Some new thin sets of integers in harmonic analysis
Abstract
We randomly construct various subsets A of the integers which have both smallness and largeness properties. They are small since they are very close, in various senses, to Sidon sets: the continuous functions with spectrum in Λ have uniformly convergent series, and their Fourier coefficients are in ℓp for all p > 1; moreover, all the Lebesgue spaces LΛq are equal forq < +∞. On the other hand, they are large in the sense that they are dense in the Bohr group and that the space of the bounded functions with spectrum in Λ is nonseparable. So these sets are very different from the thin sets of integers previously known.
Full text
a Xi :0912.4214 1 [ma h.FA] 21 Dec 2009
Some new hin se s o in ege s in
Ha moni Analysis
Daniel Li,
He é Queéle, Luis Rod íguez-Piazza
Abs a
.
We andomly ons u a ious subse s
Λ
o he in ege s whih ha e bo h
smal lness and la geness p ope ies. They a e smal l sine hey a e e y lose, in a ious
meanings, o Sidon se s: he on inuous un ions wi h spe um in
Λ
ha e uni o mly
on e gen se ies, and hei Fou ie oeien s a e in
ℓp
o al l
p > 1
; mo eo e , al l
he Lebesgue spaes
Lq
Λ
a e equal o
q < +∞
. On he o he hand, hey a e la ge in he
sense ha hey a e dense in he Boh g oup and ha he spae o he bounded un ions
wi h spe um in
Λ
is non sepa able. So hese se s a e e y die en om he hin se s
o in ege s p e iously known.
Résumé
.
On ons ui aléa oi emen des ensembles
Λ
d'en ie s posi i s jouissan si-
mul anémen de p op ié és qui les on appa aî e à la ois omme pe i s e omme
g ands. Ils son pe i s a ès p ohes à plus d'un éga d des ensembles de Sidon: les
on ions on inues à spe e dans
Λ
on une sé ie de Fou ie uni o mémen on e -
gen e, e on des oeien s de Fou ie dans
ℓp
pou ou
p > 1
; de plus, ous les
espaes de Lebesgue
Lq
Λ
oïniden pou
q < +∞
. Mais ils son pa ail leu s g ands
au sens où ils son denses dans le ompa ié de Boh e où l'espae des on ions
bo nées à spe e dans
Λ
n'es pas sépa able. Ces ensembles son don ès dié en s
des ensembles mines d'en ie s onnus aupa a an .
Key-wo ds
. e go di se launa y se
Λ(q)
-se quasi-indep enden se
andom se
p
-Ride se Rosen hal se
p
-Sidon se se o uni o m
on e gene uni o mly dis ibu ed se .
Ma hema is Sub je Classia ion
.
P ima y
: 42A36 42A44 42A55
42A61 43A46;
Seonda y
: 60D05
In o du ion
I is well known ha he Fou ie se ies o an in eg able un ion dened on
he uni -i le
T=R/2πZ
o he omplex plane
C
an b e badly b eha ed. Fo
example, i is well known ha he e exis on inuous un ions whose Fou ie
se ies is no e e ywhe e on e gen (see [30℄, Th. 18.1, and Th. 19.5 o he
op imal esul ), and in eg able ones wi h e e ywhe e di e gen Fou ie se ies
(see [30℄, Th. 19.2 o ins ane; see also [29℄).
The p oblem o hin se s o in ege s is he ollowing: ins ead o onside ing
all he in eg able un ions on
T
, o all he on inuous ones, we onside only
1
hose whose sp e um ( he se whe e hei Fou ie o eien s do no anish)
is on ained in a p es ib ed subse
Λ
o he in ege s
Z
. This se
Λ
will b e said
hin i he Fou ie se ies o hese un ions b eha es b e e han in he gene al
ase. A ypial example is
Λ = {1,3,32,...,3n,...}
. I is well known (see [62℄,
o ins ane) ha e e y in eg able un ion
wi h sp e um in
Λ
(
∈L1
Λ
) is
a ually squa e in eg able, and ha e e y on inuous un ion
wi h sp e um
in
Λ
(
∈ CΛ
) has a no mally on e gen Fou ie se ies (equi alen ly
b
∈ℓ1
).
In his seminal pap e [54℄, W. Rudin dened wo no ions o hinness o
Λ
:
Λ
is a Sidon se i
∈ CΛ
implies ha
b
∈ℓ1
, and
Λ
is a
Λ(q)
-se o some
q > 1
,
i
∈L1
Λ
implies ha
∈Lq
. These onep s may as well b e dened in he
mo e gene al se ing o a ompa ab elian g oup
G
equipp ed wi h i s no malized
Haa measu e, and o a subse
Λ
o i s dis e e dual g oup
Γ
.
W. Rudin s udied he gene al p op e ies o hose se s and he onne ion
b e ween he wo no ions. In pa iula , he showed ha Sidon se s a e
Λ(q)
-se s
o all
q < +∞
, and ha , mo e p eisely:
(0.1)
Λ
Sidon implies
k kq≤C√qk k2
o e e y
Λ
-p olynomial
and o e e y
q≥2
, whe e
C
is a ons an whih depends only on he Sidon ons an
o
Λ
.
Sine hen, se e al new no ions o hin se s eme ged. These inlude
p
-Sidon
se s (see [2℄, [3℄, [4℄, [5℄, [14℄, [18℄, [21℄, [23℄, [24℄, [34℄, [47℄, [60℄), and se s o
uni o m on e gene (see [1℄, [19℄, [20℄, [21℄, [26℄, [33℄, [44℄, [45℄, [56℄, [57℄): e e y
on inuous un ion wi h spe um in suh a se has i s Fou ie se iesin
ℓp
o
uni o mly on e gen , esp e i ely. Bu he examples o suh se s we e always
nea ly he same: p o du s (some imes a ional p o du s: [3℄, [4℄, [5℄), o
sums o Sidon se s, whih is a se e e es i ion o he geome y o he Banah
spae
CΛ
. Fo example, F. Lus Piqua d ([40℄) p o ed ha :
(0.2) The inje i e enso p o du
ℓ1b
⊗ε···b
⊗εℓ1
has he Shu p op e y (
i.e.
weakly null sequenes on e ge in no m o ze o).
I ollows easily ha :
(0.3) I
Λ = E1×···×Ek
, whe e he
Ej
's a e Sidon se s, hen
CΛ
has he Shu
p op e y; in pa iula ,
CΛ
do es no on ain
c0
, he spae o sequenes
going o ze o a inni y.
Sine hese se s we e essen ially he only known examples o
p
-Sidon se s
( hey a e exa ly
2N/(N+ 1)
-Sidon), one ould b elie e ha all
p
-Sidon se s
ha e his p op e y. I should b e men ionned ha in [3℄, R. Blei ons u ed o
eah
p∈]1,2[
, exa ly
p
-Sidon se s, using a ional p o du s, so o a die en
yp e, bu he o esp onding spae
CΛ
app ea s as an
ℓ1
-sum o ni e dimensional
spaes, and so do es ha e he Shu p op e y (we hank R. Blei o his ema k).
Beause o his lak o examples, he ompa ison be ween wo lasses o
hin se s p o ed o be e y diul : whe he a
p
-Sidon, o a se o uni o m
on e gene is a
Λ(q)
-se o some
q > 1
is s ill an op en p oblem. On he o he
2
hand, onside able p og ess one ning he Sidon se s o
Λ(q)
-se s has b een
made: o example, G. Pisie ([47℄, Th. 6.2) p o ed ha he on e se o (0.1)
is ue, and J. Bou gain ([12℄) p o ed ha o eah
q > 2
he e exis exa ly
Λ(q)
-se s,
i.e.
se s whih a e
Λ(q)
, bu
Λ(q′)
o no
q′> q
. Bo h au ho s used
andom me ho ds, and mo e sp eially, J. Bou gain p opula ized he me ho d o
sele o s o p o due se e al hin se s
Λ
wi h unusual p op e ies, suh as b eing
uni o mly dis ibu ed, whih implies, by a esul o F. Lus Piqua d ([42℄),
ha
CΛ
on ains
c0
and he e o e is no a Rosen hal se (
i.e.
he e a e b ounded
measu able un ions wi h sp e um in
Λ
wih a e no almos e e ywhe e equal
o a on inuous un ion), and whih also implies ha
Λ
is dense in he Boh
g oup (see [6℄, Theo em 1). This allowed he s named au ho o see ha
he e a e se s o in ege s whih a e
Λ(q)
o all
q < +∞
bu no Rosen hal ([37℄;
see also [43℄).
