scieee Open visual document viewer

Uplink beamforming for the FDD mode of UTRA

Mestre Pons, Francesc X.,Rodríguez Fonollosa, Javier,Vázquez Grau, Gregorio

Abstract

This paper presents some link level simulation results for the evaluation of adaptive antennas in the uplink of the FDD mode of UTRA (UMTS terrestrial radio access). Two families of algorithms were initially considered, the basic difference between them being their ability/disability to suppress the contribution from W-CDMA directional interfering sources. Two distinct schemes were established as representatives for each family and their performance was evaluated in presence of some illustrative interfering scenarios. In the light of the results it is shown that time-reference beamforming algorithms suffer from severe beam pattern distortion effects when applied as such. This in turn causes harsh performance degradation in terms of raw BER, especially at high SINR levels. It is shown that these shortcomings are essentially caused by the uplink multiplexing of the traffic channel, which is seen by the base station as a powerful interfering source coming from the direction of arrival of the desired user.

Full text

UPLINK BEAMFORMING FOR THE FDD MODE OF UTRA Xa ie Mes e, Ju ie R. Fonollosa, G ego i Vazquez Depa men o Signal Theo y and Communica ions Uni e si a Poli ecnica de Ca alunya c/Jo di Gi ona, 1-3,08034 Ba celona, SPAIN Phone: +34 93 4017052 Fax: +34 93 4016447 e-mail: [ mes e, ono, g ego i]@gps. sc.upc.es ABSTRACT This pape p esen s some link le el simula ion esul s o he e alua ion o aclap i e an ennas in he uplink o he FDD mode o UTRA. Two amilies o algo i hms we e ini ially conside ed, he basic di e ence be ween hem being hei abili y/disabili y o supp ess he con ibu ion om WCDMA di ec ional in e e ing sou ces. Two dis inc schemes we e es ablished as ep esen a i es o each amily and hei pe o mance was e alua ed in p esence o some illus a i e in e e ing scena ios. In he ligh o he esul s i is shown ha ime- e e ence beam o ming algo i hms su e om se e e beampa e n dis o ion e ec s when applied as such. This in u n causes ha sh pe o mance deg ada ion in e ms o aw BER, especially a high SINR le els. I is shown ha hese sho comings a e essen ially caused by he uplink mul iplexa ion o he a ic channel, which1 is seen by he base s a ion as a powe ul in e e ing souce coming om he di ec ion o a i al o he desi ed use . 1. INTRODUCTION The i s aim o he wo k p esen ed he ein was o e alua e he con enience o a ay-p ocessing in e e ence canceling schemes in ypical W-CDMA scena ios. Clea ly, he pe o mance o such a chi ec u es will depend s ongly on bo h spa ial dis ibu ion and empo al s uc u e o he ansmi ed signals. Since he analy ical modeling o hese e ec s becomes somewha bu densome, a i s app oxima ion o he p oblem by means o ex ensi e simula ions seemed mos app op ia e. The e alua ion p ocess was ca ied ou ollowing FRAMES ecommenda ions as desc ibed in [2]. Thus he “Ac ual Value In e ace” (AVI) was chosen as he mos sui able connec ion be ween link-le el and sys em-le el simula ions. The echnique es ablishes ha he link le el simula ion esul s should be measu ed in a bu s -by-bu s basis so ha he sys em simula o unde akes all coding and link le el adap a ion. Thanks o ha , all adio esou lce managemen algo i hms (ha ing an ac i a ion pe iod highe han bu s du a ion) can be accu a ely simula ed on he sys em le el pla o m. 2. (CHANNEL AND SIGNAL, MODEL We deno e x( ) (Pxl column ec o ) he ecei ed snapsho a a pa icula ime ins an . I a&) ep esen s he ansmi ed This wo k was pa ially suppo ed by he Eu opean Coinmission unde ACTS P ojec AC347 SIJNBEAM, he Spanish Go e nmen (TIC96-0500-C10-01, TIC98-0412, TlC98-0703) and he Ca alan Go e