scieee Open visual document viewer

The new external microbeam facility of the Oxford nuclear microprobe and its application to problems in archaeological science

Grime, G.W.

Abstract

Recent developments of the extemal beam facility of the Oxford Nuclear Microprobe have led to an enhancement of the capabilities of the instrument for analysing large or sensitive objects in air with a spatial resolution of 50 to 100 (xm. Used in conjunction with the 1 pm resolution in-vacuo facility this provides a unique elemental analysis facility which is being applied to a number of archaeological problems. This paper describes briefly the capabilities of the faci lity and outlines the range of applications.

Full text

436 I!; ' I ' : i| i ' k /^aUPTMANM ^9] Keesmann. I.. 1989, Chemischc und m • - a ion eisen eiche Schiacken. In R p. nciailun c sucluiniien zu 1987. Symposium Lihlice Í9H7. P aguc o i O'^' Í20] C addock,PT., 1995.£ í / /V/í «/A/,»,,,„ , 1211 ^i i n I - * " l* n(im i(>n. uJinhu uh '■''i Gale, N.H., Papas ama aki. A.. S os-Gale y . " ce- and Coppe Me allu gy in he Acgean B o— ^ CoppC w An iqui y, ed. PT. C addock and ""<1 Snwl in i Technology 81-101. ^22] Le y, T., Adams, R.A. and Na|j „ Hughcs). B i . .Musi:um C)cc. ' Jo dán: The Jaba! Ham a Fidan (^k dí!Tu Homepage. A duu-nlo^y P ojcc. 1999. In e ne - Kólschbach,S., 1999. Expc imcnic zu .Simni. . . . . ■y.i.- Ve ah ens echnik on Windd cn. P iili'sK. ische Kup c gcwinnung. Wissenscha en, Rhcin.-Wes al. T-cchn M ""u «-''"ghau. Hii enwesen und [241 D , "• ^'<» hschulc Aachcn. ' oachmann, H.G. and Ro hcnbc g. B.. 19x0 In ^ i/cesFup e /,n77nwa- a/. (cds.H.G Con on S- e he J, Bochum, 215-236. ^ Rolhcnbc g). Dc Anschni . Be»- Haup mann, A., Lu z, J., Pe nicka. £. yp.i . 1 • , , -y de iihes en Kup e e hü ung im Vo dc cn O icn ' í'"u ii Teclinolog» Moun ains-A chaeologica Ana olica e M " ""iTn e ! ciío o . , / I '-^''poia nica Alba Painiicn Dedica a Uni e Si a La Sapienza, Rom, ícd. M. F angipane H w. 4 1 ;, ' au - « M. Mellink^ 541-572. Haup mann, M. I.i^c an , P. Mn lhiae & New ¡=™ ' A . B^'^h-nann H.G, nd Maddin. R,. |yy„, c halcl. hic Cppe Sme ing; AM ?T h . A chnc.mci y (ej s. Demi ci. Oze and G.D. Summc .s),Tubi ak. Anka a 3 jo Haup'^nn.A.andRoden.C.. '''««■ A cha«mciailu g¡sche Un c suchungcn zu Kup c - N.H., Bachmann, HG.. Rchenbe g. B., S ns-Cú lc. Z.A. and Tylcc e R F.. 1990, ne Ad en i iou.s P oduclion o I on in ihc .Smeliing al Coppc . In Resmn hes in 'hn ^abah 1959.1984. V„l. II.-The Aneen, Me,.,lu„.^, „, c- In.,-,. A,-cl,.,eo-McU,ll■ S'"' (ed. B. Ro henbe g), London, 182-191 . Roilie ibe g, B. and Shaw, C.T., 1990. The Disco e y <, a Oippo Mine and Sme"®'' m Ihe End o Ihe Ea ly B onze Age (EB IV) in he Timna Vallcy. In.s . A chaeo-Me- • S udies, Newsle e 15/16, 1-8. ^^"P mann. A., 1989, The Ea lie.s Pe iod.s o Coppe Me.allu gy in Feinan/Jo dan. I" « ^o ld A chaeome allu gy, íed: A. Haup mann. E Pe nicka and G.A. Waene ). C>e ^nschn¡ ,Beihe 7 .Bochum, 119-135. [27] [28] [29] [30] [3l] p. VCU.y, I7/0, -y [32j Is ael Explo . Soc., Je u.salem. ®=''-A ieh, I., 1983, Cenl al-Sou hem Sinai in he Ea ly B onze Age II and ,,, Reía ^"■ an, R. (ed,), 1978, Ea y A ad: The Chalc„u,hu Seniemen, and Ea ly B onze Age ^"y- Is ael Explo . Soc., Je usalem. ^'•-A ieh, I., 1983, Cenl al-Sou hem Sin 