Full text
Desc ip ion o a species o he genus Pa ameso i on (Cauda a,
Salamand idae) om Guizhou, China, based on mo phological
and genomic e idence
Tao Luo1,2,3*, Jia-Jia Wang2*, Mei Liao2, Ming-Yuan Xiao4, Huai-Qing Deng4, Ning Xiao5,
Jiang Zhou2
1 School o Li e Sciences, Yunnan Uni e si y, Kunming, China
2 School o Ka s Science, Guizhou No mal Uni e si y, Guiyang, China
3 Sou hwes Uni ed G adua e School, Kunming, China
4 School o Li e Sciences, Guizhou No mal Uni e si y, Guiyang, China
5 Guiyang Heal hca e Voca ional Uni e si y, Guiyang, China
h ps://zoobank.o g/8D40ED2F-A2AB-463F-97D3-C97884C8BE1E
Co esponding au ho : Jiang Zhou ([email p o ec ed])
* These au ho s con ibu ed equally o his pape .
Academic edi o : Umilaela A i in ♦
Recei ed
11 Feb ua y 2025 ♦
Accep ed
4 Sep embe 2025 ♦
Published
1 Oc obe 2025
Abs ac
Species iden i ica ion and delimi a ion a e c i ical o biodi e si y conse a ion. Recen mi ochond ial-based phylogene ic s udies o he
genus Pa ameso i on, a g oup o small salamande s inhabi ing moun ain s eams in sou he n China and no he n Vie nam, sugges ha
i s di e si y may be unde es ima ed. In his s udy, we con i m and cha ac e ize a new species, Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis sp. no .,
using mo phological, mi ochond ial NADH dehyd ogenase subuni 2 (ND2), mi ogenome, and genomic e idence. This new species
can be dis inguished om o he Pa ameso i on species by cha ac e is ics such as ough and la ge body wa s, la ge eyes, he absence
o es igial gills and gill ilamen s in adul s, and dis inc i e ome ine ee h. S a is ical analysis o he mo phological da a u he showed
ha he new species is signi ican ly di e en om i s close ela i es. Phylogene ic econs uc ion based on conca ena ed and coalescen
app oaches, using bo h mi ochond ial DNA and nuclea single nucleo ide polymo phisms (SNPs) gene a ed by es ic ion si e-associa ed
DNA sequencing, e ealed ha he new species o ms a dis inc lineage wi hin he genus Pa ameso i on, exhibi ing a minimum gene ic
dis ance o 0.63% in mi ochond ial ND2 compa ed o congene s. The obse ed cy onuclea disco dance and mino mi ochond ial di e -
ences among species may s em om his o ical gene low and/o incomple e lineage so ing, and u u e s udies using genomic e idence
a e needed o in es iga e hei espec i e con ibu ions. Based on his disco e y, we ecommend ha independen e idence, especially ge-
nomic e idence, be in eg a ed in o he classi ica ion o closely ela ed species o a oid alling in o he ap o mi ochond ial in og ession.
Key Wo ds
Guizhou, mo phology, mi ochond ial in og ession, phylogenomics
In oduc ion
The Asian new s o he genus Pa ameso i on Chang,
1935 (Cauda a, Salamand idae) a e among he mos spe-
cies-di e se cauda e amphibians in China, second only o
he genus Tylo o i on (AmphibiaChina 2025). Cu en ly,
15 species ha e been eco ded, which a e di ided in o wo
species g oups: he P. caudopunc a us g oup, which in-
cludes P. caudopunc a us (Liu & Hu, 1973), P. longliensis
Li, Tian, Gu & Xiong, 2008, P. malipoensis Rao, Liu, Zhu
Zoosys . E ol. 101 (4) 2025, 1933–1947|DOI 10.3897/zse.101.149144
Copy igh Luo, T. e al. This is an open access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion License (CC BY 4.0), which pe mi s un es ic ed use, dis i-
bu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal au ho and sou ce a e c edi ed.
zse.penso .ne
Luo, T. e al.: Genus Pa ameso i on1934
& Ma, 2022, P. maolanensis Gu, Chen, Tian, Li & Ran,
2012, P. wulingensis Wang, Tian & Gu, 2013, and P. zhi-
jinensis Li, Tian & Gu, 2008, and he P. chinensis g oup,
which includes P. au an ius Yuan, Wu, Zhou & Che, 2016,
P. chinensis (G ay, 1859), P. delous ali (Bou e , 1934),
P. uzhongensis Wen, 1989, P. guangxiensis (Huang,
Tang & Tang, 1983), P. hongkongensis (Mye s & Le i-
on, 1962), P. labia us (Un e s ein, 1930), P. qixilingen-
sis Yan, Zhao, Jiang, Hou, He, Mu phy & Che, 2014, and
P. yunwuensis Wu, Jiang & Hanken, 2010 (Fei e al. 2006;
Fei and Ye 2016; Rao 2022). These species a e p ima ily
dis ibu ed in sou he n China and no he n Vie nam (Fei e
al. 2006; Fei and Ye 2016; AmphibiaChina 2025).
The mi ochond ial gene-based phylogeny iden i ied
wo o h ee c yp ic species wi hin he P. caudopunc a us
g oup (Luo e al. 2021; Luo e al. 2022). Luo e al. (2021)
iden i ied a Pa ameso i on popula ion in Da ang Coun y,
Guizhou P o ince, China, as a po en ial c yp ic species,
ini ially e e ed o as Pa ameso i on sp2 (DF) and la e
as P. longliensis (DF) (Luo e al. 2022). Howe e , his spe-
cies was no o mally desc ibed in ei he s udy. This c yp-
ic species exhibi s minimal mi ochond ial a ia ion (less
han 2%) compa ed o cu en ly ecognized species, ais-
ing ques ions ega ding i s alidi y. This ela i ely small
mi ochond ial a ia ion may be a ibu ed o his o ical mi-
ochond ial in og ession. Fo ins ance, mi ogenome in o-
g ession be ween Odo ana g ahami and O. junlianensis
in sou he n China led o minimal di e ences in mi ochon-
d ial cy och ome oxidase subuni I bu signi ican nuclea
gene di e gence (Yuan e al. 2022). This highligh s he
impo ance o geno yping-by-sequencing o ob ain hou-
sands o nuclea single nucleo ide polymo phisms (SNPs)
o accu a e species delimi a ion. Simila ly, whole-ge-
nome esequencing has been employed o gene a e la ge
SNP da ase s, esol ing he axonomy o closely ela ed
species and iden i ying c yp ic di e si y (Hu e al. 2020;
Yang e al. 2022; Gu e al. 2023). Thus, genome-le el SNP
da a p o ided c i ical insigh s o esol ing axonomic
unce ain ies among closely ela ed species, pa icula ly
hose a ec ed by mi ochond ial in og ession, and o e ed
obus suppo o species delimi a ion.
