Semisynthesis of Betaxanthins from Purified Betacyanin of Opuntia dillenii sp.: Color Stability and Antiradical Capacity

Citation: Cruz, S.; Checa, N.; Tovar, H.; Cejudo-Bastante, M.J.; Heredia, F.J.; Hurtado, N. Semisynthesis of Betaxanthins from Purified Betacyanin of Opuntia dillenii sp.: Color Stability and Antiradical Capacity. Molecules 2024,29, 2116. https://doi.org/10.3390/ molecules29092116 Academic Editor: RuAngelie Edrada-Ebel Received: 3 April 2024 Revised: 21 April 2024 Accepted: 23 April 2024 Published: 3 May 2024 Copyright: © 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). molecules Article Semisynthesis of Betaxanthins from Purified Betacyanin of Opuntia dillenii sp.: Color Stability and Antiradical Capacity Silvia Cruz 1, Neyder Checa 1, Hugo Tovar 1, María Jesús Cejudo-Bastante 2,* , Francisco J. Heredia 2 and Nelson Hurtado 1 1Grupo de Investigación en Productos de Importancia Biológica (GIPIB), Universidad de Nariño, San Juan de Pasto, Nariño 1175, Colombia; [email protected] (S.C.); [email protected] (N.C.); [email protected] (H.T.); [email protected] (N.H.) 2Food Colour and Quality Laboratory, Área de Nutrición y Bromatología, Facultad de Farmacia, Universidad de Sevilla, 41012 Sevilla, Spain; [email protected] *Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: The availability of pure individual betalains in sufficient quantities which permit deeper understanding is still a challenge. This study investigates the high-yielding semisynthesis of betaxanthins using betalamic acid from a natural source (Opuntia dillenii), followed by condensation with Ï− amino acids and further purification. Moreover, the color stability of the four synthesized individual betaxanthins, namely proline ( Ï− ProBX), alanine ( Ï− AlaBX), leucine ( Ï− LeuBX), and phenylalanine ( Ï− PheBX) betaxanthins, was investigated at different pHs. Their relative contribution to free radical scavenging was also scrutinized by TEAC and DPPH. Ï− AlaBX and Ï− LeuBx showed a significantly (p< 0.05) higher antioxidant activity, whereas Ï− ProBX was the most resistant to the hydrolysis of betaxanthin and hence the least susceptible to color change. The color stability was strongly influenced by pH, with the color of Ï− ProBX, Ï− LeuBX, and Ï− AlaBX at pH 6 being more stable, probably due to the easier hydrolysis under acid conditions. The semisynthesis and purification allowed us to have available remarkable quantities of pure individual betaxanthins of Opuntia dillenii for the first time, and to establish their color properties and antioxidant capacity. This study could be a step forward in the development of the best natural food colorant formulation, based on the betalain structure, which is of special interest in food technology. Keywords: Opuntia dillenii; betaxanthins; semisynthesis; color stability; antioxidant capacity 1. Introduction Bioactive compounds, specifically pigments such as anthocyanins, betalains, and carotenes, isolated from natural sources, have demonstrated significant potential as food colorants and in preventing free radical damage as a food component and antioxidant agent in the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industry [ 1 ]. Additionally, drugs derived from plants containing these compounds play a crucial role in the prevention and treatment of human diseases [ 2 – 4 ]. Among these compounds, betalains are characterized by the presence of betalamic acid (4-(2-oxoethylidene)-1,2,3,4-tetrahydropyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid) as a structural unit, and their classification depends on the type of residue that is condensed with them. If they are amines or amino acids, they are referred to as betaxanthins, displaying a yellow-orange color. Alternatively, they are called betacyanins if they are condensed with cyclo-DOPA and its glycosylated derivatives, exhibiting a violet-purple color [5]. The fruit of Opuntia dillenii, a cactus plant, is typically found in tropical and subtropical regions, primarily in desert or semi-desert areas. In Colombia, the species is mainly located in the dry regions of the Santander, Nariño, and la Guajira departments [ 6 ]. The pigments found in this type of cactus belong to the betalain class [ 2 , 6 ]. According to a recent study published by our research group [ 6 ], the betalain extract derived from Opuntia dillenii sp. is Molecules 2024,29, 2116. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules29092116 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/molecules Molecules 2024,29, 2116 2 of 15 a rich source of antioxidants. It contains a betacyanin content of 16.63 mg betanin/100 g fresh fruit and a betaxanthin content of 7.55 mg indicaxanthin/100 g fresh fruit, containing major betacyanins such as 17-decarboxybetanin and 17-decarboxyisobetanin, 6 ′ -O-sinapoylO-gomphrenin and 6 ′ -O-sinapoyl-O-isogomphrenine, and 2 ′ -O-apiosyl-4-O-phyllocactin and 5 ′′ -O-E-sinapoyl-2 ′ -apiosyl-phyllocactin, as well as betaxanthins (tryptophan, prolineand tyrosine-betaxanthins (portulacaxanthin II), and some polyphenolic compounds, such as isoramnethin-3-glucuronide and quercetin-3-O-glucoside. Betalains are highly significant not only for their coloring abilities but also for their nutraceutical potential and biological activity. Several studies have reported on their antiinflammatory, antitumor, neuroprotective, hepatoprotective, and hypotensive properties [3,5] , as well as their antioxidant activity [ 3 – 11 ]. These studies indicate that extracts rich in betalains generally exhibit higher antioxidant activity compared to commonly used antioxidants such as ascorbic acid, catechin, and trolox [ 7 , 11 , 12 ]. Also, recent research has examined the potential applications of these fruit pigments in the food and cosmetic industries [ 2 , 13 ]. Moreover, betalains offer an advantage for the food industry as they are more water-soluble and have a coloring capacity three times greater than carotenes and anthocyanins. Additionally, they demonstrate greater stability at a pH level between 3 and 5, making them well-suited dye options for neutral or low-acid foods [ 14 , 15 ]. Therefore, due to consumers’ increasing demands for healthy and natural foods in both manufacturing and consumption, betalains are compounds of special interest for the food industry and deserve a deeper knowledge of their behavior. The majority of the biological activities and color characteristics are reported with plant extracts that have undergone limited pigment purification [ 6 , 12 , 16 , 17 ]. While these studies are helpful for identifying potential activities, it is imperative to have available individual and pure betalains to evaluate the described effects. Nonetheless, the limited presence and low concentration of these pigments in plants, together with betalains, make them arduous to isolate from crude extracts and have a low yield [ 3 , 8 , 18 , 19 ], making their purification challenging. An alternative approach would be to synthesize these compounds in the laboratory. However, obtaining them by total synthesis is also challenging due to the high toxicity of the reagents, the low yields, and the numerous synthesis steps involved [ 20 , 21 ]. Consequently, Gandía-Herrero’s group [ 12 , 21 ] proposed semisynthesis protocols, based on fast-flow Q-Sepharose resin, to obtain betalamic acid through the hydrolysis of red beet betanin. Despite enabling the production of semisynthetic products, they still reported low yields or required several inefficient purification steps [ 22 – 25 ]. Biotechnological procedures for acquiring betalains in microbial reactors have been recently published [ 19 ], but they can be costly and time-consuming [ 19 ]. For obtaining betaxanthins specifically, there are limited reports detailing their synthesis and, unfortunately, the use of the extracted betalamic acid from crude betalain extracts can negatively impact betaxanthins’ performance and purification processes. Therefore, this study introduces the semisynthesis of betaxanthins, utilizing betacyanin fractions obtained from Opuntia dillenii fruit as a starting point, and using a less-polar resin based on a counterion, Cl − , allowing interactions via the quaternary amino groups and vinyl groups to occur. Compared to Gandia-Herrero [ 21 ], the present methodology permits the whole raw material (Opuntia dillenii) to be used and the entire synthesis mixture to be purified in a single step, rather than using a fast-flow chromatography system with a Q-Sepharose column. Thus, this fact allowed for a longer contact time between the synthesis mixture and the IRA-402 resin, removing the linked molecules by increasing the ionic strength through elution with Cl − . Betalamic acid, obtained by betacyanin hydrolysis, and different Ï− amino acids participate in in situ condensing reactions to synthesize the respective betaxanthins. Further purification processes were also undertaken to achieve high-purity betaxanthins. This work presents the first report on the synthesis of high-yield betaxanthins from purified betacyanins of Opuntia dilleni. In addition, the correlation between the structural makeup and antiradical capacity (ABTS and DPPH) and their color properties depending on Molecules 2024,29, 2116 3 of 15 pH over time were scrutinized, which could be of special interest in the natural food colorant industry. 2. Results and Discussion 2.1. Isolation of the Purified Extract from the Fruit of Opuntia Dilleni and Obtaining Betalamic Acid The synthesis of betaxanthins utilizes betalamic acid (BA) as the starting compound, which is the structural unit of betalains. BA is typically produced by hydrolyzing crude extracts of betalains [ 23 , 24 ]. Our work involved isolating the crude extract (CE) (228 g) and obtaining a purified extract (PE1) that was free of mucilage and proteins. Subsequently, an extract free of colorless polyphenols (PE2) was obtained, from which the betacyanins (PE3, magenta color) and betaxanthins (yellow color) [6] were derived (Figure 1). Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 of 16 Opuntia dilleni. In addition, the correlation between the structural make-up and antiradical capacity (ABTS and DPPH) and their color properties depending on pH over time were scrutinized, which could be of special interest in the natural food colorant industry. 