Quantum Mechanics and Mathematical Economics are Isomorphic. John von Neumann between Physics and Economics

Lambe ini, Luca Wo king Pape Quan um Mechanics and Ma hema ical Economics a e Isomo phic. John on Neumann be ween Physics and Economics Quade ni - Wo king Pape DSE, No. 370 P o ided in Coope a ion wi h: Uni e si y o Bologna, Depa men o Economics Sugges ed Ci a ion: Lambe ini, Luca (2000) : Quan um Mechanics and Ma hema ical Economics a e Isomo phic. John on Neumann be ween Physics and Economics, Quade ni - Wo king Pape DSE, No. 370, Alma Ma e S udio um - Uni e si à di Bologna, Dipa imen o di Scienze Economiche (DSE), Bologna, h ps://doi.o g/10.6092/unibo/amsac a/4939 This Ve sion is a ailable a : h ps://hdl.handle.ne /10419/159211 S anda d-Nu zungsbedingungen: Die Dokumen e au EconS o dü en zu eigenen wissenscha lichen Zwecken und zum P i a geb auch gespeiche und kopie we den. Sie dü en die Dokumen e nich ü ö en liche ode komme zielle Zwecke e iel äl igen, ö en lich auss ellen, ö en lich zugänglich machen, e eiben ode ande wei ig nu zen. So e n die Ve asse die Dokumen e un e Open-Con en -Lizenzen (insbesonde e CC-Lizenzen) zu Ve ügung ges ell haben soll en, gel en abweichend on diesen Nu zungsbedingungen die in de do genann en Lizenz gewäh en Nu zungs ech e. Te ms o use: Documen s in EconS o may be sa ed and copied o you pe sonal and schola ly pu poses. You a e no o copy documen s o public o comme cial pu poses, o exhibi he documen s publicly, o make hem publicly a ailable on he in e ne , o o dis ibu e o o he wise use he documen s in public. I he documen s ha e been made a ailable unde an Open Con en Licence (especially C ea i e Commons Licences), you may exe cise u he usage igh s as speci ied in he indica ed licence. h ps://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by-nc/3.0/ Txdqwxp Ph kdql dqg Pdwkhpdwl do H q pl duh L p uskl M kq y q Qhxpdqq ehwzhhq Sk| l dq g H q pl 4 Ox d Odpehuwlql Ghsduwphqw i H q pl Xqlyhu lw| i E o jqd Vwudgd Pdjjl uh 78/ 73458 E o jqd/ Lwdo| id{= .6<0384053<5997 h0pdlo= odpehuwlC se 1xqle 1lw Iheuxdu| 5</ 5333 4 L z xog olnh w wkdqn Hqql Fdyd}}xwl/ Pd lp Pdulqd l/ Vwhskhq Pduwlq/ Pdqxhod P d dqg Ul dug U yhool i u