scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)

Applications of Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MSMS) in estimating the post-mortem interval using the biochemistry of the vitreous humour

Abstract

It is widely accepted that the quantification of potassium concentrations ([K+]) and hypoxanthine ([Hx]) in the vitreous humour is useful in estimating the time of death within a recent time interval. Despite all the advances made in this area, it is well recognized that difficulties in calibration, validation and the use of different methodologies and instrumentation from different laboratories may lead to obtaining different concentrations from the same sample. The extraction of the vitreous humour itself should also be carried out with a precise technique, taking care during the procedure to avoid causing any vascular injury that might lead to haematic contamination. Any fluid that is not clear could lead to erroneous results and should be discarded. We present a new LC–MSMS method developed for quantitative and qualitative analysis of [Hx] (valid also for guanine and xanthine), and qualitative determination of uric acid in vitreous humour. We also introduce a methodology to assess haematic contamination in order to improve the estimation of time since death. The method was fully validated in terms of linearity, sensitivity, imprecision, analytical recovery, extraction and process efficiency and matrix effect.

Read accessible full text

Applications of Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MSMS) in estimating the post-mortem interval using the biochemistry of the vitreous humour

Author: Cordeiro, Cristina; Vieira, Duarte Nuno; Lendoiro Belío, Elena; Rodríguez Calvo, María Sol; Suárez Peñaranda, José Manuel; López-Rivadulla Lamas, Manuel; Muñoz Barús, José Ignacio
Publisher: ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD
Year: 2012
DOI: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2012.08.022
Source: https://minerva.usc.es/bitstreams/f1fa8820-ec37-45df-85a3-125879308bf7/download
Applica ions o Tandem Mass Spec ome y (LC–MSMS) in es ima ing he pos -mo em
in e al using he biochemis y o he i eous humou
Elena Lendoi oa, C is ina Co dei ob,c, Ma ía S. Rod ıíguez-Cal od, Dua e N. Viei ab,c,
José M. Suá ez-Peña andad, Manuel López-Ri adullaa,d, José I. Muñoz-Ba úsa,d,*
a Ins i u e o Fo ensic Science, Uni e si y o San iago de Compos ela, Spain
b Na ional Ins i u e o Legal Medicine and Fo ensic Sciences o Po ugal – Cen e B anch,
Po ugal
c Cen e o Fo ensic Sciences (CENCIFOR), Uni e si y o Coimb a, Po ugal
d Depa men o Pa hology and Fo ensic Science, Uni e si y o San iago de Compos ela, Spain
*Co esponding au ho : joseignacio.munoz.ba [email protected]
ABSTRACT
I is widely accep ed ha he quan ifica ion o po assium concen a ions ([K+]) and hypoxan hine
([Hx]) in he i eous humou is use ul in es ima ing he ime o dea h wi hin a ecen ime
in e al. Despi e all he ad ances made in his a ea, i is well ecognized ha di ficul ies in
calib a ion, alida ion and he use o diffe en me hodologies and ins umen a ion om diffe en
labo a o ies may lead o ob aining diffe en concen a ions om he same sample. The
ex ac ion o he i eous humou i sel should also be ca ied ou wi h a p ecise echnique,
aking ca e du ing he p ocedu e o a oid causing any ascula inju y ha migh lead o haema ic
con amina ion. Any fluid ha is no clea could lead o e oneous esul s and should be
disca ded. We p esen a new LC–MSMS me hod de eloped o quan i a i e and quali a i e
analysis o [Hx] ( alid also o guanine and xan hine), and quali a i e de e mina ion o u ic acid
in i eous humou . We also in oduce a me hodology o assess haema ic con amina ion in o de
o imp o e he es ima ion o ime since dea h. The me hod was ully alida ed in e ms o
linea i y, sensi i i y, imp ecision, analy ical eco e y, ex ac ion and p ocess e ficiency and
ma ix effec .