Al hough ou p e ious wo k using mi ochond ial
ND2 and combining phylogene ic and species delimi a-
ion me hods iden i ied he c yp ic species Pa ameso i-
on sp2 (DF) o P. longliensis (DF) (Luo e al. 2021; Luo
e al. 2022), he smalle mi ochond ial di e ences wi h
closely ela ed species make hei alidi y no s ongly
suppo ed. An addi ional p oblem is ha while whole-ge-
nome esequencing can yield a la ge numbe o SNPs, he
P. caudopunc a us g oup cu en ly has no close e e ence
genome ha can be used. The e o e, we pe o med e-
s ic ion si e-associa ed DNA sequencing (RADseq), a e-
duced- ep esen a ion genome sequencing echnique (Mill-
e e al. 2007; And ews e al. 2016) ha is e sa ile and
does no equi e a e e ence genome, on 46 samples, he e-
by ob aining a la ge amoun o SNP da a. In his s udy, ou
aim is o con i m he alidi y o his c yp ic species and
o mally desc ibe i in combina ion wi h mo phology.
Ma e ials and me hods
Sampling and mo phological analyses
Among he 46 samples collec ed, nine we e om P. cau-
dopunc a us, 10 om P. longliensis, wo om P. maolan-
ensis, 10 om P. zhijinensis, eigh om Pa ameso i on
sp2 (DF), and se en om he ou g oup (Fig. 1, Suppl.
ma e ial 1). Tissue samples and specimens o he e-
maining species we e collec ed be o e 2018, excep o
Pa ameso i on sp2 (DF), which was collec ed in July
2018. Muscle samples we e collec ed om he ail ip and
immedia ely p ese ed in 95% anhyd ous e hanol, and
specimens we e ixed using 75% alcohol imme sion and
s o ed indoo s in a e ige a o a −80 °C. The ield su -
ey ollowed he ules o he Wildli e P o ec ion Law o
he People’s Republic o China. All muscle samples and
specimens we e p ese ed in he Animal Ecology Lab-
o a o y, Guizhou No mal Uni e si y, Guiyang, Guizhou
P o ince, China. All animal expe imen s we e app o ed
by he Resea ch E hics Commi ee o Guizhou No mal
Uni e si y (app o al numbe : 202504001).
In his s udy, we measu ed 15 mo phological cha -
ac e s o 29 specimens using digi al calipe s accu a e
o 0.1 mm (Gu e al. 2012; Suppl. ma e ial 1), including
new species ( ou males and h ee emales), P. longliensis
(eigh males and nine emales), and P. zhijinensis ( i e e-
males). The measu ed cha ac e s we e as ollows: TOL =
o al leng h ( om ip o snou o ip o ail); SVL = snou –
en leng h ( om ip o snou o pos e io edge o en );
HL = head leng h ( om pos e io edge o le pa o oid o
snou ip); HW = head wid h (maximum head wid h); SL
= snou leng h ( om ip o snou o he an e io co ne o
eye); TKL = unk leng h (dis ance be ween axillae along
igh body side); IOD = in e o bi al dis ance (minimum
dis ance be ween he eyes); ED = eye diame e ( om he
an e io co ne o he pos e io co ne o he eye); TAL =
ail leng h ( om an e io ip o cloaca o ip o ail); TH =
ail heigh (maximum ail heigh ); TW = ail wid h (max-
imum ail wid h); FLL = o elimb leng h ( om he base
o he o elimb o he ip o he longes inge ); HLL =
hindlimb leng h ( om he base o he hindlimb o he ip
o he longes oe); DAG = dis ance be ween axilla and
g oin ( om he pos e io ma gin o he base o he o e-
limb o he an e io ma gin o he base o he hindlimb);
and SW = snou wid h (maximum snou wid h). P incipal
componen analysis (PCA) wi h eigen alues g ea e han
1, he maximum a iance me hod, and simple bi a ia e
sca e plo s we e used o explo e and cha ac e ize he
mo phome ic di e ences be ween he new species and
closely ela ed species. A canonical disc iminan analy-
sis (CDA) was employed o dis inguish be ween he new
species and closely ela ed species, as well as o p edic
g oup membe ship, ollowing me hods used in p e ious
s udies (Pa sons and Jones 2000; Polaszek e al. 2004;
Xiong e al. 2015; Shen e al. 2020). To educe he e ec
o allome y, each mo phome ic measu emen was co -
ec ed by di iding i by he TOL be o e conduc ing he
Zoosys . E ol. 101 (4) 2025, 1933–1947
zse.penso .ne
1935
PCA and CDA analyses. One-way analysis o a iance
(ANOVA) was conduc ed o de e mine he signi icance
o di e ences in mo phome ic cha ac e s be ween he
new species and he a o emen ioned closely ela ed spe-
cies. All s a is ical analyses we e pe o med using SPSS
.21.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA), wi h di e ences
conside ed s a is ically signi ican a p < 0.05. Mo pho-
logical compa isons o he new species wi h congene s
we e based on specimen examina ion and li e a u e.
Sex iden i ica ion was pe o med based on Fei e al.
(2006) and Fei and Ye (2016)—speci ically, males pos-
sess a la ge and low cloaca, wi h a ela i ely long longi-
udinal anal issu e and inge -like papillae on he cloacal
wall. In con as , emales ha e a small and high cloaca,
a sho o al-shaped anal issu e, and lack inge -like
papillae on he cloacal wall.
