scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Nutritional analysis of the Spanish population: a new approach using public data on consumption

Cerrillo, Isabel; Saralegui-Díez, Pablo; Morilla Romero de la Osa, Rubén; González de Molina, Manuel; Guzmán, Gloria I.

Abstract

Official population consumption data are frequently used to characterize the diet of countries; however, this information may not always be representative of reality. This study analyses the food consumption of the Spanish population by reconstructing the whole food chain. The results have been compared with the data provided by the National Consumption Panel to which the food losses/waste reported in the literature along the distribution chain have been added. The difference between them allowed a new calculation of the estimated food consumption that was subjected to a dietary-nutritional analysis. Most of the foods were consumed more than those officially reported (range of 5–50%). The unhealthy ratios of consumed foods and recommended servings were: meat products (Rcr = 3.6), fruits and legumes (Rcr = 0.5), and nuts (Rcr = 0.14). Caloric intake surpasses needs. The results were consistent with the data on the prevalence of overweight and obesity in Spain, as well as with the prevalence of associated diseases. To make a judgment about the quality of a country’s diet, it is necessary to have reliable data on food consumption, as well as energy and nutrient intake. This study encourages other authors to implement this method to verify and quantify the possible difference between official and real consumption data.

Full text

Citation: Cerrillo, I.; Saralegui-Díez, P.; Morilla-Romero-de-la-Osa, R.; González de Molina, M.; Guzmán, G.I. Nutritional Analysis of the Spanish Population: A New Approach Using Public Data on Consumption. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642. https:// doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20021642 Academic Editors: Paul B. Tchounwou, Hui Wang and Xu Tian Received: 1 December 2022 Revised: 4 January 2023 Accepted: 11 January 2023 Published: 16 January 2023 Copyright: © 2023 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health Article Nutritional Analysis of the Spanish Population: A New Approach Using Public Data on Consumption Isabel Cerrillo 1,2 , Pablo Saralegui-Díez 2,3 , Rubén Morilla-Romero-de-la-Osa 2,4,5,6,* , Manuel González de Molina 2,3 and Gloria I. Guzmán2,3 1Department of Molecular Biology and Biochemistry Engineering, Area of Nutrition and Food Sciences, Pablo de Olavide University, Carretera de Utrera Km 1, 41013 Seville, Spain 2Alimentta, Think Tank para la Transición Alimentaria, 18320 Santa Fe, Spain 3Laboratory of the History of Agroecosystems, Pablo de Olavide University, Carretera de Utrera Km 1, 41013 Seville, Spain 4Department of Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, Physiotherapy and Podiatry, Universidad de Sevilla, 41015 Seville, Spain 5Hospital Universitario Virgen del Rocío, Instituto de Biomedicina de Sevilla, Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), Universidad de Sevilla, 41015 Seville, Spain 6Centro de Investigación Biomédica en Red de Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Hospital Universitario Virgen del Rocío, 41015 Seville, Spain *Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Official population consumption data are frequently used to characterize the diet of countries; however, this information may not always be representative of reality. This study analyses the food consumption of the Spanish population by reconstructing the whole food chain. The results have been compared with the data provided by the National Consumption Panel to which the food losses/waste reported in the literature along the distribution chain have been added. The difference between them allowed a new calculation of the estimated food consumption that was subjected to a dietary-nutritional analysis. Most of the foods were consumed more than those officially reported (range of 5–50%). The unhealthy ratios of consumed foods and recommended servings were: meat products (Rcr = 3.6), fruits and legumes (Rcr = 0.5), and nuts (Rcr = 0.14). Caloric intake surpasses needs. The results were consistent with the data on the prevalence of overweight and obesity in Spain, as well as with the prevalence of associated diseases. To make a judgment about the quality of a country’s diet, it is necessary to have reliable data on food consumption, as well as energy and nutrient intake. This study encourages other authors to implement this method to verify and quantify the possible difference between official and real consumption data. Keywords: nutritional status; diet food and nutrition; nutrition policy; public health; public sector 1. Introduction Over the past 50 years, dietary habits in industrialised countries have been changing and worsening