Determination of Sapphire Off‐Cut and Its Influence on the Morphology and Local Defect Distribution in Epitaxially Laterally Overgrown AlN for Optically Pumped UVC Lasers [original]

Determination of Sapphire Off-Cut and Its In ﬂ uence on
the Morphology and Local Defect Distribution in
Epitaxially Laterally Overgrown AlN for Optically Pumped
UVC Lasers
Johannes Enslin,* Arne Knauer, Anna Mogilatenko, Frank Mehnke, Martin Martens,
Christian Kuhn, Tim Wernicke, Markus Weyers, and Michael Kneissl
Her ein, a sy stem at ic stu dy of the morp ho log y and loc al def ect di stri bu tion in
ep itax ia lly la te rall y ov er grow n (EL O) Al N on
c
-p lane sa pph ire subs tr ates wi th
dif fe rent of f- cut an gles ra ng ing fr om 0.08  to 0. 23  is pres en ted . Prec ise me as-
ur emen ts of the of f-c ut angl e
α
, usin g a com bi nati on of op ti cal al ig nmen t and X -ray
dif fr acti on wi th an acc urac y of  5  fo r the of f- cut di rec tion an d  0. 015  for th e off -
cut an gl e, are ca rr ied ou t. For EL O AlN gr owth , a tran sit ion fr om ste p ﬂ ow grow th
at
α
< 0.14  wi th he igh t und ul atio ns o n the su rf ace to step bu nchi ng wi th st ep
he ight s up to 20 nm for
α
> 0. 14  i s obse rv ed. F urth er more , th e terr ac es of the
ste p-b un ched surf ac e exhi bit cu rv ed st eps . An an alys i s of th e loca l de fect dist ri -
bu tion by sc an ning tr an smis si on elec tr on mic ros copy an d a comp aris on with
at omic f orce mi cr osco py re veal a bu nc hing of de fe cts in li ne with th e ELO patt er n
an d a roug he ning of st ep edge s in hi ghl y defec ti ve regi ons. In ad dit ion , a re duc tion
in th e thre sho ld exci ta tion po we r den sit y for op tica lly pu mp ed ultr av iole t- C (UVC )
las er s with sm ooth su rfac e morp ho logi es i s obse rved .
1. Introduction
Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and laser diodes (LDs) emitting in
the ultraviolet-C spectral region between 200 and 280 nm have a
wide range of applications such as water puri ﬁ cation,
[1]
disinfec-
tion of surfaces, gas sensing,
[2,3]
and medical diagnostics.
[4]
These devices require high-quality layers
in terms of dislocation density as well as
smooth surface morphologies to reach high
ef ﬁ ciencies, high output power levels, and,
in the case of LDs, low-threshold power
densities. The relatively high threading
dislocation densities (TDDs) of the AlN
template layers used for AlGaN growth
[5]
limit the internal quantum ef ﬁ ciency of
optical devices.
[6]
Epitaxially laterally over-
grown (ELO) AlN/sapphire
[7]
is one
method for the effective TDD reduction
on c -plane sapphire substrates. This ELO
process allows a TDD reduction down to
5  10
8
cm
 2
.
[8,9]
In this article, we present the system atic
variation of the off- cut angle of (0001)-
oriented sapphire substr ates and its impact
on the surface morphology an d the local
de fect distribu tion of E LO AlN/s apphir e
template s. In a previous study, we c ompared ELO AlN/sapphire
templa te s on sapphi re w afers with n omin al off- cut angles of
0. 1   0.1  and 0.2   0.1  . O ff -c ut ang les of 0 .2   0.1  resulted
in t he f or ma ti on o f ma cr os tep s wit h hei gh ts o f sev e ra l nano -
me ters .
[10]
Here, the off-cut angle was determined by precise
X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements combi ned with an optical
alignment. Subsequently, the wafers were processe d and over-
grown to obtain ELO AlN/sapph ire templates. Their surface mo r-
p h o l o g ya sw e l la st h e i rd e f e c td i s t r i b u t i o nw a si n v e s t i g a t e db y
atomic force microscopy (AFM) and scanning transmission
electron micr oscopy ( STEM), respe ctively. Furthermore, laser het-
erostructu res were grown with a n emission wavele ngth of 27 0 –
275 nm on these templates to investigate the in ﬂ uence of the tem-
plate morph ology on the p erforman ce of optically pumped devices.
