RESEARCH ARTICLE
Dono -de i ed IL-17A and IL-17F de iciency
igge s Th1 allo- esponses and inc eases gu
leakage du ing acu e GVHD
I an OdakID
1☯
, Alina Depka -Jakob
1☯
, Maleen Beck
2
, Michael Ja ek
3
, Yan Yu
4
,
U sula Seidle
4
, Sascha Da id
5
, A nold Ganse
2
, Reinhold Fo
¨ s e
1
, Immo P inz
1☯
,
Ch is ian KoeneckeID
1,2☯
*
1Ins i u e o Immunology, Hanno e Medical School, Hanno e , Ge many, 2Depa men o Hema ology,
Hemos asis, Oncology and S em-Cell T ansplan a ion, Hanno e Medical School, Hanno e , Ge many,
3Helmhol z Cen e o In ec ion Resea ch, B aunschweig, Ge many, 4Depa men o Gas oen e ology,
Hepa ology and Endoc inology, Hanno e Medical School, Hanno e , Ge many, 5Depa men o
Neph ology, Hanno e Medical School, Hanno e , Ge many
☯These au ho s con ibu ed equally o his wo k.
*koenecke.ch is ian@mh-hanno e .de
Abs ac
IL-17A and IL-17F cy okines a e impo an egula o s o acu e g a - e sus-hos -disease
(GVHD). Howe e , con a y e ec s o hese cy okines in in lamma o y diseases ha e been
epo ed. To in es iga e he e ec s o dono -de i ed IL-17A and IL-17F on GVHD, we made
use o single (Il17a
-/-
o Il17
-/-
) and double de icien (Il17a
-/-
) allogeneic dono CD4
+
T cells.
We could demons a e ha ansplan a ion o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
dono T cells led o agg a a ed
GVHD. Howe e , his pheno ype was no obse ed a e ansplan a ion o single, Il17a
-/-
o
Il17
-/-
, de icien CD4
+
T cells, sugges ing edundan e ec s o IL-17A and IL-17F. Mo eo e ,
Il17a
-/-
cell ecipien s showed an inc ease o sys emic IFNγ, indica ing a heigh ened p o-
in lamma o y s a e, as well as in il a ion o IFNγ-sec e ing CD4
+
T cells in he ecipien s’ in es-
inal ac . These ecipien s exhibi ed signi ican gu leakage, and ma kedly mac ophage in il-
a ion in he gas oin es inal epi helial laye . Mo eo e , we saw e idence o impai ed eco e y
o gu epi helial cells in ecipien s o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cells. In his s udy, we show ha IL-17A/F
double de iciency o dono CD4
+
T cells leads o accele a ed GVHD and he e o e highligh
he impo ance o hese cy okines. Toge he , IL-17 cy okines migh se e as a b ake o an
in ensi ied Th1 esponse, leading o he exace ba ed gu damage in acu e GVHD.
In oduc ion
Acu e G a - e sus-Hos disease (GVHD) is s ill a majo cause o non- elapse- ela ed mo al-
i y a e allogeneic hema opoie ic s em-cell o bone ma ow ansplan a ion (BMT) [1]. The
cu en s anda d o ca e o highe g ade GVHD is he sys emic use o s e oids. Fu he he a-
peu ic op ions, especially o s e oid- e ac o y GVHD a e spa se [2]. The e o e, iden i ica ion
o new he apeu ic a ge s bo h o p ophylaxis and ea men o GVHD a e needed. Alloge-
neic dono lymphocy es induce and o ches a e his highly in lamma o y disease in he lym-
pho-hema opoie ic compa men and in GVHD a ge o gans, espec i ely. In pa icula
PLOS ONE
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 1 / 16
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
OPEN ACCESS
Ci a ion: Odak I, Depka -Jakob A, Beck M, Ja ek M,
Yu Y, Seidle U, e al. (2020) Dono -de i ed IL-17A
and IL-17F de iciency igge s Th1 allo- esponses
and inc eases gu leakage du ing acu e GVHD.
PLoS ONE 15(4): e0231222. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222
Edi o : Pie e Bobe
´, Uni e si e Pa is-Sud, FRANCE
Recei ed: Decembe 10, 2019
Accep ed: Ma ch 18, 2020
Published: Ap il 6, 2020
Copy igh : ©2020 Odak e al. This is an open
access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he
C ea i e Commons A ibu ion License, which
pe mi s un es ic ed use, dis ibu ion, and
ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal
au ho and sou ce a e c edi ed.
Da a A ailabili y S a emen : All ele an da a a e
wi hin he pape and i s Suppo ing In o ma ion
iles.
Funding: This wo k was suppo ed by Deu sche
Fo schungsgemeinscha : SFB738/A8 o C.K. and
SFB900/B8 o C.K. and I.P. The unde had no ole
in s udy design, da a collec ion and analysis,
decision o publish, o p epa a ion o he
manusc ip .
