Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
NANOCI—Nano echnology Based Cochlea Implan Wi h
Gapless In e ace o Audi o y Neu ons
y§§Pascal Senn, yMa a Roccio, yS e an Hahnewald, zClaudia F ick, zMonika Kwia kowska,
zMasaaki Ishikawa, zPe e Bako, §Hao Li, §F ed ik Edin, §Wei Liu, §Helge Rask-Ande sen,
jjIlma i Pyykko¨, jjJing Zou, jjMa ika Manne s o¨m, {He be Keppne , {Alexand a Homsy,
{Edi h Laux, {Miguel Lle a, #Jean-Paul Lellouche, #S ella Os o sky, #Ehud Banin,
#Aha on Gedanken, #Nina Pe kas, U e Wank, Ka l-Heinz Wiesmu
¨lle , yyPa el Mis ı´k,
yyHe al Bena , yyCa olyn Ga nham, yyClaude Jolly, zzFilippo Gande , zzPe e Ul ich,
zMa cus Mu
¨lle , and zHube Lo¨wenheim
Uni e si y Depa men o ORL, Head & Neck Su ge y, Inselspi al;
y
Depa men o Clinical Resea ch, Uni e si y o Be n, Be n,
Swi ze land;
z
Depa men o O o hinola yngology–Head & Neck Su ge y, Uni e si y o Tu
¨bingen, Tu
¨bingen, Ge many; §Depa men
o Su gical Sciences, Sec ion o ORL, Uppsala Uni e si y, Uppsala, Sweden;
jj
Hea ing and Balance Resea ch Uni , Depa men o
O o hinola yngology and The Finnish Cen e o Al e na i e Me hods, Uni e si y o Tampe e, Tampe e, Finland;
{
Hau e Ecole A c
Inge
´nie ie, HES-SO - Uni e si y o Applied Sciences Wes e n Swi ze land, La Chaux-de-Fonds; #Depa men o Chemis y, The
Cen e o Ad anced Ma e ials and Nano echnology and The Mina and E e a d Goodman Facul y o Li e Sciences, Ba Ilan
Uni e si y, Rama Gan, Is ael; EMC Mic ocollec ions GmbH, Tu
¨bingen, Ge many;
yy
MED-EL GmbH, Wo ldwide Headqua e s,
Innsb uck, Aus ia;
zz
SCIPROM Sa
` l, Rue du Cen e 70, S -Sulpice; and §§Depa men o Clinical Neu osciences,
Se ice o ORL and HNS, HUG, Uni e si y Hospi al o Gene a, Gene a, Swi ze land
Cochlea implan s (CI) es o e unc ional hea ing in he
majo i y o dea pa ien s. Despi e he emendous success o
hese de ices, some limi a ions emain. The bo leneck o
op imal elec ical s imula ion wi h CI is caused by he
ana omical gap be ween he elec ode a ay and he audi o y
neu ons in he inne ea . As a consequence, cu en de ices
a e limi ed h ough 1) low equency esolu ion, hence sub-
op imal sound quali y and 2), la ge s imula ion cu en s,
hence high ene gy consump ion ( esponsible o signi ican
ba e y cos s and o impeding he de elopmen o ully
implan able sys ems). A ecen ly comple ed, mul ina ional
and in e disciplina y p ojec called NANOCI aimed a o e -
coming cu en limi a ions by c ea ing a gapless in e ace
be ween audi o y ne e ibe s and he cochlea implan
elec ode a ay. This ambi ious goal was achie ed in i o by
neu o ophin-induced a ac ion o neu i es h ough an in a-
cochlea gel-nanoma ix on o a modi ied nanoCI elec ode
a ay loca ed in he scala ympani o dea ened guinea pigs.
Func ionally, he gapless in e ace led o lowe s imula ion
h esholds and a la ge dynamic ange in i o, and o educed
s imula ion ene gy equi emen (up o i e old) in an in i o
model using audi o y neu ons cul u ed on mul i-elec ode
a ays. In conclusion, he NANOCI p ojec yielded p oo o
concep ha a gapless in e ace be ween audi o y neu ons and
cochlea implan elec ode a ays is easible. These indings
may be o ele ance o he de elopmen o u u e CI sys ems
wi h be e sound quali y and pe o mance and lowe ene gy
consump ion. The p esen o e iew/ e iew pape summa izes
he NANOCI p ojec his o y and highligh s achie emen s
o he indi idual wo k packages. Key Wo ds: Audi o y
ne e egene a ion—BDNF—Cochlea implan —Gapless
in e ace—Guinea pig—Hea ing loss—Hyd ogel—Mul i-
elec ode a ay—Neu on–elec ode in e ace.
O ol Neu o ol 38:e224–e231, 2017.
Cochlea implan s (CI) ha e become he gold s anda d
ea men o acqui ed and congeni al dea ness, allowing
he es o a ion o unc ional hea ing in he majo i y o
ecipien s. As o oday o e 300,000 de ices a e in use.
Despi e he emendous success o cu en sys ems, he e is
a subs an ial a iabili y o pe o mance ac oss CI-use s. In
some cases, sound quali y is poo o music and onal
languages, and use s may s uggle in noisy en i onmen s.
