scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Scene Recognition through Visual Attention and Image Features: A Comparison between SIFT and SURF Approaches

Abstract

In this work we study how we can use a novel model of spatial saliency (visual attention) combined with image features to significantly accelerate a scene recognition application and, at the same time, preserve recognition performance. To do so, we use a mobile robotlike application where scene recognition is carried out through the use of image features to characterize the different scenarios, and the Nearest Neighbor rule to carry out the classification. SIFT and SURF are two recent and competitive alternatives to image local featuring that we compare through extensive experimental work. Results from the experiments show that SIFT features perform significantly better than SURF features achieving important reductions in the size of the database of prototypes without significant losses in recognition performance, and thus, accelerating scene recognition. Also, from the experiments it is concluded that SURF features are less distinctive when using very large databases of interest points, as it occurs in the present case.

Read accessible full text

Scene Recognition through Visual Attention and Image Features: A Comparison between SIFT and SURF Approaches

Author: López García, Fernando; Fernández Vidal, Xosé Ramón; Pardo López, Xosé Manuel; Dosil Lago, Raquel
Publisher: InTech Open
Year: 2011
DOI: 10.5772/14343
Source: https://minerva.usc.es/bitstreams/3633619a-d078-4ee9-a918-2bc87e4d49b1/download
Selec ion o ou books indexed in he Book Ci a ion Index
in Web o Science™ Co e Collec ion (BKCI)
In e es ed in publishing wi h us?
Con ac book.depa men @in echopen.com
Numbe s displayed abo e a e based on la es da a collec ed.
Fo mo e in o ma ion isi www.in echopen.com
Open access books a ailable
Coun ies deli e ed o Con ibu o s om op 500 uni e si ies
In e na ional au ho s and edi o s
Ou au ho s a e among he
mos ci ed scien is s
Downloads
We a e In echOpen, he wo ld’s leading publishe o Open Access booksBuil by scien is s, o scien is s
12.2%
180,000
195M
TOP 1%
154
6,700
12
Scene Recogni ion h ough Visual A en ion
and Image Fea u es: A Compa ison be ween
SIFT and SURF App oaches
Fe nando López-Ga cía1, Xosé Ramón Fdez-Vidal2,
Xosé Manuel Pa do2 and Raquel Dosil2
1Uni e sidad Poli écnica de Valencia
2Uni e sidade de San iago de Compos ela
Spain
1. In oduc ion
In his wo k we s udy how we can use a no el model o spa ial saliency ( isual a en ion)
combined wi h image ea u es o signi ican ly accele a e a scene ecogni ion applica ion
and, a he same ime, p ese e ecogni ion pe o mance. To do so, we use a mobile obo -
like applica ion whe e scene ecogni ion is ca ied ou h ough he use o image ea u es o
cha ac e ize he di e en scena ios, and he Nea es Neighbo ule o ca y ou he
classi ica ion. SIFT and SURF a e wo ecen and compe i i e al e na i es o image local
ea u ing ha we compa e h ough ex ensi e expe imen al wo k. Resul s om he
expe imen s show ha SIFT ea u es pe o m signi ican ly be e han SURF ea u es
achie ing impo an educ ions in he size o he da abase o p o o ypes wi hou signi ican
losses in ecogni ion pe o mance, and hus, accele a ing scene ecogni ion. Also, om he
expe imen s i is concluded ha SURF ea u es a e less dis inc i e when using e y la ge
da abases o in e es poin s, as i occu s in he p esen case.
Visual a en ion is he p ocess by which he Human Visual Sys em (HVS) is able o selec
