scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

HIBOU 2030: an integrated method for the Hybrid assessment of the Interactions between the BiOdiversity, the nature-based solutions, and the Urban system

Centre Scientifique et Technique du Bâtiment

Abstract

The objective of this paper is to present the integrated method HIBOU 2030, which is employed to assess the efficiency of the Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) and their alternatives (e.g. grey, hybrid solutions) for urban projects. The HIBOU 2030 method aligns with international initiatives, such as the Science-based targets Network for nature[1] that promote the integrated assessment approaches. The HIBOU 2030 method is thus design to place the urban system integrating the NBS and theirs alternatives at the core of its approach, with the objective of contributing to several of the action-oriented global targets for 2030 outlined in the Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF)[2] such as: Target 11 - Restore, Maintain and Enhance Nature’s Contributions to People, the Target 12 - Enhance Green Spaces and Urban Planning for Human Well-Being and Biodiversity and the Target 14 - Integrate Biodiversity in Decision-Making at Every Level. HIBOU 2030 is based on the hybridization of several area of expertise (e.g. Life Cycle Assessment, ecology, urban planning, etc.) and its fundamental principles are as follows: 1) interactions (both positive and negative ) between biodiversity, NBS and the urban project occur on the project site (in situ) but also on global scale (ex-situ) 2) the multifunctionality of NBS is one of the answers to numerous urban challenges and it must be taken into account in the analysis of the results; 3) the integrated approach necessitates the establishment of a shared semantics among the various fields of expertise; a common macro-model to characterize the system to be assessed and the different development options; the interdependence of results for each issue. Consequently, a parameter variation to address one of the questions will inherently influence the others. HIBOU 2030 method and its associated toolset facilitate the assessment the urban project’s contribution to the following urban challenges: 1) the climate change (1 indicator); 2) the biodiversity in situ and ex situ (8 indicators). These indicators are designed to address as much as possible of the five pressures on the biodiversity: global warming, land use change, pollution, overexploitation of resources, introduction of invasive species; 3) the stormwater management (1 indicator); 4) the urban heat island (UHI) mitigation (1 to 3 indicators); 5) the urban quality for the citizens, based on a qualitative assessment grid considering 24 criteria. HIBOU 2030 is a tool used to conduct expertise and research studies, thereby supporting various stakeholders’ analyses and decision-making processes concerning construction and renovation actions for buildings and urban projects. Continuous improvement is achieved through the collection and analysis of feedback from its use in various European contexts.

Full text

HIBOU An integrated method for the Hybrid assessment of the Impacts and Benefits of the nature-based sOlutions in Urban system SCHIOPU Nicoleta, BRACHET Aline, FARDEL Alexandre, KYRIAKODIS Georgios, BAILLY Emeline, FIES Bruno, SABRE Maeva CSTB –Centre Scientifique et Technique du Bâtiment, France 2025, April 29th nicoleta.schiop[email protected] 2 HIBOU Integrated method for the Hybrid assessment of the Impacts and Benefits of the naturebased sOlutions in Urban systems N a t u r e B a s e d S o l u t i o n s t o a d d r e s s u r b a n c h a l l e n g e s HIBOU The aim of the method 3 The aim of the method Assess the efficiency of the Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) for urban projects, based on an integrated approach, by considering: ➢their benefits (e.g. for summer heat or stormwater management, for biodiversity, etc.) & ➢their impacts (e.g. on water consumption, on carbone emissions, etc.) versus or in synergy with theirs alternatives (e.g. air conditioning, stormwater harvesting, etc.) to adress the various urban challenges 4 The main principles of the method 1) the interactions (benefits & impacts) between the NBS and the urban project take place: ▪on the project site (in situ), but also ▪at the global scale (ex-situ) 2) the multifunctionality (i.e. provide multiple benefits simultaneously) of the NBS should be considered in the results analysis of impacts ; 3) the integrated approach implies: - a common macro-model for characterizing the system to be assessed; -shared semantics and ontology across different areas of expertise (biodiversity, hydrology, etc.); - the interdependence of the results for each adressed challenge. 5 The overall approach A set of quantitative and qualitative indicators, based on the hybridization of various scientific methods, according to the integrated approach principles (shared semantics and ontology, common macromodel, and results interdependence) Ecology Building and Urban planning Sciences Risk analysis Environmental Sciences Life Cycle Assessment Ec olo gy Enviro nment al scienc e Life Cycl e Ass ess men t N a t u r e B a s e d S o l u t i o n s t o a d d r e s s u r b a n c h a l l e n g e s HIBOU © CSTB, Freepik 6 The use cases The present version of the HIBOU method & associated toolset allow to assess the urban projects contribution to: ✓the climate change impact (1 indicator); ✓the biodiversity in situ and ex situ,by using a family of 9 indicators to cover as much as possible the five pressures on the biodiversity (global warming, land use change, pollution, overexploitation of resources, introduction of invasive species); ✓the stormwater management (2 indicators); ✓the urban heat island (UHI) effect and mitigation strategies (1 to 3 indicators); ✓the urban quality for the citizens, based on a qualitative assessment grid considering 24 criteria. 7 Indicators, based on the integrated method Reference values Target & solutions Collaborative approach to meet the final goal of the HIBOU method: contribute to the definition of the pathways to reach the targets in addressing the various urban challenges through the identification and promotion of the most suitable solutions in each context The framework of the development For each indicator: ➢Absolute value ➢Normalized value % of the max. potential at the time of the study and considering the local constraints of each project e.g. for the in-situ Biodiversity (indicator : harmonized Biotype Area Factor (0-1), BAFh), if the maximum BAFh of the project site is 0.6 and the BAFh for the designed project is 0.48, then the project reaches 80% of the maximum potential. 8 HIBOU application in WILSON project https://wilson-project.eu/ 9 Assessment of an urban project, considering the NBS and other interventions: the renovation actions for the existing buildings, the new buildings construction, the landscaping of outdoor spaces Risk management Urban Heat Island (UHI) HIBOU application in WILSON project In situ Biodiversity Land use change and occupation Environmental footprint Climate change Ex - situ Biodiversity PDF.m².an PDF : Potentially Disappeared Fraction of species Kg eq CO2 /m² BAFh: Harmonized Biotype Area Factor (0-1) ∆T °C Simulated temperature difference between the project site in urban area and its surrounding rural areas