2. Determination of Sapphire Off-Cut
Since the transition from step ﬂ ow growth to step bunching for
ELO AlN/sapphire occurs at very small off-cut angles between
0.1  and 0.2  ,
[10]
a highly accurate determination of the substrate
off-cut is necessary to determine the critical angle for this tran-
sition. Thus, precise off-cut measurements were carried out
using a combination of an optical alignment of the wafer and
J. Enslin, Dr. F. Mehnke, Dr. M. Martens, C. Kuhn, Dr. T. Wernicke,
Prof. M. Kneissl
Institut für Festkörperphysik
Technische Universi tät Berlin
Hardenbergstr. 36, EW 6-1, 10623 Berlin, Germany
E-mail: johannes.enslin@phys ik.tu-berlin.de
Dr. A. Knauer, Dr. A. Mogilatenko, Prof. M. Weyers, Prof. M. Kneissl
Ferdinand-Braun-Institut
Leibniz-Institut für Höchstfrequenztechnik
Gustav-Kirchhoff-S tr. 4, 12489 Berlin, Germany
The ORCID identi ﬁ cation number(s) for the author(s) of this article
can be found under https://doi.org/10.1002/pssa.201 900682.
© 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA,
Weinheim. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License , which permits use, distribution and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
DOI: 10.1002/pssa.201900682
ORIGINAL PAPER
www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (1 of 6) © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

XRD reciprocal space maps ( φ / ω ). This technique is similar to
the one described by Halliwell and Chua
[11]
extended by an
additional alignment step of the wafer. Using this alignment,
the surface normal of the sapphire wafer can be adjusted parallel
to the rotation axis of the diffractometer. Figure 1 shows the
setup for the off-cut determination.
[12]
The wafer is mounted
onto a tiltable sample holder in a Philips X ‘ Pert MRD Pro
X-ray diffractometer. The X-ray beam is directed onto the sample
under the angle ω . The cradle can either be rotated around its
rotation axis ( φ -angle) or tilted perpendicular to the plane of
the beam ( χ -angle).
[13]
A collimated red laser beam is directed
at the center of the sample holder — corresponding to the rotation
axis position — and is re ﬂ ected by the sapphire surface. Using two
mirrors, the re ﬂ ected beam is guided over a distance of 15 m to a
screen. Typically an inplane rotation around the rotation axis of
the diffractometer results in a precession of the laser spot on the
screen due to the tilt between the surface normal and the goni-
ometer axis. By tilting the sample holder independently from the
goniometer ( ω / φ / χ ), the precession radius was minimized,
which corresponds to an adjustment of the surface normal
parallel to the rotation axis of the diffractometer. The error for
the following measurements was estimated by correlating the
radius of the residual precession to a shift in the ω -angle of
the goniometer. The error was estimated for every single
measurement and ranges from  0.007  to  0.015  .
After the alignment of the surface normal to the goniometer
rotation axis, a map in ω and φ of the (0006) re ﬂ ection of sapphire
was acquired ( Figure 2 ). A rotation of the wafer variation of φ -
angle results in a variation of the peak position in ω -direction, as
the lattice planes are tilted according to the off-cut angle. The
location of each peak in the ω scans was extracted, and the result-
ing peak position ω max ð φ Þ was ﬁ tted with a sine function (solid
blue line). The amplitude of the sine curve corresponds directly
to the off-cut angle α marked in red. As shown in Figure 2 by gray
lines, a minimum of the sine function at φ ¼ 0 would corre-
spond to a wafer with a pure off-cut into the m -direction of sap-
phire (considering the orientation of the wafer in relation to the
goniometer, shown in Figure 2). A shift of the minimum of the
sine function to positive or negative φ -angles indicates a shift of
the direction of the off-cut toward the a -direction of sapphire
( φ ¼ 90  for pure off-cut to the a -direction of sapphire), which
is the case for the measured off-cut in Figure 2 (black hexagons).
The position of the ﬂ at is used to determine the off-cut direction.
The misalignment of the ﬂ at given by the manufacturer is  0.2 
in reference to the ½ 11 ¯
20  direction of sapphire, which is negligi-
ble in comparison with the estimated error due to the manual
alignment of the wafer on the goniometer, which is estimated
to be  5  . In case a higher precision is required, the measure-
ment can be extended by an asymmetric φ -scan to correlate the
crystal axis to the sample holder; however, this was not per-
formed for the measured wafers. The off-cut angle α can be split
into the component in the sapphire m -direction ( α
m
) by calculat-
ing the difference in ω for φ ¼ 0 ∘ and φ ¼ 180 ∘ (see Figure 2).
