scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Cultivating Media Literacy and Information Responsibility among Older Adults: A Three‑Year Intergenerational Framework for Inclusive Digital Citizenship

Pan, Sophia Jui-An

Abstract

ABSTRACT: As populations age and digital technologies rapidly advance, middle-aged and older adults (55 years and older) are increasingly engaging with complex online environments shaped by algorithmic suggestions, viral content, and fragmented virtual communities. These environments raise the risk of misinformation spreading and pose significant challenges for ethical and critical media engagement. This research presents the conceptual framework and research plan for a three-year study titled “From Echo Chambers to Responsibility Awareness: Exploring the Third-Person Effect, Information Responsibility Literacy, and Intergenerational Co-Learning in Social Media Use Among Middle-Aged and Older Adults.” Using an interdisciplinary approach that combines adult education, information science, communication studies, and social psychology, the project aims to explore how middle-aged and older adults in Taiwan can develop information responsibility literacy, including skills such as critical media literacy, responsible sharing practices, and greater awareness of echo chambers and third-person perceptions on social media. The research framework recognizes that the media behaviors of middle-aged and older adults are shaped not only by personal abilities but also by social and intergenerational influences. Using interdisciplinary theories and approaches, the project focuses on intergenerational co-learning and blended eLearning as primary instructional methods, encouraging collaboration between older and younger learners to critically analyze, assess, and develop responsible information practices. The methodology includes three phases. The first involves egocentric network interviews and focus groups to explore older adults’ trust networks, decision-making, and moral reasoning in digital environments. Insights from these qualitative studies will guide the second phase, which will utilize Delphi methods and iterative expert consensus to create and validate competency indicators that outline the essential aspects of media literacy and information responsibility for this group. In the third phase, a hybrid media literacy curriculum will be implemented and evaluated using a quasi-experimental design within community-based learning settings. This curriculum will combine in-person workshops with online modules, encouraging intergenerational collaboration and allowing observation of changes in participants’ information behaviors, reflection skills, and collaborative attitudes. Although the project is still in its early stages and has not yet produced empirical data, its design offers a progressive and well-grounded approach to addressing urgent global issues, such as disinformation, algorithmic polarization, and digital exclusion, which affect older populations. The impact of this research goes far beyond academia. By helping middle-aged and older adults to identify, evaluate, and responsibly share information, the project aims to improve communication across generations, strengthen social bonds, and foster a more resilient and inclusive digital environment. At the APERA–TERA 2025 International Conference, this presentation will detail the project’s interdisciplinary base, theoretical framework, and research approach, encouraging constructive feedback and collaboration to improve and broaden the study.