Keywo ds: Tandem mass spec ome e ; Pos mo em in e al; Hypoxan hine; Vi eous humou
1. In oduc ion
In he field o o ensic pa hology one o he mos impo an issues is he co ec es ima ion o
he pos mo em in e al (PMI). This is o pa icula ele ance in c iminal in es iga ion, whe e
ecou se o a me hod ha p o ides a PMI whose p ecision can be upheld in a cou o law can
be c ucial [1,2]. I is widely accep ed ha he quan ifica ion o po assium concen a ions ([K+])
and hypoxan hine ([Hx]) in he i eous humou is use ul in es ima ing he ime o dea h wi hin
a ecen ime in e al [3–7].
The impo ance o his p oblem is demons a ed by he ac ha i has become he subjec o
nume ous publica ions in leading jou nals in his field, which highligh s he di ficul ies o his
app oach, and has led o u he compa a i e s udies [8]. I has been epo ed ha u ea (U)
may modi y he ela ionship be ween he concen a ion o i eous po assium and PMI [4,9,10]
and ha he cause o dea h i sel can also modi y his ela ionship [10,11]. Diffe en analy ical
me hods o quan ifica ion o po assium and [Hx] ha e been de eloped in o de o imp o e
accu acy in es ima ing he ime o dea h [12,13].
Al hough an in e se p edic ion by changing he a iables is he s a is ical me hod o choice
when using linea eg ession o ela e he [K+] o [Hx] in he i eous wi h PMI [4,14], o he
mo e flexible me hods o eg ession ha e been de eloped which by including all he possible
a iables [K+], [Hx], [U], in he i eous humou oge he wi h he cause o dea h, p o ide a
mo e accu a e es ima e [11]. Al hough he calcula ion is much mo e complex han he simple
applica ion o he ypical single-line eg ession o mula, a ee o use s a is ical package has
been p esen ed which p o ides a as and in ui i e esul [15].
Despi e all he ad ances made in his a ea, i is well ecognized ha he di ficul ies in
calib a ion, alida ion, diffe en me hodologies and ins umen a ion om diffe en labo a o ies
may lead o ob aining diffe en concen a ions om he same sample [16,17]. I has also been
demons a ed ha p e- ea men o samples be o e analysis may lead o some a ia ions in
he de e mina ion o po assium and u ea [17]. Howe e , no only p e- ea men o he sample,
bu he ex ac ion o he i eous humou i sel should be ca ied ou wi h a p ecise echnique,
aking ca e du ing he p ocedu e o a oid causing any ascula inju y which migh lead o
haema ic con amina ion. Any fluid ha is no clea could p oduce e oneous esul s and should
be disca ded [2,4,9,18].
Liquid ch oma og aphy coupled o mass spec ome e (o andem mass spec ome e ) (LC–MS
o LC–MSMS) has ecen ly become inc easingly impo an in pos -mo em oxicology as a
eliable echnique o ou ine analysis. Unlike gas ch oma og aphy coupled o mass
spec ome e (o andem mass spec ome e ) (GC–MS o GC–MSMS), i enables he analysis o
pola compounds wi h no de i a iza ion s ep, bu has he same sensibili y and specifici y as
GC–MSMS [19]. LC–MSMS has been employed o he iden ifica ion and/o quan ifica ion o
d ugs o abuse, he apeu ic d ugs, poisons and/o hei me aboli es in pos -mo em samples
such as whole blood, plasma, se um, u ine, ce eb ospinal fluid, i eous humou , li e and hai
[20].
The aim o his p esen pape is o imp o e he es ima ion o PMI wi h i eous biochemis y
using a new analy ical me hod, based on LC–MSMS, o he de e mina ion o Hx in i eous
humou ( alid also o u ic acid (UA), guanine (G), and xan hine (X)), and a me hodology o
assess haema ic con amina ion in appa en ly clea samples o i eous humou showing no
haema ic colo a ion due o he low p esence e y h ocy es in he sample.
2. Ma e ials and me hods
2.1. Chemical and eagen s
Hx, G, X and UA as a solid o m we e pu chased by Ac os O ganics (Geel, Belgium). The in e nal
s anda d (IS), 5-(p-me hylphenyl)-5-phenylhidan oin, was supplied by EGA-Chemie (S einheim,
Ge many). Ace oni ile and me hanol we e p o ided by Pan eac Quimica S.A.U. (Ba celona,
Spain). Ammonia solu ion (32%) and o mic acid we e supplied by Scha lau (Sen mena , Spain).