Labo a o y p o ocols, sequencing, and
bioin o ma ic me hods
The genomic DNA o 46 samples was ex ac ed om
95% e hanol-p ese ed issue using a s anda d CTAB
p o ocol (Hanania e al. 2004). Genomic DNA om each
sample was diges ed using he es ic ion enzyme EcoRI
(GAATTC) ollowing p e iously published p ocedu es.
DNA lib a ies o each sample we e cons uc ed acco d-
ing o he RAD p o ocol (Bai d e al. 2008). PCR p oduc s
we e pu i ied o eco e 350–550 bp DNA, and pai ed-
end sequencing was conduc ed on he MGISEQ-2000.
Raw eads we e deposi ed in he NCBI Sequence Read
A chi e da abase (h ps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.go /s a) un-
de he BioP ojec accession numbe PRJNA1016311.
Raw eads o samples we e il e ed using as p
.0.23.4 (Chen 2023) wi h de aul pa ame e s. Nex , we
pe o med u he quali y con ol on he cleaned eads
using STACKS .2.61 (Roche e e al. 2019). The p o-
cess_ ad ags module was used o clean he ags by dis-
ca ding low-quali y eads, emo ing eads wi h uncalled
bases, and escuing ba codes and ad ags. Addi ionally,
we used he clone_ il e module in STACKS o iden i-
y and emo e PCR duplica es om he RADseq da a.
Single nucleo ide polymo phism (SNP) calling o each
sample was pe o med using he deno o_map.pl sc ip in
STACKS. We used he us acks, cs acks, ss acks, s 2bam,
and popula ions modules om he STACKS pipeline o
comple e he de no o assembly o cleaned eads, gene a e
consensus sequences, and pe o m SNP calling o each
sample. To de e mine he op imal assembly pa ame e s,
we ollowed p e ious me hods o e alua e wo key pa-
ame e s (Pa is e al. 2017; Gundappa e al. 2022): (−M),
he maximum numbe o nucleo ide misma ches allowed
be ween s acks, and (−m), he minimum dep h o co e -
age equi ed o c ea e a s ack. Fo ou da ase , M anged
om 3 o 8 (in in e als o 1), while m anged om 4 o
14 ( alues: 4, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 14). Fo he pa ame e n
Figu e 1. Dis ibu ion and sampling o he P. caudopunc a us g oup and ou g oup Pachy i on inexpec a us in Guizhou, China.
zse.penso .ne
Luo, T. e al.: Genus Pa ameso i on1936
( he numbe o misma ches allowed be ween sample loci
when building he ca alog) in he cs acks module, we ol-
lowed he ecommenda ion o Pa is e al. (2017) and se
n = M. Based on he 80 ule (Pa is e al. 2017), he inal
op imal pa ame e combina ion was M = 6, m = 10, and n
= 6. In o al, he STACKS p og am iden i ied 15,581,665
biallelic SNPs ac oss 46 indi iduals.
In his s udy, we geno yped and il e ed he samples o
ob ain eliable SNPs using he ollowing p ocess: (1) ini ial
geno ype il e ing was pe o med based on geno ype miss-
ing a e and minimum allele equency using VCF ools
.0.1.16 (Danecek e al. 2011) wi h he ollowing unning
pa ame e s: ---ma 0.01 ---max-missing 0.5 ---min-alleles
2 -- ecode -- ecode-INFO-all –ou . (2) PLINK .1.90 (Pu -
cell e al. 2007) was hen used o il e ou samples wi h a
missing geno ype a e g ea e han 50%. (3) Missing gen-
o ypes we e impu ed using Beagle (B owning and B own-
ing 2016). (4) Finally, he SNPs gene a ed in he p e i-
ous s ep we e u he il e ed using he R package bigsnp
.1.9.11 (P i é e al. 2018) based on linkage disequilib i-
um-based SNP clumping. In his s udy, only one SNP pe
locus was e ained in he inal SNP da ase .
Phylogene ic econs uc ion and gene ic
di e en ia ion based on SNP da a
We used IQ-TREE .1.6.12 (Nguyen e al. 2015) o econ-
s uc phylogene ic ees based on maximum likelihood
o conca ena ed sequences om all loci o in e phylog-
enomic ela ionships. The analysis was pe o med wi h
he ollowing pa ame e s: −s −keep-iden −s DNA −n
−m GTR+ASC −bb 1000 −p e. Node suppo alues we e
assessed using he ul a as boo s ap app oxima ion (UF-
Boo ) me hod (Hoang e al. 2018). Species ee in e ence
was pe o med using SVDqua e s (Chi man and Kuba -
ko 2014) implemen ed in PAUP* 4.0a (Wilgenbusch and
Swo o d 2003). SVDqua e s es ima es ela ionships be-
ween axa unde he coalescen model by in e ing spli s
among qua e s o andomly sampled axa. All possible
axon qua e s we e e alua ed, and node suppo was es-
ima ed using 100 s anda d boo s ap eplica es. In cases
whe e node suppo was low, he SVDqua e s analysis
helped iden i y po en ial incomple e lineage so ing o in-
og ession among species. Bo h analyses used 1,475,246
unlinked SNPs. The ixa ion index (Fs ) be ween he new
species and i s closely ela ed species was assessed using
VCF ools .0.1.16 (Danecek e al. 2011) o quan i y he
deg ee o gene ic a ia ion among di e en species.
Phylogene ic econs uc ion, gene ic dis ance,
and haplo ype ne wo k based on mi ochond ial
sequences
The 48 mi ochond ial ND2 sequences and 19 mi ochon-
d ial genomes used o phylogene ic econs uc ion we e
p ima ily sou ced om ou p e iously published da a
(Table 1) (Luo e al. 2021; Luo e al. 2022). Mul iple se-
quence alignmen was pe o med using MUSCLE (Edga
2004) wi hin MEGA .7.0 (Kuma e al. 2016), wi h de-
aul se ings. Based on he Bayesian in o ma ion c i e-
ion, we e alua ed he bes - i pa i ioning schemes and
co esponding nucleo ide subs i u ion models o ND2
and mi ochond ial genomes using Pa i ionFinde .2.1.1
(Lan ea e al. 2017). Phylogene ic ees we e cons uc ed
using bo h maximum likelihood (ML) and Bayesian in-
e ence (BI) me hods. ML analysis was un in IQ-TREE
.1.6.1 (Nguyen e al. 2015) wi h he bes model and
20,000 ul a as boo s ap (UBP) eplica es. The BI ee
was econs uc ed using M Bayes .3.2.1 (Ronquis e al.