Compe ing in e es s: The au ho s ha e decla ed
ha no compe ing in e es s exis .
CD4
+
T cells show a high deg ee o plas ici y in he cou se o he disease [3]. Func ional oles
o Th1, Th2 and egula o y T cells (T egs) a e well known in GVHD [4,5]. Howe e , he exac
ole o IL-17 and Th17 cell esponses in acu e GVHD is less clea .
The subse o CD4
+
T cells e med Th17 cells is cha ac e ized by p oduc ion o i s signa u e
cy okine IL-17A. Howe e , he IL-17 cy okine amily comp ises IL-17A, IL-17B, IL-17C, IL-
17D, IL-17E and IL-17F, all ha ing a simila p o ein s uc u e and sha ing be ween 62% o 88%
o homology o mu ine o human [6]. The co esponding IL-17 ecep o amily consis s o i e
membe s, IL-17RA, IL-17RB, IL-17RC, IL-17RD and IL-17RE. IL-17RA o ms a he e odime
wi h IL-17RC, which oge he binds IL-17A dime s, IL-17F dime s, as well as IL-17A:IL17F he -
e odime s [7,8]. IL-17A and IL-17F sha e 55% homology on he amino acid le el, and a e syn e-
nic bo h in mice and humans [9]. Bo h cy okines a e in ol ed in an i- ungal, bac e ial and
alle gic immune esponses [10,11]. Howe e , despi e he appa en simila i ies, he e is e idence
o dis inc oles o he wo cy okines in immuni y [12]. Depending on he expe imen al model,
IL-17 cy okines IL-17A and IL-17F may exe ei he pa hogenic o p o ec i e e ec s, e.g. p o-
mo ing espi a o y alle gy [11] o media ing p o ec ion in neph i is [13]. To da e, Janus-head
oles aken by Th17 and associa ed cy okines such as IL-17A and IL-22 du ing acu e GVHD
ha e been documen ed [14] In one s udy, IL-17A de iciency led o disease educ ion [15],
whe eas ano he s udy showed ha he absence o IL-17A- sec e ing cells exace ba ed GVHD
[16]. Howe e , expe imen al se ups and GVHD models di e ed in hose s udies. IL-17A is p o-
posed o exe a p o ec i e ole du ing gu -in lamma ion by limi ing excessi e pe meabili y and
he eby main aining ba ie in eg i y [17,18]. Ano he p o ec i e ole in coli is model has been
a ibu ed o IL-17A by o cing he exp ession o Th1- associa ed esponses [19]. Since excessi e
endo helial and epi helial pe meabili y is one o he p e equisi es o acu e GVHD [20], we
hypo hesized ha dono -de i ed IL-17 cy okines exe a p o ec i e ole in acu e GVHD.
In his s udy, we dissec he ole o dono -de i ed IL-17A and IL-17F o endo helial and
epi helial pe meabili y in an expe imen al acu e GVHD model using single- (Il17a
-/-
,Il17
-/-
)
and double-de icien (Il17a
-/-
) dono T cells. Ou esul s show a p o ec i e ole o mu ually
edundan dono -de i ed IL-17 cy okines IL-17A and IL-17F. We u he demons a e ha
inc eased gu leakage and mac ophage in il a ion occu s when dono -de i ed IL-17A and IL-
17F a e absen . Ou esul s sugges ha dono -de i ed IL-17 migh con ibu e o p o ec ion o
he in es inal ba ie du ing acu e GVHD.
Ma e ial and me hods
Animals
Wild ype (WT) C57BL/6 Thy1.2 (BL6, H-2K
b
), BALB/c (H-2K
d
), B6xDBA2 F1 (BDF1, H-2K
bxd
)
mice we e ob ained om Cha les Ri e Labo a o ies (Sulz eld, Ge many). B6.129P2-Il17a
m1Yiw
(Il17a
–/–
) mice we e kindly p o ided by Y. Iwaku a (The Uni e si y o Tokyo, Bunkyō-ku,
Japan) B6.129S6-Il17
m1Awai
(Il17
–/–
) mice we e kindly p o ided by B. Beche (Uni e si y o
Zu¨ ich, Zu¨ ich, Swi ze land). WT C57BL/6 Thy1.1, Il17a
–/–
,Il17
–/–
and Il7a
-/-
(C57BL/6J-Il17a/
Il17 m1Imp ) we e b ed a he cen al animal acili y o Hanno e Medical School unde spe-
ci ic pa hogen- ee condi ions. All animal expe imen s we e ca ied ou in acco dance wi h ins i-
u ional and go e nmen al di ec i es and we e app o ed by Niede sa¨chsisches Landesam u¨
Ve b auche schu z und Lebensmi elsiche hei (pe mi numbe : 33.14-42502-04-11/0619 and
33.19-42502-04-14/1660).