Accordingly, the sapphire a -direction component ( α
a
) can be cal-
culated by evaluating the ω -angle at φ ¼ 90 ∘ and φ ¼ 90 ∘ . The
correlation between the off-cut α and its components α
a
and α
m
is
given by: α ¼ ﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃ ﬃ
α 2
a þ α 2
m
p . Two batches of c -orientated sapphire
wafers with nominal off-cut angles of 0.1   0.1  and 0.2   0.1 
toward the sapphire m -direction were examined. For wafers with
a nominal off-cut angle of 0.1   0.1  , we observed variations
from 0.08  to 0.12  and for wafers with a nominal off-cut angle
of 0.2   0.1  , values between 0.16  and 0.23  were observed.
Although, the speci ﬁ cations given by the wafer supplier are
satis ﬁ ed, there is a certain variety within each batch of wafers.
To cover a broad range of off-cut angles, we selected eight wafers
with off-cut angles varying from 0.08  to 0.1   0.23  for further
investigations (see Figure 3 , open symbols).
3. ELO AlN/Sapphire Morphology and Defects
3.1. Experimental Procedure
After the determination of the off-cut angles, the sapphire wafers
were overgrown with a 0.5 μ m-thick AlN layer in an Aixtron
2400-G3 planetary reactor with standard precursors.
[14]
Subsequently, these templates were patterned with stripes along
the ½ 10 ¯
10  direction of AlN ( ½ 2 ¯
1 ¯
10  direction of sapphire) and
overgrown with 5.8 μ m ELO AlN, as described in the study by
Figure 1. Experimental setup to align the surface normal of the sapphire
wafer parallel to the rotation axis ( φ ) of the XRD sample holder.
Figure 2. Peak positions of an ω – φ – XRD map of a sapphire wafer near the
(0006) re ﬂ ection indicating the off-cut angle α and the components in
a - and m -directions ( α
a
and α
m
). The direction in reference to the ﬂ at
is illustrated in the upper half of the image. The stripes drawn on the wafer
schematic depict the direction of the processed ELO trenches.
www.advancedscienc enews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (2 of 6) © 2019 The Auth ors. Published by WIL EY-VCH Verlag Gmb H & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

Knauer et al.
[10]
The morphology and local defect distribution of
these ELO AlN/sapphire templates were investigated using AFM
and STEM.
3.2. Surface Morphology of ELO AlN/Sapphire
In Figure 4 , AFM images are shown, presenting the surface mor-
phology of ELO AlN grown on sapphire wafers with different off-
cut angles to the sapphire m -direction. For off-cut angles between
0.08  and 0.12  , the images show a wavelike surface morphology
with monoatomic steps and an overall undulation with a height
difference between the lowest and the highest point on the
surface ranging from 3 to 5 nm. For higher off-cut angles
(0.16  – 0.23  ), the AlN surfaces exhibit macrosteps with increas-
ing heights from 14 nm at α ¼ 0.16 ∘ to 21 nm at α > 0.20 ∘ . The
periodicity of the wavelike surface features as well as the period-
icity of the macrosteps for high off-cut angles corresponds to the
periodicity of the underlying ELO pattern of 3.5 μ m. In addition,
AFM images give insight into the roughness of the grown sam-
ples. The root mean square (RMS) roughness was evaluated on a
20 μ m  20 μ m scale and is shown in Figure 4. Templates with
off-cut angles between 0.08  and 0.12  exhibit rather smooth
surfaces with low and constant RMS values around 1.5 nm.
On the contrary, templates with off-cut angles between 0.16 
and 0.23  exhibit RMS values increasing from 3.5 to 5.3 nm with
increasing off-cut angle. The surface morphologies for this wide
range of off-cut angles were investigated and showed a transition
from a wavelike surface morphology to a surface with macrosteps
at a critical angle of α ¼ 0.14 ∘  0.02 ∘ for this growth parameter
regime.
