The interplay of values and skill: How do they impact graduates' employability?

Kruja, Alba Demneri; Hysaj, Belita; Oztas, Ahmet Article The interplay of values and skill: How do they impact graduates' employability? Administrative Sciences Provided in Cooperation with: MDPI – Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute, Basel Suggested Citation: Kruja, Alba Demneri; Hysaj, Belita; Oztas, Ahmet (2024) : The interplay of values and skill: How do they impact graduates' employability?, Administrative Sciences, ISSN 2076-3387, MDPI, Basel, Vol. 14, Iss. 9, pp. 1-17, https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci14090201 This Version is available at: https://hdl.handle.net/10419/321015 Standard-Nutzungsbedingungen: Die Dokumente auf EconStor dürfen zu eigenen wissenschaftlichen Zwecken und zum Privatgebrauch gespeichert und kopiert werden. Sie dürfen die Dokumente nicht für öffentliche oder kommerzielle Zwecke vervielfältigen, öffentlich ausstellen, öffentlich zugänglich machen, vertreiben oder anderweitig nutzen. Sofern die Verfasser die Dokumente unter Open-Content-Lizenzen (insbesondere CC-Lizenzen) zur Verfügung gestellt haben sollten, gelten abweichend von diesen Nutzungsbedingungen die in der dort genannten Lizenz gewährten Nutzungsrechte. Terms of use: Documents in EconStor may be saved and copied for your personal and scholarly purposes. You are not to copy documents for public or commercial purposes, to exhibit the documents publicly, to make them publicly available on the internet, or to distribute or otherwise use the documents in public. If the documents have been made available under an Open Content Licence (especially Creative Commons Licences), you may exercise further usage rights as specified in the indicated licence. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Citation: Kruja, Alba, Belita Hysaj, and Ahmet Oztas. 2024. The Interplay of Values and Skill: How Do They Impact Graduates’ Employability? Administrative Sciences 14: 201. https://doi.org/10.3390/ admsci14090201 Received: 25 July 2024 Revised: 26 August 2024 Accepted: 28 August 2024 Published: 2 September 2024 Copyright: © 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). administrative sciences Article The Interplay of Values and Skill: How Do They Impact Graduates’ Employability? Alba Kruja 1,* , Belita Hysaj 1and Ahmet Oztas 2 1Department of Business Administration, Epoka University, 1032 Tirana, Albania; [email protected] 2Department of Civil Engineering, Epoka University, 1032 Tirana, Albania; [email protected] *Correspondence: akr[email protected] Abstract: The purpose of this research is to explore the development of values and skills throughout university education and their subsequent manifestation in the workplace, with a particular focus on the impact on graduates’ employability and the creation of value for society. The study’s research question probes the dynamics of values, skills, employability, and social value creation by analyzing and evaluating the main missions of universities, which essentially involve teaching, researching, and extracurricular activities. An exploratory factor analysis is used to extract the relevant factors of graduates’ performance. A progressive model is developed pointing out the interplay of values and skills that lead to professional performance. The research comes up with practical and theoretical implications. It seeks to provide helpful findings for higher education institutions, industry, and policymakers in promoting the enhancement of graduates’ values and skills, ensuring their successful transition into the job market and generating long-term societal benefits. Keywords: higher education; values; skills; graduates’ employability 1. Introduction As the world becomes more interconnected and industries continue to evolve, employability has become a focal point for higher education institutions (HEIs) and employers worldwide. Employability encompasses a collection of accomplishments, abilities, knowledge, and individual traits that enhance graduates’ prospects of securing employment and thriving in their preferred professions, resulting in advantages for themselves, the labor force, the community, and the economy (Yorke 2006). The responsibility for fostering such crucial factors for employability in the workplace falls primarily on HEIs (Chetty 2012). The alignment of educational outcomes with the workforce needs to plays an essential role in promoting both individual socioeconomic mobility and national economic growth and competitiveness (Finley 2021, p. 4). The transformation of universities into hubs of practical learning and career preparation is becoming one of the main reasons why students decide to pursue a degree, as HEIs are constantly striving to bridge the gap between academia and industry essentially through teaching and extracurricular activities (Kuh 2008). This can be attributed to the growing recognition of the need for graduates to possess not only academic knowledge but also a diverse range of skills, attributes, and values. Nowadays, apart from the course edges, providing interdisciplinarity in trainings, enhancing collaboration within industry and with ecosystem stakeholders is crucial for sustainable growth (European Commission 2019;Kruja and Berisha 2021). This shift reflects a broader focus on the holistic development of students, equipping them with the values, skills, and attitudes critical for their overall growth and future professional opportunities. In this perspective, HEIs’ focus has switched, in addition to the acquisition of academic knowledge, to the development of values, skills, and attitudes that are critical for students’ general growth and future professional possibilities as well. Moreover, HEIs have been Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci14090201 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/admsci Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 2 of 17 pressured over the past few years to add activities beyond teaching and research, with a third mission depicted as “contribution to society” (Abreu et al. 2016;Compagnucci and Spigarelli 2020;Urdari et al. 2017). These “third mission activities arise from the need of higher education institutions to contribute to society in a meaningful way through knowledge and technology transfer, lifelong learning, entrepreneurship or exchanges of workers with business”. (Mora et al. 2015, p. 30). Hence, the development of values, skills, and attitudes is mainly conducted by accomplishing the three general missions of HEIs, as follows: teaching, researching, and contributing to society. By closely examining and evaluating the core missions of universities, this research seeks to unravel the intricate relationship between values, skills, employability, and societal impact. Understanding the interdependence of values and skills, as well as their joint influence on graduate performance, is critical for educational institutions, businesses, and policymakers alike. It is highly important to investigate the extent to which the development of values and skills at HEIs affects graduates’ capacity to effectively satisfy the demands of the labor market and simultaneously create value for society. This research examines the influence of developing values and skills via teaching, research, and extracurricular activities throughout the university, using Epoka University as a case study. Epoka University, located in Albania, has established itself as a distinguished institution of higher education that promotes a holistic approach to student growth (Epoka University 2023). The university serves as an exemplary case study for researching the impact of the cultivation of values and skills, guided by its commitment to academic excellence and the values outlined by the Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum (MCU), a global network of universities dedicated to fundamental values in higher education (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). Focusing on the individual student as the primary subject of investigation, the study examines how the values and skills developed through teaching, research, and extracurricular activities impact their employability and professional success. One pivot point is exploring how HEIs can contribute to developing factors essential to employability by fostering values and skills in their students. The study aims to add to the current literature on the influence of values and skills development in HEIs and sheds light on the practical consequences of these efforts in the context of Epoka University. This HEI has shown significant dedication to incorporating MCU principles and values throughout its educational activities such as teaching and the extracurriculars organized by the student clubs. This dedication lays solid groundwork for investigating the influence of these values on students’ growth and eventual professional achievement. The purpose of this research is to develop a comprehensive model that integrates both values and skills, fostered through the university’s teaching, research, and extracurricular activities, and to evaluate their impacts on graduates’ employability (Figure 1). In this perspective, the study seeks answers to the following research questions: RQ 1: How do the values and skills developed through academic and extracurricular activities during university affect graduates’ professional performance? RQ 2: How are the values and skills interrelated with each other? The study draws on information gathered at the 10th annual “Career Fair” at Epoka University, organized in May 2023. A purposive sample was obtained by surveying 52 companies, to assess the relationship between the acquired values, skills, and their work performances. Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 3 of 17 Adm. Sci. 2024, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 17 Figure 1. Research framework. 2. Literature Review 2.1. Employability, Skills, and Values Academic accomplishments are perceived as a crucial condition for the employment of university graduates (Brown et al. 2002; Yorke 2006). The gap among graduates’ fundamental competencies and labor market requirements is reported by many scholars worldwide (Ahmetaj et al. 2023; Al-Azzam 2022; Baird and Satyanarayana 2019; Houcine and Sofiane 2018; Jackson 2015). In addition to a university degree, employers have become increasingly specific in identifying the values and skills they desire, showcasing greater sophistication during their recruitment procedures (Harvey et al. 2002). The labor market is requesting graduates capable of adapting to dynamic environments, as well as working with divergent groups (Tomlinson 2023). Communication skills are listed continuously among the most crucial skills during the requitement process (Armstrong and Landers 2018). They are clearly expressing their belief that a university degree should encompass far more than just a certain number of courses (Kuh 2008), as there is room for improvement in the development of students’ broader skills and qualities, such as teamwork, communication, leadership, critical thinking, and problem solving (Lowden et al. 2011). For graduates to attain sustainable employment, it is advised that universities enhance their current curriculum frameworks by emphasizing a greater focus on the employability skills and values that are highly sought after by the labor market (Fenta et al. 2019; GarcíaÁlvarez et al. 2022). Taking into consideration such shortcomings, curriculum frameworks are now incorporating attitudes and values more extensively, recognizing that competencies go beyond academic knowledge and skills (OECD 2019). Hence, students emphasize the importance of communication skills, teamwork, time management, responsibility, and decision-making skills as competencies acquired during their time in university, which have proven to be beneficial in their present professional roles (Alanazi and Benlaria 2023; Catacutan et al. 2020; Kruja and Kadiasi 2020; Sermsuk et al. 2014; Zenelaj and Kruja 2017). Other useful skills also include problem solving, professionalism, leadership, multicultural fluency, and analytical thinking (National Association of Colleges and Employers 2022). However, it is of high importance to note that academic knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values do not exist in isolation; rather, they evolve in an interconnected manner (OECD 2019). Interacting and collaborating are crucial for gaining a broad scope of “skills, attitudes, and experiences” facilitated by common “values, goals, and expectation” (Haste 2018). As educational institutions, organizations, professional environments, and communities become increasingly diverse in terms of ethnicity, culture, and language, highlighting the interdependence of knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values becomes increasingly crucial. Gamage et al. (2021, p. 20) consider values as crucial “social or soft skills” that Activities Values Skills Employability Figure 1. Research framework. 