Bone ma ow ansplan a ion and GVHD induc ion
Fo BMT and GVHD-induc ion in he C57BL/6!BALB/c model, 8–10 weeks old BALB/c
ecipien s ecei ed le hal i adia ion wi h 8 Gy om a Cs γ-sou ce. Dono cells we e
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 2 / 16
ansplan ed wi hin 24 hou s a e i adia ion. All ecipien mice ecei ed 3.0–5.0x10
6
T cell-
deple ed bone ma ow (TCD BM) C57BL/6 o BALB/c BM cells and 0.5x10
6
CD4
+
T cells
om C57BL/6 WT, Il17a
–/–
,Il17
–/–
o Il17a
–/–
mice. Single-cell suspensions we e p epa ed
om pe iphe al lymph nodes (pLN) and spleen and en iched ia magne ic mic obeads
(MACS, CD4
+
T cell isola ion ki ; Mil enyi Bio ec, Be gisch-Gladbach, Ge many). BM cells
we e ha es ed om he emu s and ibias o dono mice. BM cells we e s ained wi h bio iny-
la ed an i-CD3 (clone 17A2, homemade) and sepa a ed ia s ep a idin-conjuga ed magne ic
beads (Mil enyi Bio ec, Be gisch-Gladbach, Ge many) in o de o deple e T cells. A e ans-
plan a ion, mice we e kep on an ibio ic wa e (Co imoxazol; Ra iopha m, Ulm, Ge many)
un il he end o he expe imen . Su i al, weigh loss and clinical GVHD-signs o ecipien
mice we e moni o ed and sco ed acco ding o Cooke e al [21]. Clinical signs o acu e G HD,
such as u led u , weigh loss (mild >10% o ini ial body weigh ; se e e >25% o ini ial body
weigh ), hunched back, inac i i y and dia hea, we e moni o ed wo imes pe day. Se e i y o
each clinical sign was sco ed (no = 0; mild = 1; se e e = 2) and animals wi h a o al sco e o �6
we e sac i iced immedia ely by ce ical disloca ion and coun ed as GVHD le hali y. All ans-
plan ed mice we e p o ided wi h mois ened ood o allow easie eeding and aid hyd a ion.
Hanno e Medical School p o ided he esea ch s a wi h special aining in animal handling.
Despi e equen moni o ing, occasionally, mice we e ound dead wi hou clinical signs o
GVHD wi hin he i s 10 days a e ansplan a ion. This was limi ed o ewe han 5% o
mice in ol ed in he s udy and was conside ed as non-GVHD mo ali y, and hose mice we e
excluded om he inal analysis.
Cell p oli e a ion assay
P oli e a ion o Il17a
–/–
o WT T cells a e unspeci ic s imula ion wi h CD3/CD28 beads
(The moFishe , Schwe e, Ge many) o allogeneic BM-de i ed DCs was de e mined by
3
H-Thymidine up ake as ollows: 5,000 cells we e incuba ed in a 96-well pla e wi h 150μl
RPMI medium supplemen ed wi h 10% FCS, 1% L-glu amine, 1% Pen-S ep and 0.04% gen a-
mycine. The cells we e incuba ed o wo days in 95% humidi ied a mosphe e by 5% CO
2
a
37˚C, be o e 0.8 mCi
3
H-Thymidine (Ha man) was added pe well. The inco po a ion o
adioac i e hymidine was measu ed 16h la e in a Mic obe a wo ks a ion (Pe kin Elma ).
B dU p oli e a ion assay
Day 20 a e BMT, mice we e i.p. injec ed wi h 3mg 5-B omo-20-deoxyu idine (B dU) (Sigma-
Ald ich) and se on 0.8mg/ml B dU con aining wa e o e nigh . A e 24h, mice we e sac i-
iced 24h and SI and colon we e ixed in 4% o maline (Sigma-Ald ich) o e nigh and p o-
cessed as desc ibed abo e. De ec ion o inco po a ed B dU was pe o med wi h he B dU In-
Si u De ec ion Ki (Ca No. 550803, BD Biosciences) acco ding o he manu ac u e ’s manual.
Pic u es we e acqui ed wi h an Olympus BX61 (Olympus, Hambu g, Ge many) con ocal
mic oscope and p ocessed wi h he cellSens Dimensions 1.9 so wa e (Olympus, Hambu g,
Ge many).
