INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2024 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
Publishe
Sus ainabili y o Regions
40
A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF INTEGRATED ENERGY STORAGE BATTERIES IN
RENEWABLE ENERGY STATIONS: TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS, CHALLENGES AND
FUTURE TRENDS
*
Assia Redouani ¹, Ghi a Ikmel ², Kamal Za ed 3, Gied ius Čy as 4, Najiba El Am ani El Id issi 5
1,2,3,5 Labo a o y o Signal Sys em and componen , Facul y o Sciences and Technologies,
Sidi Mohamed Ben Abdellah Uni e si y, Fez, Mo occo
4 Depa men o Business Technologies and En ep eneu ship, Vilnius Gediminas Technical Uni e si y, Vilnius, Li huania
E-mails:1 assia. [email protected]; 2 ghi a.[email p o ec ed]c.ma; 3 kamal.za [email protected];
4gied ius.cy as@ ilnius ech.l ; 5 najiba.elam a[email p o ec ed]c.ma
Recei ed 11 May 2024; accep ed 5 Sep embe 2024; published 30 Sep embe 2024
Abs ac . The in eg a ion o ene gy s o age ba e ies in o enewable ene gy s a ions is a c ucial de elopmen in he ques o sus ainable
and eliable ene gy solu ions. This e iew p o ides a comp ehensi e analysis o his in eg a ion, de ailing he ypes o ene gy s o age
ba e ies, including li hium-ion, lead-acid, and low ba e ies, as well as hei espec i e bene i s and limi a ions. The s udy add esses
signi ican challenges such as he in e mi ency o enewable ene gy sou ces, ba e y deg ada ion and li e ime, cos and e iciency issues,
and echnical challenges. I also explo es po en ial solu ions o hese challenges. Addi ionally, u u e di ec ions a e discussed, ocusing on
eme ging ba e y echnologies and sma g id sys em in eg a ion. This pape highligh s he essen ial ole o ene gy s o age ba e ies in
o e coming he in e mi ency o enewable sou ces and ensu ing a s able and e icien ene gy supply.
Keywo ds: ene gy s o age; enewable ene gy; echnical challenges; sma g id in eg a ion; sus ainable ene gy
Re e ence o his pape should be made as ollows: Redouani, A., Ikmel, G., Za ed, K., Čy as, G., El Am ani El Id issi, N. 2024. A
comp ehensi e e iew o in eg a ed ene gy s o age ba e ies in enewable ene gy s a ions: echnological ad ancemen s, challenges and
u u e ends. Insigh s in o Regional De elopmen , 6(3), 40-52. h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
JEL Classi ica ions: O33, Q55
1. In oduc ion
Because o he inc easing demand o elec ici y, pollu ion, and deple ion o non enewable ene gies (Ali e al.,
2021), enewable ene gies a e conside ed a po en ial solu ion. The ad an ages o using enewable ene gies (REs)
can be summa ized in hei secu i y and en i onmen al impac compa ed o con en ional powe gene a ion
(Halkos & Gkampou a, 2020). I also se es o educe he global demand o ene gy. Howe e , he high le el o
in eg a ion o enewable ene gies (RE) in o an elec ici y g id p esen s a numbe o challenges (Basi e al., 2020),
such as ol age o equency a ia ions, load ollowing, and inally, he ene gy p oduced does no always ma ch
load demand. As he in eg a ion o enewable ene gy-based powe sys ems becomes a eali y, a new ield is
suppo ing his g oup wi h app op ia e ools, including, bu no limi ed o, ene gy s o age sys ems (ESs).
The ques o an e ec i e ene gy s o age sys em is as old as mankind i sel ; s a ing om he a chaic
hyd o he mal ene gy s o age sys ems down o he mode n elec ical s o age de ices (Si i e al., 2022). Today, he
*
The esea ch leading o hese esul s has ecei ed unding om he p ojec i led "Clus e o inno a i e ene gy" in he
ame o he p og am "HORIZON-MSCA-2022-SE-01" unde he G an ag eemen numbe 1011298205.
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
41
e icien and e ec i e in eg a ion o ene gy s o age echnologies in he global ene gy in as uc u e is an u gen
bu echnologically di icul subjec . In ligh o he g owing demand o ene gy du ing peak pe iods, he necessi y
o a mo e dependable ene gy sys em, he ad ancemen o g een cul u e, g id esilience, and echnological
inno a ions in enewable ene gy sou ces (RES), he u ilisa ion o ene gy s o age is becoming inc easingly c ucial.
