Partial depletion of histone H4 increases homologous recombination-mediated genetic instability

MOLECULAR AND CELLULAR BIOLOGY, Feb. 2005, p. 1526–1536 Vol. 25, No. 4 0270-7306/05/$08.00⫹0 doi:10.1128/MCB.25.4.1526–1536.2005 Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved. Partial Depletion of Histone H4 Increases Homologous Recombination-Mediated Genetic Instability Fe´lix Prado and Andre´s Aguilera* Departamento de Gene´tica, Facultad de Biologı´a, Universidad de Sevilla, Seville, Spain Received 13 July 2004/Returned for modification 19 August 2004/Accepted 19 November 2004 DNA replication can be a source of genetic instability. Given the tight connection between DNA replication and nucleosome assembly, we analyzed the effect of a partial depletion of histone H4 on genetic instability mediated by homologous recombination. A Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain was constructed in which the expression of histone H4 was driven by the regulated tet promoter. In agreement with defective nucleosome assembly, partial depletion of histone H4 led to subtle changes in plasmid superhelical density and chromatin sensitivity to micrococcal nuclease. Under these conditions, homologous recombination between ectopic DNA sequences was increased 20-fold above the wild-type levels. This hyperrecombination was not associated with either defective repair or transcription but with an accumulation of recombinogenic DNA lesions during the S and G 2 /M phases, as determined by an increase in the proportion of budded cells containing Rad52-yellow fluorescent protein foci. Consistently, partial depletion of histone H4 caused a delay during the S and G 2 /M phases. Our results suggest that histone deposition defects lead to the formation of recombinogenic DNA structures during replication that increase genomic instability. Genetic instability leads to loss of cell fitness and is characteristic of cancer and a number of genetic diseases (31). This instability can be associated with errors during DNA replication. Thus, it is induced by either mutations affecting replication fork progression or replication inhibitors. In addition, genetic instability arises in S-phase checkpoint mutants in the absence of genotoxic agents, suggesting that DNA replication per se can be a source of spontaneous DNA rearrangements (28). Part of this instability involves DNA exchanges between homologous sequences, indicating that chromosomal rearrangements may result via homologous recombination from DNA lesions generated during replication. In accordance with this, homologous recombination has been shown to be required for the rescue of stalled replication forks in bacteria (13, 36, 50), and recombination intermediates have been physically detected during defective DNA replication in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (55, 69). Newly replicated DNA is rapidly assembled into chromatin in a stepwise manner, with the initial deposition of the histone H3/H4 tetramers, followed by binding of two histone H2A/ H2B dimers. Nucleosome assembly is catalyzed by histone chaperones and ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling complexes. Two different chaperones, conserved from S. cerevisiae to humans, have been involved in replication-dependent chromatin assembly: CAF-1 (chromatin assembly factor 1) and Asf1 (antisilencing function 1) (1, 37, 59). CAF-1 and Asf1 physically interact with each other, cooperate in chromatin assembly in vitro, and participate with redundant and specific roles in heterochromatin silencing, transcription, and DNA repair (29, 51, 60). In addition to CAF-1 and Asf1, the histone chaperone Spt6 has been shown to control chromatin structure in vivo and to participate in nucleosome assembly in vitro (9). DNA replication and chromatin assembly are tightly coordinated. The coupling between DNA replication and chromatin assembly is mediated by the proliferating cell nuclear antigen, which interacts physically with the largest subunit of CAF-1 (52) and functionally with both CAF-1 and Asf1 in heterochromatin silencing and in vitro chromatin assembly (29, 51). In addition, the coordination of DNA replication and nucleosome assembly relies on the coregulation of the levels of DNA and histone synthesis. Thus, histone gene expression is cell cycle regulated to ensure the accumulation of histones during DNA replication: histone genes are actively transcribed in late G 1 /early S and repressed in early G 1 ,G 2 , and M phases (22, 42, 56). Consistently, replication inhibitors and mutations that block DNA synthesis lead to histone gene repression from S. cerevisiae to human cells (34, 54), and repression of histone genes inhibits DNA synthesis in human cells (40). In addition, a Rad53-dependent surveillance mechanism that regulates histone levels during