16S DNA Illumina sequencing o s ool bac e ia in GVHD si ua ion
F esh s ool samples we e collec ed om il17a
–/–
and WT ecipien s a day 14 and day 21 a e
BMT. Bac e ial DNA was isola ed using QIAamp DNA S ool Mini Ki (Qiagen) acco ding o
manu ac u e ’s manual. In he i s PCR ound, 16S V3-V4 egions we e ampli ied by 15 PCR
cycles using published p ime s [22]:
S-D-Bac -0341F (5’-acac c ccc acacgacgc c ccga c CCTACGGGNGGC
WGCAG-3’) and S-D-Bac -0785R (5’-
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 3 / 16
g gac ggag cagacg g gc c ccga c GACTACHVGGGTATCTAATCC-3’). In
he second PCR wi h 13 cycles Illumina-adap e s we e added using ollowing p ime s: adap-
e _ o : (5’ aa ga acggcgaccaccgaga c acac c ccc ac 3’) and adap e _-
e : (5’-caagcagaagacggca acgaga XXXXXXg gac g-3’). The XXXXXX bases
ep esen he MID egion, each sample was coded wi h a dis inc DNA agmen o la e
assignmen . All PCR s eps we e pe o med wi h Ad an age2 PCR ki (Taka a). PCR p oduc s
we e sepa a ed wi h a 2% aga ose gel in TAE bu e . Fo gel ex ac ion, QIAquick Gel ex ac-
ion ki (Quagen) was used acco ding o manu ac u e ’s manual. Lib a y concen a ion was
adjus ed and 250bp pai ed-end sequencing was pe o med on he Illumina MiSeq sys em ol-
lowing s anda d p o ocol. Quali y con ol and adap e clipping o he sequences was done
using as q-mc ool o ea-u ils [23]. Sequencing da a we e p ocessed acco ding o he wo k-
low lis ed: Pai ed- eads we e joined using o ea-u ils. Chime as we e excluded using Usea ch
[24] sequence analysis ool wi h uchime [25] command based on chime aslaye gold 16s
RNA da abase ( elease 4.29.2010) as e e ence. Taxonomy assignmen was pe o med by
RDP-classi ie 2.8 [26] wi h con idence alue o 0.5.
T ansendo helial elec ical esis ance (TEndoR)
Human umbilical ein endo helial cells (HUVECs) we e g own o con luence in polyca bona e
wells con aining e apo a ed gold mic oelec odes in se ies wi h a la ge gold coun e connec ed
o a phase-sensi i e lock-in ampli ie as desc ibed p e iously. TEndoR was measu ed using
an elec ical cell-subs a e impedance sensing sys em (ECIS) (Applied BioPhysics Inc.) as
desc ibed elsewhe e [27]. Each condi ion’s endpoin esis ance was di ided by i s s a ing
esis ance o gi e he no malized TEndoR. When he cells eached he esis ance mo e han
1500 ohm, cells we e ea ed wi h 10ng/ml IL-17 (Sigma-Ald ich, S -Luis, MO) and TEndoR
was measu ed he ea e in eal- ime.
T ansepi helial esis ance (TEpiR) and luo escein pe meabili y
measu emen s
Epi helial pe meabili y: Caco-2Bbe cells we e seeded on 0.4 μm snapwells (Co ning Li e Sci-
ences, USA) a 1.5 ×104/cm
2
and g own o 14 days. TEpiR was measu ed daily using a
EVOM2 ol ohmme e (Wo ld P ecision Ins umen s, Sa aso a, FL). On day 14, IFN-γ10ng/
ml (Sigma Ald ich, Ge many) ±IL-17 (IL-17A o IL-17F 2.5ng/ml ~ 10ng/ml) (Sigma Ald ich,
Ge many) was added o he apical and basola e al ba h e e y 12 hou s. A e 24h, bo h sides o
he cell monolaye we e incuba ed wi h TNF-α10ng/ml ±IL-17 (IL-17A o IL-17F 2.5ng/ml ~
10ng/ml) in he con inuous p esence o INF-γ, and TEpiR was measu ed be o e, 2h, 4h, 8h,
12h and 24h a e TNF-αaddi ion. Subsequen ly, he cell we e ans e ed o an Ussing Cham-
be sys em (Easymoun , Physiologic Ins umen s, CA), incuba ed in a bu e con aining NaCl
116 mM, KH2PO4 0.4 mM, K2HPO4 2.4 mM, MgCl2 1.2 mM, CaCl2 1.2 mM, NaHCO3 24
mM, gassed wi h 95% O2 and 5% CO2 a 37˚C. TEER was moni o ed wi h KCl aga elec odes.
100 μM luo escein o (FITC)-dex an-4000 was added o he apical side, and bo h apical and
basola e al samples we e collec ed 1 hou la e and measu ed wi h a luo ome e a 520 nm
(Tecan In ini e M200, Tecan, Swi ze land). Fluo escein and (FITC)-dex an-4000 pa acellula
luxes we e p esen ed as he a io o he ace in he basola e al compa men and in he apical
compa men . T ace luxes = basola e al FITC in ensi y / apical FITC in ensi y ×100%. Da a
a e p esen ed as mean ±SEM, n = 3–4 samples in each condi ion.