om a gi en scene egions o in e es ha con ain salien in o ma ion, and hus, educe he
amoun o in o ma ion o be p ocessed (T eisman, 1980; Koch, 1985). In he las decade,
se e al compu a ional models biologically mo i a ed ha e been eleased o implemen
isual a en ion in image and ideo p ocessing (I i, 2000; Ga cía-Díaz, 2008). Visual
a en ion has also been used o imp o e objec ecogni ion and scene analysis (Bonaiu o,
2005; Wal he , 2005). In his chap e , we s udy he u ili y o using a no el model o spa ial
saliency o imp o e a scene ecogni ion applica ion by educing he amoun o p o o ypes
needed o ca y ou he classi ica ion ask. The applica ion is based on mobile obo -like
ideo sequences aken in indoo acili ies o med by se e al ooms and halls. The aim is o
ecognize he di e en scena ios in o de o p o ide he mobile obo sys em wi h gene al
loca ion da a.
The isual a en ion app oach is a no el model o bo om-up saliency ha uses local phase
in o ma ion o he inpu da a whe e he s a is ic in o ma ion o second o de is dele ed o
achie e a Re inop ical map o saliency. The p oposed app oach join s compu a ional
mechanisms o he wo hypo heses la gely accep ed in ea ly ision: i s , he e icien coding
www.in echopen.com
Objec Recogni ion
186
(Ba low, 1961; A nea e, 1954), which pos ula es ha he mission o he i s s ages o he
isual p ocessing chain is o educe he edundancy o p edic abili y in he incoming da a;
and second, in he isual co ex ele an a ibu es o he image a e ea ly de ec ed using
local phase o ene gy analysis, such as edges o objec s. A hose poin s whe e hese ea u es
a e loca ed he e is an alignmen o he local phase o he Fou ie ha monics (Phase
Cong uency). The model o local ene gy o de ec ea u es (Mo one & Bu , 1988; Mo one
& Owens, 1987; Ko esi, 1999) is based on his idea and demons a ed i s sui abili y o
pe cep ual appea ance and image segmen a ion. Ne e heless, i is no able o p io i ize he
ea u es wi h ega ds o he isual saliency. This ac is illus a ed in Figu e 1, whe e he
inpu image is o med by ba s ha inc emen i s o ien a ion in s eps o 10º om le o igh
and op o bo om, excep o he cen al ba ha b eaks his pe iodici y c ea ing a pop-ou
e ec o he HVS.
a) O iginal Image. b) Salience om PC. c) Salience om ou model.
Fig. 1. Saliency maps o he o iginal image; (a) om Phase Cong uency (b) and he p oposed
model (c).
In Fig. 1b we see he map o saliency achie ed using Ko esi’s model (Ko esi, 1999) based on
Phase Cong uency (PC). I p o ides app oxima ely equal weigh o all ea u es clea ing
away he pop-ou e ec . We hink he eason o ha is he high edundancy in images
which implies co ela ions and hus Gaussianism in ch oma ic and spa ial componen s. I is
known ha o handle in o ma ion abou phase s uc u e is equi alen o use non-Gaussian
in o ma ion in da a dis ibu ion (Hy ä inen e al., 2009). Thus, o ocus in he in o ma ion
ha does no depend on co a iances (local phase) i is necessa y o educe edundancy, ha
is, o deco ela e he da a. One way is h ough da a whi ening. Redundancy in RGB colo
componen s is dele ed h ough PCA and spa ial edundancy is a oided using an s a egy o
il e -based whi ening in equency domain. In Fig. 1c i is shown ha his hypo hesis wo ks
making possible o p io i ize he salience o isual ea u es om local phase.
Scene ecogni ion is pe o med using SIFT (Lowe, 2004) and SURF (Bay, 2008) o image
ea u ing ( wo di e en app oaches ha we compa e) and he Nea es Neighbo ule o
classi ica ion. SIFT ea u es a e dis inc i e image ea u es ha a e in a ian o image scale
and o a ion, and pa ially in a ian o change in illumina ion and 3D iewpoin . They a e
