scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Advancing Black Sea Research and Innovation for Sustainable Blue Economy

Alexander, Brittany; Heymans, Johanna; Salihoglu, Baris; Niiranen, Susa; Barbanti, Andrea; GUITTARD, ALICE; Frederick, Herpers; Matteo, Bocci

Abstract

BRIDGE-BS was a Horizon 2020 project that advanced the Black Sea’s marine research and innovation capacity in order to co-develop blue economy pathways under multiple stressors for the sustainable use of ecosystem services. It developed an ecosystem-based management framework to enable policy uptake and foster citizen engagement. The project ran from June 2021 to November 2025. This policy brief is a summary of key policy-relevant outputs from the project and includes policy and scientific recommendations for a sustainable blue economy in the Black Sea.

Full text

PUBLISHED NOVEMBER 2025 European Marine Board IVZW Belgian Enterprise Number: 0650.608.890 Jacobsenstraat 1 8400 Ostend Belgium Tel: +32 (0)59 56 98 00 www.marineboard.eu This project has received funding from the European Commission’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation programme under grant agreement N° 101000240. Project coordinator: Middle East Technical University (METU), Turkey. The information and views in this document lie entirely with the authors. The European Commission is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains. This Policy Brief was written by the EMB Secretariat and other partners in the BRIDGE-BS project. BRIDGE-BS – POLICY BRIEF 2 1 Lacks oxygen in its bottom waters (i.e. is anoxic) and is rich in hydrogen sulfide, a toxic gas produced by microbes under anoxic conditions. 2 The benefits provided by the processes, functions and structure of the marine environment that directly or indirectly contribute to societal welfare, health and economic activities (https://www.marineboard.eu/valuing-marine-ecosystems).. 3 Well-established industries in the Black Sea include shipping, transport, port operations and logistics, shipbuilding and repair, fisheries and aquaculture, and tourism. Emerging industries include energy and offshore resources, blue biotechnology, defense and maritime security. 4 For more information on war-related pollution in the Black Sea see: https://black-sea-maritime-agenda.ec.europa.eu/safeguarding-black-sea-region-resultsregional-roundtable-war-related-pollution 5 The capacity of natural and socioeconomic systems to persist, adapt or transform when faced with disturbances, whilst maintaining their essential functions (https://www.marineboard.eu/publications/building-coastal-resilience-europe p14). 6 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27643946/ 7 The critical point at which a transition to a new state is triggered, and a return to the previous state is difficult or impossible (https://www.marineboard.eu/ publications/building-coastal-resilience-europe). BRIDGE Black Sea (BRIDGE-BS) BRIDGE-BS was a Horizon 2020 project that advanced the Black Sea’s marine research and innovation capacity in order to co-develop blue economy pathways under multiple stressors for the sustainable use of ecosystem services. It developed an ecosystem-based management framework to enable policy uptake and foster citizen engagement. The project ran from June 2021 to November 2025. BRIDGE-BS partner organisations The consortium consisted of 31 partners from 14 countries: Introduction The Black Sea is a semi-enclosed basin with 10 large, inflowing rivers. It has a maximum depth of 2,210m, and is the largest anoxic-sulfidic1 water body on Earth. With unique habitats, abundant resources, and rich cultural heritage, the Black Sea is vital to its coastal communities, and the more than 160 million people inhabiting its watersheds. Black Sea ecosystem services2 support a vibrant blue economy3, with new technological innovations offering significant potential to further enhance its sustainability. Several stressors negatively impact the Black Sea, including those relating to climate change (i.e. warming, acidification, deoxygenation), as well as eutrophication, marine litter, chemical pollution, overfishing, the introduction of invasive alien species, and war-related impacts4. These lead to biodiversity loss and are a threat to socio-ecological resilience 5 . Between the 1970s and the early 1990s, unsustainable levels of fishing, nutrient pollution and invasive species led to the weakening of Black Sea ecosystem resilience causing the collapse of its fisheries, widespread eutrophication and increased deoxygenation. However, the ecosystem has stabilised and partially recovered since the 2000s6, likely due to better management, although it is still far from its previous healthier state. Building on past and current projects and initiatives, BRIDGE Black Sea (BRIDGE-BS) developed new tools and capabilities to predict the long-term impact and emerging risks from multiple stressors. This enables the identification of a safe operating space, respecting ecosystem boundaries, within which a sustainable blue economy can flourish. It includes innovations in environmental monitoring, data integration, climate scenario modelling, analysis of the resilience of Black Sea ecosystems, their ecosystem services and tipping points7, and risk assessments to support ecosystembased management. Through co-development with local communities and policy makers, key management measures for a resilient and productive Black Sea were identified to ensure the long-term sustainability (to 2050 and 2100) of the Black Sea’s blue economy. 