Truth and utility in fuzzy logic

sYbs m 7BP ]B8}Z$t E w d D dMTd qZY stI =$j$k $t 3Z99k NB${ V 7BA$tB *} NB${ stI Bsj _Y$jBRB}Yk =t$% 7st$sB I ]B8}BRjs ]s8}ZR =t$%R$s$B R t dx(E 7st$sB I ]B8}BRjs 7}s$t j4sj-oZR{R VARs{ qY tB$Bt BP I BP ZY ZRI $t PZ99k jB${ {st A $t}I $t 8R BP }s$sj ZY B $t 8R BP Z$j$k k $t%R$s$t YBb YR $t}s$BtR h $t b$Y qsR,$:R Iht$$Bt BP ZY Y$R }s} -}jBR RB8 BP Y$ $8}j${s$BtR stI Y$ {BtRJZt{R PB Y PBZtIs$BtR stI {I$A$j$k BP PZ99k jB${ kbBIRU zsZtRR qZY =$j$k 3Z99k jB${ d ytBIZ{$Bt qY tB$Bt BP ZY $R {tsj B {jsRR${sj A$%sjt jB${ bY${Y $R {B88Btjk IT R{$AI sR Y RZIk BP Y }B}ss$Bt BP ZY Ak %sj$I IIZ{$% }B{RRR 3Z99k jB${ $R BPt IR{$AI sR s PB8sj$R8 PB sRBt$t $t R$Zs$BtR B bY${Y Zt{s$tk $R $tYt $ sRRB{$sR ABY }8$RR stI {Bt{jZR$BtR b$Y IR BP ZY T s {Bt{} sR PZtIs8tsj B PZ99k jB${ sR ZY $R B {jsRR${sj jB${ T stI }B%$IR s {sj{ZjZR sjjBb$t sRBtsAj %sjZs$Bt BP Y I BP {s$tk b$Y bY${Y {Bt{jZR$BtR {st A s{YI PB8 %sZ }8$RR stI $8}{$R jB${sj js$BtRY$}R y $R bjj ,tBbt Ys IR BP ZY {st A $t}I $t R%sj I$&t bskR !t BP Y 8BR ZRZsj %$bR RR Y8 sR JZst$Pk$t ZY $RjP RB Ys s I BP ZY jRR Yst d((0 $tI${sR s }s$sj ZY  stBY RR Y8 sR JZst$Pk$t ZRPZj ZY >nH yt}I sR 8sRZR BP }s$sj ZY Yk -}RR s}}B-$8s$BtR B s bYBj ZY Ys $R Ztss$tsAj A{sZR BP js{, BP Ps{Zsj B $tPt$sj $tPB8s$Bt PB -s8}j s IB{B stI$t s BsI s{{$It %${T $8 b$YBZ I$stBR${ JZ$}8t 8ZR Isb $tPt{R Bt Y AsR$R BP $8}P{ ,tBbjI BP Y %${$8:R {BtI$$Bt yt}I sR 8sRZR BP XZRPZj" ZY Yk -}RR st st:R RZA`{$% {BthIt{ $t Y ZY BP Y }B}BR$$Bt $t JZR$Bt PB -s8}j $t I$R$AZ$t Y$ RZIk $8 RZItR s, $tB s{{BZt Y IR BP {BthIt{ Yk Ys% $t Y$ {Zt sA$j$k B }sRR -s8$ts$BtR $t Y %s$BZR RZA`{R e$Y bsk sR -}RR$BtR BP }s$sj ZY B ZRPZj ZY IR BP ZY s js$% B st BA`{$% ZY Ys $R Ztss$tsAj A{sZR BP {Zt js{, BP $tPB8s$Bt dM d( V 7BA$tB yt {jsRR${sj jB${ Y tB$Bt BP BA`{$% ZY $R ZRZsjjk jsI B Ys BP T tsj ZY B s jsR B Y tB$Bt BP s ZY b$Y s {s$t 8}Bsj RsA$j$k yt }s${Zjs Y %$h{s$Btsj {$$s BP }YkR${R stI 8sY8s${R tIBb Y$ }B}BR$$BtR b$Y s {s$t RsA$j$k B $88ZsA$j$k yt PZ99k jB${ Y {Bt{} BP $8}{$R ZYR $R ZRZsjjk jsI $Y B Y tI B {sk BZ sRBt$t }B{RRR $t R$Zs$BtR $t bY${Y $8 $R RYB stI }{$R $tPB8s$Bt {Bt{t$t }8$RR stI $8}j${s$BtR {sttB A bs$I PB B R$Zs$BtR $t bY${Y }{$R $tT PB8s$Bt