scieee Science in your language
[en] (orig)
Investigation of localized electr ochemi cal
interfaces with advanced microscopic
techniques:
AFM-SECM and FIB/SEM t omography

Zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades D r. rer. nat.
der Fakultät für Naturwissenschaf ten der Universität Ul m

vorgelegt v on
Angelika Holzinger
aus Heilbronn

Ulm, 20 19

Amtierender Dekan: Prof. Dr. Peter Dürre
Erstgutachter: apl. Prof. Dr. Ch ristine Kranz
Zweitgutachter: Prof. Dr . Jürgen R. Behm
Tag der Promotion: 16. Juli 2019

i

ii

Much to learn you still have .
- Yod a

iv

Co n te n t
Content ......................................................................................................................... iv
Abbreviations ............................................................................................................... vi
Abstract ........................................................................................................................ ix
Zusammenfassung ....................................................................................................... xii
Experimental background ......................................................................................... - 1 -
F UNDAMENTALS IN ELECTR OCHE MISTRY ........................................................................ - 1 -
P OTENTIOMETRY ................................................................................................ . - 4 -
D IFFUSION - LIMITED CURRENT S AT UME S ................................................................... - 8 -
Surface and geometry of UMEs ........................................................................... - 9 -
E LECTROCHEMISTRY AT THE I TIES ........................................................................... - 10 -
The interface between tw o liqu ids ................................................................... - 12 -
Electrochemistry at ITIES ................................................................................... - 13 -
E LECTROCHEMISTRY AT NANO - INTERFACES ................................................................ - 14 -
S CANNING PROBE TECHNI QUES .................................................................................. - 17 -
A TOMIC FORCE MICROSCO PY ................................................................................. - 17 -
S CANNING ELECTROCHEMICA L MICROSCOPY ............................................................... - 20 -
AFM-SECM ..................................................................................................... - 23 -
FIB/SEM TOMOGRAPHY ........................................................................................ - 28 -
Results and discussion ............................................................................................. - 32 -
H 2 O 2 SENSING WITH AFM TIP - INTEGRATED ELECTRODES ................................................. - 33 -
I NTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. - 33 -
E XPERIMENTAL .................................................................................................. - 36 -
R ESULTS AND DISCUSSION ..................................................................................... - 40 -
PB/NiHCF-modified UMEs ................................................................................. - 40 -
PB/NiHCF-modified AFM-SECM probes ............................................................ - 54 -
Localized detection of H 2 O 2 by AFM-SECM ....................................................... - 63 -
C ONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK .................................................................................. - 67 -
AFM TIP - INTEGRATED P H SE NSORS ................................ ............................................ - 69 -
I NTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. - 69 -
E XPERIMENTAL .................................................................................................. - 71 -
R ESULTS AND DISCUSSION ..................................................................................... - 75 -
AFM tip-integrated pH sensors ......................................................................... - 76 -
Investigation of calcite dissolution by AFM-SECM ............................................ - 80 -
Electrochemical deposition of iridium oxide film electrodes ........................... - 87 -

v

C ONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK .................................................................................. - 92 -
I NVESTIGATION OF THE ITIES AT NANOP ORE ARRAYS ...................................................... - 94 -
I NTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. - 94 -
E XPERIMENTAL .................................................................................................. - 98 -
R ESULTS AND DISCUSSION ................................................................................... - 103 -
Diffusion at nanopore arrays .......................................................................... - 103 -
ITIES at nanopore arrays ................................................................................. - 109 -
Silica deposits at the ITIES for localization of the i nterface ............................ - 116 -
Investigation of the elem ental composition of deposited silica at nanopores- 123 -
C ONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK ................................................................................ - 130 -
Final remarks ......................................................................................................... - 132 -
References ................................ ............................................................................. - 136 -
Appendix ............................................................................................................... - 153 -
IX. A . U SED CHEMICALS AND MATER IALS ....................................................................... - 153 -
IX. B . U SED INSTRUMENTS ........................................................................................ - 155 -
IX. C . T ABLE OF T ABL ES ............................................................................................ - 156 -
IX. D . T ABLE OF F IGURES .......................................................................................... - 157 -
Acknowledgment .................................................................................................. - 173 -
Curriculum Vitae .................................................................................................... - 174 -
Publications ........................................................................................................... - 176 -
Eidesstattliche Erklärung ....................................................................................... - 178 -

vi

Ab bre vi ati o n s

ACT

-

Aqueous complexation followed by transfer

AFM

-

Atomic force microscopy

Ag/AgCl

-

Silver/silver chloride reference electrode

AIROF

-

Anodic iridium oxide film

ATR FTIR

-

Attenuated total reflection FT IR

BSE

-

Backsc attered electron(s)

CE

-

Counter electrode

CV

-

Cyclic voltammetry

DPA

-

Differential pulse amperometry

DRIE

-

Deep reactive ion etchin g

EDX

-

Energy dispersive X- ray

EIROF

-

Electrochemically deposited iridium oxide film

ETD

-

Everhart-Thornley detector

FIB

-

Focused ion beam

FTIR

-

Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy

HOPG

-

Highly oriented pyrolytic graphite

IBID

-

Ion beam induced deposition

ISE

-

Ion selective electrode

ISFET

-

Ion sensitive field effect transistor

ITIES

-

Interface between two immiscible electrolyte sol utions

Mt/AFM- SECM

-

Molecule touching/ AFM-SECM

NHE

-

Normal hydrogen electrode

NiHCF

-

Nickel hexacyanoferrate

NMR

-

Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

NPP model

-

Nernst-Planck, Poisson model

OCP

-

Open circuit potential

ORR

-

Oxygen reduction reaction

PECVD

-

Plasma-enhanced chemi cal vapor deposition

vii

PB

-

Prussian blue

RE

-

Reference electrode

ROS

-

Reactive oxygen species

SE

-

Secondary electron(s)

SECM

-

Scanning electrochemical microscopy

SEM

-

Scanning electron microscopy

SG/TC mode

-

Substrate generation / tip collection mode

SHE

-

Standard hydrogen electrode

SiN

-

Silicon nitride

SIROF

-

Sputtered iridium oxide film

SNOM

-

Scanning near-f ield microscopy

SPM

-

Scanning probe microscopy

STEM

-

Scanning transmission electron microscopy

STM

-

Scanning tunneling microscopy

SVET

-

Scanning vibrating electrode technique

TARM – AFM-SECM

-

Tip-attached redox mediator – AFM-SECM

TATB

-

Tetraphenylarsonium tetraphenylborate

TEM

-

Transmission electron microscopy

TIC

-

Transfer by interfacial complexation

TID

-

Transfer by interfacial dec omplexation

TLD

-

Through-the-lens detector

TOC

-

Transfer followed by organic-phase complexation

TOIROF

-

Thermal oxidation of ir id ium oxide film

UME

-

Ultramicroelectrode

XRD

-

X-ray diffraction

viii

ix

Ab st ract
Comprehensive knowledge about interfacial processes is essential for the development of
innovative miniaturized sensors or the in vestigatio n of biological samples. Miniaturization
of sensors with sub-micron and nanoscale dimen sions and sensor arrays i s accompanied
by challenges, s uch as changes in the efficiency of the sensor, changes in the general
behavior at small se nsor dimen sions, or difficultie s in handlin g of such devices. Th erefore,
a detailed eval uation o f possible factors influencing the performance of miniaturized
sensors has to be done prior to applications. Studying processes at s urfaces, ranging from
e.g., single cells 1 to c orroding ma terials 2 a nd i nvestigations o f nanoscale 3D an d 2D
materials, e.g. nanotubes 3 an d graphene 4 , got accessible with high-resolutio n microscopic
techniques with improved resolution down to the sub -nanoscale 5 – 7 . Esp ecially comb ined
scanning probe techniques (SPM) 2,8 – 10 en able t he investigation of localized surface
properties. Amongst other hybrid methods, atomic f orce - scanning electrochemical
microscopy (AFM-SECM) is h ighly attractive for stu dying process es at the solid/liquid
interface, and also f or in vestigations of liquid/liquid interfaces 11 . In order t o enhance the
field of applications, AFM-SECM probes may be modified facilitating the requireme nts for
biomedical applications an d for usage with electroanalytical t echniques. Whereas AFM-
SECM p rovides predominantly information of surface processes , the combination of
focused ion beam (FIB) and scanning electro n microscopy (SEM) 12,13 e nables the detection
and reconstruction of the inner st ructure of (nano)porous materials. This was alread y
reported for several materials, ranging from nanoparticles in dye-sensitive solar cells 14 to
investigations of biological 15,16 and geological 16 samples.
Within the f irst part of this t hesis, the focus of researc h is targeted towards modification
of AFM-SECM probes fac ilitatin g biomedical ly relevant measurements, such as sen sing
hydrogen peroxide (H 2 O 2 ) release or generation in close proximity to a sample surface
(chapter 4), and localized pH sensing with associated surface changes (chapter 5 ).
In chapter 4, t he surface m odification of AFM tip-integrated electrodes wit h
electrocatalytically activ e layers is p resented, namely Prussia n Blue ( PB ) for H 2 O 2 sensing.
In contrast to a relative ly high potential (0.5 – 0.8 V vs. normal hydrogen electrode

x

(NHE) 17 ) for H 2 O 2 oxidation at plat inum electrodes, mo dification with PB pro vides
moderate electrochemical reduction p otentials (-0.05 V vs. standard re ference electrode
(SHE) 18 ) and improved selectivity 19 . The disadvantage of the limited stability o f PB
particular in higher H 2 O 2 concentration can be att enuated by co-d eposition of PB and
nickel-hexacyanoferrate (NiHCF) 20 . Prior to AFM- SECM investigations, diffe rent electrode
materials and con ditions, e.g. vacuum condition s and drying processes, which are
necessary for AFM-SECM probe f abrication, are evaluated on modified
ultramicroelectrodes (U ME). Besides a thorough characterizati on, the stability a nd
sensitivity of the H 2 O 2 sensor s are investiga ted, an d f irst results t oward s localized H 2 O 2
detection by AFM-SECM are presented in 4.3 .3.
In chapter 5, solid-state pH sensors integrated into AFM t ips are evaluated sin ce local p H
changes play an important role, fo r example in corrosion scie nce or inves tigation of living
cells 21,22 . Antimony/anti mony oxide 23 , 24 , a nodic iridium oxide film (AI ROF) 25,26 and
electrochemical iri dium oxide film (EIRO F) 27 wer e inv estigated as AFM tip- integrated pH
sensor materials. The most suita ble modif ication with res pect to s tability and s ensitivity
in pH calib rations is evaluated (5.3.1 a nd 5. 3.3) and first AF M- SECM meas urements o f t he
dissolution of calcite c rystals as a model sample mapping s urface changes along w ith a pH
change to more alkaline pH values 28,29 are presen ted in 5.3.2 .
In chapter 6, de tailed investigations of FIB- milled nanoporous arrays in silicon nitride (SiN)
membranes are presented, which were used as solid- state s upport for el ectrochemistry
at the interface b etween two immiscible ele ctroly te solutions (ITIES) 30,31 . FIB can be used
for mask-less prototyping of arrays with readily adju stable dimensions 32 – 34 . Sin ce this
fabrication process may change t he performan ce of such micro - and nanoporous solid-
state materials due to implantation of positively charged Ga ions 35 or due to a varyin g
pore shape resulting f rom re-deposition during the FIB milling process 32,36,37 , a
comprehensive a nalysis of these devices is essential. The sui tability of AFM -SECM in the
investigation of micro- and nanoscale interfaces is shown b y the performance of AFM -
SECM with a conductive AFM t ip, which was used to visualize the different diffusion
behavior at these na noporo us arrays , as the ra tio between the pore size a nd the dis tance
between single pores wit hin an array are affect ing the diffusio n behavior at these devices
(6.3.1). Th e det ailed investigations on the location of the nano -interfaces at the

xi

nanoporous Si N mem branes are shown in 6.3 .3 and 6.3.4 . I n additi on, the localized
electrochemical dep ositi on of silica at th e nanoI TIES was u sed t o visualize th e location of
the interface within the n anopores . For t he first time, FIB/SEM tomograph y was
performed for the investigations of the location of this interface at such silica deposits.

xii

Zu s am me nf a ss ung
Zur Entwicklung in novativer mi niaturisierter Sensoren, sowie zur Untersuchung
biologischer Vorgänge, ist ein detailliertes Verständnis der zugrundeliegenden Prozesse
notwendig, die a n Grenzflächen a blaufen. Mögliche Einflü sse, die das Ver halten und die
Anwendbarkeit solcher M ikrosensoren b eeinträchtigen könn en, m üssen im Vorfel d
detailliert untersucht werden. Untersuchungen an Grenzflächen in der Größenordnung
weniger Mikro- oder Na no meter profit ieren von den Weiterentw icklungen im Bereich der
hochauflösenden Mikroskopie- Technike n 5 – 7 und insbesondere k ombinierter
Rastersondentechniken 2,8 – 10 , da hier or tsaufgelö ste Messungen von elektrochemisc he n
Oberflächenprozessen ermöglicht werden. D ie K ombinationstechnik von Rasterkraft - und
elektrochemischer Ras tersondenmikroskopie ( atomic force - s cannin g electrochemical
microscopy , AFM -SECM), welche hoch auflösende Abbildungen einer Oberfläche b ei
gleichzeitiger Bestimmung elektrochemischer Ober flächenprozesse vereint, ist ein
Beispiel einer solchen Hybridtechnik . Eine weitere Mikroskopie-Technik stellt die
Kombination aus fokussiertem Ionenstrahl (FIB) und Raster elektronenmikr oskopie (SEM)
dar, die es ermöglicht Proben h insichtlich ihrer mikro - und nanoporösen Strukturen 12,13
zu untersuchen. Dabei erstreckt sich das Anwendungsgebiet d er FIB/SEM Tomographie
von der U ntersuchung v on N anopartikel n, die in Solarzellen genutzt werden 14 , bis hin zu
Untersuchungen von biologischen 15,16 und geologischen 16 Proben.
Der erste Abschnitt der z ugrundeliegenden Arbeit umfasst die Mod ifikat ion von AFM -
SECM Sensoren, die biomedizinisch relevante Untersuchungen ermö glic ht, wie zum
Beispiel d ie Detektion von Wasserstoffperoxid ( H 2 O 2 , Kapit el 4) od er ortsaufgelöste pH
Änderungen (Kapitel 5 ).
In Kapitel 4 wird die elektrochemische Modifikation der elektroaktiven Fläche von AFM-
SECM Spitzen mit Preußisch Blau (PB) gezeigt. Im Gegensatz z u Platinelektroden, die hohe
Oxidationspotentiale (0. 5 – 0.8V vs. NHE 17 ) z ur H 2 O 2 Bestimmung benötigen, kan n mit tels
PB -modifizierten Elektroden unter milden Bedingungen (-0.05 V vs. SH E 18 ) gemessen
werden. Gleichzei tig wur de eine erhöhte Selektivi tät beobachtet 19 . Ein Nacht eil vo n PB ist
die begrenzte Stabilität, besonders b ei hohen H 2 O 2 Konzentrationen, welc he jedoch durch

xiii

zusätzliche Abscheidung von NiHCF 20 verbessert werden kann. Unterschiedliche
Elektrodenmaterialien und M essbedingungen, die während der Herstell ung von AFM -
SECM Sensoren erf orderlich sind, wurden a nhand m odifizierter Ultram ikroelektroden
(UME) untersucht. Neben einer detaillierten Untersuchung und Charakterisierung der
modifizierten Spitzen, wurde die H 2 O 2 Sensitivität und das lineare Ansprec hverhalten der
Sensoren untersucht. Er ste AF M -SECM Messungen vo n lokalisiert erzeugtem Per oxid
werden in Abschnitt 4.3.3 d iskutier t.
In Kapitel 5 wird die Modifikation von AFM -SECM Pr oben mit einem pH Se nsor
präsentiert, d a d ie Änderung d es p H -Wertes sowoh l in Korrosion, ab er auch in
biologischen Zellen eine wichtige Rolle s pielt, um nur zwei Beispiele zu nennen 21,22 .
Unterschiedliche Modifikationen von pH -sensitiven AFM-SECM Spitz en wurden
un tersucht, und zwar Antimon/Antimonoxid 23 , 24 , an odischer Iridiu moxid-Film (AIROF) 25,2 6
und elektrochemisch abgeschiedene Iridiumoxid-Filme (EIROF) 27 als p H-sensitives
Elektrodenmaterial. Dabei wurden d iese untersch iedlichen pH Sens oren auf ihre Stabilität
und Sensitivität in pH Messu ngen untersu cht und verglichen ( 5.3.1 u nd 5.3.3). Erst e
Untersuchungen mittels AFM -SECM werden in Abschn itt 5.3 .2 gezeigt. Dabei wurd en
Calcit-Kristalle abgebild et, d ie beim Lösen in wäss riger Lösung eine lokale pH Än derung zu
basischen pH erzeugen 28,29 .
In Kap itel 6 wird d ie genaue Untersuchung von nano porösen Siliziumnitrid M embranen
dargestellt, die als Supportmaterial für nanoITIES ( na no-interface bet ween two immiscible
electrolyte solu tions ) verwend et wer den 30,31 . U nter anderem w urde A FM -SECM daz u
genutzt, u m das Diffusionsverhalten an diesen nanoporösen St rukturen zu u ntersuchen,
da dieses maßgeblich von dem Verhältnis zwischen dem Porenradius und d em Abstand
zwischen den Poren abhängt ( 6.3.1). Neben dem Einfluss der Herstellungsart dieser
nanoporösen Memb ranen durch FIB, wie in Ab schnitt 6.3.2 gezeigt, wird eine gen au e
Untersuchung der Lage der Grenzf läche von ITIES in diesen N anoporen beschrieben und
anhand der elektrochemisc hen Abschei dung v on Silik apartikeln an der Phasengrenze
zweier nichtmischbaren Flüssigkeiten i nnerhalb des nanoporösen Netz werkes gezeigt
(Abschnitt 6.3.3 u nd 6.3.4) D es Weiteren ermöglicht die genaue Untersuchung der
Nanoporen mittels FIB/SEM Tomographie ei ne R ekonstruktion der por ösen Struktur und
der lokalen Abscheidung der Silika partikel .

- 1 -

Ex pe rim e nt al b a ck gro un d
The following section gives a comprehensive overview o f the theoretic al background,
which is the basis of th e research presented wit hin this thesis: fundamental principles of
electrochemistry at UMEs and at ITIES, AFM, SECM, the comb ination of AFM -SECM and
FIB/SEM tomography.
Fun d am entals in el ec tr oc hem is try
Electrochemistry includes a ll p rocesses related to elect ric re actions that c an be t raced to
chemical p rocesses . In case of potentiometry, no measurable current flow is involved . In
case that the process induces a current flow, one can dist inguish between galvanic or
electrolytic processes . Thereby, galvan ic reactions are sp ontaneous by connecting two
systems by a co nductive media, which is im portant for energy storage and production. If
a reaction is forced by an applied external potential larger than the eigenpot ential of t he
system, it is called electrolytic. In electrolytic cells, different t ypes of rea ctions are p ossible
with t he concordance that ever y syst em s trives for the e quilibrium s tate with minimized
molar free en ergy Δ r G, resulting in the chemical p otential µ i of component i wi thin an
electrochemical process described as 38 :

μ i = μ i 0 + RTlna i

(1)

µ i = ( ∂ G
∂n i ) T,P,n j≠i

(2)

With t he st andard chemical p otential ( μ i 0 ) of component i, the activity of the component
i (a i ), the molar gas constant (R) and the t emperature (T), the pressu re (P) a nd t he amount
of substance (n i ).
The equilibrium is dynamic, which means that both, oxidat ion and reduction, are takin g
place at the same rate i n the e quilibrium state. The chemical po tential leads t o the Nernst
equation, which describes t he Galvani pot ential in equilibrium in dependence of the
activity of the participating compounds. If the Galvani potential difference Δ ϕ is measure d
against the SHE, it can be replaced by the electrod e potential E 39 :

- 2 -

E = E 0 + RT
nF ( ∏ a ox
v
ox
∏ a red
v
red )

(3)

With the number of participating electrons ( n), t he Faraday constant (F), the potential at
standard conditions (E 0 ) and a stoichiometric fact or (v).
To reac h the equilibrium state within a certain t ime ( dt ) , a charge ( dQ ) is tran sferred
within the system resulting in a faradaic current (i) 38 :

𝑖 = 𝑑𝑄
𝑑𝑡

(4)

The Nernst equat ion applies therefore for reversible reactions. Reversible electrochemical
processes are governed b y the concentrations at the surface, by fast electron transfer ,
and lack of additional homogenous reactions in solution of the produced species forming
side p roduct when a reduced sp ecies is oxid ized and vice versa . Whereas for irreversible
reactions, the back reaction is kin etically hindered or ad ditional side p roducts inhibit the
conversion of all redu c ed spec ies back to oxidized species (and vice versa) . Quasi-
reversible reactions are govern ed by kinetic and mass tran sport . The Nernst equation
describes the electroche mical reaction fro m a thermod ynamic p oint of view. I f kinet ic
processes are affecting the elec trochemical reaction, an additional potential, the so-called
overpotential ( η ), has to be applied to overcome the activation en ergy a nd to drive th e
reaction . The Tafel equation describes this ove rpotential in relation to t he decadic
logarithm o f the current and o f the exchang e current, which d escribes th e resulting
faradaic ac tivity in t he equilibrium state with a zero current 38 . The kine tics of a redox
re action can be exp ressed by the standard rate constant k 0 with high values (1 – 10 cm/s) 38
for reactions reaching the equilib rium state in a s hort time. The rate constant is used to
describe the kinetics of the cathodic reaction k catho dic (or anodic as k anodic ) by :

𝑘 𝑐𝑎𝑡ℎ𝑜𝑑𝑖𝑐 = 𝑘 0 ∙ 𝑒 − 𝛼𝑓 ∙(𝐸 −𝐸 0 ′ )

(5)

𝑘 𝑎𝑛𝑜𝑑𝑖𝑐 = 𝑘 0 ∙ 𝑒 (1−𝛼 )𝑓∙(𝐸 − 𝐸 0 ′ )

(6)

- 3 -

E 0 ’ is the formal potential and E the relative e nergy of the electro n participating in the
redox reaction. The Butler-Volmer 40 describes the anodic (i + ) and t he cathodic (i - ) cu rrent
depending on the excha nge current(i 0 ) in dependence of the overpotential by :

i = i + + i − = i 0 [𝑒 − 𝛼𝑓 η − 𝑒 (1−𝛼 )𝑓η ]

(7)

Nonfaradaic c urrent contributions t o the overall recorded cu rrent are based especially on
the growth of a capacitance layer, namely the el ectrical double layer. The double layer
can be d escribed as a capacitor, resu lting in a current flow b y app lying an external voltage.
The curren t i C is described by the differential capacitance (C d ), the potential (E) and time
(t) and is dependent on the electrodes’ surface and the electrolyte solution 39 :

i C = C d ∙ dE
dt

(8)

The do uble laye r co nsists of differe nt regio ns described by the S tern model . This theory
combines the f ormer mo dels of Helmhol tz and of Gouy and C hapman. In close proximity
to the electrode, an oriented ion layer is formed, w hi c h is termed the inner Helmholtz
layer with adsorbed ions on the su rface of the electrodes due to Van der Waals forces ,
and the outer Helmholtz layer with the ions su rrounded by solvent molecules and
described by the Poisson equation 39 :

𝑑 2 𝜑
𝑑 𝑥 2 = − 𝜌
𝜀 𝑟 𝜀 0

(9)

The second derivative of the potential ( ϕ ) to the perpendicular direction to t he electrode
( x) is thereb y dependent on the charge density ( ρ ) and the relative (index r) and ab solute
(index 0) permittivity ( ε ).
The Gouy-Chapman model describes an adjoining diffu se region considering the thermal
motion of the ions near th e electrode surface and includes the presence of counter ions
within the diffusive layer, This layer is described b y the so-called zeta potential, wh ich
drops exponentially with distance 39 .

- 4 -

Potentiometry
Potentiometric mea surements are b ased on t he d etection of changes in th e
eigenpotential of a system due to con centration changes with respect to the p otential of
a reference electrode. This is t he basic principle of ion -selective electrod es (ISE), in which
an inner reference electrode located in an inner electrolyte solution is sepa rated from the
analyte solution b y a semipermeable membrane . Diffusion and exchange of se lective ions
within this membrane leads to a potential difference at the mem brane. The membrane
can be either made of glass, as used in th e p H glass electrode, or by a solid or liquid
crystalline membrane. This membrane is d oped with either charged ions en abling the
detection of analytes of opposite polarity, or with io nophores enabling the sele ctive
interaction of ions. This ionophores with in the membrane can be both, neutral or charged ,
depending on the an alyte species 41 . The potential gradient according t o the exchange of
the analyte ions within this me mbrane is measured via the open circuit potential (OCP)
and is described by the Ner nst equation (1-3). Exemplarily, for detecting p H changes, the
Nernst equation can be re -written as:

𝐸 = 𝐸 0 + 𝑅𝑇
𝑛𝐹 ∙ log (𝑎 𝐻 3 𝑂 + ) → 𝐸 = 𝐸 0 − 59 .2 𝑚𝑉
𝑛 ∙ 𝑝𝐻

(10)

With the gas constant (R), t he temperature (T) , the Faraday constant (F), th e number of
electrons (n) and the activity of H 3 O + ion s (a).
Hence, this approach just represents the p otential in the case of thermodynamic
equilibrium. Diffu sional, kinet ic or migration proce sses are not taken into acc ount . In case,
the solution contains a mixture of ion s, interferences have to b e con sidered. A semi -
empirical exte nsion of the Nernst eq uation for the potential (E) of ISEs is described b y the
Nikolsky-Eisenman equation 41 .

𝐸 = 𝐸 𝑖 0 + 𝑅𝑇
𝑧 𝑖 𝐹 ∙ ln (𝑎 𝑖 + ∑ 𝑘 𝑖𝑗
𝑝𝑜𝑡 ∙ 𝑎 𝑗 𝑧 𝑖 /𝑧 𝑗
𝑖 ≠𝑗 )

(11)

With the constant potential ( 𝐸 𝑖 0 ), ion charge (z), gas const ant (R), temperature (T), Far aday
constant (F), activity a and the selectivi ty constant ( 𝑘 𝑖𝑗
𝑝𝑜𝑡 ) for two ions i and j. Th e

- 5 -

interfering ion contributi ng to the measure d potential is represented by the index j. The
equation is b ased on the equilibrium state and an y kinetic effects of ion transfer are
neglected. An extension to t he general assumption of the equilibrium state is given by the
diffusion-layer-model, which takes into account the steady -state and local equilibrium
conditions at the mem brane surface. T he diffusi on and the ion concentrati on a t or within
the membrane are thereby time dependent. Th e most det ailed description of
potentiometric measurements is given by an advanced non - equilibrium model
considering both, variations i n time and in distance. Th is mo del is based on the Nernst -
Planck equation, describing the ion flux dependent on time and space and the Poisson
equation, defining the c urrent density 42 . The graphs in Figure 1 re present the potentials
described by the N ernst-Planck and Poisson (NPP) mod el (Figu re 1 A) in comparison to th e
phase b oundary model ( Figure 1 B), which is a classical mod el assuming eq uilib rium
conditions a nd n eglecting migration and kin etic effects. Th e variation in th e membrane
potential changes in the ran ge of mV for th e NPP model com pared to the p hase boundary
model (B).

Schemes o f the tim e- and sp ace-depend ent p otentials de scribed by the NPP model (A) and
compared to the classical phase bo undary model (B). The membrane poten tial in (A ) is defin ed
as the integral over th e distance between a point in t he bulk solution x b,L and a p oint in th e
internal s olution x b ,R at different times: 4 x 10 -4 s (a), 1.64 s (b), 13.1 s (c), 26.2 s (d), 104.8 s (e),
420 s (f) an d at stead y-stat e co nditions (13440 s, g). 42 Reprint ed with per mission from Boba cka,
J., Ivaska, A. L ewenstam, A. Chem. Rev. 2 008 , 108 , 329- 351 . Copyright 20 19 Amer ican
Chemical Soci ety. htt ps://doi.org/10.10 21/cr0681 00w .

- 6 -

ISEs are used for the detection of a large variet y of ions, as a sta ndard an alytical method
in water analysis or f ood contro l, and are also us ed f or characterization o f ph armaceutical
or biological samples 43 . Th e most used ISE is for the determination of pH using a
hydronium- sensi tive glass elect rode developed ove r a century ago and based on the
exchange of ion s within the glass as the semipermeable membrane 44 . Next to ion-
selective e lectrodes, ion -selective sensing can be performed with soli d -state e lectrodes,
such as conductive polymers, metals or ion -sensitive field-effect t ransistors (ISFETs). This
is especially favor able for miniaturized sensors. The capab ility of p H sensing using metals
as solid electrode materials is based on the equilibrium between the metal and its oxide,
or be tween two oxid ation states of the me tal/material. A variation in pH leads to changes
in th e equilibrium state and, ther efore, to a change in the eigenp otential of the material.
Thereby, the composition of the metal and its oxide (or of two different oxid es) varies
leading to a n electron t ransfer towards t h e elec trode and th e d etection of t he cha nged
pH value by the electronic setup. Because there i s a limited amount of the metal and its
oxide (or of both metaloxides), especially f or miniaturized se nsors, also the capaci tance
of t he material is reduced. Th i s results i n a hig her material resistance, which affect s the
potential stability in potentiometric measurements 42 . Competing site-reac tions may lead
to false interpretations or to p otential d rifts d uring the measurements . Many met al/metal
oxides can be used for pH sensing, wherea s stability and/or linearity vary dep endent on
the different met al/met al oxid es, conditions, and comp lexity of sample mixtures 45,46 .
Suitable me tal/metal oxides have to be stable in solut ion, but also soluble enough that
the ratio of metal and corresponding oxide may vary t o achieve equilibrium depen ding on
pH changes. The pH response h as to be fast, just depending on the diffu sion of the H 3 O +
ions towards the p H sensor, and reproducible over a wide pH range. Response times
determined by a n electr ochemical time- of -flight technique were up t o a tenth o f seconds
for AIROF 25,26 electrodes, dependent on the film thickness 47 . Dep endent on the underlying
redox reaction of the pH -sensitive materials, the sensitivity varies as shown in Table 1 for
a selection of metal/metal oxides. The u nderlying red ox pro cess during pH detection is
shown exemplarily for the AIROF and the antimony/ antimony oxide electrode 23 , 24 , which
were used in experiments p resented within this thesis. Th e potential d etermining
equilibrium for the AIROF and the antimony electrode may be written as f ollows:

- 7 -

2 Ir O 2 ( 0H ) (2−𝑥) (𝐻 2 𝑂 ) (2+𝑥 )
( 2−𝑥 ) − + ( 3 − 2x ) H + + 2e − ↔ Ir 2 O 3 ( OH ) 3 ( H 2 0 ) 3
3− + 3 H 2 O
Sb 2 O 3 + 6 H + + 6 e − ↔ 2 Sb + 3 H 2 O

metal/metal oxide or metal oxides as
pH sensor

pH response

pH range

monocrystalline Sb/ SbO 2

52 mV/pH

pH 2- 10

Ir/IrO 2

63 mV/pH

pH 2-9

Pd/PdO (th ermal)

59.6 mV/pH

pH 2.5 – 8.5

Pd/PdO (electro chemical)

71.4 mV/pH

pH 3 - 8 48

AIROF (electro chemical)

65 – 80 mV/pH

pH 2.5 – 8.5

AIROF (thermal)

59 mV/pH

pH 2 - 12 49

AIROF (sputt ered)

59.5 mV/pH

pH 2 – 8.5

PtO 2

46.7 mV/pH

pH 5 – 10

RuO 2

61.8 mV/pH

pH 2 – 12

RhO 2 x H 2 O

62.8 mV/pH

pH 2 – 12

OsO 2 x H 2 O

51.2 mV/pH

pH 2 – 11

Table 1 pH response and linear p H range for some metal/metal oxi des suitable as p H sensors 45 .
Different fabrication strategies have b een reported with respect to crystallograp hic
properties 50 – 52 , stability 53 , and efficiency in p H sensing 54 , 55 . Especially, t he response of
iridium oxide electrodes varies depending on the f abrication process, namely, the
sputtered iridium oxide film (SIROF) 56 , 57 , thermal oxidation of Ir salts (TOIROF) 58 , 59 or

- 8 -

electrochemically deposited films like EIROF 27 , and AIR OF 60 – 62 . The slo pe for t he pH
response for AIROF elect rodes can also be exp ressed b y 59· (3 - 2x)/2 mV/pH 45 .
Additionally, the infl uence of oxidation state 27 and of t he substrate f or the pH -sensitive
film with respect to stabi lity 63 has been investigated. All pH sensors have to be calibrate d
prior to usage.

Diffusion-limited currents at UMEs
In voltammetric measurements, the faradaic current related to a redox reaction is
recorded. The cur rent si gnal is infl uenced by transport processes in the electrolytic cell,
namely diffusion, migr ation and convection. In a system w ith n o additional steering and
no temperatur e or density gradient, convection c an be neglected. In elect rolyte solution
with h igh electrolyte concentrations in the range of 0.1 – 1 M, the migration of charged
particles from the bulk so lution to the ele ctrode surface is most ly suppresse d and can also
be neglected because the electrolyte ions are carrying 97 % of the current in bulk
so lution 38 . In case of fast ele ctron transfer kinetics, the faradaic current can then be
described by the diffusion processes towards t he electrode’s surface. The diffusion-
limited current I(t) is desc ribed for a spherical el ectrode by a semi-infinite approach via
the Cottrell equation 38 :

𝐼 ( 𝑡 ) = 𝑛𝐹𝐴 √ 𝐷 0 𝑐 0 ∗
√ 𝜋𝑡 + 𝑛𝐹𝐴𝐷 0 𝑐 0 ∗
𝑟 0

(12)

Thereby, the current consists of a time -d ependent and a time- independent term,
respectively, defined by the elec trode area (A) a nd radius (r 0 ), Faraday constant (F) , the
number of ele ctrons (n), t he b ulk con centration (c 0 *) and diffusion coefficient (D 0 ) of the
electroactive species (labelled with the index 0). In case, the diffusion layer, which is
rather a region than a la yer, is much smaller than the electrode area , the current signal
becomes time -dependent. In the case of ult ramicroelectrodes def ine d by t he c ritical
radius of 25 µm 38 , t his relation c hanges a nd the d iffusion layer is i n the same d imension
or even larger t han the e lectrode size. The c urrent signal becomes time-indep endent an d
is termed steady-state current I ss 38 :

- 9 -

𝐼 𝑠𝑠 = 𝑛𝐹𝐴𝐷 0 𝑐 0 ∗
𝑟 0

(13)

At short time scales, however, the time-depending term cannot b e neglected. Calculated
by Shoup and Szabo 64 , the t ime-dependence can b e expressed f or a planar d isk
microelectrode as:

𝑓 ( 𝜏 ) = 0. 7854 + 0. 8862 𝜏 − 1 2
⁄ + 0 . 2146 𝑒 (−0. 7823 𝜏 − 1 2
⁄ )

(14)

With τ as a dimensionless variable for the time defined as

𝜏 = 4𝐷 0 𝑡
𝑟 0 2

(15)

According to equation ( 15 ), the time dependenc e is strongly related to the size of the
electrode and results either in a li near or radial di ffusion. For U MEs, the diffusion is linear
to the surface within nano- to microseconds, but this merges within milliseconds into a
radial diffusion and a resultin g steady-state current. Due to this fast response at UMEs,
fast electrochemical processes can be investiga ted under steady- state conditions.

Surface and geometry of UMEs
The current response dep ends o n the electrode’s geometry an d surface rou ghness ,
defined by the relati on b etween t he microsco pic area (A m ) and the geo metric area (A g ),
which can b e interpreted as t he pro jection of the surface boundary . For polished
electrodes, the surface roughness is low, with 38 :

2 − 3 > 𝐴 𝑚
𝐴 𝑔

(16)

In case that the diffusion layer is larger than th e actual electrode size , which is th e case
for t ime scales above some seconds at UMEs, just the so-called geometric area of the
surface is relevant. In case that the roughness is within the dimension of the diffu si on

- 10 -

field, which is the case for fast time scales (nano or milliseconds) or unpolished surfaces,
the ac tual electrode are a is relevant . Clearly apparent from equation (1 2) and (13), the
current is related to the area A of the electrode and d ifferent geometr ies, such as f rame ,
disk, band , cylindrical, or con ical electrodes re sult in different current respon ses 65 . An
overview of the steady-state current re sponses with respect t o the geometrical parameter
is summarized in Table 2.

electrode geometry

steady-state current 66

disc microelectrode

I ss = 4nFaDc 0 ∗

(17)

ring microelectrode

I ss = nF l o Dc 0 ∗
with l 0 = [ π 2 ( b + c ) ]
ln [ 16 ( b + c ) / ( c − b ) ] , c b < 1. 25

(18)

conical microelectrode

I ss = 4nFDc 0 a ( 1 + qH p )
with H = h/a, q = 0.3661 and p = 1.14466

(19)

Table 2 Overvi ew o f the steady- state current at nano/micro -el ectrodes with respect to differ ent
electrode geo metries.
For SECM mea surements (see section 2.2), which allows mapping of local heterogeneity
of electrochemical properties, the d imensions of the in sulating sh eath of the UME are
crucial, b ecause the c urrent flow , when the UME is in close proximity to t he sample
surface, is not on ly influenced by the n ature of th e sample but also by th e insulating
sheath of the UME . An optimal ratio (RG value) of t he radius of the electrode (r UME ) and
the insulating sheath (r insulating sh eath ) was derived from numerical simulations 67 as

10 ≥ 𝑟 𝑖𝑛𝑠 𝑢𝑙𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑠ℎ𝑒𝑎𝑡ℎ
𝑟 𝑈𝑀 𝐸

(20)

Electrochemistry at the ITIES
Besides electrochemistry at the interface between a solid electrode and a liquid
electrolyte solution, a polarized interface between two immiscible electr olyte solutions
(ITIES) is highly int erestin g for ele c troanalysis . Th ereby, electrochemical processes within
the liquid/liquid system are described by different mechanisms, summariz ed in Figure 2.

