scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

(nano)Materials for accelerating syntrophic fatty acids degradation to methane

Braga, Cátia Sofia Neves

Abstract

O metano é produzido a partir de uma ampla diversidade de resíduos orgânicos por comunidades microbianas anaeróbias, onde as relações sintróficas desempenham um papel determinante na eficiência do processo. Os mecanismos de transferência de eletrões interespécies (IET) podem envolver a troca de transportadores de eletrões (hidrogénio, formato), mas também a transferência direta de eletrões entre espécies (DIET). Os materiais condutores melhoram as taxas de produção de metano (MPR), mas os mecanismos envolvidos nessa IET mediada pelos materiais ainda são controversos e não totalmente conhecidos. Nesta tese, investigou-se o efeito de vários (nano)materiais, nomeadamente carvão ativado (AC), magnetite (Mag), nanotubos de carbono (CNT), AC/CNT modificados, zeólito (Zeo), areia e esferas de vidro, na produção de metano (MP). Apesar das diferenças a nível físico-químico, em geral, os (nano)materiais aumentaram as atividades metanogénicas, diminuindo as fases de latência que antecedem a MP e aumentando as MPR. As diversas características físico-químicas dos (nano)materiais, como a área de superfície específica, a área dos mesoporos, o volume dos microporos, a condutividade elétrica, a acidez/basicidade do material e as impurezas presentes na sua composição (por exemplo, S e N), isoladamente não conseguem explicar as melhorias observadas na MP. O silício foi um elemento encontrado em todos os materiais testados e melhorou a MP por mecanismos ainda desconhecidos, que merecem ser investigados. As mudanças observadas no potencial redox do meio de crescimento na presença de (nano)materiais não se correlacionaram diretamente com a melhoria na MP. Além disso, diferentes (nano)materiais podem afetar de forma diferente o mesmo microrganismo metanogénico. Por exemplo, o Methanobacterium formicicum foi bastante estimulado pelo AC e drasticamente inibido pela Mag. Contudo, o mesmo (nano)material não afetou outras espécies da mesma forma. Por exemplo, o Zeo melhorou a MPR do M. formicicum (a crescer em H2/CO2) e da Methanothrix harundinacea (a crescer em acetato), mas não teve efeito sobre a MP do Methanospirillum hungatei (a crescer em H2/CO2) e da M. barkeri (a crescer em acetato). Os resultados sugerem ainda que as espécies microbianas são afetadas diferencialmente, independentemente do tipo de substrato. O efeito dos (nano)materiais também varia dependendo da cocultura sintrófica, uma vez que o AC aumentou a atividade metanogénica da cocultura sintrófica Syntrophomonas zehnderi e M. formicicum, mas a Mag causou uma drástica inibição. Já noutra cocultura, constituída por Syntrophomonas wolfei e M. hungatei, o AC e a Mag não causaram impacto significativo. A atividade microbiana também parece influenciar o efeito dos (nano)materiais, já que melhorias significativas foram observadas principalmente por culturas menos ativas. Por exemplo, o AC melhora as MPR do M. formicicum quando adicionado na altura da inoculação, mas não teve efeito quando adicionado a culturas ativas deste microrganismo durante a fase de crescimento exponencial. Esta relação entre a atividade microbiana e o efeito dos (nano)materiais também foi observada em enriquecimentos microbianos e no bioreator operado em contínuo. A composição microbiana dos enriquecimentos especializados na degradação de butirato e desenvolvidos com e sem (nano)materiais foi diferente, e não foram enriquecidas espécies eletroativas (tais como Geobacter spp.) na presença dos materiais. Análises microscópicas, taxonómicas e de expressão genética sugerem que a conversão de butirato a hidrogénio e acetato foi efetuada por microrganismos do género Syntrophomonas, e nenhum gene relacionado com DIET foi detetado.

Full text

Universidade do Minho Escola de Engenharia Cátia Sofia Neves Braga (nano)Materials for accelerating syntrophic fatty acids degradation to methane Abril 2023 UMinho | 2023Cátia Sofia Neves Braga (nano)Materials for accelerating syntrophic fatty acids degradation to methane Universidade do Minho Escola de Engenharia Cátia Sofia Neves Braga (nano)Materials for accelerating syntrophic fatty acids degradation to methane Tese de Doutoramento Doutoramento em Engenharia Química e Biológica Trabalho efetuado sob a orientação da Doutora Andreia Filipa Ferreira Salvador Doutora Luciana José Ribeiro Pereira E da Professora Doutora Inês Antunes Cardoso Pereira Abril 2023 ii DIREITOS DE AUTOR E CONDIÇÕES DE UTILIZAÇÃO DO TRABALHO POR TERCEIROS Este é um trabalho académico que pode ser utilizado por terceiros desde que respeitadas as regras e boas práticas internacionalmente aceites, no que concerne aos direitos de autor e direitos conexos. Assim, o presente trabalho pode ser utilizado nos termos previstos na licença abaixo indicada. Caso o utilizador necessite de permissão para poder fazer um uso do trabalho em condições não previstas no licenciamento indicado, deverá contactar o autor, através do RepositóriUM da Universidade do Minho. Licença concedida aos utilizadores deste trabalho Atribuição-NãoComercial-SemDerivações CC BY-NC-ND https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS During this journey, many people contributed with knowledge, inspiration, encouragement and support, making me grow professionally and personally. To all of them, I offer my gratitude. To Professor Madalena Alves, for giving me the opportunity to join her incredible team (BRIDGE group), for pushing me out of my comfort zone and for the scientific inspiration that she gave in all the meetings where we discussed science. And thank you for the support during the development of this PhD project. To my supervisors, Doctor Andreia Salvador, Doctor Luciana Pereira, and Professor Inês Pereira, for accepting being part of this project, and for helping and supporting me to accomplish the conclusion of this thesis. Thank you for sharing your scientific knowledge, for dedicating your time and for all the suggestions that contributed to this work. To Andreia Salvador, for being more than my supervisor. For being a friend, for believing in my work and for not letting me fall when things went less well. Thank you for inspiring me in science and for being a person with such a big heart. To Gilberto Martins, for all his expertise and contributions for the work developed. To Salomé Duarte and João Sequeira for gladly contributing with their expertise in different phases of this work. Thank you for your help and for being part of this project. To all external collaborators that contributed to my PhD work, namely Professor Fernando Pereira (FEUP), Doctor Salomé Soares (FEUP), Professor Isabel Neves (UMinho) and Rui Fernandes (HEMS, i3S), thank you for the availability and the cooperation over this work. To my colleagues and friends from BRIDGE, for the constant support, help and friendship. In particular to Salomé, Rita, Carla, Sónia and Sérgio, thank you for being such good friends and always being there for me at any time. Thank you to Ana Júlia Cavaleiro for also contributing with her expertise and for the advices given during the development of this project. And thank you to CEB and all the technical staff. To my family, specially my mom and my sister, and my friends, specially Fi, Daniela Martins, Rita Sousa, and João Campos. Thank you for being always there for me. To Nelson, for being my partner, and for believing, supporting and encouraging me all the time. Thank you for being there for me too. This PhD was supported by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (FCT) through the grants SFRH/BD/132003/2017 and COVID/BD/152431/2022, and by European Union, through the Portuguese State Budget and the European Social Fund under the scope of Norte2020 - Programa Operacional Regional do Norte. Entities supporting this work: FCT under the scope of the strategic funding of UIDB/04469/2020 unit, and LABBELS - associate laboratory in biotechnology and bioengineering and microelectromechanical systems. This research was also supported under the scope of the CM4Methane project (Ref: PTDC/BTA-BTA/2249/2021) financed by national funds through FCT, I.P. iv STATEMENT OF INTEGRITY I hereby declare having conducted this academic work with integrity. I confirm that I have not used plagiarism or any form of undue use of information or falsification of results along the process leading to its elaboration. I further declare that I have fully acknowledged the Code of Ethical Conduct of the University of Minho. v (NANO)MATERIAIS PARA ACELERAR A DEGRADAÇÃO SINTRÓFICA DE ÁCIDOS GORDOS A METANO RESUMO O metano é produzido a partir de uma ampla diversidade de resíduos orgânicos por comunidades microbianas anaeróbias, onde as relações sintróficas desempenham um papel determinante na eficiência do processo. Os mecanismos de transferência de eletrões interespécies (IET) podem envolver a troca de transportadores de eletrões (hidrogénio, formato), mas também a transferência direta de eletrões entre espécies (DIET). Os materiais condutores melhoram as taxas de produção de metano (MPR), mas os mecanismos envolvidos nessa IET mediada pelos materiais ainda são controversos e não totalmente conhecidos. Nesta tese, investigou-se o efeito de vários (nano)materiais, nomeadamente carvão ativado (AC), magnetite (Mag), nanotubos de carbono (CNT), AC/CNT modificados, zeólito (Zeo), areia e esferas de vidro, na produção de metano (MP). Apesar das diferenças a nível físico-químico, em geral, os (nano)materiais aumentaram as atividades metanogénicas, diminuindo as fases de latência que antecedem a MP e aumentando as MPR. As diversas características físico-químicas dos (nano)materiais, como a área de superfície específica, a área dos mesoporos, o volume dos microporos, a condutividade elétrica, a acidez/basicidade do material e as impurezas presentes na sua composição (por exemplo, S e N), isoladamente não conseguem explicar as melhorias observadas na MP. O silício foi um elemento encontrado em todos os materiais testados e melhorou a MP por mecanismos ainda desconhecidos, que merecem ser investigados. As mudanças observadas no potencial redox do meio de crescimento na presença de (nano)materiais não se correlacionaram diretamente com a melhoria na MP. Além disso, diferentes (nano)materiais podem afetar de forma diferente o mesmo microrganismo metanogénico. Por exemplo, o Methanobacterium formicicum foi bastante estimulado pelo AC e drasticamente inibido pela Mag. Contudo, o mesmo (nano)material não afetou outras espécies da mesma forma. Por exemplo, o Zeo melhorou a MPR do M. formicicum (a crescer em H2/CO2) e da Methanothrix harundinacea (a crescer em acetato), mas não teve efeito sobre a MP do Methanospirillum hungatei (a crescer em H2/CO2) e da M. barkeri (a crescer em acetato). Os resultados sugerem ainda que as espécies microbianas são afetadas diferencialmente, independentemente do tipo de substrato. O efeito dos (nano)materiais também varia dependendo da cocultura sintrófica, uma vez que o AC aumentou a atividade metanogénica da cocultura sintrófica Syntrophomonas zehnderi e M. formicicum , mas a Mag causou uma drástica inibição. Já noutra cocultura, constituída por Syntrophomonas wolfei e M. hungatei , o AC e a Mag não causaram impacto significativo. A atividade microbiana também parece influenciar o efeito dos (nano)materiais, já que melhorias significativas foram observadas principalmente por culturas menos ativas. Por exemplo, o AC melhora as MPR do M. formicicum quando adicionado na altura da inoculação, mas não teve efeito quando adicionado a culturas ativas deste microrganismo durante a fase de crescimento exponencial. Esta relação entre a atividade microbiana e o efeito dos (nano)materiais também foi observada em enriquecimentos microbianos e no bioreator operado em contínuo. A composição microbiana dos enriquecimentos especializados na degradação de butirato e desenvolvidos com e sem (nano)materiais foi diferente, e não foram enriquecidas espécies eletroativas (tais como Geobacter spp.) na presença dos materiais. Análises microscópicas, taxonómicas e de expressão genética sugerem que a conversão de butirato a hidrogénio e acetato foi efetuada por microrganismos do género Syntrophomonas , e nenhum gene relacionado com DIET foi detetado. Palavras-chave: Ácidos gordos; Interações sintróficas; Metano; (nano)Materiais; Transferência de electrões interespécies. vi (NANO)MATERIALS FOR ACCELERATING SYNTROPHIC FATTY ACIDS DEGRADATION TO METHANE ABSTRACT Methane is produced from a wide diversity of organic wastes by anaerobic microbial communities, where syntrophic relationships play a key role in the efficiency of the process. Interspecies electron transfer (IET) mechanisms may involve the exchange of electron carriers (hydrogen, formate), but also direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). Conductive materials improve methane production rates (MPR), but the mechanisms involved in this material mediated IET are still controversial and not fully known. In this thesis, the effect of several (nano)materials, namely activated carbon (AC), magnetite (Mag), carbon nanotubes (CNT), modified AC/CNT, zeolite (Zeo), sand and glass beads, on methane production (MP) was investigated. Despite their physicochemical differences, generally, (nano)materials enhanced methanogenic activities, by decreasing lag phases preceding MP and increasing MPR. The various physicochemical characteristics of (nano)materials, such as the specific surface area, area of mesopores, volume of micropores, electrical conductivity, material acidity/basicity, and impurities present on material composition (e.g., S and N) could not explain per se the enhancement observed on MP. Silicon was an element found in all materials tested and, per se, improved MP by mechanisms yet unknown, which deserve to be further explored. The changes observed on redox potential of the growth medium in the presence of (nano)materials were not directly correlated with the improvement of MP. Besides, different (nano)materials can impact differently the same methanogen. For example, Methanobacterium formicicum was greatly stimulated by AC and drastically inhibited by Mag. However, the same (nano)material did not impact all species in the same way. For instance, Zeo improved MPR by M. formicicum (growing on H2/CO2) and Methanothrix harundinacea (growing on acetate) but had no effect on MP by Methanospirillum hungatei (growing on H2/CO2) and M. barkeri (growing on acetate). These results likewise suggest that microbial species are differentially affected, independently of the type of substrate. The effect of (nano)materials also varies depending on the syntrophic coculture, since AC enhanced the methanogenic activity of the syntrophic coculture Syntrophomonas zehnderi and M. formicicum , but Mag caused severe inhibition. Yet, in another coculture, composed by Syntrophomonas wolfei with M. hungatei, AC and Mag did not cause significant impact. The microbial activity also seems to dictate the effect of (nano)materials, as significant improvements were mainly observed by less active cultures. For instance, AC generally improved MPR of M. formicicum cultures, but had no effect when added to highly active M. formicicum cultures during the exponential growth phase. This relation between microbial activity and the effect of (nano)materials was also observed in enrichment cultures and in the continuous bioreactor. Microbial composition of butyrate-degrading enrichments developed with and without (nano)materials was different, but electroactive species (e.g., Geobacter ) were not enriched in the presence of any material. Microscopic, taxonomic and gene expression analyses suggested that butyrate conversion to hydrogen and acetate occurred by microorganisms closed related to Syntrophomonas , and no genes related to DIET were detected. Keywords: Fatty acids; Interspecies electron transfer; Methane; (nano)Materials; Syntrophic interactions. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1 .................................................................................................................................... 1 1. Thesis Scope ............................................................................................................................. 1 1.1. Context .............................................................................................................................. 2 1.2. Aims .................................................................................................................................. 3 1.3. Thesis outline..................................................................................................................... 4 1.4. Scientific outputs ............................................................................................................... 5 CHAPTER 2 .................................................................................................................................... 8 2. General Introduction .................................................................................................................. 8 2.1. Syntrophic interactions in anaerobic digestion processes .................................................... 9 2.1.1. Mechanisms of interspecies electron transfer ....................................................... 11 2.1.1.1. Indirect interspecies electron transfer ................................................................... 11 2.1.1.2. Direct interspecies electron transfer ..................................................................... 13 2.1.1.3. Conductive materials and interspecies electron transfer........................................ 16 2.1.2. The microbiology of syntrophic butyrate degradation ............................................ 19 2.1.2.1. Butyrate-degrading syntrophic bacteria ................................................................. 20 2.1.2.2. Methanogenic partners in syntrophic fatty acids degradation ................................ 22 2.2. Effect of (nano)materials on methane production .............................................................. 25 2.2.1. Effect of CM on methanogenic pure cultures and on syntrophic cocultures ........... 26 2.2.2. Effect of CM on microbial enrichments from natural sediments ............................ 31 2.2.3. Effect of (nano)materials on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities ..................................................................................................... 38 2.3. Characteristics of (nano)materials and their role on MP .................................................... 49 2.3.1. Carbon-based materials ....................................................................................... 49 2.3.2. Iron-based materials ............................................................................................ 51 2.3.3. Zeolites ............................................................................................................... 52 2.4. Methodologies to evaluate the effect of (nano)materials on methanogenic cultures ............ 53 2.4.1. Taxonomic analysis ............................................................................................. 53 2.4.2. Meta-omics analyses ........................................................................................... 54 2.4.3. Microscopy analyses ............................................................................................ 55 2.4.4. Cyclic voltammetry .............................................................................................. 56 CHAPTER 3 .................................................................................................................................. 57 xiv List of Figures - Appendix Figure A. 1. Profiles of cumulative methane production for increasing concentrations of conductive materials (CM) incubated with M. formicicum during the first 3 d of incubation. ............................... 160 Figure A. 2. Complete profiles of cumulative methane production for the incubations of M. formicicum with different concentrations of conductive materials. ...................................................................... 161 Figure A. 3. a) Variation of oleate concentration over time during abiotic experiments with and without activated carbon (AC, batch 1), and with magnetite (Mag), at different concentrations. Oleate quantification was affected by its poor solubility and tendency to be adsorbed in surfaces/materials. b) Images of the bottles in abiotic conditions with and without materials, and visual differences in the turbidity of the medium. ............................................................................................................................... 162 Figure A. 4. Acetate consumption over time for pure cultures of a) M. barkeri and b) M. harundinacea , growing without and with different materials (AC (batch 2), Mag, Zeo). The results are the mean and standard deviation of triplicate assays. ............................................................................................ 162 Figure A. 5. Acetate concentration over time in abiotic assays without materials and with 0.5 g∙L-1 of AC (batch 2), Mag, and Zeo. Assays were performed in duplicates and the values represented the average and the respective standard deviation. ............................................................................................ 163 Figure A. 6. Butyrate concentration over time in abiotic assays with and without a) 0.5 g∙L-1 of AC (batch 2) and Mag, and b) 0.5 g∙L-1 of Zeo. The values are the average and the respective standard deviation of duplicate assays. Zeo tests were performed in a different period of AC and Mag experiments. .......... 163 Figure A. 7. Concentrations over time of VFA (acetate, propionate, and butyrate) and ethanol in the influent (Cin) and effluent (Cout) during the continuous operation of the EGSB bioreactor. The operation occurred in four periods in which the variables were the COD of the feed and the presence or absence of GAC (and even its concentration inside the bioreactor). ................................................................... 164 Figure A. 8. Complete cumulative MP profiles of the two lines of butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures, with and without conductive materials (AC, Mag). ............................................................................ 165 xv LIST OF TABLES Table 2.1. Standard free Gibbs energies of some VFA and methanogenic reactions involved in fatty acid oxidation and MP (adapted from Stams and Plugge (2009)) .............................................................. 11 Table 2.2. Summary of the studies with defined cocultures where CM act as mediators in IET ......... 18 Table 2.3. Summary of studies with pure cultures of methanogens and the effects of materials on methanogenic activity. The main impacts highlighted were regarding the decrease (↓) of lag phase time (given in percentage, comparing the control condition with the best concentration of CM applied (best concentration in bold type)) and the number of times that MPR increases (+) or decreases relatively to the control ........................................................................................................................................ 28 Table 2.4. Summary of studies showing the effect of the addition of materials on methanogenic activity of syntrophic cocultures by the number of times that MPR increases (+) relatively to the control, and the degree of decrease (↓) in lag phase time (in percentage), comparing the control without material with the assay with materials ......................................................................................................................... 30 Table 2.5. Summary of studies using CM to develop enrichment cultures, highlighting the main impacts promoted by the presence of materials in terms of lag phase reduction (↓) and MPR improvement for each transfer (“n” represents the number of transfers performed), and the main bacteria and methanogens enriched in the final microbial communities ................................................................. 33 Table 2.6. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials ............................................................................................................... 40 Table 3.1. Summary of the modified materials and composites used in the incubations .................. 64 Table 3.2. Physicochemical characterization of materials regarding SBET, Smeso, Vmicro, total pore volume (micropore and mesopore, Vp P/Po=0.95), pHpzc, conductivity, chemical analysis, and elemental composition assessed by SEM-EDS ...................................................................................................................... 69 Table 3.3. Characterization of ACb2 (starting material), modified AC, and ACb3, in terms of SBET, Smeso, Vmicro, total pore volume (Vp P/Po=0.95), pHpzc, and elemental analysis ................................................................. 70 xvi Table 3.4. Values of ORP, pH, and conductivity of the growth medium with H2/CO2, at the beginning (a), middle (b) and end (c) of abiotic assays in the presence of different concentrations (C) of materials ... 74 Table 3.5. Values of initial concentration of substrate (CH2), lag phase duration, IMPR, EMPR, and incubation time (t) for the conversion of H2/CO2 to methane, for the assays with and without CM ....... 77 Table 3.6. Number of times that the IMPR and EMPR increases, or decreases (> 1 or < 1, respectively), relatively to the biotic control without CM .......................................................................................... 78 Table 3.7. Values of ORP, pH, and conductivity of the growth medium at (a) the beginning, (b) during exponential MP, and (c) at the end of incubations with M. formicicum pure cultures .......................... 80 Table 3.8. Results of the incubations of M. formicicum with modified AC, AC from different batches, and with Zeo, glass beads and sand, regarding the initial concentration of substrate (CH2), the duration of lag phase, the IMPR, the EMPR, and the time of incubation (t) required for the complete conversion of H2/CO2 to methane ....................................................................................................................................... 82 Table 3.9. Summary of the IMPR and EMPR improvements or decrease (> 1 or < 1, respectively), relatively to the biotic control without materials and some physicochemical properties of materials .... 83 Table 3.10. Effect of different modified AC, AC from different batches, and Zeo, glass beads, sand on the growth medium parameters (ORP, pH and conductivity) a) after 24 h the beginning and b) at the end of the incubations with the pure culture M. formicicum ...................................................................... 85 Table 4.1. Relation between the presence of AC, Mag or Zeo and the number of times the IMPR and EMPR increases, or decreases (> 1 or < 1, respectively), relatively to the control assays without materials ...................................................................................................................................................... 101 Table 5.1. Summary of the butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures used in batch incubations and the designation adopted ....................................................................................................................... 114 Table 5.2. Summary of the values of VS for each sludge used as inoculum (Inoc.) in each type of incubation (in gVS·gbiomass-1 and gVS·L-1) and values of SMA in H2/CO2 (80/20, v/v) and acetate (30 mmol·L-1). The pre-treatment applied to the sludge was also listed ................................................................... 