2. Results and Discussion 2.1. Isolation of the Purified Extract from the Fruit of Opuntia Dilleni and Obtaining Betalamic Acid The synthesis of betaxanthins utilizes betalamic acid (BA) as the starting compound, which is the structural unit of betalains. BA is typically produced by hydrolyzing crude extracts of betalains [23,24]. Our work involved isolating the crude extract (CE) (228 g) and obtaining a purified extract (PE1) that was free of mucilage and proteins. Subsequently, an extract free of colorless polyphenols (PE2) was obtained, from which the betacyanins (PE3, magenta color) and betaxanthins (yellow color) [6] were derived (Figure 1). Figure 1. HPLC–DAD chromatogram: (A) Purified magenta fraction, 538 nm (PE3), and (B) purified yellow fraction, 480 nm. (1) Betanin, (2) 17-decarboxy-betanin, (3) isobetanin, (4) 17-descarboxyisobetanin, (5) tryptophan-betaxanthin, (6) tyrosine-betaxanthin, (7) proline–betaxanthin. Spectrophotometric analysis revealed that the fruit (CE) contains 16.33 ± 0.3 mg betanin/100 g of fresh fruit and a betaxanthin content of 7.15 ± 0.1 mg indicaxanthin/100 g of fresh fruit. BA was obtained by hydrolysis of PE3; to achieve this, 10 mL of PE3 with a concentration of 11.5 mg betanin/L, which is equivalent to 2.1 × 10 −4 mmol betanin, was used. Figure 2 shows the hydrolysis of PE3 and the formation of BA. The presence of a maximum at 424 nm indicates the formation of light–yellow BA. Figure 1. HPLC–DAD chromatogram: (A) Purified magenta fraction, 538 nm (PE3), and (B) purified yellow fraction, 480 nm. (1) Betanin, (2) 17-decarboxy-betanin, (3) isobetanin, (4) 17-descarboxyisobetanin, (5) tryptophan-betaxanthin, (6) tyrosine-betaxanthin, (7) proline–betaxanthin. Spectrophotometric analysis revealed that the fruit (CE) contains 16.33 ± 0.3 mg betanin/100 g of fresh fruit and a betaxanthin content of 7.15 ± 0.1 mg indicaxanthin/100 g of fresh fruit. BA was obtained by hydrolysis of PE3; to achieve this, 10 mL of PE3 with a concentration of 11.5 mg betanin/L, which is equivalent to 2.1 × 10 −4 mmol betanin, was used. Figure 2shows the hydrolysis of PE3 and the formation of BA. The presence of a maximum at 424 nm indicates the formation of light–yellow BA. Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 4 of 16 Figure 2. UV–Vis spectrum of the PE3 fraction before and after hydrolysis. This betanin, after hydrolysis, should theoretically produce 0.0443 mg of BA. In order to quantify the hydrolysis, the generated BA was purified using Amberlite IRA-402 resin, and the purified extract was immediately quantified by UV–Vis. The photometric measurement (ε = 27,000 L/mol cm) showed a final concentration of 4.68 mg BA/L (0.0441 mg of BA), indicating a percentage of hydrolysis close to 100% under the given methodological conditions. 2.2. Semisynthesis of ʟ −Amino Acid-Betaxanthins Due to previous publications [20,24] in which low yields were obtained when purified BA was reacted with amino acids, an in situ reaction between the two components was carried out in this work. Four betaxanthins of ʟ−amino acid origin were synthesized, namely ʟ−proline betaxanthin (ʟ−ProBX), ʟ−alanine betaxanthin (ʟ−AlaBX), ʟ−leucine betaxanthin (ʟ−LeuBX), and ʟ−phenylalanine betaxanthin (ʟ−PheBX) (Figure 3). In in situ synthesis, excess amino acids shift the equilibrium towards betaxanthin formation, thus avoiding condensation with cyclo−Dopa and reducing the number of synthesis steps. The condensation of BA with the amino acid was carried out in a single step without prior purification of the BA [21]. Figure 3. Structures of semisynthetic ʟ−amino acid-betaxanthins: (1) ʟ−ProBX, (2) ʟ−AlaBX, (3) ʟ−LeuBX, (4) ʟ−PheBX. Finally, in order to purify the betaxanthins, it was essential to use Amberlite IRA-402. The Amberlite IRA-402 ion-exchange resin was utilized as a microreticular gel with quaternary ammonium groups as an exchange group. This is because the carboxylate groups (–COO − ) of the betaxanthins can replace the exchangeable chloride anions of the resin, compensating for the positive charge of the quaternary ammonium groups. N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH N H N H H3C COOH H HOOC COOH N H N H COOH H HOOC COOH N H N H COOH H HOOC COOH C H3 H3C 123 4 Figure 2. UV–Vis spectrum of the PE3 fraction before and after hydrolysis. Molecules 2024,29, 2116 4 of 15 This betanin, after hydrolysis, should theoretically produce 0.0443 mg of BA. In order to quantify the hydrolysis, the generated BA was purified using Amberlite IRA-402 resin, and the purified extract was immediately quantified by UV–Vis. The photometric measurement ( ε = 27,000 L/mol cm) showed a final concentration of 4.68 mg BA/L (0.0441 mg of BA), indicating a percentage of hydrolysis close to 100% under the given methodological conditions. 2.2. Semisynthesis of Ï−Amino Acid-Betaxanthins Due to previous publications [ 20 , 24 ] in which low yields were obtained when purified BA was reacted with amino acids, an in situ reaction between the two components was carried out in this work. Four betaxanthins of Ï− amino acid origin were synthesized, namely Ï− proline betaxanthin ( Ï− ProBX), Ï− alanine betaxanthin ( Ï− AlaBX), Ï− leucine betaxanthin ( Ï− LeuBX), and Ï− phenylalanine betaxanthin ( Ï− PheBX) (Figure 3). In in situ synthesis, excess amino acids shift the equilibrium towards betaxanthin formation, thus avoiding condensation with cyclo − Dopa and reducing the number of synthesis steps. The condensation of BA with the amino acid was carried out in a single step without prior purification of the BA [21]. Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 4 of 16 Figure 2. UV–Vis spectrum of the PE3 fraction before and after hydrolysis. This betanin, after hydrolysis, should theoretically produce 0.0443 mg of BA. In order to quantify the hydrolysis, the generated BA was purified using Amberlite IRA-402 resin, and the purified extract was immediately quantified by UV–Vis. The photometric measurement (ε = 27,000 L/mol cm) showed a final concentration of 4.68 mg BA/L (0.0441 mg of BA), indicating a percentage of hydrolysis close to 100% under the given methodological conditions. 