- 11 -

Scheme of different electroch emical ly induced pro cesses at ITIE S : electron transfer by two
redox reactions in both phases (I), ion tran sfer (II) an d facili tated ion tran sfer in the presence
of a ligand molecul e in one o f the phases (III).
The charge transfe r at ITIES can be b ased on elec tron transfer, but als o on ion transfer,
which can be either a direct tran sfer of a molecule soluble in b oth phases or a facilitated
transfer in the presence of a ligand molecule in o ne of the phases. The fac ilitated tra nsfer
can be grouped into different types of tran sfer, as summar ized in Table 3.

types of
facilitated
ion transfer

ACT – aqueous
complexation
followed by transfer

TIC – transfer by
interfacial
complexation

TID – transfer by
interfacial
decomplexation

TOC – transfer
followed by organic -
phase complexatio n

schemes

Table 3 Overvi ew of facilitated ion t ranspo rt 68 .
Additionally, adsorption an d desorption processes at the interface can be analyzed b y
impedance measurements and el ectrocapillary curves. Thereby, the k inetics of layer
formation can be investigated, and new materials can be formed at a d efect-free interface
between two liquids. The ther modynamics of char ge transfer at the li quid/liquid interface
are described by the Nernst equation like in the case of a liquid/solid interface (see
equations 1-3) a nd t he Galvani potential of the transfer can be describe d by the solvation
potentials in the aqueous and the organic phase, respectively . For the electron transfer,
two redox reaction s, one in ea ch liquid , are taking place at the same time . In most cases,
the charge transfer is coupled with mu ltiple reactions and additional transfer due to
charge b alance within t he system has to be taken int o account . The current is expressed
by the Butler- Vol m er equation (see equation 7) with the f lux of ch arge J i or J el , whic h is

- 12 -

described by first -order kinetics in case of ion transfer and b y second -order kinetics for
electron t ransfer at ITIES. The kinetics of the transf er can be expresse d by t he rat e
constants of the forw ard (k f ) and backward (k b ) transfer of an ion i w ith a c oncentration c i
as 69

𝐽 𝑖 = 𝑘 𝑓 𝑐 𝑖 ( 𝑤 ) − 𝑘 𝑏 𝑐 𝑖 (𝑜)

(21)

𝐽 𝑒𝑙 = 𝑘 𝑓 𝑐 𝑅1 ( 𝑤 ) 𝑐 𝑂2 ( 𝑜 ) − 𝑘 𝑏 𝑐 𝑂1 (𝑤 )𝑐 𝑅2 ( 𝑜)

(22)

The indices R and O in equation ( 22 ) re present the reduced and oxidiz ed species in the
water and organic phase, respectively . T he c urrent with in t he liquid/liquid system is
defined as positive with t he t ransport of a p ositive charge f rom the water to t he organic
phase, and vice versa 69 .

The interface between tw o liquids
Compared t o electrochemistry at a solid/ liquid interface, for which the charge distribution
is described by t he electrical double layer at the compact interface of a solid electrode ,
the interface bet ween two liquids can be interpret ed as two mirrored, diffusive layers, the
so -called back- to - back doub le la yer, each of them facing one of the electrolyte solutions.
The two diffusive layers can be described b y the Gouy- Chapman model . The charge
distribution at the liquid/liquid interface is described by the modified Verwey-Niessen
model 70 , whereas in early publications, both d iffusive layers are se parated by a compa ct
inner layer similar t o the inner Helmholtz layer with a negligible potential d rop 71 . An
extension t o firs t assumpt ions was the description of t his inner laye r as a sandwich
structure of alt ernating solvent mol ecules fro m the aqueous and organic phase,
respectively 72 , or as a mixtu re of b oth solvents 73 , 74 . Girault and Schiffrin des cribed
additionally inter facial io n pairs of both electrolyt es as a k ind of specific ad sorpt ion at the
interface 75 . The potentia l d ifference ( ∆ 𝑜
𝑤 𝜙) at the i nterface can b e expressed as the sum
of the se th ree layers, t he interfacial potential drop within the inner layer ( Δ 𝑜
𝑤 𝜙 𝑖𝑛 ) and the
potential of the diffusive layers 𝜙 2 in both phases as 69 :

∆ 𝑜
𝑤 𝜙 = Δ 𝑜
𝑤 𝜙 𝑖𝑛 + 𝜙 2 𝑜 − 𝜙 2 𝑤

(23)

- 13 -

Electrochemistry at ITIES
For electrochemical experiments at liquid/liquid interfaces, four electrodes are necessary,
where one counter (C E) and one refere nce electrode (R E) ar e placed in each elect rolyte
solution ( SY as organ ic and RX as aqueous electrolyte), respectively. For miniaturized
electrochemical interfaces, the detected current is low (in the ran ge of pA to nA) and a
two electrode setup ca n be used, w ith one re ference electr ode in eac h phase. The
polarized interface itself acts as the working el ectrode w ithin the non-polarizable syste m.
The electrochemical cell is expressed by the following notation 69 :

For the detection of standard potentials of a redox couple u sing a conventional three -
electrode system, only the potential of the referen ce elect rod e h as t o b e taken into
account. In liquid /liqui d interface measurements, t he potentials of b oth reference
electrodes, as well as the potential at the second liqu id/liqui d inter face (represented as
SX(w´)|SY(o´) in the notation , marked in b lue) necessary for the referenc e electrode of
the organic p hase solution, are influencing the overall potenti al and t he standard
potential of the ion/electron transfer. The cell potential (E cell ) can be d escribed as the
difference between the p otentials at the referen ce electrode in the aqueous phase (E aq )
and in the organic phase (E org ) 69 :

𝐸 𝑐𝑒𝑙𝑙 = 𝐸 𝑜𝑟 𝑔 − 𝐸 𝑎𝑞 = ∆ 𝜙
𝑜
𝑤 − Δ 𝜙
𝑜´
𝑤´ + 𝐸 𝑗

(24)

The term (Δ 𝜙
𝑜´
𝑤´ + 𝐸 𝑗 ) represents the potential difference a t the interface of the organic
electrolyte solution and th e reference electrode of the organic ph ase with an aqueous
reference solution. An aqueous (quasi- ) reference electrode is used in most cases, due to
the limited numb er of available non-aqueous reference elec trodes . Th e referen ce
electrode of the organic ph ase can be considered as an ion-sele ctive-type electrode with
the liquid junction (E j ) at the interface between the reference electrode (aq) and the

- 14 -

organic electrolyte soluti on. The potential window is d efined or limited b y the transfer of
the electrolyte ions. In the electrochemical cell given above, the limit at positive potentials
is the transfer of the R + ion from the aqueous to the organic electroly te solu tion or the
transfer of th e Y - ion f rom the or ganic to the aqueous solution. The limit at negative
potentials is vice versa, the posit ive ion (S + ) of t he organic electrolyte solution is
transferred to the aqueous phase or the X - (aq) ion to the organ ic electrolyte solution.
Similar to the standard hydrogen ele ctrode, the organic ele ctrolyte tetraphenylarsonium
tetraphenylborate (TATB) is defined as the zero potential 69 by

∆ 𝑜
𝑤 𝜙 = 0

(25)

within the system, which is used to determine the half-wave potential of an analyte. Th e
center of th e current-p otential curve is defined as zero, because the ion size, the d iffusion
coefficients in water and the potential for the tra nsfer to wards the aqueous solution are
equal for TA + and TB - (or at lea st very similar that they can be assumed to be equal). This
is also called th e TATB assumption 76 . Hence, adsorption p henomena at the interface , the
energy of t he transfer back to the organic solvent or the solvat ion of t he ion s in both
phases ar e not taken into account in the TATB assumption 77 .

Electrochemistry at nano-interfac es
Electrochemistry at

micro- and nanometer -sized interfaces using nanopipettes 78,79 and
solid-state s upports s uch as membranes 80 – 86 is a promising tool for analy tical applications
as the miniaturizatio n of interfaces resu lts in an enhance d signal sho wing increased
charge and mass transfer compared to any macroscopic app roach, which is also th e case
for electr ochemical rea ctions at the ITIES 11 . Additionally, mi niaturization reduce s the
ohmic d rop and leads to a reduced capacitive current 87,88 . With n anoporou s arrays, a la rge
number of single interfaces can be achie ved , leading to an enlarged ele ctroc hemical signal
by multiple interfaces. A d etailed u nderstanding of the kinetics of ion tra nsport can be
investigated at small scale interfaces, which was reported first b y the groups of Girault 89,9 0
and Mirkin 78 , and for ele ctron transport by Bard and co -workers 91 . Th e d iffusional
behavior at micro- and nanopores or -pipettes depends on the location of the interface

- 15 -

(see Figu re 3) resulting i n either a linear diffusion profile within the pore or pipette, or in
a rad ial d iffusion at the orifice of th e pore/pipette 92 , 93 . For ITIES, d iffusion occurs in b oth
directions fro m the interface f acing the aqueous and the organic electrolyte,
respectively 68 .

Scheme o f thre e d ifferent po res with interfac es (marke d in red) located a t different position s
within the pores, namely inlaid and recessed f or pores with parallel pore walls, and a recessed
interface for a tru ncated con e-shaped geo metry.
The c urrent I i at micro- and nano- ITIES for the transfer of an ion i is described by the
modified Cottrell equation (see equ ation 13) for radial diffusion towards an in laid
interface located at a pore/pipette ori fice with radius r o 94 :

𝐼 𝑖 = 4𝑛𝐹𝐷 𝑐 𝑖 𝑟 𝑜

(26)

With th e bulk concentration of the ion i (c i ), the Faraday con stant (F), the di ffusion
coefficient (D) and the number of participating electrons (n). Fo r a re cess ed in terface a t
the p osition (L) withi n the pore (which can b e also seen as t he len gth of the pore/pipe tte),
the limiting current is desc ribed by 94

𝐼 𝑖 = 4𝜋𝑛𝐹𝐷 𝑐 𝑖 𝑟 𝑜 2
4𝐿 + 𝜋 𝑟 𝑜

(27)

For a truncated cone- shaped pore or pipette, both radii of the orif ices have to b e
considered with r o < r L resulting in the following equation 37 .

𝐼 𝑖 = 4𝜋𝑛𝐹𝐷 𝑐 𝑖 𝑟 𝑜 𝑟 𝐿
4𝐿 + 𝜋 𝑟 𝑜

(28)

- 16 -

Single pores w ithin a soli d material can be arrang ed either ordered w ithin an arra y with
defined distances b etween single pores or randomly distributed in an ensemble 82 . The
distance or pore- to -pore separation influe nces the diffusion p rofiles of the
array /ensemble, resulting in either overlapped d iffusion regions for pore s in close
proximity t o each other (see Figure 4 A) , or in i ndividual diffusion at each pore (see Figure
4 B) 30 .

Influence of the p ore- to -por e separation ratio within a pore ar ray . For closely arranged pore s
as shown in the SEM image in A, the radial di ffusion at a single pore results in an over laid
diffusion profile for th e overall array as schematically repre sented be low. Whereas for a large
pore- to -pore separation as shown in the SEM image in B , the diffusion profiles are not
overlapping an d in dividual hemispherical diffu sion at the pores , as indicated in th e
corresponding sch emes, i s governing th e overall r esponse.
Numerical simu lations compared to experimentally ob tained cyclic voltammograms at
nano-ITIES within pores 95,96 or por e arrays 97 – 99 we re u sed to localize t he interfaces . Also,
simulations were performed to identify individual radial diffusion at the pores with
determining a separation ratio between the pore radius ( r a ) and the distance b etween
single nanopores (r c ) 97,100 with a critical value for individual diffusion of 30 :

𝑟 𝑐
𝑟 𝑎 > 56 .

(29)

- 17 -

Sc ann in g pr ob e te ch niq u es
Atomic force microscopy
Since the introduction in 1986 by Binnig, Quate , and Gerbe r 101 , AFM d eveloped into an
important too l in surface character ization, ran gin g from material science to biology 102 . In
AFM , the force interaction between a surface and a sharp tip located at the end of a
cantilever is d etected. These for ces can be described by the Lennard -Jones potential and
can be divided i nto a ttractive or re pulsive forces. Th e electric doubl e layer in teractions or
interactions r esulting from ove rlapping atomic orbitals are repulsive, whe reas cap illary,
electrostatic and Van der Waals forces are attractive. Other for ces such as chemical,
hydrophobic, s teric or m agnetic forces may b e attractive or repulsive. The tip is l ocated a t
the end of a flexible cantilever, typically made of silicon nitride or Si . The AFM tip ca n be
additionally modified wit h e.g. nano tubes 103 , nanowires 104 , microneedles 10 5 , coll oids 106 or
single mo lecules 107 for imaging high aspect rat io features or for single -molecule force
spectroscopy experiments . Critical for AFM pro bes is t heir r esonance f requency ( f 0 ),
spring constant ( k ) and the quality factor ( Q ), which should be chosen carefully in respec t
to the targeted application and investigated sample, re spectively. The parameters
describe the stiff ness of the AFM ca ntilever a nd with this the ability to react on external
forces. With high reso nance fr equencies in the ra nge of 1 – 500 k Hz and with small spring
constants (0.07 - 100 N/m), forces of 10 -6 to 10 - 12 N can be measure d, without issues that
the cantilever is influenced by external vibrations. Different operation modes are available
with respect to the ch aracteristics of the substrate under investigation. The contact m ode
is preferably used for hard surfaces d ue to strong force interaction between tip and
substrate. The surface can be sca nned i n eithe r constant height or constant force mode
(also called top ographical mode) . The t ip is either kept in a defined p osition in the z-axis,
recording t he variations in force, or a defined force is kept constant and th e height is
adjusted when the force in teraction between tip and sam ple varies while scann ing in x ,y
-direction. In the d ynamic mod e, the tip oscillates in a defined distance above t he surface.
This mode can be either f requ ency-modulated or amplitude -modulated 108 . For the
investigation of soft samples, the tapping mode 109 (or intermittent mode) is used that
results f rom the amplitude-modulated mode but ad ditionally st rikes the sample surface

- 18 -

on every oscillation 109 . Th e tip is oscillating close t o its resonance frequency and the
change in the amplitude due to tip -sample intera ction is detec ted. Additionally, a phase
shift indicates a varyin g adhesio n or viscosity of the surface mat erial. In all operation
modes, the interaction results in a bending of the cantilever, which is det ected - in most
cases - via a laser focused at the back side o f the ca ntilever and re flected to a split
photodiode. The de tected photocurrent signal is the n converted in to an output volt age,
which is used via a n electronic feedback sy stem to maintai n a fixed force, or am plitude or
resonance frequency of the AFM probe by the z-piezo when the cantilever is b ent due to
the force interactions. Du e to these interactions, t he topography of a samp le can be
mapped and additional information about mechanical properties of t he sample can be
obtained and different mater ials c an b e dist ing uished due to varying adhesion be tween
the tip and the sample surf ace.

Scheme of an AFM prob e in front and side view (A ) ; th e dete ction of th e d eflection and frict ion
signal in AFM conta ct mode with corresponding s ignals shown as p rofile (B-D). Th e AFM probes
in (C-D) labeled with 1 -3 sho w the AFM p robe at three d i fferent positions r epresentin g th e
movement of the tip in the scan direction.

- 19 -

AFM measurements can be performed in air, liqui d and under vacu um condition, wherea s
the latter is m ost se nsitive an d atomic res olution can b e achieved under optimized
conditions 110 . Tip artifacts, as shown in Figure 6, c an be minimized or avoided by suit able
experimental co nditions and a careful a djustment of scan parameters. Nevertheless, the
results have to be interpreted carefully. So far, a variety of advanced AFM modes were
developed e.g., p eak force t apping TM AFM 111 gaining additional information on adhesion,
and Young mo dulus, force volume mode 112 , enabling the mapping o f in teractive forces by
recording a se t of f orce curves, scanning Kelvin probe microscopy 113 recording the contact
potential difference between the tip and a surface, and esp ecially AF M -SECM, which is
discussed in detail in 2.3 .

Scheme of possible artifacts i n AFM me asure ments. The topograp hy image may reflect the
shape of the AFM tip, in case t hat the structure of the sample has smaller dimensions than the
tip (A), edges might b e also imaged not correctly (B) . Con taminated AFM p robes may re sult in
double or multip le imaging of the actu al s ample structure (C ). The dis played tips in A- C
represents one tip at different times moving in the scan d irection.

- 20 -

Scanning electrochemical microscopy
In SECM, which was first report ed in 19 89 by Bard and coworkers 1 14 , a n ano- or
microelectrode is scanned across a sample su rface of interest mapp ing local
electrochemical processes . SECM c an b e a pplied in many fields res earch f ields i ncluding
life sciences 115 or corrosion studies 116 , and investigations of amperometric,
potentiometric or conductive sign als at homogeneous and heterogeneous samp les can be
monitored 117 . A comprehensive description of SECM instrumentation, SECM tips , and
applications in various f ields is given elsewhere 117 . Briefly summarized, the posit ioning
and movement of th e SECM tip is re alized - in most cases – by st epper mo tors and
piezoelectric d evices. A thre e- or f our-electrode set-up is used consisting of the scann ing
UME as working electrode , a counter , and a reference electrode and if req uired, t he
substrate as the seco nd working electrode . In a first s tep, t he SECM tip is brought in close
proximity to the s ubstrate ’ s surface, which is realized by recording a pproach curves
(Figure 7 A, B). In t he presence of a redox active species with fast electron t ransfer
characteristic, the c urrent is measured at the ti p, which is b iased at the req uired potential
while approaching to the surface. In bulk solution, the conversion of the redox active
species results in a steady-state current signal. When the tip is in a distance of several radii
of t he electroactive radius of t he SECM tip to the surface, th e current signal is influenced
depending on the nature of the substrate. At insulating su bstrates, the current d ecreases
due to hindered d iffusion of t he redox mediat or to the SECM tip, which is termed
‘ negative feed back ’ . In t he p resence of a conductive s ubstrate, th e converted red ox
species can be regenerated a t the sam ple s urface resulting in an increased current signal,
called ‘ positive feedback ’ . To d etermine the distance between the SECM tip and t he
surface, the resulting approach curves are compared to theoretical curves obtained via
numerical simulation. While imaging, t he distance between tip and substrate plays a
crucial role. For relatively flat sam ples, the scan ning can be performed i n c onstant height ,
whereas for rough surfaces (influence of r oughness corre sponds t o the size of the SECM
tip), approaches have been introduced to keep a constant distance between the sample
and the SECM tip (Figur e 7 D) . Th is can be realiz ed by applying a hor izontal vibration to
the SECM t ip, which results in damping in the oscillation with varying dist ances. This
damping can be mea sur ed either by optical 118 or piezoelectric detectors 119 as published
by Schuhmann and co -work ers, or by t he integration of a tuning fork, as presented by

- 21 -

James et al. 120 . The damping is used as the signal for a f eedback l oop to k eep the distance
constant – this mode is adapted from scanning ne arfield microscopy (SNOM) and t ermed
shear force mode. A constant distance can b e fu rther detected in the constant current 12 1
or con stant impedance mod e 122 . A similar approach k eeping the electrode area in a
defined distance is given by SECM with soft - stylus p robes 123 , w hereas the insulating
material is in contact with the samp le surface. T he SECM tip is bent due to the f lexible
insulating material. Next to different positioning modes, the imaging of a sample can be
also divided into di fferent modes. In the generation/collection mode 124 , the
electrochemical species is generated a t t he SECM t ip and then detected at the substrate’s
surface or vice versa (Figure 7 C). A variat ion of the generatio n/collection mode is th e
redox competition mode 125 , in which the same ele ctrochemical reaction is detected by
both, SECM tip and substrate.

Schemes of different op eration modes u sed in SECM : The feedback mod e (A) with
corresponding approach curves (B), tip generation/ substrate collection (TG/SC) and s ubstra te
generation/ tip collection (S G/TC) mode (C) and mod es related to the detection in either
constant d istance or constant h eight (D).

- 22 -

In the so-called direct mode 126 , the a pplied potential between the tip and a substrate c an
be used for localized modification of the sa mple, by deposition 126 or by generating
localized pit corrosion 127 . SECM has also b een combined with a nu mb er of analytical
methods, e.g. optical microscopy 128 , IR sp ectroscopy 129 , surface p lasmon resonance 130 ,
and o ther sc anning probe techniques. For example, b y replacing t he S ECM ele ctrode with
a micropipette, which is known as scanning ion conductance microscopy (SICM) , the
conductance between a reference electrode located in an ele ctrolyte solution within the
pipette an d t he re ference electrode i n the bath solution is d etected 131 . SI CM is frequently
used to map the topography of soft samples given a non- invasive approac h. By combining
bo th SE CM and SICM, the topographical information detected by SICM can be directly
correlated to electroc hemical processes at the sample surface detect ed by SECM. A
miniaturized el ectrode can be ei ther integrated into the pipette as a ring electrode
surrounding t he ori fice of t he pipette or in a double (or multi ple) cha nnel arrangement,
using o ne barrel of the p ipette filled with ele ctroly te sol ution for SICM and another barrel
filled with the electrode mater ial for SECM (Figure 8 A ). The comb ina tion with AFM is
described in detail in the followi ng section.

Scheme of co mbined SECM/ SICM tips w ith varyin g geometries ( A ); th e black area show s th e
electrode material, scheme for the diff erent imaging principles (B): the SECM ring-electro de is
detecting electroche mical processes, wher eas the cond uctance between two re ference
electrodes (ind icated as green dots) is used to d etermine th e top ography. A. Holzinger, C.
Steinbach, C. Kranz, „Chapter 4: Scannin g E lectroche mical Microscopy (SECM) : Fun damenta ls
and App lications in Life Sciences“, in Electroch emical Str ategies in Detection Science (Ed .
Damien W. M. Arri gan), RSC Detection Science, 201 5. Adapte d from Ref. 115 with permission
from the Royal Society o f Chemistry. http s://doi.org/1 0.1039/97817826 22529 -00125 .

- 23 -

AFM-SECM
First publish ed by Macpherson and Unwin in 2000 132 , the combination of AFM and SECM
enables imaging of high-resolution topography and ele ctrochemical processes by
detection of force interaction between a conical tip and a surface ( AFM) and the
electrochemical signal related t o surface pro perties (SECM) . Wherea s in this publication,
a cantilever-sh aped conical electrode served as the AFM tip and simulta neously as the
SECM electrode, the independent detection of an electro c hemical signal by a recessed
AFM tip-integrated electrode was f irst realized by Kranz et al. 133 . First imaging of soft
biological sam ples w as re ported for the i nvestigations of th e activity of glucose oxidase 134
or horseradish peroxidase 135 by AFM in tapping or contact mo de, respectively, and SECM
generation/collection m ode. Modi fication o f AF M -SECM probes by im mobilization o f
redox media tors, n amely, tip-attached redox med iator (TARM)- AFM-SECM 136 and
investigation of immobilized macromolecules or DNA in the so -called molecule touching
(Mt)/AFM-SECM 137 was s hown by D emaille and co-workers. For example, the detection o f
proteins by measurements in AF M tapping mode and SECM feedback mode w ith a latera l
resolution in t he topography of a few 10 0 nm 138 was re ported. Th e immobilization of DNA
sensors to AFM/SECM pro bes was also realized by modification of the tip -integrated
electrode with polypyrrole 139 . Further in vestigations of biolo gical samp les were reali ze d
by Hirata et al. 140 , mapping glu cose oxidase immobilized on highly oriented pyrolytic
graphite (HOPG) in tapping mode, and by Kranz and co -workers with the localiz e d
mapping of enzymatic c onsumption of glucose b y det ection of H 2 O 2 wit h a horseradish
peroxidase-modified AF M-SECM probe i n AFM contact mode 141 . Besides investigations of
biological samples, AFM -SECM can be used for visualizing corro sion processes and the
electrochemical behavior of metal compositions. Macpherson a nd co -workers
investigated the beh avio r of me tal an odes by AFM -SECM 142 and Davoodi et al. detected
active pitting and local corrosion of mixed Al alloys by an L-shaped AFM tip with an
integrated Pt wire as SECM electrode 143 – 145 . The localiz ed corrosio n of copper in acidic
solution was rep orted by Izquierdo et al. 146,147 . The dissolution of calcite was detected by
AFM -SECM 148 , whereby t he tip-integrated Pt electrode w as used for water oxida tion by
an applied anodic potential and afterward used for detecting pits w ithin t he calcite in the
acidic region by t he generated protons. Inve stigations of diffusional transport at

- 24 -

nanopores b y AFM-SECM was reported for the t ransport of glucose 149 , of redox-active
species 150 , as well as for electrode arrays within c losely-sp aced microdiscs 150,15 1 .

Overview on different AFM -S ECM p robe geometries: Schemes of a han d-made AFM-SECM
probe with a conical microelectrod e with a sph erical apex 15 2 (A ); batch -fabricated AFM -SECM
probe with a triangular, conductive AFM tip 153 (E) and commercial AFM probe modified by a
conductive lay er cond uctive BDD layer and insulated, follow ed by the exposure of a recessed
frame el ectrode b y FIB -milling 154 (I). The detection p rinciple of the e lectrochemical signal is
depicted in B, F and J and corres pondin g results of AFM -SECM mea surements are sho wn for
the d etection of Au parti cles i n Mt/AFM -SECM 152 ( C), indivi dual recorded topograp hy (G) an d
current signal (H) with a condu ctive AFM tip 153 and simultan eously detected topography (K,
M) and current signal (L, N) of an UME with an AFM-SECM prob e with a rece ssed conductive
BDD electrode ; magni fied vi ew of the results (M , N) show the b locked current signal of the
UME due to a diamond particle at the UME surface 154 . R eprin t with permission from Eifert, A.,
Kranz, C. Anal. Chem. 2 014 , 86 , 5190−5200. Copy right 201 9 American Chemical Society.
https://doi.org/10 .1021/ac50 08128 .

- 25 -

Different geometries and f abrication procedures of AFM -SECM probes have been
published so f ar, for example, hand-made 155,15 6 , ba tch-fabrication 153,157,158 a nd
modification of comm ercially available pr obes 140,159 – 16 1 , of w hich some examples are
depicted in Figure 9 . Accordin g t o the fabrication process, different electrode shapes an d
sizes are p ossible, n amely ring s haped 162 , s quare 163 , f rame 133,159 , disk 164 , cone-shaped 132
or sp herical 165 . Especially, FIB p rocessing enables man ufacturing a wide range of different
geometries, electrode shapes, and siz es, or different arrangements of t he electrode area
within the AFM-SECM probe 133,16 1,166 . This contribution is b ased on the fabrication of
recessed frame electrodes as first reported by Kranz et al. 133 . This method implies the
modification of a comme rcially available AFM probe with a thin adhesive l ayer of Ti and a
conductive gold layer, followed by insulation with Si x N y , Si x N y /SiO 2 mixed layers or
Parylene C.

SEM images of an AFM- SECM probe durin g FIB-milling in two different per spectives, either
perpendicular to wards the electron o r ion beam, indicated on the left side: an insulated AFM-
SECM prob e with mark-ups o f the area, which i s remov ed by FIB (A) and after FIB -milling (B).
By mounting the AFM -SECM p robe in 90° to the original position an d removing the marked
region in (C ) by FIB -milling, the ele ctrode is expo sed with a th orn located in the center . The
SE M im ages depicted in D-F show the Au and the insulation l ayers d uring the single fabrication
steps, 90° to wards th e ion b eam and 52° towards the e -beam, re spectively. Ac celeratio n
voltage: 3 kV an d beam curre nt: 36 pA.

- 26 -

The exposure of the recessed electrode area is done by FIB -milling, which is also used f or
the preparation of a new AFM tip located in the center of the square for med by the frame -
shaped electrode. The individual fabrication FIB -milling steps are summarized in Figure
10 . The resulting Au frame electrode with a frame wid th of about 100 nm, depending o n
the thickness of the deposited Au layer, can be varied in size according t o the desired
application. Additional mod ification s of the tip-integrated electrode result in advanced
probes suit able f or detection of specific analytes . Th e AFM tip p roduced by FIB-milling is
located in the center of the Au frame. In this case, the tip is resh aped from the original Si
AFM p robe, but variations in position ar e also p ossible and L-sh aped AFM- SECM p robes
made of insulating material (Parylene C) and lo cated n ext to the electrode area were
reported and used for the mapping of carbon nanotubes 159 .

SEM images of the final AFM- SECM probe imaged in differen t perspectives as shown in Fi gu re
10 (A , B) an d top view of the f inal Au frame (C); Acceleratio n voltage: 3 kV an d beam curren t:
36 pA.
A p recise characterization of the actual geo metry of AFM -SECM probes is essential and
small variations, the RG values, artifacts within the AFM -SECM p robe and t he posit ion of
the tip at or within the AFM- SECM probe 167,168 show an imp act on the current signal, which
was shown by simu lations for AFM -SECM probe s with the AFM ti p as co nical electrode .
Additionally, the effect at the border between insulating and conductive regions of a
sample has been shown by simulations f or AFM -SECM probes with a rec essed electrode
geometry p redicting an overlapped current signal of the insulating and conductive region,
respectively 169 .

- 27 -

Different electrode materials ca n be used for AFM -SECM. Gold 133,156,170, 171 or
platinum 132,159 are most common ly utilized, b ut also bor on -doped diamond 154,172 , carbon
nanotubes 164 or c onductive colloids 165 have been reported so far. Additionally,
modification of gold el ectro des w ith a P t/C comp osite deposited via IB ID 173,174 enables a n
easily tunable electrode area, adjustable to the re quirements of the targeted AFM-SECM
measurements.

- 28 -

FIB /SE M t om og r aph y
In scanning elect ron microscopy (SEM ) 175 , a high en ergy ele c tron beam is generated by a
thermionic or field emission emitt er, focused and de- magnified by a set of
electromagnetic lenses and is finally scanned over a defined area of the sample surface.
When the en ergetic electrons penetrate the sample, elastic and in elastic scattering occurs
at atoms of the samp le, whereby the t rajectories of t he el ectrons are changed and energy
is tran sferred during scattering event s. This interaction with the sample causes th e
emission of seco ndary electrons (SE), as well as c haracteristic X- rays a nd bremsstrahlung .
The actual trajectories of the primary electrons within t he sample volume can be
described by Monte- Carlo simulations 176 . Incident electrons, which are able to leave the
sample after sca ttering are called b ackscattered electrons (BSE). Th e i nterac tion between
the primary electron beam and the sample t hereby depends on the acceleration voltage
of the electron b eam, as a high er acceleration voltage re sults in a higher penetration
depth within the sample (Figure 12 ). Additionally, t he yield of detectable electrons is
dependent on the composition and de nsity of the sample m aterial and the incide nt angle
of the electron beam tow ards the sample surface.

Scheme of a model sa mple and the influence of th e accelera tion voltage of the primary e-b eam
(represented by th ree arrows for three different accelerati on voltages) in the d etected SEM
(top view): the h igher the ap plied voltage, th e more of th e inn er structure of a sample i s visible
in the SEM image.

- 29 -

Therefore, as they originate from a cer tain depth of the sam ple, the amoun t of BSE abl e
to leave the sample depend s strongly on den sity and composition, as well as crystal
orientation. SE are se nsitive for surface relie f, due to their l ow er energy cont ent (50 eV
and less). On ly SE emitted near the sample surface are able to leave the sample and be
collected by a detector. The contrast in SEM images results from vary ing amounts of
detected electrons per pixel. SEM gives , therefore , information on the localized structure
of material s of known composition wit hin the sample and the surface str ucture. In SEM ,
conductive samples can be easily imaged, whereas imaging of insulating materials may
cause distor tions due t o charging effects. The most commonly used detector in SEM is th e
Everhart-Thornley detector (ETD) 177 based o n the conversion of electrons i nto photon s by
a scintillator, enhancing the signal b y 10 5 – 10 6 times with in a ph otomultiplier and signal
collection by a computational read-out system. The ETD is located perpe ndicular to the
optical axis of the primary elect ron b eam wit hin the chamber of the SEM. State- of -the-art
microscopes provide an enh anced resolution by using an ele ctron detector p laced above
the o bjective lens pole pieces wit hin the electron colum n, whic h are referred to as
through-the-lens detector (TLD). The use of the so -called immersion mode, in which the
magnetic field from the objective lens pole piece is extended to the sample su rface,
attracts SE t o travel towards the TL D. SEM is used primarily as an imaging method , but
modification and structuring of samples are also possible with a focu sed ele ctron bea m 178 .
A b eam of accelerated ions instead of electrons is preferred for nano- and
microstructuring of materials. FIB is high ly suitabl e for mask-less tunable fabricat ion steps
compared to other microfabrication processes, e.g. e -beam lithography 179 or deep
reactive ion etching ( DRIE) 83 . For FIB, mostly a gallium ion source is used 180 . FIB plays a
significant role, ranging from microfabrication, investigat ion of materials perpendicular to
the surface by cross- sectioning, TEM sample preparation, up to deposit ion of metals and
insulator ma terials by ion beam induce d de position (IBID) eit her as p rotection layer or for
surface mod ification. Examples for FIB applications relevant to the research presented
within this thesis are th e exposure of the electroa ctive area in AF M-SECM p robes 133,160,161 ,
fabrication of nanop or ous arrays in solid -state mat erials 31 – 34 , cross-sectioning of
nanopores f or investigation of electron or ion be am -induced variatio ns i n pore sh apes 36
and fabrication of high-aspect AFM p robes for investigation of such nanopores by FIB -
milling con sidering e.g. t he surface tilt or other param eters 181 . With the availability of

- 30 -

FIB/SEM d ual-beam i nstruments 182 , the inves tigation and reconstruction of materials b y
FIB/SEM tomography 183 becomes possible and structu res of several nanometers can be
resolved 184,185 . By an automated successive FIB millin g and SEM imaging of the freshly
exposed faces, a whole sample volume can be investiga ted with an axial re solution of 3 –
30 nm 10 . T he acq uired image s tack, which represents t he sampled volume, is proc essed
by a 3D software, whereby sample drifts or varia tions in co ntrast d uring FIB/SEM image
acquisition can be corrected. The 3D reconstruction of the ac tual mo rphology of t he
sample gi ve s access t o the p orosity and inner structure wi th nanometer resolution . Fig ure
13 gives an overview of FIB/SEM tomography and 3D reconstruction of a nanoporous
structure, w hich is d iscussed in detail in section 6. FIB/SEM tomography can be a pplied to
a large variety o f scientific questions , s uch as the invest igations of nanoparticles in d ye-
sensitive solar cells 14 and of nanotube arrays 3 . Investigations of the inner structure of
micro- and nanoporous mat erials 12,13 or Al-Si alloys 186 , but also the investigation of
biological 15,16 and geolog ical 16 samples have been reported.

- 31 -

FI B/SEM tomograp hy: For 3D tomograp hy, the sample of interest i s stabilized with a Pt/C
protection-layer an d a cros s-s ection is milled b y FIB. Th e FIB -induced SE i mage in A show s the
perspective of the ion b eam, whereas in B the perspecti ve of the SEM with a tilt corr ection of
38° toward s the ion beam is shown (th e a ctual angle between ion an d e lectron b eam i s 52°
and defined by the spatial arrangement of the e-beam and ion-beam columns). The yellow -
framed SEM images repr esent single slices after con secu tive FIB milling. After drift and
contrast correction, th e slices can be reconstructed as a 3D image (C). The structure can be
presented in different p erspe ctives ( D). A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J . Aus ten, A. Gam ero -
Quijano, G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan, A. Ziegler, P. Walther, and C. Kranz, Faraday Discuss. ,
2018, 210 , 113. Adap ted from Ref. 187 . D istribu ted under th e lic en se Creative Commo ns
Attribution-N onCommercial 3.0 Unpo rted (CC- BY -NC 3.0),
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .

- 32 -

Re s ul ts a n d di sc us s io n
In the following, th e results ob tained by modifications of AFM -SECM probes are
presented. In chapter 4 , t he influence of the indi vidual pretreatment steps necessary for
the mountin g of the AFM tip -integrated PB/NIHCF b ilayers as H 2 O 2 - sensitive mater ial into
the exp erimental setup is evalu ated in re spect to sensitivity and stability. First results f or
the detection of localize d H 2 O 2 genera tion at an UME is presented i n 4.3.3 . In c ontrast, to
the mo dification of AFM-SECM p robes with th e active se nsor mat erial, in chap ter 5, th e
modification of AFM-SECM probes with an additional metal layer for t ip-integrated pH
sensors is evaluated. First measu rements have already been re ported by Jong Seok
Moon 188 , who fabrica ted the Ir and Sb integrated A FM tips, respectively, used in chapter
5. Within this thesis, the performance in pH sensi ng of these mo dified AFM -SECM probes
is p resented and first AFM -SECM measurements of localized su rface changes together
with ongoing pH changes during the dissoluti on of calcite crystals are detec ted (5.3.2).
In chapter 6, the diffusion at nanoporous membranes is presented visualizi ng the d iffusion
behavior dependent on the pore- to -pore sep aration of individual nanopores with in an
array and showing the capability of AFM -SECM with a conductive AFM t ip for t he
detection of localized electrochemical p rocesses 181 . Th e nanoporous solid -state materials ,
which are presented i n this thesis, were fabricated by FIB milling enabling readily tunabl e
geometries of nanopore arrays. Although, FIB fabricated nano porous membranes were
already i nvestigated for electrochemical process es at the liquid/ liquid interf ace 30,31 , the
actual l ocation of the interface b etween both liqu ids within t hese na nopores is not
verified yet. The actual pore s hape and implantation of Ga + i ons d uring FIB milling might
change t he hydroph ilic ity of these nanopores and with this chang e the behavior of these
devices used as support material for electrochemistry at liquid/li quid interfaces. T his was
no t considered so far in previous publications and will be evaluated in chapter 6 , amo ng
other investigations, by FIB/SEM tomography.

- 33 -

H 2 O 2 se ns ing wi th A FM tip -in te gra t ed el ec tr od es
Introduction
Hydrogen p eroxide ( H 2 O 2 ) plays a crucial role in biological systems as reactive oxygen
species (ROS) 189 , as a p roduct of the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in acidic media 190 ,
and thus, H 2 O 2 is import ant for develo ping new c atalytic materials in energy storage 191 . It
is also a n important species in environmental water and atmospheric samples indicating
phototoxic e ffects and environmental pollutions 192 . Next to others, like fluorometric 193 or
spectrophotometric 194 methods, H 2 O 2 can be determined by electrochemical
approaches 195 . First det ection approaches with solid metal electro des were reported f or
the oxi dation of H 2 O 2 at p otentials of + 0.5 – 0.8V vs. N HE 17 in acidic or neutral s olutions
depending on the electrode material, or H 2 O 2 reduction at 1.76 vs. NHE 196 . Hence,
reduction of O 2 and other electroactive com pounds present in samples, such as ascorbic
acid in biological samples, migh t interfere wit h the electrochemical d etection of H 2 O 2 197 .
Additionally, the H 2 O 2 conversion shows large overpotential s at metal electrodes 196 .
Therefore, ele ctrode modifications h ave been investigated enabling the conversion of
H 2 O 2 at moderate potentials with enhanced sensitivity for H 2 O 2 195 . Examples f or suc h
sensors are elect rodes mod ified with enzymes emb edded e.g. in redox p olymers 198 or
nano-sized materials, suc h as mul ti-walled carbon nanotubes with nanoparticles 199 . Metal
hexacyanoferrates and especially Prussian Blue (PB) 19 show also a promising response in
H 2 O 2 d etection via the Fenton reaction 200 . PB , wi th KFe(II )[ Fe(III)(CN) 6 ] as the soluble a nd
Fe(III) 4 [Fe(II) (CN) 6 ] 3 t he insoluble salt , and analogues met al h exacyanoferrates form a
face-center-cubic structu re with iron(II) and iron(III) ions in t he network of the complex 201 .
The ele c trocatalytic activity of PB is related t o the FeN x units in the crystal framework
determined by x-ray diffraction ( XR D) and Fourier-transform infrared spe ctroscopy ( FT -
IR ) 202 . The reduction of H 2 O 2 occurs at a potential of - 0.05V vs. SCE and is catalyzed by
Fe(II) ions 18 , whereas O 2 does not interfere, because the reduction of O 2 to H 2 O occurs at
a potential of 0.2V vs. S CE 18 . Additionally, PB is insensitive to other reductant s inter fering
in H 2 O 2 sensing in biological samples 203 . Fo r meta l h exacyanoferrates other than PB, t he
electrocatalytic activity for H 2 O 2 is due to d efects of PB crys tals in the sal t l attice 19 ,204 . The
oxidation and reduc tion of iron hexacyanoferrate lead s to the formation of Berlin Green
(or Prussian Yellow, Fe (III)[Fe(III )(CN) 6 ]) 201 and the Everitt’s salt (or Prussian White, Berlin
White, K 2 Fe(II)[Fe(II)(CN) 6 ]) with structures comparable to PB 205 .