2. Literature Review 2.1. Employability, Skills, and Values Academic accomplishments are perceived as a crucial condition for the employment of university graduates (Brown et al. 2002;Yorke 2006). The gap among graduates’ fundamental competencies and labor market requirements is reported by many scholars worldwide (Ahmetaj et al. 2023;Al-Azzam 2022;Baird and Satyanarayana 2019;Houcine and Sofiane 2018;Jackson 2015). In addition to a university degree, employers have become increasingly specific in identifying the values and skills they desire, showcasing greater sophistication during their recruitment procedures (Harvey et al. 2002). The labor market is requesting graduates capable of adapting to dynamic environments, as well as working with divergent groups (Tomlinson 2023). Communication skills are listed continuously among the most crucial skills during the requitement process (Armstrong and Landers 2018). They are clearly expressing their belief that a university degree should encompass far more than just a certain number of courses (Kuh 2008), as there is room for improvement in the development of students’ broader skills and qualities, such as teamwork, communication, leadership, critical thinking, and problem solving (Lowden et al. 2011). For graduates to attain sustainable employment, it is advised that universities enhance their current curriculum frameworks by emphasizing a greater focus on the employability skills and values that are highly sought after by the labor market (Fenta et al. 2019;García-Álvarez et al. 2022). Taking into consideration such shortcomings, curriculum frameworks are now incorporating attitudes and values more extensively, recognizing that competencies go beyond academic knowledge and skills (OECD 2019). Hence, students emphasize the importance of communication skills, teamwork, time management, responsibility, and decision-making skills as competencies acquired during their time in university, which have proven to be beneficial in their present professional roles (Alanazi and Benlaria 2023;Catacutan et al. 2020;Kruja and Kadiasi 2020;Sermsuk et al. 2014;Zenelaj and Kruja 2017). Other useful skills also include problem solving, professionalism, leadership, multicultural fluency, and analytical thinking (National Association of Colleges and Employers 2022). However, it is of high importance to note that academic knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values do not exist in isolation; rather, they evolve in an interconnected manner (OECD 2019). Interacting and collaborating are crucial for gaining a broad scope of “skills, attitudes, and experiences” facilitated by common “values, goals, and expectation” (Haste 2018). As educational institutions, organizations, professional environments, and communities become increasingly diverse in terms of ethnicity, culture, and language, highlighting the interdependence of knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values becomes increasingly crucial. Gamage et al. (2021, p. 20) consider values as crucial “social or soft skills” that students should not only acquire within educational institutions but practice as well. Recognizing Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 4 of 17 shared social values and norms, in turn, could empower individuals to engage in collective action to bring about social change (Haste 2018, p. 13). Moreover, the OECD Learning Compass 2030 defines attitudes and values as the principles and beliefs that influence one’s choices, judgements, behaviors, and actions on the path towards individual, societal, and environmental well-being (OECD 2019, p. 4). Advancing attitudes and values through HEIs is continuously promoted in international forums (OECD 2019). Hence, it is crucial that HEIs define their values through brief words or statements with the purpose of directing and informing policy or behavior (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). Expressed values through diverse international organizations are reported in the Table 1below. Table 1. Values as expressed by diverse organizations. Organization Values Observatory Magna Carta Universitatum Included as important values universities should adhere to are “academic freedom”, “institutional autonomy”, “social responsibility”, “integrity”, “fairness”, “equity”, “creativity”, “innovation”, “excellence”, “community service”, “diversity”, and “inclusiveness”. OECD Global Competency Framework Includes values (“valuing human dignity” and “valuing cultural diversity”) as guiding principles for attitudes, such as “openness towards people from other cultures”, “respect for cultural otherness”, “global mindedness”, and “responsibility” Sustainable Development Goal 4.7 on Education Focuses on Global Citizenship Education and Education for Sustainable Development; knowledge of global issues and universal values, such as “justice”, “equality”, “dignity”, and “respect”, as well as aptitudes for “networking and interacting with people of different backgrounds, origins, cultures and perspectives”, and behavioral capacities to “act collaboratively and responsibly to find global solutions for global challenges” and to “strive for the collective good” Council of Europe Competence Framework for Democratic Culture Includes values (e.g., “human dignity and human rights”, “cultural diversity”, and “democracy, justice, fairness, equality and the rule of law”) and attitudes (e.g., “openness to cultural otherness and other beliefs”, “world views and practices”, “respect”, “civic-mindedness”, “responsibility”, “self-efficacy”, and “tolerance of ambiguity”) G7 Summit Leaders’ Declaration 2016 Recognizes the importance of common values and principles for all humanity (e.g., “freedom”, “democracy and respect for privacy”, “human rights”, and “human dignity”) at a time of violent extremism, terrorist attacks, and other challenges United Nations instruments Values articulated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the UN Charter, and the UN Millennium Declaration include “equality”, “freedom”, “justice”, “dignity”, “solidarity”, “tolerance”, “peace and security”, and “sustainable development” Source: (adapted from OECD 2019;Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). Among such notable organizations, the “Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum” takes a prominent role, as it is dedicated to helping universities across the globe establish, pursue, and embody their values effectively. Referring to MCU principles, values are crucial to helping universities understand and identify themselves and communicate that identity and mission to