both normal cell cycle progression and in response to DNA damage in S. cerevisiae has been recently reported (21). The absence of the Asf1 chromatin assembly factor in S. cerevisiae increases genomic instability and sister chromatid exchange, suggesting that defective chromatin assembly may generate recombinogenic DNA lesions during DNA replication (46). Nevertheless, the function of Asf1 is not restricted to DNA replication. Asf1 is required for histone deposition during nucleotide excision repair in vitro (38) and for the repair of double-strand breaks (DSBs) and DNA lesions caused by UV light, methyl-methane sulfonate (MMS), and hydroxyurea (HU) in vivo (30, 60). The activity of Asf1 in DNA repair seems to be mediated by its dynamic interaction with the checkpoint protein Rad53 (15, 23). In addition, Asf1 participates in the chromatin remodeling required for transcription regulation (2, 58). * Corresponding author. Mailing address: Departamento de Gene´tica, Facultad de Biologı´a, Universidad de Sevilla, Avda. Reina Mercedes 6, 41012 Seville, Spain. Phone: (34) 954557107. Fax: (34) 954557104. E-mail: [email protected]. 1526 on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from To determine whether inefficient chromatin assembly during DNA replication leads to genetic instability mediated by homologous recombination, a yeast strain expressing histone H4 under the control of the regulated tet promoter was constructed. As expected from the requirement for high histone levels for proper nucleosome assembly during replication, partial depletion of histone H4 altered chromatin structure. Importantly, such a depletion led to an increase in the frequency of homologous recombination that was associated with an accumulation of budded cells containing Rad52-yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) foci and with a delay of the cell cycle during the S and G 2 /M phases. The increase in recombination was not associated with defective DNA repair or transcription. These results link replication-dependent chromatin assembly and the control of genetic instability mediated by homologous recombination. MATERIALS AND METHODS Yeast strains and growth conditions. Yeast strains used in this study are listed in Table 1. Yeast cells were grown in synthetic complete (SC) medium as described previously (26). Doxycycline (DOX) was added to the medium at 0.25 or5␮g/ml as indicated. Plasmids. All plasmids used were centromeric. Plasmids pRS314-GL (44), pRS314-LNA, pRS314-LNAT (47), pRS316-SU, and pRS316-LY⌬NS (18) contain the different recombination systems used in this study. p413TARtetH4 contains HHF2 under the control of the tet promoter. p413TARtetH4 was constructed by inserting the following fragments into the vector pRS413 (53): the XhoI-EcoRI fragment from pCM176 (8), containing the tetR⬘::VP16 activator, at the XhoI-EcoRI site; the SphI (blunt ended)-XhoI fragment from pCM242 (8), containing the tetR-SSN6 repressor, at the ApaI (blunt ended)-XhoI site; the XhoI (blunt ended)-BamHI fragment from pCM176, containing the ADHter:: tetO7::CYC1TATA sequence, at the NotI (blunt ended)-BamHI site; and a BamHI fragment containing the HHF2 gene amplified by PCR with oligonucleotides 5⬘-GCATGGATCCCAATAAAATAATGTCCGGTA-3⬘and 5⬘-TGAAG GATCCTTAGCCAGTGACTCAAAATT-3⬘, at the BamHI site. pWJ1344 is a centromeric plasmid containing the Rad52-YFP construct (R. Rothstein, Columbia University). Recombination and DNA repair assays. Spontaneous recombination frequencies in plasmids harboring direct and inverted repeat systems were obtained by fluctuation assays as the median value of six independent colonies as described previously (45). Yeast colonies were isolated in SC medium containing either 2% glucose or 2% galactose as indicated (44). MMS and HU sensitivities were determined by 10-fold serial dilutions plated onto SC medium containing either MMS or HU. Sensitivity to UV light was determined as previously described (20). Flow cytometry. Analysis of DNA content was performed by flow cytometry (12). Mid-log-phase cells were fixed in 70% ethanol and then incubated for 8 h in phosphate-buffered saline with 1 mg of RNase A/ml and stained for 30 min with 5 ␮g of propidium iodide/ml. Samples were sonicated to separate single cells and analyzed in a FACSCalibur flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson). Mid-log- phase BY4741 and BYtetH4l-1C cell growth with 5 ␮g of DOX/ml was arrested in G 1 by twice adding ␣factor at 2 and 5 ␮g/ml at 1- and 2-h intervals, respectively. For synchronization of BYtetH4l-1C growth with 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml, ␣ factor at 5 ␮g/ml was added four times at intervals of 90 min. Then, cells were washed three times to remove the ␣factor and released in fresh medium for different times before DNA content analysis. Chromatin