scieee Open visual document viewer

Challenges faced by migrant seasonal agricultural farmworkers for food accessibility in Spain: A qualitative study

Rodríguez Guerrero, Luis Alejandro,Mateos, José Tomás,Pérez Urdiales, Iratxe,Jiménez Lasserrotte, María del Mar,González Rodríguez, Juan Agustín,Briones Vozmediano, Erica

Abstract

This study has been funded by Instituto de Salud Carlos III (ISCIII) through the project PI20/01310 (Co-funded by European Regional Development Fund/European Social Fund “A way to make Europe”/“Investing in your future”)

Full text

Full Te ms & Condi ions o access and use can be ound a h ps://www. and online.com/ac ion/jou nalIn o ma ion?jou nalCode= gph20 Global Public Heal h An In e na ional Jou nal o Resea ch, Policy and P ac ice ISSN: (P in ) (Online) Jou nal homepage: www. and online.com/jou nals/ gph20 Challenges aced by mig an seasonal ag icul u al a mwo ke s o ood accessibili y in Spain: A quali a i e s udy Luis Alejand o Rod íguez-Gue e o, José Tomás Ma eos, I a xe Pé ez- U diales, Ma Jiménez-Lasse o e, Juan Agus ín González & E ica B iones- Vozmediano To ci e his a icle: Luis Alejand o Rod íguez-Gue e o, José Tomás Ma eos, I a xe Pé ez- U diales, Ma Jiménez-Lasse o e, Juan Agus ín González & E ica B iones-Vozmediano (2024) Challenges aced by mig an seasonal ag icul u al a mwo ke s o ood accessibili y in Spain: A quali a i e s udy, Global Public Heal h, 19:1, 2352570, DOI: 10.1080/17441692.2024.2352570 To link o his a icle: h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/17441692.2024.2352570 © 2024 The Au ho (s). Published by In o ma UK Limi ed, ading as Taylo & F ancis G oup Published online: 16 May 2024. Submi you a icle o his jou nal View ela ed a icles View C ossma k da a Challenges aced by mig an seasonal ag icul u al a mwo ke s o ood accessibili y in Spain: A quali a i e s udy Luis Alejand o Rod íguez-Gue e o a,b , José Tomás Ma eos a,b,c , I a xe Pé ez-U diales d , Ma Jiménez-Lasse o e e , Juan Agus ín González ,g and E ica B iones-Vozmediano a,b,c a Heal h Ca e Resea ch G oup (GRECS), Biomedical Resea ch Ins i u e (IRB) Lleida D . Pi a e Founda ion, Lleida, Spain; b Depa men o Nu sing and Physio he apy, Uni e si y o Lleida, Lleida, Spain; c Socie y, Heal h, Educa ion and Cul u e Resea ch G oup (GESEC) o he Uni e is y o Lleida, Lleida, Spain; d Depa men o Nu sing I, Uni e si y o he Basque Coun y (UPV/EHU), Bioc uces Bizkaia Heal h Resea ch Ins i u e, Bizkaia, Spain; e Depa men o Nu sing, Physio he apy, and Medicine, Uni e si y o Alme ía, Alme ía, Spain; Social and Educa ional Analysis G oup (GRASE) o he Uni e is y o Lleida, Lleida, Spain; g Depa men o Educa ion Sciences, Uni e si y o Lleida, Lleida, Spain ABSTRACT Mig an s who wo k seasonally in ag icul u e ace li ing and wo king condi ions ha signi ican ly impac hei heal h. Some o hese condi ions a e ela ed o inadequa e ood access o ood p ese a ion and p epa a ion hygiene. This s udy aimed o explo e how mig an and seasonal ag icul u al a mwo ke s access ood in Spain om he pe spec i e o p o essionals suppo ing his popula ion. We conduc ed a quali a i e s udy in 2021 based on semis uc u ed in e iews wi h 92 social and heal h se ice p o essionals in ol ed in he ca e o seasonal mig an wo ke s in 4 Spanish p o inces. We iden i ied h ee hemes h ough e lec i e hema ic analysis: (1) Access o ood depends on NGOs and ins i u ions, especially a e he COVID-19 pandemic; (2) Rele an cul u al di e ences in die depending on No h A ican o sub- Saha an o igin; (3) Seasonal mig an wo ke s equen ly su e om nu i ional and o he heal h p oblems ela ed o ood secu i y. The p o essionals in e iewed desc ibed he die o seasonal mig an wo ke s as based on ood wi h li le a ie y, insu icien p o ein con en , and obesogenic p oduc s. They also epo ed a gene alized lack o hygiene in ood s o age and p epa a ion. This s udy calls o encou aging die a y suppo s a egies o educe challenges in ood accessibili y, which would p e en heal h p