Ene gy s o age is a i al componen in he managemen and balancing o load, he dispa ching o ene gy, he
con ol o ansien s abili y, he assu ance o sel -su iciency, he compensa ion o luc ua ions in he g id, he
moni o ing o load demand and he egula ion o equency (Shazon & Jawad, 2022). Ene gy s o age aims o
mi iga e i egula i ies and co ec he ime lag be ween elec ici y demand and supply o bo h enewable and
con en ional ene gy sys ems (Foley e al., 2020). This is impo an because in mos pa s o he wo ld, demand
o en exceeds a ailable supply capaci y, leading o powe ou ages and longe sho age. Figu e1 illus a es he
wo ld's planned ene gy s o age acili ies, highligh ing a d ama ic inc ease in demand d i en by he ise in
enewable ene gy sou ces.
Fig. 1. Cumula i e Global Ene gy S o age Ins alla ions Wo ldwide
Sou ce: (Em ani & Be ada, 2024)
Ba e y ene gy s o age echnology has a wide ange o applica ions, such as in eg a ing enewable ene gy in o he
g id, managing mic og ids (MGs) (Zhang e al., 2021), p o iding backup powe , load le eling, and peak sha ing.
Al hough ene gy s o age echnology can also add ess he issue o g id a iabili y (Tan e al., 2021), ene gy
s o age sys ems will be mo e compe i i e, and mo e p ac ical p ojec s will be de eloped using ad anced ene gy
s o age de ices. Resea che s a e ac i ely explo ing and making ad ances in ba e y manu ac u ing echnologies
ma e ials, and a e in pu sui o cheape ba e ies wi h longe li e cycles and highe ene gy densi y (Yang e al.,
2022).
1.2. Pu pose o he Re iew
This e iew p o ides a holis ic compa ison o s a e-o - he-a ene gy s o age ba e y echnologies. The con e sion
o enewable ene gy sou ces aises he challenge o in e mi ency due o he lack o su icien s o age in low-
densi y g ids o ansmission lines. Ene gy s o age is essen ial o minimize he ad e se e ec s o in e mi ency in
enewable ene gy plan s. Va ious ypes o s o age echnologies, including Lead-Acid, Nickel-Cadmium, Nickel-
Me al Hyd ide, Li hium-Ion, Flow Ba e y, and Ul acapaci o a e discussed ex ensi ely wi h hei speci ic
ad an ages and limi a ions. Some ou s anding echnical challenges and oppo uni ies o s o age ba e ies a e
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
42
highligh ed in o de o p omo e u u e esea ch in his a ea. This e iew also speci ies and classi ies he exis ing
challenges and solu ions in ypical applica ions o ene gy s o age ba e ies wi h enewable ene gy sou ces, he
g id, o ene gy managemen sys em.
In his e iew, we will add ess he in eg a ion o ene gy s o age ba e ies in enewable ene gy s a ions, co e ing
a ious aspec s such as echnological, economic, and ope a ional ac o s. Fi s , he in oduc ion ou lines he
pu pose o he s udy, emphasizing he impo ance o imp o ing he e iciency and eliabili y o enewable ene gy
sys ems h ough e ec i e s o age solu ions. Secondly, he Types o Ene gy S o age Ba e ies sec ion examines
li hium-ion, lead-acid, and low ba e ies, highligh ing hei speci ic cha ac e is ics and applica ions. The
Challenges and Solu ions sec ion hen add esses issues such as he in e mi ency o enewable sou ces, ba e y
deg ada ion and li e ime, cos and e iciency, and echnical challenges, discussing s a egies o o e coming hese
obs acles. Fu u e Di ec ions sec ion explo es eme ging ba e y echnologies and he in eg a ion o sma g id
sys ems, which a e se o e olu ionize ene gy s o age and managemen . Finally, he Conclusion ea i ms he
c ucial ole o ene gy s o age ba e ies in mi iga ing he in e mi ency o enewable ene gy sou ces and ensu ing a
s able and eliable ene gy supply o he u u e.
2. Types o Ene gy S o age Ba e ies
Renewable ene gy sou ces (Behab u e al., 2020) such as sola panels and wind u bines a e gaining in impo ance
as ene gy sou ces and eed-in a i s because hey p o ide cleane and mo e s able powe . Also, hey a e modula ,
easy o ins all, and equi e sho implemen a ion imes. Howe e , hese ene gy sou ces a e p one o ins abili y,
ha sh ola ili y, and uncon olled p oduc ion, making in eg a ion in o he adi ional powe g id a di icul ask
(Rahman e al., 2020). The e o e, ene gy s o age sys ems a e becoming mo e and mo e necessa y ins alla ions in
enewable ene gy s a ions, as hey can p o ide many se ices needed o in eg a e hese s a ions in o he adi ional
powe g id, such as equency egula ion, peak sha ing, spinning ese es, amp a e con ol, demand esponse,
islanding mode, among o he s.