pphqw dqg gl x l q1 Wkh x xdo gl odlphu dssolh 1 De wud w D phwk g o jl do gl x l q l su s hg/ dlplqj dw k zlqj wkdw jdph wkh0 u| lq sduwl xodu +dqg pdwkhpdwl do h q pl lq jhqhudo, dqg xdqwxp ph kdql duh l p uskl 1 Wkl uh xow uholh q wkh h xlydohq h i wkh wz ixqgdphqwdo shudw u hpso |hg lq wkh wz hog / qdpho|/ wkh h{sh whg ydoxh lq h q pl dqg wkh ghq lw| pdwul{ lq xdqwxp sk| l 1 Wkl lq lghq h dq eh wud hg ed n w wkh qwulexwl q i y q Qhxpdqq lq e wk gl lsolqh 1 MHO Fod l dwl q= E58/ E74/ F:3 Nh|z ug = h{sh whg ydoxh/ ghq lw| pdwul{/ xq huwdlqw| 4 Lqwu gx wl q Ryhu wkh od w iwhhq |hdu / d ju zlqj dp xqw i dwwhqwl q kd ehhq ghy whg w wkh kl w u| i jdph wkh u|1 Dp qj wkhu uhd q / wkl lqwhuh w dq odujho| eh mx wlhg q wkh ed l i wkh Q eho sul}h w Qd k/ Kdu dq|l dqg Vhowhq lq 4<<71 4 K zhyhu/ wkh olwhudwxuh ghdolqj zlwk wkh kl w u| i jdph wkh u| pdlqo| dg sw dq lqqhu shu sh wlyh/ l1h1/ dq dqjoh wkdw doo z x w uh q wux w wkh ghyho sphqw i wkl xe0gl lsolqh xqghu wkh jhqhudo khdglqj i h q pl 1 P| dlp l glhuhqw/ w wkh h{whqw wkdw L lqwhqg w su s h dq lqwhusuhwdwl q i wkh i updo uhodwl q kls ehwzhhq jdph wkh u| +dqg h q pl , dqg wkh kdug lhq h 1 D odujho| d hswhg ylhz pdlqwdlq wkdw wkh i xqgdwl q i e wk jdph wkh0 u| dqg/ lq jhqhudo/ qwhps udu| pdwkhpdwl do h q pl duh w eh i xqg lq Wkh Wkh u| i Jdph dqg H q pl Ehkdyl u +y q Qhxpdqq dqg P u0 jhq whuq/ 4< 77,1 5 Iu p wkdw z un qzdug / zh e huyh wkh zlgh suhdg x h i wkh shudw u nq zq d h{sh whg ydoxh lq h q pl 1 Wudglwl qdoo|/ dqg uuh wo|/ wkh u w i x k shudw u duh wud hg ed n w wdwl wl + hh Il k0 exuq dqg Zdnnhu/ 4<<8/ dqg wkh uhihuhq h wkhuhlq,1 K zhyhu/ wkl ylhz 4 Rq wkh kl w u| i jdph wkh u|/ hh Dxpdqq +4<;8/ 4<;:/ 4<<<,/ Zhlqwudxe +4<<5,/ Oh qdug +4<<7/ 4<<8, dqg P|hu q +4<<<,/ lqwhu dold 1 Rq wkh dssudl do i wkh u oh i jdph wkh u| lq qwhps udu| h q pl / hh ydq Gdpph dqg Zhlexoo +4<<8,1 5 Lq y q Qhxpdqq dqg P ujhq whuq +4<77,/ wkh q hsw i wdeoh hw i u shudwlyh jdph psohphqw wkh plqlpd{ wkh uhp +y q Qhxpdqq/ 4<5;, i u q q shudwlyh jdph 1 K zhyhu/ wkh odwwhu l dssol deoh qo| lq }hu xp jdph 1 Qd k +4<83, lqwu gx hg dq h xloleulxp q hsw i u q q0}hu xp q q shudwlyh jdph / dqg wkh edujdlqlqj oxwl q i u shudwlyh jdph +Qd k/ 4<84,1 