The aim o his pap e is he ons u ion o andom se s
Λ
o in ege s whih
ha e hinness p op e ies, bu wih a e no Rosen hal se s (
i.e.
CΛ
is no he
whole
L∞
Λ
), a ually suh ha
CΛ
on ains
c0
, and a e dense in he Boh g oup.
In iew o (0.3), hese se s will neessa ily b e e y exo i ompa ed o he
p e iously known examples. This shows ha eplaing absolu e on e gene o
he Fou ie se ies by uni o m on e gene (se s o uni o m on e gene) o by
ℓp
on e gene o
p > 1
(
p
-Sidon se s) gi es se s whih a e e y a om Sidon
se s. This ons as s wi h Pisie 's esul saying ha
Λ
is neessa ily a Sidon
se whene e
b
∈ℓ1,∞
o e e y
∈ CΛ
( om [48℄, Théo ème 2.3 ( i), and he
op o page 688). On he o he hand, hough non-Sidon Rosen hal se s do exis
([53℄), i ollows om Bou gain-Milman's o ype heo em ([13℄) ha , o e e y
non-Sidon se
Λ
,
CΛ
do es on ain
ℓn
∞
uni o mly, so ha he p esene o
c0
inside
CΛ
o non-Sidon
Λ
may app ea no so su p ising. Al hough i is no known
whe he Sidon se s may be dense in he Boh g oup, we ob ain in his pape , as
men ioned ab o e, se s whih a e dense in he Boh g oup, and a e o uni o m
on e gene and
p
-Sidon o e e y
p > 1
.
We ons u essen ially ou ypes o se s. Eah o hem will b e a non
Rosen hal se , bu a se o uni o m on e gene,
Λ(q)
o all
q < +∞
, and wi h
mo eo e addi ional p op e ies o
p
-Sidonii y.
The s one (Theo em 2.2) is a e y launa y se
Λ
wi h he nies p op-
e ies: i is
p
-Sidon o all
p > 1
. The seond and hi d ones (Theo em 2.5 and
Theo em 2.6) a e medium launa y se s: o eah
p
wi h
1< p < 4/3
, hey a e,
in Theo em 2.5,
p
-Ride (a weake p op e y han b eing
p
-Sidon, see he deni-
ion b elow), bu no
q
-Ride o
q < p
, and a e
q
-Sidon o e e y
q > p/(2 −p) ;
and in Theo em 2.6, hey a e
q
-Ride o e e y
q > p
, bu no
p
-Ride , and hey
a e
q
-Sidon o e e y
q > p/(2 −p)
. Finally, he ou h ype (Theo em 2.7) is a
se
Λ
whih is, in some sense as li le launa y as possible i we wan i s ae on
eah in e al
[N, 2N[
o ha e a b ounded Sidon ons an . I leads o se s whih
a e 4/3-Ride , bu no
q
-Ride o
q < 4/3
.
We ons u hese se s by using a ious hoies o sele o s, and adding
a i hme ial, un ional o p obabilis i a gumen s. The ea men o he las
ase equi es a die en p obabilis i app oah, aken om [8℄.
3
I should b e no ed ha in he wo s ases he se s a e uni o mly dis-
ibu ed; in he ou h ase , howe e , he se s
Λ
only ha e p osi i e upp e
densi y in uni o mly dis ibu ed se s. Ne e heless,
CΛ
s ill on ains
c0
, by a
esul o F. Lus -Piqua d ([42℄, Th. 5).
Aknowledgemen .
Pa o his pap e was made when he s named au ho
was a gues o he Depa amen o de Análisis Ma emá io de la Uni e sidad de
Se illa in Ap il 1999, and when he hi d named au ho was a gues o he
Uni e si é d'A ois in Lens in june 1999.
1 No a ion, deni ions and p elimina y esul s
We deno e by
T
he ompa ab elian g oup o omplex numb e s o mo dulus
one, equipp ed wi h i s no malized Haa measu e
m
.
C(T)
deno es he spae o
on inuous omplex un ions dened on
T
, equipp ed wi h i s
sup
no m
kk∞
and
iden ied as usual wi h he spae o on inuous
2π
-p e io di omplex un ions
dened on
R
. I
Λ
is a subse o he dual g oup
Z
,
CΛ
will deno e he subspae
o
C(T)
onsis ing o un ions whose sp e um lies in
Λ
:
b
(n)≡ZT
e−ndm = 0
i
n∈Z Λ,
whe e
en(z) = zn
, o equi alen ly,
en( ) = ein
.
CΛ
is he uni o m losu e o he spae
PΛ
o igonome i p olynomials wi h
sp e um in
Λ
,
i.e.
he uni o m losu e o he subspae
PΛ
gene a ed by he
ha a e s
en
, wi h
n∈Λ
.
Fo
∈ C(T)
,
1≤q < +∞
,
M
and
N
p osi i e in ege s, we shall deno e he
Fou ie sums o
by:
SM,N ( ) =
N
X
−Mb
(n)en
and he symme i Fou ie sums o
by:
SN( ) = SN,N ( ) =
N
X
−Nb
(n)en.
|A|
deno es he a dinali y o he ni e se
A
.
A
ela ion
in
Λ⊆Z∗≡Z {0}
is a
(+1,−1,0)
- alued sequene
(θk)k∈Λ
suh ha
P|θk|<+∞
and
Pθkk= 0
. The se
S={k;θk6= 0}
is alled he
suppo
o he he ela ion, and
|S|=P|θk|
is alled i s
leng h
.
The ela ion
(θ′
k)k∈Λ
is said o b e
longe
han he ela ion
(θk)k∈Λ
i
θk6= 0
implies
θk=θ′
k
.
The se
Λ⊆Z∗
is
quasi-independen
i i on ains no non- i ial ela ion
(
i.e.
wi h non-emp y supp o ). Typially,
Λ = {1,2,4,...,2n,...}
is quasi-
indep enden . The quasi-indep enden se s a e he p o o ype o Sidon se s,
i.e.
4
o se s
Λ
o whih:
kb
k1≤Kk k∞
o all
∈ CΛ
. The b es ons an
K
in his
inequali y is alled he Sidon ons an o
Λ
and is deno ed by
S(Λ)
. We will e e
o [39℄ o s anda d no ions on Sidon se s. I is known ha quasi-independen
se s a e no only Sidon se s bu hei Sidon ons an is bounded by an absolu e
ons an : his ollows om [54℄, Th. 2.4 and [49℄, Lemma 1.7. O he p o o s
an b e ound in [48℄, lemme 3.2, and in [9℄, P op. 1. We shall use he a ha
S(Λ) ≤8
i
Λ
is quasi-indep enden .
Le us eall now some lassial deni ions and esul s.
A se
Λ⊆Z
is said o b e a
Λ(q)
-se
(whe e
q > 2
) i he e exis s a p osi i e
ons an
Cq
suh ha
k kq≤Cqk k2
o e e y
∈ PΛ
.
The no ion o a
Λ(q)
-se is, in some sense, lo al. Tha ollows om he
Li lewo o d-Paley heo y. The nex p op osi ion is essen ially well-known, exep
o he g ow h o he ons an , o whih we ha e ound no e e ene. Ao d-
ingly, we oe a sho p o o .
P op osi ion 1.1
Le
Λ⊆[2,+∞[
. Then:
(a)
Le
(Mn)n≥1
be a sequene o posi i e in ege s suh ha
M1≤2
and
Mn+1/Mn≥α > 1
. I
Λ∩[Mn, Mn+1[
,
n≥1
, has a uni o mly bounded Sidon
ons an , hen
Λ
is
Λ(q)
o al l
q≥2
; mo e p eisely:
k kq≤C(q, α)k k2
o
e e y
∈ PΛ
.
(b)
I
Λ∩[2n,2n+1[
,
n≥1
, has a uni o mly bounded Sidon ons an ,
Λ
is
Λ(q)
o e e y
q≥2
and, mo e p eisely:
k kq≤Cq2k k2
o e e y
∈ PΛ
and o some nume ial ons an
C
.
P o o .
(a) Se
k=X
Mk≤n<Mk+1 b
(n)en
and
S =+∞
X
k=1 | k|21/2.