Howe e , ene gy s o age solu ions ha e low ound ip e iciency, empe a u e managemen issues, p esen
di icul solu ions o second li e applica ions, equi e special ca e in elec oly e managemen , and a e no well
sui ed o la ge-scale ins alla ions (Tan e al., 2021). Ene gy s o age echnologies a e ypically ca ego ized based
on he ype o ene gy hey s o e, which includes elec o-chemical, mechanical, chemical, he mal, and elec ical
ene gy s o age. They can also be classi ied acco ding o esponse ime, s o age du a ion, and applica ion
(Nyama hulla & Dhanamjayulu, 2024). Ne e heless, he a ailable ba e y solu ions ha e in insic p ope ies ha
can lead o ini ial in es men and subsequen g ow h by combining la ge , mo e sophis ica ed s o age solu ions.
The e o e, la gescale ba e ies ha e been limi ed un il oday. Cu en ly, ba e ies al eady in use o maybe
app op ia e o u ili y-scale Ba e y ESS applica ions include lead acid, li hium, and low ba e ies (Em ani &
Be ada, 2024). The ollowing able shows he a ious echnical pa ame e s o ene gy s o age sys ems.
Table 1. A compa a i e analysis o he echnical pa ame e s o di e en ene gy s o age sys ems
ESS
Powe Range
(MW)
Ene gy Densi y
(Wh/Kg)
E iciency
(%)
Li es Yea s
Cycling Capaci y
Lead-Acid
0-21
30-75
70-90
5-15
200-2000
Li hium-ion
0-0.1
100-200
70-85
5-15
1000-10,000
Flow Ba e ie
<15
15-85
60-75
5-10
>12.10^3
Sou ce: (Em ani & Be ada, 2024)
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
43
2.1. Li hium-ion Ba e ies
Li hium-ion ba e ies (Wen e al., 2020) a e simply an essen ial ene gy s o age de ice when a seamless ene gy
supply is demanded. Thei ull-packed ene gy densi y makes hem sui able o small olumes bu wi h la ge
ene gy s o age capaci y, making hem easonable op ions o mino ene gy esou ces. Howe e , hei high ini ial
cos and sho cycle li e ha e held back hei widesp ead use. Despi e his, hey ha e become a mains eam ene gy
s o age ool in many consume elec onics p oduc s, as well as o hyb id elec ic anspo and elec ic ucks (He
e al., 2020), because o he as de elopmen o he EV (elec ic ehicle) indus y. The li hium-ion ba e y could
be a anged in a a ie y o s uc u es, including ubula , p isma ic, and pocke shapes, o sui di e en equipmen .
These di e en design s a egies a e gene ally combined wi h mesh-like o po ous elec odes (Zhao e al., 2021).
One bes ading cha ac e is ic comme cial ea u es o his ype o ba e y is ha hey ha e a u n o a ional design
s a egy. This lexible packaging pa e n helps in con ibu es o he ba e y's low cos , so he s a egy has indeed
been used o la ge-scale p oduc ion wi h high po en ial in hei comme cial applica ion. The elec onics o he
powe apezoids no mally mus be o med in highe abili y, which is o en he case o his ype o ba e ies. The
medium and longe - e m p ospec s o Li-ion ba e ies depend on he sa e y enhancemen s and g owing
applica ions o bo h au omo i e and g id echnologies.
2.2. lead-acid Ba e ies
Recha geable lead-acid accumula o cells (ba e ies) (Vasan Kuma & Sa akons i, 2023) a e elec ochemical
de ices ha use chemical ene gy o gene a e elec ical po en ial. Elec ochemical eac ions con e lead and lead
dioxide in o lead sul a e and wa e , s o ing elec ical ene gy in he o m o chemical ene gy (Gua nie i, 2022).
Since hei in oduc ion by Camille Alphonse Fau e in 1881, lead-acid ba e ies ha e been widely used in
e e yday li e o condi ion elec ical ene gy - om small applica ions (mobile phones) o la ge and complex
ins alla ions (Kay Lup, 2022) (unin e up ible powe supplies o compu e cen e s, eme gency powe supplies o
hospi als, powe supplies o swi ching applica ions in elecommunica ions, and elec ic ehicles).
The de elopmen o elec ic ehicles in he 19 h cen u y e ealed he need o s o e elec ical ene gy and made i
necessa y o con e chemical ene gy in o powe and ice e sa eliably, economically, and conside ably (Xu,
2024). Once i was disco e ed ha a basic shee o lead could gene a e elec ici y on con ac wi h an acidic
sodium sul a e solu ion, i did no ake long o de elop an elec ic lead-acid s o age powe pack, which became
widely used in ea ly elec ic ehicles (Rajamand, 2022). In o he wo ds, he ime lag be ween elec ici y
consump ion and sola lux could also enable he use o sola ene gy s o age sys ems based on lead-acid ba e ies.
Al hough he andom p oduc ion o sola loads a ies acco ding o ime o day and day o yea , he e is no
p ac ical o adequa e model o model he andom iming o elec ici y consump ion. Fluc ua ing elec ici y
consump ion changes he a e age wai ing ime. Fluc ua ing elec ici y consump ion means ha peak loads will be
se ed by he g id a midnigh , he opposi e o he ime when sola ba e y sel -cha ging is mos e ec i e.
