Full text
Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 60:325-346 (1993) Rabies in southern Africa R. SWANEPOEL1, B.J.H. BARNARD2, C.D. MEREDITH2, G.C. BISHOP3 G.K. BRUCKNER4, C.M. FOGGIN5 and O.J.B. HUBSCHLE6 ABSTRACT SWANEPOEL, R. , BARNARD, B.J.H., MEREDITH, C. D ., BISHOP, G., BRUCKNER, GK , FOGG IN , C.M. & HUBSCHLE, O.J.B. 1993. Rabies in southern Africa. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 60:325-346 The first confirmed outbreak of rabies in Africa, believed to have followed the importation of an in fected dog from England in 1892, occurred in the eastern Cape Province of South Africa, and was brought under control in 1894. An unconfirmed epidemic of rabies in dogs occurred in western Zambia in 1901 . By the following year the disease had apparently spread along a major trade route, to cause an outbreak in Zimbabwe which engulfed most of the country before being eradicated in 1913. The existence of endemic rabies of viverrids (mongooses and genets) was confirmed in South Africa in 1928, and since then the viverrid disease has continued to occur widely on the interior plateau of the country with spill-over of infection to cattle and a variety of other animals. From about 1947 onwards, an invasive form of dog rabies spread from southern Zambia and/or Angola into Namibia, across northern and eastern Botswana into Zimbabwe and the northern Transvaal by 1950, entered Mozambique in 1952, and spread from there to Swaziland in 1954. Dog rabies extended from southern Mozambique into Natal in 1961 to cause a major epidemic which was brought under control in 1968. The disease re -entered northern Natal from Mozambique in 1976 and since then dog rabies has proved difficult to control in the peri-urban settlements of Natai-KwaZulu. The disease spread from Natal to Lesotho in 1982, and into the Transkei region of the eastern Cape Province in 1987, to reach the Ciskei by 1990. The spread of the disease in dogs was followed by the emergence of rabies of jackals and cattle in central Namibia, northern Botswana, Zimbabwe and the northern Transvaal. A unique outbreak of rabies in kudu antelope occurred in central Namibia from 1977 to 1985, apparently involving oral spread of infection between individuals. A few cases of rabies in the bat-eared fox were recognized each year in Namibia from 1967 onwards, and from the 1970s the occurrence of the disease in the fox has emerged as a distinct problem in the northern Cape Province and spread to the west coast. The rabies-related viruses, Lagos bat, Mokola and Duvenhage, associated with bats, shrews and rodents in Africa, are known to have caused isolated cases of disease in South Africa, and on one occasion a small outbreak involving si x cats and a dog in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. However, the results of monoclonal antibody tests on numerous specimens indicate that the rabies-related viruses are not a major cause of disease in southern Africa. INTRODUCTION 1 National Institute for Virology, Private Bag X4, Sandringham, 2131 South Africa 2 Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute, Private Bag X5, Onderstepoort, 0110 South Africa 3 Regional Veterinary Laboratory, Allerton, Private Bag X2, Cascades, 3200 South Africa 4 Directorate of Animal Health, Private Bag X138, Pretoria, 0001 South Africa 5 Veterinary Research Laboratory, Causeway, Harare, Zi mbabwe 6 Central Veterinary Laboratory, Windhoek, Namibia Rabies (rabidus, L. = mad) is a highly fatal nervous disease of humans and all other warm-blooded vertebrates, caused by a virus which is present in saliva late in infection and which is generally transmitted by the bite of diseased animals, most commonly dogs and other carnivores. The causative agent of the disease is a member of the Rhabdoviridae family of rod or bullet-shaped viruses (rhabdos, Gr. = rod), which have a single-stranded, negative-sense RNA genome (complementary to mRNA). Within the family, 325
Rabies in so uthe rn Af ri ca rabies virus is placed in the genus Lyssavirus (l yssa, Gr.= rage or fury), while the family also includes the Ephemera virus (bovine ephemeral fever and related viruses) and Vesiculovirus (vesicular stomatitis and related viruses) genera of animal viruses, plus certain viruses offishes, invertebrates, and plants (Calisher, Karabatsos, Zeller, Digoutte, Tesh, Shope, Travassos Da Rosa & St George 1989; Anonymous 1993). The lyssaviruses include rabies virus (designated lyssavirus serotype 1) and the so-called rabiesrelated viruses, Lagos bat, Mokola and Duvenhage (lyssavirus serotypes 2, 3 and 4) which are associated with bats, shrews and rodents in Africa, plus seven other viruses which are of unknown veterinary or medical significance (Calisher et a/ . 1989). Rabiesrelated viruses have also been isolated from bats in Europe, and these have been provisionally designated European bat lyssaviruses 1 (EBL 1) and 2 (EBL 2) , but it is as yet uncertain whether these are to be regarded as subtypes of Duvenhage virus or recognized as separate serotypes (King 1991 ). It should be noted that despite early reports to the contrary, infection of bats with rabies virus proper (lyssavirus 1) has been confirmed only in the Americas, where the disease occurs in both non-haematophagous and vampire bats (Baer 1975a; 1975b; Beran 1981 ; Smith & Baer 1988). It is of great epidemiological significance that recent monoclonal antibody and nucleic acid studies have shown that strains of rabies virus (lyssavirus 1) which circulate in particular host species within given geographic regions, tend to undergo genetic adaptation, resulting in the development of so-called biotypes, with subtle changes in antigenicity and pathogenicity (Wiktor & Koprowski 1978; Wiktor, Flamand & Koprowski 1980; Blancou 1988a; Smith & Baer 1988; Smith 1989; Sacramento, Bourhy & Tordo 1991; Smith, Fishbein, Rupprecht & Clark 1991 ). The biotypes are uniquely adapted to circulate in specific animals, so that within an affected area the disease is manifested predominantly by a ·single host species, or less commonly more than one, and this same host appears to be responsible for maintenance and spread of the virus; disease in other animals represents spill-over of infection resulting from sporadic contact with the major host species (Smith & Baer 1988; Smith 1989). Rabies is widely distributed in the world, with only certain countries, mainly islands and peninsulas, being historically free of the disease or having succeeded in eradicating it in recent times (Biancou 1988b; WHO 1989; 1991). It is estimated that there are at least 25 000 human cases of the disease each year, over 90% of which result from transmission by dogs (Fernandes & Arambula 1985; Bagel & Motschwiller 1986). The developed nations of western Europe and North America have succeeded in drastically 326 reducing the occurrence of the disease in dogs (urban rabies) over the past four decades, but ironically they have experienced a marked increase in the disease of wild vertebrates (sylvatic rabies) over the same period (Smith & Baer 1988; Blancou 1988b ; WHO 1991). Dog rabies predominates in most of the developing nations of Central and South America , Asia and Africa, and human disease is rife. Sylvatic rabies, on the other hand, is recorded relatively infrequently in most of the developing nations, and this is ascribed partly to deficient monitoring of the disease in wild vertebrates. Largely as a result of lack of resources, the occurrence of sociopolitical upheavals, and the existence of other national priorities, rabies appears to be least well monitored in the continent of Africa (Biancou 1988b; WHO 1991 ; Swanepoel1994) . The disease has been present in North Africa since antiquity, where it occurs principally as urban rabies (Biancou 1988b). In sub-Saharan Africa, where humans and other animals are more widely distributed than in northern Africa, there has been a greater tendency for epidemics of dog rabies to spread over large areas and for the disease to be observed in domestic herbivores and wild vertebrates (Biancou 1988b). This trend is most noticeable in the more developed countries of southernmost Africa, where the high proportions of cases recorded in wild animals must to some extent reflect more intensive monitoring of the disease. Nevertheless, it is clear from· the history of the disease in the sub-continent (Swanepoel 1994), presented here in abbreviated form, that southern Africa has a unique blend of urban and sylvatic rabies. ZAMBIA AND ANGOLA Rabies was apparently present in Zambia during the 19th century, and in 1901 Chief Lewanika of the Barotse in the west of the country ordered the destruction of all dogs in the area in an attempt to control a severe outbreak of the disease (Edmonds 1922; Snyman 1940; Shone 1962). The diagnosis of the disease was first confirmed in 1913 and rabies has continued to occur throughout the country (Zyambo, Sinyangwe & Bussein 1985; Tuchili 1988; Sinyangwe 1992). The disease affects ma inly dogs, but apprec iable numbers of cattle are affected in the south-central part of the country, particularly in locations where jackal rabies is diagnosed close to nature reserves (Zyambo eta/ . 1985). Rabies was first confirmed in Angola in 1929 and since then the disease has been diagnosed mainly in dogs, with very few cases being recorded in other dqmestic or wild animals (Duarte, Rosliacov, Nsalambi & Gomes 1985), but protracted civil war in the country has hampered monitoring and control of the disease over the past few decades .