Sine
Mk+1/Mk≥α > 1
and
Λ⊆[M1,+∞[
, we ha e ([62℄, Chap. XV, Th.
2.1):
k kq≤C0(q, α)kS kq.
Now, using he 2-on exi y o he
Lq
-no m o
q≥2
, we ob ain:
kS kq≤+∞
X
k=1 k kk2
q1/2.
Bu
k∈ PΛk
, whe e
Λk= Λ ∩[Mk, Mk+1[
has a uni o mly b ounded Sidon
ons an . The e o e
k kkq≤C1√qk k2
, whe e
C1
is a nume ial ons an . The
esul ollows.
(b) We now make use o he lassial squa e un ion
Sg =X
k∈Z|gk|21/2,
5
whe e
gk=X
2k≤n<2k+1 bg(n)en,i k≥0 and gk=X
−2|k|+1<n≤−2|k|bg(n)eni k < 0.
Fo his lassial squa e un ion, we ha e he ollowing sha p inequali y, due
o J. Bou gain ([11℄, Th. 1):
kSgkp≤C0(p−1)−3/2kgkp o 1 < p ≤2,
whe e
C0
is a nume ial ons an . We dedue by duali y ha :
k kq≤C0q3/2kS kq o 2 ≤q < +∞.
In a , by o hogonali y ( eall ha
∈ PΛ
and ha
Λ⊆[2,+∞[
) and he
CauhyShwa z inequali y, we ha e, o e e y
g∈Lp
wi h
kgkp= 1
(
1/p +
1/q = 1
):
|< , g > |=
+∞
X
k=1
< k, gk>=ZT
+∞
X
k=1
k(− )gk( )dm( )
≤ZT
S (− )Sg( )dm( )
≤ kS kqkSgkp≤C0(p−1)−3/2kS kq
≤C0q3/2kS kq.
This means ha he e we a e allowed o ake
C0(q, 2) = C0q3/2
in pa (a) o
he p o o . The es is unhanged, and we an also ake
C(q, 2) = C1√qC0q3/2=
Cq2
.
A se
Λ⊆Z
is alled a
se o uni o m on e gene
(in sho a
UC-se
) i , o
any
∈ CΛ
, he symme i Fou ie sums
SN( )
on e ge uni o mly o
. I s
ons an o uni o m on e gene
U(Λ)
is he smalles ons an
K
suh ha , o
any
∈ CΛ
:
sup
NkSN( )k∞≤Kk k∞.
The ollowing a ian u ns ou o b e mo e a able ([56℄).
Λ
is alled a
se
o omple e uni o m on e gene
(in sho a CUC-se ) i he ansla es (
Λ+a
) a e
uni o mly UC o
a∈Z
, o equi alen ly, i he Fou ie sums
SM,N ( )
on e ge
uni o mly o
as
M, N
go o
+∞
, o e e y
∈ CΛ
.
The wo no ions u n ou o b e dis in ([20℄), bu lea ly oinide i
Λ⊆N
,
whih will always be he ase in he sequel. The no ion o CUC-se is also a
lo al one as he ollowing p op osi ion shows.
P op osi ion 1.2 ([57℄, Th. 3)
Le
Λ⊆N∗
and
ΛN= Λ ∩[N, 2N[
.
(a)
I
U(ΛN)
is bounded by
K
o
N= 1,2,...
, hen
Λ
is a
CUC
-se .
(b)
Le
(Mn)n≥1
be a sequene o posi i e in ege s suh ha
Mn+1/Mn≥2
.
Then, i
Λ∩[Mn, Mn+1[
a e quasi-independen o eah
n
, o mo e gene al ly i
hey a e Sidon se s wi h uni o mly bounded Sidon ons an , hen
Λ
is a
CUC
-se .
6
Rema k.
(b) is a use ul i e ion o p o due se s ha a e CUC bu no Sidon;
o ins ane, i
Λ = S+∞
n=1{2n+ 2j;j= 0,...,n−1}
, hen
Λ∩[2n,2n+1[
is
quasi-indep enden , whe eas
Λ∩[1, N]
has abou
(log N)2
elemen s, and he e o e
anno b e Sidon ( he mesh ondi ion o Sidon se s, see P op osi ion 1.6 b elow,
is iola ed).
The andom a iables whih we shall use will always be dened on some
p obabili y spae
(Ω,A,P)
whih will play no explii ole, and he exp e a ion
wi h esp e o
P
will always b e deno ed by
E
:
E(X) = ZΩ
X(ω)dP(ω).
Reall he (mo e o less) lassial de ia ion inequali y (see [32℄, 6.3):
Lemma 1.3
Le
X1,...,XN
be independen en e ed omplex andom a iables
suh ha
|Xk| ≤ 1
,
k= 1,...,N
. Le
σ≥
N
P
k=1
E|Xk|2
. Then, one has, o e e y
a≤σ
:
P(|X1+···+XN| ≥ a)≤4 exp(−a2/8σ).
Le
( n)n
b e a Be noulli sequene,
i.e.
a sequene o indep enden andom
a iables suh ha :
P( n= 1) = P( n=−1) = 1/2.
Fo
∈ P
, he spae o igonome i p olynomials,
[[ ]]
deno es he no m o
in he Pisie 's spae
C
a.s.
:
[[ ]] = E
X
n
nb
(n)en
∞.
See [25℄ and [47℄ o mo e in o ma ion ab ou his no m.
Deni ion 1.4
A se
Λ⊆Z
is al led a
p
-Sidon se (
1≤p < 2
) i he e exis s
a ons an
K
suh ha
kb
kp≤Kk k∞
o al l
∈ PΛ
.
I is said o be a
p
-Ride se i he e exis s a ons an
K
suh ha
kb
kp≤
K[[ ]]
o al l
∈ PΛ
.
p
-Ride se s we e implii ely in odued, wi h die en deni ion, in [18℄
(Th. 2.4), and in [23℄, p. 213, as lass
Tp
(see also [47℄, Th. 6.3). They we e
explii ely dened and s udied in [51℄ and [52℄ unde he name
p
-Sidon p esque
sû s. We used almos su ely
p
-Sidon se in he s e sion o his pap e , bu ,
ollowing a sugges ion o J.-P. Kahane, we now use he e minology
p
-Ride .
Clea ly, e e y
p
-Sidon se is
p
-Ride . The on e se is ue o
p= 1
: his
is a ema kable esul due o D. Ride ([50℄), making le e use o D u y's
on olu ion de ie (whih p o es ha he union o wo Sidon se s is Sidon [17℄).
Whe he his on e se is s ill ue o
1< p < 2
is an op en p oblem.
7
Deni ion 1.5
We shal l say ha a ni e se
B⊆Λ
is
M
-pseudo-omplemen ed
in
Λ
i he e exis s a measu e
µ
on
T
suh ha :
|bµ| ≥ 1
on
B;bµ= 0
on
Λ B;kµk ≤ M .
The ollowing p op osi ion gi es some neessa y, suien , o neessa y and
suien ondi ions o a se
Λ
o b e
p
-Sidon o
p
-Ride . Pa (b) o his
p op osi ion seems o b e new.
P op osi ion 1.6
Le
Λ⊆Z∗
and
1≤p < 2
. Se
ε(p) = 2/p −1
. Then:
(a)
Λ
is a
p
-Ride se i and only i he e exis s a ons an
δ > 0
suh ha ,
o e e y ni e se
A⊆Λ
, he e exis s a quasi-independen subse
B⊆A
suh
ha
|B| ≥ δ|A|ε(p)
.
(b)
Le
q0>1
. I he e exis s a ons an
δ > 0
suh ha , o e e y ni e se
A⊆Λ
, he e exis s a quasi-independen subse
B⊆A
suh ha
|B| ≥ δ|A|1/q0
and i
B
an mo eo e be aken
M
-pseudo-omplemen ed in
Λ
, o some xed
M
, hen
Λ
is a
q
-Sidon se o e e y
q > q0
.
()
I
Λ
is a
p
-Ride se , we ha e he ol lowing mesh ondi ion:
|Λ∩[1, N]| ≤ C(log N)p/(2−p).
P o o .