as o compu e and obus o dis up ions due o occlusion, clu e o noise. SIFT ea u es
ha e p o en o be use ul in many objec ecogni ion applica ions and cu en ly hey a e
conside ed he s a e-o - he a o gene al pu pose and eal-wo ld objec lea ning and
ecogni ion, oge he wi h SURF ea u es. SURF is a obus image desc ip o used in
www.in echopen.com
Scene Recogni ion h ough Visual A en ion
and Image Fea u es: A Compa ison be ween SIFT and SURF App oaches
187
compu e ision asks like objec ecogni ion o 3D econs uc ion. The s anda d e sion o
SURF is se e al imes as e han SIFT and i is claimed by i s au ho s o be mo e obus
agains di e en image ans o ma ions han SIFT. Howe e , he esul s o ou expe imen al
wo k showed ha SIFT ea u es pe o m signi ican ly be e han SURF ea u es. In
combina ion wi h saliency maps, SIFT ea u es lead o d as ic educ ions in he numbe o
in e es poin s in oduced in he da abase o p o o ypes (used in 1-NN classi ica ion), also
achie ing e y good pe o mance in scene ecogni ion. Thus, since he compu ing cos s o
classi ica ion a e signi ican ly educed he scene ecogni ion is accele a ed.
The chap e is de eloped as ollows. Nex Sec ion p esen s he model o spa ial saliency. An
o e iew o he image ea u ing me hods is p o ided in Sec ion 3. Sec ion 4 deals wi h he
scene ecogni ion applica ion. Expe imen al wo k and esul s a e p esen ed in Sec ion 5.
Finally, Sec ion 6 is de o ed o conclusions.
2. Model o spa ial saliency
Figu e 2 shows a gene al low diag am o he saliency model. Following we desc ibe each
s age o he model.
2.1 Ea ly s age
The goal o his ini ial s age is o dele e he s a is ical in o ma ion o second o de in colo
componen s (RGB) and spa ial componen s (be ween pixels o each colo componen ),
h ough di e en whi ening p ocesses.
The aim o he ini ial s ep in his s age is o p o ide he model wi h a colo space ha con ains
a mechanism, biologically inspi ed, called sho - e m adap a ion (Simoncelli & Olshausen, 2001;
Ba low & Foldiak, 1989), which main goal is o achie e a inal synch oniza ion in he adap i e
p ocess ha p omo es he mos use ul aspec s o la e p ocessing. Fo ha , he colo RGB
image is decomposed in o h ee channels maximally deco ela ed using P incipal Componen
Analysis (PCA). Ne e heless, we a e no in e es ed in educing he colo space dimension,
hus, we use a ans o med space o he o iginal dimension (3 colo componen s). The i s
componen co esponds o opponen s channel B/W and he emaining wo co espond o
opponen s simila o R/G and Y/B. Howe e , he space, unlike he opponen s space CIE-Lab,
is adap ed o he speci ic s a is ic o he incoming image.
In a second s ep, he goal is o elimina e he spa ial edundancy among he pixels in each
colo channel. In his case, we use a il e -based s a egic in equency domain called
Spec al Whi ening (SW). I is consequence o he Wiene -Khinchin heo em: “ o a
s ochas ic p ocess, he a e age powe spec um is he Fou ie T ans o m o he au oco ela ion
unc ion”. Thus, a whi ened image should ha e a la powe spec um. This can be easily
achie ed using an adap i e il e in he equency domain ha no malizes he spec um o
he ans o med Fou ie co esponding o he incoming image I(x,y) in he ollowing way:
()
()
()
(
)
()
,
,
,,,
xy
xy
xy
Ixy
nIxy
ωω
ωω ωω
⎡⎤
ℑ⎣⎦
==
⎡⎤
ℑ⎣⎦
(1.1)
whe e
[
]
ℑ⋅ is he ans o med Fou ie and 22
sx
y
ω
ωω
=+ is he spa ial equency.
Physically, SW is a edis ibu ion o he spec um ene gy ha will achie e an enhancemen
www.in echopen.com
Objec Recogni ion
188
Fig. 2. Gene al diag am showing how he da a lows h ough he model.
www.in echopen.com