oblems in his popula ion and b ing hem social jus ice. ARTICLE HISTORY Recei ed 7 Augus 2023 Accep ed 2 May 2024 KEYWORDS Mig an s; ag icul u al wo ke s; ood access; COVID-19; quali a i e esea ch In oduc ion Eu opean coun ies’ ag icul u al sec o s depend on mig an wo ke s, especially du ing speci ic pe iods such as ha es season (Moline o-Ge beau, 2021). Likewise, Spain has his o ically been a coun y des ina ion o ag icul u al wo ke s om ab oad (Ma in, 2016). These wo ke s a e mainly ec ui ed du ing speci ic pe iods o a ew mon hs, which a y om egion o egion and in ol e di e en wo k ac i i ies such as ha es ing and p ocessing ag icul u al p oduc ion (Zimme e © 2024 The Au ho (s). Published by In o ma UK Limi ed, ading as Taylo & F ancis G oup This is an Open Access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion-NonComme cial License (h p://c ea i ecommons. o g/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which pe mi s un es ic ed non-comme cial use, dis ibu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal wo k is p ope ly ci ed. The e ms on which his a icle has been published allow he pos ing o he Accep ed Manusc ip in a eposi o y by he au ho (s) o wi h hei consen . CONTACT Jose Tomás Ma eos [email p o ec ed] GLOBAL PUBLIC HEALTH 2024, VOL. 19, NO. 1, 2352570 h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/17441692.2024.2352570 e al., 2020). Mig an and seasonal ag icul u al a mwo ke s (MSAFW’s) in Spain a e mainly people om he Magh eb, sub-Saha an A ica, Eas e n Eu ope, and, o a lesse ex en , La in Ame ica (González, 2018; Ma in, 2016). In 2018, a ound 150,000 and 276,000 empo a y wo ke s we e hi ed in Spain o ag icul u al wo k (Augè e-G anie , 2021). O en, MSAFW’s ace p eca ious li ing and wo king condi ions caused by ins abili y in employ- men , in some cases i egula , which implies geog aphic mobili y and less gua an ee o hei igh s (F ies-Te sch e al., 2021; T ianda yllidou & Ba olini, 2020). These poo e condi ions en ail a highe isk o poo e heal h and less access o he heal h and social p o ec ion sys em (U ego- Pa a e al., 2022). This si ua ion also en ails a high isk o su e ing challenges o access nu i ion- ally adequa e ood due o poo e access o ood and mo e signi ican di icul ies in ood p epa a ion and p ese a ion (Kiehne & Mendoza, 2015). Food secu i y depends undamen ally on ou aspec s: a ailabili y, access, u iliza ion, and s ab- ili y (FAO, 2009). In his s udy, we will ocus on access o ood, unde s ood as he household’s o indi idual’s abili y o ob ain a ailable ood (B iones e al., 2018). While malnu i ion is no solely de e mined by his aspec , i can lead o an inc eased isk o ood- ela ed p oblems (Pins up- Ande sen, 2009). In his sense, ood access p oblems a e also included when his access leads o ul- ne abili y o ma ginaliza ion, such as h ough dona ions, cha i ies, ood banks, o he (Ande son, 1990; Radime e al., 1992). Among MSAFW’s, he p e alence o ood insecu i y is es ima ed a 87% (Al-Bazz e al., 2022; Kiehne & Mendoza, 2015). The e a e ba ie s o accessing ood, such as emo eness om supe ma - ke s and g oce y shops, a lack o means and ime o do he shopping, and a lack o access o a o d- able, su icien , a ied, and heal hy ood (Meie o o & Som Cas ellano, 2020; Summe s e al., 2015). As a esul , hey could ha e poo die a y beha iou s, including i egula in ake pa e ns, low con- sump ion o nu i ious oods, and a lack o ime o meal p epa a ion (Benazizi e al., 2018; Rod í- guez, 2019; Sliwa e al., 2015). Because o he di icul y o accessing his popula ion, o he bes o ou knowledge, ew s udies ha e desc ibed access o ood and i s implica ions o he heal h o MSAFW’s in Spain. One way o app oaching he eali y o MSAFW’s is h ough he p o essionals who wo k in he p o ec ion and suppo sys em o mig an s in public ins i u ions o NGOs (Cáno as e al., 2022; Mozo e al., 2022). The lack o knowledge ela ed o ood accessibili y ha is expe ienced among he mig an popu- la ion, in gene al, and among