We e e o [51℄ o he p o o o (a) and (). To p o e (b), le
∈ PΛ
,
x
> 0
, and se
A={|b
|> }
. Take
B⊆A
and
µ
as in Deni ion 1.4. Then
B
is a Sidon se wi h Sidon ons an
≤8
, and sine
∗µ=P
n∈Bb
(n)bµ(n)en
,
k k∞≥M−1
X
Bb
(n)bµ(n)en
∞≥1
8MX
B|b
(n)||bµ(n)|
≥1
8MX
B|b
(n)| ≥ |B|
8M≥ δ|A|1/q0
8M·
In o he wo ds, o some ons an
C > 0
, one has:
.|{|b
|> }|1/q0≤Ck k∞,
o e e y
> 0,
whih means ha he Lo en z no m o
b
in he Lo en z spae
ℓq0,∞
is domina ed
by
k k∞
.
Now,
ℓq0,∞
is on inuously inje ed in
ℓq
o
q > q0
(see o ins ane [38℄, I I
p. 143), and his gi es he desi ed esul .
We deno e, as usual, by
c0
he lassial spae o sequenes
x= (xn)n≥0
ending o ze o a inni y, equipp ed wi h he no m
kxk= supn|xn|
. We say, in
he usual amilia way, ha a Banah spae
X
on ains
c0
i
X
has a losed
subspae isomo phi o
c0
. Ou no a ion o Banah spaes is lassial, as an
b e ound in [16℄, [38℄ o [59℄ o ins ane.
A subse
Λ
o
Z
is said o b e a
Rosen hal se
i e e y b ounded measu able
un ion on
T
wi h spe um in
Λ
is almos e e ywhe e equal o a on inuous
8
un ion (in sho
L∞
Λ=CΛ
).
Λ
is no Rosen hal i and only i
L∞
Λ
is no
sepa able, so suh a se an b e hough as being a big se .
E e y Sidon se is lea ly Rosen hal, bu H.P. Rosen hal ga e examples o
non-Sidon se s whih a e Rosen hal ([53℄). We shall make use o he ollowing
well known nega i e i e ion (see [41℄, 3), whih ollows om he lassial
heo em o C. Bessaga and A. Peªzy«ski ([38℄, I.2.e.8), saying ha a dual spae
whih on ains
c0
has o on ain also
ℓ∞
.
P op osi ion 1.7
I
CΛ
on ains
c0
, hen
Λ
is no a Rosen hal se .
Deni ion 1.8
Le
Λ⊆N∗≡N {0}
, and se
ΛN= Λ ∩[1, N]
and
AN( ) = 1
|ΛN|X
n∈ΛN
en( ).
We say ha
Λ
is:
-
e go di
i
(AN( ))N≥1
on e ges o a limi
lΛ( )∈C
o eah
∈T
.
-
s ongly e go di
i i is e godi and mo eo e he limi un ion
lΛ
denes
an elemen o
c0(T)
: o e e y
ε > 0
he se
{ ∈T;|lΛ( )|> ε }
is ni e.
-
uni o mly dis ibu ed
i i is (s ongly) e godi and, mo eo e ,
lΛ( ) = 0
o
6= 0
mod.
2π
.
The eason o his e minology is ha he e go di se s a e hose o whih
an e go di heo em holds:
(1/|ΛN|)Pn∈ΛNTn
on e ges in he s ong op e a o
op ology o e e y on a ion
T
o a Hilb e spae. Typially, he se o
d h
p e e p owe s, o he se o p ime numbe s a e s ongly e go di (ao ding
o he esul o Vinog ado o
i a ional mo d.
2π
, and o he Di ihle 's
a i hme i p og ession heo em o
a ional mo d.
2π
). The hi d name omes
om H. Weyl's lassial i e ion o he equidis ibu ion o a eal sequene mo d.
2π
.
The ela ionship b e ween hese no ions omes om:
Theo em 1.9 (F. Lus -Piqua d [42℄)
Le
Λ⊆[1,+∞[
be a se o posi i e
in ege s. Then:
(a)
I
Λ
is s ongly e godi,
CΛ
on ains
c0.
(b)
Mo e gene al ly, i
Λ
is s ongly e godi and
D⊆Λ
has a posi i e uppe
densi y wi h espe o
Λ
, hen
CD
on ains
c0
as wel l.
He e p osi i e upp e densi y means ha :
lim
N→+∞|D∩[1, N]|
|Λ∩[1, N]|>0.
Pa (b) will b e use ul o us in he las heo em o Se ion 2.
See [42℄ o he p o o o his heo em. The unde lying idea o (a) is ha
i
AN( )→lΛ( )
o e e y
∈T
,
lΛ
denes an elemen o he bio hogonal
C⊥⊥
Λ
, and he ondi ion
lΛ∈c0(T)
implies ha i is he sum o a weakly un-
ondi ionally Cauhy se ies o on inuous un ions. By using a p e u ba ion
9
Pu
ν=δ0−VMn
, whe e
δ0
is he Di a p oin mass a
0
, and
VMn
he
de la Vallée-Poussin ke nel o o de
Mn
. Conside he Riesz p o du
R=
Q
k∈B
(1 + Reek)
, and se
µ= 2ν∗R
. We laim ha :
kµk ≤ 8 ; bµ≥1
on
B;bµ= 0
on
Λ B.
Indeed,
kνk ≤ 4
and
B
is quasi-indep enden , so he Riesz p o du
R
e ies
kRk=b
R(0) = 1
. The e o e
kµk ≤ 8
.
Take
l∈B
. Then
l > 2Mn
and
bν(l) = 1
. As
b
R(l)≥1/2
, we ha e
bµ(l)≥1
.
I
A⊆Λ
and
|A|ε≤n1
, any single on
B
o
A
is quasi-indep enden ,
1
-
omplemen ed in
Λ
, and
|B| ≥ n−1
1|A|ε
.
We ha e hus e ied he hyp o hesis o pa (b) o P op osi ion 1.6, and so
Λ
is
q
-Sidon o any
q > 1/ε
. In pa iula , i is
p
-Sidon, and his ends he p oo
o Theo em 2.2.
Rema k 1.
The p o o shows ha we an a ually ex a om
A
, o e e y
α > 0
, a quasi-indep enden se
B
suh ha
|B| ≥ δ|A|/(log |A|)2+α
. Mo eo e ,
a sligh modia ion leads o se s e en lose o Sidon se s.
P op osi ion 2.4
Le
α > 1
and
ϕα
be he O liz un ion
x7→ xlog(1+x)α
.
Then, he e exis s a se
Λ
as in Theo em 2.2 , and mo eo e suh ha
b
∈ℓϕα,∞
o e e y
∈ CΛ
.
Reall ha
ℓϕα,∞
is he weak O liz-Lo en z spae o sequenes
(an)n
suh
ha
sup
n
ϕ−1
α(n)a∗
n<+∞
, whe e
(a∗
n)n
is he non-in easing ea angemen o
(|an|)n
. The e o e, ano he way o ph ase he p op osi ion is, se ing
an=b
(n)
:
a∗
n≤Cαk k∞(log n)α/n
o e e y
∈ CΛ.
The p o o jus onsis s in hanging
Mn
. We ake
Mn=en(log log n)2
, whe e
[ ]
s ands o he in ege pa . We s ill ha e
P
n
PΩn(Mn)<+∞
, sine
PΩn(Mn)≤2Cn
nn
(log Mnlog log Mn)n
Mn≤exp −n(log log n)2/2
o
n
la ge enough. A guing as p e iously, we ge o e e y ni e subse
A
o
Λ
, a
quasi-indep enden subse
B
o
A
suh ha
|B| ≥ δ|A|/(log |A|)α
, and suh ha
CB
is uni o mly pseudo-omplemen ed in
CA
. As in he p o o o P oposi ion 1.6,
we ob ain
|{|b
|> }| ≤ C ϕαk k∞
,
whih gi es he esul (a guing as in [34℄ o ins ane).
We anno elimina e a loga i hmi a o , and eplae
α > 1
by
α > 0
b eause, due o Bou gain's i e ion, we ha e o assume ha
σn/log n
go es o
16
inni y in o de ha
CΛ
on ains
c0
. Howe e , o eah
α > 0
, he e do exis
non-Sidon se s
Λ
o whih
b
∈ℓϕα
when
∈ CΛ
(as an b e seen om [5℄, p.
69).
The se
Λ
is, in some sense, e y lose o b e Sidon, whe eas
CΛ
on ains
c0
.