NAMIBIA An outbreak of disease fitting the description of ra - bies and in volving dogs, cattle and small livestock was apparently observed in Namibia in 1887 (Schneider 1985; Hubschle 1988), and from 1925 onwards there were sporadic reports of outbreaks of disease involving dogs, humans and, on one occasion a hyena, in the Ovambo, Kavango and Caprivi Strip districts in the north, bordering Angola and Zambia, with an isolated case being recorded further south in a child bitten by a dog in Swakopmund in 1928 and another in a woman bitten by a wild cat in Grootfontein in 1937 (Von Maltitz 1950). A diagnosis of rabies was finally confirmed in a dog from Rundu in Kavango in 1938, but a suspected outbreak of the disease which occurred on farms in the Gibeon and Marienthal districts in the south in 1945 could not be confirmed (Von Maltitz 1950). The position changed sharply with the occurrence of the second confirmed case of rabies in 194 7, also in a dog in Rundu, which was followed in 1948 by the appearance of the disease south of the Etosha National Park in cattle in Outjou district, whence spread of disease involving black-backed jackals (Canis mesomelas) and cattle continued southwards to reach Otjiwarongo in 1949 and the central districts of Gobabis and Windhoek by 1951 (Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute [OVI) 1932-1992, unpublished records; Von Maltitz 1950; Alexander 1952; Schneider 1985}. From 1967 onwards a few cases of the disease, less than ten, were recorded regularly each year in bat-eared foxes (Otocyon mega/otis) (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records). Rabies has remained a problem in Namibia, with dog and human cases being recorded mainly in the north where the density of the rural population is greatest, jackal and cattle rabies dominating in the central ranching area, and sporadic disease being associated mainly with felids (African wild cats and caracals) and viverrids (genets and mongooses) in the sheep-rearing areas of the south (OVI1932-1992, unpublished records; Schneider 1985; Depner 1992). An unusual development in Namibia involved epidemic spread of rabies in kudu antelope (Trage- /aphus strepsiceros) from 1977 to 1985 in the central ranching area. A localized outbreak of rabies in kudus occurred in Windhoek district in 1975, but the epidemic which followed began in Okahandja district in 1977 and over the next few years spread to Karibib, Omaruru, Windhoek, Otav i, Otjiwarongo, Outjou, Gobabis, Grootfontein and Tsumeb districts, causing an estimated loss of 30 000-50 000 antelope, or 20% of the population, by the time the outbreak subsided in 1985 (Shaw 1980; Barnard & Hassel 1981; Barnard, Hassel, Geyer & De Koker 1982; Hassel 1982; Schneider 1985; Hubschle 1988). It is believed that the kudu population had attained an unprecedented density during the 15 years preceding the R. SWANEPOEL eta/ . epidemic, and this was ascribed largely to the conservation of the antelope because of the increasing value of trophy hunting and export of venison, and the occurrence of a succession of seasons of above average rainfall. An increase in jackal rabies was noted prior to the epidemic and it was surmised that rabid jackals initiated the infection in the kudus, but thereafter the number of cases recorded in the antelope was disproportionately high in comparison to that in jackals, suggesting that the disease was also transmitted directly between kudus. This possibility was strengthened by the fact that eastwards extension of the outbreak was initially checked for two years by a game control fence which hindered the passage of antelope but not small carnivores. It is believed that transmission between kudus was favoured by their propensity to indulge in self and mutual grooming, and by the fact that oral transmission would have been facilitated by the mouth injuries which kudus sustain when browsing on the Acacia thorn trees which predominate in the affected area. However, individuals sometimes browse in close proximity to each other, so that transmission of infection through contamination of vegetation was possible. It was shown that kudus are highly susceptible to infection by the oral route, and that infected individuals excrete high concentrations of rabies virus in saliva (Barnard eta/ . 1982). The start of the epidemic in kudus was followed by the occurrence of an outbreak of rabies in the Etosha National Park in the early 1980s, involving carnivores ranging from bat-eared foxes and jackals to lions. The Etosha National Park lies in the pathway of the southwards spread of rabies in 1948 and cases of the disease had been recorded there prior to 1980, but it is believed that the infection was probably re-introduced from Tsumeb district in the 1980s by jackals which are able to penetrate the gameproof fence of the park (Basson 1992). The total cases of rabies confirmed in Namibia from 1938-1992 are summarized in Table 1 (OVI 19321992, unpublished records; Schneider 1985; Depner 1992; Central Veterinary Laboratory 1992a, unpublished records). BOTSWANA In Botswana, there were unconfirmed focal outbreaks of rabies in Lobatse in the south-east in 1919 and 1922, and in Ngamiland district in the north-west in 1936, where the diagnosis was first confirmed in a dog in 1938 according to laboratory records (Ciuver 1927; OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Depner 1992; Snyman 1940; Henning 1956; Mansvelt 1956). From unpublished veterinary correspondence and records (Foggin 1988; Tremlett 1993), it appears that an outbreak of dog rabies of more serious proportions was noted in Ngamiland adjacent to the Caprivi Strip and Kavango districts of Namibia, at some 327
Rabies in southern Africa TABLE 1 Total confirmed cases of infection with rabies and rabies-related viruses recorded in four countries of southern Africa. Modified and updated from Swanepoel (1994). Sources of information as cited in text South Africa Namibia Botswana Zimbabwe Species 1928-1992 1938-1992 1938-1992 1950-1992 Wild animals Cynictis penicillata Yellow mongoose 2 119 -- - Unspecified mongooses 1 3006 16• 158 55b Galerella sanguinea Slender mongoose 18 1 -39 Galerel/a purverulenta Small grey mongoose 38 - - - Herpestes ichneumon Large grey mongoose ---3 Mungos mungo Banded mongoose 4 1 -- Atilax pa/udinosus Water mongoose 13 --1 Paracynictis selousi Selous' mongoose 1 --- Helogale parvula Dwarf mongoose 1 --- /chneumia albicauda White-tailed mongoose 2 --6 Suricata suricatta Suricate 118 4 -- Civettictis civetta Civet 3 - - 29 Genetta genetta Small-spotted genet 174 23 22 3 Mellivora capensis Honey badger 23 27 16 45 lctonyx striatus Striped polecat 67c 2 -5 Poecilogale albinucha Striped weasel 1 -- - Unspecified otter species 1 -- - Panthera leo Lion -4 - - Panthera pardus Leopard -2 1 2 Acinonyx jubatus Cheetah -4 -- Felis lybica African wildcat 14 15 -6 Fel is caracal Car a cal 14 4 1 - Felis serval Serval --1 3 Felis nigripes Small-spotted cat 3 -1 - Unspecified felids 170d 47d 12d - Canis mesomelas Black-backed jackal 230° 360 193 1 5951 Canis adustus Side-striped jackal -- - 166 Otocyon mega/otis Bat-eared fox 273 67 6 2 Lycaon pictus Wild dog -1 -3g Vulpes chama Cape fox 9 8 - - Proteles cristatus Aardwolf 23 14 -6 Hyaena brunnea Brown hyaena 1 2 -- Crocuta crocuta Spotted hyaena 1 -4 6 Hystrix africaeaustralis Po rc upine -1 -- Xerus inauris Ground squirrel 32 1 -- Paraxerus cepapi Tree squirrel 1 - - - Thryonomys swinderianus Greater canerat 2 -- - Lepus saxatilis Scrub hare 1 --- Orycteropus afer Ant bear - - -2 Procavia capensis Cape hyrax 8 --1 Papio ursinus Chacma baboon 1 - - 2 Cercopithecus aethiops Vervet monkey -1 -2 Galago moholi Lesser bushbaby -1 - - Phacochoerus aethiopicus Warthog 1 -- - Sylvicapra grimmia Duiker 17 9 5 7 Raphicerus campestris Steenbok 4 1 -- Trage/aphus strepsiceros Kudu 3 386 1 2 Taurotragus oryx Eland 1 17 -4 Hippotragus niger Sable - - -2 Alcelaphus buselaphus Red hartebeest -1 -- Damaliscus dorcas phillipsi Blesbuck 1 - - - Redunca arundinum Reedbuck 1 - - 1 Antidorcus marsupia/is Springbok 3 1 -- Equus burchelli Burchell's zebra 2 -- - Unspecified herbivores 6 -1 - Epomophorus wanlbergi Epauletted fruit bat 14h --- Nycteris thebaica Slit-faced bat 1 --1 Unidentified chiropterid, possibly Miniopterus schreibersii 1' --- Unidentified chiropterid Insectivorous bat 1 Unspecified/ un identified 32i 2 -- Total wild animals 4 754 1 023 279 1 999 328
R. SWAN EP O EL eta/ . TABLE 1 (continued) Country South Africa Namibia Botswana Zimbabwe Period 19281992 1938-1992 1938-1992 1950-1992 Domestic animals Dogs 3 720 642 640 4 063 Cats 454 ' 70 21 152 Cattle 2 332 1 472 761 1 567 Sheep 127 65 7 81 Goats 75 76 264 89 Horses and donkeys 58 28 42 79 Pigs 25 2 -17 Water buffalo -1 -- Guinea pigs 1 --- Total domestic animals 6 792 2 355 1 735 6 048 Total 11 546 3 378 2 014 8 047 Humans • Believed to be mainly C. penicillata Believed to be mainly G. sanquinea c Probably includes some P. albinucha d Be lieved to be mainly F. lybica • Possibly includes a few C. adustus in north-eastern Transvaal stage before March 1950, and by September the disease had crossed to Serowe in the east and swept down the eastern border to the south of the country, i.e. infection spread to all areas where the human, and therefore dog, population was most dense. Along the way, the infection spread into south-western Zimbabwe and the northern Transvaal region of South Africa. The disease has remained active in all of the areas of Botswana initially affected, but in addition to the original problem of dog rabies with occasional human cases, there has been a tendency for increasing numbers of jackals, cattle and other livestock to be involved (Maganu & Staugard 1985; Mosienyane 1988; Masupu 1992; Tremlett 1993). From about 1980 onwards a separate outbreak of rabies involving domestic herbivores and wild animals developed in the Ghanzi district on the western border of Botswana, apparently as an extension of the kudu epidemic in Namibia, and within a few years had spread 1 000 km south-eastwards across the country to Kgatleng