- 34 -

Fe [ Fe ( CN ) 6 ] + K + + e − ⇌ KFe [ Fe ( CN ) 6 ] + K + + e − ⇌ K 2 Fe [ Fe ( CN ) 6 ]
Prussian Yellow ↔ PB ↔ Prussian White
Fe 4 [ Fe ( CN ) 6 ] 3 + 3K + ⇌ 3 KFe [ Fe ( CN ) 6 ] + Fe 3+
insoluble ↔ solu ble

Thereby, the role of potassium ions is significa nt for the redox reaction , because the
electrochemical p rocesses are re lated t o the t ransport of K + rath er than the t ransfer of
electrons within the PB lattice 206 . Th e amount of K + with in the PB crystal stru cture also
affects the sensitivity for H 2 O 2 detection. T he infl uence of the used el ectrolyte solut ion ,
containing K + cations during electrochemical PB deposition was shown by Zh ang et al. 2 07 .
A potential shift in the open circuit potential of PB was obta ined in dependence to the
used electrolyte . K + ions with in t he crystal lat tice also guarantee the electro -neutrality.
The ability for K + (de- )ins ertion during oxidation and reducti on, respectively, enables also
the u se of PB f or insertio n electrochemistry in e.g. en ergy stor age due to its capability t o
store K + ions 208,209 . PB is frequently used for H 2 O 2 sensing, especially in biosensors 203 and
even the synonym “artificial peroxidase” was established in literature 210 .
The f irst deposition of PB on electrode materials b y dipping the electrodes into a ferric
ferricyanide solution was pub lished in 1978 and the redox behavior was shown by single
sw eep voltammograms 211 . The first el ectrochemical deposition w as presen ted by I taya e t
al. 212 ,213 . Since th en, d ifferent approaches f or th e electrochemical synthesis of PB has been
reported resulting in a va riation of the s tructure and the stoichiometric composition of PB
depending on the elect rochemical conditions. Ep itaxial growth o f PB on g old was real ized
by electrochemical deposition at a constant pot ential 214 . PB was d eposited on gold
nanoparticles t o enhance the sensitivity (10.6 µ A/(µM · cm 2 )) 215 toward s H 2 O 2 compare d
to b ulk gold electrodes , and even the sim ultaneous formation of gold nanoparticles and
PB on gold or glassy carbon electrodes was report ed by Ku mar et al. with H 2 O 2 sensitivities
up to 5 nA/nM 216 . Other materials u sed as supporting electrode materials for PB
deposition are Pt and carbon paste usi ng a ferri c yanide solu tion for t he e lectrochemical

- 35 -

deposition by cyclic voltammetry 217 , or Pt/C composite dep osited via IBID sh owing
enhanced st ability and H 2 O 2 sensitivity compared to g old as electrode mater ial 218 . A
drawback of PB for H 2 O 2 sensing is its reduced lo ng-term stabili ty. Th e stability of PB is
influenced by the p H value of the an alyte solution and a loss of stability can be seen in
alkaline solutions due to t he p ossible formation of Fe(OH) 3 219 . Because the conversion of
H 2 O 2 results in the production of OH - ions in n eutral an d alkaline media, t he lon g-term
stability of PB is limit ed to a few minutes in the p resence of higher amounts (tenths of
mM) of H 2 O 2 220 . PB can be stabilized by co-deposition of conductive polym ers 221 enabling
additionally the embedding of enzymes in biosensors 203 . An alternative modification to
overcome th is limitation is the co -deposition with other metal hexacyanoferrates showing
no sen sitivity to H 2 O 2 , but exhibit enhanced stability in neutral and alkali ne media 204,222 .
Komkova et al. examined an optimal ratio for mixed metal hexacyanoferrates of three
bilayers of PB and nickel hexacyanoferrate (NiHCF) with reduced s ensitivity comp ared to
PB films but enhan ced long -term stability for several hours 20 . PB -modified electrodes
were already u sed for the localize d detection of H 2 O 2 evolution by SECM in t he
generation/collection mode 218 and u sed as a lactate b iosensor in soft-stylus SECM 223 . A
H 2 O 2 sen sitivity of 1.6 A/(M · cm 2 ) 223 could be achieved f or the lactate biosensor .
Additionally, the d issolution and corresponding loss in H 2 O 2 sensitivity for mixed PB/N iHCF
bilayers 20,224 were investi gated via SECM .

- 36 -

Experimental
The modi fication of electrodes with H 2 O 2 sensitive PB/N iHCF w as done a ccording to the
procedure published by Komkova et al. 20 . Three bilayers of PB/NiHCF were
electrochemically deposited by alternating d eposition of PB and NiHCF. All
electrochemical measurements were performed with a (bi)potentiostat (660A or 660C,
CH Inst ruments). All solutions were d iluted with ultrapure water (18.2 M  , ELGA
LabWater, Veolia Water Solutions & Technologies). PB as first laye r was deposited in a
solution containing 4 m M FeCl 3 · 6 H 2 O (pro analysi, M erck KGaA ) and 4 mM K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ]
(Honeywell, Flu ka) in 0.1 M HCl (f rom 32% HCl Normapu re, V WR Chemicals) and 0.1 M KC l
(pro analysi, Merck KGaA ) by cyclic voltammetry within a potential range of 0.4 to 0.75 V
vs. Ag/ AgCl re ference electrode (sat. KCl, RE- 1CP, ALS Co ) at a scan rate of 20 mV/s. The
electrodes were rinsed a fter deposi tion with ultrapure w ater and the first layer was dr ied
at 80°C for 15 min. NiHCF w as deposited at a potential range of 0 – 0.8 V at 100 mV/s i n a
mixture of 1 mM NiCl 2 ( pro analysi, Merck KGaA ) and 0.5 mM K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ] i n 0.1 M HCl and
0.5 M KCl. Subsequent depositions were d one with out additional tempering by alternating
deposition of PB and NiHCF u p to 6 depositions of 2 CV cyc les for each compound resulting
in three bilayers of mixed films.

Electrochemical deposition of PB (A) an d N iHCF (B) by cycl ic voltammetry : P B: 1 st (blue), 3 rd
(red) and 5 th (green) layer were deposited at 0.4 - 0.75 V vs. Ag/AgCl refe rence electrode; scan
speed: 20 mV/s. NiHCF: 2 nd (bl ue), 4 th (red) and 6 th (gr een) layer were deposited at 0 - 0.8 V vs.
Ag/AgCl referenc e electrode ; scan speed: 10 0 mV/ s.

- 37 -

After deposition, the fil m was activated by cycling at a poten tial range of 0 – 0.85 V vs.
Ag/AgCl re ference electrode at 40 mV/s in 0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl with varying numbers of
scans. Af ter ac tivation, the e lectroactive PB/NiHC F film was d ried at 80 °C for at least 3 0
min. Before and after electrochemical modification of the UMEs, the electr ode surface
was invest igated by optical microscopy (AXIO Ima ger.M1m, Zeiss ) a nd by SEM (Qua nta 3D
FEG, ThermoFisher Scien tific), if no t s tated other wise. The sensitivity and response of the
modified electrodes to ward s H 2 O 2 were tested by calibration at a constant pot ential of 0
V vs. Ag/AgCl reference electrode with s ubsequent addition of equimolar al iquots of H 2 O 2
(40 µL (50 µL) of 1 0 mM H 2 O 2 (fr om 30 % H 2 O 2 , EMSURE, Merck)) to 0.05 M phosphate
buffer (4 mL (5 mL), pH 6 -7, consisting of Na 2 HPO 4 · 12 H 2 O (NORMAPUR, VWR
Chemicals)/NaH 2 PO 4 · H 2 O (pro analysi, Merck KGaA ) in 0.1 M KCl electrolyte solution
within a co ncentration range of 99 – 476 µM. For evaluation of the results, the averaged
steady-state currents after c urrent leveli ng were used . High conce ntrations of H 2 O 2 ( 1 – 2
mM ) were us ed next to calibrat ions to test the stability of t he sensors. T he activation in
0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl was u sed to determine the amount of active PB film on the electrodes
after being exposed to H 2 O 2 solution.

H 2 O 2 calib ration in 0.05 M phosphat e buffer of a PB/NiHCF - modified Pt UME (diameter: 25
µm) with successive ad dition o f equimolar aliquo ts o f 10 mM H 2 O 2 (A) an d corre spondin g CV
in 0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M K Cl recor ded prior to calibration ; scan rate: 0.02 mV/ s (B).

- 38 -

Additionally, t he dissolution of PB/NiHCF bilayers was investigated in solution b y con tact
AFM -SECM (5500 AFM/SPM microscope, Keysight Techno logies). All AFM image s and
correlating h eight and current profiles were processed by Pico View (Keysight
Technologies) or Gwydd ion 225 . The electrochemical liquid cell consisted of t he AFM-SECM
probe as working electrode, an Ag /AgCl quasi-reference elec trode (G oodfellows) and a Pt
wire (Goodfellows) as coun ter electrode. Different conditions were evaluated with
respect o n the stability a nd res ponse o f t he PB/ NiHCF film f or H 2 O 2 sensing . Details of the
AFM -SECM probe fabrication is based on the procedu res described elsew her e 133 . Brie fly
summarized, the modification of an AFM tip-integrated electrode is comparable t o the
modification o f U MEs. It has to be e nsured that t he sharp AFM tip rema ins u nmodified .
Therefore, the AFM- SECM probe was investigated b y SEM after modific ation with
PB/NiHCF bilayers and the AFM tip had to be reshaped in case of deposited particles
located on t he AFM tip, because N iHCF is known to deposit spontaneousl y, also without
applied potentials d uri ng el ectrochemical deposition and t hus, the dep osition of
PB/NiHCF bilayers is not just occurrin g at t he electrode surface. Additionally, the electrode
area of ti p-integrated electrodes was en larged by IBID (pr ecursor: methyl -
cyclopentadienyl-trimethyl platinum, ThermoFisher Scienti fic ) of a Pt/C composite 174 and
the PB/NiHCF films deposited on t his electrode m aterial were evaluated for stability, H 2 O 2
response and sensitivity. The modification of t he AFM -SECM p robes with Pt/ C was done
by consecutive deposition of rectangular patterns surroun ding the AFM tip (Figure 16). To
guarantee that the AFM tip remai ns f ree of the conductive material, a circular pattern was
used removing possible Pt /C deposition at or close to t he AF M tip. Thereby, the AFM tip
was reshaped after the final deposition of t he PB /NiHCF film to obtain a sharp and clean
AFM ti p. Single steps of the Pt/C deposition an d c leaning by FIB milling are summarized i n
Figure 16.

- 39 -

SEM images showing th e mod ification of A FM- SECM probe s with Pt/C co mposite b y IBID: The
exposed Au frame electrode (shown in A) is modified by IBID (rectangular blue area), foll owed
by circular cle aning ar ound th e AFM tip an d rectangu lar cleanin g patterns n ext to th e actual
electrode area (marked in red) by FIB milling prior to electrochemical modification with
PB/NiHCF ( B). Sin gle fab rication steps ar e sho wn 54° tilted, before (C) an d aft er (D ) Pt/C
deposition and after FIB cleanin g-(E). Acc eleration voltage : 3kV and beam current: 35.5 p A.

The AFM-SECM p robes have to be glued onto the AFM mount (nosecone) and the
electrical contact of the electrode was insulated aft erward by UV glue (Dymax 9001 -E-
V3.1 or DYMAX 425, Dymax Europe GmbH ). The influence of UV light (U V light:  = 320 -
395 nm, 9 W/cm 2 , Dymax UV lamp 75 Blue Wave, Dymax Corp .), which is req uired for
curing the glue, on the stability of PB/N iHCF films was also examined. Preliminary
measurements were done with UMEs being less time consuming to modif y and enabling
simplified handling compared to AFM -SECM pro bes. The Pt and A u UMEs used for these
measurements were fabricated as described elsewhere 65,226 .

- 40 -

Results and discussion
This first section summarizes and d iscuss es t he resu lts obt ained with PB/NiHCF-mo difie d
UMEs, f ollowed b y th e modification and optimization for the electrochemical deposition of
PB/NiHCF on to AFM-tip-integrated electrodes. First re sults in AFM-SECM measurements are
presented in section 4.3.3.

PB/NiHCF-modified UMEs
The modifica tion of UMEs with three PB/NiHCF b ilayers resulte d in an inhomogeneous film
with differ ent structures and colors as visible in SEM and optical images (Figure 17) ,
respectively. Thereby, the varying colors indicate different oxidation st ates of the PB and
varying stoic hiometry o f the PB structure. No correlation between the c olor or the shape of
the deposited film and the electroch emical deposition could be drawn.

SEM (A, C) an d op tical images (B, D, E) of UMEs (diameter: 25 µm ) before (A, B) and after (C -E)
electrochemical d eposition of P B/NiHCF bilayer s.

- 41 -

The i nhomogeneous structure might be also relat ed to an inhomogeneous mixtu re of the PB
and the NiHCF at the surfaces of the modified electrodes . To exclude ch anges in morphology
and correlating loss of H 2 O 2 sensitivi ty during the measurement due to an irregular
composition o f the PB/NiHC F -mixed bil ayers, the elem ental composit ion of the film was
investigated via EDX mapping as shown in Figure 18. The counts for Ni are homogeneously
distributed over the entire film and the Fe map i n Figure 18 shows ad ditionally an enhanced
intensity for Fe compared to Ni as a consequence of the presence of Fe ions in both, iron and
nickel hexacyanoferrates. The i ntensity distribution of the Pt signal originating from the
electrode m aterial b eneath the PB/NiHC F bilaye rs reveals a n i nhomogeneous thick ness o f t he
PB/NiHCF film with less d eposit on the areas with high Pt counts ( white labeled i n Figure 18 ,
Pt ). The excita tion volum e according to the p enet ration depth of t he electron beam into th e
sample volume is, of course, larger than the actual thickness of the PB/ NiHCF b ilayers, which
is apparent in the detected Pt intensities.

SEM (A, B) and EDX map ping (colored images sho wing the distributio n of th e elements : red (Fe),
green (Ni) and blue (Pt)) of an UME (diameter: 25 µm) modified with PB/NiHCF -mixed film .
Acceleration voltag e: 5 k V. EDX mapping repr esents th e average el emental distributio n of in sum
512 frames (re solution: 256 x 200 pixels).

- 42 -

A penetration depth of up to at least a µm has to be assumed in PB/NiHCF layers at an
acceleration voltage of 5 kV as used in the f ollowing EDX mappings, depe nding on the local
material composition and density. This varying thickness can not be related to t he composition
of the mixed film and higher Fe and Ni intensities in the EDX map s are likely related t o an
increased thickness of the PB/NiHCF bilayers. The ob served cracks may be associat ed with the
vacuum conditions. Because the p recise stoichiometry of PB 227 and NiHCF 228 is not known due
to varying composition and oxidation states of PB and varying K + content in both salt
structures, quanti fi catio n is not possible. The h omogeneous distribution of Ni is clearly visibl e
in Figure 18. In case of an irregular composition of th e mixed PB/NiHC F film, the distributio n
of the i ntensity for Ni should be i rregular as well. Another appro ach for the i nvestigation of
the composition of the mixed film of PB/NiHCF is the dissolution of singl e PB particles in the
presence of H 2 O 2 detecta ble by chan ges in the morphology of the f ilm. The dissolution of the
PB/NiHCF was measured in- situ by AFM-SECM and the results are depicted in Figure 19 . N ext
to the dissolution of these particles, the change in topography can be also explained by
mechanical re moval of surface structures due to the scanning AFM tip . Th ereby, resulting
art ifacts w ithin the topographical image are visible and marked by white arrows (see Figure
19 ). While imaging of t he modified UME as depicted i n the images in Figure 19 A and B, no
H 2 O 2 was present in the solution and n o potential was ap plied to the AFM -S ECM probe. Hen ce,
the ob served ch anges in topography cou ld be addressed to mechanical removal of the
PB/NiHCF bilayers. The A FM topography shown in Figure 19 C is the last scan recor ded a fter a
duration of in t ot al 7.5 h s howing the PB/NiHCF film that was not re moved d uring th is
measurement. Between the results shown in B and C, a potential was applied to the AFM -
SECM tip sufficient for generating H 2 O 2 ( - 0.5 V vs. quasi-Ag/AgCl r eference electrode) a nd t he
surface c hanges during consecutive AFM scans w ere detected. For improved visualization of
the morphological changes, just a small section of the PB/NiHC F -modif ied UME was
investigated in detail (white square in Figure 19 B). The results f or three con secutive AFM
scans are depicted in the AFM topography images in Figure 19 D-F. The morphology of the
PB/NiHCF-modified UM E changed w ithin appro ximately 12 mi n in the presence of H 2 O 2
generated a t t he AF M -SECM probe. The dissolution of a large particle is visible, whic h is also
partially removed by the scanning AFM tip.

- 43 -

Investigation of the stability and surface chang es of a modified UME while H 2 O 2 is generated at the
AFM -SECM pro be, by contact AFM in liqu id. Du ring imaging the surface depicted in A-C, no p otential
was app lied to the AFM - SECM prob e. Origina l s ize: 50 x 5 0 µ m 2 (A, B), 60 x 60 µm 2 (C), scan speed:
0.6 ln/s ( 60 µ m/s) (A,B), 0.8 ln/s (9 6 µ m/s) (C). The timeline (not to scale) depicted in the figure
shows the ti mes (min ) when the imag es were recorded durin g a tota l duration of the experiment
of 7.5 h. For the small ar ea of the PB/NiHCF- modified UME depicted in D-F, the AFM -SECM probe
was b iased at -0.5 V vs. quasi-Ag/Ag Cl ref erence e lectr ode and H 2 O 2 was generated in close
proximity to the surface. Scan direction: down (D), up (E) and down (F), original size: 25 x 25 µm 2 ,
scan speed: 1.5 ln/s (37 µm/s ). The AFM to pograph y in D-F shows single scans r ecorded in between
the scans sho wn in B a nd C, after a d uration o f 198, 204 and 210 min, r espectively.
But the reduced size of the particle and shrinkage of its structure visible in th e morphological
changes in i mage E to F can be associated wit h the dilution in t he pre senc e of H 2 O 2 generated
at the AFM- SECM probe. Thereby, the volume of this particle is reduced by approximately
62%. Following scans at different scan areas in the presence of H 2 O 2 , however, showed no
further changes i n the AF M topography (resul ts are no t shown). The AFM -S ECM investigation
in Figure 19 shows that higher regions of the PB/NiHCF b ilayers or particles locat ed on t op of
the ‘ main ’ PB/N iHCF bilayers are predominantly removed in th e presence of H 2 O 2 . In SEM

- 44 -

images, t hese regions are also visible a nd chang es in surface morphology after ex posure of
the PB/NiHCF-modified ele ctrodes t o vary ing c oncentration of H 2 O 2 w ere obs erved. T he
sensitivity loss in H 2 O 2 detection observe d in t he record ed electrochemic al i -t curves may b e
correlated to the morphology changes visible i n the consecutively recorded SEM images. H 2 O 2
sensitivity and response of th e modif ied electrodes were d etermin ed by ca libration
measurements before and after th e exposure of modified electrodes to H 2 O 2 , whereas in
between th e single SE M i mages shown in Figure 20, the U ME was exposed t o solu tions of 0.7,
0.8 and 1 mM H 2 O 2 , res pectively, and a n i-t-curve was recorde d over a period of 2 5 min f or
each H 2 O 2 con centration. Comparin g the SEM d ata t o the topographical changes ob served in
the AFM-SECM investigation shown in Figure 19, a chang e or dissolution of these particles on
top of the ‘main’ PB/NiHCF film would be expected.

SEM in vestigation of a PB/NiHCF- modified UME after electro chemical d eposition (A) and after
exposure to d ifferent H 2 O 2 co ncentration s: 0.7 mM (B), 0.8 mM (C, D) and 1 mM (E, F ). R egions o f
the PB/NiHCF bilayers lab eled by red arrows and circles are stable in the presence of H 2 O 2 .
Acceleration voltag e : 5 k V; 53 pA (A,B) and 852 pA (C - F ).

- 45 -

These particles are mark ed b y a red arrow and cir cle in Figure 20 and s howed h owever almo st
no changes during the consecutive H 2 O 2 exposures in between recording t he individual SE
images. In contrast to AFM investigations, the main characteristic of th e PB/Ni HCF bilayers is
a plate-structured deposit on the UME, which showed a reduction in surface coverage with
consecutive H 2 O 2 detection. The changes in the surface coverage are more obvious wit h
additional H 2 O 2 exposure, especially visible in t he SEM images di s played in E and F showing a
larger area of the PB/N iHC F-mo dified UME. The dissolution of the PB/NiHCF film seems to be
homogeneous and along the edges of the visible structures, which is energetically favorable.
Whereas the particles on top of th ese main characteristic plate- struc tured deposits were
dissolved during AFM investigat ions, t hese struc tures observed in the SEM images as bright
single particles, appear to be not a ffected by the H 2 O 2 exposure. Hence, t hese particles might
consist either of NiHCF a s a stable component of the mixed film insensitive to H 2 O 2 or these
particles a nd structures consist of mixed components of PB/NiHCF. The resu lts obtained b y
EDX mapping shown in Figure 18 indicate that a homogeneous mixture of PB and NiHCF is
most likely. The localized change and dissolution of a pure PB film in the presence of H 2 O 2
were detected in co nsecutive AFM sca ns as sh own in Figure 21 . Thereby, a Pt UME modified
only with PB was in vestigated at a constant H 2 O 2 concentration (1 mM) similar to the
concentrations used in the SEM studies (as shown in Figure 20).

AFM topograp hy of a PB-modified Pt UME (d iameter: 25 µm) in the presence of 1 mM H 2 O 2 in 0.05
M phosphate buffer. The depi cted AFM i mages are recorded at 16, 84 and 153 min, respectively, of
in tota l 2.5 h , showing the ch anges in th e surface coverage during this AFM investigation. Original
size: 60 x 60 µ m 2 , s can sp eed: 0.5 ln/s. E lectroche mical dep osition of PB wa s done with 20 cycle s
according to t he experimental condition s described in 4.2.

- 46 -

Within approximately 2.5 h, t he whole PB film was re moved. A possib le influence of the
vacuum conditions during SEM imaging was also investigated. A H 2 O 2 cal ibration curve and
corresponding loss of PB at a modified electrode with consecutive H 2 O 2 exposure is
exemplarily shown in Figure 22 . In between the deposition of PB and N iHC F, the electrodes
were exposed to vacuum (chamber vacuum of the SEM , in the range of 10 -6 mbar ), namely
after t he 1 st (PB), 2 nd (NiHCF) and 3 rd (PB) layer. After t he deposition of in sum 6 layers in
accordance with 3 PB/NiHCF-mixed bilayers, the electrode was investigat ed by SEM.

1 st H 2 O 2 calibration in 0.05 M p hosphate buffer of a PB/NiHCF-modifi ed Pt UME (diameter: 25 µm)
and correspondin g CV in 0.1 M HCl/KCl (scan rate: 0.02 mV/s) afte r 1 st calib ration (blue) and afte r
successive exposure to 1 mM H 2 O 2 for 25 min, respectively (running order: red, gree n, yell ow). SEM
images after PB/NiHC F d eposition (C) an d after H 2 O 2 detection (D) of in tota l of 3.5 mM H 2 O 2 over
a period o f approximately 2 h; acceleration voltage: 5kV, 7pA (C) an d 8 nA (D).
In between the single H 2 O 2 calibrat ions, the PB/NiHCF-modif ied UME was only characterized
by CV in 0.1 M HCl/KCl and the ch ange in the morphology was det ected b y optical m icroscopy
avoiding any influence of additional vacuum conditions i n between con secutive H 2 O 2

- 47 -

exposures. In the optical images depicted in Fig ure 23 , a clear change in the composition of
the mixed bilayers is visi ble, i ndicated by a change in color. T hereby, PB is redu ced to Prussian
Yellow, visible as a yellow-brown re gion on the modified UME, and Pr ussian White, which is
insensitive to H 2 O 2 . Single spots of the PB/NiHCF film were removed during H 2 O 2 exposure
that is visib le i n Figure 23 B and C at t he bright r egions within the fi lm showing the underlying
Pt electrode surface.

Optical images of a PB/NiHCF -modified UME after electroch emical depo sition of PB/NiHC F bilayers
(A), after the 1 st H 2 O 2 calibra tion ( B ) and after 2 nd exposure to 1 mM H 2 O 2 for 25 min (C).
Comparable results obtained by optical images of a PB/NiHCF - modifie d Pt UME without
vacuum conditions in between the sin gle layer deposit ions showed enhanced removal of the
active b ilayers without any distinctive color changes. The change in t he surface of the mod ifie d
electrode with successive H 2 O 2 calibrations is show n in Figure 24.

Optical images of a PB/NiHCF -modified UME after electrochemical deposition of PB/NiHCF bilayers
(A), aft er th e 1 st H 2 O 2 calibration (B) and aft er 5 th calibratio n, which equals an exposure to app rox.
2 mM H 2 O 2 (C).

- 48 -

In Figure 25, the comparison between two H 2 O 2 calibrations with PB/N iHC F- modified UMEs
with a nd without vacuu m conditions, resp ectively, shows e nhanced sta bility for t he b ilayers
exposed to vacuum, which is in accordance to the observat ion via optical microscopy.

H 2 O 2 calibration of PB/NiHCF-modified Pt UMEs (diameter: 25 µm) with (dashed lines; 1 st : ora nge
and 2 nd : green) and witho ut exposure to vacuum conditio ns between lay er deposition (so lid lines;
1 st : blue and 2 nd : red) .
The enhanced stability of the modified UMEs, which were exposed to vacuum , might be
related to the removal of water (‘drying p rocesses ’) in t he crystal lat tice. The locat ion of water
molecules in the PB lattic e has been determined by attenuated total re flection FTIR ( ATR-
FTIR) 229 and powder neutron diffraction revealing b oth, coordinated and u ncoordinated
regions of water molecules within the crystal lattice of PB 230 . Investigations of PB by 1 H nuclear
magnetic resonance spectroscopy ( NMR) showed that the water molecules are bo und to the
high-spin Fe(III) ions in the crystal lattice influ enc ing t he co nductivity of the ma terial 231 . O n
the other h and, coordinated water mo lecules occupy space in the PB lattic e, which might be
filled with K + ion s that en able charge t ran sport during electrochemical pro cesses 227 as
described in t he introduction. Water mo lecu les after electrochemical deposit ion f rom
aqueous solution might also be located in between PB particles and the removal of
incorporated wa ter fr om pores within t he PB film by vacuum might lead to enhanced stability

- 49 -

of the PB layers. A simpl e explanation for the reported enhanced sensitivity might by the fact
that rap id drying under vacuu m conditions indu c es fractures w ithin the PB film , which leads
to an e nlargement of the surface area. Thereby, the film might be mo re sensitive to H 2 O 2 but ,
on the other side, PB dilution p referentially occurs at these edges, which reduce s the st abili ty.
This was not observed during the course of these investigations.
In the n ext s tep, Pt /C composite as elec trode ma terial for t he electrochemical deposition o f
PB/NiHCF-mixed films was investigated. The acti vation of the PB/N iHCF-modified UME b y
cycling in 0.1 M HCl/KCl shows an enlarged amount of PB deposited on the UME with Pt/C
composite as electrode material (Figure 26 ). The ele ctrode area modified by Pt/C deposition
was determined by CV using [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ]Cl 3 as outer sp here redox species resulting in a n act ive
electrode area of 755 µm 2 , whereas a bare Pt electrode used for compa rison had an active
electrode area of 825 µm 2 . In contrast to the smaller active electro de area, the current o f the
PB redox signal is approximately 5 times h igher for Pt /C comp osites as electrode material
compared to the PB/NiHCF modification of bare P t UMEs.

CV in 0. 1 M H Cl/ 0.1 M KC l of PB/NiHCF -modified Pt UME (d iameter: 25 µm, A) and on a Pt UME
(diameter: 25 µm) modified with Pt/C compo site prior to layer deposition (B), scan rate: 0.02 V/s.
Blue CVs were r ecorded after d eposition of PB/NiHC F bilaye rs an d red CVs we re recorded after H 2 O 2
calibration, r espectively. After 4 consecutive calibrations (99 - 476 µM H 2 O 2 for each calibration) a t
the UME, where data are shown in (A), and after 5 consecu tive calib rations (9 9 - 476 µM H 2 O 2 for
each calibration ) for the Pt/C modified UME sho wn in (B).

- 50 -

In Figure 27, t he optical imag e of an UME is shown after th e deposition of Pt/ C composite by
IBID, whereas the optical images in B and C show the electrodes after electrochemical
deposition of the PB/ NiHC F bilayers. In Figur e 27 C, a large overspread o f the PB/NiHCF film is
visible, which might be also the explanation for the enhanced amount of PB located on the
UME.

Optical images o f UME s (diam eter: 2 5 µ m) with add itional deposition of a Pt /C compo site b y IBID ;
before (A) an d after ( B, C) the electro chemical deposition o f PB/N iHCF bilayer s. The o verspread of
deposited PB/NiH CF depict ed in C is r educed by add itional FIB milling prior to lay er depo sition (A)
as depicted in (B).
This oversprea d s hould b e avoi ded in t he modif ic ation of AFM -SECM probes du e to the loss
of the lateral resolution in localized H 2 O 2 detection. It was assumed that this overspread is
related to additional deposition of Pt/C n ext to the actual electrode area. To confirm this
assumption and to avoid t his overspread, the region surrounding the ac tual electrode area
was clean ed b y FIB m illing after d eposition of the Pt/C composite, b ut prior t o the
electrochemical deposition of the PB/NiHCF film ( Figure 27 A). Th e resulting PB/NiHCF
modification of the UM E is shown in Figure 27 B with a n egligible overspread around the actual
electrode su rface. Thereby, it can be con cluded that t his ove rspread was act ually based on
the additional deposition of Pt/C composite . A dire ct comparison of the H 2 O 2 sensitivity of
PB/NiHCF-modified UMEs with bare Pt or Pt /C composite as supporti ng electrode material is
shown in Figure 28 . Additionally, the effect of the FIB clean ing after deposition of t he Pt/C
composite to reduce the overspread of PB/NiHCF is taken into account.

- 51 -

Comparison of H 2 O 2 sensitivity and stability of a PB/NiHCF-modified UME at d ifferent supporting
electrode materials: Pt/C composite (blue), Pt/C composite with ad ditional FIB c leaning (green) and
bare Pt UME with no ad ditional treatment prior to electrochemical deposition of PB/NiHCF (red )
(A). The stability in con secutive calibratio ns of PB/N iHCF- modified UME s is co mpared in (B) wherea s
dashed lines represent the first and solid lines the s econd calibration, respectively (colors are same
as in (A)).
The measured current respon se at the 5 consecutive H 2 O 2 a ddition s of the comp ared t hree
UMEs vary with a factor of 3.5 ± 0.2 (Pt/C without FIB milling ) and 5.0 ± 0.3 (Pt/C with FIB
milling), respectively, within the data sets f or Pt supporting electrode mat erial and Pt/C -
modified Pt (o r Au ) UMEs with or without additional FIB millin g ( Figure 28 ). A loss of sen sitivity
is observable for con secutive c alibrations for all electrodes, but for Pt /C -modified UMEs
improved stability compared to bare Pt as supp orting electrode material is ob served. The
enhanced H 2 O 2 sensitivity may be related to an inc reased amount of PB within the PB/NiHCF
bilayers, whereas this is not necessarily related t o an enl arged electro de su rface , but to the
differen t su pporting elec trode material s, namely Pt and P t/C composite. Th e sta bility of th e
PB/NiHCF bilayers within con secutive calibrations (up t o 5 calibration s) of H 2 O 2 in phosphate
buffer was investigated on different su pporting electrode m aterials and fo r UMEs exposed to
vacuum .

- 52 -

The results are compared in Figure 29. The loss in sensitivity is clearly recognizable for all
investigated electrodes, but increased stability for the electrodes exposed to vacuu m between
single H 2 O 2 calibrations i s visib le comp ared to U MEs w ith no additional t reatment. Th e Pt/C
modification of the UMEs prior t o th e d eposition of PB/NiHC F bilayers resulting in en hanced
sensitivity for H 2 O 2 , shows also enhanced stability in H 2 O 2 detection.

Comparison of the H 2 O 2 sensitivity for 5 successi ve calibrations of two PB/NiHCF- modified UMEs
with no add itional treatmen t (green) , two PB/NiHCF -modified U MEs addition ally exp osed to
vacuum condition s (blue) and two PB/NiHCF-mod ified UMEs with Pt /C as supportin g electrode
material (red ).

- 53 -

Investigation of H 2 O 2 stability after the exposure of the PB/NiHCF -modifi ed electrodes to UV light:
consecutive H 2 O 2 calibra tions in 0.05 M phosphate buffer of a PB/NiHCF -modified UME (diameter:
25 µm) with Pt/C composite a s suppo rting electrod e materi al (A ), colors: 1 st (blue), 2 nd green) an d
3 rd (red) calibra tion, and corresponding CV s in 0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl ( B) a fter depo sition (yellow) ,
exposure to UV light (purple) an d after con secutive H 2 O 2 ca librations (ru nning ord er: b lue, green,
red), scan rate: 0.02 mV/s. The sensitivity of three con secutive H 2 O 2 calibratio ns recorded at three
individual UMEs modified with Pt/C (red) and additionally exposed to UV lig ht (green), is compared
in C.
Also, t he in fluence of UV light towards t he p erformance of PB/ NiHCF -mo dified UMEs i n
respect t o H 2 O 2 sensitivity and stability was investigated. Th erefore, a PB/NiHCF-mo dified Au
UME with Pt/C composite as supporting electrode material was exposed to UV light for 120 s
after electrochemical deposition of PB/NiHCF bilayers and after thei r act ivation by cycling in
0.1 M HCl/0.1 M KCl ( Figure 30 ). The H 2 O 2 calib ration in phosphate buffer showed good
linearity wit hin the con centration range of 99 – 909 µM H 2 O 2 and a sensitivity o f 0.82
µA/(cm 2 ·µM) for the first calibrat ion ( Figure 30 A), which is comparable to the results obtained

- 54 -

by modified Pt/C-UM Es without UV light exposure. Between recording the calibrations, the
PB/NiHCF bilayers were characterized b y CV in HCl/KCl ( Figu re 30 B). Additionally, the
influence of the UV light in respect to the H 2 O 2 response was compared i n the CVs recorded
prior and after the exposure of the modified U ME to UV l ight (see yellow and purple CVs in
Figure 3 0 B). No significant change in the amount of PB could be detected and no negative
effect within the following consecutive calibrations was observed . Both treatments, namely
the vacuum and the UV exposure of the modifie d electrodes, might res ult in a loss of hydrate
water and an e nhanced drying of the H 2 O 2 -active film. In lit erature, the exposure of PB to ligh t
of different wavelength has been reported a nd an increase in the formation of PB could be
associated t o the photo-reduction of the iron(III) in the [Fe(III)(CN) 6 ] 3- ani on 232 . The transfer of
ferricyanide to ferrocyan ide was shown for UV lig ht (  = 365 m) 232,233 . Th e photo -reduction is
not linked to the wavelength of the used light source, but to t he en ergy transferred by
irradiation. T herefore, i t is p ossible that residues o f FeCl 3 an d [Fe(III)( CN) 6 ] 3- within the freshly
prepared PB films are reduced t o Fe(II) and PB is add itionally formed. H owever, the redox
signal of PB shown in Figure 30 B doesn’t show signif icant differences b etween the CVs
recorded prior and after th e exp osure of the modifie d UMEs to UV lig ht. Also, IR investigations
indicated no change of t he vibrat ion bands within the film (data n ot shown). Th ereby, a chan ge
of the PB structure can be excluded and the enhanced stability of the PB/NiHC F - modified films
is probably re lated t o the fast drying of t he film and additional PB formatio n for both, vacuum
and UV c onditions. In co nclusion, vacuum conditions and UV light, which are necessary for the
preparation of modified AFM -SECM probes, seem to h ave a positive effect on the
performance of the ele c trodes . Impro ved stability is observed under both conditions. Pt /C
composite as supporting electrode material is also suit able and show ed enhanced stability
and sensitivity compared to bare Pt UMEs as supporting electrode material .

PB/NiHCF-modified AFM-SECM probes
Modification of AFM tip -integrated ele ctrodes with PB/NiHCF bilayers, which h as been
investigated within this thesis for the first t ime, was obtained u sing the s ame conditions as
described for UMEs with concent rations of t he solutions for PB and NiHCF dep osition adopted
from Komkova et al. 20 (4 mM FeCl 3 /K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ] and 1 mM NiCl 2 / 0.5 mM K 3 [ Fe(CN) 6 ]) . Thereby,
the el ectrode area was exposed by FIB milling and increased with a Pt/C composite by IB ID 174 .
First measurements with these modified AFM-SECM probes wer e performed in H 2 O 2

- 55 -

calibration experiments to investigate their H 2 O 2 sen sitivity and stability (Figure 31 C). In
Figure 31 A and B, an AFM -SECM p robe after the d eposition of 3 PB/NiHCF bilayers is shown.
The SEM images reveal a complete coverage of the whole pyramidal AFM tip. Because the
deposition of NiHCF is known to be spontaneous, this might be reasonable for the o bserved
deposition of the H 2 O 2 -sensitive PB/NiHCF layer onto the whole AFM tip. This should be
avoided to ensure localized measurements of H 2 O 2 .

SEM image o f a PB/NiHCF -modified, tip -integrated: top view (A) and side view (B) of th e py ramidal
AFM tip. Linearity an d H 2 O 2 sensitivity of 5 successive calibratio ns (C; ru nning order: blue, red,
green, orange, purple). Because o f th e huge ove rspread of the PB/NiHCF bilayers , the electrode
area was not tak en into account an d the absolute current signal is correlated to the H 2 O 2
concentration (C).
Therefore, the deposition of PB/NiHCF bil ayers has been optimi zed with tip -less AFM-SEC M
probes and tested in H 2 O 2 calibrat ion experimen ts. In Figure 32, the deposit ion of PB/NiHCF
following the procedure of K omkova et al. 20 is depicted i n A, whereas the de p osition of two
PB/NiHCF bilayers using a reduced concentration of the original deposition solutions by 66 %
is sh own in B. It is ob vio us that the optimization of the PB/NiHCF layer deposit ion resulted in

- 56 -

the localized deposition of H 2 O 2 -sensitive material located at the or iginal electrode area wit h
an overspread d ue to a radial diffusion at the microelectrode during the electrochemical
deposition. In Figure 32 C, the PB/NiHCF d eposition occurred additionally at the area
surrounding the actual microelectrode as a result of t he Pt/C deposition by IBID and/or the
spontaneous deposition of NiHCF .