Ammonium ace a e was supplied by Pan eac (Ba celona, Spain). Pu ified wa e was ob ained in
he labo a o y using a Milli-Q sys em (Le Mon -su -Lausanne, Swi ze land). OASIS MAX ca idges
(60 mg, 3 mL) we e om Wa e s (Mild o d, USA).
2.2. Ins umen a ion
The HPLC sys em consis ed o a Wa e s Alliance 2795 Sepa a ion Module wi h a Wa e s Alliance
se ies column hea e /coole (Wa e s Co p, Mil o d, USA). Fo he ch oma og aphic sepa a ion,
an A lan is T3 (2.1 mm 100 mm, 3 mm) (Wa e s Co p, Mil o d, USA) analy ical column was used
a 30 8C. The mobile phase was ammonium ace a e 10 mM (pH = 4.5) (A) and ace oni ile (B),
wo king in g adien mode a a flow a e o 0.25 ml/min, and pu ge liquid was ace oni ile. The
g adien applied was as ollows: 0–2 min 100% A; 2–2.5 min om 100% o 20% A; 2.5–6.5 min
20% A; and 6.5–7 min om 20% o 100% A. The o al un ime was 14 min. Fo de ec ion, a
Qua o Mic oTM API ESCI iple quad upole (Wa e s Co p, Mil o d, USA) was employed. The
ins umen was ope a ed in elec osp ay in posi i e mode (ESI+) o p oduce p o ona ed
molecules o he analy es unde he ollowing op imized se ings: capilla y ol age 3.0 kV; sou ce
block empe a u e 130 8C; desol a ion gas (ni ogen) empe a u e 400 8C; desol a ion gas
flow a e 800 L/h; and cone gas (ni ogen) flow a e a 50 L/h.
Da a we e acqui ed in MRM (mul iple eac ion moni o ing) mode, which consis s in he selec ion
o he ion o in e es ( he p ecu so ) in he fi s quad upole (Q1), i s agmen a ion o o m
diffe en p oduc ions in he collision cell and finally he selec ion o a specific p oduc ion in he
hi d quad upole (Q3). The associa ion be ween he p ecu so and one p oduc ion is e e ed
as a ansi ion. T ansi ions, cone ol age and collision ene gy we e op imized by in usion o each
indi idual analy e in o he mass spec ome e (10 mM in NH4OH 2 mM) a 20 mL/min. Two
p ecu so -p oduc ansi ions pe compound we e moni o ed, excep o IS, o which only one
ansi ion was selec ed. In Table 1, MRM ansi ions, cone ol age, collision ene gy and e en ion
ime (RT) a e indica ed o each analy e and IS. Da a acquisi ion was con olled using MassLynx
4.0 so wa e and p ocessed wi h QuanLynx 4.0 so wa e (Wa e s Co p, Mil o d, USA).
2.3. Calib a o s and quali y con ol p epa a ion
The p ima y s anda d solu ion o each compound was p epa ed sepa a ely a e being weighed
in solid o m and econs i u ed in ammonia solu ion (32%); ini ial concen a ions o Hx, G and X
we e 10 mM, and 5 mM o UA. Each solu ion was p epa ed daily. Wo king s anda d solu ions
we e p epa ed in wa e by dilu ion o p ima y solu ions, and final concen a ions we e 1000, 200
and 100 mM o Hx and UA, and 100, 20 and 10 mM o G and X. The p ima y IS solu ion was
p epa ed in me hanol a 10 mM, and he wo king IS solu ion was p epa ed by dilu ion in
me hanol a 1 mM. Calib a ion cu es (10–400 mM o Hx and UA, and 1–40 mM o G and X)
we e p epa ed by adding 15, 30 and 60 mL o he co esponding wo king solu ion, and 25 mL o
wo king IS solu ion (1 mM). The analy es we e endogenous compounds, consequen ly a iable
concen a ions we e ound in con ol i eous humou ; o his eason calib a ion cu es we e
p epa ed in 150 mL o wa e .
Quali y con ols a low (10 mM o [Hx], 1 mM o G, 2 o X, and 20 o AU), medium (50 mM o
Hx and UA, and 5 mM o G and X) and high (150 mM o Hx, 25 mM o G and X, and 250 mM
o UA) concen a ions we e p epa ed daily in wa e om wo king solu ions sepa a e om hose
used o calib a o s.