[14]
This can be explained by the fact that the height of the
surface steps appearing at coalescence positions of two neighbor-
ing ELO stripes increased with increasing off-cut angle. The high
steps cannot be planarized anymore with further overgrowth to
obtain a smooth surface for α > 0.14 ∘ . Thus, the surface steps are
preserved during subsequent growth, which results in step
bunching at the surface. Detailed studies would be necessary
to completely understand the transition from smooth morphol-
ogies to step bunching.
A clos er loo k at the sam ples ex hib itin g step bu nchi ng re veal s
the sur face mo rpho lo gy of th e macr ote rr ace (a rea be twee n macr o-
ste ps) . In Fi gu re 5 a, a sing le macr ost ep was sel ected , and th e
mo noat omic ste p edge s obse rved on t he macr ote rrac e we re
ma rked in gr ee n. The te rr ace ex hibi ts a conv ex bo w with th e lowe st
poi nts clo se to the ma cros tep ed ge. Fur thermo re, th e mono atomi c
ste ps a re cu rved . The no rma l to th e curv e of th e step (g reen line s
in Fi gure 5 a) in the mi ddle be twee n th e macr os teps poi nt s into the
m -d ir ect io n of Al N ½ 10 ¯
10  ( ½ 2 ¯
1 ¯
10  di re ctio n of sapp hir e) (i.e ., the
step ﬂ ow t akes pla ce al ong the macr ostep s). F igur e 5b sho ws
step ﬂ ow g rowt h on th e hig he st po int o f the co nvex t erra ce (p urpl e
are a) with la rge ter race wi dth s betw ee n t he steps of o ve r 40 0 nm.
In co nt rast , Fig ur e 5c sho ws mo no atomi c step s — cl ose to the ma c-
rote rr ac e e dge — runn ing alo ng the AlN a -d irec tio n ½ 1 ¯
210  ( ½ 10 ¯
10 
dir ecti on of sap phi re) (i .e., t he ste p ﬂ ow tak es pla ce acr os s the ma c-
rot erra ce) wi th ter race wi dth be twee n th e st eps of less tha n
100 nm . The off -c ut tow ard th e m -d irec tion ½ 10 ¯
10  of sap phire
( ½ 1 ¯
210  d ir ecti on of Al N) on th e terr ace is qu ite sma ll due to a co m-
pen sat ion th roug h the step ped sur fac e, and t hus th e fra ctio n of t he
off -cut to ward t he sap phi re a -dir ectio n ½ 2 ¯
1 ¯
10  ( ½ 10 ¯
10  di rect ion o f
Al N, par all el to ma cros teps ) dicta tes the st ep ﬂ ow di re ctio n. The
co nvex s ha pe of the te rrace co uld be ex pla ined by diff usio n of ada-
tom s over t he ed ge of th e macr ostep , leadi ng to a r educ ed gro wt h
rat e cl os e to th e macr ostep .
3.3. Local Defect Distribution in ELO AlN/Sapphire
By conducting high-resolution AFM measurements, it is possible
to observe surface pits which are most likely caused by threading
dislocations. Tarsa et al. found that the number and type of
surface pits observed by AFM in GaN ﬁ lms ﬁ t very well to the
defect density determined by transmission electron microscopy
(TEM).
[15]
To visualize single defects, AFM images were
acquired, and a polynomial background was subtracted from
the recorded data to ﬂ atten the image. The processed AFM
Figure 3. Off-cut angles α of two batches of sapphire wafers with nominal
off-cut angles of 0.1   0.1  (blue) and 0.2   0.1  (green). Open symbols
mark the selected wafers for further analysis.
Figure 4. AFM micrographs of the ELO AlN/sapphire surface for increasing sapphire off-cut angles from 0.08  to 0.12  with wavelike surface morphology
and from 0.16  to 0.23  with step bunching and corresponding RMS roughness measu red on a 20 μ m  20 μ m area.
www.advancedscienc enews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (3 of 6) © 201 9 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

images are shown in Figure 6 a,b), and the local defect densities
were determined. In Figure 5a, for example, dislocations with a
screw component can be identi ﬁ ed by two monolayer steps orig-
inating from the pits, as marked by red circles; furthermore,
areas close to the macrostep exhibit a high defect density of about
1  10
10
cm
 2
. This value corresponds very well to the defect
density of planar AlN/sapphire templates.