2012). Two independen uns we e conduc ed in he BI
analysis, each o which was pe o med o 5 million gen-
e a ions and sampled e e y 1000 gene a ions. The i s
25% o he samples we e disca ded as a bu n-in. Nodes
we e conside ed well suppo ed when he Bayesian pos-
e io p obabili y (BPP) was g ea e han 0.95 and he ML
ul a as boo s ap alue (UBP) was g ea e han 95%.
Unco ec ed p-dis ances (1000 eplica es) based on he
ND2 gene we e calcula ed using MEGA .7.0 (Kuma e
al. 2016). Addi ionally, we econs uc ed he mi ochon-
d ial ND2 gene haplo ype ne wo k using PopART .1.7
(Leigh e al. 2015) based on he median-joining me hod
(Bandel e al. 1999).
Da a a ailabili y s a emen
The da ase s con aining he accession numbe s o he
P. caudopunc a us g oup gene a ed in his s udy a e
a ailable as supplemen al in o ma ion. O iginal sequence
eads o genome da a a e a ailable a he Na ional Cen-
e o Bio echnology In o ma ion (accession numbe s
SAMN37379588–SAMN37379633).
Resul s
Mo phological di e ences based on measu ed
da a
We measu ed 15 mo phological cha ac e s in 29 speci-
mens (Suppl. ma e ial 1) and pe o med PCA, CDA, and
ANOVA analyses o assess di e ences be ween P. wu-
mengshanensis sp. no . and closely ela ed species. Fo
males and emales, h ee and h ee p incipal componen s
we e ex ac ed, espec i ely. The i s wo componen s
accoun ed o 72.87% and 73.84% o he o al a ia-
ion (Suppl. ma e ial 2). In he PC1 e sus PC2 sca e -
plo , P. wumengshanensis sp. no ., P. longliensis, and
P. zhijinensis o med nea ly dis inc clus e s, wi h sligh
sepa a ion along he PC1 axis (Fig. 2A, B). Fo males,
ai s ha loaded on he PC1 axis included o al leng h,
snou – en leng h, head leng h, head wid h, eye diam-
e e , ail wid h, o elimb leng h, and dis ance be ween
axilla and g oin (Suppl. ma e ial 2). Fo emales, ai s
Zoosys . E ol. 101 (4) 2025, 1933–1947
zse.penso .ne
1937
ha loaded on he PC1 axis included o al leng h, snou –
en leng h, snou leng h, unk leng h, in e o bi al dis-
ance, ail leng h, o elimb leng h, hindlimb leng h, and
dis ance be ween axilla and g oin (Suppl. ma e ial 2).
The CDA based on he 15 mo phological ai s clea ly
classi ied all indi iduals in o speci ic axa, wi h CAN1
and CAN2 explaining 87.2% and 12.8% o he o al a i-
ance, espec i ely. Dis inc clus e s we e o med along
he CAN1 axis (Fig. 2C; Suppl. ma e ial 2).
Uni a ia e ANOVA e ealed signi ican mo phological
di e en ia ion be ween he new species and i s congene s
(Table 2). Among males, P. wumengshanensis sp. no .
and P. longliensis showed s a is ically signi ican di e -
ences (p < 0.05) in snou leng h, ail wid h, and snou
wid h (Table 2). In con as , P. wumengshanensis sp. no .
and P. zhijinensis exhibi ed signi ican mo phological di-
e gence ac oss nine measu ed ai s: o al leng h, unk
leng h, in e o bi al dis ance, ail leng h, ail heigh , ail
wid h, o elimb leng h, hindlimb leng h, and snou wid h
(p < 0.05). Among emales, P. wumengshanensis sp. no .
and P. longliensis showed signi ican di e en ia ion in
eigh mo phological cha ac e s (Table 2).
Table 1. Locali ies, ouche in o ma ion, and GenBank numbe s o all samples used. Fo he ouche numbe and locali y o he
mi ogenome, see Luo e al. (2022b).
ID Species Vouche numbe Locali y (* ype locali ies) ND2 Mi ogenome
1P. longliensis GZNU 20070421001 Longli, Guizhou, China* FJ169608 ON357921
2P. longliensis KIZ-GZH 081025 Longli, Guizhou, China* GU980576
3P. longliensis GZNU 20070421004 Longli, Guizhou, China* JF438975
4P. longliensis GZNU 20070421003 Longli, Guizhou, China* JF438974
5P. longliensis GZNU 20070421002 Longli, Guizhou, China* JF438973
6P. longliensis GZNU 2018061813 Huishui, Guizhou, China MW147285 ON357922
7P. longliensis GZNU 2018061814 Huishui, Guizhou, China MW147283 MW524141
8P. longliensis GZNU 20180618016 Huishui, Guizhou, China MW147286
9P. longliensis GZNU 20180618017 Huishui, Guizhou, China MW147284
10 P. maolanensis GZNU 2006030003 Libo, Guizhou, China* FJ169607 ON357924
11 P. maolanensis GZNU 2006030006 Libo, Guizhou, China* JF438972
12 P. maolanensis GZNU 2006030004 Libo, Guizhou, China* JF438993
