Full text
Mixed Reali y Head-Moun ed Displays in Heal hca e
A Design Science Pe spec i e on Requi emen s, Applica ions, and
Economic Impac in Ch onic Wound Managemen and Den is y
Inaugu aldisse a ion
zu E langung des akademischen G ades eines Dok o s de
Wi scha swissenscha en des Fachbe eichs
Wi scha swissenscha en de Uni e si ä Osnab ück
o geleg on
Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp, M.Sc.
Osnab ück, Ok obe 2025
Dekan
P o . D . Robe Gillenki ch
Re e en en
P o . D . F ank Teu ebe g
P o . D . Ingma Icke o
Da um de Dispu a ion: 28.10.2025
P e ace
This disse a ion was w i en as pa o he p ojec Do gemeinscha 2.0 unded by
he Fede al Minis y o Educa ion and Resea ch. The wo k was ini ia ed while I was
wo king as a esea ch assis an a Osnab ück Uni e si y o Applied Sciences, Facul y o
Managemen , Cul u e and Technology.
I g ea ly app ecia e all hose who ha e accompanied, suppo ed, and encou aged me
h oughou my jou ney o his disse a ion. In pa icula , I would like o hank P o-
esso F ank Teu ebe g o his dedica ed supe ision o he disse a ion, his suppo in
inding he opic and he me hodological o ien a ion o he con ibu ions, and o his
help ul and cons uc i e eedback h oughou he en i e p ocess o w i ing he disse a-
ion—including on e y sho no ice be o e deadlines, which was always g ea ly app e-
cia ed. Special hanks go o P o esso Ingma Icke o o his decisi e ole in ini ia ing
he doc o a e and his p ojec - ela ed suppo h oughou he doc o al pe iod.
My since e hanks go o my amily and iends, who accompanied me along he way.
I am especially g a e ul o my mum o he con inuous suppo in all phases o he
doc o a e and o always being a ailable as my discussion pa ne on a ious opics
ela ed o my wo k. I would also like o hank he o he sus ained in e es in my
p og ess, e en i he en husiasm o inqui ing abou i occasionally exceeded my own. I
am deeply hank ul o my husband o his cons an suppo . His mo i a ing pe se e ance
con ibu ed signi ican ly o he comple ion o his disse a ion.
Geo gsma ienhü e, Juni 2025
Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp
No es on he S uc u e o he Documen
This disse a ion is di ided in o wo pa s: an in oduc o y o e iew and he esea ch
con ibu ions.
Sec ion 1 o he in oduc o y o e iew p esen s he cu en s a e o he a ega ding
he adop ion o new echnologies in he heal hca e sys em. Sec ion 2 ou lines he mo-
i a ion o his disse a ion, which o ms he basis o he objec i e and he esea ch
ques ions (RQs) p esen ed in Sec ion 3. Sec ion 4 desc ibes he esea ch design used o
add ess he esea ch ques ions. I also summa ises he selec ed con ibu ions and ou lines
he me hodology applied. Sec ion 5 summa ises he key indings o he con ibu ions o
highligh oppo uni ies and ba ie s o adop ing mixed eali y head-moun ed displays in
a heal hca e con ex . In addi ion, i p esen s a amewo k o de eloping such sys ems.
The discussion in Sec ion 6 p o ides implica ions o esea ch and p ac ice, iden i ies
u u e esea ch oppo uni ies, and add esses limi a ions.
The second pa complemen s he in oduc o y o e iew by p esen ing a summa y
o he selec ed esea ch con ibu ions, including key bibliog aphic in o ma ion and ab-
s ac s.
Con en s
1 In oduc o y O e iew 9
1.1 S a eo heA ................................. 9
1.2 Mo i a ion ................................... 10
1.3 Objec i e & Resea ch Ques ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
1.4 Resea chDesign ................................ 12
1.4.1 Summa y o he Resea ch Con ibu ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
1.4.2 Spec um o Me hods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
1.5.1 Applica ions o Mixed Reali y Head-Moun ed Displays in Heal hca e 19
1.5.2 T ans o ma i e Oppo uni ies in Heal hca e . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
1.5.3 Ba ie s o E ec i e Implemen a ion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
1.5.4 S uc u ed Sys em & In e ac ion F amewo k o De eloping Mixed
Reali y Head-Moun ed Displays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
1.5.5 Cos -E iciency and Economic Impac o Mixed Reali y Head-Moun ed
DisplaysinHeal hca e......................... 29
1.6 Discussion.................................... 30
1.6.1 Implica ions o Resea ch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
1.6.2 Implica ions o P ac ice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
1.6.3 Limi a ions ............................... 34
1.7 Conclusion ................................... 35
2 Resea ch Con ibu ions 42
2.1 Con ibu ion 1: IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen —Findings
o a Mul i-Me hod Resea ch Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
2.2 Con ibu ion 2: The Fu u e o Digi al Wo k—Use Cases o Augmen ed
Reali yGlasses ................................. 58
2.3 Con ibu ion 3: Design Recommenda ions o Augmen ed Reali y Appli-
ca ions—A Case S udy in Heal hca e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65
2.4 Con ibu ion 4: Technology-Suppo ed Den al Home Visi s by Non-Medical
Pe sonnel o Reduce In ec ion Risk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
2.5 Con ibu ion 5: Cos -Bene i Analysis o Using Mixed Reali y in Den-
is y—Keeping he Den is in he Pic u e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80
Lis o Figu es
1.1 Augmen ed eali y, assis ed eali y, mixed eali y and i ual eali y ac-
co ding o Dwi edi e al. (2021) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
1.2 Ca ego isa ion o he indi idual con ibu ions acco ding o he design sci-
ence app oach (He ne e al., 2004) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
1.3 F equency o ISIC di isions associa ed wi h mixed eali y head-moun ed
display applica ion scena ios (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019) . . . . . 19
1.4 F equency o iden i ied use cases o mixed eali y head-moun ed displays
(Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
1.5 Laye s o he S uc u ed Sys em & In e ac ion F amewo k (own illus a ion) 26
Lis o Tables
1.1 In e connec ion o esea ch ques ions and indings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
1.2 O e iew o con ibu ions included in his disse a ion . . . . . . . . . . . 14
1.3 O e iew o me hods used in his disse a ion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Lis o Abb e ia ions
3D Th ee-Dimensional
AR Augmen ed Reali y
BPMN Business P ocess Model and No a ion
CBA Cos -Bene i Analysis
DSR Design Science Resea ch
ECIS Eu opean Con e ence on In o ma ion Sys ems
FHIR Fas Heal hca e In e ope abili y Resou ces
HDM Hospi al Discha ge Managemen
HMD Head-Moun ed Display
ISIC In e na ional S anda d Indus ial Classi ica ion
IT In o ma ion Technology
LNI Lec u e No es in In o ma ics
MR Mixed Reali y
RQ Resea ch Ques ion
VoFI Visualisa ion o Financial Implica ions
VR Vi ual Reali y
WI Wi scha sin o ma ion (EN: Business In o ma ics)
WKWI Wissenscha liche Kommission Wi scha sin o ma ik im Ve band de
Hochschulleh e ü Be iebswi scha e.V.
1 In oduc o y O e iew
1.1 S a e o he A
Mode n heal hca e sys ems ace inc easing challenges, pa ly due o ou da ed s uc u es
and poli ical negligence. Po e and Gu h (2012) epo a sho age o skilled wo ke s,
gaps in heal hca e p o ision, especially in u al egions, inc easing cos s, and luc ua ing
ca e quali y. Inconsis en echnology s anda ds and p op ie a y in e aces lead o media
discon inui ies. In e sec o al da a sha ing, in pa icula , s ill elies on pape -based da a
ans e , he eby inc easing he likelihood o e o s and in o ma ion loss, and u he
exace ba ing he al eady high wo kload o heal hca e p o essionals (Mille & S ie , 2014;
Wong & Hogan, 2016).
Cu en ly, se e al e o s aim o add ess hese challenges, pa icula ly h ough he
use o echnology. In Ge many, se e al laws we e es ablished ha empowe he use
o mode n echnologies o b ing heal hca e o people, including he use o elemedicine
(Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei , 2019), and apps ha suppo pa ien s (Bundesmin-
is e ium ü Gesundhei , 2020b), people in need o long- e m ca e, o ca egi ing ela i es
(Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei , 2023). To imp o e da a ans e and a ailabil-
i y, he elec onic heal h eco d (Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei , 2020a)—a pa ien -
managed online eposi o y o heal h- ela ed da a—was in oduced. By suppo ing he
in e na ional Fas Heal hca e In e ope abili y Resou ces (FHIR) s anda d (HL7 In e -
na ional, 2024), au ho ised heal hca e p o essionals and he pa ien s hemsel es can
place and synch onise ele an heal h documen s in his cen al space. Despi e hese e -
o s, he p e iously men ioned echnologies a e only slowly gaining momen um (Schmi ,
2024).
The pa ame e s in luencing echnology adop ion a e mani old, as is he deg ee o
echnologisa ion wi hin he heal hca e sys em. While some medical in e en ions a e
suppo ed by ul a-mode n echnological achie emen s, such as he da Vinci Su gical
Sys em (G ade e al., 2019), o he p ocesses emain pape -based o ely on ou da ed
echnologies, such as ax sys ems, o he communica ion o pa ien da a (Ko ekamp,
Süßmu h, e al., 2019).
Den al p ac ices o en ha e a compa a i ely high deg ee o digi isa ion (Mühlemann
e al., 2019). Technology is employed in a ious a eas, including pa ien managemen ,
imaging, and he ab ica ion o ce amic es o a ions. One impo an ac o in luencing
echnology adop ion is he pe cei ed ad an age, such as inancial bene i s o imp o ed
ea men quali y (Bhambhani e al., 2013).
In his disse a ion, mixed eali y (MR) is de ined acco ding o Dwi edi e al. (2021).
To e lec he g owing numbe o possible combina ions be ween physical and i ual
1.4 Resea ch Design In oduc o y O e iew
o p e iously speci ied p oblems wi hin he heal hca e sys em by p o iding guidelines,
equi emen s, and usage scena ios o ailo ed so wa e ha can suppo heal hca e p o-
essionals.
The o e all objec i e is o esea ch how echnology, pa icula ly MR HMDs, can help
add ess mode n p oblems o heal hca e p o essionals. The objec i es o indi idual con i-
bu ions a y depending on he ocus, including he de elopmen o design guidelines o
MR HMD so wa e (Ko ekamp e al., 2020) o a cos -bene i analysis o MR HMDs in
den al p ac ices (Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Each con ibu ion p esen s di e en a e ac s
ha con ibu e o he o e all goal o he wo k, which is o iden i y ac o s in luencing
he adop ion and use o MR HMDs in he heal hca e sec o .
To add ess he opic o design and de elopmen , sys ema ic esea ch me hods like
li e a u e sea ch, expe in e iews and g oup discussions we e used o de elop speci ic
usage scena ios and design p inciples (Ko ekamp e al., 2020, 2021). Fu he mo e, a
complex cos -bene i amewo k was de eloped o e alua e he inancial alue o MR
HMDs in den al p ac ices (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
Fo demons a ion and e alua ion pu poses, heo e ical demons a ions and implemen-
a ion concep s illus a ed he a e ac s’ unc ionali y. Fo example, he design p inciples
o MR HMD applica ions we e p esen ed based on a concep o an applica ion ha
could suppo ch onic wound managemen p o essionals. The cos -bene i amewo k
was e alua ed du ing expe in e iews, based on an exempla y use-case scena io. These
heo e ical app oaches helped o assess he usabili y and economic iabili y o he de-
eloped a e ac s.
The inal s ep, communica ion, was accomplished by p esen ing he esea ch indings
a a ious in e na ional con e ences, including he Eu opean Con e ence on In o ma-
ion Sys ems, and publishing hem in jou nals o make hem a ailable o he scien i ic
communi y and p ac i ione s.
The o e all me hodological app oach ollows a mixed-me hods design (Venka esh e
al., 2013), combining quali a i e and quan i a i e elemen s o p o ide a comp ehensi e
unde s anding o he esea ch p oblem. Gi en he no el y o he opic o MR HMDs, pa -
icula ly in he heal hca e sec o , quali a i e me hods we e he p edominan app oach.
On he one hand, he lack o da a became appa en du ing he li e a u e sea ches,
which, despi e using b oad sea ch e ms, yielded only a limi ed numbe o ele an e-
sul s. Addi ionally, when a emp ing o collec p ac ice da a, only a ew p o essionals
wi h expe ience in using MR HMDs in a medical con ex could be ound, making i im-
possible o conduc quan i a i e su eys. Howe e , quan i a i e me hods we e applied
whe e app op ia e, o example, in he cos -bene i analysis. Table 1.3, oge he wi h
he ollowing pa ag aphs, p o ides an o e iew o he me hods used.
In e iews a e a quali a i e esea ch me hod ha helps o gain deepe insigh s in o he
in e iewees’ subjec i e opinions, expe iences, and pe spec i es. One o hei bene i s is
ha hey allow o he explo a ion o speci ic ques ions while s ill allowing o esponses
o un o eseen aspec s. In e iews a e sui able o unde s anding complex p ocesses ha
depend on he in e iewees’ indi idual expe iences (Gläse & Laudel, 2010). In his dis-
16
1.4 Resea ch Design In oduc o y O e iew
Resea ch Me hod Con ibu ion Re e ence
12345
Quali a i e Me hods
In e iews Gläse and Laudel, 2010
G oup Discussion Flick, 2009
Shadowing McDonald, 2005
Li e a u e Re iew Vom B ocke e al., 2015; Webs e
and Wa son, 2002
Quali a i e Con en Analysis May ing, 2014
Quan i a i e Me hods
Cos -Bene i Analysis G ob, 1989; Heis e , 1962; Sassone
and Scha e , 1978
Mon e-Ca lo Simula ion Sa ides, 1994
Table 1.3: O e iew o me hods used in his disse a ion
se a ion, in e iews we e employed o gain a deep unde s anding o he daily challenges
aced by heal hca e p o essionals (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019) and o alida e
he indings used o calcula e he VoFI ables (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
G oup discussions a e a quali a i e esea ch me hod especially sui ed o ga he collec-
i e opinions, a i udes and pe cep ions on a p ede ined opic. Acco ding o Flick (2009),
he pa icipan s’ in e ac ions du ing g oup discussions allow esea che s o disco e new
pe spec i es and illumina e he opic in-dep h. The cha ac e o he discussions p o-
mo es open exchange, allowing esea che s o analyse no only indi idual opinions bu
also g oup dynamic p ocesses and collec i e iews. The me hod is especially sui ed o
including di e en in e es g oups. This disse a ion employed g oup discussions o de-
elop a concep o an MR-based use in e ace (Ko ekamp e al., 2020) and o iden i y
po en ial use cases and challenges o using MR HMDs in den al p ac ices (Ko ekamp
e al., 2021).
Shadowing is a quali a i e esea ch me hod whe e he esea che obse es a pe son
in hei na u al wo k en i onmen . The goal is o ollow he pe son’s ac i i ies and
in e ac ions o gain a deepe unde s anding o hei asks, p ocesses and challenges.
Shadowing is especially use ul o analysing wo k and decision p ocesses in a eal-wo ld
con ex , as i allows he esea che o obse e no only he pe son’s ac ions bu also he
si ua ional con ex and in e ac ions wi h o he ac o s (McDonald, 2005). In con as o
in e iews o ques ionnai es, shadowing p o ides di ec and de ailed insigh s in o p ac-
17
1.4 Resea ch Design In oduc o y O e iew
ice, elimina ing he need o e ospec i e o subjec i e epo s om pa icipan s. In
his disse a ion, shadowing was used o gain an unde s anding o he daily challenges
and p ocesses aced by discha ge managemen employees. This me hod unco e ed alu-
able insigh s such as c i ical p ocesses and media dis up ions in in e - and in asec o al
in o ma ion lows (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019).
Li e a u e e iew is a sys ema ic me hod ha helps o iden i y, analyse and agg ega e
exis ing knowledge wi hin a speci ied esea ch opic. Using a s uc u ed app oach, li e -
a u e e iews can help o iden i y esea ch gaps and pu esea ch in o con ex . Sys em-
a ically selec ing and analysing scien i ic publica ions om ele an da abases ensu es
holis ic and esilien indings (Vom B ocke e al., 2015; Webs e & Wa son, 2002). In
his wo k, li e a u e e iews we e employed o p o ide an o e iew o he cu en s a e
o he a ega ding he use o MR HMDs in heal hca e en i onmen s. Fo example, a
li e a u e sea ch o o e 650 publica ions om ele an da abases, such as EBSCOhos ,
p o ided insigh s in o he cu en use o MR HMDs ac oss di e en ades and use cases,
and allowed o he de i a ion o guidelines o decision-make s and asks o esea che s
(Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019).
Quali a i e con en analysis is a s uc u ed me hod o sys ema ically de i ing ca e-
go ies om la ge amoun s o da a, such as in e iew ansc ip s o li e a u e. May ing
(2014) dis inguishes be ween an induc i e and deduc i e app oach depending on whe he
he ca ego ies a e de eloped based on he ma e ial (induc i e) o based on exis ing he-
o y (deduc i e). The goal is o ex ac ele an da a and s uc u e i in a clea and
comp ehensible manne , allowing well- ounded insigh s o be de i ed. In his disse -
a ion, quali a i e con en analysis is used o analyse da a om expe in e iews and
li e a u e sea ch. Fo ins ance, o gain a holis ic pic u e o he use s’ needs, he equi e-
men s analysis o MR HMD so wa e used in den al applica ions employs in e iew
ansc ip s and ele an li e a u e o deduce key equi emen s and summa ise hem in o
supe o dina e ca ego ies.
Cos -bene i analysis is a quan i a i e me hod ha sys ema ically assesses a p ojec ’s
economic ad an ages and disad an ages. Cos -bene i analysis (CBA) is sui able o
e alua ing mone a y and non-mone a y cos s o p o ide a well- ounded basis o in es -
men decisions (G ob, 1989). Heis e (1962) de eloped he me hod u he o make i
sui able o complex p ojec s wi h mul iple a iables and unce ain ies. The me hod
o e s a de ailed s uc u e o iden i ying, e alua ing and p io i ising cos s and bene i s
h oughou an in es men ’s li e cycle. This disse a ion employs a CBA o e alua e he
economic iabili y o using MR HMDs in den al p ac ices. To alida e he indings, VoFI
ables and Mon e-Ca lo simula ions we e used o analyse possible isks ega ding u u e
in es men s (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
18
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings
In he ollowing sec ion, he indings om he a ious con ibu ions a e hema ically
g ouped o add ess he h ee o e a ching esea ch ques ions (see Sec ion 1.3). How
MR HMDs can be applied in he business sec o , pa icula ly in heal hca e (RQ1) is
answe ed in Sec ions 1.5.1 and 1.5.2. The esul s o Sec ions 1.5.3 and 1.5.4 con ibu e
o equi emen s and design p inciples ha should be conside ed o he use o MR HMDs
(RQ2), wi h Sec ion 1.5.3 highligh ing possible ba ie s and Sec ion 1.5.4 p esen ing
de i ed ecommenda ions and p inciples. Sec ion 1.5.5 p o ides insigh s in o he cos -
e iciency o MR HMDs (RQ3).
Sec ion 1.4 o e s a de ailed o e iew o he esea ch me hods employed; he e o e,
his sec ion will ocus on he indings.
