scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

The influence of alkaline activator on immmoblization of metals in alkali-activated blast furnace slag

Abstract

In this work the influence of alkaline activator on immobilization of lead and copper in alkali-activated blast furnace slag was investigated. A total of five alkali activators were used; sodium waterglass, potassium waterglass, sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide and sodium carbonate. The leaching test according to ČSN EN 12457 -4 was used to evaluate the level of immobilization of heavy metals, the leached solutions were analyzed by ICP-OES. For a better understanding of immobilization process, the selected samples were characterized by analytical methods (SEM, XPS). It was found that the degree of immobilization of Pb2+ and Cu2+ in AAS was very high regardless of the type of alkaline activator used. The high degree of immobilization is caused by formation of insoluble or poorly soluble lead and copper compounds in an alkaline environment while the insoluble compounds have been confirmed by SEM and XPS.

Read accessible full text

The influence of alkaline activator on immmoblization of metals in alkali-activated blast furnace slag

Author: Bystrianska, Emília; Koplík, Jan
Publisher: IOP Publishing
Year: 2020
DOI: 10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
Source: https://dspace.vut.cz/bitstreams/7a8ebd28-4c5a-4b25-b1b7-1d280c718888/download
IOP Con e ence Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing
PAPER • OPEN ACCESS
The in luence o alkaline ac i a o on immobiliza ion o me als in alkali-
ac i a ed blas u nace slag
To ci e his a icle: E Bys ianska and J Koplik 2021 IOP Con . Se .: Ma e . Sci. Eng. 1039 012013
View he a icle online o upda es and enhancemen s.
This con en was downloaded om IP add ess 147.229.117.44 on 20/04/2021 a 07:39
Con en om his wo k may be used unde he e ms o heC ea i eCommonsA ibu ion 3.0 licence. Any u he dis ibu ion
o his wo k mus main ain a ibu ion o he au ho (s) and he i le o he wo k, jou nal ci a ion and DOI.
Published unde licence by IOP Publishing L d
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
1
The in luence o alkaline ac i a o on immobiliza ion
o me als in alkali-ac i a ed blas u nace slag
E Bys ianska1 and J Koplik1
1 B no Uni e si y o Technology, Facul y o Chemis y, Pu kyňo a 118, 612 00 B no,
Czech Republic
Email: emilia.bys ianska@ u .cz
Abs ac . In his wo k he in luence o alkaline ac i a o on immobiliza ion o lead and coppe
in alkali-ac i a ed blas u nace slag was in es iga ed. A o al o i e alkali ac i a o s we e used;
sodium wa e glass, po assium wa e glass, sodium hyd oxide, po assium hyd oxide and sodium
ca bona e. The leaching es acco ding o ČSN EN 12457؎4 was used o e alua e he le el
o immobiliza ion o hea y me als, he leached solu ions we e analyzed by ICP-OES. Fo a be e
unde s anding o immobiliza ion p ocess, he selec ed samples we e cha ac e ized by analy ical
me hods (SEM, XPS). I was ound ha he deg ee o immobiliza ion o Pb2+ and Cu2+ in AAS
was e y high ega dless o he ype o alkaline ac i a o used. The high deg ee
o immobiliza ion is caused by o ma ion o insoluble o poo ly soluble lead and coppe
compounds in an alkaline en i onmen while he insoluble compounds ha e been con i med by
SEM and XPS.
1. In oduc ion
Solidi ica ion/s abiliza ion (S/S) is one o he mos impo an echniques o ea ing was es con aining
hea y me al con aminan s. The pu pose o S/S echnology is physically as well as chemically ix hea y
me als (o pollu ed was e) in he solid ma ix o educe hei mobili y and he e o e minimize he h ea
o he en i onmen . This echnology is widely used o dispose o low-le el adioac i e was e, haza dous
and mixed was e. O dina y Po land cemen (OPC) has been he mos common solidi ica ion ma e ial
because o i s a ailabili y and low cos . Howe e , OPC binde s a e no e y e ec i e in s abilizing some
hea y me als [1–2].