2.2. Semisynthesis of ʟ −Amino Acid-Betaxanthins Due to previous publications [20,24] in which low yields were obtained when purified BA was reacted with amino acids, an in situ reaction between the two components was carried out in this work. Four betaxanthins of ʟ−amino acid origin were synthesized, namely ʟ−proline betaxanthin (ʟ−ProBX), ʟ−alanine betaxanthin (ʟ−AlaBX), ʟ−leucine betaxanthin (ʟ−LeuBX), and ʟ−phenylalanine betaxanthin (ʟ−PheBX) (Figure 3). In in situ synthesis, excess amino acids shift the equilibrium towards betaxanthin formation, thus avoiding condensation with cyclo−Dopa and reducing the number of synthesis steps. The condensation of BA with the amino acid was carried out in a single step without prior purification of the BA [21]. Figure 3. Structures of semisynthetic ʟ−amino acid-betaxanthins: (1) ʟ−ProBX, (2) ʟ−AlaBX, (3) ʟ−LeuBX, (4) ʟ−PheBX. Finally, in order to purify the betaxanthins, it was essential to use Amberlite IRA-402. The Amberlite IRA-402 ion-exchange resin was utilized as a microreticular gel with quaternary ammonium groups as an exchange group. This is because the carboxylate groups (–COO − ) of the betaxanthins can replace the exchangeable chloride anions of the resin, compensating for the positive charge of the quaternary ammonium groups. N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH N H N H H3C COOH H HOOC COOH N H N H COOH H HOOC COOH N H N H COOH H HOOC COOH C H3 H3C 123 4 Figure 3. Structures of semisynthetic Ï− amino acid-betaxanthins: (1) Ï− ProBX, (2) Ï− AlaBX, (3)Ï−LeuBX, (4)Ï−PheBX. Finally, in order to purify the betaxanthins, it was essential to use Amberlite IRA402. The Amberlite IRA-402 ion-exchange resin was utilized as a microreticular gel with quaternary ammonium groups as an exchange group. This is because the carboxylate groups (–COO − ) of the betaxanthins can replace the exchangeable chloride anions of the resin, compensating for the positive charge of the quaternary ammonium groups. Unbound substances are easily removed by washing with water [ 22 ], and the betaxanthins bound to the resin are finally eluted with NaCl due to the increase in ionic strength [26]. Figure 4shows the HPLC − DAD chromatogram of the synthesized betaxanthins. The analysis of abundance data for the diastereoisomers indicated a higher abundance for the S,S isomer in all cases. This is in accordance with previous findings by other researchers [ 20 , 21 ]. In addition, as the BA molecule has S and R isomers in its structure, the synthesis process generated S,S and S,R diastereoisomers. Table 1shows the ratio, yields, and % area of the diastereoisomers. In the case of Ï− ProBX, the S,S diastereoisomer represents 66.4% of the total area, while S,R represents 33.6%. This betaxanthin is present in Opuntia dillenii fruit [ 6 ] and could serve as a standard to identify this compound in other plant materials. To calculate the reaction yields, in the case of Ï− ProBX, 7 mL of PE3 (which is equivalent to 1.17 × 10 −3 mmol BA) was mixed with 0.819 mmol Ï− proline, which theoretically should yield 1.17 × 10 −3 mmol Ï− ProBX (0.361 mg). The final concentration was 16.22 mg Ï− ProBX/L (8.92 × 10 −4 mmol Ï− ProBX, 0.275 mg), with a yield of 76.2% (mg Ï− ProBX/100 mg Ï− ProBX theoretical). The same procedure was followed for the synthesis of the other betaxanthins (Table 1). Despite the lack of reports using this type of Molecules 2024,29, 2116 5 of 15 synthesis from purified betacyanin extracts, some groups have published lower yields than those obtained in this study [20,24,25]. Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 16 Unbound substances are easily removed by washing with water [22], and the betaxanthins bound to the resin are finally eluted with NaCl due to the increase in ionic strength [26]. Figure 4 shows the HPLC−DAD chromatogram of the synthesized betaxanthins. The analysis of abundance data for the diastereoisomers indicated a higher abundance for the S,S isomer in all cases. This is in accordance with previous findings by other researchers [20,21]. In addition, as the BA molecule has S and R isomers in its structure, the synthesis process generated S,S and S,R diastereoisomers. Table 1 shows the ratio, yields, and % area of the diastereoisomers. In the case of ʟ−ProBX, the S,S diastereoisomer represents 66.4% of the total area, while S,R represents 33.6%. This betaxanthin is present in Opuntia dillenii fruit [6] and could serve as a standard to identify this compound in other plant materials. Figure 4. HPLC–DAD chromatogram of the synthesized betaxanthins, including the S,S (higher retention) and S,R (lower retention) diastereoisomers. Table 1. UV−Vis data, experimental and theoretical ratio, and yield of synthesized betaxanthins and abundance of each stereoisomer. Betaxanthin λ max Ratio Experimental/Theoretical Yield (%) % Area (HPLC) S,S/S,R ʟ−ProBX 484 0.275/0.361 76.2 66.4/33.6 ʟ−AlaBx 475 0.149/0.198 75.3 47.8/45.2 ʟ−LeuBX 475 0.267/0.379 70.1 72.7/27.3 ʟ−PheBX 477 0.482/0.697 69.2 86.3/13.7 To calculate the reaction yields, in the case of ʟ−ProBX, 7 mL of PE3 (which is equivalent to 1.17 × 10 −3 mmol BA) was mixed with 0.819 mmol ʟ−proline, which theoretically should yield 1.17 × 10 −3 mmol ʟ−ProBX (0.361 mg). The final concentration was 16.22 mg ʟ−ProBX/L (8.92 × 10 −4 mmol ʟ−ProBX, 0.275 mg), with a yield of 76.2% (mg ʟ−ProBX/100 mg ʟ−ProBX theoretical). The same procedure was