Full text
In e na ional Jou nal o
En i onmen al Resea ch
and Public Heal h
A icle
Rowing T aining in B eas Cance Su i o s:
A Longi udinal S udy o Physical Fi ness
Juan Ga ala-González 1, Ismael Gál ez-Fe nández 2,* , Pe e Me cadé-Melé3and
JoséCa los Fe nández-Ga cía2
1Depa men o Physical Educa ion and Spo s, Uni e si y o Se ille, 41013 Se ille, Spain; [email p o ec ed]
2Depa men o Didac ics o Languages, A s and Spo , Uni e si y o Malaga, Andalucia-Tech, IBIMA,
29071 Malaga, Spain; [email p o ec ed]
3Depa men o S a is ics and Econome ics, Uni e si y o Malaga, Andalucia-Tech, 29071 Malaga, Spain;
[email p o ec ed]
*Co espondence: [email p o ec ed]
Recei ed: 5 May 2020; Accep ed: 6 July 2020; Published: 9 July 2020
Abs ac :
The aim o his s udy was o de e mine whe he a owing aining p og am leads o
imp o emen s in physical i ness and body composi ion in women who ha e su i ed b eas cance
(53.70
±
7.88 yea s). The pa icipan s (n =30) comple ed a wel e-week aining p og am consis ing
o h ee sessions pe week, wi h each session las ing om six y o nine y minu es. An an h opome ic
and gene al physical i ness assessmen was pe o med be o e and a e he p og am. The esul s
showed s a is ically signi ican imp o emen s in all he physical i ness es s pe o med: si and
each (2.82 cm); back sc a ch, dominan (3.29 cm); back sc a ch, non-dominan (4.59 cm); coun e
mo emen jump (1.91 cm); hand g ip, dominan (2.54 kg ); hand g ip, non-dominan (2.53 kg );
chai s and (2.56 ep); and six-minu e walk (51.56 m). In addi ion, a signi ican imp o emen was
obse ed in he e iciency o he ca dio ascula sys em measu ed by hea a e, in bea s pe minu e
(bpm), bo h be o e (
−
12.63 bpm) and a e he six-minu e walk es (
−
11.46 bpm). The e alua ed body
composi ion pa ame e s also imp o ed, speci ically o al lean mass (2.18 kg) and he pe cen age o
o al body a (
−
2.63%). We can he e o e conclude ha owing aining p og ams can be a s a egy o
be conside ed o imp o ing physical i ness in his popula ion gi en he imp o emen ob ained in
bo h an h opome ic and physical i ness a iables, hus leading o be e heal h and quali y o li e.
Keywo ds: b eas cance ; owing; i ness; an h opome y; hea a e
1. In oduc ion
Acco ding o he In e na ional Agency o Resea ch on Cance (IARC), b eas cance is he mos
common cance wo ldwide, a ec ing 2.1 million indi iduals each yea and is he leading cause o
dea h among women. In 2018, app oxima ely 627,000 women los hei li es o b eas cance [1].
Acco ding o he 2018 IARC s udy, 4% o women wo ldwide will ha e b eas cance a some ime
in hei li es [
2
]. This pe cen age is inc easing, and i is expec ed ha in 2040, he pe cen age o women
who will be a ec ed by his ype o cance will double, ising o 8% o he global popula ion [3].
In con as , b eas cance is no longe a al bu is becoming ch onic, as he a e o su i o s is abo e
70% i e yea s a e in e en ion. This pe cen age is associa ed wi h he e ec i eness o ea men s,
o he inc ease in ea ly diagnosis and o he p e en ion o elapse [
4
,
5
]. Howe e , he isk o elapse
20–30 yea s a e diagnosis is a he high [
6
]. The inc ease in li e expec ancy o hese indi iduals is
e idence ha mo e people a e li ing wi h he side e ec s o b eas cance ea men (loss o muscle
mass and s eng h, loss o mobili y and disabili y o he uppe ex emi ies, lymphedema, a igue and
ca diac oxici y) [7].
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938; doi:10.3390/ije ph17144938 www.mdpi.com/jou nal/ije ph
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 2 o 12
Physical ac i i y dec eases he du a ion and in ensi y o a igue [
8
,
9
], educes anxie y and
dep ession [
10
], inc eases muscle mass and s eng h, dec eases disabili y in he uppe ex emi ies [
11
]
and imp o es quali y o li e [
12
,
13
], as well as es o ing and e en imp o ing unc ionali y and
well-being in women who ha e o e come b eas cance [
14
]. Se e al me a-analyses and e iews a i m
ha physical ac i i y also con ibu es o educing he isk o b eas cance ecu ence [
15
–
28
], while
o he s ha e ob ained neu al esul s, implying ha physical ac i i y does no cause any changes [
29
–
31
].