2.4. Sample p epa a ion
Vi eous humou samples we e ini ially cen i uged o 10 min a 14,500 pm in a Mini Spin Plus
(Eppendo , Hambu g, Ge many). 2 mL o ammonium hyd oxide 2 mM and 25 mL o IS we e
added o an aliquo o 150 mL o i eous humou , p e iously cen i uged. Samples we e
submi ed o a solid-phase ex ac ion wi h OASIS MAX ca idges (Wa e s, Mild o d, USA). A e
condi ioning wi h 2 mL me hanol and 2 mL wa e , samples we e applied di ec ly in o he SPE
column. Cleanup was accomplished by sequen ial washes wi h 2 mL 5% ammonium hyd oxide
in wa e and 2 mL 5% ammonium hyd oxide in me hanol. Ca idges we e d ied o 10 min unde
acuum. Elu ion was pe o med in wo sequen ial s eps: fi s elu ion wi h 2 mL 2% o mic acid in
wa e , and second elu ion wi h 2.5 mL o mic acid in me hanol. Elua es we e collec ed in he
same ube and e apo a ed o d yness wi h ni ogen a 40 8C. Finally samples we e
econs i u ed in 100 mL ammonium ace a e 10 mM (pH = 4.5), and 30 mL we e injec ed in o LC–
MSMS.
2.5. Valida ion
The me hod was submi ed o a ull alida ion, including linea i y, limi o de ec ion (LOD), limi
o quan ifica ion (LOQ), imp ecision, analy ical eco e y, ex ac ion e ficiency, p ocess e ficiency,
and ma ix effec . Selec i i y was no e alua ed because i was no possible o ob ain blank
i eous humou ma ixes (i.e. wi hou Hx, G, X and UA).
Linea i y was de e mined by he analysis o ou calib a ion cu es p epa ed on 4 diffe en days.
These calib a ion cu es we e p epa ed in wa e , and leas -squa es eg ession was applied.
Accep able linea i y was achie ed i coe ficien o de e mina ion ( 2) was a leas 0.99, and
calib a o esidual was 20% a he LOQ and 15% a he o he concen a ion le els.
The LOD was defined as he lowes concen a ion wi h accep able ch oma og aphy, and he
p esence o he wo ansi ions wi h a signal- o-noise a io o a leas 3. The LOQ was he lowes
concen a ion wi h a signal- o-noise o a leas 10, imp ecision lowe han 20%, and analy ical
eco e y be ween 80% and 120%.
Imp ecision and analy ical eco e y we e de e mined a low, medium and high QC le els, wi h 5
eplica es on 4 diffe en days (n = 20), p epa ed in wa e . Imp ecision, exp essed as coe ficien
o a ia ion (CV) o he measu ed alues, was expec ed o be less han 15%. K ouwe and
Rabinowi z guidelines [21] we e ollowed o calcula ion o pooled in a-day, in e -day and o al
imp ecision. The analy ical eco e y was e alua ed as he pe cen age o he a ge concen a ion
(n = 20), wi h an accep ance c i e ion o 85–115%.
Ex ac ion e ficiency, p ocess e ficiency and ma ix effec we e de e mined using eal specimens
o i eous humou a wo le els o concen a ion (low and high) o Hx, G and X; and a one le el
o concen a ion o UA and IS. Howe e , analy es a e endogenous compounds, which a e
p esen in significan concen a ion in i eous humou specimens. Fo his eason, specimen
concen a ions we e p e iously measu ed (‘‘base alue’’); and hese ‘‘base alues’’ we e
sub ac ed om he alues o he same samples a e he addi ion o 20 o 60 mM o Hx, 100
mM o UA, and 2 o 6 mM o G and X (‘‘spiked alue’’). Ex ac ion e ficiency was calcula ed

compa ing he alue ob ained a e sub ac ion o a e age peak a eas o ‘‘base alue’’ and
‘‘spiked alue’’ o i eous humou specimens o ified p io o ex ac ion (n = 6) wi h hose
ob ained a e sub ac ion in specimens o ified a e ex ac ion (n = 6) a he same
concen a ion. P ocess e ficiency was de e mined by compa ing he alue ob ained a e
sub ac ion o a e age peak a eas o ‘‘base alue’’ and ‘‘spiked alue’’ o i eous humou
specimens o ified p io o ex ac ion (n = 6), wi h peak a eas o samples a he same nominal
concen a ions p epa ed in ini ial mobile phase (‘‘unex ac ed samples in mobile phase’’). Ma ix
effec was assessed by compa ing analy e peak a eas a e sub ac ion o ‘‘base alues’’ in 6
diffe en i eous humou ex ac ed samples o ified a e ex ac ion wi h analy e peak a eas o
‘‘unex ac ed samples in mobile phase’’.