1.5.1 Applica ions o Mixed Reali y Head-Moun ed Displays in Heal hca e
To be e unde s and he echnological and economic con ex o he p esen ed appli-
ca ion scena ios o MR HMDs in heal hca e, he In e na ional S anda d Indus ial
Classi ica ion o All Economic Ac i i ies (ISIC) (Uni ed Na ions. S a is ical Di ision,
2008) is used as a amewo k. ISIC de ines 21 sec ions, u he di ided in o 78 di isions.
Ko ekamp, We ning, e al. (2019) iden i ied nine sec ions and 26 di isions associa ed
wi h MR HMD applica ion scena ios. Figu e 1.3 p esen s an o e iew o he ele an
di isions and he equency wi h which he ade di isions a e named in he li e a u e.
Among hese, he ca ego y Human heal h and social wo k ac i i ies s ands ou , wi h a
equency o o e 25%, ma king i as he mos equen ly ci ed a ea.
Figu e 1.3: F equency o ISIC di isions associa ed wi h mixed eali y head-moun ed dis-
play applica ion scena ios (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019)
19
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
Figu e 1.4: F equency o iden i ied use cases o mixed eali y head-moun ed displays
(Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019)
Wi hin hese ade di isions, Ko ekamp, We ning, e al. (2019) iden i ied se en ap-
plica ion scena ios as shown in Figu e 1.4. In he con ex o heal hca e applica ions,
h ee p ima y scena ios a e pa icula ly ele an : da a access & isualisa ion, aining
& educa ion, and collabo a ion & communica ion. Acco dingly, his sec ion will ocus on
hose scena ios.
Wi hin he Da a Access and Visualisa ion applica ion scena io, MR HMDs a e em-
ployed ac oss a ious medical use cases, including ch onic wound managemen , den al
home isi s by non-medical s a , and he isualisa ion o p ocedu al s eps in den al
p epa a ion, planning, and su ge y.
In he con ex o ch onic wound managemen , MR HMDs can be used e ec i ely du ing
wound assessmen (Ko ekamp e al., 2020). A key ad an age is hei hands- ee usage,
so ha documen a ion and ea men can be pe o med simul aneously wi hou he need
o e-s e ilisa ion in be ween. This acili a es mo e de ailed and p ecise documen a ion,
which is c ucial o ea men success (Deu sches Ne zwe k ü Quali ä sen wicklung in
de P lege, 2015). Pa ien s bene i om as e wound healing, while cos -bea e s bene i
om educed ea men cos s. Especially when combined wi h sma ea u es, such as
con ex -sensi i e sugges ions o app op ia e wound ma e ials, cos s can be signi ican ly
educed, as cu en ly only 30% o 40% o ch onic wound ca e ma e ials a e being used
e ec i ely (Made , 2016).
MR HMDs could also elie e den is s by enabling allied den al pe sonnel o pe o m
a ious den al asks. Ko ekamp e al. (2021) epo i e possible use cases ha could
be pe o med du ing home isi s by allied den al pe sonnel based on hei aining and
expe ise i equipped wi h an MR HMD. The use cases ange om ideo documen a ion
o he o al ca i y pe o med by medical o nu sing s a o den al p ophylaxis pe o med
20
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
by a den al hygienis . The MR HMD can suppo he den al pe sonnel by p o iding
in o ma ion abou he pa ien , guiding hem h ough p ocedu es and documen ing he
ea men ou come. I necessa y, he den is o o he expe s can be consul ed ia a
ideo call, allowing hem o obse e he pa ien ’s si ua ion di ec ly h ough he MR
HMD’s came a eed.
Ano he use case in he Da a Access and Visualisa ion applica ion scena io in ol es he
u ilisa ion o MR HMDs du ing p epa a ion, planning and su ge y. Using he pa ien ’s
3D da a, ana omical s uc u es can be iewed and analysed in 3D du ing p eope a i e
planning (Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Du ing su ge y, he 3D imaging da a can be o e laid
on o he pa ien and enhanced wi h addi ional in o ma ion, such as he co ec d ill
posi ioning and c i ical ana omic s uc u es (Song e al., 2018). In implan ology, he
p eope a i ely planned placemen can be compa ed wi h he cu en implan posi ion in
eal- ime (Pelleg ino e al., 2019; Yo pibulwong e al., 2022).
The aining and educa ion applica ion scena io en ails use cases applicable o all
s ages o den al educa ion, om s uden o specialis aining. Using he 3D isualisa ion
capabili ies o MR HMDs o s udying den al ana omy by p o iding supplemen a y 3D
isual ma e ial ac i a es highe -o de cogni i e skills and, hus, can enhance he lea n-
ing expe ience signi ican ly (Espejo-T ung e al., 2015). Addi ionally, using MR HMDs
can help simula e complex p ocedu es. Specialised simula o s combine MR HMDs wi h
moni o s and hap ic de ices o simula e a wide ange o den al p oblems wi hou con-
suming na u al ma e ials, allowing s uden s o ge accus omed o he co ec pos u e
and de elop necessa y ine mo o skills (Li e al., 2022).
Collabo a ion and communica ion is ano he applica ion scena io o MR HMDs. The
collabo a i e ea u es enable in e disciplina y coope a ion by p o iding he ools o
expe s om di e en speciali ies o iew he same 3D da a and join ly consul on
he op imal su gical p ocedu e (Ba ella e al., 2021). Addi ionally, he use o his
echnology can enhance s uden -ins uc o in e ac ions in clinical aining en i onmen s.
Fo example, ins uc o s can p o ide immedia e guidance while obse ing p ocedu es
om he s uden ’s pe spec i e du ing p ac ical aining sessions, which leads o mo e
e ec i e supe ision (Må ell-Olsson & Jahnke, 2019).
1.5.2 T ans o ma i e Oppo uni ies in Heal hca e
The abo e-men ioned usage scena ios and capabili ies o MR HMDs ha e he po en ial
o p o ide se e al bene i s when using hem in heal hca e se ings.
Op imised ope a ional wo k lows. Using an MR HMD can imp o e ope a ional e i-
ciency and e ec i eness (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019; Ko ekamp e al., 2024)
by helping s eamline wo k lows, educing ea men ime and he need o suppo i e
s a (Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Telecommunica ion and documen a ion ea u es could
imp o e o e all ime managemen in den al p ac ices by allowing allied den al pe sonnel
o ake o e de ined asks, he eby educing he doc o ’s wo kload (Ko ekamp e al.,
2021).
21
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
Medical p ocess enhancemen . MR HMDs can help du ing di e en s ages o medical
wo k lows. S a ing wi h p e-ope a ional planning, he 3D isualisa ion o pa ien da a
can lead o a be e spa ial unde s anding o ana omical s uc u es, and hus o mo e
p ecise p ocedu es (Ba ella e al., 2021). Using he elecommunica ion ea u e in his
con ex can also imp o e in e disciplina y coope a ion, helping in complex cases whe e
di e en medical disciplines need o collabo a e o success ul su ge y (Ba ella e al.,
2021). Du ing su ge y, p ojec in o ma ion such as con ex -based da a, isual cues and
3D ana omical s uc u es can be p ojec ed di ec ly on o he pa ien o in o he su geon’s
iew, helping wi h na iga ion and keeping hei ocus on he pa ien (A ms ong e al.,
2016; Song e al., 2018).
Howe e , MR HMDs can also be help ul in o he heal hca e se ings, such as pa ien
ca e, by p o iding eal- ime da a and ins uc ions o he wea e (Ko ekamp e al., 2020).
Fo example, ele an pa ien in o ma ion and guidelines can be di ec ly displayed wi hin
he wea e ’s ield o iew, elimina ing he need o shi a en ion be ween documen a ion
on pape o ano he sc een, he eby keeping he ocus on he pa ien (Klinke e al.,
2020). This can also be used o s ep-by-s ep ins uc ions and o suppo less expe ienced
s a while pe o ming complex o new asks (Ko ekamp e al., 2021).
E icien da a handling in s e ile en i onmen s. A signi ican ad an age is he hands-
ee usage o MR HMDs (Klinke e al., 2020; Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019; Ko -
ekamp e al., 2020, 2021; Mewes e al., 2017). Especially in s e ile en i onmen s, as
his ea u e enables he wea e o access, isualise and edi da a wi hou he isk o con-
amina ion du ing medical ea men s (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019; Ko ekamp
e al., 2020, 2021). Fo example, in he case o ch onic wound ca e ea men , his can
lead o imp o ed ou comes o pa ien s and heal hca e p o ide s alike, as con inuous
and de ailed documen a ion is an impo an ac o o he wound healing p og ess when
ea ing ch onic wounds (Ko ekamp e al., 2020; Pan il e al., 2015). Enhanced da a
a ailabili y is also bene icial o o he a eas in heal hca e, as da a dis up ion emains an
essen ial opic, especially when conside ing da a dis up ion in combina ion wi h in e -
sec o al pa ien ans e s (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019).
Real- ime collabo a ion. MR HMDs echnology p o ides ideo calls and i ual mee -
ings, enabling di e se applica ions o coope a ion and collabo a ion. Du ing hose mee -
ings, he pa ien ’s 3D da a can be iewed by all pa icipan s so ha i can be used o
in e sec o al umou boa ds o p eope a i e planning sessions o complex cases (Ko -
ekamp e al., 2024; Teppe e al., 2017). When encoun e ing issues du ing medical
ea men , MR HMDs can also acili a e coope a ion wi h dis an expe s who can be
consul ed ia a ideo call. The ad an age is ha he expe can iew he si ua ion om
he wea e ’s pe spec i e, he eby gaining a be e unde s anding o he si ua ion and
he pa ien ’s condi ion (Ko ekamp e al., 2020, 2021). Apa om po en ially be e
pa ien ou comes, his also has ad an ages in e ms o educed a el cos s and ime
(Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
22
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
Medical educa ion and aining. P ac ical expe ience plays an impo an ole in med-
ical educa ion and aining. MR HMDs can enhance on- he-job aining by p o iding
con ex -sensi i e in o ma ion o emo e suppo om expe s (Ko ekamp, We ning, e
al., 2019). The imp o ed spa ial unde s anding and simula ion capabili ies o specialised
aining gea can enhance s uden s’ p ac ical skills wi hou equi ing physical esou ces,
such as eal ee h, o s udying oo h mo phology (Mah ous e al., 2021; Mladeno ic,
2020). Using he 3D p esen a ion capabili ies, s uden s can imp o e hei knowledge o
ana omic s uc u es (Espejo-T ung e al., 2015), lea n complex p ocedu es and—when
combined wi h specialised gea like he Uniden al Mixed Reali y Simula o —acqui e he
necessa y ine mo o skills and co ec pos u e needed o hei wo k as a den is (Li
e al., 2022).
Cus omised isual augmen a ion. Ano he use case, apa om medical ca e, is he
use o MR HMDs by isually impai ed indi iduals. Since MR HMDs a e see- h ough
and enhance eali y wi h isual in o ma ion, hey can be used o assis he wea e in
hei daily li es and also help hem wi h na iga ion (Sandnes & Eika, 2017). I is also
possible o highligh impo an objec s o imp o e he en i onmen ’s isual con as s o
accommoda e hei wea e ’s needs (Eh lich e al., 2017).
1.5.3 Ba ie s o E ec i e Implemen a ion
The ollowing subsec ion p esen s po en ial obs acles and challenges, including echno-
logical limi a ions, accep ance om medical p o essionals and ques ions ega ding da a
secu i y.
In eg a ion and in e ope abili y challenges. The in eg a ion o new in o ma ion ech-
nology (IT) sys ems in o exis ing heal hca e IT ecosys ems is o en challenging, as many
manu ac u e s o heal hca e IT solu ions s ick o hei p op ie a y s anda ds. P o iding
he necessa y in e aces may equi e high expendi u es o ei he de elopmen o licens-
ing cos s. Howe e , o use MR HMDs e ec i ely, da a exchange and compa ibili y a e
c ucial (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019).
E en mo e complex is he opic o in e sec o al communica ion (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h,
e al., 2019), i.e., sha ing da a be ween inpa ien and ou pa ien acili ies, as his in ol es
no only echnical speci ica ions bu also p ocedu al hu dles, especially adhe ence o
p i acy laws (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019).
Adminis a i e and ope a ional o e heads. Apa om echnical and egula o y di i-
cul ies, in oducing a new IT sys em such as an MR HMD will also come wi h signi ican
adminis a i e o e heads du ing he implemen a ion phase (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al.,
2019; Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Be o e i can be used e icien ly, p ocesses migh need
ewo king, and he s a needs adequa e aining. Du ing he amilia isa ion and aining
phase, he wo kload and cos s migh be highe han be o e, un il he new p ocesses wo k
smoo hly and he bene i s ake e ec (Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Especially in he medical
23
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
ield, his can be a hu dle, as he wo kload is al eady high and he nega i e aspec s o
he implemen a ion phase a e mo e angible han he long- e m bene i s (Ko ekamp
e al., 2024).
Regula o y and da a secu i y challenges. The use o new echnology is o en con-
on ed wi h di e en legal ques ions. Especially on mobile de ices, conce ns ega ding
he secu i y o ulne able pa ien da a a ise (Ca enzo e al., 2015; Kane sky e al., 2019;
Spa wasse e al., 2018). The e o e, igo ous secu i y measu es need o be implemen ed,
including hose ha comply wi h applicable egula o y equi emen s (Ko ekamp e
al., 2024). Howe e , hese measu es in combina ion wi h obus secu i y p o ocols can
inc ease he echnical and inancial bu dens (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019), con-
ibu ing u he o he discou aging e ec . In combina ion wi h equi emen s om
exis ing da a p i acy egula ions, such as he GDPR (Eu opean Pa liamen and Coun-
cil, 2016), ealising e icien and accessible in o ma ion, especially ac oss ins i u ional
bounda ies, is o en challenged by pa ien da a p o ec ion equi emen s (Ko ekamp,
Süßmu h, e al., 2019).
Technical limi a ions. Technology is ad ancing apidly, bu o he cu en models,
some echnical limi a ions o heal hca e use cases we e epo ed. Cu en models ha e
pe o mance limi a ions ega ding hei limi ed s o age capaci y and p ocessing powe
(Gala i e al., 2020; Talaa e al., 2019). The mobile p ocesso capabili ies cons ain
he e icien use o complex applica ions (Gala i e al., 2020; Spa wasse e al., 2018).
Addi ionally, he ba e y li e was ound o be unsa is ac o y, limi ing con inuous usage
du ing p olonged p ocedu es (Gala i e al., 2020; Ma in e al., 2020; Spa wasse e
al., 2018). In addi ion, many mobile MR HMD applica ions ely hea ily on ne wo k
connec ions, so ha ne wo k s abili y and bandwid h issues can signi ican ly dis up
usage (Ma in e al., 2020).
The abo e limi a ions can be pa ly ci cum en ed by using MR HMDs ha a e no
s and-alone bu a e powe ed by a desk op compu e . Howe e , he e, he equi ed cable
connec ions and he mobili y loss we e deemed imp ac ical (Moosbu ne e al., 2019;
Spa wasse e al., 2018).
Use expe ience and in e ac ion. Using MR HMDs in a p o essional con ex also
means ha he sys em is used daily o mo e ex ended pe iods. This makes com o
an impo an ac o (K ichenbaue e al., 2014). While he i s Mic oso HoloLens
had a on -hea y design ha nega i ely impac ed he use pos u e du ing p olonged
use (Gala i e al., 2020), he newe model shi ed cen al componen s like he compu ing
uni and ba e y o he back o he headse , esul ing in a mo e balanced composi ion and
an enhanced wea ing com o e en du ing longe usage pe iods (Pose-Díez-de-la-Las a
e al., 2022).
As one o he mos c i ical capabili ies, he isualisa ion o 3D da a and objec s con-
ibu es essen ially o he o e all use expe ience. MR HMDs o en su e om a limi ed
24
1.5 Summa y o Con ibu ions and Essen ial Findings In oduc o y O e iew
isual ield ha is smalle han he na u al human ield o iew. This can lead o o ien-
a ion issues, especially i i ual da a o in o ma ion lies ou side he HMDs’ isual ield
(Moosbu ne e al., 2019; Pelleg ino e al., 2019). Al hough help ul o ce ain asks,
he i ual o e lays can also ha e a nega i e impac du ing su ge y, as he esponse o
un o eseen e en s migh be slowe (Kane sky e al., 2019).
Due o he e sa ile usage possibili ies, he con en design o MR HMDs aces some
challenges. The de ices a e used in he e ogeneous usage condi ions wi h di e en ligh ing
and eal-li e si ua ions (Ko ekamp e al., 2020). This means ha in o ma ion mus
be displayed in a manne ha ex and isual con en emain clea and legible ac oss
en i onmen s (Emme ich e al., 2017). This also leads o a mix o i ual and eal
en i onmen s (Klose e al., 2019) so ha possible dange s migh be o e seen (de Belen
& Bedna z, 2019; Klose e al., 2019).
As a esul o he a o emen ioned challenges, he usabili y o such de ices is simul a-
neously c i ical and challenging. Add essing issues such as com o and use in e ace
design is c ucial o b oade accep ance in heal hca e se ings (Be kemeie e al., 2017).
Issues named include he calib a ion p ocess o op ical se ings being cumbe some, espe-
cially in sha ed-use scena ios (Moosbu ne e al., 2019), and us a ing e o s in oice
and ges u e ecogni ion (Gala i e al., 2020; Moosbu ne e al., 2019). The la e is
especially p oblema ic o use cases in heal hca e and po en ially s e ile en i onmen s.
Use accep ance also depends on success ully in eg a ing he sys em in o he exis ing
wo k lows o medical p o essionals. While sys em design plays an impo an ole, o gan-
isa ional measu es a e also necessa y, o example, conside ing he expe ience and usage
con ex , adap ing exis ing wo k lows o c ea ing incen i es (Ghosh e al., 2017).
Adop ion and in eg a ion ba ie s. Va ious conce ns, including e iciency and he cos s
associa ed wi h implemen a ion and aining, con ibu e o poo adop ion o MR HMDs
(Ko ekamp e al., 2024; Zobel e al., 2016). Ano he poin is ha he e ec i e use o
MR HMDs demands a high le el o digi isa ion, such as he a ailabili y o 3D pa ien
da a and adequa e ne wo k in as uc u e. To ensu e hese p e equisi es, addi ional
in es men s in suppo ing echnologies, such as in a-o al scanne s, migh be necessa y
(Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Fu he , cu en so wa e solu ions o MR HMDs a e o en no
ce i ied o medical use o don’ ma ch he quali y o adi ional 2D ools, po en ially
limi ing hei e ec i eness (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
1.5.4 S uc u ed Sys em & In e ac ion F amewo k o De eloping Mixed
Reali y Head-Moun ed Displays
The ollowing sec ion will summa ise he equi emen s om di e en con ibu ions and
uni e hem in a s uc u ed sys em and in e ac ion amewo k, in ended o guide he
u he de elopmen and adop ion o MR HMDs in medical con ex s. Figu e 1.5 gi es
an o e iew o he six laye s ha we e induc i ely de ined by g ouping he indi idual
equi emen s in o meaning ul chunks. The laye s build on each o he , s a ing wi h
en i onmen al p e equisi es (Laye 1) and p og essing o mo e speci ic equi emen s,
25
1.6 Discussion In oduc o y O e iew
addi ion, Con ibu ion 4 supplemen s he knowledge base wi h p inciples o he design
o MR sys ems in mobile medical esea ch by p esen ing issues, me a- equi emen s and
design p inciples (Ko ekamp e al., 2021).