Cu en ly, he li e a u e p o ides no scien i ic e idence on he p esc ip ion and s uc u e o physical
exe cise o b eas cance su i o s [
17
,
18
]. Consequen ly, his s udy ollowed he ecommenda ions o
he Ame ican College o Spo s Medicine (ACSM), which s a e ha cance su i o s should pe o m
150 min o mode a e ae obic ac i i y o 75 min o igo ous ae obic ac i i y pe week and esis ance
aining wo days pe week [
32
]. Physical exe cise plays an impo an ole in imp o ing quali y o
li e [
11
] and p e en ing o delaying he onse o o he diseases in cance su i o s [
15
–
24
] by imp o ing
ae obic capaci y and muscle s eng h [
11
] and educing a igue [
8
], all o which a e key elemen s in
eco e y om his disease and i s sequelae [32].
Wi h ega d o exis ing s udies on physical ac i i y and b eas cance , we highligh he s udy
by Di Blasio e al. (2017) in which hey ca ied ou a s eng h p og am esul ing in imp o ed
physical i ness [
33
]. The s udy by Keilani e al. (2016) implemen ed an ae obic p og am and
ound imp o emen s in quali y o li e and physical i ness [
34
]. S udies ha implemen ed mixed
p og ams [
35
–
37
] epo ed imp o emen s in physical i ness and body composi ion. Among hem is
he esea ch by Dieli-Conw igh e al. (2018), in which a combined 16-week ae obic and esis ance
p og am signi ican ly imp o ed i ness, wi h inc eases in bo h uppe and lowe ex emi y s eng h [
35
].
Simila ly, Thomas e al. (2018) ca ied ou a 12-mon h aining p og am, inding a dec ease in body
a (0.9%; 1 kg/m
2
) and an inc ease in lean mass (0.5 kg), as well as imp o ed uppe and lowe
ex emi y s eng h [
36
]. Modali ies such as yoga and pila es also p o ide bene icial esul s in join
mobili y, muscle s eng h and quali y o li e [
20
,
23
,
27
]. Finally, se e al s udies on he e ec s o d agon
boa aining p og ams on b eas cance su i o s ha e iden i ied imp o emen s in join mobili y
anges [38], s eng h in di e en body segmen s [38,39] and quali y o li e [40–42].
In ou s udy, owing was p esc ibed as he basis o a physical exe cise p og am. This spo was
chosen because i in ol es he muscles o bo h he lowe and uppe ex emi ies [
43
] and almos all
he muscles o he body [
44
], al hough he main ea u e di e en ia ing owing om mos o he spo s
is he cyclic and al e na ing ac ion o he lexion and ex ension o he uppe and lowe limbs and
he s abilizing muscles o he unk and back du ing paddling o enhance echnique [
45
]. While he
exis ing li e a u e on physical ac i i y and b eas cance is sca ce, in he case o owing and b eas
cance i is non-exis en . Fo his eason, we belie e ha ou s udy may ep esen an impo an ad ance
in he p esc ip ion o heal hy exe cise o b eas cance su i o s. Se e al s udies ha e been conduc ed
on d agon boa aining and b eas cance [
42
,
46
–
49
], al hough a b ie biomechanical analysis e eals
ha his is an asymme ic spo equi ing compensa o y e o and a se ies o di icul mo emen s ha
a e no ecommended in his popula ion. In con as , owing is a comp ehensi e spo ha de elops
he lowe , uppe , on , back, igh and le sides o he body in almos iden ical p opo ions, since
he mo emen is symme ical. A he same ime, he posi ion o he body segmen s is much mo e
ad isable o women who ha e su e ed om cance and su ge y a ec ing he uppe limbs, since
owing does no equi e o ced mo emen s.
The aim o his s udy was o de e mine how a aining p og am based on he spo o owing may
a ec physical i ness and body composi ion in women who ha e su i ed b eas cance .
2. Ma e ials and Me hods
2.1. Design and Pa icipan s
The pa icipan s, all o whom we e b eas cance su i o s, and whose main cha ac e is ics a e in
Table 1, we e ec ui ed in o a owing club. Once selec ed, hey me wi h he p ojec coo dina o , who
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 3 o 12
explained he na u e o he s udy, indica ing ha hei anonymi y would be main ained a all imes,
ollowing he e hical conside a ions o Spo and Exe cise Science Resea ch [
50
] and in acco dance
wi h he p inciples included in he Decla a ion o Helsinki [
51
], which de ines e hical guidelines o
esea ch on human subjec s, and he Uni e si y o M
á
laga ga e he egis e ed iden i ica ion numbe
o he e hics commi ee: 2020/REGSED-17007. All he pa icipan s signed a w i en in o med consen
o m. In addi ion, du ing he en i e in e en ion and he ea e , ac ion was aken unde he p o isions
o O ganic Law 3/2018, o 5 Decembe , on he P o ec ion o Pe sonal Da a and he gua an ee o digi al
igh s ega ding he p o ec ion o pe sonal da a in he Spanish legisla ion.
Table 1. Cha ac e is ics o he sample abou b eas cance .