from a nutritional viewpoint [ 1 ]. According to the report recently published by the EAT-Lancet Commission, higher intakes of unhealthy foods, such as red meat and sugar, instead of healthy ones, such as nuts, fruits, vegetables and legumes, are contributing to a rising prevalence of obesity and diet-related non-communicable diseases (NCDs), including coronary heart disease, stroke, and diabetes [ 2 ]. Spain is a representative case of these worsening dietary patterns. The country currently presents notable rates of overweight and obesity, as well as a high prevalence of chronic diseases associated with a poor quality diet. According to the latest data published by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), 53% of adults in Spain are overweight [ 3 ]. The child and youth population in Spain also presents worrying data, with 34.1% of the young population aged 5 to 19 years being overweight or obese, and 40.6% of the children aged 6 to 9 years being overweight according to the ALADINO 2019 study [ 4 ]. Additionally, the Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20021642 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/ijerph Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 2 of 15 prevalence of chronic diseases associated with overweight or obesity, such as cardiovascular diseases, diabetes type 2, or some cancer diseases [ 5 , 6 ] is very high, entailing a high socioeconomic cost and a greater risk of mortality. The latest data from the Spanish Ministry of Health and Consumer Affairs indicated the following figures: 19% hypercholesterolemia, 17% hypertension, and 7% diabetes in Spain [ 7 ]. It has also recently been observed that obese patients suffer worse outcomes after contracting the COVID-19 infection [ 8 ]. Previous studies have revealed that food consumption changes in Spain would lead to decreasing the environmental impact of current dietary patterns [ 9 , 10 ] and would also reduce some chronic pathologies such as cardiovascular diseases [11,12]. However, assessments of the Spanish diet based on data from the household consumption surveys of the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food [ 13 , 14 ] might not fully explain the prevalence of overweight or obesity reported. Some studies have also shown differences in the data on actual dietary intake, calculated using FAO food balances or apparent food consumption [ 15 – 17 ]. Other studies, based on direct consumer surveys, also show contradictory results [ 18 – 20 ]. On this basis, our current hypothesis is that there exists a possible inaccurate estimation of consumption data, which results in an overall approach to Spanish dietary-nutritional health missing to justify the current disease prevalence, as databases do not collect real tendencies and patterns. Our approach wants to fill this knowledge gap as it tries to identify possible miscalculation inaccuracies, and therefore, estimates current consumption patterns by using multiple databases. The measurement and monitoring of food environments (variety of foods available, affordability, convenience and desirability for the population) through the evaluation of diet quality play a key role in establishing effective policies, as in the case of sugary drinks for example [ 21 ]. Reliable data on food consumption are, therefore, necessary to better explain the impacts of dietary changes and the progressive shift away from the Mediterranean diet on the health of Spanish people. Indeed, as noted by other authors, it is essential to assess food consumption and diet quality, as such an appraisal allows the identification of the dietary patterns required to improve the nutritional status of Spain’s population [22,23]. Lastly, a review was performed by del Pozo de la Calle et al. (2015) of the different tools available to collect information on community feeding at the national, household or individual level. The authors highlighted the limitations and strengths of the different methods but did not support their conclusions with quantitative data, so their findings remain theoretical [ 24 ]. Therefore, it seems that the best approach to carry out this type of analysis is that the population consumption pattern remains unclear. The objective of the present study was twofold. Firstly, we sought to quantify inaccuracies in the official data by developing a method to quantify the food consumption of the Spanish population using secondary data from official sources, overcoming the limitations and inconsistencies observed in other studies mentioned above. Secondly, we compared the population’s current food consumption patterns based on our approach with today’s dietary recommendations by conducting a nutritional analysis 2. Materials and Methods Design and sources. Secondary data obtained from public sources were analysed. This type of design is exempt from the requirement of approval by an ethics committee. Figure 1illustrates the methodological design used to calculate the divergence between Spanish food consumption according to official public sources dedicated towards reporting this information, and our own estimation using new public information intended for other purposes, e.g., usage by commerce or industry. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 3 of 15 Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023, 20, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 16 Figure 1. Methodological approach to calculate official consumption and final apparent consumption. The orange lines are the computed loss streams (added or subtracted). The green lines represent the amount of product that passes to the next phase of the food chain. The purple line indicates the output of the product to other uses. The existence of at least two generic phases in the transformation process was considered. They are related to the production of processed foods since they use part of the agricultural and livestock products for their production processes, although these phases may be more numerous. An example would be processed tomato, such as fried tomato, which has at least two consecutive phases: transformed tomato paste is used in its production (whose original raw material was fresh tomato in a previous phase), and crushed fresh tomato, combined in variable proportions (see Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). All the information used was obtained from different public access databases. The bases used in each phase of the analysis, as well as the possible paths that any raw material can take to the point of sale are shown in Figure 2: Figure 1. Methodological approach to calculate official consumption and final apparent consumption. The orange lines are the computed loss streams (added or subtracted). The green lines represent the amount of product that passes to the next phase of the food chain. The purple line indicates the output of the product to other uses. The existence of at least two generic phases in the transformation process was considered. They are related to the production of processed foods since they use part of the agricultural and livestock products for their production processes, although these phases may be more numerous. An example would be processed tomato, such as fried tomato, which has at least two consecutive phases: transformed tomato paste is used in its production (whose original raw material was fresh tomato in a previous phase), and crushed fresh tomato, combined in variable proportions (see Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). All the information used was obtained from different public access databases. The bases used in each phase of the analysis, as well as the possible paths that any raw material can take to the point of sale are shown in Figure 2: Data analysis procedure. The methodology employed required a multitude of calculations to determine balances of food produced, marketed, consumed, or used for purposes other than human consumption. For this reason, in this section, we present the calculations that we believe are essential to understand the study. We refer readers to the Supplementary Material for further information on tourist food consumption, agrarian production, disaggregated Spanish industrial production data, raw materials and processed products conversion, foreign trade, agricultural and industrial production correspondence, and food chain reconstructions (See Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 4 of 15 Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023, 20, x FOR PEER REVIEW 4 of 16 Figure 2. Diagram of the databases and paths to the point of sale. DATACOMEX: Foreign trade statistics of goods from Spain and the EU, SABI: Spanish acronym for Iberian Balance Sheet Analysis System, it provides information about Spanish companies or groups of companies, AESAN: Spanish acronym for Spanish Agency for Food Safety and Nutrition, MERCASA: a public company of the State Administration that has been providing a public service to the entire food chain since 1966, structuring the largest network of wholesale markets in the world, which covers the whole of Spain’s territory. (See Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). Data analysis procedure. The methodology employed required a multitude of calculations to determine balances of food produced, marketed, consumed, or used for purposes other than human consumption. For this reason, in this section, we present the calculations that we believe are essential to understand the study. We refer readers to the Supplementary Material for further information on tourist food consumption, agrarian production, disaggregated Spanish industrial production data, raw materials and processed products conversion, foreign trade, agricultural and industrial production correspondence, and