In his con ex , u u e esea ch should ocus on speci ying and e alua ing he design
ecommenda ions and design p inciples. Possible cul u al di e ences should also be
conside ed. One possibili y would be o es he p esen ed applica ion scena ios in
p ac ice, wi h a ocus on usabili y and use accep ance. In addi ion, i could be analysed
o wha ex en exis ing design ecommenda ions o iden i ied p oblems om ela ed
a eas, such as VR, can also be ans e ed o MR.
Ano he i al poin p o ides he implemen a ion concep om Con ibu ion 4 (Ko -
ekamp e al., 2021). By linking echnological, o ganisa ional and medical equi emen s
wi hin he a eas o heal hca e, in o ma ics and e gonomics, he concep suppo s he
demand o in e disciplina y design p ocesses. These indings con ibu e o and suppo
he concep s o human-cen ed design (Bødke & Kyng, 2018).
Fu he esea ch and es ing a e needed o explo e possible applica ions and he p ac-
ical sui abili y o MR o den al home isi s. In e disciplina i y and he indi idual
should be conside ed as decisi e ac o s.
Con ibu ion 5 success ully ans e s he VoFI me hod o he new con ex o den is y
(Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Combined wi h a cos axonomy and a bene i amewo k, i is
shown ha hese me hods can be success ully applied o he use case o IT in es men s
in he heal hca e sec o . Besides, he ca ego ised cos s and bene i s can be adap ed
easily o indi idual scena ios.
Mo eo e , a esea ch gap is iden i ied, pa icula ly wi h ega d o he cos s and possi-
ble disad an ages o using MR HMDs in he heal hca e sec o , which unde lines he need
o co esponding analyses in his a ea (Ko ekamp e al., 2024). Acco dingly, po en ial
economic disad an ages and cos s should be u he esea ched o enable he de elop-
men o mo e eliable cos ac o s and calcula ions. Case s udies conduc ed wi h den al
p ac ices can also be help ul in gene a ing eal-li e da a. In his con ex , u he adop ion
pa ame e s should be iden i ied and possible wo k lows analysed. Socio- echnical aspec s
also play an impo an ole, which should no be igno ed in u u e esea ch p ojec s.
The p esen ed con ibu ions ad ance he scien i ic knowledge base o business in o -
ma ics and heal h IT by u he de eloping me hodological app oaches, de i ing ele an
design guidelines, and in eg a ing economic and echnological conside a ions. Fu u e
esea ch should ocus on empi ically alida ing he p oposed models and u he in es-
iga ing he in eg a ion possibili ies o new digi al echnologies in o exis ing heal h IT
in as uc u es.
1.6.2 Implica ions o P ac ice
The p esen con ibu ions iden i ied se e al challenges ega ding heal h IT and he use
o MR HMD de ices. By add essing hese challenges, possible solu ions and implica ions
o manu ac u e s and decision-make s could be de i ed.
Con ibu ion 1 iden i ied se e al media dis up ions and ine icien p ocesses ha occu
speci ically when in o ma ion is sha ed ac oss di e en heal h sec o s, po en ially lead-
32
1.6 Discussion In oduc o y O e iew
ing o in o ma ion loss and ca e p oblems du ing in e -o ganisa ional ansi ions. This
indica es a need o in e ope able IT sys ems ha enable seamless da a ans e be ween
inpa ien and ou pa ien acili ies. In his se ing, IT sys ems ha allow o he sha -
ing and accessing o up- o-da e pa ien da a can suppo in e sec o al communica ion
and eamwo k, ee up ime esou ces, and elimina e possible sou ces o e o s. These
ad an ages can enhance he e iciency and e ec i eness o he wo ke ’s asks. Decision-
make s can use hese indings as a basis o hei indi idual equi emen s analysis be o e
in es ing in new so wa e ha can simpli y in e disciplina y communica ion and educe
manual adminis a i e e o . So wa e manu ac u e s may d aw on hese insigh s as
a basis o de eloping use -cen ed sys ems. He e, egula eedback loops can help o
con inuously adap he IT sys em o cu en equi emen s (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al.,
2019).
The ade classi ica ion and use case ca ego isa ion om Con ibu ion 2 p o ides de el-
ope s and decision-make s wi h an o e iew o he ades and a eas in which MR HMDs
a e al eady being used success ully (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019). Decision-make s
and de elope s may ind his in o ma ion help ul be o e in oducing new MR HMDs in o
ades o use cases. I allows hem o ocus i s on easily accessible ades and use cases,
whe e MR HMDs a e al eady in use. These scena ios allow hem o u ilise he a ailable
eal-li e da a as a basis o ho ough e alua ion and decision-making. Also associa ed
wi h a ela i ely low isk a e ade and use cases ha a e simila o hose whe e MR
HMDs a e al eady in use. The knowledge om ela ed use cases can be ans e ed o
he new use case (Ko ekamp, We ning, e al., 2019).
O e all, Con ibu ion 2 o e s ecommenda ions o de eloping new use cases, pa ic-
ula ly in indus ies whe e MR HMDs a e less es ablished, such as ag icul u e o wa e
managemen . Decision-make s can bene i om he syne gies and inc eased ma ke ac-
cep ance ha he ans e o use cases o new indus ies b ings (Ko ekamp, We ning,
e al., 2019).
Ano he challenge is suppo ing medical s a in a ious ac i i ies wi hin a s e ile
en i onmen . This includes e ie ing pa ien da a, documen ing medical ac i i ies pe -
o med, and p o iding isual suppo du ing ope a ions by displaying ana omical s uc-
u es. MR HMDs enable hands- ee access o his in o ma ion and unc ions (Ko ekamp
e al., 2020, 2021, 2024).
Con ibu ion 4 and 5 add ess issues ela ed o IT adop ion wi hin he den al sec o .
This in o ma ion can be used as a basis o adop ion and de elopmen s a egies. The
de ined applica ion scena ios o home isi s, he p ac ical implemen a ion concep using
he Mic oso HoloLens 2, and he o e iew o possible applica ions, wi h a ocus on
he den al su ge y sec o , enable s akeholde s o make in o med decisions ega ding IT
adop ion (Ko ekamp e al., 2021, 2024).
Addi ionally, he esul s o Con ibu ion 4 o e guidance o den is s. They help
decision-make s o ca ego ise which applica ion scena ios exis , which equi emen s a e
necessa y, which implemen a ion app oaches a e al eady a ailable and which p oblems
could po en ially a ise. Fo so wa e manu ac u e s, he esul s can be help ul by showing
possible applica ions ha new MR HMD sys ems should be able o co e and which
33
1.6 Discussion In oduc o y O e iew
indi idual equi emen s he espec i e speciali y places on he sys em (Ko ekamp e
al., 2021).
The de elopmen o e ec i ely usable digi al heal h applica ions is complex due o
he combina ion o a ious egula o y, unc ional and non- unc ional equi emen s in
conjunc ion wi h a b oad s akeholde base. The di e en na u e o MR HMDs in e ms
o in e ac ion and con en p esen a ion makes he de elopmen o in ui i e applica ions
in he medical ield pa icula ly challenging. Con ibu ion 3 and 4 add ess his issue,
wi h he o me ocusing on design ecommenda ions o MR HMD applica ions (Ko e-
kamp e al., 2020). The la e ocuses on he de ini ion o me a- equi emen s and design
p inciples o MR HMDs hemsel es (Ko ekamp e al., 2021).
The esul s can se e as a basis o so wa e and ha dwa e manu ac u e s. In e dis-
ciplina y use and he ea ly in ol emen o po en ial use g oups a e also emphasised.
Apa om ha , he indings can also help in e es ed decision-make s de ine equi e-
men s ailo ed o he indi idual si ua ion, he eby simpli ying he selec ion and success-
ul in eg a ion o new echnologies in o exis ing in as uc u e and p ocesses.
The e a e se e al adop ion ba ie s, especially when i comes o eme ging echnologies
wi hin he heal hca e sec o . Howe e , one o he key ques ions is whe he he in es men
is p o i able. To add ess his issue, Con ibu ion 5 p o ides a cos - axonomy and bene i
amewo k. Decision-make s can apply hese indings o hei own use case o be e
conside he po en ial impac s o new in es men s. The exempla y cos -bene i analysis
o he use o MR HMDs in a den al p ac ice shows ha MR HMDs ha e he po en ial
o be economically ad an ageous unde ce ain condi ions (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
Decision-make s can u ilise he Excel ool o adap he VoFI analysis o hei own needs,
allowing hem o base hei decision on ac s a he han eelings.
Mo eo e , he indings o Con ibu ion 5 sugges se e al ecommenda ions o decision-
make s be o e in es ing in MR HMDs, including ha he MR HMD sys ems need o
be ailo ed o hei indi idual needs and equi emen s, and ha he sys em needs o
be co ec ly in eg a ed in o exis ing p ocesses o be used e ec i ely (Ko ekamp e al.,
2021).
The con ibu ions demons a e ha digi al echnologies can enhance inpa ien and
ou pa ien ca e in a ious scena ios. Howe e , success depends on a use -cen ed design
o he de ice and applica ion, an indi idual assessmen o he si ua ion and economic
impac , as well as a close in eg a ion in exis ing wo k p ocesses.
1.6.3 Limi a ions
This disse a ion is subjec o se e al limi a ions. Rega ding me hodological and em-
pi ical aspec s, mos con ibu ions ely hea ily on indings om li e a u e, al hough
s akeholde s we e included whe e possible (Ko ekamp, Süßmu h, e al., 2019; Ko e-
kamp e al., 2020). Po en ial use s and heal hca e p o essionals should be included in
u he esea ch and de elopmen p ocesses. Besides, he de eloped a e ac s, such as he
design guidelines and me a- equi emen s, we e p esen ed h ough concep s. Al hough
hose we e based on he indings, a eal-li e e alua ion is s ill pending (Ko ekamp,
We ning, e al., 2019; Ko ekamp e al., 2021). Addi ionally, his disse a ion ocuses
34
In oduc o y O e iew
mainly on echnical success ac o s o he use o MR HMDs. Socio- echnological and
en i onmen al ac o s, such as pa ien and s a accep ance, as well as he in luence o
changing en i onmen s du ing e e yday use, should also be aken in o accoun .
Ano he ac o is he a ailable echnology. MR HMDs and applica ions a e o en
no ully de eloped and lack he necessa y ce i ica ions o use in he medical sec o
(Ko ekamp e al., 2024). The echnology and applica ions a e cons an ly being u he
de eloped, demanding a con inuous e alua ion.
Economic and egula o y limi a ions also play a ole due o esea ch gaps, especially
ega ding po en ial cos s o disad an ages o using MR HMD de ices in medical scena -
ios. O he ac o s in luencing echnology adop ion besides po en ial cos s and bene i s,
such as he legal amewo k, socio- echnological aspec s and echnological ma u i y, mus
also be conside ed (Ko ekamp e al., 2024).
1.7 Conclusion
This disse a ion aims o explo e he applica ion o MR HMDs in heal hca e se ings,
wi h a ocus on ch onic wound ca e and den is y. To answe he de ined esea ch
ques ions, he design science app oach was used o ga he ele an in o ma ion om
scien i ic li e a u e and ele an s akeholde s.
RQ1 is answe ed by iden i ying use cases o suppo ing hospi al discha ge manage-
men wo ke s, p o iding an o e iew o indus y sec o s MR HMDs a e cu en ly used
in, and de i ing po en ial applica ion scena ios o using MR HMDs in den al p ac-
ices. These indings illus a e how hese de ices can be applied in he business sec o ,
pa icula ly in heal hca e.
By de ining equi emen s o a so wa e sys em ha assis s hospi al discha ge manage-
men wo ke s, de i ing bes p ac ices o designing MR HMD in e aces and highligh ing
issues, me a- equi emen s and design p inciples o MR HMDs his disse a ion gi es in-
sigh in o answe s o he ques ion which equi emen s and design p inciples should be
conside ed o he use o MR HMDs in heal hca e, and, hus add esses RQ2.
The cos -e iciency o MR HMDs in heal hca e se ings is examined by p esen ing a
cos axonomy and bene i amewo k o he adop ion o MR HMDs in den al p ac ices
in combina ion wi h a sample cos -bene i assessmen , he eby answe ing RQ3.
These indings enhance he exis ing body o knowledge and o e aluable guidance
o esea che s and p ac i ione s alike aiming o de elop o implemen MR HMDs in
heal hca e se ings.
35
Bibliog aphy
A ms ong, R., W igh , T., de Ribaupie e, S., & Eagleson, R. (2016). Augmen ed eali y o
neu osu gical guidance: An objec i e compa ison o planning in e ace modali ies. In G.
Zheng, H. Liao, P. Jannin, P. Ca in, & S.-L. Lee (Eds.), Medical Imaging and Augmen ed
Reali y (pp. 233–243). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Azuma, R. T. (1997). A su ey o augmen ed eali y. P esence: Teleope a o s & Vi ual En i-
onmen s,6(4), 355–385.
Ba ella, A. K., Kamal, M., Kuhn , T., He ing, K., Halama, D., Pausch, N. C., & Le haus,
B. (2021). Mixed eali y in o al and maxillo acial su ge y: A symbiosis o i ual and
augmen ed eali y o a poin less echnological gadge ? In e na ional Jou nal o Compu -
e ized Den is y,24(1), 65–76. h p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.go /pubmed/34006064
Bende , D., & Sa ipi, K. (2013). HL7 FHIR: An agile and REST ul app oach o heal hca e in o -
ma ion exchange. P oceedings o he 26 h IEEE In e na ional Symposium on Compu e -
Based Medical Sys ems, 326–331. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/CBMS.2013.6627810
Be kemeie , L., We ning, S., Zobel, B., Icke o , I., & Thomas, O. (2017). De Kunde als Diens -
leis e : Akzep anz und Geb auchs auglichkei on Sma Glasses im Sel -Se ice. HMD
P axis de Wi scha sin o ma ik,54 (5), 781–794.
Bhambhani, R., Bha acha ya, J., & Sen, S. K. (2013). Digi iza ion and i s u u is ic app oach
in p os hodon ics. The Jou nal o Indian P os hodon ic Socie y,13(3), 165–174.
Bødke , S., & Kyng, M. (2018). Pa icipa o y design ha ma e s— acing he big issues. ACM
T ansac ions on Compu e -Human In e ac ion,25(1), 1–31. h ps://doi.o g/10.1145/
3152421
Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei . (2019). Gese z ü eine besse e Ve so gung du ch Digi al-
isie ung und Inno a ion (Digi ale-Ve so gung-Gese z – DVG) [Bundesgese zbla I p.
2562 (Accessed: 09.06.2025)]. h p://www.bgbl.de/xa e /bgbl/s a .xa ?s a bk=
Bundesanzeige _BGBl&jumpTo=bgbl119s2562.pd
Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei . (2020a). Gese z zum Schu z elek onische Pa ien enda en in
de Telema ikin as uk u (Pa ien enda en-Schu z-Gese z – PDSG) [Bundesgese zbla
I p. 2115 (Accessed: 09.06.2025)]. h ps://www.bgbl.de/xa e /bgbl/s a .xa ?s a bk=
Bundesanzeige _BGBl&jumpTo=bgbl120s2115.pd
Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei . (2020b). Ve o dnung übe das Ve ah en und die An o de un-
gen an die P ü ung de E s a ungs ähigkei digi ale Gesundhei sanwendungen in de
gese zlichen K anken e siche ung (Digi ale-Gesundhei sanwendungen-Ve o dnung – Di-
GAV) [Bundesgese zbla I p. 2466 (Accessed: 09.06.2025))]. h p://www.bgbl.de/xa e /
bgbl/s a .xa ?s a bk=Bundesanzeige _BGBl&jumpTo=bgbl120s0768.pd
Bundesminis e ium ü Gesundhei . (2023). Ve o dnung übe das Ve ah en und die An o de un-
gen an digi ale P legeanwendungen und de en Finanzie ung in de sozialen P lege e -
siche ung (Digi ale-P legeanwendungen-Ve o dnung – DiPAV) [Bundesgese zbla I p.
85 (Accessed: 09.06.2025)]. h p://www.bgbl.de/xa e /bgbl/s a .xa ?s a bk=
Bundesanzeige _BGBl&jumpTo=bgbl122s1568.pd
Bibliog aphy
Ca enzo, L., Ba a, F. L., Ing assia, P. L., Colombo, D., Cos a, A., & Della Co e, F. (2015). Dis-
as e medicine h ough Google Glass. Eu opean Jou nal o Eme gency Medicine,22(3),
222–225. h ps://doi.o g/10.1097/MEJ.0000000000000229
Cido a, M. A., Bank, P. J., & Lukosch, S. G. (2019). Design ecommenda ions o augmen ed
eali y games o objec i e assessmen o uppe ex emi y mo o dys unc ion. 2019 IEEE
Con e ence on Vi ual Reali y and 3D Use In e aces (VR), 1430–1438. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1109/VR.2019.8797729
Da is, F. D. (1989). Pe cei ed use ulness, pe cei ed ease o use, and use accep ance o in o ma-
ion echnology. MIS Qua e ly,13 (3), 319–340. h ps://doi.o g/10.2307/249008
De Amicis, R., Ce u i, A., F ancia, D., F izzie o, L., & Simões, B. (2018). Augmen ed eali y
o i ual use manual. In e na ional Jou nal on In e ac i e Design and Manu ac u ing
(IJIDeM),12(2), 689–697. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s12008-017-0451-7
de Belen, R. A., & Bedna z, T. (2019). Mixed eali y and in e ne o hings (MRIoT) in e ace
design guidelines o elde ly people. 2019 23 d In e na ional Con e ence in In o ma ion
Visualiza ion – Pa II, 82–85. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/IV-2.2019.00025
Deu sches Ne zwe k ü Quali ä sen wicklung in de P lege. (2015). Expe ens anda d P lege on
Menschen mi ch onischen Wunden.
Die Sp eche de Wissenscha lichen Kommission Wi scha sin o ma ik im Ve band de Hoch-
schulleh e ü Be iebswi scha (WKWI) und des Fachbe eichs Wi scha sin o ma-
ik de Gesellscha ü In o ma ik (GI-FB WI). (2008). WI-O ien ie ungslis en. Wi -
scha sin o ma ik,50(2), 155–163.
Dwi edi, Y. K., Ismagilo a, E., Hughes, D. L., Ca lson, J., Filie i, R., Jacobson, J., Jain, V., Ka -
jaluo o, H., Ke i, H., K ishen, A. S., Kuma , V., Rahman, M. M., Raman, R., Rauschn-
abel, P. A., Rowley, J., Salo, J., T an, G. A., & Wang, Y. (2021). Se ing he u u e
o digi al and social media ma ke ing esea ch: Pe spec i es and esea ch p oposi ions.