Age (Yea s) Yea s om Diagnosis B eas (%) S age (%) Su ge y (%)
53.70 ±7.88 6.57 ±5.02
Righ 26.09 I 4.35 P ese a ion 53.52
II 30.43 To al Mas ec omy 39.13
Le 73.91 III 52.17
IV 8.7 Double Mas ec omy 4.35
2.2. Ins umen s
Weigh was measu ed o he nea es 0.1 kg using a Tani a model BC730 scale, ollowing he
p o ocol o he manu ac u e o clo hing and p e ious in ake o liquids o ood. Heigh was measu ed
o he nea es 0.1 cm wi h a SECA model 213 po able s adiome e , acco ding o he F ank u plane o
body posi ioning. In he e alua ion o body a and muscle mass, a dual-ene gy X- ay densi ome e
(DXA, Hologic Explo e , Wal ham, MA, USA) was used.
In addi ion, pa icipan s comple ed he physical i ness es s desc ibed below:
The si and each es [52] is used as a gene al es o lexibili y. The subjec si s on he loo wi h
knees s aigh , legs ex ended and wi h he soles o he ee p essed i mly agains he box. The a ms a e
ex ended o wa d wi h he palms acing downwa ds on he uppe su ace o he scale. In his posi ion,
he subjec eaches o wa d as a as possible and holds he posi ion. The sco e is he mos dis an
poin eached and held on he ou h mo emen . The es adminis a o s ands close beside he scale
and eco ds he mos dis an line ouched by he inge ips o bo h hands. I he hands each une enly,
he hand eaching he sho e dis ance de e mines he sco e. The sco e is eco ded o he nea es hal
inch. I he each appea s o be exac ly hal -way be ween wo lines, he sco e is based on he las line
ac ually ouched. The bes alue o wo obse a ions was conside ed. The scale on he si and each
box has an accu acy o 5 mm.
The hand g ip es [
53
] is used o measu e he maximum isome ic s eng h o he hand and o ea m
muscles. To s a , he hand dimension is i s measu ed, and hen he g ip a ea o he dynamome e
is adjus ed acco ding o he leng h o he hand. Measu emen s we e ob ained unde s anda dized
condi ions, wi h he pa icipan s in he sea ed posi ion, elbow a nine y deg ees and handle adjus ed o
he second posi ion. A e ecei ing an explana ion o he p ocedu es and becoming amilia ized wi h
he ins umen , maximum g ip s eng h should be applied o 3 o 5 s. The p ocedu e was pe o med
h ee imes wi h each hand al e na ely, wi h an in e al o one minu e be ween each measu emen .
The highes alue o h ee obse a ions o each hand was conside ed. A TKK-5401 model digi al hand
dynamome e was used, which has a measu ing ange o 0.5 o 100 kg- o ce (kg ) and a minimum uni
o measu emen o 0.1 kg .
The coun e mo emen jump [
54
] measu es explosi e and elas ic o ce. I is pe o med wi h he
subjec s a ing om an up igh posi ion and wi h he hands on he hips. Then, an upwa d jump is
pe o med by means o lexion ollowed as quickly as possible by ex ension o he legs. Knee lexion
should each an angle o nine y deg ees and he unk should be p e en ed om bending in o de o
elimina e any posi i e in luence on he jump o he han om he lowe ex emi ies. The legs du ing
he ligh phase should be ex ended and he ee a he momen o con ac wi h he pla o m should be
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 4 o 12
suppo ed i s by he me a a sal a ea and hen by he back o he oo . Measu emen s we e aken wi h
he My Jump 2 mobile applica ion [55].
The six-minu e walk es [
56
] is a ca dio- espi a o y unc ion es ha measu es he maximum
dis ance a subjec can walk o six minu es on a la su ace. The hea a e pe minu e is aken be o e
and a e he es .
The chai s and es [
57
] assesses lowe ex emi y s eng h by measu ing he numbe o imes he
pa ien si s down and s ands up om a chai , s abilized o sa e y. The subjec si s in he cen e o he
chai , wi h ee sp ead apa and es ing on he loo . The a ms a e c ossed and held close o he ches .
F om he si ing posi ion, he subjec s ands up comple ely and hen si s down again, epea ing his
cycle o 30 s. The inal sco e is ob ained by coun ing he o al numbe o ull squa s (each ime he
subjec s ands up).
The back sc a ch es [
58
] e alua es lexibili y in he uppe ex emi ies. The subjec s ands up and
wi h he dominan hand mus ouch he shoulde o he same a m. Wi h he inge s ex ended, he
subjec mus ad ance along he back, b inging he elbow up un il ying o each he middle o he
back. The o he a m eaches a ound he back wi h he palm acing ou wa ds, he goal being o ouch
he middle inge s o bo h hands behind he back. The dis ance be ween he ips o he middle inge s
o bo h hands is measu ed. I he inge ips ouch, he sco e is ze o. I hey do no ouch, he sco e is
nega i e, and i hey o e lap, he sco e is posi i e.