The e iciency o he hea y me al immobiliza ion is s ongly ela ed o he mic os uc u e
o ha dened pas e and o al po osi y. Ha dened alkali-ac i a ed slag (AAS) binde s ha e less po osi y
han OPC binde . The e o e, he mi iga ion o solu ion in o he AAS binde is limi ed which esul s in
a lowe leachabili y o oxic was e. Excep o o al po osi y o binde s, pH alues o pas es play
an impo an ole in he p ocess o S/S and ype o C-A-S-H gel o ming in pas e oo. In a high alkaline
en i onmen , mos o he hea y me als p ecipi a e in o less soluble o insoluble compounds. Besides
low pe meabili y and alkaline po e solu ion, AAS binde s p esen o he impo an p ope ies including
high mechanical s eng h and high esis ance o acid o chlo ide a ack. Due o all hese physical and
chemical ad an ages, alkali-ac i a ed slag binde s a e conside ed o be mo e e ec i e o was e
immobiliza ion han OPC [3–5].
The abili y o alkali-ac i a ed slag o immobilize hea y me als o o he haza dous ma e ials in i s
s uc u e has been in es iga ed in a ious s udies [6–8]. The e iciency o hea y me al immobiliza ion
in alkali-ac i a ed slag binde s depends on many ac o s including na u e and concen a ion o alkaline
ac i a o used o ype o immobilized ma e ial and i s dosage. Hea y me als addi ion (Zn2+, Pb2+, Cd2+
a C 6+) up o 2% o slag weigh can be well s abilized in NaOH, Na2CO3, and sodium silica e-ac i a ed
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
2
slag binde [9]. Solidi ica ion/s abiliza ion o Pb2+ and Cu2+ we e mos ly in es iga ed in ly ash-based
geopolyme s wi h high immobiliza ion e iciency [10–13].
The aim o his wo k is o compa e he abili y o AAS binde s ac i a ed by di e en ypes o alkaline
ac i a o s o immobilize Pb and Cu in hei s uc u e. In he p esen wo k, we ha e also ied o de e mine
i he hea y me als a e s abilized by chemical con e ing in o hei less soluble o insoluble o ms.
2. Expe imen al p ocedu e
2.1. Ma e ials
2.1.1. G ound g anula ed blas u nace slag. G ound g anula ed blas u nace slag (GGBFS) was
ob ained om Ko ouč Š ambe k, L d. ha ing a Blaine speci ic su ace a ea o 400 m2∙kg−1. The GBFS
was mos ly amo phous bu i also con ained c ys alline phases such as åke mani e, calci e, me wini e,
and qua z (measu ed by X- ay powde di ac ion). The chemical composi ion o GGBFS measu ed by
he X- ay luo escence echnique used o alkali ac i a ion is gi en in able 1.
Table 1. Chemical composi ion o g ound g anula ed blas u nace slag.
GGBFS Ko ouč Š ambe k [w . %]
CaO
SiO2
MgO
Al2O3
SO3
TiO2
K2O
MnO
Na2O
Fe2O3
41.1
34.7
10.5
9.1
1.4
1.0
0.9
0.6
0.4
0.3
2.1.2. Alkaline ac i a o s. Fo his wo k i e alkaline ac i a o s we e used: Liquid sodium wa e glass
(S-WG) – Silica e modulus Ms = 1.96; Liquid po assium wa e glass (P-WG) – Silica e modulus
Ms = 1.67; Sodium hyd oxide (SH); Po assium hyd oxide (PH) and Sodium ca bona e (SC). Sodium
and po assium hyd oxide we e used as 50% solu ion. Sodium ca bona e was dissol ed in wa e and
cooled o ambien empe a u e be o e alkali ac i a ion. The Na2O/K2O dosage o he alkaline ac i a o
was kep he same.
2.1.3. Hea y me als. The hea y me al-con aining compounds Pb(NO3)2 p.a. and Cu(NO3)2.3H2O p.a.
ha e been used in sample p epa a ion. The amoun s o hea y me als (Pb2+, Cu2+) adding o he hyd a ing
samples we e on le el 1% o slag weigh .
2.2. Tes s and me hods
2.2.1. Sample p epa a ion. The pas es we e p epa ed a he wa e o binde a io equal o 0.38 (w/b was
kep he same o each ac i a o used). The concen a ion o alkaline ac i a o in he slag binde was 6%
o Na2O/K2O o he slag con en o each ac i a o used. The alkaline ac i a o s we e ully dissol ed in
wa e and a e ha mixed wi h slag. The pas es we e mixed in a s anda d labo a o y mixe o 180 s,
cas in o moulds (20 × 20 × 100 mm) and ib a ed o 30 s o emo e la ge ai bubbles. All he samples
we e ma u ed in he moulds o he i s 24 h a 20 C and 100% ela i e humidi y. A e ha samples
we e open-ai cu ed a ambien condi ions.