district on the Transvaal border of South Africa (Mosienyane 1988). Southward extension occurred into Kgalagadi district (Mosienyane 1988), where the Gemsbok National Park of Botswana adjoins the Kalahari Gemsbok National Park of South Africa, with which it is managed as a unit, and in 1986 rabies was diagnosed in the spotted hyaena (Crocuta crocuta) in the South African park (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records). The total cases of rabies confirmed in Botswana from 1938-1992 are summarised in Table 1 (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Maganu & Stau307 12 1 Probably includes many C. adustus 9 Captive animals 32 h Only two bats positively identified as E. wah/berg1 ' Possible identity based on circumstantial eviden ce I Probably includes domestic animals 159 gard 1985; Mosienyane 1988; Masupu 1992; Tremlett 1993). It should be noted that there are discrepancies with the figures presented by Swanepoel (1994); in particular, species identities have been published for animals previously recorded as unspecified (Tremlett 1993). ZIMBABWE Zimbabwe was apparently free of rabies in 1890 when European colonists arrived in the country, but some of the older indigenous inhabitants could recall that the disease had been present in their young days (Edmonds 1922). In 1902, dog rabies appeared in the Bulawayo area in south-western Zimbabwe, and there appears to be little doubt that the disease was introduced from western Zambia where the disease was known to be rampant in the Barotseland area in 1901 (there was considerable traffic between these regions along the major trade route linking the two countries at the time) (Edmonds 1922; Shone 1962). Within two years 60 000 dogs were destroyed in an attempt to control the disease in Zimbabwe, and, although this must have represented a considerable proportion of the population at the time, the disease continued to spread throughout most of the country. Control of the disease was finally achieved in 1913, this being ascribed largely to the imposition of a dog tax, which provoked drastic voluntary re - duction of the population on the part of dog owners (Edmonds 1922; Shone 1962). The infection apparently did not become established in wild hosts, and failure of the outbreak to extend into South Africa was ascribed to preventive action in the form of a 329
Rabies in southern Africa radical reduction of the dog population within an 80 km wide strip of the Transvaal along the Limpopo river where it forms the northern borders of the country with Zimbabwe and Botswana (Mansvelt 1956). After 1913, Zimbabwe remained free of rabies until 1938, when two cases were diagnosed in dogs at Victoria Falls, and, as before, the evidence indicated that the infection had been introduced from Zambia (Shone 1962). Except for bridges at certain points, the Zambezi river and the present day Lake Kariba form an effective natural barrier to the spread of rabies from Zambia, and after 1938 Zimbabwe again remained free of the disease until dog rabies crossed the south-western and southern borders of the country from Botswana and the Transvaal in 1950it is believed that the virus was introduced by dogs which accompanied people who crossed the borders illegally to purchase grain (Adamson 1954; Shone 1962). The disease spread rapidly through Zimbabwe, following routes along the more densely populated communal farming areas, and by 1954 had reached the north of the country (Adamson 1954; Shone 1962). The growth in the human population since 1913 made it difficult to enforce formerly effective control measures, such as dog "tie-up" orders and the destruction of strays, and from 1951 onwards mass immunization campaigns were conducted with Flury LEP (low egg passage) vaccine, which had only recently become available (Adamson 1954; Shone 1962; Williamson 1976). By the early 1960s control of the disease had been achieved over most of Zimbabwe, apart from resistant foci on the eastern and western borders with Mozambique and Botswana, and vaccination campaigns were scaled down (Mackinnon 1963; Williamson 1976; Foggin 1988). From 1965 onwards, however, political unrest culminating in civil war rendered it increasingly difficult to immunize dogs in the communal farming areas, and the incidence of rabies progressively rose to a record level of 861 confirmed cases in 1981, after the cessation of the war in 1980 (Swanepoel & Foggin 1978; Lawrence, Foggin & Norval 1980; Fogg in & Swanepoel 1985; Fogg in 1988). Following the formal ending of the war, the control of dog rabies was complicated by continued strife in Matabeleland in the south-west, and by an influx of refugees from the civil war in Mozambique in the east, while elsewhere in the country rackal rabies assumed serious proportions (Foggin 1988). Dogs, jackals and cattle comprise 91 , 8% (7 391 /8 04 7) of all animals in which rabies was confirmed in Zimbabwe from 1950 to 1992 inclusive (Table 1) (Fogg in 1988; Bingham 1992; Veterinary Research Laboratory 1992b, Zimbabwe, unpublished records) and no other country has recorded as many cases of jackal rabies. A minor portion of the land in Zimbabwe is devoted to national parks and urban development, while the 330 bulk of the country is divided approximately equally between commercial and communal farming. Commercial farms are generally well wooded, and apart from large wild carnivores and herbivores which have been eliminated, wildlife, including jackals, is generally preserved or tolerated, and few dogs are kept (Foggin 1988). In contrast, communal farming areas are generally overgrazed and deforested, wildlife is scarce, and dogs are kept for hunting. Consequently, dog rabies has occurred mainly in or close to communal farming areas, and jackal rabies has occurred almost exclusively on commercial farms (Fogg in 1988). Both the black-backed jackal and the side-striped jackal (C. adustus) occur in Zimbabwe, with partially overlapping distributions, and both are involved in outbreaks of rabies. Jackal rabies was first diagnosed in Zimbabwe in 1952, some 15 months after the disease had entered the country in 1950, and the first outbreaks occurred along the eastern border (Cumming 1982; Foggin 1985a; 1988). Thereafter, outbreaks of jackal rabies occurred in widely separated districts at irregular intervals of many years (Cumming 1982; Foggin 1988; Kennedy 1988). Since the outbreaks always appeared to occur in proximity to outbreaks of dog rabies and did not recur in the same areas for periods of seven years or more, it was argued that the virus was not adapted for maintenance in jackals but had to be re-introduced by dogs (Cumming 1982). However, several of the outbreaks which have occurred since 1965, and sporadic isolations of the virus from jackals, have taken place well away from known centres of infection in other species (Foggin 1988). Moreover, in one particular instance it was clear that an outbreak of rabies in dogs in fact followed spread of the disease in jackals (Kennedy 1988). It can therefore be concluded that rabies appears to be readily transmitted by jackals in Zimbabwe, and that the infection is freely communicable between dogs and jackals, as seems to be the case in other parts of southern Africa. An alternative explanation given for the failure of rabies to persist in circumscribed areas of commercial farming where epidemics occurred in jackals, was that the disease reduced the density of jackals in these areas to below the threshold required for the spread of the infection (Foggin 1988). As observed in parts of Zambia, Namibia, Botswana and South Africa where jackal rabies occurs, outbreaks of the disease in jackals in Zimbabwe are invariably accompanied by the occurrence of the disease in cattle, but the reported degree of involvement of cattle varies: it is a common finding in southern Africa that laboratory confirmation of the diagnosis is sought in only a minor proportion of suspected cases of rabies in cattle, particularly once the diagnosis has already been established in a herd (Von Maltitz 1950; Bruckner, Hurter & Boshoff 1978; Maganu & Staugarr;J 1985; Zyambo eta/ . 1985; Fogg in
1985a; 1988; Mosienyane 1988). In one outbreak in Zimbabwe it was established by retrospective investigation that 1 200 cattle had died, of which 140 were confirmed to have been rabid (Foggin 1988). As with cattle, the occurrence of rabies in most other species in Zimbabwe appears to represent spill-over of infection from either dogs or jackals, but there have been clusters of cases of the disease in the slender mongoose (Galerel/a sanguinea) in the south-west of the country on occasion, which suggests the existence of an independent cycle of transmission in this species (Foggin 1988). SOUTH AFRICA, MOZAMBIQUE AND SWAZILAND There are historical reports extending back to the eighteenth century of sporadic cases of disease resembling rabies in dogs and humans having been observed in South Africa (Ciuver 1927; Neitz & Marais 1932; Snyman 1940; Henning 1956). However, an outbreak of the disease in dogs was first confirmed in the eastern Cape Province in 1893 by inoculation of rabbits, and this represents the first occasion on which a diagnosis of rabies was confirmed on the continent of Africa (Hutcheon 1894). The outbreak was initially recognized in Port Elizabeth in April1893, but the results of inquiries suggested that the first case had occurred in September 1892 in a dog imported from England, which had become rabid a few weeks after its arrival. The outbreak was believed to have affected about 90 dogs, seven cats and a few cattle, but no wild animals, and had spread to Uitenhage, Jansenville, Willowmore and Albany districts by the time that it was brought under control in August 1894, through the muzzling and restriction of dogs and the destruction of strays (Hutcheon 1894; Eddington 1895; Henning 1956). After 1894, rabies was not confirmed again in South Africa for 34 years, but there was mounting anecdotal evidence to indicate that an endemic form of the disease associated with viverrids was present. In particular, there