2.3. P ocedu e
Each pa icipan , ba e oo and wea ing ligh clo hing, unde wen an ini ial an h opome ic
assessmen o weigh and heigh o calcula e BMI. Subsequen ly, each pa icipan pe o med he
physical es s in he ollowing o de : hand g ip, coun e mo emen jump, back sc a ch, si and each,
chai s and and six-minu e walk.
A e he ini ial assessmen , he pa icipan s comple ed a p og am o wel e consecu i e weeks
o owing aining (Table 2). Fo his p og am, each week included h ee days o aining las ing
be ween six y and nine y minu es pe session. These sessions we e supe ised by a pe sonal aine
who ensu ed a endance, co ec execu ion o he asks and he in ensi y o he sessions, in addi ion o
excluding om he s udy hose pa icipan s who did no mee a leas 90% pa icipa ion. The aining
pe iod was di ided in o h ee s ages, wi h each s age las ing ou weeks and each week ha ing h ee
sessions. The in ensi y and echnical di icul y o hese s ages was p og essi ely inc eased and was
egula ed h ough he subjec i e pe cep ion o he e o o he pa icipan s, using he Bö g scale [59].
Table 2. Exe cise p esc ip ion design o he p og am.
S age Con en
1Ini ial phase wi h mobili y exe cises, p op iocep i e exe cises and pos u al con ol
exe cises. Main phase wi h owing aining. Final phase wi h s e ching. Bö g scale 5–6.
2Ini ial phase wi h mobili y exe cises, p op iocep i e exe cises and pos u al con ol
exe cises. Main phase wi h owing aining. Final phase wi h s e ching. Bö g scale 6–7.
3Ini ial phase wi h mobili y exe cises, p op iocep i e exe cises and pos u al con ol
exe cises. Main phase wi h owing aining. Final phase wi h s e ching. Bö g scale 7–8.
A he end o he wel e-week aining p og am, he pa icipan s we e e-e alua ed using he
same p ocedu e used in he ini ial e alua ion.
2.4. Da a Analysis
The da a we e collec ed in an Excel sp eadshee , including age, heigh , weigh , BMI, he esul s o
he di e en es s and pa icipan a ilia ions. S a is ical analyses we e pe o med using he S a is ical
Package o Social Sciences, e sion 25 (IBM Co p., New Yo k, NY, USA).
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 5 o 12
To examine whe he he e we e signi ican di e ences esul ing om he owing aining, we
analyzed he di e ences be ween he means o each a iable p e- and pos - aining and hen conduc ed
pa ame ic es ing wi h S uden ’s - es o ela ed samples (pai ed da a). P io o his analysis, he
no mali y o he dis ibu ion was e i ied h ough he Shapi o–Wilk es (p- alue >0.05 in all he
a iables unde s udy). Rega ding women’s age, 30.43% a e aged 41 o 50, 52.17% om 51 o 60 yea s
old and 17.39% om 61 o 70 yea s old.
3. Resul s
Table 3shows he means o he di e en a iables bo h be o e and a e aining as well as hei
di e ences and compa isons o de e mine whe he he e a e s a is ically signi ican di e ences. All he
pa icipan s showed imp o emen s in all he a iables s udied. In addi ion, hese di e ences we e all
s a is ically signi ican excep in he a iables weigh , BMI and o al body a , which al hough hey
imp o ed a e aining, we e no s a is ically signi ican : (di Weigh
Pos -P e
=
−
0.37
±
2.58; =
−
0.798;
p=0.431; di BMI
Pos -P e
=
−
0.14
±
1.02; =
−
0.786; p=0.438; di To al Body Fa
Pos -P e
=
−
1.77
±
7.6;
=
−
1.28; p=0.211). The a iables si and each (di
Pos -P e
=2.82
±
1.87; =8.24; p=0.000);
back sc a ch, dominan (di
Pos -P e
=3.29
±
3.15; =5.72; p=0.000); back sc a ch, non-dominan
(di
Pos -P e
=4.59
±
3.90; =6.44; p=0.000); coun e mo emen jump (di
Pos -P e
=1.91
±
1.71;
=6.12; p=0.000); hand g ip, igh (di
Pos -P e
=2.54
±
1.56; =8.93; p=0.000); hand g ip, le
(di
Pos -P e
=2.53
±
1.91; =7.22; p=0.000); chai s and (di
Pos -P e
=2.56
±
1.71; =8.19; p=0.000);
hea a e a he s a o he 6-min walk es (di
Pos -P e
=
−
12.63
±
14.68; =
−
4.71; p=0.000); hea a e a
he end o he 6-min walk es (di
Pos -P e
=
−
11.46
±
28.39; =
−
2.21; p=0.000); dis ance a elled in he
6-min walk es (di
Pos -P e
=51.56
±
48.26; =5.85; p=0.000); o al lean mass (di
Pos -P e
=2.18
±
4.81;
=2.48; p=0.019); and pe cen age o o al body a (di
Pos -P e
=
−
2.63
±
5.43; =
−
2.65; p=0.013) all
showed signi ican ly posi i e di e ences be ween p e- and pos - aining. P ac ically all he a iables
ha show s a is ically signi ican di e ences p esen he size o he e ec s, calcula ed om he Cohen’s
d o a pai ed sample, being g ea e han 0.8. The e o e, he di e ences a e s a is ically signi ican and
clinically ele an .