4 g h q w jud s dq lqwhuh wlqj d sh w lq pp q ehwzhhq pdwkhpdwl do h 0 q pl dqg sk| l / lq sduwl xodu xdqwxp sk| l / wkdw l / wkh id w wkdw e wk wkh ulh wudq plw d odujho| dqdo j x ph djh q huqlqj xu nq zohgjh + u uhsuh hqwdwl q, i uhdo z uog skhq phqd1 Rxu h{ dqwh nq zohgjh +l1h1/ xu i uh d wlqj dsdelolw|, l ghqhg lq wkh dph su edelol wl whup / lqghshq0 ghqwo| i zkhwkhu zh h{dplqh wkh ehkdyl xu i xedw pl sduwl oh u wkh ehkdyl xu i up dqg q xphu 1 Zkdw L zdqw w k z lq wkh uhpdlqghu l wkdw wkl lq lghq h +s lqwlqj xowlpdwho| w wkh lghd wkdw xu nq zohgjh l p ghoohg lq wkh dph zd| luuh0 sh wlyho| i wkh sh l hog 6 ,/ kd ehhq odujho| kdshg wku xjk wkh d wlylw| i d lqjoh uh hdu khu/ M kq y q Qhxpdqq/ zk / yhu d g }hq |hdu +4<650 77, kd c{hg* wkh ed l lghd lq e wk gl lsolqh e| jlylqj wkhp wkh dph phwk g o j|/ wkx pdnlqj wkhp odujho| l p u skl w hd k wkhu1 Wkh nh| w wkl lqwhusuhwdwl q l wkh shudw u odehoohg d h{sh whg ydoxh e| h q pl w dqg ghq lw| pdwul{ e| sk| l l w 1 Lq wkh u w hglwl q +lq Jhupdq, i Pdwkhpdwl do I xqgdwl q i Txdqwxp Ph kdql / y q Qhxpdqq +4<65, dg sw wkh whup Huzduwxqj zhuw / zkl k lq Hqjol k l h{sh wdwl q ydoxh 1 Wkl do dsshdu lq y q Qhxpdqq dqg P ujhq whuq +4<77,/ zkloh lq wkh i oo zlqj h q pl olwhudwxuh lw x xdoo| eh ph h{sh whg ydoxh 1 Lq sk| l / h{sh wdwl q ydoxh l x hg w lqgl dwh wkh hohphqwdu| q wl q i wkh pdwkhpdwl do h{sh wdwl q i d udqg p yduldeoh/ zkloh ghq lw| pdwul{ lqgl dwh / udwkhu o ho| shdnlqj/ wkh udqg p xw ph i dq h{shulphqw1 Lq wkh i oo zlqj h wl q/ L hu d x lq w ylhz i wkh i updo h xlydohq h 6 Rq wkl l xh/ hh Shqu h +4<;<,1 5 ehwzhhq wkh wz wkh ulh +dqg wkh zd| wkh| exlog xs wkhlu suhgl wlyh s zhu,/ wku xjk d zhoo nq zq sdudeoh lq xdqwxp sk| l 1 5 Wkh l p uskl p ehwzhhq pdwkhpdwl do h 0 q pl dqg xdqwxp sk| l = d nhw k Txdqwxp sk| l +dqg lw su shu xe hw/ xdqwxp ph kdql , dq dssu {0 lpdwho| eh q lghuhg +q w doo sk| l l w djuhh q wkl pdwwhu, d d jhq0 hudol dwl q i Qhzw qldq sk| l +dqg ph kdql ,1 Lq sduwl xodu/ zkhq wkh skhq phqd ehlqj lqyh wljdwhg lqy oyh +l, shhg zkl k duh q lghudeo| o zhu wkdq wkh shhg i oljkw lq yd xxp> +ll, x! lhqwo| o z judylw|> dqg +lll, e0 mh w zkl k duh qhlwkhu w pdoo q u w elj/ wkhq qh dq su hhg d uglqj w wkh