3 NORTHWESTERN BLACK SEA (ODESSA BAY) İSTANBUL SITE WESTERN SHELF (VARNA & BURGAS) WESTERN BLACK SEA (DANUBE DELTA REGION) BASIN WIDE EASTERN BLACK SEA (BATUMI SITE) SOUTHWESTERN BLACK SEA (SİNOP SITE) PS4 PS3 PS5 PS6 PS7 PS2 PS1 KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS PILOT SITES: KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES AND REGIONAL MULTI-STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES KEY MULTIPLE STRESSORS KEY ECOSYSTEM SERVICES REGULATING & MAINTENANCE PROVISIONING: FISHERIES & AQUACULTURE PORTS & SHIPPING CULTURAL SERVICES: RECREATION & TOURISM OVERFISHING NUTRIENT LOADS & EUTROPHICATION COASTAL EROSION ILLEGAL FISHING INVASIVE SPECIES & HABITAT LOSE ACUTE POLLUTION WATER QUALITY DETERIORATION MILITARY-BASED PRESSURES CLIMATE CHANGE STORMS & FLOODS ADVANCING BLACK SEA RESEARCH AND INNOVATION FOR A SUSTAINABLE BLUE ECONOMY 8 Deliverable 5.2: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17229148 9 For an explanation of the link between warming and deoxygenation see p12: https://marineboard.eu/publications/ocean-oxygen New knowledge and predictive tools to evaluate risks from multiple stressors BRIDGE-BS expeditions, surveys and model results have provided updated understanding of the current status of the Black Sea and the impact of multiple stressors. Pilot sites (Figure 1) were used as focal points for research, and various offshore areas were also surveyed. In addition, harmonised marine monitoring methods were developed for implementation across the region. Environmental assessments8 show that: • The Black Sea has warmed at least 2.6 °C since 1980, which is faster than the global average of 0.6 °C; • Preliminary data from the Western Black Sea indicate that nitrate levels have declined from 8 to 5 μm between 1988 and 2022, however local eutrophication events still occur; • The Black Sea remains oxygen poor, and future warming9 could further shrink the upper oxygen-rich layer; and • Toxic hydrogen sulphide is present as shallow as 80 m in central parts of the Black Sea, posing risk to blue economy sectors. However, inflow of oxygen-rich water from the Mediterranean limits its build up, and should be included in future oxygen budgets to better predict risks. Figure 1: The pilot sites used as focal points for research, stakeholder engagement, and the development of sustainable blue economy scenarios. Each site has unique ecosystem services and stressors. Basin-wide assessments were also carried out. BRIDGE-BS – POLICY BRIEF 4 The biotechnology potential10 of Black Sea marine resources has been demonstrated through the identification of thousands of industrial enzyme candidates from sediment microbes with potential use in biorefinery, bioremediation, pharmaceuticals, and food processing and processes (e.g. sulphide oxidation, denitrification). A basin-scale resilience assessment11 showed that the Black Sea ecosystem crossed a tipping point around 2005. From the late 1980s, the ecosystem was characterised by eutrophication, large numbers of jellyfish, and low numbers of zooplankton and fish. After 2005, fish stocks started to recover and phytoplankton and jellyfish numbers decreased, indicating a shift towards partial recovery, improved health and a more resilient ecosystem enabled by better management and positive changes in ecosystem structure. However, crossing future tipping points is still a possibility if temperatures continue to rise. Initial assessments using fisheries landing data show differences in tipping point dynamics between the north-western and southern Black Sea; thus resilience assessments are needed at both basinand localscales. This will require further research on ecosystem functioning and services at localand regionalscales, improved local monitoring and data sharing, and better use of remote sensing and modelled data. To move towards a cost-effective, integrated land-sea early warning system for multiple stressors, BRIDGE-BS tested and verified the use of a combination of smart sensor technologies12 (Figure 2). These showed high feasibility for adoption and technological readiness up to full operational scale. A tailored approach is recommended for the integration of these methods into observation systems and national monitoring programmes. Sensors technologies tested include: • Biogeochemical sensors for pH, carbon dioxide, and hydrogen sulphide tailored to the environmental conditions of the Black Sea. These can be used by local municipalities, national monitoring programmes, and offshore sectors to help cope with climate change risks; • eDNA13 as a non-invasive, rapid and