MSAFW’s, inc eases he in isibili y o he ulne abili y o hese g oups and hinde s he e ec i e gua an ee o he igh s o heal h and an adequa e s anda d o li ing (Co ado & Palumbo, 2022). The e o e, his s udy aimed o explo e how MSAFW’s access ood in Spain om he pe spec i e o p o essionals suppo ing his popula ion. Ma e ial & Me hods S udy design and se ing This quali a i e, explo a o y and desc ip i e s udy is pa o he i s phase o a b oade p ojec (ANO- NIMIZED), ocused on assessing he in luence o job insecu i y and social exclusion on he heal h o mig an women and men wo king in he ag icul u al sec o in Spain. Du ing 2021, semis uc u ed in e iews we e ca ied ou in ou p o inces o Spain wi h di e en ypes o ag icul u al p oduc ion (seasonal campaigns: Ca alonia and La Rioja/in ensi e ag icul u e: Andalusia and Mu cia). Ag icul- u al seasons in he no h (Lleida and La Rioja) las a ew mon hs and a e open-ai , ex ensi e, and ocused on exploi ing a educed ange o p oduc s. In con as , he campaigns in he sou h (Mu cia and Alme ia) end o las se e al mon hs, be in ensi e, unde plas ic o o cha ds, and p oduce a wide ange o p oduc s (Ma ínez Fe nández, 2020; Moline o-Ge beau & Muñoz-Rico, 2022; So uco- Pa ada, 2021). In all o hem, he e a e many ag icul u al wo k ac i i ies: ha es ing, p uning, picking, p ocessing, and packaging (González e al., 2021). Seasonal wo k is mainly ca ied ou in he ield o ha es ing, p ocessing, and opping ui and ege ables, in ag icul u al s a ions o ha es ing, on 2 L. A. RODRÍGUEZ-GUERRERO ET AL. a ms o ineya ds, o in nu se ies. The e is also a signi ican g oup dedica ed o wo king in sheds o wa ehouses o he packaging and s o age o p oduce and s o age o p oduce (Gadea e al., 2016). Pa icipan s Pa icipan s we e heal h and social ca e p o essionals wo king in public ins i u ions and NGOs in ol ed in he suppo o MSAFW’s. Pa icipa ing NGOs we e na ional and local o ganiza ions c ea ed o imp o e li ing condi ions in a eas such as heal h, educa ion, housing, public se ices, anspo , and employmen , among o he aspec s (Delgado, 2010). Rec ui men was ca ied ou by pu posi e sampling by iden i ying key in o man s in he ou selec ed egions and hen by using he snowballing echnique. A o al o 92 pa icipan s (55 women, 37 men) in ol ed in he ca e and suppo o e ed o MSAFW’s we e ec ui ed, including p o essionals om Heal h ca e: physicians, nu ses, psychologis s (n = 23), social se ices (n = 3), NGOs and cul u al media o s (n = 43), wo ke unions (n = 17) and Go e nmen al ins i u ions (n = 6) in ou Spanish egions: Andalusia (n = 31), Ca alonia (n = 24), La Rioja (n = 20) and Mu cia (n = 17)[ Table 1]. We chose semis uc u ed in e iews as he da a collec ion echnique o ob ain deep in o ma ion om each in o man ega ding se e al opics included in he in e iew guide. We conduc ed 86 in e iews (indi idual n = 80 o in pai s n = 6) in pe son o by Zoom un il he in o ma ion sa - u a ion. This esul ed in no new in o ma ion being ob ained. A single in e iew sc ip wi h open-ended ques ions was designed by he p ojec ’s esea ch eam in acco dance wi h he p ojec ’s objec i es and p e ious li e a u e. I con ained i e sec ions: ca e and suppo o MSAFW’s p o ided by he se ice, mig a o y ajec o y, MSAFW’s li ing con- di ions, MSAFW’s heal h and impac o he COVID-19 pandemic. The in e iews we e conduc ed om Janua y o Oc obe 2021. The du a ion o he in e iews las ed on a e age 60 minu es (be ween 30 and 90 minu es). The eam o in e iewe s we e membe s o he men ioned esea ch p ojec . The in e iews we e conduc ed bo h online and in-pe son in he a o emen ioned egions. They we e audio- eco ded elec onically and hen ansc ibed e ba im. Analysis The ansc ip s we e impo ed in o he ATLAS. i web so wa e (online e sion 9) (ATLAS. i Scien- i ic So wa e De elopmen GmbH, 2022), which was used o o ganize and code he in o ma ion du ing he analysis. We conduc ed a e lec i e hema ic analysis (B aun & Cla ke, 2022). In he i s s ep, he esea che s elabo a ed a code ee based