2.3. Flow Ba e ies
Flow ba e ies a e an eme ging echnology ha has gained popula i y in ecen yea s (Zhang e al., 2024) due o
hei scalabili y as well as hei po en ially e y long cycle li es. These sys ems a e based on liquid elec oly es
lowing h ough pe meable elec odes whe e e e sible eac ions occu . This con inuous low concep o e s a
na u al solu ion o powe decoupling. E en hough low ba e ies a e known in he indus y as echnology,
applica ions o his ba e y chemis y a e seen in la ge-scale ene gy s o age, elec ic mobili y, s a ion powe , and
shipboa d powe dis ibu ion. In low ba e ies, ene gy s o age ma e ials a e s o ed in la ge ex e nal anks and
hen low h ough he ba e y's eagen essels (Zhang e al., 2022). This means hey comp ise a cell o cells
whe e elec ici y is di ec ly p oduced and consumed, con e e s o in e ac ion wi h he g id, pumps o ci cula e
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
44
he elec oly e, a hea exchange o con ol elec oly e empe a u e, and a cooling uni . The s ack (ac i e
componen ) has many common simila i ies. Flow ba e y sys ems a e de eloped in wo basic combina ions o
elec oly es. This allows a much highe ene gy s o age capaci y han in adi ional sealed ba e ies, making low
ba e ies an a ac i e op ion o s o ing la ge-scale ene gy, such as ha om sola o wind powe . Flow ba e ies
can ha e di e en ma e ials han adi ional ba e ies, since he elec ode ma e ial doesn' need o abso b he
cha ge. Consequen ly, low ba e ies o en ha e much cheape and longe -las ing ma e ials. Flow ba e ies can
also pe o m cha ge/discha ge ope a ions, which gene ally wea ou and deg ade mos ba e ies wi hou li e
limi a ions (Pe o e al., 2021).
3. Challenges and Solu ions
S o age sys ems make i possible o in eg a e mo e enewable ene gies in o he powe sys em, acili a ing he
ma ke pene a ion o enewable ene gies. They enable lexible connec ion, high-quali y powe supply and
smoo h in e mi en luc ua ions. They also p o ide se ices such as peak sha ing, illing, and moni o ing o
s agge ed loads. Renewable ene gy sou ces such as sola and wind a e impo an . Ene gy om hese sou ces is
con e ed in o elec ical ene gy by pho o ol aic cells and wind u bines, and applied o he g id (Pomme e &
Schube , 2022).
The in e mi en na u e o enewable esou ces, such as wind speed and sola adia ion, causes la ges and as
equency luc ua ions du ing ansi ion e en s om non-p oduc ion o p oduc ion (Sahoo & Se hi, 2021).
Howe e , he hea y eliance on enewable sou ces o elec i y he g id is no ully exploi ed due o hei
in e mi en na u e, unp edic abili y, and sou ce a iabili y. This can lead o signi ican p oblems such as he
occu ence o a powe misma ch be ween supply and demand, a ec ing he economy and s abili y o he powe
g id and unplanned load sha ing o he g id in he e en o low p oduc ion. The e o e, he in eg a ion o ene gy
s o age in enewable ene gy sou ces o s o e he ex a desi ed ene gy and hen use i when needed has become
necessa y and he eby imposes he economic and s abili y solu ion o g id p oblems in case o luc ua ion,
a iabili y, and unp edic abili y o he enewable ene gy sou ces (Tahi e al., 2021). To ully mani es he
ad an ages o ESBs in enewable ene gy s a ions, an in elligen ene gy s o age ba e y sys em in eg a ed in
enewable ene gy s a ions is p oposed.
3.1. In e mi ency o Renewable Sou ces
In e mi ency in enewable ene gy p oduc ion is a majo challenge in making such ene gy sou ces capable o
mee ing g id demand o con inuous, s able powe supply. In e mi en beha io o enewable ene gies is due o
hei dependence on wea he condi ions such as sola insola ion o wind powe (Mlilo e al., 2021). Sola adia ion
esou ces con ain a high ol age o luc ua ions and a iabili ies in o e ime in each egion on Ea h due o
wea he condi ions and seasons. The changes in hese condi ions a e uncon ollable, making enewable ene gy
p oduc ion unce ain (Abaza i e al., 2020). This has become a se ious conce n, hus inc easing he impo ance o
eliable, consis en , and a o dable elec ical ene gy s o age echnologies. Many me hods o con olling
elec ici y in e mi ency ha e been discussed and analyzed.