Add ess co espondence and ep in eques s o Pascal Senn, M.D.,
Depa men o Clinical Neu osciences, Se ice ORL & CCF, Hoˆpi aux
Uni e si ai es de Gene` e (HUG), Rue Gab ielle Pe e -Gen il 4, 1211
Gene a, Swi ze land; E-mail: [email p o ec ed]
M.M. and H.L. ha e equal con ibu ion o he a icle.
Disclosu e: The NANOCI-p ojec (www.nanoci.o g) was unded by
he Eu opean Union unde he g an ag eemen no. 281056 in he 7
h
ame wo k p og amme.
The au ho s disclose no con lic s o in e es .
This is an open access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he
C ea i e Commons A ibu ion-Non Comme cial-No De i a i es
License 4.0 (CCBY-NC-ND), whe e i is pe missible o download
and sha e he wo k p o ided i is p ope ly ci ed. The wo k canno be
changed in any way o used comme cially wi hou pe mission om he
jou nal.
DOI: 10.1097/MAO.0000000000001439
e224
O ology & Neu o ology
38:e224–e231 Copy igh ß2017 The Au ho (s). Published by Wol e s Kluwe Heal h, Inc. on behal o O ology & Neu o ology, Inc.
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
The majo bo leneck o op imized s imula ion is he
ana omical gap be ween he implan ed elec ode a ay
and he s imula ed egions o he audi o y ne e. As a
consequence o he gap and he associa ed cu en sp ead
du ing a s imulus pulse, housands o audi o y neu ons a e
s imula ed om de ices ea u ing only be ween 12 and 22
elec odes (depending on he manu ac u e ). Whe eas
mo e han eigh independen channels a e needed in
challenging lis ening si ua ions (1), CI use s ypically
pe o m as i hey ha e only abou eigh channels o
in o ma ion (2). The main eason o his is sp ead o
exci a ion om he elec odes and in e e ence ac oss
channels. Any a emp o inc ease channel numbe s is
limi ed by his signi ican ‘‘c oss alk’’ o elec odes o
o e lapping elec ical ields. Hence, he esolu ion and
speci ici y o neu onal s imula ion is low, which is he
main eason o subop imal sound quali y and a iabili y
o speech and music pe cep ion. Addi ionally, he high
ampli udes con ibu e o a high ene gy consump ion
associa ed wi h signi ican main enance cos s o ba e ies.
Mo eo e , high ene gy consump ion challenges he de el-
opmen o ully implan able sys ems, which would ha e
se e al ad an ages such as inc eased usabili y o small
child en, in isibili y, hea ing while sleeping and be e
accep ance by pa ien s.
I is gene ally acknowledged ha elimina ing he
gap be ween neu ons and he elec ode a ay, and
inc easing he numbe o ac i e channels, should
g ea ly imp o e he e ec i eness o audi o y ne e
s imula ion (3).
The NANOCI p ojec , he e o e, was concei ed wi h
he aim o c ea e a gapless man:machine in e ace in he
cochlea by a ac ing he pe iphe al p ocesses o he
audi o y ne e owa ds he elec ode a ay (Fig. 1). Such
a gapless in e ace could open he doo o a highe
equency esolu ion o he CI sys em, because smalle
g oups o audi o y neu ons could be s imula ed om a
highe numbe o sepa a e elec odes, coming close o
he si ua ion in he ‘‘no mal’’ human inne ea , whe e
a ound 3,500 inne hai cells s imula e a ound 30,000
audi o y neu ons. In acous ic simula ion s udies o
no mal hea ing subjec s, a highe equency esolu ion
is associa ed wi h imp o ed speech and music pe cep-
ion. In addi ion o his, he gapless in e ace has a high
chance o cu ing down ene gy consump ion.
Suppo i e e idence o he easibili y o he NANOCI
aim o ec ui spi al ganglion neu on (SGN) p ocesses o
he CI can be ound in he li e a u e. Di e en neu o-
ophins ha e been epo ed o ha e p osu i al and
guidance e ec s on SGNs. Fi s , du ing emb yonic de el-
opmen , audi o y hai cells exp ess he neu o ophin
p o eins b ain-de i ed neu o ophic ac o (BDNF) and
neu o ophin-3, which di ec g ow h o adial ibe bun-
dles om he cen ally localized spi al ganglion in o he
o gan o Co i (4). Di ec ed g ow h o ne e ibe s can
also be induced expe imen ally a e in ec ion o sup-
po ing cells wi h adeno i al ec o s encoding o BDNF
leading o i s p oduc ion in adul dea ened guinea pigs
(5). Simila ly, BDNF in combina ion wi h ib oblas
g ow h ac o was capable o p omo ing su i al and
FIG. 1. Schema ic concep o he NANOCI p ojec . O e iew (A) and mid-modiola c oss-sec ion h ough he cochlea wi h a CI elec ode
a ay inse ed in o he scala ympani ( pink,B) a dis ance om he audi o y neu on (g een,B–D). By p o iding s uc u al suppo , guidance,
and a ac ion cues om an injec ed, unc ionalized nanoma ix (blue shaded ill,B–D) and om he modi ied elec ode a ay su ace (whi e
coa ing o pink elec ode a ay,Cand D), a guided g ow h o he neu i e on o he elec ode su ace is induced whe e a gapless ne e-CI
in e ace is o med. CI indica es cochlea implan s.