Table 3.
S a is ical analysis o he s udied a iables. Mean
±
s anda d de ia ion; di e ences, -s uden
es , e ec size and p- alue.
Va iables P e es Pos - es Di Pos -P e -S uden E ec Size p
Weigh (kg) 68.67 ±10.98 68.29 ±10.79 −0.37 ±2.58 −0.798 0.14 0.431
BMI (kg/m2)26.34 ±3.78 26.19 ±3.67 −0.14 ±1.02 −0.786 0.14 0.438
To al body a (kg) 27.62 ±6.79 25.85 ±6.29 −1.77 ±7.60 −1.28 0.23 0.211
To al lean mass (kg) 40.43 ±4.61 42.61 ±3.45 2.18 ±4.81 2.486 0.45 0.019 *
Pe cen age o o al body a (%) 40.07 ±4.84 37.44 ±4.88 −2.63 ±5.43 −2.657 0.48 0.013 *
Si and each es (cm) 0.87 ±6.61 3.69 ±6.57 2.82 ±1.87 8.242 1.51 0.000 **
Dominan back sc a ch es (cm) −2.19 ±8.22 1.10 ±6.54 3.29 ±3.15 5.726 1.04 0.000 **
Non-dominan back sc a ch es (cm) −6.64 ±7.47 −2.05 ±5.72 4.59 ±3.90 6.44 1.18 0.000 **
Coun e mo emen jump es (cm) 14.67 ±4.30 16.58 ±4.28 1.91 ±1.71 6.128 1.12 0.000 **
Dominan hand g ip es (kg ) 23.89 ±4.56 26.44 ±5.00 2.54 ±1.56 8.933 1.63 0.000 **
Non-dominan hand g ip es (kg ) 21.73 ±4.37 24.26 ±4.06 2.53 ±1.91 7.229 1.32 0.000 **
Chai s and es ( ep) 14.90 ±2.41 17.46 ±2.75 2.56 ±1.71 8.194 1.50 0.000 **
S a ing hea a e a six-minu e walking es (bpm) 98.43 ±16.72 85.80 ±9.79 −12.63 ±14.68 −4.712 0.86 0.000 **
Final hea a e a six-minu e walking es (bpm) 143.26 ±32.64 131.80 ±18.62 −11.46 ±28.39 −2.212 0.40 0.000 **
Dis ance in six-minu e walking es (m) 611.23 ±87.01 662.80 ±85.82 51.56 ±48.26 5.852 1.07 0.000 **
*=p<0.05; ** =p<0.001.
In he ollowing g aphs, he a iables can be obse ed g ouped acco ding o s eng h, ae obic,
hea a e, lexibili y and an h opome y. The g aphs show how he a iables ha e e ol ed be o e and
a e aining and a i y he di e ences ha ha e been analyzed in Table 2.
Figu e 1shows how all s eng h a iables imp o e a e aining, wi h s a is ically
signi ican di e ences. The chai s and es is he one wi h he g ea es absolu e di e ence
(di Pos -P e =2.56 ±1.71).
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 6 o 12
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020, 17, x 6 o 12
In he ollowing g aphs, he a iables can be obse ed g ouped acco ding o s eng h, ae obic,
hea a e, lexibili y and an h opome y. The g aphs show how he a iables ha e e ol ed be o e
and a e aining and a i y he di e ences ha ha e been analyzed in Table 2.
Figu e 1 shows how all s eng h a iables imp o e a e aining, wi h s a is ically signi ican
di e ences. The chai s and es is he one wi h he g ea es absolu e di e ence (di Pos -P e = 2.56 ±
1.71).
Figu e 1. S eng h a iable. P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; CMJ = coun e mo emen jump es ; DH =
dominan hand g ip es ; NDH = Non-dominan hand g ip es ; CH = chai s and es ; ep = epe i ions.
Figu e 2 shows he ae obic a iable, dis ance in he six-minu e walking es , and a clea
imp o emen is obse ed a e aining (di Pos -P e = 51.56 ± 48.26).
Figu e 2. Dis ance in he six-minu e walking es . P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; 6mw = six-minu e
walking es .
Figu e 3 g aphically analyzes he hea a e a iables and clea ly shows how hese wo a iables
dec ease signi ican ly due o aining.
Figu e 1.
S eng h a iable. P e =p e es ; Pos =pos - es ; CMJ =coun e mo emen jump es ;
DH =dominan hand g ip es ; NDH =Non-dominan hand g ip es ; CH =chai s and es ;
ep = epe i ions.
Figu e 2shows he ae obic a iable, dis ance in he six-minu e walking es , and a clea
imp o emen is obse ed a e aining (di Pos -P e =51.56 ±48.26).