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 4 / 16
Da a analysis and s a is ics
S a is ical analysis was pe o med wi h P ism 7 (G aph-Pad So wa e, Inc.). S a is ical di e -
ences o he mean alues a e as ollows: �, P�0.05; ��, P�0.01; and ���, P�0.001. S uden ’s
es , Mann Whi ney U es o ANOVA we e used o calcula ing s a is ical signi icance. The
analysis o su i al da a was pe o med using Kaplan-Meie es ima ion and log- ank es .
Fu he de ails on me hods a e a ailable as supplemen a y me hods and ma e ial.
Resul s
Dono IL-17A and IL-17F de iciency leads o agg a a ed acu e GVHD
To assess he e ec s o IL-17 p oduced by dono -de i ed Th17 cells in acu e GVHD, we com-
pa ed he ou come o expe imen al acu e GVHD induced by adop i e ans e o allogeneic
CD4
+
T cells om wild ype (WT) o Il7a
-/-
dono s [5] using C57BL/6 dono s and le hally
i adia ed BALB/c ecipien s. Pheno ype o s eady s a e CD4
+
cells om Il17a
-/-
mice we e
analyzed by low cy ome y and showed no majo di e ences compa ed o WT CD4
+
T cells
(S1 Fig). Recipien s o Il17a
-/-
CD4 T cells showed a signi ican inc ease o GVHD se e i y
and mo ali y as compa ed o WT con ols (Fig 1A and 1B). In e es ingly, ecipien s o
Il17a
-/-
T cells su e ed om se e e dia hea ea ly a e ansplan a ion (Fig 1C).
To e i y he occu ence o Th17 cells a e BMT, we analyzed IL-17 sec e ion o CD4
+
T
cells in hos issues by in acellula cy okine s aining. We e-isola ed dono lymphocy es om
ecipien s’ colon, small in es ine (SI) and lymph nodes 21 days a e ansplan a ion and
s ained o IL-17A and IL-17F. Thy1.1 was used o sepa a e dono om emaining hos CD4
+
T cells ha escaped elimina ion by condi ioning. IL-17A and F sec e ion by CD4 T cells was
e iden in pe iphe al lymph nodes (pLN) and GVHD a ge o gans (Fig 1D). Nex , we ana-
lyzed sys emic cy okine le els a e GVHD ini ia ion. We obse ed a ma ked inc ease o IL-6,
IFNγand MCP-1 le els in Il17a
-/-
ecipien s as compa ed o WT- ecipien s a di e en ime
poin s a e ansplan a ion (Fig 1E). F om hese da a we conclude ha dono -de i ed IL-17A
and IL-17F exe p o ec i e e ec s in he ea ly cou se o GVHD. Since he IL-17 iso o ms A
and F bo h bind o he IL-17RA ecep o , we checked whe he ei he lack o IL-17A o F
al e ed p o ec ion om acu e GVHD. To ha end, we made use o single Il17a
-/-
,Il17
-/-
and
double IL-17-de icien (Il17a
-/-
) CD4
+
T cells. We obse ed ha only ecipien s ecei ing
Il17a
-/-
, bu no Il17a
-/-
,Il17
-/-
CD4
+
T cells, de eloped an agg a a ed GVHD as compa ed o
WT con ols (Fig 2A and 2B). In o de o alida e ou expe imen al se up, we e-isola ed
dono CD4
+
T cells om pLNs o ecipien s and s ained o IL-17A and IL-17F o check o
sec e ion o IL-17 cy okines. Indeed, we obse ed exp ession o bo h IL-17A and IL-17F om
WT CD4
+
cells, whe eas Il17a
-/-
and Il17
-/-
CD4
+
T cells exp essed only IL-17F and IL-17A
espec i ely. Expec edly, Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cells did nei he exp ess IL-17A no IL-17F (Fig 2C).
IL-17 de iciency o dono T cells does no al e he mic obial lo a a e
BMT
The composi ion o he gu mic obiome a ec s GVHD ou come [28] and i has been shown
ha Th17 cells ha e an impac on modula ion o he mic obiome in se e al expe imen al
GVHD models [29]. O no e, bac e oidaceae species ha e been shown o compose he majo i y
o he s ool mic obio a in pa ien s wi hou acu e GVHD [30]. The e o e, we sequenced s ool
samples o Il17a
-/-
o WT CD4
+
T cell ecipien s a day 14 and day 21 day a e ansplan a ion
(Fig 3A and 3B). In e es ingly, we ound no signi ican di e ence in he o e all mic obio a
di e si y be ween ecipien s ei he on day 14 o day 21 pos allo-BMT as assessed by Shannon
indices (Fig 3C and 3D) o in p e alence o he bac e oidaceae amily be ween g oups (Fig 3E).
