scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Some classes of divergence measures between fuzzy subsets and between fuzzy partitions

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to present and study one important class of divergence measure between fuzzy subsets, and one important class of divergence measure between fuzzy partitions, each of them having some specific properties. In the first case, the divergence measure attempts to quantify the degree of difference between two fuzzy subsets $\A$ and $\B$ by comparing the fuzziness of both $\A$ and $\B$ with the fuzziness of the intermediate fuzzy subset. In the second case, we use this divergence between subsets to measure the divergence between partitions.

Read accessible full text

Some classes of divergence measures between fuzzy subsets and between fuzzy partitions

Author: Montes Rodríguez, Susana,Gil Álvarez, Pedro Angel
Publisher: Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya. Secció de Matemàtiques i Informàtica
Year: 1998
Source: https://upcommons.upc.edu/bitstream/2099/3529/1/12montes.pdf
sYbs m 7BP ]B8}Z$  x
w
dM
D
1xnT1Ex
7B8 ]jsRRR BP *$% { sRZR b
3Z99k 7ZARR s I b 3Z99k _s$$B R
7ZRs s B R s I _IB p$j
*}ss8 B I eRsI?R${s  y! k *
= $%R$k BP !%$IB ] ]sj%B 7BjB R  nn(d !%$IB 7}s$
T8s$jU R8}IBo}$ B {{ZZ $B%$R
VARs{
qY s$8 BP Y$R }s} $R B }R  s I RZIk B  $8}Bs  {jsRR BP
I$% { 8sRZ Ab PZ99k RZARR s I B  $8}Bs  {jsRR BP I$%T
 { 8sRZ Ab PZ99k }s$$B R s{Y BP Y8 Ys%$  RB8 R}{$h{
}B}$R y Y hR {sR Y I$% { 8sRZ s8}R B JZs $Pk Y
I BP I$& { Ab bB PZ99k RZARR

s I

4
Ak {B8}s$  Y
PZ99$ RR BP ABY

s I

4
b$Y Y PZ99$ RR BP Y $ 8I$s PZ99k RZAR
y Y R{B I {sR b ZR Y$R I$% { Ab RZARR B 8sRZ Y
I$% { Ab }s$$B R
kbBIRU
I$% { 8sRZ jB{sj I$% { PZ99$ RR 8sRZ PZ99k
}s$$B 
d y BIZ{$B
!Z bB, sIR Y RZIk BP Z {s$ k sRRB{$sI b$Y RkR8R $ s PZ99k  T
%$B 8  qY Rs$  }B$  BP BZ Rs{Y YsR A Y s-$B8s${ $ PB8s$B
YBk BP 3B s I Fs8}?I3 $
w
>;H
D
 bY Z {s$ k $R I${jk sRRB{$T
sI b$Y s {Bjj{$B BP
w
{$R}
D
RZARR BP s R}s{  y Y Ps8 BP Y$R YBk $ $R
}BRR$Aj B ZRR Ys Y -$RR s Ps$jk RB  js$B RY$} Ab Z {s$ k
w
s I $ PB8s$B
D
s I PZ99$ RR s I Ab Z {s$ k s I {jsRR${sj I$% {
y Y$R R}{ s PZ Is8 sj bB, YsR A I%jB}I Ak * NZ{sTq8$ $ >nH
bYB $ BIZ{I s ,$ I BP 8sRZ BP PZ99$ RR
w
Y B }BAsA$j$R${  B}k BP s
PZ99k R
D
AsRI B s }BAsA$j$R${ Z {s$ k 8sRZ
y BZ B}$ $B  Y A$I Ab Y
w
{$R}
D
$ PB8s$B
w
b$Y B b$YBZ
}BAsA$j$k
D
s I 8sRZR BP Z {s$ k s I $8}{$R$B $ PZ99k  %$B 8 R
8sk j$ $ bYs b P B sR I$% { A{sZR BP Y s sjBk b$Y Y {jsRR${sj
8s $  BP Y 8 ZRI Ak %s$BZR sZYBR
w
>H 
D
$ {B8}s$  bB }BAsA$j$k
I$R$AZ$B R ! { b Ys% {Yss{$9I s I RZI$I Y 8sRZ BP Y I$& {