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020, 17, x 6 o 12
In he ollowing g aphs, he a iables can be obse ed g ouped acco ding o s eng h, ae obic,
hea a e, lexibili y and an h opome y. The g aphs show how he a iables ha e e ol ed be o e
and a e aining and a i y he di e ences ha ha e been analyzed in Table 2.
Figu e 1 shows how all s eng h a iables imp o e a e aining, wi h s a is ically signi ican
di e ences. The chai s and es is he one wi h he g ea es absolu e di e ence (di Pos -P e = 2.56 ±
1.71).
Figu e 1. S eng h a iable. P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; CMJ = coun e mo emen jump es ; DH =
dominan hand g ip es ; NDH = Non-dominan hand g ip es ; CH = chai s and es ; ep = epe i ions.
Figu e 2 shows he ae obic a iable, dis ance in he six-minu e walking es , and a clea
imp o emen is obse ed a e aining (di Pos -P e = 51.56 ± 48.26).
Figu e 2. Dis ance in he six-minu e walking es . P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; 6mw = six-minu e
walking es .
Figu e 3 g aphically analyzes he hea a e a iables and clea ly shows how hese wo a iables
dec ease signi ican ly due o aining.
Figu e 2.
Dis ance in he six-minu e walking es . P e =p e es ; Pos =pos - es ; 6mw =six-minu e
walking es .
Figu e 3g aphically analyzes he hea a e a iables and clea ly shows how hese wo a iables
dec ease signi ican ly due o aining.
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 7 o 12
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020, 17, x 7 o 12
Figu e 3. Hea a e in he six-minu e walking es . P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; SHR = s a ing hea
a e; FHR = inal hea a e; bpm = bea s pe minu e.
Figu e 4 g aphically displays he lexibili y a iables whe e hey all p esen be e esul s a e
aining, all o which a e s a is ically signi ican .
Figu e 4. Flexibili y a iable. P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; SR = si and each es ; DBS = dominan
back sc a ch es ; NDBS = non-dominan back sc a ch es .
Figu e 5 shows he an h opome ic a iables whe e all o hem imp o e a e he aining es s.
These di e ences a e s a is ically signi ican .
Figu e 3.
Hea a e in he six-minu e walking es . P e =p e es ; Pos =pos - es ; SHR =s a ing hea
a e; FHR = inal hea a e; bpm =bea s pe minu e.
Figu e 4g aphically displays he lexibili y a iables whe e hey all p esen be e esul s a e
aining, all o which a e s a is ically signi ican .
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020, 17, x 7 o 12
Figu e 3. Hea a e in he six-minu e walking es . P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; SHR = s a ing hea
a e; FHR = inal hea a e; bpm = bea s pe minu e.
Figu e 4 g aphically displays he lexibili y a iables whe e hey all p esen be e esul s a e
aining, all o which a e s a is ically signi ican .
Figu e 4. Flexibili y a iable. P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; SR = si and each es ; DBS = dominan
back sc a ch es ; NDBS = non-dominan back sc a ch es .
Figu e 5 shows he an h opome ic a iables whe e all o hem imp o e a e he aining es s.
These di e ences a e s a is ically signi ican .
Figu e 4.
Flexibili y a iable. P e =p e es ; Pos =pos - es ; SR =si and each es ; DBS =dominan
back sc a ch es ; NDBS =non-dominan back sc a ch es .
Figu e 5shows he an h opome ic a iables whe e all o hem imp o e a e he aining es s.
These di e ences a e s a is ically signi ican .
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 8 o 12
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020, 17, x 8 o 12
Figu e 5. An h opome y a iable. P e = p e es ; Pos = pos - es ; W = weigh ; BMI = body mass index;
TBF = o al body a ; TLM = o al lean mass; TBFP = pe cen age o o al body a .
To sum up, he esul s in Table 3 a e displayed g aphically in he i e igu es. All ae obic,
s eng h and lexibili y a iables imp o e, since hey p esen highe alues a e aining. Hea a e
a iables imp o e by dec easing ensions a he end o he ac i i y. Finally, he an h opome ic
a iables imp o e by lowe ing he alue o weigh , body mass index, o al body a and pe cen age
o o al body a , in addi ion o inc easing he o al lean mass once he owing ac i i y is inished.
4. Discussion
The s udy o b eas cance om he pe spec i e o physical ac i i y is ela i ely ecen , as
demons a ed by he limi ed li e a u e and ecommenda ions published by he ACSM [31] less han
six mon hs ago. A p e ious analysis iden i ied only a small numbe o a icles indica ing ha physical
ac i i y causes nei he a posi i e no a nega i e eac ion in b eas cance su i o s [29–31]. Mos
s udies, howe e , ha e ound ha physical ac i i y in indi iduals wi h b eas cance leads o a ange
o imp o emen s, he mos no able being a dec ease in he pe cep ion o a igue [8,9] and he delay
o absence o o he diseases such as b eas cance ecu ence [15–24].