116 Table 5.3. Adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures in different conditions and the impacts towards the IMPR, the EMPR, the duration of lag phase and the time of incubation for MP ............... 127 xvii Table 6.1. Characterization of butyrate-degrading enrichments without and with materials in terms of: number of transfers performed, lag phase duration, IMPR, MPR, and the time of incubation (t) required for the total conversion of butyrate to methane ................................................................................ 142 Table 6.2. Taxonomic characterization presented at the Genus level (at relative abundance ≥ 2.00 %) of anaerobic inocula sludge and stable butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures, with and without (nano)materials, based on 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. The relative abundance of each taxon (given in percentage) is the average and standard deviation for (at least) duplicate samples ............. 146 List of Tables - Appendix Table A. 1. Values of initial concentration of substrates (Ci), lag phase duration, IMPR, EMPR, and the time of incubation (t) in each assay, with and without materials (namely, AC, Mag and Zeo) ............. 166 Table A. 2. Values of the growth medium parameters, i.e., ORP, pH, and conductivity, at the beginning (a), during exponential MP (b), and at the end (c) of incubations ...................................................... 168 Table A. 3. Effect of different materials (at 0.5 g∙L-1) on parameters (ORP, pH and conductivity) of abiotic medium with acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) at the beginning (a), after 24 h (b), in the middle (c) and at the end (d) of abiotic assays (same composition of M. harundinacea growth medium) .................................. 170 Table A. 4. Effect of different materials (at 0.5 g∙L-1) on ORP, pH, and conductivity of anaerobic medium (a) at the beginning, (b) after 24 h, (c) in the middle and (d) at the end of the of abiotic tests with butyrate (10 mmol∙L-1) .................................................................................................................................. 170 Table A. 5. Values of ORP, pH and conductivity of anaerobic medium with oleate (1 mmol∙L-1) at the middle of the abiotic assays without materials and with different concentrations (C) of AC and Mag . 171 Table A. 6. Initial butyrate concentration and values of acetate accumulation in the assays with enrichment cultures specialized in MP only via hydrogenotrophic pathway: AC-adapted culture (MoreAct- B-AC-3) and Mag-adapted culture (MoreAct-B-Mag-3) in the original incubation conditions and in the absence of the material to which each the culture was adapted to ................................................... 171 Table A. 7. Mean values of the COD fed, organic loading rate (OLR), methane produced as its COD equivalent (g COD-CH4) and methane yield expressed as the volume of CH4 produced per gram of COD removed (CODrem) obtained for each period .................................................................................. 171 xviii Table A. 8. Values for ORP, pH and conductivity measured after 24 h of the beginning and at the end of the incubation of adapted butyrate-degrading cultures developed with and without materials (in original conditions and when incubated in other conditions) ......................................................................... 172 Table A. 9. Values of the substrate concentration and concentration of acetate after some time (t) of incubation for less active butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures .................................................... 173 Table A. 10. Values of ORP, pH and conductivity, measured after 24 h of the beginning and at the end of the incubation of stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures developed with and without (nano)materials .................................................................................................................. 173 Table A. 11. Complete taxonomic characterization presented at the Genus level of inocula (anaerobic sludge) and microbial enrichment communities specialized in butyrate degradation, developed with and without (nano)materials, based on 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. The average and standard deviation for (at least) duplicate samples is given (in percentage) for the relative abundance of each taxon. The double line in the table separates archaea members from bacteria ........................................... 174 xix LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AC Activated carbon ACb1 Activated carbon from batch 1 ACb2 Activated carbon from batch 2 ACb3 Activated carbon from batch 3 Ack Acetate kinase Acs Acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthetase Act Acetyl-CoA acetyltransferase AC-b1 Stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment with activated carbon from the first batch of experiments AC_HNO3 Activated carbon oxidized with nitric acid AC_HNO3_400 Activated carbon oxidized with nitric acid at 400 °C AC_HNO3_600 Activated carbon oxidized with nitric acid at 600 °C AC_HNO3_900 Activated carbon oxidized with nitric acid at 900 °C AC_H2SO4 Activated carbon treated with sulfuric acid AC_H2SO4_ HNO3 Activated carbon treated with H2SO4 and HNO3 AC_N Activated carbon thermal treated with nitrogen flow AC@2%Fe Activated carbon impregnated with 2 % of iron, calcinated and reduced at 400 °C AD Anaerobic digestion AGS Anaerobic granular sludge Ak Acetate kinase ANOVA Single factor analysis of variances ASi Silicic acid in aqueous solution At Phosphate acetyltransferase AtoB Acetyl-CoA C-acetyltransferase ATPase ATP synthase Bcd Butyryl-CoA dehydrogenase BET Brunauer-Emmett-Teller B-AC-1 Enrichment culture with activated carbon, first incubation B-AC-2 Enrichment culture with activated carbon, second incubation (1st transfer) B-Mag-1 Enrichment culture with magnetite, first incubation B-Mag-2 Enrichment culture with magnetite, second incubation (1st transfer) B-without-AC-Mag-1 Enrichment culture without activated carbon or magnetite, first incubation B-without-AC-Mag-2 Enrichment culture without activated carbon or magnetite, second incubation (1st transfer) B-without-Zeo-1 Enrichment culture without zeolite, first incubation B-without-Zeo-2 Enrichment culture without zeolite, second incubation (1st transfer) B-Zeo-1 Enrichment culture with zeolite, first incubation xx B-Zeo-2 Enrichment culture with zeolite, second incubation (1st transfer) Bty-b1 Stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment without materials from the first batch of experiments Bty-b2 Stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment without materials from the second batch of experiments C Concentration CH2 Initial concentration of hydrogen c1 Low concentration of substrate c2 High concentration of substrate CIET Conductive material mediated interspecies electron transfer CM Conductive materials CNT Carbon nanotubes CNT@2%Fe Carbon nanotubes impregnated with 2 % of iron, calcinated and reduced at 400 °C CoA Coenzyme A CoB Coenzyme B COD Chemical oxygen demand Codh Carbon-monoxide dehydrogenase Codh-Acs Carbon monoxide dehydrogenase/acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthase complex CODrem Chemical oxygen demand removal CoM Coenzyme M Ctr Crotonyl-CoA hydratase CV Cyclic voltammetry DIET Direct interspecies electron transfer EA Elemental analysis EC Enzyme commission number Ech Energy-converting hydrogenase EDS Energy dispersive spectrometry EET Extracellular electron transfer EGSB Expanded granular sludge bed Eha Energy-converting hydrogenase A EIS Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy EMPR Exponential methane production rates Etf Electron transfer flavoprotein EtfAB Electron transfer flavoproteins A and B e-pili Electrically conductive pili Fd Ferredoxin FDox Oxidized ferredoxin Fdred Reduced ferredoxin Fdh Formate dehydrogenase Fdh1, Fdh3 Formate dehydrogenases (1 and 3) xxi Fdh2, Fdh4 NADH dependent formate dehydrogenases (membrane bound, quinone reducing) FeS Complex membrane bound FeS-oxidoreductase FID Flame ionization detector FISH Fluorescence in situ hybridizing Fnt Formate transporter Fpo F420H2 dehydrogenase Frh Coenzyme F420-reducing hydrogenase Ftr Formyl-methanofurantetrahydromethanopterin formyl-transferase Fwd Formyl-methanofuran dehydrogenase GAC Granular activated carbon GC Gas chromatography HbdH 3-hydroxybutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase Hdr Soluble heterodisulfide reductase HdrDE Membrane-bound heterodisulfide reductase (acetoclastic metabolism) Hmd H2-dependent methylenetetrahydromethanopterin dehydrogenase HPLC High performance liquid chromatography HRT Hydraulic retention time Hyd1 Electron confurcating (NADH-dependent) hydrogenase Hyd2 Membrane-bound [FeFe]-hydrogenase Hyd3 Ferredoxin dependent hydrogenase H4MPT Tetrahydromethanopterin IET Interspecies electron transfer IFT Interspecies formate transfer IHT Interspecies hydrogen transfer IMPR Initial methane production rates Inoc-b1 Inoculum for the first batch of experiments with enrichment cultures Inoc-b2 Inoculum for the second batch of experiments with enrichment cultures LCFA Long chain fatty acids LessAct Less active LessAct-B-AC-1a Less active enrichment developed with activated carbon during 2nd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-AC-1b Less active enrichment developed with activated carbon during 2nd transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-AC-2a Less active enrichment developed with activated carbon during 3rd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-AC-2b Less active enrichment developed with activated carbon during 3rd transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-Mag-1a Less active enrichment developed with magnetite during 2nd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-Mag-1b Less active enrichment developed with magnetite during 2nd transfer, bottle b xxii LessAct-B-Mag-2a Less active enrichment developed with magnetite during 3rd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-Mag-2b Less active enrichment developed with magnetite during 3rd transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-1a Less active enrichment developed without activated carbon or magnetite during 2nd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-1b Less active enrichment developed without activated carbon or magnetite during 2nd transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-2a Less active enrichment developed without activated carbon or magnetite during 3rd transfer, bottle a LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-2b Less active enrichment developed without activated carbon or magnetite during 3rd transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-without-Zeo-1b Less active enrichment developed without zeolite during 4th transfer, bottle b LessAct-B-Zeo-1a Less active enrichment developed with zeolite during 4th transfer, bottle a Mag Magnetite Mag-b1 Stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment with magnetite from the first batch of experiments Mcr Methyl-coenzyme M reductase McrABG Methyl-coenzyme M reductase ABG Mch Methenyl-tetrahydromethanopterin cyclohydrolase Mer 5,10- methylenetetrahydromethanopterin reductase MFR Methanofuran MoreAct More active MoreAct-B-AC-3 Well adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment culture developed with activated carbon after 9 transfers (methane only produced via hydrogenotrophic pathway) MoreAct-B-Mag-3 Well adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment culture developed with magnetite after 8 transfers (methane only produced via hydrogenotrophic pathway) MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3 Well adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment culture developed without activated carbon or magnetite after 9 transfers (methane only produced via hydrogenotrophic pathway) MP Methane production MPh Methanophenazine MPR Methane production rates MQ Menaquinone (or methylnaphthoquinone) Mtd Methylene-tetrahydromethanopterin dehydrogenase Mtr Methyl-H4MPT:CoM methyltransferase (hydrogenotrophic metabolism) MtrA-H Tetrahydromethanopterin S-methyltransferase (acetoclastic metabolism) Mvh F420-non-reducing hydrogenase MWCNT Multiwalled carbon nanotubes n Number of transfers performed in microbial enrichment studies xxiii nc Not calculated nd Not detected Non-CM Non-conductive materials OLR Organic loading rate ORP Oxidation reduction potential (redox potential) PAC Powdered activated carbon pHpzc pH at the zero point charge Pta Phosphate acetyltransferase rGO Reduced graphene oxide SBET Specific surface area SEM Scanning electron microscope SMA Specific methanogenic activity Smeso Mesopore surface area STP Standard temperature and pressure conditions t Time of incubation TEM Transmission electron microscopy TS Total solids VFA Volatile fatty acids Vh0 Nickel-iron-sulfur haemoprotein Vmicro Micropore volume Vp Pore volume VS Volatile solids VSS Volatile suspended solids Vp P/P0=0.95 Total pore volume Zeo Zeolite Zeo-b2 Stable and well-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment with zeolite from the second batch of experiments ZVI Zero-valent iron ΔG0 Gibbs free energy λ Lag phase Chapter 1 | Thesis scope 7 DCE21 - Doctoral Congress in Engineering - 4th Symposium on Chemical and Biological Engineering. Porto, Portugal, June 28-29, 189-190, 2021. ISBN: 978-972-752-282-8. 5. Faria, Juliana; Rocha, Ana; Duarte, Maria Salomé; Braga, Cátia S.N.; Fonseca, António M.; Neves, Isabel C.; Alves, M. Madalena. Effect of zeolite nanomaterials in methanogenic communities. XXVII Encontro Nacional da Sociedade Portuguesa de Química. No. P27, Braga, Portugal, July 14-16 julho, 232, 2021. 6. Alves, M. Madalena; Braga, Cátia S.N.; Martins, Gilberto; Salvador, Andreia F.; Pereira, M.F.R.; Pereira, Luciana; Soares, O.S.G.P.; Cavaleiro, Ana Júlia; Pereira, M. Alcina; Stams, Alfons J.M. Conductive materials affect methanogenic activity of pure cultures of methanogens and syntrophic cocultures . Electromicrobiology 2019. No. P1, Aarhus, Denmark, March 21-22, 36, 2019. 8 CHAPTER 2 2. GENERAL INTRODUCTION Conductive (nano)materials, like activated carbon (AC), magnetite (Mag), and carbon nanotubes (CNT), have been applied in anaerobic digestion (AD) processes with the aim of enhancing the efficiency of methane production (MP) during the degradation of organic wastes. Previous research suggested that interspecies electron transfer (IET) mechanisms may change in the presence of conductive materials (CM), but this cannot explain the improvements observed in methanogenic pure cultures. This chapter provides a contextualization about the syntrophic relationships in AD processes and the mechanisms known for IET. A literature review is also presented for the application and the effects of CM in systems of different complexity, i.e., from pure cultures of methanogens to complex microbial communities. A general overview is given for the main possible mechanisms reported in the literature when carbon- and iron-based materials, and also zeolites (Zeo), are applied in anaerobic environments. Finally, some methodologies considered important to study anaerobic systems in the presence of (nano)materials are presented. Chapter 2 | General introduction 9 2.1. SYNTROPHIC INTERACTIONS IN ANAEROBIC DIGESTION PROCESSES Anaerobic digestion is a biotechnology process where biomethane, a renewable biofuel, is produced during the treatment of organic wastes. The conversion of wastes to methane is accomplished through a sequence of four steps, namely hydrolysis, acidogenesis, acetogenesis and methanogenesis (Borja et al., 2011). It is a complex biological process that involves the activity of different microbial groups, i.e., hydrolytic, acidogenic and acetogenic bacteria, and methanogenic archaea (Figure 2.1) (Borja et al., 2011; Stams et al., 2012). Methanogens are dependent on acetogenic bacteria which convert a wide range of organic compounds to their simple substrates, i.e., H2/CO2, formate and acetate, which are used by methanogens to produce methane (Whitman et al., 2006). But acetogens are dependent on methanogens as well. The acetogenic reactions, like the oxidation of volatile fatty acids (VFA) to acetate and H2/CO2, are thermodynamically unfavourable (Table 2.1) (Moraes et al., 2015; Zhang et al., 2023). For instance, the Gibbs free energy change of butyrate reaction is positive (+48 kJ per mole of butyrate oxidized) under standard conditions (pH 7, 1 atm of H2 and 1 mmol·L-1 of acetate and butyrate (Sieber et al., 2012)). Butyrate degradation becomes thermodynamically favourable only when hydrogen and formate concentrations are maintained at low levels as they are consumed by methanogens, with a Gibbs free energy change of -39 kJ per mole of butyrate (1 Pa of H2 partial pressure and 0.1 mmol·L-1 of butyrate and acetate) (Sieber et al., 2012). This mutualistic interaction is known as syntrophy, where the intermediates that are exchanged between the syntrophic partners must be maintained at very low concentrations to keep occurring an efficient cooperation among partners (Sieber et al., 2012). By removing hydrogen from the system, methanogens maintain the hydrogen partial pressure at low levels, which is a favourable condition to keep acetogenic reactions to occur, while the acetogenic bacteria provide the methanogenic substrates as a product of their metabolism (Shen et al., 2016). This is a mutual dependent relationship, since specific organic compounds cannot be degraded by neither the bacterium nor the archaeon alone (J R Sieber et al., 2010; Stams and Plugge, 2009). Chapter 2 | General introduction 10 Figure 2.1. Schematic representation of the complex organic matter degradation during AD process and the microbial groups involved. The cooperation between syntrophic partners is established by transferring electrons from one species to the other, in a process called interspecies electron transfer (IET) (Stams and Plugge, 2009; Zhang et al., 2023). For instance, typical fatty-acids degrading syntrophic bacteria store the electrons (present in VFA) in hydrogen molecules and the resulting H2 is then transferred to hydrogenotrophic methanogens that use it for methane production (MP) via CO2 reduction (J.-H. Park et al., 2018). For many years, electron transfer via H2/formate carriers between syntrophic bacteria and methanogens were the only known mechanisms for IET (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Martins et al., 2018). However, mechanisms for IET in microbial communities can also include IET directly via biological electrical connections (e.g., nanowires), or by the mediation of electrons via CM (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Lovley, 2017a; Rotaru et al., 2021). Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) and conductive materials mediated interspecies electron transfer (CIET) can be alternative mechanisms to IET or can exist coupled to the formation of H2/formate electron carriers. The mechanisms for external electron exchange between syntrophic partners will be presented in more detail in the following subsections. Chapter 2 | General introduction 11 Table 2.1. Standard free Gibbs energies of some VFA and methanogenic reactions involved in fatty acid oxidation and MP (adapted from Stams and Plugge (2009)) Substrates Reactions ΔG°’/ (kJ·mol-1) Fatty acids oxidation Propionate C3H5O2 −+2H2O→C2H3O2 −+3H2+CO2 +72 Butyrate C4H7O2 −+2H2O→2C2H3O2 −+H++2H2 +48 Acetoclastic methanogenesis Acetate C2H3O2 −+H+→CH4+CO2 -36 Hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis Hydrogen 4H2+CO2→CH4+2H2O -131 2.1.1. Mechanisms of interspecies electron transfer In methanogenic environments, the mechanisms responsible for IET can be diverse. Electrons can be transferred between electron-donating bacteria and electron-accepting methanogens through the following mechanisms: a) interspecies hydrogen transfer (IHT) or interspecies formate transfer (IFT); b) direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), via electrically conductive pili ( e -pili) and/or c -type cytochromes; or c) conductive material mediated interspecies electron transfer (CIET) (Figure 2.2) (Lovley, 2017b; Martins et al., 2018; Rotaru et al., 2021). Figure 2.2. Schematic representation of IET mechanisms occurring in methanogenic environments (adapted from Martins et al . (2018)). 2.1.1.1. Indirect interspecies electron transfer The IHT/IFT (Figure 2.2a) are mechanisms that involve the production and consumption of electron carriers (i.e., hydrogen and formate), being classified as an indirect mechanism for IET (Stams and Plugge, 2009). The electron-donating bacteria are able to produce soluble molecules (H2 and formate) as a way to dissipate the electrons generated from the degradation of organic compounds (Martins et al., 2018; Shen et al., 2016). Then, electrons are transferred via diffusible electron-carrying molecules between the electron-donating species (syntroph – the acetogenic bacteria) and the electron-accepting partner (methanogenic archaea) (J.-H. Park et al., 2018). In IHT, protons are reduced to H2 which can be Chapter 2 | General introduction 12 oxidized by hydrogenotrophic methanogens producing methane via CO2 reduction (Rotaru et al., 2014a). Some hydrogenotrophic methanogens are also capable to produce methane using formate as electron donor (J. H. Park et al., 2018; Rotaru et al., 2014b). Comparing both molecules in terms of diffusivity, hydrogen can diffuse 30 times faster than formate and IHT becomes more favourable when interspecies distances are low (Shen et al., 2016; Stams, 1994). Moreover, the IHT rate is significantly improved when bacteria and methanogens form aggregates, because microorganisms are packed together and the small distance between cells facilitates hydrogen diffusion (Shen et al., 2016; Stams and Plugge, 2009). In contrast, formate is about 1 000 times more soluble than hydrogen, so IFT could be the dominant mechanism when interspecies distances are high (Shen et al., 2016; Stams, 1994). This way, under certain conditions IFT may prevail over IHT, and vice-versa (Shen et al., 2016; Zhang et al., 2023). Examples of syntrophic relationships involving IHT and IFT are the Syntrophomonas wolfei (a facultative syntrophic bacteria) in coculture with Methanospirillum hungatei (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015) and the syntrophic coculture Syntrophomonas zehnderi (an obligatory syntrophic bacteria) with Methanobacterium formicicum (Sousa et al., 2007). In the case of the first example, S. wolfei can grow axenically in pure culture on unsaturated fatty acids, such as crotonate (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015). However, to grow with other fatty acids, such as butyrate, S. wolfei needs the presence of a suitable hydrogen- and/or formate-utilizing partner, like M. hungatei (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015). The role of the methanogenic partner will be to maintain hydrogen and formate (the electron carriers produced during butyrate degradation) at low levels, allowing butyrate degradation to be thermodynamically favourable (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015, 2014). This way, IHT and/or IFT is required for butyrate oxidation (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015). On the other hand, the bacterium S. zehnderi is not able to grow axenically with any substrate tested so far, although it degrades a wide range of medium to long-chain fatty acids (LCFA) with different degrees of saturation (e.g., butyrate, caproate, palmitate, stearate, oleate), when in cooperation with a syntrophic partner (Sousa et al., 2009, 2007). Therefore, in certain methanogenic environments, syntrophic relationships may be the key factor for the complete biodegradation of fermentation products, like fatty acids, by microorganisms that live in conditions close to thermodynamic equilibrium (Desmond-Le Quéméner et al., 2021; Sousa et al., 2009; Xu et al., 2019). In addition, IET can also occur by other indirect mechanisms, like via extracellular insoluble compounds, such as humic acids that can mediate electrons transfer between humics-reducing and humics-oxidizing microorganisms. Also, humic acids can be used as redox mediators in the anaerobic substrate degradation coupled to the abiotic reduction of metal oxides (e.g., Fe(III)), being reoxidized and Chapter 2 | General introduction 13 participating in many cycles (Martins et al., 2018). Other examples of insoluble compounds are flavin, sulfide, cysteine and riboflavin, and phenazine that can be used in the reduction of sulphate or insoluble electron acceptors (Shen et al., 2016). In contrast to soluble electron carriers, such as hydrogen and formate (they can diffuse in and out of the cell), the insoluble compounds cannot penetrate the cell surface (Martins et al., 2018). 