[10]
Furthermore, there
is a 1.5 μ m-wide region exhibiting a reduced defect density of
1  10
9
cm
 2
. As shown in the cross-section annular dark- ﬁ eld
(ADF) STEM image (see the study by Mehnke
[12]
)i n
Figure 6c, the pattern of a 1.5 μ m-wide defect-reduced region
above the trenches followed by a 2 μ m-wide defect-rich region
is consistent with the AFM image. The mean defect density
obtained by STEM correlates well with the one extracted from
the AFM images as well as defect densities calculated from
XRD rocking curves
[13]
of the (0002) and ð 30 ¯
32 Þ re ﬂ ections which
are all in the range of 6  10
9
cm
 2
. The measurement geometry
was selected such that the incoming X-ray beam was parallel
to the direction of the ELO trenches (in AlN ½ 10 ¯
10  direction)
to avoid additional peak broadening due to wing tilt.
[16]
Figure 6b shows the defects on the surface for a template grown
on a sapphire wafer with an off-cut angle of 0.12  .A2 μ m-wide
area proceeding from the upper left corner of the image to the
lower right corner exhibits a high density of defects. Further-
more, the growth fronts of the monoatomic steps are rougher
in this area compared with the remaining part of the image
due to impediment of the step motion by defects. The defect den-
sities in the two areas are almost identical to those of samples
with high off-cut angles.
Figure 5. a) AFM images of one convex macrostep terrace grown on a
sapphire wafer with an off-cut angle of 0.16  , b) exhibiting wide monoa-
tomic steps (image taken from the area marked with a purple square in (a),
and c) small terrace widths between the steps (this image is taken from a
similar area of the macrostep terrace as marked in (a) in red).
Figure 6. AFM images ﬂ attened by substraction of a polynomial background of an ELO AlN/sapphire surface with a) stepbunches and b) a wavelike
surface morphology illustrating defect-ric h regions between the dashed lines and the macrostep edge and between the dashed lines, respectively.
Cross-section ADF STEM images showing the defect distribution in ELO AlN/sapphire with off-cut angles of c) α > 0.14 ∘ and d) α < 0.14 ∘ . White arrows
indicate coalescence boundaries between two wing regions.
www.advancedscienc enews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (4 of 6) © 2019 The Auth ors. Published by WIL EY-VCH Verlag Gmb H & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

A comparison with ADF STEM images (Figure 6d) reveals the
same geometrical pattern and defect distribution as the AFM
investigations. ELO AlN/sapphire samples with high off-cut
angles show an inclined grain boundary, whereas samples grown
on substrates with low off-cut angles exhibit a vertical grain
boundary originating from the coalescence region. The inclina-
tion of threading dislocations for higher off-cuts is caused by
formation of the macrostep at the coalescence position and its
lateral propagation during further growth, which is already
described in the study by Knauer et al.
[10]
Contrary to that, sam-
ples with low off-cut angles exhibit no macrosteps boundaries,
and the correlation between the underlying ELO pattern and
the surface undulations is ﬁ xed. Therefore, the conclusion can
be drawn that the off-cut angles in the investigated ELO AlN/
sapphire templates have no signi ﬁ cant in ﬂ uence on the defect
distribution but on the surface morphology at a given thickness
of 2 μ m after coalescence of the investigated templates. It should
be noted that a thicker ELO AlN layer ( > 6 μ m) for templates with
high off-cut angles and inclined grain boundaries can result in a
collection and partial annihilation of dislocations.
[9]
4. Optically Pumped Laser Structures
4.1. Experimental Procedure
Finally, optically pumped laser structures consisting of AlGaN
multiple quantum wells emitting between 270 and 275 nm
embedded in Al
0.7
Ga
0.3
N waveguides and an AlGaN cladding
layer
[17]
were grown on top of ELO AlN/sapphire templates.
Excitation power-dependent photoluminescence (PL) measure-
ments were carried out on laser bars with cleaved facets
[18]
in
stripe geometry using a 193 nm ArF laser as the optical excitation
source.
[17]
Modal losses of the grown structures were determined
based on optical gain spectra obtained by the variable stripe
length method.
[19]
4.2. Off-Cut In ﬂ uence on Laser Threshold
The net gain obtained from the variable stripe length method for
both structures is shown in Figure 7 a. The structure exhibiting
step bunching shows internal losses, increased by a factor of ﬁ ve,
in comparison with the structure without step bunching. This
results in a drastically decreased net gain. The integrated PL
intensity collected from the facet as a function of the excitation
power density for both structures is shown in Figure 7b. Both
heterostructures exhibit lasing between 270 and 275 nm as the
power-dependent PL intensity shows a threshold behavior in
combination with spectral narrowing (not shown here).