'dnship wi h Pales ino. Le an! XV, .39-48. THE NEW EXTERNAL MICROBEAM FACILITY OF THE OXFORD NUCLEAR MICROPROBE AND ITS APPLICATION TO PROBLEMS IN ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE G.W. G ime*'^ Abs ac Recen de elopmen s o he ex emal beam acili y o he Ox o d Nuclea Mi- c op obe ha e led o an enhancemen o he capabili ies o he ins umen o analysing la ge o sensi i e objec s in ai wi h a spa ial esolu ion o 50 o 100 (xm. Used in conjunc ion wi h he 1 pm esolu ion in- acuo acili y his p o ides a unique elemen al analysis acili y which is being applied o a numbe o a - chaeological p oblems. This pape desc ibes b ie ly he capabili ies o he aci li y and ou lines he ange o applica ions. 1. INTRODUCTION Ion Beam Analysis (IBA) has a well-es ablished ole in he cha ac e isa ion o a - chaeological and his o ical objec s. The combina ion o ace elemen sensi i i y and quan i a i e accu acy o e ed by he echniques o P o on Induced X- ay Emission (PIXE) o Ru he o d Backsca e ing (RBS) p esen s a solu ion o many p oblems in- ol ing he s udy o a e ac s and aw ma e ials. Using a sui able mic o- ocusing sys- em, IBA can be ca ied ou wi h a spa ial esolu ion o he o de o 1 pm [1], bu his is o en inapp op ia e o a chaeological objec s. This is due o he na u e o he ma e ials, which a e o en he e ogeneous, con aining pa icula e inclusions wi h diame e s o less han 100 mic ome es. The long pene a ion dep h o MeV ligh ions a e ages he signal o e he ange o he ions ( ens o mic ome es) and so unless hin samples a e used, i is no possible o analyse small inclusions sepa a ely om he ma ix and he ad an age o using mic on o sub-mic on beams is los . Ano he p ac ical disad- an age o high esolu ion mic obeam acili ies o a chaeological applica ions is he equi emen o place he sample in an e acua ed chambe , which o mos a chaeo- Uni e si y o Ox o d. Depa lmen o Ma e ials. Pa ks Road. Ox o d. OXl 3PH. UK 438 íi i ilü 11 ! '<. 1^1 N G.W. logical o his o ical objec s equi es sampling, which may be highiy undesi able o p ecious, delica e objec s. 2. THE OXFORD EXTERNAD MICROBEAM FACILITY The long ange o MeV ions in ai p esen s he possibili y o analysing la ge o agüe objec s in ai wi h no sampling equi ed. The beam diame e is deg aded by collisions wi h ai molecule (by app oxima ely 10 pm pe mm o ai pa h), bu as dis- cussed abo e, his is no a majo p oblem o a chaeological samples and by ca e ul design, a spa iai esolu ion o less han 50 pm can be achie ed. Fo he majo i y o sample ion beam analysis in ai is non-des uc i e; he p esence o ai o helium a ound he sample dispe ses any localised hea ing cause by he beam, and so p e en s any he mal damage. In o ganic ma e ials, decomposi ion o la ge o ganic molecules can III Cong eso Nacional de A queome ía 439 x- ay de ec o (ligh elemen s) Beamiine (High acuum) Pa ióle de ec o (below) Magne ic de lec o ;^^Sample Exi nozzle Gamma ay de ec o abso be x- a/de ec o ( ace eie/wdd sj j . ihe V ^^hema ic plan iew o he ex e nal beam analysis acüi y al Ox o d. The beam eme ges o n Q "^o he beamiine h ough a 300 pm diame e hale in a 2mm diame e coppe nozzle sealed Q ^ . ^ hm) plás ic oil. X- ays emi ed om he sample a e de ec ed by wo de ec o s moun ed aí ay /• ^he beam. One de ec o is i ed wi h an x- ay ab.so be o kiü he in ense low ene gy has ensu e good de ec ion limi s o he ace elemen s while he o he de ec o he °^^ ) be and is i ed wi h a magne ic de lec o o ensu e ha high ene gy p o ons do no each o de ec o o gamma ays is moun ed a 90" o he beam. Below he beamiine. a de ec o ple'^^^^'^' S p o ons eco ds he RBS spec um and allows he o al amoun o cha ge alling on he sa n- ^^m o ed. No shown in his diag am a e a ideo mic oscope which uses a mi a o iew he samni"'!'"