Good quan ifica ion o eal samples wi h calib a ion cu es p epa ed wi hou ma ix was es ed
by he analysis o fi e i eous humou s be o e and a e adding 100 mM o Hx and UA, and 10
mM o G and X. The diffe ences be ween hese wo measu es we e e alua ed in e ms o
p ecision (calcula ed as %CV) and accu acy (exp essed as inaccu acy and as he pe cen age o
he mean ela i e e o (%MRE)).
2.6. E alua ion effec o blood con amina ion
Acciden al punc u e o he blood essels in he i eous humou du ing sample collec ion can
al e [Hx] alues, leading o an e oneous PMI in e p e a ion. To es he effec o blood
con amina ion, eal specimens we e con amina ed using ising blood concen a ions and he
esul s compa ed wi h blood- ee ma ix om he same sou ce. To simula e blood
con amina ion, a blood dilu ion a 5% was p epa ed in saline solu ion, and 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 mL o
his dilu ion we e added o diffe en aliquo s (150 mL) o he same i eous humou . These
esul s we e compa ed wi h he alues ob ained om he same uncon amina ed i eous
humou . This me hodology was applied o 7 diffe en i eous humou s, wi h 5 le els o blood
con amina ion o each one. Finally, we pe o med a mic oscopic con ol o haema ic
con amina ion o he diffe en aliquo s by Pap s aining a e concen a- ion by
ul acen i uga ion.
3. Resul s and discussion
3.1. Valida ion
Linea i y was e ified o all he compounds excep UA, whe e he esul s we e no su ficien ly
sa is ac o y o de e mine i s coe ficien ( 2) and esiduals. The calib a ion cu es o he es o
he compounds we e fi ed wi h 1/x2-weigh ed ac o , and he 2 we e abo e 0.99. The esiduals
we e wi hin 20% a LOQs and 15% a o he calib a o concen a ions o all compounds. The
LOD anged be ween 0.25 and 2.5 mM, and he LOQ was he lowes poin o he calib a ion
ange. These esul s a e summa ized in Table 2. The LOD and LOQ alues achie ed wi h his
me hod a e app op ia e o Hx de e mina ion, gi en ha he alues o his analy e ound in
p e iously pape s anged be ween 10.67 mM o 125.27 mM in 176 cases analyzed by Muñoz e
al. [9] and be ween 4.8 mM and 45.6 mM in 120 cases analyzed by Jashnani e al. [7].
Table 3 shows he esul s o imp ecision and analy ical eco e y. These we e sa is ac o y o all
es ed compounds excep UA, which had p oblems wi h linea i y. Table 4 shows ex ac ion
e ficiency, p ocess e ficiency and ma ix effec esul s o Hx, G, X, UA and IS. Ex ac ion e ficiency
anged om 62.6% o 114.4%, wi h alues highe han 50% o all analy es. Hx, G and IS showed
ion enhancemen anging om 14.1% o 137.1%, and UA ion supp ession. X showed no
significan ma ix effec . In all cases % CV was below 20%. P ocess e ficiency anged om 25.3%
om 127.6%.
Good quan ifica ion o eal specimens wi h non-ma ix calib a ion cu es was achie ed o Hx, G
and X. Adequa e accu acy was ound, wi h alues o %MRE below 15% (-0.3% o Hx, -12.8 o G
and -3.3 o X). P ecision esul s (%CV was 7.7 o Hx, 12.7 o G and 17.4 o X) we e sa is ac o y
o Hx and G, wi h alues below 15%, and sligh ly highe o X, bu below 20%.