on he in e iew sc ip o iden i y he key concep s in he ansc ip s, assigning a code wi h a simila meaning o each sen ence o pa ag aph. In he second s ep, hey labelled he pa ag aphs ela ed o he s udy’s objec i es wi h open codes summa ising he meaning o each sen ence. Finally, ollowing a cons an compa ison p ocess, he esul ing lis o open codes was g ouped unde g oups o codes acco ding o hei simila i y, esul ing in he sub hemes and hemes shown in he esul s sec ion. The au ho s me se e al imes o discuss he inal hemes and he s uc u e o he esul s. Table 1. S udy pa icipan s acco ding o he sec o and egion (N = 92). Region Sex Sec o Female Male Heal h ca e Social se ices NGOs Media ion Wo ke unions Go e nmen al ins i u ions Andalusia 25 6 9 1 17 4 0 0 Ca alonia 10 14 9 0 7 4 2 3 La Rioja 13 7 3 2 5 0 6 2 Mu cia 7 10 2 0 6 0 9 1 To al pa icipan s N = 92 55 37 23 3 35 8 17 6 GLOBAL PUBLIC HEALTH 3 The igou o he analysis was ensu ed h ough a combina ion o s a egies, including he e ogen- ei y o pa icipan p o iles, egions o o igin and esea che pe spec i es, as well as by accompany- ing he esul s wi h meaning ul exce p s ( e ba im quo a ions) om he in e iews. E hical conside a ions The s udy was conduc ed aking in o accoun all e hical conside a ions o he Decla a ion o Hel- sinki. P io o da a collec ion, app o al was ob ained om he Heal hca e E hics Commi ee o he A nau o Vilano a Hospi al in Lleida in 2021 [CEIC– 2459].. Responden s ag eed o pa ici- pa e olun a ily and signed an in o med consen documen gua an eeing con iden iali y o he da a. Du ing da a collec ion and ansc ip ion, an iden i ica ion numbe was assigned o each pa icipan in o de o p ese e hei anonymi y. Consolida ed C i e ia o Repo ing Quali a i e Resea ch (COREQ) c i e ia we e ollowed (Tong e al., 2007). Resul s The esul s ha e been s uc u ed in o h ee eme ging hemes (1) Suppo and ood dis ibu ion by ins i u ions and NGOs; (2) Nu i ion cha ac e is ics o MSAFW’s; and (3) Nu i ion- ela ed heal h p oblems o MSAFW’s, wi h hei co esponding sub hemes. Suppo and ood dis ibu ion by ins i u ions and NGOs Seeking suppo and accessing ood- ela ed esou ces The pa icipa ing p o essionals desc ibed ha MSAFW’s ace si ua ions o economic p eca ious- ness. Al hough, in some cases, MSAFW’s eso o collabo a ion o begging s a egies, dona ions om ins i u ions and NGOs a e hei p ima y sou ce o accessing ood. P o essionals highligh ed ha MSAFW’s main demands o suppo a he ins i u ions a e ood and housing cos s. Pa ici- pan s iden i ied ba ie s o accessing ood esou ces, such as knowing whe e ood esou ces a e p o- ided, ime cons ain s, and he size o he ci y o go o such places. Fo example, i hey come ou side o egula hou s, I won’ eed hem, and some imes someone will come one and a hal hou s la e. The e’s a schedule he e and you ha e o s ick o i . (E50, Social wo ke , NGO, La Rioja) The pa icipa ing p o essionals indica ed ha hey also assis ed homeless MSAFW’s by suppo - ing hem in ob aining ood, housing, and economic esou ces. Some NGOs ha e speci ic p og ams o help people expe iencing homelessness, no speci ic o MSAFW’s, and p o essionals epo ed ha hey se e many o hem. In o he cases, p o essionals di ec ly ga e ood o homeless MSAFW’s when hey assis ed hem wi h o he adminis a i e o heal h- ela ed issues. Some imes you’ll bump in o a guy and he’ll ask i you can please lend him 50 cen s. I he hasn’ ea en o wo days o one day, well, you eally eel like you ha e o buy him a sandwich. (E32, Media o , Media ion, Ca alonia) To dis ibu e ood and essen ial p oduc s, local councils and public ins i u ions diagnose basic needs, e e o he co esponding ci cui s, p omo e p ope con ac s, and dis ibu e ood and hygiene p oduc s wi h NGOs. I can be done egula ly in acili ies o by anspo ing he ood o he MSAFW’s loca ions. Usually, he ood packs include h ee meals daily (b eak as , lunch, and dinne ), o example, including a lunch box wi h a sandwich hey b ing o wo k, depending on he a ailable budge . The e’s a