nmen CIRlT 1998SGR-0008 1. (analy ic) signal coming om he s- h mobile s a ion, i s con ibu ion o he ecei ed snapsho can be modeled as ollows: being g,, a complex p opaga ion gain and s,,( ) a ime- a ying supe posi ion o s ee ing ec o s. This gene alized s ee ing ec o s,,( ) -as i is commonly e e ed o in he li e a u e- inco po a es he angula in o ma ion o he channel and depends on ime due o he Dopple e ec . In he sequel we will assume ha 1) he ecei ed signal is p ope ly sampled a a mul iple o he chip a e (Nsc sa nples/chip) and 2) pe ec synch oniza ion wi h he use o in e es has been a ained al eady. Now, ga he ing M consecu i e snapsho s o he ecei ed signal a he base s a ion in o an AhP ma ix X, we ha e: x = [x(o) X(TS) ... x((M -l)Ts)lT wi h Ts deno ing he sampling pe iod. Le us now in oduce an MxL segmen o con olu ion ma ix: d((L-1)Nsc +1) d((L - 2)Nsc+l) .’. d(1) d((L -~)Nsc + 2) d((L - ~)Nsc + 2) d((L -1)Nsc + M) d((L - 2)Nsc + M) ... d(M) gene a ed om M+(L-1)Nsc samples o he desi ed use ’s aining sequence d( ) ansmi ed in he Con ol Channel (PDCCH) -o a epe i ion he eo whene e M+(L-1)Nsc is bigge han he pe iod o he aining sequence-. Upon he de ini ion o an LxP ma ix including he wo-dimensional disc e e (1 sample/chip) channel impulse esponse: (4) we can exp ess he spa ial- empo al ecei ed signal ma ix as: X=DH+W (5) whe e W (MxP) includes no only spa ial- empo al backg ound noise bu also he con ibu ion o signals ansmi ed om o he mobile s a ions as well as a ic channels embedded in he desi ed use ’s da a s eam. P o ided ha he leng h o he channel assumed a he ecei e (L) is no su icien ly la ge o cope wi h he whole delay sp ead o he adio channel, he la es e lec ions o he incoming signal a e assumed o be included in his noise e m. 0-7803-5565,-2/99/$10.00 0 1999 IEEE 867 3. UPLINK ALGORITHMS UNDER TEST The main pu pose o he conside ed simula ions was o in es iga e he in luence o di e en ep esen a i e W-CDMA in e e ing scena ios on he pe o mance o con en ional adap i e an enna sys ems. The objec i e was o quan i y he po en ial ad an ages o in e e ence canceling schemes in on o pu ely di e si y combining a chi ec u es. Thus, wo di e en amilies o algo i hms we e conside ed, each one eso ing o a dis inc p esump ion conce ning he spa ial na u e o in e e ence. Figu e 1. Vec o ial Rake Recei e The i s scheme unde conside a ion, he eina e e e ed o as V-Rake Recei e (Figu e l), was chosen as ep esen a i e o he amily o algo i hms which do no ake in o accoun he p esence o di ec ional in e e ing sou ces. The scheme can be basically shown o be he op imum de ec o om a maximum- likelihood poin o iew when only omnidi ec ional Gaussian noise is p esen in he scena io. Assuming ha he componen s o he ma ix W a e join ly Gaussian-dis ibu ed, he ecep o can be de i ed om he maximiza ion o he ollowing likelihood unc ion: ?,I = ec"(X-DH)R-,' ec(X-DH) (6) wi h R, he MPxMP co a iance ma ix o ec(W), and 0 and ec() deno ing he K onecke p oduc and he column-wise ma ix s acking ope a ion espec i ely. A e some manipula ion o (6) we ge : ?,I = ecH(X)R: ec(X) +2Reb]+ (7) + ecH (D)R ec(D) whe e we ha e de ined: y = ecX(DH)R: ec(X) (8) R = (H* 61~ )R;(H~ 61,) wi h Inn he MxM iden i y ma ix. This o mula ion allows sepa a ion o he combining pa o he ecei e om i s subsequen da a-de ec ion pa . P o ided ha noise and in e e ence can be conside ed spa ially and empo ally unco ela ed, y becomes equal o (up o a scala ac o ): y = ecH(DH) ec(X) = [(DHIXX] (9) I we conside he ollowing decomposi ion o he channel and inpu signal ma ices: H=[h,...h,] x =[XI ... x,] he scala y can be exp essed in he ollowing way: P y = zh DHxp p=i Each e m hXDHX can be in e p e ed as he ou pu o a Rake ecei e ma ched o each an enna channel impulse