Con en s lis s a ailable a ScienceDi ec
Vi ology
jou nal homepage: www.else ie .com/loca e/y i o
Li e baculo i us ac s as a s ong B and T cell adju an o monome ic and
oligome ic p o ein an igens
Su i Heinimäki, Ki si Tamminen, Ma ia Malm, Timo Vesika i, Vesna Blaze ic
⁎
Vaccine Resea ch Cen e , Uni e si y o Tampe e, Finland
ARTICLE INFO
Keywo ds:
Adju an
Baculo i us
Immunogenici y
Vi us-like pa icle
ABSTRACT
Recombinan p o eins p oduced by baculo i us (BV) exp ession sys ems con ain esidual BV a e c ude
pu ifica ion. We s udied adju an effec o BV on an ibody and T cell esponses agains wo model an igens,
monome ic o albumin (OVA) p o ein and oligome ic no o i us (NoV) i us-like pa icles (VLPs). BALB/c mice
we e immunized in ade mally wi h OVA alone o OVA o mula ed wi h li e o inac i a ed BV, and VLP
o mula ions comp ised o ch oma og aphically pu ified NoV GII.4 VLPs alone o mixed wi h BV, o o c ude
pu ified VLPs con aining BV impu i ies om exp ession sys em. Li e BV imp o ed immunogenici y o NoV
VLPs, spa ing VLP dose up o 10- old. Mo eo e , soluble OVA p o ein induced IgG2a an ibodies and T cell
esponse only when co-adminis e ed wi h li e BV. BV adju an effec was comple ely ab oga ed by emo al o
inac i a ion o BV. These findings suppo he usage o c ude pu ified p o eins con aining esidual BV as accine
an igens.
1. In oduc ion
Nume ous cu en ly licensed accines a e based on li e a enua ed
o inac i a ed pa hogens, bu he e is a endency owa ds de elopmen
o sa e non- eplica ing subuni p o ein accines. The e o e, no el
accines unde de elopmen a e o en based on ecombinan p o eins.
P oduc ion o ecombinan p o eins esul s in subs an ial amoun s o
impu i ies ela ed o he exp ession echnology u ilized in he p oduc-
ion p ocess. Impu i ies de i ed om baculo i us (BV) exp ession
sys em include li e BV, baculo i al dsDNA genome, and baculo i al
p o eins, pa icula ly en elope glycop o ein gp64 (He as-S ubbs e al.,
2007; Huh i e al., 2013; Lappalainen e al., 2016).
A p esen , se e al ecombinan p o ein accines based on BV
exp ession echnology a e comme cially a ailable, including human
accines agains human papilloma i us (Ce a ix®, GlaxoSmi hKline)
and influenza i us (Flublok®, P o ein Sciences), as well as e e ina y
accines agains classical swine e e i us (Po cilis Pes i®, MSD
Animal Heal h) and po cine ci co i us ype 2 (Po cilis®PCV, MSD
Animal Heal h; Ci coFLEX®, B. Ingelheim). Mo eo e , o he po en ial
accine candida es a e in ad anced s ages o clinical ials, such as
hose di ec ed agains no o i us (NoV) (Vesika i and Blaze ic, 2015;
A ma e al., 2016). Because o a s ic egula o y con ol, subs an ial
effo s a e unde aken o pu i y p o eins o use as human accine
an igens. On he o he hand, impu i ies ela ed o BV exp ession
sys em ha e commonly been associa ed wi h s ong immunos imula-
o y effec s. BV has been epo ed o possess adju an p ope ies,
p omo ing humo al and cellula immune esponses agains o eign
an igens as well as ac i a ion o inna e immune esponses by inducing
ype I and II IFNs (G onowski e al., 1999; Abe e al., 2005; He as-
S ubbs e al., 2007; Suzuki e al., 2010). Mo eo e , wild- ype BV has
con ibu ed o p o ec ion in mice om a le hal challenge o encepha-
lomyoca di is i us (EMCV) (G onowski e al., 1999), influenza i us
H1N1 (Abe e al., 2003) and oo -and-mou h disease i us (FMDV)
(Molina i e al., 2011; Qua occhi e al., 2013), whe e p o ec ion was
di ec ly associa ed wi h immune esponses elici ed by BV.
In he his o y o human accines, he mos success ul in disease
con ol and e adica ion ha e been hose employing li e a enua ed
i uses (e.g. polio, measles, yellow e e , influenza i us, o a i us)
(Mino , 2015). As hese i uses can s ill in ec cells and eplica e o a
ce ain limi , he li e a enua ed accines a e able o induce as and
du able p o ec i e immuni y. Ins ead, ecombinan p o eins a e gen-
e ally weakly immunogenic unless adminis e ed wi h an ex e nal
adju an (Bachmann and Jennings, 2010; Jose sbe g and Buckland,
2012). Due o he adju an and an i i al p ope ies o BV desc ibed
abo e, esidual BV o igina ing om he exp ession sys em could be
conside ed as an adju an o imp o e immunogenici y o hese
p o eins.
In he p esen s udy, we in es iga ed adju an effec o BV on
h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1016/j. i ol.2017.08.023
Recei ed 16 May 2017; Recei ed in e ised o m 15 Augus 2017; Accep ed 16 Augus 2017
⁎
Co espondence o: Vaccine Resea ch Cen e , Uni e si y o Tampe e, Bioka u 10, 33520 Tampe e, Finland.
E-mail add esses: su i.heinimaki@u a.fi(S. Heinimäki), ki si. amminen@u a.fi(K. Tamminen), ma ia.malm@u a.fi(M. Malm), imo. esika i@u a.fi(T. Vesika i),
esna.blaze ic@u a.fi(V. Blaze ic).
Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
A ailable online 24 Augus 2017
0042-6822/ © 2017 The Au ho s. Published by Else ie Inc. This is an open access a icle unde he CC BY-NC-ND license (h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/BY-NC-ND/4.0/).
MARK
an ibodies and T cell media ed immune esponses agains wo diffe en
model an igens, a soluble monome ic o albumin (OVA) p o ein and
NoV i us-like pa icles (VLPs). We demons a e he e ha li e BV
p omo ed immunogenici y o bo h OVA and NoV VLPs, and he effec
was abolished by i us inac i a ion.
2. Ma e ials and me hods
2.1. An igenic o mula ions
2.1.1. O albumin
Lyophilized OVA (Albumin om chicken egg whi e; Sigma) was
dissol ed a 2 mg/mL in phospha e-buffe ed saline (PBS; Lonza,
Ve ie s, Belgium). The s ock was s e ilized wi h a 0.2 µm fil e p io
o use.
2.1.2. P oduc ion o mock BV
Li e BVs we e gene a ed in Bac- o-Bac BV exp ession sys em
(In i ogen, Ca lsbad, CA) in S 9 insec cells and pu ified on suc ose
g adien s and ul acen i uga ion as p e iously desc ibed (Huh i e al.,
2013). The in ec ious BV i e o he mock BV, exp essed as plaque-
o ming uni pe mL (p u/mL), was de e mined using a BacPAK™
Rapid Ti e Ki (Clon ech Labo a o ies, Moun ain View, CA) acco ding
o he manu ac u e 's ins uc ions.
The inac i a ed BV (IBV) was p epa ed om li e BV by hea
inac i a ion a 60 °C o 1 h. The inac i a ion o li e BVs was confi med
by BacPAK™Rapid Ti e Ki .
2.1.3. P oduc ion o ecombinan NoV VLPs
NoV GII.4 (Re e ence s ain accession numbe AF080551) VLPs
we e p oduced in BV–insec cell exp ession sys em, as desc ibed in
de ails elsewhe e (Huh i e al., 2010). GII.4 VLPs we e c udely pu ified
on wo discon inuous suc ose g adien s and ul acen i uga ion as
desc ibed ea lie (Huh i e al., 2010). In o de o ob ain highly pu ified
p o eins, he c ude GII.4 VLPs we e u he pu ified using a combina-
ion o wo-s ep anion exchange (HiT ap Q, GE Heal hca e, Uppsala,
Sweden) ch oma og aphy p ocedu es (Huh i e al., 2013).