food chain reconstructions (See Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). The main calculations performed on this basis are detailed below: (a) Calculation of the estimated official food consumption (EOFC). First, we calculated the official gross food consumption (Equation (1)) using the data of the Food Consumption Panel of the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (2017), completed with the extra-domestic consumption data from the 2017 Report on food consumption in Spain (Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, 2017) [25]. In addition, the balance of tourist food consumption was also considered (consumption of the tourists who visit the country vs. Spanish tourists who are absent from the country, see Supplementary Material). Finally, food losses and waste during food distribution were taken into account according to a previously described methodology [37]. These data were calculated for the 34 most Figure 2. Diagram of the databases and paths to the point of sale. DATACOMEX: Foreign trade statistics of goods from Spain and the EU, SABI: Spanish acronym for Iberian Balance Sheet Analysis System, it provides information about Spanish companies or groups of companies, AESAN: Spanish acronym for Spanish Agency for Food Safety and Nutrition, MERCASA: a public company of the State Administration that has been providing a public service to the entire food chain since 1966, structuring the largest network of wholesale markets in the world, which covers the whole of Spain’s territory. (See Supplementary Material supported by references [25–53]). The main calculations performed on this basis are detailed below: (a) Calculation of the estimated official food consumption (EOFC). First, we calculated the official gross food consumption (Equation (1)) using the data of the Food Consumption Panel of the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (2017), completed with the extra-domestic consumption data from the 2017 Report on food consumption in Spain (Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, 2017) [ 25 ]. In addition, the balance of tourist food consumption was also considered (consumption of the tourists who visit the country vs. Spanish tourists who are absent from the country, see Supplementary Material). Finally, food losses and waste during food distribution were taken into account according to a previously described methodology [ 37 ]. These data were calculated for the 34 most representative products, which, according to the Panel, accounted for 76% of the volume consumed. The remaining 24% showed great similarities with the domestic/extra-domestic consumption relation of the considered foods (e.g., the extra-domestic consumption of garlic was almost identical to that of onion) [ 37 ]. In other cases, we assumed, on the Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 5 of 15 contrary, that the official consumption (Equation (1)) was equivalent to the final apparent consumption (e.g., honey). EOFC =Cpanel 1−FLWdistrib +Cpanel.%extradom.(1−%extradom)−1.(1−FLWdistrib)−1(1) Equation (1), where EOFC: estimated official food consumption, Cpanel: household consumption indicated by the Food Consumption Panel, FLWdistrib: losses in food distribution and %extradom: estimated extra-domestic consumption factor [37] Next, the final apparent consumption (FAC) was calculated for the 34 products, defined as the amount of food obtained from the reconstruction of the food chains destined for the Spanish population (Equation (2)). The FAC was obtained considering that: (a) A share of the products is consumed fresh and another part is used as industrial raw material; (b) Industrial processing (i.e., dehydration by curing, cooking, concentration, dilution, etc.) modifies the volume of food products available for human consumption; (c) Some products (i.e., animal fats for feed production) are not intended for human consumption FAC =P+I−E− i ∑ 0 PCFn− i ∑ 0 FLWn(2) Equation (2), where P: national production, I: import, E: export, PCF: processed and conserved food, and FLW: losses and waste throughout the chain for each phase of the food chain considered (Hui, 2012 [54]). The necessary information for the rebuilding of food chains and the different uses of their products was obtained through expert knowledge, academic literature, Codex Alimentarius protocols, consultations with agents of the sector and using food industry manuals and protocols [34,40,54–56]. The Agrarian Statistics Yearbook [ 57 ] and the Livestock Statistics [ 58 ] and Industrial Production Survey [ 27 ] (for semi-transformed and transformed products) were used to calculate the national production. Import and export data were obtained from DATACOMEX (Ministry of Industry, Trade and Tourism, 2017) [ 39 ]. Losses and waste in the food chain according to FAO (2011) [37] were also taken into account. The difference