2.2.2. Mechanical p ope ies es ing. Specimens wi h dimensions 20 × 20 × 100 mm we e used o
comp essi e s eng h de e mina ion using he Des es 4310 Compac A (Be on Sys em, L d.).
The comp essi e s eng h o he alkali-ac i a ed slag was measu ed a e 1, 7, and 28 days on h ee
samples.
2.2.3. Leaching es . The leaching es s we e pe o med using an adap a ion o s anda d ČSN EN
12457–4:2002. A e 28 days o cu ing, specimens o dimensions 20 × 20 × 100 mm we e placed in o
he PET bo le wi h dis illed wa e a a liquid/solid a io 10:1 and o a ed a 10 pm o 24 h.
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
3
The leacha es we e analysed on ICP-OES spec oscope (Induc i ely coupled plasma op ical emission
spec ome y).
2.2.4. Cha ac e iza ion o ma e ials, hyd a ion p oduc s and mic os uc u e analysis. The GGBFS was
cha ac e ized by XRD and XRF me hods. XRD measu emen was pe o med using a PANanaly ical
Empy ean X- ay di ac ome e . The ube ol age and cu en we e 40 kV and 30 mA, espec i ely.
The ube anode was CuKα1 (1.54 Å). The sample was s ep-scanned om 5° o 90° 2θ using e ical
high- esolu ion goniome e wi h a s ep size o 0.01313 2θ. Times pe s ep we e 96 s.
The chemical composi ion o GGBFS was de e mined wi h he Xenem ics EX-6600 XRF
spec ome e . Measu emen o GGBS powde was pe o med in acuum using accele a ed ol age
30 kV.
Hyd a ion p oduc s and mic os uc u e in es iga ions o AAS wi h and wi hou hea y me als
addi ion we e ca ied ou by SEM and XPS (X- ay pho oelec on spec oscopy). These in es iga ions
we e pe o med on samples a e 28 days o cu ing.
The SEM analysis was pe o med on ZEISS EVO LS 10 wi h he ene gy dispe si e X- ay
spec oscopy (EDS) de ec o . Accele a ed ol age was se o 15 kV and he wo king dis ance was
12 mm. All samples we e spu e ed by gold o ob ain good su ace conduc i i y.
The XPS analyses we e conduc ed wi h K a os Axis Ul a DLD spec ome e using a monoch oma ic
Al Kα (hν = 1486.7 eV) X- ay sou ce ope a ing a 150 W (10 mA, 15 kV). The high- esolu ion spec a
we e measu ed wi h a s ep size o 0.1 eV and 20 eV pass ene gy. The ins umen base p essu e was
2 × 10-8 Pa.
3. Resul s and discussion
3.1. Comp essi e s eng h
As can be seen om da a ob ained ( able 2) he ype o he alkaline ac i a o used s ongly in luenced
he comp essi e s eng h o AAS pas es. Wi hou hea y me als addi ion he highes 28-day comp essi e
s eng hs we e ob ained om AAS samples ac i a ed by sodium and po assium wa e glass. E ec
o ca ions (Na+,K+) om silica e ac i a o s canno be desc ibed because o di e en silica e modulus
o wa e glass ac i a o s used. Howe e , in sodium and po assium hyd oxide ac i a ion wi h same
dosage, KOH-ac i a ed samples o med dense mic os uc u e [14]. Sodium ca bona e-ac i a ed slag
pas es equi ed a p olonged se ing ime so hey we e kep in moulds o 3 days. The longe ha dening
p ocess is ela ed o he slow de elopmen o he alkalini y equi ed o ini ializing slag dissolu ion.
Al hough, a e 28 days o cu ing, he sodium ca bona e-ac i a ed samples gained ela i ely high
comp essi e s eng hs (56.9 MPa) [15].
The in luence o 1% Pb2+ addi ion on he comp essi e s eng h o alkali-ac i a ed slag is no e y
signi ican . In wa e glass-ac i a ed samples he measu ed 1-, 7- and 28-day comp essi e s eng hs we e
e y compa able o he e e ence samples. Samples wi h Pb2+ addi ion ac i a ed by sodium o po assium
hyd oxide exhibi ed s eng h loss up o 30% a e 28 days o cu ing. The addi ion o 1% Cu2+ in luenced
he comp essi e s eng h mo e signi ican ly ega dless o alkaline ac i a o used. Sodium ca bona e-
ac i a ed samples we e mos a ec ed by Cu2+ addi ion and he 28-day comp essi e s eng hs eached
only hal he s eng h compa ed o he e e ence samples.