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 5 / 16

Fig 1. De iciency o IL-17A and IL-17F in dono CD4
+
T cells leads o agg a a ed GVHD. BALB/c mice we e le hally
i adia ed and ansplan ed wi h 5x10
6
TCD BM and 0.5x10
6
CD4
+
T cells om BL6 WT o Il17a
-/-
dono s. A) Su i al cu e
o Il17a
-/-
and WT T cell ecipien s. Da a a e pooled om ou independen expe imen s (Il17a
-/-
n = 21, WT CD4
+
cells
n = 22). Fo s a is ical analysis he log ank es was used. B) Clinical sco e. C) Pe cen age o dia hea- ee mice. D) FACS
so ed dono Thy1.1
+
CD4
+
T cells we e analyzed o he exp ession o IL-17A and IL-17F. Dono WT o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cells
we e isola ed om BALB/c ecipien s om colon, SI and pLNs on day 21 a e BMT. Da a we e collec ed om h ee
independen expe imen s o colon and SI (WT n = 10, Il17a
-/-
n = 11); and wo expe imen s pLNs (WT = 8, Il17a
-/-
n = 7). E)
Concen a ions o IL-6, MCP-1 and IFNγcy okines in he se a o WT o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cell ecipien s sac i iced a day 7, 14,
and 21 a e BMT. (day 7 WT n = 10, Il17a
-/-
n = 10; day 14 WT n = 11, Il17a
-/-
n = 12; day 21 WT n = 16, Il17a
-/-
n = 15).
S a is ical signi icance was de e mined by S uden ’s es . The ba s show he mean and e o ba s show SEM.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222.g001
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 6 / 16
Lack o dono CD4
+
T cell-de i ed IL-17A and IL-17F esul s in inc eased
in es inal leakage
Recipien s o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cells showed ea ly and se e e dia hea (Fig 1C), sugges ing al e -
a ion o he in es inal ba ie . To es he unc ionali y o he in es inal ba ie a e GVHD-ini-
ia ion, we applied FITC-dex an by o al ga age o BMT- ecipien s [31]. The ea e , se um
FITC-Dex an concen a ions we e assessed a day 21 pos - ansplan a ion. We obse ed a sig-
ni ican ly inc eased in es inal leakage in ecipien s o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cells (Fig 4A), indica ing
in es inal ba ie b eakdown. We es ed whe he IL-17 cy okines exe p o ec i e e ec s in
i o. Fo his pu pose, we used ECIS o analyze he e ec o IL-17 on endo helial leakage.
In e es ingly, we did no see any e ec o ei he o he IL-17 cy okines in educ ion o TNFα-
induced leakage in such expe imen s (Fig 4B).
Fig 2. IL-17A and IL-17F a e ecip ocally compensa ed du ing GVHD. BALB/c mice we e le hally i adia ed and ansplan ed wi h 5x10
6
TCD BM and 0.5x10
6
CD4
+
T cells om BL6 WT, Il17a
-/-
,Il17a
-/-
, o Il17
-/-
dono s. A) Su i al cu e o BL6 BL6 WT, Il17a
-/-
,Il17a
-/-
, o
Il17
-/-
CD4
+
T cell ecipien s, da a we e gene a ed in wo expe imen s (BL6 WT, Il17a
-/-
,Il17a
-/-
n = 8, Il17
-/-
n = 10) B) Clinical sco e. C)
Exp ession o IL-17A and IL-17F by dono CD4
+
T cells isola ed om pLNs o BL6 WT, Il17a
-/-
Il17a
-/-
, o Il17
-/-
CD4
+
T cell ecipien s in
expe imen al GVHD a day 21 a e ansplan a ion. Fo s a is ical analysis, non-pa ame ic wo- ailed T es was used. Da a ep esen he
equency and he SD o a single expe imen (n = 3 pe g oup). �p�0.05.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222.g002
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 7 / 16
The e has been eme ging e idence o a p o ec i e ole o IL-17 in os e ing gu in eg i y ia
modula ion o epi helial igh junc ions, albei in a di e en expe imen al se up [32]. The e-
o e, we analyzed he consequences o IL-17A and IL-17F adminis a ion in an in i o-sys em
o gu -epi helial-leakage. To ha end, we used he well-cha ac e ized Caco2BBe cell line
exp essing IL-17 ecep o , g own as di e en ia ed monolaye cul u es on pe meable il e s,
and measu ed he TEpiR as a measu e o pa acellula pe meabili y. TEpiR was measu ed
daily wi h an EVOM2 (Vol ohmme e , WPI), and a he end o he incuba ion ime in an
Fig 3. IL-17 A/F de iciency does no al e he mic obial lo a a e allogeneic BMT. BALB/c mice we e le hally i adia ed and ansplan ed wi h
5x10
6
TCD BM and 0.5x10
6
CD4
+
cells om BL6 WT o Il17a
-/-
dono s. A-B) Rep esen a i e g aph o mic obial lo a in he eces o WT and
Il17a
-/-
T cell ecipien s a A) day 14 o B) day 21 a e BMT. Hea -maps o he ela i e abundance o bac e ial species a phylogene ic le el o
amilies a e p esen ed o one ep esen a i e expe imen . Each column ep esen s one sample om indi idual mouse. (day 14 WT n = 3,
Il17a
-/-
n = 3; day 21 WT n = 4, Il17a
-/-
n = 4). C) Shannon index o di e si y o all samples on he amily le el a day 14 and D) day 21 a e BMT.