municipal meal se ice. They ha e wo e sions. One does ho meals, whe e hey se e lunch and dinne , and his ope a es e e y day o he yea , and we can e e hem he e om he echnical depa men . And hen he o he one is a lowe -demand se ice, whe e hey gi e ou sandwiches o people who don’ sign 4 L. A. RODRÍGUEZ-GUERRERO ET AL. up o he lunch se ice o a en’ signed up o a jobseeke s plan, bu ha sandwich se ice somehow gua an- ees ha hey ge a leas one meal a day e en i i ’s some hing empo a y. (E52, Social wo ke , Ci y Hall, Ca alonia) The in e iewed p o essionals explained ha ood dis ibu ion can also be o e ed h ough ou- che s o inancial alloca ion. We need o mo e owa ds ha ing hem buy hei own [ ood], we need o help wi h di ec ans e s, and one e y in e es ing measu e ha is wo king in Ba celona, bu hasn’ been b ough in he e ye , is ca ds. (E14, Social wo ke , Union, Ca alonia) And he o he aid ha ’s inc eased he mos is he money we gi e ou . I ’s a di ec cash ans e o hem o buy ood. This is wha ’s inc eased he mos as a esul o he pandemic. Wha hey call ‘ inancial dona ions’ i ’s jus hey b ing you hei ouche s and you gi e hem he money … (E15, NGO, Ca alonia) In addi ion, he in e iewees explained ha o dis ibu e ood, he NGOs conside hei speci ic needs, such as hei age, he loca ion o he MSAFW’s homes and household appliances, and hei employmen si ua ion. Fo ins ance, i hey don’ ha e wo k, we gi e hem ood and a bi … They’ll ha e o manage hei shopping a bi , bu also conside ing whe he hey ha e a idge o no . (E64, Nu se, Heal hca e, Andalusia) Collabo a i e wo k o di e en NGOs and an ex ensi e olun ee ne wo k a ailable a e in cha ge o ood dis ibu ion. O he ac ions ca ied ou by NGOs we e e e als o o he suppo de ices. I mean, he e a [NGO] we ha e no esou ces, I can’ eed hem, I ha e o send hem o [NGO], you know wha i ’s like. I’m in cha ge o ulne abili y p og ams. So abou aid, i we ge one o hem he e, hen we ha e o send hem o e he e, whe he i ’s he shel e i hey need a place o sleep, o o [NGO] i hey need somewhe e o ea . (E27, Social wo ke , NGO, La Rioja) Ano he in e en ion highligh ed was heal h educa ion ela ed o ood p ocessing and hygiene o p e en illnesses om ood con amina ion. A he same ime, he p o essionals hemsel es ecog- nized ha li ing condi ions o en do no allow MSAFW’s o gua an ee hese measu es. One o he hings NGOs do is all he en i onmen al s u , like helping hem clean up he camp and explaining some basic simple s u like i hey used a ba e y, hen don’ lea e i nea he ood s o age o wa e supply, o a oid con amina ion. (E2, Nu se, Heal hca e, Andalusia) Food dis ibu ion du ing he COVID-19 pandemic Du ing he i s wa e o he COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and 2021, ci y halls and NGOs ha e p o- ided di e en ypes o humani a ian aid o co e he basic needs o MSAFW’s, such as hygiene (laun- d y, showe s) and ood. The in e iewees indica ed ha he municipali ies we e esponsible o coo dina ing he dis ibu ion o ood and hygiene ki s ollowing COVID-19 p e en ion egula ions. NGOs also wo ked collabo a i ely o dis ibu e ood and e e als o o he suppo mechanisms. [O he NGO] hey’d p o ide a special an o dis ibu ing meals. We we e making he ood, we mo ed o a ki chen ha was se up he e, om a en in he s ee so he e would be en ila ion. On each ip we’d eed some 25 people, so we had o se up ou , ou ood s a ions. (E50, Social wo ke , NGO, La Rioja) Nu i ion cha ac e is ics o MSAFW’s Die cha ac e is ics o MSAFW’s The in e iewees explained ha he die o he MSAFW’s was based on essen ial p oduc s and, wi h li le a iabili y, cheap ood deli e ed by associa ions and NGOs based on ice, lou , and pulses. While consuming ui and p o ein was limi ed, oods high in suga we e high. Some o hem wo k e e y o he day, ge ing hei wages one day a a ime, don’ hey? Well, hose esou ces a e wha hey buy hei ood wi h, bu he ood hey can buy is e y basic ood, like maybe some lou , o some GLOBAL PUBLIC HEALTH 5 beans, bu hei access o a balanced die is limi ed, hey