The pu i y, iden i y and mo phology o he c ude and ch oma o-
g aphically pu ified NoV GII.4 VLPs we e de e mined using p e iously
published p ocedu es (Huh i e al., 2013; Blaze ic e al., 2016), such as
SDS-PAGE ollowed by PageBlue™s aining (The mo Fishe Scien ific
Inc., Rock o d, IL) o immunoblo ing wi h an i-BV gp64 (San a C uz
Bio echnology Inc, San a C uz, CA), Quan -i dsDNA B oad-Range
Assay Ki (In i ogen), Limulus Amebocy e Lysa e Assay (Lonza,
Walke s ille, MD), BacPAK™Rapid Ti e Ki , and ansmission
elec on mic oscopy (FEI Tecnai F12, Philips Elec on Op ics,
Holland) a e nega i e s aining.
2.1.4. Syn he ic pep ides
A mu ine CD4
+
T cell epi ope (
323
ISQAVHAAHAEINEAGR
339
,
In i oGen, San Diego, CA) de i ed om chicken OVA (McFa land
e al., 1999) was used o es OVA-specific T cell esponses by enzyme-
linked immunospo (ELISPOT) in e e on gamma (IFN-γ) assay.
Ro a i us-specific 14-me R6-1 pep ide (
289
RLSFQLMRPPNMTP
302
)
syn he ized by P oimmune LTd. (Ox o d, UK) was used as an i ele an
nega i e con ol pep ide in he assays.
Se en y-six 18-me o e lapping pep ides ep esen ing he en i e
539 amino acid (aa) sequence o GII.4–1999 NoV VP1 we e cus om
syn he ized (Synpep ide Co. L d, Shanghai, China) and pooled (Malm
e al., 2016b, 2016c). A comple e pep ide pool (named 99 pool) as well
as an indi idual pep ide 99-50 (
344
TRAHKATVSTGSVHFTPK
361
)
co esponding o he p e iously iden ified mu ine 18-me NoV-specific
CD4
+
T cell epi ope (Malm e al., 2016c) we e used o es NoV-specific
T cell esponses by he ELISPOT.
2.2. Animal immuniza ion and sample p epa a ion
Female BALB/c OlaHsd mice, aged 6 weeks, we e pu chased om
En igo (Ho s , he Ne he lands). The mice we e andomly di ided in o
eigh g oups (G I–VIII), acclima ized unde con olled specific pa ho-
gen- ee condi ions o one week p io o he s a o he expe imen ,
and main ained h oughou he s udy pe iod wi h ood and wa e
p o ided ad libi um. Animals (3–4 mice/expe imen al g oup) we e
immunized wice (a s udy weeks 0 and 3) in ade mally (i.d.) a he
base o he ail wi h 50 µl o diffe en an igenic o mula ions, each
o mula ion dilu ed in s e ile PBS o con ain he indica ed dose o
immunogen (Table 2). Con ol g oup ecei ed no an igen (PBS only).
Immuniza ions we e pe o med unde gene al anes hesia induced wi h
a mix u e o Hypno m®(Ve aPha ma Limi ed, Leeds, UK) and
Do micum®(Roche Pha ma AG, G enzach-Wyhlen, Ge many).
To es he kine ics o he an ibody esponses in se a, ail blood
samples (dilu ed 1:200 in PBS a he ime o collec ion) we e collec ed
a s udy weeks 0 (p e-bleed, non-immune se a) and 2 o 3. Mice we e
sac ificed 35 days a e he fi s immuniza ion (a s udy week 5) by
decapi a ion, when whole blood and lymphoid issues we e collec ed.
P epa a ion o blood samples and a single-cell suspension om he
spleen o each mouse was conduc ed acco ding o he published
p ocedu es o ou labo a o y (Tamminen e al., 2012). All o he
expe imen al p ocedu es ca ied ou we e in acco dance wi h he
egula ions and guidelines o he Finnish Na ional Expe imen Boa d
(pe mission numbe s ESLH-2009–06698/Ym-23 and ESAVI/4106/
04.10.03/2012) and all effo s we e made o minimize animal suffe -
ing. Animals we e moni o ed o physical condi ions h oughou he
expe imen .
2.3. De ec ion o se um IgG and IgG sub ypes by ELISA
2.3.1. OVA- and NoV GII.4-specific IgG, IgG1 and IgG2a esponses
Se a o expe imen al mice we e es ed in ELISA o he p esence o
OVA- o NoV GII.4-specific IgG, IgG1 and IgG2a an ibodies as
desc ibed in de ail elsewhe e (Blaze ic e al., 2011; Tamminen e al.,
2012). B iefly, 96-well hal -a ea polys y ene pla es (Co ning Inc,
Co ning, NY) we e coa ed wi h OVA (200 ng/well o IgG, 100 ng/well
o IgG sub ypes) o GII.4 VLPs (20 ng/well). Se um samples a 1:200
dilu ion o se ially dilu ed wo- old we e added on he pla es, and he
bound an ibodies we e de ec ed wi h ho se adish pe oxidase (HRP)-
conjuga ed an i-mouse IgG (Sigma-Ald ich, S . Louis, MO), IgG1
(In i ogen) o IgG2a (In i ogen) and SIGMA FAST OPD subs a e
(Sigma-Ald ich). Op ical densi y (OD) alues a 490 nm (OD
490
) we e
measu ed by a mic opla e eade (Vic o
2
1420; Pe kinElme ,
Wal ham, MA). A sample was conside ed posi i e i he OD
490
was
abo e he cu -off alue (mean OD
490
o he con ol mice + 3 × SD) and
OD
490
> 0.1. The end-poin i e s we e defined as he ecip ocal o he
highes dilu ion wi h an OD
490
abo e he cu -off alue. A i e o 100
was assigned o nega i e samples, being a hal o he s a ing se um
dilu ion.
2.3.2. BV-specific IgG esponse
Induc ion o BV-specific IgG esponse was e alua ed by es ing
1:200 dilu ed se um samples o indi idual expe imen al mice by ELISA
as desc ibed abo e o OVA- and NoV-specific esponses, bu he
mic o i e pla es we e coa ed wi h mock BV (100 ng/well).
2.4. An ibody a idi y assay
The a idi y o OVA- and NoV-specific IgG an ibodies was de e -
mined in 1:200 dilu ed se um samples acco ding o he p e iously
published a idi y assay (Tamminen e al., 2012) using an ex a u ea
incuba ion s ep o emo e he low-a idi y an ibodies. Resul s we e
exp essed as a idi y index: (OD
490
wi h u ea/OD
490
wi hou u ea) ×
100%.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
115
2.5. NoV blocking assay
To examine he abili y o se um an ibodies o block he binding o
NoV VLPs o a cellula his o-blood g oup an igen (HBGA) ecep o , pig
gas ic mucin (PGM) ype III (Sigma Chemicals) was used as a sou ce
o HBGAs acco ding o he published p ocedu e (Lindesmi h e al.,
2012) wi h sligh modifica ions (Malm e al., 2017). G oup-wise pooled
wo- old se um dilu ions (s a ing a 1:50) we e p e-incuba ed o 1 h
a 37 °C wi h 0.1 µg/mL o NoV GII.4 VLPs be o e pla ing on 96-
mic owell pla es coa ed wi h 2.5 µg/mL o PGM. Maximum binding
was de e mined wi h NoV VLPs wi hou se um. Bound VLPs we e
de ec ed wi h human NoV an ise um, an an i-human IgG-HRP (No ex)
and Sigma FAST OPD subs a e, ollowed by de e mina ion o OD
490
eadings wi h a mic opla e eade (Vic o
2
1420). Blocking index (%)
was calcula ed as ollows: 100% −[OD
490
(wells wi h se um)/ OD
490
(wells wi hou se um, maximum binding) × 100%]. Resul s we e
exp essed as he blocking i e 90 (BT90), he ecip ocal o he highes
se um dilu ion blocking ≥90% o he VLPs binding o he HBGAs.