wdqgdug Qhzw qldq p gho1 hw/ zkhq lw ph hlwkhu w wkh yhu| ed l sduwl oh +h1j1/ xe0dw pl sduwl oh olnh hoh wu q ,/ u w wkh ehkdyl xu i emh w kdud whul hg e| dq h{wuhpho| kljk judylwdwl qdo i u h +h1j1/ eod n k oh / xd du dqg sxo du ,/ xdqwdo ihdwxuh eh ph uhohydqw wkdw wkh| dqq w eh gl uhjdughg1 D dq loox wudwlyh h{dpsoh/ q lghu wkh w u| wudglwl qdoo| nq zq d V kuùglqjhu* sdudg { u V kuùglqjhu* dw0lq0wkh0e { / zkl k L dp de xw w whoo d uglqj w d yxojdwd pp qo| dg swhg lq wkh xuuhqw olwhudwxuh lq wkh hog1 7 7 Huzlq V ukùglqjhu/ w jhwkhu zlwk E ku/ Hlq whlq/ Glud / Khl hqehuj dqg Sdxol/ l qh i wkh i xqglqj idwkhu i xdqwxp sk| l 1 Wkh uhpdlqghu i wkl h wl q e uu z iu p Kdz nlqj dqg Shqu h +4<<9, dqg Shqu h +4<<:,1 I u ixuwkhu +dqg px k p uh wh kql do, uhdglqj / hh Vdnxudl +4<;8,/ V kzdeo +4<<5,/ dqg Jd l u zl } +4<<9,/ lqwhu dold 1 6 Wkl sdudg { uhihu w dq h{shulphqw/ zkhuh d dw l o nhg lq d e {/ lq iu qw i d kdqgjxq/ zkl k l o dghg1 8 Wkh e { l sd xh w e wk oljkw dqg xqg/ wkdw wkh sk| l l w px w shq lw w e huyh wkh dw* qglwl q 1 Wkh wuljjhu l olqnhg w d hq u/ o dwhg xw lgh wkh e {/ lq iu qw i d exoe1 D xph wkh sk| l l w dq zlw k q wkh exoe/ su gx lqj d lqjoh xdqwxp i oljkw +d sk w q, dw d wlph1 Wkh hq u phd xuh wkh slq i wkh sk w q1 Lq wkh uhpdlqghu/ L zloo d xph qyhqwl qdoo| wkh i oo zlqj1 Li wkh sk w q u wdwh uljkwzdug +l1h1/ wkh slq l s lwlyh,/ wkhq wkh hq u sxoo wkh u sh +dqg wkh wuljjhu,/ dqg wkh kdqgjxq k w wkh dw ghdg1 Li lq whdg wkh sk w q u wdwh ohiwzdug +l1h1/ wkh slq l qhjdwlyh,/ wkhq wkh hq u g h q w sxoo wkh u sh +dqg wkh wuljjhu,/ wkdw wkh dw xuylyh 1 Wkh sdudg { wdnh sod h lq wkh sk| l l w* plqg ehi uh wkh h{shulphqw l duulhg xw/ u/ h xlydohqwo|/ ehi uh kh shq wkh e { w hh zkhwkhu wkh dw l wloo dolyh u q w1 Wkh sk| l l w nq z wkdw/ h{ s w / wkh dw l j lqj w eh hlwkhu ghdg u dolyh1 K zhyhu/ h{ dqwh / wkh wz wdwh i wkh | whp0 dw +l1h1/ dolyh dqg ghdg , d zhoo d wkh wz wdwh i wkh z uog +wkdw dq eh odehoohg d wkh kdqgjxq k w eh dx h wkh slq zd s lwlyh / dqg wkh kdqgjxq glgq *w k w eh dx h wkh slq zd qhjdwlyh , h{l w lq wkh h{shulphqwhu* plqg1 Wkl sdudg { shu l w xqwlo kh shq wkh e { w e huyh wkh dw* 8 Wkl dq eh ylhzhg d d Jhgdqnhqh{shulphqw +wk xjkw