esponse. In conclusion, he op imum ecei e esul s in he scheme he ein ega ded as he V-Rake Recei e (see Figu e 1). Ye one issue emains open: since he channel impulse esponse H is no known, i mus be es ima ed om he incoming da a. An ML channel es ima e can be ob ained aking de i a i es o he cos unc ion (6) wi h espec o ec(H*) and o cing he co esponding g adien o be ze o: PP om whe e we ob ain: ec(H)= [(IL ODH)R;(I, @D)Y(IL @D")R;' ec(X) (13) Finally, o he V-Rake Recei e conside ed he e: H = (D~D)-'D~x (14) The app oxima ion o empo al unco ela ion o in e e ing componen s o he inpu signal seem easonable as long as we deal wi h digi ally modula ed signals sampled a he chip a e. On he con a y, hei spa ial whi eness can no be so easily jus i ied and will depend s ongly on he ac ual scena io unde conside a ion. A mo e sensible app oxima ion, judging by conclusions d awn om measu emen campaigns in [7], is o conside ha he s uc u e o he dis inc gene alized s ee ing ec o s sI in (4) does no a y in obse a ion in e als sho e han he delay sp ead o he mobile adio channel. This is equi alen o he app oxima ion: H = has; ec(H) = so @ ha whe e ho and ep esen he equi alen one-dimensional channel impulse esponse and gene alized s ee ing ec o espec i ely. Subs i u ion o (15) in o (8) leads o: y = (sa 63 ha)H (I, 6 DH)R;' ec(X) (16) o , a e some algeb a: whe e, by i ue o he spa ial- empo al sepa a eness app oxima ion, we ha e decomposed he non-desi ed signal co a iance ma ix in o i s spa ial and empo al componen s R, = R, @ R, . We obse e ha he op imum combining p io o he sequence de ec ion collapses in o wo sepa a e s ages: a spa ial s age, in which he incoming snapsho s a e p ep ocessed by he op imum beam o ming (in he sense ha i p o ides maximum Signal o In e e ence plus Noise Ra io SINR a i s 868 ou pu ); and a i empo al s age, which can be in e p e ed as a single Rake ecei e . In his con ex , he second algo i hm unde es - he so-called Ma ched Desi ed Impulse Response MDIR Recei e [ 8][3] (Figu e 2)- eso s o he sepa a eness app oxima ion in (15) in o de o p o ide he ML es ima ion o he ansmi ed da a, he beam o me weigh s and he equi alen channel he Assuming Gaussiani y o he non-desi ed in e e ences he log-likelihood unc ion o he ecei ed da a a e he spa ial p ocessing can be exp essed (up o a cons an ) as: {=(Xb-Dh)HRi (Xb-Dh) (18) whe e we ha e conside ed ha he channel impulse esponse a e he beam o ming p ocess h, he da a, and he beam o me i sel b a e all de e minis ic quan i ies. As al eady discussed, i seems easonable o assume he spa ial co a iance ma ix is close o he iden i y so ha he ML cos unc ion u ns ou o be a mean squa e e o measu e: { = llXb - Dhll* (19) In o de o a oid he i ial solu ion an addi ional cons ain mus be imposed. Fo ins ance, one may se he powe associa ed wi hi he aining sequence a he ou pu o he beam o me equal o cons an : bXHD(DHD)DHXb = 1 (20) The eby, using he Lag ange mul iplie s me hod he solu ion may be shown o be [3]: XHXb = am,,XHD(DHD)-'DHXb (21) h = (DXD)-'DHXb Thus, he beam o ming weigh ec o is ound as he eigen ec o co esponding o he minimum gene alized eigen alue o he ma ix pencil [x~x, X~D(D D lD /x]. Since his eigen alue is equal o he in e se o he ou pu SINR minus one, he solu ion is yielding op imali y in e ms o SINR be o e he Rake ecei e . 