E) Rela i e abundance o Bac e oidaceae amily in he eces o WT and Il17a
-/-
T cell ecipien s a day 21 a e BMT. (day 14 WT n = 10,
Il17a
-/-
n = 10; day 21 WT n = 13, T Il17a
-/-
n = 14). Sequences wi h an abundance o less han 1% we e excluded om he analysis.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222.g003
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 8 / 16
Ussing chambe se up. Addi ionally, we assessed apical o basola e al luo escein (FITC)
luxes. Howe e , we saw no e idence o a p o ec i e ole o IL-17A o IL-17F agains TNFα-
induced dec ease in TEpiR (Fig 4C and 4D). While TNFαincuba ion esul ed in a signi ican
dec ease in TEpiR, e i ied by TEpiR measu emen s in he Ussing Chambe (Fig 4E) and by
an inc ease in FITC pe meabili y, he p e-incuba ion o 24 h wi h IL-17A o IL-17F did no
p e en he inc ease in epi helial pe meabili y (Fig 4F).
Lack o dono -de i ed IL-17A and F cells leads o inc eased IFNγ
p oduc ion o dono CD4 T cells and mac ophage in lux o he in es ine
Th1 T cells p oducing he p oin lamma o y cy okine IFNγha e been shown o be de imen al
in inducing GVHD [33]. Hence, we compa ed he numbe s o CD4
+
T cells sec e ing IFNγin
Fig 4. Recipien s o Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
cells show gu -leakiness. BALB/c mice we e le hally i adia ed and ansplan ed wi h 5x10
6
TCD BM and 0.5x10
6
CD4
+
cells om BL6 WT o Il17a
-/-
dono s. A) Concen a ion o ansloca ed FITC-dex an in he se a o WT and Il17a
-/-
CD4
+
T cell ecipien s a
day 21 a e BMT. (n = 6, Il17a
-/-
n = 4) B) Inc ease in ansendo helial elec ical esis ance (TEndoR) no malized o ehicle. C) Inc ease in
ansepi helial elec ical esis ance (TepiR, measu ed daily wi h an EVOM2 ol ohmme e , o e he days in cul u e a e con luency. All ou g oups
had a simila inc ease in TEpiR p io o he cy okine ea men . D) a day 14 pos con luency, he cells we e incuba ed wi h 10ng/ml in e e on-γ±
IL17A o IL17F, ollowed by 10g/ml TNF-α10ng/ml ±IL-17 (IL-17A o IL-17F 10ng/ml) 24 h la e , and TEpiR was assessed a he indica ed imes. E)
A e 24h, he il e s we e ans e ed o an Ussing-chambe sys em, and bo h TEpiR, and F) FITC pe meabili y was assessed. The alues in C and D
a e gi en in % o he alue ea ed wi h IFN-γand TNF-αonly. All da a a e pooled om wo o h ee independen expe imen s. E o ba s ep esen
SEM. Fo s a is ical analysis Log- ank es was used. �p�0.05.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222.g004
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 9 / 16
31. Hanash AM, Dudako JA, Hua G, O’Conno MH, Young LF, Singe N V., e al. In e leukin-22 P o ec s
In es inal S em Cells om Immune-Media ed Tissue Damage and Regula es Sensi i i y o G a e sus
Hos Disease. Immuni y [In e ne ]. 2012 Aug; 37(2):339–50. A ailable om: h ps://linkinghub.else ie .