h{shulphqw,/ lq wkdw zh px w q w qh h dulo| o n d dw lqw d e { w yhuli| wkh ydolglw| i zkdw i oo z 1 Lq jhqhudo/ d Jhgdqnhqh{shulphqw l q l whqw zlwk wkh nq zq odz i sk| l / hyhq wk xjk lw pd| q w eh wh kql doo| ihd leoh1 V / phd xulqj wkh d hohudwl q gxh w judylw| q wkh xuid h i wkh xq l d Jhgdqnhqh{shulphqw / zkhuhd phd xulqj wkh G ssohu kliw i xqoljkw d hhq iu p d sd h kls p ylqj zlwk wzl h wkh yho lw| i oljkw l q q hq h +Jd l u zl }/ 4<<9/ s1 54/ iq1 4 7,1 Lq wkh suh hqw d h/ uhsod h wh kql doo| ihd leoh zlwk s olwl doo| uuh w 1 7 khdowk qglwl q 1 L zloo i updol h wkh h{shulphqw e| lqwu gx lqj wkh i oo zlqj= Ghqlwl q 4  i S@cS_ j l wkh zdyh ixq wl q/ u wkh wdwh yh w u i wkh | whp +wkh dw,1 Lq Ghqlwl q 4/ lqwxlwlyho|/ S@ ' wkh dw l dolyh> S_ ' wkh dw l ghdg1 P uh yhu/ Ghqlwl q 5 i i  c_ j l wkh yh w u i wkh wdwh i wkh z uog1 Lq Ghqlwl q 5/ lqwxlwlyho|/  ' wkh kdqgjxq k w +eh dx h wkh slq zd s lwlyh,> _ ' wkh kdqgjxq glg q w k w +eh dx h wkh slq zd qhjdwlyh,1 Ilqdoo|/ zh kdyh Ghqlwl q 6 ) i S@cS_ j l wkh wdwh yh w u i wkh sk| l l w duu|lqj xw wkh h{shulphqw1 Wkh uhd q zk| ) hhp w lq lgh zlwk wkh zdyh ixq wl q  zloo eh ph ohdu lq wkh uhpdlqghu1 Wkh h{ dqwh yhuodsslqj ehwzhhq wkh wdwh i wkh | whp/ l d xqwhg i u e| wkh w wdo wdwh yh w u i wkh | whp = m  |J| l ' / m S@ l n 4 m S_ l +4, zkhuh e wk / dqg 4 eho qj w F dqg ml l doohg nhw 1 Lw psohphqw km l doohg eud / dqg kml l doohg Glud * eud nhw / diwhu S1D1P1 Glud zk lqwu gx hg wkl whuplq o j| lq 4<63 + hh Glud / 4<63/ 4<8; e > hh do Glud / 4<58,1 8 D q d wkh h{shulphqwhu shq wkh e { w e huyh wkh wdwh i wkh | whp/ wkh zdyh ixq wl q  oods h / wkdw l / wkhuh wdnh sod h wkh 0 doohg uhgx wl q i wkh wdwh yh w u m  |J| l  Khq h/ wkh h{shulphqwhu e huyh hlwkhu S @ u S_ / exw xuho| q w e wk wdwh dw wkh dph wlph1 Rq wkh qwudu|/ d o qj d wkh h{shulphqwhu g h q w shq wkh e {/ wkh wz wdwh h{l w lq d xdqwdo hq h 1 9 I u uhd q wkdw L g q w gzhoo xs q khuh/ / dqg 4 duh psoh{ qxpehu 1 : Lq sduwl xodu/ zkdw L dp lqwhuh whg lq/ l wkh lqi updwl q wkdw wkh p gxox i e wk / dqg 4 l h xdo w  * s 2  W wkh xduh/ wkl |lhog  * 2 c zkl k l wkh su edelolw| wkdw wkh sk w q kdyh hlwkhu d s lwlyh u d qhjdwlyh slq1 Wkl / d zh kdoo hh lq wkh uhpdlqghu/ kd uhohydqw ehdulqj xs q p| dlp i k zlqj wkh h{l whq h i dq l p uskl p ehwzhhq xdqwxp sk| l dqg pdwkhpdwl do h q pl +jdph wkh u| lq sduwl xodu,1 Wkh w wdo wdwh yh w u i wkh h{shulphqwhu dq eh q wux whg w o n olnh wkdw i wkh | whp +exw uh doo wkdw wkh wz yh w u g q w lq lgh ,= k ) |J| m ' / k S@ m n 4 k S_ m c/ ' 4 ' * s 2  +5, Lq su edelol wl whup / wkh h{shulphqwhu* h{ dqwh nq zohgjh de xw wkh wdwh wkdw wkh | whp dq wdnh h{ s w l xppdul hg e| wkh 0 doohg ghq lw| pdwul{ = ( '  2 m S@ lk S@ m n 2 m S_ lk S_ m c +6, 9 Sk| l l w kdyh olyho| dujxphqw q huqlqj wkh dowhuqdwlyh lqwhusuhwdwl q i x k d wdwhphqw/ l1h1/ zkhwkhu wdwh d dqg g h{l w lq sdudooho xqlyhu h u lq wkh h{shul0 phqwhu* plqg1 D idu d wkh suh hqw sdshu l q huqhg wkl gl wlq wl q/ dowk xjk lqwuljx0 lqj/ dq eh gl uhjdughg1 : Vhh wkh dsshqgl{1 I u ixuwkhu gl x l q/ hh/ lqwhu dold / Vdnxudl +4<;8,/ V kzdeo +4<<5, dqg Jd l u zl } +4<<9,1 9 Uhihuhq h ^4` Dnhuo i/ J1 +4<:3,/ Wkh Pdunhw i u Ohp q = Txdolw| Xq huwdlqw| dqg wkh Pdunhw Ph kdql p/ Txduwhuo| M xuqdo i H q pl / ;7 / 7;;08331 ^5` Dxpdqq/ U1M1 +4<;8,/ Zkdw L Jdph Wkh u| Wu|lqj w D p sol kB/ lq Duu z/ N1 dqg V1 K qnds kmd +hg 1,/ Iu qwlhu lq H q pl / R{i ug/ Eod nzhoo1 ^6` Dxpdqq/ U1M1 +4<;:,/ Jdph Wkh u|/ lq Hdwzhoo/ M1/ P1 Plojdwh dqg S1 Qhzpdq +hg 1,/ Wkh Qhz Sdojudyh= D Gl wl qdu| i H q pl / O qg q/ Pd ploodq1 ^7` Dxpdqq/ U1M1 +4<<<,/ Jdph Wkh u| lq L udho= O nlqj Ed nzdug dqg I uzdug/ sdshu suh hqwhg dw DVVHW<</ Who Dyly/ R w ehu 43044/ 4<<<1 ^8` Ed dq/ E1/ P1 V du lql dqg V1 ]dplu +4<<:,/ L G q *w Zdqw w Nq z$ Fdq Lw Eh Udwl qdoB gl x l q sdshu q1 48;/ Fhqwhu i u Udwl qdolw| dqg Lqwhud wlyh Gh l l q Wkh u|/ Wkh Kheuhz Xqlyhu lw| i Mhux dohp1 ^9` Glud / S1D1P1 +4<58,/ Wkh Ixqgdphqwdo H xdwl q i Txdqwxp Ph0 kdql / Su 1 U |1 V 1 +O qg q, D/ 43< / 97509861 ^:` Glud / S1D1P1 +4<63/ 4<8; e ,/ Wkh Sulq lsoh i Txdqwxp Ph kdql / R{i ug/ R{i ug Xqlyhu lw| Suh 1 ^;` Il kexuq/ S1 dqg S1 Zdnnhu +4<<8,/ Wkh Lqyhqwl q i wkh Lqghshqghq h F qglwl q i u Suhihuhq h / Pdqdjhphqw V lhq h / 74 / 4463044771 ^<` Jd l u zl }/ V1 +4<<9,/ Txdqwxp Sk| l 1 Vh qg Hglwl q / Qhz un/ Zloh|1 46 ^43` Kdznlqj/ V1 dqg U1 Shqu h +4<<9,/ Wkh Qdwxuh i Vsd h dqg Wlph / Sulq hw q/ QM/ Sulq