13 P. maolanensis GZNU 2006030005 Libo, Guizhou, China* JF438994
14 P. wumengshanensis sp. no . GZNU 20180709024 Da ang, Guizhou, China* MT811029 MW524142
15 P. wumengshanensis sp. no . GZNU 2018070904 Da ang, Guizhou, China* MT811030 ON357926
16 P. wumengshanensis sp. no . GZNU 2018070905 Da ang, Guizhou, China* MT811031
17 P. wumengshanensis sp. no . GZNU 2018070903 Da ang, Guizhou, China* MT811028
18 P. zhijinensis GZNU 20070415002 Zhijin, Guizhou, China* JF438976 ON357925
19 P. zhijinensis GZNU 20070415003 Zhijin, Guizhou, China* JF438977
20 P. zhijinensis GZNU 20070415004 Zhijin, Guizhou, China* JF438978
21 P. zhijinensis GZNU 20070415001 Zhijin, Guizhou, China* FJ169609
22 P. zhijinensis KIZ-GZH 081026 Zhijin, Guizhou, China* GU980575
23 P. wulingensis GZNU 07072001 Jiangkou, Guizhou, China FJ938040 ON357928
24 P. wulingensis GZNU 2007071002 Jiangkou, Guizhou, China JF438987
25 P. wulingensis GZNU 2007071004 Jiangkou, Guizhou, China JF438989
26 P. wulingensis GZNU 08072603 Youyang, Chongqing, China* JF438991
27 P. wulingensis GZNU 08072602 Youyang, Chongqing, China* JF438990
28 P. wulingensis GZNU 2007071003 Youyang, Chongqing, China* JF438988
29 P. wulingensis GZNU 08072604 Youyang, Chongqing, China* JF438992
30 P. wulingensis KIZ 21898 Fanjingshan, Guizhou, China KJ650055
31 P. wulingensis KIZ 21899 Fanjingshan, Guizhou, China KJ650056
32 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 2007071001 Leishan, Guizhou, China* FJ169606 ON357930
33 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 200904251 Leishan, Guizhou, China* MW147288
34 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 200904252 Leishan, Guizhou, China* MW147287
35 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 2007072005 Leishan, Guizhou, China* JF438986
36 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 2009042501 Leishan, Guizhou, China* JF438983
37 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 20050727001 Leishan, Guizhou, China* JF438985
38 P. caudopunc a us GZNU 20050727002 Leishan, Guizhou, China* JF438984
39 P. delous ali Tissue ID: GZNU35 Hekou Coun y, Yunnan, China ON357931 ON357931
40 P. guangxiensis Tissue ID: GZNU36 Shiwandashan, Guangxi, China* ON357932 ON357932
41 P. yunwuensis GZNU20201018003 Xinyi Ci y, Guangdong, China* ON357933 ON357933
42 P. labia us GZNU20210531001 Jinxiu Coun y, Guangxi, China* ON357934 ON357934
43 P. uzhongensis GZNU20070520002 Zhongshan, Guangxi, China* ON357935 ON357935
44 P. hongkongensis Tissue ID: GZNU37 Hong Kong, China* ON357937 ON357937
45 P. qixilingensis Tissue ID: GZNU38 Yongxin Coun y, Jiangxi, China* ON357938 ON357938
46 P. au an ius GZNU20201018001 Jingning Coun y, Zhejiang, China* ON357939 ON357939
47 P. chinensis Tissue ID: GZNU39 Ningbo Ci y, Zhejiang, China* ON357940 ON357940
48 Pachy i on inexpec a us GZNU20180706001 Danzhai Coun y, Guizhou, China ON422325 ON422325
zse.penso .ne
Luo, T. e al.: Genus Pa ameso i on1938
Gene ic da a in o ma ion
In his s udy, he ull leng h o he mi ochond ial ND2 used
o phylogene ic econs uc ion was 1407 base pai s (bp),
o which 409 we e a iable and 277 we e pa simony-in o -
ma i e. The model selec ion analysis sugges ed a di ision
in o h ee pa i ions, i.e., he i s codon, he second codon,
and he hi d codon o ND2, co esponding o he mod-
els HKY+G, HKY+I, and HKY+I. Fo he mi ochond ial
genome o 15,467 bp, he ollowing e olu iona y mod-
els we e iden i ied as op imal o he co esponding gene
segmen s: TVM+I+G o 12S RNA and 16S RNA,
HKY+I+G o RNAs, GTR+G o p o ein-coding genes
(COX2, COX1, COX3, Cy b, ATP8, ND2, ND3, ND4,
ATP6, ND1, ND5, and ND4L), and HKY+G o ND6.
A o al o 46 samples gene a ed app oxima e-
ly 2948.5 Gb o aw da a and 1004 million pai ed-end
eads, wi h an a e age o 64.09 Gb o da a and 21.8 mil-
lion pai ed-end eads pe sample. A o al o 15,581,665
biallelic SNPs we e gene a ed om he STACKS-cleaned
eads. A e il e ing o low-quali y indi iduals using
PLINK, 1,475,250 SNPs emained.
Table 2. Mo phome ic s a is ics and esul s o analysis o a iance om P. wumengshanensis sp. no . (PW), P. longliensis (PL), and