don’ … So hey do ha e access o he bes ege ables hey can ge in he g eenhouses whe e hey’ e hi ed, o whe e one o hei na ionals is hi ed, bu no access o a balanced die whe e hey ge hei mea and hei ish, well, none o ha . (E87, Coo dina o , NGO, Andalusia) As a esul , p o essionals desc ibed MSAFW’s die s as based on essen ial p oduc s, unbalanced and incomple e. They explained i because o hei p eca ious wo king condi ions, which p e en hem om buying enough ood. In his ega d, pa icipan s iden i ied he die o MSAFW’s li ing in shan y se lemen s and wi hou a amily as wo se han hose li ing wi h hei amilies. Pa icipan s also sugges ed ha occasionally, o su i al easons, MSAFW’s eso ed o socially unaccep able ood-hoa ding s a egies, such as s ealing ood o ea ing dog mea in he se lemen s. We ge newcome immig an s, bu hey ha e amily he e al eady … Thei die is usually a bi be e , bu he ones li ing in he camps don’ usually ge any amily suppo , hey don’ ha e he suppo om a iend. So hen hei die is e y limi ed. (E4, P ima y Ca e Physician, Heal hca e, Andalusia) Cul u al di e ences among MSAFW’s The in e iewees no ed ha ood consump ion a ied acco ding o he o igin o he MSAFW’s. They explained ha MSAFW’s wo king in he Spanish camps we e mainly om he Magh eb p o inces, especially Mo occo, and sub-Saha an A ica; while he o me a e meals wi h a a ie y o oods (mea , ege ables, and hei adi ional ood) and indi idual ea ing p ac ices; he la e a e low-cos , inexpensi e ood (such as ice o b eak as , lunch, and dinne ) as hey canno a o d o buy mea due o i s high p ice, and end o eso o communi y o ganiza ional s a - egies o educe ood cos s, such as making e e yday pu chases o sacks o ice ha hey cook oge he . No h A icans ha e a di e en a i ude, hey espec p i acy mo e … Making a communal la ine, sha ing he cooking spaces and all ha is much mo e common among Sub-Saha ans han among No h A icans. No h A icans look o mo e p i acy. I hey ge a oom, hen hey’ll ha e a cooke , hei ke le, hey ha e e e y hing in hei own oom … (E12, P ojec coo dina o , NGO, Mu cia) In his sense, he in e iewees explained ha some imes he ood dis ibu ed by NGOs is no he mos app op ia e and could be ejec ed by MSAFW’s i i is no conside ed cul u ally accep able o i hey need o lea n how o cook i . Then, he impo ance o conside ing p e e ences when dis i- bu ing ood was highligh ed. I ’s a bi o a p oblem o us some imes, when we go a ound gi ing ou ood. Because, o example, we’ll gi e hem beans and people don’ know how o cook hem. So he e’s no poin in gi ing hem ha . Then we ha e o conside hings like ha when we gi e ou ood. (E6, Nu se, Heal hca e, Andalusia) They won’ ea his ype o ood and hen his ood ge s h own away. Appa en ly, a lo o i goes o was e. (E54, Media o , Ci yhall, Ca alonia) Nu i ion- ela ed heal h p oblems o MSAFW’s Risky die a y p ac ices- ela ed isky p oblems o MSAFW’s The in e iews e ealed se e al ailmen s and heal h p oblems a ising om sca ci y o ood and poo hygienic p ac ices. The pa icipan s iden i ied diges i e p oblems, such as s omach ache o gas o- en e i is, and o al p oblems among he MSAFW’s. This si ua ion was especially acu e in i egula se lemen s whe e many MSAFW’s li e in unsani a y condi ions. They ela ed i o an unheal hy die , li le a ie y in hei ood, and a lack o hygiene. Fo ins ance, in e iewees in e ed ha omi - ing, i ching, headaches, and s omach pain could be due o ea ing unwashed ui exposed o pes i- cides, con amina ed wa e , and sani a y p oduc s. And hen s omach aches o s omach discom o , omi ing … […] They say i chy, i chiness, a lo o i , head- aches, and especially i ching, and s omach aches, s omach … Because hey ea ui , some imes hey won’ wash i . (E9, Nu se, Heal hca e, Ca alonia) 6 L. A. RODRÍGUEZ-GUERRERO ET AL. On he one hand, o he heal h p oblems desc ibed among MSAFW’s we e skin and eye p oblems ela ed o i amin de ici s. E en some in e iews iden i ied ha MSAFW’s unheal hy die could ac as a p ecu so o p oblems such as hype choles