Physical ac i i y has been shown o imp o e quali y o li e in b eas cance su i o s [12,13] and
unc ionali y [14] in an isola ed way o associa ed wi h aspec s o physical i ness, including bo h
join mobili y and muscle s eng h [20,23,27]. Th ough ac i i ies such as yoga o pila es [20,23],
ae obic ac i i ies [32], speci ic s eng h p og ams [33], combined ae obic and muscle s eng h
exe cises [35–37] o he p ac ice o d agon boa [42,46–48], imp o emen s in physical i ness ha e
been ound, especially in s eng h in he ex emi ies [36,37] as well as in body composi ion [35].
Se e al s udies ha e conduc ed ae obic [33] o s eng h p og ams [34], which esul ed in
imp o emen s in quali y o li e and physical i ness. Howe e , i should be no ed ha mos o he
p e ious s udies implemen ed mixed in e en ions ollowing he ecommenda ions o he ACSM
[32]. In ou owing aining p og am, he du a ion was wel e weeks, and he indings iden i ied
signi ican imp o emen s in bo h he an h opome ic and physical i ness a iables analyzed. These
esul s a e in line wi h hose o Dieli-Conw igh e al. (2018) and Thomas e al. (2018), in which
imp o emen s in an h opome ic a iables we e epo ed a e a p og am o six een weeks and
wel e mon hs, espec i ely [35,36].
In ou s udy, based on he adminis a ion o a owing aining p og am, imp o emen s we e
obse ed in all body composi ion pa ame e s e alua ed h ough DXA, which dec eased o al body
a and pe cen age o o al body a and inc eased lean mass (Table 3). All o hese imp o emen s
we e signi ican and g ea e han in any p e ious s udies in he li e a u e.
In addi ion, he esul s pe aining o physical i ness showed signi ican imp o emen s in he
di e en s anda dized es s ha measu e a wide ange o mani es a ions o physical i ness including
Figu e 5.
An h opome y a iable. P e =p e es ; Pos =pos - es ; W =weigh ; BMI =body mass index;
TBF = o al body a ; TLM = o al lean mass; TBFP =pe cen age o o al body a .
To sum up, he esul s in Table 3a e displayed g aphically in he i e igu es. All ae obic, s eng h
and lexibili y a iables imp o e, since hey p esen highe alues a e aining. Hea a e a iables
imp o e by dec easing ensions a he end o he ac i i y. Finally, he an h opome ic a iables imp o e
by lowe ing he alue o weigh , body mass index, o al body a and pe cen age o o al body a , in
addi ion o inc easing he o al lean mass once he owing ac i i y is inished.
4. Discussion
The s udy o b eas cance om he pe spec i e o physical ac i i y is ela i ely ecen , as
demons a ed by he limi ed li e a u e and ecommenda ions published by he ACSM [
31
] less han six
mon hs ago. A p e ious analysis iden i ied only a small numbe o a icles indica ing ha physical
ac i i y causes nei he a posi i e no a nega i e eac ion in b eas cance su i o s [
29
–
31
]. Mos
s udies, howe e , ha e ound ha physical ac i i y in indi iduals wi h b eas cance leads o a ange
o imp o emen s, he mos no able being a dec ease in he pe cep ion o a igue [
8
,
9
] and he delay o
absence o o he diseases such as b eas cance ecu ence [15–24].
Physical ac i i y has been shown o imp o e quali y o li e in b eas cance su i o s [
12
,
13
] and
unc ionali y [
14
] in an isola ed way o associa ed wi h aspec s o physical i ness, including bo h join
mobili y and muscle s eng h [
20
,
23
,
27
]. Th ough ac i i ies such as yoga o pila es [
20
,
23
], ae obic
ac i i ies [
32
], speci ic s eng h p og ams [
33
], combined ae obic and muscle s eng h exe cises [
35
–
37
]
o he p ac ice o d agon boa [
42
,
46
–
48
], imp o emen s in physical i ness ha e been ound, especially
in s eng h in he ex emi ies [36,37] as well as in body composi ion [35].
Se e al s udies ha e conduc ed ae obic [
33
] o s eng h p og ams [
34
], which esul ed in
imp o emen s in quali y o li e and physical i ness. Howe e , i should be no ed ha mos o he
p e ious s udies implemen ed mixed in e en ions ollowing he ecommenda ions o he ACSM [
32
].
In ou owing aining p og am, he du a ion was wel e weeks, and he indings iden i ied signi ican
imp o emen s in bo h he an h opome ic and physical i ness a iables analyzed. These esul s a e
in line wi h hose o Dieli-Conw igh e al. (2018) and Thomas e al. (2018), in which imp o emen s
in an h opome ic a iables we e epo ed a e a p og am o six een weeks and wel e mon hs,
espec i ely [35,36].
In ou s udy, based on he adminis a ion o a owing aining p og am, imp o emen s we e
obse ed in all body composi ion pa ame e s e alua ed h ough DXA, which dec eased o al body a
and pe cen age o o al body a and inc eased lean mass (Table 3). All o hese imp o emen s we e
signi ican and g ea e han in any p e ious s udies in he li e a u e.