NANOCI e225
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
inducing e-sp ou ing o audi o y neu ons a e expe -
imen ally induced dea ness in adul guinea pigs (6).
Mo eo e , hese au ho s obse ed ou g ow h o ne e
ibe s up o he bo de o he scala ympani, whe e he
neu o ophins we e eleased. The pe iphe al p ocesses
o he audi o y neu ons did no , howe e , en e he
pe ilymph, possibly due o lack o s uc u al suppo .
In addi ion, he neu o ophic e ec o BDNF can be
enhanced i combined wi h elec ical s imula ion (7).
Finally, in a ecen animal s udy i was shown ha ec opic
ne e ibe s obse ed in he cochlea in esponse o
ch onic neu o ophin deli e y we e associa ed wi h lowe
exci a ion h esholds and no inc eased sp ead o ac i-
a ion compa ed wi h dea ened con ols (8).
Impo an ly, speci ic neu o ophin ecep o s a e
exp essed in he human cochlea neu al issue also in
adul hood (9,10), making he ea men wi h exogenous
neu o ophins such as BDNF by local in acochlea
deli e y sys em clinically highly ele an . The e o e,
based on he li e a u e i seemed clea ha neu o ophins
such as BDNF could be ideal candida es o induce and
e-di ec neu i e ou g ow h owa ds a modi ied CI elec-
ode a ay ac ing as a sou ce o deli e y. Ne e heless,
he luid illed gap be ween he neu ons and he su ace o
he CI elec ode a ay would be likely o inhibi he
eg ow h. To o e come his limi a ion, we hough ha
a s uc u al suppo should be o e ed, along wi h guid-
ance and g ow h cues o ec ui neu ons o he a ay
(Fig. 1).
Fo his challenging endea o , expe ize om di e en
backg ounds was me ged in an in e na ional and mul i-
cen ic conso ium (Table 1—o e iew o conso ium
pa ne s and hei key compe ences). The complex
esea ch p ojec was subdi ided in o se e al smalle uni s
(called wo k packages [WPs]) wi h de ined goals and
miles ones, which a e discussed along wi h he esul s
ob ained in mo e de ail below. The main aim o he
p esen e iew a icle is o summa ize he his o ical
backg ound o he NANOCI p ojec and o gi e an
o e iew o i s achie emen s.
WP1—Nanoma e ials and Bioac i e Compounds o
Imp o ing he In e ace
The main objec i es o his wo k package we e: 1) o
de elop a biocompa ible and bio- unc ionalized, h ee-
dimensional sca old, o nanoma ix, o p omo e neu al
ou g ow h o ne e ibe s h ough he scala ympani on o
he su ace o he CI elec ode pad, 2) o de elop bio-
mime ic analogues o BDNF, and 3) o in oduce nano-
su ace modi ica ions o he elec ode con ac s o s ably
lock neu ons while imp o ing he elec ode conduc i e
p ope ies.
In he i s place, comme cially a ailable ibe o ming
gel ma ices we e assessed. Pu aMa ix
TM
was selec ed
as he bes candida e as i ul illed he basic equi emen s
o being injec able as solu ion, gela inizing in esponse o
ionic changes (i.e., con ac wi h he pe ilymph) wi hou
swelling o mechanical s ess o su ounding issues.
In addi ion, i had been shown o p omo e neu i e
g ow h (11).
Pa ne EMC mic ocollec ions GmbH (EMC) esyn he-
sized he published gel o ming Pu aMa ix
TM
pep ide
sequence and addi ionally modi ied i wi h laminin-
de i ed sequences o neu on adhesion. Addi ionally,
linking s a egies we e included o bio unc ionalize he
nanoma ix wi h neu o ophic ac o s such as BDNF (12).
As ou lined in he in oduc ion, neu o ophic ac o s
a e impo an o media e su i al and sp ou ing o audi-
o y neu ons in i o and in i o. Howe e , BDNF is no
an ideal molecule o clinical inne ea applica ions
because o i s sho in i o hal -li e ime. Small biomi-
me ic compounds could o e an in e es ing way o sol e
his p oblem. Howe e , o ou knowledge, only ew
biomime ic analogues o BDNF ha e been published,
TABLE 1. Lis o NANOCI conso ium pa ne ins i u ions wi h key compe ences
Role A ilia ion Key Compe ences
Coo dina o Uni e si y o Be n, Swi ze land Inne ea egene a ion, human and mu ine bioassays, in i o
elec ophysiology (mul i-elec ode a ays)
Pa ne 1 Uni e si y o Tu
¨bingen, Ge many In i o elec ophysiology, his ology, mu ine bioassays
Pa ne 2 Uni e si y o Uppsala, Sweden Human bioassays, ime-lapse ideo
Pa ne 3 Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finnland Nano oxici y assays in i o, d ug elease s udies, CB-CT and MRI
imaging
Pa ne 4 Uni e si y o applied sciences,
HES-SO, La Chaux-de-Fonds,
Swi ze land
Nanos uc u iza ion by solid on liquid deposi ion, i adia ion;
d ug-elu ion solu ions, modeling o elease
Pa ne 5 Ba -Ilan Uni e si y, Rama Gan, Is ael Nanos uc u iza ion by sonochemis y, bac e ia bioassays, p oduc ion
o nanopa icles (e.g., ca bon nano ubes)
Pa ne 6 EMC Mic ocollec ions, GmbH,
Tu
¨bingen, Ge many
P oduc ion o BDNF mime ics, pu i ica ion and unc ionaliza ion o
hyd ogels
Pa ne 7 MEDEL, Innsb uck, Aus ia P oduc ion o animal- and human g ade nanoCI p o o ypes wi h
su ace unc ionaliza ions; modelling
Pa ne 8 Scip om Sa` l, S -Sulpice, Swi ze land P ojec managemen , websi e design, o ganiza ion o mee ings
BDNF, b ain-de i ed neu o ophic ac o ; CB-CT, conebeam compu ed omog aphy; MRI, magne ic esonance imaging.