^^ o/ e sample du ing analysis and a low powe alignmen láse o a.ssis in po.si ioning he ^ o analysis. Figu e 2. A gene al iew o he new ex e nal beam acili y being used o he cha ac e isa ion o su ace laye s on an IB"" cen u y b ome s a ue o Bud- dha. cause discolo a ion, bu in many cases (e.g. pape s) his ades o e a pe iod o days and in any case is con íned o he small a ea o he beam. An ex e nal beam sys em has been de eloped o he Ox o d Scanning P o on Mic o- p obe acili y using design concep s desc ibed i s by he AGLAE g oup in Pa ís [2] (see i gu es 1 and 2). The key o high pe o mance o his ype o sys em is o mini- mise he dis ance be ween he exi o he beam om he acuum and he sample. This educes beam sca e ing and also educes he abso p ion o he emi ed signáis, bu in o de o allow a ee pa h om he sampling poin o he de ec o . In his design he exi nozzle consis s o a hollow coppe cylinde wi h he diame e educing in s eps om 12 mm o app oxima ely 2 mm. Coppe was chosen o he nozzle ma e ial in o de o educe he gamma ay backg ound which migh esul i ligh elemen s such as Al we e used and he beam s ikes he inne su ace. The only signáis induced om coppe a e he Cu x- ays, which do no escape om he walls o he nozzle. The beam eme ges in o ai h ough a 300 (jim diame e ape u e co e ed wi h an 8 (jim Kap on 440 (y y. GRME III CoNGRi-so Nacional db A queomb ía 441 $ ,. | lli i ■ 'i : í' i I : 1 , Figu e 3. View h ough he ideo " ic oscope o he ex e na! beam ocili y, This shows he coppe exi ozzle p ojec ing om he bo om he image and he ^ i ace o a sampie o J 8"" cen u y islamic lus ewa e. Fhe ou line o he lus e giazed deco a ion can be seen as he da k egions o he sampie. ^indow. Two quad upole lenses ocus he beam h ough he no/.zlc, so ha he amoun beam s iking he ape u e is minimised. No e ha his aiso means ha he spa ial '"esolu ion is no de e mined by he size o he ape u e holc. The sampie is moun ed 3pp oxima ely 4 mm om he window, allowing a csolu ion o 40-50 pm o be ^chie ed on he sampie. De ec o s o x- ays, ecoiling p o ons and gamma ays allow ®"3lysis using PIXE, RBS and also P o on índuced Gamma- ay Emission (PIGE) analy- o he de ec ion o ligh elemen s such as Li and F. This allows i ually he en- Pe iodic abie o be co e ed in a single measu emen . A ideo mic oscope and a Powe láse a e used o align he desi ed egión o he sampie in he beam (sea gu e 3). pyjj echnical de ails o he new ex emal beamiinc will be p esen ad alsa- whe e [3]. ^ sepa a a de elopmen , he ex e nal beam acili y has been i ed wi h a high ^®^^sed pulsad láse o enable he su ace o he sampie o be abla ad a axac ly spe ^Po as he analysis is aking place (4). This exci ing de elopmen is aimed em^' co osión laye s on ancien me áis, bu he abili y o dia ^"^3ce ilms in a well con olled manne o e an a ea o less han 100 pm ha e implica ions o many aspec o he analysis