com/ e ie e/pii/S1074761312003317
32. Lee JS, Ta o CM, Joyce-Shaikh B, Gulan F, Caya e C, Chen Y, e al. In e leukin-23-Independen IL-17
P oduc ion Regula es In es inal Epi helial Pe meabili y. Immuni y [In e ne ]. 2015; 43(4):727–38. A ail-
able om: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.immuni.2015.09.003
33. Choi J, Ziga ED, Ri chey J, Collins L, P io JL, Coope ML, e al. IFNγR signaling media es allo eac i e
T-cell a icking and GVHD. Blood. 2012; 120(19):4093–103. h ps://doi.o g/10.1182/blood-2012-01-
403196 PMID: 22972985
34. Wu C, Xue Y, Wang P, Lin L, Liu Q, Li N, e al. IFN-γP imes Mac ophage Ac i a ion by Inc easing Phos-
pha ase and Tensin Homolog ia Down egula ion o miR-3473b. J Immunol [In e ne ]. 2014; 193
(6):3036–44. A ailable om: h p://www.jimmunol.o g/lookup/doi/10.4049/jimmunol.1302379
35. Eye ich K, Dima ino V, Ca ani A. IL-17 and IL-22 in immuni y: D i ing p o ec ion and pa hology. Eu J
Immunol. 2017; 47(4):607–14. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/eji.201646723 PMID: 28295238
36. Van de Waa AB, an de Velden WJFM, Blijle ens NM, Dols a H. Ta ge ing he IL17 pa hway o he
p e en ion o g a - e sus-hos disease. Biol Blood Ma ow T ansplan [In e ne ]. 2014; 20(6):752–9.
A ailable om: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.bbm .2014.02.007
37. Dubin PJ, Kolls JK. In e leukin-17A and In e leukin-17F: A Tale o Two Cy okines. Immuni y [In e ne ].
2009; 30(1):9–11. A ailable om: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j.immuni.2008.12.010
38. Tang C, Kaku a S, Shimizu K, Kadoki M, Kamiya T, Shimazu T, e al. Supp ession o IL-17F, bu no o
IL-17A, p o ides p o ec ion agains coli is by inducing T eg cells h ough modi ica ion o he in es inal
mic obio a. Na Immunol [In e ne ]. 2018; 19(7):755–65. A ailable om: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1038/
s41590-018-0134-y
39. Papo o PH, Ribo JC, Sil a-San os B. IL-17 + γδ T cells as kick-s a e s o in lamma ion. Na Immunol.
2017; 18(6):604–11. h ps://doi.o g/10.1038/ni.3726 PMID: 28518154
40. Be nink JH, Ohne Y, Teunissen MBM, Wang J, Wu J, K abbendam L, e al. c-Ki -posi i e ILC2s exhibi
an ILC3-like signa u e ha may con ibu e o IL-17-media ed pa hologies. Na Immunol [In e ne ]. 2019;
A ailable om: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1038/s41590-019-0423-0
41. Gladia o A, Wangle N, T au wein-Weidne K, LeibundGu -Landmann S. Cu ing Edge: IL-17–Sec e -
ing Inna e Lymphoid Cells A e Essen ial o Hos De ense agains Fungal In ec ion. J Immunol. 2013;
190(2):521–5. h ps://doi.o g/10.4049/jimmunol.1202924 PMID: 23255360
42. Bu man AC, Bano ic T, Kuns RD, Clous on AD, S anley AC, Mo is ES, e al. IFNγdi e en ially con ols
he de elopmen o idiopa hic pneumonia synd ome and GVHD o he gas oin es inal ac . Blood.
2007; 110(3):1064–72. h ps://doi.o g/10.1182/blood-2006-12-063982 PMID: 17449800
43. Wang H, Asa a oengchai W, Yeap BY, Wang MG, Wang S, Sykes M, e al. Pa adoxical e ec s o IFN-
γin g a - e sus-hos disease e lec p omo ion o lymphohema opoie ic g a - e sus-hos eac ions
and inhibi ion o epi helial issue inju y. Blood. 2009; 113(15):3612–9. h ps://doi.o g/10.1182/blood-
2008-07-168419 PMID: 19211507
44. Janeway Cha les A J , T a e s Paul, Walpo Ma k and MJS. Immunobiology: The Immune Sys em in
Heal h and Disease. In: 5 h ed. New Yo k: Ga land Science; 2001.
45. Alexande KA, Flynn R, Linebu g KE, Kuns RD, Teal BE, Ol e SD, e al. CSF-1–dependan dono -
de i ed mac ophages media e ch onic g a - e sus-hos disease. J Clin In es [In e ne ]. 2014 Oc 1;
124(10):4266–80. A ailable om: h p://www.jci.o g/a icles/ iew/75935
46. Nishiwaki S, Nakayama T, Mu a a M, Nishida T, Te aku a S, Sai o S, e al. Dexame hasone palmi a e
amelio a es mac ophages- ich g a - e sus-hos disease by inhibi ing mac ophage unc ions. PLoS
One. 2014; 9(5).
PLOS ONE
IL-17A and IL17F and acu e GVHD
PLOS ONE | h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pone.0231222 Ap il 6, 2020 16 / 16