Scene Recogni ion h ough Visual A en ion
and Image Fea u es: A Compa ison be ween SIFT and SURF App oaches
189
o he less edundan pa e ns. This whi ening me hod was p e iously used in he saliency
model p oposed by Guo e al. (Guo e al., 2008) which is based on global phase analysis.
2.2 Analysis s age
In his s age, i is analyzed he maximum alignmen o he local phase o each pixel in each
whi ened colo channel weigh ed by he s eng h o he isual ea u es in he analyzed scale.
Classical me hodology o es ima e he ampli ude and phase in a 1D signal is he Analy ic
Signal. Howe e , he 2D e sion was achie ed pa ially using a quad a u e phase bank il e
(Gabo like il e s), un il he in oduc ion o he Monogenic Signal by Felsbe g & Somme
(Felsbe g & Somme , 2001). Ou model uses his las me hodology ha achie es a new 2D
analy ic signal om he Riesz’s ans o m, which is he 2D iso opic ex ension o Hilbe ’s
ans o m. I s ep esen a ion in Fou ie ’s domain is a se o wo simple il e s in phase-
quad a u e ha a e no selec i e nei he in scale no o ien a ion:
()()
()
12 22 22
,, , , y
x
xy xy
xy xy
HH i i
ω
ω
ωω ωω ωω ωω
⎛⎞
⎜⎟
=⎜⎟
⎜⎟
++
⎝⎠
(1.2)
The Monogenic Signal is a ec o unc ion o h ee componen s o med by he o iginal
signal and wo componen s achie ed by con ol ing i wi h he il e s o Riez’s ans o m,
ha is:
(
)
(
)
(
)
12
, (,),(,) , ,(,) ,
M
xy xy xy h xy xy h xy
⎡
⎤
=∗∗
⎣
⎦