2.1.1.2. Direct interspecies electron transfer The mechanism of DIET relies on direct cell-to-cell electrical contacts by e -pili and/or c -type cytochromes (membrane-bound electron transport proteins), which are the main biological structures known to participate in this type of IET (Figure 2.2b) (Lovley, 2017b; Rotaru et al., 2021). This mechanism is shuttle-free, which means it does not involve the exchange of electron carriers like hydrogen or formate (Martins et al., 2018). For this reason, DIET has the potential to transfer electrons at higher rates than IHT/IFT, once it does not rely on molecules diffusion between syntrophic partners (Desmond-Le Quéméner et al., 2021). Conductive e -pili are biological cellular structures that possess the flexibility and length to connect the syntrophic partners and have electrical conductivity to support physiologically relevant rates of extracellular electron transfer (EET) (Lovley, 2017b). These filamentous protein appendages in the cell surface can only be produced by bacteria with genes encoding pili protein, such as the gene pil A (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Shen et al., 2016). So far, Geobacter species are the ones known to produce e -pili and to participate in DIET, but other microorganisms may also have the capacity to produce pili (Lovley, 2017b). The conductivity of pili must be assessed (by direct measurement) in order to verify if the structure is capable of supporting long-range electron transport (Lovley, 2017b). The outer membrane cytochromes enable the electrons to be transferred from within a cell to another cell outside (Shen et al., 2016). There may be occasions that electrical contacts are made between cytochromes associated with the outer membranes of the syntrophic partners, instead via e -pili (Lovley, 2017b). DIET was first demonstrated in artificial cocultures of Geobacter metallireducens and Geobacter sulfurreducens degrading ethanol, with fumarate as the electron acceptor (Liu et al., 2015; Lovley, 2017b; Rotaru et al., 2021). These energy sources could not be used by neither the partners alone, and together they established a metabolically co-dependent coculture (Rotaru et al., 2021). G. metallireducens was capable of oxidizing ethanol, but could not use fumarate as an electron acceptor, while G. sulfurreducens could reduce fumarate to succinate but could not consume ethanol (Chen et al., 2014b; Liu et al., 2015). The possibility of IHT/IFT by the coculture was excluded, because G. metallireducens is unable to degrade Chapter 2 | General introduction 14 ethanol with the production of H2 or formate and, the fact that when a G. sulfurreducens strain (lacking the genes encoding hydrogenases and formate dehydrogenases, being incapable of hydrogen and formate uptake) was used, the IET kept occurring (Chen et al., 2014b). These species have the genes to produce e -pili capable of long-range electron transfer (Liu et al., 2015; Lovley, 2017b), and to produce cytochromes that can participate in EET (either associated with pili or alone) (Xu et al., 2019). It was proposed that the electrons would be released extracellularly via e -pili and outer-membrane multiheme c - type cytochromes by G. metallireducens , and G. sulfurreducens only need an outer membrane multiheme cytochrome (like OmcS, which can form electrically conductive cytochrome-chains) to accept the electrons (Liu et al., 2015; Rotaru et al., 2021). The conductivity of the pili is not due to the presence of OmcS along the length of pili, but it is thought that its presence facilitates electron transfer between the pili and extracellular acceptors or donors (Liu et al., 2015; Summers et al., 2010). Nevertheless, the importance and the functional role of each type of electrical connection in different syntrophic interactions are not completely understood. The work developed by Liu et al . (2018) highlighted the importance of extracellular cytochromes in DIET performed by Geobacter cocultures, which contradicts the previous assumption that both e -pili and extracellular cytochromes were essential for DIET (Liu et al., 2018). The authors reported that two pilus-free Geobacter species in coculture ( G. metallireducens with G. sulfurreducens ) formed aggregates and grown syntrophically via DIET. These results suggested that e -pili were not necessary to facilitate DIET and that cytochromes alone could establish the IET (Liu et al., 2018). However, e -pili would be required during EET between Geobacter species to reduce extracellular insoluble electron acceptors (e.g., anodes) (Liu et al., 2018). The opinion of the authors is that the actual functional role of the pili in DIET is uncertain, because when pil A is deleted there was a change on the distribution of outer-surface cytochromes (OmcZ and OmcS required for DIET), while the repression of pil B (which motors the assembly of type IV pili) in both Geobacter species inhibited the pilus assembly but did not alter the distribution of extracellular cytochromes (Liu et al., 2018). Furthermore, syntrophic interactions via DIET between G. metallireducens and methanogens assigned to order Methanosarcinales were also observed. Electron-donating bacteria released electrons extracellularly which are accepted by the electron-accepting methanogen that use these electrons to produce methane from the reduction of CO2 (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Martins et al., 2018; J. H. Park et al., 2018). In methanogenic environments, methanogens would be the electron-accepting partner for syntrophs like G. metallireducens (Rotaru et al., 2021). Only few microorganisms, namely G. metallireducens with acetoclastic methanogens ( Methanosaeta or Methanosarcina species), were unequivocally demonstrated as performing DIET (Holmes et al., 2018; Lovley, 2017a; Rotaru et al., Chapter 2 | General introduction 15 2014b, 2014a). The capability of Methanosaeta harundinacea (Rotaru et al., 2014b) and Methanosarcina barkeri (Rotaru et al., 2014a) of receiving electrons via DIET to reduce the CO2 was discovered when these methanogens could only grow in coculture with strains of ethanol-utilizing, as G. metallireducens , capable of producing e -pili (Rotaru et al., 2014b, 2014a). Note that till then, Methanosaeta species were thought to be obligate acetoclastic methanogens, only capable of using acetate as substrate for MP (Xu et al., 2019). The conductive e -pili produced by bacteria was considered to be very important for the EET when in coculture with methanogens, but the cell machinery involved in electrons uptake by the methanogen remains unknown (Martins et al., 2018; Rotaru et al., 2014a). In other words, the extracellular electron contacts that might allow some methanogenic archaea to accept electrons via DIET are not known yet (Martins et al., 2018; Rotaru et al., 2014a). Firstly, it was hypothesized that if cytochromes were a requirement for DIET, only the genera Methanosaeta and Methanosarcina would be more likely to play a role in DIET due to their high c -type cytochromes content, which hydrogenotrophs lack (Rotaru et al., 2018, 2014a). But it is also possible that unprecedented electron uptake mechanisms may be employed by members of Methanosarcinales that are unknown so far (Rotaru et al., 2021). It was recently found that Methanosarcina did not need the multiheme c -type cytochromes to establish DIET or to interact directly with electrodes (Rotaru et al., 2021; Yee and Rotaru, 2020). This was demonstrated when the multiheme c -type cytochromes of Methanosarcina mazei was deleted, and this methanogen kept participating in DIET or retrieving electrons from a cathode (Yee and Rotaru, 2020). On the other hand, the cellular envelopes of Methanothrix and Methanosarcina have multiple redox proteins and external proteins (e.g., ferredoxin) that may be involved in obtaining electrons from electron-donating bacteria (Castilho et al., 2022). Other hypothesis is that flagellar appendages of methanogens might be involved in extracellular electron uptake once they are similar to conductive pili (Castilho et al., 2022). Regarding hydrogenotrophic methanogens, experiments point out to the inability of M. formicicum , M. hungatei , and Methanoculleus marisnigri to perform DIET with G. metallireducens (Rotaru et al., 2014b; Yee and Rotaru, 2020), but a Methanobacterium strain growing on formate was reported to perform DIET with G. metallireducens (Zheng et al., 2020). Other results in this research field have shown that depending on the species, the electron uptake mechanism might be different, even when they belong to the same genus (Yee et al., 2019). For example, Yee et al. (2019) tested two methanogens belonging to Methanosarcina genus ( M. barkeri and M. horonobensis ) for their ability to accept electrons directly from insoluble electron donors (intrinsic electroactivity) (Yee et al., 2019). Comparative genome analysis revealed differences between the two Methanosarcina species in energy metabolism, extrachromosomal functions and ion transporters (Yee et Chapter 2 | General introduction 16 al., 2019). The results also showed that while both Methanosarcina species grew syntrophically using DIET, only M. barkeri grew on a cathode (Yee et al., 2019). So, electron uptake routes from cathodes, or from other cells, might be different between Methanosarcina species and not all DIET-methanogens are electroactive (Yee et al., 2019). Besides, the diversity of microorganisms capable of participating in DIET may include other organisms aside from the typical electroactive bacteria (i.e., Geobacter spp.). For instance, Walker et al . (2020) showed that Syntrophus aciditrophicus, a typical hydrogen-producing syntroph, can also produce e -pili and can grow via DIET (Walker et al., 2020). This species is one of the most studied pure culture models for IHT/IFT, which was not previously characterized as an electrogen (Rotaru et al., 2021; Walker et al., 2020). It was formerly thought that this species would be unlikely to participate in DIET because it lacked a gene homologous to the pilin monomer that assembles e -pili in Geobacter (Walker et al., 2020). Therefore, it cannot be ruled out that other typical syntrophic fatty-acids degrading bacteria might have the capacity for DIET (Walker et al., 2020). 2.1.1.3. Conductive materials and interspecies electron transfer IET can be accelerated in the presence of CM, such as iron-based and carbon-based materials, through a mechanism known as CIET (Figure 2.2c) (Rotaru et al., 2021). CM can function as electrical conduits, allowing the attachment of syntrophic partners on the surface of CM through which electron exchange occurs (Barua and Dhar, 2017). This external cell-to-cell electron transfer can enhance the syntrophic conversion of different organic compounds to methane, without the need for cells to form agglomerates or to be in direct contact as it occurs in DIET (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Rotaru et al., 2021). A significant downregulation of the typical genes involved in DIET occurs when CM are present (Rotaru et al., 2021). Conductive based-carbon materials, such as carbon cloth (Chen et al., 2014b), biochar (Chen et al., 2014a), and granular activated carbon (GAC) (Liu et al., 2012), have been shown as IET mediators in defined cocultures of G. metallireducens with G. sulfurreducens by replacing the biological electrical connections required for DIET (Table 2.2). For example, in the incubations with mutant strains, which could not express e -pili, CIET replaced DIET (Chen et al., 2014b, 2014a; Liu et al., 2012; Lovley, 2017b). In addition, CIET was observed in syntrophic cocultures of G. metallireducens with M. barkeri in the presence of GAC (0.05 mmol·L−1) (Liu et al., 2012; Rotaru et al., 2014a), carbon cloth (20 g·L−1) (Chen et al., 2014b) or biochar (around 25 g·L−1) (Chen et al., 2014a) . In general, wild-type strains in the presence of CM produced methane at higher rates and down-regulated the genes involved in DIET (Chen et al., 2014b, 2014a; Liu et al., 2012; Lovley, 2017b). Chapter 2 | General introduction 23 hydrogenotrophic methanogens essential for their survival (J. H. Park et al., 2018). While methanogens from almost all methanogenic orders can perform hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis to produce methane from H2/CO2, the MP from acetate (acetoclastic methanogenesis) is only performed in the order Methanosarcinales by two genera, Methanothrix and Methanosarcina (Borja et al., 2011; Enzmann et al., 2018; Whitman et al., 2006). The dominant species may vary, and Methanothrix may be dominant at low acetate concentrations, as they have higher affinity for acetate when compared with Methanosarcina species (Enzmann et al., 2018; Harirchi et al., 2022). Examples of methanogens commonly found in anaerobic digesters are M. formicicum , Methanococcus maripaludis , and M. hungatei , involved in MP from H2/CO2, and M. barkeri , M. mazei and Methanothrix concilli involved in MP from acetate (Borja et al., 2011; Wainaina et al., 2019). Methanogens like M. hungatei are known to cooperate with syntrophs, such as S. wolfei , to perform syntrophic butyrate degradation (Schmidt et al., 2013; Sieber et al., 2015). Despite methanogenesis being biochemically complex (involving the structure and synthesis of many coenzymes), the methanogens only use simple compounds to produce methane (Whitman et al., 2006). In hydrogenotrophic metabolism (Figure 2.3), CO2 is firstly reduced by using the reduced ferredoxin (Fdred) as electron donor, and activated to formyl-methanofuran (Enzmann et al., 2018). Methanofuran (MFR) acts as a formyl carrier, it can present different forms among methanogens, and it activates CO2 to formyl- MFR (Whitman et al., 2006). Then, the formyl group is transferred to tetrahydromethanopterin (H4MTP) originating formyl-H4MTP (Enzmann et al., 2018). H4MTP is a one-carbon carrier, in which the formyl group is dehydrated and reduced to methylene-H4MTP, and then to methyl-H4MTP by using the reduced F420 (F420H2) as electron donor (Enzmann et al., 2018; Whitman et al., 2006). Coenzymes are electron donors in methanogenesis, and the coenzyme F420 participates in two-electron transfer reactions, being coupled to hydrogenase, formate dehydrogenase, or other enzymes (Whitman et al., 2006). The transference of the methyl group to coenzyme M (HS-CoM) forms the methyl-CoM, which is then reduced to methane using as electron donor the coenzyme B (HS-CoB) (Enzmann et al., 2018). Thus, HS-CoM is a one-carbon carrier unique to methanogens, being the terminal carbon carrier (as methyl-S-CoM is reduced to CH4) (Whitman et al., 2006). Finally, the reduction of the resulting heterodisulfide (CoM-S-S- CoB) with H2 allows to recycle the coenzymes (Enzmann et al., 2018). The electrons required for CO2 reduction can also be derived from formate instead of H2 (Enzmann et al., 2018). Formate can be converted to hydrogen by formate hydrogen lyase, which is a membrane-associated enzyme complex, or it can be excreted and consumed by methanogens (Stams and Plugge, 2009). In methanogens using formate, firstly, four formate molecules are oxidized to CO2 by formate dehydrogenases (Fdh), and then one CO2 molecule is reduced to methane (Enzmann et al., 2018). Chapter 2 | General introduction 24 In acetoclastic methanogenesis (Figure 2.3), acetate is activated using ATP and CoA, and converted to acetyl-CoA (Enzmann et al., 2018). Then, the carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (Codh)/acetyl-CoA synthase split the acetyl-CoA (Enzmann et al., 2018). The methyl group is transferred to H4MTP (noting that in Methanosarcina it will be tetrahydrosarcinapterin (H4SPT)) and the conversion to methane follows the same steps of the CO2 reduction pathway as explained above in hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis (Enzmann et al., 2018). Ferredoxins are especially abundant in acetoclastic methanogens (Whitman et al., 2006). Methanogens also need a number of vitamins, such as thiamine, riboflavin, pyridoxine, corrinoids, biotin, niacin, and pantothenate (Whitman et al., 2006). For instance, flavins can function as electron carriers for hydrogenases, NADH reductases and formate dehydrogenases in Methanobacterium (Whitman et al., 2006). On the other hand, corrinoids can function as methyl carriers, being important during MP (Whitman et al., 2006). According with the mode of energy conservation, methanogens can be divided in methanogens with and without cytochromes (Enzmann et al., 2018; Stams and Plugge, 2009). All methanogens of Methanosarcinales are cytochrome-containing methanogens (Thauer et al., 2008). Cytochromes can function as electron carriers during methanogenesis from acetate, as they participate in the oxidation of this substrate during its disproportionation (Whitman et al., 2006). Methanogens belonging to the orders Methanopyrales , Methanococcales , Methanobacteriales , and Methanomicrobiales do not possess cytochromes (Enzmann et al., 2018; Thauer et al., 2008). Hydrogenotrophic methanogens without cytochromes (the ones that exclusively use H2/CO2 for MP) can consume hydrogen at very low concentrations making use of ferredoxin and coenzyme F420 as redox mediators, being the most important methanogens for the removal of hydrogen in syntrophic communities (Stams and Plugge, 2009). Methanogenic archaea without cytochromes possess methyl-H4MPT:CoM methyltransferase (Mtr) that couples the methyl group transfer to an electrochemical sodium gradient over the membrane (Enzmann et al., 2018). This Na+ gradient can be used for ATP synthesis (Enzmann et al., 2018). In addition, the reduction of CoM-S-S-CoB with H2 is catalysed by a complex involving a (methyl viologen-reducing) hydrogenase and heterodisulfide reductase (Mvh-Hdr) (Enzmann et al., 2018). This also couples the reduction of oxidized ferredoxin (Fdox) via flavin-based electron bifurcation (Enzmann et al., 2018). Electron bifurcation involves the separation of two electrons from ubiquinol (Thauer et al., 2008). On the other hand, cytochrome-containing methanogens (e.g., M. barkeri , M. mazei ) also generates a Na+ gradient over the membrane using Mtr (complex MtrA-H that contains a corrinoid bounded to the MtrA subunit, coupling the translocation of two sodium ions), but the reduction of CoM-S-S-CoB is catalysed differently Chapter 2 | General introduction 25 (Enzmann et al., 2018; Thauer et al., 2008). For that, methanogens with cytochromes use a membranebound heterodisulfide reductase (HdrED complex is an iron-sulphur haemoprtein) and the electrons derived from reduced methanophenazine (MPhH2) via cytochrome b subunit, generating a proton motive force (Enzmann et al., 2018). In hydrogenotrophic metabolism, hydrogen is oxidized by a membranebound (F420 non-reducing) hydrogenase (VhoACG complex, a nickel-iron-sulfur haemoprotein) and electrons are transferred via cytochrome b to the oxidized methanophenazine (MPh), which creates a proton motive force again (Enzmann et al., 2018). The endergonic reduction of Fdox with H2 can be coupled by another membranous energy-converting [NiFe] hydrogenase (complex EchA-F, a nickel-iron-sulfur protein) to the intrusion of H+ (i.e., by using the proton motive force) (Enzmann et al., 2018). In these methanogens, methanogenesis is coupled with the generation of H+ and Na+ gradients (Enzmann et al., 2018). In some cases, Vh0 and Ech are absent, and an Rnf complex is thought to establish the Na+ gradient over the membrane by transferring electrons from Fdred to MPh (Enzmann et al., 2018). Then, a H+ gradient will be generated as a result of the subsequent electron transport from MPhH2 to HdrED (Enzmann et al., 2018). Another difference is that methanogens without cytochromes do not contain methanophenazine (which is an analogue for functional menaquinone), while cytochromes-containing methanogens do (Thauer et al., 2008). In methanogenic environments like anaerobic digesters, cytochrome-containing methanogens, like Methanosarcina , cannot compete with methanogens without cytochromes for hydrogen (Enzmann et al., 2018). For instance, M. barkeri can use a variety of substrates, like acetate and H2/CO2 to produce methane, but methanogens without cytochromes would prevail when H2/CO2 is the available substrate (Thauer et al., 2008). In summary, obligate syntrophic communities involving acetogenic bacteria and methanogenic archaea can only degrade VFA by cooperating with each other, where intermicrobial distances will affect the biodegradation rates and the specific growth rates of the microorganisms involved (Stams et al., 2012). So, the process is favoured by self-aggregation of syntrophic partners in aggregates, and the metabolism of one microorganism will be directly affected by the other members of the community (Stams et al., 2012; Stams and Plugge, 2009). 2.2. EFFECT OF (NANO)MATERIALS ON METHANE PRODUCTION The metabolism of syntrophic partners can be enhanced in the presence of conductive (nano)materials, like Mag (10 mmol·L−1) (Liu et al., 2015) and GAC (0.05 mmol·L−1) (Rotaru et al., 2014a), where CIET was proved to occur. Several other studies were performed with the aim to enhance AD process and to Chapter 2 | General introduction 26 improve the efficiency of MP by applying different types of materials. The effects promoted in the presence of (nano)materials were positive in most studies, but the explanations behind these effects are generally not satisfactory, as they result mostly in speculations based on indirect proves. For instance, the shift of IET mechanisms from HIT/HFT to CIET is the main explanation based only on the observation of the improvement of AD performance and/or on the enrichment of electroactive microorganisms during biodegradation. The fact that IET does not occur in methanogenic pure cultures and methanogens alone can also be stimulated by CM rises even more doubts regarding the common justification for the improvements caused by CM. In the following subsections an overview of the studies showing the main effects caused by the presence of different (nano)materials towards the methanogenic activity in systems with different complexity, i.e., in pure cultures of methanogens and syntrophic cocultures, in microbial enrichments and in other complex microbial communities, will be presented. 2.2.1. Effect of CM on methanogenic pure cultures and on syntrophic cocultures Little is known about the mechanisms behind the improvements towards the methanogenic activity of pure cultures of methanogens and syntrophic cocultures in the presence of (nano)materials, especially when Geobacter spp. are not the syntrophic partner. Table 2.3 presents a summary of studies showing the effects of materials on the activity of methanogenic pure cultures. The direct impact of materials was evaluated towards some acetoclastic species, such as M. barkeri (Fu et al., 2019; Xiao et al., 2020), M. mazei (Salvador et al., 2017; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xiao et al., 2020) and M. concilii (Salvador et al., 2017), and some hydrogenotrophic pure cultures like M. formicicum (Salvador et al., 2017), M. hungatei (Salvador et al., 2017), M. maripaludis (Fu et al., 2018; W. Zhang et al., 2018), and Methanocella conradii (Fu et al., 2018; Xia et al., 2019). More recently, Zheng et al . (2020) investigated the activity of Methanobacterium sp. strain YSL growing with formate as electron donor in the presence of CM (Zheng et al., 2020). The diversity of materials is huge but only the impact of CNT (Fu et al., 2019; Salvador et al., 2017; Xia et al., 2019; Xiao et al., 2020; W. Zhang et al., 2018), GAC (Zheng et al., 2020), Mag (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019), nano-graphite (Fu et al., 2019) and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) (W. Zhang et al., 2018) was investigated. It seems that the effect of CM varies according to the microbial species. For example, the presence of 5 g·L-1 CNT enhanced the methane production rate (MPR) up to 17 times by M. formicicum (Salvador et al., 2017), and up to 4 times the MPR by M. mazei and M. barkeri with 0.2 g·L-1 CNT (Xiao et al., 2020), but 5 g·L-1 CNT inhibited the hydrogenotrophic activity of M. maripaludis (W. Zhang et al., 2018). The presence of GAC (25 g·L-1) was reported to inhibit the growth of the Methanobacterium sp. strain YSL (Zheng et al., 2020). Besides, Fu Chapter 2 | General introduction 27 et al . (2018) studied the effect of Mag (4.64 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) towards Syntrophomonas erecta subsp. sporosyntropha growing in pure culture with crotonate, and no effects were observed in the presence of the material (Fu et al., 2018). Regarding the positive impacts, the presence of CNT contributed to significantly reduce the lag phases preceding MP by approximately 75 % in M. formicicum (Salvador et al., 2017), 100 % in M. hungatei (Salvador et al., 2017), and 12.5 % in M. mazei (Salvador et al., 2017) pure cultures, while Mag reduced up to 50 % the lag phase of M. mazei in pure cultures (H. Wang et al., 2020). The presence of CM also caused an impact towards MPR and lag phases duration on syntrophic cocultures (Table 2.4). CNT (5 g·L-1) accelerated the MRP (around 1.5 times) in syntrophic cocultures of S. wolfei with M. hungatei (Salvador et al., 2017). In addition, butyrate degradation by the syntrophic coculture S. wolfei with M. maripaludis was stimulated by CNT (2 g·L-1) and rGO (0.1 g·L-1), but not in the presence of kaolinite which is a clay mineral (considered a non-conductive material (non-CM)) (W. Zhang et al., 2018). The syntrophic ethanol degradation was also enhanced in the presence of GAC (25 g·L-1) (Zheng et al., 2020). The main explanations suggested for the improvements observed in pure cultures, in the presence of CM, were related with the microbial adhesion to the surface of CM serving as a support for microbial growth or the substrate adsorption to CM (Salvador et al., 2017). On the other hand, it was found that CM directly favoured MP from acetate (Xiao et al., 2020), and the explanation proposed for the improvement of acetoclastic methanogenesis was based on the redox cycling of Fe(II) and Fe(III) in Mag composition (H. Wang et al., 2020). In syntrophic cocultures, the main explanation suggested was the occurrence of CIET (W. Zhang et al., 2018; Zheng et al., 2020). Chapter 2 | General introduction 28 Table 2.3. Summary of studies with pure cultures of methanogens and the effects of materials on methanogenic activity. The main impacts highlighted were regarding the decrease (↓) of lag phase time (given in percentage, comparing the control condition with the best concentration of CM applied (best concentration in bold type)) and the number of times that MPR increases (+) or decreases relatively to the control Pure culture Substrate CM Effects on MP References ↓Lag phase MPR Methanobacterium formicicum (DSM 1535T) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) CNT (0.1, 0.5, 1 and 5 g·L-1) 75 % (+) 16.6× (Salvador et al., 2017) Methanospirillum hungatei (DSM 864T) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) CNT (0.1, 0.5, 1 and 5 g·L-1) ~ 100 % (+) 5.5× (Salvador et al., 2017) Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM 14266) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) rGO (0.02, 0.1, 0.2 g·L-1) (no effect) (no effect) (W. Zhang et al., 2018) Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM 14266) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) CNT (0.2, 1, 2 and 5 g·L-1) (no effect) (-) negative effect (W. Zhang et al., 2018) Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM 14266) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) Mag (4.64 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) (no effect) (no effect) (Fu et al., 2018) Methanocella conradii (HZ254T) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) Mag (10 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) (no effect) (-) negative effect (Xia et al., 2019) Methanocella conradii (HZ254T) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) CNT (5 g·L-1) (-) negative effect (no effect) (Xia et al., 2019) Methanocella conradii (DSM 24694) H2/CO2 (80:20, v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) Mag (4.64 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) (no effect) (no effect) (Fu et al., 2018) Methanobacterium strain YSL (isolated) formate (40 mmol∙L-1) GAC (25 g·L-1) (Inhibition) (Inhibition) (Zheng et al., 2020) Methanosaeta concilii (DSM 3671T) acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) CNT (0.1, 0.5, 1 and 5 g·L-1) (no effect) (+) 1.2× (Salvador et al., 2017) Methanosarcina mazei (DSM 2053T) acetate (20 mmol∙L-1) CNT (0.1, 0.5, 1 and 5 g·L-1) 12.5 % (+) 2.0× (Salvador et al., 2017) Chapter 2 | General introduction 29 Table 2.3. Continued. Summary of studies with pure cultures of methanogens and the effects of materials on methanogenic activity. The main impacts highlighted were regarding the decrease (↓) of lag phase time (given in percentage, comparing the control condition with the best concentration of CM applied (best concentration in bold type)) and the number of times that MPR increases (+) or decreases (-) relatively to the control Pure culture Substrate CM Effects on MP References ↓Lag phase MPR Methanosarcina mazei acetate (20 mmol∙L-1) CNT (~0.2 g·L-1) (no effect) (+) ~ 4.1× (Xiao et al., 2020) Methanosarcina mazei zm-15 (isolated) acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) Mag (7.5 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) 51 % (+) ~ 2.0× (H. Wang et al., 2020) Methanosarcina barkeri (DSM800) acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) Mag (4.64 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) (no effect) (+) ~ 2.0× (Fu et al., 2019) Methanosarcina barkeri (DSM800) acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) Nano-graphite (Unknown concentration) (no effect) (-) ~ 0.7× (Fu et al., 2019) Methanosarcina barkeri (DSM800) acetate (10 mmol∙L-1) CNT (Unknown concentration) (no effect) (no effect) (Fu et al., 2019) Methanosarcina barkeri acetate (20 mmol∙L-1) CNT (~0.2 g·L-1) (no effect) (+) ~ 2.6× (Xiao et al., 2020) Syntrophomonas erecta subsp. Sporosyntropha (DSM 16215) crotonate (20 mmol∙L-1) Mag (4.64 mmol∙L-1 in Fe) (no effect) (no effect) (Fu et al., 2018) Chapter 2 | General introduction 30 Table 2.4. Summary of studies showing the effect of the addition of materials on methanogenic activity