SEM images of PB/NiHCF -mo dified, tip-integrated electrod es, with 4 mM FeCl 3 /K 3 [Fe(CN ) 6 ] an d 1
mM NiCl 2 / 0.5 mM K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ] con centrations for the ele ctrochemical depositio n of 3 PB/NiHCF
bilayers (A ) and reduced concentra tion s of the used soluti ons of 1.33 mM FeCl 3 /K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ] an d
0.33 mM NiCl 2 / 0. 17 mM K 3 [F e(CN) 6 ]) du ring electrochemic al depo sition of 2 PB/NiHCF bi layers (B -
D); without (C) an d with (D) addition al FIB cleaning aft er IBID of th e Pt/ C composite. Acc eleration
voltage: 5 kV (A) and 3 kV (B- D) / 24 pA (A), 43 pA (B) an d 86 pA (C, D) . Th e SE M images i n ( B – D )
are recorded in the im mersion mode.
This increased d eposition of a thin Pt/C layer next to the actual microelectrode area was
reduced by s ubsequent FIB milling as d epicted in Figure 32 D. Th e sensitivity and s tability o f
the PB/N iHCF-modified AFM -SECM p robes with a reduced concentration of the deposition
solutions were tested in consecutive H 2 O 2 calibrations. In the following graph (Figure 33), the
H 2 O 2 sensitivit y of a PB/NiHCF-mo dified, tip-integrated electrode (in blue) is compared to
results obtained with m odified UMEs. The reduction of t he amount o f PB and NiHCF d uring

- 57 -

electrochemical deposition didn’t show a reduced sensitivity , in contrast even an enhanced
sensitivity for the f irst 3 H 2 O 2 calibrations with t he PB/NiHCF-mod if ied, tip-integra ted
electrode was ob served. The i nfluence of UV light exp osure on the behavior of the PB/NiHCF
bilayers was also investigated as the mounting of the AFM-SECM probes requires the exposure
to UV light.

Comparison of the H 2 O 2 se nsitivity for 5 successive calibra tions of a PB/NiHCF -modified tip -
integrated electrod e (blue) to P B/NiHCF -modified UME s mo dified with Pt/C (light an d dark red).
The investigation of the i nfluence of the UV light was already tested w ith modified UMEs (s ee
4.3.1), resu lting in enha nced stabili ty of PB/NiHCF b ilayers. The AFM- SECM probes were
exposed to UV light after the deposition of the 1 st and the 3 rd layer corresponding to the
deposition of PB, whereas the 2 nd and 4 th layer correspond to the deposition of NiHCF resulting
in two PB/N iHCF bilayers. In the following section, individ ual AFM -SECM probes are compared
showing good H 2 O 2 sensitivity in consecutive cali brations. Using a re duced conce ntration of
the deposition solutions, for the modification of AFM -SECM probes with PB/NiHCF bilayers
resulted in ra ther limited rep roducibility. In f act, only the 4 (13 %) presented probes show ed
a response t o H 2 O 2 and 27 (87 %) tested AFM -SECM probes sh owed either n o sign al in the

- 58 -

‘activation’ CV i n HCl/KCl or no H 2 O 2 se nsitivity at all. In t he following, the different responses
of th e presented probes are evaluated in d etail t o identify the re ason for th is good H 2 O 2
sensitivity. The H 2 O 2 sensitivity of different AFM- SECM p robes with slightly different electrode
sizes and geometries are compare d in Figure 34 A. The compared probes are named according
to the colors in the graphs, namely purpl e, blue, red and black.

Comparison of H 2 O 2 sen sitivity and linearity o f PB/NiHCF-modified AFM-SECM probes with UV
exposure (purp le, blue, red) and w itho ut (black) UV ex posure d uring electrochemic al layer
deposition (A). CV in 0. 1 M H Cl/ 0.1 M KCl of PB /NiHCF -m odified AFM -SECM p robes (B) recorded
prior to ca librations depicted in (A), scan rate: 0.02 V/ s. Corr esponding dat a are of the sa me color.
A summary of the sensitivities and elec trode area is given i n Ta ble 4. The 1 st H 2 O 2 calibrations
obtained wit h PB/NiHC F-modified AFM -SECM p robes are shown in Fig ure 34 A, being ex posed
to UV lig ht (pu rple, blue and red dashed lines ; results correspond to three individual AFM -
SECM probes), an d wit hout being exposed t o UV light (black dashed li ne). It is clearly visible
that the se nsitivity of the probes exp osed to UV light is s trongly enhanced by a factor of 4.9
up to 16.3 in relation to the resu lts labeled in black. Ju st one PB/NiHCF -modified AFM -SECM
probe with additional UV exposure (red dashed line in Fig ure 34 A) shows a red uced sensitivity
by a factor of 0.5. Although the same conditio ns for th e electrochemical deposition of
PB/NiHCF bilayers were app lied t o all samples, the deviation in the resul ting sensitivities is
huge. A comparison of the ‘activation‘ CVs o f the H 2 O 2 - active bilayers in 0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl

- 59 -

black

red

blue

purple

exposed to UV
light

No

Yes

FIB cleaning
after PB/NiHCF
bilayer
deposition

No

No

Yes

H 2 O 2 sensitivity
[µA/(cm 2 · µM)]

1.24

0.65

6.10

20.17

ratio

-

0.5

4.9

16.3

electrode
geometry

square,
no AFM
tip

Pt/C frame electrode
+ AFM tip

electrode
surface [µm 2 ]

13.8

12.7

1.1

1.8

Table 4 Comparison of H 2 O 2 sensitivity and corres pondin g ratio o f AFM- SECM probes exposed t o UV
light in respect to the AFM-S ECM p robe not expose d to UV light (black), electrode surf ace as
determined by CV in 1,1’ -ferrocenedimethan ole and H 2 O 2 se nsitivity regardl ess of the a ctive
electrode surfac e of PB/NiHC F-modi fied AFM-SE CM prob es as depicted in Figure 3 4.
(the amount of PB can be estimated by its redox signal at appro ximatel y 0.2 V vs. Ag/AgCl
reference electrode (Figure 34 B)) doe sn’t explai n these enhanced sensitivities. Only the data
obtained for one AFM-SECM probe ex posed to UV light during ele ctrochemical layer
deposition (displayed in r ed colors in Figure 34 a nd Table 4) sh ows a re duced se nsitivity an d a
low con centration of PB, accordin g to t he redox signal for PB in the CV displayed in Figure 34
B. Indeed, the electrode revealing t he highest signal (black CV in Figure 34 B) shows for the 1 st
calibration the worst sensitivity (not exposed to UV ligh t). The comp arison of the active
electrode surface as determined by CV in 5 mM 1,1’ -ferro cenedimethano le shows deviations
for the respective AFM-SECM p robes as summarized in Table 4. The differ ences in electrode
size and H 2 O 2 se nsitivity are shown in Figure 34 B and in Table 4, respectively. The individual
samples are named according to the colors in Fig ure 34 . Th e data in Table 4 sh ow sig nificant
deviations in the H 2 O 2 sensitivities, which does not correlate with the actual e lectrode surface.
Whereas f or the probe ‘black’ (no UV exposu re), a square electrode was used without an AF M
tip (as depicted in Figure 32 B), the A FM -SECM probes with an electrode area (named as bl ue
and purple) reflect Pt/C frame electrodes s urrounding the AFM tip (SEM image of the ‘ blue’

- 60 -

AFM -SECM probe is shown in Figure 32 D). The AFM-SECM probe labeled as ‘red’ is shown in
the SEM image in Figure 32 C, without additional FIB cleaning after Pt/C deposition, b ut also
with an AFM tip surrounded by the active Pt/C - modified electrode area. Because t he ‘re d’
AFM -SECM probe shows c omplete coverage of the pyrami dal AFM p robe i n the SE M image in
Figure 32 C, the actual electrode area before the deposition of PB/NiHCF -bilayers is larger (see
values listed in Table 4). The detection of H 2 O 2 correlates with the amount of PB as the H 2 O 2 -
sensitive material. The amou nt of PB is d ependent on t he concentration of FeCl 3 and
K 3 [Fe(CN) 6 ] during elec trochemical deposition an d the actual elec trode area, on which the PB
is deposited. Because the concentration during the electrochemical deposition for all AFM -
SECM p robes in the compared results was kept the same, the d ifferenc es in sensitivity are
either related to the electrode s urface or to the p ositive influence of the e xposure to UV ligh t
in between the deposition of the individual layers. In deed, the AFM - SECM probe (‘red ’),
exposed to UV light and w ith the high est electrode area (see CV recorded in 1,1’ -
ferrocenedimethanole) an d a PB/NiHCF coverage of t he whole pyramidal AFM p robe visibl e
in the SEM image in Figure 32 C, shows the worst sen sitivity with the lo west amo unt of PB
according to the results shown in Figure 34 . The difference b etween t his AFM -SECM probe
and the other probes is th e additio nal FIB cleaning next to the act ual electrode area, which
guarantees a localized d eposition of PB/N iHCF b ilayers. This add itional t reat ment doesn’t h ave
a direct influence on the H 2 O 2 sen sitivity but on the amount of deposited material. The
amount of P B as est imated by the redox signal in the CVs shown in Figure 34 B is comp arable
for the ‘purple’ a nd ‘blue’ AFM p robes, b ut lower for the ‘red’ AFM probe. Up to this p oint, no
correlation could be f ound between the amount o f PB/NiHCF bilayers , detected by the
‘activation’ of the b ilayers by cycling in HCl/KCl solut ion and the coverage area observed in the
SEM images, and the resulting H 2 O 2 sensitivity of the modified AFM -SECM probes. All
PB/NiHCF-modified AFM- SECM probes showed a sensitivity loss with cons ecutive H 2 O 2
calibrations, w hich is in accordance with a diminishing concentratio n of PB during H 2 O 2
detection due to more alk aline p H values of the s olution induced by the H 2 O 2 reduction.

- 61 -

The ‘blue’ AFM -SECM p robe t ested by two succe ssive H 2 O 2 calibrations showed a sensitivity
loss of approximately 58 %, t he ‘purple’ probe sh owed a sensitivity loss of 45 %, red probe of
31 % an d black probe of 25 %. The PB/NiHCF elect rochemical deposition of two bilayers with
reduced concentration compared t o the origi n al deposition p rotocol was repeated. It would
be f avorable to reactivate used PB/NiHCF -modified AFM- SECM probes for further
investigations.

H 2 O 2 sensitivities for two consecuti ve calibrations of the PB/NiHCF -modified AFM -SECM prob es.
The colors are in a ccordan ce with the modified AFM -SECM prob es summarized in Table 4 .
Additional deposition of PB and NiHCF shou ld also result in a n enlarged amount of PB on the
AFM -SECM p robe. Beca use t he sam e p robe is used, there are no d iffere nces in preliminary
preparation s teps (electrode siz e, additional FIB c leaning , etc.) of the AFM-SECM probe that
showed already good behavior in H 2 O 2 sensing. With the assum ption that the electrochemical
deposition results in PB/NiHCF- mixed b ilayers as postulated by Karyakin and coworkers 222 , t he
amount of PB/ NiHCF-mixed material s hould be increased wit h additional deposition. Because
the modified A FM -SECM p robe was u sed in H 2 O 2 calibration and according t o the loss of
sensitivity of the H 2 O 2 -active film during the 2 nd calibration, the amount of PB and NiHCF still
left on the electrode area is unknown. Neverthel ess, an enhan ced H 2 O 2 s ensitivity after the

- 62 -

2 nd electrochemical d ep osition of mixed b ilayers is expected. In Figure 36 A, the H 2 O 2
calibration (gree n d ashe d line) actually shows an en han ced sensitivity, which is three times
higher than the sensitivit y of the 1 st calibration after the 1 st ele ctrochemical deposition of

Comparison of H 2 O 2 sensitivity and linearity of one PB/N iHCF-modified AFM-SECM prob e with UV
exposure du ring electrochemical layer deposition (A): 1 st (bl ue) and 2 nd (red) H 2 O 2 calibrat ion after
1 st electroche mical lay er d eposition an d H 2 O 2 calibration ( green) after 2 nd e lectroch emical layer
deposition. CV in 0.1 M H Cl/ 0.1 M KCl o f the PB/NiHCF-m odified A FM -SECM prob e (B) recorded
after 1 st (blue) an d 2 nd (green ) electrochemi cal layer depo sition an d prior to calibratio ns d epicted
in (A), scan rate: 0. 02 V/s.
PB/NiHCF (blue), b ut the amount of PB sho ws just a small d eviation in the CVs r ecorded in
0.1M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl (Figure 36 B). In both electrochemical depositions, the AFM -SECM probe
was exposed to UV light after the 1 st and the 3 rd layer deposition. The difference in sensitivity
is t herefore not associat ed with the exp osure of the PB/NiHCF -modified AFM-SECM probe to
UV ligh t. T he enhanced st ability can be addresse d neither to t he exp osure of th e PB/NiHCF-
modified AFM- SECM probes to UV light nor to the amount of PB. Because the same AFM -
SECM probe was use d in this comparison, t here w ere no additional diffe rences, namely the
electrode area or geo metry of the original Pt/C - modified electrode. Add itionally, the
hypothesis that alternating electrochemical deposition of PB and N iH CF results in the
formation of bilayers is questionable. The presented re sults are reflecting individual AFM -
SECM probes, at th is st age, no quantitative conclusion could b e drawn. The investiga tion o f

- 63 -

27 of 31 PB/N iHCF-modified AFM- SECM probes showed no H 2 O 2 sensitivity or any st able
behavior in H 2 O 2 detection if this is related to h andling issues (e.g., electrical discharge , etc.)
or insufficient stability of the deposited layers cou ld not be clarified .

Localized detection of H 2 O 2 by AFM-SECM
For t he first AFM-SECM meas urements, t he ori ginal deposition pr otocol as p ublished by
Komkova et al. 20 was u se d resulting in a PB/NiHCF- modified AFM- SECM probe with complete
coverage of the pyramidal AFM ti p . In t his investigation, no localized signal was exp ected t o
reflect the si ze of an electrode as a model sample during H 2 O 2 generation by an applied
potential. There fore, the PB/NiHCF-mod ifie d AFM-SECM p robe was used for imaging the H 2 O 2
evolution at a Pt/C-modified Pt UME biased at – 0.5 V vs. quasi-Ag/ AgCl reference electrode,
which is sufficient to generate H 2 O 2 234 . The mo rphology was detected i n AFM contact mode
and th e generated H 2 O 2 in SECM generation/collection mode (Figure 37 B, D , and F). Control
experiments were performed at a sample bias of 0 V vs. Ag/AgCl quasi - reference electrode,
which is not sufficient for H 2 O 2 gen eration (Figu re 37 A, C and E). The current signal in Figu re
37 F recor ded b y the PB/NiHCF-mo dified, tip-integrated electrode clearly sh ows a respo nse to
H 2 O 2 generated at the UME. Even a difference between the original electrode area and the
overlapping Pt/C composite could be detected.

- 64 -

AFM -SECM image s record ed at an UME with a PB/NiHCF- modified AFM -SECM pro be ; setup
according to the schemes depicted in (A) and (B): topograp hy (C, D) and corre sponding tip current
(E, F) recorded at th e AFM -SECM probe with a s ample b ias of 0 V (E) and – 0.5 V (F) v s. Ag/AgCl
quasi-reference electrode, res pectively, and a tip bias at 0 V vs. Ag/AgCl quasi -reference e lectrode
in both measurements. Origin al size: 54 x 54 µm 2 , scan rate: 0.2 ln/s (10 .9 µm/s).

- 65 -

Although the used AFM- SECM probe was completely covere d with H 2 O 2 -active PB/NiHCF
bilayers (as sh own in Fig ure 31 A, B ), still localized information could b e obtained, as the signal
of the H 2 O 2 red uction ma inly results fro m t he film at or close to the AFM -integrated electrode
surface. This b ecomes more obvious in the 3D representation of the AFM topography overlaid
with the current signal as shown in Figure 38.

3D representa tion of the re sults sho wn in Figu re 37. The cu rrent signal o f H 2 O 2 reduction detected
at a PB/NiHCF- modified AFM -SECM p robe (A) and AFM to p ography (B).
In addition, the H 2 O 2 -sensitive PB/NiHCF bilayers may also h ave been remo ved during
previous scan s or calibrations, which would also explain that t here are no obvious artifact s in
the topography visible. Th e H 2 O 2 conversion is predominantly located at PB/NiHCF bilayers
deposited onto the AFM tip- integrated microe lectrode. Nevertheless, for investigations of
unknown sample m orphology and/or s patially he terogenous H 2 O 2 release , the H 2 O 2 se nsing
layer should b e well defined and confined to the electrode surface. Although the current signal
was stable during 5 consecutive AFM scans, partial dissolution of the PB/NiHCF film du ring
measurements might lead to a f alse interpretation of the det ected current signals for
unknown samples.

- 66 -

To exclude electrochemical activity in the absenc e of the PB/NiHCF bilayers an d any crosstalk
between the c urrent signal and the topography det ected simu ltaneously by AFM -SECM, an
unmodified AFM-SECM probe was us ed addition ally as shown in Figure 39. As expected, n o
current response related to H 2 O 2 consumption could be detected b y the unmodified AFM -
SECM probe.

AFM -SECM image of an UME recorded with an unmodified AFM- SECM pro be; s et-up acco rding to
the scheme depicted in (A ): Topography (B) and correspon ding tip current (C) recor ded at a n
unmodified AFM -SECM probe with the s ample bias ed at – 0.5 V v s. Ag/AgCl quasi-reference
electrode and with a n AFM -SECM p robe bias of 0 V vs. Ag/AgCl qu asi -reference electro de. Original
size: 46 x 46 µm 2 , scan rate: 0. 25 ln/s (11.4 µ m/s).

- 67 -

Conclusion and outlook
Within this section, PB/NiH CF-mod ified UMEs and AFM -SECM probes for H 2 O 2 d etection have
been investigated. Thereby, significant influenc es of parameters used for the fabrication of
AFM -SECM probes have been identified, namely the influe nce of vacuum c ondit ions, UV light
and Pt/C composite as supporting electrode material. In general, no negative effect of all these
parameters co uld b e detected . In contrast, a significantly improve d st ability an d sensitivi ty for
the detection of H 2 O 2 was achieved. Preliminary experiments for mapping localized H 2 O 2
evolution at an UME using a PB/NiHCF-modified AFM -SECM probe are presented. Althou gh
the used AFM -SECM probe was completely covered with PB/NiHCF bilayers, a localized
detection of H 2 O 2 could be shown. This can be explained that only the PB/NiHCF-covered tip-
integrated el ectrode area close to the sample surface contribu ted predominantly to the
recorded signal. Addit io nally, a change in the morphology of the PB/NiHCF film, as shown in
4.3.1 for the modificatio n of UMEs, might resul t in that the non - electrod e areas cover ed by
PB/NiHCF film are not significantly c ontributing to the overall signal. To avoid the coverage of
the c omplete tip, AFM-SECM investigations h ave t o be repeat ed w ith o ptimized parameters
for the electro chemical d eposition of PB/N iHCF b ilayers reported within this section . The
bilayer-modified probes, either UMEs or AFM tip -integrated ele ctrodes, showed a good
response t o H 2 O 2 with enhanced stability compared to PB as electrocatalytic layer for H 2 O 2
reduction . A reduced concentration and number of d eposited PB/NiHCF bilayers u sed for the
modification of AFM tip -integrated ele ctro des showed a reduce d amount of PB/NiHCF locat ed
on the AFM- SECM p robe as detected by SEM, but H 2 O 2 calibrations showed enh anced
sensitivity for H 2 O 2 . However, the reproducibility with respect to AFM -SECM probe
modification needs to be improved i n future experiments . C haracterization of individ ual
PB/NiHCF-modified AFM-SECM probes s howed additionally n o comparable behavior and n o
correlation between the redox signals with in cycli ng in 0.1 M HCl/ 0.1 M KCl for ac tivation of
the PB/NiHCF bilayers an d the actual sensitivity toward s H 2 O 2 . All investigations of the
PB/NiHCF bilayers by AFM -SECM, SEM, EDX, optical microscopy and electrochemical
measurements led to t he con clusion that the f ormation of bilayers by alternating
electrochemical deposition of PB and N iHCF c ould not be confirmed, b ut rather the f ormation
of a homoge neous PB/NiHC F film w ith vary ing thicknesses in rela tion to the am ount of
deposited PB and NiHCF is mos t likely. Fu rther investigati ons w ith r espect to the actual
composition of PB/N iHCF-mixed layers are needed in future. With a detailed investigation of

- 68 -

the mixed f ilms, the modification of AFM-SECM pr obes can be optimized and a h igher yi eld of
PB/NiHCF-modified sensors with appropriate p erformance in H 2 O 2 sensing can be gained.

- 69 -

AF M tip -in tegr a ted pH s ens ors
Introduction
The miniaturiza tion of pH sensors is essential for localiz ed pH m easurements and enables
research of metabolic or signaling pr ocesses i n biomedical related researc h f or examp le
mapping changes of p H at t he cell level 21 , as well as the detection of loca lized corrosion
processes 22 . Th erefore, the sensor material ha s to be biocompat ible, mechanically
resistant and th e pH sensor has to be miniaturize d 45 . The most common pH sen sor is the
pH -sensitive glass electrode . C arter et al. 235 used a glass microelec trode for t he stud y of
corrosion processes. For th e investigation of biologi cal samp les, P. C. Caldwell used a glass
microelectrode for intracellular pH sensing at muscle fibers of crabs 236 and at a giant squi d
axon 237 . Next to pH- sensitive glass electrodes, m etal/metal oxides were w idely used for
pH detection d urin g the l ast century 45 , 238 . A range of suitable me tal/metal oxides, such a s
RuO 2 239 , WO 3 240 , and most important irid ium oxide 62 and the antimony/antimony
oxide 23 , 24 electrode, h ave been investigated so f ar and su ccessfully applied for pH
monitoring in biological resear ch. For example, intracellular investigation of the giant
squid axon wit h a 1 µm antimony electrode 241 and in ex tracellular investigations o f
endothelial cells 242 and carbonic anhydrase located at t he brain 243 have been
demonstrated . SECM is highly suitable for the localized detection of changes in
electrochemical signals at a surface and potentiometric measurements combined with
SECM were also s uccessfully sh own 244 – 246 . Mirkin and co-work ers investigated pH chan ges
around human b reast epithelial cells with a 7 µm Sb UME 247 . The investigation of corrosion
processes by SECM has bee n reviewed by Niu et al. 248 . For the detection of the oxygen
reduction reaction and corresponding pH changes due t o corrosion of metal or metal alloy
surfaces, Sb 22 , Ir oxide particles 249 or h y drogen ionophore liquid membranes 250 in
combination with SECM have been used so far. Although SECM is highly su itable for
mapping local changes in electrochemical signals, typically it is challeng ing t o obtain
simultaneously topogr aphical information of t he investigated sample. This gap can be
closed by the combination of SECM with other surface sen sitive techniques, e.g. with
scanning vibrating electrode technique (SV ET) 251,252 an d SICM 253 for pH mappin g. pH
measurements in close vicinity to the area of interest with h igh spatial resolution may

- 70 -

further provide in formation on t he reactio n mechanism, the r ate of r eaction or th e
involved species itself. The combination of a pH -sensitive electrode inte grated in to an
AFM p robe may enable the local detection of pH chan ges sim ultaneou s w ith chan ges in
topography. Although the metal/metal oxid e pH sensors have b een used in a broad variety
of applications, i nsufficient stability was reported, e.g. for the iridium oxide electrodes,
and different oxidation states of the iridi um oxide or different fabrication s chemes of the
active films showed a distribut ion of p H sensitivities of 82 – 92 mV/pH 27 , 62 – 74 mV/pH 61 ,
or 59 - 77 mV/pH 45 . Additionally, decreasing p H sensitivi ty in consecutive calibrat ions w as
also observed for i ridium oxide electrodes 49 . How ever, n o statistical d ata are available in
literature and most of the publications present investigations in respect to individual
sensors, which will be al so discussed in the f ollowing sections. Within this thesis, Ir and
Sb – modified AFM- SECM p robes are investigat ed as pH sensors and the performance of
the modified AFM-SECM probes is investigated by monitoring the dissolution of calcite
crystals. Unwin and co -workers investigat ed the d issolution of calcite using a p latinized
Si x N y AFM cantilever to reduce the pH value t o more acidic pH values , whi ch accelerates
the crystal dissolution 148 . Fu rthermore, the electrochemical deposition of EIROF on to AFM
tip – integrated Au and Pt/C – modified Au microelectrodes is evaluated within the follo wing
chapter and investigated at Au and P t/C – modified Au UM Es.

- 71 -

Experimental
Ultrapure water (18.2 M  , ELGA LabWater, Veolia Water Solutions & Te chnologies) was
used for the preparation of all solutions. For Ir -modified AFM probes and iridium oxide
modified U MEs, CV s in de-aerated 0.5 M H 2 SO 4 (from 98 %, VWR Chemicals) in a po tential
range of - 0.45 V to 0.75 vs. Hg/HgSO 4 reference electrode (sat. K 2 SO 4 , CH Instruments) a t
a scan rat e of 1 V/ s was used to activate t he iridium oxide film ( Figure 40 A) p rior to pH
calibration.

CV (A ) in 0.5 M H 2 SO 4 vs. Hg /HgSO 4 referenc e electrode, showing the 1 st (black) and the last
(blue) CV of in sum 500 cycles. Scan rate: 1 V/s . OCP m easurement (B) in 0.05 M TRI S buffer
with corre spondin g pH valu es determined by a pH gla ss electro de at ro om t emperature after
addition of HCl and N aOH, respectively .
OCP measure ments (Figure 40 B) vs. Ag/ AgCl reference electrode (sat. KCl, RE -1CP, ALS
Co) were done in 0.05 M TRIS buffered solution (pH 6.96, tris(hydroxymethyl)-
aminomethane, Mer ck KGaA) within a pH range of 2 – 11 u sing a (bi)potentiostat
(CHI660A and CHI660C, CH Instruments). The pH values w ere adjusted by addition of 5 M
HCl (from 30 % HCl, Normapure, VWR Internatio nal GmbH) or 0.5 M NaOH (Merck KGaA),
respectively. A comp lete exchan ge of different buffered sol utio ns took s everal minutes,
which imp edes proper d etection of the response time o f the pH sensor towards p H
changes. Therefore, the pH calibration was done by con secutive addi tion of aliquots of
HCl or NaOH, re spectivel y. Af ter mixing the s olution, a pH glass electrode (InLab ® Expe rt
pro, Mettler-Toledo Intl. Inc.) with an int egrated temperature sen sor was used t o
determine the p H values of the buffered solutions. Th e pH calibrations were done at room
temperature with small f luctuations of 1 – 2 °C du ring meas urements. A simultaneous
detection of the pH with the pH glass el ectrode during OCP measureme nts in the same

- 72 -

solution was not p ossible due t o strong i nterfere nces in the d etected OC P signal b y t he
glass electrode (see Figure 41 ).

Influence of the p H glass elect rode towards the OCP signal o f an Ir /IrOx – modified AFM pr obe .
OCP me asure ment in 0.05 M TRIS buffer at pH 2.5. The pH glass ele ctrod e w as kept within the
liquid cell in th e Faraday ca ge and was turned o n/off as labeled with in the graph .
Different AF M tip- integrated p H se nsors w ere inv estigated within this thesis, w hich w ere
fabricated by former co- workers of Mizaikoff an d Kranz. AFM probes modified with a pH -
sensitive Sb layer were fabricated by Jong Seok Moon 188 . Briefly, a commercial Si x N y AFM
cantilever was mod ifie d with a t hin Ti adhesion layer and an Au layer (100 n m) with a DC
sputter coater, followed by the deposition of Sb at the AFM tip with varying thicknesses
(35 - 225 nm) by an RF sputter system. Afterward, t he AFM-SECM probes were in sulated
by PECVD with Si x N y and SiO 2 . An active pH -sensitive electrode and a defined AFM tip were
exposed by FIB milling (Quanta 3D FEG, ThermoFisher Scientific) as reported in section
4.2. AFM-SECM probes were batch-fab ricated by Heungjoo Shin 254 und modified with Ir.
Silicon cantilevers were mod ified with a th in P t layer and an Ir layer with a thickness of
300 - 40 0 n m. After the re lease of the cantilevers, ad ditional deposition is re quired t o
compensate stress in order to use such probes for AFM measurements.

- 73 -

SEM of Ir (A , C) and Sb ( B, D) modified AFM probes. The whole AFM tip shown in (A) was cut
by FIB milling to expos e all components of the Ir – mod ified AF M tip (labeled in C). The
electrode area of an insulate d Sb – mod ified AFM probe ( B) was also e xposed by FIB milling.
The Sb layer deposited on Au is labeled in (D). Acc eleration voltage: 3 kV,10 pA (Ir)/ 20 pA ( Sb).
The different geometries of the A FM tip -integrated pH sensors are summarized in Figure
42 . Prior to the cali bration of the AF M tip - i ntegrated p H sensors, the AFM -SECM p robes
were mounted onto an AFM n osecone or an i nsert usin g UV glue (Dyma x 9001- E-V3.1 or
DYMAX 42 5, Dymax Eu rope Gmb H). Electroc hemical deposition of iridium oxide film
electrodes was done according to Yamanaka et al. 255 . 71.3 mg/50mL iridium(I V) oxide (Alfa
Aesar GmbH & Co. KG) was stirred for 30 min, followed by the a ddition of 0.5 mL H 2 O 2
(30%, Merck KGaA). After 10 min stirring, 208.2 mg anhydrous oxalic aci d (Fluka Chemie
GmbH) w as a dd ed to the sol ution. T he pH was adjusted t o 10.5 by the addition of KCO 3
(Merck KGaA). After storing the solution for t hr ee d ays, th e solut ion was purged with
argon f or 30 min prior to electrochemical deposition . Au wires (diameter: 10 µm,
Goodfellows) were used as electrodes fabricated as described elsewhere 65,226 . Some Au
electrodes were additionally mo dified with a Pt/C composite by IBID (precursor: methyl -
cyclopentadienyl-trimethyl platinum, ThermoFisher Scien tific) with respect to th e EIROF

- 74 -

modification of AFM tip-int egrated pH sensors. AFM-SECM probes were prepared based
on the procedures as already reported 1 33 and described in section 4.2. Th e AFM tip –
integrated Au electrode was modified with Pt/C via IBID . 5 mM [Ru (NH 3 ) 6 ]Cl 3 (98 %,
Aldrich) in 0.1 M KCl (Merck KGaA) and 5 mM 1,1’ -ferrocenedimethanole (98 %, Acros
Organics) in 10% ethanol ( from 96 %, VWR Chemicals) and 0.1 M KCl (Merck KGaA) were
used to determine the electroactive ele ctrode surface of t he UMEs and the AFM -SECM
probes prior to electroc hemical modification with EIROF. pH -active iridi um oxid e films
were deposited u sing a (bi)p otentiostat. D ifferent depositio n techniques were evaluated
as summarized in Table 5.

deposition parameters

constant current

0.2 nA for 300 s

constant potential

0.75 V vs. Ag/AgCl for 300 s

CV

- 0.45 V - + 0.7 vs. Ag/Ag Cl, scan rates: 1- 10 V/s,
20 - 500 cycles

pulsed potential

E 1 = 0.75 V, E 2 = -0.45 V for 0.25 s, respective ly;
number of cycles: 25 -250

Table 5 Summary of deposition techniques with corresponding d eposition parameter s u sed for
the EIROF formation , by CV , at a constant current, and a t constant or pulsed po tentials.
The m odified UMEs were investigated after electrochemical deposition b y optical
microscopy (AXIO Imager .M1m, Zeiss), SEM (Q uanta 3D FEG, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and
contact mode AFM (55 00 AFM/SPM microsco pe, Keysight Tech nologies) with silicon
nitride tip s (OTR-P, Olympus). All AFM images and correlating height and current p rofiles
were processed by Pico View (Keysight Technologies) or Gw yddion 225 . AFM-SECM
measurements were done in contact mode A FM detecting the dissolution of calcite and
the local associated pH changes by OCP measurements using a bipotentiostat (CHI842B,
CH Instru ment). The OCP outp ut signal of the bipotentiostat was f ed to an AD channel of
the AFM controller for correlating the potentiometric data with the topographical image.

- 75 -

Prior to AFM-SECM investigations in TRIS buffered solution, the calcite sample was imaged
in air in AFM contact mod e to locate single calcite crystals. Calcite crystals were
synthesized by the ammonia diffusion method fr om dissolved CaCl 2 (95 %, Carl Roth) and
(NH 4 ) 2 CO 3 (Me rck KGaA ) under N H 3 – saturated atmosphere 256 . T he calcite crystals were
embedded in Crystalbond ( 509, Plano) a nd parti ally polished with Al 2 O 3 susp ension (5 0
nm, MasterPrep, Buehler ).

Results and discussion
In the following section, resu lts of AFM -SECM probes modified with either an Ir or Sb
metal layer are p resente d by p H calibrations i n 5. 3.1 . Due to a limited n umber of available
AFM -SECM p robes modified with an Ir or Sb metal layer, respectively, the following results
might b e interpreted as first investigations sh owing the suitability of these AFM tip -
integrated pH s ensor s, but also in detection of localized pH c hanges, exemplarily shown
by AFM-SECM investigations of the d issolution of calcite crystals in 5.3.2 . The fabrication
of such modified AF M-SECM probes resu lted i n st rong be nding of the AF M c antilever due
to intrinsic stress du ring sputteri ng of the e.g. Ir metal layer 254 . A limited number of Sb or
Ir coated probes were available for co mbined measurements in the time frame of this
thesis showing a can tilever bending o f 1 – 2°. AFM cantilevers with more bending were
used i n OCP measurements f or pH calibrations in bulk experiments. Additionally, EIROF -
modified microe lectro des were t ested in consecutive pH calibrations at UMEs (diameter :
10 µm), as presented in 5 .3.3, as alternative f abric ation s trategy of a pH sensor integrated
into AFM probes.

- 76 -

AFM tip-integrated pH sensors
After insulation of the AFM probes and exposure of an ac tive electrode area b y FIB milling
as described in section 4.2, the pH se nsitivity and linearity was investigated performing
calibrations. The AFM p robes with an integrated pH – sensitive AIROF electro de showe d
a sta ble pH response in long-term measurement s (Figure 43 ) wit hin consec utive
calibrations. The pH response for th e exemplarily pre sented pH sensor was 54.3 mV/pH,
whereas a p H re sponse of 65.4 mV/pH - also referred to as super-Nernstian b ehavior
reported f or AIROF electrodes 45 - could be determined in the buffered r egion s hown in
the zoomed graph in Figure 43. The linearity of the calibration graphs is in an acceptabl e
range (inlaid table in Figure 43) t o investigate qualitative p H changes, localized at a sample
surface in following AFM-SECM investigations.

OCP vs. Ag/ AgCl referenc e electrode of an AIRO F-modified AFM prob e in 0.05 M TRIS b uffer
detecting pH changes b y ad dition of either 5 M HCl or 0.5 M NaO H, respectively. The tab le
summarize s the sensitivity and lin earity of the whole calibrat ion experiment an d the b uffered
region shown in th e zoomed extra ct.

- 77 -

Exemplarily, the results f or 4 consecutive calibrations of one Ir -modified AFM -SECM
probe are shown i n Figure 44, pH sensitivity and linearity are give n in the imp lemente d
table for the different calibrations. The result s reveal that th e OCP signal show ed a more
linear behavior with a h igh r ecovery within con secutive calibrations for neu tral to alkal ine
pH values, whereas the d istribution of the detected p otentials was increased in the acidi c
pH ran ge. This h as been alre ady reported for AIROF ele ctrodes showing a varying p H
response with different pH sensitivities in correla tion to the measured pH val ues 257 .

Calibration of an AIROF -modified AFM -SECM probe: Lin ear regre ssions of 4 consecutive pH
calibrations with sensiti vity and linearity given in the implemented table labeled by the
respective colors. Th e 3 rd calib ration is n ot shown due to i nsufficient stability (see also F igure
45 ).
The OCP measu rement for th e third and the fourth calibration of this AIROF -modified
AFM -SECM prob e is p resented in Figure 45 . In contrast to Sb – modified electrodes, the
iridium oxide f ilm can b e regenerated a nd pH se nsitivity and lineari ty can be recove red by
cycling in H 2 SO 4 . In Figure 4 5, t he OCP meas urements recorded wit h an AIROF -mo dified
AFM probe ar e shown bef ore and after the regeneration of the active ir idium oxid e film,
demonstrating the great ad vantage of Ir over S b. The p resented results here correspo nd

- 78 -

to o ne AF M-SECM pro be tested in consecutive pH calibrations due t o a limi ted number o f
available AFM-SECM probes. Limitatio ns accordin g to available AFM-SECM probes were
also a problem for Sb-modified AFM- SECM pro bes.

Regeneration of AIROF electrodes: O CP vs. Ag/AgCl r eferen ce electrod e in 0.05 M TRIS b uffer
detecting pH changes b y addition of either 5 M HCl or 0.5 M NaOH, re spective ly, bef ore (A)
and after (B ) cycling in 0.5 M H 2 SO 4 . Th e linear regression of t he re sults shown in (B) is depic ted
in Figure 44 as ca libration 4 (red).

- 79 -

Individual probes could be tested i n pH calibrations, as exem plarily depicted in Figure 46 ,
showing two OCP mea surements with correlati ng pH values of the buffered solution
detected with a 10 0 nm Sb-mo dified AFM pr obe in a short (A) and a long-t erm (B )
calibration, The results sh ow a fast an d stable pH respon se up to 300s (A) a nd being linear
over severa l minutes at the same time (B). Th e pH sen sitivity was 50.3 (A) and 55.9 (B)
mV/pH, respectively, whereas the linearity i n the OC P measurements was 99 % (A) an d
97 % (B).

OCP vs. Ag/AgCl re ference el ectrode in 0.05 M TRIS b uffer detecting p H changes by addition
of either 5 M H Cl or 0.5 M NaOH, respectively. The change in short time s cales (A) and stab ility
within long time measuremen ts (B) were investigat ed.
However, on ly a small percentage of available potentiometric Sb AFM - SECM sensors
showed a measurable pH response, whic h may b e associated with the long storage time
(approx. 4 years) under ambient conditions . Additionally, some sensors showed a strong
surface ch ange after OCP measurements as depicted in Figu re 47 B an d C. It seems that
the Sb layer u ndergoes s ome dissolution process and sprea d as small p arti cles around the
actual electrode area, which may be associated with the complete oxidation of t he Sb
layer during the long sto rage time. The Au layer is still visible and the in -plane area of the
Au can be identified as the f rame in the zoomed SE image in C, whereas the pyramidal
shape of th e Au modified AFM tip became visible in the surroundin g region formerly
covered by t he Sb layer. In case of Sb – modified A FM-SECM probes, b oth met al layers (Au
and S b) are exposed and connected within an electrolyte s olution resulting in a ga lvanic
couple and, therefore, in th e dissolution of S b as the less nob le metal. Loca lized corrosion
and the adjoin ing r emoval of the Sb film because of impurities on the Sb electrodes was

- 80 -

SEM image s of a Sb-modi fied AFM - SECM probe before ( A) an d after (B) calibration. T he
zoomed region (C) s ho ws th e removal of th e Sb layer. Acceleration voltage: 5 kV, 27 pA (A) /47
pA (B, C).
already reported, whereas these impurities were not specified 52 . However, prior studies
using these Sb-modified AFM - SECM probes didn’ t show t h is behavior 188 . T o elimi nate a ny
possible dissolution of the Sb metal layer b y forming a galvan ic cou ple, t he deposition of
Sb should be limited to the AFM tip and p art of the cant ilever, whereas Au as an elec tronic
connection layer might be just deposited onto the AFM chi p and cantilever 188 . Another
possibility would be the exposu re of an electrode area next to the pyramidal AFM tip,
exposed by FIB milling in a top-down a pproach. Thereby, ju st the Sb meta l deposited on
top of Au is exposed. The SECM signal is t hen sh ifted towards the topograp hical
information with respect on the distance between the AFM tip and the electrode area
located close to the AFM tip. These investigations were not the focus of this t hesis.