The minimum he mal gene a ion adop ed by he elec ic u ili ies limi s he sha e o wind and sola powe ha he
g id can accep . Renewable ene gy s o age echnologies a e essen ial o mee s uc u al demands and manage he
inc easing low o a iable enewable ene gy esou ces. Fu he mo e, when eed-in a i s ha e changed and
be e incen i es o analysis ha e been in oduced, u ili ies a e eaping g ea bene i s, and la ge enewable plan s,
ei he o u ili ies o la ge p ojec de elope s. Changes in he elec ici y s uc u e in ol e, o ins ance, al e ing
he esidence o ansmission lines, ins i u ions, g ids, and u ili ies, ha may be ha med by decen alized
es ablishmen , bu egula ing his p ocess may es o e incen i es o ne wo k owne s o in e connec enewable
ene gy sou ces (Hu e al., 2023).
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
45
Indeed, p e en ing he powe luc ua ions ha accompany he in e mi en mode o enewable ene gy sou ces is
no limi ed o imp o ed sola cell design o powe con ol s a egies. The i m powe capaci y o sola ene gy
sys ems will become e y signi ican o imely ma ke -le el con ol a he han simple end-use p ice slices o
load shi ing owa ds pe iods o a o able p icing. This b ings us o he in eg a ion o ene gy s o age ba e ies.
Wi h he help o ene gy s o age ba e ies, he goal is o ans o m he dis ibu ed and in e mi en ene gy esou ces
in o a po olio o i ual ene gy sou ces ha p o ide a mo e eliable powe supply, wi h educed powe le el
adjus men s, and p edic able ene gy dis ibu ion. Howe e , he economic alue o inc easing ba e y-pack powe
h ough a load le eling algo i hm and op imizing he bene i o he peak-sha e a e cu en ly o lesse impo ance.
S o ing excess ene gy in ene gy s o age ba e ies and discha ging s o ed ene gy o he g id acco ding o echnical
equi emen s, as well as p e ailing p ice, can acili a e supe luous ma ke pa icipa ion in he sola gene a ion.
3.2. Cos and E iciency
Cos is undoub edly one o he d i ing ac o s o ene gy s o age echnologies, in addi ion e iciency. The cos o
ins alling a ba e y ene gy s o age sys em has allen signi ican ly o e pas 10 yea s due o ad ancemen s in
ba e y echnology, making hem mo e iable han be o e. The educ ion in cos s opens up po en ial applica ions
such as g id applica ions (Mallap agada e al., 2020). Ba e y cos s a e ypically quo ed in $/kWh capaci y, bu o
g id and ancilla y se ices, he cos o o al sys em in $/kW esponses is mo e impo an . The mass manu ac u ing
has also helped o educe cos s, mainly by op imizing manu ac u ing p ocesses a he han ba e y a chi ec u e
(Mongi d e al., 2020). The cos o a li hium-ion ba e y a ies acco ding o many ac o s, such as ba e y
manu ac u ing, geog aphical loca ion, and ma ke demands.
As a gene al ule, he cos s o di e en chemical composi ions o li hium-ion ba e ies wi h di e en o m ac o s
a y conside ably, as each ba e y has i s own p ope ies as well as ade-o s be ween ca hode, anode, and
assu ance chemis y. Fo example, li hium cobal oxide ba e ies a e cheape han NCA (LiNi1−x−yCoxAlyO2)
and li hium cobal manganese ba e ies (W. Li e al., 2020). LiCoO2 ba e ies ha e highe ene gy densi ies bu a e
less s able han cu en LFP (Li hium i on phospha e ba e y) and NMC (LiNi1−x−yMnxCoyO2) ba e ies. The
ma e ials used in ba e y p oduc ion and manu ac u ing also domina e cos (Sha ique e al., 2023). I is di icul o
accu a ely assess and compa e cos s o eme ging echnologies such as me al ai and solid-s a e ba e ies as he e
a e no es ablished and p o en manu ac u ing p ocesses o hem.
3.3. Ba e y Deg ada ion and Li e ime
Li e ime o cycle li e o a ba e y is one o he co e a ibu es ha usually de e mines i s abili y o success ully
suppo i s applica ion. To es ablish he cycle li e o a li hium-ion ba e y, i mus discha ge and echa ge o a
speci ied se o cycles a a pa icula C- a e. Ba e y li e ime and du abili y can be designed o cha ge o discha ge
quickly in hal an hou o less o decades, by using ul a- as ul a- as cha ging. Fu he mo e, ba e y
deg ada ion is caused by i e e sible in e nal and ex e nal p ocesses (Zhang e al., 2022). The ma e ials and
elec ochemical eac ion mechanisms used in he ba e y ha e di ec implica ions. O e ime, ba e y capaci y
dec eases due o i e e sible changes (Li e al., 2021). The ba e y uses mo e uns able ma e ials, and as a esul ,
he ba e y cha ge-discha ge balance inc eases, accele a ing ba e y ageing (Diaz e al., 2022). These si ua ions
pose a secu i y isk.