2.6. Cell-media ed immune esponses
2.6.1. NoV and OVA-specific ELISPOT IFN-γ
An igen-specific T cell esponses we e analyzed using a sligh ly
modified ELISPOT IFN-γassay (Tamminen e al., 2013). G oup-wise
pooled splenocy es (0.2×10
6
cells/well) we e pla ed on Mul isc een
HTS-IP fil e pla es (Millipo e, Bille ica. MA) coa ed wi h a monoclonal
an i-mouse IFN-γan ibody (Mab ech AB, Nacka S and, Sweden) a
5 µg/mL. Fo de ec ion o OVA-specific IFN-γp oducing cells, cell we e
s imula ed in duplica es wi h OVA pep ide (0.2, 1, 2, and 4 µg/mL) o
R6-1 pep ide (nega i e con ol, 4 µg/mL). To de ec NoV-specific IFN-
γp oducing cells, cells we e s imula ed in duplica es wi h GII.4–99
pep ide pool (2 µg/mL), GII.4 99-50 pep ide (4 µg/mL) o OVA pep ide
(nega i e con ol, 4 µg/mL). Backg ound con ol (cul u e medium;
RPMI 1640 supplemen ed wi h 10% FBS, 100 U/mL penicillin,
100 µg/mL s ep omycin, 50 µM 2-me cap oe hanol, and 2 mM L-
glu amine; all om Sigma-Ald ich) and cell iabili y con ol (10 μg/
mL T cell mi ogen Concana alin A; Sigma-Ald ich) we e es ed in each
assay. A e o e nigh incuba ion a 37 °C, IFN-γsec e ion was
de ec ed wi h bio inyla ed an i-mouse IFN-γmonoclonal an ibody
and alkaline phospha ase -conjuga ed s ep a idin (bo h om
Mab ech AB). The spo s de eloped wi h BCIP/NBT (5-b omo-4-
chlo o-3-indolyl-phospha e) subs a e (Mab ech AB) we e coun ed by
ImmunoSpo ®au oma ic CTL analyze (CTL-Eu ope GmbH, Bonn,
Ge many). The esul s we e exp essed as mean spo - o ming cells
(SFC)/10
6
splenocy es o duplica e wells. An inc ease o a leas wice
abo e he nega i e con ol pep ide SFC coun s was conside ed as a
posi i e esul .
2.6.2. BV-specific ELISPOT IFN-γ
BV-specific T cell esponses we e assessed by ELISPOT IFN-γassay
as desc ibed abo e, excep g oup-wise pooled splenocy es (1×10
5
cells/
well) o immunized and con ol mice we e s imula ed wi h mock BV
(1×10
4
–10
6
p u/well).
2.7. S a is ical analyses
The Mann-Whi ney U- es and K uskal-Wallis es we e employed
o de e mine he s a is ical diffe ences be ween he non-pa ame ic
obse a ions o wo o mo e independen g oups. All analyses we e
conduc ed by IBM SPSS S a is ics o Windows (IBM Co p., A monk,
NY), Ve sion 23.0. The s a is ically significan diffe ence was defined as
p≤0.05.
3. Resul s
3.1. Cha ac e iza ion o NoV VLPs used o immuniza ion
C ude and ch oma og aphically pu ified NoV GII.4 VLPs we e
cha ac e ized o pu i y, iden i y and mo phology p io o use o
immunizing animals. Fig. 1A shows SDS-PAGE, whe e NoV capsid
p o ein appea ed as a double band, ypical o he capsid GII.4 p o ein
(Huh i e al., 2010), in bo h VLP p epa a ions. Ins ead, a ain band
co esponding o he size o he BV en elope gp64 p o ein, was
obse ed only in he c ude p epa a ion (Fig. 1A). The p esence o
gp64 in he c ude pu ified VLPs was confi med by immunoblo ing
(Table 1) wi h an i-BV gp64. Fu he mo e, he p esence o BV was
u he es ed by de e mining he in ec ious BV i e s (Table 1).
Al hough c ude VLPs a e p oduced by he s anda d me hods as
desc ibed abo e, diffe en p oduc ion lo s ha e inconsis en quan i y
o BV (da a no show). Mo eo e , c ude and ch oma og aphically
Fig. 1. Cha ac e iza ion o NoV GII.4 VLPs used o immuniza ions. (A) Pu i y and in eg i y analysis o c ude (lane 1) and ch oma og aphically pu ified (lane 2) NoV GII.4 VLPs wi h
SDS-PAGE ollowed by PageBlue s aining. Lane M, molecula weigh ma ke . (B) Elec on mic oscopy images o c ude (panel 1) and ch oma og aphically pu ified (panel 2) NoV GII.4
VLPs co esponding o he espec i e SDS-PAGE lanes 1 and 2 (A). P o ein s uc u es we e examined a e nega i e s aining wi h 3% u anyl ace a e. Images we e obse ed a 18500 ×
magnifica ion.
Table 1
Speci ica ions and analysis o impu i ies ela ed o he exp ession sys em in he c ude
pu i ied and ch oma og aphically pu i ied NoV GII.4 VLPs.
Specifica ion C ude GII.4
VLPs
Pu e GII.4 VLPs
Mo phology
a
VLPs (~38 nm) VLPs (~38 nm)
In ec ious BV (p u/mL)
b
10
7
0
BV gp64
c
+–
To al DNA (ng dsDNA/10 µg
p o ein)
d
<30 <10
Endo oxin (EU/10 µg p o ein)
e
< 0.1 < 0.1
a
Elec on mic oscopy a e nega i e s aining.
b
BacPAK™Rapid Ti e Ki .
c
SDS-PAGE ollowed by immmunoblo ing wi h an i-BV gp64.
d
Quan -i dsDNA B oad-Range Assay Ki .
e
Limulus Amebocy e Lysa e Assay.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
116
pu ified NoV GII.4 VLPs we e mo phologically simila as indica ed by
EM analysis (Fig. 1B). Hence, he ch oma og aphic pu ifica ion did no
affec mo phology o in eg i y o VLPs, bu emo ed impu i ies ela ed
o he BV exp ession sys em, as i ually no aces o dsDNA genome,
li e BV o baculo i al p o eins we e de ec ed in he pu e VLP
p epa a ions (Table 1).
3.2. Assessmen o physical condi ion
Rega dless o he an igenic o mula ion used o immuniza ion, all
animals emained heal hy and gained weigh du ing he s udy pe iod
(Table 2). No diffe ence in body weigh be ween he expe imen al
g oups was obse ed (p=0.98).
3.3. Enhancemen o OVA-specific se um an ibody esponses by BV
Possible influence o BV on OVA-specific immune esponses was
in es iga ed by immunizing he expe imen al mice on a wo-dose
schedule wi h 45 μg o OVA alone o oge he wi h li e BV o IBV a
an in e al o h ee weeks (Table 2). Two immuniza ions o each
o mula ion elici ed conside able le el o o al an i-OVA IgG an ibodies
(Fig. 2A). Simila IgG esponses wi h end-poin i e s o 12800 we e
induced, when OVA was adminis e ed alone o oge he wi h IBV.
Ins ead, co-adminis a ion o OVA wi h li e BV esul ed in 16- old
inc ease in he IgG i e (end-poin i e 204800). No OVA-specific
an ibodies we e de ec ed in se a o con ol mice.