of syntrophic cocultures by the number of times that MPR increases (+) relatively to the control, and the degree of decrease (↓) in lag phase time (in percentage), comparing the control without material with the assay with materials Syntrophic coculture Substrate Materials Effects on MP References ↓Lag phase MPR Syntrophomonas wolfei (DSM 102351T) and Methanospirillum hungatei (DSM 864T) butyrate (20 mmol∙L-1) CNT (5 g·L-1) (no effect) (+) 1.5× (Salvador et al., 2017) Syntrophomonas wolfei (DSM 102351) and Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM 14266) butyrate (10 mmol∙L-1) CNT (2 g·L-1) 100 % (+) ~ 1.5× (W. Zhang et al., 2018) Syntrophomonas wolfei (DSM 102351) and Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM14266) butyrate (10 mmol∙L-1) rGO (0.1 g·L-1) (no effect) (+) ~ 1.5× (W. Zhang et al., 2018) Syntrophomonas wolfei (DSM 102351) and Methanococcus maripaludis (DSM 14266) butyrate (10 mmol∙L-1) Kaolinite (2 g·L-1) (no effect) (no effect) (W. Zhang et al., 2018) Geobacter metallireducens strain GS-15 (ATCC 53774) and Methanobacterium strain YSL ethanol (10 mmol∙L-1) GAC (25 g·L-1) 85 % (no effect) (Zheng et al., 2020) PilA-deficient Geobacter metallireducens (mutant strain) and Methanobacterium strain YSL ethanol (10 mmol∙L-1) GAC (25 g·L-1) 70 % (+) ~ 2.9 (Zheng et al., 2020) Chapter 2 | General introduction 31 2.2.2. Effect of CM on microbial enrichments from natural sediments The development of microbial enrichment cultures, under controlled laboratory conditions, is an approach to investigate the effect of different environmental conditions towards the microbial composition and activity (Vanwonterghem et al., 2014). This approach has been used to investigate the impact of (nano)materials when they are in contact with anaerobic communities for extended periods. In this subsection, a review on enrichment studies is presented in Table 2.5. In general, the presence of CM decreased the lag phases preceding MP, increased the MPR, and altered the relative abundances of microorganisms in the final communities. For instance, MPR from butyrate was improved in lake sediment microbiomes in the presence of CNT (5 g·L-1), whose incubations were transferred over time, and it was followed by changes in the microbial community composition, with the enrichment of typical fatty-acid degrading bacteria ( Syntrophomonas spp.) (W. Zhang et al., 2018). However, different sediments led to different enrichment cultures (under the same conditions), with Syntrophomonas as the major group of the bacterial populations in both enrichments, but the dominant methanogens comprised Methanosarcina and Methanospirillum in one enrichment (from Weiming Lake) and Methanoregula and Methanospirillum in another (from Erhai Lake) (W. Zhang et al., 2018). Under controlled conditions, as in anaerobic bioreactors, the addition of CM can be used as a strategy to boost MP, for recovering the biomethane which can be used as a sustainable energy (Castilho et al., 2022; Prussi et al., 2021). But at the same time, knowing that methanogenesis has a central role in the global carbon cycle in nature (Stams and Plugge, 2009), the increase of MP in the presence of CM is also a problem. Conductive minerals (e.g., iron oxide minerals) or black carbon are present in natural environments (e.g., lake and/or river sediments) as a result of incomplete burning of plant biomass (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018). Experimental studies have been demonstrated the acceleration of MP by enrichment cultures in the presence of CM, like Mag (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; Kato et al., 2012; Li et al., 2015; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019; Zhang and Lu, 2016; W. Zhang et al., 2018), CNT (Fu et al., 2018; Xia et al., 2019; Zhang and Lu, 2016; W. Zhang et al., 2018), biochar (Yuan et al., 2018), and GAC (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018), using as inoculum anaerobic microbial communities from samples of different natural sediments. The anthropogenic activity can increase the input of CM in sediments via runoff from forestry industry or other industrial activities (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018), which can contribute to increase the methane fluxes to the atmosphere, where methane is a strong greenhouse gas (Stams et al., 2012; Stams and Plugge, 2009). Although natural sediments have been used as inoculum to study the impact of CM towards MP (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018; Fu et al., 2019, 2018; Kato et al., 2012; Li et Chapter 2 | General introduction 32 al., 2015; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019; Yuan et al., 2018; Zhang and Lu, 2016; W. Zhang et al., 2018) (Table 2.5), less attention has been paid to enrichment studies using anaerobic sludge as inoculum. CIET is commonly proposed as the cause for the improvements towards MP in enriched communities (Fu et al., 2018; Kato et al., 2012; Li et al., 2015; Xia et al., 2019; Zhang and Lu, 2016; W. Zhang et al., 2018), but not disregarding that IHT/IFT may occur at the same time (Fu et al., 2018; Xia et al., 2019; W. Zhang et al., 2018). The support for this hypothesis is usually the composition of the enriched microbial communities in the presence of materials. Some microbial enrichment studies with CM showed that electroactive bacteria like Geobacter spp. were enriched in the presence of biochar (growing on ethanol) (Yuan et al., 2018), GAC (growing on acetate) (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018), Mag (growing on butyrate) (Li et al., 2015), and Mag (growing on ethanol or acetate) (Kato et al., 2012), suggesting the hypothesis that CM stimulated CIET mechanism between Geobacter and methanogens. However, in other studies applying Mag or CNT for the degradation of VFA (e.g., acetate, propionate, butyrate), Geobacter was not enriched (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019; Zhang and Lu, 2016; W. Zhang et al., 2018). Then, it was hypothesized that other species would be capable of participating in CIET. For instance, some reports raised the hypothesis that Syntrophomonas spp. would switch from IHT/IFT for CIET in the presence of CM, based on the improvement of methanogenic activity and the null impact of CM towards pure cultures of methanogens (Fu et al., 2018; W. Zhang et al., 2018). Chapter 2 | General introduction 39 Despite the beneficial effect of most (nano)materials, some studies have been reporting the toxic effect of certain CM towards microorganisms’ activity (e.g., carbon black nanoparticles) (Martins et al., 2018; J. H. Park et al., 2018; Wu et al., 2020). Some materials may promote direct inhibition by the presence of Fe(III), substrate competition or toxic effects to microorganisms (e.g., by particle size) (Wu et al., 2020). Cellular oxidative stress and cell apoptosis are examples of toxicity to cell promoted by certain (nano)materials (Barua and Dhar, 2017; Wu et al., 2020). Also, iron-based materials, such as magnesium oxide, silver nanoparticles and ferrihydrite, were shown as inhibitors for methanogenic activity (Martins et al., 2018; Wu et al., 2020). This way, since the effects are not always positive, the evaluation of different (nano)materials is needed before their application in AD systems in order not to compromise the process. Chapter 2 | General introduction 40 Table 2.6. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic sludge butyrate AC 0.5 1.3 1.3 5.3 1.0 In this study Anaerobic sludge kitchen waste AC 10.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.0 (Hu et al., 2022) Anaerobic sludge activated sludge AC 8.0 4.8 0.2 96.6 0.9 (Liu et al., 2020) Anaerobic sludge acetate c1 GAC 0.5 1.0 0.8 20.0 11.1 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate c1 GAC 5.0 1.0 0.8 20.0 11.1 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate c1 GAC 25.0 1.0 0.2 80.0 10.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge propionate c1 GAC 0.5 0.5 0.6 -20.0 0.9 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge propionate c1 GAC 5.0 0.5 0.6 -20.0 1.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge propionate c1 GAC 25.0 0.5 0.6 -20.0 0.8 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge butyrate c1 GAC 0.5 1.0 0.8 20.0 1.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge butyrate c1 GAC 5.0 1.0 0.5 50.0 1.1 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge butyrate c1 GAC 25.0 1.0 1.0 0.0 0.9 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate c2 GAC 0.5 0.3 0.3 0.0 1.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate c2 GAC 5.0 0.3 0.4 -33.3 1.1 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate c2 GAC 25.0 0.3 0.4 -33.3 1.1 (Xu et al., 2018) Coastal sediments acetate GAC 10.0 35.0 7.0 80.0 10.9 (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge commercial dog food GAC 50.0 170.0 4.0 97.6 50.0 (Dang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge acetate GAC 11.1 7.6 6.4 15.5 1.1 (Lee et al., 2020) Anaerobic sludge food waste GAC 25.0 19.0 13.0 31.6 1.6 (Ryue et al., 2019) Anaerobic granular sludge oleate GAC 2.0 23.5 7.7 67.2 0.1 (Tan and Lens, 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge oleate GAC 2.0 23.5 14.6 37.9 0.2 (Tan and Lens, 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 0.5 16.6 16.3 1.8 1.3 (Tan et al., 2021) Chapter 2 | General introduction 41 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 1.0 16.6 15.5 6.6 1.4 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 2.0 16.6 13.2 20.5 2.2 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 4.0 16.6 12.0 27.7 3.0 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 8.0 16.6 9.5 42.8 1.2 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 16.0 16.6 2.6 84.3 0.8 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 25.0 16.6 1.6 90.4 0.5 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 33.0 16.6 1.6 90.4 0.6 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 2.0 17.1 14.2 17.0 1.3 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge oleate GAC 2.0 18.3 15.8 13.7 1.6 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed oleate GAC 2.0 16.4 12.6 23.2 1.1 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed real butter wastewater GAC 2.0 17.0 16.6 2.4 1.2 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge crushed real dairy wastewater GAC 2.0 12.2 6.5 46.7 1.2 (Tan et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge propionate c2 GAC 0.5 4.3 3.5 18.6 1.5 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge propionate c2 GAC 5.0 4.3 1.1 74.4 7.5 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge propionate c2 GAC 25.0 4.3 1.0 76.7 7.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge butyrate c2 GAC 0.5 13.0 11.0 15.4 1.6 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge butyrate c2 GAC 5.0 13.0 5.0 61.5 8.0 (Xu et al., 2018) Chapter 2 | General introduction 42 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic sludge butyrate c2 GAC 25.0 13.0 7.0 46.2 8.8 (Xu et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate GAC 6.0 6.6 6.5 1.5 1.7 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge acetate GAC 12.0 6.6 6.4 3.0 1.7 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge ethanol GAC 6.0 6.7 6.2 7.5 1.3 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge ethanol GAC 12.0 6.7 6.6 1.5 1.7 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge fat, oil and grease + waste activated sludge GAC 10.0 1.5 1.0 33.3 1.0 (He et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge fat, oil and grease + waste activated sludge GAC 5.0 1.5 0.5 66.7 1.0 (He et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge fat, oil and grease + waste activated sludge GAC 15.0 1.5 0.2 86.7 0.8 (He et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge dewatered wasted activated sludge GAC 3.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.2 (Yang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge dewatered wasted activated sludge GAC 6.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Yang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge dewatered wasted activated sludge GAC 13.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.4 (Yang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge dewatered wasted activated sludge GAC 33.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.5 (Yang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge food waste GAC 25.0 10.0 7.0 30.0 1.3 (Ryue et al., 2019) Chapter 2 | General introduction 43 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic sludge acetate GAC 30.3 6.0 3.0 50.0 1.8 (Zhang et al., 2017) Wetland sediment butyrate Mag 0.4 1.0 1.0 0.0 1.0 (Fu et al., 2018) Wetland sediment acetate Mag 0.4 1.0 1.0 0.0 1.4 (Fu et al., 2019) Anaerobic sludge sludge Mag 9.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.5 (Li et al., 2022) Anaerobic sludge butyrate Mag 0.5 1.3 1.3 3.8 0.9 In this study Anaerobic granular sludge glucose Mag 0.3 - - nc 4.0 (Barrena et al., 2023) Flocculent sludge glucose Mag 0.1 - - nc 0.7 (Barrena et al., 2023) Flocculent sludge glucose Mag 0.3 - - nc 5.3 (Barrena et al., 2023) Flocculent sludge glucose Mag 0.5 - - nc 6.7 (Barrena et al., 2023) Flocculent sludge glucose Mag 1.0 - - nc 8.0 (Barrena et al., 2023) Rice paddy soil ethanol Mag 1.5 10.0 10.0 0.0 1.4 (Kato et al., 2012) Rice paddy soil acetate Mag 1.5 10.0 7.0 30.0 1.5 (Kato et al., 2012) Anaerobic sludge acetate Mag 11.1 7.6 4.9 35.8 1.3 (Lee et al., 2020) Paddy soil sediment butyrate Mag 0.5 8.0 8.0 0.0 1.2 (Li et al., 2015) Rice paddy soil propionate Mag 1.5 17.1 11.7 31.9 0.9 (Yang et al., 2016) Lake sediment butyrate Mag 0.8 72.0 27.0 62.5 1.3 (Zhang and Lu, 2016) Anaerobic sludge acetate Mag 6.0 6.6 6.7 -1.5 1.4 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge ethanol Mag 6.0 6.7 6.5 3.0 1.2 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Chapter 2 | General introduction 44 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Lake sediment butyrate Mag 0.8 9.0 9.0 0.0 1.5 (Zhang and Lu, 2016) Wetland sediment acetate Mag 0.4 5.2 2.5 52.0 1.5 (H. Wang et al., 2020) Lake sediment propionate Mag 0.8 12.0 12.0 0.0 1.7 (Xia et al., 2019) Anaerobic sludge waste activated sludge Mag 0.8 3.8 5.3 -38.5 2.6 (Yan et al., 2020) Anaerobic sludge wheat straw Mag (-) 0.1 1.0 0.0 100.0 1.5 (Yang Liu et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge wheat straw Mag (+) 0.1 1.0 0.0 100.0 1.2 (Yang Liu et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge wheat straw Mag (neutral) 0.1 1.0 0.0 100.0 1.3 (Yang Liu et al., 2021) Anaerobic granular sludge oleate PAC 2.0 23.5 3.4 85.5 0.2 (Tan and Lens, 2021) Anaerobic sludge acetate PAC 6.0 6.6 6.4 3.0 1.4 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge ethanol PAC 6.0 6.7 6.7 0.0 1.1 (J.-H. Park et al., 2018) Anaerobic sludge fruit and vegetable waste + layer chicken manure PAC 10.0 5.0 0.0 100.0 1.3 (de Quadros et al., 2022) Digestate ethanol PAC 20.0 1.7 2.1 -25.0 1.0 (König et al., 2022) Anaerobic sludge waste activated sludge PAC 0.5 3.8 4.3 -12.8 2.7 (Yan et al., 2020) Piggery waste manure acetate Zeo (natural) 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 (Milán et al., 2001) Chapter 2 | General introduction 45 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Piggery waste manure methanol Zeo (natural) 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.1 (Milán et al., 2001) Anaerobic sludge butyrate Zeo (type-13X) 0.5 1.9 1.9 -1.6 0.9 In this study Piggery waste manure swine wastes Zeo 10.0 30.0 17.0 43.3 692.3 (Zheng et al., 2015) Piggery waste manure swine wastes Zeo 10.0 30.0 30.0 0.0 3.0 (Zheng et al., 2015) Piggery waste manure swine wastes Zeo 10.0 30.0 5.0 83.3 1620.0 (Zheng et al., 2015) Municipal sludge municipal activated sludge Zeo 4.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Amen et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge food waste (+ 4 g·L-1 NH4+) Zeo 15.0 8.9 5.3 40.4 1.1 (Cardona et al., 2021) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 4.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.0 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 8.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.6 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 12.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.7 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 4.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.3 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 8.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.7 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Pig waste manure pig waste Zeo (natural) 12.0 2.0 2.0 0.0 1.5 (Kotsopoulos et al., 2008) Chapter 2 | General introduction 46 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic sludge slaughterhouse waste + industrial and food waste + stearic acid + palmitic acid Zeo (natural) 5.0 10.0 0.0 100.0 1.3 (Nordell et al., 2013) Anaerobic sludge acetate Zeo (natural) 30.3 6.0 6.0 0.0 1.8 (Zhang et al., 2017) Anaerobic sludge food waste Zeo 15.0 6.5 6.9 -6.2 0.9 (Cardona et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge fruit and vegetable waste + layer chicken manure Zeo (natural) 10.0 5.0 5.0 0.0 1.1 (de Quadros et al., 2022) Anaerobic sludge fruit and vegetable waste + layer chicken manure Zeo (faujasite) 10.0 5.0 0.0 100.0 1.3 (de Quadros et al., 2022) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 2.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 4.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 6.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 8.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 10.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 12.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Chapter 2 | General introduction 47 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Piggery waste manure piggery waste + sewage Zeo (natural) 16.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 (Montalvo et al., 2005) Anaerobic sludge slaughterhouse waste + industrial and food waste Zeo (natural) 5.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.6 (Nordell et al., 2013) Anaerobic sludge pulp and paper sludge Zeo (natural) 0.2 5.6 5.8 -3.7 1.0 (Huiliñir et al., 2014) Anaerobic sludge pulp and paper sludge Zeo (natural) 0.5 5.6 6.9 -22.4 0.8 (Huiliñir et al., 2014) Anaerobic sludge pulp and paper sludge Zeo (natural) 1.0 5.6 7.1 -27.0 0.9 (Huiliñir et al., 2014) Anaerobic sludge pulp and paper sludge Zeo (natural) 20.0 - - nc nc (Huiliñir et al., 2014) Digestate ethanol Zeo 10.0 2.7 2.5 9.2 0.9 (König et al., 2022) Anaerobic sludge VFA (acetic, propionic, butyric acids) Zeo (natural) 1.4 10.0 10.0 0.0 0.7 (Milán et al., 2010) Anaerobic sludge food waste Zeo (heated at 400 °C) 15.0 6.5 5.8 10.8 0.9 (Cardona et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge food waste (+ 4 g·L-1 NH4+) Zeo (heated at 400 °C) 15.0 8.9 7.1 20.2 1.1 (Cardona et al., 2021) Anaerobic sludge food waste Zeo (soluble ions removed) 15.0 6.5 6.8 -4.6 1.0 (Cardona et al., 2021) Chapter 2 | General introduction 48 Table 2.6. Continued. Summary of studies reporting the effect of AC, GAC, Mag and Zeo (and the concentration of material applied – C) on anaerobic sludge, sediments, and other complex microbial communities. The presence of (nano)materials affected the lag phase duration (by reducing (↓), or increasing (values < 0) it) and the MPR (i.e., MPR > 1, increased; MPR < 1, decreased), when comparing with the control condition without materials Type of inoculum Substrate Materials Lag phase MPR References Type C/ (g·L-1) Control/ d Material/ d ↓Lag phase/ % Anaerobic sludge food waste (+ 4 g·L-1 NH4+) Zeo (soluble ions removed) 15.0 8.9 9.0 -1.1 1.1 (Cardona et al., 2021) * c1 and c2 represent increasing concentrations of substrates. * nc – not calculated; in these studies, no MP was observed in the control condition but the material improved the substrate conversion to methane. * Different types of Zeo differ in their chemical and mineralogical composition (e.g., natural Zeo are different regarding the composition in clinoptilolite), and particle sizes. Chapter 2 | General introduction 55 expression of CO2 reduction genes in Methanothrix spp. (Rotaru et al., 2014b). The reduction of CO2 to produce methane is performed by hydrogenotrophic methanogens, but Methanothrix spp. are acetoclastic methanogens, incapable of using hydrogen and formate as electron donors to reduce CO2 (Rotaru et al., 2014b; Van Steendam et al., 2019). Thus, in defined cocultures with G. metallireducens , it was demonstrated through the transcription of CO2 genes in Methanothrix that Methanothrix harundinacea could accept electrons via DIET (Rotaru et al., 2014b). This way, meta-omics approaches can be helpful to detect genes, transcripts and proteins associated with IET mechanisms, like IHT/IFT or DIET (via CO2 reduction pathway), and to better understand the relationships between microorganisms in microbial communities, and the influence of the presence of (nano)materials. 2.4.3. Microscopy analyses Microscopy analyses allow to visualize the cellular spatial arrangement when cells are in contact with (nano)materials (Van Steendam et al., 2019). Examples of microscopic analyses are scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to observe the interaction of cells with (nano)materials, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) used to identify cell morphology (Van Steendam et al., 2019). For instance, in the work of Salvador et al . (2017), SEM images showed the arrangement of different methanogenic cultures in the presence of CNT and the arrangement of cells without the material (Salvador et al., 2017). In other work, SEM images showed the morphology of cell aggregates in different sediment enrichments with and without CNT, for example, revealing information about the shape of cells present in each type of enrichment (W. Zhang et al., 2018). On the other hand, TEM images were taken to explore the effect of the size of Mag particles on a sludge during propionate degradation, showing differences in the abundances of egg- and rod-shaped bacteria for different sizes of Mag (Yin et al., 2022). These strategies may also allow the identification of biological structures like pili and cytochromes (Van Steendam et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2023). SEM can also be coupled with energy dispersive X-ray analysis (SEM-EDS), which allows to investigate the elemental composition of specific details during SEM observations, ultimately helping to understand if the elements present in abiotic materials can be incorporated or not by cells (Van Steendam et al., 2019). In addition, fluorescence in situ hybridizing (FISH) can be used to identify syntrophic partners, once it involves oligonucleotide probes whose target are unique sequences in DNA or RNA molecules, determining the spatial distribution of syntrophic partners stained after hybridization by observing the fluorescence signal in a fluorescence microscope or confocal laser scanner (Van Steendam et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2023). This technique was also used by Zhang et al . (2018) to observe the spatial distribution of bacteria and methanogens in different sediment enrichments with and without Chapter 2 | General introduction 56 CNT, and also in syntrophic cocultures (W. Zhang et al., 2018). Based on the results obtained in SEM and FISH analyses, the authors conclude that methanogens and bacteria form cell-CNT aggregates (W. Zhang et al., 2018). 2.4.4. Cyclic voltammetry Specifically, to investigate EET mechanisms, cyclic voltammetry (CV) can be a suitable method to detect electron exchange between microorganisms and (nano)materials (Van Steendam et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2023). For example, through CV may be possible to characterize electron exchange between microorganisms and (nano)materials by determining the standard extracellular electron transfer rate constant, or the type of redox reactions occurring through electron transfer (Van Steendam et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2023). For example, it is known that acetate oxidation peak occurs at -0.35 V, and CO2 reduction peak occurs at -0.32 V (Van Steendam et al., 2019). Besides, detecting an increased electron transfer rate could be related with an increase of electro-active microorganisms and mechanisms involving EET, like DIET, could be considered for further investigation (Van Steendam et al., 2019). This approach has been applied in some studies, for instance, to explore the electrochemical activity of cultures in the presence of GAC impregnated with Mag (Song et al., 2019) or carbon fibers (Barua et al., 2018). The disadvantage of this method is that usually it is applied ex situ and a sample of biomass (from the anaerobic system under study) has to be transferred to an electrochemical system (like an electrochemical cell), and the biofilm formation on the electrode has to occur before performing the analysis (Van Steendam et al., 2019). However, the sample taken from the original system may not be enough to represent the community or the biofilm growth on the electrode may change in community structure due to changes in environmental factors, so it could not be representative of the original system as well (Van Steendam et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2023). 57 CHAPTER 3 3. THE INFLUENCE OF CONDUCTIVE AND NON-CONDUCTIVE MATERIALS ON THE METABOLISM OF THE HYDROGENOTROPH METHANOBACTERIUM FORMICICUM Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 58 ABSTRACT Hydrogenotrophic metabolism has been shown to be enhanced in the presence of carbon nanotubes (CNT), which is relevant once hydrogenotrophs are crucial microorganisms for the conversion of organic wastes to methane. In this study, the effect of several conductive materials (CM) including carbon-based (activated carbon (AC), CNT, modified AC) and iron-based materials (magnetite (Mag), CM impregnated with Fe), non-conductive materials (sand and glass beads), and one type of a zeolite (Zeo, type-13X), on the hydrogenotrophic activity of Methanobacterium formicicum was investigated. The aim was to test materials with distinct physicochemical properties to identify which are the characteristics of materials that contribute most for the methanogenic activity improvement. For that purpose, the methanogen was incubated with different concentrations of materials (from 0.1 to 5 g·L-1) and with H2/CO2, and methane production (MP) was followed. The materials were characterized regarding textural properties (specific surface area, area of mesopores, volume of micropores), pH at zero point charge, conductivity, and elemental composition. Chemical oxidation treatments with HNO3 (AC_HNO3), H2SO4 (AC_H2SO4) or both (AC_HNO3_H2SO4), and thermal treatments, were applied to obtain modified AC. Microscopy techniques were used to investigate the interaction of cells with materials. All materials, with exception of Mag, and AC_HNO3_H2SO4, improved the methanogenic activity. Carbon-based materials significantly reduced the lag phases preceding MP (from approximately 5 d, in the control, to circa 1 d). Zeo, sand, and glass beads, also reduced the lag phases but less than carbon-based materials (i.e., from 5 d to 1.5, 2.7 and 3.5 d, respectively). Additionally, exponential MP rates were up to 1.5 times higher in the assays with Zeo, glass beads and sand than in the assays with the control condition. A direct relationship between the physicochemical properties evaluated and the enhancement of MP was not found. Yet, the element silicon, common in all materials composition, was found to stimulate, per se, the activity of this methanogen. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 59 3.1. INTRODUCTION Hydrogenotrophic methanogens reduce CO2 using H2 or formate as electron donors (Lyu et al., 2018; Whitman et al., 2006). The production of methane from CO2 reduction is very important as it maintains the concentration of hydrogen and formate at low levels, allowing endergonic acetogenic reactions to become exergonic, and enabling the syntrophic communities to survive (Morris et al., 2013; Stams et al., 2012; Stams and Plugge, 2009; Whitman et al., 2006; Zabranska and Pokorna, 2018). Conductive materials (CM), like activated carbon (AC), magnetite (Mag), and carbon nanotubes (CNT) have been reported as contributing to accelerate methane production (MP) in anaerobic controlled systems, and promoting methanogenesis, including methanogenesis from H2/CO2 (Castilho et al., 2022; Martins et al., 2018). Modified materials also showed to stimulate MP in anaerobic systems, which has been attributed to their enhanced electron (in the case of materials like GAC combined with Mag) or ionic exchange capacity (in materials like Zeo) (Barua et al., 2019; Romero-Güiza et al., 2016; Song et al., 2019). Despite the research advances in this topic, many questions about the application of CM remain unexplained, including the importance of certain properties of the materials on methanogenic metabolism. The materials may differ in many properties, such as surface area, porosity, size, pH at zero point charge (pHpzc), electrical conductivity, and chemical composition (Hassanein et al., 2021; H. Liu et al., 2021; Yiwei Liu et al., 2021; Paritosh et al., 2020; A. R. Silva et al., 2021a; Wu et al., 2020). As conductive minerals are also naturally present in natural sediments, their impact directly on MP by individual microorganisms deserves to be further investigated. So far, CM such as CNT (Fu et al., 2019; Salvador et al., 2017; Xia et al., 2019; Xiao et al., 2020; W. Zhang et al., 2018), granular activated carbon (GAC) (Zheng et al., 2020), Mag (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019), nanographite (Fu et al., 2019) and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) (W. Zhang et al., 2018) were investigated towards the methanogenic activity by pure cultures of methanogens. The effect was tested on acetoclastic pure cultures, like Methanosarcina barkeri (Fu et al., 2019; Xiao et al., 2020), Methanosarcina mazei (Salvador et al., 2017; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xiao et al., 2020) and Methanosaeta concilii (Salvador et al., 2017), and some hydrogenotrophic species such as Methanobacterium formicicum (Salvador et al., 2017), Methanospirillum hungatei (Salvador et al., 2017), Methanococcus maripaludis (Fu et al., 2018; W. Zhang et al., 2018), and Methanocella conradii (Fu et al., 2018; Xia et al., 2019). Acetoclastic methanogens are more favoured by the presence of CM than hydrogenotrophs. For instance, it was reported that CNT enhanced the acetoclastic activity of M. mazei and M. barkeri (Xiao et al., 2020), but inhibited the hydrogenotrophic activity of M. maripaludis, particularly at high concentrations (at 5 g·L-1 Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 60 CNT) (W. Zhang et al., 2018). The inhibitory effect of carbon-based materials like GAC was also reported on a culture of Methanobacterium sp. strain YSL growing on formate (Zheng et al., 2020), and CNT, as well as Mag, had a negative or no effect towards the methanogenic activity of the hydrogenotroph M. conradii (Fu et al., 2018; Xia et al., 2019). The acceleration of methane production rates (MPR) by hydrogenotrophic methanogens in the presence of CM was only reported in the work developed by Salvador et al . (2017). The authors reported the improvement of MPR by the pure cultures M. hungatei and M. formicicum up to 6- and 17-fold in the presence of CNT in comparison with the controls without CNT, respectively (Salvador et al., 2017). This is very important once hydrogenotrophs are essential microorganisms during the conversion of organic wastes to methane, making this research area particularly relevant. From all methanogens reported in the literature so far, the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph M. formicicum was the most stimulated in the presence of CM. In this work, M. formicicum was incubated with several types of materials (AC, CNT, Mag, zeolite (Zeo), sand, glass beads, modified AC/CNT) to evaluate the effects and the possible properties influencing its methanogenic activity. It was hypothesized that methanogenic activity could be affected in a different extent by different types and concentrations of materials. M. formicicum was incubated separately with AC, CNT, and Mag, in concentrations ranging from 0.1 g·L-1 to 5 g·L-1. Besides, experiments with modified carbon-based materials and with materials like Zeo type-13X, sand, and glass beads, were performed aiming to investigate the influence of materials with different physicochemical properties towards MPR. The interaction of microbial cells with the materials was investigated by microscopic techniques. 3.2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 3.2.1. Conductive and non-conductive materials Commercial materials, namely Mag (nanopowder, particle size 50 – 100 nm, Iron (II, III) oxide, Fe3O4), Zeo (Molecular sieve, type 13X - beads, 4-8 mesh) and glass beads (acid washed, 212-300 µm, 50-70 U.S. sieve), were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (USA). Commercial AC (Norit ROX 0.8 GAC, pellets with 0.8 mm of diameter and 5 mm of length) was supplied by Norit, and commercial multiwall CNT (NC3100TM) from Nanocyl S.A. (Sambreville, Belgium). The original characteristics of Zeo and CNT were described elsewhere (Salvador et al., 2017; R. M. Silva et al., 2021). Sand sample was collected from Apúlia beach (Esposende, Portugal), which was washed with distilled water several times, and followed by organic contaminants removal at 550 °C, for 2 h. In the experiments, GAC, modified AC, and Zeo, Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 61 were used as powder by being crushed (increasing the external surface area) and sieved (particle size < 280 µm). The other materials (glass beads and sand) were also sieved to limit the range of particle size in the assays (i.e., all materials were used with a particle size < 280 µm). The tests with different materials can be divided into three main experiments (Figure 3.1): Experiment I – test the effect of AC, CNT, and Mag at different concentrations (0.1, 0.5, 1, 2 and 5 g·L-1); Experiment II – test the effect of modified AC with different physicochemical characteristics; Experiment III - test the effect of Zeo, sand and glass beads, which are materials different from carbon-based materials in physicochemical properties, including electrical conductivity. As experiments were performed in different periods, three different commercial AC (with different physicochemical characteristics) were used in the experiments and will be referred in this chapter as: i) AC from batch 1 (ACb1) – used in the assays of Experiment I (Figure 3.1); ii) AC from batch 2 (ACb2) – used in the assays of Experiment II (Figure 3.1), where ACb2 is the control to compare with modified AC, in order to conclude if any modification was better than the original material as ACb2 was the starting material to prepare the AC with different modifications; and iii) AC from batch 3 (ACb3) - tested in the same round of the experiments with ACb2 (Figure 3.1, Experiment II). Regarding the assays with ACb2 and ACb3, the aim was to investigate if the same type of material (AC from same supplier) would present different physicochemical characteristics when acquired in different moments. The assumption is that if these physicochemical differences contribute to differently affect the methanogenic activity, then it is possible to obtain different results even when it is considered the same material. Starting from commercial ACb2, and CNT, different modifications were made aiming to obtain a broaden number of materials, and composites (i.e., materials impregnated with magnetic nanoparticles), differing in some physicochemical properties according to the treatment applied, but the type of material remaining the same. The preparation of modified materials and composites, as their physicochemical characterization, were performed by the research group from Catalysis and Materials Associate Laboratory, at Engineering Faculty of Oporto University. The following treatments were carried out to prepare the modified AC, with ACb2 as the starting material: liquid phase treatments with H2SO4, HNO3, or both, with different concentrations and/or contact times. Heat treatments at different temperatures were also performed, which remove some of the functional groups. In addition, a set of materials was prepared from the modified ACb2, by doping them with nitrogen. Chemical oxidation treatments and thermal treatments allow to obtain materials with different surface chemistry, conferring to them acid or basic character (A. R. Silva et al., 2021a). Composites of AC (AC@2%Fe) and of CNT (CNT@2%Fe) impregnated Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 62 with 2 % of iron (amount of Fe2+ or Fe3+ to be impregnated) were also prepared. The final modified materials and composites used in the assays are summarized in Table 3.1. The procedures to perform these types of modification or composites’ preparation are described elsewhere (Pereira et al., 2017, 2010; Restivo et al., 2014; Rocha et al., 2014; Silva et al., 2020). The characterization of materials included the following surface and textural properties: Brunauer-Emmett- Teller (BET) specific surface area (SBET), mesopore surface area (Smeso), micropore volume (Vmicro), total pore volume (Vp P/P0=0.95), and pHpzc, as described elsewhere (Pereira et al., 2010; A. R. Silva et al., 2021b). The chemical characterization of the surface (surface groups releasing CO, CO2, CO/CO2 by temperature programme dessorption) was done only for ACb1, as described by Pereira et al . (2010), and elemental analyses were performed for ACb2, modified AC, and ACb3, as described by Silva et al . (A. R. Silva et al., 2021b). The morphology of materials, namely ACb1, Mag, CNT, and CNT@2%Fe, was attained by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and chemical elemental composition was carried out by SEM coupled with energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) (values given in percentage, w/w). Electrical conductivity of Mag and Zeo was obtained after determining their electrical resistance through electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The device used for impedance analysis required a firm sample, and as Mag and Zeo were used in powder, pellets of each sample (Mag and Zeo) were obtained by applying a high pressure using a lab manual press machine. Firm circular pellets were obtained, and their thickness was measured (0.994 mm and 0.388 mm were obtained for Mag and Zeo, respectively) with a Digimatic Micrometer IP54 (Mitutoyo). Due to the physical characteristics of powder AC and CNT, the impedance analysis was not carried out due to the impossibility in obtaining firm pellets necessary to proceed with analysis. For EIS measurements, it was used a support cell and two parallel Au disk electrodes (Figueira et al., 2014). The measurements were carried out in triplicate to check data reproducibility, at room temperature, using GAMRY analyzer (GAMRY Instruments, Reference 600+, Potentiostat/Galvanostat/ZRA, 39008). Data was analyzed using Gamry Echem Analyst software as described elsewhere (Figueira et al., 2014). The resistance value for Mag was obtained using this software. The model fitting with the Gamry Echem Analyst software was not adequate for Zeo results, so the resistance value for Zeo was determined using the tools (for data analysis) of Origin software. Considering the resistance values for each sample, the values of conductivity were calculated as described by Figueira et al . (2014). Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 63 Figure 3.1. Illustrative scheme of the assays performed with the pure culture M. formicicum . The data obtained for control condition is the same for experiments II and III,i) (i.e., the control condition for the assays with modified AC, “Control without AC”, and for the tests with Zeo, sand and glass beads, “Control without materials”, is the same), once the assays were performed at the same time. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 64 Table 3.1. Summary of the modified materials and composites used in the incubations Modified materials/composites Description AC_HNO3 AC treated with HNO3 AC_HNO3_400 AC treated with HNO3 at 400 °C AC_HNO3_600 AC treated with HNO3 at 600 °C AC_HNO3_900 AC treated with HNO3 at 900 °C AC_H2SO4 AC treated with H2SO4 AC_H2SO4_ HNO3 AC treated with H2SO4 and HNO3 AC_N AC doped with nitrogen AC@2%Fe AC impregnated with 2 % of iron, calcinated and reduced at 400 °C CNT@2%Fe CNT impregnated with 2 % of iron, calcinated and reduced at 400 °C 3.2.2. Incubation conditions The strain M. formicicum (DSM 1535T) was obtained from DSMZ (Braunschweig, Germany) and maintained at the laboratory for many years under the conditions that will be described below. Batch assays were performed in 120 mL serum bottles (50 mL of working volume), containing anaerobic medium prepared as described elsewhere (Salvador et al., 2017; Stams et al., 1993). The materials were added to the bottles, which were then sealed with butyl rubber stoppers and aluminium crimp caps. The headspace was flushed with H2/CO2 (80:20 % v/v; 1.7 × 105 Pa) and the bottles containing the medium growth and the materials were sterilized by autoclaving (120 °C, 20 min). Vitamins solution and sodium sulfide (Na2S·9H2O, > 98 %, Acros Organics, Fisher Scientific, USA) were filter sterilized. Prior to inoculation, the anaerobic medium was reduced with Na2S·9H2O (0.8 mmol·L-1), vitamins were supplemented, and acetate (acetic acid sodium salt, anhydrous, ≥ 99.0 %, Sigma-Aldrich, USA) added at 2 mmol·L-1 (sterilized by autoclaving). After inoculation (10 % v/v), the bottles were incubated at 37 °C, in the dark, and under agitation (120 min-1), to improve the transfer of the substrate from the headspace to the liquid phase. All assays were performed in triplicate. The biotic assays can be divided in three different experiments (schematic representation in Figure 3.1): • In Experiment I, M. formicicum was incubated with AC, CNT, CNT@2%Fe, and Mag, in different concentrations (0, 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2 and 5 g·L-1) to select the best material for accelerating methanogenic activity and the optimal concentration. • The Experiment II was carried out with the various materials with distinct properties (ACb2, AC_HNO3, AC_HNO3_400, AC_HNO3_600, AC_HNO3_900, AC_H2SO4, AC_H2SO4_ HNO3, AC_N, AC@2%Fe, ACb3), at 0.5 g·L-1. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 71 So, the application of different treatments allowed to obtain AC with distinct characteristics. In summary, in this work, the AC samples treated with HNO3 presented a lower specific surface area, lower mesopore surface area, and a slight decrease on micropore volume than the starting ACb2 (Table 3.3). These parameters in general slightly increased during heat treatment at increasing temperatures (400 °C, 600 °C and 900 °C). What also increased with HNO3 treatment was mainly the content in nitrogen, followed a slight increase in hydrogen and sulfur. The combination of HNO3 with heat treatment did not cause almost any impact on the H, N and S content in comparison with ACb2. On the other hand, the treatment with H2SO4 allowed an increase in sulfur amount with a consequently decrease on specific surface area (more functional groups are spread around all surface of the material) comparing with ACb2. Combining HNO3 and H2SO3 treatments caused the decrease in almost all parameters, namely specific surface area, mesopore surface area, micropore volume and a drastically alteration of the distribution of elements (loss of some carbon material, decrease of sulfur content, and increase of hydrogen and nitrogen contents), comparing with ACb2. By doping AC with nitrogen (AC_N), the increase of N content on the material occurred with a consequent decrease on the specific surface area, as well as on the mesopore surface area, and micropore volumes. Regarding the pHpzc, these values are critical to determine the net charge (positive or negative) carried on the materials surface as a function of the pH of the solution (Pereira et al., 2010). The surface becomes positively charged at pH < pHpzc and negatively charged at pH > pHpzc (Pereira et al., 2010). Considering that the pH of the growth medium is around 7, the results showed that the following materials presented a neutral or slightly acidic character: ACb2, AC_ HNO3_600, CNT and CNT@2%Fe. The lower values of pHpzc in the materials AC_ HNO3_ H2SO4, AC_ H2SO4, AC_ HNO3, Mag, AC_ HNO3_400, revealed that they are acidic materials (negatively charged surface at pH 7), while the rest (AC@2%Fe, ACb3, AC_N, AC_ HNO3_900, Glass beads, sand, Zeo) presented a basic character (positively charged surface at pH 7). The elemental analysis of materials allows to get more details about their composition. For instance, Tessonier et al . (2009) determined the percentage of impurities present on commercial CNT, being iron (Fe), cobalt, sulfur (S) and aluminum (Al) the main contaminants found (Tessonnier et al., 2009). In carbon-based materials (AC, CNT), used in this study, carbon (C) was the most abundant element detected, while Fe was the most abundant element found in Mag, as expected. However, other elements were commonly observed comparing the different materials, but in different amounts. These elements include the silicon (Si) which was at higher percentages in ACb1 than in CNT or Mag (Table 3.2), and it is expected to be the main element in the composition of glass beads, sand, and Zeo. Zeo type-13X is an aluminosilicate constituted by 1 Na2O:1 Al2O3:2.8 ± 0.2 SiO2:xH2O, with a structures similar to faujasite Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 72 structure (R. M. Silva et al., 2021). Other elements, namely nitrogen (N) and S also varied in amount for each material under study (Table 3.2 and Table 3.3). In terms of conductivity, Mag ((2.1 ± 0.7) × 10-5 S·cm-1) is almost 10 times more conductive than Zeo ((3.3 ± 0.7) × 10-6 S·cm-1), both with a semiconductor profile. Materials or conjugated polymers can be classified as insulators, semiconductors, and conductors, according with the values of electrical conductivity. For instance, quartz and diamond are considered insulators since their electrical conductivity are in the range between 10-16 S·m-1 and 10-10 S·m-1 (Spadafora, 2011). In the range of 10-10 S·m-1 to 102 S·m-1 are the semiconductors like glass (in the transition zone insulator-semiconductor) and silicon, while conductors like copper, iron or silver are in the range between 102 S·m-1 and 108 S·m-1 (Spadafora, 2011). In the literature, the values of electrical conductivity of Mag were reported as correlated with the amount and particles size of Mag samples (Weidenfeller et al., 2002). So, different values of electrical conductivity might be found for Mag in different studies. For instance, Lee et al . (2020) used a Mag with an electrical conductivity of 3.8 × 10-5 S·cm-1, which is a higher value than in the present study, although in the same order of magnitude (Lee et al., 2020). Regarding the type of Zeo, the conductivity can also vary. For example, it was reported values from ((4.24 ± 0.22) × 10-4) S·m-1 to ((6.99 ± 4.26) × 10-4) S·m-1 for the faujasite type-Y (Yimlamai et al., 2011), which are higher values than the ones obtained in this study. However, in this study it was used the commercial type-13X, also with the faujasite structure, but with lower Si/Al ratio (R. M. Silva et al., 2021) (in contrast with type-Y). The differences in Si/Al ratios imply also differences in the Zeo’ properties, such as the particle size, the morphology, and the distribution of framework aluminium (Busca, 2014), and then it is possibly that it could interfere in the value of electrical conductivity as well. The conductivity of AC and CNT were not obtained in this study due to the physical properties of these materials that hindered the measurement, with the type of equipment used. However, according to the literature, the value of conductivity for GAC can be around (1.68 × 10-4) S·cm-1 ( (Lee et al., 2020), (3 × 10-3) S·cm-1 (Martins et al., 2018; J. H. Park et al., 2018), or even approximately (8.6 × 10-3) S·cm-1 (Song et al., 2019), and 0.14 S·cm-1 for powdered AC (König et al., 2022), while CNT can present conductivities from 10 to 100 S·cm-1 (Martins et al., 2018). These values suggested that both GAC and CNT possess a conductor profile, with CNT being the material with the highest electrical conductivity. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 73 3.3.2. Abiotic assays: effects of (nano)materials on growth medium parameters and interaction with gaseous substrates The results of abiotic assays showed that the concentrations of hydrogen in the presence and absence of materials were maintained and followed the same profile (Figure 3.3), excluding the possible adsorption effects of the substrate to the surface of materials. Figure 3.3. Monitoring of hydrogen concentration over time in the following abiotic conditions: a) with CNT, CNT@2%Fe, Mag and ACb1, at 0.1 g∙L-1 and 5 g∙L-1; and b) with Zeo, glass beads and sand, at 0.5 g∙L-1. The abiotic assays with the different set of materials were carried out in different periods. Each condition was evaluated in duplicate, and it is represented as the mean and the respective standard deviation. The values for pH, ORP and conductivity in the abiotic anaerobic medium, with and without materials, are given in Table 3.4. The ORP and pH values exactly at the beginning of the assays differed slightly from the other sampling time points, maybe due to some reactions that were ongoing. Taken this into consideration, it was decided in further studies to measure these parameters after 24 h of the beginning of the assays to allow the stabilization of the reactions. For instance, the addition of sulfide solution results in products of sulfide oxidation which would be stabilized after 24 h (Whitman et al., 2006). Yet, initial differences were observed in the ORP values in the presence of carbon-based materials. At the highest concentration tested, the presence of AC and CNT decreased the values of ORP. During the time of the assay, the ORP values were decreasing during the time, excepting for the conditions with 5 g∙L-1 of CNT@2%Fe and Mag. Indeed, the presence of Mag and CNT@2%Fe (mainly at 5 g∙L-1) contributed to the highest ORP values registered. Regarding pH and conductivity values, the presence of AC, CNT, CNT@2%Fe and Mag seems not to interfere with these parameters, as the values did not differ much Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 74 from those of the medium without materials. The presence of Zeo, sand and glass almost did not alter the values of ORP, pH and conductivity, although the values of pH of the medium tended to be higher with Zeo, which could be related with its basic character. Table 3.4. Values of ORP, pH, and conductivity of the growth medium with H2/CO2, at the beginning (a), middle (b) and end (c) of abiotic assays in the presence of different concentrations (C) of materials C/ (g∙L-1) ORP/ (mV) pH Conductivity/ (mS∙cm-1) a b c a b c a b c Abiotic medium 0 -179 ± 1 -263 ± 11 -351 ± 0 7.32 ± 0.03 7.30 ± 0.01 7.27 ± 0.01 - 5.84 ± 0.16 5.76 ± 0.06 CNT 0.1 -174 ± 15 -275 ± 1 -350 ± 8 7.35 ± 0.01 7.31 ± 0.06 7.27 ± 0.01 - 5.97 ± 0.21 5.86 ± 0.15 5 -237 ± 75 -328 ± 8 -376 ± 18 7.42 ± 0.03 7.31 ± 0.02 7.28 ± 0.01 - 6.08 ± 0.09 5.98 ± 0.12 CNT@2%Fe 0.1 -158 ± 3 -306 ± 0 -373 ± 27 7.53 ± 0.03 7.37 ± 0.04 7.29 ± 0.04 - 5.95 ± 0.08 5.92 ± 0.06 5 -183 ± 4 -241 ± 4 -222 ± 27 7.54 ± 0.07 7.40 ± 0.03 7.30 ± 0.01 - 6.01 ± 0.03 5.83 ± 0.02 ACb1 0.1 -179 ± 2 -305 ± 1 -339 ± 3 7.43 ± 0.04 7.33 ± 0.01 7.28 ± 0.01 - 6.01 ± 0.06 5.93 ± 0.01 5 -282 ± 51 -390 ± 10 -348 ± 2 7.44 ± 0.05 7.30 ± 0.06 7.27 ± 0.04 - 6.17 ± 0.33 6.18 ± 0.33 Mag 0.1 -187 ± 14 -308 ± 2 -337 ± 17 7.43 ± 0.01 7.35 ± 0.01 7.31 ± 0.07 - 5.93 ± 0.16 5.99 ± 0.11 5 -184 ± 3 -210 ± 33 -212 ± 8 7.43 ± 0.01 7.36 ± 0.01 7.31 ± 0.01 - 6.05 ± 0.02 5.93 ± 0.01 Abiotic medium 0 -285 ± 5 -310 ± 19 -249 ± 28 7.16 ± 0.04 7.24 ± 0.04 7.28 ± 0.06 7.41 ± 0.17 7.45 ± 0.21 7.49 ± 0.21 Zeo 0.5 -291 ± 4 -333 ± 2 -297 ± 12 7.25 ± 0.01 7.35 ± 0.02 7.37 ± 0.00 7.71 ± 0.16 7.77 ± 0.12 7.79 ± 0.13 Glass beads 0.5 -295 ± 3 -341 ± 6 -311 ± 1 7.14 ± 0.01 7.26 ± 0.01 7.30 ± 0.01 7.73 ± 0.06 7.73 ± 0.08 7.77 ± 0.01 Sand 0.5 -307 ± 5 -339 ± 7 -290 ± 5 7.13 ± 0.01 7.24 ± 0.01 7.31 ± 0.01 7.68 ± 0.22 7.71 ± 0.23 7.70 ± 0.25 (-) equipment not available. * The abiotic assays with AC, CNT, CNT@2%Fe and Mag were carried out in a different period of the abiotic assays with Zeo, glass beads and sand. 3.3.3. Biotic assays 3.3.3.1. Experiment I: Effect of different materials on MP The presence of CM (i.e., CNT, CNT@2%Fe, AC and Mag) affected the methanogenic activity of M. formicicum (Figure 3.4). The main impact observed was the decrease of lag phases preceding MP in the presence of carbon-based materials and its increase in the presence of the iron-based material (i.e., Mag). Another observation was that increasing concentrations of carbon-based materials contributed to a higher Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 75 decrease of the lag phases duration. In the presence of the highest concentration of carbon-based materials tested, the lag phases were decreased from approximately 4 d (in the control condition) to less than 1 d (Table 3.5). For example, this impact corresponded to a decrease of 97.5 % of the lag phase in the presence of 5 g·L-1 of AC. On the other hand, the presence of Mag extended the lag phase duration up to 20 d, depending on the concentration tested. Therefore, this drastic decrease in the lag phases preceding MP in the presence of carbon-based materials led to an acceleration of the initial methane production rates (IMPR) during the first 3 d of incubation (Table 3.5). Consequently, the IMPR increased with increasing concentrations of CNT and CNT@2%Fe, up to the highest concentration evaluated, but only up to 0.5 g·L-1 with AC, and decreasing with 2 g·L-1 and 5 g·L-1 of AC (Table 3.5; Figure A. 1, Appendix). Evaluating the effects for each concentration tested, AC was always the best material in decreasing the lag phases and in increasing the IMPR, except for the concentration of 5 g·L-1, for which the stimulatory effect was more or less the same independently of the type of carbon-based material used (Figure 3.4). Regarding the effects of CM towards the EMPR, the results showed that once the biotic control reached this phase of MP, its rate was by far faster than in the presence of any CM tested (Table 3.5). The complete MP profiles are presented in Figure A. 2 (Appendix). However, the effects of CM towards lag phase and IMPR cannot be ignored. For instance, considering the first 3 d of incubation, the presence of 0.5 g·L-1 of AC allowed the consumption of (41 ± 3) % of hydrogen, while almost no hydrogen consumption occurred ((2 ± 1) %) by the biotic control without CM, for the same period. Thus, the IMPR was around 15 times higher in comparison with the IMPR of the biotic control without CM (Table 3.6). Furthermore, the presence of 5 g·L-1 of CNT and CNT@2%Fe improved the IMPR up to 11 and 9 times, respectively. Another important remark was that the EMPR were less affected at lower concentrations of CM (Table 3.6), highlighting the importance of optimizing the concentration of materials. Considering the effects of Mag, all concentrations caused a partial inhibition of the methanogenic activity by increasing the lag phases duration (Table 3.5). However, after some time the cultures eventually started to produce methane (Erro! A origem da referência não foi encontrada., Appendix). The MP in the presence of Mag was different for each concentration tested and for each bottle, including replicates of the same concentration that evolved differently, showing big differences in their recovery, which is represented by the high standard deviations (Figure A. 2, Appendix; Table 3.5). Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 76 Figure 3.4. Cumulative methane production during the first days of incubation of M. formicicum with and without different CM, i.e., AC, CNT, CNT@2%Fe, and Mag, at concentrations varying between 0.1 g·L-1 and 5 g·L-1. The results are the mean of triplicate assays with the respective standard deviation. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 77 Table 3.5. Values of initial concentration of substrate (CH2), lag phase duration, IMPR, EMPR, and incubation time (t) for the conversion of H2/CO2 to methane, for the assays with and without CM Condition CM/ g·L-1 CH2/ mmol·L-1 Lag phasea/ d IMPR b/ mmol·L-1·d-1 R2 b EMPR a/ mmol·L-1·d-1 R2 a t/ d Biotic control 0 62.4 ± 0.7 3.9 ± 0.2 0.21 ± 0.10 0.80 ± 0.02 6.49 ± 0.42 1.00 ± 0.00 7 AC 0.1 62.9 ± 2.2 2.1 ± 0.4 2.25 ± 0.85 0.84 ± 0.01 5.84 ± 2.11 1.00 ± 0.00 8 0.5 62.7 ± 0.6 1.2 ± 0.3 2.99 ± 0.35 0.99 ± 0.01 3.97 ± 0.82 0.99 ± 0.00 8 1 62.4 ± 1.0 0.6 ± 0.3 3.02 ± 0.59 1.00 ± 0.00 3.04 ± 0.99 0.99 ± 0.01 9 2 62.5 ± 1.9 0.5 ± 0.3 2.10 ± 0.30 0.99 ± 0.00 2.19 ± 0.51 0.99 ± 0.00 15 5 61.3 ± 0.6 0.1 ± 0.1 1.87 ± 0.07 0.99 ± 0.01 1.71 ± 0.12 0.99 ± 0.00 24 CNT 0.1 61.4 ± 0.6 4.6 ± 0.6 0.17 ± 0.12 0.82 ± 0.16 3.43 ± 0.90 1.00 ± 0.00 13 0.5 61.3 ± 0.6 2.8 ± 0.3 0.53 ± 0.16 0.88 ± 0.03 1.90 ± 0.27 1.00 ± 0.00 14 1 (*) 65.0 1.8 1.05 0.94 1.86 1.00 14 2 60.8 ± 0.2 0.9 ± 0.2 1.78 ± 0.23 0.99 ± 0.00 1.95 ± 0.49 0.99 ± 0.00 14 5 61.8 ± 1.6 0.7 ± 0.1 2.22 ± 0.08 0.99 ± 0.00 2.24 ± 0.03 0.99 ± 0.00 14 CNT@2%Fe 0.1 61.9 ± 0.7 3.4 ± 0.3 0.43 ± 0.03 0.95 ± 0.02 6.18 ± 0.80 0.99 ± 0.00 8 0.5 61.6 ± 0.1 2.0 ± 0.3 0.72 ± 0.25 0.97 ± 0.00 1.40 ± 0.21 1.00 ± 0.00 14 1 62.2 ± 1.6 1.2 ± 0.1 1.27 ± 0.04 0.99 ± 0.00 1.68 ± 0.35 0.99 ± 0.00 14 2 61.7 ± 0.3 0.9 ± 0.0 1.72 ± 0.07 0.99 ± 0.00 1.89 ± 0.03 0.99 ± 0.00 14 5 61.8 ± 1.9 0.7 ± 0.0 1.89 ± 0.06 0.99 ± 0.00 1.94 ± 0.00 0.99 ± 0.00 14 Mag 0.1 61.7 ± 0.7 4.8 ± 0.4 - - 4.27 ± 0.93 0.99 ± 0.00 9 0.5 62.1 ± 0.6 13.1 ± 0.4 - - 1.50 ± 0.24 0.99 ± 0.00 24 1 60.6 ± 0.8 21.1 ± 2.5 - - 1.84 ± 0.42 1.00 ± 0.00 > 29 2 60.7 ± 1.0 16.7 ± 2.9 - - 2.09 ± 0.69 0.93 ± 0.10 > 27 5 61.2 ± 0.4 14.1 ± 1.2 - - 1.81 ± 0.50 0.99 ± 0.00 24 (*) During the assays with 1 g∙L-1 CNT, two bottles were lost, which means these values are only from one of the triplicates. a kinetics parameters obtained by modified Gompertz model. b IMPR was calculated for the early MP between days 1 and 3. The complete conversion of H2/CO2 to methane was achieved almost in all conditions (Erro! A origem da referência não foi encontrada., Appendix; Table 3.5). However, as Mag inhibited the activity of Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 78 M. formicicum and took longer times for converting the substrate to methane, the assays were given as finished before reaching the highest point of methane, being this one of the reasons why the values for MP in assays with Mag were lower comparing with the other conditions. Table 3.6. Number of times that the IMPR and EMPR increases, or decreases (> 1 or < 1, respectively), relatively to the biotic control without CM Concentration of CM/ g·L-1 AC CNT CNT@2%Fe Mag IMPR EMPR IMPR EMPR IMPR EMPR IMPR EMPR 0.1 11.0 0.9 0.8 0.5 2.1 1.0 # 0.7 0.5 14.6 0.6 2.6 0.3 3.5 0.2 # 0.2 1 14.7 0.5 5.1 0.3 6.2 0.3 # 0.3 2 10.2 0.3 8.7 0.3 8.4 0.3 # 0.3 5 9.1 0.3 10.8 0.3 9.2 0.3 # 0.3 #The number of times that IMPR was affected relatively to the control could not be calculated because there was no growth in M. formicicum assays with Mag for the period of analysis of the IMPR (i.e., the first 3 d of incubation). Considering the results obtained, AC was selected as the best material to accelerate MP by M. formicicum pure cultures, and for this reason, the next experiments with modified materials had AC as the starting material. In experiments II and III (Figure 3.1), it was used the optimal concentration found for AC (0.5 g·L-1). 3.3.3.1.1. Interaction of microbial cells with CM The arrangement of cells with and without CM can be observed in Figure 3.5. In the presence of carbonbased materials, many cells were observed in direct contact with CNT (Figure 3.5ii), CNT@2%Fe (Figure 3.5iii), and AC (Figure 3.5i). Aggregates were formed between cells and carbon-based materials, and the cells seemed not to suffer any damage by the presence of CM. Particularly with AC, cells were attached to the surface of the material. On the other hand, lower abundance of cells was observed interacting with Mag, even the sample for SEM analysis had also been taken during the middle of the exponential of MP (Figure 3.5iv). These observations are aligned with the results of MP in the presence of these CM. In the absence of materials, the cells seemed to be aggregated to each other and linked by what seems to be extracellular substances (Figure 3.5v). The analysis by SEM-EDS of Z1 (in red at the image), showed that the elemental composition consisted in 0.49 % Al, 0.66 % Si, 0.85 % Cl, 43.37 % C, 12.43 % O, 1.54 % Ca, 10.43 % N, 2.93 % P, 3.07 % Fe, 1.22 % Na, 6.02 % S, 0.45 Mg, 9.47 % Au, 1.63 % Pd, and 5.45 % Zn (w/w). Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 79 Figure 3.5. SEM images of M. formicicum incubated with i) AC), ii) CNT, iii) CNT@2%Fe, and iv) Mag, and v) without CM. In the control condition without CM, SEM-EDS analysis was performed at zone 1 (Z1) indicated at the image in red. The shape of cells are long or short rods (Whitman et al., 2006). The cell width of M. formicicum is typically between 0.4 µm to 0.8 µm, and cell length can vary from 2 µm to 15 µm (Whitman et al., 2006). 3.3.3.1.2. Effects of CM on growth medium parameters in biotic conditions The presence of CM in biotic conditions did not significantly alter the values of pH and conductivity of the growth medium (Table 3.7). The values of these parameters varied during the incubation time, but without drastic differences among conditions. Regarding ORP values, the presence of carbon-based materials promoted the decrease of ORP (specially at 1 g·L-1 or 2 g·L-1) and higher ORP values were observed in the presence of Mag, and even in the presence of 5 g·L-1 CNT@2%Fe. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 80 Table 3.7. Values of ORP, pH, and conductivity of the growth medium at (a) the beginning, (b) during exponential MP, and (c) at the end of incubations with M. formicicum pure cultures Condition C/ (g∙L-1) ORP/ (mV) pH Conductivity/ (mS∙cm-1) a b c a b c a b c Biotic control 0 -308 ± 5 -348 ± 9 -352 ± 10 7.29 ± 0.02 7.51 ± 0.12 8.26 ± 0.23 5.78 ± 0.15 5.94 ± 0.13 5.78 ± 0.06 CNT 0.1 -318 ± 5 -380 ± 9 -367 ± 14 7.34 ± 0.11 7.98 ± 0.29 8.16 ± 0.09 6.18 ± 0.80 6.14 ± 0.50 6.80 ± 0.96 0.5 -322 ± 26 -388 ± 21 -368 ± 10 7.30 ± 0.04 7.39 ± 0.05 8.07 ± 0.09 5.80 ± 0.21 5.76 ± 0.15 5.70 ± 0.17 1 -338 ± 35 -380 -368 7.23 ± 0.06 7.43 8.24 5.80 ± 0.10 5.88 5.79 2 -394 ± 7 -398 ± 4 -409 ± 2 7.15 ± 0.02 7.62 ± 0.09 8.02 ± 0.09 5.73 ± 0.09 5.79 ± 0.08 5.81 ± 0.09 5 -329 ± 27 -371 ± 47 -397 ± 2 7.25 ± 0.03 7.40 ± 0.03 8.10 ± 0.05 5.85 ± 0.20 5.87 ± 0.21 5.78 ± 0.06 CNT@2%Fe 0.1 -323 ± 21 -353 ± 7 -355 ± 6 7.23 ± 0.03 7.59 ± 0.03 8.25 ± 0.04 5.77 ± 0.09 5.73 ± 0.02 5.70 ± 0.04 0.5 -334 ± 22 -388 ± 15 -414 ± 1 7.23 ± 0.04 7.46 ± 0.03 8.22 ± 0.07 5.87 ± 0.21 5.81 ± 0.17 5.67 ± 0.39 1 -341 ± 29 -417 ± 2 -396 ± 23 7.25 ± 0.02 7.41 ± 0.09 8.25 ± 0.03 5.85 ± 0.19 6.08 ± 0.27 5.75 ± 0.06 2 -371 ± 14 -375 ± 28 -317 ± 45 7.26 ± 0.03 7.60 ± 0.02 8.21 ± 0.05 5.91 ± 0.05 5.92 ± 0.14 5.93 ± 0.15 5 -342 ± 3 -215 ± 41 -216 ± 12 7.25 ± 0.04 7.38 ± 0.06 8.19 ± 0.08 5.73 ± 0.12 5.86 ± 0.03 5.71 ± 0.20 AC 0.1 -318 ± 4 -363 ± 5 -352 ± 2 7.27 ± 0.03 7.95 ± 0.22 8.24 ± 0.07 5.91 ± 0.10 5.89 ± 0.08 5.80 ± 0.13 0.5 -365 ± 9 -379 ± 12 -355 ± 34 7.26 ± 0.03 8.11 ± 0.10 8.21 ± 0.04 5.92 ± 0.17 5.86 ± 0.11 5.81 ± 0.08 1 -345 ± 8 -400 ± 7 -364 ± 25 7.29 ± 0.02 7.38 ± 0.04 8.29 ± 0.06 5.90 ± 0.12 5.91 ± 0.24 5.69 ± 0.09 2 -331 ± 12 -374 ± 4 -383 ± 3 7.29 ± 0.07 7.74 ± 0.12 8.18 ± 0.01 5.97 ± 0.13 5.88 ± 0.10 5.82 ± 0.12 5 -295 ± 48 -338 ± 11 -124 ± 71 7.27 ± 0.03 7.35 ± 0.01 8.20 ± 0.04 5.88 ± 0.14 5.76 ± 0.10 5.80 ± 0.09 Mag 0.1 -316 ± 3 -365 ± 4 -349 ± 11 7.28 ± 0.01 8.22 ± 0.11 8.19 ± 0.15 5.84 ± 0.11 5.74 ± 0.03 5.81 ± 0.03 0.5 -321 ± 7 -310 ± 8 -310 ± 10 7.27 ± 0.03 8.05 ± 0.15 8.39 ± 0.47 6.01 ± 0.09 5.85 ± 0.20 5.87 ± 0.13 1 -331 ± 21 -299 ± 34 -319 ± 27 7.20 ± 0.03 7.47 ± 0.06 7.99 ± 0.38 5.94 ± 0.07 6.21 ± 0.53 5.88 ± 0.16 2 -311 ± 3 -299 ± 8 -353 ± 12 7.26 ± 0.01 7.87 ± 0.15 8.22 ± 0.11 5.86 ± 0.09 5.82 ± 0.11 5.77 ± 0.14 5 -315 ± 7 -336 ± 18 -295 ± 43 7.26 ± 0.03 8.08 ± 0.14 8.31 ± 0.49 5.92 ± 0.09 5.82 ± 0.06 5.81 ± 0.10 (*) During the assays with 1 g∙L-1 CNT, two bottles were lost, which means these values are only from one bottle (there are no replicates only for this condition). Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 87 came from, even for the same supplier. This was observed in the incubations with AC from different batches (Table 3.3, Figure 3.6d), with ACb3 improving better the methanogenic activity than ACb2. These results brought the attention to the importance of the physicochemical characterization of the materials as it can impact the results obtained. However, there is a lack of information about the characterization of materials in most of the studies, avoiding a clear comparison of results (e.g., values of electrical conductivity of CM) (Castilho et al., 2022; Martins et al., 2018). This study, and all the others published, show that results can be affected either by the different cultures or by materials with different characteristics (even when materials are considered to be of the same type). Effects of different types of CM at different concentrations In this study, M. formicicum was particularly stimulated in the presence of AC, at relatively low concentrations, when compared with CNT (Figure 3.4). From an applied point of view, the fact that AC can promote better results than CNT is something to be into account, because regardless the potential of CNT to improve the AD process, it can bring higher costs than AC, when applied in large scale (Abbas et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2021). Furthermore, commercial AC can be replaced by bio-based carbons, being more economical and sustainable attractive, once AC can be obtained through different biomass wastes at lower costs (Abbas et al., 2021). The improvements observed by each material also varied with the concentration (Figure A. 1, Appendix). With CNT, the IMPR increased with increasing concentrations and the same effect was observed in other studies (Salvador et al., 2017). However, with AC, the best results were not obtained with the highest concentration tested (Figure A. 1, Appendix). In fact, concentrations higher than 1 g·L-1 impacted negatively the EMPR (Table 3.5 and Table 3.6). For instance, it was observed in other study that applying 5 or 25 g∙L-1 of GAC would not promote significant differences in MP performance (Xu et al., 2018). Inhibitory effects have also been observed at high concentrations of other CM (Cavalcante et al., 2021; Yiwei Liu et al., 2021). Thus, this dose-effect impact become an important factor also to consider, as finding the optimal concentration will allow to achieve a cost-energy- effective treatment (Castilho et al., 2022; Xu et al., 2019). Possible explanations behind the effects of carbon- and iron-based materials on MP From a fundamental point of view, AC, CNT, and Mag caused different impacts towards the hydrogenotrophic activity of M. formicicum . The carbon-based materials contributed to decrease the lag phases preceding MP, and consequently increasing the IMPR, while Mag caused an extension of the lag phase preceding MP (Figure 3.4). The physicochemical characteristics of the materials may be relevant Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 88 for the results obtained. The analyses of many reports performed by Castilho et al . (2022) suggested that no apparent correlation existed between the enhancement of MP and the electrical conductivity of materials (Castilho et al., 2022). This is aligned with the results here presented, firstly because the conductivity of materials has been related with the mechanism of conductive material mediated interspecies electron transfer (CIET) (Martins et al., 2018) and there is no interspecies electron transfer in pure cultures and, secondly, CNT presents higher conductivity than AC (Table 3.2) and yet, AC resulted in the best results (Table 3.6). The particle size of material may also play a role, as large materials may support microbial growth (Castilho et al., 2022; Wu et al., 2020), and the results obtained showed the attachment of M. formicicum cells growing on the surface of AC (Figure 3.5i), which means it can serve as a support for cells growth. The substrate adsorption in the surface of materials could also contribute to influence the microbial activity. In this case, hydrogen adsorption to AC surface could bring closer M. formicicum and its substrate, but this phenomenon seemed not to be relevant here once hydrogen concentrations remained unchanged in abiotic conditions with or without CM (Figure 3.3). The effect of Mag towards M. formicicum , by causing a temporary MP inhibition, could be related with the sensitivity of M. formicicum to the Fe(III) present in the composition of Mag (H. Wang et al., 2020). In previous studies, it was shown the sensitivity of pure cultures of methanogens growing on H2/CO2 in the presence of Fe(III), which could be explained based on the possible inactivation of cofactors or proteins (e.g., factor F420) by Fe(III), which are important in MP via hydrogenotrophic pathway (Van Bodegom et al., 2004). Other studies also reported the increase of lag phase duration up to 11.5 % when testing Mag, and one of the explanations proposed for the delay of methanogenesis was the requirement of higher time for the production of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), as a defence mechanism against Mag as an exogenous substance (Zhong et al., 2022). In the study of Zhong et al . (2022), the highest EPS secretion was observed with the smallest Mag particles investigated, meaning that the size of Mag interfered with the result. In this study, it was not possible to conclude if this occurred, and further investigations would be needed to explore the influence of Mag (and the other materials) towards EPS secretion by M. formicicum . Yet, the analysis performed by SEM suggested that EPS secretion by M. formicicum would be lower in the presence of carbon-based materials (Figure 3.5i, 3.5ii, 3.5iii) comparing with the control without materials (Figure 3.5v, red zone Z1). In biotic conditions without materials (Figure 3.5v, Z1), the excretion of substances by M. formicicum seemed to be abundant. The impact of materials towards EPS production also seems to vary depending the study conditions, once CM are reported to increase EPS production in some studies with Mag, pyrite or CNT (Jiao et al., 2023; Xu et al., 2019; Yan et al., 2018), and reported to decrease it in assays with CNT in pure cultures of methanogens (Salvador et al., 2017). Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 89 The production of EPS is usually connected with the cluster formation by maintaining different microorganisms adhered to each other or to abiotic surfaces (Oh et al., 2018). For instance, the contribution of M. formicicum for EPS production in anaerobic granules was previously reported as being significant (Veiga et al., 1997). The polymer matrix of granules contributes to the adhesion between different species of methanogenic archaea and syntrophs, enhancing their stability (Veiga et al., 1997). At 37 °C (temperature of incubation in the present study), as expected, M. formicicum grew as clumps, as can be observed in SEM images (Figure 3.5v). Besides, the production of EPS by M. formicicum was also found to be reduced under lower nitrogen and phosphorous conditions (Veiga et al., 1997). Thus, the presence of carbon-based materials may contribute to decrease the EPS secretion by M. formicicum cells possibly: i) by acting as a support for cells adhesion maintaining cells close to each other and then there is no need of EPS for the formation of clumps; or ii) elements like sulfur, present in the composition of materials (Table 3.2 and Table 3.3), may function as a nutritional supplement, thus affecting the EPS secretion. The second hypothesis seems less likely, since species of Methanobacterium are usually known to use ammonium, sulfide, and elemental sulfur as nitrogen and sulfur sources (Whitman et al., 2006), and this element is present in the growth medium. Particularly, in the presence of Mag, EPS seemed not be produced in high amounts (Figure 3.5iv), but it is not a precise result since the amount of cells found near Mag was very reduced to reach any conclusion. However, it seemed clear that Mag represented toxicity for cells as methanogenic activity was negatively affected. Observing the micrographs obtained during TEM analysis (Figure 3.8), differences in the thickness of cell walls, especially when cells were in contact with Mag (Figure 3.8d), seemed to be relevant. The cell envelope structure is diverse among methanogens, and the cell wall of the Methanobacteriaceae is composed of pseudomurein (Whitman et al., 2006). Pseudomurein confers shape to the rod cells. Depending on the mode of living, some methanogens were found to change their cell wall thickness (i.e., cell wall thickness was different for methanogens growing in syntrophic coculture than those growing in pure culture) (Nakamura et al., 2006). As cell wall represents an interface between the cells and the external environment, mechanisms may be activated to neutralize cell wall damage (e.g., reinforcing the cell wall integrity) and to adapt to new conditions, which may imply changes in the cell wall structure (Martínez et al., 2020). Considering the hypothesis of inhibition of cofactors and proteins by Fe(III), in hydrogenotrophs, and considering that the permeability of the cell wall is influenced by the thickness of pseudomurein (Nakamura et al., 2006), M. formicicum may have to activate mechanisms of defence in the presence of Mag, such as the increase of the cell wall thickness, as an adaptive mechanism to minimize the negative impact of Mag towards its metabolism. Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 90 Physicochemical characteristics of modified activated carbons and their effect on MP Besides the impact of particle size, concentration, adsorption capacity, and electrical conductivity of materials towards MP, the results obtained may be due to the effect of other characteristics like surface area, ORP or pHpzc(Castilho et al., 2022; Martins et al., 2018). Comparing the characterization of all materials tested by order of IMPR improvement (Table 3.9), it was not found a key property that could explain per se the improvements occurred in the presence of materials. The values of textural properties (e.g., SBET, Smeso, Vmicro) varied and, for example, neither the material with the highest value of SBET (i.e., ACb3) nor the material with the lowest value (i.e., AC_H2SO4_ HNO3) corresponded to the one that promoted the best results (i.e, Zeo). So, it was not found a tendency between textural properties and improvements on MP promoted by materials. Considering the values of pHpzc of the materials, it is possible to predict their net charge in the growth medium and therefore their interaction with cells (assuming that cells present a negative charge) (A. R. Silva et al., 2021a; Silva et al., 2020). This way, for positively charged materials an attractive interaction with cells would be expected, while for materials with a negatively charged surface a repulsive interaction would be expected. So, attractive interactions between cells and Zeo, ACb3, AC_HNO3_900, AC@2%Fe, AC_N, sand, and glass beads, and repulsive interactions with AC_HNO3_400, AC_HNO3, AC_H2SO4, AC_H2SO4_ HNO3, may occur, while the rest of materials can be considered neutral. However, both acidic and alkaline materials improved the IMPR, as for example Zeo which improved up to 15.6 times (alkaline material) and AC_HNO3_400 up to 9.9 (acidic material) the IMPR (Table 3.9). Thus, no evidence was found to support the explanation for MP improvements based on attractive interactions between cells and materials. The role of materials in providing nutrients, like N and S, for microbial growth was not considered important to explain the results here obtained as well (Table 3.9). Both N and S are considered macronutrients (Lamers et al., 2012), and they are essential nutrients for anaerobic microorganisms (Abbas et al., 2021). However, the materials with higher amounts of N (AC_HNO3 and AC_N) or S (AC_H2SO4) were not responsible for the highest improvements, since the best materials to accelerate MP presented lower amounts of these elements in their composition (e.g., AC_HNO3_900 from the group of modified AC). The functionalization with iron could either offer Fe as a micronutrient (H. Liu et al., 2021; Paritosh et al., 2020) or it could be a strategy for materials recovery after the treatment, by the application of a simple magnetic field (Pereira et al., 2017). Within trace elements, iron is one of the micronutrient that can participate in the synthesis and activation of many enzymes involved in methanogenic metabolism, thereby affecting methanogenesis (H. Liu et al., 2021; Paritosh et al., 2020). On the other hand, magnetic nanoparticles combined with carbon-based materials would allow to apply a simple, low cost, quick and Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 91 efficient way of retain and recover the materials, which can be then re-use (Pereira et al., 2017). Although the presented results did not support that the presence of Fe would be important for the methanogenic activity of M. formicicum , the same results also showed that its presence in AC@2%Fe or CNT@2%Fe did not negatively affect the MP, so it can be used as a strategy for materials’ recovery in specific applications. Silicon effect on methanogenic activity The acceleration of MP via hydrogenotrophic pathway in the presence of Zeo, glass beads and sand, was surprising. Interestingly, this group of materials even improved EMPR, which not occurred in the presence of carbon-based materials. The addition of Zeo in AD systems, or its application as a packing material column, has contributed to enhance AD performance (Cardona et al., 2021; Montalvo et al., 2012; Paritosh et al., 2020; Zheng et al., 2015). The effects are specially attributed to its capacity of immobilizing microorganisms and its ion-exchange property (attractive in ammonia stressful conditions by substituting cations like Na+, Ca2+ and Mg2+ in its structure by NH4+, reducing ion ammonium in solution which can cause microbial activity inhibition) (Cardona et al., 2021; Montalvo et al., 2012; Paritosh et al., 2020; Zheng et al., 2015). Also, similar improvements were found with either Zeo or sand towards AD processes, suggesting their contribution for biomass immobilization to explain the higher performance observed comparing with the control (Montalvo et al., 2005). In another studies, the use of glass beads, or Zeo (as non-CM) did not improve methanogenesis (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018; König et al., 2022). These results show that conductivity of the material is not a requisite for improving the methanogenic activity of M. formicicum , as Zeo presented a lower conductivity than carbon-based materials, and sand and glass beads are considered non-CM (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018). Giving the composition of each material (e.g., Zeo, sand, glass beads, AC), the main element found in common to all of them was Si. The most common component of Zeo, sand and glass, is silicon dioxide (SiO2), also known as silica (Busca, 2014; Montalvo et al., 2005). During SEM-EDS analyses of the CM (Table 3.2), the presence of Si was also detected in low amounts in AC, CNT, CNT@2%Fe and Mag, being the highest percentage detected in AC samples. Silicon is an element that is not known as being essential for the activity of methanogens, like M. formicicum . The effect of silicon has been mainly studied in the growth of plants (Bist et al., 2020; Fauteux et al., 2005; Pavlovic et al., 2021), growth of fungi (Das and Das, 2010; Wainwright et al., 1997), and in the medical area (Jurkić et al., 2013). It was also reported that some zeolites can have the ortho-silicic acid-releasing property, which means these materials can release small but significant amounts of ortho-silicic acid (H4SiO4), which is the bioavailable form of silicon for microorganisms, plants, animals and humans (Jurkić et al., 2013). Thus, the availability of Si in the Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 92 growth medium may be a consequence of Si being released from Zeo or the other materials, and it can be the factor behind the enhancement of the M. formicicum metabolism. The impact of Zeo enhancing the growth of microorganisms like Methanobacterium was reported elsewhere (Cardona et al., 2021). Besides, the biogeochemistry of peatlands was also found to be influenced by Si availability (Reithmaier et al., 2017). The availability of Si was found to accelerate organic matter decomposition, increasing methane concentrations in these ecosystems, which confirmed the relevance of Si for the carbon cycle (Reithmaier et al., 2017). In the present study, preliminary assays showed the stimulatory effect of Si in MP by M. formicicum , using silicic acid (H2SiO3) in aqueous solution, which would result in the formation of H4SiO4 (Jurkić et al., 2013). However, these water soluble forms will be in reversible equilibrium reactions and be stable only in highly diluted aqueous solutions, or it can ended in its precipitation as hydrated silica (Jurkić et al., 2013). This way, 1 mg·L-1 was the concentration applied as the lowest concentration found as possible to be handle in laboratory conditions. The results suggested that Si can stimulate M. formicicum metabolism, but the exact biological roles of silicon towards methanogenic activity are unknown and this topic deserves to be further explored. Another strategy could be the incorporation of different amounts of Si on the materials, and to test its impact towards the microbial activity. Changes on growth medium parameters in the presence of (nano)materials In this study, it was not possible to observe a relation between the alterations on the growth medium parameters (like pH, ORP, and conductivity) in the presence of (nano)materials with the improvements on methanogenic activity. Regarding conductivity values of the growth medium, no big differences were detected among the different conditions. In the case of pH, the values varied from 7.0 to 7.3 at the start of incubations for all conditions, which is a range within the optimal pH for M. formicicum (between 6.6 and 7.8) (Whitman et al., 2006), and the pH increased up to 8.4 at the end of incubations. The increase of the final value of pH to around 8 could be related with the loss of buffer capacity in maintaining the pH at approximately 7, once bicarbonate buffer needs to be in equilibrium with CO2 in the gas phase, but this CO2 was consumed during MP. Nevertheless, the main change promoted by materials was observed for the ORP values of the growth medium. The main differences were in the presence of carbon-based materials that decreased the ORP values, while iron-based materials contributed to increase them. Methanogenesis is favoured at lower ORP values (between −200 mV to −400 mV), so it could be a possible explanation for MP improving in the presence of carbon-based materials (Salvador et al., 2017). Nonetheless, the results of this study did not fully support this explanation, once materials like Zeo did Chapter 3 | The influence of conductive and non-conductive materials on the metabolism of the hydrogenotroph Methanobacterium formicicum 93 not contribute as much as carbon-based materials to decrease ORP values and yet it was the best material to improve MP from all the materials tested. The increase of ORP values in the presence of iron-based materials has also been reported in other studies, and some attributed this to the inhibitory effects observed against methanogenesis once methanogens are sensitive to high ORP (Fu et al., 2019; Kato et al., 2012; Z. Wang et al., 2022; Wu et al., 2020). Yet, the inhibitory effect observed in these experiments did not seem to be caused by the increase of ORP by Mag, once the highest value reached was approximately -295 mV, which still is in the optimal range for methanogenesis. So, the results suggested that the improvements or inhibition effects were not related with changes in the growth medium parameters. 