o ancien ma e ials, ^ desi able o cha ac e ise sepa a ely bo h he co osión ilm o pa ina and •^nde lying bulk ma e ial. 3. ^PPLICATIONS OF THE OXFORD EXTERNAL BEAM FACILITY The e iai/- applica ions o he Ox o d ex e nal beam o a chaeological ma- summa ised below: Panel ( un) Hg% Top 5,08 11,30 Top 5,08 11,60 Cen e 5,06 15,00 Bo om 6,16 14,50 Mean 5,35 13,10 s.d. 0,54 1,92 3.1. CORROSION FILMS, SURFACE LAYERS AND BULK COMPOSITION OF METALS In addi ion o using PIXE o cha ac e ise he composi ion o bulk me áis, hin (< 10 pm) su ace laye s can be cha ac e- i sed accu a ely and non-des uc i ely using RBS. This p o ides in o ma ion comple- men a y o ha which can be ob ained o hick laye s using he láse abla ion acil i y. The Ox o d ex emal beam has been used o in es íga e a wide ange o me al ypes, and alloys based on coppe , sil e , gold and i on ha e been in es iga ed. In a s udy o a medie al al a c oss [3], he hickness and composi ion o he gilding laye s was de e mined om he ela i e in ensi ies o he gold, me cu y and coppe x- ays induced by he beam. The a io o he gold and me cu y L-lines p o ided he Au:Hg a io in he amalgam gilded i lm, and since he coppe x- ays om he subs a e a e abso bed by he o e lying gilding laye , he a io o he coppe K-line o he gold L-line p o ides a e y accu a e measu emen o he hickness o he i lm, as shown in able 1, in which p esen s he hickness and pe cen age o me cu y eco ded on he h ee back panels. Ano he example, shown in i gu e 2, in ol ed he in es iga ion o a I?"* cen u y Buddha om Thailand. Al hough his objec was b onze, he black su ace had an un- usual appea ance. Using RBS, i was possible o de e mine ha he su ace was coa ed wi h a hin laye o o ganic ma e ial ich in ca bón and oxygen which was di using in o he coppe . One explana ion o his could be he in e ac ion o he me al wi h he smoke o de o ional lamps and candles o e a long pe iod. 3.2. POTTERV AND GLAZES A majo ad an age o he ex emal beam acili y in he s udy o po e y is he abili y o analyse he whole objec wi hou sampling, which can be di icul and undesi ed on a e agile objec s. A ange o analyses ha e been ca ied ou bo h on whole ob- jec s (e.g. he cha ac e isa ion o blue and whi e glazes on Chínese po celain) and on agmen s (e.g. he analysis o IS"* cen u y Islamic lus e glazes). In he case o he lus e glazes, he composi ion o he me al su ace laye can be de e mined using PIXE and he hickness o he me al laye can also be de e mined using RBS. Figu e 3 shows he su ace o a lus e giazed she d iewed h ough he ideo mic oscope o he ex emal beam acili y. The coppe beam exi nozzle can be seen a he bo om o he pic u e and he deco a ion o he sampie can be seen. The da k egions a e lus e giazed. Figu e 4(a) shows he RBS spec mm acqui ed om he lus e giazed egión using a p ima y beam ene gy o 3 MeV. The small high ene gy peak in he spec mm indica es he me al lie coppe laye esul ing om he lus e glaze. The o al a ea o his peak is a measu e o he amoun o coppe p esen in he ilm, while he shape gi es an in- dica ion o he dep h dis ibu ion. In his case, al hough he s a is ics we e no con- 442 Q.W. G iue III Cong eso Nacional de A queome ía 443 ÍH5 195 205 2i5 225 2^^ 2-3** 2^^ 275 Kca.ojÍ ^MeV " ins ewa e ^lazc e n dcd in ai nm/ií; p o on.s i /¡ an iniíUil en^^'Sy iiXC l TÍ/ Z*^/ I í* (*/ y I li u y/ í* y/y 1 yi»9y/ (/«•■• /■'>•.. «7... *í/ / S'/ //// i Iíi ¡ í/// //V / // ? ^ ^ 'neasu ed da a is shown as do s and hc hin ¡hu- is a hc( e ín p o iig , "'"•^" ea aai ^nd he appeu s as he snudl peak in hc hii h ene s^' e pión o he un¡ ig J O om he glaze appea as s eps a lowe ene py. The ¡a pe peak in he cen e o a bg ecoils om ni open and nxypen nuelei in he ai . The dala n /. eeo ded in 90 ^Pec ^ o JOOpA. (h): The iheo e iea! sample dep h dis ihu ion used o ealeida e he "^ igu e 4 (a). ^lus easibili y s udy, he e is a s ong indica ion o a di usion p o ile in he glaze, as shown by he simuia ed cu es, esul ing in he p o ile shown "gu e 4(b). he 3.3. *3lass and enamel beajp ^ conside a ions o sampling aiso appiy o glass objec s and he ex e nal h3s also been applied o he cha ac e isa ion no only o ancien jec jy í^ ge agmen s bu also minia u e mediae al enamelled panels. Thc ob- such analyses has la gely been o de e mine he na u e o added cons i uen s ^olo an s. Jewp,. ■^LLERY and gems ones Th P o epa^ inc easing in e es in he analysis o ancien gems ones as an aid s udies [5 and 6]. Many gems one mine als do no ha e a ixed comp^si- ion, and may comp ise a mix u e o end-membe s in a ying concen a ions. Exam- ples o hese include game s which ha e h ee end membe s and ou malines wi h as many as wel e. De e mining he end-membe ac ion allows he compa ison o s ones (e.g. o de e mine whe he all s ones in an objec we e om he same sou ce), while he ace elemen con en may be cha ac e is ic o he mine al deposi , al hough he e is s ill a only a limi ed amoun o compa ison da a a ailable o his ype o applica- ion. The ex emal beam acili y is ideal o he cha ac e isa ion o moun ed gems ones, since hey do no ha e o be emo ed om he objec in which hey a e moun ed and he echnique is non-des uc i e. The Ox o d acili y has been used in a numbe o easibili y s udies, including he cha ac e isa ion o he í s ime o he ou maline in- aglio o Alexande he G ea om he Ashmolean Museum [7]. 4. CONCLUSION AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This b ie desc ip ion o he Ox o d ex emal beam acili y has demons a ed he ca- pabili ies o in-ai mic o-analysis using ocused beams o MeV ions. This echnique o - e s unique ad an ages o he a chaeological scien is o he cha ac e isa ion o ancien ma e ials and a e ac s, and a b ie summa y o applica ions has been p esen ed. This wo k has na u ally in ol ed he collabo a ion o co-wo ke s om many di e en ins i u- ions, and he au ho especially wishes o acknowledge he con ibu ions o he ollow- ing people: Ms M.H. Ab aham and D J.P No ho e o he Uni e si y o Ox o d Depa - men o Ma e ials, D R. Cambe o So heby's, London, D M. Vicke s o he Ashmolean Museum, Ox o d, P o . M. Ti e o he Resea ch Labo a o y o A chaeology and he His o y o A , Ox o d and D L. Tho eson o he Ge y Museum, Los Angeles. 