cost-effective method for assessing biodiversity14. This can complement traditional trawling techniques as part of monitoring programmes that support conservation, sustainable fisheries management, and the identification of areas for protective measures; • DNA metabarcoding15 as a tool for rapidly monitoring phytoplankton biodiversity and Harmful Algal Bloom (HAB) species, with greater sensitivity in taxonomic resolution than traditional approaches using microscopy. This can enhance biodiversity assessments carried out by environmental agencies and monitoring authorities; • A combination of underwater acoustic and aerial dronebased methodologies for rapid and non-invasive jellyfish detection, which can be applied to monitoring activities; • Metagenomic16 exploration of novel enzymes with biotechnological potential that can be scaled up for industrial applications; and • Autonomous platforms such as gliders and scanfish (a towed vehicle), and fixed (benthic) platforms connected to mobile platforms with Internet of Things (IoT) technologies17. 10 Deliverable 5.4: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17229461 11 Deliverable 3.2 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 12 Deliverable 5.5 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 13 Genetic material obtained from environmental samples such as sediment or water, without any obvious signs of biological source material. It is used as an indicator for the presence of species. 14 Deliverable 5.3 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 15 Sequencing genetic ‘barcodes’ to identify species from an environmental sample (e.g. water or sediment samples containing eDNA) to identify multiple species simultaneously (i.e. communities) and their abundances. 16 The study of the structure and function of DNA from all the organisms in an environmental sample. 17 A network of smart, interconnected underwater objects that enable monitoring of vast, unexplored areas of the Ocean. 5 E-DNA METABARCODING FOR GENERAL BIODIVERSITY ENZYMES METAGENOMICS BENTHIC OBSERVING SYSTEMS DRONES FOR JELLYFISH MONITORING ACOUSTIC JELLYFISH DETECTOR DNA METABARCODING FOR PHYTOPLANKTON AND HAB MONITORING SMART SENSORS AND PLATFORMS COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH CRUISES Incorporate new technologies, methods, and protocols Address data gaps identified by BRIDGE-BS Update and harmonise marine monitoring programmes across Black Sea countries SCANFISH GLIDER pH CARBON DIOXIDE BIOGEOCHEMICAL SENSORS HYDROGEN SULPHIDE ADVANCING BLACK SEA RESEARCH AND INNOVATION FOR A SUSTAINABLE BLUE ECONOMY Biological indicators have been tested as potential new indicators of ecosystem resilience to help assess how close the system is to a tipping point18. These include indicators of food web structure (trophic levels19 of catches/populations) and the function of seafloor biological communities (bioturbation20 and bioirrigation21). These can inform the development of restoration plans, including for coastal blue carbon habitats, and can be adapted for monitoring environmental status. Further testing of these indicators is required for their validation and future uptake. The BRIDGE-BS Digital Twin Ocean (DTO) demonstrator22 (Figure 3) is one of the key outputs of BRIDGE-BS, combining many of the tools developed. It aims to be a virtual representation of the Black Sea to support policy makers in informed decision making using what-if scenarios, trade-off analyses, and sectoral and stakeholder input. It integrates data from the BRIDGE-BS portal and database, high-resolution biophysical models of the Black Sea and its watershed, socio-economic scenarios, the resilience assessments, the Artificial Intelligence-based decision support tool, and the risk-based cumulative efect assessment tool (see below for individual descriptions of these). It defines current and future ecosystem status and risks, and develops risk management contexts and policy objectives for specific areas, focusing on ecosystem services and future pressure scenarios. The DTO demonstrator can be used to define ecosystem boundaries for a safe operating space for the Black Sea blue economy and to inform adaptive management. 18 Deliverable 3.1 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 19 Describes an organism’s position in a food chain or food web based on how it obtains energy and nutrients. 20 The mixing and disturbance of sediments and soils by living organisms, such as through burrowing, feeding, and plant root activity. 21 The process by which organisms living in sediment actively exchange water and dissolved substances between the overlying water column and the sediment by burrowing, pumping, and feeding. 