Ve y ew p e ious pape s epo [Hx] de e mina ion by LC– MSMS [22,23], and hese cases used
u ine samples. No p e ious me hods ha e been de eloped o de e mina ion o his analy e in
i eous humou , despi e he high sensi i i y and specifici y o his echnique.
3.2. E alua ion effec o blood con amina ion
Mac oscopically, he samples showed no colo a ion al hough he i eous humou s we e
con amina ed wi h blood. Mic oscopically, a e s aining he aliquo s, he e was no e idence o
e y h ocy es. These samples seem o show a dec ease in Hx concen a ions, as well as in G and
X concen a ions, in ela ion o inc eased blood concen a ions. Howe e , no significan
co ela ion be ween he 5 le els o blood con amina ion was obse ed in any o he 15 samples
analyzed. Table 5 shows he alues ob ained o he selec ed analyzed samples o i eous
humou and hei le el o blood con amina ion.
Applying he o mula p oposed [12] o de e mining PMI, and gi en he alue o [Hx], he change
in he cen al alue o PMI o he confidence in e al es ima ed can cause a a ia ion in a PMI
es ima e om 14.4 h o an uncon amina ed sample o 8.6 h o a con amina ed one (see Table
5, Specimen 1. The mean a ia ion o o al specimens was 4.02 h). No s a is ically significan
ela ion- ship be ween he inc ease in blood concen a ion and changes in he es ima e we e
ound, which u he demons a es he impossibili y o es ima ing PMI by means o de e mining
blood Hx because an e oneous PMI alue would be ob ained om con amina ed samples. Such
modifica ions also affec G and X (Table 5).
Howe e , UA showed cha ac e is ic beha iou and all samples wi h blood con amina ion showed
a o al disappea ance o he wo MRM ansi ions o his analy e. Al hough UA alida ion was
no sa is ac o y, in e ms o linea i y, analy ical eco e y and p ecision, i was possible o make a
quali a i e de e mina ion. Fig. 1 p esen s he ch oma og am o a eal specimen o i eous
humou be o e and a e blood con amina ion wi h 1 mL o blood dilu ion in saline solu ion a
5%. A o al disappea ance o UA was clea ly obse ed.
This me hod makes i possible o iden i y hose samples whe e blood con amina ion is due o
imp ope ex ac ion o he i eous humou . E en a low le els o con amina ion (when no
mic oscopically e iden ), and be o e Hx concen a ions a e affec ed, he wo MRM ansi ions o
UA disappea , hus enabling he samples o be disca ded, in he same manne as he clea ly
con amina ed samples, and hus a oid e oneous esul s in PMI [2,4,9,18]. The p ocedu e has
been applied in he ou ine analysis o hypoxan hine in i eous humou . A o al o 186 clea
i eous, ob ained by well- ained o ensic pa hologis wi h long expe ience in ob aining he
samples, we e analyzed. O hese, 7 showed o al disappea ance o he wo ansi ions o u ic
acid al hough no mac oscopically blood con amina ion was obse ed, p o ing he ele ance o
using his new analy ical p ocedu e.
4. Conclusions
A new LC–MSMS me hod was de eloped o quan i a i e and quali a i e analysis o Hx, G and X,
and quali a i e de e mina ion o UA. The me hod was ully alida ed in e ms o linea i y,
sensi i i y, imp ecision, analy ical eco e y, ex ac ion and p ocess e ficiency, and ma ix effec .
Du ing he p ocess o i eous humou ex ac ion blood con amina ion can occu as a esul o
ascula inju y and such con amina ion could dis o he esul s o PMI. Howe e , by moni o ing
UA i has been possible o es ablish a new c i e ion o iden i y specimens o i eous humou
wi h blood con amina ion, e en when no colo a ion is e iden . Fo hese easons i is a me hod
o choice o he es ima ion o he PMI by means o he de e mina ion o Hx and whe e haema ic
con amina ion can be objec i ely demons a ed.
Acknowledgmen s
We g a e ully acknowledge he suppo by INCITE (Conselle ía de Inno ación e Indus ia, Xun a
de Galicia), P ojec Numbe INCITE09 228 166 PR.
P esen ed in pa a he 19 h Mee ing o he In e na ional Associa ion o Fo ensic Sciences,
Funchal.