followed for the synthesis of the other betaxanthins (Table 1). Despite the lack of reports using this type of synthesis from purified betacyanin extracts, some groups have published lower yields than those obtained in this study [20,24,25]. Figure 4. HPLC–DAD chromatogram of the synthesized betaxanthins, including the S,S (higher retention) and S,R (lower retention) diastereoisomers. Table 1. UV − Vis data, experimental and theoretical ratio, and yield of synthesized betaxanthins and abundance of each stereoisomer. Betaxanthin λmax Ratio Experimental/Theoretical Yield (%) % Area (HPLC) S,S/S,R Ï−ProBX 484 0.275/0.361 76.2 66.4/33.6 Ï−AlaBx 475 0.149/0.198 75.3 47.8/45.2 Ï−LeuBX 475 0.267/0.379 70.1 72.7/27.3 Ï−PheBX 477 0.482/0.697 69.2 86.3/13.7 2.3. Tentative Characterization of Betaxanthins by UV-Vis and HPLC-ESI-MS Table 2and Figure S1 present the m/zratio of the pseudomolecular ion in positive [M + H]+ mode. The Ï− ProBX compound exhibited an m/zof 310.02547 [M + H] + units, which was confirmed by the presence of an absorption peak at λmax 484 nm due to the absorption generated by the π→π* transitions characteristic of betaxanthins. Table 2. Molecular formula, retention times, and mass spectral values of semisynthetic betaxanthins identified by UHPLC-ESI-MS. Betaxanthin Molecular Formula Rt(min) (S,S/S,R) m/z[M + H]+ Ï−ProBX C14H17N2O68.6/7.9 310.02547 Ï−AlaBx C12H15N2O65.4/5.1 284.16047 Ï−LeuBX C15H21N2O628.8/26.4 326.80460 Ï−PheBX C18H19N2O632.0/29.5 360.12592 The pseudomolecular ion for the Ï− AlaBX molecule was observed at m/z284.16047 [M + H]+ . For Ï− LeuBX, the pseudomolecular ion was observed at m/z326.80460 [M + H]+ , Molecules 2024,29, 2116 6 of 15 and for Ï− PheBX, the pseudomolecular ion was observed at m/z360.13 [M + H] + in positive mode (Table 2). Comparing the retention times with those published in the literature [18,19,26] , it is observed that they follow the same trend, i.e., the S,S diastereoisomers retained more than the S,R ones. These data, together with their λmax (Table 1) and mass values, are similar to those reported in the literature [ 20 , 21 ], confirming the synthesis of these compounds. 2.4. Determination of the Antioxidant Capacity Due to the complexity of oxidative reactions, a single assay may not be sufficient to predict all oxidative details in molecules. Therefore, antioxidant assays based on electron transfer (such as TEAC and DPPH) were conducted to estimate the antioxidant potential of the synthesized betaxanthins. The mechanism is based on the electron transfer capacity of betaxanthins to inhibit ABTS •+ and DPPH • radicals. As different studies have found that the antioxidant capacity depends on the pH of the surrounding medium, in this study, measurements were carried out at pH 7 (Table 3). The TEAC value of ascorbic acid (1.24 ± 0.01 mmol trolox/mmol BX), the positive control, agreed with that used by other authors [27]. Table 3. Antioxidant capacity values by TEAC and DPPH. Betaxanthin TEAC (mmol Tx/mmol BX) DPPH (% Inhibition) Ï−ProBX 1.17 ±0.07 a9.85 ±1.48 a Ï−AlaBx 2.27 ±0.04 b16.22 ±1.49 b Ï−LeuBX 1.61 ±0.03 c12.54 ±1.36 c Ï−PheBX 1.27 ±0.03 a11.32 ±1.97 c Betalamic acid 2.15 ±0.62 b8.73 ±1.39 a Values are expressed as mean ± SD (n= 3). Values in the same column followed by different letters are significantly different by ANOVA test (p< 0.05). Table 3shows the ability of the synthesized molecules and betalamic acid to reduce ABTS •+ and DPPH • radicals. According to data analysis using Fisher’s least significant difference (LSD) procedure with a confidence level of 95% and a statistical significance of p< 0.05, betalamic acid exhibits superior antioxidant properties compared to ascorbic acid. The antiradical capacity followed the following order: Ï− AlaBX > Ï− LeuXx > Ï− PheBX, Ï− ProBX. The analysis of the synthesized betaxanthins indicates that the Ï− AlaBX molecule was more effective in capturing the free radicals ABTS •+ and DPPH • than Ï− ProBX, Ï− LeuBX, and Ï− PheBX (Table 3). The pigments selected for synthesis in this study exhibit amino acids with structural diversity that reacted with the aldehyde group of betalamic acid through a Schiff condensation reaction. The pigment Ï− PheBX contains a phenyl group in its structure, while Ï− AlaBX and Ï− LeuBX have a linear chain to the carboxylic acid. Furthermore, Ï− ProBX has a positively charged iminium group within its structure, as depicted in Figure 3. Therefore, it seemed that molecules with a linear chain to the carboxylic acid show the highest antiradical capacity (Table 3). Likewise, significant differences in TEAC’s and DPPH’s antiradical capacity were observed between Ï− ProBX, which has a lower antioxidant capacity, and Ï− AlaBX, Ï− LeuBX, and betalamic acid (Table 3). The difference between the values could be associated with the findings of Esteves [ 24 ], Fernando [ 9 ], and Gandía-Herrero [ 28 ], who suggest that the presence of the positively charged iminium group of the secondary amine causes a decrease in antioxidant capacity. This behavior demonstrates how the structural characteristics of the molecule affect its capacity to eliminate free radicals. In the case of Ï− Phe-BX, which has an antiradical activity comparable to Ï− ProBX, the low antiradical activity may be due to the fact that the aromatic ring of this molecule does not participate in the resonance delocalization of the 1,7-diazaheptamethinium system [ 25 , 28 ]. The lower antiradical activity of Ï− ProBX can be attributed to the presence of the imino group of the secondary amine, Molecules 2024,29, 2116 7 of 15 which stabilizes the molecule. In the case of Ï− PheBX, its low activity may be due to the fact that the aromatic ring does not participate in resonance delocalization. These findings are in accordance with previous research [ 25 , 28 ] and help in understanding antiradical mechanisms. The different structural characteristics of the synthesized betaxanthins have been studied in previous research on betaxanthins [28,29]. 