De e mina ion o OVA-specific IgG sub ype IgG1 and IgG2a i e s,
ep esen ing Th2- and Th1- ype esponses, e ealed induc ion o IgG1
an ibodies by each OVA o mula ion (Fig. 2B) bu induc ion o
significan IgG2a an ibodies only by he OVA o mula ions con aining
li e BV (Fig. 2C). Co-adminis a ion o OVA wi h BV gene a ed ≥16-
old highe le els o IgG1 (end-poin i e 409600) compa ed o
adminis a ion o OVA alone o oge he wi h IBV. No IgG2a was
de ec ed a e immuniza ion o mice wi h OVA alone while o mula ion
wi h IBV induced e y low le el o IgG2a, p obably due o incomple e
inac i a ion o BV (Table 2) con aining 10
3
p u. In con as , combina-
ion o OVA and li e BV induced e y high an i-OVA IgG2a an ibodies
(end-poin i e 102400).
Se um samples om indi idual mice we e u he assayed o he
a idi y o OVA-specific IgG an ibodies. Immuniza ion wi h OVA o
combina ion o OVA and IBV induced IgG an ibodies wi h low a idi y
( espec i e a idi y indices 21.0 ± 5.8% and 10.4 ± 1.3%), bu inclusion
o BV in he o mula ion ele a ed he a idi y o an ibodies (a idi y
index 47.5 ± 8.8%) (Fig. 2D). No s a is ical diffe ence (p=0.083) was
de ec ed in he a idi y indices be ween he g oups immunized wi h
OVA alone and a combina ion o OVA and BV, bu he a idi y was
significan ly g ea e (p=0.021) in mice co-adminis e ed wi h OVA and
BV compa ed o he mice co-adminis e ed wi h OVA and IBV.
3.4. Induc ion o OVA-specific T cell esponses by li e BV
The diffe ence in induc ion o Th1 esponses by OVA o mula ions
wi h o wi hou BV was u he s udied measu ing Th1- ype cy okine
IFN-γp oduc ion om he splenocy es o immunized mice (Fig. 3).
Cells om he mice ecei ing OVA and BV esponded wi h conside able
IFN-γ elease o ex i o s imula ion wi h he 17-me OVA-specific
pep ide, ep esen ing a CD4
+
T cell epi ope (Fig. 3). On he con a y,
immuniza ion wi h OVA alone o oge he wi h IBV did no induce
OVA-specific IFN-γp oduc ion by T cells (p=0.020 o bo h) (Fig. 3).
No esponse o he nega i e con ol pep ide R6-1 was de ec ed in any o
he s udy g oups (da a no shown).
3.5. Imp o ed immunogenici y o NoV VLPs by BV
To examine effec o BV on NoV GII.4-specific humo al immune
esponses, mice we e immunized wice wi h 1 o 10 µg doses o pu e
NoV GII.4 VLPs, 1 µg dose o pu e VLPs combined wi h BV o 1 µg
dose o c ude-pu ified VLPs con aining BV (Table 2). A e he fi s
immuniza ion, 1 µg o pu e VLPs induced significan ly lowe IgG
esponse in compa ison wi h o he VLP o mula ions (p=0.003),
whe eas 10 µg dose o pu e VLPs as well as bo h VLP o mula ions
con aining BV esul ed in simila esponses (p=0.221) a s udy week 2
o 3 (Fig. 4A). Two immuniza ions o each an igenic o mula ion
con aining NoV GII.4 VLPs elici ed high le el o o al an i-GII.4 IgG
an ibodies a week 5 (Fig. 4A). Con ol mice emained nega i e o
GII.4-specific o al IgG du ing he s udy pe iod (Fig. 4A).
De e mina ion o IgG sub ype i e s showed induc ion o bo h Th2-
and Th1- ype esponse by each GII.4 VLP o mula ion. Simila IgG1
esponses we e elici ed, i espec i e o he p esence o absence o BV
(Fig. 4B). Ins ead, adminis a ion o he GII.4 VLPs wi h BV esul ed in
8- old highe IgG2a i e s (end-poin i e s o 204800) compa ed wi h
adminis a ion o 1 o 10 µg doses o pu e VLPs (end-poin i e s o
25600) (Fig. 4C). No GII.4-specific IgG sub ype an ibodies we e
de ec ed in se a o con ol mice (Fig. 4B and C).
3.6. Effec o BV on unc ionali y o GII.4-specific an ibodies
Tes ing o indi idual immune se a o he a idi y o GII.4-specific
IgG an ibodies indica ed, ha immuniza ion wi h 1 µg o pu e VLPs
induced an ibodies wi h a conside ably lowe (p=0.029) a idi y (a idi y
index 18.4 ± 7.9%) as compa ed wi h an ibodies induced wi h a
combina ion o VLPs and BV (67.2 ± 10.3%) o c ude-pu ified VLPs
wi h esidual BV (60.9 ± 3.9%) (Fig. 5A). No s a is ical diffe ence
(p=0.624) was obse ed be ween he g oups o mice immunized wi h
10 µg o pu e VLPs (a idi y index 48.7 ± 8.9%) and he wo VLP
o mula ions con aining BV (Fig. 5A).
The unc ionali y o he GII-4-specific an ibodies was u he
examined by measu ing he blocking po en ial o he pooled immune
se a, whe e PGM was employed as he HBGA sou ce o GII.4 VLP
binding. Each VLP o mula ion induced an ibodies able o block ≥90%
o he VLP binding (Fig. 5B). Howe e , 4- old highe blocking i e s
BT90 we e obse ed in mice immunized wi h VLPs combined wi h BV
o c ude-pu ified VLPs con aining BV, compa ed wi h mice immunized
wi h 1 µg dose o pu e VLPs (Fig. 5B). Mo eo e , adminis a ion wi h
10 µg dose o pu e VLPs esul ed in an ibodies wi h 2- old g ea e
BT90 as compa ed wi h an ibodies induced wi h lowe dose o pu e
VLPs (Fig. 5B).
3.7. Enhancemen o GII.4-specific T cell esponses by BV
Induc ion o T cell esponses by NoV GII.4 VLP o mula ions was
Table 2
An igenic o mula ions used o immuniza ion o expe imen al mice g oups and body
weigh s.
Expe imen al
g oup
Immunogen Injec ion
dose
S a
weigh
(g)
a
Te mina ion
weigh (g)
b
I OVA 45 µg 17.9 ± 0.3 21.0 ± 0.8
II OVA + BV 45 µg +
10
7
p u
17.4 ± 1.1 20.6 ± 1.2
III OVA + IBV 45 µg +
10
3
p u
17.9 ± 1.4 21.4 ± 1.8
IV GII.4 VLPs 1 µg 17.9 ± 0.9 20.5 ± 1.0
V GII.4 VLPs 10 µg 17.5 ± 0.4 20.5 ± 0.5
VI GII.4 VLPs + BV 1 µg + 10
7
p u
17.3 ± 4.3 21.1 ± 3.9
VII C ude GII.4 VLPs 1 µg (10
5
p u)
17.2 ± 1.0 20.8 ± 2.1
VIII PBS –17.8 ± 0.6 20.7 ± 0.5
a
Mean weigh +/−SD pe expe imen al g oup o mice a s udy week 0 (p io o
immuniza ion).
b
Mean weigh +/−SD pe expe imen al g oup o mice a s udy week 5.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
117
cha ac e ized by analyzing Th1- ype cy okine IFN-γp oduc ion om
he splenocy es o expe imen al mice. Splenocy es om he mice
ecei ing 1 µg o pu e GII.4 VLPs did no p oduce IFN-γin esponse
o any s imula ion (Fig. 6). Ins ead, immuniza ion o mice wi h all
o he VLP o mula ions elici ed a obus IFN-γ esponse, when
s imula ed wi h he 18-me 99-50 pep ide ep esen ing a NoV-specific
CD4
+
T cell epi ope, o wi h 99 pep ide pool ep esen ing he en i e
GII.4–1999 NoV VP1 (Fig. 6 and da a no shown). Ten µg dose o pu e
VLPs induced simila quan i ies o IFN-γsec e ing cells o 1 µg o VLPs
combined wi h BV (p=0.08) as well as 1 µg o c ude-pu ified VLPs
con aining BV (p=0.885). Nega i e con ol OVA pep ide s imula ed no
IFN-γp oduc ion by he cells om any o he expe imen al g oups
(Fig. 6).