(1.3)
whe e h1(x,y) and h2(x,y) a e he ep esen a ions in he spa ial domain o H1(ωx,ωy) and
H2(ωx,ωy) espec i ely. Because il e s H1 and H2 a e o ien ed in equency domain bu a e
no selec i e in scale, commonly a Gaussian like band-pass il e is used o build scaled
e sions o Riez’s il e s. In ou case, we used he ollowing log-Gauss il e :
()
2
2
log
2log
,
o
o
k
sxy
Ge
ωω
ω
ωω
⎛⎞
⎛⎞
⎜⎟
⎜⎟
⎝⎠
⎜⎟
−⎜⎟
⎛⎞
⎛⎞
⎜⎟
⎜⎟
⎜⎟
⎜⎟
⎝⎠
⎝⎠
⎝⎠
= (1.4)
whe e ω=(ωx,ωy) is he spa ial equency, ωo =( ωox, ωoy) is he cen al equency o he il e
and k is he pa ame e ha go e ns he bandwid h o he il e . I gs(x,y) is he spa ial
ep esen a ion o p e ious il e , he monogenic space o scales is buil as ollows:
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
,12
1, 2,
, (,) , ,(,) , , ,(,) , ,
(,), (,), (,)
Ms s s s
sss
xy xy g xy xy g xy h xy xy g xy h xy
xyh xyh xy
⎡⎤
=∗ ∗∗ ∗∗ =
⎣⎦
⎡⎤
=⎣⎦

(1.5)
The chosen bank o il e s is o med by h ee scales (s=3) which cen al wa eleng hs we e
dis ibu ed in 1 oc a e om he minimum wa eleng h (assigned o λ1=8 pixels), ha is λi={8,
16, 32} pixels. The k pa ame e was ixed o achie e a bandwid h o 2 oc a es in each il e in
o de o ob ain a good spec al co e age in he bank o il e s. A simple implemen a ion o
he monogenic signal, in he equency domain, can be ound in (Ko esi, 2000).
www.in echopen.com
Objec Recogni ion
190
Once i is achie ed he monogenic decomposi ion, he impo ance o each isual ea u e is
measu ed by maximizing in each pixel o he image and o all he scales, he le el o local
phase alignmen o he Fou ie Ha monics, weigh ed by he s eng h o he isual s uc u e
in each scale (measu ed as local ene gy
(
)
,,
Mi
xy). We call his measu e Weigh ed
Maximum Phase Alignmen (WMAP), and is he ollowing:
(
)
(
)
{
}
() ()
()
()
dn 1 ,
dn 1 ,
1, 2,
11 1
dn 1 1, 2,
1
,wmax ,cos
,
wmax , ,
(,), (,), (,)
=w max (,), (,), (,)
(,)
s
iMi i
local
s
iMi
local
ss s
iii
ii i
s
ii i i
s
i
i
WMPA x y x y
Exy
xy
Exy
xy h xy h xy
xyh xyh xy
xy
θ
=
=
== =
=
=
=⋅ ⋅ =
⎧⎫
⎛⎞
⎪⎪
⎜⎟
=⋅ =
⎨⎬
⎜⎟
⎪⎪
⎝⎠
⎩⎭
⎛⎞
⎜⎟
⎝⎠
⋅⋅
⎛
⎜
⎝
∑∑ ∑
∑