G;R TR4RIT
{ Y $ Y$R }s} $R RZ}}BI $ }s A k *py]Oq ps  WB _ ;Tdn1M
1xn
1x;
7 B R m _ p$j
Ab bB
w
PZ99k B {$R}
D
RZARR Ys $R Y I$% { 8sRZ Ab PZ99k
RZARR
w
R >MH
D
 BZ Zj$8s BA`{$% {B R$RR $ ZR$  Y$R 8sRZ B %sjZs
Y PZ99$ RR s I
B Y Z {s$ k
qY RZIk BP Y bsk B 8sRZ Y I$& { Ab bB RZARR B bY${Y
b b$jj P B sR I$% { Ab RZARR $R $% $ 7{$B 1 s I b RZIk
8s$ jk Y {sR bY Y I$% { $R BAs$ I PB8 PZ99$ RR 8sRZR *}sT
$  PB8 Y$R b$I {jsRR BP I$% { 8sRZ b RZIk s jB BP }B}$R qY
bsk B 8sRZ Y PZ99$ RR BP s PZ99k }s$$B R s I Y Ih $$B BP I$% {
Ab PZ99k }s$$B R b$jj A $% $ 7{$B n y Y$R R{$B b RZIk sjRB s
}s${Zjs {jsRR BP I$% { Ab }s$$B R bY${Y $R Y {jsRR BP I$% {R
$ I} I  BP Y 8sRZ
1 *$% { 8sRZ PB8 PZ99$ RR 8sRZ
qY 8sRZ BP Y I$& { BP bB PZ99k RZARR $R Ih I s-$B8s${sjjk B Y
AsR$R BP Y PBjjBb$  sZsj }B}$RU
T
y $R s B s$% s I Rk88${ PZ {$B BP Y bB PZ99k RZARR B A
{B8}sI
T
y A{B8R 9B bY Y bB RR {B$ {$I
T
y I{sRR sR Y bB RZARR A{B8 X8B R$8$js" $ RB8 R R
GYsR $ $R sRk B s sjk${sjjk PB8Zjs Y hR s Y R{B I {B I$$B  Y
Y$I B  I} IR B Y PB8sj$9s$B BP Y {B {} BP X8B R$8$js" G AsR
BZ s}}Bs{Y B Y Ps{ Ys $P b sII
w
$ Y R R BP Z $B
D
s RZAR
"
g
B ABY
PZ99k RZARR
"
s I
"
4
 b BAs$ bB RZARR bY${Y s {jBR B s{Y BY Y
Rs8 Ys}} R b$Y Y $ R{$B  7B b }B}BR Y PBjjBb$ 
*h $$B 1d
w
>MH
D
N

A Y Z $%R s I j
"
h
w

D
A Y Ps8$jk BP Y PZ99k
RZAR BP

 V 8s}
;
U
"
h
w

D

"
h
w

D

{p
$R s I$% { 8sRZ $P s I B jk
$P

"
,
"
4
;
"
h
w

D
 Rs$RPk Y PBjjBb$  {B I$$B RU
d
;
w
"
,
"
4
D
)
;
w
"
4,
"
D

1
;
w
"
,
"
D
)(

n
8s-
;
w
"

"
g,
"
4

"
g
D
,;
w
"

"
g,
"
4

"
g
D
i
;
w
"
,
"
4
D
,

"
g
;
"
h
w

D


"
g
;
"
h
w

D

V Y A$ $  BP Y$R R{$B b Ys% $ I${sI Ys $ $R sZsj B sRRZ8
Ys Y I$% { $R B s$% Y$R {B I$$B YsR B A $ {jZII $ Y
s-$B8R R$ { $ {s A IIZ{I PB8 Y8
3B8 Bb B  b b$jj {B R$I B jk Y {sR bY  )
?
@
,?