e226 P. SENN ET AL.
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
and hei e ec s on he inne ea neu ons a e as ye
unknown (13). Pa ne EMC, he e o e, se ou o design
and p oduce small molecule biomime ic compounds
deduced om he di e en s uc u al pa s (loops) o
he BDNF molecule wi h high s abili y, biocompa ibili y,
and bioa ailabili y in he inne ea . P omising candida es
we e es ed in an in i o bioassay using an audi o y
neu on explan assay. Resul s o his sc een a e cu en ly
p epa ed o publica ion.
Fo s able locking o audi o y neu i es on he pla inum
elec ode su ace and op imiza ion o elec ode con-
duc i i y, di e en nano unc ionaliza ions we e de el-
oped and es ed by pa ne Ba -Ilan Uni e si y (BIU).
F om a pool o se e al candida es, hyb id nanocompo-
si es o conduc i e polyme s and mul iwall ca bon nano-
ubes we e ound o subs an ially oughen he pla inum
su ace and he eby o imp o e conduc i i y o s anda d
cochlea implan pla inum pads in elec ochemical
measu emen s by pa ne MEDEL (14). In addi ion,
hese nanocomposi es subs an ially educed s imula ion
h esholds o audi o y neu onal explan cul u es on
mul i-elec ode a ays compa ed wi h s anda d g ey
pla inum su aces.
WP2—Nano unc ionaliza ion o he Elec ode
A ay Su ace
This wo k package was designed o s uc u ally op i-
mize he non-conduc i e silicone ca ie su ace o he CI
o d ug deli e y and o implemen an ibac e ial ac i i y.
Pa ne HES-SO e alua ed wo di e en echnologies
o elease o p o eins om ese oi s on he su ace.
Fi s ly, he solid on liquid (SOLID) nano echnology was
e alua ed. To his end, he silicone ca ie o he elec-
ode was u he coa ed wi h a pa ylene laye con aining
mic oscale ese oi s wi h 60 mm holes c ea ed by lase
(15,16). This allowed o elease o luo escen mol-
ecules ( luo escine), used as epo e s in hese s udies.
In addi ion, nanos uc u iza ion me hods such as local-
ized i adia ions o Pa ylene-coa ed su aces passed bio-
compa ibili y es ing wi h an audi o y neu on su i al
assay, sugges ing ha such echnologies migh be used
o p ecise local e ching o a pa ylene-coa ed su ace o
c ea e wells o nanopo es o con olled elease o g ow h
ac o s (17).
Finally, a simple app oach was e alua ed, whe ein
luo escein c ys als, in powde o m, we e encapsula ed
in a hin laye o pa ylene, hence c ea ing andom nano-
me e -sized pinholes. This was ound o be e ec i e o
con olled d ug- elease om he elec ode su ace (18).
The e o e, he app oach was selec ed, as i would acili-
a e he s o age o p o eins on he CI silicone su ace in a
solid o m (powde ), g ea ly imp o ing handling and
shipping p ope ies.
To diminish he isk o in ec ions and coloniza ion o
he elec ode a ay, pa ne BIU u he modi ied he non-
conduc i e silicone pa s wi h an imic obial nanopa -
icles. ZnO-MgF
2
and CuZnO we e inco po a ed in o
he silicone a ay sonochemically. These nanopa icles
p o ed o be s ably locked on he su ace wi h minimal o
absen leaching o in o a i icial pe ilymph and wi h
subs an ial inhibi ion o bio ilm o ma ion (19).
WP3—Modeling, Coding, and In o ma ion T ans e
This wo k package add essed he unc ional exploi a-
ion o he gapless elec ode–audi o y neu on in e ace
and looked in o op imized design o u u e cochlea
implan sys ems wi h inc eased bi-di ec ionali y and
highe channel numbe s.
In e ace-dependen s imula ion pa e ns we e s udied
using spi al ganglion neu on explan cul u es on mul i-
elec ode a ays (MEAs) by he Uni e si y o Be n (20).
