Full text
SOME ASPECTS OF THE ENERGY COST LINKED TO THE IAQ. IMPACT OF FREE-COOLING AND HEAT RECOVERY IN OFFICE BUILDINGS. Topic 3: HVAC Applications in Commercial and Community Buildings R. Velazquez, S.Alvarez, J.F. Coronel, J. Guerra Grupo de Termotecnia. Escuela Superior de Ingenieros. Universidad de Sevilla.Avda. Reina Mercedes s/n E-41012, Sevilla (SPAIN) ABSTRACT Increasing air exchange rate to improve IAQ may increase energy consumption, but this increase may be compensated for by strategies such as free cooling and heat recovery. The frame of the proposed paper is the examination of the potential at a regional level (the Iberian peninsula) of the different strategies mentioned above in typical office buildings. Based on a set of reference building morphologies, studies are conducted to evaluate the impact of increasing air ventilation rates for different orientations, quality of the envelope (opaque walls and glazing), operating schedules and indoor set-point temperatures. Then, the impact of the increased air ventilation rates is corrected by introducing the effect of free-cooling, air-to-air heat recovery devices of different types and finally, the combined effect of both energy savings strategies. The research provides Maps allowing: 1. To identify zones when heating or cooling regimes are dominant, in terms of both, peak load conditions and energy requirements. 2. To compare the expected performance of the two energy saving strategies at a certain locality. 3. To compare the potential benefit of applying a given strategy at different localities. 4. To indicate regions of recommendable application of the strategies and the expected energy savings achievable. 1. INTRODUCTION AND CONTENTS The energy impact of ventilation must be conceptually examined at two different levels: •The effect on the building performance of increasing air ventilation rates in order to improve IAQ. •The potential of reducing the energy impact of increasing air exchanges by means of freecooling and air to air heat recovery systems. Free-cooling, sometimes called ventilation cooling, is particularly suited to large office buildings where high heat loads are developed through lighting, computing and other electrical sources. Thus, the building often requires cooling while the outdoor temperatures 1
are lower that indoors. Ventilation rates for cooling will normally be well in excess of that needed to meet the basic fresh air requirements of occupants. Ventilation heat recovery is the process by which thermal energy is recovered from exhaust air for re-use within the building. The studies have been conducted based on a set of scenarios representative of the scope of the project. Consequently, the conclusions achieved are only applicable within the range defined by the scenarios. The scenarios include locations, building morphologies, building operational and constructive characteristics and efficiency of the heat recovery systems. A first level of specific information is provided for a specific building in two locations, Madrid (Spain) and Porto (Portugal). A second level of generalised information is provided in a set of maps of the Iberian peninsula (Spain and Portugal). This second step is aimed to know to what extent the conclusions obtained in the first level are applicable to other buildings or locations. All the information was obtained via hourly based computer simulation, for which it was necessary: • The generation of the climatic data (Test Meteorological Years) for 35 different locations covering the different climates of the Iberian peninsula. • A detailed building energy analysis tool (PASSPORT PLUS Software) to obtain the thermal load hour by hour, • The development of specific routines to characterise the performance of the free-cooling, heat recovery and conventional cooling coil components. • The development of postprocessors to perform the massive simulations and analyse the results in an automatic way. • To compile easily available climatic data (monthly mean values) of 40 additional sites of the Iberian peninsula to completely cover the geographic region which would be represented in the maps. • To develop physical and geographical interpolation procedures to build up the maps. PASSPORT PLUS has been taken as the basic tool used inside this project for the detailed thermal building performance. Passport Plus is a dynamic simulation software to calculate the thermal behaviour of multi-zones and multi-element buildings. This software package has been developed in the frame of the European research project (PASCOOL) EC-JOU- 0013-CT92 of the XII General Directorate of the European Union. This software is totally compatible with the simulation of cooling and heating systems, and has been well tested against results from other programs and experimental values. Its internal structure makes this program very appropriated for the development and incorporation of pre-processors and post-processor software specific for every different application. 2