stakeholders, namely, students, employers, etc. (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). The complexity and uncertainty faced by universities today are monumental, arising from the ever-expanding expectations of students and employers, the shifting dynamics of national and international politics, heightened competition for students and funding, challenges posed by internationalization, and the rapid evolution of technology. Values, which have been essential to universities since their creation, remain important tools in effectively overcoming these challenges (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). Moreover, evidence suggests that endorsing value-related behavioral intentions is key for academics, HEIs, and other stakeholders (Moosmayer 2012). Hence, by reverting to the understanding of values as a set of guiding principles, employers can also gain enormous benefits (Gamage et al. 2021;Palmer et al. 2004). According to the MCU framework, the most important values that universities should adhere to are academic freedom, institutional autonomy, social responsibility, integrity, fairness, equity, creativity, innovation, excellence, community service, diversity, and in- Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 5 of 17 clusiveness (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). Studies show that students recognize the significance of corporate social responsibility in an academic context, as evidenced by their level of engagement in activities related to this concept (Burcea and Marinescu 2011). This means that the higher education sector and the corporate world share common ground when it comes to social responsibility, and instilling this value in students during their university experience could be a powerful catalyst to address the new realities of the environment and society. Among many other benefits, social responsibility has been proven to enhance workplace safety and make meaningful contributions to a company’s long-term growth (Koo and Ki 2020). Similarly, community service has proven to be advantageous to students, fostering their professional, personal, and academic development (Donnison and Itter 2010). Students who are more aware of integrity see this value as an important element of both academic and graduate life (Anohina-Naumeca et al. 2020). 2.2. Extracurricular Activities With the labor market becoming more competitive, a greater emphasis is placed on students’ development of “soft skills” through extracurricular activities or work experience (Al-Najjar and Merhi 2022;Fisher 2013;Kruja and Kalluci 2021). Research has evidenced that acquiring compatible skills and competencies with the labor market during university is crucial for the employability of graduates (Al-Azzam 2022;Alanazi and Benlaria 2023; Baird and Satyanarayana 2019;Houcine and Sofiane 2018;Qenani et al. 2014). Griffiths et al. (2021) investigated, in addition to academic activities, the role extracurricular activities have in students’ employment self-efficacy and transversal skills. Meanwhile, Kanar and Bouckenooghe (2021) explored the impact of extracurricular activities on students’ employment self-efficacy perception. Hence, another avenue for HEIs to enhance the workplace preparedness of their students is by going beyond academic studies. Extracurricular activities have been distinguished by many researchers as a critical instrument for enhancing graduates’ employment (Dickinson et al. 2020;Griffiths et al. 2021;Harvey et al. 2017;Pinto and Ramalheira 2017; Thompson et al. 2013). Other scholars have provided evidence in the literature indicating that these activities have an even higher impact on graduates as “whole-person education” (Chan 2016, p. 224) or even “life-wide learning” (Jackson 2008). Even though there is no consensus on what an extracurricular activity comprises, Thompson et al. (2013, p. 136) classifies it as activities such as “hobbies, social groups, cultural or religious, and voluntary or paid work” that focus on “communal interest or benefit”, as well as “structure or organization”. Other scholars have defined extracurricular activities as those endeavors organized inside the HEIs; nevertheless, they point out the need to expand the definition to integrate on-site activities as well as off-site ones (Clegg et al. 2010;King et al. 2020; Stevenson and Clegg 2011). Meanwhile Griffiths et al. (2021) determined extracurricular activities to be both on-site and off-site HEIs activities. Engagement in extracurricular activities results in having a positive relationship with one’s particular workplace (Kanar and Bouckenooghe 2021;Pinto and Ramalheira 2017; Thompson et al. 2013;Tieu et al. 2010). Stuart et al. (2009) found that the opportunities and support provided by HEIs for these activities were closely linked to the stakeholders’ awareness of their value and benefits. Additionally, other studies have confirmed that institutions have implemented policies to encourage and recognize students’ participation in extracurricular activities, helping them stand out in a competitive labor market and make a positive impression on employers (Prospects 2021;Roulin and Bangerter 2013). These activities help students develop various skills and values, such as caring for responsibilities, time management, and intercultural communication (Dickinson et al. 2020), as well as confidence (Harvey et al. 2017;Thompson et al. 2013), communication, teamwork, and project management (Wood et al. 2011). Beyond academic pursuits, students can benefit from nonacademic extracurricular activities and experiences during their university years, which allow them to develop skills, perspectives, beliefs, and values that are important in the workplace, thereby enhancing their overall experience as students. Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 6 of 17 Moreover, employers view the development of these skills as a crucial responsibility of both universities and professional organizations (Ibourk and El Aynaoui 2023;Montano et al. 2001). 