We we e able o demons a e a educ ion in he ene gy
needed o elici a esponse as a unc ion o he dis ance o
he s imula ing elec ode o he neu onal cul u e. This
p o ed he key hypo hesis ha he gapless in e ace
allows o educ ion o s imula ion ene gy.
In addi ion, op imiza ion o s imula ion pulses using
in e phase gaps, ains o pulses, and long biphasic pulses
was assessed. The la e we e also shown o allow o a
educ ion o he ene gy needed o s imula ion o SGNs
(20). The close p oximi y o he elec odes o he neu ons
allows many elec odes o be ac i e a he same ime, hus
imposing less s ic empo al es ic ion on coding s a -
egies compa ed wi h cu en CI sys ems. Based on his
da a, sound coding s a egies o an implan ea u ing a
gapless in e ace and mo e han 30 independen channels
we e modeled using a cus om-made, mul icompa men
model o he audi o y ne e by pa ne MEDEL (da a no
published).
To inc ease bi-di ec ionali y o u u e CI-sys ems, a
Fab y–Pe o ibe ip senso was de eloped o measu e-
men o empe a u e and p essu e sui able o inco po a-
ion in o he elec ode a ay. The sys em includes a
low-bending loss ibe equipped wi h a solid on liquid
deposi ed e minal (21). The sensi i i y o he sys em
heo e ically allows o he de ec ion o con ac o he ip
wi h he su ounding s uc u es in he cochlea, in e es ing
o measu ing inse ion o ces in obo ic su ge y, bu also
po en ially o use as an implan able mic ophone o
p essu e senso .
WP 4—Bioassays
A a ie y o bioassays we e used in NANOCI o es
g ow h ac o s, g ow h ac o mime ics, nanoma e ials,
elec ode su aces, d ug elease, an ibac e ial ac i i y,
and s imula ion pa e ns, among o he en i ies. The pa -
ne Uni e si y o Tu
¨bingen es ed he injec able, pep ide-
based hyd ogel de eloped by pa ne EMC o i ’s
pe missi e p ope ies o acili a e neu i e g ow h owa ds
he CI in a spi al ganglion explan assay (12). In addi ion,
he pa ne Uni e si y o Uppsala s udied neu al p ogen-
i o cell-de i ed spi al ganglion-like neu ons (22). They
also s udied he egene a i e capaci y o human su ge y-
de i ed es ibula neu ons (23) as well as he possibili y
o a ac ing and guiding hese p ima y es ibula
neu ons in a 3-D nanoma ix (Li e al., Unpublished
da a, cu en ly unde e ision). In addi ion, his ological
s udies we e unde aken o be e unde s and he spi al
NANOCI e227
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
ganglion ana omy and i s ele ance o cochlea implan-
a ion oday as well as o po en ial u u e sys ems wi h a
gapless in e ace o audi o y neu ons (24–26).
These esul s show, o he i s ime ha he human
audi o y ne e has a egene a i e capaci y and ha
audi o y neu ons can g ow h ough a 3-D nanoma ix.
The his opa hological s udies also e eal po en ial
unde lying mechanisms ha may allow human audi o y
neu ons o, unlike hei animal coun e pa s, pe sis
a e hai cell loss, making he use o cochlea implan s
possible.
WP5—Imaging, Biocompa ibili y, and Release
Dynamics o he Modi ied CI Elec ode
The aims o his wo k package we e 1) o assess he
neu o ophin elease om hyd ogels and om implan
su aces, 2) o measu e and isualize he gap be ween he
elec ode a ay and he medial cochlea wall using cone-
beam compu ed omog aphy (CBCT), and 3) o assess
he biocompa ibili y and sa e y o he modi ied elec ode
a ay a e coa ing wi h nanoma e ials. The pa ne a
he Uni e si y o Tampe e, in collabo a ion wi h o he s,
mainly led his WP.
I was demons a ed ha he elease o neu o ophins
o small molecules in a phan om model wi h a i icial
pe ilymph (da a no published) co esponds o he in i o
dis ibu ion o labeled Gadolinium nanocomposi es o
T kB-ligands in he a cochlea a e ans ympanic
injec ion, as measu ed by MRI (27,28). Based on hese
expe imen s, he inne ea dis ibu ion o neu o ophins
eleased om he hyd ogel and om he cochlea implan
su ace was p edic ed.
Fo he second aim, imaging pa ame e s o cone-
beam CT we e op imized yielding highe esolu ion a
lowe i adia ion doses. Cada e ic human empo al
bones we e implan ed wi h di e en human g ade coch-
lea implan elec ode a ays (Fig. 2) and s udied wi h
he op imized CBCT se ings o inse ion dep h, scala
loca ion, and he dis ance o he a ay om he modiola
wall (29).
Finally, he biocompa ibili y and oxici y o nano ech-
nologically modi ied elec ode componen s we e e al-
ua ed in i o using he BALB/c3T3 and NR8383 cell
lines ollowing he ISO 10993–5 and OECD GD-129
guidelines. No in i o o speci ic o o oxici y es s we e
pe o med o he bulk o nanoma e ial candida es and
oxici y was p edic ed based on issue equi alen s a his
s age. Some o he ea lie candida es o an ibac e ial
nanocoa ing in he p ojec (ZnO and MgF
2
) we e la e
abandoned due o oxici y in hese assays. The nano-
composi es used o coa he pla inum elec ode pa s
(mul iwall ca bon nano ubes) we e ound o be no oxic
o BALB/c3T3 cells, while sligh ly dec easing iabili y
o NR8383 cells (30).