P. zhijinensis (PZ). All uni s a e in mm. P- alues a e a 95% signi icance.
Measu emen s P. wumengshanensis sp. no . P. longliensis P. zhijinensis P- alue om ANOVA
Male (n = 4) Female (n = 3) Male (n = 8) Female (n = 9) Male (n = 5) Male Female
Range
(Mean ± SD)
Range
(Mean ± SD)
Range
(Mean ± SD)
Range
(Mean ± SD)
Range
(Mean ± SD)
PW s. PL PW s. PZ PW s. PL
TOL 95.5–123.6
(110.2 ± 13.6)
150.1–160.0
(155.8 ± 5.1)
97.2–143.6
(117.0 ± 15.5)
114.6–136.3
(126.2 ± 8.4)
128.1–142.4
(136.7 ± 5.4)
0.610 0.014 0.013
SVL 53.0–72.6
(63.4 ± 8.9)
82.3–87.8
(85.6 ± 2.9)
47.7–78.3
(60.7 ± 9.9)
65.4–91.8
(71.5 ± 8.3)
63.7–68.3
(66.3 ± 1.8)
0.610 1.000 0.052
HL 16.5–23.9
(20.8 ± 3.3)
23.5–25.2
(24.6 ± 0.9)
16.3–22.1
(19.4 ± 1.8)
18.5–43.1
(22.7 ± 7.7)
20.9–23.9
(22.3 ± 1.1)
0.308 0.806 0.052
HW 11.8–18.9
(16.0 ± 3.3)
18.3–19.2
(18.7 ± 0.5)
12.5–16.6
(13.9 ± 1.5)
13.2–37.5
(17.8 ± 7.6)
15.1–17.9
(17.1 ± 1.1)
0.308 0.902 0.052
SL 6.3–8.6
(7.1 ± 1.1)
7.1–8.3
(7.9 ± 0.7)
5.7–7.6
(6.2 ± 0.6)
5.8–7.3
(6.5 ± 0.5)
7.0–8.5
(7.6 ± 0.6)
0.042 0.327 0.033
TKL 37.5–52.5
(45.6 ± 6.5)
61.0–66.5
(63.6 ± 2.7)
36.2–57.9
(46.7 ± 6.7)
46.9–59.8
(51.6 ± 4.3)
52.2–56.8
(54.6 ± 1.7)
0.865 0.027 0.013
IOD 4.5–6.8
(5.8 ± 1.1)
6.6–7.7
(7.3 ± 0.6)
4.5–7.7
(6.5 ± 0.9)
3.6–5.3
(4.4 ± 0.6)
8.3–9.5
(8.7 ± 0.6)
0.308 0.014 0.013
ED 2.9–3.9
(3.4 ± 0.5)
3.6–4.8
(4.1 ± 0.6)
2.3–3.8
(2.9 ± 0.5)
2.9–4.5
(3.6 ± 0.5)
2.7–3.6
(2.9 ± 0.4)
0.126 0.050 0.116
TL 40.8–55.1
(48.6 ± 6.1)
66.6–74.4
(70.0 ± 4.0)
45.8–63.8
(55.8 ± 6.1)
48.3–60.2
(54.7 ± 4.4)
63.8–71.9
(69.0 ± 3.5)
0.089 0.014 0.012
TH 6.3–9.9
(7.6 ± 1.6)
6.6–11.2
(9.1 ± 2.3)
6.7–10.0
(8.1 ± 1.0)
7.6–11.2
(9.0 ± 1.4)
8.4–20.0
(12.5 ± 4.5)
0.234 0.027 0.926
TW 2.4–3.3
(2.9 ± 0.4)
3.5–5.8
(4.7 ± 1.1)
3.4–5.1
(4.3 ± 0.5)
3.5–4.4
(3.9 ± 0.3)
4.5–7.3
(5.8 ± 1.1)
0.007 0.014 0.309
FLL 13.9–24.5
(18.4 ± 5.1)
26.0–28.2
(27.2 ± 1.1)
17.5–23.0
(20.4 ± 1.8)
19.4–23.6
(20.8 ± 1.3)
22.7–31.5
(27.5 ± 3.2)
0.497 0.027 0.013
HLL 14.8–26.2
(21.1 ± 4.8)
26.2–31.0
(28.0 ± 2.6)
17.5–27.1
(21.1 ± 2.9)
21.5–24.9
(23.2 ± 1.3)
24.2–30.9
(27.4 ± 2.4)
0.734 0.027 0.013
DAG 23.1–35.4
(29.9 ± 5.2)
41.3–41.9
(41.6 ± 0.3)
23.2–38.2
(28.7 ± 4.9)
23.0–40.5
(31.6 ± 5.7)
30.1–35.2
(32.2 ± 2.1)
0.865 0.462 0.013
SW 4.4–4.7
(4.6 ± 0.2)
4.1–5.8
(4.9 ± 0.9)
4.4–7.3
(5.5 ± 0.8)
4.1–5.8
(4.8 ± 0.7)
5.5–6.1
(5.8 ± 0.2)
0.027 0.014 0.926
Figu e 2. Plo s o p incipal componen analysis (A, B) and canonical disc iminan analysis (C) sco es o P. wumengshanensis sp.
no ., P. longliensis, and P. zhijinensis based on mo phological cha ac e s. A. Male; B. Female; C. Male and emale.
Zoosys . E ol. 101 (4) 2025, 1933–1947
zse.penso .ne
1939
Phylogene ic econs uc ion, gene ic dis ance,
and haplo ype
Phylogene ic econs uc ion based on he mi ochond ial
ND2 gene and mi ogenome e ealed ha Pa ameso i on
can be di ided in o Clade I and Clade II (Fig. 3A, B). Clade
I co esponds o he P. chinensis g oup, wi h a la ge gene ic
di e gence be ween he species, and he in e speci ic ela-
ionships a e ini ially esol ed. Clade II co esponds o he
P. caudopunc a us g oup, which exhibi s ela i ely low mi-
ochond ial di e gence ye encompasses six dis inc e o-
lu iona y lineages (Fig. 3A). The ou samples om Da-
ang, Guizhou, o m a dis inc e olu iona y lineage wi hin
Clade II, which is close o P. longliensis and P. maolan-
ensis (BPP/UFB = 0.84/72; Fig. 3A). Howe e , he phy-
logene ic ee econs uc ed om he mi ogenome showed
ha he wo Da ang samples om Guizhou clus e ed close
o P. longliensis wi h low suppo (BPP/UFB = 0.47/42;
Fig. 3B). The new species had small mi ochond ial gene -
ic dis ances om ela i es, anging om 0.63 o 9.39%
(Table 3). The haplo ype ne wo k based on ND2 showed
no sha ed haplo ypes wi hin he P. caudopunc a us g oup,
wi h he new species o ming a unique haplo ype (Fig. 3C).
Using bo h conca ena ion and coalescen -based
app oaches, we econs uc ed maximum-likelihood (ML)
(Fig. 4A) and species ees (Fig. 4B) based on SNP da a
h ough IQ-TREE and SVDqua e s analyses, espec-
i ely. Bo h analyses s ongly suppo ed he samples
om Da ang, Guizhou, as a dis inc e olu iona y lin-
eage. Howe e , we obse ed phylogene ic disco dance
be ween he ML and species ee opologies ega ding
he placemen o he new species and P. zhijinensis, sug-
ges ing po en ial in luences o incomple e lineage so -
ing and gene low e en s on phylogene ic econs uc ion.
The new species exhibi s mode a e gene ic di e en ia ion
Table 3. Unco ec ed p-dis ance (%) be ween six species o he
P. caudopunc a us g oup based on mi ochond ial ND2.
ID Species 1 2 3 4 5
1P. wumengshanensis
sp. no .