The na u e o alkaline ac i a o plays an impo an ole in comp essi e s eng h de elopmen .
The highes comp essi e s eng hs we e ob ained by sodium and po assium wa e glass and he lowes
comp essi e s eng h we e measu ed on he samples ac i a ed by sodium o po assium hyd oxide.
Simila esul s we e ound in o he s udies [9, 16].
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
4
Table 2. Comp essi e s eng h o AAS samples wi h di e en alkali ac i a o used.
Comp essi e s eng h [MPa]
Sample
1 day
7 days
28 days
Na-WG
19.4
69.2
102.1
Na-WG (1% Pb)
18.6
68.0
94.9
Na-WG (1% Cu)
11.2
39.6
77.5
NH
10.4
22.0
37.4
NH (1% Pb)
4.6
16.3
24.6
NH (1% Cu)
4.3
9.3
22.6
K-WG
20.6*
50.6
76.5
K-WG (1% Pb)
20.1*
44.9
78.1
K-WG (1% Cu)
10.5*
17.0
59.4
KH
10.2
30.2
44.3
KH (1% Pb)
5.2
19.1
36.3
KH (1% Cu)
4.4
12.7
31.5
NC
-
51.1
56.9
NC (1% Pb)
-
13.1
45.8
NC (1% Cu)
-
10.1
28.4
*samples measu ed a e 3 days o cu ing
3.2. Leaching es s
Leaching es s we e pe o med based on he ČSN EN 12457–4:2002. Th ee specimens om each sample
we e subjec ed o a leaching es in dis illed wa e o 24 hou s. Resul s om hea y me al leaching a e
gi en in able 3 and able 4. The esul s showed ha he immobiliza ion e iciency o bo h hea y me als
(Cu and Pb) is e y high. The highes Pb elease occu ed in sodium wa e glass-ac i a ed samples which
could be a esul o mic oc acks obse ed in hese samples. The leaching a e o Pb2+ co esponds
o he indings ob ained by Deja e al who epo ed ha amoun s o Pb2+ ions leached om wa e glass-
ac i a ed mo a s a e highe han om Na2CO3-ac i a ed mo a s [9].
Samples wi h Cu2+ addi ion also showed a low concen a ion o hea y me al in leacha es. F om
he da a ob ained he bes coppe and lead s abiliza ion is achie ed by po assium wa e glass-ac i a ed
slag binde . I should be no ed ha concen a ions o bo h hea y me als in all samples a e low and all
ypes o alkaline ac i a o s p o ide sa e hea y me als immobiliza ion. High immobiliza ion e iciency
o Pb2+ and Cu2+ in alkali-ac i a ed GGBFS was p esen ed in he wo k o Gie giczny e al [12].
Table 3. Concen a ion o Pb2+ in leacha e.
sample
Na-WG (1 % Pb)
NH (1 % Pb)
K-WG (1 % Pb)
KH (1 % Pb)
NC (1 % Pb)
c(Pb2+)
[mg/l]
3.070 ±1.146
0.870 ±0.345
0.413 ±0.039
2.797 ±0.050
1.240 ±0.388
Table 4. Concen a ion o Cu2+ in leacha e.
sample
Na-WG (1 % Cu)
NH (1 % Cu)
K-WG (1 % Cu)
KH (1 % Cu)
NC (1 % Cu)
c(Cu2+)
[mg/l]
0.950 ±0.138
0.930 ±0.043
0.443 ±0.072
0.980 ±0.024
0.470 ±0.076
3.3. Mic os uc u e o pas es
The mic os uc u e o ha dened alkali-ac i a ed pas es wi h hea y me als addi ion was in es iga ed by
SEM analysis. All he AAS samples ( ega dless o alkaline ac i a o used) had a e y dense s uc u e
wi h C-(A)-S-H gel as he main componen . The signi ican di e ences be ween he samples doped wi h
hea y me als and e e ence samples we e no obse ed. The samples wi h sodium wa e glass ac i a ion
showed highe amoun s o mic oc acks han any o he samples ( igu e 1). Hea y me al compounds (lead
and coppe ) we e a he cumula ed in some egions han dispe sed h ough he s uc u e.
The p ecipi a ed lead compound can be seen in igu e2 and hollow compound con aining coppe is

ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
5
shown in igu e 3. F om EDS analysis aken in a eas wi h high hea y me al concen a ion ( able 5, able
6) can be seen ha lead and coppe a e p ima y cumula ed wi h oxygen.