Investigation of calcite dissolution by AFM-SECM
First AFM-SECM measurements were c onducted with S b- and AIR OF-modified AF M- SECM
probes. Changes in the OCP detected b y the AFM t ip -integrated pH sensor were
interpreted just qualit ati vely according to the obtained results in section 5.3.1. Prior t o
AFM -SECM investigations, t he p H sensors were test ed towards their pH sensitiv i ty to
guarantee a change in the OCP signal to more negative potenti als f or more alkaline pH
values. As a model system, t he dissolution of calc ite was imaged with the AFM- SECM pH

- 81 -

sensors. Calcite is dissolved in aqueous solution by characteristic surface changes showing
rhombohedral e tch pits due to d issolution 28 . Add itionally, the dissolution process results
in a pH change to more alkaline p H values 29 . The reby both, a surface change an d a p H
change sh ould b e detectable by the AFM-SECM probes . Similar in vestigations were
published by Unwin and coworkers 253 , detecting the dissolution of a calci te crystal with
an edge length of approximately 25 µm by SECM-SICM revealing limited t opographical
information. In Figure 4 8, the r esults for the AFM- SECM in vestigations with an AFM tip -
integrated Sb electrode are shown. The electrode area is located next to t he actual AFM
tip as depicted in the SE images i n A - C. In the AFM deflection and topography images
shown in D and E, the change in morphology of the calcite crystal is clearly vi sible revealing

AFM -SECM measure ment of the dis solution of calcite u sing an AFM tip -integrat ed Sb
electrode: SEM images o f the used AFM -SECM pro be in sid e view (A) and 52° t ilted (B), wi th a
zoomed view to the a ctual electrod e area with an edge l ength of 189 nm (C). Accelera tion

- 82 -

voltage: 3 kV, 43 pA. AFM deflection (D) and topography ( E) recorded in AFM con tact mode
and correlating poten tial chan ges d etected b y OCP v s. Ag/AgCl quasi- reference el ectrod e (F).
Original size: 80 x 80 µm 2 , scan rate: 0.1 ln/s (16 µ m/s).
the characteristic pit s tructures. Th e potential c hanges during AFM sc annin g are depicted
in Figure 48 F showing low er potential values compared to regions without calcite, which
correlate to a p H change toward s more alkaline pH values. The lateral r esolution in Figure
48 F is insufficie nt within the single li ne scans ( x-direction ), w hereas a change in signals is
localized with respect to t he sca n directio n (marked b y an arrow in Fig ure 48 , y-direction).
Same investigations were repeated with AFM- SE CM probes with tip-integrated AIROF pH
sensors. One AFM -SECM investigation is exem plarily shown in Fig ure 49. Thereby, a
smaller calcite crystal (approx. 2-8 µm in length), compared to the one depicted in Figure
48 , was mapped u sing th e maximum sca n range o f the piezoe l ectric positioner in case the
missing lateral resolution is correlated to convection effects of the moving tip. Althou g h
the Ir e lectrode ar ea in tegrated i nto t he AF M pr obe is large with an oute r diameter of the
ring electrode o f 3.6 µm, the resol ution in th e scan direct ion (y-direction) w as su fficient
to detect localized pH c hanges re lated to the dissolution of calcite. However, no laterally
resolved information on pH change in x-direction w as observed. The height and potential
profiles at the marke d position s in E and D of Figure 49 are clearly showing a potential
change towards lower potentials correlating with a higher pH value at the position of t he
calcite crystal with an elevated topography visible comp ared to the surro unding su rface,
in which the calci te crys tal was e mbedded. Nevertheless, the change in the potential is
still s pread over t he wh ole dis tance i n x-direction l acking late ral informatio n in the r egion
of the calci te crystal. This broadening of the OCP signal seems to be ab sent in the y -
direction, which indicat es that the lack of resolution is not associated with the actual
electrode size .

- 83 -

AFM -SECM ima ging of the calc ite dissolution with a tip-integrated AIROF el ectrode: SEM image
of the u sed AFM -SECM prob e with a ring electrode with an inn er diameter of 2.9 7 µm (o uter
diameter = 3.64 µ m, A). Acceleration voltage: 3 kV, 10 pA. AFM deflection (B) and topography
(C) dete cted in AFM conta ct mode with corre lating poten tial changes detected b y OCP vs.
Ag/AgCl quasi-refer ence electrode (D). The actu al, expose d calcite crystal is marked by a white
dotted circle in ( B) embedded in crystal b ond. The pro files of the top ography and O CP at th e
marked region in (C) an d (D ), respectively, are given belo w. Original size : 90 x 79 µm 2 , scan
rate: 0.14 ln/s (25 µ m/s).

The AFM-SECM measurement shown in Figure 49 is analyzed in d etail in the following
figures. I n Figure 50 , t he chan ge in the detect ed OCP signal extracted as single line scans
(x -direction) is evalu ated in de tail. There by, the onset of a decreasing p otential correlated

- 84 -

to the more alkaline pH value in close pro ximity to the calcite crys tal can b e seen i n the
first potential profile depicted in B and labeled with 1. This data corresponds to t he d ashed
white line (1) in the AFM t opography imag e shown in A. Line (2) corresponds t o the las t
extracted profile as marked in Figure 50 A, indicating the actual location of t he calcite
crystal. This position is also marked in the corres ponding heightprofile (labeled with an
arrow, 2 in B). Thereby, the onset of the detectable p otential change is shifted by
approximately 7.3 µm, re presenting t he distance between t he dashed w hite li nes 1 an d 2
in (A). The minimum value for t he OCP signal represents a change of a pprox. 3 mV in an
area of 20 µm in t he x- direction (dashed lines) shown in the profile in (C) corresponding
to the OCP signal in the 3D represe ntation in (B) as indicated by a blue arrow .

Response tim e o f the OCP sig nal correlated to the loca tion of the calcite crystal: Single height
profiles as labeled by white d ashed line s in the AFM topog raphy (A) for th e fir st (1) and the
last (2) extracted profiles ar e comp ared to correspondin g changes of th e OCP at same p ositions
(B). The scan direction (y-directio n) is labeled by a black d ashed arrow (in A and B) and the
location of the crystal is indicated b y an arrow in (B). Dat a correspond to the results shown in
Figure 49.

- 85 -

The detailed evaluation of the response time w ith re spect to the sca n dir ection (y-
direction) is shown in Figure 51 . At the position m arked by a white dotted line in the OCP
image in A, t he h eightprofile in B and the OCP profile vs. d istance shown in D are extracted.
Additionally, the det ecte d OCP signal vs. t ime as recorde d b y t he external bipotentiostat
is shown in C . Indeed, the profiles in C a nd D are almost identical, i ndicating no resol ution
in x- di rection during the detected resu lts. The onset of the changing potential towards
more negative potentials correlating with a mo re alkaline pH is shi fted towards the
location of the calcite crystal by 7 .3 µm. This larg est potential change recorded du ring 2-
3 µm (in y -direction) is approximately 10 mV followed by an i ncreasing potential leveling
to the background response in betwee n a distance of 10 µm in the y-direction.

Evaluation of the response time in AFM scan direction (y -direction): Extracted pro file s at the
location marked b y a dashed white line in the OCP signal (A) showing th e potential chan ges in
scan d irection (ind icated by a black, dashed arrow). The height profile (B) with the loca tion of
the act ual calcite crystal marked by an arro w is compare d to th e OCP signal vs. time dete cted
by the external b ipotentio stat (C) and the OCP change vs. distance (D) as extracted from the
OCP image in (A). Data corr espond to the results shown in Figure 49.

- 86 -

In comparison, the obtained results reported by Unwin a nd coworkers 253 for SECM -SICM
investigations us ing an AIROF-modified nanoelectrode, show that the detected OCP signal
is increased compared to the actual size of the calcite crystal by the factor 2 -3 or by a
factor of 1.5 – 2 comp ared t o a simulated potential shift according to the pH distribution
above the calcite crys tal. Whereas in this pub lication, the p H sensor had a dim ension of
100 nm and additionally, the calcite dissolutio n was recorded in the SECM hopping mode
recording single positions of the SECM-SICM probe along t he x,y -direction without la teral
scanning. The det ected potential changes were record ed in a distance of approximately
100 nm toward s th e calcite crystal. Compared to this investigation, the obt ained result
shown in Figure 49 to Figure 51 is in a comparable range. The distance between the AIROF-
modified el ectrode and the sample surface was in the range of 1 µm as defined b y the
length of the reshaped AFM tip, which also in dicates a broadened signal due to enhanced
diffusion. Indeed, the enlarged AIRO F sensor used in the presen ted results in com parison
to the nanoelectrode used by Unwin and coworkers 253 showed an enhanced resolution
with respect to the scan directi on (y -direction). This can be definitively interpre ted as a
positive trend for f urther investigations with AIROF -mod ified AFM-SECM probes.
However, t he resolu tion in the x -direction or the direction of single line sc ans has t o be
improved for future st udies. In the AFM-SECM measurement shown in the previous
figures, the resolution was 512 x 51 2 p ixel, representing a line scan every 0.17 µm. With
the scan speed of 0.14 ln/s (25 µm/s) one line wa s recorded in approximat ely 7 s an d the
area m arked by t he white dashed lines 1 a n d 2 in Figure 50 wit h the distance of 7.3 µ m
represent 43 lines, which were recorded in 5 min. This also correla tes to the OC P sig nal
detected by the external bipotentiostat showing a c hange in th e potential i n a durat ion of
7 min. Wipf and cowor kers reported an optimal re sponse t ime of < 10 s for AIROF
microelectrodes 249 , wher eas for EIR OF-mod ified electrodes, detected i n a potentiometric
time- of -flight exper iment, the response t ime was det ermined as s everal t enths of seconds
in relation t o t he thickness of deposited EIROF 258 . Thereby, t he detected insuf ficient pH
response in the x-direction of the single line scans migh t be indeed re late d to a scan speed,
which is too fas t for detec ting an a dequate pH ch ange . Similar AFM-SECM measurements
with comparable Ir and Sb - modified AFM- SECM probes with only small d eviation in
electrode size were used with varying AFM scan s peed and scan si ze, resulting always in
insufficient resolution in the x-direction (results are not shown). One exp lanation for t he

- 87 -

lack in resolution may be additionally t he mentioned convective e ffects of t he scannin g
AFM probe. This effect should b e strong for high scan speeds, whereas , during slow
scanning, convection should be negligible.

Electrochemical depositio n of iridium oxide film electrodes
Both, Ir- and Sb-derived p H active layers showed a broad distribution in pH sensitivity . I n
addition, bending of the cantilever might be an i ssue for the fabrication of such p robes
due to intrinsic st ress during sputtering of Ir t hat requires additional microfabrication
steps. Hence, the electrochemical deposition of pH -sen sitive material onto the AFM tip
integrated Au electrode was in vestigated. EIROF was deposited by d ifferent
electrochemical techniques (see Tab le 5 in 5.2). The evaluation of optimized d eposition
parameters was tested with Au UMEs (dia meter: 10 µm) p rior t o the m odification of AFM-
SECM probes. Ad ditionally, the pH res ponse of EIROF el ectrodes deposited to Pt/C -
modified Au UMEs was evaluated . Pt/C composite was tested as the sub strate material
for EIROF pH sensors as the AFM tip -integrated Au frame ele ctro des ca n be incr eased by
an ad ditional Pt/C composite layer. This addi tional step results in an enh anced d eposition
of pH active iridium oxide, which is localized at a small electrode area bu t contains a
sufficient amount of ac tive pH ma terial f or stable p H response giv en the e nlarged sur face
area by Pt/C deposition compared to the 1 00 nm thin Au frame electrode .

EIROF deposition o n Au UMEs (diameter: 10 µm) modified with a 150 nm thin Pt/C co mposite
by IBID: AFM topography of t he modified UME (A) and corresponding height profiles (B) of the
bare Au UME (blu e), after modification via IBID (green) an d after EIROF d eposition by 100 pulse
cycles (red), record ed in AFM contact mode. Origina l size: 1 7 x 17 µm², scan speed: 0. 34 l n/s.

- 88 -

The first i nvestigations of the mo dification o f Au and Pt/C - modified Au UM Es were
evaluated by imagi ng the el ectrode surface by optical microscopy, SEM an d AFM to
guarantee a homogeneous deposition on the whole electrode area by a thin EIROF layer.
Figure 52 A shows the AFM topography of an A u UME (diameter: 1 0 µm) mo dified with
150 nm Pt/C layer via IBID, which is additionally mo dified with EIROF by applying 100
potential pulse cycles. The corresponding height profiles of the UME are shown in Figure
52 B after ea ch modification of the surface with the final height p rofile showin g the
surface after deposition of a t hin iridium oxid e f ilm (red). The EIROF deposition s b y CV and
multiple pulses showed the mos t satisfactory results and both t echniques were evaluated
in more detail b y chang ing deposition parameters. The pH response of the EIROF pH
sensors was tested in consecutive p H calibrations ( 2 – 4 calibrations depend ing on the
stability of t he individual sensors) comp aring d ifferent deposition c ycles for both
techniques . The r esults obtained for EIROF-modif ied UMEs with respect t o t he p H
response in consecutive calib rations and t he linea rity o f the obtained sig nals during these
calibrations are presented in Figu re 53 . In A, the sensitivity is compared for sensors
deposited via CV (shown in squares) and via multiple pulses (m arked b y crosses). The grey
bar represe nts t he s ensitivity rang e for neutral to alkaline pH values (> p H 6) for EIR OF-
modified sensors as re ported by Wipf et al. 257 . Only two ou t of 8 sensors, which are
compared in Figure 53, showed a respo nse to p H changes wit hin 4 consecutive
calibrations, whereas m ost of the o thers gave a stable response in two calibrations.
Indeed, t he li nearity for all presented pH sensors as shown in Figure 53 B , was insufficient
for q uantitative pH de tection. T he b lack dotted li ne i n B labels linearity of 90 % a nd the
majority of the results are below this linearity.

- 89 -

Sensitivity (A) an d linearity (B) of pH calibrations for 8 EIROF -modified UMEs (diam eter: 1 0
µm): The graphs r epresent results obta ined with Au and Pt/C - modi fied UMEs by EIROF
deposition via CV (square s in A an d solid b ars in B) an d via MP (crosses in A and dashed b ars
in B) with varying nu mbers of cy cles or p ulses. The dashed bar in (A) shows the s ensitivity range
reported by Wipf e t al. 257 , the dashed line in (B) marks linear ity of 90 %. Correspondin g data is
depicted in the same colors .

Similar t o the results presented in section 5.3.1 , the EIROF ele ctrodes showed a broad
distribution in pH sen sitivity. The stability and the linearity in bet we en consecutive
calibrations, but also for different tested se nsors, was unsatisfactory. The res ults of
consecutive pH calib rati on of exemplarily two EIROF- modified Au UMEs are presented in
Figure 54 . These results correspond to the t wo p H sensors sh own in Figure 53 with 4
consecutive calibrations. The quite large distribution measured with a singl e EIROF-
modified sensor is for the obtained OCP values approximately 200 mV at pH values of 6 –
8 in co nsecutive pH calibrations, for both, EIROF deposited via CV (A ) and multiple
potential pulses (B).

- 90 -

Calibration of EIROF-modifi ed Au U MEs (diameter: 10 µm), electrochemically depo sited by CV
(A) or by multiple potential puls es (B): Linear re gressions of 4 consecutive pH calibrations with
sensitivity and lin earity summ arized in th e tables below lab eled in correspond ing colors.
Similar results were also obt ained by other rese archers, e.g. by Wipf et al. with EIROF-
modified carbon fiber microe lectrodes 257 , by Marz ouk using d ifferent mm -sized
substrates as supporting material f or AEIROF sensors 63 , or by Elsen et al., who investigated
different deposition protocols for EIROF -modified gold microelectrodes 258 . In all of these
reported investigatio ns, ind ividual pH sensors were reported also s howing broad
distributions in pH sensi tivity betwee n individual sensors and no informa tion is given in
respect to long-term stability of th ese pH sensors. Alt hough d ifferent suppo rting electrode
materials or different sizes of t he modified electrodes a re presented in the described
examples above, a clear trend is recognizable. T he results obtained in this thesis with the
EIROF modif ication of either UMEs or AFM -SECM probes are in agreement with the
reported findings . The electrochemical deposition of EIROF was init ially investigated to
overcome limitations of AFM - SECM p robes with int egrated Sb or Ir metal layers as pH
sensor. But the res ults for EIROF-modified A u and Pt/C UMEs also show ed a broad
response in the range of 17 to 96 mV/pH wit h ins ufficient li nearity (Figure 53Figure 5 3 B) .
Nonetheless, first EIROF modif ication of AFM -SECM probes with gold frame el ectrodes

- 91 -

and electrodes additiona lly modified with P t/C c omposite via IBID w ere ele ctrochemically
modified by either CV or multiple poten tial pulses and characterized via calibration
experiments. Thereby, the re sponse t ime of the EIROF -mod ified AFM-SECM probes
towards pH changes i n TRI S buffered solution was investigated. The p H calibration c urves
obtained for 4 individual pH -sensitive AFM-SECM probes are summarized in the table
shown in Figure 55 . Again, a bro ad distributio n ranging f rom 37 to 91 mV/pH in pH
sensitivity f or d ifferent probes, similar to the results of EIROF – modified UMEs was
observed.

Calibration of EIROF -modif ied AFM-SECM probes, electro chemically deposited b y mul tiple
pulses (MP ) or CV on Au or Pt/C - modi fied Au AFM -SECM probes: Lin ear r egressions o f 4 pH
calibration graphs with sensitivity and linearity given in th e tab le in respect to electrochemical
deposition and substrate, are labeled in corre sponding colors.
No differences between either the electroch emical deposition technique nor the
underlying ele ctrode material for the iridium oxide f ilm showed prefera ble behavior in
stability, pH sen sitivity or linearity, in concordance w it h the r esults published elsewhere
by Wipf et al. 257 , Marzouk 63 or Elsen et al. 258 . Similar investigations for EIROF sensors at a
macroscopic rotating ring-d isk electrode as reported by Steegstra et al. 27 reported also a
broad distribution in pH sen sitivity according to the oxidation state of t he iridium oxides.
Indeed, they also address the results of in dividual EIROF ele ctrodes and again no statistical
data were presen ted. As the f abrication p rocess is more t ime- consuming i n respect to t he
modification of AFM- SECM probes, as every single AFM -SECM probe has to be modified

- 92 -

individually, further op timization of EIROF -modified AFM tip-integrated pH sen sors was
not further pursued within this thesis .

Conclusion and outlook
Within this section, AFM t ip-integrated Sb and Ir pH sensors were investigated towards
their pH re sponse. The experiments performed within this thesis also show a limited
reproducibility of the miniaturized pH electrodes as already reported in severa l
publications (see introduction) . For all different modification strategies, a b roa d
distribution of pH sensitivity was ob served. pH sen sors prepared under the same
conditions showed varying p H sensitivity f or d ifferent pH electrodes but also for
consecutive pH calibrations . The stability of the pH sensors was examined for
approximately 1 h showing good pH sensitivity and recovery after sever al minutes. In case
of EIROF pH sensors electrochemically deposi te d on Pt/C-modified Au electrodes, either
in AFM-SECM probes or as UMEs, the pH sensitivity and linearity was i nsuf ficient, and the
electrochemical deposition of iridium oxide see ms t o be un suitable for tip-integrated p H
sensors. Although the successful mod ification of car bon nanoelectrodes w ith
electrochemical deposit ed iridium oxide used in combi ned SECM-SICM investigations of
the calcite d issolution was reported b y Unwin and co- workers 253 , no information was
provided for long-term stability of the p resented pH sensors , nor multiple pH
measurements were shown. Within this thesis, no clear improvement of the
electrochemical modification in respect t o reproducib ility of the p H sensors cou ld be
observed. In section 5.3.2, Sb and Ir-modified A FM -SECM probes were us ed to detect t he
localized dissolution of calcite crystals with simultaneously record ed pH ch anges. No
lateral resolution of pH ch anges cou ld be observed. Variations in sca n speed, scan size,
the original pH of the electrolyte solutio ns or the used pH sensor, either Sb or Ir, alw ays
resulted in a change of the detected potential close to calcite particles , but with out a clear
correlation t o the imaged morphology. However, compared to already reported
investigations, e.g. by SEC M-SICM 253 , the resoluti on in the prese nted resul ts of this t hesis
obtained for AIROF-modified AFM- SECM probes are in an acceptable range , esp ecially in
the sc an d irection (y - direction, see 5.3.2) of the measurements. Whereas a broad ran ge
in sensitivity was observed for both, Sb and Ir-modif ied AFM-SECM p robes, the great

- 93 -

advantage of Ir-based pH sensors ove r Sb is its possib ility t o be ‘ reactiv ated ’ b y anodic
oxidation in H 2 SO 4 . AIROF electrodes were also in vestigated by Wipf and coworkers 249
towards their long-term stability in pH sensing. The size of the reported el ectrode was in
the range of 1 0 µm i n d iameter consisting of Ir microparticles located in a microcap illary
with an active electrode surf ace significantly larger than the h ere reported AFM-SECM
sensors . Nevertheless, t hey re ported the s tability of individual s ensors f or over 2 month s ,
also showing a r educed s ensitivity in pH calibrations, but with linear beh avior over severa l
calibration experiments du ring these 2 months. Indeed, the results presented in this
publication refer to one individual AIROF sen sor showing good linearity d uring this period
an d just sm all deviations in sensi tivity ra nging from 66 – 74 mV/pH 249 . T hey also reporte d
a yield of 30 – 50 % of in total 510 inves tigated AIROF sensors. Studies involving such a
large number of miniaturized pH sensors is beyond the scope of this thesis. However, the
reported long-term stability o f t he AIROF p H se nsor seems t o b e promising also for AFM
tip-integrated AIROF electrodes and further investigati ons should be f ocused on the
optimization of the fabric ation of these pH sensors.

- 94 -

In ves tig ation of the I TIE S a t n an op ore arr a ys
Introduction
The detailed characterization of nanoporous array s used for electrochemis try at the ITIES
is crucial for a compre hensive understanding and interpretation of transport ph enomena
taking p lace at t he liquid/liquid interface. Especially, when changing the f abricatio n
processes of such nanosized devices, the behavior , e.g. in diffusion or the location of the
interface in these d evices, might change dramatically. The direct visualization o f diffusio n
phenomena a t FIB-mille d nano porous ar rays w as shown by localized deposition of silica
at the liquid/liquid inte rface in collaboration with Damien Arrigan’s group at Curtin
University (Li et al. 181 ) . The localized d eposition showe d different diffusional behavior for
nanoporous arrays with varying pore- to -pore separation . However, it has to be noted that
the final silica formation is realiz ed by the h ydrolyzation initialized by the e lectrochemical
ion transfer of a p recursor at the ITIES, followed by rinsing and d rying pr ocesses, which
may change or influence the actual or localized silic a format ion. For the in -situ observation
of d iffusion processes at nanoporous arrays, AFM- SECM is highly suitable. ITIES at
nanoporous ar rays profit from an en hanced ch arge transfer and are a p ro mising in terface
for sensing applications 259 . The diffusion b ehavior at these micro - and nanoporous
membranes are not just dependent on the dimension s (length and diamet ers) of the
actual micro- or nanopo res, but on the pore- to -pore sep aration resulting in an overlaid
diffusion p rofile for sho rt p ore d istances w ithin the array (s ee also 1.4). Micro- and
nanoporous membranes can b e fabricated by standard microfabrication processes . For
example, DRIE has been applied for membranes used in ITIES investigations 83 , as well as
e-beam lithography 98 . Especially, FI B e nables the f abrication of arrays, without the need
for shadow masks and with varyin g an d easily adjustable p ore- to - pore sep arations, as
already reported for various materials 32 – 34 . The f abrication of nanosized geometries by FIB
processing is favorable due to an eas ily tunab le geometry within on e f abr ication ste p i n
varying materials, e.g. thin SiN membranes 31 or p orous alumina 260 . Tong e t al. 261 reported
the fabrication of n anopores with diameters do wn to 10 nm by addit ional silica deposition
using low-pressure chemical vapor deposition to FIB-milled nanopores within SiN
membranes. Additional (c old) ion b eam sculpti ng results in nanopores of j ust a f ew
nanometer s in diameter as repor ted by Li et al. 32 and Kua n et al. 34 . F or investigations of
the ITIES at nanopo rous arrays, theo retical simulat ions and cyclic voltammetry showed

- 95 -

additionally that the separation of the individual interfaces p lays a crucial role in the
current signal and results in an overlapped d iffusion profile for closely- spaced
nanopores 30,97 . Local di ffusion processes can be detected by sc anning probe t echniques
as alrea dy re ported f or the diffusion at nanop orous membranes by SECM 262 or SICM 263 –
266 . AFM-SECM offers the ad vantage of simultaneous detection of the topography of
nanoporous ar ray by AFM and the l ocalized detection of the electrochemical processes.
The diffusional tran sport through pores by AFM -SECM has been shown by Kueng et al. for
the transport of glucose 149 , of redox-active species by Macpherson et al. 150 and for the
diffusion at electrode arrays with closely-spaced microdiscs 150,151 . For the used
nanoporous arrays in SiN membranes fabricated by e-beam lithography, an inlaid
interface was p redicted with the organic phase located within the nanopores due to t he
resulting electrochemical signals of the transfer of a model analyte at ITIES 26 7 .
Investigations at similar nanostructured samples pred ic ted the aqueous phase within the
nanopores as shown by deposited nan oparticles located at the inter face at n anoporous
alumina membra nes 86 or size exclusion of a lig and molec ule at nanoporous silic alite
membranes 268
.
T he h ydrophilicity of t he SiN membranes w as characterized by contact
angle 98,267 resul ting in a hydrophobic back an d a h ydrophilic front side of the membrane .
The p ore walls were also assumed t o be hydrophobic and therefore, the pores should be
filled with the organic ph ase, w hich was suppor ted by calculatio ns 267 . The same ge ometry
and location of t he interface were assumed for FIB-milled nanoporous arrays and
calculations of electroc hemical transport at ITIES at these nanoporous arrays were base d
on an inlaid interface 31,267 .

Scheme of th e used SiN m embranes with correspon ding dimensions; top view (A) and side
view (B).

- 96 -

FIB fabrication results in the implantation of Ga + ions 35 and results i n a truncated cone-
shaped geometry of the nanopores due to re-deposition of FIB-milled material 32,36 ,37 .
Indeed, t he impla ntation of charged ions in the SiN membranes sh ould show an influence
on the hydrophobicity of the surface. Contact angle measurements are not possible for
the inner wall of nanosc ale pores, hen ce the location of the interface has to be d etected
otherwise. With the t runcated cone- shaped ge ometry resulting from FIB-millin g, the
nanopores have two var ying orifices located at either the organic or aqueous f acing side
of the SiN m embrane , respectively. This effect has not been ta ken into account yet f or
nanopore arrays used for ITIES i nvestigations, only for solid-state electrodes recessed at
th e bott om of truncated pores 37 . Therefore, in the following section of this thesis, t he
nanopore arrays were fabricated by FIB -milling from either the front or the back of the
SiN membrane resulting in varying pore diameters at each side of the membrane.

Scheme of front (left) and back (right) side FIB-milled n anopores and the varying pore
diameters at on e side of the membrane marked in red and green.
With the comparison of the re sulting currents for the tran sfer of a model analyte , e.g.
tetrapropylammonium chloride at the ITIES, the location of t he interface at or within the
nanopores can be predicted. Th is prediction is sti ll based on theoretical assumption and
the actual loca tion o f t he i nterface ca n dramatically vary from t hese predictions, in
particular when the inner side walls of the pore might be altered due to FIB millin g . The
interface betwee n two liquids may be also of dynamic nature and a s tatic interface, which
is used for theoretical calculations, may not be suit able to characterize t he locat ion of
these int erfaces in detail . Different approaches for the in vestigation of the liquid/liquid

- 97 -

interface have b een reported so far b y spa tial scannin g sp ectroelec trochemistry a nd
localized d eposition of nanoparticl es 269 , by UV -VIS spectroscopy 270 , and R aman c onfocal
spectroscopy 271 with a spat ial resolution in z-direction in the µm- range. Hence, the
investigation of t he interface between two immiscible liquids by spectroscopic
approaches is lacking the required resolution essential to investigate nano-sized por es
within membranes. T he parallel displacement of t he excitation lig ht s ource as used in the
mentioned techniques is n ot suitable f or solid-st ate membranes. The visualization of the
interior and shape of nanopore s in SiN membranes has been demonstrated by high-
resolution TEM tomography 272,273 .
The first part of this section will show the visualization of different diffusi on al behavior in
relation t o th e p ore- to -pore separation by mapping th e diffusion of a redox species at
ITIES by AF M-SECM 181 . T hese measurements c omplete the investigations of the influence
of t he pore- to -pore separation by CV and corresponding theoretical calculations . Next to
AFM -SECM, the localized d eposition o f silica deposits at ITIES w as used for visualization of
the diffusion p rofiles sh owing overlapped or individual diffusion in dependence of the
pore- to -pore s eparation 181 . T he fo rmation o f a solid phase directly at the i nterface due to
an ion t ransfer at t he ITIES may be used t o identify the location o f this interface within th e
nanopores. In section 6.3.2 , different current responses of the transfer of
tetrapropylammonium chloride (TPrACl) as a model analyte at the ITIES with in FIB -milled
nanopore arrays, fab ricated either f rom the front or the back, are compared.
Electrochemical silica deposit ion at the interface at the t wo differen t na nop orous array s
is used t o visualize the differences between both approaches. Addition ally, such silica
deposits at ITIES were investigate d b y FIB/SEM tomography enabling the recon struction
of the pore shape, the mo rphology of the deposited silica d irectly located at th e
nanopore s and especiall y within the nan opores. Ad ditional E DX and STEM measurements
were conducted to characterize the silica deposits.
The following results have been published partly by Liu et al. 181 and by Holzinger et al. 187 .

- 98 -

Experimental
SiN membranes (SIMPore Inc. and Du raSiN Films, Protochips) with 50 and 100 nm
thickness, respectively, were used as supporting material for nanoporous arrays
fabricated by FIB milli ng (Zeiss Neon 40EsB, Carl Zeiss N ano Technology Systems for the
arrays used for visualization of diffu sion p rocesses and FEI Helios Nanolab 600,
ThermoFisher Scientific for electrochemical measurements and FIB/SEM tomography) .
The AFM-SECM p robes used in p art 6.3.2 of th is chapter were p roduced as described
elsewhere 133,160 . In brief, n on -metalized silicon nit ride probes ( OTR-P, Olympus) were
modified with a 5 nm Ti adhesio n layer and a 100 nm gold layer p rior to insulation by
silicon nitride (PECVD) . Then, the probes were additionally modif ied with a conical
conductive tip of Pt/C composite by IBID (precursor: methyl -cyclopentadien yl-trimethyl
platinum, Therm oFisher Scientific). The fabrication steps by FIB milling and IBID a re
displayed in Figure 58.

SEM images of th e u sed AFM -SECM probe with a conductive Pt/C tip : the Au electrode fr ame
(approximately 600 nm in diameter) was exposed by FIB mil ling (30 kV, A ), Pt /C comp osite was
deposited by IBID on top of the Au frame (square -shaped pattern with an edge le ngth of 1 µm
and an ap proximate height of 466 n m, B) an d reshaped by FIB milling r esulting in a curva ture
radii of 20-25 nm (C). Adap ted with p ermission from Y. Liu , A. Holzinger, P. Knittel, L. Poltorak,
A. Gamero-Qu ijano, W. D.A Rickard , A. Walcarius, G. H erzog, C. Kran z, and D.W.M. Arrigan .
Visualization of d iffu sion with in nan oarrays. Anal. Chem. 88, 6689 – 6695 (2 016). Copy right
2019 American Chemic al Soc iety . http s://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.102 1/ac s.analchem .6b00513 .

- 99 -

The AFM-SECM probe was characterized by CV i n d e -aerated 5 mM Ru( NH 3 ) 6 Cl 3 / 0.1 M
KCl (98 %, Aldrich/ pro analysi, Merck KGaA) a t a scan rate of 0.1 V/s ( Figure 59 B). For
AFM -SECM mea surements, AFM (5500 AFM/SPM microscope, Keysigh t Technologies)
was used i n contact mode and SECM was d one in the generation - collection mode in 0.1
M KCl (pro analysi, Merck) d etecting the reduction of Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ at - 0.3 V vs. Ag/AgCl in
a three-electrode setup with the AFM-SECM probe as working elect rode, a Ag/AgCl qu asi-
reference electrode (Goodfellows) and a Pt counter electrode (Goodfellows). All AFM
images a nd correlati ng h eight a nd current p rofiles were processed by Pico View (Key sight
Technologies). All solutions were prepared with ultrapure water (18.2 M  , ELGA
LabWater, Veolia Water Solu tions & Technologies). Dynamic mode AFM was addit ionally
used to characterize the p ore shapes of t he nanopores used in section 6.3 .2 and 6.3.3 with
a FIB-sharpened NCL probe (k = 48 N/m, 190 kHz, Nano World). The electr ochemical

Scheme o f the AF M- SECM setup used for detection of different diffusion beha vio r at
nanop orous arrays within SiN membranes (A) , with the upper reservoir filled with 0.1 M KC l
(light b lue) an d the low er re servoir b eneath the membrane filled with 20 m M Ru (NH 3 ) 6 Cl 3 / 0.1
M KCl (grey-blue). CV of the conductive AFM tip recorded in 5 mM Ru(NH 3 ) 6 Cl 3 / 0.1 M KC l,
scan rate: 0.1 V/s (B). Ada pted with permission f rom Y. Liu, A. Holzinger, P. Knittel, L. Poltorak,
A. Gamero-Qu ijano, W. D.A Rickard , A. Walcarius, G. H erzog, C. Kran z, and D.W.M. Arrigan .
Visualization of d iffu sion with in nan oarrays. Anal. Chem. 88, 6689 – 6695 (2 016). Copy right
2019 American Chem ical Soc iety . https://pub s.acs.org/doi/10.102 1/acs.analchem .6b00513 .

- 100 -

investigations in 6.3.2 of ITIES at nanoporous arrays are based on the f ollowing
electrochemical cell:
Ag/AgCl | x µM TPrACl, 10 mM LiCl aq || 10 mM BTPPATPBCl DCH | Ag
using T PrACl ( Aldrich) as t he model analyte in lithium chloride solu tion (LiC l, ≥ 99%, Sigma
Life Scie nce) as the aqu eous ele ctrolyte. Aliquots of TPrACl were add ed t o the aqueous
phase and gently mixed with a pipette for a homogeneous concentration during
calibrations. The organic ele ctrolyte was synth esized as d escribed elsewhere 274 by
metathesis of potassiumtetrakis (4 -chlorophenyl) borate (K + TPBCl - , Alfa Aesar) and
bis(triphenylphosphoranylidene )ammoniumchloride (BTPPA + Cl - , Alfa Aesar).
Bis(triphenylphosphoranylidene )ammoniumtetrak is (4 -chlor ophenyl)borate
(BTPPATPBCl) was used as organic electrolyte in 1,6-dich lorohexane (98%, Aldrich). All
electrochemical measurements were done by using a (bi)potentiostat (CompactSt at,
Ivium Technologies) with Ag/AgCl quasi-reference electrod es . The electrochemical
deposition of sil ica at t he interface b etween water and 1,2 -dichloroethane was obtained
according to Poltorak et al. 275 and Herzog and co-workers 187 . A sol of 50 mM TE OS in 5
mM N aCl was adjusted to pH 3 b y addition of aliquots of 1 M HCl, stirred for 90 minutes
at room temp erature to allow hydrolysis to occur. The ethan ol p roduced by the hydr olysis
was removed by evap oration and the pH w as raised to pH 9 by t he additio n of aliquots of
1 M NaOH solution (unless stated otherw ise). The used e lectrochemic al c ell can be
described by:
Ag/ AgCl ǀ 50 mM TEOS hydrol yzed + 5 mM NaCl aq ǀǀ 14 mM CTA + TPBCl - D CE ǀ Ag
The template salt in the organic phase was prepared by metathesis f rom K + TPBCl - and
cetyltrimethylammonium bro mide ( CTAB) as d escribed els ewhere 276 . A potential of - 0.1
V or 0 V was a pplied for 30 - 60 s enabling th e t ransfer of CTA + f rom the organic to t he
aqueous phase, triggerin g t he conden sation reaction bet ween silanol groups to for m Si -
O-Si bonds. After the electrochemical deposition step, the membrane was carefully
removed from the sol ution a nd ri nsed with a flow of ultrapure w ater to avoid any
formation of silica through evaporation. The me mbranes were the n p laced in an oven a t
130 °C for 16 h to ensure cross-lin king.

- 101 -

Automated data acqui sition for FIB/SEM tomography (Helios Nanolab 600, FEI,
ThermoFisher Scien tific) was performed with the ‘slice and view’ so ftware p ackage (FEI,
ThermoFisher Scientif ic) with autom ated FIB milling (30 kV, 1.5 - 48 pA) providing a lateral
resolution of 5 or 10 nm for slicing, respectively, and SEM imaging (5 kV, 86 pA) i n
immersion mode after each milling step. Stabilization of the silica deposits while FIB
milling or TEM f oil prepa ration w as achieved b y additional d eposition of a thin P t layer (3 -
4 n m) by sp utter coating (SCD 005, BAL-TEC) and by Pt/C deposi tion via IBID. Th e 3D slices
were processed by Fiji 277 using the ‘linea r s tack ali gnment wi th SIFT’ 278 a nd applying a FFT
bandpass filter. 3D graphs were processed by Aviz o 9.1.0 Lite (FEI, Thermo Fisher
Scientific). An overview of the d ifferent fabrication steps in FIB/SEM tomography is shown
in Figure 60.

SEM imag es (5 kV/ 8 6pA) of the prepar ation steps for FIB/SEM tomography : A singl e silica
deposit (A) was covered with a Pt /C protection layer by IBID (30kV, 48pA) (B) and th e sample
was exposed by a cross-secti on to loca lize the SiN membrane below the silica d eposit ( C). A
different number of slices (8 0 – 400) with th icknesses of 5 and 10 nm, respectively, was
recorded du ring ‘ Slice an d View ’ . The slices showin g the p ore were then used to generate 3D
projections of the sampl e (SEM in 2D and correspondin g 3 D representation are gi ven in th e

- 102 -

lower pane l of the figure ). A. Ho lzinger, G. Neu sser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Gamero -Quijano , G.
Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan, A. Zi egler, P. Walther, and C. Kran z , Faraday Discu ss. , 201 8, 210 , 113.
Adapted from Ref. 187 . Dis tributed under the licen se Creative Commons Attribution -
NonComm ercial 3.0 Unpo rt ed (CC - BY - NC 3.0 ), https:// creativecom mons.org/licenses/by -
nc/3.0/ .
TEM lamellae were pr epared by several successive FIB milling steps as described in detail
elsewhere 279 and summarized in Figure 61 . TEM (EM 912 TEM, Zeiss) images were
recorded with an acceleration voltage of 1 20 kV . STEM a nd EDX measurements were done
with an FE -SEM (30 kV, S-5200, Hitachi), equipped with a X- ray detector ( Pheonix, E DAX)
and a STEM detector (Hitachi). The images were also processed by Fiji 277 .

Overview of th e pr eparation of TEM lam ella: app rox. 1 µm (in thickn ess) la mella is isolated
from th e membran e conta ining the silica -modified nan opore by FIB milling step s . The la mella
is then attached via IBID (30 kV) to a micromanipu lator needle (Omniprobe) (A ), removed from
the sample and transferred onto a Cu TEM grid (Om niprobe) (B, b lue square marks the
micromanipu lation needle wit h the TEM sample ) and fixed via IBID to th e grid ( C ). Aft erward ,
the micro manipulat ion n eedle is re moved (D ) an d the lamella i s thin ned b y FIB to a thickn ess
of ap proximately 150 - 200 nm (E). A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Gamero-Qui jano,
G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan , A. Ziegler, P. Walthe r, and C. Kran z, Faraday Discus s. , 201 8, 210 ,
113. Adapted fr om Ref. 187 . Distribute d under the license Creative Comm ons Attribution -
NonComm ercial 3.0 Unpo rt ed (CC - BY - NC 3.0 ) , https://creative commo ns.org/ licenses/by-
nc/3.0/ .