2.5. Stability Evaluation of Semisynthetic Ï−Amino Acid-Betaxanthins by Tristimulus Colorimetry This study examines how the structure of betaxanthins, produced by creating the aldimine bond between betalamic acid and four chosen amino acids for semisynthesis, influences the color and storage stability at pH 4 and pH 6. The four synthesized betaxanthin solutions were kept for eight days at room temperature (18 ◦ C) in the dark and in the presence of oxygen at pH 4 and pH 6. Based on the CIELAB parameters (L*, a*, b*, C* ab , h ab ) (Table 4), the color stability of betaxanthins is dependent on both pH and structure. The aqueous solutions of the betaxanthins (5 × 10 −5 M) prepared early (t = 0) showed the highest chroma value (C* ab ) at the highest pH value (pH 6), indicating a greater intensity of color (higher color purity). However, at this pH, the solutions tended to be lighter (higher L*). The molecule Ï− AlaBX exhibited the highest C* ab value (51.0, pH 6), that is, it showed a greater color intensity (greater color purity), while Ï− PheBX exhibited the lowest chroma value (16.4, pH 4). Furthermore, at pH 4, all betaxanthin solutions displayed yellow-green tonalities ranging from 94.5 ◦ to 85.6 ◦ , while at pH 6, the hues were slightly more yellow, ranging from 91.4 ◦ to 90.3◦. Table 4. CIELAB color parameters (L*, a*, b*, C* ab , h ab ) of semisynthesized betaxanthins before (BS) and after (AS) the storage period, visual color based on CIELAB color parameters, and lightness, chroma, and hue differences (∆L*, ∆C*ab,∆hab) and color differences (∆E*ab) over time. Betaxanthins pH Storage Visual Color L* a* b* C*ab hab ∆L* ∆C*ab ∆hab ∆E*ab Ï−Ala-Bx 4 BS 93.8 ±0.22 − 2.1 ± 0.03 37.2 ±0.07 37.3 ±0.10 93.2 ±0.37 3.4 20.6 0.35 20.9 AS 97.2 ±0.38 − 1.0 ± 0.01 16.7 ±0.04 16.7 ±0.05 93.5 ±0.28 6 BS 92.9 ±0.15 − 1.2 ± 0.03 50.9 ±0.11 51.0 ±0.13 91.4 ±0.18 1.5 7.9 0.50 8.1 AS 94.3 ±0.09 − 1.4 ± 0.05 43.0 ±0.08 43.1 ±0.07 91.8 ±0.13 Ï−Leu-Bx 4 BS 94.2 ±0.13 − 1.5 ± 0.02 35.4 ±0.07 35.5 ±0.09 92.4 ±0.19 2.9 25.5 5.6 25.7 AS 97.0 ±0.11 0.55 ±0.00 10.0 ±0.04 10.0 ±0.08 86.9 ±0.16 6 BS 93.1 ±0.08 − 0.7 ± 0.01 42.2 ±0.11 42.2 ±0.11 91.0 ±0.13 2.0 15.3 1.1 15.4 AS 95.1 ±0.21 − 1.0 ± 0.01 26.9 ±0.06 26.9 ±0.04 92.1 ±0.11 Ï−Phe-Bx 4 BS 97.3 ±0.19 − 1.2 ± 0.02 16.3 ±0.08 16.4 ±0.05 94.4 ±0.10 1.3 10.5 2.0 10.6 AS 98.6 ±0.27 − 0.7 ± 0.00 5.9 ±0.05 5.9 ±0.04 96.3 ±0.21 6 BS 92.3 ±0.15 − 0.2 ± 0.00 43.5 ±0.09 43.5 ±0.09 90.3 ±0.14 42.4 30.8 1.6 52.4 AS 49.9 ±0.08 0.29 ±0.01 12.7 ±0.10 12.7 ±0.03 88.7 ±0.21 Ï−Pro-Bx 4 BS 93.6 ±0.09 3.3 ±0.03 43.9 ±0.15 44.1 ±0.09 85.7 ±0.21 2.6 18.8 0.72 18.9 AS 96.2 ±0.20 1.6 ±0.00 25.3 ±0.07 25.3 ±0.03 86.4 ±0.09 6 BS 93.3 ±0.16 3.7 ±0.02 47.4 ±0.08 47.5 ±0.07 85.5 ±0.07 0.27 0.44 0.46 0.64 AS 93.6 ±0.11 4.1 ±0.04 47.8 ±0.08 48.0 ±0.08 85.1 ±0.19 Thus, it is clear that pH has an impact on the CIELAB parameters of the initial betaxanthin solutions. However, the colorimetric characteristics (L*, C* ab , h ab ) and color differences ( ∆ E* ab ) showed different patterns of evolution over time with respect to pH. After the storage period at pH 6, the solutions of betaxanthins Ï− AlaBX, Ï− LeuBX, and Ï− ProBX experienced the smallest changes in lightness, chroma, and hue ( ∆ L*, ∆ C* ab , and ∆ h ab ) (Table 3). In contrast, Ï− PheBX showed drastic changes in L* and C* ab at the same pH value ( ∆ L* = 42.4 and ∆ C* ab = 30.8). This indicates that when stored at pH 4, the chroma and luminosity present less variation during this time interval (Table 4). The colorimetric parameters of the aqueous solution of Ï− ProBX experienced the least changes at pH 6, while at pH 4, the Ï− PheBX solution had the least variation in the parameters L* and C* ab . It is important to note that these observations are objective and based on the experimental data. Table 4shows that the color changes ( ∆ E* ab ) over time differed among the four betaxanthin solutions stored at pH 4 and pH 6. Overall, greater color Molecules 2024,29, 2116 8 of 15 differences were observed for all solutions at pH 4 compared to those stored at pH 6, except for the Ï− PheBX solution. The greater color degradation (less stability) at pH 4 may be attributed to degradation by acid hydrolysis, similar to what was observed by Herbach when studying the color stability of betalain extracts [ 30 ]. Hydrolysis results in the cleavage of the aldimino bond, isomerization, decarboxylation, and dehydrogenation at the chiral carbon, or decarboxylation of betalamic acid. The present study observed a gradual loss of yellow color in the case of betaxanthins. It has been confirmed that a ∆ E* ab greater than two CIELAB units indicates color differences that are appreciable to the human eye [ 31 ]. The aqueous solutions of betaxanthins Ï− AlaBX, Ï− LeuBX, and Ï− PheBX displayed noticeable color differences when stored at pH 4 and pH 6 ( ∆ E* ab > 2); however, the changes in ∆ E* ab were less drastic at pH 6. Ï− ProBX showed minimal color changes at pH 6 ( ∆ E* ab = 0.64), making it the most stable synthesized betaxanthin under these storage conditions, with the least hydrolytic degradation (Figure 5). This behavior suggests that the previously observed reduction in antioxidant capacity for Ï− Pro-BX may be attributed to the greater stability of this particular molecule. The presence of the cyclopentyl ring effectively stabilizes the iminium cation, resulting in greater stabilization and decreased hydrolysis. The chemical structure clearly affects color stability during storage at both pH levels. Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 16 Figure 5. Evolution over time of the absorbance and UV–Vis spectrum of the most stable betaxanthin, ʟ−ProBX: (a) UV-Vis pH 4, (b) UV-Vis pH 6. As previously mentioned, the ʟ−PheBX solution displayed the smallest color differences at pH 4, although they were visually noticeable (ΔE* ab = 10.6). This analysis agrees with the previously observed variations in chroma, lightness, and hue in the solutions of ʟ−ProBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 6) and ʟ−PheBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 4). The observed discrepancy may be attributed to the higher acid dissociation constant (Ka = 6.7 × 10 −3 ) of the amino acid condensed to betalamic acid to form ʟ−PheBX, in this case, phenylalanine, compared to other amino acids such as alanine (Ka = 4.89 × 10 −3 ) [31]. Therefore, it can be assumed that it is hydrolyzed more easily in a less-acidic medium (pH 6). The research conducted by Abu-Eittah [32] found that phenylalanine has a lower dipole moment (µ = 2.2909 D) compared to alanine (µ = 2.5622 D). This suggests that the polarization of the benzene ring is in the opposite direction to that of the –COOH group, which explains why phenylalanine is a stronger acid than alanine. This work only used phenylalanine as the aromatic amino acid in the synthesis of betaxanthins. The ʟ−PheBX solution was found to be the least resistant to color changes (ΔE* ab = 52.4) at a pH value of 6 (Table 4). Moreover, the phenylalanine has a slightly negative charge on the benzene ring, indicating its potential to function as an electron donor and acceptor [32], which can lead to faster hydrolysis (Figure 6) and less stabilization of the iminium bond by the benzyl group compared to other amino acids attached to the semisynthetic betaxanthins under examination, an aspect that is in accordance with what was published by Abu-Eittah [32]. Imine hydrolysis occurs easily in both acidic and basic media and has been extensively analyzed using kinetic methods. The reaction mechanism is dependent on the composition of the reactant molecule and the pH of the solution. Under mildly acidic conditions, the imine bond breaks as the hydroxyl group adds to the C=N bond; then, the amino group of betaxanthin receives a proton from a water molecule, causing the elimination of the amino acid (Figure 6). N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH N H H 2 NCOOH H HOOC COOH O H 3 O + + H 2 O N H H 2 NCOOH H HOOC COOH HO N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH H HO - 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 11 12 Figure 6. Hydrolysis mechanism in basic medium of ʟ−PheBX. Figure 5. Evolution over time of the absorbance and UV–Vis spectrum of the most stable betaxanthin, Ï−ProBX: (a) UV-Vis pH 4, (b) UV-Vis pH 6. As previously mentioned, the Ï− PheBX solution displayed the smallest color differences at pH 4, although they were visually noticeable ( ∆ E* ab = 10.6). This analysis agrees with the previously observed variations in chroma, lightness, and hue in the solutions of Ï− ProBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 6) and Ï− PheBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 4). The observed discrepancy may be attributed to the higher acid dissociation constant (Ka = 6.7 × 10 −3 ) of the amino acid condensed to betalamic acid to form Ï− PheBX, in this case, phenylalanine, compared to other amino acids such as alanine (Ka = 4.89 × 10 −3 ) [ 31 ]. Therefore, it can be assumed that it is hydrolyzed more easily in a less-acidic medium (pH 6). The research conducted by Abu-Eittah [ 32 ] found that phenylalanine has a lower dipole moment ( µ = 2.2909 D) compared to alanine ( µ = 2.5622 D). This suggests that the polarization of the benzene ring is in the opposite direction to that of the –COOH group, which explains why phenylalanine is a stronger acid than alanine. This work only used phenylalanine as the aromatic amino acid in the synthesis of betaxanthins. The Ï− PheBX solution was found to be the least resistant to color changes ( ∆ E* ab = 52.4) at a pH value of 6 (Table 4). Moreover, the phenylalanine has a slightly negative charge on the benzene ring, indicating its potential to function as an electron donor and acceptor [ 32 ], which can lead to faster hydrolysis (Figure 6) and less stabilization of the iminium bond by the benzyl group compared to other amino acids attached to the semisynthetic betaxanthins under examination, an aspect that is in accordance with what was published by Abu-Eittah [ 32 ]. Imine hydrolysis occurs easily in both acidic and basic Molecules 2024,29, 2116 9 of 15 media and has been extensively analyzed using kinetic methods. The reaction mechanism is dependent on the composition of the reactant molecule and the pH of the solution. Under mildly acidic conditions, the imine bond breaks as the hydroxyl group adds to the C=N