In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 4938 9 o 12
In addi ion, he esul s pe aining o physical i ness showed signi ican imp o emen s in he
di e en s anda dized es s ha measu e a wide ange o mani es a ions o physical i ness including
uppe ex emi y and hip ange o mo ion, lowe and uppe ex emi y s eng h, ae obic capaci y and
hea a e a es and a e p olonged e o .
Consequen ly, he esul s o ou s udy can con ibu e o imp o ing he heal h and quali y o
li e o women who ha e o e come b eas cance , o e ing hem a new s a egy o physical exe cise
p esc ip ion o a p oblem ha a ec s mo e han wo million women each yea .
5. Conclusions
Ou esea ch o e s a no el me hodological p oposal o physical exe cise p esc ip ion a e b eas
cance h ough a aining p og am based on owing, a cyclic and symme ical spo ha combines
o e all s eng h wi h ae obic endu ance. This new p oposal has a ela i ely sho du a ion, wel e
weeks, and is capable o b inging abou imp o emen s in all aspec s o physical i ness and ca diac
unc ion du ing s ess, as well as in an h opome ic pa ame e s such as a and lean mass.
Au ho Con ibu ions:
I.G.-F. and J.G.-G. concei ed and concep ualized he s udy. I.G.-F. and P.M.-M. collec ed
and analyzed he da a. I.G.-F., J.C.F.-G., J.G.-G. and P.M.-M. conduc ed he necessa y li e a u e e iews and
d a ed he i s manusc ip . J.C.F.-G. p o ided c i ical eedback and helped shape he analysis and manusc ip .
All au ho s con ibu ed o he e ision and w i ing o he inal d a . All au ho s ha e ead and ag eed o he
published e sion o he manusc ip .
Funding:
This esea ch was unded by he “Resea ching in Spo Sciences” esea ch g oup (CTS-563) o he
Andalusian Resea ch Plan.
Acknowledgmen s:
We would like o hank he Real Club Medi e aneo o Malaga, i s owing cap ain: Juan
Ca los Ma il Rod
í
guez and he eam o he Malaga D agon Boa BCS o opening hei doo s o us, gi ing
us all he acili ies in he wo ld and o gi ing us he mos impo an hing: hei ime and inspi ing us wi h
hei impe us and ene gy, hanks o which we can p esen he i s esul s o his s udy. To Ma ia Repice, o he
help wi h he English e sion o his manusc ip . Finally, we would also like o hank Alejand o S
á
nchez o his
pa icipa ion in he da a collec ion o his s udy.
Con lic s o In e es : The au ho s decla e no con lic o in e es .
Re e ences
1.
Wo ld Heal h O ganiza ion. B eas Cance : P e en ion and Con ol. A ailable online: h ps://www.who.in /
opics/cance /b eas cance /en (accessed on 11 Ap il 2020).
2.
In e na ional Agency o Resea ch on Cance . Cance Today. A ailable online: h ps://gco.ia c. / oday/home
(accessed on 14 Ap il 2020).
3.
In e na ional Agency o Resea ch on Cance . Cance Tomo ow. A ailable online: h ps://gco.ia c. /
omo ow/home (accessed on 14 Ap il 2020).
4.
Can a e o-Villanue a, I.; Fe n
á
ndez-Lao, C.; Del Mo al-A ila, R.; Fe n
á
ndez-de-Las-Peñas, C.;
Fe iche-Fe n
á
ndez-Cas anys, M.B.; A oyo-Mo ales, M. E ec i eness o co e s abili y exe cises and eco e y
myo ascial elease massage on a igue in b eas cance su i o s: A andomized con olled clinical ial.
E id. Based Complemen . Al e na . Med. 2012,2012, 620619. [C ossRe ]
5.
An his, N.J.; Ka anaugh-Lynch, M.H.E. The Global Challenge o P e en B eas Cance : Su acing New Ideas
o Accele a e P e en ion Resea ch. In . J. En i on. Res. Public Heal h 2020,17, 1394. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
6. Dixon, J.M.; Mon gome y, D. Follow-up a e b eas cance . BMJ 2008,336, 107–108. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
7.
So iano-Maldonado, A.; Ca e a-Ruiz,
Á
.; D
í
ez-Fe n
á
ndez, D.M.; Es eban-Sim
ó
n, A.; Maldonado-Quesada, M.;
Mo eno-Poza, N.; del Ma Ga c
í
a-Ma
í
nez, M.; Alca az-Ga c
í
a, C.; V
á
zquez-Sousa, R.; Mo eno-Ma os, H.; e al.
E ec s o a 12-week esis ance and ae obic exe cise p og am on muscula s eng h and quali y o li e in
b eas cance su i o s: S udy p o ocol o he EFICAN andomized con olled ial. Medicine
2019
,98, e17625.
[C ossRe ]
8.
Rome o-Ba que o, C. Ac i idad
í
sica en el iempo lib e p e iene en e medades ca diacas/ca dio ascula es:
Una e isión sis emá ica. Re . Ibe oam. Cienc. Ac . Física y Depo e 2020,9, 1–22. [C ossRe ]