hw q Xqlyhu lw| Suh 1 ^44` Nohpshuhu/ S1 dqg Ph|hu/ P1 +4<;9,/ Sul h F pshwlwl q y Txdqwlw| F pshwlwl q= Wkh U oh i Xq huwdlqw|/ UDQG M xuqdo i H q pl / 4: / 94;06;1 ^45` Nohpshuhu/ S1 dqg Ph|hu/ P1 +4<;<,/ Vxsso| Ixq wl q H xloleuld lq Rolj s o| xqghu Xq huwdlqw|/ H q phwul d / 8: / 45760::1 ^46` Ohodqg/ K1 +4<:5,/ Wkh u| i wkh Ilup Id lqj Xq huwdlq Ghpdqg/ Dphul dq H q pl Uhylhz / 95 / 5:;0<41 ^47` Oh qdug/ U1M1 +4<<7,/ Uhdglqj F xuq w/ Uhdglqj Qd k= Wkh Fuhdwl q dqg Vwdelol dwl q i wkh Qd k H xloleulxp/ H q pl M xuqdo / 437 / 7<508441 ^48` Oh qdug/ U1M1 +4<<8,/ Iu p Sduo u Jdph w V ldo V lhq h= y q Qhx0 pdqq/ P ujhq whuq/ dqg wkh Fuhdwl q i Jdph Wkh u|/ M xuqdo i H q pl Olwhudwxuh / 66 / :630:941 ^49` P|hu q/ U1 +4<<< ,/ Qd k H xloleulxp dqg wkh Kl w u| i H q pl Wkh u|/ M xuqdo i H q pl Olwhudwxuh / 6 : / 439:043;51 ^4:` Qd k/ M1I1 +4<83,/ H xloleulxp S lqw lq q0Shu q Jdph / Su hhg0 lqj i wkh Qdwl qdo D dghp| i V lhq h i wkh XVD / 6 9 / 7;07<1 ^4;` Qd k/ M1I1 +4<84,/ Q q0F shudwlyh Jdph / Dqqdo i Pdwkhpdwl / 87 / 5;<05<81 47 ^4<` Shqu h/ U1 +4<;<,/ Wkh Hpshu u* Qhz Plqg / R{i ug/ R{i ug Xqlyhu0 lw| Suh 1 ^53` Shqu h/ U1 +4<<:,/ Wkh Odujh/ wkh Vpdoo dqg wkh Kxpdq Plqg / Fdp0 eulgjh/ Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhu lw| Suh 1 ^54` Vdnxudl/ M1M1 +4<;8,/ P ghuq Txdqwxp Ph kdql 1 Uhyl hg Hglwl q / Qhz un/ Dggl q0Zh oh|1 ^55` V kzdeo/ I1 +4<<5,/ Txdqwxp Ph kdql / Ehuolq/ Khlghoehuj/ Vsulqjhu0 Yhuodj1 ^56` ydq Gdpph/ H1 dqg M1 Zhlexoo +4<<8,/ H xloleulxp lq Vwudwhjl Lq0 whud wl q= Wkh F qwulexwl q i M kq F1 Kdu dq|l/ M kq I1 Qd k dqg Uhlqkdug Vhowhq/ V dqglqdyldq M xuqdo i H q pl / <: / 480731 ^57` y q Qhxpdqq/ M1 +4 < 5;,/ ]xu Wkh ulh ghu Jh hoo kdiw slhoh/ Pdwhp0 dwl kh Dqqdohq / 433 / 5<806531 ^58` y q Qhxpdqq/ M1 +4<65,/ Pdwkhpdwl kh Ju xqgodjhq ghu Txdqwhq0 ph kdqln / Vsulqjhu Yhuodj/ Ehuolq0Khlghoehuj + Pdwkhpdwl do I xqgd0 wl q i Txdqwxp Ph kdql / Sulq hw q/ QM/ Sulq hw q Xqlyhu lw| Suh / 4<88,1 ^59` y q Qhxpdqq/ M1 h R1 P ujhq whuq +4<77,/ Wkh Wkh u| i Jdph dqg H q pl Ehkdyl u / Sulq hw q/ QM/ Sulq hw q Xqlyhu lw| Suh 1 ^5:` Zhlqwudxe/ U1 +4<<5/ hg1/,/ W zdug d Kl w u| i Jdph Wkh u| /lq Kl w u| i S olwl do H q p| / 57 +Vxssohphqw,1 48