4. SIMULATION ASPECTS The main di icul y ha a ises when simula ing a W-CDMA en i onmen esides in aking in o accoun all possible bi a es, and consequen ly sp ead ac o s, ha migh be in ol ed in an ac ual scena io. In o de o o e come his p oblem wo di e en kinds o use s we e de ined, he di e ence be ween hem being basically he ype o se ice ha hey equi e: High Bi Ra e (LBR) and Low Bi Ra e (HBR) use s. The o me a e supposed o ha e a highe bandwid h demand and, consequen ly, an ac ual mobile ne wo k will be capable o handling a high numbe o LBK use s whe eas he numbe o mobiles equi ing a HBR se ice will be limi ed. Fu he mo e, he highe he bi a e, he mo e ansmi ed powe is needed in o de o p ese e a gi en quali y o se ice. All his sugges s ha LBR use s can be p ope ly modeled as omnidi ec ional Gaussian noise. In ou case, a cons an sp ead ac o (SF) was assigned o all HBR use s i espec i ely o whe he hey cons i u e desi ed o in e e ing sou ces. Conce ning he signal gene a ion in he simula ions, each senso equency-selec i e channel was modeled wi h a apped delay line o ime- a ying coe icien s as shown in (1). Pa icula ly, he models e e ed o as Ou doo o Indoo and Pedes ian and Vehicula in [6] we e conside ed o he gene a ion o he channel equency selec i i y, whe eas he angula app oach p esen ed in 171 was used o cha ac e ize he angula dispe sion o he p opaga ion p ocess. Thus each la - ading componen o he mobile channel was gene a ed using a ay model, whe e he numbe o impinging wa e o ms was se equal o a Poisson andom a iable (mean equal o 25 ays). In addi ion, a Laplacian Powe Angula Spec um was conside ed, along wi h a Gaussian dis ibu ion o he di e en di ec ions o a i al o each use . The Powe Angula Sp ead was ixed o 8 deg ees o all aps and scena ios. The mobile speed was se o 3km/h and 120km/h o he Pedes ian and Vehicula models espec i ely. Acco ding o he Ac ual Value In e ace, he simula ion du a ion was se equal o he minimum powe con ol ac ualiza ion pe iod, namely 0.625ms. n XI@) Beam o ming Design 1 ,, I Me ic I T aining Sequence D h Figu e 2. Ma ched Desi ed Impulse Response Recei e . All he a ay-p ocessing algo i hms we e simula ed on a linea equally spaced a ay o 8 an ennas, in which he in e elemen sepa a ion was se o hal wa eleng h a he ca ie equency (1950 MHz). All mobile angula loca ions we e a bi a ily se by a uni o m andom a iable wi hin [-60,601 deg ees, i.e. 120 deg ees sec o iza ion was assumed. Each use was supposed o gene a e a single Dedica ed Physical Da a Channel (DPDCH) oge he wi h i s associa ed Dedica ed Physical Con ol Channel DPCCH (see 191 o de ails o he modula ion o ma s). 5. SIMULATION RESULTS Two in e e ing scena ios we e simula ed o each powe delay p o ile model, one wi h a single domina ing HBR in e e ence and ano he wi h i e. Apa om he a ay beam o ming algo i hms p esen ed in sec ion 3, a single-senso Rake ecei e was conside ed o compa ison pu poses. Uplink esul s a e depic ed in e ms o aw (uncoded) BER in Figu e 3 and Figu e 4. Al hough simula ions ook in o accoun a high ange o LBR powe ( e lec ed in he Eb/No a io), only esul s wi h Eb/No=lOdB a e p esen ed he ein. No e ha he BER is always exp essed as a unc ion o he ins an aneous Eb/Io pe senso (i.e., ecei ed by a single an enna and 869 measu ed wi hin an ac ualiza ion pe iod o he as powe con ol). Thanks o ha , a con en ional planning ool can di ec ly use hese esul s and he e o e dis ega d he exis ence o adap i e an ennas. Pedes ian, 115 inle eie s. EbINo-10 dB 100 I ' ' 'Q Smole-senso Rake I ... ., .. ............. :I -" ............... ......... 0 5 10 15 20 25 1 o-~ -15 -10 -5 Eblia pe senso [dB1 Figu e 3. Uplink esul s o he Pedes ian Channel Model. Vehicula , 115 In e e e s, EblNo=lO dB P io 5 H 10 0 5 10 15 20 25 lo-+ -15 -10 -5 Ebllo pe senso [dB] Figu e 4. Uplink esul s o he Vehicula Channel Model. Compa ing he pe o mance o he p oposed algo i hms, he MDIR ecei e gene ally a ains he bes esul s in e ms o equi ed Eb/No and Eb/Io o a pa icula aw BER in he ange o in e es (usually om lo-' o 10.' o aw BER). This is a logical esul , since nei he he V-Rake algo i hm no i s single- senso coun e pa ake in o conside a ion he p esence o