WP6—Pilo , Animal G ade nanoCI
Mul icomponen Valida ion
The inal goal o wo k package 6 was o de elop an
animal-g ade p o o ype o in i o es ing inco po a ing he
di e en nano- and bio- unc ionaliza ion discussed abo e.
The pa ne MEDEL p oduced a 4-channel guinea
pig elec ode a ay (Fig. 3), which was hen unc ionalized
wi h di e en componen s. Namely 1) conduc i e
polyTh copolyme (pEDOT)/oxidized mul iwall ca bon
nano ubes bound on pla inum con ac s, 2) pa ylene-coa ed
elec ode a ay ca ie doped wi h an i ouling agen
(CuZnO nanopa icles), and 3) 7,8,3- ihyd oxy la one,
a BDNF analogue shown o ac as a high a ini y agonis
FIG. 2. P o o ype o he NANOCI elec ode a ay ea u ing 36 elec odes on able (A) and a e inse ion in o a cada e ic human empo al
bone, as isualized h ough cone-beam compu ed omog aphy (Band C). This p o o ype yields p oo o concep , ha channel numbe s can
be ipled wi h oday’s manu ac u ing me hods. No in acochlea damage and an in ac basila memb ane we e obse ed (D). Howe e , due
o inc eased s i ness o he de ice, a ull inse ion was no possible.
e228 P. SENN ET AL.
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017

Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
o he T kB ecep o , deposi ed in solid s a e in he su ace
o he elec ode a ay ca ie .
Fu he mo e, MEDEL p oduced a ca he e o in a-
cochlea applica ion o he pu i ied and laminin-loaded
hyd ogel (p oduced by EMC unde WP2, Fig. 3D).
The mul icomponen alida ion o hese p oduc s
included i s he ypical quali y and pe o mance es ing
a MEDEL, ollowed by in i o expe imen s pe o med
a he Uni e si y o Tu
¨bingen using a dea ened guinea pig
animal model. Dea ened guinea pigs we e implan ed
FIG. 3. Speci ica ions (A) and pho og aphs o he p o o ype on able (B) and inse ed in o he cochlea (C) o he guinea pig cochlea implan
wi h ou elec odes (a ows in B). The leng h o he in acochlea a ay is 4 mm, as indica ed wi h a s oppe (blue o al) loca ed be ween wo
da k ma ke s a dis ance 3 and 5 mm om he ip o be e es ima e o achie ed inse ion dep h. Ca he e s o in acochlea injec ion o he
nanoma ix in luidic o m (D). The ca he e s we e manu ac u ed in wo a ian s wi h di e en diame e s o he silicone ubing (0.3 mm wi h
yellow s anda d sy inge needle and 0.6 mm wi h whi e s anda d sy inge needle). The black do indica es he 3-mm inse ion dep h as a
e e ence poin (a ows in D). CI indica es cochlea implan s.
FIG. 4. P oo o concep o he gapless in e ace be ween audi o y neu ons (g een) and he CI-elec ode a ay in scheme (A) and in he
dea ened guinea pig inne ea in i o (B). Audi o y neu ons a e s ained wi h a neu on-speci ic ma ke o b-III ubulin (g een, TUJ), cell nuclei
a e s ained in blue (DAPI nuclea s aining), pho og aph p o ided by Ma cus Mu
¨lle and Hube Lo
¨wenheim. CI indica es cochlea implan s.
NANOCI e229
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
wi h s anda d and modi ied guinea pig cochlea implan
elec ode a ays (Fig. 3) in combina ion wi h unc ion-
alized nanoma ix gels applied h ough he a o emen-
ioned ca he e (Fig. 3D). The in i o expe imen s
yielded p oo o p inciple ha neu i es can g ow unde
neu o ophin s imula ion and h ough s uc u al suppo
om he nanoma ix in o he scala ympani and on o he
su ace o he elec ode a ay, o ming a gapless in e ace
in he dea ened and implan ed cochlea (Fig. 4). Func-
ionally, he gapless in e ace led o lowe s imula ion
h esholds and a la ge dynamic ange in hese animals in
i o and he de ailed esul s a e cu en ly being p epa ed
o publica ion.
Finally, MEDEL es ed he limi s o oday’s manu-
ac u ing echnologies and buil a human-g ade p o o ype
elec ode a ay ea u ing 36 pla inum con ac s (Fig. 2A).
The human-g ade p o o ype elec ode a ay was inse ed
in o a cada e ic human empo al bone a he Uni e si y
o Tampe e o imaging (and no used in i o) (Fig. 2B).
No in acochlea damage was obse ed (Fig. 2B and C),
howe e due o inc eased s i ness ela ed o he highe
pla inum con en s o he a ay, i could no be ully
inse ed in o he cochlea.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
In conclusion, he NANOCI p ojec yielded p oo o
concep ha a gapless in e ace be ween audi o y neu ons
and cochlea implan elec ode a ays is easible in i o.