In e na ional Jou nal o In o ma ion Managemen ,59(July), 102168. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1016/j.ijin omg .2020.102168
Eck, U., & Winkle , A. (2018). Display-Technologien ü Augmen ed Reali y in de Medizin. De
Un allchi u g,121(4), 278–285. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00113-018-0463-1
Eh lich, J. R., Ojeda, L. V., Wicke , D., Day, S., Howson, A., Lakshmina ayanan, V., & Mo oi,
S. E. (2017). Head-moun ed display echnology o low- ision ehabili a ion and ision
enhancemen . Ame ican Jou nal o Oph halmology,176, 26–32. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/J.AJO.2016.12.021
Emme ich, F., Klemke, R., & Hummes, T. (2017). Design pa e ns o augmen ed eali y lea ning
games. In J. Dias, P. A. San os, & R. C. Vel kamp (Eds.), Games and Lea ning Alliance
(pp. 161–172). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Espejo-T ung, L. C., Elian, S. N., & De Ce quei a Luz, M. A. A. (2015). De elopmen and
applica ion o a new lea ning objec o eaching ope a i e den is y using augmen ed
eali y. Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,79(11), 1356–1362. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/j.0022-
0337.2015.79.11. b06033.x
Eu opean Pa liamen and Council. (2016). Regula ion (EU) 2016/679 o he Eu opean Pa -
liamen and o he Council o 27 Ap il 2016 on he p o ec ion o na u al pe sons wi h
ega d o he p ocessing o pe sonal da a and on he ee mo emen o such da a (Gene al
Da a P o ec ion Regula ion) [O icial Jou nal o he Eu opean Union L 119/1 (Accessed:
09.06.2025)]. h ps://eu -lex.eu opa.eu/eli/ eg/2016/679/oj
E ans, D., Bu ns, L., Mills, I., B yce, M., & Hanks, S. (2023). Rec ui men and e en ion in
den is y in he UK: A scoping e iew o explo e he challenges ac oss he UK, wi h a
pa icula in e es in u al and coas al a eas. B i ish Den al Jou nal 2023, 1–7. h ps:
//doi.o g/10.1038/s41415-022-5406-0
37
Bibliog aphy
Fishe , J. A. (2016). S ong concep s o designing non- e bal in e ac ions in mixed eali y na a-
i es. In F. Nack & A. S. Go don (Eds.), In e ac i e S o y elling (pp. 298–308). Sp inge
In e na ional Publishing.
Flick, U. (2009). An in oduc ion o quali a i e esea ch (4 h). SAGE Publica ions L d.
Gala i, R., Simone, M., Ba ile, G., De Luca, R., Ca anese, C., & G assi, G. (2020). Expe imen al
se up employed in he ope a ing oom based on i ual and mixed eali y: Analysis o
p os and cons in open abdomen su ge y. Jou nal o Heal hca e Enginee ing,2020(1),
8851964. h ps://doi.o g/10.1155/2020/8851964
Geddis-Regan, A. (2023). Den al ca e o people li ing wi h demen ia: Cu en challenges and
planning o he u u e. The UK pe spec i e. Communi y Den al Heal h,40 (2), 125–130.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1922/CDH_00279Geddis-Regan06
Ge man Academic Associa ion o Business Resea ch. (2024). VHB publica ion media a ing
2024. h ps:// hbonline.o g/en/se ice/ hb- a ing-2024/
Ghosh, S., Sh u hi, C. S., Bansal, H., & Se hia, A. (2017). Wha is use ’s pe cep ion o na u al-
ness? An explo a ion o na u al use expe ience. In R. Be nhaup , G. Dal i, A. Joshi,
D. K. Balk ishan, J. O’Neill, & M. Winckle (Eds.), Human-Compu e In e ac ion –
INTERACT 2017 (pp. 224–242). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Gisbe Mi alles, J., Hein ze, C., & Dini, L. (2020). Hausä z liche Delega ionskonzep e in No d-
hein-Wes alen E gebnisse de hausä z lichen Be agung zum Einsa z on EVA, VE-
RAH, VERAH Plus zu Delega ion de inie e Tä igkei en. Zei sch i ü E idenz, Fo -
bildung und Quali ä im Gesundhei swesen,156-157, 50–58. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.
ze q.2020.07.010
Gläse , J., & Laudel, G. (2010). Expe enin e iews und quali a i e Inhal sanalyse. Sp inge -Ve -
lag.
Goo, H. W., Pa k, S. J., & Yoo, S.-J. (2020). Ad anced medical use o h ee-dimensional imaging
in congeni al hea disease: Augmen ed eali y, mixed eali y, i ual eali y, and h ee-
dimensional p in ing. Ko ean Jou nal o Radiology,21(2), 133–145.
G ade, M., Flebbe, H., F anke, F. S., Egbe s, J.-H., Popeneciu, I. V., T ojan, L., Rücke , J.-C.,
Elsne , A., Kimmig, R., & Ghadimi, B. M. (2019). Ak uelle Möglichkei en und E idenz
obo e assis ie e Eing i e in de chi u gischen Onkologie. De Onkologe,25 (1), 14–27.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00761-019-0622-1
G ob, H. L. (1989). In es i ions echnung mi olls ändigen Finanzplänen (1s ed.). Vahlen, Mün-
chen.
Heis e , M. (1962). Ren abili ä sanalyse on In es i ionen (Vol. 17). VS Ve lag ü Sozialwis-
senscha en. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-663-02894-9
He ne , A., Ma ch, S. T., Pa k, J., & Ram, S. (2004). Design science in IS esea ch. MIS Qua -
e ly,28(1), 75–105.
HL7 In e na ional. (2024). FHIR Release 5 – The Fas Heal hca e In e ope abili y Resou ces
Speci ica ion [Accessed: 14 June 2025]. h ps://www.hl7.o g/ hi /
I shad, S., & Rambli, D. R. A. (2016). Design implica ions o quali y use eXpe ience in mobile
augmen ed eali y applica ions. In H. A. Sulaiman, M. A. O hman, M. F. I. O hman,
Y. A. Rahim, & N. C. Pee (Eds.), Ad anced Compu e and Communica ion Enginee ing
Technology (pp. 1283–1294). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Kane sky, J., Sa an, T., Zammi , D., Lin, S. J., & Gila dino, M. (2019). Making augmen ed and
i ual eali y wo k o he plas ic su geon. Annals o Plas ic Su ge y,82(4), 363–368.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1097/SAP.0000000000001594
Klinke , K., Wiesche, M., & K cma , H. (2020). Digi al ans o ma ion in heal h ca e: Augmen ed
eali y o hands- ee se ice inno a ion. In o ma ion Sys ems F on ie s,22(6), 1419–
1431.
38
Bibliog aphy
Klose, E. M., Mack, N. A., Hegenbe g, J., & Schmid , L. (2019). Tex p esen a ion o augmen ed
eali y applica ions in dual- ask si ua ions. 2019 IEEE Con e ence on Vi ual Reali y and
3D Use In e aces (VR), 636–644. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/VR.2019.8797992
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2020). Ges al ungsemp ehlungen ü Augmen ed-
Reali y-Applika ionen – Ein Anwendungsbeispiel im Gesundhei swesen. In P oceedings
o he 15 h In e na ional Con e ence on Wi scha sin o ma ik (WI 2020). h ps://doi.
o g/10.30844/wi_2020_ 4-ko ekamp
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2021). Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische Haus-
besuche du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu Minde ung des Ans eckungs isikos. HMD
P axis de Wi scha sin o ma ik,58, 754–764. h ps://link.sp inge .com/10.1365/
s40702-021-00733-z
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Kajü e Rod igues, P., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2024). Cos -bene i anal-
ysis o using mixed eali y in den is y—keeping he den is in he pic u e. ECIS 2024
P oceedings. h ps://aisel.aisne .o g/ecis2024/ ack18_heal hi / ack18_heal hi /8
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Süßmu h, M. C. I., Hildne , A., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2019). IT-
suppo ed hospi al discha ge managemen — indings o a mul i-me hod esea ch de-
sign. In INFORMATIK 2019: 50 Jah e Gesellscha ü In o ma ik – In o ma ik ü
Gesellscha (pp. 65–78). Gesellscha ü In o ma ik e.V. h ps://doi.o g/10.18420/
in 2019_09
Ko ekamp, S.-S., We ning, S., Icke o , I., & Thomas, O. (2019). The u u e o digi al wo k—use
cases o augmen ed eali y glasses. P oceedings o he 27 h Eu opean Con e ence on
In o ma ionSys ems (ECIS). h ps://aisel.aisne .o g/ecis2019_ p/165
K ichenbaue , M., Yamamo o, G., Take omi, T., Sando , C., & Ka o, H. (2014). Towa ds aug-
men ed eali y use in e aces in 3D media p oduc ion. 2014 IEEE In e na ional Sympo-
sium on Mixed and Augmen ed Reali y (ISMAR), 351. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/ISMAR.
2014.6948484
Lampe, A., Djalilo a, S., Glassman, P., & Phillips, V. (2023). Imp o ing o al heal h using ele-
den is y and i ual den al homes: Concep s and p og ess. Jou nal o he Cali o nia
Den al Associa ion,51(1). h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/19424396.2023.2256035
Li, Y., Ye, H., Wu, S., Zhao, X., Liu, Y., L , L., Zhang, P., Zhang, X., & Zhou, Y. (2022). Mixed
eali y and hap ic-based den al simula o o oo h p epa a ion: Resea ch, de elopmen ,
and p elimina y e alua ion. JMIR Se ious Games,10(1), e30653. h ps://doi.o g/10.
2196/30653
Made , A. (2016). P ak isches Wundmanagemen : pa ien eno ien ie handeln — kompe en
übe lei en. Schlü e sche.
Mah ous, A., Elg ea ly, A., Qian, F., & Schneide , G. B. (2021). A compa ison o p e-clinical
ins uc ional echnologies: Na u al ee h, 3D models, 3D p in ing, and augmen ed eali y.
Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,85(11), 1795–1801. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/jdd.12736
Må ell-Olsson, E., & Jahnke, I. (2019). Wea able echnology in a den is y s udy p og am: Po-
en ial and challenges o sma glasses o lea ning a he wo kplace. In Pe spec i es on
Wea able Enhanced Lea ning (WELL) (pp. 433–451). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-64301-4_20
Ma in, G., Koizia, L., Koone , A., Ca e key, J., Ross, C., Pu kayas ha, S., Si anan han, A.,
Tanna, A., P a , P., & Kin oss, J. (2020). Use o he HoloLens2 mixed eali y head-
se o p o ec ing heal h ca e wo ke s du ing he COVID-19 pandemic: P ospec i e,
obse a ional e alua ion. Jou nal o Medical In e ne Resea ch,22(8), e21486. h ps:
//doi.o g/10.2196/21486
May ing, P. (2014). Quali a i e con en analysis: Theo e ical ounda ion, basic p ocedu es and
so wa e solu ion.
39
Bibliog aphy
McDonald, S. (2005). S udying ac ions in con ex : A quali a i e shadowing me hod o o ga-
niza ional esea ch. Quali a i e Resea ch,5(4), 455–473. h ps://doi.o g/10.1177/
1468794105056923
Mewes, A., Hensen, B., Wacke , F., & Hansen, C. (2017). Touchless in e ac ion wi h so wa e
in in e en ional adiology and su ge y: A sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. In e na ional
Jou nal o Compu e Assis ed Radiology and Su ge y,12(2), 291–305. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1007/s11548-016-1480-6
Mille, M., & S ie , A. (2014). En lassungs- und Übe lei ungsmanagemen . Ak uelle U ologie,
45(05), 381–397. h ps://doi.o g/10.1055/s-0034-1383031
Mladeno ic, R. (2020). The usage o augmen ed eali y in den al educa ion. In Sp inge Se ies
on Cul u al Compu ing (pp. 139–157). Sp inge . h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-030-
42156-4_8
Moosbu ne , S., Remde, C., Tang, P., Queisne , M., Haep, N., P a schke, J., & Saue , I. M. (2019).
Real wo ld usabili y analysis o wo augmen ed eali y headse s in isce al su ge y. A -
i icial O gans,43(7), 694–698. h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/ao .13396
Mühlemann, S., Sand ini, G., Ioannidis, A., Jung, R. E., & Hämme le, C. H. (2019). The use
o digi al echnologies in den al p ac ices in Swi ze land: A c oss-sec ional su ey. Swiss
Den al Jou nal,129(9), 700–707.
Mum o d, E. (2006). The s o y o socio- echnical design: Re lec ions on i s successes, ailu es
and po en ial. In o ma ion Sys ems Jou nal,16(4), 317–342. h ps://doi.o g/h ps:
//doi.o g/10.1111/j.1365-2575.2006.00221.x
Niemölle , C., Zobel, B., Be kemeie , L., Me zge , D., We ning, S., Adelmeye , T., Icke o ,
I., & Thomas, O. (2017). Sind Sma Glasses die Zukun de Digi alisie ung on A -
bei sp ozessen? Explo a i e Falls udien zukün ige Einsa zszena ien in de Logis ik.
P oceedings de 13. In e na ionalen Tagung Wi scha sin o ma ik (WI 2017), 410–424.
h p://aisel.aisne .o g/cgi/ iewcon en .cgi?a icle=1059&con ex =wi2017
No man, D. (2013). The design o e e yday hings: Re ised and expanded edi ion. Basic Books.
Pan il, E.-M., Baue n eind, G., Be ge , K., Fei e , A., Goe z, M., Hampel-Kal ho , C., Kozon,
V., Neube , T., P o z, K., Schöning, D., e al. (2015). Expe ens anda d P lege on
Menschen mi ch onischen Wunden. Deu sches Ne zwe k ü Quali ä sen wicklung in de
P lege (DNQP)(H sg.) Expe ens anda d P lege on Menschen mi ch onischen Wunden.
Hochschule Osnab ück,26(29), 44–45.
Pelleg ino, G., Mangano, C., Mangano, R., Fe i, A., Ta aschi, V., & Ma che i, C. (2019).
Augmen ed eali y o den al implan ology: A pilo clinical epo o wo cases. BMC
O al Heal h,19(1), 158. h ps://doi.o g/10.1186/s12903-019-0853-y
Po e , M. E., & Gu h, C. (2012). Chancen ü das deu sche Gesundhei ssys em: Von Pa iku-
la in e essen zu meh Pa ien ennu zen. Sp inge .
Pose-Díez-de-la-Las a, A., Mo e a-Ma inez, R., Ga cía-Se illa, M., Ga cía-Ma o, D., Cal o-
Ha o, J. A., Media illa-San os, L., Pé ez-Mañanes, R., on Hax hausen, F., & Pascau,
J. (2022). HoloLens 1 s. HoloLens 2: Imp o emen s in he new model o o hopedic
oncological in e en ions. Senso s,22(13). h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/s22134915
Sandnes, F. E., & Eika, E. (2017). Head-moun ed augmen ed eali y displays on he cheap: A DIY
app oach o ske ching and p o o yping low- ision assis i e echnologies. In M. An ona
& C. S ephanidis (Eds.), Uni e sal Access in Human-Compu e In e ac ion. Designing
No el In e ac ions (pp. 167–186). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
San os, C., Mi anda, B., A aujo, T., Ca nei o, N., Ma ques, A., Mo a, M., Mo ais, J., & Meiguins,
B. (2016). Guidelines o g aphical use in e ace design in mobile augmen ed eali y
applica ions. In S. Lackey & R. Shumake (Eds.), Vi ual, Augmen ed and Mixed Reali y
(pp. 71–80). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
40
Sassone, P. G., & Scha e , W. A. (1978). Cos -bene i analysis: A handbook (Vol. 182). Academic
P ess New Yo k.
Sa ides, S. (1994). Risk analysis in in es men app aisal. P ojec App aisal,9(1), 3–18.
Schmi , T. (2024). New go e nance o he digi al heal h agency: A way ou o he join decision
ap o implemen elec onic heal h eco ds in ge many? Heal h Economics, Policy and
Law,19(2), 269–288. h ps://doi.o g/10.1017/S1744133123000142
Song, T., Yang, C., Diana , O., & Azimi, E. (2018). Endodon ic guided ea men using aug-
men ed eali y on a head-moun ed display sys em. Heal hca e Technology Le e s,5(5),
201–207. h ps://doi.o g/10.1049/h l.2018.5062
Spa wasse , P., Schoeb, D., Mie nik, A., & Bo gmann, H. (2018). Augmen ed Reali y und Vi ual
Reali y im Ope a ionssaal – S a us Quo und Quo adis. Ak uelle U ologie,49(06), 500–
508. h ps://doi.o g/10.1055/a-0759-0029
S ocke , A., Spi ze , M., Kaise , C., Rosenbe ge , M., & Fellmann, M. (2017). Da enb illen-
ges ü z e Checklis en in de Fah zeugmon age. In o ma ik-Spek um,40(3), 255–263.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00287-016-0965-6
Talaa , S., Ghoneima, A., Kaboudan, A., Talaa , W., Ragy, N., & Bou auel, C. (2019). Th ee-
dimensional e alua ion o he holog aphic p ojec ion in digi al den al model supe im-
posi ion using HoloLens de ice. O hodon ics & C anio acial Resea ch,22(S1), 62–68.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/oc .12286
Teppe , O. M., Rudy, H. L., Le kowi z, A., Weime , K. A., Ma ks, S. M., S e n, C. S., Ga ein,
E. S., Chen, A. D., & Lin, S. J. (2017). Mixed eali y wi h HoloLens: Whe e i ual eali y
mee s augmen ed eali y in he ope a ing oom. Plas ic and Recons uc i e Su ge y,
140(5), 1066–1070. h ps://doi.o g/10.1097/PRS.0000000000003802
Uni ed Na ions. S a is ical Di ision. (2008). In e na ional s anda d indus ial classi ica ion o all
economic ac i i ies (ISIC) (4 h ed.). Uni ed Na ions Publica ions.
Venka esh, V., B own, S. A., & Bala, H. (2013). B idging he quali a i e-quan i a i e di ide:
Guidelines o conduc ing mixed me hods esea ch in in o ma ion sys ems. MIS Qua -
e ly,37(1), 21–54. h p://www.js o .o g/s able/43825936
Venka esh, V., Thong, J. Y. L., & Xu, X. (2012). Consume accep ance and use o in o ma-
ion echnology: Ex ending he uni ied heo y o accep ance and use o echnology. MIS
Qua e ly,36(1), 157–178. h p://www.js o .o g/s able/41410412
Vom B ocke, J., Simons, A., Rieme , K., Nieha es, B., Pla au , R., & Cle en, A. (2015). S and-
ing on he shoulde s o gian s: Challenges and ecommenda ions o li e a u e sea ch in
in o ma ion sys ems esea ch. Communica ions o he Associa ion o In o ma ion Sys-
ems,37(1), 9.
Webs e , J., & Wa son, R. T. (2002). Analyzing he pas o p epa e o he u u e: W i ing
a li e a u e e iew. MIS Qua e ly,26(2), xiii–xxiii. h ps://www.js o .o g/s able/
4132319
Wong, C., & Hogan, D. B. (2016). Ca e ansi ions: Using na a i es o assess con inui y o ca e
p o ided o olde pa ien s a e hospi al discha ge. Canadian Ge ia ics Jou nal,19(3),
97.
Yo pibulwong, T., A unja oensuk, S., & Pimkhaokham, A. (2022). Applica ion o augmen ed
eali y wi h na iga ion sys em and labo a o y guide a ec ed on he de ia ion o den al
implan —a pilo clinical s udy. P oceedings o RSU In e na ional Resea ch Con e ence
2022, 193–201. h ps://doi.o g/10.14458/RSU. es.2022.17
Zobel, B., Be kemeie , L., We ning, S., & Thomas, O. (2016). Augmen ed Reali y am A bei s-
pla z de Zukun : ein Usabili y-F amewo k ü Sma Glasses. In INFORMATIK 2016
(pp. 1727–1740). Gesellscha ü In o ma ik e.V.