2P. caudopunc a us 9.39
3P. longliensis 1.03 9.68
4P. maolanensis 0.63 9.49 0.61
5P. wulingensis 9.39 2.70 9.69 9.50
6P. zhijinensis 1.84 9.64 1.82 1.42 9.65
Figu e 3. Recons uc ed phylogeny and haplo ype ne wo k. A. Phylogene ic ee econs uc ed based on he mi ochond ial ND2
gene; B. Phylogene ic ee econs uc ed based on he mi ochond ial genome. In phylogene ic ees, Bayesian pos e io p obabili ies
(BPP) om BI analyses/ul a- as boo s ap suppo s (UFB) om ML analyses we e no ed beside nodes. The scale ba ep esen s
0.02 nucleo ide subs i u ions pe si e; C. ND2-based mi ochond ial haplo ype ne wo k.
0.02
Pa ameso i on qixilingensis
Pa ameso i on yunwuensis
Pa ameso i on hongkongensis
Pa ameso i on au an ius
Pa ameso i on guanxiensis
Pa ameso i on chinensis
Pachy i on inexpec a us
Pa ameso i on delous ali
Pa ameso i on labia us
Pa ameso i on uzhongensis
1.00/99
100/1.00
1.00/94
0.71/65
0.99/89
0.52/71
0.97/96
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/100
0.41/77
1.00/98
0.84/72
P. longliensis
Pa ameso i on maolanensis
Pa ameso i on
wumengshanensis sp. no .
Pa ameso i on zhijinensis
Pa ameso i on wulingensis
Pa ameso i on caudopunc a us
Pa ameso i on
Ou g oup
BPP/UFB
A
I
II
P. caudopunc a us
P. wulingensis
P. wumengshanensis sp. no .
P. maolanensis
P. longliensis
P. zhijinensis
1
6
C
B
Pa ameso i on
Ou g oup
I
II
0.02
Pa ameso i on labia us
Pachy i on inexpec a us
Pa ameso i on hongkongensis
Pa ameso i on delous ali
Pa ameso i on uzhongensis
Pa ameso i on qixilingensis
Pa ameso i on guanxiensis
Pa ameso i on yunwuensis
Pa ameso i on caudopunc a us
Pa ameso i on chinensis
Pa ameso i on zhijinensis
Pa ameso i on maolanensis
Pa ameso i on wulingensis
Pa ameso i on au an ius
0.47/42
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/98
0.65/46
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/74
1.00/100
1.00/100
1.00/98
Pa ameso i on longliensis
Pa ameso i on
wumengshanensis sp. no .
BPP/UFB
0.99/99
1.00/99
1.00/100
1.00/100
zse.penso .ne
Luo, T. e al.: Genus Pa ameso i on1940
om i s closely ela ed congene s, wi h Fs alues ang-
ing om 0.16 o 0.19 (Fig. 4C), sugges ing pa ial bu
signi ican species di e gence.
Based on mo phological, mi ochond ial, and nuclea
gene ic di e ences, he e is clea suppo ha he Pa ame-
so i on geog aphic popula ion om Da ang, Guizhou,
China, should be ea ed as a new species.
Taxonomic accoun
Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis Luo & Zhou, sp. no .
h ps://zoobank.o g/72A9ACFC-B93C-4727-BA3F-ACA804B7B041
Figs 5, 6, Suppl. ma e ial 1
Ch esonymy. Pa ameso i on sp2 (DF): Luo e al. 2021
(Da ang, Guizhou, China); Pa ameso i on longliensis
(DF): Luo e al. 2022 (Da ang Coun y, Guizhou, China).
Holo ype. Adul male, GZNU20180711, collec ed
by Tao Luo on 11 July 2018, in Yuchong Township, Da-
ang Coun y, Guizhou P o ince, China, 27.44933332°N,
105.95403671°E, ele a ion 1137 m a.s.l.
Pa a ypes. Th ee adul males: GZNU2018070903,
GZNU2018070904, and GZNU2018070905. Th ee adul
emales: GZNU2018070901, GZNU2018070902, and
GZNU20180709011. The locali y and da e o all pa a-
ypes a e same as holo ype.
E ymology. The speci ic epi he wumengshanensis
e e s o he ype locali y, loca ed wi hin he Wumeng
Moun ains, Guizhou, China. The sugges ed English name
is he Wumeng Moun ains Wa y New , and he Chinese
name is Wū Mēng Shān Luǒ Yuán (乌蒙山瘰螈).
Diagnosis. (1) la ge body size, TOL 95.5–123.6 mm in
adul males, TOL 150.1–160.0 mm in adul emales; (2)
absence o dis inc colo ed s ipes on do sola e al idges,
consis en wi h body colo a ion; (3) absence o es igial
gills and gill ilamen s; (4) ex e nal eyes no mal, eye
diame e 14–20% o head leng h; (5) absence o colo ed
spo s on he ails o males, a single ed-o ange s ipe om
he pos e io ma gin o he cloaca o he 4/5 pa s o ail on
en al side; (6) ough skin, body wa s ough and la ge,
and longi udinal g oo es dis inc on he body lanks; (7)
yellow spo below he pos e io ma gin o he eye absen ;
(8) ome ine ee h dis inc , middle pa dep essed ou wa d,
ha ing a sligh ly wide and shallow g oo e a middle base
o each choana, and a dis inc ly p ominen bony pla e is
p esen pos e io o he choana; (9) an e io end o he
epib anchial bone o he hyoid appa a us is nea T-shaped.
Desc ip ion o he holo ype. Adul male, TOL 123.6 mm,
SVL 72.6 mm. Measu emen s a e p esen ed in Suppl. ma e-
ial 1. Body ela i ely slende . Head la , dis inc ly longe
han wide (leng h/wid h = 1.4), dis inc scen glands on side
o head; knob-like (Fig. 6D), wi h a leshy p o ube ance p es-
en in he b anchial egion. Snou sho ; snou a is e iden ,
unca ed, ex ending beyond lowe lip; snou leng h dis inc -
ly longe han eye diame e ; nos ils sho , close o snou ip;
