imp o ing EoL o C&DW and adop ing ci cula economy solu ions
can educe he embodied ene gy le els in buildings and p omo e esou ce e iciency
4. Conclusion
This s udy compa a i ely assessed he impac o al e na i e design op ions, building en elope solu ions and
ope a ional condi ions in he LC ene gy o a sou he n Eu opean independen house loca ed in Po ugal. In he
pa ame ic s udy, al e na i e pa ame e s we e e alua ed: loca ion, building o ien a ion, building shape, window
placemen and sizing, insula ion le el, ex e io wall ypology, ope a ional pa e n, en ila ion le el, hea ing sys em,
and end-o -li e scena io. I is concluded ha in mild Medi e anean clima e, he embodied ene gy o cons uc ion
elemen s (e.g. conc e e s uc u e, slabs, b ick ex e io and in e io walls) may ep esen mos o LC NRPE o houses.
The esul s sugges ha design op ions a e as signi ican as he en elope cons uc ion op ions and he e o e, hey
should be simul aneously add essed. C&DW ep esen s massi e was e lows. The EoL scena ios assessed showed
ha new ci cula economy solu ions, namely ocused in disman ling and euse building componen s (e.g., doo s
and windows) and o p oduce seconda y agg ega es and powde s om C&DW o eplace bu densome p ima y
ma e ials (e.g. cemen ) can p omo e ma e ial esou ce e iciency and educe he embodied ene gy le els o u u e
buil en i onmen and cons uc ion wo ks.
CRediT au ho ship con ibu ion s a emen
Helena Mon ei o: In es iga ion, Fo mal analysis, Valida ion, Visualiza ion, W i ing – o iginal d a , W i ing –
e iew & edi ing. Nelson Soa es: W i ing – o iginal d a , Visualiza ion, W i ing – e iew & edi ing.
Decla a ion o compe ing in e es
The au ho s decla e ha hey ha e no known compe ing inancial in e es s o pe sonal ela ionships ha could
ha e appea ed o in luence he wo k epo ed in his pape .
531
H. Mon ei o and N. Soa es Ene gy Repo s 8 (2022) 526–532
Acknowledgmen s
This wo k builds on esea ch unded by FCT SFRH/BD/33736/2009 and, i is aligned wi h esea ch ocused on
indus ial sus ainabili y o building and cons uc ion indus y de eloped in he scope o Eu opean Union’s Ho izon
2020 esea ch and inno a ion p og amme unde he G an s Ag eemen 894511, and 810764.
Re e ences
[1] Soa es N, Bas os J, Pe ei a LD, Soa es A, Ama al AR, Asadi E, Rod igues E, Lamas FB, Mon ei o H, Lopes MAR, Gaspa AR. A
e iew on cu en ad ances in he ene gy and en i onmen al pe o mance o buildings owa ds a mo e sus ainable buil en i onmen .
Renew Sus ain Ene gy Re 2017;77:845–60. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j. se .2017.04.027.
[2] Palma P, Gou eia JP, Ba bosa R. How much will i cos ? An ene gy eno a ion analysis o he Po uguese dwelling s ock. Sus ain
Ci ies Soc 2022;78:103607. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.scs.2021.103607.
[3] Mon ei o H, F ei e F, Fe nández JE. Li e-cycle assessmen o al e na i e en elope cons uc ion o a new house in sou h-wes e n
eu ope: Embodied and ope a ional magni ude. Ene gies 2020;13(4145). h p://dx.doi.o g/10.3390/en13164145.
[4] Ta a es V, Soa es N, Raposo N, Ma ques P, F ei e F. P e ab ica ed e sus con en ional cons uc ion: compa ing li e-cycle impac s o
al e na i e s uc u al ma e ials. J Build Eng 2021;41:102705. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2021.102705.
[5] Mon ei o H, F ei e F, Soa es N. Li e cycle assessmen o a sou h Eu opean house add essing building design op ions o o ien a ion,
window sizing and building shape. J Build Eng 2021;39:102276. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2021.102276.
[6] Mon ei o H, Fe nández JE, F ei e F. Compa a i e li e-cycle ene gy analysis o a new and an exis ing house: The signi icance o
occupan ’s habi s, building sys ems and embodied ene gy. Sus ain Ci ies Soc 2016;26:507–18. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.scs.2016.06.002.
[7] Mon ei o H, F ei e F. Li e-cycle assessmen o a house wi h al e na i e ex e io walls: Compa ison o h ee impac assessmen me hods.
Ene gy Build 2012;47:572–83. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.enbuild.2011.12.032.
[8] Mon ei o H. Comp ehensi e li e cycle assessmen o new houses in po ugal: building design, en elope, and ope a ional condi ions (Ph.D.
hesis), Facul y o Sciences and Technology o Uni e si y o Coimb a (FCTUC; 2017.
[9] Ajayi SO, Oyedele LO, Ilo i OM. Changing signi icance o embodied ene gy: A compa a i e s udy o ma e ial speci ica ions and
building ene gy sou ces. J Build Eng 2019;23:324–33. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2019.02.008.
[10] Asd ubali F, G azieschi G. Li e cycle assessmen o ene gy e icien buildings. Ene gy Rep 2020;6:270–85. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/
j.egy .2020.11.144.
[11] S ephan A, C aw o d RH, de My enae e K. A comp ehensi e assessmen o he li e cycle ene gy demand o passi e houses. Appl
Ene gy 2013;112:23–34. h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.apene gy.2013.05.076.
[12] Gus a sson L, Joelsson A. Li e cycle p ima y ene gy analysis o esiden ial buildings. Ene gy Build 2010;42:210–20. h p://dx.doi.o g/
10.1016/j.enbuild.2009.08.017.
[13] Bas os J, Ba e man SA, F ei e F. Signi icance o mobili y in he li e-cycle assessmen o buildings. Build Res In 2016;44:376–93.
h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1080/09613218.2016.1097407.
[14] Ramesh T, P akash R, Shukla KKK. Li e cycle ene gy analysis o buildings: An o e iew. Ene gy Build 2010;42:1592–600.
h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.enbuild.2010.05.007.
[15] Rod igues C, F ei e F. En i onmen al impac ade-o s in building en elope e o i s a egies. In J Li e Cycle Assess 2017;22.
h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1007/s11367-016-1064-2.
[16] Nem y F, Uihlein A. En i onmen al imp o emen po en ials o esiden ial buildings (IMPRO-Building). Bauphysik 2008. h p:
//dx.doi.o g/10.2791/38942.
532