e olemia, kidney disease, and diabe es – which in u n could be unde -diagnosed; In women, we did see some signi ican nu i ional de ici s, some o hem, o ins ance, ha e de eloped skin o ocula condi ions … (E4, P ima y Ca e Physician, Heal hca e, Andalusia) Thei die s a e e ible. So hey ge choles e ol p oblems e y ea ly on, a a e y young age, and kidney issues. Righ ? And so I hink we’ e s ill a he beginning, so we’ll see a wa e o ch onic condi ions ha a e ypical o ma ginalized popula ions … (E24, Ac i is , Andalucía) On he o he hand, o he in e iewed p o essionals indica ed ha nu i ional diso de s in MSAFW’s we e sca e. We hough ha maybe he disease, diabe es, could be mo e p e alen in hese people, whe e we hink i could be linked o hei die s; hey d ink lo s o suga y be e ages, hey ha e lo s o ca bohyd a es. (E6, Nu se, NGO, Andalusia) Discussion P o essionals suppo ing MSAFW’s iden i ied hem as a isk o expe iencing challenges in he ood supply in Spain. Acco ding o he esul s, he pandemic posi i ely impac ed, c ea ing a g ea e syne gy be ween NGOs and public ins i u ions. Mo eo e , he deploymen o ood aid and e e al o speci ic ood aid mechanisms du ing he pandemic was a bene icial s a egy o educe ood sca - ci y and ackle s uc u al ba ie s like ma e ial po e y, accessing esou ces, and cul u al cha ac e - is ics o MSAFW’s. The esul s could be explained h ough he lens o he concep ual amewo k o Weise e al. (2015). Acco ding o his model, challenges in ood supply con ibu e o ood insecu - i y by ac ing a h ee le els: a communi y-s uc u al le el, a household-beha io al le el, and an indi- idual le el. The e is an in e ela ion be ween hese le els, whe e challenges o ood supply igge ood insecu i y, shape nu i ional beha io , in luence physical heal h, and ha e epe cussions on mo bidi y and mo ali y (Weise e al., 2015). A he communi y-s uc u al le el, he cons an demand o ood aid by MSAFW’s seems o be a consequence o he pa e n o ag icul u al seasons in Spain ha encou ages mo emen be ween egions (Ma in, 2016). The e o e, ood subsidies a e a necessa y sus enance, no a empo a y elie measu e. Al hough ood dis ibu ion sys ems a e a suppo ne wo k, hey a e unable o espond o all he die a y demands and needs o MSAFW’s on hei own (Baze ghi e al., 2016). Al hough mainly NGOs a e esponsible o p o iding di ec ood suppo h ough solida i y and dona ions, his s udy has iden i ied collabo a i e wo k wi h public ins i u ions, such as local go - e nmen s. Tha was he case, o example, in esponding o he needs o MSAFW’s du ing he i s wa es o he COVID-19 pandemic. The measu es aken o con ain he COVID-19 ou b eaks led o an imp o emen in baseline le els o hygiene in some se lemen s ha lacked basic se ices (Cockbu n, 2020). Howe e , his join esponse has unc ioned as a coping s a egy in esponse o he high demand o suppo ha collapsed aid sys ems (Güell & Ga cés-Masca eñas, 2020). E i- dence om he USA, whe e simila s a egies ha e been adop ed, indica es ha some o he changes in oduced ha e no necessa ily been sus ained o e ime (Acco si e al., 2020). A he household-beha iou al le el, he MSAFW’s economic p ojec ocuses on sa ing as much as possible a he expense o hei ood and ma e ial needs. Economic ma ginalisa ion, esul ing om wo king condi ions, esul s in equi ing suppo o mee hei ood needs (Rod íguez e al., 2021). Also, he epo ed ood was age by some MSAFW’s may be a consequence o cul u al di e - ences, such as un amilia i y wi h local ood and a lack o means o knowledge o ood p epa a ion, as has been epo ed in a s udy in Canada wi h a No h A ican popula ion (Hassan & Hekma , 2012). In his ega d, he s a egies used o cope wi h hunge , like ood sha ing and ecei ing GLOBAL PUBLIC HEALTH 7 dona ions desc ibed in sub-Saha an A icans, we e p e iously epo ed in o he con ex s o ex eme po e y o ace challenges ela ed o ood sca ci y (Mbhenyane e al., 2020). Mo eo e , ood accep ance migh depend on cul u al ac o s such as ma ied s a us, which has been iden i ied as a egula