[20]
The las e r st ru ct ur e on E L O Al N/ sa pp hi r e wi th a sm o oth su rf ac e
mor pho l og y ex hi b it s la si ng a t a thr e sh ol d po we r de nsi ty of
1.7 MW c m
 2
. Thi s v al ue i s in c rea se d t o 2. 8 MW cm
 2
for
a las er st ruc t ur e gr ow n on an EL O A lN /s ap ph ir e te mpl a te
exhibiting step bunching. This increase in threshold power den-
sity could be attributed to optica l scattering losses within the
waveguide due to 15 – 20 nm -h ig h mac ro st ep s. In add it io n ,
a stronger Ga incorporation at the macrostep edge
[8]
can r es ul t
in an increased modal loss due to absorption in Ga-rich regions.
Considering this, avoiding macrosteps is cru cial to achieve low
laser thresholds. Therefore, the right choice of substrate off-cut
for ELO AlN/sapphire needs to be considered. On the one
han d, a su f ﬁ cie n tly h ig h s ub str a te o ff- c ut i nt o the s ap ph ir e
m -direction for ELO AlN/sapphire needs to be chosen to
ens u re c oal e sc en ce a n d av oi d n uc le at io n o f r an do ml y di st ri b-
ute d i sl an ds . On th e ot he r h an d, t he sub st r at e of f -c ut c ho se n
needs to be small enoug h, as shown in this study, to avoid
ma cro st e ps .
5. Conclusion
Using a combination of XRD and optical alignment of the
sapphire surface, we measured the off-cut angles of c -plane sap-
phire wafers with a precision down to  0.015  . After AlN growth,
processing, and overgrowth with ELO AlN, the surface morphol-
ogy changes from a wavelike surface morphology to step bunch-
ing at a critical angle of α ¼ 0.14 ∘  0.02 ∘ for the used AlN growth
conditions. Macroterraces exhibit curved monoatomic steps. An
analysis of the defect distribution on the surface by precise AFM
and STEM measurements revealed an inhomogeneous distribu-
tion of the defects caused by ELO patterning with a similar
overall defect density for both types of surface morphologies.
The threshold power density for optically pumped lasing
decreases drastically for laser structures emitting at 270 and
Figure 7. a) Net gain spectra for evaluation of internal losses and b) normalized integrated PL intensity versus excitation power density of an AlGaN
multiple quantum well laser structure grown on an ELO AlN/sapphire template without step bunching and with step bunching.
www.advancedscienc enews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (5 of 6) © 201 9 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

275 nm grown on surfaces exhibiting no macrosteps. These ﬁ nd-
ings show that low laser thresholds of optically pumped laser
structures can be achieved for c -plane sapphire wafers with
smooth surface morphologies. For the presented ELO AlN/
sapphire templates, this could be realized for off-cut angles
α < 0.14 ∘ .
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Tobias Meisch and Marian Calibe from
University of Ulm for fruitful discussions . This work was partially sup-
ported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinsc haft (DFG) within the
Collaborative Research Centre 787 and the German Federal Ministry of
Research and Education (BMBF) within the Advanced UV for Life initiative.
Con ﬂ ict of Interest
The authors declare no con ﬂ ict of interest.
Keywords
AlN, epitaxially laterally overgrown, off-cut, optically pumped lasers,
sapphires, UVC
Received: August 21, 2019
Revised: October 18, 2019
Published online: November 12, 2019
[1] S. Vilhunen, H. Särkkä, M. Sillanpää, Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 2009 , 16 ,
439.
[2] J. Hodgkinson, R. P. Tatam, Meas. Sci. Technol. 2013 , 24 , 012004.
[3] F. Mehnke, M. Guttman n, J. Enslin, C. Kuhn, C. Reich, J. Jordan,
S. Kapanke, A. Knauer, M. Lapeyrade, U. Zeimer, H. Krüger,
M. Rabe, S. Einfeldt, T. Wernicke, H. Ewald, M. Weyers,
M. Kneissl, IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 2017 , 23 , 29.
[4] J. Hargis, J. Philip, T. J. Sobering, G. C. Tisone, J. S. Wagner,
S. A. Young, R. J. Radloff, Optical Instrumentation for Gas
Emissions Monitoring and Atmospheric Measurements , SPIE,
McLean, VA 1995 .