bond; then, the amino group of betaxanthin receives a proton from a water molecule, causing the elimination of the amino acid (Figure 6). Molecules 2024, 29, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 16 Figure 5. Evolution over time of the absorbance and UV–Vis spectrum of the most stable betaxanthin, ʟ−ProBX: (a) UV-Vis pH 4, (b) UV-Vis pH 6. As previously mentioned, the ʟ−PheBX solution displayed the smallest color differences at pH 4, although they were visually noticeable (ΔE* ab = 10.6). This analysis agrees with the previously observed variations in chroma, lightness, and hue in the solutions of ʟ−ProBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 6) and ʟ−PheBX (which exhibits higher color stability at pH 4). The observed discrepancy may be attributed to the higher acid dissociation constant (Ka = 6.7 × 10 −3 ) of the amino acid condensed to betalamic acid to form ʟ−PheBX, in this case, phenylalanine, compared to other amino acids such as alanine (Ka = 4.89 × 10 −3 ) [31]. Therefore, it can be assumed that it is hydrolyzed more easily in a less-acidic medium (pH 6). The research conducted by Abu-Eittah [32] found that phenylalanine has a lower dipole moment (µ = 2.2909 D) compared to alanine (µ = 2.5622 D). This suggests that the polarization of the benzene ring is in the opposite direction to that of the –COOH group, which explains why phenylalanine is a stronger acid than alanine. This work only used phenylalanine as the aromatic amino acid in the synthesis of betaxanthins. The ʟ−PheBX solution was found to be the least resistant to color changes (ΔE* ab = 52.4) at a pH value of 6 (Table 4). Moreover, the phenylalanine has a slightly negative charge on the benzene ring, indicating its potential to function as an electron donor and acceptor [32], which can lead to faster hydrolysis (Figure 6) and less stabilization of the iminium bond by the benzyl group compared to other amino acids attached to the semisynthetic betaxanthins under examination, an aspect that is in accordance with what was published by Abu-Eittah [32]. Imine hydrolysis occurs easily in both acidic and basic media and has been extensively analyzed using kinetic methods. The reaction mechanism is dependent on the composition of the reactant molecule and the pH of the solution. Under mildly acidic conditions, the imine bond breaks as the hydroxyl group adds to the C=N bond; then, the amino group of betaxanthin receives a proton from a water molecule, causing the elimination of the amino acid (Figure 6). N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH N H H 2 NCOOH H HOOC COOH O H 3 O + + H 2 O N H H 2 NCOOH H HOOC COOH HO N H NCOOH H HOOC COOH H HO - 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 11 12 Figure 6. Hydrolysis mechanism in basic medium of ʟ−PheBX. Figure 6. Hydrolysis mechanism in basic medium of Ï−PheBX. In summary, after the storage period at both pH values, appreciable differences were observed in the color of the solutions of Ï− AlaBX, Ï− LeuBX, and Ï− PheBX; on the contrary, Ï− ProBX is more resistant to changes in pH. Color differences at pH 6 were not perceptible to the human eye, possibly being one of the compounds that contributes the most to the stability of the crude extract of Opuntia dillenii. These findings on color stability in relation to pH align with Cejudo-Bastante [ 17 ], who noted that the hue in crude extracts of Opuntia dillenii fruit is more stable in less acidic pH levels. These results are consistent with the data presented in the work of Wu [ 33 ], which demonstrated that storage at room temperature (23–27 ◦ C) of Bougainvillea extracts rich in betaxanthins maintains the yellow color. At pH values between 5 and 7, the extracts retain their color, while at pH values less than 5, they experience a loss of color. 3. Materials and Methods 3.1. Reagents and Solvents All reagents and solvents (ethanol, methanol, glacial acetyl acid, sodium hydroxide, formic acid, ammonium hydroxide, triethylamine, Ï− alanine, Ï− proline, Ï− leucine, Ï− phenylalanine, 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazine (DPPH), 2,2 ′ -azino-bis-(3-ethylbenzothiazolin)- 6-sulfonic acid (ABTS), potassium persulfate, gallic acid, Amberlite XAD-7, Amberlite IRA-402, and silica functionalized with C18 groups) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA). 3.2. Plant Material The samples were collected from the village of Chachagui (Nariño, Colombia), which is located approximately 25 km north of the city of San Juan de Pasto. It is located approximately at 1 ◦ 24 ′ 31 ′′ latitude N and 77 ◦ 17 ′ 23 ′′ longitude W at an altitude of 1950 m above sea level, with an average temperature of 18 ◦ C. On 15 October 2020, the fruit was harvested, and a specimen of the plant was stored in the herbarium of the Universidad of Nariño (code number 13691). A representative set of samples of up to a weight of about 2.5 Kg was harvested. The mature fruits were collected according to visual characteristics and similar size. A simple random sampling model of ten plants was performed. After homogenization, only 1200 g of fruits was considered, with an average weight of each fruit being around 10 g. They were carefully washed and dried with paper, and the prickles were manually removed. Fruits were kept under refrigeration at 4 ◦ C and then lyophilized until their analysis. Figure 7shows the methodological scheme of the synthesis and purification of betalains from the fruits of Opuntia dillenii.