Re e ences
[1] W.Q. S u ne , G.E. Gan ne J ., The pos -mo em in e al. A s udy o po assium in he
i eous humo , Am. J. Clin. Pa hol. 42 (1964) 137–144.
[2] J.I. Coe, Vi eous po assium as a measu e o he pos -mo em in e al: an his o ical
e iew and c i ical e alua ion, Fo ensic Sci. In . 42 (1989) 201–213.
[3] T.O. Rognum, S. Hauge, S. Oyasae e , O.D. Saugs ad, A new biochemical me hod o
es ima ion o pos -mo em ime, Fo ensic Sci. In . 51 (1991) 139–146.
[4] J.I. Muñoz, J.M. Suá ez-Peña anda, X.L. O e o, M.S. Rod íguez-Cal o, E. Cos as, X.
Miguéns, L. Conchei o, A new pe spec i e in he es ima ion o pos -mo em in e al (PMI)
based on i eous, J. Fo ensic Sci. 46 (2001) 209–214.
[5] C. Henssge, B. Knigh , T. K ompeche , B. Madea, L. Nokses, Es ima ion o he ime since
dea h, in: The Ea ly Pos -mo em Pe iod, 2nd edn, A nold, London, 2002.
[6] B. Madea, C. Henssge, Time since dea h, in: J. Payne-James, A. Busu il (Eds.), Fo ensic
Medicine: Clinical and Pa hological Aspec s, G eenwich Medical Media Limi ed, London, 2003,
pp. 91–114.
[7] K.D. Jashnani, S.A. Kale, A.B. Rupani, Vi eous humo : biochemical cons i uen s in
es ima ion o pos -mo em in e al, J. Fo ensic Sci. 55 (2010) 1523–1527.
[8] N. Lange, S. Swea e , W.Q. S u ne , Human pos -mo em in e al es ima ion om
i eous po assium: an analysis o o iginal da a om six diffe en s udies, Fo ensic Sci. In . 66
(1994) 159–174.
[9] J.I. Muñoz, J.M. Suá ez-Peña anda, X.L. O e o, M.S. Rod íguez-Cal o, E. Cos as, X.
Miguéns, L. Conchei o, Imp o ed es ima ion o pos -mo em in e al based on diffe en ial
beha iou o i eous po assium and hypoxan hine in dea h by hanging, Fo ensic Sci. In . 125
(2002) 67–74.
[10] B. Madea, C. Henssge, Eye changes a e dea h, in: B. Knigh (Ed.), The Es ima ion Time
Since Dea h in he Ea ly Pos -mo em Pe iod, 3 d edn, Edwa d A nold, London, 1996, pp. 106–
137.
[11] J.I. Muñoz-Ba ú s, M. Feb e o-Bande, C. Cada so-Suá ez, Flexible eg ession models o
es ima ing pos -mo em in e al (PMI) in o ensic medicine, S a . Med. 27 (2008) 5026–5038.
[12] J.I. Muñoz, E. Cos as, M.S. Rod íguez-Cal o, J.M. Suá ez-Peña anda, M. Lopez-
Ri adulla, L. Conchei o, A high pe o mance liquid ch oma og aphy me hod o hypoxan hine
de e mina ion in i eous humou : applica ion o es ima ion o pos mo em in e al, Hum. Exp.
Toxicol. 25 (2006) 279–281.
[13] M.L. Passos, A.M. San os, A.I. Pe ei a, J.R. San os, A.J. San os, M.L. Sa ai a, J.L. Lima,
Es ima ion o pos -mo em in e al by hypoxan hine and po assium e alua ion in i eous humo
wi h a sequen ial injec ion sys em, Talan a 79 (2009) 1094–1099.
[14] B. Madea, A. Rödig, Time o dea h dependen c i e ia in i eous humo : accu acy o
es ima ing he ime since dea h, Fo ensic Sci. In . 164 (2006) 87–92.
[15] J.I. Muñoz-Ba ús, M.S. Rod íguez-Cal o, J.M. Suá ez-Peña anda, D.N. Viei a, C.
Cada so-Suá ez, M. Feb e o-Bande, PMICALC: an R code-based so wa e o es ima ing pos -