bBZjI A RB %BjZ8$tBZR sR B 8s, $R }B{RR$t $8}s{${sj B B R$Zs$BtR $t bY${Y Y s tB s%s$jsAj 8{Yst$R8R PB }B{RR$t }{$R $tPBT 8s$Bt $t s bsk Ys ZsstR {Bt{jZR$BtR BP s j$sA$j$k Yst YBR Ys {st A Isbt Bt Y AsR$R BP $8}{$R $tPB8s$Bt ]jsRR${sj jB${ sR Y RZIk BP Y }B}ss$Bt BP ZY Ak %sj$I IIZ{$% }B{RRR RR Bt st $Isj {$$Bt BP ZY i$BBZR Iht$$BtR BP ZY Ys% At }B}BRI Ak qsR,$ w }$8s$jk b$Y PB8sj jstZsR $t 8$tI D stI $t %$b BP Y }BAj8R s$R$t bYt qsR,$:R Iht$$Bt $R s}}j$I B tsZsj jstZsR Ak R%sj BY sZYBR G$Y PZ99k jB${ $t 8$tI pBZt >EH YsR }B}BRI s XRB{$sj" Iht$$Bt BP ZY b$Y PsZR $tY$I PB8 R}{Y s{ YBk >dH s RB{$sj {Bt{} BP ZY {Bt{tR tB Z Rtt{R AZ Z Zst{R 8$I Ak }s${Zjs stR b$Y }s${Zjs BsjR $t }s${Zjs R$Zs$BtR V }BAj8 b$Y RZ{Y s {Bt{} $R Ys Y js{, BP }j${sA$j$k BP Y {${Z8Rst{R stI$t st Zst{ YBb IBZAR Bt Y BA`{$%$k BP ZY sRR$t8tR Ys s 8sI B I}tI Bt YR {${Z8Rst{R ]s$tjk PZ99k jB${ s}}sR B JZ$ RB8 ,$tI BP RB{$sj {Bt{} BP ZY R$t{ $ s8}R B 8BIj sjTj$P sRBt$t {BtRs$tI Ak j$8$I $8 stI $tT PB8s$Bt }B{RR$t }Bb V Y Rs8 $8 YBb% $ {js$8R B A BA`{$% w %t YBZY PZ99k }B}BR$$BtR 8sk A $t RB8 {Bt-TI}tIt RtR BP j$8T $I sY Yst Zt$%Rsj R{B} D  stI Yt{ B JZ$ s Iht$$Bt BP ZY Ys $R BA`{$%jk s}}j${sAj $t s bsk Ys R8R AkBtI Y s{Y BP RB{$sj {Bt{}R BP ZY 3Z99k jB${ bBZjI YZR R8 B tI s {Bt{} BP sII ZY Ys $R t%YjRR RZR{}$Aj B s Iht$$Bt BP Y ,$tI Ys qsR,$ }B}BRI PB Y ZY BP {jsRR${sj jB${ yt Y$R }s} y ZR qsR,$:R ZY {$$Bt B -s8$t {s$t j$8$s$BtR stI $8}j${s$BtR BP Y tB$BtR BP ZY stI Z$j$k ZRI $t PZ99k jB${ yt 7{$Bt 1 AjBb y stsjkR Y {Bt{}R BP $Isj ZY w 1d D  RB{$sj ZY w 11 D stI 8Zj$}jT %sjZI ZY w 1n D $t7{$Btny{BtR$IZY stI Z$j$k $t s PZ99k {Bt- stI $t 7{$Bt ; y R,{Y RB8 {jBR$t 4-$BtR 1 qY tB$Bt BP ZY 1d yIsj ZY ]jsRR${sj jB${ $R {Bt{tI b$Y Y PB8sj {BtRZ{$Bt BP Y {BtRJZt{R BP R{$t$h{ jstZs T }ssI$8s${sjjk Y jstZsR BP }YkR${R stI 8sY8s${R hjIR $t bY${Y Rs{Y $R {B88Btjk Rs$I B sR}$ B BA`{$% ZY qY$R $tT tII BA`{$%$k jsIR B Y JZ$8t Ys stk Iht$$Bt BP ZY A $ D BP qZY stI =$j$k $t 3Z99k NB${ dd tsj s}}j${sA$j$k stI $$ D BtBjB${sjjk stI }$R8BjB${sjjk tZsj y $R ZRZT sjjk {BtR$II Ys ABY YR JZ$R$R s Rs$RhI Ak Y YBk BP ZY }Z PBbsI Ak qsR,$ >d1H $t dnE bY${Y }B}BRR {BtI$$BtR Ys RYBZjI A 8 Ak stk sIJZs ZY YBk stI }RtR s Iht$$Bt BP ZY PB