22 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/black-sea-dto/; https://dekosim.ims.metu.edu.tr/digitaltwin/ Figure 2: Overview of smart sensors and platforms tested during BRIDGE-BS collaborative research cruises. BRIDGE-BS – POLICY BRIEF 6 BRIDGE-BS DTO Scenarios Desired Scenarios Climate Change Fish Plastic Pollution SAFE OPERATING SPACE IN THE BLACK SEA Incorporates diverse components and services essential for a Safe Operating Space Links ecosystem services and Marine Spatial Planning, assesses ecosystem vulnerability (MSFD indicators) and resilience for holistic assessment. Coupled Ensembled Models Co-Design process with Stakeholders •Database •Smart Observation & Techs BRIDGE BLACK SEA DTO DEMONSTRATOR Risk-based Cumulatıve Effect Analysıs Ecosystem Resilience Assessment AI EMULATOR Desired Scenarios Co-designed with stakeholders The BRIDGE-BS portal and database23 is an interdisciplinary platform that provides public access to methodology as well as physical, chemical and biological datasets from Black Sea observations and modelling generated from BRIDGE-BS, previous projects and other regional, European and global databases (including SeaDataNet24, EMODnet25, Sentinel26, and the Black Sea Water Quality Database27). The Marine Ecosystem and Climate Research Center (DEKOSİM28) of the Middle East Technical University will maintain the BRIDGE-BS portal, database, and the DTO demonstrator. It is also leading in the integration of the DTO demonstrator into the EDITO infrastructure29, as part of the European DTO initiative. An Artificial Intelligence based decision support tool30 uses prototype machine learning models to analyse how the Black Sea ecosystem responds to multiple pressures and to inform adaptive management. The tool provides regional and pilot site-level analysis of cause-effect relationships between environmental pressures and forecasted biological responses. It also integrates basin-scale observational and model data to investigate more complex interactions across space and time. To improve the accuracy of this tool, physical and biogeochemical data gaps need to be filled, including full spatial time series from observations and/or model outputs. In the future, this tool may be used to support scenario testing and in the development of early warning systems for HABs or fisheries collapses. A risk-based cumulative effects assessment decision support tool31 was developed for stakeholders to understand and predict spatial hotspots of environmental impacts of cumulative pressures from blue economy sectors. Impact scores from specific sectors are generated to test and assess future adaptive management strategies, which can support marine spatial planning. Further development of the tool depends on the integration of socio-economic data to link cumulative pressures to impacts on ecosystem services. An ensemble of Black Sea-specific high-resolution coupled models32 covering the full marine system can be used to assess the current and future impact of multiple stressors to help decision makers to understand current environmental status, assess trade-offs, develop management strategies, and revise regional and national maritime policies. 23 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/bridge-bs-database-logged/ 24 https://www.seadatanet.org/ 25 https://emodnet.ec.europa.eu/en 26 https://sentinels.copernicus.eu/ 27 https://blackseadb.org/ 28 https://dekosim.metu.edu.tr/ 29 https://edito-infra.eu/ 30 Deliverable 4.3 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 31 Deliverable 4.4 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 32 Deliverable 2.3 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 Figure 3: Overview of the BRIDGE-BS Digital Twin Ocean (DTO) demonstrator. 7 ADVANCING BLACK SEA RESEARCH AND INNOVATION FOR A SUSTAINABLE BLUE ECONOMY 33 https://blackseabeo.eu 34 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/black-sea-accelerator/; Deliverable 7.3 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 35 https://www.doorsblacksea.eu/ 36 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/virtual-blue-career-center/ 37 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/2024/10/04/bridge-bs-phd-students-are-advancing-black-sea-research/ 38 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/young-ambassadors/ 39 Deliverable 9.5 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 40 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/bridge-black-sea-mooc/; https://ocw.metu.edu.tr/course/view.php?id=365 41 A space where local communities, experts, and decision makers get together to develop, test and improve ideas. 42 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/ocean-literacy-network/ 43 Deliverable 9.6 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 44 Deliverable 2.4 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 45 Deliverable 4.5 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 Visions for the future of the Black Sea Key projections for the future state of the Black Sea under different climate change scenarios have been developed using coupled physical-biogeochemical models that have been downscaled to provide local-scale information. These indicate that sea surface temperature will increase between 0.9 to 3.8 °C by 2100 depending on future carbon dioxide emissions. This will impact oxygen concentration, which is expected to decrease by at least 9%. Biodiversity is predicted to decline, and ecosystem