Func ionally, he gapless in e ace led o lowe s imu-
la ion h esholds and a la ge dynamic ange in i o
compa ed wi h un ea ed animals and o an up o i e old
educ ion in equi ed s imula ion ene gy in an in i o
model using audi o y neu ons cul u ed on mul i-elec-
ode a ays. The ele ance o his p omising obse a ion
o po en ial u u e clinical applica ions emains
unknown a his poin in ime. Pa icula ly, i canno
be o eseen, how many eg own neu i es will be unc-
ionally ele an and how many pa allel channels o he
cochlea implan can be e ec i ely used o s imula ion
in he u u e. In addi ion, he o al ene gy consump ion o
a u u e CI sys em ha could be based on he NANOCI
p inciple canno be p edic ed based on ou expe imen s,
as many ac o s ele an o clinical CI sys ems we e no
aken in o accoun in he expe imen al models. Se e al
o he issues such as sa e y and unc ional s abili y o e
ime and beyond e-implan a ion p ocedu es need o be
se iously add essed. Ne e heless, we emain op imis ic
ha some o he de elopmen s made du ing he NANOCI
p ojec may help o imp o e cochlea implan sys ems in
he u u e in one way o ano he . I is impo an o no e
ha all o he esea che s expe ienced a subs an ial
bene i om he in e disciplina y collabo a ion o he
conso ium pa ne s in ol ed in he p ojec .
Acknowledgmen s: The au ho s would like o hank he ol-
lowing NANOCI collabo a o s o hei aluable con i-
bu ions: Emanuele Ma coni, Anne Tsche e , Ju
¨ g S ei ,
Hans Ruedi Widme , S e ano di San o, Ma ija Bos o¨m,
Sebas ien B un, F ancois Feu ie , Thie y Allen, Ha y
Wi hlow, Rena e Spohn, Raphael Ki an, Roland Hessle ,
F ede ik Klause , Jochen Tillein, Giulia Ma ini, So¨ en Schilp,
Te esa Melchionna, Raimund Naschbe ge , Ingebo g Hochmai
and Ki s en Leu gen. Fu he , hey would like o hank S e an
Helle and Daniel Bodme o being pa o he ad iso y boa d
and Silke K ol (p ojec echnical assis an ) and Heico F ima
(p ojec o ice ) o hei aluable wo k o he p ojec a he EU.
They would also like o hank Michal Na an o he con ibu ions
o his wo k.
REFERENCES
1. Shannon RF, Fu QJ, Gal in J 3 d. The numbe o spec al channels
equi ed o speech ecogni ion depends on he di icul y o he
lis ening si ua ion. Ac a O ola yngol Suppl 2004;50–4.
2. F iesen LS, Shannon RV, Basken D, Wang X. Speech ecogni ion
in noise as a unc ion o he numbe o spec al channels: com-
pa ison o acous ic hea ing and cochlea implan s. J Acous Soc Am
2001;110:1150–63.
3. Wilson BS, Do man MF. Cochlea implan s: cu en designs and
u u e possibili ies. J Rehab Res De 2008;45:695–730.
4. F i zsch B, Tessa ollo L, Coppola E, Reicha d LF. Neu o ophins
in he ea : hei oles in senso y neu on su i al and ibe guidance.
P og B ain Res 2004;146:265–78.
5. Shiba a SB, Co ez SR, Beye LA, e al. T ansgenic BDNF induces
ne e ibe eg ow h in o he audi o y epi helium in dea cochleae.
Exp Neu ol 2010;223:464–72.
6. Gluecke R, Bi sche M, Mille JM, e al. Dea e en a ion-associ-
a ed changes in a e en and e e en p ocesses in he guinea pig
cochlea and a e en egene a ion wi h ch onic in ascala b ain-
de i ed neu o ophic ac o and acidic ib oblas g ow h ac o .
J Comp Neu ol 2008;507:1602–21.
7. Shephe d RK, Coco A, Epp SB, C ook JM. Ch onic depola iza ion
enhances he ophic e ec s o b ain-de i ed neu o ophic ac o in
escuing audi o y neu ons ollowing a senso ineu al hea ing loss.
J Comp Neu ol 2005;486:145–58.
8. Land y TG, Fallon JB, Wise AK, Shephe d RK. Ch onic neu o-
ophin deli e y p omo es ec opic neu i e g ow h om he spi al
ganglion o dea ened cochleae wi hou comp omising he spa ial
selec i i y o cochlea implan s. J Comp Neu ol 2013;521:
2818–32.
9. Liu W, Kinne o s A, Bos om M, Rask-Ande sen H. Exp ession o
T kB and BDNF in human cochlea-an immunohis ochemical s udy.
Cell Tissue Res 2011;345:213–21.
10. Liu W, Gluecke R, Kinne o s A, Sch o -Fische A, Bi sche M,
Rask-Ande sen H. Dis ibu ion o P75 neu o ophin ecep o in
adul human cochlea–an immunohis ochemical s udy. Cell Tissue
Res 2012;348:407–15.