3.8. Induc ion o BV-specific an ibodies and T cell esponses
Induc ion o BV-specific IgG esponse was e alua ed in se um
samples o mice immunized wi h OVA o mula ions (g oups I-III,
Table 2). As expec ed, addi ion o li e BV o IBV o he OVA
o mula ion induced BV-specific esponses (p=0.015). No BV esponse
was elici ed immunizing wi h OVA alone, bu conside able le els o BV-
specific an ibodies we e induced, when OVA was co-adminis e ed wi h
BV o IBV (Fig. 7A). No diffe ence in an ibody le els was no ed whe he
OVA was adminis e ed wi h BV o IBV (p=0.149).
Induc ion o BV-specific T cell esponses was s udied measu ing
IFN-γp oduc ion om he splenocy es o he expe imen al g oups.
Cells om he mice ecei ing OVA alone did no p oduce IFN-γin
esponse o s imula ion wi h BV (Fig. 7B). Ins ead, immuniza ions o
mice wi h o mula ions con aining li e BV elici ed high IFN-γ esponse
(Fig. 7B). Mo eo e , low le els o IFN-γwe e induced by co-adminis-
a ion o OVA wi h IBV, which we e subs an ially lowe compa ed wi h
he esponses induced by li e BV o mula ion (p=0.019). No BV-
specific IFN-γ esponse was de ec ed by he cells o nega i e con ol
mice (Fig. 7B).
4. Discussion
Se e al epo s ha e shown li e BV o ha e s ong adju an
p ope ies, p omo ing adap i e immune esponses agains co-adminis-
e ed an igen and ac i a ion o inna e immuni y (Abe e al., 2003;
Fig. 2. OVA-specific se um IgG esponses. End-poin i a ions o an i-OVA IgG (A), IgG1 (B) and IgG2a (C) an ibodies o g oup-wise pooled e mina ion se a o mice immunized wi h
OVA alone o o mula ed wi h BV. Con ol mice ecei ed PBS only. Mean i a ion cu es wi h s anda d e o s o duplica e wells a e shown. (D) Mean a idi y indices (%) wi h s anda d
e o o he means o se um OVA-specific IgG an ibodies.
Fig. 3. OVA-specific T cell esponses. Diffe en concen a ions o an OVA-specific
pep ide we e employed o s imula e IFN-γp oduc ion om he g oup-wise pooled
splenocy es o mice immunized wi h OVA alone o oge he wi h BV o IBV. Mean IFN-γ
spo - o ming cells (SFC)/10
6
splenocy es o duplica e wells wi h s anda d e o s o he
means a e shown.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
118

He as-S ubbs e al., 2007; Molina i e al., 2011; Ma gine e al., 2012;
Qua occhi e al., 2013). The adju an and an i i al p ope ies o BV
make i an in e es ing ool o be conside ed in imp o emen o
immunological esponses o accine an igens. This s udy was designed
o in es iga e adju an effec o BV on adap i e immune esponses
agains wo diffe en model an igens, monome ic OVA p o ein and
oligome ic NoV VLPs. We ound significan diffe ences be ween he
immune esponses igge ed by hese p o eins alone o o mula ed wi h
BV in e ms o an igen-specific an ibody kine ics and i e s, IgG
an ibody sub ypes, induc ion o T cell esponses, and impo an ly,
unc ionali y o he induced an ibody esponses. The diffe ences we e
clea ly associa ed wi h he p esence o li e BV in he p epa a ions and
no he s uc u al o mo phological diffe ences (Fig. 1), as emo al and
inac i a ion o BV ab oga ed he esponses.
The exac mechanism h ough which BV exe s i s adju an
beha io is no ully elucida ed. Acco dingly, mannose-binding esi-
dues in gp64 ha e been p oposed o in e ac wi h he mannose ecep o
exp essed on mac ophages and dend i ic cells (DCs) (Abe e al., 2003).
Al hough mannose ecep o plays an impo an ole in hos de ense
and induc ion o inna e immuni y, se e al e idence con adic s gp64 as
he main ac o in he s imula o y ac i i ies o BV (Abe e al., 2005;
He as-S ubbs e al., 2007). Ins ead, gp64-media ed up ake o BVs and
ecogni ion o unme hyla ed CpG sequences wi hin baculo i al DNA by
Toll-like ecep o 9 (TLR9)/MyD88 dependen and independen pa h-
ways ha e been sugges ed o be necessa y o he ac i a ion o inna e
immune esponses (Abe e al., 2005, 2009). BV is a po en induce o
IFN-αand IFN-β(G onowski e al., 1999; Abe e al., 2005; He as-
S ubbs e al., 2007) bu also o he cy okines o ele ance, mos no ably
IFN-γ(Suzuki e al., 2010). Adju an ac i i y is p ima ily media ed by
he p oduc ion o IFN-αand IFN-βby immune cells (Abe e al., 2005;
Fig. 4. NoV-specific se um IgG esponses. (A) Kine ics o NoV GII.4-specific o al IgG
an ibodies in se um samples o mice immunized wi h 1 o 10 µg o pu e NoV GII.4 VLPs,
1 µg o pu e VLPs combined wi h BV o 1 µg o c ude-pu ified VLPs con aining BV a
weeks 0 and 3. Con ol mice ecei ed PBS only. G oup mean OD
490
alues wi h s anda d
e o o he means o ail blood samples collec ed a s udy weeks 0 (p e-immune se a)
and 2 o 3 as well as e mina ion se a a week 5 a e shown. End-poin i a ions o an i-
GII.4 IgG1 (B) and IgG2a (C) sub ype an ibodies o g oup-wise (4 mice/g oup) pooled
e mina ion se a. Mean i a ion cu es wi h s anda d e o s o duplica e wells o up o 2
independen expe imen s a e shown.
Fig. 5. A idi y and blocking an ibody i e s o mice immunized wi h NoV GII.4 VLP o mula ions. (A) Mean a idi y indices (%) wi h s anda d e o o he means o GII.4-specific IgG
an ibodies in e mina ion se a o immunized g oups. (B) An ibody i e s o g oup-wise pooled se a blocking ≥90% (BT90) o he VLPs binding o he HBGAs.
Fig. 6. NoV GII.4-specific T cell esponses.NoV GII.4–1999 –specific 99 pep ide pool
and a single 99-50 pep ide we e used o s imula e IFN-γp oduc ion om he g oup-wise
pooled splenocy es o mice immunized wi h 1 µg o pu e NoV GII.4 VLPs o 1 µg o pu e
VLPs combined wi h BV. Cul u e medium (CM) as well as an OVA pep ide we e used as
nega i e con ols. Mean IFN-γspo - o ming cells (SFC)/10
6
splenocy es o duplica e
wells wi h s anda d e o s o he means a e shown.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
119
He as-S ubbs e al., 2007), p obably due o he abili y o ype I IFNs o
imp o e B cell as well as T cell esponses (Le Bon e al., 2001, 2003;
Deal e al., 2013).
The cu en s udy demons a es ha li e BV has desi able ea u es
a ibu ed o classical adju an s, which wo k o spa e he dose o he
an igen and imp o e he immune esponses. We de ec ed a conside -
ably highe immunogenici y o bo h an igens, OVA and NoV VLPs,
when o mula ed wi h BV. Impo an ly, BV was able o spa e he dose
o he NoV VLPs used o immuniza ion. In addi ion, BV ac ed o
p omo e bo h Th1- and Th2- ype esponses wi hou skewing he
o e all immune esponse in any pa icula di ec ion. Howe e , BV
could be conside ed a po en Th1- ype adju an , as OVA p o ein was
capable o inducing an igen-specific IgG2a immunoglobulin sub ype
only when co-adminis e ed wi h BV. Consis en wi h his obse a ion,
Ma gine and co-wo ke s (Ma gine e al., 2012) epo ed, ha esidual
BV in an igenic o mula ions biases he iso ype dis ibu ion o he
an ibody esponse owa ds he IgG2a immunoglobulin sub ype, sug-
ges ing s imula ion o cell-media ed esponses. In he e, he BV
adju an effec was s ongly affec ed by he emo al o inac i a ion o
BVs, indica ing ha he adju an p ope ies we e due o he p esence o
li e BV. This is no su p ising, as BV inac i a ion has been shown o
comple ely ab oga e immunopo en ia ion effec , pa ly due o abol-
ished p oduc ion o ype I IFNs (He as-S ubbs e al., 2007), which a e
gene a ed in esponse o li e i uses (Goodbou n e al., 2000).