dynamics and fisheries productivity to be altered. In addition, BRIDGE-BS models have provided future projections of plastic pollution based on socioeconomic scenarios with different levels of economic growth, population, and potential environmental policies affecting plastic input from rivers and coastal cities44. These projected increases in stressors will impact the resilience of the Black Sea, increasing the need for caution to ensure the sustainable development of blue economy activities. Three types of scenarios (see paragraphs below) have been created to inform the development of adaptive management recommendations and future actions for blue economy sectors to align with desired sustainability objectives45. These scenarios are included in the Black Sea DTO demonstrator and should be used to update Black Sea sustainable blue economy strategies and policies. They can also be used by blue economy operators to make decisions on where to channel innovation and investments, and on appropriate management measures to ensure sustainability. The blue economy observatory for the Black Sea33 is an online platform that provides a dashboard for monitoring the sustainable development of the Black Sea blue economy. It provides an overview of the current status of blue economy sectors in each Black Sea country, and various future scenarios developed by BRIDGE-BS. Policy makers, researchers, and businesses can gain insight to inform evidence-based decision making to support regional and national level blue economy policies. It also highlights the current regional sustainability deficiencies, data gaps, and data access issues. Data from the observatory feeds into the BRIDGE-BS DTO demonstrator and future plans are being developed for the long-term maintenance of the observatory. The BRIDGE-BS Black Sea accelerator34 operated in cooperation with the DOORS Black Sea project35 and supported 15 startups, small to medium-sized enterprises, and researchers to scale up innovative solutions and sustainable blue economy businesses in a variety of sectors ranging from fisheries and aquaculture to maritime transport. Two BRIDGE-BS High Tech Summits for the Black Sea showcased innovations to a regional audience and promoted dialogue among diverse blue economy actors. Ideas were explored for new services and products that bring value and jobs, including for plastic management, energy, sustainable local aquaculture, and algal biotechnology. Training and capacity building activities (Figure 4) strengthened the Black Sea research community. These include the Virtual Blue Career Centre36, the PhD programme on blue economy37, Young Ambassadors Programme38, Summer and Winter Schools39, and a science-policytechnology Massive Open Online Course40 (MOOC). Local stakeholders were engaged through living labs41, local and regional policy makers through a series of participatory events, and the general public made aware of the importance of a healthy Black Sea and sustainable blue economy through Ocean Literacy activities, the Black Sea Ocean Literacy Network42 and citizen science campaigns43. BRIDGE-BS – POLICY BRIEF 8 Training and capacity-building activities enhanced the skills and expertise of Black Sea ECOPs. VIRTUAL BLUE CAREER CENTER SUMMER & WINTER SCHOOLS PhD STUDENTS BLACK SEA YOUNG AMBASSADORS MOOC Local stakeholders were engaged with regional policymakers through participatory events and Living Labs. ENGAGING STAKEHOLDERS SCIENCE-POLICY EVENTS THREE ROUNDS OF LIVING LABS The Black Sea blue economy research and innovation community was actively engaged, its growth accelerated, and networks strengthened. ADVANCING BLUE ECONOMY NETWORK BLACK SEA ACCELERATOR TWO ROUNDS OF HIGH-TECH SUMMIT FOR THE BLACK SEA RESPONSIBLE CONSUMPTION COOKBOOK BOOK FOR BLACK SEA LIGHTHOUSES BRIDGING THE SCIENCE AND SOCIETY CITIZEN SCIENCE CAMPAIGNS INFORMATIVE VIDEO SERIES DOLPHIN-WATCHING AND DIVING EVENTS The public was reached through informative and engaging mediums, and science outreach. AWARENESS-RAISING ACTIVITIES BRIDGE-BS Capacity Building for Policy Brief_v3 2 1 7/11/2025 10:50 EMPOWERING EARLY CAREER OCEAN PROFESSIONALS (ECOPS) 2050 sustainable blue economy imaginaries46 offer plausible future trajectories for the Black Sea’s blue economy for 2050, assuming that sustainability is achieved. They were developed at basinand pilot sitescales, using a foresight exercise that took into account varying innovation (technological to social) and governance (sea basin to local) conditions, and local stakeholder perspectives. These imaginaries provide a way for decision makers and wider stakeholders to foster collective thinking and strategic dialogue to navigate future challenges and opportunities, and to make decisions under uncertainty. They can be used by national administrations to support the development of blue economy strategies. Desired scenarios47 combine the physical-biogeochemical model results, sustainable blue economy imaginaries, and perspectives from local actors gathered through the living labs. They highlight preferred and realistic scenarios for