3.5. CONCLUSIONS Several materials with different physicochemical properties were tested and all of them stimulated the methanogenic activity of M. formicicum , only with exception of Mag and AC_HNO3_ H2SO4. The results do not show a direct influence of physicochemical properties of materials such as electrical conductivity, specific surface area, mesopores surface areas, micropores volumes, and pHpzc on the improvements towards methanogenic activity. No evidence for the adsorption of gaseous substrate to the surface of materials facilitating the substrate access to microorganisms or even the extra nutrient supplementation provided by materials in their composition (with Fe, N or S) was found. The composition of all materials tested, i.e., AC, CNT, Mag, Zeo, sand and glass beads, had in common the element silicon. When silicic acid was supplemented, the results showed a stimulatory response by decreasing lag phases and the increasing MPR, which are similar effects as the ones observed in the presence of materials. The mechanisms behind the improvement of methanogenic activity of M. formicicum by materials or Si alone are still unknown. These results suggest that they can be related with the physicochemical characteristics of the materials (i.e., presence of silicon in their composition, but also possibly other properties). Overall, having methanogenesis an important role in bioenergy production, the application of (nano)materials can be the key to boost the impact of AD process during the energetic transition. More studies are needed to evaluate the impact of sand and glass beads during the conversion of waste to methane, but if the effects were like the ones obtained during the conversion of H2/CO2 to methane, then they could be an alternative to replace the use of CM, as sand and glass beads are low-cost materials and with lower impact for natural environments than CM. 94 CHAPTER 4 4. METHANE PRODUCTION RATE BY PURE CULTURES OF METHANOGENS AND BY SYNTROPHIC COCULTURES IS REGULATED BY ACTIVATED CARBON, MAGNETITE AND ONE TYPE OF A ZEOLITE Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 95 ABSTRACT Methane production rate (MPR) is enhanced by of conductive materials (CM), like activated carbon (AC), or magnetite (Mag), but the causes still require investigation. A screening of diverse CM (AC, Mag), and one zeolite (Zeo) (at 0.5 g·L-1) on the activity of four pure cultures of methanogens, and two syntrophic cocultures, is assessed and discussed taking into consideration the characteristics of the growth media (pH, redox potential (ORP), and conductivity) in the presence of the materials (AC, Mag, Zeo). The effect of materials on the different cultures was dissimilar. The hydrogenotrophic activity of Methanobacterium formicicum was the most affected, increasing significantly with AC and Zeo (MPR up to 20 times faster) and decreasing drastically with Mag (lag phases preceding methane production (MP) increased almost 3 times). Similarly, oleate degradation by the coculture of Syntrophomonas zehnderi with M. formicicum was also improved by AC, and severely inhibited by Mag. The effect of materials on the other microorganisms was not so impressive, although lag phases were generally reduced. The materials did not cause changes in the pH and conductivity of the growth medium, but altered the ORP, although there was no correlation between ORP variations and the impact on MP. The importance of physicochemical characteristics of the materials on MP was discussed. These results showed clearly that the MP by several species of methanogens is greatly improved by some materials, suggesting that their effect on complex microbial communities can be totally, or at least partially, attributed to this stimulatory effect towards methanogenic activity. Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 96 4.1. INTRODUCTION The addition of conductive materials (CM) has been shown to improve methane production (MP) from several types of wastes (Martins et al., 2018), and it is also known that microbial interactions, including interspecies electron transfer (IET) (Rotaru et al., 2021), and the activity of pure cultures of methanogens are also affected (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; Salvador et al., 2017; H. Wang et al., 2020; Xia et al., 2019; Xiao et al., 2020; W. Zhang et al., 2018; Zheng et al., 2020). Nevertheless, different methanogens showed different responses to CM, particularly to those that are referenced in the literature as potential candidates to improve anaerobic digestion (AD), such as magnetite (Mag) and activated carbon (AC) (He et al., 2021; Lee et al., 2020; Peng et al., 2018; Jingxin Zhang et al., 2020; Zhao et al., 2017a). For example, Mag (an iron based-CM) accelerated the acetoclastic activity of Methanosarcina barkeri and Methanosarcina mazei (Fu et al., 2019; H. Wang et al., 2020), but inhibited the activity of Methanocella conradii (HZ254T) (Xia et al., 2019), and had no effect towards the hydrogenotrophic activity of Methanococcus maripaludis and M. conradii (DSM 24694) (Fu et al., 2018) nor on the activity of Syntrophomonas erecta subsp. sporosyntropha (Fu et al., 2018). Furthermore, granular AC inhibited the growth of Methanobacterium sp. strain YSL (Zheng et al., 2020). In this work, the effect of different types of materials on the activity of pure cultures of methanogens and syntrophic cocultures commonly found in anaerobic digesters, were investigated, namely AC, Mag and one type of a zeolite (Zeo), with distinct physicochemical characteristics, including different conductivities. 4.2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 4.2.1. Pure cultures and syntrophic cocultures Two hydrogenotrophic methanogens ( Methanobacterium formicicum (DSM 1535T), Methanospirillum hungatei (DSMZ 864T)), two acetoclastic methanogens ( Methanothrix harundinacea (DSM 17206T) and Methanosarcina barkeri (DSM 800T)), and two syntrophic cocultures ( Syntrophomonas zehnderi (DSM 1780T) with M. formicicum (DSM 1535T), and Syntrophomonas wolfei (DSM 102351T) with M. hungatei (DSMZ 864T)), were purchased from DSMZ (Braunschweig, Germany) and maintained in our laboratory. These cultures were incubated with AC, Mag and Zeo, at 0.5 g∙L-1. The exception was for the coculture of S. zehnderi with M. formicicum , where 0.1 g∙L-1 AC was tested instead of 0.5 g∙L-1 (the concentration of 0.1 g∙L-1 was chosen based on preliminary assays in which this concentration increased the activity of M. formicicum ), and the effect of Zeo on this coculture was not tested. The incubations were carried out in 120 mL serum bottles (working volume of 50 mL), containing the growth medium and prepared as Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 103 AC (Table A. 1, Appendix), and the acetate consumption was slightly faster in AC condition as well (Figure A. 4a, Appendix). However, these small improvements did not greatly impact the overall efficiency of MP, since the total time of incubation was similar for all conditions (Table A. 1, Appendix). So, although there were slight differences between incubations with and without materials, these differences were not significative (Figure 4.1c, 4.1f). On the other hand, the acetoclastic M. harundinacea was affected by all materials. Zeo and AC increased its methanogenic activity, with total acetate conversion to methane in 23 d, contrasting with the 25 d necessary for the culture growing without materials (Figure 4.1g; Table A. 1, Appendix). Mag affected the activity of M. harundinacea negatively, by increasing the lag phase, but it did not affect the total time necessary to convert acetate to methane, when compared to the control assay (Figure 4.1g). The consumption of acetate over time is shown in Figure A. 4b (Appendix). Zeo affected slightly the microorganisms (Figure 4.1b, 4.1c, 4.1e, 4.1f), with exception of M. formicicum, which was significantly stimulated by Zeo ( p < 0.05 level). The presence of Zeo caused a reduction of the lag phase of approximately 67 % (from 4.5 to 1.5 d, Figure 4.1a; Table A. 1, Appendix), and the IMPR increased 19.6 times (Table 4.1). No differences on hydrogen, acetate and butyrate quantification were detected among abiotic assays performed with and without materials, suggesting that no hydrogen, acetate or butyrate adsorption occurred on the surface of materials (Figure 3.3, Chapter 3; Figure A. 5, Figure A. 6, Appendix). Furthermore, no stimulatory effect was observed when the materials were added to pre-grown cultures (Figure 4.3). Figure 4.3. Cumulative MP in pre-grown pure cultures of a) M. formicicum and b) M. hungatei . The materials were only added after the cultures reached the exponential phase followed by a second supplementation with substrate (H2/CO2). The results are the mean and standard deviation of triplicate assays. Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 104 4.3.2. Effect of materials on ORP, pH and conductivity of the growth medium The presence of materials in the growth medium affected mainly the values of ORP, either in biotic (Table A. 2, Appendix) or abiotic assays (Table 3.4, Chapter 3; Table A. 3, Table A. 4, Table A. 5, Appendix). In general, the presence of AC contributed to decrease the ORP values of the growth medium of pure cultures (e.g., in M. formicicum assays, ORP decreased from (-296 ± 24) mV in the control to (-365 ± 9) mV at the beginning of the incubations) and syntrophic cocultures incubations (e.g., in assays with syntrophic coculture S. wolfei with M. hungatei , ORP changed from (-308 ± 7) mV in the control to (-338 ± 6) mV). On the other hand, Mag had the opposite effect by increasing ORP values (e.g., in syntrophic coculture S. zehnderi with M. formicicum assays, ORP increased from (-264 ± 14) mV in the control to (-176 ± 20) mV) (Table A. 2, Appendix). Similarly to AC, Zeo also decreased the ORP values of the growth medium (e.g., in M. formicicum assays, ORP decreased from (-296 ± 24) mV in the control to (-324 ± 4) mV at the beginning of the incubations; Table A. 2, Appendix), but generally less than AC. The pH values (between 7.0 and 7.3 at the beginning of all incubations) or conductivity values (around 4.0 mS·cm-1 for syntrophic coculture incubations of S. zehnderi with M. formicicum , and between 6 mS·cm-1 and 8 mS·cm- 1 for the other incubations, at the beginning of the assays) were not considerably affected by the presence of materials (Table A. 2, Appendix). The same trend was observed in the results of abiotic incubations with H2/CO2 (Table 3.4 in Chapter 3), acetate (Table A. 3, Appendix), butyrate (Table A. 4, Appendix), and oleate (Table A. 5, Appendix). In the presence of AC, ORP values were generally lower than the values obtained in abiotic assays without materials. These results were more evident in abiotic assays with AC and H2/CO2 (e.g., (-263 ± 11) mV in abiotic assay vs (-390 ± 10) mV with 5 g·L-1 of AC) (Table 3.4 in Chapter 3), or butyrate (e.g., (-343 ± 1) mV in abiotic assay vs (-378 ± 4) mV with 0.5 g·L-1 of AC) (Table A. 4, Appendix), mostly at the middle of incubation time. In addition, variations in the values of this parameter can also be observed over incubation time, as they were different between the beginning and the end of the assays (e.g., ORP values of abiotic assays with H2/CO2 were (-179 ± 1) mV at the beginning of incubation, (-263 ± 11) mV in the middle, and (-351 ± 0) mV at the end, Table 3.4 in Chapter 3). On the other hand, the presence of Mag increased the ORP values over the incubation time, being ORP values higher than the ones observed in the abiotic assay without materials (e.g., (-263 ± 11) mV in the abiotic assay vs (-210 ± 33) mV with 5 g·L-1 of Mag in the middle of time of the assay with H2/CO2, Table 3.4 in Chapter 3). Another observation was that the concentration of material also affected the ORP values. For instance, higher concentrations of AC contributed to decrease the ORP values in abiotic assays with H2/CO2 (for instance, (-263 ± 11) mV in abiotic assay vs (-305 ± 1) mV with 0.1 g·L-1 of AC vs (-390 ± 10) mV with 5 g·L-1 of Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 105 AC, in the middle of the assay), and higher concentrations of Mag increased the ORP values (for instance, (-263 ± 11) mV in abiotic assay vs (-308 ± 2) mV with 0.1 g·L-1 of Mag vs (-210 ± 33) mV with 5 g·L-1 of Mag, in the middle of the assay) (Table 3.4 in Chapter 3). In the case of abiotic assays with Zeo, in general, only a slight decrease of ORP values occurred, for instance, from (-285 ± 5) mV (abiotic assay) to (-291 ± 4) mV (with Zeo), at the beginning of incubations with H2/CO2 (Table 3.4 in Chapter 3). For the rest of the parameters (pH and conductivity), only slightly changes occurred among conditions, and these parameters were rather stable around pH 7.2 and 7.4, and conductivity around 4 mS·cm-1 for the abiotic assays with butyrate and oleate, and between 6 mS·cm-1 and 8 mS·cm-1 for the abiotic assays with H2/CO2, acetate, and butyrate (with and without Zeo). 4.4. DISCUSSION Motivated by the fact that some CM affect the activity of microbial communities and methanogenic microorganisms, this study aimed to understand how materials with different characteristics, and specifically different conductivities, affect a number of microorganisms typically found in anaerobic digesters and in anaerobic natural environments. The conductivity of the materials is usually linked to their function in serving as mediators for IET (Kato et al., 2012; Mostafa et al., 2020; Song et al., 2019; Wu et al., 2020; W. Zhang et al., 2018), but IET does not occur in pure cultures, so this cannot be the main explanation for the improvement of activity in all situations. In addition, besides the possible higher conductivity of AC in comparison with Zeo, the results of this study showed that Zeo can be even better than AC on accelerating MP, as it was observed for the assays of M. formicicum (Figure 4.1a). This is the first study showing the potential of Zeo to directly stimulate pure cultures of methanogens and syntrophic cocultures. However, previous studies showed that zeolites did not impact the biogas production of complex methanogenic communities (König et al., 2022). Apart from these studies, the potential of Zeo to improve AD processes has been explored mainly as an adsorbent for ammonium and heavy metals removal due to its unique property of ion exchange capacity, or used to adsorb organic micro pollutants (Cardona et al., 2021; Milán et al., 2010; Szerement et al., 2021). In other studies, great improvements towards MP with materials with different conductivities (e.g., carbon cloth vs GAC (Wu et al., 2020); Mag vs hematite (J. H. Park et al., 2018)) were also observed. For instance, the effect of Mag (0.038 mS·cm-1) and GAC (0.168 mS·cm-1) on microbial activity showed that Mag promoted a better methanogenic performance than GAC even with a lower conductivity value (Lee et al., 2020). In addition, biochars with similar values of conductivities (but originated from different feedstocks) did not have the same impact Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 106 on MPR by enrichment cultures of methanogenic microbial communities (Yuan et al., 2018). Thus, there is no correlation between conductivity and enhancement of microbial activity. Other characteristics of the materials may also contribute to influence the microbial activity, such as the particle size, the adsorption capacity of the material, the pHpzc values, the chemical composition, and the modifications that materials can exert in the growth medium, for instance by altering the ORP. Larger materials like AC (Bueno-López et al., 2020) and Zeo (Emami Moghaddam et al., 2018; Montalvo et al., 2020, 2012; Paritosh et al., 2020) may provide a support for cells growth and a closer interaction between different microorganisms (Paritosh et al., 2020; Wu et al., 2020). The attachment of M. formicicum and S. zehnderi onto AC surface was observed by SEM analysis highlighting the importance of AC as a support material (Figure 3.5i in Chapter 3, Figure 4.2b). The adsorption capacity of materials can also be important since it might bring microorganisms closer to their substrates. In the assays with the syntrophic coculture S. zehnderi and M. formicicum (Figure 4.1d), this phenomenon could have been especially relevant, with oleate becoming more bioavailable for the bacteria. Indeed, our results showed that oleate adsorption occurred during abiotic experiments (Figure A. 3a, Appendix), but the same was not observed for the other substrates (Figure 3.3, Chapter 3; Figure A. 5, Figure A. 6, Appendix). The pHpzc values may also be important for the observations, since materials with pHpzc values higher than the pH of the medium growth, which is the case of Zeo used in this study, tend to be positively charged (A. R. Silva et al., 2021a) and therefore attract the microbial cells (which are negatively charged (Lee et al., 2020; A. R. Silva et al., 2021a)). On the contrary, Mag had a pHpzc lower than the pH of the growth medium, so cell repulsion is expected. Indeed, SEM images showed microbial cells growing on AC (neutral character or slightly positive charged in growth medium), but not on the Mag particles (Figure 3.5iv). Different elements present in the composition of different materials (Table 3.2 and Table 3.3, Chapter 3) might also influence the microbial activities, since some of them are important nutrients for the microorganisms. However, the growth medium used in our experiments was developed to guarantee the nutritional requirements and the important cofactors for methanogenic cultures. Nevertheless, one cannot rule out that extra elements provided by the materials (e.g., iron (Fe), sulfur (S), nitrogen (N), silicon (Si)) may be beneficial for cell growth (Jurkić et al., 2013; Lamers et al., 2012; Paritosh et al., 2020), however, this was not investigated in this work. On the other hand, although Fe could be used as a micronutrient by methanogens (Xiao et al., 2020), it is also known that Fe(III) (present in the composition of Mag (H. Wang et al., 2020)) can inhibit the hydrogenotrophic activity (Van Bodegom et al., 2004), as it was also observed in the assays with M. formicicum (Figure 4.1a). Additionally, the ORP of the growth medium is one of the physicochemical characteristics that have been shown to change in the presence of materials. Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 107 This was verified before by Salvador et al . (2017) with CNT (which caused a decrease on the values of ORP of the growth medium, favoring the methanogenic activity), and also in this work. It was verified that the ORP decreased with AC (which generally increased the methanogenic activity) but increased with Mag (which improved the activity of some cultures and inhibited others), and almost did not change with Zeo (which caused an increase of around 20 times on the activity of M. formicicum , Table 4.1) (Figure 4.1; Table A. 2, Appendix). Thus, ORP variations per se cannot explain the improvement of the microbial activity. It seems clear that the microbial activity is not only influenced by the physicochemical properties of materials but is also dependent on the identity of the microorganisms. In this and in other studies, it is evident that the effect of materials is different depending on the microbial species. For instance, M. formicicum and M. hungatei were stimulated by AC and CNT (Salvador et al., 2017), but other hydrogenotrophic microorganisms were inhibited by CNT (e.g., M. maripaludis (W. Zhang et al., 2018)). The differences are also evident when these methanogens are cultivated in syntrophic cocultures. For instance, CNT stimulated the metabolism of S. wolfei with M. maripaludis , but the syntrophic coculture S. wolfei with M. hungatei was found to be only slightly stimulated by CNT (Salvador et al., 2017) and barely affected by AC (Figure 4.1e, Table 4.1), showing that depending on the syntrophic partner and type of material, the rate of butyrate conversion by cocultures with S. wolfei is different. On the other hand, AC stimulated the activity of the syntrophic coculture S. zehnderi with M. formicicum , as oleate degradation could be enhanced 12 times (Table 4.1) and lag phase was reduced from 18 d to 10 d (Figure 4.1d; Table A. 1, Appendix) in the presence of the material. These findings are extremely relevant from an applied point of view since anaerobic degradation of LCFA is a slow process that relies on the activity of syntrophic bacteria and hydrogenotrophs, such as S. zehnderi and M. formicicum . The fact that the coculture activity is significantly ( p < 0.05 level) enhanced suggests that application of AC in AD is promising to boost MPR from LCFA especially for starting up phases of operation. By the analysis of the results obtained in this and previous studies (Salvador et al., 2017; W. Zhang et al., 2018), it seems that generally, the materials have greater impact in slow growing cultures, for instance M. formicicum (Figure 4.1a; Table A. 1, Appendix) when compared to the other methanogens (Figure 4.1b and 4.1c in the present study, and Figure 7 in ref. (W. Zhang et al., 2018)) which grow faster. The same trend is verified with S. zehnderi which grows much slower in oleate than, for example, S. wolfei in butyrate (Figure 4.1d and 4.1e; Table A. 1, Appendix; Figure 1d in ref. (Salvador et al., 2017); Figure 6 in ref. (W. Zhang et al., 2018)). In addition, no improvement on methane production could be detected when the materials were added to pre-grown cultures (Figure 4.3). Also, most active inocula (as was the Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 108 case of cultures of M. hungatei and M. barkeri , as can be seen by the high activity of the cultures when growing without material (Figure 4.1b and 4.1c)), are generally less affected by the presence of materials. These observations indicate that the major impact of the materials is the lag phase reduction, i.e., accelerating the start-up of biodegradation and MP, which is particularly evident in less active slow growing microbial communities. On the other hand, the enhancement of microbial activity in the presence of CM is usually attributed to the change in IET. In our study, we used S. wolfei and S. zehnderi , that are known to participate in interspecies hydrogen transfer (IHT), and are not reported to be capable of direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) (Jessica R. Sieber et al., 2010; Sousa et al., 2007), so the hypothesis that the materials mediate IET doesn’t seem plausible. The bacterium S. wolfei is a syntrophic bacteria which apparently lacks the genomic machinery required for extracellular electron transfer (Li et al., 2015). Indeed, traditional syntrophic fatty-acid degrading bacteria are probably not capable of DIET because they lack the genes for outer membrane c -type cytochromes and for pil A , which are reported as necessary for DIET (Sieber et al., 2014; Summers et al., 2010). Yet, the application of CM in AD has led to the enrichment of species assigned to Syntrophomonas and for that reason, the ability of this genus to transfer electrons via CM has been speculated (W. Zhang et al., 2018; Zhao et al., 2018). Many genera, including Syntrophomonas, contain genes coding for e-pili (Zhao et al., 2020), which means that the possibility of DIET by these microorganisms cannot be completely excluded. However, homologues for the G. sulfurreducens e-pili gene (Jessica R. Sieber et al., 2010), or for ctype cytochromes were not found in the genome of S. wolfei (by searching the UniProt database (data not shown)). Nevertheless, there is still much to discover about the genetic machinery and the microorganisms that might be able of donating and accepting electrons via DIET or via mediation with CM. For instance, the typical syntrophic bacterium Syntrophus aciditrophicus , known to perform IHT and interspecies formate transfer (IFT), was recently found to produce e-pili and to grow via DIET (Walker et al., 2020). This species was previously thought as unlikely to participate in DIET because it lacked a gene homologous to the pilin monomer that assembles e-pili in Geobacter (Walker et al., 2020). Thus, it cannot be ruled out that other typical syntrophic fatty-acids degrading bacteria, known to grow via IHT/IFT, might have the capacity to exchange electrons directly with other species with or without the mediation of CM (Walker et al., 2020; Yin et al., 2020; Zhao et al., 2020). Different electrical contacts, as well as the specific proteins that function as electrical contacts for DIET, have evolved and are different for different species (Zhao et al., 2020). Recognizing this, it is possible that the currently available metabolic model for Geobacter spp. may not be the same for other microbes that may be able to participate in DIET (Zhao et al., 2020). On the other Chapter 4 | Methane production rate by pure cultures of methanogens and by syntrophic cocultures is regulated by activated carbon, magnetite and one type of a zeolite 109 hand, studies with gene deletions showed that mutant strains lacking e-pili or key outer-surface c -type cytochromes were inhibited and incapable of DIET, but CM could mediate the extracellular electron transfer (Zhao et al., 2020). So, it could be also hypothesized that bacteria and methanogens that usually performed IHT/IFT, in the presence of CM could also use the materials to transfer electrons as a simple way of establishing the electrical connection (Zhao et al., 2020). Yet, it does not explain the impact of materials on the activity of pure cultures like hydrogenotrophs. Hydrogenotrophic methanogens are not known to participate in DIET, with the exception of Methanobacterium sp. strain YSL that was reported as being able to participate in DIET with G. metallireducens and in IET via GAC, but only growing in formate (Zheng et al., 2020). It was mentioned that strains of Methanobacterium growing with hydrogen cannot grow via DIET in coculture with G. metallireducens because they may have lost the features needed for DIET with the continuous transfers over the years (Zheng et al., 2020). Zheng et al . (2020) reinforced the idea that GAC would not be expected to improve IHT (Zheng et al., 2020), but other studies have reported the improvement of hydrogenotrophic activity in the presence of CNT (Salvador et al., 2017). In this work, the M. formicicum strain DSM1535 has been continuously transferred with hydrogen as electron donor and the results clearly show that its hydrogenotrophic activity was significantly stimulated both with AC and Zeo. But the reason behind this enhancement remains unclear. 