o o adhe ence o a mo e adi ional die in No h A ica (El Rhazi e al., 2015). In sub-Saha an A icans, ac o s such as inaccessibili y o adi ional ing edien s esul in accul u a ion o a mo e high-calo ie Wes e n die (Renzaho & Bu ns, 2006) ha migh no be ob ained in he ood aid se ices epo ed, as ou da a poin ou . These ac o s mus be conside ed o p o ide success ul ood aid se ices ha educe ood sca ci y. A he indi idual le el, heal h p o- blems such as o al heal h ha e been p e iously linked o MSAFW’s poo die in he USA (Kiehne & Mendoza, 2015). As iden i ied in he esul s, cons ipa ion and diges i e p oblems ela ed o an as ingen die ha e been ela ed o condi ions o po e y, wi h lowe expendi u e on high- ib e oods, such as ui and ege ables (D ewnowski & Spec e , 2004). None heless, a lack o access o he heal h sys em ansla es in o a highe incidence o heal h p oblems, such as diabe es (Quand e al., 2018). In con as , in Spain, access o he na ional heal h sys em is uni e sal, al hough he e may be o he ba ie s (Be nal-Delgado e al., 2018). The absence o delay in he diagnosis o me abolic p oblems such as dyslipidaemias, diabe es, o neph opa hies could be due o he lack o diagnos ic se ices in p ima y heal h ca e (Bawadi e al., 2012; Gil- González e al., 2015; Sa ía-San ame a e al., 2016). This could be explained because an absence o p e en i e heal h educa ion, which leads o igno ing he signs o he onse o me abolic diseases, has been documen ed (Sa ía-San ame a e al., 2016; U ego-Pa a e al., 2022). In u n, e idence indica es ha he g ea e he numbe o a ms whe e MSAFW’s wo k, he highe he incidence o diseases ela ed o pes icide and chemical con amina ion (Edelson e al., 2018). Heal h p omo ion ac ions a e equi ed o educe he impac o pes icides in he ood MSAFW’s consume. Mo eo e , a he communi y le el, MSAFW’s migh ha e me hei die a y needs by accessing eme gency ood esou ces, such as ood banks (Baze ghi e al., 2016). E idence om he USA sugges s ha when MSAFW’s a e bene icia ies o p og ams aimed a educing ood sca ci y, he e is an inc ease in die a y knowledge and an imp o emen in hei ea ing habi s (Lee & Won, 2015). Howe e , me abolic heal h p oblems unde epo ed by p o essionals in ou da a could be ela ed o he age o debu o me abolic diseases (Olson e al., 2023) o o expe iencing ba ie s in accessing heal hca e due o incompa ibili y o wo king hou s wi h heal h ca e se ices schedules (Caxaj e al., 2023). Fo example, in Mexican MSFW, only 3% epo ed me abolic heal h p oblems, possibly due o a lack o p ima y heal hca e access and low-quali y and unhygienic nu i ional se ices (O ega e al., 2016). In addi ion, in he U.S., MSAFW’s wi hou ecen heal hca e access had 83% lowe odds o epo ing known diabe es in compa ison o nonmig an a mwo ke s (Olson e al., 2023). Gua an ee access o p ima y ca e heal h is essen ial o co ec ly diagnose heal h p oblems in MSAFW’s. Limi a ions and s eng hs The limi a ions o his s udy include ha , i s ly, he in o ma ion epo ed wi hin is no exemp om a possible memo y bias o pass o e speci ic in o ma ion om p o essionals in ol ed in ea - ing MSAFW’s. Since speci ic in o ma ion ela ed o he age o he MSFWs was no discussed among he pa icipan s, he young age o mos o he MSFWs wo ke s migh lead o an unde -diagnosis o he expec ed a es o ch onic disease and heal h p oblems. The nex s ep would equi e pe o ming a de ailed die assessmen o Spanish MSAFW’s o measu e he consequences o he challenges ela ed o ood access and i s impac on heal h. Secondly, he esul s a e limi ed o he ou a o e- men ioned Spanish egions, al hough hey can be conside ed he mos ep esen a i e egions in e ms o he p esence o MSAFW’s. E en hough no gende di e ences ha e eme ged, e idence indica es ha emale MSAFW’s ace mo e challenges ela ed o ood accessibili y and ha e a mo e signi ican unpaid wo kload associa ed wi h ca e asks ela ed o ood acquisi ion and p epa - ing ood o hei amily compa ed o men (Kiehne & Mendoza, 2015). 8 L. A. RODRÍGUEZ-GUERRERO ET AL.