analysis by MNase digestion. Mapping of micrococcal nuclease (MNase) cleavage sites was performed as previously described (11). Briefly, spheroplasts were prepared from mid-log-phase cells and then treated with different amounts of MNase. MNase-cleaved genomic DNA was extracted and run in 0.8% agarose gels for bulk chromatin analysis. Nucleosome positioning along the endogenous GAL1 gene and the SU recombination system was performed by indirect end labeling: MNase-treated DNA was restricted with either EcoRI (GAL1) or ClaI (pRS316-SU), resolved in a 1.5% agarose gel, blotted onto a Quiabrane Nylon-Plus membrane (Quiagen), and probed with either the 196-bp fragment immediately downstream of the EcoRI site (GAL1) or the 221-bp fragment immediately downstream of the ClaI site (pRS316-SU). Plasmid supercoiling analysis. Total DNA from yeast cells transformed with pRS316-SU was isolated as described by Allers and Lichten (6) with the modifications of Wellinger et al. (63) in the absence of hexamine cobalt trichloride. DNA samples were run in 0.7% agarose gels containing either 4 or 8 ␮gof chloroquine/ml for 48 h at 2 V/cm to resolve plasmid topoisomers (10). These were probed with either a ClaI-EcoRV LEU2 (pRS316-SU) or an EcoRV-NdeI FLP1 (2␮m circle) fragment and quantified in a Fuji FLA3000 reader. RNA analysis. Yeast RNA was extracted and analyzed by Northern hybridization as previously described (47). mRNA was probed with specific DNA fragments, quantified in a Fuji FLA3000 reader, and normalized with respect to the 25S rRNA value. Western blot analysis. Yeast protein extracts were prepared essentially as described previously (16), except that 20% trichloroacetic acid-treated cells were washed three times with acetone. Protein extracts were run on a sodium dodecyl sulfate–15% polyacrylamide gel, and histone H4 was detected with histone H4 polyclonal antibody (Abcam Ltd.) by standard Western analysis. Detection of Rad52-YFP. Rad52-YFP foci from mid-log-phase cells transformed with plasmid pWJ1344 were visualized with a Leyca TCS SL confocal microscope (excitation, 514 nm; emission, 535 nm) as described by Lisby et al. (33). RESULTS Construction of a yeast strain partially depleted of histone H4. In order to understand the role of chromatin assembly in genetic instability, we constructed a yeast strain in which his- TABLE 1. S. cerevisiae strains used in this study a Strain Relevant genotype Source BY4741 MATaEuroscarf Y07202 MATatrp1⌬::kan Euroscarf Y03144 MATahhf1⌬::kan Euroscarf Y15356 MAT␣hhf2⌬::kan Euroscarf BYth2-1B MATahhf2⌬::kan trp1⌬::kan This work Y11310 MAT␣asf1⌬::kan Euroscarf Y02806 MATarad1⌬::kan Euroscarf BY51 MATarad51⌬::hyg This work BY59 MATarad59⌬::hyg This work Y10540 MAT␣rad52⌬::kan Euroscarf BYtetH4-10D MAT␣hhf1⌬::kan hhf2⌬::kan(p413TARtetH4) This work BYtetH4-1C MATahhf1⌬::kan hhf2⌬::kan trp1⌬::kan(p413TARtetH4) This work BY51tetH4-3C MATahhf1⌬::kan hhf2⌬::kan rad51⌬::hyg(p413TARtetH4) This work BY59tetH4-2A MAT␣hhf1⌬::kan hhf2⌬::kan rad59⌬::hyg(p413TARtetH4) This work BY52tetH4-2D MAT␣hhf1⌬::kan hhf2⌬::kan rad52⌬::kan trp1⌬::kan(p413TARtetH4) This work a All strains are isogenic to BY4741 (MATahis3⌬1leu2⌬0ura3⌬0met15⌬0). BY51, BY59, and Y0 are met15⌬0LYS2, Y1 strains are MET15 lys2⌬0, and BYth2 and BYtet strains are MET15 LYS2. VOL. 25, 2005 PARTIAL HISTONE H4 DEPLETION INCREASES RECOMBINATION 1527 on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from tone H4 could be partially depleted (Fig. 1A). This strain (t::HHF2) is a null mutant for the two copies of the histone H4 gene (hhf1⌬hhf2⌬) and contains a plasmid (p413TARtetH4) expressing HHF2 under the control of the bacterial tet promoter. This plasmid harbors copies of the tetR⬘-SSN6 and tetR-VP16 fusions, which positively regulate the tet promoter in response to DOX in a dose-dependent manner (8). Since histone H4 is essential for cell viability, t::HHF2 cells do not grow in the absence of DOX (the tet promoter is repressed) and are extremely sick in 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml (t::HHF2[0.25]), which leads to a reduction in the level of histone H4 and a doubling time of 5 h versus 2 h for the wild type (Fig. 1B and C). This growth defect was partially rescued with 5 ␮g of DOX/ml (t::HHF2[5]), which fully activates the tet promoter and results in cells with a slight reduction in the level of histone H4 and a doubling time of 3 h (Fig. 1B and C). Therefore, t::HHF2 cells are depleted partially of histone H4, which leads to growth defects that are more severe as the expression of histone H4 from the tet promoter is reduced. Partial depletion of histone H4 affects chromatin assembly. To analyze the effect of partial depletion of histone H4 on nucleosome assembly, plasmid supercoiling density and chromatin accessibility to MNase were determined. Since the