i
1,
222
11
(,) (,)
i
ss
ii
hxy hxy
==
⎧ ⎫
⎛⎞
⎪ ⎪
⎜⎟
⎪ ⎪
⎜⎟
⎪ ⎪
⎜⎟
⎨ ⎬
⎜⎟
⎛⎞
⎪ ⎪
⎜⎟
⎞⎛ ⎞⎛ ⎞
⎜⎟
⎪ ⎪
++
⎜⎟
⎟⎜ ⎟⎜ ⎟
⎜⎟
⎪ ⎪
⎜⎟
⎜⎟
⎠⎝ ⎠⎝ ⎠
⎝⎠
⎝⎠
⎩ ⎭
∑∑
(1.6)
whe e
()
,,
Mi
xy

is he monogenic signal o he i- h scale and θi is he angle be ween ec o s
()
,,
Mi
xy

and local
E

. This angle measu es he de ia ion o he local phase in he monogenic
signal a he i- h scale espec o he local ene gy ec o in pixel (x,y).
We a e only in e es ed on hose pixels whe e local phase is cong uen o he mos o he
used scales. Thus, ou measu e mus inco po a e a ac o ha penalizes oo na ow
equency dis ibu ions. Fac o w dn is achie ed as i was p oposed by Ko esi (Ko esi, 1999)
o his measu e o local Phase Cong uency (PC).
2.3 Ou pu s age
The inal s age o he model has he aim o achie ing a Re inop ic measu e o he salience o
each pixel in he image. Fo ha , we in eg a e in each pixel he WMPA(x,y) measu es o
each colo channel:
()
3
1
,(,)
c
Salienc
y
x
y
WMAP x
y
=
=∑ (1.7)
Finally, a smoo hing is in oduced by a Gaussian il e and also a no maliza ion in o de o
make easy o in e p e he saliency map as a p obabili y unc ion o ecei e a en ion.
2.4 Compu a ional complexi y
The compu a ional e iciency o he model is low due o he load in oduced by he PCA
analysis, which g ows lineally wi h he numbe o pixels in he image (N) and cubically wi h
he numbe o componen s (colo channels), O(M3+N M2). The numbe o componen s is low
and cons an , M=3, hus, he asymp o ic complexi y depends on N. The compu a ional
complexi y o he model depends on he FFT (Fas Fou ie T ans o m) complexi y pe o med
in il e ing p ocessing. This complexi y is O(N log(N)). On he o he hand, he compu a ional
iming o he model is low, by example, o an image o 512x384 pixels using an In el Co e2
Quad p ocesso a 2.4 GHz and 4Gb o RAM memo y, he algo i hm akes 0.91 seconds. We
ha e o ake in o accoun ha he algo i hm is scien i ic so wa e p og ammed in MATLAB.
www.in echopen.com
Scene Recogni ion h ough Visual A en ion
and Image Fea u es: A Compa ison be ween SIFT and SURF App oaches
191
3. Image ea u es
SIFT and SURF belong o a se o me hods aimed o de ec and desc ibe local ea u es in
images. Among hese me hods we can ound (Mikolajczyk, 2005): shape con ex , s ee able
il e s, PCA-SIFT, di e en ial in a ian s, spin images, complex il e s, momen in a ian s
and g adien loca ion and o ien a ion his og ams (GLOH). Ne e heless, SIFT and SURF
ha e cap u ed ecen a en ion o esea che s wo king on applica ions like objec
ecogni ion, obo mapping and na iga ion, image s i ching, 3D modeling, ideo acking,
e c, being i s compa ison a cu en issue in li e a u e (Baue , 2007).
Wi h ega ds o SIFT ea u es, we used he Lowe´s algo i hm (Lowe, 2004) which wo ks as
ollows. To iden i y he in e es poin s (keypoin s), scale space ex ema a e ound in a
di e ence-o -Gaussian (DoG) unc ion con ol ed wi h he image. The ex emas a e ound
by compa ing each poin wi h i s neighbo s in he cu en image and adjacen scales. Poin s
a e selec ed as candida e keypoin loca ions i hey a e he maximum o minimum alue in
hei neighbo hood. Then image g adien s and o ien a ions, a each pixel o he Gaussian
con ol ed image a each scale, a e compu ed. Fo each key loca ion an o ien a ion,
de e mined by he peak o a his og am o p e iously compu ed neighbo hood o ien a ions,
is assigned. Once he o ien a ion, scale, and loca ion o he keypoin s ha e been compu ed,
in a iance o hese alues is achie ed by compu ing he keypoin local ea u e desc ip o s
ela i e o hem. Local ea u e desc ip o s a e 128-dimensional ec o s ob ained om he
p e-compu ed image o ien a ions and g adien s a ound he keypoin s.
SURF ea u es (Bay, 2008) a e based on sums o 2D Haa wa ele esponses and make a e y
e icien use o in eg al images o speed-up he p ocess. As basic image desc ip o s hey use
a Haa wa ele app oxima ion o he de e minan o Hessian blob de ec o . The e a e wo
e sions: he s anda d e sion which uses a desc ip o ec o o 64 componen s (SURF-64),
and he ex ended e sion which uses 128 componen s (SURF-128). SURF a e obus image
ea u es pa ly inspi ed by SIFT, being he s anda d e sion o SURF se e al imes as e
han SIFT. SURF ea u es p o ide signi ican ly less keypoin s han SIFT, app oxima ely he
hal o hem (see Figu e 3).
Fig. 3. SIFT (le ) and SURF ( igh ) keypoin s compu ed o he same ame.
www.in echopen.com
Objec Recogni ion
192
4. Scene ecogni ion applica ion
Scene ecogni ion is ela ed wi h he ecogni ion o gene al scena ios a he han local
objec s. This app oach is use ul in many applica ions such as mobile obo na iga ion, image
e ie al, ex ac ion o con ex ual in o ma ion o objec ecogni ion, and e en o p o ide
access o ou is in o ma ion using came a phones. In ou case, we a e in e es ed in
ecognize a se o di e en scena ios which a e pa o uni e si y acili ies o med by ou