was a general belief in the eastern and northern Cape Province that bites from genets caused fatal, rabies-like illness in humans, and specific reports of such incidents dated back to 1885 (Fitzsimmons 1919; Cluver 1927; Snyman 1940; Nelson 1962). Cluver (1927) documented 11 unconfirmed cases of human rabies (frequently misquoted as ten cases) which occurred in the southern Transvaal, Orange Free State and northern Cape Province from 1916 to 1927, following bites by yellow mongooses (Cynictis penicillata), dogs and a small-spotted genet (Genetta genetta). The disease was finally confirmed in 1928 in two children bitten by a yellow mongoose in Wolmaransstad district in the south-western Transvaal (Herzenberg 1928), and since that time rabies has been diagnosed regularly in South Africa. R. SWANEPOEL eta/. Within a short period after the diagnosis of the disease was confirmed in 1928, rabies was recognized in numerous locations in South Africa in dogs, domestic cats, yellow mongooses, suricates (Suricata suricatta), genets and wild felids, and in humans and farm animals which had been bitten by these carnivores (Du Toit 1929; Neitz & Marais 1932; Neitz & Thomas 1933; 1934; Snyman 1937). Initial conjecture that the disease might have arisen by extension from the epidemics of dog rabies which had occurred in the eastern Cape Province from 1892 to 1894 and in Zimbabwe from 1902 to 1913, gave way to the conviction that rabies had long been present in viverrids in South Africa, possibly for centuries, but had simply not been recognized (Du Toit 1929; Neitz & Marais 1932; Neitz & Thomas 1933; 1934; Du Toit 1936; Snyman 1937; 1940). The veterinary investigators were well aware that the newly recognized disease in South Africa, which occurred principally in the yellow mongoose, differed fundamentally from what they termed classical European type dog rabies in that there were sporadic cases in dogs, but no real tendency for the infection to spread among them. In fact, Neitz & Marais (1932) pre-empted the concept of rabies virus biotypes by several decades when they stated: "There seems to be complete adaptation [of the virus] to one family of Carnivora [Viverridae] and occasionally a domestic animal or human being is accidentally bitten and contracts the disease. There the outbreak ends in spite of the fact that conditions are being [sic] favourable for the spread of the disease .. . the adaptation of the disease to one family, is surely not something which can occur in so short a period as a decade or two". Later, brief reference was made to the fact that experimentally infected mongooses were unable to transmit infection to dogs by bite, but the strain of virus, species of mongoose and numbers of an imals on experiment, were not specified (Alexander 1952). As the area known to be affected by rabies expanded, there was speculation that this was due to both recent spread and the fact that the true distribution of the disease was still being elucidated (Snyman 1940), but subsequently the results of deliberate investigations revealed that the occurrence of endemic mongoose rabies was confluent over the greater part of the interior plateau of South Africa west of the Drakensberg mountains (Meredith 1977; 1982). The only areas to be excluded were those which fell outside the distribution of the yellow mongoose-the northern Transvaal apart from a narrow central strip passing through Soutpansberg district, Natal apart from the north-eastern margin of the province, the easternmost Transkei portion of the Cape Province and a narrow coastal region extending from Port Elizabeth towards Cape Town (Meredith 1977; 1982; Smithers 1983). The mongoose occurs 331
Rabies in southern Africa less abundantly in Botswana where it is absent in the east, and it is present in Namibia apart from the coastal Namib desert (Smithers 1983). The yellow mongoose is diurnal and its role as a maintenance host for rabies virus is facilitated by the fact that it lives in colonies (Snyman 1940; Zumpt 1968; 1969; 1976; 1982; Smithers 1983; Wenhold 1990; Raza, Wenhold, Howard, Marais, & Pallett 1992). It is most abundant in the north-western Orange Free State and in the adjacent south-western Transvaal, and mongoose rabies is most prevalent in this area (Snyman 1940; Zumpt 1976; 1982). Over much of its distribution, the yellow mongoose utilizes and adapts warrens pioneered by the ground squirrel (Xerus inauris), a rodent with which the r:nongoose shares the warrens in apparent harmony (Snyman 1940; Zumpt 1976). Itinerant groups of suricates, which are also viverrids, occasionally evict yellow mongooses and ground squirrels temporarily from warrens (Snyman 1940; Zumpt 1982). Comparatively few cases of rabies have been recorded in ground squirrels and suricates, the distributions of which largely coincide with that of the yellow mongoose, but there appear to have been no specific attempts to determine the relative population densities of the three species. It is possible that rabid ground squirrels and suricates have been misidentified as yellow mongooses on occasion, or categorized as unidentified mongooses. As early as 1930 efforts were made to control viverrid rabies through the eradication of the yellow mongoose, and from 1939 onwards it became routine ~o pump cyanogas (later phosphine) into warrens 1n locations where mongoose rabies was diagnosed (Snyman 1940; Zumpt & De Bruyn 1967). About 50 000-160 000 hectares were treated annually until exceptionally heavy rains in 197 4-1976 restricted the access of control teams to affected sites (Department of Agriculture 1940-1992, unpublished records; Snyman 1940, Zumpt & DeBruyn 1967). Sine~ then mongoose control, which had become proh1b1t!vely expensive, has been applied much more selectively to strategic locations where the disease occurs in proximity to urban centres. It was realized from an early stage that focal eradication of the mongoose provided only temporary control of rabies, and the incidence of the disease rose progressively in each decade from 1950 onwards to reach epidemic proportions by the early 1970s, despite the application of the control ~eas ures, and continued to fluctuate at h1gh levels 1n the 1970s and 1980s following the abandonment of systematic mongoose control (Table 2) (OVI1932-1992, unpublished records; Snyman 1940; Zumpt 1982). Rabies of the yellow mongoose remains hyperendemic in the south-western Transvaal and adjoining north-western Orange Free State, but occurs through332 out the southern Transvaal, and the Orange Free State where the mongoose constitutes approximately 60% of all animals in which the disease has been recorded over the past two decades (OVI 193~- 1992, unpublished records). There is spill~over of Infection to cattle, dogs, cats, other domest1c an1mals, the striped polecat (lctonyx striatus) and the slender and water (Atilax paludinosus) mongooses. Sporadic cases of rabies are also recorded in suricates, genets, bat-eared foxes, jackals and wild felids, particularly in the drier western districts (OVI 1932-1992 , unpublished records). Since sheep outnumber cattle in the areas where mongoose rabies occurs, and both species predispose themselves to facial bites by displaying curiosity towards rabid mongooses (Du Toit 1929· OVI1932-1992 , unpublished records; Alexander 1' 952; Mare 1962; Mansvelt 1965), it is curious that the number of cases of rabies recorded in cattle vastly outnumber those in sheep (Table 1 ). The epidemiology of the disease is more complex in the Cape Province, where the yellow mongoose constitutes less than 30% of rabid animals recorded over the past 20 years (OVI1932-1992, unpublished records), and where several other carnivor.es appear to be involved in independent transm1ss1on of the virus. Suricates, striped polecats and ground squirrels seem to acquire the infection only where the disease occurs in the yellow mongoose, but there have been clusters of cases suggestive of localized spread in the water mongoose, and in the small grey m.ongoose (Galerella purverulenta), which occurs mamly south of the Orange River (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records). In the northern Cape Province, rabies of genets and wild felids has been diagnosed more frequently than elsewhere in the count~y, but it is not clear whether there is independent mculation of virus in these animals or whether they acquire infection from mongooses, possibly in their role as predators. However, there has also ?een a much higher incidence of rabies in domestic cats 1n the same area than elsewhere (Barnard 1979a), and this could indicate that there is spread of infection among felids with the African wild cat (Felis lybica) serving as a link to feral domestic cats with which it interbreeds. There is stronger evidence to suggest that there is independent spread of rabies in the bat-eared fox, a small canid which occurs in the drier western parts of the sub-continent, and which subsists largely on termites. Sporadic cases of rab1es were recorded in the fox from 1955 onwards, but an Increase in the incidence of the disease was noted in the northern and western Cape Province during the 1970s, shortly after there had been a similar increase in Namibia (see above), and from 1980 onwards there have been up to 24 confirmed cases each year, with progressive spread of the disease to the west coast (almost to the environs of Cape