assembly of one nucleosome introduces one negative superhelical turn in a circular DNA molecule (62, 65), a loss of plasmid superhelical density in cells partially depleted of histone H4 was expected. As can be seen in Fig. 2A, the endogenous 2␮m plasmid in t::HHF2 cells displayed a shift in the distribution of topoisomers that indicated a loss of negative supercoiling, whereas the centromeric plasmid pRS314-SU displayed an increase in DNA supercoiling that was similar to that observed in the absence of the chromatin assembly factor Asf1 (data not shown; 46). Partial MNase digestion of bulk chromatin leads to the formation of a nucleosome ladder (41). As observed in Fig. 2B, this ladder was more diffuse in t::HHF2[0.25] cells, pointing to a general loss of nucleosome density. However, the depletion of histone H4 in t::HHF2[5] cells was not sufficient to induce this chromatin alteration. For a more detailed molecular analysis of the effect of partial depletion of histone H4 on chromatin structure, we determined nucleosome positioning along two different DNA sequences: the endogenous GAL1 promoter and the LEU2 promoter of the SU recombination system. Figure 2C shows that nucleosomes remained well positioned along the regulatory region of GAL1 in both t::HHF2[0.25] and t::HHF2[5] cells. In the case of the SU recombination system, the LEU2 promoter region was more sensitive to MNase in t::HHF2 [0.25] cells than in wild-type cells (Fig. 2D). As previously observed for bulk chromatin, most of these alterations were suppressed in t::HHF2[5] cells. Taken together, our results suggest that chromatin assembly is affected in t::HHF2 cells, leading to subtle changes in chromatin structure. Partial depletion of histone H4 increases homologous recombination. To determine the effect of partial depletion of histone H4 on homologous recombination, we used intramolecular recombination systems based on two direct repeats of a 0.6-kb internal fragment of the LEU2 gene (Fig. 3A, LY⌬NS system). Recombination between these repeats leads to the deletion of the intervening sequence and one of the repeats, generating a wild-type copy of the LEU2 gene (45). The effect of partial depletion of histone H4 on inversions in the recombination system SU was also analyzed; the SU system differs from the LY⌬NS system only in the orientation of the repeats (Fig. 3A). Recombination between these repeats leads to the inversion of the intervening sequence and the formation of a FIG. 1. Construction of a yeast strain (t::HHF2) that can be gradually depleted of histone H4. (A) Scheme of the main genotype of strain t::HHF2. This strain is a null mutant for the two copies of the histone H4 gene (hhf1⌬hhf2⌬) that contains a plasmid (p413TARtetH4) expressing HHF2 under the control of the bacterial tet promoter, which responds to DOX in a dose-dependent manner. (B) Growth analysis of BYtetH4-10D at 5 (t::HHF2[5]) or 0.25 (t::HHF2[0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml or in the absence of DOX and of BY4741 at 5 ␮g of DOX/ml (wild type [wt]). Cell growth of BY4741 was not affected by the presence or absence of DOX (data not shown). (C) Histone H4 content from strains described in panel B as determined by Western blot analysis. Total protein content was determined by Coomassie staining. The luminescence signals corresponding to histone H4 in t::HHF2[5] and t::HHF2[0.25] cells were 71 and 52% of the wild-type levels, respectively. 1528 PRADO AND AGUILERA MOL.CELL.BIOL. on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from FIG. 2. Analysis of plasmid superhelical density, chromatin accessibility, and nucleosome positioning in wild-type and t::HHF2 cells. (A) Topoisomer distribution of centromeric pRS316-SU and multicopy 2␮m plasmids after electrophoresis in agarose gels containing 4 ␮g of chloroquine/ ml. At this chloroquine concentration, negatively supercoiled topoisomers are resolved, consistent with a slower migration with 8 ␮gof chloroquine/ml (data not shown). r and sc indicate relaxed and negatively supercoiled plasmids, respectively. (B) MNase accessibility of bulk chromatin. MN, MNase I. (C and D) MNase digestion patterns of the endogenous GAL1 gene and the intervening sequence between the inverted leu2 repeats of the SU repeat system, respectively. A scheme of the analyzed sequences is shown on the left of each panel. Bands whose intensity is modified relative to the wild type are indicated with asterisks. Strains and other details are the same as for Fig. 1B. VOL. 25, 2005 PARTIAL HISTONE H4 DEPLETION INCREASES RECOMBINATION 1529 on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from wild-type copy of the LEU2 gene (45). As shown in Fig. 3A, deletions and inversions increased 5- to 10-fold above wildtype levels in hhf1⌬and hhf2⌬single mutants, in which histone H4 RNA