5. REFERENCES [11 G ime, G.W., Dawson, M., Ma sh, M., McA hu , I.C. and Wa , F., 1991, The Ox o d sub-mic on nuclea mic oscopy acili y. Nucí. Ins . and Me hs. B54, 52-63. [2] Calliga o, T, Maca hu , J.D., and Salomen, J., 1996, An imp o ed expe imen al se up o he simul aneous PIXE analysis o hea y-elemen s and ligh -elemen s wi h a 3 MeV p o on ex emal-beam. Nucí. Ins . and Me hs. B109, 125-128. [3] G ime, G.W., Ab aham, M.H., and No ho e , J.P., The new ex emal mic obeam o he Ox o d Nuclea Mic oscopy acili y, o be p esen ed a he 7"' In ema ional Con e ence on Nuclea Mic obeam Technology and Applica ions, Bo deaux, Sep embe 2000, and published in Nucí. Ins . and Me hs B, 2001. [41 Ab aham, M.H., G ime, G.W., and No ho e , J.P., The combina ion o ex emal ion beam analysis wi h con olled láse abla ion o he s udy o hick co osión i lms on ancien me áis, o be p esen ed a he 7"' In ema ional Con e ence on Nuclea Mic obeam Tech nology and Applica ions, Bo deaux, Sep embe 2000, and published in Nucí. Ins . and Me hs B, 2001. [51 Que e, G., Bouquillon, A., Calliga o, T., Dubus, M., and Salomón, J., 1996, PIXE analy sis o jewels om an Achaemenid omb (4"'-cen u y-BC), Nucí. Ins . and Me hs. B109, 686-689. 444 G.W. Gk/aíe [6] Calliga o, T., Mossmann, A., Poi o , J.P., and Que é. G., 1998, P o enance s udy o u bíes om a Pa hian s a ue e by PIXE analysis. Nucí. Ins . ami Mah.s . B138, 846-850. [6] G ime, G.W., and Tho esen. L.. Ion Beam Analysis o Gems ones - In es iga ion o a Tou malíne In aglio o Alexande he G ea in he Ashmolcan Museum. in A chaeogeni- mology, (ed. L. Tho esen), Ge y Museum Publica ions. Los Angeles, (in p css). THE DEVELOPMENT OF SPANISH METALLURGY AND COPPER CIRCULATION IN PREHISTORIC SOUTHERN SPAIN Sophie S os-Gale'" 1. INTRODUCTION The e is no doub ha in he Spanish Coppe Age he ea lies echnological de e- lopmen s o coppe smel ing, and he ex ac ion o sil e and in, we e based on he mine al esou ces o he Ibe ian Península. Much wo k has been conduc ed ecen ly in Spain by scien is s ying o link he ace elemen al composi ion o p ehis o ic me al a e ac s wi h he known o e sou ces, in pa icula a la ge amoun o da a on coppe based me áis and sil e a e ac s om all dis ic s o Spain ha e been published e cen ly by Ro i a Llo ens [1]. Howe e , he a chaeome allu gical su ey o mine al e sou ces, ha needs o accompany such esea ch, is la gely limi ed o sou hem Spain, in pa icula he sou h wes [2]. In he eas em Medi e anean in he las wen y yea s he e we e se e al p ojec s combining a chaeome allu gical su eys and chemical and lead iso ope analyses o o es and B onze Age a e ac s [3 and 4]. The lead iso ope composi ions o o es and a e ac s a e used as hei cha ac e is ic ' mge p in s' [5], The analy ical me hod used cu - en ly o lead iso ope cha ac e isa ion o a chaeological ma e ials and o e mine als is The mal lonisa ion Mass Spec ome y (TIMS). This echnique p o ides highly accu- a e da a o lead iso ope (LI) composi ions o lead p esen in ancien me áis, glasses, glazes and pigmen s, e en i lead is p esen only a he le el o a ew pa s pe mil- lion [6]. The LI p o enance s udies a e based on he di e si y o p opo ions o lead iso ope a oms in o e mine als ela ed o hei geological his o y. This ea u e allows o cha ac e ise geog aphical sou ces o mine als acco ding o he pa em o he lead iso ope a ios measu ed in hem. The lead iso ope cha ac e is ics o o es do no change du ing hei smel ing, ca ying he LI inge p in o he o e in o he me al. The me hodology o lead iso ope p o enance esea ch is based on accumula ing iso opic, geochemical and a chaeome allu gical in o ma ion abou known o e deposi s ox Iso ace Labo a o y o he Resea ch Labo a o y o A chaeology. Uni e si y o Ox o d. Keble Rd. .^RH.