Besides, o he po en ial aging phenomena a ise, such as c ys al dissolu ion, liquid elec oly e in e ace o ma ion,
ca bon coa ings, solid eu ec ic in e ace laye s (Colla h e al., 2022), pa icle agglome a ions, and solu es ha can
o m s onge , less li hia ed in e aces, inc ease esis ance due o hese luc ua ions and hus con ibu e o he
con inued loss o li hium ions (Xiong e al., 2020). In addi ion o s ess, non-uni o m plas ic comp essi e s ess
can ampli y he compac ion signa u e and induce s ess compa ibili y wi hin he elec ode.
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
46
As a solu ion, cells can be ab ica ed in a manne ha ypically imp o es he p obabili y o a long, eliable, and
s able li espan wi h bo h nylon and clo hs. This could encou age u u e expansion by demons a ing ela i ely low
p ices and la ge ma ke popula ions on which o alida e i du ing he de elopmen o an ad anced bipola
li hium-sauce, wi h signi ican added alue.
3.4 Technical Challenges
The p ocess o in eg a ing ba e ies in o enewable ene gy sys ems can be a complex ask in ol ing echnical,
egula o y, and adminis a i e challenges (E ukudoh e al., 2024). Va ious cha ging and discha ging condi ions
a e p esen a he in e ace be ween ene gy sou ces and ene gy s o age sys ems. Fo example, a he in e ace
be ween wind u bine sys ems and ene gy s o age sys ems, cha ging condi ions a y om ull o emp y ene gy
s o age sys ems in he p esence o low o high wind ene gy (Da a e al., 2021). Simila ly, a he same in e ace,
discha ging condi ions a y when wind ene gy is p esen du ing low wind speeds and du ing sudden ol age
d ops. Each high-powe pulse discha ge o ba e ies can ha e a nega i e impac on hei cyclic ageing. The e o e,
dynamic con ol o discha ge powe managemen is e y impo an o p o ec he ageing o ba e ies du ing
discha ging (Oyekale e al., 2020).
Acco ding o he on ie s o PV in e e s and PV powe elec onic con e sion in a PV-wind powe sys em, in
e ms o in e ace, cha ge/discha ge limi a ion and con ol, he ba e y connec ion be ween hyb id PV-wind powe
in a u al g id-connec ed ene gy s o age sys em is a challenge (Emad e al., 2021). To ex end he li e o ene gy
s o age de ices, discha ging cu en needs o be scheduled. The de elopmen o elec onic powe in e ace
con e e s, p o ec ion, and li e ime i ems need be e design schemes. To ace he u u e o high-le el dis ibu ed
mul i-mic og id ins alla ions o esiden ial amilies, so wa e and con ol-upda ing, he sma ness and modula i y
o con igu able mul ipo building powe elec onic con e e s a e essen ial (Ra ada e al., 2020). Rega dless o
hese conside a ions, he e a e se e al ways o connec ene gy s o age de ices wi h in e sec ion ene gy sys ems.
4. Technological Ad ances and Fu u e T ends
The esea ch conduc ed on he wo ldwide s a us o ene gy s o age, including pa ame e s o he main and well-
known ene gy s o age echnologies and new p omising solu ions o la ge and small-scale applica ions, indica es
he impo ance o ene gy s o age sys ems in u u e sma g ids (Cale o e al., 2022). Wi h inc eased le els o
enewable ene gy pene a ion, he subjec o g id-ine ial condi ions is becoming c i ical, equi ing he use o
sma powe -elec onics in e aces (SPEI) and p o ec i e schemes o suppo g id s abiliza ion (Shi e al., 2020).
Ene gy s o age sys ems can p o ide a e y impo an con ibu ion o u u e g id s abiliza ion and lexibili y, o
which disposal cos s should ake in o accoun he ull li e cycle cos o ene gy s o age sys ems (Foley e al.,
2020).
4.1. Inno a ions in Ba e y Technologies
Se e al no el ba e y echnologies ha e been de eloped in ecen yea s. These include sodium-sul u ba e ies
(NSB), zinc-anode ba e ies (ZAB), Li-ai ba e ies, li hium sul u ba e ies, and low ba e ies (RFB), all o
which a e expec ed o ha e a signi ican impac as high-pe o mance, sa e, and low en i onmen al-pollu ion
ba e y sys ems. Na-S ba e ies using mol en elec oly es we e i s used in la ge-scale ene gy s o age and ha e
demons a ed 20-yea o ope a ional expe ience.
Zinc-ai ba e ies (Khez i e al., 2022) a e cha ac e ized by high-ene gy capaci y, abundance, and low cos
associa ed wi h zinc, bu a e limi ed by ca hode ins abili y and po osi y, elec oly e loss o educ ion ine iciency.