accumulated at 40 and 80% of the wild-type levels, respectively (data not shown). Notably, the frequency of deletions increased 25- and 14-fold in t::HHF2[0.25] and t::HHF2 [5] cells, respectively, and the frequency of inversions increased 22- and 18-fold, respectively (Fig. 3A). Therefore, partial depletion of histone H4 causes genetic instability mediated by homologous recombination. To determine the genetic basis of the recombination events induced by partial depletion of histone H4, we analyzed the effects of rad52⌬,rad59⌬, and rad51⌬mutations (Fig. 3B), whose genetic consequences on recombination are known to depend on the type of event. Thus, deletions and inversions require Rad52 and Rad59, but they can occur efficiently in the absence of Rad51 (5, 7, 24, 48). As observed with wild-type cells, both deletions and inversions were partially dependent on Rad59 and completely dependent on Rad52 in t::HHF2 cells. However, the level of inversions stimulated by histone H4 depletion in rad51⌬cells was fourfold above the level in RAD51 cells. This indicates that homologous recombination in the absence of Rad51 is more efficient under conditions of histone H4 depletion. This is in agreement with the increase in FIG. 3. Recombination in cells partially depleted of histone H4. (A) Frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants in BY4741 (wild type [wt]), Y03144 (hhf1⌬), and Y15356 (hhf2⌬)at5␮g of DOX/ml and BYtetH4-10D at either 5 (t::HHF2[5]) or 0.25 (t::HHF2[0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml. (B) Frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants in BY4741 (wt), BY51 (rad51⌬), BY59 (rad59⌬), Y10540 (rad52⌬), BYtetH4-10D (t::HHF2[5]), BY51tetH4 (t::HHF2[5] rad51⌬), BY59tetH4 (t::HHF2[5] rad59⌬), and BY52tetH4 (t::HHF2[5] rad52⌬)at5␮g of DOX/ml. All strains carried either the pRS316-LY⌬NS or the pRS316-SU plasmid, harboring the direct repeat system LY⌬NS or the inverted repeat system SU, respectively. A scheme of each recombination system is shown at the top of the panels. The frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants of wild-type, hhf1⌬,hhf2⌬,rad51⌬,rad52⌬, and rad59⌬strains were not affected by the presence or absence of DOX (data not shown). The averages and standard deviations of three or four median frequencies obtained with two or three independent transformants are shown. 1530 PRADO AND AGUILERA MOL.CELL.BIOL. on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from recombination in rad51⌬cells carrying either a single copy of the histone H2A and H2B loci or the spt6-140 mutation (35) and the requirement for Rad51 in DSB-induced recombination in the silenced mating-type loci (57). Our results suggest that recombinational repair may be a highly relevant process for the viability of cells partially depleted of histone H4. Consistent with this conclusion rad52⌬ t::HHF2 cells grew poorly in 5 ␮g of DOX/ml and were extremely sick in 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml (Fig. 4A). Hyperrecombination induced by partial depletion of histone H4 is not associated with defective repair or transcription. Since the absence of the Asf1 and CAF1 chromatin assembly factors leads to defects in DNA repair and transcription (2, 17, 30, 58, 60), it was important to know whether partial depletion of histone H4 caused similar defects that could be associated with the increase in recombination. Thus, we analyzed the capacity of t::HHF2 cells to repair DNA lesions induced by either the alkylating agent MMS, the replication inhibitor HU, or UV light, which are subject to different DNA repair mechanisms (64). As can be seen in Fig. 4, t::HHF2 cell viability was not reduced by MMS or UV light and showed only a slight decrease at high levels of HU, as determined by CFU. Therefore, hyperrecombination in t::HHF2 cells seems not to be due to the recombinational processing of unrepaired DNA lesions. Histone H4 depletion affects global transcription regulation but not the expression levels of recombination proteins (66). However, since transcription induces homologous recombination (4), we wondered whether recombination induced by histone H4 depletion could be mediated by transcription. To analyze this possibility, three recombination systems based on the same direct repeats as those in the LY⌬NS system were used (Fig. 5). The first two systems differ in the presence (LNAT) or absence (LNA) of a terminator just downstream of the first leu2 repeat, which impedes transcription elongation progress through the intervening sequence located between the repeats. The third system (GL) is under the control of the GAL1 promoter; thus, transcription could be turned on and off with galactose or glucose, respectively. Recombination was analyzed in t::HHF2[5] cells for the LNA and LNAT systems because recombination levels were