In addi ion o he sys ema ic li e a u e sea ch, s a u o y equi emen s ega ding he discha ge
managemen as well as he expe s anda d discha ge managemen in heal hca e [Ex09]
we e analysed.
3 Analysis and Findings
3.1 Consolida ed equi emen s and use cases
Use cases a e qualiĄed o a clea p esen a ion o unc ional equi emen s. They p o ide a
ool o desc ibing he asks and goals o he in ol ed ac o s as well as he desi ed sys em
beha iou in di e en si ua ions. The esul can be used in o de o deba e he le el o
he sys em de elopmen in a g oup and o p esen he planning o an in e disciplina y
eam o s akeholde s [Co08]. We used he p inciples desc ibed in [Co08] o gain sho and
meaning ul use cases.
We iden iĄed a o al o 37 equi emen s based on he semis uc u ed in e iews, he
shadowing and he sys ema ic li e a u e sea ch. In o de o p o ide a clea and mo e help ul
o e iew, we g ouped he equi emen s wi h simila ai s and used his as a basis o he
de elopmen o he use cases. Ele en equi emen s a e alid o all in e ac ions wi h he
so wa e. They we e assigned o he h ee induc i ely o med ca ego ies: documen a ion
and inpu o pa ien da a,in e ope abili y and secu i y (c . Table 1).
Ca ego y Requi emen s
In e ope abili y Adap s he e minology depending on he use Šs p o ession c,[Hü15; MS14]
P o ides a use and igh s managemen c,[Ra16]
Is accessible by di e en use s a he same ime a,b,c,[Ra16]
Enables all au ho ised s a o access ele an pa ien da a a,c,[Hä17]
In eg a es seamlessly in all wo k p ocesses b,c,[Hü15]
Suppo s s anda dised p ocesses and esponsibili ies
c,[Hä17; HK13; MS14; PK11]
Documen a ion and
inpu o pa ien da a
Runs a eal- ime alidi y check du ing da a inpu b,c,[Ra16]
P o ides help unc ionali y o Ąlling ou p edeĄned o ms and epo s
b,c,[Ra16]
Is able o de ec e o s du ing da a inpu c,[MS14; Ra16; WH16]
Secu i y
Suppo s he e iĄca iono sen and ecei edelec onicdocumen s
b,c,[Ra16]
Suppo s high da a secu i y s anda ds a,c,[Ra16]
aIn e iews; bShadowing; cLi e a u e
Tab. 1: Supe o dina e equi emen s
The equi emen s in he ca ego y named In e ope abili y cons i u e he sys emŠs basis. Due
o he b oad ange o di e en elec onic hospi al in o ma ion sys ems, i is essen ial ha
he desc ibed sys em is compa ible wi h he exis ing one when i comes o e ms o da a
inpu and e ie al. In his way, all ele an ac o s can access and edi he pa ien Šs da a.
IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen 69
Di ec ly linked o he Ą s ca ego y, is he ca ego y Documen a ion and inpu o pa ien da a.
The sys em suppo s he inpu and modiĄca ion o da a. Po abili y ensu es ha da a can be
inpu whe e i is collec ed. The p omp inpu o da a diminishes he chance o incomple e
and ou da ed in o ma ion. To u he dec ease he chance o aul y da a, he IT sys em
should be able o check he en e ed in o ma ion o alidi y and inconsis encies. Also, da a
can be used o Ąll in, send and expo o mulas au oma ically. Manually exchanging da a
and edundan da a se s we e a common issue o he in e iewees. Fo example, he p ocess
o pa ien admission o pa ien discha ge a he hospi al in ol ed Ą e da a ansi ions om
digi al o non-digi al da a and ice e sa ega ding a pa ien Šs medica ion in o ma ion.
The las ca ego y Secu i y holds a pa icula posi ion in he managemen o heal h ca e da a.
I is no only necessa y o deny unau ho ised pe sons access o he da a bu also o e i y
he consigno .
Table 2 shows he emaining 26 equi emen s on he le and he de i ed use cases on he
igh . Each equi emen ega ding he discha ge managemen o a pa ien ha in ol es
in e ac ion wi h he so wa e is ep esen ed in one o ou een use cases. They a e numbe ed
consecu i ely o c oss- e e encing in he ex and Ągu e 1.
One c i ical ac o in hese use cases is ha use s can di ec ly en e new o missing pa ien
da a in he sys em (1). Due o low capaci ies a ollow-up ca e acili ies, he discha ge
managemen wo ke has o plan a pa ien Šs hospi al discha ge as soon as possible. The e o e,
he iden iĄca ion o ulne able pa ien s is essen ial (2). On he one hand, his ensu es ea ly
de ec ion o pa ien s equi ing discha ge managemen and on he o he hand, no esou ces
a e was ed on pa ien s no equi ing discha ge managemen . In doing so, an IT-suppo ed
sys ema ic assessmen should be implemen ed, and he epo ing o eligible pa ien s mus
be as easy as one click (3).
In o de o no miss impo an deadlines (e.g. o cos e unds) o gua an ee a seamless
ansi ion o he new ca e o ehab acili y, i is he ime componen ha ma e s. In no
case should he IT-sys em hinde he discha ge managemen wo ke bu ins ead suppo
and au oma ise asks. The e o e, he IT sys em helps by assigning epo ed pa ien s o he
esponding wo ke and p o iding help ul o e iews ega ding pa ien s, asks and deadlines
(4). Addi ionally, i p o ides an o e iew o possible ollow-up ca e acili ies and medical
aids (8, 9). Fu he suppo is gi en, by p o iding an easy and as way o documen he
whole p ocess as well as expo ing o mulas o applica ions and accoun ing (7, 10).
The discha ge managemen wo ke has di ec con ac o he pa ien in o de o access he
p e-hospi al li ing si ua ion as well as wishes ega ding pos -hospi al heal h ca e, e.g.
s a u o y o ambulan ca e and he a ou ed ca e p o ide (5, 6).
Also, he ac o s a e subjec o conside able cons ain s ega ding hei ime managemen .
Recei ing and sendingmessageswi hou heneed o wai o hei coun e pa sa es aluable
ime. Time is also a ac o when i comes o he elec onic exchange o pa ien in o ma ion
and da a (11-14). Being able o send da a igh om he IT sys em o ollow-up ca e acili ies
70 Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp e al.
Use Cases Requi emen s
1 Inpu pa ien da a in o
IT sys em
Suppo sinpu ands o ageo all necessa y pa ien da a
a,b,c,[Ra16]
2 Assess c i ical pa ien s
Suppo s a sys ema ic ulne abili y assessmen o new pa ien s
a
3 Repo c i ical pa ien s Suppo s a one-click epo o c i ical pa ien s a
Inhibi s edundan epo s o c i ical pa ien s a,b
4 Plan asks
Assigns epo ed pa ien s au oma ically o he speciĄed esponsi-
ble wo ke , e.g. based on he pa ien Šs wa d a
Gi es an o e iew o epo ed c i ical pa ien s incl. so ing
unc ions a,b,c,[B 13; Ra16] Suppo s ull calenda unc ionali y a
Shows asks in a calenda iew a
Shows an o e iew o all due asks b,c,[Ex09; Ra16]
Suppo s eminde s and p io i y se ings o scheduled e en s
a,b,c,[B 13; Hä15; HK13; Ra16]
Shows he esponsible discha ge managemen wo ke b,c,[Ra16]
5 Ob ain in o med
consen om pa ien
Allows he documen a ion o he in o med consen
c,[Hä15; Hä17; KS16; MS14]
6 Assess pa ien s needs
and wishes
Allows simple inpu o da a acqui ed du ing pa ien in e iews
on- he-go a,c,[Ex09; Ra16]
Mus be po able b
Allows o sea ch and access s uc u ed da a and applica ion
equi ed o he cos uni a,b,c,[Ra16]
7 Reques e und a cos
uni
Suppo s he documen a ion, accoun ing da a and appica ion
equi ed o he cos uni a,b,c,[Ra16]
8 Reques medical aids Shows in o ma ion ega ding u he ea men possibili ies a
9 Look o ee capaci ies
o ollow-up ca e
acili ies
P o ides an in e ac i e o e iew o possible ollow-up ca e
acili ies and home ca e a,b,c,[MS14; Ra16]
P o ides an o e iew unc ion showing ee capaci ies om
ollow-up ca e p o ide s a,b
10
D aw up and send
s a emen o accoun o
cos uni
Gene a es documen s such as ans e shee s om sa ed pa ien
da a a,b
11-
14 Communica ion wi h
ollow-up ca e
p o ide / acili y
Is linked o all necessa y s akeholde s such as anspo a ion a
Enables he exchange o da a and in o ma-
ion wi h all ele an ollow-up ca e gi e s
a,b,c,[B 15; Ex09; Hä12; HK13; Me17; MS14; Os15; Ro13]
Is able o exchange elec onic documen s wi h all ele an ollow-
up ca e gi e s a
Enables in e nal and ex e nal synch onous communica ion b
Enables asynch onous communica ion wi h s a iona y and ambu-
lan s akeholde s b,c,[Ra16]
P o ides eedback unc ion o all ele an s akeholde s
a,c,[Ex09]
aIn e iews; bShadowing; cLi e a u e
Tab. 2: Iden iĄed use cases and esponding equi emen s
IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen 71
leads o highe a ailabili y o pa ien da a wi hou he po en ial o losing da a and ime
which may esul om a manual ansmission. The emphasis lies he e on da a secu i y
s anda ds including he e iĄca ion o sen and ecei ed documen s. Pa ien da a is highly
sensi i e, and in Ge many, in o med consen o he pa ien is necessa y o he ac o s in
o de o be able o send hose da a.
3.2 Visualisa ion o he use cases h ough a p ocess model
The ŞBusiness P ocess Modeling No a ionŤ (bpmn) is sui ed o documen exis ing p ocesses,
in oduce new p ocesses and o isualise changes made by digi ising exis ing p ocesses
[FR14]. The no a ion is a he simple wi h s ic ly deĄned elemen s and ules ha can
be combined o pic u e complex p ocesses. In his case, he aim is o suppo an exis ing
p ocess by implemen ing an IT sys em. Figu e 1 shows he use cases s a ed abo e in bpmn.
The p ocess shows ou lanes, one o each p ima y ac o . The lanes a e clus e ed depending
on he supe o dina ed ins i u ion. He e, hese a e he hospi al on he one hand and he
ollow-up ca e acili y on he o he . Each lane accommoda es he asks ( ec angles) and
e en s (ci cles) ha e e o he esponding p ima y ac o . Th ee di e en lines link he
sepa a e elemen s. A solid line wi h a Ąlled a ow deĄnes he sequence o asks and e en s,
a dashed line wi h an emp y a ow indica es he Ćow o messages, and a do ed line wi h a
cu ed a ow links a e ac s. The a e ac s used in his bpmn-p ocess a e he da a s o age
and he da a objec . The Ą s exis s independen ly om he p ocess. Fo example, s o ed da a
is s ill a ailable a e he p ocess o discha ging a pa ien has ended. The la e ep esen s
in o ma ion ha only exis s du ing he un ime o he p ocess Şdischa ge managemen Ť
[FR14], i.e. da a is no longe a ailable a e wa ds.
The p ocess o a pa ien sŠ discha ge s a s wi h he admission o he pa ien o he hospi al.
When en e ing he cen al pa ien admission, he soon- o-be pa ien makes con ac Ą s wi h
he nu ses. They collec he pa ien Šs pe sonal in o ma ion and en e he da a in o he IT
sys em. Nex , hey conduc a s anda dised assessmen o he pa ien sŠ need o discha ge
managemen . The esul is en e ed in o he IT sys em. I he pa ien equi es discha ge
managemen , he discha ge managemen wo ke is in o med. I no , he p ocess ela ed o
discha ge managemen ends.
When a pa ien equi es discha ge managemen , he IT sys em no iĄes he discha ge
managemen wo ke . The nex s ep is he analysis o he equi ed p oceedings and asks.
The IT sys em suppo s he discha ge managemen wo ke wi h an o e iew o epo ed
pa ien s. I also helps wi h so ing ou daily asks. The discha ge managemen wo ke hen
isi s he pa ien in o de o gi e in o ma ion abou he upcoming p ocedu e and ask o
in o med consen . An assessmen ega ding he pa ien Šs needs and wishes is ca ied ou .
The wo ke di ec ly en e s all he acqui ed in o ma ion in he IT sys em, and hus makes
i a ailable o ollowing asks and au ho ised s a . Especially when ega ding pa ien s in
72 Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp e al.
Fig. 1: Use case dependencies (bpmn P ocess)
IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen 73
need o discha ge managemen , i is possible ha hey a e no able o make decisions on
hei own. In his case, he discha ge managemen wo ke consul s he pa ien Šs cus odian.
A e he necessa y s eps o a gapless discha ge a e so ed ou , he discha ge managemen
wo ke s a s o ganising he ollow-up ca e. The Ą s s ep is o Ąle applica ions o he
esponding cos uni s o he discussed i ems, such as Ąnancing nu sing ca e o medical aids.
I a e und is declined, he wo ke will discuss o he possibili ies o adequa e ollow-up
ca e wi h he pa ien o cus odian.
Two main asks when o ganising he ollow-up ca e a e o de ing needed medical aids and
Ąnding a acili y ha p o ides s a iona y o ambula o y ca e. I depends on he needs and
wishes o he pa ien , wha measu emen s a e aken. I he pa ien needs medical aids, he
espec i e o m can be Ąlled ou au oma ically wi h he a ailable pa ien in o ma ion om
he IT sys em. The o m can also be adjus ed manually and hen expo ed o di ec ly sen o
he p o ide .
Since communica ion wi h ollow-up ca e p o ide s is necessa y, he second ask is mo e
di icul . In o de o ci cum en manually calling a lis o ca e acili ies, he IT sys em shows
a lis wi h ee capaci ies o he discha ge managemen wo ke . The ca e acili ies p o ide
hei s a us in o ma ion a egula ime in e als. The esul s shown can be so ed o limi ed
o ma ch he needs o he cu en pa ien . I a ca e acili y is sui able, he IT sys em sends a
eques o he chosen acili y. I includes essen ial pa ien in o ma ion such as age, sex and
necessa y ca e. The ca e acili y can hen e alua e whe he hey can p o ide he needed ca e
o he pa ien . They answe back o he discha ge managemen wo ke ia email. In case o
a nega i e answe , he IT sys em sends a new eques o ano he sui able ca e acili y, is he
answe posi i e, he wa d o he pa ien is also no iĄed.
The nu ses a he wa d main ain con ac wi h he ollow-up ca e acili y and p o ide mo e
de ailed in o ma ion ha helps he ca e acili y o plan o he pa ien Šs a i al Ů hus
ensu ing gapless ca e a e discha ge. The nu ses a e also esponsible o communica ing
he ime and da e o he planned discha ge as well as changes o he plan.
A e he success ul ansi ion, he discha ge managemen wo ke is esponsible o d awing
up he s a emen o accoun and sending i o he cos uni . Since all execu ed s eps a e
documen ed in he IT sys em, he in o ma ion can be used o Ąll ou he p edeĄned o ms
au oma ically. The Ąnished o ms can be expo ed o sen di ec ly o he cos uni .
4 Discussion and Conclusion
In his pape he esea ch ques ion ŞWha use cases can he IT-sys em suppo o a hospi al
discha ge managemen and wha equi emen s o such a sys em exis ?Ť was examined.
Thehospi aldischa gemanagemen isanin e disciplina ymul i-use p ocess.Theimplemen-
a ion o an IT sys em can enhance he e iciency and e ec i i y o he accomplished asks
74 Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp e al.
and goals. The au ho s conduc ed mul i-me hod esea ch in o de o analyse equi emen s
o an IT sys em and de i e ele an use cases. Mos equi emen s could be iden iĄed solely
by analysing he in e iews and he shadowing p o ocol (32 o 37 equi emen s; 86.5%).
Only ele en o he equi emen s esul ed om bo h me hods. The li e a u e analysis, in
combina ion wi h he analysis o he s a u e and he expe s anda d Śdischa ge managemen
in heal hca eŠ, esul ed in 24 ou o 37 equi emen s (64,9%). Thus, by combining he
di e en me hods, a mo e holis ic iew o he opic could be o med.
Especially he Śexpe s anda d discha ge managemen Š in heal hca e yielded only a ew
equi emen s. The eason migh become e iden when ega ding i s aim. The expe s anda d
p o ides an ins umen o secu ing and de eloping quali y in heal h ca e, wi h a ocus
on he imp o emen o he coope a ion be ween inpa ien and ou pa ien ca e. I does no
cons i u e a se o ules o o ganisa ional p ocesses.
The s udy iden iĄed mainly unc ional equi emen s. Non- unc ional equi emen s we e
nei he named du ing he in e iews no ound when analysing he li e a u e. The only
excep ion is he equi emen Śpo abili yŠ which o igina es om he shadowing. Rega ding
he ou come o he li e a u e sea ch, he lack o non- unc ional equi emen s migh be due
o he na u e o he ound li e a u e. The publica ions ocus mainly on he inĆuence o new
s a u es ega ding discha ge managemen o on enhancing he p ocesses om he pa ien sŠ
poin o iew. Howe e , he de elopmen o implemen a ion o IT sys ems is missing.
Ne e heless, non- unc ional equi emen s such as usabili y, an in ui i e in e ace, eliabili y
andsuppo o lea ningmus be akenin oaccoun , whende elopingITsys ems.Fo una ely,
mos o hese equi emen s a e uni e sal and he e o e al eady desc ibed in he scien iĄc
li e a u e (c . [Ba11]) as well as in DIN s anda ds (c . [E 06]).
The discha ge o a hospi al pa ien is a highly in e disciplina y p ocess. Fo success,
communica ion and eamwo k a e key aspec s. The p ocess in ol es no only se e al wa ds
wi hin one ins i u ion bu can also equi e se e al independen ambula o y heal h ca e
p o essionals. Being able o sha e he da a a he han ha ing o ( e)collec , ( e)inpu and
( e)p in hem anew in e e y ins i u ion o wa d, would ha e wo main ad an ages. Fi s , i
would ee mo e ime esou ces ha a e e y ha d in need a he momen (also ega ding
he ongoing lack o skilled wo ke s). Second, i would assu e ha up- o-da e pa ien da a
is a ailable whe e i is needed and when i is needed. E o s ha may happen by manual
ansi ion can be diminished.
In addi ion o he p ac ical beneĄ s lis ed abo e, he de elopmen o such IT s uc u es
equi es in e disciplina y esea ch in o de o unde s and he ull ange o p oblems and
hei solu ions. Also, esea ch ega ding ac o s ha ensu e he pa icipa ion o heal h ca e
ins i u ions on he one hand and so wa e de elopmen en e p ises on he o he could be
help ul. The lack o so wa e in e aces and he associa ed in e ope abili y o he sys ems
migh be one limi e ega ding in e sec o al communica ion. The e o e, we deduced he
ollowing implica ions o u u e de elopmen and esea ch:
IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen 75
1.
The IT-sys ems should suppo in e sec o al coope a ion and mo i a e he educ ion
o hie a chical s uc u es.
2.