,333,?
z
i
$R
h $ y Y$R {sR $P b {B R$I Y {BZ}jR
w
"
,
"
4
D
,
w
"

?
7
i
,
"
4

?
7
i
D
bY${Y
7B8 ]jsRRR BP *$% { sRZR b 3Z99k 7ZARR
1xx
B jk I$& $ Y $
0_
j8 
w
$ YsR A {Ys I PB8
w
"
w
?
7
D
,
"
4
w
?
7
D
D
B
w
d
,
d
D
D

$ R8R sZsj B RZ}}BR Ys Y %s$s$B BP I$% { B jk I} IR B bYs
YsR A {Ys I qYZR b $ BIZ{ Y PBjjBb$ 
*h $$B 11
w
>MH
D
V I$% { 8sRZ YsR Y jB{sj }B}k
w
B A$4k X$R
jB{sj"
D
$P

"
,
"
4
;
"
h
w

D
,

?
7
;

 b Ys% Ys
;
w
"
,
"
4
D

;
w
"

?
7
i
,
"
4

?
7
i
D
)
_
w
"
w
?
7
D
,
"
4
w
?
7
D
D
3
qY$R }B}k $R sZsj $  sj AZ B sjj I$% { YsR Y jB{sj }B}k
V bsk B {Yss{$9 Y jB{sj I$% {R $R $ Y PBjjBb$  Rs8 
_B}BR$$B 1n
w
>MH
D
V 8s}}$ 
;
U
"
h
w

D

"
h
w

D

{p
 bY

$R s h $
Ps8
)
?
@
,?

,333,?
z
i
$R s jB{sj I$% { $P s I B jk $P Y -$RR s PZ {$B
_
U>(
,
dH

>(
,
dH

{p
RZ{Y Ys
;
w
"
,
"
4
D
)
z
!
7
@
_
w
"
w
?
7
D
,
"
4
w
?
7
D
D
s I
$
D
_
w
?,
D
)
_
w
,?
D
,

?,
;
>(
,
dH

$$
D
_
w
?,?
D
)(
,

?
;
>(
,
dH

$$$
D
_
w
?,F
D

8s-
_
w
?,
D
,_
w
,F
D
i
,

?, ,F
;
>(
,
dH
b$Y
?c cF

qY }{I$  }B}BR$$B sjjBbR ZR B {B RZ{ jB{sj I$% { PB8 s bBT
R$I PZ {$B
_
 7B8$8R RB8 I$
^{Zj$R 8sk s$R $ %$Pk$  {B I$$B $$$
D

7B b RsI Y PBjjBb$ 
]BBjjsk 1;
w
>MH
D
]B I$$B $$$
D
$ _B}BR$$B 1n {s A }js{I Ak $$$
1
D
_
w
N
,
D
$R s PZ {$B I{sR$  $
>(
,
H
s I $ {sR$  $
>
,
dH

qY hR bsk b {YBBR B {B8}s Y 88ARY$} %sjZR $R Ys BP {B8}s$ 
Y PZ99$ RR BP ABY
"
s I
"
4
b$Y Y PZ99$ RR BP Y $ 8I$s PZ99k RZAR
qY$R jsIR B s b$I {jsRR BP 8sRZR y Ps{ Y$R bsR Y Rs$  }B$  BP BZ
Rs{Y
N ZR {B R$I Y {jsRR BP PZ99$ RR 8sRZR >xH
w
BP jB{sj k}
D
$% Ak
W
w
"
D
)
!
?
%
;

`
w
"
w
?
7
D
D
1xE
7 B R m _ p$j
bY
`
U>(
,
dH

{p
L
$R s {B {s% PZ {$B  $ {sR$  $ >(
,
d
b
1H Rk88${ b$Y
R}{ B Y }B$  d
b
1 b$Y
`
w
(
D
)
`
w
d
D
)(
qY  sB BP Y PZ99$ RR
w
PZ {$B
`
D
{s sjRB  s s jB{sj I$% {
y Ps{ Ak }BR$ 
_
w
?,
D
)
`
M
?
L
1
9