similar at 5 and 0.25 ␮gof DOX/ml (Fig. 3) and in hhf2⌬cells for the GL system because the GAL1 promoter was derepressed in t::HHF2 cells (data FIG. 4. DNA repair in cells partially depleted of histone H4. (A) Growth analysis of BYtetH4-10D (t::HHF2) and BY52tetH4 (t::HHF2 rad52⌬) at either 5 (t::HHF2[5]) or 0.25 (t::HHF2[0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml. (B, C, and D) UV light, HU, and MMS sensitivities of the strains indicated in the legend to Fig. 1, respectively. rad1⌬,asf1⌬, and rad52⌬strains are controls for UV light-, HU-, and MMS-induced DNA repair, respectively, and were analyzed at both 5 (t::HHF2[5]) and 0.25 (t::HHF2[0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml. Since UV light, HU, and MMS sensitivities of wild-type, rad52⌬,asf1⌬, and rad1⌬strains were not affected by the presence or absence of DOX (data not shown), only the data for 5 ␮g of DOX/ml are shown for these strains. VOL. 25, 2005 PARTIAL HISTONE H4 DEPLETION INCREASES RECOMBINATION 1531 on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from not shown). As can be seen in Fig. 5, hyperrecombination in t::HHF2[5] and hhf2⌬cells was independent of the transcriptional state of the DNA sequence (compare the LNA and GL [galactose] systems versus the LNAT and GL [glucose] systems). Therefore, hyperrecombination mediated by partial depletion of histone H4 is not dependent on transcription. Hyperrecombination induced by partial depletion of histone H4 is related to defective DNA replication. Given the tight connection between nucleosome assembly and DNA synthesis, we wondered whether hyperrecombination in t::HHF2 cells was linked to DNA replication defects. Thus, we would expect that growth retardation in t::HHF2 cells was due to a delay during the S and G 2 /M phases of the cell cycle. In accordance with this, DNA content analysis of asynchronous cultures by flow cytometry showed an accumulation of t::HHF2 cells during the S and G 2 /M phases with both 0.25 and 5 ␮g of DOX/ml (Fig. 6A). Also, t::HHF2 cells accumulated as budded cells and showed a heterogeneous increase in cell size (Fig. 6A). To confirm the delay during S phase, cell cycle progression of ␣-factor-synchronized cultures was monitored by flow cytometry. As shown in Fig. 6B (time zero), a fraction of t::HHF2 cells could not be arrested in G 1 with ␣factor, particularly in 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml. It is possible that this fraction corresponds to those t::HHF2 cells accumulated in G 2 /M that do not to progress into G 1 and consequently do not respond to ␣factor. Alternatively, t::HHF2 cells could be less sensitive to ␣factor. Indeed, t::HHF2[0.25] cells required five times more ␣factor for synchronization than wild-type cells. This reduced sensitiv- FIG. 5. Effect of transcription in recombination induced by partial depletion of histone H4. (A) leu2 RNA levels and frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants of strains Y07202 (wild type [wt]) and BYtetH4-10D (t::HHF2[5]) transformed with pRS314-LNA or pRS314-LNAT and grown in 5␮g of DOX/ml. (B) leu2 RNA levels and frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants of strains Y07202 (wt) and BYth2-1B (hhf2⌬) transformed with pRS314-GL and grown in either glucose- or galactose-containing medium, in which the GAL1 promoter of the GL system is either repressed or activated, respectively. Schemes of the direct repeat systems are shown. Dashed arrows indicate the transcripts produced by the recombination systems. As a probe, the ClaI-EcoRV LEU2 fragment was used. The averages and standard deviations of two to four median frequencies obtained with two to four independent transformants are shown. 1532 PRADO AND AGUILERA MOL.CELL.BIOL. on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from ity could also explain the apparent early entrance of t::HHF2[0.25] cells into S phase upon ␣-factor release (Fig. 6B, time 15⬘). Nevertheless, it is clear that most wild-type cells reached G 2 while t::HHF2 cells accumulated in S phase at 30 min upon release from ␣-factor arrest. Therefore, cells partially depleted of histone H4 accumulate in S and G 2 /M phases, in agreement with replication-associated cell cycle defects. To determine the importance of DNA replication, recombination in t::HHF2 cells was measured in the presence of HU, an inhibitor of nucleotide reductase, which pauses replication by limiting deoxynucleoside triphosphate pools (68). HU-me- diated impairment of DNA replication has been shown to lead to single- and double-strand DNA breaks and an increase in homologous recombination (19, 49). Importantly, HU-induced DNA damage is repaired in t::HHF2 cells (Fig. 4C). As shown in Fig. 7A, HU treatment increased recombination up to 15- fold in wild-type cells and only 2-fold in t::HHF2[5] cells. In