in e e ence, which has a mos de imen al e ec on he ecei e pe o mance. No e howe e ha o high Eb/No o Ebb0 le els he Mul isenso Rake ecei e ac ually ou pe o ms he MDIR scheme, he eason o ha being basically wo old. Fi s , he MDIR s a egy bases i s ope a ion upon he adap a ion o a na owband beam o me , an app oxima e solu ion o he impai men s in oduced by he ime-dispe si e channel. Second, non-ideal es ima es o he co ela ion ma ices a e bound o o igina e signi ican pe o mance losses, especially when he powe o he ecei ed signals is high enough. The loss in oduced by he app oxima ion by he use o a na owband beam o me ins ead o an a ay o FIR il e s (app oach equi alen o ha o a wideband beam o me ) becomes ully jus i ied by he on -end complexi y educ ion ha he o me en ails. O mo e se ious conce n is he deg ada ion in oduced by impe ec es ima ion o he co ela ion ma ices needed in he MDIR algo i hm. Basically, he eason o his beha io is ha he a ic channel mul iplexed wi h he pilo is seen by he base s a ion as an in e e ing signal coming om he e y same angula di ec ion (no e ha only he aining sequence componen is iden i ied as 'desi ed sou ce' by he beam o ming algo i hm). This leads o a deg ada ion o he desi ed signal es ima ed co a iance ma ix equi alen o a andom poin ing e o when ackling wi h con en ional sou ces. Besides, he highe he desi ed ecei ed powe (and so he measu ed Eb/(No+Io)) he mo e p ecise he es ima ion has o be in o de o p e en he desi ed signal om being cancelled ou by he beam o me [I]. Since accu acy is in his case limi ed by he in e e ence o he a ic channel, a high Eb/(No+Io) a ios he sys em can no a oid supp essing he desi ed signal ins ead o enhancing i . A ay Fac o , Eblla= WE, EbiNo= 3MB 0 -5 -10 -15 --20 D 3 -25 e - -30 -35 -40 -45 -50 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 Azimulh (deg) Figu e 5. Deg ada ion o he a ay esponse due o he p esence o he a ic channel. Solid and dash-do ed line: spa ial esponse o he global beam o me . Do ed line: spa ial esponse o he eigen ec o co esponding o he maximum eigen alue o he desi ed signal co a iance ma ix. Desi ed signal DOA -20 deg. In e e ing signal DOA 40 deg. The consequences o his e ec on he a ay spa ial esponse can be no iced in Figu e 5, whe e he a ay ac o has been ep esen ed o a Pedes ian scena io in p esence o a high le el o desi ed signal powe . In o de o ob ain mo e insigh in o he beampa e n dis o ion e ec s, a low angula sp ead was chosen (0.01 deg ees). I may ini ially seem ha when he aining sequence is ansmi ed oge he wi h a a ic channel he scheme can s ill es ima e he desi ed signal spa ial signa u e (do ed line) wi h a ce ain deg ee o accu acy. Howe e he global beam o me spa ial esponses show ha small e o s in his es ima e esul in g ea dis o ion e ec s o he global beampa e n, wha in u n b ings abou high deg ada ion o he BER a he mobile s a ion. 870 Se e al possible solu ions o his dis o ion e ec a e cu en ly being unde in es iga ion. They a e based on semi-blind es ima ion echniques and basically seek o ake in o accoun no only he aining sequence bu also o he unknown in e e ing symbols embedded in he modula ed da a s eam [4]. The o mula ion o hese algo i hms is no epo ed he e o lack o space, al hough we do include p elimina y esul s o demons a e hei po en ial. In pa icula , Figu e 6 shows he ou pu SINR o he beam o me as a unc ion o he inpu powe le el (wi h espec o he backg ound noise) in an scena io wi h wo HBR use s ansmi ing wi h SF=8. As he powe o he HBR use s inc eases beyond 10 dB, p ope ou pu SINR alues can no longe be sus ained. Ne e heless, his p ocli i y is success ully o e come by means o he applica ion o a semi- blind echnique based on a Condi ioned ML c i e ion. The in e es ed eade is e e