3. Materials and Methods 3.1. Data Collection A quantitative research methodology was utilized to examine the perspectives of employers from different companies in Albania regarding the values and skills instilled by universities that are perceived as crucial for graduate employment. Specifically, this study targeted representatives of 64 companies that participated in the 10th annual “Career Fair” organized by “Epoka University” on 10 May 2023 and who had significant experience in and were directly responsible for the hiring process of graduates. The Career Fair is an annual event organized by “Epoka University”, designed to connect students with potential employers. Company representatives attend the fair to introduce their organizations, discuss job opportunities, internships, workshops, and other events, and invite students to engage with their companies. Students have the opportunity to learn about what skills and qualifications are needed for employment or internships, engage in discussions with the representatives (including alumni working at these companies), exchange contact information, and register for newsletters. This interaction helps bridge the gap between academic preparation and the labor market. Data collection was carried out during the career fair, and a physical copy of the questionnaire was handed out to each of the company representatives to complete. The companies came from different sectors of the labor market such as banking and finance, architecture, construction and engineering, telecommunication, business, law, technology, artificial intelligence, etc. Each had sufficient time to read and comprehend the survey questions. On average, it took about 15 min for the respondents to complete the survey, allowing them to thoughtfully consider their responses. Out of the 64 questionnaires distributed, a total of 52 were returned, resulting in an 81% response rate. 3.2. Research Instrument The measuring instrument used for this study was a structured questionnaire organized in five sessions, each aiming to evaluate the perceptions of the respondents regarding (i) the percentage of “Epoka University” graduates within the workforces of the companies, (ii) the overall performance of these graduates, (iii) the significance of developing values and skills in higher education institutions from an employers’ perspective, (iv) the demonstration of these values and skills by “Epoka University” students at their companies, and (v) the importance of extracurricular activities in cultivating skilled employees. The respondents were required to evaluate them based on their performance/significance/importance, using a Likert Scale from 1-Not important at all to 5-Absolutely essential. The relevance of the questionnaire is rooted in its alignment with established educational values and industry expectations. Since “Epoka University” is a signatory university of the Magna Charta Universitatum, the values in the questionnaire were cited from the “Living Values Prospectus” (Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum 2023). This ensures that the instrument evaluates values that are not only central to the university’s mission but are also recognized globally as essential to higher education institutions. Additionally, the skills in the questionnaire were derived from these values and supported by literature, emphasizing the questionnaire’s relevance in assessing the qualities that are most likely to contribute to graduates’ success in the workforce. Lastly, the extracurricular activities were gathered from the annual reports of the “Dean of Students annual activity reports” (Dean of Students 2020) throughout the years. These activities represent a critical aspect of student life and are instrumental in the holistic development of graduates. By evaluating the perceived importance of these activities, the questionnaire captures a comprehensive view of the educational experience offered by “Epoka University”. Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 7 of 17 A pilot test was conducted before the administration of the questionnaire and used to refine the questions, ensuring clarity and relevance. Internal consistency was assessed using Cronbach’s alpha. The alpha values for the different sections of the questionnaire were all above 0.7, indicating a high level of internal consistency and reliability. 4. Results 4.1. Descriptive Analysis The research involved responses from representatives of 52 companies from different sectors and industries. According to the findings, “Epoka University” can produce graduates in high demand from employers, as evidenced by their presence in the workforce of the companies surveyed. 4.1.1. Employment Distribution of Epoka University Graduates Following the surveying of the sample, the findings reveal that “Epoka University” graduates had a presence at a variety of companies. Specifically, 29 companies from the sample reported that less than 10% of their employees comprised “Epoka” graduates, 15 companies indicated that 11–20% were “Epoka” alumni, 7 companies had a proportion of 21–30%, and only 1 company had 31–50% of its employees from “Epoka”. While none of the surveyed companies employed more than 50% of their staff as “Epoka” alumni, the fact that several companies reported having graduates from the university indicates a level of engagement and recognition of the university’s graduates in the labor market. This distribution suggests that “Epoka University” is successfully producing graduates who are competitive in the job market, even though their presence within individual companies may not yet dominate, due to factors such as company size or diversity in recruitment sources. 4.1.2. Performance Evaluation of Epoka University Graduates When assessing professional performance, the representatives considered the graduates’ performance to be consistently good across all companies surveyed. “Epoka” graduates with whom they had hired, supervised, or collaborated were evaluated on a scale from 1—poor to 5—excellent, with the majority of ratings falling between 4 (above average) and 5 (excellent). The recorded evaluations appear to be relatively consistent and clustered around the mean value of 4.15, indicating agreement among respondents about the graduates’ performances and the high level of satisfaction among employers, indicating a robust alignment between the skills and values instilled by the university and the expectations of the labor market. 4.1.3. Importance of Educational Activities in Cultivating MCU Values The importance of using educational activities within HEIs for cultivating MCU values (Figure 2) was asked to be rated by the respondents, who rated these values on a 5-point Likert scale, with the results indicating that all listed values are considered significant to some extent by the companies surveyed. It is worth noting that the mean ratings for all values ranged from “moderately important” to “extremely important”, indicating that all listed values were considered significant to some extent by the companies polled. However, the values with the highest mean ratings by the respondents were “Creativity and Innovation”, “Integrity and Fairness”, and “Equity”, suggesting that companies particularly value these attributes, likely because they are essential in fostering an ethical, equitable, and forward-thinking workplace culture. Meanwhile, “Institutional Autonomy”, “Academic Freedom”, and “Community Service” appear to be less important, reflecting the perception that these attributes, while valuable, might be less directly applicable to the immediate needs of the business environment. Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 8 of 17 Adm. Sci. 2024, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 17 Figure 2. Cultivation of MCU values. Source: (authors’ elaboration). It is worth noting that the mean ratings for all values ranged from “moderately important” to “extremely important”, indicating that all listed values were considered significant to some extent by the companies polled. However, the values with the highest mean ratings by the respondents were “Creativity and Innovation”, “Integrity and Fairness”, and “Equity”, suggesting that companies particularly value these attributes, likely because they are essential in fostering an ethical, equitable, and forward-thinking workplace culture. Meanwhile, “Institutional Autonomy”, “Academic Freedom”, and “Community Service” appear to be less important, reflecting the perception that these attributes, while valuable, might be less directly applicable to the immediate needs of the business environment. 4.1.4. Demonstration of Values by “Epoka” Graduates Furthermore, respondents evaluated the graduates’ demonstration of the mentioned values (Figure 3). Graduates demonstrated a generally high level of the mentioned values. The highest mean score for “Integrity and Fairness” was 4.32, indicating that the graduates were committed to ethical behavior and fairness. “Equity” and “Excellence” received similar high mean scores of 4.19 and 4.15, suggesting that the graduates prioritized equality and met high standards in their work. With a mean of 3.98, “Community Service” had the lowest mean score. While this is still a relatively high score, it suggests that the graduates’ participation in community service may have been slightly lower when compared to other values. Overall, “Epoka” graduates demonstrated a positive alignment with the values, demonstrating a commitment to integrity, fairness, equity, social responsibility, and other important characteristics that contribute to a well-rounded education and professional development. 0246810 Creativity and Innovation Integrity and Fairness Equity Social Responsibility Diversity and Inclusiveness Excellence Community Service Academic Freedom Institutional Autonomy Values Importance Demontration Figure 2. Cultivation of MCU values. Source: (authors’ elaboration). 4.1.4. Demonstration of Values by “Epoka” Graduates Furthermore, respondents evaluated the graduates’ demonstration of the mentioned values (Figure 3). Graduates demonstrated a generally high level of the mentioned values. The highest mean score for “Integrity and Fairness” was 4.32, indicating that the graduates were committed to ethical behavior and fairness. “Equity” and “Excellence” received similar high mean scores of 4.19 and 4.15, suggesting that the graduates prioritized equality and met high standards in their work. With a mean of 3.98, “Community Service” had the lowest mean score. While this is still a relatively high score, it suggests that the graduates’ participation in community service may have been slightly lower when compared to other values. Overall, “Epoka” graduates demonstrated a positive alignment with the values, demonstrating a commitment to integrity, fairness, equity, social responsibility, and other important characteristics that contribute to a well-rounded education and professional development. Adm. Sci. 2024, 14, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 17 Figure 3. Skills development. Source: (authors’ elaboration). 4.1.5. Importance and Demonstration of Skills by “Epoka” Graduates Following the above, the companies were asked to evaluate the importance of incorporating educational activities within HEIs as a method of developing the skills listed in Figure 3 below, indicating that companies consider all of the listed skills to be important for inclusion in HEIs. Communication and responsibility were regarded as the most important skills, with mean values of 4.47 and 4.50, respectively, pointing to the priority that companies place on them and reflecting a broad consensus on their critical roles in both personal and professional contexts. Cultural competencies and empathy had lower mean values when compared to other skills, implying that companies may regard these skills as less important or in need of further development within HEIs, although they still remain important. The higher standard deviations associated with these skills, indicate that companies may have differing opinions or perspectives on their significance. Overall, the results indicate that companies value a wide range of skills, including analytical thinking, time management, teamwork, adaptability, open-mindedness, conflict resolution, visionary thinking, and risk-taking, as all had mean values greater than four. Furthermore, the participants were asked to rate the demonstration of these skills by “Epoka” graduates in their professional settings. The mean values for each skill ranged from 3.91 to 4.30, with most skills falling around or above the 4.00 mark, indicating that “Epoka” graduates are perceived to have good to excellent levels of proficiency in all of the listed skills. Communication had the highest average rating, with a mean of 4.30, suggesting that “Epoka” graduates excel at communicating effectively in professional settings. Conflict Resolution, on the other hand, had the lowest average rating, with a mean of 3.91, indicating that the graduates have room for improvement in this skill. They may need to improve their skills in resolving conflicts in professional settings. 4.1.6. Importance of Performed Extracurricular Activities by “Epoka” Graduates Additionally, the respondents had to evaluate the importance of the extracurricular activities organized by student clubs in cultivating values and skills that are beneficial from an employer’s perspective (Figure 4). When compared to other extracurricular activities, research projects, workshops, competitions, and mentoring emerged as the most highly regarded activities, receiving relatively higher mean scores, suggesting that employers value candidates who engage in these intellectually and professionally enriching activities. 