addition, recombination frequencies were the same in wildtype and t::HHF2[5] cells at 100 mM HU. The lack of an additive effect of histone H4 depletion and HU on recombination is consistent with the idea that replication is the major process affected in histone H4-depleted cells. In this regard, the spt16-197 point mutation of SPT16, an essential chromatin remodeling gene involved in replication (25), does not affect growth of t::HHF2 cells at either 5 or 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml (data not shown). These results are consistent with the idea that the recombination events induced by partial depletion of histone H4 may by associated with replication defects. Partial depletion of histone H4 leads to an accumulation of Rad52 foci during DNA replication. To determine whether recombinogenic DNA lesions were accumulated during replication as a consequence of the depletion of histone H4, the formation of Rad52-YFP foci was analyzed. These foci have previously been shown to appear both spontaneously and in response to DSBs during S and G 2 /M phases, providing a FIG. 6. Cell cycle analysis of cells partially depleted of histone H4. (A) DNA content and cell morphology of asynchronous cultures of the strains and at the conditions indicated in the legend to Fig. 1. Similar profiles were obtained with BYtetH4l-1C (data not shown). (B) Cell cycle progression of BYtetH4l-1C at either 5 (t::HHF2[5]) or 0.25 (t::HHF2[0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml and of BY4741 at 5 ␮g of DOX/ml (wild type [wt]). DNA content of wild-type and t::HHF2 cells was determined by flow cytometry at the indicated times upon release from ␣-factor arrest in G 1 . FIG. 7. (A) Effect of HU on recombination induced by partial depletion of histone H4. Frequencies of Leu ⫹ recombinants of the strains indicated in the legend to Fig. 1 grown with 5 ␮g of DOX/ml and either 0, 25, or 100 mM HU. (B) Accumulation of Rad52-YFP foci in t::HHF2 cells. Rad52-YFP foci were visualized by fluorescence microscopy in asynchronous cultures of BYtetH4-10D transformed with pWJ1344 and grown in either 5 (t::HHF2[5]) or 0.25 (t::HHF2 [0.25]) ␮g of DOX/ml and of BY4741 transformed with pWJ1344 and grown in 5 ␮g of DOX/ml (wild type [wt]). The percentages of unbudded (G 1 ) and budded (S and G 2 /M) wild-type and t::HHF2 cells containing Rad52-YFP foci are shown. The total numbers of analyzed cells were 50 for unbudded cells and 150 for budded cells. The averages and standard deviations of two independent experiments are plotted. VOL. 25, 2005 PARTIAL HISTONE H4 DEPLETION INCREASES RECOMBINATION 1533 on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from specific link between DNA replication and homologous recombination (32, 33). As previously published, Rad52-YFP foci were detected in 3% of unbudded (G 1 ) and 18% of budded (S and G 2 /M) wild-type cells (Fig. 7B) (33). In t::HHF2 cells the Rad52-YFP foci appeared at wild-type levels (4%) in unbudded cells but increased to 46 and 51% in budded cells in the presence of 5 and 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml, respectively (Fig. 7B). Therefore, partial depletion of histone H4 leads to an accumulation of DNA lesions during DNA replication that are repaired by homologous recombination. DISCUSSION In this study we show that partial depletion of histone H4 affects chromatin assembly and causes genetic instability by increasing the frequency of homologous recombination between ectopic DNA sequences. This increase in recombination is associated with an accumulation of Rad52-YFP foci and a cell cycle delay during the S and G 2 /M phases. Our results suggest that defective chromatin assembly mediated by partial depletion of histone H4 impairs DNA synthesis and leads to the formation of recombinogenic structures. To impair nucleosome deposition during DNA replication, a yeast strain (t::HHF2) in which the expression of histone H4 is under the control of the regulated tet promoter was constructed. This strain can be gradually depleted of histone H4. Our results suggest that chromatin assembly is affected in this strain. Thus, partial depletion of histone H4 leads to subtle changes in plasmid superhelical density and chromatin accessibility to MNase, particularly at 0.25 ␮g of DOX/ml. Also, t::HHF2 cells are delayed in the S and G 2 /M phases and accumulate as budded cells with a heterogeneous increase in cell size. Our results are reminiscent of those obtained for cells completely depleted of histone H4, which show dramatic changes in plasmid topology and chromatin accessibility and stop growing at the S and G 2 /M phases of the cell cycle (27). It is worth noting that chromatin assembly factor mutants display phenotypes similar to those of t::HHF2 cells. Thus, yeast mutants lacking the chromatin assembly factor Asf1 