ed o [4] o u he de ails o he algo i hm as well as mo e ex ensi e pe o mance simula ion esul s. Ou pu SINR s Inpu SNR Semi-blind CML g a -10 -20 -20 _-------- - J’ -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Inpu SNR (dB) Figu e 6. Oiu pu SINR e sus Inpu SNR in a scena io wi h wo HBR use s ansmi ing wi h SF=8 and he same powe . Vehicula 115 in e e e s, Eb/No=PO dB 10” 10 ’ I I cc m p 102 g - In addi ion o lhe wo k p esen ed he e, link-le el simula ions o downlink a ay-p ocessing algo i hms o he FDD mode o UTRA ha e also been pe o med (see [5] o de ails). Figu e 7 p esen s pe o mance cu es o wo di e en beam o ming algo i hms: a poin ing scheme (DPA) and a null-s ee ing scheme (DBNS). The DPA app oach seeks o gene a e a maximum may esponse owa ds he di ec ion o a i al o he desi ed use whe eas he DBNS deploymen is pa icula ly in ended o maximize he SINR a he mobile s a ion inpu . Su p isingly, i can be obse ed ha he DPA algo i hm ou pe o ms he DBNS scheme o alues o he ins an aneous Ebb0 abo e 5-8 dB. Once again, his beha io is basically mo i a ed by a poo es ima ion o he desi ed signal spa ial signa u e. As al eady shown, his es ima ion is p ecise enough o p ope ly poin a he desi ed use , bu no so eliable o a oid he desi ed signal supp ession when a maximum SINR s a egy is adop ed. 6. CONCLUSIONS This pape has p esen ed some link-le el simula ion esul s o he uplink and downlink o he cu en UTRA-FDD s anda d de ini ion. Resul s show ha applica ion o classical ime- e e ence beam o ming echniques encoun e s se e e pe o mance p oblems when ope a ing a high inpu SNR le els. A beampa e n dis o ion e ec , p incipally induced by he mul iplexed a ic channel, has been shown o be he ul ima e esponsible o he pe o mance deg ada ion. Finally, semi-blind echniques a e pu o wa d as alid a chi ec u es o ake in o accoun he p esence o he au o-in e e ing channel. Pe o mance esul s o hese echniques will be u he add essed in [4]. 7. REFERENCES [I] Comp on R. T., “Poin ing Accu acy and Dynamic Range in a s ee ed bedm adap i e a ay”, IEEE T ans. on AES, ol. AES-16, 121 Hdmlllinen S., Slanina P., Ha man M., Lappe ellinen A., Holma H., Salonaho O., “A No el In e ace be ween Link and Sys em Le el Simula ions”, P oc. ACTS Mobile Telecomm. Summi , Aalbo g, Denma k, pp. 599-604, Oc obe 1997. 131 Lagunas M.A., Pi ez A. and Vidal J., “Join Beam o ming and Vi e bi Equaliza ion in Wi eless Communica ions”, P oc. 3 1” Asiloma Con e ence on Signals, Sys ems and Compu e s, Paci ic G a e, Cali o nia, No embe 1997. 141 Mes e X., Fonollosa J. R., An 6n C., “Adap i e Beam o ming o HBR se ices in he FDD mode o UTRA”, submi ed o he IEEE Vehicula Technology Con e ence, 1999-Fal1, Ams e dam, The Ne he lands. [SI Mes e X., Fonollosa J.R, “Pe o mance E alua ion o UTRA- FDD’, P oc. FRAMES Wo kshop, Del (The Ne he lands), Janua y 1999. [6] Nikula E., “Ai In e ace Speci ica ion, Laye 1, D a ”, In e media e Deli e able ACO~~/NOK/PTO/DS/R/~I~/~J~. FRAMES p ojec . [7] Pede sen K.I., Mogensen P.E., Fleu y B.H., “A S ochas ic Model o he Tempo al and Azimu hal Dispe sion seen a he Base S a ion in Ou doo P opaga ion En i onmen s”, submi ed o he IEEE T ans. on Vehicula Technology. [SI Pipon E.P., Che alie P., Villa P., Mono J.J, “Join Spa ial and Tempo al Equaliza ion o channels wi h IS1 and CCI- Theo e ical and Expe imen al esul s o a base s a ion ecep ion”, P oc. IEEE Signal P ocessing Wo kshop on Signal P ocessing Ad ances in 191 “Submission o P oposed Radio T ansmission Technologies: he ETSI UMTS Te es ial Radio Access (UTRA) ITU-R R’M Candida e Submission”, ETSI SMG2. Da e o submission: 29/1/1998. A ailable a he ITU WWW h p://www.i u.ch/im / 1976, pp. 280-287. Wi eless Communica ions, Pa is, F ance, Ap il 1997, pp.309-3 12. 87 1