[5] M. Kneissl, J. Rass, III-Nitride Ultraviolet Emitters: Technology and
Applications , Springer International Publishing, Schweiz 2015 .
[6] S. Y. Karpov, Y. N. Makarov, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2002 , 81 , 4721.
[7] V. Kueller, A. Knauer, C. Reich, A. Mogilatenko, M. Weyers,
J. Stellmach, T. Wernicke, M. Kneissl, Z. Yang, C. Chua,
N. Johnson, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 2012 , 24 , 1603.
[8] U. Zeimer, V. Kueller, A. Knauer, A. Mogilatenko, M. Weyers,
M. Kneissl, J. Crystal Growth 2013 , 377 , 32.
[9] A. Mogilatenko, V. Kueller, A. Knauer, J. Jeschke, U. Zeimer,
M. Weyers, G. Traenkle, J. Crystal Growth 2014 , 402 , 222.
[10] A. Knauer, A. Mogilatenko, S. Hagedorn, J. Enslin, T. Wernicke,
M. Kneissl, M. Weyers, Phys. Status Solidi (b) 2016 , 253 , 809.
[11] M. Halliwell, S. Chua, J. Crystal Growth 1998 , 192 , 456.
[12] F. Mehnke, Ph.D. Thesis , Technische Universität (Berlin) 2017 .
[13] M. A. Moram, M. E. Vickers, Rep. Progress Phys. 2009 , 72 ,
036502.
[14] O. Reentilae, F. Brunner, A. Knauer, A. Mogilate nko, W. Neumann,
H. Protzmann, M. Heuken, M. Kneissl, M. Weyers, G. Traenkle,
J. Crystal Growth 2008 , 310 , 4932.
[15] E. J. Tarsa, B. Heying, X. H. Wu, P. Fini, S. P. DenBaars, J. S. Speck,
J. Appl. Phys. 1997 , 82 , 5472.
[16] D. Lübbert, T. Baumbach, P. Mikulk, P. Pernot, L. Helfen, R. Köhler,
T. M. Katona, S. Keller, S. P. DenBaars, J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 2005 ,
38 , A50.
[17] M. Martens, F. Mehnke, C. Kuhn, C. Reich, V. Kueller, A. Knauer,
C. Netzel, C. Hartmann, J. Wollweber, J. Rass, T. Wernicke,
M. Bickermann, M. Weyers, M. Kneissl, IEEE Photonics Technol.
Lett. 2014 , 26 , 342.
[18] J. van Look, S. Einfeldt, O. Kruger, V. Hoffmann , A. Knauer,
M. Weyers, P. Vogt, M. Kneissl, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 2010 ,
22 , 416.
[19] K. L. Shaklee, R. F. Leheny, Appl. Phys. Lett. 1971 , 18 , 475.
[20] C. Kuhn, T. Simoneit, M. Martens, T. Markurt, J. Enslin, F. Mehnke,
K. Bellmann, T. Schulz, M. Albrecht, T. Wernicke , M. Kneissl, Phys.
Status Solidi A 2018 , 215 , 1800005.
www.advancedscienc enews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019 , 216 , 1900682 1900682 (6 of 6) © 2019 The Auth ors. Published by WIL EY-VCH Verlag Gmb H & Co. KGaA, Weinheim

Why institutions use Plag.ai for originality review, entry 55

Plag.ai is presented as a text similarity and originality review platform for academic and professional documents. Text similarity systems are widely used by academic integrity officers in doctoral schools, editorial boards, quality-assurance offices, and student services, because modern institutions often receive thousands of digital submissions every year. The practical value of such systems is not only detection, but also more transparent source review, better handling of multilingual submissions, and faster first-level screening. Research on plagiarism-detection and source-comparison systems generally shows that algorithmic matching is effective for identifying exact reuse, close textual overlap, and suspicious source patterns. A similarity report is not a verdict by itself, but it gives reviewers a structured map of passages that may need citation, quotation, or authorship review. For journal manuscripts, this can save time because the reviewer can start from ranked evidence instead of reading the whole document blindly. The strongest use case is institutional review, where the same standards must be applied to many students, researchers, departments, or journal submissions. Plag.ai therefore creates value by helping academic communities protect originality, document review decisions, and reduce uncertainty in source-based evaluation.

Review text similarity