0246810 Responsibility Communication Teamwork Analytical Thinking Visionary Thinking Open-mindness Adaptability Time Management Conflict Resolution Empathy Risk-taking Cultural Competences Skills Importance Demontration Figure 3. Skills development. Source: (authors’ elaboration). Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 15 of 17 Al-Najjar, Fatima Al-Zahra Muhammed, and Hiyam Abdel-Aal Muhammed Ibrahim Merhi. 2022. The Relationship between Student’s Activities and positive Thinking, Speaking Anxiety among Educational Qualification Students at Al-Azhar University. A Peer-Reviewed Scientific Journal for Educational, Psychological and Social Research 41: 131–90. Anohina-Naumeca, Alla, Ilze Birzniece, and Tatjana Odi n , eca. 2020. Students’ awareness of the academic integrity policy at a Latvian university. International Journal for Educational Integrity 16: 12. [CrossRef] Armstrong, Michael B., and Richard N. Landers. 2018. Gamification of employee training and development. International Journal of Training and Development 22: 162–69. [CrossRef] Baird, Anthony M., and Parayitam Satyanarayana. 2019. Employers’ ratings of the importance of skills and competencies college graduates need to get hired. Education + Training 61: 622–34. [CrossRef] Brown, Phillip, Anthony Hesketh, and Sara Williams. 2002. Employability in a Knowledge Economy. Working Paper Series No, 26. Cardiff: School of Social Sciences, University of Cardiff. Burcea, Marin, and Paul Marinescu. 2011. Students’ Perceptions on Corporate Social Responsibility at the Academic Level. Case Study: The Faculty of Administration and Business, University of Bucharest. Amfiteatru Economic Journal 13: 207–20. Catacutan, Karen Joy A., Fe Rose-Anne Maramag, Mary Ann Bartolome, Rose Marie Hiquiana, and Marie Jean Mendezabal. 2020. Employability Study of the Business Administration Graduates of Catholic Educational Institution. Universal Journal of Educational Research 8: 156–61. [CrossRef] Chan, Yiu-Kong. 2016. Investigating the Relationship among Extracurricular Activities, Learning Approach and Academic Outcomes: A Case Study. Active Learning in Higher Education 17: 223–33. [CrossRef] Chetty, Yuraisha. 2012. Graduateness and employability within the higher education environment: A focused review of the literature. Developing Student Graduateness and Employability 5–24. Clegg, Sue, Jacqueline Stevenson, and John Willott. 2010. Staff Conceptions of Curricular and Extracurricular Activities in Higher Education. Higher Education 59: 615–26. [CrossRef] Compagnucci, Lorenzo, and Francesca Spigarelli. 2020. The Third Mission of the university: A systematic literature review on potentials and constraints. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 161: 120284. [CrossRef] Dean of Students. 2020. Dean of Students Annual Activity Report 2019–2020. Tirana: Epoka University. Dickinson, Jill, Teri-Lisa Griffiths, and Alex Bredice. 2020. ‘It’s Just Another Thing to Think About’: Encouraging Students’ Engagement in Extracurricular Activities. Journal of Further and Higher Education 45: 744–57. [CrossRef] Donnison, Sharn, and Diane Itter. 2010. Community service learning: A first year transition tool for teacher education. Australian Journal of Teacher Education 35: 59–74. Epoka University. 2023. About Epoka. Available online: https://epoka.edu.al/home-about-epoka-about-epoka-1-1039.html (accessed on 25 May 2023). European Commission. 2019. Key Competences for Lifelong Learning. Brussels: Publications Office for the European Union. Fenta, Haile Mekonnen, Zeleke Siraye Asnakew, Petros Kibebew Debele, Sifelig Taye Nigatu, and Aragaw Mulu Muhaba. 2019. Analysis of supply side factors influencing employability of new graduates: A tracer study of Bahir Dar University graduates. Journal of Teaching and Learning for Graduate Employability 10: 67–85. [CrossRef] Finley, Ashley. 2021. How College Contributes “to” Workforce Success: Employer Views on What Matters Most. Washington, DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities. Fisher, Dara Ruth. 2013. Educating Engineers for the 21st Century: A Framework for Skill Development through Co-Curricular and Extracurricular Involvement. Doctoral dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA. Gamage, Kelum A. A., D. M. S. C. P. K. Dehideniya, and Sakunthala Y. Ekanayake. 2021. The role of personal values in learning approaches and student achievements. Behavioral Sciences 11: 102. [CrossRef] García-Álvarez, Jesus, Ana Vázquez-Rodríguez, Anais Quiroga-Carrillo, and Diana Priegue Caamaño. 2022. Transversal Competencies for Employability in University Graduates: A Systematic Review from the Employers’ Perspective. Education Science 12: 204. [CrossRef] Griffiths, Teri-Lisa, Jill Dickinson, and Catherine J. Day. 2021. Exploring the relationship between extracurricular activities and student self-efficacy within university. Journal of Further and Higher Education 45: 1294–309. [CrossRef] Harvey, Anfrew, Lisa Andrewartha, Daniel Edwards, Julia Clarke, and Kimberly Reyes. 2017. Student Equity and Employability in Higher Education. Report for the Australian Government Department of Education and Training. Melbourne: Centre for Higher Education Equity and Diversity Research (CHEEDR). Available online: https://www.ncsehe.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2018 /06/73_LaTrobe_AndrewHarvey_Accessible_PDF.pdf (accessed on 27 August 2024). Harvey, Lee, Lee Harvey, William Locke, and Alistair Morey. 2002. Enhancing Employability, Recognising Diversity: Making Links between Higher Education and the World of Work: Main Report. London: Universities UK. Haste, Helen. 2018. Attitudes and Values and the OECD Learning Framework 2030: A Critical Review of Definitions, Concepts and Data, OECD. Available online: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?title=Attitudes%20and%20values%20and%20the%20 OECD%20learning%20framework%202030:%20A%20critical%20review%20of%20definitions,%20concepts%20and%20data& publication_year=2018&author=H.%20Haste (accessed on 1 June 2023). Houcine, Benlaria, and Mostéfaoui Sofiane. 2018. Estimating the return of Higher Education in Algeria: Evidence from Adrar University. Journal of Education and Training Studies 6: 118–24. [CrossRef] Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 16 of 17 Ibourk, Aomar, and Karim El Aynaoui. 2023. Career Trajectories of Higher Education Graduates: Impact of Soft Skills. Economies 11: 198. [CrossRef] Jackson, Denise. 