2. REFERENCE CASE A representative office building has been selected. The building has square shape with 1600 m² (40 x 40 m) of floor area in each floor. It will be divided in 6 different zones: south, east, north, west, internal zone and false ceiling (see figure 1). The external zones (south, east, north and west) have an average depth of 6 m; the rest of the usable floor is internal zone. The false ceiling will be simulated as a free floating zone, so that, all the energy results hereinafter will be refereed only to the first five zones. In the four facade the percentage of glazed area is 60 % and 40% the opaque one. The exterior walls, glazing, floors and ceilings are typical constructive element for these kind of buildings, with a medium level of constructive quality. • Walls: Double brick (12 cm), insulation layer (5 cm), single brick (7 cm) (U = 0.57 W/m²K) • Glazing: Double glazing 6-6-6 mm, Global solar Transmitance = 0.66 (U = 3.4 W/m² K) • Window Frames: Aluminum, low airtightness • Roof: Concrete (3 cm), air layer and extruded polystyrene (3 cm), ceramic space between girders. (U = 0.61 W/m² K) Figure 1: Scheme of one floor of the building Figure 2: Scheme of wall and the roof This building will be studied in two different climates inside the Iberian peninsula: • Porto (Portugal) 3
Latitude: 41° 08’ N Longitude: 08° 36’ W Altitude: 10 m • Madrid (Spain) Latitude: 40° 27’ N Longitude: 06° 06’ W Altitude: 650 m Figure 3: Madrid and Porto geographical location. The sensible internal gains have been considered to be 30 W/m² (lights, occupation and equipment), constant during all the working hours. The working or occupation period is 9- 14 and 16-19 hours. The infiltration rate out of the occupation period will be considered as 0.5 air changes per hour (ach) (2560 m3/h). The occupation density during the working period is about: 1 occupant / 10 m². The size of the air conditioning equipment and the total supply air flow used by the air distribution system have been calculated using the cooling peak load of each zone. It has been assumed that the five different zones have five different air treatment units and its distribution system. The cooling peak load is for all the cases higher than the heating peak load. So, for every different zone and every different ventilation level, there will be a different cooling peak load and consequently a different system size. 3. BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE 3.1. Building energy performance - Reference case The energy requirement calculations has been performed using 26.5 °C as set point for cooling and 20 °C for heating. The equipment operates during the working period every day, being the building under free floating evolution the rest of the time. The reference ventilation rate has been fixed 1 ach (1420 L/s) during the working period (for this building, 1 ach is equivalent to 8.9 liters of air per second and occupant). The supply air flow has been sized using the peak cooling load of the building (without the ventilation load). Consequently, the supply air flow depends on the zone and the climate. The following table shows the energy requirements and the peak loads zone by zone and for all the building. 4
Location Zone Sensible cooling requirem. (kW·h/m²) Total1 cooling requirem. (kW·h/m²) Heating requirem. (kW·h/m²) Sensible cooling peak (W/m²) Heating peak (W/m²) South 117.4 122.3 6.4 116.2 72.2 East 117.1 122.8 10.8 162.0 79.9 Madrid North 72.3 76.7 12.3 97.2 72.3 West 116.1 121.5 12.8 152.5 79.9 Intern. 53.4 57.0 3.5 59.2 38.8 Building 81.1 85.5 7.2 98.6 58.2 South 115.3 130.7 2.1 106.4 55.0 East 109.0 125.8 3.6 136.9 64.6 Porto North 64.7 78.9 3.6 88.9 61.0 West 107.9 125.8 4.2 148.9 66.2 Intern. 49.5 61.9 0.8 56.9 28.7 Building 75.7 90.1 2.1 91.3 45.9 1Total: (Sensible + Latent) Table 1:Energy requirements and load peaks for the building placed in Madrid and Porto. It can be observed in the previous table and in the figure 4 that the cooling requirements are much more important than heating for all the zones, both in Madrid and Porto (remember that ventilation reference level is 1 ach). The latent cooling requirement (Total - Sensible) is much more important for Porto than for Madrid (Porto has a higher level of outdoor humidity). 123456789101112 0 5 10 15 20 25 Load (kw·h/m²) 123456789101112 Month Cooling Heating Madrid 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 0 5 10 15 20 25 Load (kw·h/m²) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Month Porto Figure 4: Monthly energy requirements (heating and cooling) for Madrid and Porto 5
Figure 4 shows the monthly building energy requirements (cooling and heating) for the whole building placed in Madrid and in Porto. 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Hour W/m² 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 °C Cooling Load T. Outdoor Madrid 0 20 40 60 80 100 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Hour W/m² 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 °C Porto Figure 5: Hourly cooling load and outdoor dry bulb temperature for a typical summer day in Madrid and Porto Figure 5 shows the hourly evolution for a typical summer day, 15th of July (this day is not mandatory the cooling peak day). Together with the cooling load hourly evolution, we have graph the exterior ambient dry bulb temperature. It can be noted that there are an interval of time (14 to 16) where the conditioning equipment is switch off and thus the loads are zero. The behavior of the whole building has been calculated adding zone loads. Therefore, the building performance is very closed to the behavior of the internal zone, due to the “weight” of the internal zone with respect to the outer zones. Building energy performance - Regional Evaluation Maps showing the regional distribution of peak loads and energy requirements have been included. For the building morphology defined before, these maps represent averages of 6 different combinations of constructive and operational characteristics defined as follows: 6