Howe e , i anno be o o lose wi hou b eing Sidon beause i
b
∈ℓ1,∞
, he
Lo en z spae weak-
ℓ1
, o e e y
∈ CΛ
, hen
Λ
is Sidon. In a , his ondi ion
implies an inequali y o he ype:
|{|b
| ≥ }| ≤ C
k k∞(∗)
o e e y
∈ CΛ
. Le now
A
b e a ni e subse o
Λ
, and
=P
n∈A
en
and
ω=P
n∈A
n(ω)en
, whe e
n
,
n≥1
a e he Rademahe un ions. Then,
inequali y (
(∗)
) applied wi h
= 1
gi es
k ωk∞≥(1/C)|A|
. In eg a ing in
ω
gi es
[[ ]] ≥(1/C)|A|
, om whih ollows, by a esul o G. Pisie ([48℄, Théo ème
2.3 ( i)), ha
Λ
is a Sidon se .
Rema k 2.
I one akes sele o s o mean
δn
suh ha
nδn
is b ounded, he
o esp onding andom se
Λ(ω)
is almos su ely a Sidon se . This is a well-known
esul o Y. Ka znelson and P. Mallia in ([28℄, o [27℄), and Lemma 2.1 gi es
ano he p o o o his a . I sues o ake
Mn=An
, whe e
A
is a gi en in ege ,
la ge enough o ha e
P+∞
n=1 PΩn(Mn)<1
. Then, wi h posi i e p obabili y
Λ(ω)∩[Mn,+∞[
on ains no ela ion o leng h
≤n
, whe eas
|Λ(ω)∩[1, Mn]| ≤
Cn
. Hene, o e e y ni e subse
A
o
Λ(ω)
, we an nd a quasi-indep enden
subse
B⊆A
suh ha
|B| ≥ δ|A|
, o some xed
δ=δ(ω)
. I ollows om
Pisie 's ha a e iza ion ([48℄, Th. 2.3 (i )) ha , wi h p osi i e p obabili y, and
hene almos su ely by Kolmogo o 's
0−1
law,
Λ(ω)
is a Sidon se .
As is now well-known, Sidon se s a e ha a e ized by a ious p op e ies
(suessi ely weake ) o he Banah spae
CΛ
:
Λ
is a Sidon se
i
CΛ
is isomo -
phi o
ℓ1
([58℄),
i
CΛ
has o yp e 2 ([31℄, Th. 3.1, [46℄), and
i
CΛ
has a ni e
o yp e ([13℄). This la e p op e y an b e exp essed by saying ha
CΛ
do es no
on ain
ℓn
∞
uni o mly. So, de e minis ially, one has he diho omy:
(a) ei he
Λ
is a Sidon se , and so
CΛ
is isomo phi o
ℓ1
;
(b) o
CΛ
on ains
ℓn
∞
uni o mly.
The p obabilis i diho omy is s onge : aking sele o s o mean
δ1, δ2,...
,
wi h
(δn)n
de easing, one has:
(a) ei he almos su ely
Λ
is a Sidon se (i
nδn
is b ounded);
(b) o almos su ely
CΛ
on ains
c0
(i
nδn
is no bounded), and
Λ
is e en
uni o mly dis ibu ed.
Y. Ka znelson ([27℄) al eady no ied suh a diho omy: he showed ha
(unde a die en hoie o sele o s om ou s) ei he almos su ely
Λ
is a
Sidon se , o almos su ely
Λ
is dense in he Boh g oup. Howe e , his is
p e haps no a ue diho omy sine i is a well-known op en p oblem whe he
he e an exis Sidon se s dense in he Boh g oup (see [15℄, ques ion 2, p. 14;
17
i is s a ed o he Boh g oup o
R
, bu also makes sense o he Boh g oup o
Z
).
The diho omy s a ed he e s eng hens Ka znelson's esul sine e e y uni-
o mly dis ibu ed se is dense in he Boh g oup (see [6℄, Theo em 1); indeed,
saying ha
Λ = {λ1, λ2,...}
is uni o mly dis ibu ed means ha he measu es
µN= 1/N
+∞
P
n=1
δλn
(
δλn
is he e he Di a measu e a he poin
λn
) on e ge
weak-s a o he Haa measu e
µ
o he Boh g oup
bZ
; bu hese measu es a e
a ied by
Λ
, so he losed supp o o
µ
is on ained in he Boh losu e o
Λ ;
sine he Haa measu e is on inuous, we ge ha his losu e is he whole Boh
g oup.
Rema k 3.
The andom se s
Λ
ha we ons u ha e an asymp o ial quasi-
indep endene:
Λ∩[Mn,+∞[
on ains no ela ion o leng h
≤n
. This is eminis-
en o he ollowing esul o J. Bou gain ([7℄): i
Λ
is a Sidon se and
n∈N∗
,
he e exis s
ln=l(Λ, n)
suh ha
Λ
an b e deomp osed in
ln
se s
Λ1,...,Λln
,
eah o whih on ains no ela ion o leng h
≤n
.
We now in es iga e wha happ ens when we le
p
in ease away om
1
.We
ge se e al die en esul s, and
p= 4/3
seems o play a sp eial ole.
We s s a e wo e y simila esul s.
Theo em 2.5
Fo e e y
1< p < 4/3
, he e exis s a se
Λ
o in ege s whih is:
(1)
uni o mly dis ibu ed (so
Λ
is dense in he Boh g oup,
CΛ
on ains
c0
,
and
Λ
is no a Rosen hal se ), and whih is:
(2)
Λ(q)
o al l
q < +∞
, a
CUC
-se , and mo eo e is:
(a)
p
-Ride , bu no
q
-Ride o
q < p
(b)
q
-Sidon o al l
q > p/(2 −p)
.
Theo em 2.6
Same as Theo em 2.5, exep ha , ins ead o
(a)
,
Λ
is:
(a')
q
-Ride o e e y
q > p
, bu is no
p
-Ride .
Rema k.
A e his pap e was omple ed, P. Le è e and he hi d-named
au ho p o ed ([36℄) ha e e y
p
-Ride se wi h
p < 4/3
is a
q
-Sidon se , o all
q > p/(2 −p)
. A weake , unpublished, esul , due o J. Bou gain, is quo ed in
[15℄, p. 41. Hene ondi ion (b) always ollows om ondi ion (a), and is no
sp ei o he ons u ion. We do no know whe he his gap b e ween
p
and
p/(2 −p)
ollows only om ehnial easons. Fo
p > 1
, whe he e e y
p
-Ride
se is a ually
p
-Sidon is an op en ques ion.
In Theo em 2.5, we ob ain se s whih a e
p
-Ride bu no
q
-Ride o
q < p
.
We do no know i hese se s a e
p
-Sidon, so exa ly
p
-Sidon, in he e minology
o R. Blei. He ons u ed suh se s using a ional p o du s ([3℄, [4℄). We
may all he se s in Theo em 2.5
exa ly
p
-Ride se s
. The se s app ea ing
in Theo em 2.6 a e o a die en kind. We may all hem
exa ly
p+
-Ride
se s
. Suh se s we e also ob ained in [3℄, Co ol. 1.7 d), whe e hey we e alled
exa ly non-
p
-Sidon, and we e alled asymp o i
p
-Sidon in [5℄.
18
P o o .
I is simila o ha o Theo em 2.2, so we shall be e y ske hy.
Le
α= 2(p−1)/(2 −p)∈] 0,1 [
.
Fo Theo em 2.5, we use sele o s
εk
o mean
δk=c(log k)α
k(log log k)α+1
o
k≥4.
As in Lemma 2.3, we ha e, wi h
Mn=nn
,
Pn≥1PΩn(Mn)<+∞
, and
almos su ely
C0nα+1 ≤ |ΛMn| ≤ C1nα+1
and
|Λ′
n| ≤ C1nα
o
n
la ge enough.
Fo Theo em 2.6, we in ease he means
δk
sligh ly, eplaing hem by
δk=c(log k)αlog log k
k·
Rema k.
In o de o p o e ou heo ems, we used sele o s wi h a ious means.
They a e smalle in Theo em 2.2 han in Theo em 2.5, o ins ane. We ema k
ha sele o s
(εk)k
o mean
δk
wi h
δk≤δ′
k
may b e ahie ed as he p o du
o wo indep enden sequenes o sele o s
(ε′
k)k
and
(ε′′
k)k
o mean
δ′
k
and
δ′′
k=
δk/δ′
k
. I ollows ha , o example, he se s in Theo em 2.2 may b e ons u ed
inside he esp e i e se s o Theo em 2.5.