Full text

sophia-pan.com @SophiaJPan CRED LAB Critical Research | Ethics | Digital Ontologies 知識責信與高齡數位素養實驗室 Dr. Sophia J.-A. Pan (She/Her) Department of Adult and Continuing Education National Chung Cheng University [email protected] Nov. 1, 2025 Cultivating Media Literacy and Information Responsibility among Older Adults: A Three‑Year Intergenerational Framework for Inclusive Digital Citizenship APERA-TERA 2025 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17486098 Content Project Background Research Gaps 8 Call for Global Partners 9 Theoretical Framework Innovation & Value 11 Research Aims & RQs 4 5 6 7 Overview of the 3-Year Research This project / study is funded by the National Science and Technology Council (NSTC), Taiwan, under Grant No. 114-2410-H-194-098-MY3. Dr. Sophia J. PAN Lab P.I. 0000-0002-4633-8934 CRED LAB Critical Research | Ethics | Digital Ontologies 知識責信與高齡數位素養實驗室 sophia-pan.com Ruby YANG Student Research Assistant Yan-Zi GUO Student Research Assistant Lyida Y. C. CHANG Graduate Research Assistant Syuan-Ting WANG Graduate Research Assistant 3/12 Research Areas third-person effect (TPE) media literacy intergenerational learning (IL) algorithm effect (AE) educational technology (EdTech) research integrity scholarly publishing ethcis adult education echo chamber effect (ECE) 55+ learners As of 2025, Taiwan has officially entered the stage of a super-aged society (20% aged 65+). The “Gray Digital Divide”: Financial scams surged in Q4 2024 (NT$37.2B ≈ US$1.215B lost); 55+ women were the primary victims (Ministry of the Interior of Taiwan, 2025). Psychosocial Vulnerability: Such scams are designed to target cognitive biases, tech unfamiliarity, and a high level of trust in authority and peer networks. Local Context (Southern Taiwan): Local lifelong learning institutions face unique challenges, e.g., the shortage of qualified media literacy instructors and the highly diverse learning needs, styles, and preferences of older learners. Project Background & Motivation 4/12 sophia-pan.com Reference: Ministry of the Interior of Taiwan (2025, Jan 16). Analysis of high-value fraud financial loss trends in Q4 2024: 3% of fraud cases account for over 57% of financial losses! The Ministry of the Interior urges the public to be cautious with investments to avoid being scammed [Press release]. https://www.moi.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=2&s=324961. Gap 1 (Skills vs. Social Structure): Current instruction too focuses on skills (e.g., edit photos), ignoring social and structural risks (e.g., psychological and algorithmic bias). Gap 2 (Literacy vs. Accountability): Past studies overlooked the accountability for online behavior, including the ethical, legal, and social consequences of sharing misinformation. Gap 3 (Lack Practical Model): Missing instructional models that integrate older individuals’ cognitive biases with their socio-technical environments. Goal of the Project: To empower local 55+ adults to become ethical and responsible social media practitioners, rather than passive and vulnerable users. sophia-pan.com Research Gaps (Motivation) & Social Relevance 5/12 Information Responsibility Literacy Indicator for Taiwanese Elder Adults” (IRLI-TEA): The core construct, moving beyond skills to encompass ethical engagement, and social and critical awareness of algorithmic influence. Echo Chamber Effect (ECE): The mechanisms of social filtering that generate homogeneous information bubbles that reinforce existing beliefs and amplify polarization. Third-Person Effect (TPE): A cognitive bias where individuals believe that negative media (e.g., fake news) affects “others” more than “themselves,” thereby lowering personal vigilance and responsibility. Intergenerational Co-Learning: The primary intervention strategy of the project. Facilitates task-based collaboration between age groups to bridge digital and value divides, fostering reciprocal learning and shared understanding. Theoretical Framework & Key Concepts 6/12 sophia-pan.com Research Aims & Key Questions To develop and validate the “Information Responsibility Literacy Indicator for Taiwanese Elder Adults” (IRLI-TEA), and to design a corresponding modular, hybrid, and intergenerational eLearning curriculum grounded in media literacy. Aim How do the Echo Chamber Effect (ECE) and Third-Person Effect (TPE) shape the (a) information judgment, (b) decision-making processes, and (c) information-sharing behaviors of local adults aged 55+ in online contexts? What are the core competencies and structural dimensions of information responsibility literacy among this demographic? In what ways can a modular media literacy–based eLearning curriculum be designed and implemented to cultivate information responsibility literacy among 55+ adults effectively? QRs RQ1 RQ2 RQ3 7/12 sophia-pan.com Scope & Collaborators A 3-year mixed-methods study From Aug. 2025 − Jul. 2028 Funded by the NSTC of Taiwan The CREDO LAB, CCU students (18+) 55+ living in southern Taiwan International collaborators (see next page) Collaborators Y1: Qualitative Exploration Y1: IRLI-TEA Indicator Scoping Y2: IRLI-TEA Indicator Construction Y2: Curriculum Prototyping Y3: Curriculum Implementation Y3: Quasi-Experimental Validation Main Methods Y1: Egocentric Network Interviews Y2: Focus Groups & Delphi Method Y2: Design-Based Research (DBR) Method Y3: Quasi-Experimental Field Testing Expected Outputs IRLI-TEA Indicator (openly available) A modular hybrid media literacy curriculum Open educational resources (CC license) Community workshops and exhibitions Journal articles (indexed in SSCI, SCIE) Overview of the 3-Year Mixed-Methods Research 8/12 sophia-pan.com Call for Partners (International) (Y1–Y3) Methodology Research Partners & Global Research Networks: Co-design international studies applying egocentric social network analysis, design-based research (DBR), and quasi-experimental approaches in community-based learning contexts. (Y2–Y3) Theoretical Collaboration & Global Research Exchange: Engage in joint theoretical development on information responsibility, digital citizenship, and intergenerational learning, aiming to refine and validate the IRLI-TEA framework across diverse cultural contexts. (Y2–Y3) Comparative Studies (International): Conduct cross-cultural comparative research on cognitive biases (ECE/TPE) and media literacy practices among middle-aged and older adults worldwide. 9/12 sophia-pan.com