Table 5. EDS analysis o he a ea wi h high Pb concen a ion om igu e 2.
Elemen
O
Na
Mg
Al
Si
Ca
Pb
A om. %
41.21
3.29
0.37
0.33
7.35
1.13
15.73
Table 6. EDS analysis o he hollow pa icle con aining coppe om igu e 3.
Elemen
O
Na
Si
Cl
Ca
Cu
A om. %
61.89
9.54
0.72
5.31
1.22
20.34
Figu e 1. Sodium wa e glass AAS binde doped wi h Pb2+.
Figu e 2. Sodium ca bona e AAS binde doped wi h Pb2+.
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
6
Figu e 3. Sodium hyd oxide AAS binde doped wi h Cu2+.
3.4. XPS analysis
The XPS spec a o Pb o sample Na-WG (1% Pb) is showed in igu e 4. The binding ene gies o Pb
4 7/2 and Pb 4 5/2 a e 138.6 eV and 143.3 eV. These alues a e ypical o Pb(OH)2. The highly soluble
p ima y phase Pb(NO3)2 dissol es du ing sample p epa a ion and Pb2+ ions in an alkaline solu ion
p ecipi a e in o an insoluble hyd oxide.
Figu e 4. XPS spec a o Pb in sample ac i a ed by sodium wa e glass.
In XPS spec a ( igu e 5) o a sample con aining coppe and ac i a ed by 50% solu ion o sodium
hyd oxide (1% Cu) a e shown wo di e en chemical s a es. The i s , Cu 2p3/2 componen wi h binding
ene gy 935.35 eV wi h s ong shake-up sa elli es belongs o Cu(OH)2. Shake-up sa elli es occu when
an ou going elec on in e ac s wi h a alence elec on and exci es i (shakes i up) o a highe ene gy
le el. As a consequence, he ene gy co e elec on is educed and a sa elli e s uc u e appea s a ew eV
below (KE scale) he co e le el posi ion. The second peak, Cu 2p3/2 wi h binding ene gy 933.50 eV,
ep esen s he bond be ween Cu and O. Tha can be in e p e ed as he o ma ion o coppe oxide o
130132134136138140142144146148150
in ensi y [a.u]
binding ene gy [eV]
Pb 4 7/2
Pb(OH)2
Pb 4 5/2
Pb(OH)2
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
7
he o ma ion o he bond wi h he ma ix. Bo h coppe compounds (CuO and Cu(OH)2) a e insoluble
in dis illed wa e [17, 18].
Figu e 5. XPS spec a o Cu in sample ac i a ed by sodium hyd oxide.
4. Conclusion
The in luence o alkaline ac i a o ype on hea y me als (Pb and Cu) immobiliza ion was in es iga ed.
Fi e alkaline ac i a o s we e used: sodium wa e glass, po assium wa e glass, sodium hyd oxide,
po assium hyd oxide and sodium ca bona e. F om he esul s ob ained by leaching es s (ČSN EN
12457–4:2002) can be seen ha he immobiliza ion e iciency o hea y me als (Pb2+ and Cu2+) is e y
high o all ypes o alkaline ac i a o used. Sligh ly highe concen a ions o hea y me als in leacha es
we e obse ed when he samples we e ac i a ed by sodium wa e glass. I was p obably caused by
p esence o mic oc acks which allowed leaching ou hea y me als om samples. F om SEM obse a ion
can be seen ha bo h hea y me als – lead and coppe , we e a he cumula ed in some a eas han dispe se
h ough he whole s uc u e. Finally, XPS analysis con i med ha Pb and Cu o med insoluble sal s in
alkali-ac i a ed slag binde s.
Re e ences
[1] Yilma O, Ünlü K and Cokca E 2003 Solidi ica ion/S abiliza ion o Haza dous Was es Con aining
Me als and O ganic Con aminan s Jou nal o En i onmen al Enginee ing 129(4) pp 366–376
[2] Al-kindi G, P o is J L, Mye s R J, San Nicolas R and Van De en e J S J 2019 E alua ion
he Solidi ica ion/S abiliza ion o Hea y Me als by Po land Cemen : Al e na i e ma ices o
he immobilisa ion o haza dous was es Jou nal o Ecological Enginee ing 20(3) pp 91–100
[3] Shi C, Fe nández-Jiménez A, Rekha P, Bindhu V H and Anjaneyulu Y 2006
S abiliza ion/solidi ica ion o haza dous and adioac i e was es wi h alkali-ac i a ed
cemen s Jou nal o Haza dous Ma e ials 137(3) pp 1656–1663
[4] P o is J L and Van De en e J S J 2014 Alkali Ac i a ed Ma e ials: S a e-o - he-A Repo ,
RILEM TC 224-AAM.