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
D
1
,

?,
;
>(
,
dH
b BAs$ s PZ {$B
_
bY${Y YsR sjj Y }B}$R JZ$I $ _B}BR$$B 1n $P
`
$R b${ I$& $sAj RB Ys
;
w
"
,
"
4
D
)
z
!
7
)d
_
w
"
w
?
7
D
,
"
4
w
?
7
D
D
$R s jB{sj I$% { 8sRZ
qB }B% Y$R $ $R RZ^{$  B }B% Ys
_
Rs$RhR Y {B I$$B R $
D
$$$
D
$
]BBjjsk 1; yP
?,
s $ >(
,
dH b Ys% YsU
$
D
_
w
?,
D
)
`
w
?
L
1
D

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
D
1
)
`
w
L
?
1
D

`
w
D
L
`
w
?
D
1
)
_
w
,?
D
,

?,
;
>(
,
dH
$$
D
_
w
?,?
D
)
`
w
?
L
?
1
D

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
?
D
1
)
`
w
?
D

`
w
?
D
)(
$$$
D
G I B Ak
_
Y PZ {$B
_
w
N
,
D
PB s h-I
 7$ {
_
$R s RZ8 BP
I$& $sAj PZ {$B R $ $R sjRB I$& $sAj s I Y {
_
w
?
D
)
`
w
?
L
1
D

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
D
1)
p
(
(?_
w
?
D
)d
1
(
(?`
w
?
L
1
D

(
(?
`
w
?
D
1
7$ {
`
$R {B {s% b Ys% Ys
(
!
(?
!
`
w
?
D
c
(
,

?
;
>(
,
dH s I YPB Y
PZ {$B
(
(?
`
w
?
D
$R $ {sR$  bY {
F
?c
)
p
1
N
?c?
L
)
p
(
(?
`
w
?
L
1
D
c
(
(?
`
w
?
D
?k
)
p
1
N
?k?
L
)
p
(
(?
`
w
?
L
1
D
k
(
(?
`
w
?
D
3
qYZR
(
(?
_
w
?
D
$R s$% $P
?c
s I }BR$$% $P
?k
 Y$R $8}j$R Ys
_
w
?
D
Ys$R
_
w
N
,
D
 $R I{sR$  $ >(
,
H s I $ {sR$  $ >
,
dH
V }s${Zjs $8}Bs  {sR BP Y$R k} $R $% Ak Y 8sRZ BAs$ I
PB8 Y * NZ{sTq8$ $  B}k
w
>nH
D
 3Z {$B
_
BAs$ I PB8 $R
`
PZ {$B

?
jB
?

w
d

?
D
jB
w
d

?
D
$R I}${I $ 3$Z d
y R8R B A %$I  PB8 Y hZ Ys
_
$ {sRR sR
/
?

/
$ {sRR
ss$ R $R 8s-$8Z8 s Y }B$ R
w
(
,
d
D
s I
w
d
,
(
D
w
_
w
(
,
d
D
)
_
w
d
,
(
D
)
`
w
d
1
D
s I
$R 8$ $8Z8 s Y }B$ R
?
)
w
_
w
?,?
D
)(
D
D

7B8 ]jsRRR BP *$% { sRZR b 3Z99k 7ZARR
1x
3$Z dU ps}Y${ BP
_
w
?,
D

VR s -s8}j j ZR {B R$I Y RZARR
4
,
4
4,
4
g
w
R qsAj AjBb
D
BP s
Z $%R  b$Y PBZ j8 R Ih I Ak
w
YR RR s I}${I $ 3$Z 1
D


?
d
?
1
?
n
?
;
4
(
3
n (
3
 (
3
E (
3
1
4
4
(
3
1x (
3
M (
3
E (
3
d
4
g
(
3
(x (
3
; (
3
 (
3
x
4
;
(
3
 (
3
d (
3
d (
3

3$Z 1U ps}Y${ BP
4

4
4

4
g
s I
4
;