As a common indus ial and domes ic anode ma e ial as well as an elec ochemically ecyclable elec ode, zinc
(Zn) is conside ed one o he mos a ac i e elec odes o ad anced sodium-ion ba e ies (SIBs) o sa is y
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
47
mul iple ba e y equi emen s in e ms o ene gy densi y, powe densi y, cycling s abili y, and ope a ion sa e y,
ul ima ely p omo ing la ge-scale, low-cos , long- anging, dis ibu ed, and andom enewable o -g id powe
supply (A a a e al., 2021). G owing conce ns abou limi ed ossil uels, associa ed en i onmen al p oblems and
ene gy secu i y led o a undamen al in e es in al e na i e enewable ene gies such as sola , wind, hyd opowe ,
and biomass. Di e en ba e ies ha e di e en ad an ages and disad an ages and p esen a ious p ac ical
ba ie s and cycle limi a ions pending la ge-scale applica ion and, consequen ly, ha e di e en deg ees o
exposu e o oday's ene gy sec o (Lu e al., 2020). Ex ensi e heo e ical and expe imen al explo a ions should
ca alyze he de elopmen o cu ing-edge ene gy s o age sys ems and o lead o discussions on he ba e y
echnologies p esen ed in his open access e iew.
The powe and ene gy demand o a ious applica ions in sma g ids a e qui e di e se, and he e o e equi e
di e en o ms o ESS. Cu en ly, li hium-ion ba e ies a e es ablished as an ESS o esiden ial applica ions and
a e being es ed o indus ial and u ili y applica ions (Alima dani & Na imani, 2021). Howe e , a ious o he
eme ging o ms o ba e y ypes a e known o be ei he in he esea ch o de elopmen phase o low cos , long-
li e and high ene gy s o age applica ions. They a e all op imized o hei speci ic design poin s, such as
equency suppo equi emen s o he o de o seconds o du a ion o se e al hou s. A ew o he impo an
ba e y echnologies in he esea ch and de elopmen s age include zinc-based, low-based, sodium-based, and
ad anced li hium-based ba e ies (Kebede e al., 2021).
4.2. Sma G id In eg a ion
One o he mos c ucial demand-side managemen componen s, called Vehicle- o-G id (V2G), aims o modula e
he ea u es o he EV ba e y, aking ad an age o i s dual ole as load o gene a o (Mojumde e al., 2022). The
main challenge o V2G, which in ol es bidi ec ional low, is o a oid damaging he s o age uni . Thanks o he
Ba e y Managemen Sys em (BMS), decision on he co ec ope a ion cha ging o discha ging o espec he
li e ime o he pa icipa ing EV ba e ies a e pe o med. These ope a ions usually occu when he ma ke p ice o
ene gy o auxilia y se ices, as well as he use 's p e e ences, a e sa is ied (Islam e al., 2022). Ano he posi i e
consequence o V2G pa icipa ion is hei inco po a ion as ne wo k asse s. In ac , g id se ices such as ene gy
a bi age, F equency Con ol Ancilla y Se ices (FRCAS), and Ope a ing Rese e Se ices a e easily ealizable.
On he o he hand, uel cell EV will also play an impo an ope a ional ole in he ield o ene gy se ices, which
will suppo he sma g id o he in oduc ion o an inc easing amoun o enewable sou ces (Falche a &
Noussan, 2021). The e ec i e pa icipa ion o mass s o age sys ems, p ima ily buil a ound ba e ies, can o e
eal- ime suppo on he end-use 's esiden ial mic og id o ensu e he managemen o in-house elec ical needs
wi hou o e loading he connec ion o he public dis ibu ion g id. Small, modula , compac , and solid-s a e
s a iona y powe sys ems a e able o abso b he powe peaks equi ed by ancilla y and local se ices.
Conclusion
In his e iew, di e en ypes o ba e y s o age echnologies a e in es iga ed and discussed in dep h. Li hium-ion
ba e ies a e epo ed o ha e he highes ene gy densi y and Coulombic e iciency. Howe e , hey su e om
he mal issues such as o e hea ing and spon aneous combus ion. The low ba e y ype is scalable, which means
ha any desi ed capaci y can be eached by s acking mo e uni s. Ba e y li e ime is one o he mos signi ican
challenges o enewable ene gy s a ions o o he de ices whe e ba e ies a e used. Taking in o accoun deep
discha ge and shallow cycling app oaches, his e iew comp ehensi ely in es iga es low ba e y li e ime. As
p o en by he expe imen al and heo e ical wo ks in he li e a u e, i hal he discha ge a e o he ull a e eaches
he p ede e mined inal ol age, he li e ime o he low ba e y (o he li e ime o o he echnologies) can be
mul iplied by se e al imes.