Variation Walls Windows Internal Gains (W/m²) 1 Reference wall without insulation Single 30 2 Reference wall Double 30 3 Reference wall Double & Reflecting 30 Single 4 20 Reference wall without insulation 5 20 Reference wall Double 6 20 Reference wall Double & Reflecting These maps are not extrapolation of the evaluation of the reference building, but have been calculated with the same detail in the reference building. The reference wall is the one defined in the figure 2. The maps will always represent averages of the above mentioned buildings combinations. It can be seen that at regional level: • Peak cooling is always higher than peak heating, although both variables are in the same order of magnitude. • Cooling requirements are considerable higher than heating requirements, except in a small zone in the northwest of the Iberian peninsula where they are of the same order. Typically, it can be said than cooling requirements are about 5 times bigger than heating requirements. In synthesis, for 1 ach, cooling is dominant. Next maps show the distribution of the average cooling and heating energy requirements for the office building simulated (all of then with a ventilation rate of 1 ach ) within the Iberian Peninsula Cooling (kW·h/m2) Heating (kW·h/m2) 35 100 90 25 70 50 10 0 0 Figure 6:Iberian Peninsula maps of the average energy requirements for cooling and heating. 7
4. BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE WITH DIFFERENT VENTILATION LEVELS Equivalencies referred to the building: ach 1 2 3 4 7.6 8.1 L/(s·occupant) 8.9 17.8 26.7 35.6 67.6 72.0 L/(s m2) 0.89 1.78 2.67 3.56 6.76 7.20 Figure 7 represents the monthly distribution of the building (the whole building) sensible energy requirements with different ventilation levels for Madrid. It can be seen that the cooling requirement has been concentrated in the summer months cause the ventilation air during winter and intermediate months has became the cooling loads into heating loads. 1 3 5 7 9 11 0 5 10 15 20 25 Load (kw·h/m²) 1 3 5 7 9 11 Month Cooling Heating 1 ach 1 3 5 7 9 11 0 5 10 15 20 25 Load (kw·h/m²) 1 3 5 7 9 11 Month Cooling Heating 4 ach Figure 7: Monthly energy requirements (heating and cooling) for the whole building with different levels of ventilation in Madrid. When the ventilation levels increase the overall values of energy cooling requirements remain almost unaltered. However the energy heating requirements do increase significantly with the ventilation levels. Next figures show these effect for Madrid and Porto. The difference between total and sensible cooling are not so important for Madrid, but is not negligible for Porto. So the high level of humidity in Porto is a very important factor. Madrid 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 100.0 120.0 140.0 0123456789 Air Changes per Hour (ach) Energy requirements (kW·h/m² ) Total cooling Sensible cooling Heating Porto 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 100.0 120.0 140.0 0123456789 Air Changes per Hour (ach) Energy requirements (kW·h/m² ) Total cooling Sensible cooling Heating Figure 8: Energy requirements (cooling and heating) evolution with the ventilation level for Madrid and Porto The peak cooling and heating load increase linearly with the ventilation level, but heating peak load grows more than cooling one. 8
When the ventilation rate increases, cooling requirement increases or decreases depending on the locations, but they do not change in a significant way in all the Iberian Peninsula. The comparison with the reference case show deviations of within ± 20% in all cases. This variation, positive or negative, is due to the presence of two combined contradictory effects: the cooling months decrease but the cooling requirements associated to each month increase. Heating requirements grows significantly when the ventilation rate increases. This is due to the increase in the number of heating months. Comparison between cooling and heating requirements show that the zones with dominance of the cooling decrease in such a way that for 4 ach the heating and cooling dominance is split about 50%, as can be observed in the maps of the following figure Ventilation: 1 ach Ventilation: 4 ach Figure 9: Ratio cooling to heating energy requirements for two levels of ventilation (1 ach & 4 ach) 9
REFERENCES • J. Clarke. “Energy Simulation in Building Design”. Adam Hilger Ltd, Bristol (1985). • J.F. Coronel, S.Alvarez. “Detailed Algorithms for Thermal and optical performance” in Model Development. Vol 2 Solar Control. S. Sciuto ed. Final Report of PASCOOL Research Project. CEC CG 12 Brussels (1995). • J.F. Coronel, S.Alvarez, E. Rodriguez “PASSPORT Plus Intermodel comparison” in PASSPORT Plus - Final Report. S. Alvarez, C.A. Balaras eds. Final Report of PASCOOL Research Project. CEC DG 12, Brussels (1995). • E. Dascalaki, M. Santamouris “PASSPORT-Air User’s Manual”. Final Report of PASCOOL Research Project. CEC CG 12 Brussels (1995). • M. Grosso “CPCALC-User Manual”. Final Report of PASCOOL Research Project. CEC CG 12 Brussels (1995). • R. Judkoff, J.Neymark. “International Energy Agency Building Energy Simulation Test (BESTEST) and Diagnostic Method”. NREL Colorado, available NTIS and DOE, (1995). • P. Rousseau, E. Mathews. “Needs and Trend in Integrated Building and HVAC Thermal design Tools”. Building and Environment, Vol 28,Nº 4 pp. 439-452, (1993). • S. Klein. “TRNSYS- A Transient System Simulation Program”. University of Wisconsin - Madison, Engineering Experiment Station Report 38-12 (1988). • G. Walton. ”Thermal Analysis Research Program - Reference Manual”. NBSIR 83-2655, National Bureau of standards (1983). 16