[5] Palomo A, López Dela Fuen e J I, Rekha P, Bindhu V H and Anjaneyulu Y 2003 Alkali-ac i a ed
cemen i ous ma e ials: Al e na i e ma ices o he immobilisa ion o haza dous
was es Cemen and Conc e e Resea ch 33(2) pp 281–288
[6] Qian G, Delai Sun D, Hwa Tay J and Sun G 2003 Cha ac e iza ion o me cu y- and zinc-doped
alkali-ac i a ed slag ma ix Cemen and Conc e e Resea ch 33(8) pp 1251–1256
[7] Shi C, Fe nández-Jiménez A, Zhao M, Yang K, Shen R and Zheng Y 2006
S abiliza ion/solidi ica ion o haza dous and adioac i e was es wi h alkali-ac i a ed cemen s
930935940945950955960965
in ensi y [a.u]
binding ene gy [eV]
Cu 2p3/2
CuO
Cu 2p3/2
Cu(OH)2
Cu 2p1/2
shake-up sa elli es
shake-up sa elli es
ICBMPT 2020
IOP Con . Se ies: Ma e ials Science and Enginee ing 1039 (2021) 012013
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1039/1/012013
8
Jou nal o Haza dous Ma e ials 137(3) pp 1656–1663
[8] Zhang M, Yang C, Zhao M, Yang K, Shen R and Zheng Y 2017 Immobiliza ion po en ial
o C (VI) in sodium hyd oxide ac i a ed slag pas es Jou nal o Haza dous Ma e ials 321(8)
pp 281–289
[9] Deja J, Sun W, She W and Sun G 2002 Immobiliza ion o C 6 , Cd2 , Zn2 and Pb2 in alkali-
ac i a ed slag binde s Cemen and Conc e e Resea ch 32(12) pp 1971–1979
[10] Zhang Y, Sun W, She W and Sun G 2009 Syn hesis and hea y me al immobiliza ion beha io s
o ly ash based gepolyme Jou nal o Wuhan Uni e si y o Technology-Ma e . Sci. Ed. 24(5)
pp 819–825
[11] Wang Y, Han F, Mu J and Sun G 2018 Solidi ica ion/s abiliza ion mechanism o Pb(II), Cd(II),
Mn(II) and C (III) in ly ash based geopolyme s Cons uc ion and Building Ma e ials 160(8)
pp 818–827
[12] Gie giczny Z, K ól A, Zhao M, Yang K, Shen R and Zheng Y 2008 Immobiliza ion o hea y
me als (Pb, Cu, C , Zn, Cd, Mn) in he mine al addi ions con aining conc e e
composi es Jou nal o Haza dous Ma e ials 160(2–3) pp 247–255
[13] Zheng L, Wang W, Qiao W, Shi Y, Liu X and Zheng Y 2015 Immobiliza ion o Cu2 , Zn2 , Pb2
and Cd2 du ing geopolyme iza ion Jou nal o Haza dous Ma e ials 9(4) pp 642–648
[14] Tänze R, Jin Y and S ephan D 2017 Alkali ac i a ed slag binde : e ec o ca ions om silica e
ac i a o s Ma e ials and S uc u es 50(1)
[15] Be nal S A., P o is J L, Mye s R Y, San Nicolas R and Van De en e J S J 2015 Role
o ca bona es in he chemical e olu ion o sodium ca bona e-ac i a ed slag binde s:
Al e na i e ma ices o he immobilisa ion o haza dous was es Ma e ials and
S uc u es 48(3) pp 517–529
[16] Fe nandez-Jimenez A, Palomo J and Pue as F 1999 Alkali-ac i a ed slag mo a s-Mechanical
s eng h beha iou
[17] Wa s J F and Wols enholme J 2005 An In oduc ion o Su ace Analysis by XPS and AES (John
Wiley & Sons)
[18] Biesinge M C, P o is J L, Mye s R Y, San Nicolas R and Van De en e J S J 2017 Ad anced
analysis o coppe X- ay pho oelec on spec a: Al e na i e ma ices o he immobilisa ion
o haza dous was es Su ace and In e ace Analysis 49(13) pp 1325–1334