class ooms and h ee halls. The inal aim is o p o ide gene al loca ion da a use ul o he
na iga ion o a mobile obo sys em. Scene ecogni ion is commonly pe o med using
gene ic image ea u es ha y o collec enough in o ma ion o be able o dis inguish among
he di e en scena ios. Fo his pu pose we used SIFT and SURF al e na i es.
To compu e he SIFT ea u es we used he o iginal code by Lowe (h p://people.cs.ubc.ca/
lowe/keypoin s/). We also used he o iginal code o SURF ea u es by Bay e al
(h p://www. ision.ee.e hz.ch/~su /). To ca y ou he classi ica ion ask we used he 1-
NN ule, which is a simple classi ica ion app oach bu as o compu e and obus . Fo he 1-
NN app oach, we need o build p e iously a da abase o p o o ypes ha will collec he
ecogni ion knowledge o he classi ie . These p o o ypes a e a se o labelled SIFT/SURF
keypoin s ob ained om he aining ames. The class o he keypoin s compu ed o a
speci ic aining ame will be ha p e iously assigned o his ame in an o -line
supe ised labeling p ocess. The da abase is hen inco po a ed in o he 1-NN classi ie ,
which uses he Euclidean dis ance o selec he closes p o o ype o he es SIFT/SURF
keypoin being classi ied. The class o e e y es keypoin will be assigned o he class o he
closes p o o ype in he da abase, and inally, he class o he en i e es ame will be ha o
he majo i y o i s keypoin s.
5. Expe imen s and esul s
The expe imen al wo k consis ed in a se o expe imen s ca ied ou using ou ideo
sequences aken in a obo -na iga ion manne . These ideo sequences we e g abbed in an
uni e si y a ea co e ing se e al ooms and halls. Sequences we e aken a 5 ps collec ing a
o al numbe o 2,174 ames (7:15 minu es) o he i s sequence, 1,986 ames o he
second (6:37 minu es), 1,816 ames o he hi d (6:03 minu es) and 1,753 ames o he
ou h (5:50 minu es). Fi s and hi d sequences we e aken in a speci ic o de o halls and
ooms: hall-1, oom-1, hall-1, oom-2, hall-1, oom-3, hall-1, hall-2, hall-3, oom-4, hall-3,
hall-2, hall-1. The second and ou h sequences we e g abbed ollowing he opposi e o de
o collec all possible iewpoin s o he obo na iga ion h ough he acili ies. In all he
expe imen s, we used he i s and second sequences o aining and he hi d and ou h
o es ing.
In he i s expe imen we compu ed he SIFT keypoin s o all he ames o he aining
ideo sequences. Then, we labelled hese keypoin s wi h he co esponding ame class:
oom-1, oom-2, oom-3, oom-4, hall-1, hall-2 o hall-3. The whole se o labelled keypoin s
o med i sel he da abase o p o o ypes o be used by he 1-NN classi ie . Fo each ame o
he es ing sequences hei co esponding SIFT keypoin s we e compu ed and classi ied. The
inal class o he ame was se o he majo i y class among i s keypoin s. Ve y good
pe o mance was achie ed, 95.25% o co ec classi ica ion o ames. Howe e , an
impo an d awback was he compu a ional cos o classi ica ion, which was high despi e
he ac ha 1-NN is known as a low cos classi ie . This was due o he e y la ge size o he
www.in echopen.com
Objec Recogni ion
Edi ed by D . Tam Phuong Cao
ISBN 978-953-307-222-7
Ha d co e , 350 pages
Publishe InTech
Published online 01, Ap il, 2011
Published in p in edi ion Ap il, 2011
InTech Eu ope
Uni e si y Campus STeP Ri
Sla ka K au zeka 83/A
51000 Rijeka, C oa ia
Phone: +385 (51) 770 447
Fax: +385 (51) 686 166
www.in echopen.com
InTech China
Uni 405, O ice Block, Ho el Equa o ial Shanghai
No.65, Yan An Road (Wes ), Shanghai, 200040, China
Phone: +86-21-62489820
Fax: +86-21-62489821
Vision-based objec ecogni ion asks a e e y amilia in ou e e yday ac i i ies, such as d i ing ou ca in he
co ec lane. We do hese asks e o lessly in eal- ime. In he las decades, wi h he ad ancemen o
compu e echnology, esea che s and applica ion de elope s a e ying o mimic he human’s capabili y o
isually ecognising. Such capabili y will allow machine o ee human om bo ing o dange ous jobs.
How o e e ence
In o de o co ec ly e e ence his schola ly wo k, eel ee o copy and pas e he ollowing:
Fe nando Lopez-Ga cia, Xose Ramon Fdez-Vidal, Xose Manuel Pa do and Raquel Dosil (2011). Scene
Recogni ion h ough Visual A en ion and Image Fea u es: A Compa ison be ween SIFT and SURF
App oaches, Objec Recogni ion, D . Tam Phuong Cao (Ed.), ISBN: 978-953-307-222-7, InTech, A ailable
om: h p://www.in echopen.com/books/objec - ecogni ion/scene- ecogni ion- h ough- isual-a en ion-and-
image- ea u es-a-compa ison-be ween-si -and-su -app

© 2011 The Au ho (s). Licensee In echOpen. This chap e is dis ibu ed
unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion-NonComme cial-
Sha eAlike-3.0 License, which pe mi s use, dis ibu ion and ep oduc ion o
non-comme cial pu poses, p o ided he o iginal is p ope ly ci ed and
de i a i e wo ks building on his con en a e dis ibu ed unde he same
license.