- 103 -

Results and discussion
Diffusion at nanopore arrays
The diffusion of a redo x med iator through nanoporous arrays , driv en by a concentratio n
gradient of two reservoirs located below and above the nanoporous array (see Figure 59 ),
is detected . The AFM-SECM probe was located in t he upper comp artment containing
solely KCl ele ctrolyte solution and detected the d iffusion of Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ from the lower
reservoir sep arated by the SiN membrane containing the n anopore array toward s the
AFM -SECM p robe. In Figure 62, the results for the diffusion at nanopores with small pore -
to -pore spacing are pres ented.

AFM -SECM images of a nanoporous array with 21 times se par ation of the individual pores in a
hexagonal arrangement. Contact mode AFM topography (A) and GC mode SECM current signal
(B) due to th e diffusion of [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ throu gh the nan opores is depicted sho wing an
overlapped diffusion. The co rresponding height and current pro files are shown below
according to the marked lin e in (A) and (B). Original size: 35 x 35 µm 2 , scan speed: 32.0 µm/s
(0.5 ln/s), scan an gle: - 14.4 °. Adapte d with permission fr o m Y. Liu, A. H olzinger, P. Knittel, L.
Poltorak, A. Game ro- Quijano , W. D.A Ric kard, A. Walcarius, G. Herzog, C. Kranz, and D.W.M.
Arrigan . Visualization of diffusion within nanoarrays. Anal. Chem. 88, 6689 – 6695 (2016).
Copyright 2019 Am erican Chemic al Soc iety .
https://pubs.acs.or g/do i/10.1 021/acs.analche m.6b00513 .

- 104 -

The ratio of th e distance between single pores and t he rad ius of the pores ( r c /r a , see
equation 29) is 21 and s maller than the cri tical v alue f or i ndividual d iffusi on o f 5 6 as p ore -
pore sepa ration defined by Liu et al. 30 a nd re sulting in a n overlapped diffusion behavior
at t he nanoporous array. The AFM topography and the cor responding height prof ile at the
marked line in the AF M i mage are shown in A, w hereas the correlating current respo nse
with the current p rofile at the same location is s hown in B. A clear overlapped current
signal was detected with a c urrent d ensity of 0. 64 µA/cm² above the na noporous a rray.
Single current p eaks are visible at t he location of t he individual nanopor es. These
observations can be explained by the conductive AFM tip pe netrating the nanopores and
detecting the current response , which reflects t he concentration in the lower
compartment of [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ . Calculations of the expected theoretical current res ponse
(based on the electrode area, diffusion coefficient, concentration , et c.) f or these
additional current p eaks with a conical AFM tip results in a current response in the range
of 0.3 – 1 nA (Ta ble 6 ) . Th ereby, the theoretical currents I dif are calculated b y equ ation
(19) (see Table 2 ).

measure d; peak
curr ent signal,
N = 50

calculated;
for a 1 = 100 nm ,
h 1 = 155 nm

calculated;
for a 2 = 40 nm ,
h 2 = 40 nm

calculated;
for a 2 = 30 nm ,
h 2 = 30 nm

curr ent [nA]

0.08 ± 0.02

1.04

0.36

0.27

Table 6 Measur ed and calculated current for the additional current peaks as illustrated in Figure
63 . The calc ulations w ere obtain ed with equation (19).
Only th e part of the electroactive area of the AFM -SECM p robe within the pore and
reaching the other side of the membrane (with height h 1 and radius a 1 ) containing the
high conce ntrated [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ solution (20 mM) is use d t o calcul ate t he theoretical
current response (see scheme in Figure 63).

- 105 -

Current respon se (A) accordi ng to the AFM-SECM image s sho wn in Figure 62 and scheme of
the AFM tip penetratin g a single nan opore (B). The h eight h an d radiu s a, u sed for calculation
of the theoretical current va lues for th e ob served curr ent peak as shown in the over laid
current response (red cu rve), ar e labeled in white and y e llo w, respectively.
Additionally, the curren t is calculated for t he AFM tip jus t immersing into the high
concentrated [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ solution with the h eight h 2 and the radius a 2 according to th e
actual dimensions of the used AFM -SECM probe (in Table 6, t wo different heights and
radii are comp ared based on the SEM images of the actual AFM -SECM probe, which are
measured from two different sides of the AF M tip). Th e calculated currents are up to 10
times higher than the actual measu red c urrent response. Ind eed, a perfect cone sh ap e
was used for th e calculations, which is n ot the case for the actual shape of th e FIB -milled
AFM tip, a nd a maxim um conce ntration of Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ w as used as c 0 . Bec ause diffusion
close to and within th e pores changes the actual concen tration of the redox mediator in
the s olution below the nanoporous array and also t he penetration of the AFM tip into t he
pores results in ad ditional convection in opposite direction (tip moves towards the si de of
the membrane facing th e concentrated solution, whereas d iffusion is dir ected from the
high to less co ncentrated solut ion). Hence, the actual concentration for c 0 may be lower
than the original bulk concentration of Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ . Ad ditionally, the t ilt of the AFM tip
towards the surface is not t aken into account , which changes th e actual size of the AF M
tip placed within the nanopore . Fo r an estimation of the d etected current signal, the
calculations used in Table 6 are sufficient and these sin gle p eaks visible for individual
nanopores can be addressed b y the electroac tive area of t he AFM- SECM actu ally

- 106 -

penetrating the nanopores. Additionally, the over all current signals are ov erlapped in the
surrounding of the pore s due to t he overlap ping hemispherical diffusion profiles at the
individual pores . Same mea surements at nanoporous arrays with a por e- to - pore
separation sufficient for i ndividual diffusion (w ith r c /r a = 91, see equation 29) as predicted
by electrochemical in vestigations and theoretical calculations 30,31,97 are presented in
Figure 64 and show clearly h emispherical diffusio n above the single nanopores. The AFM
topo grap hy with corresponding height profile is depicted i n A and the correlating curren t
image and profile at the marked line in the current image is shown in B. Th e current
density obtained from these re sults is l ower (0.11 µA/cm²) compared to the results sh own
in Figure 62 for the overlapped diffusion, but just a small sectio n of 8 nanopores is visibl e
within the d epicted imag es in Figure 64 co mpared to the w hole array with 100 nanopores
in Figure 62 . By calculation of the current response f or solely one single nanopore within
both arrays, a current density of approximately 13.3 nA/cm² f or la rge p ore/pore
separation compared to 6.4 nA/cm² for small distances between single pores show th e
enhanced current response for single nanopores w ith individual hemispherical diffusion
profile. Th e current profile in Figure 64 B also shows the current peaks with enhan ced
current signals at the nanopores, which is again related to the p enetration of the
conductive AFM tip into the pore filled with th e solution of high concentration of
Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ .

- 107 -

AFM -SEC M images of a nanoporous array with 91 time s se par ation of the individual pores in a
hexagonal arrangement. Contact mode AFM topography (A) and GC mode SECM current signal
(B) du e to th e diffusion of [Ru (NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ thro ugh th e nanop ores is d epicted sho wing ind ividual
diffusion p rofiles at th e po r es. The cor respondin g heigh t and current p rofiles are shown
beneath according to the marked line in (A) and (B). Original s ize: 25.3 x 25.3 µm 2 , scan speed:
47.9 µm/s (1.0 ln/s), scan angle: - 34.9 °. Ada pted with pe rmission f rom Y. Liu , A. H olzinger, P.
Knittel, L. Poltorak, A. Gamero -Quijano, W. D.A Rickard, A. Walcarius, G. Herzog, C. Kranz, and
D.W.M. Arri gan . Vi sualization of d iffusion within nan oarrays. Anal. Chem. 88 , 6 689 – 6695
(2016). Copyrigh t 2019 Americ an Chemic al Society .
https://pubs.acs.or g/doi/10.1 021/ac s.analchem.6b005 13 .
The AFM-SECM investigations were repeated with an AFM tip -integrated recessed Au
frame electrode to detect the diffu sion without a dditional current peaks due to the
penetration of a conductive AF M tip into the nanop ores. Thereby, a h in dered diffusion
could b e detected b esides the pore as shown in Figure 6 5, with some pores seem t o be
blocked, indicated by an absent current signal. The results s how a nanoporous array with
a por e- to -pore sep aration of 21 in the AFM t opography with the corresponding height
profile (A) and t he curr ent response in B, which sh ows not the exp ect ed overlapped
diffusion. In deed, the current response is t oo l ow compared to calculations of the

- 108 -

predicted current for the diffusion of Ru(NH 3 ) 6 3+ and the current density (0.04 µ A/cm²) is
just 6 % of the current density for t he results sh own in Figure 62, leading to t he
assumption that the whole nanoporous arra y was blocked and not just some individual
pores of the array.

AFM - SE CM images of a nanoporous array with 21 time s s eparat ion of the individual pores in a
hexagonal arrangement. Contact mode AFM topograph y (A) and GC mod e SECM current signal
(B) d ue to th e dif fusion o f [Ru(NH 3 ) 6 ] 3+ through th e nan opores i s d epicted. Some of the p ores
are blocked and no diffusion is detectable in (B ) repres ented by dark region above the
nanop ore array. The correspo nding height and current profile s are sho wn beneath according
to the marked lin e in (A) an d (B). Original size: 4 0 x 40 µm², scan spe ed: 47.7 µ m/s (0.6 ln/ s).
The observed small change in current may be ex plained th a n by the cha nge in distance
between the surface a nd the tip integrate d electrode when the re -shaped AFM tip
penetrates the p ore s. This behavior of blocked pores could be also observed in ITIES
measurements at the nanoporous arrays. The reason for bl ocking has not been fully
investigated and might be re lated eithe r to impurities of the used solu tions or to
redeposited ma terial durin g FIB-mil ling o f t he a rrays. Additionally, small air bu bbles,
which may b e loca ted at the SiN membrane and may be possibly introduced during the
filling of the glass tubes with one of the electrolyte solut ions, might also block single p ores.

- 109 -

For a de tailed interpretation of the ob served pore blocking, a detailed understanding of
the l ocation o f the ITIES within t he nanopores is essen tial. In t he following section ,
electrochemistry at the ITIES and theoretical calculations are compared to verify the
prediction of the i nterface being located at the aqueous facing side of the nanopores as
reported for arrays produced by e-beam li thography 98,267 and also assumed for FIB-mille d
nanoporous arrays 31 .

ITIES at nanopore arrays
For the identification of the interface within nanoporous arrays, the electrochemical ly
driven t ransport of TPrA + as a model analyte at the ITIES is investigated. This was already
used for characterization of porou s SiN membranes and led to t he con clusion that the
interface a t FIB-mil led nanopores is com parable to na nopores fabricated by e-beam
lithography 31 . Thereby, an inlaid i nterface facing th e aqueous electrolyte solution was
assumed and the calculations are b ased on equation ( 26 ) (see section 1.4). Because FIB-
milling results in the implantation of positively charged Ga ions , which may result in a
hydrophilic surface, the b ehavior of FIB-milled nanopores might be different for ITIES
compared t o nanopores obtained by e- beam lithography. Additionally, the t runcated pore
shape due to redeposited ma terial during th e milling process, which was already r eported
by several groups 32,36,37 , w as so far n ot considere d.

C V recorded at ITIES (A) : black curve re pr esents the backgroun d and color ed curves represent
the CV a fter cons ecutive addit ion of TPrACl to t he aqueou s phase. The curr ent re sponse after
backgroun d sub traction is de picted in (B). Colors: 20 µM (purp le), 40 µM (yello w), 60 µM
(green), 80 µM (blu e) and 100 µM (brown) TPrA Cl. Scan sp eed: 5 mV /s.

- 110 -

In Figure 66 , the CV for th e t ransport of TPrA + from the aqueous to the or ganic ph ase
during the forward scans are shown wi thin a concentration range of 20 – 100 µM TP rA + ,
with the black CV as the background response p rior to the addition o f t he an alyte. In B,
the background subtracted current response of the f orward scan (TPrA + tran sfers from
the aqueous t o the organic phase) is depicted. A limit ing current at 0.6 – 0.65 V is visible
for the pu rple and the yellow curve in Figu re 66 B. The current at this potential was
compared t o theoretical cu rrents calculated by the different equations summarize d in 1.4 .
Prior to the electroche mical investigations, the nanoporous array was characterized by
AFM u sing a high- as pect ratio AFM tip, showing the p ore shape a nd the pore orifices o f
the FIB-milled nanopores (see Figure 67). Whereas in prior publications, the diameters of
the nanopores were evaluated by SEM 30,31 , AFM provides an accur ate geometry and size
of the pore.

Dynamic mode AF M topograp hy (A, original s ize: 2.75 x 2. 75 µm²) of a nano pore ar ray with
height p rofile (B) accord ing to the marked l ine in A. Th e re sults sho wn in Figur e 66 an d depicted
as black points in the calibration curve in C are co mpared to theoretical calcu lations for an
inlaid geometry of the int erface (black line , at h = 0 n m) and a recessed interface at different
locations within the nan opore as marked in th e depth profile in (B). The d iameter s used for
calculations of the th eoretical current s are summariz ed in (D).

- 111 -

The measurement of the pore diameter f rom SEM images is suitable for p ores with
parallel in ner walls and the same p ore diameters at both sides of the membran e, whereas
for a truncated p ore shape, th e invest igation of the por e shape of nanoporous memb ranes
with thicknesses within 50 to 100 n m via SEM will always result in mixed pore size of t he
truncated cone-shaped pore due t o th e p enetration d epth of the electron beam. Th ereby ,
the calculatio n of th e c ur rent respo nse based on an inlaid interface, which re presents the
large orifice of the t runc ated nanopores facing the aqueous side within the reported
investigations 30,31 , whereas for the reported calculation s the pore dimensions determined
by SEM were used. These pore dimensions represent indeed an intermediate pore
diameter, in b etween both orifices of a truncated cone-shaped pore. In Figure 67, the AFM
image obta ined with an ultra -sharp AF M ti p (A) an d th e corresponding depth profile of
the nanopores is depicted in B. The dashed lines within the profile repres ent the posit ion
of the i nterface used for t he calculations of the theoretical c urrent by equat ion (28) fo r
truncated cone-shaped n anopores. The diameter of the nano pores at the orifice (at 0 nm
in the depth p rofile i n Figure 6 7 B, black dashed line) is 187 nm ± 3 nm ( N = 3) a nd wa s
used as r L in t he calculation of the theoretical current (bas ed on equation ( 28) in 1.4) at
different p osition of the interface within t he n anopores marked by different colors in
Figure 67 B. The diameters for t he assumed r ecessed inter faces at diffe rent depths are
shown in Fig ure 67 D and were used for r 0 in t he calculations. Th e experimental data for
the t ransfer of TPrA + as shown in Figure 66 are presented as black p oints in the c alibration
shown in Figure 67 C. Thereb y, the data points fit well with the theoretical calibration for
an interf ace located in the p ores at a depth (or length) of L = 50 n m. The nanop orous array
had a pore- to -pore separation of 10.2 ± 0.2 (N = 3) for the results shown in Figu re 66 and
Figure 67 . Th is indicates an overlapped diffusio n p rofile a t t his n anopore arra y as shown
in the AFM-SECM investigations in chapter 6.3.1 (see Figure 62). Liu et al. 30,97 reported
that th e current re sponse for a n overlap ped diffu sion is u p to 54 % 30 reduced to individual
diffusion at the n anopor es in dependence to the pore- to -pore separat ion. In Figure 68 ,
two different assumptions for a n overlapped diffusion are c ompared t o the experimental
data and to the theoretical current with th e interface locat ed within t he trun cated cone -
shaped nanopores at a depth of L = 50 nm.

- 112 -

Schemes (A) showing th e a s sumptions u sed for theor etical calculations accordin g to an
overlapped d iffusion comp ared to the calibration curve (B, black points) of the results in Figure
66 . The red and b lue lines in B correspond to the theoretical a ssumption of one UME with the
same size as the activ e area (red) or an UME of the same size as the w hole array (blue). The
green line in B corresponds to the theoretica l assumptio n o f a rece ssed inter face loc ated
towards the organic el ectrolyt e.
The schemes in Figure 68 A are illustra ting the t heoretical assu mptio n used for t he
theoretical values depicted i n the calibration curves in B in corresponding colors. Fo r the
approach colored in red, the active area of the single nanopores is summarized and
replaced by an interface of the same area, whereas for the calculation of the whole area,
the size of the array was used a nd replaced by a d isk-shaped interface with th e same area.
Both approaches can be con sidered as t he u pper and lower limit o f current r esponse that
can b e expected for an overlapped diffusion. An other approach for the investigation of
the location of t he ITIES within FIB-milled nanopores is shown in Figure 69 . Th e tr uncated
cone shape of FIB -milled nanopores is used in t he comparison of n anoporous arra ys
fabricated from t he front or the back, so that either the small orifice is facing the aq ueous
electrolyte solution and vic e versa, as illustrated i n Figure 69 A. The used SiN membrane s
had a thickness of 100 nm and same parameters were u sed for the fabrication of the
nanopore arrays by FIB millin g. A similar approach was alread y reported by Alvarez de
Eulate et al. 84 for microporous glass membranes fabricated by laser ablation with
truncated cone-shaped pores. The hydr ophobicity of such inner pore walls was
determined by conta ct angle measurements an d corresponding experimental and
simulated data of t he diffusion at the microporous array with pores oriented t owards

- 113 -

either t he aqueous or the organ ic electrolyte solu tion results in t he assumption of a
hemispherical shape of the i nterface. Fo r the arrays rep orted in t his p ublic ation , the pores
were filled with the organic electrolyte solution 84 . For characterization of the n anopores
in the experiments presented within this thesis, an ultra - sharp AFM t ip was used. Th e
sharp AFM probes were obtained by FIB milling t aking into account the instrumental
mounting an gle (9°) of the AFM p robe towards the sample surface. The AFM topography
of a front and back side milled nanopore are show n in C with corresponding height profiles
displayed in D.

Comparison o f front an d back side m illed po res: the scheme in (A) represents the or ientation
of th e truncated con e-shape d pores towards the aqu eous and or ganic phase, respectively,
depending on the orientation o f the membrane d uring FIB milling. AF M to pography recorded
in dyn amic mode (B) of a fron t side (l eft) and back side (righ t) milled pore with co rrespon ding
height profiles as marked in (B) and depicted in (D). A high-aspect-ratio AFM tip is repre sented
in the SEM image in (C) ob tained b y FIB milling. AFM par ameters: 152 kHz (left)/ 169 kHz
(right), scan speed: 1 ln/s ( 6 µm/s), original size: 3 x 3 µm ². A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J.
Austen, A. Gamero- Quijano, G. Herzog, D. W. M. A rrigan, A. Ziegler, P. Wa lther , an d C. Kran z,
Faraday Discuss. , 201 8, 210 , 113. Adapted from Ref. 187 . Distributed u nder the license Creative
Commons Attribu tion -NonCommercial 3.0 Unported (CC -B Y-NC 3.0),
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .

- 114 -

Due to the geometry, only the pore diameter of the small orifice is accessible via AFM
measurements f or the back sid e milled nanopo res. Th e dimen sions of t he nanopores are
represented by t he height profiles of the back side milled pore (light blue line) and the
front side milled pore (dark blue line) in Figure 69 D corre sponding to the topography
marked by dashed lines in B in corresponding col ors. Th e profil e of the back sid e milled
pore represents thereby th e shape of th e AFM t ip and solely the dime nsion of the small
orifice can be gained fro m these investigations. Th e fabricated nan oporous arrays, FIB-
milled either from the front or the back of the SiN membrane , were examined in
electrochemical investig ations via CV fo r the transport of TPrA + . In case that the i nterface
is located towards the aqueous phase as assumed i n previou s publicat io ns 30,31 , a lower
current response for the b ack side milled nanopores is expected due to t he smaller orifice
facing the aqueous phase. In Figure 70 A , the b ack ground c orrected forward sweep of the
current response in dependence of the concentration of TPrA + in the ran ge of 20 – 100
µM is shown and the corresponding calibration graph is represented by red points in B.

Current response after background subtraction (A) of consecutive addition of TPrACl at a back
side mill ed nanopore array. Colors: 20 µM (pu rple), 40 µM (yellow), 60 µ M (green), 80 µ M
(blue) and 100 µM (brown) TPrACl. Scan speed: 5 mV/s. Th e calibration curve (B) comp ares
the results of A (red data) with the data obtained at ITIES at a front side milled nanopore array
(black d ata) and the th eoretical assumption (green line) of an inlaid interface f acing the
aqueous electrolyt e.

- 115 -

The green line in B represents t he calculate d d ata for an inlaid interface facing the
aqueous electrolyte solution and the black p oints rep resent the experimental results for
a front si de mill ed n anoporous ar ray as already sh own in Fig ure 6 6 . Alt hough the lin earity
for the experimental data for the nanopores FIB-milled from the back is poor, the detected
current is up to 5 times higher than for the front side milled nanoporous array. The pore-
to -pore s eparation for this array with r espect t o the radius of th e sm all ori fice is 17.6 ± 0.8
( N = 9) compare d to 10.2 ± 0.2 ( N = 3) for the results shown in Figure 66 and represented
by the black data points in Figure 70 B. According to the results obtained so far 30 , the
diffusion at this p ore array is overlapped. Either for individual or overlapped diffusion
profiles, the current response has to b e reduced for smaller pore d iameters re presented
by the back side milled n anoporous array i n case of an i nlaid in terface facing the aqueous
electrolyte solution du ring electrochemical investigations. Of course, the influence of
implanted Ga + ions has to b e considered re sulting in c hanges in the hydrophilicity of t he
membrane d ependent on the orientation of the SiN memb rane towards the ion b eam
during FIB milling. This parameter was neglected so far an d h as to b e t aken into account
in future studies. Similar results showing a variation in electrochemical invest igations
performed at conical pores in two different orientation was already re ported by Arrigan
and coworkers, b ut for µm-sized pores in a glass memb rane fabricated by laser ablation 84 .
However, the hydroph ili city of these micropores w as modified by an additional surface
modification, which en sures the same hydrophilicity for the d ifferent orientation s of th ese
micropores. This is not the case for the FIB- milled nanopores re ported wi thin this thesis.
Thereby, this is the first time that t his direct comparison of n anoporou s arra ys in SiN
membranes u sed for nan oITIES (see Fig ure 69 a nd Figure 70 ) are investigated t owards the
orientation of the membranes du ring FIB -milling. The different behavior in
electrochemical investigations at nanoITIES with respect to the orientation of cone-
shaped nan opores will be also considered in th e following sections. The lo calization of the
interface b y AFM-SECM is d ifficult d ue t o the p enetration depth o f t he AFM t ip into th e
nanopores a nd an accompanying mixture of the solutions. The d iffusi on be havior at
nanoporous arrays was also visualized by silica depositi on at the ITIES within nanoporous
arrays. The siz e of the silica deposits for med at t he interface between an aqueous ph ase
and DCE was evaluate d 181 . Within the n ext sec tion, the size variation of t he silica deposits
is compared with respect to the actual pore diameters.

- 116 -

Silica deposits at the ITIES for localization of the interface
The localized deposition of silica at the ITIES is used within the following investigations to
distinguish between nanopores FIB -milled either from the front or t he back as shown in
Figure 69. Th e pore- to -pore separation in both a rrays is sufficient for independent por e
diffusion and the diameters determined by AFM f or the or ifice facing t he aqueous
electrolyte solution a re 18 3 nm ± 29 nm (N=3) f or front sid e milled a nd 72 n m  12 n m
(N=3) for the b ack side milled arrays, respectively. Th e SEM images of the arra ys after
silica d eposition are depicted in Figure 71 A and the diameter of the single silica deposits
for both arrays are com pared in B. Thereby, a wide distribution of different deposit si zes
can be seen for both approaches with larger diameters for the back side milled
nanoporous array that i ndicates an enhanced io n transport . The siz e dis tribution within
the 100 nanopores of o ne array is even larger t han the difference betw een both arrays
fabricated by front or back side FIB milling. A paire d two-tailed t-test w ith a 95 %
confidence level showed that the variation of the silica deposit s in each array is significant
and th e standard deviation of the silica deposits (43 % an d 57% of the mea n value for
diameters, respectively) within one array, which has on ly a small standard deviat ion in the
original pore size, corresponding t o 16 – 17 % of the mean value, is larger, than the
difference between the silica depositions at both membranes. These results confirm the
interpretation gained by the comparison of electrochemical results of the t ransfer of
TPrA + at t he nan oITIES as d iscussed in 6.3.2, showing t he same trend of an enhance d
diffusion for FIB-milled nanoporous ar rays fabricated from the back of the S iN membrane.
However, d ue to the broad size distribution of the results presented in Figure 71 ,
additional investigations h ave been done at these modifi ed nanopore arrays. Therefore,
the silica deposits of t he n anoporous array fa bricated from the back are investigated in
detail by FIB cross-sections and FIB/SEM tomography. Du ring electrochemical deposition
of silica at the ITIES, the template CTA + is transferred from the organic to the aqueous
phase enabling the formation of silica by hydrolysis and condensation of TEOS.
275

Si, either
as TEOS or silica, is ju st p resent in the aqueous phase, hence the locati on of the silica
deposits is an indication for the location of the aqueous phase.

- 117 -

SEM images of the silica depositions at front (A , left) and back (A, right) side milled pore arrays,
respectively. Th e size d istributio n of the array s in A i s given in B. yello w: front side, blue: b ack
side approach . The electroch emical deposition was don e a t 0 V for 90 s (aqueous phase : pH
9). A. H olzinger, G . Neusser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Gamero -Quija no, G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan ,
A. Ziegler, P. Walther, and C. Kranz, Faraday Discuss. , 2018, 210 , 113. Reprodu ced from Ref.
18 7 . Dist ributed un der the license Creative Com mons Att ribution -NonCommercial 3.0 Unported
(CC- BY -NC 3.0), https://creati vec ommons.org /licen ses/by-nc/3.0/ .
In Figure 72 A, the FIB-induced secondary electron image is shown of one silica deposit
covered with a layer of Pt/ C, which prevents ch arging effec ts while imaging and milling,
and additionally prevents beam -induced damage of the silica deposit. In the SEM images
in B-E , the cross-sections of two silica deposi ts with varyi ng diameters are depicted . As
shown in Figure 71, the siz e distribution of the silica deposits is large and both , small

- 118 -

(< 5 µm, in B, C) and large (> 9 µm, in D, E) deposits were investigated in detail by FIB/SEM
tomography. A close-up of t he silica deposits close to the nanopores is shown in C and E.
Whereas for small deposits, the silica is d irectly attached at the SiN membrane, a gap
between the silica an d the SiN membrane is visible for large ones ( Figure 72 E). This gap
might be related to the drying step after silica formation, which might cau se shrinkage of
the silica dep osit due to solve nt l oss. This e ffect is lik ely stronger for large deposits
resulting in the separation of the deposit from the SiN membrane.

Differences in silica morpholo gy : Cross-sections of silica depo sits are compared for large (> 9
µm in diameter) and small ( < 5 µ m in diameter) deposits. The FIB-induced SE image in A shows
the silica deposit partially covered with a Pt/C protection layer, whereas the SE images in B - E
show the deposit s in a 38° tilted perspective. The SE imag es shown in C and E represent a
zoomed view of the samples shown in B and D, respectively, during consecutive FIB s ectionin g.
The b lue arro ws in E point out an inner radial region sho wing different density o f the depos ited
silica.

A. Holzinger, G . Neusser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Gamero-Quijano , G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arri gan,
A. Ziegler, P. Walther, and C. Kranz, Faraday Discuss. , 2018, 210 , 113. Reprodu ced from Ref.
187 . Dist ributed u nder the lic ense Creative Commons Att ribution -NonComm ercial 3.0 Unported
(CC- BY -NC 3.0), https://creati vec ommons.org/licen ses/by -nc/3.0/ .

- 119 -

Any other p rocesses following the silica formation, suc h as removing the elec trolyte
solutions, drying, and cle aning might also have an influence on the silica deposits and with
this o n the investigated interface. In both examples shown in Fig ure 72 , a dense structure
of t he silica deposit is visible, wherea s for the l arge deposit in Figure 72 D and E, the dense
structure shows a hemispher ical region in close proximity to the nanopore (marked by
arrows in E) with higher density acc ording to t he contrast i n t he SE imag e, compared t o
the adjacent region showing a slightly different contrast. This variation in the silica deposit
can b e addressed to an en hanced h emispherical diffusion near the n anopore du ring
electrochemical deposition resulting in an enhanced f ormation of silica and a denser
structure comp ared to the adjacent re gion. Next to the dense str ucture located in close
proximity to the Si N membra ne visible in the SE images, which correl ates with the side
facing the aqueous ele ctrolyte solution during electrochemical deposition, there is an
inhomogeneous st ructure visible below the me mbrane f acing t he organic electro lyte
solution. Th is is recognizable for small an d large silica d eposits ( Figure 72 C, E). This
structure w ill be referre d to as “residue” with in the following discussion . In the SE image
shown in C, som ething appearing as a ‘ single particle ’ is l ocated within the nanopore. In
Figure 73, several SE images of th is si lica deposit are sh own in the FIB/SEM tomography ,
where the lateral distance between single SE images was 10 nm. The f ocus in these images
was laid on the nanopore and t he residue i n close proximity to the nanopore. The conic al
shape of the nanopore is clearly visible in these images.

- 120 -

Processed SEM imag es showing a nano pore (marked area in (A)) within a series o f image s (A-
I) with 10 nm d istance between single SE images. SEM: 5 kV/ 86 pA, FIB: 30 kV/ 48 pA, 10 nm/
slice. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J . J. Au sten, A. Gamero -Quija no, G . Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan, A.
Ziegler, P. Walther, an d C. Kranz, Faraday Discu ss. , 20 18, 210 , 113. Based on Ref. 187 .
Distributed und er th e license Creative Common s Att ri bution -Non Commercial 3.0 Unp orted (CC -
BY -NC 3.0), htt ps://creativeco mmons.org/licen ses/by -nc /3.0/ .
Additionally, the bright particle in th e pore (see Fi gure 73 F) has a dimension of 10 – 20nm
as a sm all variation of the contrast in t he SE image in E might be p art of t his p article, but
the particle is already no longer vis ible in im age G. Additio nally, the particle is not
completely visible in image E, which might indicate that the pore is also filled with some
other residue. In case that th e pore is empty (ex cept this particle) a nd th e contrast just
indicates t he SiN membrane behind th e n anopore, this single particle has to be also visible
in th e images C-E. I t is d if ficult to discrimin ate b etw een t he in -plane region of the exposed
area and t he sam ple vol ume because the co ntrasts in the SE images are al ways a result of
overlapped signals due to t he p enetration d epth of the electron b eam 184 . Th is is also called

- 121 -

‘the sh ine through artifac t’ 280 . The structure of the silica deposit is homogeneous except
small variation i n co ntrast in close proximity to the nanopore, w hich migh t indica te
differences in the silica formation rate due t o enhan ced concentrations directly at the
nanopore. A detailed interpretation giving the variation in the SEM contrast is at the
current state not p ossible . The residue at the si de of the Si N membrane facing the organic
electrolyte sol ution du ring ITIES meas urements shows different regio ns given t he varying,
observed contrasts. The black regions are holes within t his residue, whereas b right regions
might be eithe r single particles of unknown content or edges indicating the in-plan e area
sectioned by the ion beam. Again, it is difficult t o interpret t he differen t contrast in SE
images with unknown samples and to distinguish between th e in - plane area and the
sample volume. S tructures, which a re visib le i n more than one S E im age d uring FIB
sectioning can be associated wit h the sample vol ume. Focusing on the nanopore, there is
some connection b etwe en re sidue and the nanopore visible, especially in th e SE images
shown in Figure 73 C - G, with a single p article s how n in F. A cle ar differentiation between
the SiN membrane an d this residue within the na nopore is still challe nging and d ata have
to be interpreted with ca re to avoid false results. The residue can be clearl y addressed to
the diffusion p rocesses in close pro ximity t o the n anopore because the residue is just
located at this nanopore. These observat ions are more o bvious in an other silica d eposit
investigated by SEM/FIB tomography , which is presented in Figure 74 . Single slices of the
3D stack are presented in A, I-IV s howing the resi due on the organic facing side of t he SiN
membrane and located close t o the orifice of the nanopore. Three differen t regions migh t
be differentiated within this residue. The f irst p art seems to be some kind of encapsulati ng
layer, followed by a poro us region a nd a diffuse i nner structure of the residue. The diffuse
inner structure seems also to be within th e nanopore. In tot al 24 SE images of the slice &
view p rocedure a re su mmarized in a 3D representation of the n anopore , pr esented by a
voxel siz e o f1.92 µm x 1. 92 µm x 10 nm . T he resid ue is shown in Figure 74 B with the inner
diffuse structure marke d in green an d the outer layer sh own in yellow. The borders o f the
SiN membrane are i ndicated in blue. T he truncate d cone shape of the nanopore is clea rly
visible in t he 3D reconstruction. The d rop -like re sidue in this example is l ocated around
the n anopore, whereas the thin layer marked i n y ellow seems to cover the SiN mem brane
over a larger region.

- 122 -

Processed SEM image sequen ce of a b ack side milled n anopore after silica deposition with a
large residue stru cture locate d at the nanopore facing th e organic electrolyte (A, I -IV). The
distance between singl e slices is 30 nm. 3 D reconstruction of th e slices and v iew stack i s sho wn
in B. SEM: 5 kV/ 86 pA, TLD a t 38° (corrected tilt), FIB: 30 kV/ 48 pA, 10 n m/slice; in to tal 80
slices are imaged . A. Holzin ger, G. N eusser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Gamero -Quijan o, G. Herzo g, D.
W. M. Arrigan, A. Ziegl er, P. Walther , and C. Kran z, Farad ay Discuss. , 2 018, 210 , 113.
Reproduce d from Ref. 1 87 . Distributed un der th e lic ense Creative Commons Attributio n -
NonComm ercial 3.0 Unpo rt ed (CC - BY - NC 3.0), https:// creativecom mons.org/licenses/b y-
nc/3.0/ .
The results s hown i n Figure 73 and Fig ure 74 indicate that the pores are filled with some
residue. Th ere is a connection between this residue and the silica deposit above th e
membrane facing the aqueous electroly te solution during electrochemical investigations,
however, the structure of t he par ticles or structures within the na nopores show different
contrast in the SE images compared to the silica deposits. A detailed in t erpretation is still
difficult due t o the ‘ shine t hrough effect ’ of porous structures 280 . Additional in formation
is gained by the investigation of the elemental composition as presented in the f ollowing
section.

- 123 -

Investigation of the elemental composition of deposited silica at nanopores
For the d etermination of t he el emental c omposition of th e silic a deposits a nd t he residue
at the sid e of t he membrane facing the organic electrolyte solution during electrochemical
deposition, a thin TE M lamella was p repared fr om a single silic a deposit. T he TE M lamella
with a thickness smaller th an 150 nm was investigated by EDX resulting in the elemental
maps shown in Figure 7 5 (color- coded SE images in res pect to the pr esent elements o n
the right). The fabrication of the TE M lamella by FIB milling resu lted in re-deposition of
material, which is indicated by the EDX signal of Pt (light blue image). The signal has a
maximum valu e at t he edge of the diffuse residue. An enhanced signal at energies for X-
rays charact eristic for the other elements at this border can be also seen in the other
images and is therefore negligible .

TEM im age of a nan opore with a d iameter of 80 nm (A) with a zoomed vie w o f the pore (B)
and SEM image of th e same loca tion, but vertically flipped by 180°. EDX mapping of th is area
is given on the right side marked by false colo r images according to the elemental composition
given in the single imag es. Acceleration voltage: 10 kV. A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J. Austen,
A. Gamero-Qu ijano, G. H erzog, D. W. M. Arrigan, A. Zi egler, P. Walther , and C. Kran z, Fa ra day
Discuss. , 2018, 210 , 113. Ad apted from Ref. 187 . Distrib uted u nder the license Cre ative
Commons Attribu tion -NonCommercial 3.0 Unported (CC - BY -NC 3.0),
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .

- 124 -

The residue located at the nanopore shows high intensities for chloride (red), carb o n
(green), but also silic on ( pink). Thereby, the Si sig nal is more pronounced and it is unlikely
that t his signal originates ju st due to rede posited material. Therefore, t his resi due mig ht
consist of Si, either as silica or as TEOS indicating the l ocation of the aqueous phase during
electrochemical silica deposition. For a deta iled interpretation of the elemental
composition of this residue, additional investigations w ill b e necessary. Th e interior of t he
nanopore cannot be evaluated h ere becau se the signal is overlaid with the signal
originating from t he SiN membrane. The STEM image depicted in A shows the TEM lamella
from one side, whereas the SE image in C and t he c orresponding E DX mapping (right side)
show a vertically flipped view of the same p osition. From t his perspective, the nanopore
is not visibl e and the SiN memb rane in this image is entirely covering the pore. For b oth,
SEM and EDX, the penetration de pth of the exc itation e-beam is larger tha n the thickness
of the TEM lamella itself 184 . For clear identification of the content within the nanopores,
the pore has to be larger than the TEM lamella. Because t he p reparation of th in lamellas
below 100 nm is challenging due to limits in the fabrication pro cess 281,282 , the n anopores
prepared by FIB milling were in creased to a range of 25 0 – 350 nm in diameter. As
visualized in the schemes in Figure 76, the larger pores are accessible from both sides in
lateral dimension that the contrast in SEM, TEM and th e signal detected by EDX of the
lamellas solely represents the inner struct ure wit hin the pores avoiding t h e convolution
of the signals with the signals originati ng from the SiN membrane.

Scheme o f two TEM lam ellas with varying po re dia meters , in sufficient (left) and suffici ent
(right) for investigation of the content within the n anopores. A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J.
Austen, A. Gamero- Quijano, G. Herzog, D. W. M. A rrigan, A. Ziegler, P. Wa lther , an d C. Kran z,
Faraday Discu ss. , 201 8, 210 , 113. Reproduc ed from Re f. 187 . Distributed under the license
Creative Commons Attribution -NonCommercial 3.0 U nported (CC - BY -NC 3.0) ,
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .

- 125 -

For the nanoporous arrays with larger diameters ranging from 250 to 350 nm, Si N
membranes with a th ickness of 50 nm were u sed. All arrays were FIB milled fro m the f ront
side facing the aqueous electrolyte solution duri ng electrochemical silica deposition. To
distinguish between Si particles located in the pore and associated with the silica deposit
process, which migh t be moved into the pore during drying or cleaning steps after silica
formation, the pH value for one silica deposition was adju sted t o suppress t he silica
formation. Additionally, the deposition time was altered, and its influence is analyze d
towards the silica deposits and the remaining residue in or below the nanopore f acing the
organic ele ctrolyte solution during electroc hemical d eposition. An overview of silica
deposits fabricated at different de position conditions are shown in Figu re 77 .

SEM images of different silica deposits with v arying depositi on parameters: array with 9 (A, B)
and 4 (C) pores and silica d eposits (D -F) corr esponding to the arrays above. Parameters :
applied p otential: - 0.1 V for all array s; for 60 s at pH 9 (A, D), for 5 s at pH 9 (B,E), for 10 s (3
times) at pH 3 (C,F). The pH value corresponds to the aqueo us phase. 5 kV, 86 pA, tilt: 0° (A-C)
and 52° (D- F) . Adapte d from Ref. 187 . Dist ributed under the lice nse Creative Commo ns
Attribution-No nCommercial 3.0 Unp orted (CC - BY -NC 3.0),
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .

- 126 -

Thereby, the SE images in A and B show a varying size of t he silica d eposit s with changes
in deposit ion time at pH 9. In C, the results f or the deposition at pH 3, insufficient for the
silica formation, is show n. At acidic pH values , the mononuclear specie s of TEOS is
dominant in the aqueous phase, whic h doesn’t facilitate the transfer of the template from
the organic to the aqueous phase and no condensation reaction of the TEOS occurs 276 . It
is clearly visible that no silica d eposits were formed above t he individual p ores at the
aqueous facing side durin g electrochemical deposition. However, some p articulat e
material was located with in the nanop ores in absen ce of silica d eposits, which ar e
embedded within the residue that was already ob served for nan oporo us arrays with
smaller p ore diameters (see Figure 72 to Figure 75). With in creasing deposition times, the
diameters of the silica deposit s i ncreased with 1.4 ± 0.3 µm ( N = 27) for 5 s compared to
3.7 ± 0.5 µm ( N = 27) for 60 s, whereas in both examples shown in Figure 77 A and B,
slightly different sizes f or single deposits in one arra y can be seen in accordance to the
results presented in section 6.3 .3 . For short deposition times of 5 s, the silica deposits
were jus t for med at some pores and 5 o f 27 nanopores of t his investigated n anoporous
array showed no silica formation. Fo r t he n anoporous array used in ITIES measu rements
with insu fficient pH values of the aqueous phase, no silic a deposits were obtained (Figur e
77 C, F), but some nanop ores showe d re sidue wit hin t he pores as shown in F. In Figu re 78 ,
the cross -sections of a silica deposit formed at pH 9 (A and B) are compared to the cross -
section of a nanopore w ithout silica for mation due to an insufficient pH valu e (pH 3, C).
The cross-sections shown in A and B, as well as the 3D reconstruction in D, show a dense
silica d eposit as already reported for th e n anopores with smaller dimensions and a diffuse
residue (marked yellow) within the p ores with a few sin gle particles (marked in gree n) and
some holes (black ). In the SE image in C, a large particle is visible within the nanopore
embedded in the so-called residue.

- 127 -

Influence of the p H in the aqu eous p hase on silica formation : A processed SEM image of a s ilica
deposit formed at pH 9 shown at two different magnificatio ns (A, B) and no silica f ormatio n at
pH 3 (C), 38° tilt ed view. The residue formed at large nan opores is shown in detail in th e 3D
representation (D, accord ing to the nanopore sho wn in A , B) with: SiN me mbrane (b lue), si ngle
particles (gr een), holes (black) and the diffuse residu e (yell ow). SEM: 5 kV/ 86 pA, TLD at 38°
(corrected tilt), FIB: 30 kV/ 48 pA, 5 nm/slice and in sum 300 slices. A. Ho lzinger, G. Neusser,
B. J. J. Aust en, A. Gamero-Qui jano, G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan, A. Ziegler, P. Walther , and C.
Kranz, Farad ay Discuss. , 2018, 210 , 113. Rep roduced from Re f. 187 . Dist ributed un der the license
Creative Commons Attribution -NonCommercial 3.0 U nported (CC - BY -NC 3.0),
https://creativeco mmons.org/licenses/by -nc /3.0/ .
Because t here is no silic a con densation at the acidic aqu eous solution i n accord ance to
literature 276 , detailed investigations of these p articles or re sidues might give further
information on the residues located on the side of the SiN membra ne f acing the organic
electrolyte solution during electrochemical silica deposi tion. Therefore, a TEM lamella was
prepared b y FIB milling and the elemental composition of t he residue withi n t he nanopore
was investigated. I n Figure 79, SE images of a nanopore (A), the c ross-sectio n of a
nanopore (B) and the preparation of a T EM lamella (C) of the nanoporous array without

- 128 -

silica formation is sh own. The EDX s pectra of two regions within the nanopore, located i n
a TE M lamella thinne r than the actual pore dia meter (STEM image in D), are compared
showing a clear differe nce between the regio n of a bright par ticle and the residue
surrounding this particle. The bright particle consists of Si as mar ke d i n blue in the EDX
spectra, wher eas th e other residue shows almo st no Si signal (marked in y ellow). The Cu
signal i n both E DX sp ectr a is associat ed with the copper T EM grid. No silica is f ormed at
the nanopore shown in Figure 79 according to insufficient pH val ue.

SE images of n anopores after electroch emical investigation s with no silica d eposits d ue t o pH
3 insufficient for th e sil ica formation at th e ITIES (A - C). SE image a fter cro ss-sectioning of a
nanop ore filled with a bright particle (B) and SE image during the preparation of a TEM lamella
by FIB milling with additional Pt/C as a protection layer (C) and STEM image of a TEM lamella
(D). EDX spectra represent the marked regions in (D) in corre sponding colors. SEM (A-C ): 5 kV/
86 pA, 38° tilted, STEM (D): 30 kV. A. Holzinger, G. Neusser, B. J. J . Austen, A. Gamero -Quij ano,
G. Herzog, D. W. M. Arrigan , A. Ziegler, P. Walther , and C. Kran z, Faraday Discus s. , 2018, 210 ,
113. Reproduced from Ref. 187 . Distribute d under the license Creative Commons Attribu tion -
NonComm ercial 3.0 Unpo rt ed (CC - BY - NC 3.0), https://creativec ommon s.org/licenses/by -
nc/3.0/ .

- 129 -

The observed particulate material within the nanopore might b e the result of a pre -
concentration of n on-condensed Si(OH) 4 of the aqu eous ph ase during removal of the
electrolyte solutions while cleaning the samp le. Because Si is just located in th e aqueous
phase, this silica- rich p article in the nanopore was either due to the presence of the
aqueous phase within the nanopore during ITIES invest igations or had to b e moved into
the nanopore during cleaning and drying steps . Both effe cts may be also a ssociated with
the res ults o btained at nanoporous arrays u nder electrochemical c onditions sufficient for
silica formation. In Figure 80, different cross-sections of silica deposits eit her formed at
small n anopores with pore diameters of 72 nm ± 12 nm (N=3) (A, B) an d for large with
nanopore diameters of 322 nm ± 8 4 nm (C ). In all SE images shown in Figure 80, there are
particles located in the r esidue at t he side of the mem brane facing the organic elec trolyte
solution during ITIES me asurements . In case of a large pore as shown in C, these particle s
may have be en moved to this side of the membrane due to cleaning an d drying steps,
whereas for the examples shown in A a nd B for small nanopores, the d imensions of the
particles are too large to be accident al ly moved to this side of the SiN membrane.

Differences in the residue : silica formation at nanoporous a rrays with s mall nanopores (72 nm
 12 nm, A, B) with p articles within the residue for large (A) and small (B) silica depo sits,
compared to silica formation and th e characteristic re sidue at the organic electrolyte facin g
side of the mem brane at nanop ores with large pore diamet ers (322 nm  84 nm, C) . SEM: 5 kV
/ 86 pA, 38° tilted view. A. Holzin ger, G. Neusser, B. J. J. Austen, A. Ga mero -Quijano, G. Herzog,
D. W. M. Arrigan, A. Zie gler, P. Walth er, and C. Kranz, F araday Discuss. , 201 8, 210 , 113.
Reproduce d from Ref. 1 87 . Distributed un der th e lic ense Creative Commons Attributio n -
NonComm ercial 3.0 Unpo rt ed (CC - BY - NC 3.0), https://creativec ommon s.org/licenses/by -
nc/3.0/ .

- 130 -

Therefore, it is most likely that t hese particles indicating the location of the aqu eous p hase
and wi th this the interface between both electrolyte solutions. All SE images and EDX
mappings shown with in this section reveal th at t hese p articles visib le within single
nanopores or in the residue at t he side of the SiN membrane, which face the organic phase
contained Si- related s pecies . At this point, it is not possible to distinguish between silica
or TEOS. Based on the results shown in Figure 80, it is h ighly unlikely that these large
particles are part of th e silica formed at the sid e of the membrane facing the aqueous
electrolyte solutio n duri ng deposition. Either t hese particles i n dicate the location of the
aqueous ph ase durin g ele ctrochemical silica deposit ion at the ITIES, or the residue
represents some kind of mixed phase close to the nanopores. Indeed, e thanol is formed
during t he hydrolysis of TEOS to silica 283 , which is soluble in the aqueous electrolyte
solution, but also in DCE. Although ethanol was removed p rior to electrochemical
deposition at the ITIES, the r esidue may still be related to mixed layer when ethanol was
not completely removed . It has been shown th at the ion transfer at trunc ated pores is
influenced by osm otic pr essures or do uble layers within the nanopores, ev en for miscibl e
solutions. This leads to an ion current recti fication with the electroosmotic flow dependin g
on the ion f low directio n with in the truncated cone- shaped geometry 284 . This mig ht also
be a reason for some kind of mixed phase forming the ob served residue. Hence, the
observed particles may be the result of a combina tion of the discussed effects.

Conclusion and outlook
The advantages of FIB milling for prototyping nanop orous arrays wit hin SiN mem branes
were shown in detail as already reported in previous publica tions 30,31,97 . The importance
of the p ore- to - pore separation with respect to th e current response for nanoporous
arrays at the liquid/liquid interface cou ld b e visualized by AFM -SECM. Additionally, the
position of t he liquid/li quid interface within the n anopores plays a crucial role in the
application of such nano sized interfaces in electroanalysis, which was investigated by the
transport of TPrA + between both electrolyte solut ions and by electrochemical silica
formation d irectly at the water/DCE interfac e. Fo r the first time, 3D FIB/SEM
investigations were used to visualize the silica formation in detail, enabli ng a close look
into th e nanopores and i nto th e silica deposition at the side of t he SiN membran e facing

- 131 -

the aqueous electrolyte solu tion during ele ctrochemical d eposition. Additionally, some
kind of r esidue was observed at th e side facing the or ganic electrolyte solution, which was
characterized by SEM and by EDX measurements performed at TEM lamell as. The results
obtained h ere indicate that the nanop ores are filled with t he aqueous phase, whereas
additional cleaning or heating procedures during samp le preparation might change the
actual situation/location du ring electrochemical ITIES measurements dramatically.
Equally reasonable and con ceivable explanations would be some kind of mixed phase
within the nan opores, which changes during the ele ctrochemical investigation a t the ITIES
and results in a mixed, diffuse residue in close proximity to the nanopores. Hence, the
assumption that the interface is located inlaid towards the aqueous ele ct rolyte sol ution
and that the nanopores are f illed with the organic electrolyte solutio n as reported
previously 31,267 , mig ht be doubted i n case of F IB-milled arrays based on the s tudies
presented here . T he direct characterization of ITI ES w ithin nanoporous membranes is s till
challenging, and the ap proach presented here is highly interesti ng accordin g to the
obtained results. In future st udies, different analytes shou ld be investigat ed b y FIB/SEM
tomography, forming a solid phase directly at the interface between two liquids an d
showing a sufficient contrast in SE images, such as metal ions or co nductive materials. To
prevent changes of the deposition due to additional cleaning and d rying steps and to avoid
art ifacts due to th e rem oval of the elec trolyte solutions, cryogenic FIB/SEM tomography
might be a valu able approach for t he investigations of the interface b etween two
liquids 285 .

- 132 -

Fi na l re m ar ks
In this thesis, the modification of AFM tip-integrated electrodes is presented eval uating
the suitability of integr ated electrochemical sensors for localized detection of H 2 O 2
release (see chapter 4 ) or p H changes (see chapter 5 ) in close proximity to a sample
surface. The results presented with in this thesis are f acing the essential challenges of
integrated min iaturized sen sors . The fabrication of AFM -SECM probes involves several
additional st eps be fore being used i n an AFM-SECM meas urement, namely FIB/SEM
(vacuum conditions) to exp ose the ele ctrode area, to reshape a sharp AFM tip and to
image the modifications, or heating and UV light exposure d uring mounting of AFM -SECM
probes an d ins ulation of the electrical c ontact. These additional tre atments might change
or influence the performance of integrated sensors. In the case of PB/NiHCF as H 2 O 2 -
active material, these additional influences were investigated showing improved stability
of the sensing layers in consecutive H 2 O 2 calibrations (see 4.3.1 ).
For AFM-SECM investigations, it is essential t o use ele ctrodes with fast response t imes in
order to observe local changes in t he elec trochemical signal during scans of the sam ple
surface. The H 2 O 2 sensors, as well as the pH s ensors i ntegrated in to AFM - SECM probes,
have been t ested towa rds their sta bility in long- term measurements showing stable
behavior in external calibrations. For PB/NiHCF- modified sen sors, a change in morphology
was detected by co nsecutive SEM imagi ng o f modified UMEs af ter bei ng exposed to H 2 O 2
(Figure 20 ), by AFM in the pre sence of relatively high H 2 O 2 concentrations of 1 mM (Fig ure
21 ), and by AFM-SECM g ener ating H 2 O 2 at the AFM tip-integrated microelectrode (Figure
19 ). Th ese morpholo gy changes might resul t in some kind of dist ortion of the detected
signals, either by a change of the detected current correlated to the reduced a mount of
H 2 O 2 -sensitive PB mat erial or b y AFM tip artifacts d ue t o t he d issolution of the sensor
material during scanning. Althou gh, changes of electrochemically deposited PB/NiHCF can
be investigated b y SEM prior and after AFM/SECM mea surements, changes occu rring
during ongoi ng measurements may remain undetected b ut might play a cr ucial limi tation
of these integrated H 2 O 2 sensors. In section 4.3.2, modifications of AFM tip -integrated
microelectrodes with optimi zed d eposition parameters for localize d deposition using

- 133 -

diluted solu tions were presented, w hich sh owed, however, a poor reproducibili ty in
several consecutive calibrations. No clear correlation between the amount of PB as
indicated by the redox sign al o f PB i n th e f ilm activat ion via CV i n H Cl/KCl an d t he
sensitivity in H 2 O 2 d etection could be drawn. T his might be also related to the separa tion
of parts of the PB/NiHCF f ilm resulting in a reduced amount of active PB actually in contact
with the underlying microelectrode and , thus, being detected in electrochemical
measurements. Especially f or PB/NiHCF- modified sensors, the modification of an AFM tip -
integrated electrode is challenging becau se the e xact composition of these mixed layers
is unknown. The ED X mapp ing pre sented in Figure 18 indica tes a homogeneous
distribution of PB and NiHCF, though, a laterally resolved determination of the distribution
between both salts is dif ficult due to the given resolution of t he method and the
penetration d epth of the acceleration e -beam, whic h is larger than the actu al t hickness of
the b ilayers. The dissolution of the PB/NiHCF bilayers dep osited on U MEs, det ected either
by AFM or by consecutive SEM imaging, showed individual regi ons of th e material being
predominantly removed under H 2 O 2 exposure. Th is indicates a variation in t he local
composition of these mixed layers. A detailed investigation of the mixed P B/NiHCF layers
with respect to th e composition of the material see ms to b e essential for these
miniaturized H 2 O 2 sen sor s, enabling a targeted optimization of deposition p arameters for
the modification of AFM-SECM probes.
For the results p resented in ch apter 5 , just a limited number of A FM -SECM probes with
integrated Sb or Ir meta l layer suitable f or imaging experiments have b een available as
these p robes h ave been fabricated b y f ormer co-workers of Kranz an d M izaikoff . The
presented investigations are focused on the evaluation o f the most suitable material for
AFM tip-integrated pH sensors facilitating future optimization of the fabrication
procedure of these p H sen sors. Th ereby, Sb/Sb O 2 , AIROF, an d EIROF-modified AFM -SECM
probes were investigated in terms of p H sensitivity and stability. Althou gh the number of
available sensors was limited, t he presented resu lts re veal trends about the most
promising material for m odification of AFM-SECM probes. For all investigated materials,
a broad dis tribution in pH sensiti vity was detected ra nging f rom 37 to 91 mV/p H for EIROF
(see 5.3.3), 31 to 54 mV/pH detected in con secuti ve calibrations of one individual AIROF -
modified AFM-SECM probe (see Figure 44 ), and 50 and 56 mV/pH for two investigated

- 134 -

AFM tip-integrated Sb/SbO 2 sensor s (see Figure 46). A significant advantage of AIROF
electrodes in comparison to Sb is the p ossibility of re generatio n of the s ensor by anodic
oxidation in H 2 SO 4 . In first AFM -SECM investiga tions w ith tip-integrated pH sensors, t he
dissolution of calcite crys tals was map ped resulting in a changed morpholo gy of the
crystals with adjoining changes in pH to more alkaline pH values. However, all
investigations p resented in section 5.3.2 were lacking a lateral resolution for t he detected
OCP signal of the Sb/SbO 2 or AIROF sensors in x-direction, but a good resolution in the
scan direct ion (y-direction), which is also comparable t o results detected by SECM-
SICM 253 . Changes in the OCP sig nal during me asurement could be correlated t o t he
location of t he actual calc ite crystal but lacking suf ficient lateral resolution . Therefore ,
further investigations should focus on optimization of response t imes of AFM tip -
integrated pH sensors.
In chapter 6 , arrays of nanopores fabricated by FIB milling in soli d-state SiN membranes
were presented and in vestigated in terms o f diffusion behavior and location of the
interface of two immisc ible solutions within nan opores. AFM -SECM mea surements
revealed the chan ge in diffusional profiles with respect to the pore - to -por e separation of
individual por es in an array an d showed an overlapped diffusion for closely spaced p ores
and individual diffusion for pores being separated by a ratio of r c /r a = 91 (see equation
(29)). Furt her investigations of the potential -driven ion transport of TPrA + at ITIES and
localized deposition o f silica p articles at the ITES within nanoporous arrays, ad dresses the
question of t he location of the i nterface. In previous publications, it was postulated t hat
the na nopores are filled wit h the organic elec trolyte solut ion, which i s t he case for
nanoporous arrays f abri cated b y e-b eam lithography. The assumption that FIB -milled
nanoporous arrays show t he same b ehavior may b e questionable due to the known
implantation of positively charged Ga ions and a conical - shaped ge omet ry of the
nanopores. Further investigations were presented in c hapter 6 a nd FIB/SEM tomogra phy,
used f or th e first t ime for the investigation of micro- and nano interfaces located in solid -
state materials, is presented in section 6.3.3 and 6.3 .4. The nanopores investiga ted
throughout this thesis are mo st likely filled wi th the aqueous phase forming some kind o f
mixed p hase w ithin the nanopores during t he presented electroc hemical sil ica deposition
at the nanoITIES. It sh oul d be n oted that the presented results obtained for the localized

- 135 -

silica d eposition at t he in terface between two immiscible liquid s requires post -
treatments, n amely rinsing and drying, prior to bein g investigated b y 3D FIB/SEM , which
may influence the location of the interface. To circumvent this, investigations of the
liquid/liquid interface c ould be performed under cryogenic conditions. Cryo-FIB/SEM
tomography offers a n ew perspective on nanoporous materials visualizing interfaces or
the composition o f mixed electrolyte solutions within na nopores and, thus, e nabling
further optimization and understanding of such devices.

- 136 -

Re f er en c es
1. Galler, K., Bräu tigam, K., Gr oße, C., Popp, J . & N eugeba uer, U. Ma king a big thi ng of a small
cell-recent adv ances in sin gle cell an alysis. Analyst 1 39, 1237 – 12 73 (2014).
2. Sarvghad-Moghad dam, M., Parvizi, R., Davoodi, A., Hadd ad-Sabzevar, M. & I mani, A.
Establishing a correla tion between interfacial microstructures and corrosi on initia tion sites
in Al / Cu joints by SEM – E DS and AFM – SK PFM. Corr os. Sc i. 79, 1 48 – 158 (2 014).
3. Phelan, R., Hol mes, J. D. & P etkov, N. Application of se rial sectioning FIB/SEM t omograph y
in the comprehensi ve anal ysis o f arra ys of metal nanotubes. J. Microsc. 2 46, 33 – 4 2 (2 012).
4. Deshpande, A. & LeRoy, B. J. Scannin g probe m icroscopy of graphene. Phys. E 44, 743 – 75 9
(2012).
5. Soliman, M., Ding, Y. & Tetard, L. Nano scale subsurface imaging. J. Phys. Condens. Matter
29, 1 73001 – 24pp ( 2017).
6. Kang, M., Momotenko, D., Page, A. , Perry, D. & Un win, P. R. Frontiers in nan oscale
electrochemical imaging: faster, m ultifuncti onal, and ultrasensitive. Langmuir 32, 7993 –
8008 (201 6).
7. Amemiya, S., Wang, Y. & Mirkin, M. V. in El ectrochemist ry 12, 1 – 43 (The Royal Soci ety of
Chemistry, 2013).
8. Kueng, A., Kranz, C. & Miz aikoff, B. Scanning probe microscopy with int egrated bi osensors .
Sens. Lett. 1, 2 – 15 ( 2003).
9. Eifert, A. & Kranz, C. Hyph enating atomic force microsc opy. Anal. Chem. 86, 519 0 – 5200
(2014).
10. Peddie, C. J. & Collinson, L. M. Exploring the third dime nsion: Volume el ectron microsc opy
comes of age. Mic ron 61, 9 – 19 (2 014).
11. Dryfe, R. A. W. in Advan ces in Chemical Physics (ed. Rice, S. A.) 141, 153 – 2 15 (John Wiley
& Sons, Inc., 2 009).
12. Neusser, G. et al. FIB and MIP: understandin g nanoscale por osity in molecularl y imprinted
polymers via 3D FIB/SEM tomograp hy. Nanoscale 9, 14327 – 1 4334 (2 017).
13. Vierrath, S. et al. Enhancing the quality o f the tom ograph y of nanoporous materials for
better understanding of polymer electrolyte fu el cell materials. J. Power Sou rces 285, 413 –
417 (2015).
14. Wollschläg er, N. et al. Characterizati on o f the inner str ucture of porous TiO2 nanoparticle
films in dye sensitiv e solar cells (DSSC) by focused ion beam (FIB) tomogr aphy and
transmission Kikuchi d iffraction (TKD) in the scann ing electron microscope (SEM). Mater.
Charact. 131 , 39 – 48 (2 017).
15. Villing er, C., Neusser, G., Kranz, C., Walther, P. & Mertens, T. 3D analy sis o f HCMV induced-
nuclear m embrane struct ures by FIB/SEM tomogra phy: Insight into an unpre cedented
membrane morphology. Vi ruses 7, 5 686 – 5704 (2015).
16. de Winter, D. A. et al. Tomography of insulating biolo gical and geological materials usin g
focused ion beam (FIB) sec tioning and low kV BSE imagi ng . J. Microsc. 233, 372 – 38 3 (2009).
17. Hickling, A. & Wilson, W. H. The anodic deco mposition of hydrog en peroxid e. J.
Electroche m. Soc. 9 8, 425 – 433 ( 1951).

- 137 -

18. Itaya, K., Shoji, N. & Uchid a, I. Catalysis of the redu ction of molecular oxygen to wat er at
Prussian blue modified el ectrodes. J. A m. Chem. Soc. 106, 3423 – 3429 (198 4).
19. Karyakin, A. A. Prussian blue and its anal ogues: Electr ochemistry and analytical
applications. Elec troanalysi s 13, 813 – 819 (2001).
20. Komkova, M. A. et al. Ultramicr osensors based on tra nsition metal hexacyanofer rates fo r
scanning electr ochemic al micr oscopy. Beilstein J. Na notech nol. 4, 649 – 654 (20 13).
21. Ng, S. R. & O’Hare, D . An iridium oxide microelectr ode for mo nitoring acute local pH
changes of end othelial c ells. Analy st 140, 42 24 – 4231 (20 15).
22. Izquierd o, J. et al. Spatially resolved measure ment of electroche mical activi ty and pH
distributions in co rrosi on processes by scannin g electroche mical microsc opy using
antimony micr oelectr ode ti ps. Electrochim. Acta 5 6, 884 6 – 8850 (2 011).
23. Roberts, E. J. & Fenwick, F. The Antimony-antimony trioxide electrode and its use as a
measure of acidity. J. Am. Ch em. Soc. 50, 21 25 – 2147 ( 1928).
24. Pitman, A. L., Pourbaix, M. & de Zoubov, N. Potential-pH diagram of th e antimon y-water
system. J. Elec trochem. Soc. 104, 594 – 60 0 (1957).
25. Gottesfeld, S., McIn tyre, J . D . E., B eni, G. & Shay, J. L. Electr ochromism in anodi c irid ium
oxide films. Appl. Phys. Lett. 33, 208 – 210 (1978).
26. Gottesfeld, S. & McIntyre, J. D. E. Electrochr omism in anodic iridium oxid e films. J
Electroche m Soc Elect rochem. Sci. T echnol . 126, 742 – 750 (1979).
27. Steegstra, P. & Ahlberg, E. Influence o f oxidation state o n the pH dependence of hydrous
iridium oxide fil ms. Electro chim. Acta 7 6, 26 – 3 3 (2012 ).
28. Renard, F. et al. Interacti on s of ar senic with calcite surfaces r evealed by in situ nanoscale
imaging. Geo ch im. Cosmoc him. Acta 1 59, 61 – 79 (201 5).
29. Kaufmann, G. & Dreybr odt, W. Calcite dis solution kinetics in the syst em CaCO3 – H2O –
CO2 at high un dersaturati on. Geochim. Cosmoch im. A cta 71, 1398 – 1410 ( 2007).
30. Liu, Y., Sairi, M., Neuss er, G., Kranz, C. & Arrigan, D. W. M. Achieve ment of diffusional
independence a t nanoscale liquid −liquid interfac es within arrays. Anal. Che m. 87, 5486 –
5490 (201 5).
31. Sairi, M., Chen-Tan, N., Neusser, G., Kranz, C. & Arrigan, D . W. M. Electrochemica l
characterisation of nanoscale liquid/liquid interfaces locat ed at f ocused i on beam-milled
silicon nitride membran es. ChemElect roChem 2, 98 – 105 ( 2015).
32. Li, J. et al. Ion-bea m sculp ting at nanomet re leng th scales. Nature 4 12, 166 – 169 (2001).
33. Yang, J. et al. Rapid and precise scanning helium ion microscope milling of solid -stat e
nanopores for biomolecule detection. Nanotechn olog y 22, 1 – 6 (2 011).
34. Kuan, A. T. & Golovchenko , J. A. Nanometer-thin soli d-state nanopores by c old io n beam
sculpting. Ap pl. Phys. Lett. 10 0, 1 – 4 (2012).
35. Hofmann, F. et al. 3D latt ice distortions and defect structures in ion-implanted nano -
crystals. Sci. Rep. 7, 1 – 10 (2 017).
36. Liu, S., Yuzvinsky, T. D. & Schmidt, H. Effect of fabrication -dependen t shap e and
composition of s olid-state nanopores o n sin gle nanop article dete ction. AC S N ano 7, 5621 –
5627 (201 3).

- 138 -

37. Lanyon, Y. H. et al. Fabrication of nanopore arra y electrodes by focused ion beam m illing .
Anal. Chem. 7 9, 3048 – 305 5 (200 7).
38. J. Bard, A. & R. Faulkner, L. Electrochemica l methods : funda mentals and application s . (John
Wiley & Sons, Inc. , 198 0).
39. Hamann, C. H., Hamnett, A. & Vielstich, W. Elect roche mistry . (WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH &
Co. KGaA, 20 07).
40. Ciobanu, M., Wilbu rn, J. P., Kri m, M. L. & Cliff el, D. E. in Handboo k of Electroche mistry (ed.
Zoski, C. G.) 3 – 29 (Elsevier , 2007).
41. Amemiya, S. in Handbook o f Electroche mistry (ed. Z oski, C. G.) 261 – 294 (Els evier, 20 07).
42. Bobacka, J., Ivaska, A. & Lewensta m, A. Potentiometri c ion sensors. Chem. Rev. 108, 329 –
351 (2008).
43. Brat ov, A., Abra mova, N. & Ipatov, A. Recent trends in pote ntio metric sensor arrays - a
review. Anal. Chim. Acta 6 78, 14 9 – 159 (2010 ).
44. Glab, S., Maj- Żurawska, M. & Hulan icki, A. in Reference M odule in Chemistry, Molecular
Sciences and Che mical Eng ineerin g (E lsevier In c., 2013 ).
45. Glab, S., Hulanicki, A., Edwall, G. & Ingman, F. Metal-metal oxide and metal oxide
electrodes as pH sensors. Crit. Rev. An al. Chem. 21, 29 – 47 (1989).
46. Gill, E., Arshak, K., Arshak, A. & Kor ostynska, O. Mix ed m etal oxide films a s pH sensing
materials. Mic rosyst. Techn ol. 14, 499 – 5 07 (2008).
47. Slowinska, K. & Majda, M . Measurements of the cap acitance and the response time o f
solid-state potentiome tric senso rs by an electroche mical time- of -flig ht method. J S olid
State Elect rochem 8, 7 63 – 771 (2 004).
48. Liu, C.-C., B occhicchio, B. C., Overmyer, P. A. & Neuma n, M. R. A palladium-palladi um o xide
miniature pH electrod e. Science 207, 1 88 – 189 (1980).
49. Kinoshita, K. & Madou, M . J. Electrochemical measurements on Pt, Ir, and Ti oxides as pH
probes. J. Elec trochem. Soc . Electroche m. Sci. Tech nol. 131, 10 89 – 1094 ( 1984).
50. Kinoshita, E., Ingman, F., Edwall, G., Thulin, S. & Glab, S. Polycrystalline and monocrystalline
antimony, iridiu m and pallad ium as electrode material for pH-sensing electrodes. Talanta
33, 1 25 – 134 (1 986).
51. Edwall, G. Impro ved antimony-anti mony ( 1 11 ) oxide pH electr odes. Med. Biol. Eng.
Comput. 16, 66 1 – 669 (1 978).
52. Edwall, G. & Jöngren, P .-A. Ev aluation of the influence of im puriti es o n the oxy ge n
sensitivity o f m onocrystal line antimony electrodes. Electr ochim. Acta 25, 1 585 – 159 0
(1980).
53. Wang, M., Yao, S. & Madou, M. A long-term stable irid ium oxide pH electrode. Sensors
Actuators, B Chem. 81, 31 3 – 315 (2 002).
54. Bishop, E. & Sh ort, G. D. Some observati ons on the zero -current behaviour of antimony
indicator electr odes. Talan ta 11, 393 – 403 (19 64).
55. Fog, A. & Buck, R. P. Electronic semiconducting oxides as pH sensors. Sensors and Actuators
5, 137 – 146 (1984 ).

- 139 -

56. Tarlov, M. J., Semancik, S. & Kreider, K. G. Mechanis tic and response studies of iridium
oxide pH sens ors. Sensors Actuators B. Chem. 1, 2 93 – 297 (1990).
57. Katsube, T., Lauks, I. & Z emel, J. N. pH-sensiti ve spu ttered iridiu m oxide film s. Sensors an d
Actuators 2, 399 – 410 ( 1982).
58. Boodts, J. C. F. & Trasatti , S. Hydrogen evolution on iridium o xide cathodes. J. Appl.
Electroche m. 1 9, 255 – 262 (1989).
59. Pauporté, T., Andolfatto, F. & D urand, R. Some electroc atalytic properti es of anodi c iridium
oxide nanoparticl es in acidi c solution. Elec trochim. Ac ta 45, 431 – 439 (19 99).
60. Hitchman, M. L. & Ra manathan , S. Evaluation of iri dium oxi de electrodes formed by
potential cy cling as pH pro bes. Analyst 11 3, 35 – 3 9 (1988).
61. Olthuis, W., Robben, M . A. M., Bergv eld, P., Bos, M. & van der Linden, W. E. pH sensor
properties of electroche mically grown iridiu m o xide. Sensors Actuato rs B. Chem. 2, 247 –
256 (1990).
62. VanHoudt, P., Lewandows ki, Z. & Little, B. Iridium oxide pH microelectrod e. Biotechnol.
Bioeng. 40 , 601 – 608 (1 992).
63. Marzouk, S. A. M . Improved electrodeposited iridium oxide pH sensor fabricated on et ched
titanium subs trates. Anal. Ch em. 75, 52 – 60 (2 002).
64. Shoup, D. & Szabo, A. Chron oamperometric current at finite disk electrodes. J Electroa nal
Chem 140, 237 – 245 (19 82).
65. Zoski, C. G. Ultramicr oelectrodes : design, fabrication, and characterization. Electroana lysis
14, 1 041 – 1051 (2 002).
66. Zoski, C. G. & Mirkin, M . V. Steady-state li miting curre nts at finite c onical microel ectrodes.
Anal. Chem. 7 4, 1986 – 199 2 (200 2).
67. Mirkin, M. V & Bard, A. J. Multidim ensional integral equations: a new approa ch solving
microelectr ode d iffusion p roblems, Par t 2: application s to microband electrodes and the
scanning electr ochemic al micr oscope. J Electroana l Chem 323 , 29 – 5 1 (1992).
68. Peljo, P. & Girault, H. H. in Encyclo pedia of Ana lytical Chemistry 1 – 28 (John Wiley & Sons,
Ltd, 2012) .
69. Samec, Z. Electrochemistr y at the interface betwe en two immiscible electrolyt e solutions .
Pure Appl. Chem. 76, 2147 – 2180 ( 2004).
70. Verwey, E. J. W. & Niessen, K. F. XL . The electrical double layer at the interfa ce of tw o
liquids. Phil os. Mag. Ser. 7 28, 435 – 446 (193 9).
71. Gavach, C., Seta, P. & D’Ep enoux, B. The double la yer and ion adso rpti on at the interface
between two non miscibl e solutions. Part I. Interfa cial tension measure ment s for the
water-nitrobenz ene tetraal ky lammoniu m bro mide sys tems. J . Electroanal. Chem. 83, 225 –
235 (1977).
72. Kakiuchi, T. & Send a, M . Structure of the electrical do uble layer at the interface between
nitrobenzene solution of tetrabutyla mmoniu m tetraph enylborate and aqueous so lution of
lithium chl oride. Bull Chem Soc Jpn 56, 1753 – 1 760 (19 83).
73. Samec, Z., Marecek, V. & Homolka, D. The double layer at the interface between two
immiscible electr olyte solutions Part II. Structure of the water/nitr obenzene interface i n

- 140 -

the presence of 1: 1 and 2:2 electr olytes. J Electroanal Chem 187, 31 – 51 (1 985).
74. Girault, H. in Modern Aspe cts of Electrochemistry (ed. Bockris, J. O.) 1 – 62 ( Plenum Press,
1993).
75. Girault, H. H. J. & Schiffrin , D. J. Thermodynamics of a polarised interface be tween two
immiscible electrol yte solutions. J Elec troanal Che m 170, 127 – 1 41 (1984).
76. Valent, O., Koryta, J. & Panoch, M. Voltam metric stud y of ion transfer across the water/ o -
nitrophenyloct yl et her interface. Part I. Reversibl e process. J. Electroanal. Chem. 226, 21 –
25 (1987).
77. Schurhammer, R. & Wipff, G. About the TATB assum ption: Effect o f charge reversal on
transfer of large spherical ions from aqueous to non-aqueous solvents and on their
interfacial beha viour. J. Mo l. Struct. THEOCH EM 500, 1 39 – 155 (2 000).
78. Shao, Y. & Mirkin, M. V. Fa st kinetic m easurement s with nan ometer -siz ed pipets. Transfer
of p otassium ion fr om water int o d ichloroethan e fa cil itated by dibenz o - 18 -crown-6. J. A m.
Chem. Soc. 11 9, 8103 – 81 04 (1997).
79. Rodgers, P. J., Amemi ya, S., Wang, Y. & Mirkin, M. V. Nanopipet voltammetry of common
ions acros s the liquid-liq uid interface. Theory and limitations in kinetic analysis of
nanoelectrod e voltam mogr ams. Anal. Che m. 8 2, 84 – 90 (2010).
80. Campbell, J. A. & Girault, H. H. Steady stat e curren t for io n transfer reactions at a micro
liquid/liq uid interface. J. El ectroanal. Chem. 266, 465 – 469 (19 89).
81. Stephenson, M. J., Holmes, S. M . & Dryfe, R. A. W. A n ovel approach to the elucidation of
facilitated ion transfer mechanisms at the liquid /liquid interface. El ectroche m. Co mmun. 6,
294 – 298 ( 2004).
82. Dryfe, R. A. W. M odifying the liquid / liquid interface : pores, particles and depositi on. P hys.
Chem. Chem. Phys. 8, 1 869 – 1883 (2006).
83. Zazpe, R., Hibert, C., O’B rien, J., Lanyon, Y. H. & Arriga n, D. W. M. I on-transfer voltam metry
at silic on membran e-based array s of micro-liquid – liqui d in terfaces. L ab Chip 7, 17 32 – 1737
(2007).
84. Alvarez De Eulate, E., Strutwolf, J. J., L iu, Y., O’Do nnell, K. & Arrigan, D. W. M. A n
electrochemical sensing pl atform based o n liquid-liquid microinterfac e arrays f ormed in
laser-ablated glas s me mbran es. Anal. Chem. 88 , 2596 – 2604 (2016).
85. Huang, X., Xie, L., Lin, X. & Su, B. Permselecti ve io n transport across the nanoscopic
liquid/liq uid interface arra y. Anal. Chem. 88, 6 563 – 656 9 (2016).
86. Platt, M., Dr yfe, R. A. W. & Roberts, E. P. L. El ectrodep osition of palladiu m n anoparticles at
the liquid-liquid interface using po rous alu mina templates. Electrochim. Acta 48, 3037 –
3046 (200 3).
87 . Tsionsk y, M., Bard, A. J. & Mirkin, M. V. Long -rang e electron transfer through a lipid
monolayer a t the liqu id/liquid interface. J. A m. Chem. Soc. 119, 1 0785 – 107 92 (1997).
88. Liu, B. & M irkin, M. V. Electrochemistry at m icrosc opic liquid -liquid interfaces.
Electroanalysis 12, 1433 – 1 446 (2000).
89. Beattie, P. D., Delay, A. & Girault, H. H. Investigation o f the kinetics of assist ed p otassiu m
ion transfer by dibenzo- 18 -crown- 6 at the micro-ITIES by means of stead y-state
voltammetry. J. Electroa nal. Chem. 38 0, 167 – 175 ( 1995).