In Theo em 2.5, he p o o ha
Λ
was
CUC
o
Λ(q)
was based on he a
ha
|Λ′
n| ⊆ Λ∩[Mn,+∞[
is quasi-indep enden . Fo
α≥1
(
i.e.
p≥4/3
), we
no longe ha e
|Λ′
n| ≤ n
, and he e o e,
a p io i
, mus gi e up hese p op e ies.
Howe e , we an use ano he ex a ion p oedu e. This p oedu e was s
in o dued by J. Bou gain ([8℄); la e , a lea s a emen was gi en in [52℄, I I I.2.
Sine his las e e ene is ha dly a ailable, we p e e o gi e a sel -on ained
p o o .
The o esp onding se
Λ(ω)
o in ege s ha we shall ob ain in his manne
sa ises
|Λ(ω)∩[2n,2n+1[| ∼ n∼log 2n
, whih is he limi ing ondi ion o mesh
(on a i hme i p og essions) o Sidon se s. This size is in some sense he la ges
p ossible i we wan o ob ain a se
Λ
wi h blo ks ha ing a uni o mly b ounded
Sidon ons an .
Theo em 2.7
The e exis s a se
Λ
o in ege s whih is uni o mly dis ibu ed
and on ains a subse
E⊆N∗
whih is:
(1)
4/3
-Ride , and no
q
-Ride o
q < 4/3
; a
CUC
-se ; a
Λ(q)
-se o al l
q < +∞
(mo e p eisely, o al l
q > 2
, we ha e:
k kq≤Cq2k k2
o al l
∈ PE
, whe e
C > 0
is a nume ial ons an ), and ne e heless,
(2)
has posi i e uppe densi y in
Λ
, so, in pa iula ,
CE
on ains
c0
, and
E
is no a Rosen hal se .
Le
A
b e a ni e subse o in ege s. Fo he p o o , i will be on enien o
dene:
ψA= sup
p≥2
keAkp
√p,
whe e
eA=X
k∈A
ek.
We need he ollowing simple es ima e o
ψA
.
19
Lemma 2.8
Le
I= [a+1, a+N]
be an in e al o in ege s o leng h
N
,
N≥3
.
Then:
ψI≤N
√2 log N·
P o o .
Fo
p≥2
,
|eI|p≤Np−2|eI|2
, so
R|eI|pdm ≤Np−2R|eI|2dm =Np−1
and
keIkp/√p≤N1−1/p/√p
. Op imizing gi es
p= 2 log N
(
≥2
), and he
lemma.
This es ima e is essen ially op imal. Indeed, i is well-known ha
ψI
is
uni o mly equi alen o
θ=keIkΨ
(
k kΨ
b eing he no m asso ia ed o he
O liz un ion
Ψ(x) = ex2−1
). Bu , o some ons an
γ
,
|eI( )| ≥ γN
o
in
an in e al
J
o leng h
≥γN−1
a ound
0
, so one has:
2≥ZJ
exp |eI|2
θ2dm ≥γN−1exp γ2N2
θ2,
whene
θ≥γ−1N/plog 2γ−1N
.
We now use sele o s
εk
o mean
δk=c n/2n
o
2n≤k < 2n+1
, whe e
c > 0
is a gi en ons an .
Se
In= [2n,2n+1[, n ≥2 ; δk=cn
2n
i
k∈In.
No e ha
(δk)k
de eases, and
δk
is o he o m
αk/k
, whe e
(αk)k
go es o
+∞
.
I
Λ = Λ(ω)
is he o esp onding se o in ege s, i will b e on enien o se :
Λn= Λ ∩In;σn=E|Λn|=X
k∈In
δk=cn .
Fo his p o o , he alue o
ψIn
is somewha la ge, and equi es
c
b e su-
ien ly small, say
c≤1/576
. We p e e o ollow ano he ou e, whih ould b e
use ul in o he on ex s, by ho osing also a andom se in
In
o whih he
ψ
ons an is small enough. We make he wo andom hoies a he same ime.
Namely, we onside
(ε′
n)n≥1
, a seond sequene o sele o s, indep enden o
(εn)n≥1
, wi h xed mean
τ
, and se
Λ′
n(ω) = {k∈Λn(ω) ; ε′
k(ω) = 1}
. In sho :
Λ′
n={k∈Λn;ε′
k= 1}; Λ′=
+∞
[
n=1
Λ′
n.
The ollowing lemma, whih is a sligh modia ion o Bou gain's ons u-
ion in [8℄, is eally he hea o he p oo .
Lemma 2.9
Almos su ely, o
n
la ge enough, one has:
(1)
(c/2) n≤ |Λn| ≤ (2c)n
and
(cτ/2) n≤ |Λ′
n| ≤ (2cτ)n
(2)
Λ′
n
on ains a mos ela ions o leng h
≤ln
, whe e
ln= [144 c2τ2n]
.
20
P o o o Lemma 2.9.
We ha e al eady seen ha :
P|Λn|−σn≥σn
2≤exp −σn
32 = exp −c n
32 ,
so, by he Bo el-Can elli lemma,
|Λn|
is almos su ely b e ween
(c/2) n
and
(2c)n
o
n
la ge enough; and his p o es he s hal o (1). The seond hal holds
o he same eason, sine
Λ′
n
o esp onds o sele o s
εkε′
k
wi h mean
(cτ)n/2n
o
k∈In
.
The p o o o (2) is mo e elab o a e.
Fix
n
, and onside he andom igonome i p olynomial:
Fω=
|In|
X
j=ln+1 X
R⊆In
|R|=jY
k∈R
εk(ω)ε′
k(ω)ek+e−k.
Se :
Nn(ω) = ZT
Fω( )dm( ).
Expanding
Fω
, we see ha :
Fω( ) =
|In|
X
j=ln+1 X
R⊆In
|R|=j
X
θk∈{−1,+1}RY
k∈R
εk(ω)ε′
k(ω)eθk
k( )
=
|In|
X
j=ln+1 X
R⊆In
|R|=jX
θk∈{−1,+1}R
ei Pk∈Rθkk.
The on ibu ion o
Nn(ω)
o an exp onen ial o his sum is
0
i
P
k∈R
θkk6= 0
,
and is
1
i
P
k∈R
θkk= 0
. The e o e,
Nn(ω)
is exa ly he numbe o ela ions o
leng h
> ln
in
Λ′
n
.
We laim ha
Nn(ω)
is almos su ely ze o o
n
la ge enough. To ha
ee , we ma jo ize he exp e a ion
J
o
Nn(ω)
, using Fubini's heo em. Indeed,
J=RTH( )dm( )
, whe e:
H( ) = ZΩ
Fω( )dP(ω) =
|In|
X
j=ln+1 X
R⊆In
|R|=j
δjY
k∈R
(ek+e−k).
and
δ=cτ n/2n
. Hene:
J=
|In|
X
j=ln+1 X
R⊆In
|R|=j
δjZTY
k∈R(ek( ) + e−k( )dm( ).
21
A his s age, i is use ul o obse e ha :
X
R⊆In
|R|=j
ZTY
k∈Rek( ) + e−k( )dm( )
≤1
j!ZTX
k∈In(ek( ) + e−k( )jdm( ).
(3)
Indeed, when we expand
X
k∈In(ek( ) + e−k( )j,
eah e m
Qk∈Rek( ) + e−k( )
app ea s
j!
imes, whe eas he o he e ms on
he igh hand side o (3) a e p osi i e. I now ollows om (3) ha :
J≤
|In|
X
j=ln+1
δj
j!ZTX
k∈In(ek( ) + e−k( )jdm( )
≤
|In|
X
j=ln+1
δj
j!2j
X
k∈In
ek
j
j≤
|In|
X
j=ln+1
2jδj
j!(ψInpj)j.
Sine
j!≥(j/e)j≥(j/3)j
, his gi es
J≤
+∞
X
j=ln+1 6δψIn
√jj≤
+∞
X
j=ln+1 6δψIn
√ln+ 1j.