An ibodies wi h high a idi y ha e been shown o p omo e efficien
i us neu aliza ion (Rockx e al., 2005; Puschnik e al., 2013). These
an ibodies ha e also been associa ed wi h p o ec ion om some i al
in ec ions, including esicula s oma i is i us (VSV) (Salmi, 1991;
Bachmann e al., 1997). Mo eo e , p e ious da a by ou g oup
demons a ed ha child en wi h high-a idi y an i-NoV IgG an ibodies
had ewe NoV in ec ions han child en wi h low-a idi y an ibodies
(Nu minen e al., 2011). The p esen s udy shows ha BV was able o
induce unc ionally efficien humo al esponse, as li e BV inc eased he
a idi y o se um IgG an ibodies agains co-adminis e ed OVA p o ein
and NoV VLPs. Fu he mo e, NoV has been shown o use HBGAs,
complex ca bohyd a es ound on ed blood cells, mucosal epi helial
cells and as sec e ed ee an igens in body fluids, as cellula a achmen
ac o s o ecep o s (Ha ing on e al., 2002; Ma ionneau e al., 2002;
Huang e al., 2003). An i-NoV an ibodies which block binding o NoV
VLPs o he HBGAs a e conside ed co ela e o p o ec ion agains NoV
in ec ion (Ha ing on e al., 2002; Reeck e al., 2010; Nu minen e al.,
2011; Malm e al., 2014). Ou esul s demons a e ha adminis a ion
o GII.4 VLPs in a combina ion wi h BV conside ably inc eased he
blocking po en ial o hese an ibodies.
Al hough he p esen s udy did no explo e he induc ion o inna e
immuni y, we hypo hesize ha ollowing i.d. immuniza ion BV is aken
up by imma u e DC in he skin, and induces ma u a ion and ac i a ion
o hese an igen p esen ing cells (APC) as p e iously demons a ed
(Molina i e al., 2011), up egula ing co-s imula o y molecules as well
as p oduc ion o p o-inflamma o y cy okines (He as-S ubbs e al.,
2007; Suzuki e al., 2010; Molina i e al., 2011; Qua occhi e al.,
2013). In conco dance wi h hese findings, we ha e ecen ly shown ha
esidual BV in he c ude pu ified p o ein p epa a ions induces TNF-α
p oduc ion by monocy es/mac ophages in i o (Malm e al., 2016a).
TNF-α igge s he ec ui men and ac i a ion o APCs a he injec ion
si e and acili a es mig a ion o APCs o lymph nodes (S oi zne e al.,
1999), hus imp o ing he an igen up ake and p esen a ion o T cells.
P e ious epo s ha e demons a ed ha BV enhances T cell
esponses agains co-adminis e ed an igens (He as-S ubbs e al.,
2007; Ma gine e al., 2012). Thus, a e obse ing he adju an effec
o BV on IgG2a an ibody p oduc ion agains bo h an igens, we
in es iga ed an igen-specific IFN-γcy okine p oduc ion, a hallma k
o Th1 cell immuni y. BV p omo ed gene a ion o T cell esponses
agains co-deli e ed an igens, as add essed by conside able sec e ion o
IFN-γby splenocy es upon s imula ion wi h OVA and NoV GII.4
de i ed pep ides co esponding o he immunodominan CD4
+
T cell
epi opes, as well as a pep ide pool co e ing he en i e sequence o NoV
VP1. Simila ly o he an ibody esponse, BV inac i a ion abolished he
capaci y o BVs o induce OVA-specific T cell esponse, sugges ing ha
induc ion o T cell esponse is also dependen on he p esence o li e
BV pa icles. Cells o mice immunized wi h o mula ions con aining
li e BV, bu no IBV, p oduced high amoun o IFN-γupon ex i o
s imula ion wi h BV. This indica es ac i a ion o T cells in lymphoid
issues by BV, which is in ag eemen wi h p e ious obse a ions by
o he s (S auss e al., 2007; Molina i e al., 2011). Pa ac ine sec e ion
o cy okines by BV-specific T cells is o a significance as hese cy okines
d i e p oli e a ion and diffe en ia ion o co-deli e ed an igen p imed
lymphocy es.
BV has a p onounced adju an effec on T cell esponses o NoV,
al hough i also imp o es unc ionali y o he an ibodies in e ms o
a idi y and blocking/neu aliza ion. Howe e , mo e p onounced B and
T cell adju an effec was obse ed o co-deli e ed OVA an igen, which
is no su p ising due o he less immunogenic na u e o soluble
monome ic p o eins in compa ison o he mo e immunogenic VLPs
(Bachmann and Jennings, 2010). Supe io immunogenici y o pa icles
o p o ein agg ega es o e soluble p o eins is s ongly linked o he
mul i alen o ganiza ion o an igen p esen ed on pa icles (Bachmann
e al., 1993; Ghosh e al., 2002). Unlike soluble p o eins, he la ge
s uc u es wi hin he size ange o ~40 nm a e efficien ly in e nalized
by APCs (Fifis e al., 2004), and hus ca ied o he lymphoid o gans
and p esen ed o T cells.
In conclusion, he p esence o li e BV in an igenic o mula ions
s eng hened bo h an ibody and T cell immune esponses o hese
p o eins, u he spa ing he dose o he an igen. The e o e, i is
emp ing o specula e, ha c ude pu ified p o eins could be excellen
candida es o e e ina y accines. Fo ins ance, a accine con aining
c ude pu ified a ian influenza an igens could be used o accina e wild
bi ds and domes ic poul y o limi he po en ial sp ead o pandemic
influenza i uses, ex emely ha m ul o human popula ion (Noh e al.,
Fig. 7. BV-specific an ibodies and T cell esponses.(A) BV-specific se um IgG esponses
in mice immunized wi h OVA alone o oge he wi h BV o IBV. Con ol mice ecei ed
PBS only. Shown a e mean OD
490
alues wi h s anda d e o s o he means o
e mina ion se a. (B) BV-specific T cell esponses induced in mice immunized wi h
diffe en OVA o mula ions. BV was used o s imula e IFN-γp oduc ion om he g oup-
wise pooled splenocy es o immunized and con ol mice. Mean IFN-γspo - o ming cells
(SFC)/10
6
splenocy es o duplica e wells o 1–3 independen expe imen s wi h s anda d
e o s o he means a e shown.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
120
2016; Pushko e al., 2017). High quan i ies o he accine s ocks could
be p oduced ela i ely easy and a a low cos , wi hou he need o ime
consuming and cos ly ch oma og aphic pu ifica ion s eps. The esidual
BV in c ude pu ified p o ein p epa a ions would alle ia e he need o
addi ion o ex e nal adju an s o he accine o mula ion because o he
in insic immunos imula o y effec o li e BV. Significan ad an ages o
BV include i s inhe en inabili y o eplica e in e eb a e cells (Tjia
e al., 1983; B usca e al., 1986), hus elimina ing he need o
inac i a ion, as well as low cy o oxici y and absence o p e-exis ing
immuni y (Shoji e al., 1997; S auss e al., 2007). Al hough he e is a
high conce n by egula o y agencies abou con amina ing i uses in
human accines, BV could be conside ed as an adju an in e e ina y
accines due o hei less s ingen egula o y equi emen s (Adams,
2015). Because i is difficul o ensu e he cons an le el o BV in c ude
p o ein p epa a ions, he ac i i y o BV in a accine o mula ion should
be e alua ed by de e mining he ange o BV concen a ions (e.g.
adding exac amoun s o BV in o he pu e VLPs) exe ing adju an
effec in ca e ully designed p eclinical animal expe imen s, and hus,
each c ude accine ba ch needs o be es ed o mee he concen a ion
ange. Since li e BVs in accine o mula ions may p o oke eac ogeni-
ci y and aise sa e y conce ns, u he s udies a e needed o asce ain
he eac ogenici y, oxici y and sa e y o BV con aining accine
p epa a ions in ele an animal models.