observed between FAC and EOFC for each product allowed us to calculate the percentage of increase (Equation (3)) used as a corrective factor of data published by the MAPA, thus establishing the estimated real food consumption (ERFC). %Increase =(FAC −EOFC) EOFC (3) Equation (3), where %Increase: percentage of increase, FAC: final apparent consumption, and EOFC: estimated official food consumption (b) Analysis of adherence of ERFC to a healthy eating pattern. Consumption patterns were compared with the current national recommendations [ 59 ] by calculating the ratio between consumed servings and recommended servings (Rcr). Due to sociodemographic variability, we considered that an Rcr interval of 0.8–1.2 would allow the maintenance of a good state of health of the population. Additionally, a nutritional analysis using the DIAL v3 (Alce Engineering) software was performed to assess whether ERFC satisfied the needs of a man and woman aged 42 years—because this age group corresponds to the largest segment of the population (38–51 years) according to the National Statistics Institute [ 60 ]—as considered by the Nutritional Assessment of the Spanish Diet report. The rest of the considerations were a weight of 68 kg and a height of 1.70 m (BMI = 23.5 kg · m −2 ) for the man, and 65 kg and 1.65 m (BMI = 24 kg · m −2 ) for the woman. A healthy BMI was considered to avoid peculiarities in food and nutritional recommendations associated with overweight/obesity. We considered a light physical activity factor of 1.374 (that is, light exercises 1–3 times/week) due to the fact that 46.5% of men and 54.8% of women do not dedicate any day of the week to physical Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 6 of 15 exercise during their leisure time and that 37.8% of the Spanish population aged over 15 years declares itself sedentary [61] Energy requirements were obtained by multiplying the basal metabolic rate (Harris Benedict’s Equation (4)) by the light activity factor [62]. BMR (men) = 66.5 + (13.76 ×kg) + (5.003 ×cm) −(6.755 ×years) BMR (women) = 655 + (9.563 ×kg) + (1.850 ×cm) −(4.676 ×years) (4) The consumption of macroand micro-nutrients was compared with the current recommended daily intake (European Food Safety Authority, 2017) [ 63 ] and latest consensus recommendations on fats and oils in the diet of the adult Spanish population [64]. 3. Results Regarding the EOFC, Table 1presents the values obtained according to Equation (1) and the percentage increase according to Equation (3) for each food group. All groups achieved a positive increase except the Fish and Nuts Groups. Table 1. Values obtained from the components of Equation (3) and ratio of consumed/recommended servings. Food (g/Serving) EOFC (gd−1p−1)%Increase ERFC (gd−1p−1) [Serving] Rec Cons [Serving] Rcr Vegetable (200 g) 233.2 23% 285 [1.4/day] 2/day 0.7 Fruits (200 g) 267.3 12% 300 [1.5/day] 3/day 0.5 Cereals * 232 51% 350 [4.5/day] 4/day ** 1.0 Milk (dairy) * 212 (109) 25% 215 (186) [2.5/day] 2–4/day 0.8 Oils (10 g) 32.7 5% 34 [3.4/day] 4–6/day 0.7 Meat (125 g) 131.7 50% 200 [11/week] 3/week 3.6 Fish (125 g) 74 0% 74 [4.0/week] 3–4/week 1.0 Legumes (70 g) 12.3 17% 14.3 [1.4/week] 2–4/week 0.5 Eggs (60 g) 27.1 39% 34.3 [4.0/week] 3–5/week 1.0 Nuts (25 g) 2.56 0% 2.56 [0.7/week] 3–7/week 0.14 * Due to the different weight/serving of each type of food, the number of consumed servings were calculated separately (according to Table S2 in the Supplementary Material), considering the sum of the group to determine the Rcr.** For a physical activity factor of 1.375, the recommendation is 4 servings/day, %Increase: percentage of increase, EOFC: estimated official food consumption, (gd −1 pc −1 ): grams · day −1· person −1 , ERFC: estimated real food consumption, Rec Cons: recommended consumption, Rcr: ratio of consumed/recommended servings. Table 1also shows the extent to which the estimated diet followed a healthy eating pattern, as well as the ERFC, the consumption recommendations, and the ratio between the two. We considered an acceptable range of consumption (0.8–1.2) and observed that cereals, dairy products, fish and eggs were within the range, while meat was three times above the upper limit. The other food groups were all below the range, Nuts accounting for the lowest ratio, followed by Legumes and Fruits, whose consumption represented half the recommended amount. We also analysed the consumption of foods that were not the subject of any specific consumption recommendations, as well as foods recommended to be consumed occasionally. The results are shown in Table 2. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 7 of 15 Table 2. Consumption of foods recommended to be consumed occasionally. Food ERFC (gd−1p−1) Sugar and honey 12 Chocolates 12.5 Buns 45 Butter 3 Sauces 11 Prepared dishes 58 Snacks 6 Soft drinks 166 Wine and beer 285 Other alcoholics drinks 7 ERFC: estimated real food consumption, (gd−1pc−1): grams·day−1·person−1. Notable among the occasional consumption foods were prepared dishes, buns and, in particular, fermented alcoholic beverages and soft drinks. The results of the nutritional analysis regarding macroand micro-nutrients are shown in Tables 3and 4, respectively. We calculated the corresponding percentages of their contribution to the nutritional needs of men and women. Table 3. Macro-nutrients’ analysis according to estimated real food consumption. RDI %Contribution Nutrients Intake Man Women Man Women Energy (kcal/day−1)2930 2156 1906 136% 154% Proteins (g/day−1)107 61–76 52–65 141% 165% Caloric profile Recommended * Proteins (%kcal) 14.6% 10–15% Lipids (%kcal) 40% 20–40% Carbohydrates (%kcal) 42% 45–60% Lipid profile Recommended ** SFA (%) 12.5% 7–8% MUFA (%) 17.3% 13–18% PUFA (%) 6.7% 5–10% Cholesterol (mg/day−1)432 300 Fibre (g/day−1)27.7 25–30 * According to the European Food Safety Authority, EFSA, ** according to the FESNAD (Spanish acronym for Spanish Federation of Nutrition, Food, and Dietetics Societies), RDI: recommended daily intake, SFA: saturated fatty acid, MUFA: monounsaturated fatty acid, PUFA: polyunsaturated fatty acid The kilocalories provided by the diet exceeded the needs of men and women by 36% and 54%, respectively. Protein consumption was 41% and 65% higher than that recommended by the WHO (0.8–1 g · kg −1· day −1 ) in men and women, respectively. Despite this, like the rest of the macro-nutrients, the percentage of kilocalories provided by protein (14.6%) fell within the EFSA recommendations. However, the lipid profile reflected an excessive consumption of saturated fat and cholesterol, while monoand poly-unsaturated fats remained within recommended amounts. Fibre intake was adequate, although carbohydrate intake was slightly lower than recommended. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 8 of 15 Table 4. Micro-nutrients’ analysis according to estimated real food consumption. Micronutrient Intake RDI %Contribution Calcium (mg) 955 950 100% Phosphorous (mg) 1356 550 246% Magnesium (mg) 351 M: 350 100% W: 300 117% M: 9.4 107% Zinc (mg) 10.1 W: 7.5 135% Iron (mg) 21.2 M:11 193% W: 16 132% Iodine (mg) 117 150 78% Vitamin B1 (mg) 1.6 0.75 213% Vitamin B2 (mg) 1.9 1.6 119% Vitamin B6 (mg) 2.8 M: 1.7 165% W: 1.6 175% Vitamin B9 (mg) 324 330 98.2% Vitamin B12 (µg) 12.2 4 305% M: 110 140% Vitamin C (mg) 154 W: 95 162% Vitamin A (µg) 1041 M: 750 139% W: 650 160% Vitamin D (µg) 3.4 15 23% Vitamin E (µg) 18.5 M: 13 142% W: 11 168% Vitamin K (µg) 276 70 394% µg: micrograms, mg: milligrams, RDI: recommended daily intake, M: man, W: woman. Table 4illustrates the micro-nutrient intake. Deficits in iodine and vitamin D can be observed, as well as an excess of phosphorus. 4. Discussion In this study, we described a new exhaustive methodology to calculate the food consumption of the Spanish population. This technique allowed the correction of the values issued by official sources and explicated the gap between them and the apparent consumption data offered by sources such as FAOSTAT or other researchers [ 17 , 65 ]. In addition, we quantified the degree of compliance with healthy diet recommendations and provided a nutritional analysis of a typical man and woman with a healthy weight. Together, this information has an important value for public health as it can be used to design programmes aimed at improving community nutritional health. Eating habits are influenced by fashions, publicity, and the availability of new exotic foods. The evolution of food consumption patterns in recent decades has come with higher mortality and morbidity rates in developed countries, creating a serious public health problem [ 66 ]. In this sense, it is necessary to have reliable data on the nutrition and food patterns in each country. We must be aware, nevertheless, of the difficulties in building accurate knowledge of dietary intakes. For more than 20 years the Food Consumption Panel has provided questionable data as it has been relying on calculations of food consumption in homes, hotels/restaurants and institutions using data recorded via the scanning of purchased products. The methodology implemented in this work, however, shows that official sources do not actually capture all food consumption. Our results revealed that generally, food consumption is higher than the figures reported by the official Consumption Panel. In addition, the recommendations of some food groups fail to be met even despite such higher intakes. The amount of fruit and vegetables was greater than that reported by the Panel, yet the current recommendations of five servings a day (three fruits and two vegetables) are still not being fulfilled, according to what has been previously reported (i.e., the amounts slightly exceed two servings) in the latest national evaluation of the consumption of these