- 141 -

90. Beattie, P. D., Dela y, A. & Girault, H. H. Investigati on of the kinetics of ion and assi sted ion
transfer by the techn ique of AC impedan ce of the micro-ITIES. Elect rochim. Ac ta 40, 2961 –
2969 (199 5).
91. Solomon, T. & Bard, A. J. Scanning electrochemical microscopy. 30. application o f glas s
micropipet tips and electro n transfer at the interface between two immiscibl e electrolyt e
solutions for SEC M imagin g. Anal. Chem. 6 7, 2787 – 27 90 (19 95).
92. Molina, A., L aborda, E. & Compton, R. G. Cyclic and square-wave voltammetry at
diffusionally asy mmetric microscopic and nanoscop ic liquid−liquid interfac es: a simpl e
theoretical approach. J. Ph ys. Chem. C 1 18, 18 249 – 18256 ( 2014).
93. Braga, C., Galindo, A. & Müller, E. A. Nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulation of
diffusion at the liquid-liqu id interface. J. Ch em. Phys. 141, 1 – 9 (20 14).
94. Bond, A. M., Luscombe, D., Oldham, K. D . & Zoski, C. G. a compariso n of the
chronoamper ometric response at inlaid and recessed disc micr oelectrodes. J Electroanal
Chem 249, 1 – 14 (198 8).
95. Josserand, J., Morandini, J., Lee , H. J., Ferrig no, R. & Gir ault, H. H. Finite element simulati on
of i on transf er r eactions at a single micro -liquid ∣ li quid interface sup ported on a thin
polymer film. J. El ectroanal . Chem. 46 8, 42 – 52 (1999 ).
96. Ellis, J. S., Strutwolf, J. & Arrigan , D. W. M . Finite-element simulati ons of the inf luence of
pore wall adsorp tion o n cyclic voltammetr y of ion transfer across a liquid – liquid interface
formed at a micropore. Phy s. Chem. Chem. Phys. 14, 2494 – 25 00 (2012).
97. Liu, Y., Strutw olf, J. & Arrig an, D. W. M. I on-transfer voltam metric behavi or of pr opranolo l
at nanoscale liqu id−liquid interface arrays. Ana l. Chem. 8 7, 4487 – 4 494 (201 5).
98. Scanlon, M. D . et al. Io n- transfer electrochemis try at arrays of nanointerfaces between
immiscible electrolyte solutions c onfined within silicon nitride nanopor e. Anal. C hem. 82,
6115 – 612 3 (2010).
99. Kralj, B. & Dryfe, R. A. W. Me mbrane voltam metry: T he interface betw een two immiscible
electrolyte solutions. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 3, 5274 – 52 82 (2001).
100. Gadaleta, A. et al. Sub -additive i onic transport across arrays of s olid-state nanopores. Phys.
Fluids 26, 1 – 11 (2014 ).
101. Binnig, G., Quat e, C. F. & G erber, C. At omic f orc e microsc ope. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 9 30 – 93 3
(1986).
102. Müller, D. J. & D ufrêne, Y. F. Atomic force m icros copy as a multifunctional molecular
toolbox in nanobi otechn ology. Nat. Nanotechn ol. 3, 261 – 26 9 (2008).
103. Dai, H., Hafner, J. H., Rinzler, A. G., Colb ert, D . T. & Sm alley, R. E. Nanotube s as nan oprobes
in scanning probe micr oscopy. Nature 3 84, 147 – 1 50 (1996).
104. Ma, X. et al. Sharp-tip silver nanowires mount ed on cantilev ers for high-aspect-ratio high-
resolution i maging. Nano L ett. 16, 6 896 – 6902 (2 016).
105. Kato, N., Kawashima, T., S hibata, T., Minet a, T. & Makino, E. Micromachining of a newl y
designed AFM probe integrated with hollow micron eedle for cellular function analysis.
Microelec tron. Eng. 87, 118 5 – 1189 (2 010).
106. Ducker, W. a., Senden, T. J. & P ashley, R. M. D irect measu rement of c olloidal forces using
an atomic forc e micr oscope. Nature 353, 239 – 2 41 (19 91).

- 142 -

107. Wey mouth, A. J., Hofmann, T. & Giessibl, F. J. Quan tifying molecular stiff ness and
interaction wi th lateral fo rce mi croscop y. Science 343, 11 20 – 1122 (20 14).
108. Pérez, R., García, R., Pe, Â., Garcõ, R. & García, R. Dynamic ato mic forc e microscopy
methods. Su rf. Sci. Rep. 47, 197 – 301 (2002 ).
109. Zhong, Q., Inniss, D ., Kjo ller , K. & Elings, V. B. Fractured polymer/silica fiber surface studied
by tapping m ode atomi c force micr oscopy. Surf. Sci. Lett. 29 0, L688 – L 692 (1993).
110. Gross, L. et al. Atomic fo rce microscopy for mole cular structure elucidation. Angew.
Chemie - Int. Ed. 57, 388 8 – 3908 (2 018).
111. Minne, S. C., Hu, Y., Hu, S., Pittenger, B. & Su, C. Nanoscale quantitative mechanical
property mapping using peak forc e tapping atomic fo rce m icros copy. Mic rosc. Microanal.
16, 4 64 – 465 (2 010).
112. Radmacher, M., Cl eveland , J. P., Fritz, M., Hansma, H. G. & Hansma, P. K. Mapping
interaction f orces with the atomic f orce micr oscope. Biophys. J. 66, 215 9 – 2165 (1 994).
113. Nonnenmach er, M., O’Boyle, M. P. & Wickram asinghe, H. K. Kelvin probe force mic roscopy.
Appl. Phys. Le tt. 58, 2921 – 29 23 (1991).
114. Bard, A. J ., Fan, F. F., Kwa k, J. & Lev, O. Scanning electr ochemical m icrosc opy. Intr oduction
and princip les. Anal. Chem. 61, 13 2 – 138 (19 89).
115. Holzinger, A., Steinbach , C. & Kranz, C. in Electroche mical S trategies in Detection Science
(ed. Arrigan , D. W. M.) 125 – 169 (2 016).
116. Luo, H. et al. Sensing appli cation in the precurs or regi on of localized corr osion b y scann ing
electrochemical micro scopy. RSC Adv. 4, 5658 2 – 56595 (20 14).
117. Bard, A. & Mirkin, M. Scann ing electrochemica l micro scopy . (CRC Press , 2012).
118. Ludwig, M., Kranz, C., Schuhmann , W. & Gaub, H. E. To pograp hy m icrosc ope fee dbac k
mechanism for the scanning electrochemi cal based on hydrodyna mic forces between tip
and sample. Rev. Sci. Inst rum. 66, 2857 – 2 860 (199 5).
119. Ballesteros Katemann, B., Schulte, A. & Schuh mann, W. Constant -distanc e mode scanning
electrochemical microscopy (SECM)-Part I: Adaptati on of a n on-o ptical shear-f or ce -based
positioning mode for SEC M tips. Chem Eur J 9, 202 5 – 203 3 (2003).
120. James, P. I., Garfias-Mesias, L. F., Moyer, P. J. & Smyrl, W. H. Scanning electrochemic al
microscopy with simultaneous independent topograp hy. J Electrochem S oc 145, L64 – L66
(1998).
121. Wipf, D. O., Bard, A. J. & Tallman , D . E. Scanning ele ctroche mical mi croscopy. 21. constant-
current imagin g with an autoswitching controller. Ana l. Chem. 65, 1373 – 13 77 (1993).
122. Alpuche-Aviles, M. A. & Wipf, D. O. I mpedance feedb ack control for scanning
electrochemical micro scopy. Anal. Chem. 73, 4873 – 4 881 (2 001).
123. Cortes-Salazar, F. e t al. Sof t stylus pr obes for scannin g electroch emical microscopy. Anal.
Chem. 81, 6 889 – 6896 (2 009).
124. Lee, C., Kwak, J. & Anson, F. C. Application of scanning electroche mical micros copy to
generation/c ollection experiments with high co llecti on efficiency. Anal. Chem. 63, 150 1 –
1504 (199 1).
125. Eckhard, K., Chen, X., Turcu, F. & Schuhmann, W. Redox competiti on mode of scannin g

- 143 -

electrochemical microscop y (RC - SE CM) for visualisati on of l ocal catalytic activi ty. Phys.
Chem. Chem. Phys. 8, 5 359 (2006 ).
126. Kranz, C., Ludwig, M. M., Gaub, H. E. & Schuhmann, W. Lateral depositi on of polypyrrol e
lines by means of the scan ning electrochemical microscope. Adv. Mate r. 7, 38 – 40 (1995).
127. Eckhard, K., Etienne, M., Sc hulte, A. & Schuh mann, W. Constant -distance mode AC-SECM
for the visualis ation of corr osion pits. Electrochem. Commun. 9, 17 93 – 1797 (20 07).
128. Lee, Y., Ding, Z. & Bard, A. J. Combined scanning electrochemical /optical microscopy with
shear force and current f eedback. Anal. Chem. 74, 3634 – 43 ( 2002).
129. Wang, L., Kowali k, J., Mizaikoff, B. & Kranz, C. Combining scanning electrochemical
microscopy with infrared attenuated total reflection spectrosc opy for in situ studies of
electrochemicall y induced processes. Anal. Chem. 82, 3139 – 3145 ( 2010).
130. Szunerits, S., Knorr, N., Calemczuk, R. & Livache, T. New approach to writing and
simultaneous reading o f micropatterns: combinin g surface plasmon resonance imaging
with scanning el ectroche mical mi croscop y (SECM). Langmuir: 20, 92 36 – 41 (20 04).
131. Hansma, P . K., Drake, B., Marti, O., G ould, S. a & Prater, C. B. The scannin g ion-conductance
microscope. Science 243, 641 – 643 (1989).
132. Macpherson, J. V. & Unwin, P. R. Combined scann ing electrochemical-atomic force
microscopy. Anal. Chem. 7 2, 276 – 285 ( 2000).
133. Kranz, C. et al. Integrati ng an ultramicr oelectr ode in an AFM cantilever: combined
technology for enhanced in formation. Anal. Che m. 73, 2491 – 500 (2 001).
134. Kueng, A., Kranz, C., Lugst ein, A., Bertagn olli, E. & M izaikoff, B. Integra ted AFM-SECM in
tapping m ode: simultaneous topographical and electr ochemical imaging of enzyme
activity. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 42, 3238 – 4 0 (2003).
135. Kranz, C., Kueng, A. , Lugs tein, A., Bertagn olli, E. & Mizaikoff, B. Mapping of enzyme activi ty
by detection of enzymatic produ cts during AFM imaging with integrat ed SECM – AF M
probes. Ultramic roscopy 1 00, 127 – 1 34 (2004).
136. Anne, A., Demaille, C. & Goyer, C. Electroche mical atomi c -force m icrosc opy using a tip-
attached redox mediator. Proof - of -concept and perspectives for functional probing of
nanosyste ms. ACS Nano 3, 819 – 82 7 (2009).
137. Wang, K., Goyer, C., Anne, A. & Demaille, C. Explori ng the motional dynamics of end -
grafted DNA o lig onucleotid es by in situ elec troch emic al atomic force m icrosc opy. J. Phys.
Chem. B 111, 6 051 – 8 (20 07).
138. Anne, A., Chovin, A., Demaille, C. & Lafouresse, M. High-reso lution m apping of redox-
immunomarked proteins using electrochemical-ato mic force microscopy in mo lecul e
touching mode. Anal. Che m. 83, 7924 – 32 (201 1).
139. dos Santos Riccardi, C. et al. Label-free DNA detection of h epatitis C virus based on
modified conducting polyp yrrole films at microelectro des and atomic force m icro scopy tip -
integrated electrodes. Ana l. Chem. 80, 2 37 – 45 (20 08).
140. Hirata, Y., Yabuki, S. & Miz utani, F. Ap plication o f int egrated SECM ultra- micro-electr ode
and AFM force pr obe to biosens or surfa ces. Bioelectroc hemistry 63, 2 17 – 24 (20 04).
141. Kueng, A., Kran z, C., Lugstein, A., Bertagn olli, E. & Mizaikoff, B. AFM -tip-integrate d
amperometric microbiosen sors: high-resolution imagi ng of membrane transport . Angew.

- 144 -

Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 44, 341 9 – 22 (2 005).
142. Gueneau de M ussy, J.-P., Macpherson, J. V & Delplancke, J. -L. Chara cterisation and
behaviour of Ti/ TiO2/n oble metal an odes. Electrochim . Acta 48, 1131 – 114 1 (2003).
143. Davoodi, A., Pan, J., Leygraf, C. & Norgren, S. Integrated AFM and SECM fo r in situ studies
of localized c orrosion of Al all oys. Electrochim. Acta 52, 7697 – 7705 (2007).
144. Davoodi, A., Farzadi, A., Pan, J., Leygraf, C. & Zhu, Y. Developing an AFM -bas ed SECM
system; instrumental set up, SECM simulation, characterizati on, and calibration. J.
Electroche m. Soc. 155, C4 74 – C48 5 (2008).
145. Davoodi, A., Pan, J., Leygr af, C. & Norgren, S. Probin g of local dissolution of Al-alloy s in
chloride soluti ons by AF M and SECM. Appl. Su rf. Sci. 252, 5 499 – 5503 (2006).
146. Izquierd o, J., Fernández-Pérez, B. M., Eifert, A., Souto, R. M. & Kranz, C. Simultaneous
atomic force - scanning electrochemical micros copy (AFM-SECM) imaging o f coppe r
dissolution. Elect rochim. Ac ta 201, 3 20 – 332 (2 016).
147. Izquierd o, J., Eifert, A., Kranz, C. & Souto, R. M. In situ investigation of copper corrosion in
acidic chloride solution using atomic force — scann ing electrochemical microscopy .
Electrochim. Ac ta 247, 588 – 599 ( 2017).
148. Jones, C. E., Unwin, P. R. & Macpherson, J. V. In situ observati on of the surface processes
involved in dissolution from the cleavag e surface of calcite in aqueous solution using
combined scann ing electr ochemical-atomic force micr oscopy (SEC M -AFM).
ChemPhysChem 4, 139 – 146 ( 2003).
149. Kueng, A., Kranz, C. & Miza ikoff, B. Imaging of ATP membrane transp ort with dual micro -
disk electrodes and s canning electroche mical m icros copy. Biosens. Bioelectron. 21, 346 – 53
(2005).
150. Macpherson, J. V., Jones, C. E., Barker, A. L. & Un win, P. R. Electrochemical imagin g of
diffusion through single nanoscale pores. Anal. Chem. 74, 18 41 – 1848 (20 02).
151. Eckhard, K., Shin, H., Mizaikoff, B., Schuhmann, W. & Kranz, C. Alternating curr ent (AC)
impedance imagin g with combined atomic force s cannin g electrochemical microscopy
(AFM-SECM). Elect rochem. Commun . 9, 1311 – 131 5 (2007).
152. Huang, K., Anne, A., Bahri, M. A. & Demail le, C. Probin g individual redox P EGyl ated gold
nanoparticles by electrochemical – at omic force microscopy. ACS Nano 7, 4151 – 4163
(2013).
153. Dobson, P. S., Weaver, J. M. R., Holder, M. N., Unwin, P . R. & Macphers on, J. V.
Characterizati on of batch-microf abricated scanni ng electrochemical-atomi c force
microscopy pr obes. Anal. C hem. 77, 424 – 434 (200 5).
154. Eifert, A. et a l. Atomic force microscopy probes with integrat ed boron doped diamond
electrodes: Fab rication and appli cation. Electroche m. Commun. 2 5, 30 – 34 (2012) .
155. Gardner, C. E., Unwin, P. R. & Ma cpherson, J. V. Correlation of membrane structure an d
transport activity using combined scanning electrochemic al – atomic force microscopy .
Electroche m. Commun. 7, 612 – 618 (2005).
156. Rodriguez, R. D., Anne, A., Cambril, E. & Demaille, C. Optimized hand fabricated AFM
probes for simultaneous topo graphical and electrochemical tapping mode imaging.
Ultramicroscop y 111, 973 – 81 (2011).

- 145 -

157. Fasching, R. J ., Ta o, Y. & Prin z, F. B. Cantilever tip prob e arra ys for simultane ous S ECM and
AFM analysis. Sensors Ac tuators B Chem. 108, 964 – 972 ( 2005).
158. Shin, H., Hesketh, P . J., Mizaikoff, B. & Kranz, C. Batch fabri cation of atomic force
microscopy pr obes with recessed integrated ring m icroele ctrodes at a wafer level. Anal.
Chem. 79, 4 769 – 4777 (2 007).
159. Lee, E., Kim, M., Seong, J., Shin, H. & Lim, G. A n L-shaped nanoprobe for scanning
electrochemical m icrosc opy-atomic force micros copy . P hys Status Solidi RRL 7, 4 06 – 409
(2013).
160. Knittel, P., Higgins, M. J. & Kranz, C. Nanoscopic p olypyrrole AFM – SECM probes enabling
force measure ments und er potential c ontrol. Nanosca le 6, 2 255 – 2260 (2014).
161. Eifert, A., Mizaikoff, B. & Kranz, C. Advanced fabric ation process for combined ato mic
force-scannin g electroch emical microscopy (AFM -SE CM) p robes. Micron 68, 27 – 35 (201 5).
162. Lugstein, A., Bertagn olli, E., Kranz, C. & Mizaikoff, B. Fabrication of a ring nanoelec trode in
an AFM tip: N ovel appr oach towards simultaneous electrochemical and topograph ical
imaging. Surf. Interface Ana l. 33, 146 – 1 50 (200 2).
163. Knittel, P., Bibikova, O. & Kranz, C. Challeng es in nanoelectroche mical and nanomechanica l
studies of individual aniso tropic gold nanoparticl es. Fa rada y Discuss. 193, 353 – 369 (2016).
164. Burt, D. P ., Wilson, N. R., Weaver, J. M . R., Dobson, P. S. & Macph e rson, J. V. Nanowire
probes for high r esolution combined scanning electrochemical microscopy - atomic f orce
microscopy. Nan o Lett. 5, 639 – 643 (2005).
165. Knittel, P., Zhang, H., Kranz, C., Wallace, G. G. & Higgins, M. J. Probing the PEDOT:PSS/cell
interface with conductive colloidal pr obe AF M-SECM. Nan oscale 8, 4475 – 448 1 (2016).
166. Moon, J., Shin, H., Mizaikoff, B. & Kranz, C. Bitm ap-assisted focused ion beam fabrication
of combined atomic force scanning electroche mical m icrosc opy probes. Journa l-Korean
Phys. Soc. 5 1, 920 (2007 ).
167. Leonhardt, K. et al. Atomic forc e microscopy-scann ing electrochemical microscopy:
Influence o f tip g eomet ry and insul ation defects on d iffusion c ontrolled cur rents at conical
electrodes. Anal. Che m. 83, 2971 – 2 977 (201 1).
168. Gullo, M . R. et al. Characte rization of mi crofabricated probe s f or co mbined atomic fo rce
and high-resoluti on scanning electrochemic al micros copy. An al. Chem. 78, 5436 – 544 2
(2006).
169. Kottke, P . a. & Fedorov, A. G. Advective and transient effects in com bined AFM/SECM
operation. J. Elect roanal. C hem. 583 , 221 – 231 ( 2005).
170. Ghorbal, A. et al. Localized electrografting o f v in ylic monomers o n a conducting su bstrate
by means of an integra ted electr ochemical AFM probe. ChemPhysCh em 1 0, 1053 – 10 57
(2009).
171. Abbou, J., Anne, A. & De maille, C. P robin g the stru cture and dyna mics of end -grafted
flexible polym er chain layer s by c ombined ato mic force-electroche mical microscopy. Cyclic
voltammetry within nan ometer-thick macro molecul ar poly(ethylene gl ycol) la yers. J. Am.
Chem. Soc. 12 6, 10095 – 1 0108 (20 04).
172. Smirnov, W. et al. D iamon d-modified AFM probes: from dia mond nanowires to atomic
force microscopy-integra ted boron-doped diamond electrodes. Anal. Chem. 83, 4936 –
4941 (201 1).

- 146 -

173. Wiedemair, J., M oon, J. S., Eaton, D. E., Mizaik off, B. & Kranz, C. Combin ed AFM-SECM:
Towards a n ovel platfor m for imagin g microbi osensor s. IFMBE Proc. 25, 37 2 – 375 (2 009).
174. Wiedemair, J., Moon, J. S., Reinauer, F. , Mizaikoff, B. & Kranz, C. Ion bea m induced
deposition of platinum carbon composite electrodes for combined atomic forc e
microscopy-scannin g electroche mical microscop y. Electrochem. Com mun. 12, 989 – 991
(2010).
175. Goldstein, J. I. et al. Scann ing electron microscopy and X-ray microanalysis . (Kluwer
Academic/ Plenum Publishe r, 200 3).
176. Demers, H. et al. Three-dimensi onal elec tron microscopy simulati on with the CASINO
Monte Carl o software. Sca nning 33, 135 – 146 (201 1 ).
177. Everhart, T. E. & Thornle y, R. F. M. Wide-band detector for micro-microa mpere low-energy
electron curr ents. J. Sci. In strum. 37, 246 – 248 ( 1960).
178. Randolph, S. J., Fo wlkes, J. D . & Rack, P . D. Focus ed, nanoscale electron -beam-in duced
deposition and e tching. Cri t. Rev. Solid S tate Mate r. Sci. 31, 55 – 89 (2006).
179. Möllenstedt , G. & Speidel, R. Elektronen optischer Mikroschreib er unter
elektronen mikroskopischer Arbeitsk ontrolle. Phys. Blä tter 16, 19 2 – 198 (196 0).
180. Yao, N. Focused ion beam sys tems . Scienc e An d Technology (Cambridge University Press,
2007).
181. Liu, Y. et al. Visualizati on of diffusion within nanoarrays . Anal. Chem. 88, 6689 – 66 95 (2016).
182. Sudraud , P. Focused-i on-be am milling , scanning-electron microscopy, and f ocused-d roplet
deposition in a single microcircuit surgery t ool. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B Microelectron.
Nanom. Struct. 6, 234 ( 1988).
183. Holzer, L ., Ind utnyi, F., Gas ser, P., Münch, B. & Wegmann, M . Three-dimensional analysis
of porous BaTiO 3 cera mics using FIB nanotomograp hy. J. Microsc. 2 16, 84 – 95 (2004).
184. Cazaux, J. Recent devel opments and new strategies in scanning electron m icrosc opy. J.
Microsc. 217, 16 – 35 (2005) .
185. Wargo, E. A., Ko taka, T., Tabuchi, Y. & Kumbur, E. C. Comparison of focused io n beam
versus nano-scale X-ray computed tomograph y for re solving 3 -D microstructures of porous
fuel cell mat erials. J. Powe r Source s 241, 608 – 61 8 (201 3).
186. Lasagni, F., Lasagni, A., Engstler, M ., Degischer, H. P. & Mücklich, F. Nano -charac terization
of cast structures by FIB-to mography. Adv. Eng . Mater . 10, 62 – 66 (2008).
187. Holzinger, A. et al. Investig ation of modified nanopore arrays usin g FIB/SEM tomography.
Faraday Discus s. 210, 113 – 130 ( 2018).
188. Moon, J. S. Next generati on of multifunctional scann ing probes. (Georgia Institute of
Technology, 2010). a t <http ://hdl.handle.net /1853 /42935>
189. Dickinson, B. C. & Chang, C. J. Chemistry and biol ogy of reactive oxygen specie s in signaling
or stress respons es. Nat. Ch em. Biol. 7, 504 – 511 ( 2011).
190. Yeager, E. Ele ctrocatalysts for O2 r eduction. Electrochi m. Acta 2 9, 1527 – 1537 (19 84).
191. Fukuzumi, S. & Yamada, Y. Hydrogen peroxide used as a solar fuel in one -compart ment fuel
cells. ChemElect roChem 3, 19 78 – 1989 ( 2016).

- 147 -

192. Gunz, D . W. & Hoffmann, M . R. Atmospheric chemistry of peroxide s: a review. Atmos.
Environ. Part A, Gen. Top. 2 4, 1601 – 1 633 (1990).
193. Miller, W. L. & Kester, D. R. Hydrogen peroxide measuremen t in seawat er by (p-
hydroxyphenyl)a cetic acid dimerizati on. Anal. Chem. 60, 271 1 – 2715 (1 988).
194. Matsubara, C., Kawam oto, N. & Taka mura, K. Ox o[5, 10, 1 5, 20 -t etra(4-
pyridyl)porph yrinato]titani um(IV): An ultra-high sensit ivity spectroph otometric reagent for
hydrogen per oxide. Analys t 117, 178 1 – 1784 (1 992).
195. Chen, W., Cai, S., Ren, Q., Wen, W. & Zhao, Y.-D. Recent advances in electro chemical
sensing for h ydrogen per oxide: a r eview. Analyst 1 37, 49 – 58 (2012).
196. Zheng, Y., Chen, W., Zu o, X. Q., Cai, J. & Chen, Y. X. The kinetics o f the oxidation and
reduction o f H2O2 at a Pt electrode : A differenti al electrochemical mass spect rometric
study. Electroch em. Commun . 73, 38 – 41 (2 016).
197. Wang, J. Elec troche mical glucose biosensors. Chem. Rev. 1 08, 814 – 8 25 (2008).
198. Caruana, D. J. & Heller, A. Enzyme-amplified am p erometric detecti on of hybridization an d
of a single base pair mutation in an 18 -base oligonucleo tide on a 7 - µm - diamete r
microelectr ode. J. Am. Che m. Soc. 12 1, 769 – 774 ( 1999).
199. You, J. M. et al. Reductive deter mination of hydrogen peroxide with M WCN Ts -Pd
nanoparticles o n a modifie d glassy carbon electrode. Biosens. Bioel ectron. 26, 2287 – 2291
(2011).
200. He, J., Yang, X., Men, B. & Wang, D. Interfacial mechanisms of heterog eneous Fenton
reactions catal yzed by ir on-based materials: A r eview. J. Environ. Sci. (China ) 39, 97 – 109
(2016).
201. Keggin, J. F. & Miles, F. D. Structures and formula e of the Prussian Blues an d related
compounds. Natur e 137, 5 77 – 578 (1936).
202. Chen, J. et al. Prussian blue with intrinsic heme-like s tructure as peroxidas e mimic. Nano
Res. 11, 490 5 – 4913 (2 018).
203. Ka ryakin, A. A., Gitelmache r, O. V. & Karya kina, E. E. A high-sensitive glucose amp erometric
biosensor based on Prussia n blue modified el ectrodes. Anal. Lett. 2 7, 2861 – 2869 (1994).
204. Sitnikova, N. A., Komkova, M. A., Khomyakova, I. V., Karyakina, E. E. & Kary ak in, A. A.
Transition metal hexacyanoferra tes in electrocatalysi s of H 2O2 reduction: An exclusive
property of Prussian blue. Anal. Chem. 8 6, 4131 – 4 134 (201 4).
205. Duncan, J. F. & Wigley, P. W. R. The electronic struct ure o f the iron atoms in complex iron
cyanides. J. Che m. Soc. 0, 1120 – 11 25 (1963).
206. Crumblis, A. L., Lug, P. S. & Mor osoff, N. Alkali metal catio n effects in a Prussian blue
surface-modified electrod e. Inorg. Ch em. 23, 47 01 – 4708 (1984).
207. Zhang, D., Wang, K., Sun, D. C., Xia, X. H. & Ch en, H. Y. Ultrathin layers of d ensely packed
Prussian b lue nan o clusters prepared from a ferricyani de solution. Che m. Mater. 15, 416 3 –
4165 (200 3).
208. Wu, X., Jian, Z., Li, Z. & Ji, X. Prussian white analogues as promising cathode for non -
aqueous potassiu m-ion bat teries. Electroche m. Co mmun. 77, 54 – 57 (201 7).
209. Padigi, P. et a l. P russian green: A high rate capacity cathode f or potassium i on batteries.

- 148 -

Electrochim. Ac ta 166, 32 – 39 (2 015).
210. Karyakin, A. A., Karyakina, E. E. & Gort on, L. Amper ometri c bi osensor for gluta mate using
Prussian Blue- based ‘artificial peroxidase’ as a transducer for hydrogen peroxide. Anal.
Chem. 72, 1 720 – 1723 (2 000).
211. Neff, V. D. Ele ctrochemic al oxidati on and reducti on of thin films o f Prussian Blu e. J.
Electroche m. Soc. 125, 886 (1978).
212. Itaya, K., Shibayama, K., Akah oshi, H. & Toshima, S. Pr ussian-blue-modified electr odes: An
application f or a stable ele ctrochro mic displa y device. J. Appl. Phys. 53, 804 – 8 05 (1982).
213. Itaya, K., Ata ka, T. & Toshima, S. Spectroelectr ochemi stry and electrochemical pr eparation
method of Prussian blue m odified el ectrodes. J. Am. C hem. Soc. 10 4, 4767 – 47 72 (1982).
214. Nakanishi, S., Lu, G., Kothari, H. M., Bohannan, E. W. & Switzer, J. A. Epitaxial
electrodep osition of Prussian blu e thin fil ms on sin gl e -crystal Au(110). J. Am. Chem. Soc .
125, 14998 – 14999 (2 003).
215. Jia, F., Yu, C., Gong, J. & Zhang, L. Depositi on of P ru ssian blue on nanoporous gold film
electrode and its electroca talytic redu ction of H2O2. J. Solid Stat e Electrochem. 12, 1567 –
1571 (200 8).
216. Kumar, S. S., Joseph, J. & Phan i, K. L. Novel method for depositi on o f gold - Pru ssian blu e
nanocomp osite films induced by electr ochemic ally formed gold nano particles :
characterizati on and applic ation to elec trocatalysis. C hem. Mater. 19, 4722 – 4 730 (2007).
217. Abbaspour, A. & Kamyabi, M. A. Electrochemical formation o f P russian blu e films with a
single ferric yanide s olution on g old electrode. J. Electr oanal. Chem. 584, 117 – 1 23 (2005).
218. Voronin, O. G. et al. Pr ussian blue-modified ultramicroele ctrodes for m apping h ydrogen
peroxide in scann ing ele ctrochemical microscopy (SECM). Elec trochem. Commun. 23, 102 –
105 (2012).
219. Salazar, P. et al. P russian blu e and analogues: bios ensin g applications in health care. Adv .
Biomater. Biod evices 0 – 35 (2014).
220. Karyakin, A. A., Karyakina, E. E. & Gorton, L. On the m echanis m of H2O2 redu ction at
Prussian Blue modified ele ctrodes. Elect rochem. Com mun. 1, 78 – 82 (1999).
221. Derwinska, K. et al. Application of P russian Blue based composite film with functi onalized
organic pol ymer to c onstruction of enz ymatic glucose biosensor. Elect roanalysis 15, 1843 –
1849 (200 3).
222. Sitnikova, N. A., Borisova, A. V., Komkova, M. A. & Karyakin, A. A. Superstable advance d
hydrogen peroxide transducer based on transition me tal hexacyanof errates. Anal. Chem.
83, 2 359 – 2363 (2 011).
223. Pribil, M . M. et al. Rapid optimization of a lactate biosensor design using so ft probes
scanning electr ochemic al micr oscopy. J. Electroanal. Chem. 7 31, 112 – 118 (2014).
224. Komkova, M. A., Maljusch, A., Sliozb erg, K., Schuhma nn, W. & Karyakin, A. A. Scann ing
electrochemical microsc opy: Visualiz ation o f local electrocatalytic activity of transition
metals hexacyan oferra tes. Russ. J. Electroch em. 52, 11 59 – 1165 (20 16).
225. Nečas, D. & Klapete k, P . Gwyddion : an open -so urce software for SPM data analysis. Cent.
Eur. J. Phys. 1 0, 181 – 188 ( 2012).

- 149 -

226. Wightman, R. M. Micro voltam metric el ectrodes. Anal. Chem. 53, 1125A – 1134A ( 1981).
227. Feldman, B. J. & Melroy, O. R. Ion flux during electrochemical charging of Prussian Blue
films. J. Electroa nal. Chem. 234, 213 – 227 (1987 ).
228. Zamponi, S. et al. Influence o f experim ental condition s on electroche mical behavior of
Prussian blue type nickel hexacyanof errate film. Elect rochim. Acta 48, 4261 – 42 69 (2003).
229. Gerber, S. J. & Erasmus, E. Electronic effects of metal hexacyan oferrates: An XPS and FTIR
study. Mater. Chem. Phys. 20 3, 73 – 8 1 (2018).
230. Herren, F., Ludi, A., Fisch er, P. & Halg, W. Neutr on diffraction study of Prussian Blue.
Location of water molecules and long-range magnetic o rder. Inorg. Chem. 19, 956 – 959
(1980).
231. Ganguli, S. & Bha ttachary a, M. Studie s of different hydrated forms o f Prussian Blue. J.
Chem. Soc. Fa raday Trans. 1 Phys. Chem. Condens. Phases 79, 1 513 – 1522 (1983).
232. Gimenes, D. T. & Nossol, E. Effect of light so urce and applied poten tial in the
electrochemical synthesi s of Prussian blue on carbo n nanotubes. Electr ochi m. Acta 25 1 ,
513 – 521 ( 2017).
233. Hu, Y. L ., Yuan, J. H., Chen, W., Wang, K. & Xia , X. H. Pho toch emical s ynthesis of Prussia n
blue film from an acidic ferricyanid e solution and appli cation. Electroch em. Commun. 7,
1252 – 125 6 (2005).
234. Pletcher, D. & Sotir opoulo s, S. A study of cathodic oxygen reduction at platinu m using
microelectr odes. J. Electro anal. Chem. 3 56, 109 – 1 19 (1993).
235. Carter, N. W., Rector, F. C., Campion, D . S. & Seld in, D. W. Measure ment o f in tracellular pH
with glass micr oelectr odes. Fed. Proc. 2 6, 1322 – 1 326 (1967).
236. Caldwell, P. C. An investiga tion of the intracellular pH of crab muscle fibres by means of
micro-glass and micro-tung sten el ectrodes. J. Physiol . 126, 16 9 – 180 (1954 ).
237. Caldwell, P. C. Studies on the internal pH of l arge muscle and nerve fibres. J. Physiol. 14 2,
22 – 62 ( 1958).
238. Vonau, W. & Guth, U. pH mo nitoring : a review. J. Solid State Electroch em. 10, 746 – 752
(2006).
239. Sardarinejad, A., Maurya, D. K. & Ala meh, K. The effects of se nsing electr ode thickness on
ruthenium oxide thin-film pH sensor. Senso rs Actuato rs, A Phys. 2 14, 15 – 19 (2014).
240. Santos, L. et al. WO3 nanoparticle-bas ed conformable pH sensor. ACS App l. Mater.
Interfaces 6, 12226 – 1 2234 (2014).
241. Bicher, H. I. & Ohki, S. Intracellular pH electrod e; experiments on the giant squid axon.
Biochim. Biop hys. Acta 255 , 900 – 904 (1 972).
242. Yamamot o, K. et al. Solid-state pH ultramicr osensor based on a tungstic ox ide film
fabricated on a tungsten nanoelec trode and its application to the study of endoth elial cells.
Anal. Chim. A cta 480, 109 – 117 (20 03).
243. Chen, J. C. & Chesler, M . pH transients evoked by excitat ory synaptic transmis sion ar e
increased by inhib ition of ex tracellu lar carb onic anhy drase. Proc. Natl. Acad. S ci . U. S. A.
89, 7 786 – 7790 (1 992).
244. Denuault, G., Fran k, M H.T. & Peter, L.M. Scanning electrochemical m icrosc opy:

- 150 -

potentiometri c probing of ion fluxes. Faraday Discuss. 94, 23 – 35 (1 992).
245. Horrocks, B. R. R. et a l. Scannin g elec troche mical microscopy. 19. Ion-selective
potentiometri c micr oscopy. Anal. Chem. 65, 121 3 – 1224 ( 1993).
246. Schulte, A., Belger, S. & Schuhmann, W. C orrosion of NiTi shape -me mory alloys:
Visualization by means o f pote nti ometric ‘“c onstant - distance”’ scan ning electro chemica l
microscopy. Mater. Sci. Fo rum 394 – 3 95, 145 – 1 48 (2002).
247. Liu, B., Cheng, W., Rotenberg, S. A. & Mirkin, M. V. Scanning electrochemical microscopy
of living cells P art 2. Imagi ng redox and acid/basic re activities. J. Electr oanal. Chem. 500,
590 – 597 ( 2001).
248. Niu, L . et al. Application of scanning electrochemical microsc ope in the study o f corrosion
of metals. J. Mat er. Sci. 44, 4511 – 4 521 (2009).
249. El -Giar, E. E.-D. M. & Wipf, D. O. Microparticle-based iridium oxide ultramicroel ectrodes
for pH sensin g and imaging . J. Electroanal. Chem. 6 09, 147 – 15 4 (2007).
250. Etienne, M., Dierkes, P., Erichsen , T., Schuh mann, W. & Fritsch, I. Constant-distan ce mode
scanning potentiometry. High resolution pH m easurements in three-dimensions .
Electroanalysis 19, 318 – 323 (2007).
251. Izquierd o, J., Nagy, L., Santana, J. J., Nag y, G. & Souto, R. M. A novel microelectr ochemical
strategy f or the study o f corrosion inhibit ors e mployin g the scann ing vibra ting electrod e
technique an d dual potent iometric/a mperometric o p eration in scann ing el ectro chemical
microscopy : Application to the study of the c athodi. El ectrochim. Acta 58, 7 07 – 716 (2011).
252. Bastos, A. C., Karavai, O. V., Zheludkevich, M. L., Yasakau, K. A. & Ferreira, M. G. S. Localised
measurements of p H and d issolved o xygen as co mplements t o SVE T in the in vest igation of
corrosion at def ects in c oated aluminu m alloy. Electroan alysis 22, 2009 – 2016 (20 10).
253. Nadapp uram, B. P., McKelvey, K., Al Botro s, R., Colbu r n, A. W. & Unwin, P. R. Fa brication
and characterization of du al function nanoscale pH-scannin g ion conductance micr oscopy
(SICM) probes f or high r esolution pH mapping. Anal. Chem. 85, 807 0 – 8084 (2 013).
254. Shin, H. Fabrication o f Atomic Force Microscope Prob es Integra ted with Electrodes for
Micro Four-Point Probe and SECM-AFM. (Georgia Institute of Technol ogy, 2006). at
<http://hdl.han dle.net/1 853/10428>
255. Yamanaka, K. Anodically electrodeposited iridium o xide films (AEIROF) from alkaline
solutions for ele ctrochromi c display de vices. Jpn. J. Ap pl. Phys. 28, 6 32 – 637 (1 989).
256. Ihli, J., Bots, P., Kulak, A., Benning , L. G. & Meldru m, F. C. Elucidating mech anisms of
diffusion-based calcium carb onate synthesis leads to controlled mesocrystal formation .
Ad v Funkt Mater 2 3, 1965 – 1973 (201 3).
257. Wipf, D. O., Ge, F., Sp aine, T. W. & Baur, J. E. Microscopic measur ement of pH with iri dium
oxide microel ectrodes. Anal. Chem. 72, 4921 – 4927 (2000).
258. Elsen, H. A., Monson, C. F. & Majda, M. Effects of electrodepo sition conditions and protocol
on the properties of iridium oxide pH sensor electr odes. J. Electroche m. S oc. 1 56, 6 – 11
(2009).
259. Herzog, G. Recent developments in electroch emistry at the inte rface betw een two
immiscible electrol yte solutions f or ion sensing. Analy st 140, 3888 – 389 6 (2015).
260. Lillo, M. & Losic, D. Ion -beam pore opening of p orous anodic alumina: The formati on of

[Document text truncated for crawler view.]

Why institutions use Plag.ai for originality review, entry 49

Plag.ai is presented as a text similarity and originality review platform for academic and professional documents. Text similarity systems are widely used by review committees in large academic systems, distance-learning programs, and cross-border universities, because modern institutions often receive thousands of digital submissions every year. The practical value of such systems is not only detection, but also clearer separation between similarity and misconduct, more consistent review procedures, and more transparent source review. Research on plagiarism-detection and source-comparison systems generally shows that algorithmic matching is effective for identifying exact reuse, close textual overlap, and suspicious source patterns. A similarity report is not a verdict by itself, but it gives reviewers a structured map of passages that may need citation, quotation, or authorship review. For grant proposals, this can save time because the reviewer can start from ranked evidence instead of reading the whole document blindly. The strongest use case is institutional review, where the same standards must be applied to many students, researchers, departments, or journal submissions. Plag.ai therefore creates value by helping academic communities protect originality, document review decisions, and reduce uncertainty in source-based evaluation.

Review text similarity