R SWANEPOEL et at. TABLE 2 Total co nfi rm ed cases of infec ti on with rabies an d rabies-related viruses recorded in an im als in South Africa, 1 928 - 1992. Sources of info rm at io n as for Table 1 Species 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Domest ic anima ls Dogs -1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 6 Ca ts --- - 2 4 6 1 3 -3 Cattle -1 3 2 2 1 1 1 7 3 16 Sheep - - -1 -2 1 --- - Goa ts -- - - - - - - - - - Horses and donkeys -- - - - - - 1 --3 Pigs -2 --- - - - - - 2 Guinea pigs - - --- - - - - - - Total domes t ic animals -4 4 4 5 8 9 4 12 4 30 Wild an i ma ls Cynictis peni cillata Yellow mongoose 2 5 1 1 6 15 8 -4 5 6 Unspecified mongooses, probably C. penicillata ----------1 Ga/erella sanguinea Sl ender mongoose --- - - - - - - - - Galerella purveru/enta Sma ll grey mongoose - - 1 -------- Mungos mungo Banded mongoose - - - --- - - - - - Atilax pal udinosus Wa ter mongoose - - --------- Paracynictis selousi Selous' mongoose - - - -- - - - --- Helogale parvula Dwarf mongoose -- - - - - - -- - - /chneumia albicauda White-tailed mongoose - - -- - - - - - - - Suricata suricatta Suricate - - 2 -1 - - -- - - Civettictis civetta Civet --------- - - Genetta spp. ma inly G. genetta Sma ll -s potted gene t -2 - - 3 1 - - 2 -1 Unspecified viverrids -1 --------- Mellivora capensis Honey badger - - --------- lcton yx striatus Striped polecate ------ - --- - Poecilogale albinucha Striped weasel -- - - - - - - - - - Aonyx ca pensis or Lutra Otter ----- - ----- maculicollis Felis /ybica African wildcat -- - - - - - - - -- Felis caracal Caracal -- - - - - - - - - - Felis nigripes Small-spotted cat - - - - ------- Unspecified felids - - - - ~ 1 2 -3 -- Canis spp. ma inly C. mesome/as Black-backed jackal - - --- - - - - - - Ot ocyon mega/otis Bat-eared fox ---------- - Vulpes chama Cape fox ---- - - - - - - - P ro te les cristatus Aard wo lf - - - - - - - - - - - Hyaena brunnea Brown hyaena ---------- - Crocuta crocuta Spotted hyaena -- - - - - - - - - - Xerus inaur is Ground squirrel - - - - - ---1 -- Paraxerus cepapi Tree squirrel --- - - - - - - - - Thryonomys swinderianus Greater cane rat ------ - -- - - Lepus spp ., probably L. saxatilis Scrub hare - - -- - - -- - - - Pr ocavia capensis Cape hyrax ------ - -- - - Papio ursinus Chacma baboon - - - - - - - - - - - Phacochoerus aethiopicus Warthog - - -- - - - - - - - Sy/vicapra grimmia Duiker ------- - - - - Raphicerus campestr is Steenbok --- - - - - - - - - Tragelaphus strepsiceros Ku du -- - - - - - - - - - Taurotragus oryx El and ------ - --- - Damaliscus dorcas phillipsi Blesbuck ---- - - - - - - - Redunca arundinum Reedbuck - - - - ------- Antidorcus marsupia/is Springbok ------- - - - - Equus burchelli Zebra -- - - - - - - - -- Unspecified herbivores -- - - - - - - - - - Epomophorus wahlbergi Wahlberg's epauletted fruit bat - - - - - - - - - - - Unspecif ie d pteropodid, probably E. wahlbergi -------- - - - Nycteris thebai ca Slit-faced bat -- - - - - - - -- - Unidentified chiropterid, possibly Miniopterus schreibersii -- - - - - - - - - - Unindentified chiropter id Insectivorous bat - - --- - - - - - - Other unspecified or u ni dentified animals* -- - - - - - 4 -- - Total wild animals 2 8 4 1 10 17 10 4 10 5 8 Total 2 12 8 5 15 25 19 8 22 9 38 * Probably in cludes domestic animals 333
Rabies in southern Africa of the rural population in the coastal and many of the midlands districts of Natal favoured the spread of the disease in dogs, and the epidemic which followed the introduction of the virus into the province in 1961 was of an intensity unprecedented in South Africa. Vigorous efforts were made to control the disease (Mansvelt 1962), and the outbreak was finally brought to an end late in 1968 (OVI 1932-1992 , unpublished records). Rabies reappeared in the northern districts of Natal, adjacent to the Maputo district of Mozambique, in mid 1976 (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records) at a time when there was an influx of refugees fleeing the unsettled conditions which followed the assumption of independence by Mozambique from Portugal. During the eight years since rabies had last been diagnosed the population of Natal had continued to burgeon, and since many rural inhabitants sought livelihoods in urban centres, informal settlements flourished, where uncontrolled dog populations provided fertile ground for epidemic spread of the disease. Dog rabies spread from Natal to the Transkei area of the eastern Cape Province in 1987, and by the early 1990s had reached the Ciskei area (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Regional Veterinary Laboratory 1987-1992, unpublished records). Like Natal, the Transkei and Ciskei areas have dense rural and peri-urban populations, and the emergence of dog rabies in the east represents yet another development in the complex pattern of rabies in the Cape Province. Since its re-introduction into Natai-KwaZulu in 1976, dog rabies has proved to be intractable. Approximately 75% of all cases of rabies recorded in dogs in South Africa since 1976 have occurred in NataiKwaZulu, and dogs represent about 88% of all animals in which rabies has been recorded in the province during this period (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Regional Veterinary Laboratory 1987-1992, unpublished records). Peak vaccination coverage of 59% of the estimated total dog population of NataiKwaZulu was attained in 1980-1981 (Department of Agriculture 1940-1992, unpublished records; Swanepoel1994) but the immunization of unrestricted dogs in informal settlements constitutes a formidable task which has been rendered increasingly difficult by the political unrest which has developed in the province. Consequently, inadequate vaccination coverage has been attained in recent years in the strategically important locations where the problem is most severe. Prior to 1950, most cases of human rabies in South Africa resulted from bites by viverrids (and sporadically other animals) in the southern Transvaal, Orange Free State and Cape Province, but following the incursion of the canid virus into the northern Transvaaf, and later Natal, dogs became the most impor340 tant source of human infection. Currently, about 1020 cases of human rabies are recorded each year in South Africa, mainly in association with dog bites in Natai-KwaZulu, but human disease is of growing importance in the eastern Cape Province (OVI 19321992, unpublished records; National Institute for Virology 1953-1992, unpublished records; Veterinary Laboratory, Transkei 1990-1992, unpublished records). Monoclonal antibody studies have confirmed that virus strains associated with endemic viverrid rabies in Botswana and South Africa can be distinguished from the canid strain which appears to have spread through Namibia, Botswana, Zimbabwe and parts of South Africa from about 1947 onwards (National In - stitute for Virology 1953-1992, unpublished records; Schneider, Barnard & Schneider 1985; King 1991 ). Virus associated with the bat-eared fox in the northern and western Cape Province conforms to the canid type (National Institute for Virology 1953-1992, unpublished records; King 1991 ), and this tends to confirm the impression that apart from the putative spread of the canid virus across the northern Transvaal and through Mozambique into Natal, there may have been a further introduction of the virus into South Africa via the fox from Namibia. The total range of species affected and numbers of cases of rabies which have been confirmed since regular monitoring was instituted in South Africa in 1928, up to 1992 inclusive, are summarised in Table 1, and annual figures are presented in Table 2. As far as possible, the information was derived from original laboratory records (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; National Institute for Virology 19531992, unpublished records; Regional Veterinary Laboratory 1987-1992 , unpublished records; Veterinary Laboratory, Transkei 1990-1992, unpublished records). Original rabies records at the Veterinary Institute, Onderstepoort, remain available only for the years from 1967 onwards, but transcripts of the original records for the years 1932-1943, and 19521966 inclusive, had been prepared by one of the present authors (C .D.M. ). Summarised figures could be derived for the years 19441951 from existing in - formation (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Department of Agriculture 1940-1992, unpublished records), although only combined totals could be determined for the two years 1944 and 1945 (Table 2) . Neitz & Marais (1932), and Neitz & Thomas (1933; 1934) published detailed records for the years 19281933, but otherwise the information presented in Tables 1 and 2 cannot be derived accurately from publications or departmental reports: figures given for ra - bies cases recorded during particular periods are either impossible to relate to calendar years, or to reconcile with each other without overlaps or gaps, or else the publications and reports do not stipulate any or all species involved, or they deal with only a
particular region, or omit figures for the self-governing and independent states, or they present figures which are at a variance with laboratory records (Du Toit 1929; 1936; Snyman 1937; 1940; 1953; Alexander 1952; Henning 1956; Mansvelt 195(?; Mare 1962; Tustin & Smit 1962; Lambrechts 1964; Neitz 1965; Zumpt 1969; Bruckner et at. 1978; 1936; Barnard 1979a; b; Gummow 1985; Gummow & Turner 1986; Keightley, Struthers, Johnson & Barnard 1987; Swart 1989). It should be noted that Tables 1 and 2 include cases of infection with rabies-related viruses recorded in South Africa and Zimbabwe, as discussed below. LESOTHO Dog rabies spread from Natal into the north-eastern corner of Lesotho in 1982, when the disease was recorded there for the first time, and within two years it had spread throughout the country (Khomari 1988; Scott 1988; Khomari 1992). Rabies has been recorded in dogs, cats, cattle, sheep, goats, horses and donkeys in Lesotho (Table 1) , but monitoring of the disease has proved to be difficult in the mountainous terrain of the country and human disease has been recorded with disproportionate frequency. There are few feral carnivores in the country and the disease has not been recorded in wild animals. Dog rabies reached the western border of Lesotho in the mid 1980s, but did not penetrate deeply into the Orange Free State where preventive vaccination had been undertaken, and where the dog population is less dense. RABIES-RELATED VIRUSES Large numbers of isolations of rabies virus (lyssavirus 1) were made from non-haematophagous bats in the Americas during the 1950s, and this prompted investigations elsewhere in the world. As a consequence, Lagos bat virus was isolated from strawcoloured fruit bats (Eidolon helvum) in Nigeria in 1956 (Boulger & Porterfield 1958), but it was not until1970 that the virus was identified as a rhabdovirus antigenically related to, but distinct from, rabies virus (Shope, Murphy, Harrison, Causey, Kemp, Simpson & Moore 1970). In 1968, a virus was isolated from Crocidura sp. shrews trapped in Mokola Forest near lbadan, Nigeria, and from a shrew found dead in lbadan (Kemp, Causey, Moore, Odeola & Fabiyi 1972; Kemp, Ottis, Setzer & Moore 1974). Identification of the Mokola virus as a rhabdovirus related to rabies virus was reported in the same publication as the identification of Lagos bat virus, and hence the concept of a rabies-related subgroup of rhabdoviruses was established (Shope et a/. 