Acknowledgemen s
We g a e ully acknowledge he echnical assis ance gi en by he
labo a o y pe sonnel o he Vaccine Resea ch Cen e . Special hanks
a e due o Ee a Jokela, Sanna Ka én and Ma ianne Ka lsbe g o
echnical assis ance. This esea ch did no ecei e any specific g an
om unding agencies in he public, comme cial, o no - o -p ofi
sec o s.
Re e ences
Abe, T., Hemmi, H., Miyamo o, H., Mo iishi, K., Tamu a, S., Takaku, H., Aki a, S.,
Ma suu a, Y., 2005. In ol emen o he Toll-like ecep o 9 signaling pa hway in he
induc ion o inna e immuni y by baculo i us. J. Vi ol. 79, 2847–2858.
Abe, T., Takahashi, H., Hamazaki, H., Miyano-Ku osaki, N., Ma suu a, Y., Takaku, H.,
2003. Baculo i us induces an inna e immune esponse and con e s p o ec ion om
le hal influenza i us in ec ion in mice. J. Immunol. 171, 1133–1139.
Abe, T., Kaname, Y., Wen, X., Tani, H., Mo iishi, K., Uema su, S., Takeuchi, O., Ishii,
K.J., Kawai, T., Aki a, S., Ma suu a, Y., 2009. Baculo i us induces ype I in e e on
p oduc ion h ough oll-like ecep o -dependen and -independen pa hways in a
cell- ype-specific manne . J. Vi ol. 83, 7629–7640.
Adams, A., 2015. Ve e ina y accines: egula ions and impac on eme ging in ec ious
diseases. In: Milligan, G., Ba e , A. (Eds.), Vaccinology: An Essen ial Guide. John
Wiley & Sons, L d, Ox o d, UK..
A ma , R.L., Baehne , F., C ame , J.P., Song, E., Bo kowski, A., Mendelman, P.M., NOR-
201 S udy G oup. 2016. Rapid esponses o 2 i us-like pa icle no o i us accine
candida e o mula ions in heal hy adul s: a andomized con olled ialJ. In ec . Dis.
214, 845–853.
Bachmann, M.F., Jennings, G.T., 2010. Vaccine deli e y: a ma e o size, geome y,
kine ics and molecula pa e ns. Na . Re . Immunol. 10, 787–796.
Bachmann, M.F., Kalinke, U., Al hage, A., F ee , G., Bu kha , C., Roos , H., Ague , M.,
Henga ne , H., Zinke nagel, R.M., 1997. The ole o an ibody concen a ion and
a idi y in an i i al p o ec ion. Science 276, 2024–2027.
Bachmann, M.F., Roh e , U.H., Kundig, T.M., Bu ki, K., Henga ne , H., Zinke nagel,
R.M., 1993. The influence o an igen o ganiza ion on B cell esponsi eness. Science
262, 1448–1451.
Blaze ic, V., Lappalainen, S., Nu minen, K., Huh i, L., Vesika i, T., 2011. No o i us VLPs
and o a i us VP6 p o ein as combined accine o childhood gas oen e i is. Vaccine
29, 8126–8133.
Blaze ic, V., Malm, M., A inobu, D., Lappalainen, S., Vesika i, T., 2016. Ro a i us capsid
VP6 p o ein ac s as an adju an in i o o no o i us i us-like pa icles in a
combina ion accine. Hum. Vaccin Immuno he . 12, 740–748.
B usca, J., Summe s, M., Couch, J., Cou ney, L., 1986. Au og apha cali o nica nuclea
polyhed osis i us efficien ly en e s bu does no eplica e in poikilo he mic
e eb a e cells. In e i ology 26, 207–222.
Deal, E.M., Lahl, K., Na aez, C.F., Bu che , E.C., G eenbe g, H.B., 2013. Plasmacy oid
dend i ic cells p omo e o a i us-induced human and mu ine B cell esponses. J.
Clin. In es . 123, 2464–2474.
Fifis, T., Gam ellis, A., C imeen-I win, B., Pie e sz, G.A., Li, J., Mo am, P.L.,
McKenzie, I.F., Plebanski, M., 2004. Size-dependen immunogenici y: he apeu ic
and p o ec i e p ope ies o nano- accines agains umo s. J. Immunol. 173,
3148–3154.
Ghosh, M.K., Bo ca, M.V., Roy, P., 2002. Vi us-de i ed ubula s uc u e displaying
o eign sequences on he su ace elici CD4+ Th cell and p o ec i e humo al
esponses. Vi ology 302, 383–392.
Goodbou n, S., Didcock, L., Randall, R.E., 2000. In e e ons: cell signalling, immune
modula ion, an i i al esponse and i us coun e measu es. J. Gen. Vi ol. 81,
2341–2364.
G onowski, A.M., Hilbe , D.M., Sheehan, K.C., Ga o a, G., Sch eibe , R.D., 1999.
Baculo i us s imula es an i i al effec s in mammalian cells. J. Vi ol. 73, 9944–9951.
Ha ing on, P.R., Lindesmi h, L., Youn , B., Moe, C.L., Ba ic, R.S., 2002. Binding o
No walk i us-like pa icles o ABH his o-blood g oup an igens is blocked by
an ise a om in ec ed human olun ee s o expe imen ally accina ed mice. J. Vi ol.
76, 12335–12343.
He as-S ubbs, S., Rueda, P., Lopez, L., Lecle c, C., 2007. Insec baculo i uses s ongly
po en ia e adap i e immune esponses by inducing ype I IFN. J. Immunol. 178,
2361–2369.
Huang, P., Fa kas, T., Ma ionneau, S., Zhong, W., Ru oen-Cloue , N., Mo ow, A.L.,
Al aye, M., Picke ing, L.K., Newbu g, D.S., LePendu, J., Jiang, X., 2003. No o i uses
bind o human ABO, Lewis, and sec e o his o-blood g oup an igens: iden ifica ion o
4 dis inc s ain-specific pa e ns. J. In ec . Dis. 188, 19–31.
Huh i, L., Blaze ic, V., Nu minen, K., Koho, T., Hy önen, V., Vesika i, T., 2010. A
compa ison o me hods o pu ifica ion and concen a ion o no o i us GII-4 capsid
i us-like pa icles. A ch. Vi ol. 155, 1855–1858.
Huh i, L., Tamminen, K., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2013. Cha ac e iza ion and
immunogenici y o no o i us capsid-de i ed i us-like pa icles pu ified by anion
exchange ch oma og aphy. A ch. Vi ol. 158, 933–942.
Jose sbe g, J.O., Buckland, B., 2012. Vaccine p ocess echnology. Bio echnol. Bioeng.
109, 1443–1460.
Lappalainen, S., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2016. Simple and efficien ul afil a ion
me hod o pu ifica ion o o a i us VP6 oligome ic p o eins. A ch. Vi ol. 161,
3219–3223.
Le Bon, A., E cha , N., Rossmann, C., Ash on, M., Hou, S., Gewe , D., Bo ow, P.,
Tough, D.F., 2003. C oss-p iming o CD8+ T cells s imula ed by i us-induced ype I
in e e on. Na . Immunol. 4, 1009–1015.