The e o e,
J≤2−ln
i
6δψIn
√ln+ 1 ≤1
2
,
i.e.
i
ln+ 1 ≥144(δψIn)2
. Bu , i ollows om Lemma 2.8 ha :
ψIn≤2n
p(2 log 2) n≤2n
√n·
The e o e
144(δψIn)2≤144cτ n
2n·2n
√n2= 144 c2τ2n,
and he hoie o
ln
jus s o ob ain
J≤2−ln
. O ou se, we ha e assumed
n
la ge enough o ha e
ln≥1
in ha p o o .
Finally, Ma ko 's inequali y implies:
X
n≥2
P(Nn≥1) ≤X
n≥2
ENn≤X
n≥2
2−ln<+∞,
22
and by he Bo el-Can elli lemma, he in ege
Nn
is almos su ely ze o o
n
la ge enough, and ha ends he p o o o Lemma 2.9.
Now, using Bou gain's Theo em 1.10 and Lemma 2.9, one an nd
Ω0⊆Ω
wi h
P(Ω0) = 1
suh ha o
ω∈Ω0
, he e exis s
n0=n0(ω)
suh ha
Λ = Λ(ω)
and
Λ′= Λ′(ω)
sa is y:
(4)
Λ
and
Λ′
a e uni o mly dis ibu ed
(5)
(c/2) n≤ |Λn| ≤ (2c)n
and
(cτ/2) n≤ |Λ′
n| ≤ (2cτ)n
o
n > n0
(6)
Λ′
n
on ains a mos ela ions o leng h less han
≤ln= [144c2τ2n]
o
n > n0
.
Λ′
n
is no qui e quasi-indep enden , so we shall mo di y i sligh ly. We adjus
one and o all
τ
, dep ending on
c
, suh ha
144c2τ2≤cτ/4
(
e.g.
aking
cτ = 1/576
), so ha
ln≤cτ n/4≤ |Λ′
n|/2
o
n > n0
, in iew o (5). Sele
hen in
Λ′
n
a ela ion
R
wi h supp o
Sn
o maximal a dinali y. Then
|Sn| ≤ ln
om (6), and
En= Λ′
n Sn
is quasi-indep enden . Mo eo e :
|En|=|Λ′
n|−|Sn| ≥ |Λ′
n|−ln≥ |Λ′
n|/2
o
n > n0
. Hene, i we se
E=S
n>n0
En
, we ha e
En=E∩In
, and, mo eo e :
(7)
E
has p osi i e upp e densi y in
Λ
(no e ha
Λ′
has upp e densi y
≥τ/4
in
Λ
by (5)),
(8)
En
is quasi-indep enden ,
(9)
|En| ≥ (cτ/4) n
,
(10) I
A⊆E
is a ni e subse , hen
A
on ains a quasi-indep enden subse
B
wi h
|B| ≥ (1/2) |A|1/2
.
The las p op e y is p o ed in he ollowing way. Se
Z={n;A∩En6=∅}
and
h=|Z|
. We dis inguish wo ases.
Case 1: he e exis s
n∈Z
suh ha
|A∩En| ≥ |A|1/2
.
Then, jus ake
B=A∩En
o ha e a quasi-indep enden se
B
suh ha
|B| ≥ |A|1/2
.
Case 2:
|A∩En|<|A|1/2
o any
n∈Z
.
Then
h≥ |A|1/2
. W i e
Z={n1<···< nh}
, and pik an in ege
mj∈
A∩Enj
o eah
j= 1,...,h
. Then
B={m1, m3,...}=: {µ1, µ2,...}
is quasi-
indep enden b eause we ha e
µj+1/µj≥2
. Mo eo e
|B| ≥ h/2≥(1/2) |A|1/2
.
I is now easy o see ha
E
has he equi ed p ope ies. Indeed, i ollows
om (4), (7), and om F. Lus -Piqua d's Theo em 1.9 ha
E
has a p osi i e
upp e densi y in
Λ
. Tha i is CUC ollows om (8) and om P oposi ion 1.2.
Tha i is
Λ(q)
o all
q < +∞
ollows om (8) and om P op osi ion 1.1.
23
The a ha
E
is
4/3
-Ride ollows om (a) in P op osi ion 1.6. Indeed, i
ε(p) = 2/p −1
, hen
ε(4/3) = 1/2
.
Finally, le
N
b e a la ge in ege , and
n
suh ha
2n≤N < 2n+1
. Then
|E∩[1, N]| ≥ |En0+1|+···+|En−1| ≥ cτ
4(n0+ 1) + ···+ (n−1)
≥d0n2≥d1(log N)2
whe e
d0, d1
a e p osi i e ons an s. I now
E
is a
p
-Ride se , we ha e he mesh
ondi ion
|E∩[1, N]|=O(log N)p/(2−p)
. This equi es
2≤p/(2 −p)
, ha is
p≥4/3
. And his ends he p oo o Theo em 2.7.
Rema k.
The hi d-named au ho p o ed he ollowing ([52℄, Lema 2.4) (whih
is a ually implii ly al eady on ained in [48℄, Lemme 7.2, Théo ème 7.1, and
Théo ème 2.3 (i )):
(
∗
) Fo e e y ni e subse
A⊆Z
, he e exis s a quasi-indep enden subse
B⊆A
suh ha
|B| ≥ δ(|A|/ψA)2
, whe e
δ > 0
is a nume ial ons an .
On he o he hand, G. Pisie ([47℄, Lemme 5.2) p o ed:
E
X
k
ak kek
Ψ≤CX
k|ak|21/2
(1)
whe e
C
is a nume ial ons an ,
( k)k
is he Rademahe sequene, and
k kΨ
is he O liz spae asso ia ed o
Ψ(x) = ex2−1
.
Taking ou sele o s
εk
wi h mean
δk=c n/2n
o
k∈In
, s anda d sym-
me iza ion and en e ing a gumen s gi e:
E
X
k∈In
εkek
Ψ≤C√n .
(2)
In o he e ms, we ha e, in iew o Lemma 2.9:
E(ψΛn)≤C√n≤C′|Λn|1/2.
(3)
I we ould p o e a onen a ion inequali y, a ian o Lemma 1.3, hen his
a ian and he Bo el-Can elli lemma would imply om (3) ha :
Almos su ely
ψΛn≤C′′|Λn|1/2
o
n
la ge enough. (4)
We ould hen ombine (
∗
) and (4) di e ly o ob ain he ollowing al e na i e
p o o o Theo em 2.7. Sele
ω∈Ω
suh ha
Λ
is s ongly e go di, wi h
|Λn| ≥ c n/2
, and
ψΛn≤C′′|Λn|1/2
; ake hen a quasi-indep enden se
En⊆Λn
o size
|En| ≥ δ|Λn|
ψΛn2
≥δC′′−2|Λn| ≥ δ′n;
he se
E=S
n
En
hen has he equi ed p op e ies.
24
To end his se ion, we onside he ase
p > 4/3
. We anno keep he
p op e y o uni o m on e gene (
CUC
), no ha o b eing
q
-Sidon s a ed in
Theo em 2.5. We do no know whe he his is only due o he me ho d. Bu
b eing
p
-Ride wi h
p > 4/3
migh b e a a he weak ondi ion (see [35℄ and [36℄).
Theo em 2.10
Fo e e y
4/3≤p < 2
he e exis s a se
Λ
o in ege s whih is
p
-Ride , bu is no
q
-Ride o
q < p
and whih is
Λ(q)
o e e y
q < +∞
, bu
whih is uni o mly dis ibu ed (so in pa iula dense in he Boh g oup, and
CΛ
on ains
c0
).
The p o o is essen ially he same as in Theo em 2.2, exep ha we ake
sele o s
εk
o mean
δk=c(log k)α
k(log log k)α+1
o
k≥1,
whe e
α= 2(p−1)/(2 −p)≥1
, and eplae
Mn=nn
by he smalles in ege
≥nβn
, wi h
β
any numb e
> α
( o ins ane
β=α+ 1
), whih we all again
Mn
. The es ima e:
PΩn(Mn)≤2cn
nn
(log Mn)n(α+1)
Mn
s ill holds, and now gi es:
PΩn(Mn)≤C′n(log n)n(α+1)
n(β−α)n·
Then easy ompu a ions show ha :
(
∗
) Almos su ely
|ΛMn| ∼ (nlog n)α+1
o
n
suien ly la ge;
(
∗∗
) Almos su ely
|Λ′
n| ∼ nα(log n)α+1
o
n
suien ly la ge.