11. McG a h AM, No iko a LN, No iko LN, Wibe g M. BD Pu -
aMa ix pep ide hyd ogel seeded wi h Schwann cells o pe iphe al
ne e egene a ion. B ain Res Bull 2010;83:207–13.
12. F ick C, Mulle M, Wank U, e al. Bio unc ionalized pep ide-based
hyd ogels p o ide pe missi e sca olds o a ac neu i e ou g ow h
om spi al ganglion neu ons. Colloids Su B Bioin e aces
2016;149:105–14.
13. Massa SM, Yang T, Xie Y, e al. Small molecule BDNF mime ics
ac i a e T kB signaling and p e en neu onal degene a ion in
oden s. J Clin In es 2010;120:1774–85.
14. Os o sky S, Hahnewald S, Ki an R, e al. Conduc i e hyb id
ca bon nano ube (CNT)-poly hiophene coa ings o inno a i e
audi o y neu on-mul i-elec ode a ay in e acing. RCS Ad 2016;
6:41714–23.
15. Cha me J, Banakh O, Laux E, e al. Solid on liquid deposi ion. Thin
Solid Films 2010;518:5061–5.
16. Homsy A, Laux E, Jeandupeux L, e al. Solid on liquid deposi ion, a
e iew o echnological solu ions. Mic oelec on Eng 2015;141:
267–79.
17. Whi low H, No a a R, Roccio M, e al. MeV ion beam li hog aphy
o biocompa ible halogena ed Pa ylenes using ape u e masks. Nucl
Ins um Me hods Phys Res B 2015;354:34–6.
e230 P. SENN ET AL.
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017
Copy igh © 2017 O ology & Neu o ology, Inc. Unau ho ized ep oduc ion o his a icle is p ohibi ed.
18. Homsy A, Laux E, B ossa d J, e al. Fine con ol o d ug deli e y o
cochlea implan applica ions. Hea Balance Commun 2015;13:
153–9.
19. Na an M, Edin F, Pe kas N, e al. Two a e be e han one:
Combining ZnO and MgF2 nanopa icles educes S ep ococcus
pneumoniae and S aphylococcus au eus bio ilm o ma ion on
cochlea implan s. Ad Func Ma e 2016;26:2473–81.
20. Hahnewald S, Ma coni E, S ei J, e al. Response p o iles o mu ine
spi al ganglion neu ons on mul i-elec ode a ays. J Neu al Eng
2015;13:016011.
21. Lle a M, Aellen T, He as J, e al. Liquid-ai based Fab y-Pe o
ca i y on ibe ip senso . Op ics Exp ess 2016;24:1–12.
22. Edin F, Liu W, Bos om M, Magnusson PU, Rask-Ande sen H.
Di e en ia ion o human neu al p ogeni o cell-de i ed spi al
ganglion-like neu ons: a ime-lapse ideo s udy. Ac a O ola yngol
2014;134:441–7.
23. Edin F, Liu W, Li H, A u o F, Magnusson PU, Rask-Ande sen H.
3-D gel cul u e and ime-lapse ideo mic oscopy o he human
es ibula ne e. Ac a O ola yngol 2014;134:1211–8.
24. Liu W, Edin F, A u o F, e al. The p e- and pos -soma ic segmen s
o he human ype I spi al ganglion neu ons—s uc u al and unc-
ional conside a ions ela ed o cochlea implan a ion. Neu oscience
2015;284:470–82.
25. Liu W, Gluecke R, Lin hicum FH, e al. Possible ole o gap
junc ion in e cellula channels and connexin 43 in sa elli e glial
cells (SGCs) o p ese a ion o human spi al ganglion neu ons: A
compa a i e s udy wi h clinical implica ions. Cell Tissue Res
2014;355:267–78.
26. Rask-Ande sen H, Liu W. Audi o y ne e p ese a ion and egen-
e a ion in man: ele ance o cochlea implan a ion. Neu al Regen
Res 2015;10:710–2.
27. Pyykko I, Zou J, Sch o -Fische A, Gluecke R, Kinnunen P. An
o e iew o nanopa icle based deli e y o ea men o inne ea
diso de s. Me hods Mol Biol 2016;1427:363–415.
28. Zou J, Os o sky S, Is ael L, Lellouche J, Pyykko¨ I. Ta ge ed
deli e y o con as agen s o he ympanic medial wall a minimum
amoun and he e icien up ake in he inne ea h ough o al and
ound windows. Aus in J Radiol 2015;2:1034.
29. Zou J, Hannula M, Leh o K, e al. X- ay mic o omog aphic
con i ma ion o he eliabili y o CBCT in iden i ying he scala
loca ion o cochlea implan elec ode a e ound window inse ion.
Hea Res 2015;326:59–65.
30. Manne s omM,ZouJ,ToimelaT,PyykkoI,HeinonenT.Theappli-
cabili y o con en ional cy o oxici y assays o p edic sa e y/ oxici y o
mesopo ous silica nanopa icles, sil e and gold nanopa icles and
mul i-walled ca bon nano ubes. Toxicol In Vi o 2016;37:113–20.
NANOCI e231
O ology & Neu o ology, Vol. 38, No. 8, 2017