4.5. CONCLUSIONS In summary, the results obtained in our study highlight the different impacts of distinct materials, like AC, Zeo, and Mag, on different methanogens and syntrophic cocultures. The research developed suggests that different materials may improve or inhibit methanogenic activity, which seemed to be dependent on the microbial species, rather than on the type of metabolism, i.e., acetoclastic or hydrogenotrophic. In addition, this work clearly showed that the activity of several species of methanogens, catalyzing the last step of AD, can be largely improved in the presence of materials. The presence of materials mainly changed the values of ORP of the growth medium, but no correlation between ORP variations and the impact on MP was observed. The physicochemical properties of materials may have a role on their effect towards MP, but further research is still necessary to clarify which characteristics of materials are more important to affect the microbial activity, and to reveal the mechanisms behind the enhancement of MP in the presence of different materials. 110 CHAPTER 5 5. THE ACTIVITY OF MICROBIAL COMMUNITIES DICTATES THE EFFECT OF ACTIVATED CARBON, MAGNETITE, AND ZEOLITE, ON METHANE PRODUCTION Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 111 ABSTRACT Conductive materials (CM) affect the efficiency of methanogenic processes by accelerating methane production (MP). Factors such as the conductivity of the materials, the presence of electroactive microorganisms that might exchange electrons directly via CM, the role as a support material for microbial growth, among others, have been pointed out as possible explanations for MP improvement. In this work, we incubated anaerobic communities with different microbial activities, in batch and in continuous bioreactors, treating butyrate and other volatile fatty acids, and ethanol. Incubations were performed with and without activated carbon (AC), magnetite (Mag), and zeolite (Zeo), which present different physicochemical characteristics. The results obtained showed that the application of those materials to active microbial communities did not improve MP, but highly affected the performance of MP by less active cultures. For example, the production of methane by a slow growing culture was enhanced by AC, once the presence of this material reduced the lag phase preceding MP in approximately 40 % when comparing with the slow growing culture without materials, allowing methane to be produced at an early stage of incubation. Extensive revision of the literature supports this conclusion. Based on this, from an applied point of view, the cost benefit analysis of applying materials should take into consideration the activity of sludge used in the anaerobic treatment. Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 112 5.1. INTRODUCTION There are several studies reporting the effect of granular activated carbon (GAC), carbon nanotubes, biochar, magnetite (Mag), or carbon cloth on MP, either from complex waste (e.g., food waste) or from simpler substrates (such as acetate and H2/CO2) (Martins et al., 2018). This is a research topic that has been extensively studied and is very well reviewed (Castilho et al., 2022; Chen et al., 2022; H. Liu et al., 2021; M. Liu et al., 2021; Martins et al., 2018; Roopnarain et al., 2021). The main observations are that conductive materials (CM) accelerate waste conversion to methane, although its effect is not always the same. In the majority of the studies, the impact relies in the decrease of lag phases preceding methane production (MP), in others CM affect mostly the methane production rates (MPR), or the methane/biogas yields (Chen et al., 2022). For example, the presence of GAC allowed the degradation of dog food by anaerobic sludge with a lag phase of approximately 4 d, while in the condition without GAC no significant MP occurred during the time of incubation (170 d), in batch conditions (Dang et al., 2017). In another study, the presence of GAC barely affected the lag phase duration, but for example, the MPR increased up to 1.5 times, also in batch conditions, improving the sludge decomposition (Yang et al., 2017). In semi-continuous bioreactors the addition of GAC increased the methane yield by 130 % (Song et al., 2019), and in batch reactors approximately by 30 % (J.-H. Park et al., 2018). In addition, the substrate concentration seemed to influence the GAC effect. For example, depending on propionate, butyrate and acetate concentrations, GAC could either increase significantly the MPR (up to 11 times) or having no impact at all (Xu et al., 2018). Another factor that might influence the effect of CM on anaerobic digestion (AD) process is the microbial communities’ composition and their methanogenic activities. For instance, no positive impact of materials, like Mag or zeolite (Zeo), was found when an high active inoculum was used during anaerobic conversions to methane (Fu et al., 2019, 2018; Li et al., 2022; Milán et al., 2001; Xu et al., 2018). On the other hand, lag phases preceding MP were significantly reduced when using less active inocula, up to 97.6 % (Amelia-Elena et al., 2018; Dang et al., 2017; Lee et al., 2020; J.-H. Park et al., 2018; Ryue et al., 2019; Tan et al., 2021; Tan and Lens, 2021; Xu et al., 2018). For example, the presence of Mag decrease the lag phase from 72 d (in the control) to 27 d, reducing the time of incubation needed for butyrate degradation by a lake sediment from 120 d (in the control) to 60 d (in the presence of Mag) (Zhang and Lu, 2016). These results suggest that not only the CM, and the substrate, dictate the results obtained, but also the microbial community. To which extent the activity of microbial communities influences the effects of CM on waste conversion to methane has not yet been investigated. Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 119 bioreactor was modified by adding a nylon membrane (pore size ≥ 125 µm) fixed in an acrylic circle (with similar internal diameter of the reactor), which was attached to the lid of reactor, in order to keep the GAC inside the reactor and avoid losses by washout. A schematic representation of the EGSB experimental set-up is shown in Figure 5.2a, and real photographs of the bioreactor, and of the nylon membrane, in Figure 5.2b. As the membrane was moveable/adjustable, it was possible to place the membrane below the liquid recycle’s exit port, to keep GAC inside the bioreactor and in contact with anaerobic sludge. The bioreactor was inoculated with an anaerobic granular sludge (15 g∙L-1 in VS) collected from an anaerobic digester treating wastewater from a cellulose industry. The VS were determined in the beginning (0.108 g∙g-1, w/w) and at the end of the experiment according to the Standard Methods (“APHA/AWWA/WEF,” 1998). The SMA in acetate and hydrogen was determined at the beginning of the experiment by using the procedures described elsewhere (Alves et al., 2001; Colleran et al., 1992). Table 5.2 contains information about the sludge used to inoculate the bioreactor. Before the inoculation of the reactor, the anaerobic granular sludge was previously acclimatized with 30 mmol∙L-1 of ethanol (Ethanol, absolute, 99.8 % v/v, Fisher Chemical, Fisher Scientific, UK) in sodium bicarbonate buffered medium containing resazurine (0.001g∙L-1), with an atmosphere of N2/CO2 (80:20 % v/v, (1.1 × 105) Pa). After the acclimatization, the medium was drained, and the sludge was used to inoculate the bioreactor. The feed composition was a mixture of acetate, propionate, butyrate and ethanol. Details on the feeding composition and preparation are given in the feed preparation subsection. The oxygen inside of the bioreactor was removed by flushing it with N2. The bioreactor was maintained in batch mode overnight and then it was operated in continuous mode for 37 d. A gas counter was set at the top of the reactor to count the volume of biogas produced. Two peristaltic pumps were used, i.e., one for feeding and another for liquid recirculation (promoting the mixing and expansion of the sludge bed inside the bioreactor). The flow rate of feeding was approximately 0.45 mL·min-1 (corresponding to approximately 6 h of hydraulic retention time (HRT)) and the recycle around 69 mL·min-1. The operation was performed at mesophilic temperatures ((37 ± 1) °C). Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 120 Figure 5.2. Schematic representation of the experimental set-up (a) and real photographs (b) of continuous bioreactor experiments. 5.2.5.1. Feed preparation The synthetic feed consisted in a mixture of VFA, namely acetate (acetic acid sodium salt, anhydrous, ≥ 99.0 %, Sigma-Aldrich, USA), propionate (propionic acid sodium salt, ≥ 99.0 %, Fluka, Sigma-Aldrich, USA) and butyrate, and ethanol. Initially, the reactor was fed with 5 g·L-1 chemical oxygen demand (COD) of VFA and ethanol at 1:10:10:10 COD ratio of acetate, propionate, butyrate and ethanol, respectively. It was supplemented with macronutrients (0.6 mL per g of COD fed) and micronutrients (1 mL·L-1) as described elsewhere (Alves et al., 2001). Stock solutions of VFA and ethanol were sterilized by autoclaving (at 120 °C, for 20 min) and added under aseptic conditions to a bottle previously autoclaved containing distilled water, and the macronutrients and micronutrients. The feed was maintained with agitation during all time of operation. The feed bottle contained a gas bag filled with N2 gas (to avoid oxygen diffusion inside the bioreactor, Figure 5.2a). As the pHin varied between 6.7 and 6.4, and pHout oscillated between 7.8 and 8.5 during all time of operation, sodium bicarbonate was not added. Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 121 5.2.5.2. Operation mode The operation of the bioreactor was divided in four different periods. Until day 15 of the operation (Period I), the bioreactor was fed with 5 g·L-1 in COD, and without GAC; during Period II, between days 15 and 23, the bioreactor was operated with 0.5 g·L-1 GAC which was added at the end of Period I, and the COD fed was maintained; in Period III, between days 23 and 31, GAC was maintained and the COD was increased to 10 g·L-1; in Period IV (days between 31 and 37) additional 0.5 g·L-1 GAC was added, resulting in a final concentration of 1 g·L-1 GAC. In this experiment, GAC (Norit ROX 0.8 granular activated carbon) was used in pellets (particle size ≥ 500 µm) to minimize the losses by washout. During the last two days of each period (before changing the operational conditions), the performance of the reactor was evaluated by taking liquid samples (3 samples per day) of the in and out flows (to measure pH, COD, and VFA and ethanol concentrations) and gas samples (to determine the content of CH4 in the biogas produced). The reactor feed was prepared in a daily base during the Periods I and II, and at each 2 days during Periods III and IV, always under sterile conditions. 5.2.6. Analytical methods To follow MP during batch incubations, gas samples (0.5 mL) were taken from the headspace of the bottles with a Pressure-Lock syringe (SGE Syringe, Trajan Scientific Australia Pty Ltd) (in aseptic conditions) and analysed in a gas chromatograph GC-FID Chrompack 9000 (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan). The column was a Carbowax 20 M (2 m × 2 mm, 80−120 mesh) and the method conditions were the same described elsewhere (Salvador et al., 2019). In bioreactor experiments, a Ritter MilliGascounter (Dr.-Ing. Ritter Apparatebau GmbH, Bochum, Germany) was used to measure the biogas production. The percentage of CH4 in the biogas was determined in a GC BRUKER SCION 456 (Billerica, MA) with the method conditions described elsewhere (Salvador et al., 2019). Gas samples (0.5 mL) were taken using a graduated gas tight syringe (1750SL, HAMILTON® GASTIGHT® syringe, Reno, Nevada, USA) and analysed in triplicate. Samples for VFA and ethanol analyses were collected, centrifuged (15 min, 20 000 g), filtered through 0.22 µm syringe filters and frozen until the moment of analysis. The analyses were carried out in a HPLC (SHIMADZU - LC2060C), using an BioRad Aminex HPX – 87H column (300 mm x 7.8 mm). HPLC was equipped with DAD (VFA analysis at 210 nm) and RI detectors (ethanol analysis). The temperature of the oven was set at 60 °C. The samples were prepared with an internal standard, which was crotonic acid (98%, Sigma-Aldrich, USA) (0.2 mmol∙L-1). The eluent used (mobile phase) was sulfuric acid (5 mmol∙L-1) Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 122 at 0.6 mL∙min-1 of flow rate, and the total time of run to acquire data was 30 min per chromatogram/sample. COD was determined in samples previously centrifuged (15 min, 20 000 g), using cuvette test kits (Hach Lange, Düsseldorf, Germany) and a DR 2800 spectrophotometer (Hach-Lange GmbH). Electrical conductivity and pH of the growth medium were measured with a Consort multi-parameter analyser C3010 and C1020, respectively. ORP was measured with a portable metre C533 (Consort, Turnhout, Belgium) equipped with an ORP electrode D 223 (VWR, Radnor, PA). 5.2.7. Statistical analysis In batch experiments, the kinetics parameters like lag phase and exponential methane production rate (EMPR) were obtained as explained in Chapter 3, subsection “3.2.6. Statistical analysis”. The statistical differences in the values obtained for kinetic parameters in batch experiments, and for methane yield during bioreactor operation, were evaluated using ANOVA also mentioned in the same subsection of Chapter 3. 5.3. RESULTS 5.3.1. Effect of materials on active microbial communities 5.3.1.1. Butyrate degradation in batch assays The anaerobic sludge used in the batch assays was an active sludge, which was reflected by its SMA on acetate (0.26 gCH4-COD·gVSS-1·d-1, Table 5.2), and the fast conversion of butyrate to methane (6 d and 9 d for complete conversion in B-without-AC-Mag-1 and in B-without-Zeo-1, respectively, Figure 5.3a). Indeed, to be considered an active sludge, the SMA on acetate should be around 0.3 gCH4-COD·gVSS-1·d-1 (Angelidaki et al., 2009), which was the value obtained for the anaerobic sludge used in these experiments (Table 5.2). The presence of AC, Mag or Zeo during butyrate degradation did not affect the conversion of butyrate to methane (Figure 5.3a), as MPR and the time needed for complete degradation was not significantly different between the assays performed with and without materials. The lag phases preceding MP had a duration of approximately 1.3 d in all conditions for the experiments of the first batch (with and without AC and Mag), and 1.9 d in the conditions for the experiments of the second batch (with and without Zeo). When the sludge was incubated a second time (by transferring 10 % v/v of the previous cultures, maintaining the original conditions), only slightly differences on the MP performance between conditions could be observed (Figure 5.3b). Lag phases preceding MP were similar for all conditions (with Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 123 or without materials), but the MP profile by B-AC-2 started to reveal a slightly improvement on the methanogenic activity comparing with the MP profile by B-without-AC-Mag-2. In the incubations with Zeo or Mag, no relevant differences were observed comparing with the incubations without materials (Figure 5.3b). From the first to the second incubations, it is important to note that the microbial communities lose some activity, as for example, the same amount of butyrate took more 9 d to be converted to methane in the assay B-without-AC-Mag-2 than B-without-AC-Mag-1. These results show that microbial communities with similar composition but different activities are differentially affected by the presence of materials. More active microbial communities are not affected by the addition of materials (Figure 5.3a), while differences on MP profiles started to be more evident in less active microbial communities (Figure 5.3b). Figure 5.3. Cumulative methane production by a) active anaerobic sludge and b) butyrate-enrichment cultures. The results are the mean of two replicates with the respective standard deviation. 5.3.1.2. Fatty acids and ethanol degradation in a continuous bioreactor The granular sludge used to inoculate the bioreactor was also an active sludge given its SMA in acetate (approximately 0.3 gCH4-COD·gVSS-1·d-1, Table 5.2), and similarly to what was observed in the batch experiments, the addition of GAC did not improve the bioreactor performance in none of the operational periods (Figure 5.4). The bioreactor showed a good performance during Period I (when GAC was not Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 124 present), without accumulation of VFA (i.e., acetate, propionate, butyrate) or ethanol (Figure A. 7, Appendix), with complete removal of the 5 gCOD·L-1 fed, and with CH4 content in the biogas of around 77.8 % (Figure 5.4a). The addition of GAC during Period II did not alter the bioreactor performance (Figure 5.4; Table A. 7, Appendix). At the end of Period II, the COD of the feed was increased to 10 gCOD·L-1, and the bioreactor performance was maintained. In order to evaluate whether the increase on GAC concentration would improve the bioreactor performance, GAC concentration was doubled (in Period IV) but neither methane recovery nor COD removal were altered (Figure 5.4; Table A. 7, Appendix). The methane yield, given in mL of methane produced per gram of COD removed, was (239 ± 12) mLCH4·gCODrem and (253 ± 11) mLCH4·gCODrem in Periods III and IV, respectively (Table A. 7, Appendix), and these results were not statistically different ( p > 0.05). At the end of operation, the VS inside the bioreactor was (20 ± 2) g·L-1 (vs 15 gVS·L-1 at the beginning), showing the active growth of anaerobic microorganisms, although some biomass was washed out during all the operation. Figure 5.4. (a) Methane content and (b) methane production rate by anaerobic sludge in the EGSB. The area colored in grey corresponds to the characterization days, i.e., 2 d with 3 sampling points per day for each period of operation. Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 125 5.3.2. Effect of materials on active butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures developed with and without materials The enrichment strategy applied resulted in several different cultures which convert butyrate to methane at different rates. The most efficient cultures include the ones designated by MoreAct-B-Zeo-3, MoreAct- B-AC-3, MoreAct-B-Mag-3 and MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3, which were enriched with Zeo, AC, Mag and without materials, respectively (Table 5.1). Cultures MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3 and MoreAct-B-Zeo-3 were specialized in the total conversion of butyrate to methane, which was achieved in approximately 12 d of incubation (Figure 5.5a, 5.5b). Cultures MoreAct-B-AC-3 and MoreAct-B-Mag-3 were specialized in the conversion of butyrate to methane and acetate which was achieved in 4 d and 6 d, respectively (Figure 5.5c, 5.5d). The addition of materials to the butyrate-degrading enrichment developed without materials (MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3), didn’t accelerate butyrate conversion to methane (Figure 5.5a). Excepting the assay with Zeo, in the assays with AC, Mag, mixture of AC and Mag, and AC@2%Fe, the MP was even delayed. For instance, the complete butyrate conversion to methane was achieved in 20 d in the presence of AC, whereas for the culture without materials only 14 d were required. Mag was the material which increased most the lag phase preceding MP, from 2 d (in the culture without materials) to 4 d, showing that the microbial enrichment in the presence of this material requires a longer adaptation time. Besides, the enrichment culture developed with Mag (MoreAct-B-Mag-3), was quite efficient on butyrate degradation, but when it was incubated without Mag, its activity was even higher, as the lag phase preceding MP was reduced in about 27 % (from 2.6 d in the incubation with Mag to 1.9 d in the incubation without Mag, Table 5.3, Figure 5.5d). These results showed that even microbial communities pre-adapted to the presence of Mag, performed better when Mag was not present, suggesting that this material did not contribute to stimulate butyrate degradation. The enrichment culture pre-adapted to AC (MoreAct-B-AC-3) slightly lost methanogenic performance when incubated in the absence of AC (Figure 5.5c). The lag phase duration by the original culture was (1.5 ± 0.0) d, which was lower than in its absence (2.1 ± 0.2) d (results statistically different p < 0.05, Table 5.3). The initial methane production rates (IMPR) were better with AC, changing from an IMPR of (0.27 ± 0.01) mmol·L-1·d-1 in the original condition with AC to (0.13 ± 0.03) mmol·L-1·d-1 in its absence (results statistically different p < 0.05, Table 5.3). However, the complete butyrate conversion to methane was achieved at the same time for all incubation conditions (around 4 d). On the other hand, the enrichment culture pre-adapted to Zeo almost maintained the microbial activity when incubated without Zeo, as differences on the MP profiles, with and without material, were not significant (Figure 5.5b). The behavior of these microbial enrichments when exposed to other incubation conditions (with or without materials), different from those they were adapted Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 126 to, showed that the presence or absence of the materials doesn’t interfere much in butyrate degradation, because the microbial communities are well adapted and active. Figure 5.5. Cumulative MP profiles over time for the following active cultures experiments: a) adapted butyratedegrading enrichment without AC or Mag (MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3) incubated in the original conditions and with several different materials; b) Zeo-adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment (MoreAct-B-Zeo-3) incubated in the original conditions and without Zeo; c) AC-adapted enrichment (MoreAct-B-AC-3) incubated in the original conditions and without AC; and d) Mag-adapted enrichment (MoreAct-B-Mag-3) incubated in the original conditions and without Mag. The results are the mean with the standard deviation of three replicates. The ORP of the growth medium changed with the presence of materials (Table A. 8, Appendix). Particularly, the presence of Mag increased the ORP values mainly at the end of incubations, for example, as it occurred in the assay of culture MoreAct-B-without-AC-Mag-3 with Mag, where ORP value was (-175 ± 23) mV, contrasting with (-333 ± 6) mV in the condition without materials. As methanogenesis is favoured at lower ORP (between −200 mV to −400 mV (Salvador et al., 2017)), the increase of ORP could affect MP. Although the results suggested that this material does not contribute to stimulate butyrate Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 127 degradation, the explanation cannot only be based on ORP alterations since the values measured in the beginning of incubations in the presence of Mag are within the optimal range for methanogenic activity. Table 5.3. Adapted butyrate-degrading enrichment cultures in different conditions and the impacts towards the IMPR, the EMPR, the duration of lag phase and the time of incubation for MP Assay Lag phase a/ d IMPR b/ mmol·L-1·d-1 R2 EMPR a/ mmol·L-1·d-1 R2 t/ d MoreAct-B-AC-3 1.5 ± 0.0 0.27 ± 0.01 0.95 ± 0.00 1.9 ± 0.1 0.994 ± 0.001 4 MoreAct-B-AC-3 without AC 2.1 ± 0.2 0.13 ± 0.03 0.96 ± 0.00 2.3 ± 0.1 0.988 ± 0.001 4 MoreAct-B-Mag-3 2.6 ± 0.0 0.12 ± 0.02 0.94 ± 0.00 1.4 ± 0.2 0.993 ± 0.002 6 MoreAct-B-Mag-3 without Mag 1.9 ± 0.1 0.31 ± 0.04 0.93 ± 0.01 1.5 ± 0.1 0.992 ± 0.001 6 a kinetics parameters obtained by modified Gompertz model. b IMPR were calculated for the first 1.3 d of incubation in the assays with MoreAct-B-AC-3 and for the first 2.2 d of incubation in the assays with MoreAct-B-Mag-3. 5.3.3. Effect of materials on slow growing microbial cultures As MP was followed in each incubation, the initial changes in the MP profiles in the different conditions (with and without materials) were detected together with the changes in the total time of incubation required for the complete conversion of butyrate to methane as well as changes in lag phase time and MPR in each transfer. The profiles of MP presented in Figure 6 show the phase of MP where the presence of materials started to impact significantly the conversion of butyrate to methane, highlighting that in the first incubation of the anaerobic sludge no effects were observed (Figure 5.3a). After three incubations, the cultures developed with AC (LessAct-B-AC-1, Figure 5.6a) showed lower lag phase duration (less than 4 d) and a faster methanogenic activity in an early stage of incubation (with a transient acetate accumulation point when 5 mmol·L-1 of CH4 was reached; Table A. 9, Appendix), in comparison with the other incubations (LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-1 and LessAct-B-Mag-1, Figure 5.6a). On the other hand, the cultures developed with Mag were partially inhibited, which was represented by longer lag phases preceding MP (higher than 10 d, Figure 5.6a). The cultures developed in the absence of materials showed a MP performance below the cultures developed with AC and above the ones developed with Mag, with lag phases approximately of 6 d (Figure 5.6a). During the following incubation, the cultures with AC still showed to be slightly faster in producing methane in an early stage of incubation (until around 5 mmol∙L-1 CH4), with lower lag phase duration (less than 4 d) in comparison with the other conditions (Figure 5.6b). However, despite of this stimulatory effect by AC at the beginning of incubations, the total conversion of Chapter 5 | The activity of microbial communities dictates the effect of activated carbon, magnetite, and zeolite, on methane production 128 butyrate to methane was slowed down (Figure A. 8, Appendix). AC cultures required more than 46 d to reach the total MP from complete butyrate degradation. In cultures with Mag, it was observed a longer lag phase duration, which varied between bottles (approximately 8 d for LessAct-B-Mag-2a, and 4 d for LessAct-B-Mag-2b, Figure 5.6b). Then, the complete MP was achieved in approximately 35 d for LessAct- B-Mag-2a and 42 d for LessAct-B-Mag-2b (Figure A. 8, Appendix). A transiently acetate accumulation was observed in all conditions (Table A. 9, Appendix). Complete butyrate conversion to methane was faster in cultures without materials (LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-2a and LessAct-B-without-AC-Mag-2b, Figure 5.6a), which occurred approximately in 25 d. On the other hand, the cultures from the experiments of batch 2 only revealed differences between the two types of incubation (with and without Zeo) after 5 incubations (Figure 5.6c). LessAct-B-Zeo-1a showed to become quite faster in butyrate conversion to methane in comparison with LessAct-B-without-Zeo-1b (Figure 5.6c). Butyrate was converted to methane in almost 30 d with Zeo, while it took approximately 45 d in the culture without Zeo. Regarding the positive or negative impacts of the presence of materials, these results showed how the performance of slow growing cultures can be highly affected in the presence of different materials.