1xM
7 B R m _ p$j
3B YR RR b BAs$ Ys
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
)(
3
(n
,;
w
4
,
4
g
D
)(
3
;E
,;
w
4
,
4
;
D
)d
3
E(
3
qY I$% { 8sRZR RYBb Ys
4
$R %k R$8$js B
4
4
s I JZ$ I$&  PB8
4
;
 WB${ Ys Y sARBjZ 8s-$8Z8
;
{s sRRZ8 $ Y$R {sR $R $% Ak
;
Ey?
);
qY I$% { AsRI B * NZ{sTq8$ $:R  B}k {s A  sj$9I y Ps{
$ >1H $ bsR }B% Ys s PZ99$ RR 8sRZ {s A BAs$ I PB8 s k Z {s$ k
8sRZ
I
 }B%$II $ Rs$RhR Y _$ {$}j BP qs RP y Y$R {sR b {s
Ih 
`
w
0
D
)
I
w
0,
d

0
D
s I Y I$% { 8sRZ s,R Y PB8
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
)
3
?
;

^
I
XX 4
L
4
4
1
~
w
?
D
,
X4
L
4
4
1
~

w
?
D
~

I
w
4
w
?
D
,
4

w
?
D
D
L
I
w
4
4
w
?
D
,
4
4

w
?
D
D
1

3
y $R sRk B {B $9 Ys $P
;
$R {B RZ{I sR sAB% PB8 s PZ99$ RR 8sT
RZ Y $ {s A -}RRI $ 8R BP PZ {$B
W
sR PBjjBbRU
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
)
W
w
E
w
4
,
4
4
D
D

W
w
4
D
L
W
w
4
4
D
1
D
bY
E
w
4
,
4
4
D
$R Y Xs%s" BP Y RZARR
4
,
4
4
 Ys $R Y PZ99k R Ih I
Ak
E
w
4
,
4
4
D
w
?
D
)
4
w
?
D
L
4
4
w
?
D
1
,

?
;

3
y Y PBjjBb$  }B}BR$$B R b RsAj$RY RB8 $8}Bs  }B}$R BP Y$R {jsRR
BP I$% { 8sRZR bY${Y -}RR sZsj {Yss{$R${R BP Y 8s $  BP BZ
8sRZ 3B8 Bb B  $ Y$R R{$B  b {B R$I Ys
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
)
W
w
E
w
4
,
4
4
D
D

W
w

D
L
W
w

4
D
1
 bY
W
$R s k jB{sj PZ99$ RR 8sRZ
_B}BR$$B 1x
N
"
s I
"
4
A $
"
h
w

D
yP
"
$R RYs} Ys
"
4
w
/
"
w
?
D

d
b
1
/
/
"
4
w
?
D

d
b
1
/
,

?
;

D
Y
;
w
"
,
"

D
$R s Ys B JZsj B
;
w
"
4,
"
4

D
 Ys $R
$P
"
U
"
4
Y
;
w
"
,
"

D

;
w
"
4,
"
4

D
3
_BBP
7$ {
W
w
"
D
)
W
w
"

D

W
w
"
4
D
)
W
w
"
4

D
s I

L


1
w
?
D
)

4
L

4

1
w
?
D
)
d
1
,

?
;
 Y
;
w
"
,
"

D

;
w
"
4,
"
4

D
3
qY$R 8s R sR bBZjI A sZsj Ys sR Y PZ99$ RR I{sRR Y I$% {
Ab s R s I $R {B8}j8  $ {sRR y s,R Y 8s-$8Z8 bY
"
$R {$R}
BB%
7B8 ]jsRRR BP *$% { sRZR b 3Z99k 7ZARR
1x
_B}BR$$B 1E
N
.,~
A bB {$R} RZARR BP

 Y
;
w
.,.

D
)
;
w
~,~

D
3
_BBP
y $R $%$sj R$ {
W
w
.
D
)
W
w
.

D
)
W
w
~
D
)
W
w
~

D
)(
_B}BR$$B 1
yP b {B R$I Y PZ {$B
W

U
"
h
w

D

{p
Ih I Ak
W

w
"
D
)
;
w
.,.