1970). In 1970, an adult male living in the Warmbaths district about 1 00 km north of Pretoria, South Africa, died of rabies-like disease five weeks after being bitten by an R. SWANEPOEL eta/. insectivorous bat, possibly Miniopterus schreibersii (Van der Merwe 1982), and a virus isolated from his brain was found to be yet another rabies-related virus; named Duvenhage after the victim (Meredith, Rossouw & Van Praag Koch 1971 ; Tignor, Murphy, Clarke, Shope, Madore, Bower, Buckley & Meredith 1977). The three rabies-related viruses have been encountered in only a few countries of western and southern Africa where appropriate investigations have been undertaken (Table 3), and recently in Ethiopia (Mebatsion, Cox & Frost 1992). In general, isolates obtained from ostensibly healthy bats, shrews or rodents in surveys were deliberately subjected to tests appropriate for the identification of rabies-related viruses, whereas isolates obtained from specimens submitted from humans and lower animals for the investigation of suspected rabies, were only recognized as rabies-related viruses because the investigators concerned were alert to nonspecific features which distinguished the infections from rabies: routine diagnostic procedures do not allow rabies and rabies-related viruses to be differentiated with certainty. Thus, the two isolations of Lagos bat virus made from cats in South Africa and Zimbabwe (Table 3), were both made from animals which had been vaccinated against rabies. The cases occurred in isolation from known cases of rabies, fluorescence was observed to be weak in diagnostic tests with polyclonal anti-rabies fluorescein conjugate, and the signs of disease manifested by the cat in Zimbabwe, lethargy and paresis without aggressiveness, were considered to be atypical of rabies (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; Fogg in 1988; King & Crick 1988). Isolations of Lagos bat virus from fruit bats in South Africa in 1980 (Table 3), were made from individuals observed to behave abnormally at a time when public awareness was heightened by the fact that dog rabies was in an epidemic phase in Natal (OVI19321992, unpublished records). Fluorescence with polycanal anti-rabies conjugate was observed in the brains of 13 of the bats submitted from Natal (ten in 1980 and three in 1981 ), and all 13 cases are included in Tables 1 and 2. The affected individuals are believed to have been common epaulleted fruit bats (Epomophorus wahlbergt) although only one was positively identified. Only three of the brains from Pinetown and Durban which fluoresced in 1980 were cultured and, although two of the isolates obtained were at one stage reported to be Mokola virus (Foggin & Swanepoel 1985; Schneider et at. 1985), all three have been confirmed to be Lagos bat virus in monoclonal antibody tests (only these three positively identified isolates are included in Table 3) (OVI 1932-1992, unpublished records; National Institute for Virology 1953-1992, unpublished records; Meredith & Standing 1981; Crick, Tignor & Moreno 1982; King & Crick 1988). A further isolation of Lagos bat 341
Rabies in southern Africa TABLE 3 Total isolations of rabies-related viruses in Africa Species Isolations Lagos bat virus Eidolon helvum (fruit bat) Micropterus pusillus (fruit bat) Epomophorus wahlbergi (fruit bat) Domestic cat Nycteris gambiensis (insectivorous bat) Eidolon helvum (fruit bat) Domestic cat Epomophorus wahlbergi (fruit bat) Dog Mok ola vi rus Crocidura sp. (shrew) Human Domestic cat Human Crocidura sp. (shrew) Dog Domestic cat Lophuromys sikapusi (myomorph rodent) Domestic cat Ouvenhage virus Human Miniopterus schreibersii (insec ti vorous bat) Nycteris thebaica (insectivorous bat) a Only one bat positively identified as E. wahlbergi b Identification of species based on circumstantial evidence c References for Table 3 a Boulger & Porterfield 1958 b Shope et a/. 1970 1 1 3a 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 6 1 1 1 1b 1 Year 1956 1974 1980 1982 1985 1985 1986 1990 1989-1990 1968 1969 1970 1971 1974 1981 19811982 1983 19 89-1990 1970 1981 1986 c Sureau, Germain, Herve, Geoffroy, Cornet, Heme & Robin 1977 d Sureau, Tignor & Smith 1980 e Cricket a/. 1982 f King & Crick 1988 g Meredith & Standing 1982 h Schneider eta/. 1985 i Anonymous 1985 j Foggin 1988 k Bishop & Swanepoel 1990 Mebatsion et a/. 1992 virus was made from an E. wah/bergi bat found dead in Durban in 1990 (Tables 1, 2 and 3) (Bishop & Swanepoel 1990), a finding which suggests that the virus is endemic in Natal. After 1968, Mokola virus was next isolated in 1969 from the cerebrospinal fluid of a young girl who suffered from non-fatal illness with fever and seizures, and in 1971 from the brain of a girl who died of paralytic disease, both in lbadan, Nigeria (Familusi & Moore 1972; Familusi, Osunkoya, Moore, Kemp & Fabiyi 1972). The possibility that the rabies-related viruses were capable of spread among domestic carnivores was raised when Mokola virus was isolated from the brains of six cats and a vaccinated dog 342 Country Lagos, Nigeria Bozo, Central African Republic Pinetown/Durban, South Africa Stanger, South Africa Kindia, Senegal Dakar, Senegal Dorowa, Zimbabwe Durban, South Africa Addis Ababa, Ethiopia lbadan, Nigeria lbadan, Nigeria Umhlanga Rocks, South Africa lbadan, Nigeria Yaounde, Cameroon Bulawayo, Zimbabwe Bulawayo, Zimbabwe Botambi, Central African Republic Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Warmbaths, South Africa Louis Trichardt, South Africa Esigodini, Zimbabwe m Kemp et a/. 1972 n Kemp eta/. 1974 o Fami lu si & Moore 1972 p Familu si et a/. 1972 Circumstances Survey Survey Abnormal behaviour Abnormal behaviour Survey Survey Abnormal behaviour Abnormal behaviour Abnormal behaviour Survey Non-fatal encephalitis Abnormal behaviour Fatal encepha li tis Survey Abnormal behaviour Abnormal behaviour Survey Abno rm al behaviour Fatal encephalitis Abnormal behaviour Survey q Le Gonidec, Rickenbach, Robin & Heme 1978 Foggin 1982 s Foggin 1983 Foggin 1985b u Wiktor et a/. 1984 Referencesc a, b c, d e-h f i i f, j k I b, m, n 0 h p q j. ru j, ru v I W, X h j v Saluzzo, Rollin, Daugard, Digoutte, Georges & Sureau 1984 w Meredith et a/. 1971 x Tignor eta/. 1977 submitted from Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, in 1981 and 1982 for the investigation of suspected rabies (Table 3) (Foggin 1982; 1983; Wiktor, Macfarlan, Foggin & Koprowski 1984; Fogg in 1985b; 1988). The findings in Zimbabwe prompted retrospective investigation of a virus which had been isolated in 1970 from a cat in Natal, South Africa, and which had been preserved because it reacted weakly in the original diagnostic immunofluorescence test with anti-rabies conjugate, and because no rabies had been recorded in the area for two years (Meredith 1970). The isolate was identified as Mokola virus (Table 3) (National Institute for Virology 1953-1992, unpublished records; Schneider et at. 1985; King 1991), but has also been reported as Lagos bat virus (Smith 1989).
Mokola virus has never been isolated from bats (Table 3} , and in retrospect it is thought that the cat and dog infections observed in Zimbabwe in 1981 and 1982, were probably the result of spill-over from an epidemic in small mammals such as shrews or myomorph rodents (Fogg in 1988). Although Mokola virus has not been isolated in southern Africa since 1982, antibody to the virus was found in rodents in Zimbabwe, particularly bushveld gerbils (Tatera l?ucogaster) (Fogg in 1988), and it is notable that virus isolation and charaterization was not attempted on the brains of two greater canerats (Thryonomys swinderianus) from the northern Transvaal which fluoresced in diagnostic tests with anti-rabies conjugate in 1985 and 1987 (Tables 1 and 2) (Swart 1989). Following its initial isolation from a human patient, Duvenhage virus was isolated in 1981 from a bat, possibly M. schreibersii (Van der Merwe 1982), caught in daylight by a cat in Louis Trichardt in the northern Transvaal (Schneider et a/. 1985), and in 1986 from a common slit-faced bat (Nycteris thebaica) caught in a survey in south-eastern Zimbabwe (Table 3) (Foggin 1988). In 1963, prior to the recognition of the rabies-related viruses, a virus was isolated from an N. thebaica bat collected in a survey from a cave in the eastern Transvaal, but the isolate was simply described as rabies virus, presumably on the basis of histopathological lesions observed in mice, and is therefore included in Tables 1 and 2, but omitted from Table 3 (Mansvelt 1965). Furthermore, immunofluorescence with anti-rabies conjugate was observed in the brain of an unidentified insectivorous bat from the northern Transvaal in 1993, but no virus could be isolated for characterization with monoclonal antibodies, and consequently this diagnosis is also included in Tables 1 and 2, and omitted from Table 3. Numerous viruses isolated in southern Africa from the brains of humans and lower animals which fluoresced in diagnostic tests with anti-rabies conjugate, have been screened with monoclonal antibodies, and, apart from the cases mentioned above (Table 3), no evidence of infection with rabies-related viruses has been found (National Institute for Virology 19531992, unpublished records; King 1991 ). The implication is that the rabies-related viruses have not adapted to spread in carnivores, but that sporadic infections may be encountered in humans and domestic animals, particularly cats (Table 3) which are predators of small mammals such as shrews, myomorph rodents and bats. There have been numerous isolations of bat-associated lyssaviruses in Europe, and at first it was suspected that Duvenhage virus may have been introduced with bats from Africa, but it is now clear that there are two distinct subtypes, European bat lyssaviruses 1 and 2, associated with serotine and myotine bats respectively (King 1991). R. SWANEPOEL eta/. REFERENCES ADAMSON, J.S. 1954. Ecology of rabies in Southern Rhodesia. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 10:75 3759. ALEXANDER, R.A. 1952. Rabies in South Africa: a review of the present position. Journal of the South African Veter in ary Medical Association, 23: 135-139 . ANONYMOUS 1985. Isolations of Lagos bat virus in west Africa. Internal Reports of Centre Collaborateur OMS de Reference et Recherche Pour les Arbovirus. lnstitut Pasteur, Dakar, Senegal. ANONYMOUS 1993. Plenary session of the International Committee for the Taxonomy of Viruses. /Xth International Congress of Virology, Glasgow, 813 August 1993. BAER, G. M. 1975a. Rabies in nonhematophagous bats, in The natural history of rabies, edited by G.M. Baer. New York: Academic Press, 2:79-97. BAER, G.M. 1975b. Bovine paralytic rabies and rabies in the vampire bat, in The natural history of rabies, edited by G. M. Baer. New York: Academic Press, 2: 155-175 . BARNARD, B.J. H. 1979a. The role played by wildlife in the epizootiology of rabies in South Africa and South West Africa. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 46:155-163. BARNARD, B.J.H. 1979b. Simptome van hondsdolheid by huisen plaasdiere in Suid-Afrika en Suidwes-Afrika. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association, 50:1 09-111. BARNARD, B.J.H. & HASSEL, R.H. 1981 . Rabies in kudus (Tragelaphus strepsiceros) in South West Africa/Namibia. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association, 52:309-314. BARNARD, B.J.H ., HASSEL, R.H ., GEYER, H.J. & DE KOKER, W. C. 1982. Non-bite transmission of rabies in kudu (Tragelaphus strepsiceros). Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 49: 191 -192. BERAN, G.W. 1981. Rabies and infections by rabies-related viruses, in Viral zoonoses, edited by G.W. Beran, Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press, (CRC Handbook Series in Zoonoses, Section B, vol. 2:57-136). BINGHAM, J. 1992. Rabies in Zimbabwe, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiolog y, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 25 June 1992: 29-33. BLANCOU, J. 1988a. Ecology and _epidemiology of fox rabies. Reviews of Infectious Diseases, 1 O:S606-S609. BLANCOU, J. 1988b. Epizootiology of rabies: Eurasia and Africa, in Rabies, edited by J.B. Campbell & K.M. Charlton. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers: 243-265. BOGEL, K. & MOTSCHWILLER, E. 1986. Incidence of rabies and post-exposure treatment in developing countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 64:883-887. BOULGER, L.R. & PORTERFIELD, J.S. 1958. Isolation of a virus from Nigerian fruit bats. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 52:421-424 . BRUCKNER, G.K ., HURTER, L.R. & BOSHOFF, J.N. 1978. Field observations on the occurrence of rabies in cattle in the magisterial districts of Soutpansberg and Messina. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association, 49:33-36. CALISHER, C.G ., KARABATSOS, N ., ZELLER, H. , DIGOUTTE, J.P ., TESH, R.B., SHOPE, R. E. , TRAVASSOS DA ROSA, A.P.A. & ST GEORGE, T.D. 1989. Antigenic relationships among rhabdoviruses from vertebrates and hematophagous arthropods. lntervirolog y, 30:241-257. CLUVER, E. 1927. Rabies in South Africa. Journal of the Medical Association of South Africa, 1:247-253. 343
Rabies in southern Africa ~~ ~~~ --~ ------------------------------ -------------------- -- - CRICK, J. , TIGNOR, G.H. & MORENO, K. 1982. A new isolate of Lagos bat virus from the Republic of South Africa. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 76: 211~213. CUMMING, D.H.M. 1982. A case history of the spread of rabies in an African country. South African Journal of Science, 78:443~ 447. DE KOCK, G. 1949. In the service of the livestock farming industry: Divisional Report for Veterinary Services, in Annual Report of the Secretary for Agriculture. Farming in South Africa, 25:521 ~ 523. DEPNER, K. 1992. Rabies in Namibia, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 2~5 June 1992: 39-44. DIAS, P.T ., NOVOA, A.M. & CLIFF, J. L. 1985. Rabies in Mozambique, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 406~414. DIAS, P. T. 1992. Rabies in Mozambique, in Proceedings ofthe International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 2~5 June 1992: 24~25. DUARTE, V.M.S., ROSLIACOV, A.A., NSALAMBI, D , GOMES, A.F. 1985. Epidemiologie et diagnostic de Ia rage en Angola, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 406~414. DU TO IT, P.J. 1929. In Proceedings of the Pan African Agricultural and Veterinary Congress, Pretoria, August 1929: 272 ~ 284. DU TO IT, P.J. 1936. Wild carnivora as carriers of rabies. Quarterly Bulletin ofthe Health Organization of the League of Nations, 5: 162 ~ 165 . EDDINGTON, A. 1895. Report of the Director of the Colonial Bacteriology Institute for the year 1894. Department of Agriculture, Cape of Good Hope. EDMONDS, C.R. 1922. Diseases of Animals in South Africa. London: Bailliere, Tindall & Cox: 195~212. FAMILUSI, J.B. & MOORE, D.L. 1972. Isolation of a rabies-related virus from the cerebrospinal fluid of a child with aseptic meningitis. African Journal of Medical Science, 3:93 ~ 96. FAMILUSI, J.B., OSUNKOYA, B.O ., MOORE, D.L ., KEMP, G.E. & FABIYI, A. 1972. A fatal human infection with Mokola virus. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 21 : 959 ~ 963. FERNANDES, M.V. & ARAMBULO Ill, P.V. 1985. Rabies as an international problem, in World's debt to Pasteur, edited by H. Koprowski & S.A. Plotkin. New York: Alan R. Liss: 187~218. FITZSIMONS, F.W. 1919. Natural history of South Africa, London: Longmans Green, 2:7. FOGGIN, C.M. 1982. Atypical rabies virus in cats and a dog in Zimbabwe. The Veterinary Record, 110:338. FOGGIN, C.M. 1983. Mokola virus infection in cats and a dog in Zimbabwe. Veterinary Record, 113:115. FOGGIN, C.M. 1985a. The epidemiological significance of jackal rabies in Zimbabwe, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 399-405. FOGGIN, C.M. 1985b. Mokola virus infection in domestic cats in Zimbabwe, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 65 ~ 70. FOGGIN, C. M. & SWANEPOEL, R. 1985. Rabies in Africa with emphasis on rabies-related viruses, in World's debt to Pasteur, edited by H. Koprowski, & S.A. Plotkin. New York: Alan R. Liss: 219 ~ 234 . 344 FOGG IN , C.M. 1988. Rabies and rabies-related viruses in Zimbabwe: historical, virological and ecological aspects. Ph.D thesis: University of Zimbabwe, Harare. GUMMOW, B. 1985. Rabies on the rise. Department of Health and Welfare, Pretoria, Epidemiological Comments, 12(6):2 ~ 23. GUMMOW , B. & TURNER, 1986. Rabies in South Africa: Epidemiological trends for the period 1980~1984. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association, 57:231~237. HASSEL, R.H. 1982. Incidence of rabies in kudu in South West Africa/Namibia. South African Journal of Science, 78:418 ~ 421. HENNING, M.W. 1956. Rabies, in Animal diseases in South Africa , 2nd ed. Cape Town: Central News Agency: 975 ~ 1022 . HERZENBERG, L. 1928. Two cases of hydrophobia. Journal of the Medical Association of South Africa, 2:659-661 . HLATSHWAKO, P. 1992. Rabies in Swaziland, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 2~5 June 1992: 43~44. HUBSCHLE, O.J.B. 1988. Rabies in the kudu antelope (Tragelaphus strepsiceros). Reviews of Infectious Diseases, 1 O:S629 ~ S633. HUTCHEON, D. 1894. Reports of the Colonial Veterinary Surgeon and Assistant Veterinary Surgeons for the year 1893. Department of Agriculture, Cape of Good Hope. KEIGHTLEY, A.l. STRUTHERS, J. K. , JOHNSON, S & BARNARD, B.J. H. 1987. Rabies in South Africa: 1980 ~ 84 . South African Journal of Science, 83:466-472. KEMP, G.E , CAUSEY, O.R., MOORE. D.L , ODEOLA, A. & FABIYI, A. 1972. Mokola virus. Further studies on I bAn 27377, a new etiologic agent of zoonosis in Nigeria. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 21 :356~359. KEMP, G.E ., OTTIS, R.C., SETZER, H.W. & MOORE, D.L. 1974. Isolation of viruses from wild mammals in West Africa. Journal of Wildlife Diseases, 1 0:279 ~ 293 . KENNEDY, D.J. 1988. An outbreak of rabies in north-western Zimbabwe 1980~1983. Veterinary Record, 122:129~133 . KHOMARI, L. 1988. Rabies in Lesotho, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology. Control and Prevention of Rabies and Brucellosis in Eastern and Southern African Countries, Gaberone, Botswana, 23 ~ 25 November 1988: 25~26 . KHOMARI, L. 1992. Rabies in Lesotho, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology. Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa. Lusaka. Zambia, 2 ~ 5 June 1992: 45 ~ 46 . KING, A. & CRICK, J. 1988. Rabies-related viruses, in Rabies. edited by J.B. Campbell & K.M. Charlton. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers: 177 ~ 200 . LAMBRECHTS, M.C. 1964. A brief summary of the sanitary position in the Republic of South Africa. Bulletin de /'Office International des Epizooties, 62 : 799 ~ 805 . LAWRENCE, J.A., FOGGIN, C.M. & NORVAL, R.A.I. 1980. The effects of war on the control of diseases of livestock in Rhodesia (Zimbabwe). Veterinary Record, 1 07:82 ~ 85. LE GONIDEC, G .. RICKENBACH. A .. ROBIN. Y & HEME. G. 1978. lsolement d'une souche de virus Mokola au Cameroun. Annali di Microbiologia. 129A:245 ~ 249 . LOPES PEREIRA, C.M , PINTO, F.G. & BAULE. C 1988. Rabies in Mozambique: update, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology. Control and Prevention of Rabies and Brucellosis in Eastern and Southern African Countries. Gaberone, Botswana, 23~25 November 1988: 37 ~ 47 .