marine and terrestrial activities that influence marine ecosystems and resources, and help support the development of a sustainable blue economy taking into account climate change. The cumulative effect assessment tool was used to predict future environmental impacts of these scenarios and showed that at basin-scale fishing, maritime transport and nutrient inputs from terrestrial sources would cause the most environmental impact, while aquaculture or offshore wind energy would cause more local impacts. These scenarios should inform evidence-based policy-making, for example for marine spatial planning by national administrations. Transformative pathways48 for the Black Sea blue economy were co-designed by coastal community stakeholders during six participatory living labs across the pilot sites, engaging a total of 162 organisations. These pathways can lead to shifts to a more sustainable, resilient and equitable state. Stakeholders identified challenges for a sustainable blue economy, agreed on a vision for 2050, and identified actions to transform blue economy sectors to reach this vision. Sectors analysed include aquaculture, tourism, marine renewable energy, marine environmental observation and management, fisheries, and the port and shipping sectors. Key actions identified include advancing technologies, digitalisation, training, and community engagement. Although stakeholders did not identify the need for holistic systems thinking, these actions do support the social-ecological resilience of coastal communities via learning and participation (i.e. monitoring, capacity building, stakeholder engagement). 46 https://bridgeblacksea.org/index.php/2025/03/14/bridge-bs-takes-you-to-the-future-of-the-black-sea-with-2050-sustainable-blue-economy-imaginaries-for-theblack-sea-report/ 47 Deliverable 4.4 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 48 Deliverable 6.3 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 Figure 4: Overview of training and capacity building activities supported by BRIDGE-BS. 9 ADVANCING BLACK SEA RESEARCH AND INNOVATION FOR A SUSTAINABLE BLUE ECONOMY Future research and policy needs To limit the impact of human activities on the health and resilience of the Black Sea, preserve core ecosystem services and provide a safe operating space for the development of a sustainable blue economy, the following actions should be achieved within the next five years. 49 Deliverable 7.2 will be available at https://zenodo.org/communities/bridge-bs/records?q=&l=list&p=1&s=10 Recommendations for policy makers • Develop and update blue economy strategies, regulations, and enforcement at national and regional level to align with the adaptive management recommendations developed by BRIDGE-BS, including to: prioritise small-scale fisheries; reinforce sustainable fisheries policies and ecosystem-based fisheries management; adopt green transport solutions for vessels and port infrastructure; develop offshore wind energy and sustainable aquaculture; reduce pollution from watersheds and coastal areas; and promote innovative and sustainable tourism; • Further strengthen the science-policy interface and dialogue in the Black Sea region by improving coordination between and supporting existing mechanisms e.g. the Black Sea Commission (BSC), Black Sea Economic Cooperation (BSEC), and the General Fisheries Commission for the Mediterranean and Black Sea (GFCM); • Implement systems and resilience thinking in the management of the Black Sea blue economy, and integrate participatory stakeholder approaches into adaptive management strategies using BRIDGE-BS scenario development and stakeholder engagement methods; • Developadedicatedfinancialframeworkforblueeconomygrants,financialincentives,andregionalcoordination among national level financing actors, and national and regional acceleration/incubation mechanisms49. A long-term framework to support future editions of the Black Sea Accelerator and the High Tech Summit to consolidate its role as a reference forum for regional innovation in the Black Sea should be established; • Implement a consistent ecosystem-based approach to marine spatial planning in each Black Sea country and at basinscale using the BRIDGE-BS tools. This will strengthen and ensure effective management of the current network of marine protected areas, including the regulation of human activities (e.g. fisheries, transport, tourism) in and around MPAs; • Update and harmonise marine monitoring programmes across Black Sea countries based on newly tested technologies, methods, protocols and data gaps identified within BRIDGE-BS. In addition, a regional monitoring framework should be established to harmonise socio-economic data collection and open access across Black Sea countries to feed into the blue economy observatory and link to the BRIDGE-BS DTO demonstrator; and • Support the continuation and expansion of capacity building activities developed under BRIDGE-BS including the Massive Open Online Course, Black Sea Young Ambassador programme, Virtual Blue Careers Centre, and the Black Sea Ocean Literacy Network.