D

;
w
"
,
"

D
,

"
;
"
h
w

D
,
Y
W

$R s PZ99$ RR 8sRZ
_BBP
y $R $%$sj R$ {
W

{B$ {$IR b$Y
W

_B}BR$$B 1M
N
.
A s {$R} RZAR BP

qY

"
,
"
4
;

b Ys%
;
w
"
,
"
4
D

;
w
.,.

D
_BBP
y $R s {B RJZ { Ys
W
w

D
L
W
w

4
D
1

(
W
w
.
D
)
W
w
.

D
)(s I
W
w

L

4
1
D

W
w
"
o
D
)
W
w
.
L
.

1
D
 bY
"
o
$R Y JZ$j$A$Z8 Ys $R Y PZ99k RZAR Ih I Ak
"
o
w
?
D
)d
b
1
,

?
;

_B}BR$$B 1
qY I$% { Ab s PZ99k RZARR s I Y JZ$j$A$Z8 $R
JZsj B Y I$% { Ab $R {B8}j8 sk s I Y JZ$j$A$Z8 Ys $R
;
w
"
,
"
o
D
)
;
w
"

,
"
o
D
,

"
,
"
h
w

D
3
BB% $P
"
U
"
4
Y
;
w
"
,
"
o
D

;
w
"
4,
"
o
D
3
_BBP
3$R sRR$B $R s {B RJZ { Ys
`
w
?
D
)
`
w
d

?
D
s I YPB
`
w
?
Ld
b
1
1
D
)
`
w
w
d

?
D
Ld
b
1
1
D
 qY R{B I B  $R s {B RJZ { Ys Y }B}T
$R BP 8B BB k s I Rk88k b$Y R}{ B d
b
1 BP Y PZ {$B
_
w
?,
D
)
`
,
?
L
1
E

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
D
1
w
Is$jR {s A PBZ I $ >H
D

VjYBZY $%$sj Y PBjjBb$  }B}BR$$B sjjBbR ZR B {Ys  Y R{sj Ps{B
BP s I$% { s{{BI$  B BZ }s${Zjs JZ$8 R
1E(
7 B
R m _ p$j
_B}BR$$B 1d(
N
*
U
{p

{p
A s B I{sR$  PZ {$B b$Y
*
w
(
D
)(

qY 8s}R
;
*
,;
*
Ih I AjBb s sjRB I$% { 8sRZR
;
*
w
"
,
"
4
D
)
3
?
;

*
X
`
X4
w
?
D
L
4
4
w
?
D
1
~

`
w
4
w
?
D
D
L
`
w
4
4
w
?
D
D
1
~
;
*
w
4
,
4
4
D
)
*
w
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
D
_BBP
3B
;
*
$ $R B jk {RRsk B }B% Ys
*
p
`
D
?
L
1
i

`
w
?
D
L
`
w
D
1
Q
Rs$RhR
Y {B I$$B R $ _B}BR$$B 1n
qY }BBP B
;
*
$R $%$sj R$ { PB sjj
4
,
4
4
s I
4
g
$
4
h
w

D
b Ys% Ys
*
w
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
D
)
*
w
;
w
4
4,
4
D
D