2015. Employability Skill Development in work-integrated learning: Barriers and best practice. Studies in Higher Education 40: 350–67. [CrossRef] Jackson, Norman. 2008. Tackling the Wicked Problem of Creativity in Higher Education. In Background Paper for a Presentation at the ARC Centre for the Creative Industries and Innovation, International Conference. Brisbane: QLD. Kanar, Adam, and Dave Bouckenooghe. 2021. The role of extracurricular activities in shaping university students’ employment self-efficacy perceptions. Career Development International 26: 158–73. [CrossRef] King, Alyson E., Fiona A. E. McQuarrie, and Susan M. Brigham. 2020. Exploring the Relationship between Student Success and Participation in Extracurricular Activities. SCHOLE: A Journal of Leisure Studies and Recreation Education 36: 42–58. [CrossRef] Koo, Ja Eun, and Eun Sun Ki. 2020. Corporate social responsibility and employee safety: Evidence from Korea. Sustainability 12: 2649. [CrossRef] Kruja, Alba, and Adela Kadiasi. 2020. Enterpreneurial skills and start-up challenges in the Albanian ecosystem. Paper presented at International Academic Conference: Social Sciences, Business & Economics, Barcelona, Spain, February 11–13, vol. 162. Kruja, Alba Demneri, and Anisa Berisha. 2021. UK-Albania Tech Hub: Enhancing Tech Entrepreneurial Ecosystem in Albania. Tirana: British Embassy Tirana. Kruja, Alba Demneri, and Lumturi Kalluci. 2021. Entrepreneurship Among Graduates: A Self Employment and Advancement Opportunity. Paper presented at Happiness and Contemporary Society: Conference Proceedings Volume, Lviv, Ukraine, March 19–20; pp. 158–61. [CrossRef] Kuh, George D. 2008. High-impact educational practices. Peer Review 10: 30–31. Lowden, Kevin, Stuart Hall, Dely Elliot, and Jon Lewin. 2011. Employers’ Perceptions of the Employability Skills of New Graduates. London: Edge Foundation, p. 201126. Montano, Jose Luis Arquero, Jose Antonio Donoso, Trevor Hassall, and John Joyce. 2001. Vocational skills in the accounting professional profile: The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA) employers’ opinion. Accounting Education 10: 299–313. [CrossRef] Moosmayer, Dirk C. 2012. A model of management academics’ intentions to influence values. Academy of Management Learning & Education 11: 155–73. Mora, Jose-Gines, Camino Ferreira, Javier Vidal, and Maria-Jose Vieira. 2015. Higher education in Albania: Developing third mission activities. Tertiary Education and Management 21: 29–40. [CrossRef] National Association of Colleges and Employers. 2022. Development and Validation of the NACE Career Readiness Competencies. Available online: https://www.naceweb.org/uploadedFiles/files/2022/resources/2022-nace-career-readiness-developmentand-validation.pdf (accessed on 27 August 2024). Norris, Megan, and Luc Lecavalier. 2010. Evaluating the use of exploratory factor analysis in developmental disability psychological research. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 40: 8–20. [CrossRef] Observatory Magna Charta Universitatum. 2023. Living Values in Higher Education Institutions. Available online: https://site.unibo. it/magna-charta/en/activities-and-projects/living-values (accessed on 1 March 2023). OECD. 2019. An OECD Learning Framework 2030. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 23–35. Palmer, Louise, Jill Foley, and Chris Parsons. 2004. Principles not values. Industrial and Commercial Training 36: 38–40. [CrossRef] Pinto, Luisa H., and Diogo C. Ramalheira. 2017. Perceived Employability of Business Graduates: The Effect of Academic Performance and Extracurricular Activities. Journal of Vocational Behavior 99: 165–78. [CrossRef] Prospects. 2021. Volunteering. Available online: https://www.prospects.ac.uk/jobs-and-work-experience/work-experience-andinternships/volunteering?utm_source=nus_web&utm_medium=partner&utm_campaign=jobs-and-work-experience (accessed on 1 April 2023). Qenani, Eivis, Neal MacDougall, and Carol Sexton. 2014. An empirical study of self-perceived employability: Improving the prospects for student employment success in an uncertain environment. Active Learning in Higher Education 15: 199–213. Roulin, Nicolas, and Adrian Bangerter. 2013. Students’ Use of Extracurricular Activities for Positional Advantage in Competitive Job Markets. Journal of Education and Work 26: 21–47. [CrossRef] Sermsuk, Savanee, Duankamol Triwichitkhun, and Suwimon Wongwanich. 2014. Employment conditions and essential employability skills required by employers for secondary school graduate. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 116: 1848–54. [CrossRef] Stevenson, Jacqueline, and Sue Clegg. 2011. Possible Selves: Students Orientating Themselves Towards the Future for Extracurricular Activity. British Educational Research Journal 37: 231–46. [CrossRef] Stuart, Mary, Catherine Lido, Jessica Morgan, and Steve May. 2009. Student diversity, extra-curricular activities and perceptions of graduate outcomes. Active Learning in Higher Education 12: 203. [CrossRef] Thompson, Leanne J., Gordon Clark, Marion Walker, and J. Duncan Whyatt. 2013. ‘It’s just like an extra string to your bow’: Exploring higher education students’ perceptions and experiences of extracurricular activity and employability. Active Learning in Higher Education 14: 135–47. [CrossRef] Tieu, Thanh-Thanh, S. Mark Pancer, Michael W. Pratt, Maxine Gallander Wintre, Shelly Birnie-Lefcovitch, Janet Polivy, and Gerald Adams. 2010. Helping out or hanging out: The features of involvement and how it relates to university adjustment. Higher Education 60: 343–55. Adm. Sci. 2024,14, 201 17 of 17 Tomlinson, Elizabeth C. 2023. Bringing an entrepreneurial lens to the Business Communication Course. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly 86: 232949062211410. [CrossRef] Urdari, Claudia, Teodora Viorica Farcas, and Adriana Tiron-Tudor. 2017. Assessing the legitimacy of HEIs’ contributions to society: The perspective of international rankings. Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal 8: 191–215. [CrossRef] Wood, Jamie, Sabine Little, and Louise Goldring. 2011. The Confidence to Do Things that I Know Nothing about—Skills Development through Extracurricular Inquiry Activity. Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education 3: 2–21. Yorke, Mantz. 2006. Employability in Higher Education: What It Is-What It Is Not: Learning & Employability Series 1. York: The Higher Education Academy. Zenelaj, Besjon, and Alba Kruja. 2017. Entrepreneurship intention of Albanian students: An evidence from computer engineering and business informatics programs. AC-EITAI 2017: 297. Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.