INSIGHTS INTO REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
ISSN 2669-0195 (online) h ps://jssidoi.o g/i d/
2023 Volume 6 Numbe 3 (Sep embe )
h p://doi.o g/10.70132/s6562942267
48
G id in eg a ion, one o he mos c ucial and signi ican aspec s o s o age, has become inc easingly popula due
o he g owing capaci y o enewable ene gy sou ces and he subsequen emphasis on p o iding solu ions o
con ol ese e sho ages. An ene gy s o age sys em, in e aced wi h he enewable ene gy sou ce, is usually
employed o sol e a a ie y o issues, including he p o ision o equency con ol ese e, p ice a bi age, powe
quali y enhancemen , peak sha ing, and demand shi ing. High e iciency, as esponse, long li e, and low
pu chase p ice a e all necessa y o he deploymen o ba e y ene gy s o age among a ays o enewable ene gy
sys ems. Since enewable ene gy s o age ba e ies play a di e en ole o ene gy s o age in con en ional powe
sys ems, hei unique cha ac e is ics in di e en scena ios need o be conside ed. Fu he mo e, he quan i y o
enewable ene gy s o age de ia es less han he uni cos o s o age unde speci ic condi ions. Fu he esea ch
in o he unc ionali y and ad an ages o balancing p ice luc ua ions be e exploi s ad an age o he enewable
ene gy o e li hium-ion, which has a highe speci ic ene gy e ec . Such wo k could suppo u u e business
ac i i ies and policymaking consensus.
Re e ences
Abaza i, A., Soleymani, M. M., Babaei, M., Gha ou i, M., Monse , H., & Behesh i, M. T. H. (2020). High pene a ed enewable ene gy
sou ces‐based AOMPC o mic og id’s equency egula ion du ing wea he changes, ime‐ a ying pa ame e s and gene a ion uni
collapse. IET Gene a ion, T ansmission & Dis ibu ion, 14(22), 5164–5182. h ps://doi.o g/10.1049/ie -g d.2020.0074
Ali, A., Audi, M., & Roussel, Y. (2021). Na u al esou ces deple ion, enewable ene gy consump ion and en i onmen al deg ada ion: A
compa a i e analysis o de eloped and de eloping wo ld. In e na ional Jou nal o Ene gy Economics and Policy, 11(3), 251–260.
h ps://doi.o g/10.32479/ijeep.11008
Alima dani, M., & Na imani, M. (2021). A new ene gy s o age sys em con igu a ion o ex end Li-ion ba e y li e ime o a household.
IEEE Canadian Jou nal o Elec ical and Compu e Enginee ing, 44(2), 171–178. 10.1109/ICJECE.2020.3034265
A a a , Y., Azha , M. R., Zhong, Y., Abid, H. R., Tadé, M. O., & Shao, Z. (2021). Ad ances in Zeoli e Imidazola e F amewo ks (ZIFs)
De i ed Bi unc ional Oxygen Elec oca alys s and Thei Applica ion in Zinc–Ai Ba e ies. Ad anced Ene gy Ma e ials, 11(26), 2100514.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/aenm.202100514
Basi , M. A., Dilshad, S., Bada , R., & Sami U Rehman, S. M. (2020). Limi a ions, challenges, and solu ion app oaches in g id‐connec ed
enewable ene gy sys ems. In e na ional Jou nal o Ene gy Resea ch, 44(6), 4132–4162. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/e .5033
Behab u, H. A., Messagie, M., Coosemans, T., Be eciba , M., Anlay Fan e, K., Kebede, A. A., & Mie lo, J. V. (2020). A e iew o ene gy
s o age echnologies’ applica ion po en ials in enewable ene gy sou ces g id in eg a ion. Sus ainabili y, 12(24), 10511.
h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/su122410511
Cale o, F., Cañiza es, C. A., Bha acha ya, K., Anie obi, C., Cale o, I., de Souza, M. F. Z., Fa okhabadi, M., Guzman, N. S., Mendie a,
W., & Pe al a, D. (2022). A e iew o modeling and applica ions o ene gy s o age sys ems in powe g ids. P oceedings o he IEEE,
111(7), 806–831. 10.1109/JPROC.2022.3158607
Colla h, N., Tepe, B., Englbe ge , S., Jossen, A., & Hesse, H. (2022). Aging awa e ope a ion o li hium-ion ba e y ene gy s o age sys ems:
A e iew. Jou nal o Ene gy S o age, 55, 105634. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.es .2022.105634
Da a, U., Kalam, A., & Shi, J. (2021). A e iew o key unc ionali ies o ba e y ene gy s o age sys em in enewable ene gy in eg a ed
powe sys ems. Ene gy S o age, 3(5), e224. h ps://doi.o g/10.1002/es 2.224
Diaz, L. B., Hales, A., Ma zook, M. W., Pa el, Y., & O e , G. (2022). Measu ing i e e sible hea gene a ion in li hium-ion ba e ies: An
expe imen al me hodology. Jou nal o The Elec ochemical Socie y, 169(3), 030523. 10.1149/1945-7111/ac5ada
Emad, D., El-Hameed, M. A., & El-Fe gany, A. A. (2021). Op imal echno-economic design o hyb id PV/wind sys em comp ising ba e y
ene gy s o age: Case s udy o a emo e a ea. Ene gy Con e sion and Managemen , 249, 114847.
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.enconman.2021.114847