MACKINNON, J. 1963. Rabies in Southern Rhodesia 1950-1962. Bulletin de /'Office International des Epizooties, 60:87-95. MAGANU, E.T. & STAUGARD, F. 1985. Epidemiology of rabies in Botswana, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 422428. MANSVELT, P. R. 1956. Rabies in the northern Transvaal (1950) outbreak. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 27:167-178. MANSVEL T, P.R. 1962. Rabies in South Africa. Field control of the disease. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33:313-319. MANSVEL T, P.R. 1965. The role of wild life in the epizootiology of some infectious and parasitic animal diseases in South Africa. Bulletin de /'Office International des Epizooties, 64:825-835. MARE, C.J. 1962. Rabies in South Africa. The epizootiology and diagnosis of the disease. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33:287-294. MASUPU, K.V. 1992. Rabies in Botswana, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 25 June 1992: 34-38. MEBATSION, T. , COX, J.H. & FROST, J.W. 1992. Isolation and characterization of 115 street rabies virus isolates from Ethiopia by using monoclonal antibodies: identification of 2 isolates as Mokola and Lagos bat viruses. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 166:972-977. MEREDITH, C.D. ROSSOUW, A.P. & VAN PRAAG KOCH, H. 1971. An unusual case of human rabies thought to be of chiropteran origin. South African Medical Journal, 45:767-769. MEREDITH, C. D. 1977. Recent studies on rabies in southern Africa, in Medicine in a tropical environment, edited by J.H.S Gear. Cape Town: A.A. Balkema: 387-397. MEREDITH, C. D. & STANDING, E. 1981 . Lagos bat virus in South Africa. Lancet, 1 :832-833. MEREDITH, C.D. 1982. Wildlife rabies: past and present in South Africa. South African Journal of Science, 78: 411 -415. MOSIENYANE, M.G. 1988. Rabies situation in Botswana, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies and Brucellosis in Eastern and Southern African Countries, Gaberone, Botswana, 2325 November 1988: 913. NEITZ, W.O. 1965. A check-list and host-list of the zoonoses occurring in mammals and bi rds in South and South-West Africa. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 32:189-337. NEITZ, W.O. & MARAIS, I.P. 1932. Rabies as it occurs in the Union of South Africa, in Eighteenth report of the Director of Veterinary Services and Anima/Industry, Union of South Africa: 71 -89. NEITZ, W.O. & THOMAS, A.D. 1933. Rabies in SoL 'th Africa. Occurrence and distribution of cases during 1932. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Science and Animal Industry, 1 : 51 -56. NEITZ, W.O. & THOMAS, A.D. 1934. Rabies in South Africa. Occurrence and distribution of cases during 1933. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Science and Anima/Industry, 3:335-342. NELSON, H. 1962. Rabies in South Africa. Rabies from the point of view of the medical officer of health or medical practitioner. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33: 327-340. RAZA, O.A.E., WENHOLD, B.A ., HOWARD, P. MARAIS, A. & PALLED, J. 1992. Reproduction in the yellow mongoose revisited. South African Journal of Zoology, 27:192-195. R. SWANEPOEL eta/. SACRAMENTO, D., BOURHY, H. & TOR DO, N. 1991. PCR technique as an alternative method for diagnosis and molecular epidemiology of rabies virus. Molecular and Cellular Probes, 5: 229-240. SALUZZO, J.F., ROLLIN, P.E , DAUGARD, C. , DIGOUTIE , J P , GEORGES, A.J. & SUREAU, P. 1984. Premier isolement du virus Mokola a partir d'un rongeur (Lophuromys sikapusi). Annales de 1'/nstitut Pasteur: Virologie, 135E:57--66. SCHNEIDER, H.P. 1985. Rabies in South West Africa/Namibia, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 520-535. SCHNEIDER, L.G., BARNARD, B.J.H. & SCHNEIDER, H. P. 1985. Application of monoclonal antibodies for epidemiological investigations and oral vaccination studies. I. African viruses, in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 47-59. SCOTI , C. D. 1988. Rabies in Lesotho. Veterinary Record, 122: 287. SHAW, J.J.H. 1980. Hondsdolheid by koedoes. Journal of the South African Veterinary Association, 51 :209. SHONE, O.K. 1962. Rabies in Southern Rhodesia 1900-1961 . Journal of The South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33: 567-580. SHOPE, R.E., MURPHY, F.A., HARRISON, A.K., CAUSEY, O.R., KEMP, G.E ., SIMPSON, D.I.H. & MOORE, D.L. 1970. Two African viruses serologically and morphologically related to rabies virus. Journal of Virology, 6:690-692. SINYANGWE, P. G. 1992.1nProceedingsofthelnternationa!Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies in Eastern and Southern Africa, Lusaka, Zambia, 25 June 1992: 19-21. SMITH, J.S. & BAER, G.M. 1988. Epizootiology of rabies: the Americas, in Rabies, edited by J.B. Campbell & K.M. Carlton. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers: 267-299. SMITH, J.S. 1989. Rabies virus epitopic variation: use in ecologic studies. Advances in Virus Research, 36:215-253. SMITH, J.S ., FISHBEIN, D. B ., RUPPRECHT, C. E. & CLARK, K. 1991. Unexplained rabies in three immigrants in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 324:205-211. SMITHERS, R.H.N. 1983. Mammals of the southern African subregion. Pretoria: University of Pretoria. SNYMAN, P.S. 1937. Rabies in South Africa. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 8:126-133. SNYMAN, P.S. 1940. The study and control of the vectors of rabies in South Africa. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Science and Anima/Industry, 15:9140. SNYMAN, P. S. 1953. Rabies in the Union of South Africa. Bulletin of Epizootic Diseases of Africa, 1 :941 05. SUREAU, P ., GERMAIN, M ., HERVE, J.P., GEOFFROY, B. , CORNET, J.P ., HEME, G. & ROBIN, Y. 1977. lsolement du virus Lagos-bat en Empire Centrafricaine. Bulletin de Ia Societe de Pathologie Exotique, 70:467-470. SUREAU, P., TIGNOR, G.H. & SMITH, A.L. 1980. Antigenic characterization of the Bangui strain (ANCB-672d) of Lagos bat virus. Annals of Virology, 131 :25-32. SWANEPOEL, R. 1994. Rabies, in Infectious diseases of livestock with special reference to southern Afr ica, edited by JAW . Coetzer, G.R. Thomson, R. C. Tustin & N.P. J. Kriek. Cape Town: Oxford University Press Southern Africa: in press. SWANEPOEL, R. & FOGGIN, C.M. 1978. The occurrence, diagnosis, treatment and control of rabies in Rhodesia. Central African Journal of Medicine, 24:10711 3. 345
Rabies in southern Africa SWART , 1989. Hondsdolheid in Suid-Afrika. Vetmed, South African Veterinary Medicine, 2:163-166. TARR, A.F., O'GRADY, J.M. & JENKINS, W.L. 1962. Rabies in South Africa . Rabies and the private practitioner. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33:323 -325. TIGNOR, G.H. MURPHY, F.A., CLARK , H.F., SHOPE, R.E., MADORE , P. , BAUER , S.P ., BUCKLEY , S.M. & MEREDITH , C. D. 1977. Duvenhage virus: morphological, biochemical, histopathological and antigenic relationships to the rabies serogroup. Journal of General Virology, 37 : 595-611 . TREMLETT , 1993. Rabies in Botswana, a review 1977-1992. Gaborone : Department of Animal Health and Production, Ministry of Agriculture. TUCHILI, L.M. 1988. Epidemiology and prevention of rabies in Zambia , in Proceedings of the International Conference on Epidemiology, Control and Prevention of Rabies and Brucellosis in Eastern and Southern African Countries, Gaberone, Botswana, 23 -2 5 November 1988: 61-65 . TUSTIN, R.C. & SMIT, J.D. 1962. Rabies in South Africa: an analysis of histological examination. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 33:295 -310. VALADAO , F.G. 1968. The most important aspects of the rabies problem in Mozambique. Veterinaria Mozambicana, 1:65-70 . VANDER MERWE, M. 1982. Bats as vectors of rabies. South African Journal of Science, 78:421-422. VAN RENSBURG , R.D.J. 1965. Preliminary report on the "humane coyote-getter" for the control of the black-backed jackal Thos mesomelas in the Transvaal. Zoologica Africana, 1:193198. VON MAL TITZ, L. 1950. Rabies in the northern districts of South West Africa. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 21 : 4-12. WEN HOLD , B.A. 1990 . The ethology and social structure of the yellow mongoose (Cynictis penicillata). M.Sc. thesis, University of Pretoria. WHO 1989. Geneva: Veterinary Public Health Unit, Division of Communicable Diseases, World Health Organization (World survey of rabies; no. 23 [for the years 1986 /1987]). 346 WHO 1991. Geneva : Veterinary Public Health Unit, Division of Communicable Diseases, World Health Organization (World survey of rabies; no. 24 [for the year 1988]). WIKTOR , T.J. & KOPROWSKI, H. 1978. Monoclonal antibodies against rabies virus produced by somatic cell hybridization: detection of antigenic variants. Immunology, 75:3938 - 3942. WIKTOR, T.J., FLAMAND , A. & KOPROWSKI , H. 1980. Use of monoclonoal antibodies in diagnosis of rabies virus infection and differentiation of rabies and rabies-related viruses. Journal of Virological Methods, 1: 33 -46. WIKTOR, T.J., MACFARLAN , R.I., FOGGIN , C.M. & KOPROWSKI, H. 1984 . Antigenic analysis of rabies and Mokola virus from Zimbabwe using monoclonal antibodies. Developments in Biological Standardization, 57:199-211 . WILLIAMSON , J.M. 1976. The history of rabies in Rhodesia and control measures. Rhodesia Science News, 10:221222. ZUMPT , I. F. & DEBRUYN, H.W. 1967. The merits of "Phostoxin" in the eradication of small Viverridae. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 38:456-457. ZUMPT , I.F. 1968. The feeding habits of the yellow mongoose, Cynictis penicillata, the suricate, Suricata suricatta and the Cape ground squirrel, Xerus inauris. 1. Analysis of stomach contents. 2. Observations on free-living and captive animals. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 39:89-91 . ZUMPT , I.F. 1969. Factors influencing rabies outbreaks: the age and breeding cycle of the yellow mongoose , Cynictis penicillata (G. Cuvier). Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 40:319-322. ZUMPT , I. F. 1976. The yellow mongoose (Cynictis penicillata) as a latent focus of rabies in South Africa. Journal of the South African Veterinary Medical Association, 47:211-213. ZUMPT , I.F. 1982. The yellow mongoose as a rabies vector on the central plateau of South Africa. South African Journal of Science, 78:417 -418. ZYAMBO , G.C.N., SINYANGWE , P.G. & BUSSEIN , N.A. 1985. Rabies in Zambia , in Rabies in the tropics, edited by E. Kuwert, C. Merieux, H. Koprowski & K. Bagel. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 415 -421.