*
w
;
w
4
,
4
D
D
)
*
w
(
D
)(
*
w
;
w
4

4
g,
4
4

4
g
D
D

*
w
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
D
s I
*
w
;
w
4

4
g,
4
4

4
g
D
D

*
w
;
w
4
,
4
4
D
D
A{sZR BP
;
A$  s I$% {
8sRZ
*
w
(
D
)(s I
*
A$  B I{sR$ 
< b Ys% }B% Y$R }B}$R PB Y$R }s${Zjs {jsRR BP I$% { 8sT
RZ BAs$ I PB8 s PZ99$ RR 8sRZ AZ b {s R
w
>H
D
Ys 8BR BP Y8 s
Z $  sj PB sjj I$% { 8sRZ bY${Y YsR Y jB{sj }B}k
n *$% { Ab }s$$B R $ I} I  BP
Y 8sRZ
y Y$R R{$B  hRjk b RZIk Y {B {} BP I$% { 8sRZ Ab }s$T
$B R sP b - I Y PZ99$ RR 8sRZ B {sj{Zjs Y PZ99$ RR BP s PZ99k
}s$$B  s I h sjjk b }R  Y {jsRR BP I$% { Ab }s$$B R $ IT
} I  BP Y 8sRZ
nd *$% { 8sRZ Ab PZ99k }s$$B R
y R8R jB${sj B Y$ , Ys Y I$% { Ab bB }s$$B R I} IR B
Y I$% { Ab Y RR $ Y8 sR bjj sR B Y 8sRZ BP YR RR
qYZR b Ys% {B R$II Ys s RZ$sAj bsk sIs}I BP 8sRZ$  Y I$% {
Ab bB }s$$B R bsR YBZY s PZ {$B Ys I} IR B Y I$% {
Ih I $ Y }%$BZR R{$B s I B s }B}jk {YBR 8sRZ BP Y RR $ Y
}s$$B R
7$8$jsjk B Y {jsRR${sj }BAsA$j$R${ I$% {R b s B$  B {B R$I s
sA$sk R s I B {B8}s bB }BRR$Aj bskR
w
Rsk Y bB }s$$B R RsAj$RYI
Ak bB -} B Y B}${
D
BP }s$$B $  $ $ B

PZ99k RZARR Ak R$  $P YR
bB bskR s %k R$8$js B %k I$& 
G b$jj P sjbskR B I$% {R Ab }s$$B R R$ { Y$R $R Y 8BR
$ R$  {sR PB ZR AZ $ Ps{ b s B$  B $% Y Ih $$B BP I$% {
Ab Ps8$j$R qYZR $ RsI BP bB,$  b$Y Y R PB8I Ak sjj }s$$B $
 b s B$  B bB, b$Y Y R PB8I PB Y RkR8R BP

RZARR BP  Ys
b b$jj I B Ak
"
B
T

7B8 ]jsRRR BP *$% { sRZR b 3Z99k 7ZARR
1Ed
3$Rjk b Ys% B IB RB8 }%$BZR {B88 R jsI B Y bsk B s{{B8}j$RY
Y 8s{Y$  Ab Y RR BP ABY Ps8$j$R B 8sRZ Y I$% { Ab
Y8
yP b {B R$I PB $ Rs { Y Ih $$B BP Y RR XOBZ " s I XWB OBZ "
BP s 1x ksRTBjI }RB s I BP s xx ksRTBjI }RB  $ $R {js Ys YR }s$$B R
s B %k R$8$js 7Z}}BR Ys Y RZj BP Y$R JZR$B $R BAR%I $ 3$Z
n
3$Z nU *h $$B BP Y RR XOBZ " s I $R {B8}j8 sk Ak bB I$& 
}RB R
y $R {js Ys b Ys% B {B8}s Y R
"
@
b$Y Y R
"
4
@
s I
"

b$Y
"
4

 GY Y$R BI B {B8}s$  $R B h-I b Ys% B s}}jk Y _$ {$}j BP
$ $8Z8 *$% {
*h $$B nd _$ {$}j BP $ $8Z8 *$% {
w
>H
D
N
"

@
s I
"


A
bB Ps8$j$R $
"
B
T
 PB8I Ak Y RR
"
%
i
T
%
@
s I
"
4
%
i
T
%
@
 R}{$%jk N
;
A s I$% { 8sRZ Ab RR G Rsk Ys YR Ps8$j$R s BII $
s{{BIs { b$Y Y _$ {$}j BP $ $8Z8 *$% {
w
;
D
 $P s I B jk $P PB sjj
}8Zs$B

BP
d
,
1
,333,
i
b Ys% Ys
T
!
%
)d
;
w
"
%
,
"
4
%
D

T
!
%
)d
;
w
"
%
,
"
4

w
%
D
D
,

7
;
d
,
1
,333,
i
3