The sha ing o necessa y pa ien da a wi h heal h ca e p o essionals aking pa in he
pa ien Šs ca e should be simpliĄed.
3.
Fu he esea ch should be conduc ed wi h an in e disciplina y eam. The same e e s
o he de elopmen o so wa e sys ems.
The p esen ed esea ch is subjec o some limi a ions. On he one hand, he in e iews and
shadowing ely on one hospi al wi h adjoining ca e suppo poin in a u al a ea. On he
o he hand, al hough he au ho s in e iewed a ious p o essionals in he hospi al, only one
discha ge managemen wo ke was obse ed in he cou se o he shadowing. E en hough
he discha ge managemen wo ke occupies he cen al posi ion ega ding he analysed
p ocesses, he o he ac o s should be aken in o accoun as well.
In u u e esea ch, addi ional s akeholde s such as physicians and pha macis s should be
included. Table 3 p o ides an o e iew o he cu en esea ch agenda. Each s ep includes
a ee alua ion o he p e ious Ąndings. The aim is o p o ide a holis ic app oach o
IT-suppo ed discha ge managemen , comp ised o an in ui i e IT sys em ha suppo s he
in e disciplina y p ocesses o he discha ge managemen and guidelines o he ans e o
he IT sys ems o ollow up heal hca e ins i u ions.
Aim Me hods Findings
1 P o o yping
De elopmen o a p o-
o ype based on he e-
qui emen s
S o yboa ds
Click-P o o ypes
Fo ma i e Analysis
IT sys em in p o o-
ypic s age ha can be
used o ealwo ld es
2
Implemen a ion
and Valida ion
E alua ion o he p o-
o ype
Cogni i e Walk-
h ough
Usabili y S udy
Summa i e Analysis
Summa i ee alua ion
o he de eloped p o-
o ype
3 T ans e
Concep o ans e o
o he heal hca e ins i-
u ions
Cos -beneĄ analysis
Quan i a i e s udy
Guideline o gene al-
isa ion o IT sys em o
o he ins i u ions
Tab. 3: Resea ch agenda
The implica ions o p ac ice and esea ch highligh he impo ance o IT-sys ems ha can
suppo and mo i a e skilled wo ke s owa ds a mo e in e disciplina y and in e sec o al
app oach. The use cases and equi emen s p esen ed in his pape shall cons i u e a basis
and guidance when de eloping o imp o ing IT-sys ems o discha ge managemen bu
migh also p o ide use ul insigh s ega ding so wa e de elopmen o in e disciplina y
eams in gene al.
76 Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp e al.
Re e ences
[Ba11]
Balze , H.: Leh buch de So wa e echnik: En wu , Implemen ie ung, Ins alla-
ion und Be ieb. Spek um Akademische Ve lag, 2011.
[B 13]
B aun,J.:En lassmanagemen imK ankenhausdu chex e neLeis ungse b inge
Ű (Un-)Ve einba kei en mi de Wahl eihei des Pa ien en. Medizin ech 31/6,
pp. 350Ű353, 2013.
[B 15]
B aun, J.: Neue Koope a ionsmöglichkei en ü Apo heken beim En lassman-
agemen Ű zugleich eine Anme kung zu BGH, U eil om 13.3.2014 Ű I ZR
120/13 Ű, MedR 2015, 36 (in diesem He ). Medizin ech 33/1, pp. 22Ű25, 2015.
[Co08] Cockbu n, Alis ai : W i ing e ec i e use cases. Pea son Educa ion, Inc., 2008.
[De73]
Denzin, N.K.: The Resea ch Ac : A Theo e ical In oduc ion o Sociological
Me hods. T ansac ion Publishe s, 1973.
[DM12]
Deimel, D.; Mülle , M.
-
L.: En lassmanagemen : Ve ne z es Handeln du ch
Pa ien enkoo dina ion. Geo g Thieme Ve lag, 2012.
[E 06]
E gonomie de Mensch-Sys em-In e ak ion - Teil 110: G undsä ze de Di-
alogges al ung (ISO 9241-110:2006-08); Deu sches Ins i u ü No mung, 2006.
[Ex09]
Expe ens anda d En lassungsmanagemen in de PĆege. Deu sches Ne zwe k
ü Quali ä sen wicklung in de PĆege, 2009.
[FR14]
F eund, J.; Rücke , B.: P axishandbuch BPMN 2.0. Ca l Hanse Ve lag GmbH
Co. KG, 2014.
[Hä12]
Häse , I.: Beach ung on Apo heken ech bei En lassmanagemen -Konzep en
Ű Vo gaben du ch das GKV-Ve so gungss uk u gese z. Klinika z 41/06/07,
pp. 270Ű272, 2012.
[Hä15]
Häse , I.: Neu egelungen zum En lassmanagemen de K ankenhäuse Ű
Auswei ung de Regelungen du ch das Ve so gungss ä kungsgese z. Klinika z
44/12, pp. 584Ű585, 2015.
[Hä17]
Häse , I.: En lassmanagemen Ű DKG klag gegen Schiedssp uch. Klinika z
46/01/02, pp. 10Ű12, 2017.
[HK13]
Hesse, S.; Klewe , J.: An o de ungen an das pĆege ische En lassungsmanage-
men eines K ankenhauses de Regel e so gung aus de Sich nachso gende
Ein ich ungen. Heilbe u eScience 4/4, pp. 153Ű156, 2013.
[Hü15]
Hübne , U.; Schul e, G.; Sellemann, B.; Quade, M.; Ro mann, T.; Fenske, M.;
Egbe , N.; Kuhlisch, R.; Rienho , O.: E alua ing a P oo -o -Concep App oach
o he Ge man Heal h Telema ics In as uc u e in he Con ex o Discha ge
Managemen . MedIn o 216/-, pp. 492Ű496, 2015.
[Ja17]
Jacobs,K.;Kuhlmey,A.;G eß,S.;Klaube ,J.:PĆege-Repo 2017:Schwe punk :
Die Ve so gung de PĆegebedü igen. Scha aue Ve lag, 2017.
IT-suppo ed Hospi al Discha ge Managemen 77
[KS16]
Kuball,L.;Saile ,R.:Meh Kompe enzen ü K ankenhausä z eŰNeue ungenim
En lassmanagemen ü Ćexible Anschluss e so gung. La yngo-Rhino-O ologie
95/10, pp. 707Ű708, 2016.
[Ma14]
May ing,P.:Quali a i econ en analysis: heo e ical ounda ion,basicp ocedu es
and so wa e solu ion. Klagen u , 2014.
[Me17]
Meinha d-Schiebel, B.: Es b auch mode nes En lassungsmanagemen zu
um assenden Be euung und Beglei ung de Menschen im häuslichen Be eich.
PĆege 30/4, pp. 245Ű246, 2017.
[MS14]
Mille, M.; S ie , A.: En lassungs- und Übe lei ungsmanagemen . Ak uelle
U ologie 45/05, pp. 381Ű397, 2014.
[Os15]
Ossege, M.: Zum Ve häl nis zwischen dem Absp ache e bo nach ğ11 Abs. 1
S. 1 ApoG und dem En lassmanagemen nach ğ39 Abs. 1 S. 4 bis 6 SGB V.
Medizin ech 33/1, pp. 36Ű38, 2015.
[PG12]
Po e , M.E.; Gu h, C.: Chancen ü das deu sche Gesundhei ssys em. Sp inge
Ve lag, 2012.
[PK11]
Piepe , C.; Kolankowska, I.: Heal h ca e ansi ion in Ge many Ű S anda diza ion
o p ocedu es and imp o emen ac ions. Jou nal o Mul idisciplina y Heal hca e
4/-, pp. 215Ű221, 2011.
[Ra16]
Rahmen e ag übe ein En lassmanagemen beim Übe gang in die Ve so gung
nach K ankenhausbehandlung nach ğ 39 Abs. 1a S. 9 SGB V. GKV Spi zen e -
band, 2016.
[Ro13]
Romagnoli, K.M.; Handle , S.M.; Ligons, F.M.; Hochheise , H.: Home-ca e
nu sesŠ pe cep ions o unme in o ma ion needs and communica ion di icul ies
o olde pa ien s in he immedia e pos -hospi al discha ge pe iod. BMJ Quali y
& Sa e y 22/4, pp. 324Ű332, 2013.
[So05]
Somme ille, I.: In eg a ed equi emen s enginee ing: A u o ial. IEEE So wa e
22/1, pp. 16Ű23, 2005.
[WH16]
Wong, C.; Hogan, D.B.: Ca e T ansi ions: Using Na a i es o Assess Con inui y
o Ca e P o ided o Olde Pa ien s a e Hospi al Discha ge. Canadian Ge ia ics
Jou nal 19/3, pp. 97Ű102, 2016.
[WW02]
Webs e , J.; Wa son, R.T.: Analyzing he pas o p epa e o he u u e: W i ing
a Li e a u e Re iew. MIS qua e ly 26/2, pp. 13Ű23, 2002.
78 Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp e al.
Wa den, C. A., S anwo h, J. O., & Chang, C.-C. (2016). Le eling up: A e non-game s and
women disad an aged in a i ual wo ld class oom? Compu e s in Human Beha io ,65,
210–219. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/J.CHB.2016.07.033
Webs e , J., & Wa son, R. T. (2002). Analyzing he pas o p epa e o he u u e: W i ing
a li e a u e e iew. MIS Qua e ly,26(2), xiii–xxiii. h ps://www.js o .o g/s able/
4132319
We ning, S., Be kemeie , L., Zobel, B., Fi e, C., Icke o , I., & Thomas, O. (2019). Sma Glasses
als Assis enzsys em in de be ieblichen Eina bei ung. HMD P axis de Wi scha sin-
o ma ik,56(3), 612–627. h ps://doi.o g/10.1365/s40702-018-00478-2
Wilke son, J., McGee, R., Rei z, B., Bellido, R., Es ab idis, K., Hewe , G., & E b, R. (2018).
Au oma ed collision a oidance de eloped wi hin a mixed eali y sys em. In J. Chen (Ed.),
Ad ances in human ac o s in obo s and unmanned sys ems (pp. 323–334). Sp inge
In e na ional Publishing. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-60384-1_31
Wojciechowski, R. (2017). Ve sa ile augmen ed eali y scenes o angible in e ac ion in eal-wo ld
en i onmen s. In L. T. De Paolis, P. Bou do , & A. Mongelli (Eds.), Augmen ed eali y,
i ual eali y, and compu e g aphics (pp. 490–500). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-60928-7_41
Wu, L., Fan, A. (, & Ma ila, A. S. (2015). Wea able echnology in se ice deli e y p ocesses: The
gende -mode a ed echnology objec i ica ion e ec . In e na ional Jou nal o Hospi ali y
Managemen ,51, 1–7. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/J.IJHM.2015.08.010
Xiao, R., Schwa z, J., Th om, N., Wilson, A. D., & Benko, H. (2018). MRTouch: Adding ouch
inpu o head-moun ed mixed eali y. IEEE ansac ions on isualiza ion and compu e
g aphics,24(4), 1653–1660. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/TVCG.2018.2794222
Yu, J., Jeon, J., Pa k, J., Pa k, G., Kim, H.-i., & Woo, W. (2017). Geome y-awa e in e ac-
i e AR au ho ing using a sma phone in a wea able AR en i onmen . In N. S ei z &
P. Ma kopoulos (Eds.), Dis ibu ed, ambien and pe asi e in e ac ions (pp. 416–424).
Sp inge In e na ional Publishing. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-58697-7_31
Zahe , M., G eenwood, D., & Ma zouk, M. (2018). Mobile augmen ed eali y applica ions o
cons uc ion p ojec s. Cons uc ion Inno a ion,18, CI–02–2017–0013. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1108/CI-02-2017-0013
Zobel, B., Be kemeie , L., We ning, S., & Thomas, O. (2016). Augmen ed Reali y am A bei s-
pla z de Zukun : ein Usabili y-F amewo k ü Sma Glasses. In INFORMATIK 2016
(pp. 1727–1740). Gesellscha ü In o ma ik e.V.
Zobel, B., Be kemeie , L., We ning, S., Vogel, J., Icke o , I., & Thomas, O. (2018). Towa ds a
modula e e ence a chi ec u e o sma glasses-based sys ems in he logis ics domain
sma glasses o logis ics se ices unc ions. P oceedings o he 9 h In e na ional Wo k-
shop on En e p ise Modelling and In o ma ion Sys ems A chi ec u es (EMISA 2018),
76–80.
2.3 Con ibu ion 3: Design Recommenda ions o Augmen ed
Reali y Applica ions—A Case S udy in Heal hca e
Con ibu ion 3
Ti le Ges al ungsemp ehlungen ü Augemen ed-Reali y-Applika ionen – Ein Anwendungsbeispiel im
Gesundhei swesen
Au ho s Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp, Ingma Icke o , F ank Teu ebe g
Yea 2020
Medium Con e ence
Ou le 15 h In e na ional Con e ence on Wi scha sin o ma ik (WI 2020)
Ranking VHB-JOURQUAL 4: B
WKWI: A
Bibliog aphic
in o ma ion
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2020). Ges al ungsemp ehlungen ü
Augmen ed-Reali y-Applika ionen – Ein Anwendungsbeispiel im Gesundhei swesen. In P oceed-
ings o he 15 h In e na ional Con e ence on Wi scha sin o ma ik (WI 2020). h ps://doi.o g/
10.30844/wi_2020_ 4-ko ekamp
Iden i ica ion DOI: 10.30844/wi_2020_ 4-ko ekamp
Link h ps://doi.o g/10.30844/wi_2020_ 4-ko ekamp
Abs ac De Einsa z on Augmen ed-Reali y-Headse s e ö ne iel äl ige Anwendungsmöglichkei en und
könn e auch in de Wund e so gung zu Anwendung kommen. Das Zusammenspiel mi de
Nu zungsumgebung sowie die e wei e en Möglichkei en de In e ak ion e höhen die Komplex-
i ä de Pa ame e , die bei de Ges al ung geeigne e Applika ionen beach e we den müssen.
Dahe e olg diese Bei ag zwei Ziele. Als e s es we den Ges al ungsemp ehlungen ü
Augmen ed-Reali y-Applika ionen ü Headse s o mulie . Als zwei es we den die zu o o -
mulie en Ges al ungsemp ehlungen anhand eines Konzep s ü eine Nu ze obe läche zu Doku-
men a ion ch onische Wunden demons ie . Es wu de eine sys ema ische Li e a u eche che
du chge üh . Von den 629 ge undenen Publika ionen konn en 15 als ele an iden i izie
we den. Die Inhal e de Publika ionen wu den mi hil e eine quali a i en Inhal sanalyse nach
May ing (2015) analysie . Insgesam konn en zehn Ges al ungsemp ehlungen ü Augmen ed-
Reali y-Applika ionen gene ie und anhand des Anwendungs alls, de Dokumen a ion ch onis-
che Wunden, demons ie we den. Die p äsen ie en Ges al ungsemp ehlungen können als
Basis ü die En wicklung on Augmen ed-Reali y-Applika ionen insbesonde e mi dem Fokus
au Headse s genu z we den.
Re e ences
An oniou, P. E., Da li, E., A a as, G., & Bamidis, P. D. (2017). Ve sa ile mixed eali y medical
educa ional spaces; equi emen analysis om expe use s. Pe sonal and Ubiqui ous
Compu ing,21(6), 1015–1024. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00779-017-1074-5
A m ield, D. M., Hill Duin, A., & Pede sen, I. (2018). Expe iencing con en : Heu is ics o human-
cen e ed design o augmen ed eali y. IEEE In e na ional P o essional Communica ion
Con e ence,2018-July, 241–247. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/P oComm.2018.00057
Azuma, R. T. (1997). A su ey o augmen ed eali y. P esence: Teleope a o s & Vi ual En i-
onmen s,6(4), 355–385.
Cido a, M. A., Bank, P. J., & Lukosch, S. G. (2019). Design ecommenda ions o augmen ed
eali y games o objec i e assessmen o uppe ex emi y mo o dys unc ion. 2019 IEEE
Con e ence on Vi ual Reali y and 3D Use In e aces (VR), 1430–1438. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1109/VR.2019.8797729
De Amicis, R., Ce u i, A., F ancia, D., F izzie o, L., & Simões, B. (2018). Augmen ed eali y
o i ual use manual. In e na ional Jou nal on In e ac i e Design and Manu ac u ing
(IJIDeM),12(2), 689–697. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s12008-017-0451-7
de Belen, R. A., & Bedna z, T. (2019). Mixed eali y and in e ne o hings (MRIoT) in e ace
design guidelines o elde ly people. 2019 23 d In e na ional Con e ence in In o ma ion
Visualiza ion – Pa II, 82–85. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/IV-2.2019.00025
Deu sches Ins i u ü No mung (DIN). (2010). DIN EN ISO 9241-210:2010, E gonomie de
Mensch-Sys em-In e ak ion – Teil 210: P ozess zu Ges al ung geb auchs augliche in e -
ak i e Sys eme (ISO 9241-210:2010); Deu sche Fassung EN ISO 9241-210:2010 [No m].
Deu sches Ins i u ü No mung (DIN). (2018). DIN EN ISO 9241-11:2018, E gonomie de
Mensch-Sys em-In e ak ion – Teil 11: Geb auchs auglichkei : Beg i e und Konzep e
(ISO 9241-11:2018); Deu sche Fassung EN ISO 9241-11:2018 [No m].
Emme ich, F., Klemke, R., & Hummes, T. (2017). Design pa e ns o augmen ed eali y lea ning
games. In J. Dias, P. A. San os, & R. C. Vel kamp (Eds.), Games and Lea ning Alliance
(pp. 161–172). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Fe ke, P. (2006). S a e-o - he-A des S a e-o - he-A . Wi scha sin o ma ik,48(4), 257–266.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s11576-006-0057-3
Fishe , J. A. (2016). S ong concep s o designing non- e bal in e ac ions in mixed eali y na a-
i es. In F. Nack & A. S. Go don (Eds.), In e ac i e S o y elling (pp. 298–308). Sp inge
In e na ional Publishing.
Gabba d, J. L., Swan, J. E., & Mix, D. (2006). The e ec s o ex d awing s yles, backg ound
ex u es, and na u al ligh ing on ex legibili y in ou doo augmen ed eali y. P esence:
Teleope a o s and Vi ual En i onmen s,15(1), 16–32. h ps://doi.o g/10.1162/p es.
2006.15.1.16
Ghosh, S., Sh u hi, C. S., Bansal, H., & Se hia, A. (2017). Wha is use ’s pe cep ion o na u al-
ness? An explo a ion o na u al use expe ience. In R. Be nhaup , G. Dal i, A. Joshi,
D. K. Balk ishan, J. O’Neill, & M. Winckle (Eds.), Human-Compu e In e ac ion –
INTERACT 2017 (pp. 224–242). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
G ego , S., & He ne , A. R. (2013). Posi ioning and p esen ing design science esea ch o max-
imum impac . MIS Qua e ly,37 (2), 337–356. h ps://dl.acm.o g/ci a ion.c m?id=
2535660
I shad, S., & Rambli, D. R. A. (2016). Design implica ions o quali y use eXpe ience in mobile
augmen ed eali y applica ions. In H. A. Sulaiman, M. A. O hman, M. F. I. O hman,
Y. A. Rahim, & N. C. Pee (Eds.), Ad anced Compu e and Communica ion Enginee ing
Technology (pp. 1283–1294). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Janßen, M., & P illa, M. (2018). In eg a ion o augmen ed eali y in o p o essional ca e p ocesses.