accumulate as large cells in S and G 2 /M phases (60) and display similar alterations in chromatin accessibility to MNase (46). In addition, the superhelical density of the centromeric plasmid pRS316-SU is increased in t::HHF2 and asf1⌬cells (Fig. 2A; 46), whereas the supercoiling of the endogenous 2␮m plasmid is decreased in t::HHF2 cells (Fig. 2A) and increased in asf1⌬ cells (data not shown; 3). Similar observations have been reported for human cells, in which HIRA-mediated histone repression and expression of a dominant-negative mutation of the chromatin assembly factor p150CAF-1 cause chromatin hypersensitivity and replication defects (40, 67). In this sense, it is worth noting that histone depletion causes S-phase arrest in human cells (40) but S-phase delay and G 2 /M arrest in yeast cells as determined by flow cytometry (Fig. 6B; 27). The most relevant observation of this study is that partial depletion of histone H4 increases recombination between ectopic DNA sequences up to 20-fold above wild-type levels. These recombination events are RAD52 dependent, as expected for events occurring by homologous recombination mechanisms. The importance of recombinational repair in cells depleted partially of histone H4 is supported by the severe growth defects of t::HHF2 rad52⌬cells. Notably, recombination was 5- to 10-fold above wild-type levels in hhf1⌬and hhf2⌬ single mutants, in which histone H4 RNA levels were reduced to 80% of that of the wild type. Our results strongly suggest that DNA stability is sensitive to slight reductions in the pool of histone H4. In accordance with this idea, deletion of HHF1 has been shown to result in telomeric sequence instability, manifested by changes in their length and sequence organization (61). The effect on recombination is less evident for a deletion of one of the two genes coding for histones H2A and H2B (35). Altogether, these results are consistent with the central role of the H3/H4 tetramer in nucleosome assembly (59). The increase in recombination and its association with an accumulation of Rad52-YFP foci in t::HHF2 cells are consistent with a general role of proper chromatin assembly in preventing genetic instability. This is strongly supported by our recent observation that yeast cells lacking the chromatin assembly factor Asf1 also display an increase in recombination and an accumulation of Rad52-YFP foci (46). In contrast to cells lacking Asf1, histone H4 depletion does not impair DNA repair, and consequently, this rules out the possibility that the increase in recombination could be due to the channeling of unrepaired DNA lesions into homologous recombination. The influence of chromatin assembly in genome integrity is also supported by the observations that a thermosensitive spt6-140 mutation leads to hyperrecombination (35) and that a chromatin assembly factor p150CAF-1 dominant-negative mutant accumulates DNA breaks and induces S-phase arrest in human cells (67). In the same vein, the absence of the yeast chromatin assembly factors CAF-1 and Asf1 leads to gross chromosomal rearrangements (GCRs) (39). These rearrangements are Rad52 and homology independent. Indeed, the frequency of GCRs is synergistically increased in rad52⌬mutants, indicating that homologous recombination partially suppresses GCRs (39). The results of the present study provide evidence that the defects in chromatin assembly also increase genetic instability mediated by homologous recombination. The tight connection between chromatin assembly and DNA synthesis provides a framework to explain the genetic instability reported here. Defective chromatin assembly could impair DNA synthesis, thus leading to the accumulation of recombinogenic structures. Consistent with this interpretation, we have shown that t::HHF2 cells are delayed during S phase and accumulate in G 2 /M. Also, the observation that hyperrecombination in t::HHF2 cells is not further increased by the presence of the replication inhibitor HU suggests that it results from lesions generated during DNA replication. Indeed, t::HHF2 cells accumulate Rad52-YFP foci (Fig. 7), which have been shown to appear spontaneously and in response to DSBs during the S and G 2 /M phases (33). Our results are in accordance with the observation that the lethality associated with total depletion of histone H4 occurs in S phase (27). Altogether, these results strengthen the idea that homologous recombination has an important role in the control of the accuracy of DNA replication. Presumably, defective nucleosome assembly increases the basal rate of replication-mediated DNA lesions and, in turn, the requirement of the recombination machinery for the repair of these lesions. Partial depletion of 1534 PRADO AND AGUILERA MOL.CELL.BIOL. on July 5, 2017 by USE/BCTA.GEN UNIVERSITARIAhttp://mcb.asm.org/Downloaded from