Le Bon, A., Schia oni, G., D'Agos ino, G., G esse , I., Bela delli, F., Tough, D.F., 2001.
Type i in e e ons po en ly enhance humo al immuni y and can p omo e iso ype
swi ching by s imula ing dend i ic cells in i o. Immuni y 14, 461–470.
Lindesmi h, L.C., Debbink, K., Swans om, J., Vinje, J., Cos an ini, V., Ba ic, R.S.,
Donaldson, E.F., 2012. Monoclonal an ibody-based an igenic mapping o no o i us
GII.4-2002. J. Vi ol. 86, 873–883.
Malm, M., Heinimaki, S., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2017. Ro a i us capsid VP6 ubula
and sphe ical nanos uc u es ac as local adju an s when co-deli e ed wi h no o i us
VLPs. Clin. Exp. Immunol..
Malm, M., Tamminen, K., Lappalainen, S., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2016a. Ro a i us
ecombinan VP6 nano ubes ac as an immunomodula o and deli e y ehicle o
no o i us i us-like pa icles. J. Immunol. Res. 2016, 9171632.
Malm, M., Tamminen, K., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2016b. No o i us-specific memo y T
cell esponses in adul human dono s. F on . Mic obiol. 7, 1570.
Malm, M., Tamminen, K., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2016c. Type-specific and c oss-
eac i e an ibodies and T cell esponses in no o i us VLP immunized mice a e
a ge ed bo h o conse ed and a iable domains o capsid VP1 p o ein. Mol.
Immunol. 78, 27–37.
Malm, M., Uusi-Ke ula, H., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2014. High se um le els o
no o i us geno ype-specificblocking an ibodies co ela e wi h p o ec ion om
in ec ion in child en. J. In ec . Dis. 210, 1755–1762.
Ma gine, I., Ma inez-Gil, L., Chou, Y.Y., K amme , F., 2012. Residual baculo i us in
insec cell-de i ed influenza i us-like pa icle p epa a ions enhances
immunogenici y. PLoS One 7, e51559.
Ma ionneau, S., Ru oen, N., Le Moullac-Vaidye, B., Clemen , M., Cailleau-Thomas, A.,
Ruiz-Palacois, G., Huang, P., Jiang, X., Le Pendu, J., 2002. No walk i us binds o
his o-blood g oup an igens p esen on gas oduodenal epi helial cells o sec e o
indi iduals. Gas oen e ology 122, 1967–1977.
McFa land, B.J., San , A.J., Lyb and, T.P., Beeson, C., 1999. O albumin(323-339)
pep ide binds o he majo his ocompa ibili y complex class II I-A(d) p o ein using
wo unc ionally dis inc egis e s. Biochemis y 38, 16663–16670.
Mino , P.D., 2015. Li e a enua ed accines: his o ical successes and cu en challenges.
Vi ology 479–480, 379–392.
Molina i, P., C espo, M.I., G a isaco, M.J., Taboga, O., Mo on, G., 2011. Baculo i us
capsid display po en ia es OVA cy o oxic and inna e immune esponses. PLoS One 6,
e24108.
Noh, J.Y., Pa k, J.K., Lee, D.H., Yuk, S.S., Kwon, J.H., Lee, S.W., Lee, J.B., Pa k, S.Y.,
Choi, I.S., Song, C.S., 2016. Chime ic bi alen i us-like pa icle accine o H5N1
HPAI and ND con e s p o ec ion agains a le hal challenge in chickens and allows a
s a egy o Diffe en ia ing In ec ed om Vaccina ed Animals (DIVA). PLoS One 11,
e0162946.
Nu minen, K., Blaze ic, V., Huh i, L., Rasanen, S., Koho, T., Hy onen, V.P., Vesika i, T.,
2011. P e alence o no o i us GII-4 an ibodies in Finnish child en. J. Med. Vi ol. 83,
525–531.
Puschnik, A., Lau, L., C omwell, E.A., Balmaseda, A., Zompi, S., Ha is, E., 2013.
Co ela ion be ween dengue-specific neu alizing an ibodies and se um a idi y in
p ima y and seconda y dengue i us 3 na u al in ec ions in humans. PLoS Negl.
T op. Dis. 7, e2274.
Pushko, P., T e yako a, I., Hidaja , R., Zsak, A., Ch zas ek, K., Tumpey, T.M.,
Kapczynski, D.R., 2017. Vi us-like pa icles displaying H5, H7, H9 hemagglu inins
and N1 neu aminidase elici p o ec i e immuni y o he e ologous a ian influenza
i uses in chickens. Vi ology 501, 176–182.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
121
Qua occhi, V., Molina i, P., Langello i, C., Gnazzo, V., Taboga, O., Zamo ano, P., 2013.
Co-inocula ion o baculo i us and FMDV accine in mice, elici s e y ea ly p o ec ion
agains oo and mou h disease i us wi hou in e e ing wi h long las ing immuni y.
Vaccine 31, 2713–2718.
Reeck, A., Ka anagh, O., Es es, M.K., Opekun, A.R., Gilge , M.A., G aham, D.Y., A ma ,
R.L., 2010. Se ological co ela e o p o ec ion agains no o i us-induced
gas oen e i is. J. In ec . Dis. 202, 1212–1218.
Rockx, B., Ba ic, R.S., de G ijs, I., Duize , E., Koopmans, M.P., 2005. Cha ac e iza ion o
he homo- and he e o ypic immune esponses a e na u al no o i us in ec ion. J.
Med. Vi ol. 77, 439–446.
Salmi, A.A., 1991. An ibody affini y and p o ec ion in i us in ec ions. Cu . Opin.
Immunol. 3, 503–506.
Shoji, I., Aizaki, H., Tani, H., Ishii, K., Chiba, T., Sai o, I., Miyamu a, T., Ma suu a, Y.,
1997. Efficien gene ans e in o a ious mammalian cells, including non-hepa ic
cells, by baculo i us ec o s. J. Gen. Vi ol. 78 (P 10), 2657–2664.
S oi zne , P., Zanella, M., O ne , U., Lukas, M., Tagwe ke , A., Janke, K., Lu z, M.B.,
Schule , G., Ech enache , B., Ryffel, B., Koch, F., Romani, N., 1999. Mig a ion o
lange hans cells and de mal dend i ic cells in skin o gan cul u es: augmen a ion by
TNF-alpha and IL-1be a. J. Leukoc. Biol. 66, 462–470.
S auss, R., Huse , A., Ni, S., Tu e, S., Ki ia , N., Sow, P.S., Ho mann, C., Liebe , A.,
2007. Baculo i us-based accina ion ec o s allow o efficien induc ion o immune
esponses agains plasmodium alcipa um ci cumspo ozoi e p o ein. Mol. The . 15,
193–202.
Suzuki, T., Chang, M.O., Ki ajima, M., Takaku, H., 2010. Baculo i us ac i a es mu ine
dend i ic cells and induces non-specific NK cell and T cell immune esponses. Cell.
Immunol. 262, 35–43.
Tamminen, K., Huh i, L., Koho, T., Lappalainen, S., Hy onen, V.P., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic,
V., 2012. A compa ison o immunogenici y o no o i us GII-4 i us-like pa icles and
P-pa icles. Immunology 135, 89–99.
Tamminen, K., Lappalainen, S., Huh i, L., Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2013. T i alen
combina ion accine induces b oad he e ologous immune esponses o no o i us
and o a i us in mice. PLoS One 8, e70409.
Tjia, S.T., zu Al enschildesche, G.M., Doe fle , W., 1983. Au og apha cali o nica nuclea
polyhed osis i us (AcNPV) DNA does no pe sis in mass cul u es o mammalian
cells. Vi ology 125, 107–117.
Vesika i, T., Blaze ic, V., 2015. No o i us accine: one s ep close . J. In ec . Dis. 211,
853–855.
S. Heinimäki e al. Vi ology 511 (2017) 114–122
122