Mensch und Compu e 2018 - Wo kshopband, (Sep embe 2018). h ps://doi.o g/10.
18420/muc2018-ws07-0467
Klinke , K., Wiesche, M., & K cma , H. (2019). De elopmen o a sma glass applica ion o
wound managemen . DESRIST, 157–171. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-030-19504-
5_11
Klinke , K., Wiesche, M., & K cma , H. (2020). Digi al ans o ma ion in heal h ca e: Augmen ed
eali y o hands- ee se ice inno a ion. In o ma ion Sys ems F on ie s,22(6), 1419–
1431.
Klose, E. M., Mack, N. A., Hegenbe g, J., & Schmid , L. (2019). Tex p esen a ion o augmen ed
eali y applica ions in dual- ask si ua ions. 2019 IEEE Con e ence on Vi ual Reali y and
3D Use In e aces (VR), 636–644. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/VR.2019.8797992
K ichenbaue , M., Yamamo o, G., Take omi, T., Sando , C., & Ka o, H. (2014). Towa ds aug-
men ed eali y use in e aces in 3D media p oduc ion. 2014 IEEE In e na ional Sympo-
sium on Mixed and Augmen ed Reali y (ISMAR), 351. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/ISMAR.
2014.6948484
Lam, K. Y., Hang Lee, L., B aud, T., & Hui, P. (2019). M2A: A amewo k o isualizing
in o ma ion om mobile web o mobile augmen ed eali y. 2019 IEEE In e na ional
Con e ence on Pe asi e Compu ing and Communica ions (Pe Com, 1–10. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1109/pe com.2019.8767388
Made , A. (2016). P ak isches Wundmanagemen : pa ien eno ien ie handeln — kompe en
übe lei en. Schlü e sche.
May ing, P. (2015). Quali a i e Inhal sanalyse G undlagen und Techniken. Bel z, J.
Mohe , D., Libe a i, A., Te zla , J., & Al man, D. G. (2009). P e e ed epo ing i ems o
sys ema ic e iews and me a-analyses: The PRISMA s a emen . PLoS Medicine,6(7),
e1000097. h ps://doi.o g/10.1371/jou nal.pmed.1000097
Nielsen, J. (1994). Heu is ic e alua ion. In Usabili y inspec ion me hods. John Wiley & Sons.
Pan il, E.-M., Baue n eind, G., Be ge , K., Fei e , A., Goe z, M., Hampel-Kal ho , C., Kozon,
V., Neube , T., P o z, K., Schöning, D., e al. (2015). Expe ens anda d P lege on
Menschen mi ch onischen Wunden. Deu sches Ne zwe k ü Quali ä sen wicklung in de
P lege (DNQP)(H sg.) Expe ens anda d P lege on Menschen mi ch onischen Wunden.
Hochschule Osnab ück,26(29), 44–45.
Pa k, Y. (2019). Typog aphy in mixed eali y. Mic oso Docs. Re ie ed No embe 18, 2019,
om h ps://gi hub.com/Mic oso Docs/mixed- eali y/blob/mas e /mixed- eali y-
docs/ ypog aphy.md
Paul, E. J. (2019). Com o . Mic oso Docs. Re ie ed No embe 18, 2019, om h ps://gi hub.
com/Mic oso Docs/mixed- eali y/blob/mas e /mixed- eali y-docs/ ypog aphy.md
Pi man, C., & LaViola, J. J. (2019). De e mining design equi emen s o AR physics educa ion
applica ions. 2019 IEEE Con e ence on Vi ual Reali y and 3D Use In e aces (VR),
1126–1127. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/VR.2019.8797908
San os, C., Mi anda, B., A aujo, T., Ca nei o, N., Ma ques, A., Mo a, M., Mo ais, J., & Meiguins,
B. (2016). Guidelines o g aphical use in e ace design in mobile augmen ed eali y
applica ions. In S. Lackey & R. Shumake (Eds.), Vi ual, Augmen ed and Mixed Reali y
(pp. 71–80). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
Shneide man, B., Plaisan , C., Cohen, M., Jacobs, S., & Elmq is , N. (2018). Designing he
use in e ace: S a egies o e ec i e human–compu e in e ac ion (6 h ed.). Pea son
Educa ion.
S ocke , A., Spi ze , M., Kaise , C., Rosenbe ge , M., & Fellmann, M. (2017). Da enb illen-
ges ü z e Checklis en in de Fah zeugmon age. In o ma ik-Spek um,40(3), 255–263.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s00287-016-0965-6
Webs e , J., & Wa son, R. T. (2002). Analyzing he pas o p epa e o he u u e: W i ing
a li e a u e e iew. MIS Qua e ly,26(2), xiii–xxiii. h ps://www.js o .o g/s able/
4132319
2.4 Con ibu ion 4: Technology-Suppo ed Den al Home Visi s
by Non-Medical Pe sonnel o Reduce In ec ion Risk
Con ibu ion 4
Ti le Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu Min-
de ung des Ans eckungs isikos
Au ho s Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp, Ingma Icke o , F ank Teu ebe g
Yea 2021
Medium Jou nal
Ou le HMD P axis de Wi scha sin o ma ik
Ranking VHB-JOURQUAL 4: C
WKWI: B
Bibliog aphic
in o ma ion
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2021). Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische
Hausbesuche du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu Minde ung des Ans eckungs isikos. HMD
P axis de Wi scha sin o ma ik,58, 754–764. h ps://link.sp inge .com/10.1365/s40702-021-
00733-z
Iden i ica ion DOI: 10.1365/s40702-021-00733-z
Link h ps://link.sp inge .com/a icle/10.1365/s40702-021-00733-z
Abs ac Ziel des Bei ags is die Iden i ika ion on P oblemen, Me a-An o de ungen und Designp inzipien
ü den Einsa z on Mixed und Vi ual Reali y B illen zu Un e s ü zung nich -ä z lichen Fach-
pe sonals bei zahnmedizinischen Hausbesuchen. Im Rahmen on zwei G uppendiskussionen und
einem Expe enin e iew wu den zunächs mögliche Einsa zszena ien iden i izie . Anschließend
wu de eine sys ema ische Li e a u eche che in den Da enbanken CINAHL, Business Sou ce P e-
mie und MEDLINE du chge üh . In de ge undenen Li e a u konn en 14 P obleme bei de
Anwendung on Mixed und Vi ual Reali y B illen iden i izie we den. Da au basie end wu den
14 Me a-An o de ungen abgelei e und in ün Designp inzipien zusammenge ass . Abschließend
wu den die E gebnisse mi den Spezi ika ionen de Mic oso HoloLens 2 abgeglichen, um eine
Eignung ü die Un e s ü zung de geplan en Hausbesuche es zus ellen. Zudem wu de ein Um-
se zungskonzep skizzie . Die E gebnisse dienen als wich ige Emp ehlungen ü die p axisnahe
Umse zung zukün ige Konzep e bezüglich de Anwendung on Mixed und Vi ual Reali y B illen
im (zahn-)medizinischen Kon ex . Die Li e a u eche che zeig eine Fo schungslücke im Be eich
zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche au . Die E gebnisse dieses Bei ags scha en dahe eine solide
Basis ü die zukün ige Fo schung.
SCHWERPUNKT
h ps://doi.o g/10.1365/s40702-021-00733-z
HMD
Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche du ch
nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu Minde ung des
Ans eckungs isikos
Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp · Ingma Icke o · F ank Teu ebe g
Eingegangen: 15. Janua 2021 / Angenommen: 19. Ap il 2021
© De /die Au o (en) 2021
Zusammen assung Ziel des Bei ags is die Iden i ika ion on P oblemen, Me a-
An o de ungen und Designp inzipien ü den Einsa z on Mixed und Vi ual Reali-
y B illen zu Un e s ü zung nich -ä z lichen Fachpe sonals bei zahnmedizinischen
Hausbesuchen. Im Rahmen on zwei G uppendiskussionen und einem Expe enin-
e iew wu den zunächs mögliche Einsa zszena ien iden i izie . Anschließend wu -
de eine sys ema ische Li e a u eche che in den Da enbanken CINAHL, Business
Sou ce P emie und MEDLINE du chge üh . In de ge undenen Li e a u konn en
14 P obleme bei de Anwendung on Mixed und Vi ual Reali y B illen iden i izie
we den. Da au basie end wu den 14 Me a-An o de ungen abgelei e und in ün
Designp inzipien zusammenge ass . Abschließend wu den die E gebnisse mi den
Spezi ika ionen de Mic oso HoloLens 2 abgeglichen, um eine Eignung ü die
Un e s ü zung de geplan en Hausbesuche es zus ellen. Zudem wu de ein Umse -
zungskonzep skizzie . Die E gebnisse dienen als wich ige Emp ehlungen ü die
p axisnahe Umse zung zukün ige Konzep e bezüglich de Anwendung on Mixed
und Vi ual Reali y B illen im (zahn-)medizinischen Kon ex . Die Li e a u eche -
che zeig eine Fo schungslücke im Be eich zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche au .
Die E gebnisse dieses Bei ags scha en dahe eine solide Basis ü die zukün ige
Fo schung.
Schlüsselwö e Designp inzipien · Mixed Reali y · Vi ual Reali y · Head-
Moun ed De ices · Zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche
S.-S. Ko ekamp () · I. Icke o
Ins i u ü Managemen und Kul u , Hochschule Osnab ück, Lingen, Niede sachsen, Deu schland
E-Mail: s[email p o ec ed]
S.-S.Ko ekamp·F.Teu ebe g
Fachgebie ü Un e nehmens echnung und Wi scha sin o ma ik, Uni e si ä Osnab ück,
Osnab ück, Niede sachsen, Deu schland
K
S.-S. Ko ekamp e al.
Technology-assis ed den al home isi s by nondoc o al p o essionals o
educe he isk o in ec ion
Abs ac The aim o his pape is o iden i y p oblems, me a- equi emen s and
design p inciples o he use o mixed and i ual eali y glasses o suppo nondoc-
o al p o essionals du ing den al home isi s. In he cou se o wo g oup discussions
and one expe in e iew, possible applica ion scena ios we e i s iden i ied. Sub-
sequen ly, a sys ema ic li e a u e sea ch was conduc ed in he da abases CINAHL,
Business Sou ce P emie and MEDLINE. The li e a u e e ealed 14 p oblems in he
applica ion o mixed o i ual eali y glasses. Based on his, 14 me a- equi emen s
we e de i ed and summa ised in i e design p inciples. Finally, he esul s we e
compa ed wi h he speci ica ions o he Mic oso HoloLens 2 o de e mine sui abil-
i y. An implemen a ion concep was also ou lined. The esul s se e as impo an
ecommenda ions o he p ac ical implemen a ion o u u e concep s ega ding he
applica ion o mixed and i ual eali y glasses in a (den al) medical con ex . The
li e a u e e iew e eals a esea ch gap in he ield o den al home isi s. The e o e,
he esul s o his pape p o ide a solid basis o u u e esea ch.
Keywo ds Design p inciples · Mixed eali y · Vi ual eali y · Head-moun ed
de ices · Den al home isi s
1 Einlei ung
Au g und de Co ona-Pandemie wu den in ielen Lände n Maßnahmen ge o en,
die eine Ausb ei ung on Co id-19 möglichs eindämmen sollen. Bes imm e Pe -
soneng uppen, wie äl e e Menschen mi ch onischen E k ankungen, sind du ch ein
e höh es In ek ions isiko und mögliche weise schwe e K ankhei s e läu e besonde s
be o en (Jo dan e al. 2020; Zhou e al. 2020).
De Besuch beim Zahna z s ell ü diese Pe soneng uppen du ch den engen
Kon ak zu ande en Pe sonen o z so g äl ige Hygienemaßnahmen ein e höh es
Ans eckungs isiko da . Ein Auslassen de Kon oll e mine ode das Igno ie en on
Beschwe den kann alle dings ebenso g a ie ende Folgen haben. So können In ek-
ionen im Mund aum du ch eine Ve schleppung on Keimen beispielsweise eine
Aspi a ionspneumonie auslösen (Baumga ne e al. 2015).
Hausbesuche könn en hie eine mögliche Al e na i e da s ellen, die eine zahn-
medizinische Ve so gung e möglich und dabei das Ans eckungs isiko ulne able
Pe sonen möglichs minimie . Die Du ch üh ung on zusä zlichen Hausbesuchen
s ell abe auch gleichzei ig eine höhe e Belas ung des zahnä z lichen Pe sonals da .
Im hausä z lichen Be eich exis ie en be ei s sei Länge em Fo bildungen ü
nich -ä z liche P axisassis enzen. Dies e möglich die Delega ion on ansons en ä z -
lichen Tä igkei en an nich -ä z liches medizinisches Pe sonal. Nich ä z liches Fach-
pe sonal kann so e schiedene Maßnahmen im Rahmen on Hausbesuchen selbs -
s ändig du ch üh en (Gisbe Mi alles e al. 2020). Dieses Angebo bes eh alle dings
noch nich ü zahnmedizinische P axen (BARMER In e ne edak ion 2020).
K
Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu ...
Auch in de Fo schung is dieses Thema kaum ep äsen ie . Eine explo a i e Li-
e a u eche che mi hil e on Google Schola e gab zwa iele E gebnisse zum Ein-
sa z on Mixed Reali y (MR) B illen zu Ausbildung ode Un e s ü zung wäh end
Ope a ionen im zahnmedizinischen Be eich. Wissenscha liche Bei äge zu Hausbe-
suchen du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal im Allgemeinen ode in Ve bindung mi
MR B illen konn en nich ge unden we den.
Das Ziel diese Fo schung is dahe die E p obung on Hausbesuchen du ch
nich -ä z liches zahnmedizinisches Pe sonal. Dabei soll beispielha die Mic oso
HoloLens 2 un e s ü zend eingese z we den. Die Fo schungs agen dieses Bei ags
lau en:
Welche Behandlungen können im Rahmen eines zahnmedizinischen Hausbesuchs
mi nich -ä z lichem Fachpe sonal und un e s ü z du ch MR B illen du chge üh
we den?
Welche An o de ungens ell dieses Nu zungsszena io an Ha dwa e und So wa e?
Inwie e n wi d die Mic oso HoloLens 2 diesen An o de ungen ge ech ?
Im nächs en Abschni wi d das me hodische Vo gehen besch ieben, be o die
E gebnisse im d i en Abschni in Fo m on Einsa zszena ien, Designp inzipien
und einem Umse zungskonzep da ges ell we den. Im le z en Abschni we den die
E gebnisse, die Limi a ionen des Bei ags sowie die p ak ische und heo e ische
Signi ikanz disku ie .
2 Me hode
Im Rahmen des Design Science Ansa zes (G ego and He ne 2013) wi d ein i e-
a i es Vo gehen an isie . En sp echend we den bes ehende E gebnisse o lau end
übe p ü und im Falle neu gewonnene E kenn nisse übe a bei e .
2.1 G uppendiskussion und Expe enin e iew
Zu Bean wo ung de e s en F age wu den zwei in e disziplinä e, o mal gelei e e
G uppendiskussionen du chge üh (Flick 2009). Un e den ün und ach Teilneh-
menden be anden sich ein Zahna z und Pe sonen aus den Be eichen de In o ma i-
ons- und Kommunika ions echnik, de Wi scha sin o ma ik sowie de E gonomie.
Die e s e G uppendiskussion dien e dem Finden mögliche Einsa zszena ien ü
nich -ä z liche zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche mi Un e s ü zung du ch die Mic o-
so HoloLens 2. Die da au olgende G uppendiskussion sowie ein halbs uk u ie es
Expe enin e iew mi einem p ak izie enden Zahna z dien en de Konk e isie ung
de sondie en Szena ien.
2.2 Sys ema ische Li e a u eche che
Um die zwei e F age zu bean wo en, wu de eine sys ema ische Li e a u eche -
che du chge üh ( om B ocke e al. 2015). Da ü wu den CINAHL und Business
Sou ce P emie als ele an e Da enbanken ü die Wi scha sin o ma ik ausgewähl .
K
S.-S. Ko ekamp e al.
Au g und des medizinischen Themas wu de MEDLINE in die Reche che einge-
schlossen. Eine Fokussie ung au MR in einem zahnmedizinischen Kon ex wa
in olge de ge ingen ele an en T e e nich möglich. Au g und de hema ischen
Ve wand scha wu de dahe auch Li e a u inkludie , die sich mi Vi ual Reali y
(VR) in einem gene ellen medizinischen Se ing beschä ig .
Fü die Suche wu den die Beg i e „Augmen ed Reali y“, „Mixed Reali y“ und
„Vi ual Reali y“ mi den Beg i en „den al*“, „den is *“, „medicine“, „ca e“ und
„ eleheal h“ kombinie . Die ge undenen Bei äge wu den sys ema isch au die Nen-
nung on P oblemen bei de Nu zung on Mixed ode Vi ual Reali y B illen un e -
such . Inklusionsk i e ien wa en die Nu zung eine solchen B ille du ch medizini-
sches Fachpe sonal. Aus- und Wei e bildungsszena ien wu den au g und zu un e -
schiedliche Pa ame e ausgeschlossen. Insgesam konn en zehn ele an e Bei äge
iden i izie we den.
Zu Bean wo ung de d i en F age wu den die iden i izie en Me a-An o de un-
gen und Designp inzipien mi den Eigenscha en de Mic oso HoloLens 2 e gli-
chen (s. Abschn. 3.3).
3 E gebnisse
3.1 Einsa zszena ien
Es konn en insgesam ün Einsa zszena ien ü die Anwendung on MR B illen
bes imm we den, die in Tab. 1, Spal e 1, da ges ell sind. In de zwei en Spal e
we den die Mindes an o de ungen an die Quali ika ion besch ieben und in Spal e 3
das Equipmen , das zusä zlich zu MR B ille e o de lich is . Im Folgenden we den
die Szena ien dezidie besch ieben.
Das e s e Szena io be ass sich mi de Video-Dokumen a ion des Mund aums
du ch med./p leg. Fachpe sonal mi hil e eine MR B ille. Ziel is es, diese Un-
e suchung o nehmen zu können, wenn med./p leg. Fachpe sonal au g und eines
Tab. 1 Mögliche Einsa zszena ien eine Mixed Reali y B ille wäh end eines zahnmedizinischen
Hausbesuchs
N Einsa zszena io Nu zende Equipmen
1 Video-Dokumen a ion des
Mund aums
Med./p leg. Fachpe sonal Zahnmedizinisches
G undbes eck
2 Regelmäßige Kon olle;
E assung eines zahnmedizini-
schen P oblems
Med./p leg. Fachpe sonal mi Wei-
e bildung, zahnmedizinisches
Fachpe sonal
Zahnmedizinisches
G undbes eck
3 Behebung on P o hesend uck-
s ellen
E ah ene zahnmedizinisches Fach-
pe sonal
Zahnmedizinisches
G undbes eck,
F äse
4 Repa a u eines abgeb ochenen
Zahns (P o hese)
Zahn echnike /in Indi iduelles zahn-
echnisches Equip-
men
5 P ophylaxe Zahnmedizinische P ophylaxehel-
e /in
Mobile Den alein-
hei
K
Technikges ü z e zahnmedizinische Hausbesuche du ch nich -ä z liches Fachpe sonal zu ...
ande en P oblems be ei s bei de zu behandelnden Pe son zu Hause is . Das zu-
s ändige zahnä z liche Fachpe sonal kann die Videoau nahme im Anschluss in de
P axis begu ach en und es s ellen, ob zahnmedizinische P obleme o liegen.