foods [ 67 ]. Similarly, the consumption of fruit and vegetables was 20% higher than that reported by the Panel, but Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2023,20, 1642 9 of 15 only half the recommended weekly portions of legumes were consumed and much less than that (Rcr = 0.14) in the case of nuts. The greatest difference was observed in the case of meat: consumption was 50% greater than the figure published by the panel. This high meat consumption rate together with the observed fibre intake insufficiency could explain Spain’s large number of cases of colorectal cancer [ 68 ]. The analysis altogether reflects how Spanish eating patterns have today moved far from the traditional Mediterranean diet—which is mainly plant-based and rich in fibre, micro-nutrients, as well as bioactive compounds with antioxidant activity. Such a situation could, in fact, be related to Spain’s high rates of cardiometabolic problems (obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular diseases) [69]. Historically, carbohydrate intakes in the Spanish diet came mainly from grain and derivatives. Nowadays, the lower amounts observed in the diet of cereals and derivatives may be due to the consumption of white bread, which might increase body weight, and/or because the bread consumed is of a lower quality [ 70 ]. Bread consumption was 368 g/day in 1964 vs. 139 g/day in 2012, reflecting a gradual decline over time. Our results indicated a Rcr = 1 for the group of cereals, and we found a 51% increase in consumption with respect to official data. This consumption rate can be regarded as reasonable given that we took a population that is not very active as a reference, and that currently the consumption recommendations for this food group in Spain are linked to physical activity [ 59 ]. The diminished consumption of cereals and the low consumption rates of vegetables and legumes, however, that are also a source of healthy carbohydrates, could suggest that the intake of these macro-nutrients is considerably below the desirable amount (42% vs. 45–60%). Other national and recent studies about the Spanish diet have revealed similar percentage of kilocalories provided by carbohydrates (41% [ 13 , 18 ] and 42% [ 14 ]). Regarding to fibre intake, our results (27.7 g/day) have been higher than previous studies that revealed amounts of 19 g/day [ 13 ], 18 g/day [ 14 ], and 25 g/day [ 71 ]. Carbohydrates could have been displaced by the consumption of lipids that have resulted in 40%, the highest recommended limit (20–40%). Similar results have been obtained in previous studies: the percentage of kilocalories provided by Lipids was 41%, 43% and 38.5%, respectively [ 13 , 14 , 18 ]. These results could be explained because the observed daily consumption (rather than the recommended sporadic and moderate consumption) of energy-dense and atherogenic ultra-processed foods, whose nutritional contributions are poor (high energy density, low fibre and micronutrient content and high amounts of saturated and trans fats, and simple sugars) [ 71 ]. Specifically, we observed high consumption rates of soft drinks, prepared dishes and pastries, along with wine and beer (Table 4). This result is in line with the findings of Monteiro et al. (2018) who analysed the distribution (%) of total household food availability (kcal · person −1· day −1 ). They found that 26.4% kcal/day came from the consumption of ultra-processed foods [ 72 ]. In 2010, ultra-processed foods represented 31.7% of daily energy acquisitions according to recent Spanish data [ 73 ]. Currently, this class of foods represents the largest source of energy intake in some countries, and this pattern of consumption is linked to an increase in obesity rates, favouring the existence of obesogenic environments [ 74 ]. However, data published in Spain on dietary caloric intake point to a decrease over the last few years. Average energy intake (domestic and extra-domestic) was 2761 kcal/day in 2006, according to an assessment based on the Food Consumption Panel, while the estimated caloric intake was 2609 and 2358 kilocalories a day, respectively, in 2012 and 2019 [ 13 , 14 , 75 ]. Our estimation corresponded to an intake of 2930 kcal/day, which we deem more accurate, considering the high intake of ultra-processed foods, characterised by large amounts of free sugars and saturated fats, which all contributes to increasing energy intake [ 76 ]. In addition, this excessive caloric intake—which goes well beyond the population’s needs –would partly explain Spain’s high prevalence of overweight and obesity in children, adolescents, and adults [3,4]. Beyond the caloric intake, our results showed that the percentage of saturated fatty acids surpassed the recommendations (12.5% of the caloric intake). Similar results to these have been published for Spain [ 18 ] revealing a worsening of the macronutrient distribution.