eyes la ge; labial old de eloped, ex ending om lowe eye
o ip o snou ; gula old de eloped; glandula idge on each
side o he head, sligh ly de eloped; ongue sho , ellip i-
cal, bo h la e al sides dissocia ed; one p emaxilla wi h iny
ee h on he uppe and lowe jaws. Vome ine ee h dis inc ,
Ʌ-shaped, middle pa dep essed ou wa d; den i ion slow-
ly comp essed om pos e io o an e io - o-an e io ma gin
0.02
D5
A8
A5
Y2
C2
C9
H9
A6
C4
A2
H3
Y1
H10
C10
Y5
A7
A4
H7
C6
C5
C8
D2
A1
Y7
D3
A3
H6
H5
H2
D6
Y4
A10
Y6
H4
D1
D4
A9
Y3
C7
D7
C1
H8
H1
M1
M2
C3
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
98
100
99
100
100
97
100
98
100
100
100
96
100
100
100
98
100
P. longliensis
P. caudopunc a us
UFBoo = 100
95≤UFBoo <100
UFBoo <95
P. maolanensis
P. zhijinensis
P. wumengshanensis sp. no .
0.6
100
100
100
Ou g oup
Clade I
Clade II
A B
PLPC PW PZ PM
0.16
0.17
0.19
0.16
C
Pachy i on inexpec a us
Figu e 4. Phylogeny and in e speci ic di e en ia ion. Maximum likelihood ee econs uc ed (A) and species ee gene a ed om
SVDqua e s (B) analysis based on 1,475,246 SNPs. Suppo alues a e displayed on nodes, and dashed lines indica e opology-con-
lic ing species. Tip labels: b anch ip numbe s a e sample numbe s o he co esponding species. No e: Sample C1 ep esen s he
new species bu e ains i s o iginal label due o ini ial misiden i ica ion and o consis ency wi h NCBI eco ds. (C) Species di e -
en ia ion be ween new species and o he species. The numbe s abo e and below he dashed line ep esen Fs alues. Abb e ia ion:
PC = P. caudopunc a us, pho o modi ied om Fei e al. (2006); PW = P. wumengshanensis sp. no .; PZ = P. zhijinensis; PL = P.
longliensis; PM = P. maolanensis, pho o modi ied om Gu e al. (2012).
Zoosys . E ol. 101 (4) 2025, 1933–1947
zse.penso .ne
1941
mee ing be ween wo na es; ha ing a sligh ly wide and
shallow g oo e a middle base o each choana; a dis inc -
ly p ominen bony pla e is p esen pos e io o he choana
(Fig. 7A). An e io end o he epib anchial bone o he hyoid
appa a us is nea T-shaped, connec ed wi h he i s and sec-
ond ce a ob anchials o he bone; ce a ohyal kni e-like, wi h
he an e io wo- hi ds in ca ilage, le and igh unconnec -
ed (Fig. 7D). Ve eb al idge de eloped, ligh an, conspic-
uous, unin e mi en , om occipu o ail. Fo elimbs sho ,
eaching o ip o snou when adp essed o wa d; hind limbs
longe and s u die han o elimbs; palm and sole o e lap
when adp essed o elimb backwa d and hind limb o wa d
along body lank; wi hou me aca pal o me a a sal ube -
cles; ou inge s and i e oes wi hou webbing o inge;
ela i e inge leng h 1 < 4 < 2 < 3; ela i e oe leng h 1 < 5 <
2 < 4 < 3. Tail ela i ely long; do sal and en al caudal ins
e iden , expanding on pos e io hal o ail; ail- ip ound-
ed. Cloaca a la ge sli , swollen in o a small mound, illous
mas oid a ound cloaca, many pubes on gaps o cloaca. Skin
ough, especially on he back o he body; many wa s and
g anula glands on do sal skin, do sal su ace o he limbs,
and la e al sides o ail. Longi udinal lank g oo es dis inc
on he body lanks, app oxima ely 17 (Fig. 6E). Ven al skin
w inkled, densely co e ed wi h small wa s (Fig. 6C, H).
Sexual dimo phism. Apophysis o cloaca o he male
la ge and low, and he coun e pa o he emale small and
high (Fig. 5C, F). Female cloaca small and o al wi hou gland
in inside and lack inge -like papillae on he cloacal wall.
Colo a ion. In li e, do sal su ace o body black-
b own and ligh oli e colo . Head, body, and en al
su aces o limbs da k b own o e all wi h i egula ed-
dish-o ange ma kings. Absence o dis inc colo ed s ipes
on do sola e al idges, consis en wi h body colo a ion.
A single ed-o ange o ange ine yellow s ipe ex ends
om he pos e io ma gin o cloaca o he 4/5 pa s o he
ail on he en al side (Fig. 6H). Finge and oe ips g ay-
ish b own. Colo ligh ens in 75% e hanol p ese a ion.
Compa ison. The new species can be assigned o he
P. caudopunc a us g oup on he basis o phylogeny and
can be dis inguished om o he species wi hin ha g oup
by he ollowing mo phological cha ac e is ics (Table 4).
Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis sp. no . di e s
om P. caudopunc a us and P. wulingensis by absence o
colo ed spo s on he ails o males and colo ed s ipes on
do sola e al idges ( s. p esence o pu plish ed spo s on
he ails o males and h ee yellowish b own longi udinal
s ipes e y dis inc on do sola e al idges).
Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis sp. no . di e s
om P. malipoensis by absence o es igial gills and
gill ilamen s in adul s ( s. p esence), snou - en leng h
g ea e han ail leng h ( s. almos equal), and absence o
dis inc colo ed s ipes on do sola e al idges, consis en
wi h body colo a ion ( s. do sola e al idges sca e ed
wi h dis inc i e o ange- ed o b ownish-yellow spo s).
Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis sp. no . di e s
om P. zhijinensis by absence o dis inc colo ed s ipes
on do sola e al idges, consis en wi h body colo a ion
( s. wo o h ee nea -con inuous yellow s ipes on he
do sola e al idge), yellow spo below he pos e io ma -
gin o he eye absen ( s. p esen ), absence o es igial
gills and gill ilamen s in adul s ( s. neo eny is common
wi h mos adul specimens ha ing es igial gills and gill
ilamen s), ome ine ee h dis inc , middle p o uding
ou wa d, den i ion slowly comp essed om pos e io o
an e io o an e io ma gin mee ing be ween wo na es,
ha ing a sligh ly wide and shallow g oo e a middle base
Figu e 5. Holo ype GZNU20180711 (A–C) and emale pa a ype GZNU20180709011 (D–F) o Pa ameso i on wumengshanensis
sp. no . in p ese a i e. (A, D) La e al iew. (B, E) Do sola e al iew. (C, F) Ven al iew.