Med./p leg. Fachpe sonal mi Wei e bildung könn e, in einem gu eingespiel-
en in e disziplinä en Team zudem egelmäßige Kon ollen de Zähne selbs s ändig
du ch üh en ode au An age ein bes imm es zahnmedizinisches P oblem e assen
(Szena io 2). Die Du ch üh ung du ch med./p leg. Fachpe sonal ha auch hie wiede
den Vo eil, dass die Un e suchung mi ande en Tä igkei en kombinie we den kann.
Die MR B ille dien dann de Dokumen a ion und bei Beda auch de Absp ache
mi dem zus ändigen zahnä z lichen Fachpe sonal.
Im Rahmen des d i en Szena ios nimm e ah enes zahnmedizinisches Fachpe -
sonal Anpassungen am Si z de P o hese de zu behandelnden Pe son o , um so
D ucks ellen zu beheben. Zusä zlich zu MR B ille und einem zahnmedizinischen
G undbes eck wi d dazu eine F äse benö ig .
Szena io ie besch eib die Repa a u eines abgeb ochenen Zahns aus eine P o-
hese. Diese Maßnahme kann on eine /einem Zahn echnike /in du chge üh we -
den, wobei indi iduelles zahn echnisches Equipmen onnö en is .
Das le z e Szena io is die Du ch üh ung de P ophylaxe du ch eine/n zahnmed.
P ophylaxehel e /in. Im Gegensa z zu den ande en Szena ien is ü diese Tä igkei
eine mobile Den aleinhei e o de lich. Die MR B ille dien hie , zusä zlich zu Do-
kumen a ion und Rücksp ache mi dem zus ändigen zahnä z lichen Fachpe sonal,
auch de Kon olle des E gebnisses.
3.2 P obleme, Me a-An o de ungen und Designp inzipien
Aus den, in de Li e a u iden i izie en, P oblemen (P) wu den die Me a-An o de-
ungen (MA) en wickel . Die Designp inzipien (DP) basie en au diesen E kenn nis-
sen und assen die Me a-An o de ungen p axisnah zusammen. Die Designp inzipien
dienen de Eignungsp ü ung de Mic oso HoloLens 2. Die genann en P obleme be-
ziehen sich zum einen au die Eigenscha en de MR B illen selbs . Zum ande en
auch au die In e ak ion mi de Technik sowie die Einbindung in die bes ehende
In as uk u .
3.2.1 Techniklimi a ionen
Bezüglich de Ha dwa e wu de meh ach die ku ze Ba e ielau zei (P1)(Spa was-
se e al. 2018; Ma in e al. 2020; Gala i e al. 2020) bemängel . Dies is besonde s
beim Einsa z in de Chi u gie beme kba , da die de zei igen Modelle mi eine Ba -
e ielau zei on zwei bis d ei S unden nu wäh end kü ze e Eing i e die gesam e
Zei übe un e s ü zen können. Hinzu komm die beg enz e Speiche kapazi ä (Talaa
e al. 2019; Gala i e al. 2020) und Rechenkapazi ä de mobilen P ozesso en (P2)
(Spa wasse e al. 2018; Gala i e al. 2020). Die Spezi ika ionen des Ge ä s soll en
dahe au die geplan e Nu zung abges imm we den. Bei Beda soll e das Ge ä wäh-
end de Nu zung kom o abel geladen we den können ode einen aus auschba en
Akku besi zen (MA1). Bei s a ionä en Einsa zszena ien und einem geeigne en Ne z-
we k soll en essou cenin ensi e P ozesse in die Cloud ausgelage we den können
K
2.5 Con ibu ion 5: Cos -Bene i Analysis o Using Mixed
Reali y in Den is y—Keeping he Den is in he Pic u e
Con ibu ion 5
Ti le Cos -Bene i Analysis o Using Mixed Reali y in Den is y—Keeping he Den is in he Pic u e
Au ho s Sa ah-Sab ina Ko ekamp, Pa icia Kajü e Rod igues, Ingma Icke o , F ank Teu ebe g
Yea 2014
Medium Con e ence
Ou le Eu opean Con e ence on In o ma ion Sys ems (ECIS 2024)
Ranking VHB-JOURQUAL 4: A
WKWI: A
Bibliog aphic
in o ma ion
Ko ekamp, S.-S., Kajü e Rod igues, P., Icke o , I., & Teu ebe g, F. (2024). Cos -bene i
analysis o using mixed eali y in den is y—keeping he den is in he pic u e. ECIS 2024
P oceedings. h ps://aisel.aisne .o g/ecis2024/ ack18_heal hi / ack18_heal hi /8
Iden i ica ion ISBN: 978-1-958200-10-0
Link h ps://aisel.aisne .o g/ecis2024/ ack18_heal hi / ack18_heal hi /8
Abs ac Digi iza ion expands in o all labou ma ke a eas, including medicine and den is y. Mixed eali y
head-moun ed displays (MR HMDs) can be used in den al su ge ies o p ojec holog ams on o
pa ien s o allow expe s o join i ually. The applica ion could educe ea men e o s and
imp o e ea men ou comes. Despi e he ad an ages, den is s ha e ha dly used he echnology
so a , pa ly due o unclea insigh s in o cos e iciency. We iden i y cos s and bene i s o
in es ing in an MR HMD den is y con ex based on a sys ema ic li e a u e e iew o add ess
his issue. The indings a e used o de elop a cos -bene i amewo k and e alua ed using he
Visualisa ion o Financial Implica ions (VoFI) me hod o an exempla y scena io. This amewo k
is he i s o deal wi h a Cos -Bene i -Analysis o MR HMDs in den is y explici ly and p o ides
p ac ical alue as den is s can use i o es ima e he cos s and bene i s o adop ing MR HMDs.
Re e ences
Alauddin, M. S., Baha uddin, A. S., & Mohd Ghazali, M. I. (2021). The mode n and digi al
ans o ma ion o o al heal h ca e: A mini e iew. Heal hca e (Swi ze land),9, 1–15.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/heal hca e9020118
Al-Khaled, I., Al-Khaled, A., & Abu ayyem, H. (2021). Augmen ed eali y in den is y: Uses and
applica ions in he digi al e a. Edelweiss Publica ions Inc,5, 25–32. h ps://doi.o g/10.
33805/2576-8484.191
Ananda ajan, A., & Wen, H. J. (1999). E alua ion o in o ma ion echnology in es men . Man-
agemen Decision,37, 329–339. h ps://doi.o g/10.1108/00251749910269375
Ba ella, A. K., Kamal, M., Kuhn , T., He ing, K., Halama, D., Pausch, N. C., & Le haus,
B. (2021). Mixed eali y in o al and maxillo acial su ge y: A symbiosis o i ual and
augmen ed eali y o a poin less echnological gadge ? In e na ional Jou nal o Compu -
e ized Den is y,24(1), 65–76. h p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.go /pubmed/34006064
Bhambhani, R., Bha acha ya, J., & Sen, S. K. (2013). Digi iza ion and i s u u is ic app oach
in p os hodon ics. The Jou nal o Indian P os hodon ic Socie y,13(3), 165–174.
Espejo-T ung, L. C., Elian, S. N., & De Ce quei a Luz, M. A. A. (2015). De elopmen and
applica ion o a new lea ning objec o eaching ope a i e den is y using augmen ed
eali y. Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,79(11), 1356–1362. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/j.0022-
0337.2015.79.11. b06033.x
E ans, D., Bu ns, L., Mills, I., B yce, M., & Hanks, S. (2023). Rec ui men and e en ion in
den is y in he UK: A scoping e iew o explo e he challenges ac oss he UK, wi h a
pa icula in e es in u al and coas al a eas. B i ish Den al Jou nal 2023, 1–7. h ps:
//doi.o g/10.1038/s41415-022-5406-0
Geddis-Regan, A. (2023). Den al ca e o people li ing wi h demen ia: Cu en challenges and
planning o he u u e. The UK pe spec i e. Communi y Den al Heal h,40 (2), 125–130.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1922/CDH_00279Geddis-Regan06
Gö ze, U., No hco , D., & Schus e , P. (2015). In es men app aisal: Me hods and models
(2nd ed.). Sp inge . h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-662-45851-8
G ob, H. L. (1989). In es i ions echnung mi olls ändigen Finanzplänen (1s ed.). Vahlen, Mün-
chen.
Gsaxne , C., Eck, U., Schmals ieg, D., Na ab, N., & Egge , J. (2021). Augmen ed eali y in
o al and maxillo acial su ge y. In J. Egge & X. Chen (Eds.), Compu e -aided o al and
maxillo acial su ge y (pp. 107–139). Academic P ess. h ps://doi.o g/h ps://doi.o g/
10.1016/B978-0-12-823299-6.00005-5
Ha es, J., & Royle, D. (1994). Measu ing he alue o in o ma ion echnology. John Wiley &
Sons, Inc.
Heis e , M. (1962). Ren abili ä sanalyse on In es i ionen (Vol. 17). VS Ve lag ü Sozialwis-
senscha en. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-663-02894-9
I ani, Z., Ghoneim, A., & Lo e, P. E. (2006). E alua ing cos axonomies o in o ma ion sys ems
managemen . Eu opean Jou nal o Ope a ional Resea ch,173, 1103–1122. h ps://doi.
o g/10.1016/j.ejo .2005.07.007
Joda, T., Gallucci, G., Wismeije , D., & Zi zmann, N. (2019). Augmen ed and i ual eali y in
den al medicine: A sys ema ic e iew. Compu e s in Biology and Medicine,108, 93–100.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.compbiomed.2019.03.012
Jo ano ić, P. (1999). Applica ion o sensi i i y analysis in in es men p ojec e alua ion unde
unce ain y and isk. In e na ional Jou nal o P ojec Managemen ,17 (4), 217–222.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/S0263-7863(98)00035-0
Klinke , K., Wiesche, M., & K cma , H. (2020). Digi al ans o ma ion in heal h ca e: Augmen ed
eali y o hands- ee se ice inno a ion. In o ma ion Sys ems F on ie s,22(6), 1419–
1431.
Kodlipe , S., Amana, R. S., Sudhaka , A., & Mano a, M. (2023). A su ey on o al su geons o
gauge hei awa eness and adop ion o eme ging echnologies like 3D p in ing, compu e -
assis ed su ge y, and i ual eali y in planning and pe o ming su ge ies. In e na ional
Jou nal o O al Ca e and Resea ch,11(3). h ps://jou nals.lww.com/injo/ ull ex /
2023/11030/a_su ey_on_o al_su geons_ o_gauge_ hei _awa eness.4.aspx
Lampe, A., Djalilo a, S., Glassman, P., & Phillips, V. (2023). Imp o ing o al heal h using ele-
den is y and i ual den al homes: Concep s and p og ess. Jou nal o he Cali o nia
Den al Associa ion,51(1). h ps://doi.o g/10.1080/19424396.2023.2256035
Li, Y., Ye, H., Wu, S., Zhao, X., Liu, Y., L , L., Zhang, P., Zhang, X., & Zhou, Y. (2022). Mixed
eali y and hap ic-based den al simula o o oo h p epa a ion: Resea ch, de elopmen ,
and p elimina y e alua ion. JMIR Se ious Games,10(1), e30653. h ps://doi.o g/10.
2196/30653
Llena, C., Folgue a, S., Fo ne , L., & Rod íguez-Lozano, F. J. (2018). Implemen a ion o aug-
men ed eali y in ope a i e den is y lea ning. Eu opean Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,
22, e122–e130. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/jdd.12736
Lysenko, A., Razumo a, A., Ya emenko, A., I ano , V., S elko , S., & K i so , A. (2022). The
use o augmen ed eali y na iga ion echnology in combina ion wi h endoscopic su ge y
o he ea men o an odon ogenic cys o he uppe jaw: A echnical epo . Imaging
Science in Den is y,52, 225. h ps://doi.o g/10.5624/isd.20210256
Mah ous, A., Elg ea ly, A., Qian, F., & Schneide , G. B. (2021). A compa ison o p e-clinical
ins uc ional echnologies: Na u al ee h, 3D models, 3D p in ing, and augmen ed eali y.
Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,85(11), 1795–1801. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/jdd.12736
Må ell-Olsson, E., & Jahnke, I. (2019). Wea able echnology in a den is y s udy p og am: Po-
en ial and challenges o sma glasses o lea ning a he wo kplace. In Pe spec i es on
Wea able Enhanced Lea ning (WELL) (pp. 433–451). Sp inge In e na ional Publishing.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-64301-4_20
May ing, P. (2014). Quali a i e con en analysis: Theo e ical ounda ion, basic p ocedu es and
so wa e solu ion.
Meuls ee, J. W., Nijsink, J., Sch eu s, R., Ve hamme, L. M., Xi, T., Delye, H. H., Bo s lap,
W. A., & Maal, T. J. (2019). Towa d holog aphic-guided su ge y. Su gical Inno a ion,
26, 86–94. h ps://doi.o g/10.1177/1553350618799552
Mladeno ic, R. (2020). The usage o augmen ed eali y in den al educa ion [14]. Sp inge . h ps:
//doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-030-42156-4_8
Mladeno ic, R., Dako ic, D., Pe ei a, L., Ma ijenko, V., & Mladeno ic, K. (2020). E ec o aug-
men ed eali y simula ion on adminis a ion o local anaes hesia in paedia ic pa ien s.
Eu opean Jou nal o Den al Educa ion,24, 507–512. h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/eje.12529
Mühlemann, S., Sand ini, G., Ioannidis, A., Jung, R. E., & Hämme le, C. H. (2019). The use
o digi al echnologies in den al p ac ices in Swi ze land: A c oss-sec ional su ey. Swiss
Den al Jou nal,129(9), 700–707.
Mu ali, S., Paul, K. D., McGwin, G., & Ponce, B. A. (2021). Upda es o he cu en landscape
o augmen ed eali y in medicine. Cu eus,13. h ps://doi.o g/10.7759/cu eus.15054
Mu phy, K. E., & Simon, S. J. (2002). In angible bene i s alua ion in ERP p ojec s. In o ma ion
Sys ems Jou nal,12, 301–320. h ps://doi.o g/10.1046/j.1365-2575.2002.00131.x
O’B ien, L., Ma zano, M., & Whi e, R. M. (2013). ‘Pa icipa o y in e disciplina i y’: Towa ds
he in eg a ion o disciplina y di e si y wi h s akeholde engagemen o new models o
knowledge p oduc ion. Science and Public Policy,40(1), 51–61. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1093/scipol/scs120
Oes e eich, T., & Teu ebe g, F. (2017). E alua ing augmen ed eali y applica ions in cons uc-
ion – a cos -bene i assessmen amewo k based on VoFI. P oceedings o he 25 h Eu-
opean Con e ence on In o ma ion Sys ems (ECIS), Pape 23. h ps://aisel.aisne .o g/
ecis2017_ p/23
Oes e eich, T. D., & Teu ebe g, F. (2018a). Looking a he big pic u e o IS in es men app aisal
h ough he lens o sys ems heo y: A sys em dynamics app oach o unde s anding he
economic impac o bim. Compu e s in Indus y,99, 262–281. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/
j.compind.2018.03.029
Oes e eich, T. D., & Teu ebe g, F. (2018b). Why one big pic u e is wo h a housand num-
be s: Measu ing in angible bene i s o in es men s in augmen ed eali y based assis i e
echnology using u ili y e ec chains and sys em dynamics. In o ma ion Sys ems and
e-Business Managemen ,16, 407–441. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s10257-017-0367-6
Pelleg ino, G., Mangano, C., Mangano, R., Fe i, A., Ta aschi, V., & Ma che i, C. (2019).
Augmen ed eali y o den al implan ology: A pilo clinical epo o wo cases. BMC
O al Heal h,19(1), 158. h ps://doi.o g/10.1186/s12903-019-0853-y
Rauschnabel, P. A., Felix, R., Hinsch, C., Shahab, H., & Al , F. (2022). Wha is XR? Towa ds
a amewo k o augmen ed and i ual eali y. Compu e s in Human Beha io ,133,
107289. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.chb.2022.107289
Sassone, P. G., & Scha e , W. A. (1978). Cos -bene i analysis: A handbook (Vol. 182). Academic
P ess New Yo k.
Sa ides, S. (1994). Risk analysis in in es men app aisal. P ojec App aisal,9(1), 3–18.
Song, T., Yang, C., Diana , O., & Azimi, E. (2018). Endodon ic guided ea men using aug-
men ed eali y on a head-moun ed display sys em. Heal hca e Technology Le e s,5(5),
201–207. h ps://doi.o g/10.1049/h l.2018.5062
S ucki, J., Das gi , R., Bau , D. A., & Que eshy, F. A. (2024). The use o i ual eali y and
augmen ed eali y in o al and maxillo acial su ge y: A na a i e e iew. O al Su ge y,
O al Medicine, O al Pa hology and O al Radiology,137(1), 12–18. h ps://doi.o g/10.
1016/j.oooo.2023.07.001
Thoma, J., Ha lena, M., S alde , S., & Gool, L. V. (2017). [pos e ] Augmen ed eali y o
use - iendly in a-o al scanning. 2017 IEEE In e na ional Symposium on Mixed and
Augmen ed Reali y (ISMAR-Adjunc ), 97–102. h ps://doi.o g/10.1109/isma âĂŚadjunc .
2017.41
Ulb ich, M., Van den Bosch, V., Bönsch, A., G ube , L. J., Ooms, M., Melchio , C., Mo maen, I.,
Wilpe , C., Rashad, A., Kuhlen, T. W., Hölzle, F., & Puladi, B. (2023). Ad an ages o a
aining cou se o su gical planning in i ual eali y o o al and maxillo acial su ge y:
C osso e s udy. JMIR Se ious Games,11, e40541. h ps://doi.o g/10.2196/40541
Vom B ocke, J., Simons, A., Rieme , K., Nieha es, B., Pla au , R., & Cle en, A. (2015). S and-
ing on he shoulde s o gian s: Challenges and ecommenda ions o li e a u e sea ch in
in o ma ion sys ems esea ch. Communica ions o he Associa ion o In o ma ion Sys-
ems,37(1), 9.
om B ocke, J., & Lindne , M. A. (2004). Se ice po olio measu emen : A amewo k o e al-
ua ing he inancial consequences o ou - asking decisions. P oceedings o he 2nd In e -
na ional Con e ence on Se ice O ien ed Compu ing, 203–211. h ps://doi.o g/10.1145/
1035167.1035197
Webs e , J., & Wa son, R. T. (2002). Analyzing he pas o p epa e o he u u e: W i ing
a li e a u e e iew. MIS Qua e ly,26(2), xiii–xxiii. h ps://www.js o .o g/s able/
4132319
Yo pibulwong, T., A unja oensuk, S., & Pimkhaokham, A. (2022). Applica ion o augmen ed
eali y wi h na iga ion sys em and labo a o y guide a ec ed on he de ia ion o den al
implan —a pilo clinical s udy. P oceedings o RSU In e na ional Resea ch Con e ence
2022, 193–201. h ps://doi.o g/10.14458/RSU. es.2022.17