P op e y (
∗
) gua an ies ha
Λ(ω)
will s ill b e almos su ely
p
-Ride , and (
∗∗
)
wi h he mesh ondi ion implies ha
Λ
is no
q
-Ride o
q < p
.
The
Λ(q)
p op e y anno b e ob ained by he Li lewo o d-Paley me ho d, bu
ollows om [43℄, Theo em 4.7.
3 La ge hin se s in p es ib ed se s o in ege s
In his se ion, we s a om a p es ibed se
Λ0={λ1< λ2< . . . < λN<
...}
o p osi i e in ege s, and andomly ons u a hin se
Λ
inside
Λ0
in he
ollowing way. We s ill ha e ou sele o s
ε1,...,εN,...
o esp e i e means
δ1,...,δN,...
. This ime, howe e , we se
Λ = Λ(ω) = {λj∈Λ0;εj(ω) = 1},
i.e.
we sele andomly some o he
λj
's, and igno e he o he in ege s. Suh
ons u ions ha e b een made p e iously by S. Neuwi h ([43℄).
25
[17℄ S. D u y, Su les ensembles de Sidon, C.R.A.S. Pa is 271 (1970), 162163.
[18℄ R.E. Edwa ds and K.A. Ross,
p
-Sidon se s, J. Fun . Anal. 15 (1974), 404
427.
[19℄ A. FigàTalamana, An example in he heo y o launa y Fou ie se ies,
Boll. Unione Ma em. I al. 3 (1970), 375378.
[20℄ J. Fou nie , Two UC-se s whose union is no a UC-se , P o. Ame . Ma h.
So . 84 (1982), 6972.
[21℄ J. Fou nie and L. Pigno, Analy i and a i hme i p op e ies o hin se s,
Pai J. Ma h. 105 (1983), 115141.
[22℄ C. F appie , Q.I. Rahman and S . Rusheweyh, New inequali ies o p oly-
nomials, T ans. Ame . Ma h. So . 288 (1985), 69-99.
[23℄ G.W. Johnson, Theo ems on launa y se s, esp eially
p
-Sidon se s, S udia
Ma h. 58 (1976), 209221.
[24℄ G.W. Johnson and G.S. Wo o dwa d, On
p
-Sidon se s, Indiana Uni . Ma h.
J. 24 (1974), 161167.
[25℄ J.P. Kahane, Some andom se ies o un ions, Seond ed., Camb idge
Uni . P ess, Camb idge (1985).
[26℄ B. Kashin and L. Tza i i, On andom se s o uni o m on e gene, Ma h.
No es 54 (1993), 677687.
[27℄ Y. Ka znelson, Sui es aléa oi es d'en ie s, Le u e No es in Ma h. 336,
Sp inge -Ve lag Be lin (1973), 148-152.
[28℄ Y. Ka znelson and P. Mallia in, Vé ia ion s a is ique de la onje u e de
la diho omie su une lasse d'algèb es de es i ion, C.R.A.S. Pa is 262
(1966), 490492.
[29℄ S. Konyagin, On di e gene o igonome i Fou ie se ies e e ywhe e,
C.R.A.S. Pa is 329 (1999), 693697.
[30℄ T.W. Kö ne , Fou ie analysis, Camb idge Uni e si y P ess (1988).
[31℄ S. Kwapien and A. Peªzy«ski, Absolu ely summing op e a o s and ans-
la ion in a ian spaes o un ions on ompa ab elian g oups, Ma h.
Nah ih en 94 (1980), 303340.
[32℄ M. Ledoux and M. Talag and, P obabili y in Banah spaes, E geb. Ma h.
23 Sp inge -Ve lag (1991).
[33℄ P. Le è e, Su les ensembles de on e gene uni o me, Publ. Ma h. d'O say
9424 (1994), 170.
[34℄ P. Le è e, Measu es and launa i y se s, S udia Ma h. 133 (1999), 145161.
32
[35℄ P. Le è e, D. Li, H. Queéle, and L. Ro d íguez-Piazza, Launa y se s
and un ion spaes wi h ni e o ype, (
submi ed
)
[36℄ P. Le è e and L. Ro d íguez-Piazza,
p
-Ride se s a e
q
-Sidon se s, (
submi -
ed
)
[37℄ D. Li, A ema k abou
Λ(p)
-se s and Rosen hal se s, P o . Ame . Ma h.
So . 126 (1998) 33293333.
[38℄ J. Lindens auss and L. Tza i i, Classial Banah Spaes I and I I, Classis
in Ma h., Sp inge (1997).
[39℄ J.M. Lop ez and K.A. Ross, Sidon Se s, Ma el Dekke 13 (1975).
[40℄ F. Lus , P o dui s enso iels inje i s d'espaes de Sidon, Collo q. Ma h. 32
(1975), 285289.
[41℄ F. Lus Piqua d, P op ié és géomé iques des sous-espaes in a ian s pa
ansla ion de
L1(G)
e
C(G)
, Sémin. Géom. Espaes Banah, Eole Poly-
ehnique, Pa is (1977-78), Exp osé n
◦
26.
[42℄ F. Lus Piqua d, Boh lo al p op e ies o
CΛ(T)
, Collo q. Ma h. 58 (1989),
2938.
[43℄ S. Neuwi h, Random ons u ions inside launa y se s, Annales Ins .
Fou ie 49 (1999), 18531867.
[44℄ K.I. Oskolko , On sp e a o uni o m on e gene, So ie Ma h. Dokl. 33
(1986), 616620.
[45℄ L. Pedemon e, Se s o uni o m on e gene, Collo q. Ma h. 33 (1975), 123
132.
[46℄ G Pisie , Ensembles de Sidon e espaes de o yp e 2, Séminai e su la
géomé ie des espaes de Banah 19771978, Eole Poly ehnique, Pa is
(1978), exp osé 14.
[47℄ G. Pisie , Su l'espae de Banah des sé ies de Fou ie aléa oi es p esque
sû emen on inues, Séminai e su la géomé ie des espaes de Banah
19771978, Eole Poly ehnique, Pa is (1978), exp osés 1718.
[48℄ G. Pisie , De nou elles a a é isa ions des ensembles de Sidon, Ma h.
Anal. and Appli., Pa B, Ad anes in Ma h. Suppl. S udies, Vol 7B
(1981), 685726.
[49℄ D. Ride , Gap se ies on g oups and sphe es, Canad. J. Ma h. 18 (1966),
389398.
[50℄ D. Ride , Randomly on inuous un ions and Sidon se s, Duke Ma h. J.
42 (1975), 759764.
33
[51℄ L. Ro d íguezPiazza, Ca a é isa ion des ensembles
p
-Sidon p.s., C.R.A.S.
Pa is 305 (1987), 237240.
[52℄ L. Ro d íguezPiazza, Rango y p opiedades de medidas e o iales. Con-
jun os
p
-Sidon p.s., Thesis, Uni e sidad de Se illa (1991).
[53℄ H.P. Rosen hal, On T igonome i Se ies Asso ia ed wi h Weak
∗
Closed
Subspaes o Con inuous Fun ions, Jou n. Ma h. Meh. 17 (1967), 485-
490.
[54℄ W. Rudin, T igonome i Se ies wi h Gaps, Jou nal o Ma h. and Meh. 9
(1960), 203227.
[55℄ I. Singe , Bases in Banah Spaes I, Sp inge Ve lag (1970).
[56℄ P.M. Soa di and G. T a aglini, On se s o omple ely uni o m on e gene,
Collo q. Ma h. 45 (1981), 317320.
[57℄ G. T a aglini, Some p op e ies o UC-se s, Boll. Unione Ma em. I al. 15
(1978), 272284.
[58℄ N.T. Va op oulos, Une ema que su les ensembles de Helson, Duke Ma h.
J. 43 (1976), 387390.
[59℄ P. Wo j aszzyk, Banah Spaes o Analys s, Camb idge Uni e si y P ess
(1991).
[60℄ G. S. Wo o dwa d,
p
-Sidon Se s and a Uni o m P ope y, Indiana Uni .
Ma h. Jou nal 25 (1976), 99511003.
[61℄ Z. Zalwasse , Polynmes asso iés aux on ions mo dulai es
ϑ
, S udia
Ma h. 7 (1938), 1635.
[62℄ A. Zygmund, T igonome i Se ies, Seond Ed., Vol. I & I I, Camb idge
Ma h. Lib a y, Camb idge Uni . P ess (1993).
34