PB8sj jstZsR Ys $R Rs$I B {B8}jk b$Y YR {BtI$$BtR qsR,$ JZ$R BP s ZY YBk Ys $ A ABY X8s$sjjk sIJZs" stI XPB8sjjk {B{" V YBk $R 8s$sjjk sIJZs bYt $ $8}j$R sjj $tRst{R BP Y qT R{Y8s 7$RZ$&} w q D bY X7" $R s ts8 $%t B RB8 Rtt{ AjBt$t B Y jstZs PB bY${Y ZY $R A$t IhtI stI } $R s Rtt{ Ys sRRR bYs Y Rtt{ 7 sRRR Y RstIsI -s8}j BP st $tRst{ BP Y qTR{Y8s $R X7tBb $R bY$" $R Z $& RtBb $R bY$ V YBk $R PB8sjjk {B{ $P Y jstZs PB bY${Y ZY $R A$t IhtI stI Y Iht$$Bt BP ZY $RjP Rs$RPk {s$t {BtI$$BtR w R qsR,$ >d1H PB }{$R Is$jR D  qsR,$:R YBk Rs$RhR Y JZ$8t BP BtBjB${sj stI }$R8BjBT ${sj tZsj$k A{sZR s}}j${s$Bt BP Y qTR{Y8s IBR tB $t$tR${sjjk $t%Bj% Y st:R ,tBbjI B Aj$PR 7s$RPs{$Bt BP Y JZ$8t BP tsj$k $R jRR BA%$BZRU hR A{sZR Y $R tB R$tj Iht$$Bt BP ZY s}}j${sAj B sjj jstZsR AZ Btjk }s${Zjs Iht$$BtR PB }s${Zjs PB8sj jstZsR B s}T }B}$sjk Zjs$9I tsZsj jstZsR stI R{BtIjk A{sZR %t sR sIR s R$tj $%t jstZs Y $R tB Iht$$Bt BP ZY $t tsj Btjk BP Y ZY BP }s${Zjs Rtt{R 7 N ZR {BtR$I Y 8s$sj sIJZs{k {BtI$$Bt $t Y {Bt- BP tsZsj jstT Zs $t{jZI$t Y jstZs BP 8}$${sj R{$t{ WB Ys Rs$RPs{$Bt BP Y qT R{Y8s IBR tB Ak $RjP {BtR$Z s Iht$$Bt BP ZY qsR,$ 8s,I Ys $P s tsZsj B R{$t$h{ jstZs YsI s ht$ tZ8A BP Rtt{R s{Y BP bY${Y bsR R8st${sjjk {jBRI Y Iht$$Bt BP ZY bBZjI A $%$sj A{sZR $ bBZjI A }BRR$Aj B j$R sjj Rtt{R stI Iht sR Z `ZR YBR Rtt{R 7 Ys stRT jsI $tB Z Rtt{R } <Bb% tsZsj jstZsR Ys% st $tht$ tZ8A BP Rtt{R qsR,$ 8 Y$R }BAj8 Ak Iht$t ZY $t 8R BP Y Rs$RPs{$Bt BP s Rtt$sj PZt{$Bt Ak $%t BA`{R stI }B%$t Ys Y$R Iht$$Bt bsR 8sT $sjjk sIJZs <Bb% Y$R RBjZ$Bt Ps$jR B s{,j s I$&t ,$tI BP }BAj8 Ys s$RR PB tsZsj jstZsRU Y -$Rt{ BP %sZ }I${sR bY${Y 8stR Ys $t Y qTR{Y8s 7 stI } 8sk $t{jZI bBIR BP $8}{$R 8st$t qY$R }BRR Y JZR$BtR BP bYY Y qTR{Y8s $R PB8sjjk {B8}s$Aj b$Y Y -$Rt{ BP %sZ }I${sR stI bYs Y $8}j${s$BtR s PB s YBk BP ZY 11 7B{$sj ZY yt s RB{$sj s}}Bs{Y B ZY Y JZR$Bt BP bYs ZY $R $R }js{I Ak JZR$BtR sABZ YBb Y bBI XZ" $R ZRI $ YBb $ $R s}}j$I B Rtt{R Ys s sRT RI B A Z !t Y$R %$b sRR$BtR sABZ ZY s %sjZsI $t Y {BZR BP RB{$sj $ts{$Bt ZR$t BI$tsk jstZs sY Yst $t st $Isj XBA`{$%" RkR8 IR$tI PB RB8 R}{$h{ }Z}BR RZ{Y sR Y PB8sj {BtRZ{$Bt BP R{$T t{ V RB{$sj Iht$$Bt BP ZY IBR tB Rs Ak JZ$$t Ys Z Rtt{R d1 V 7BA$tB 4{ Y bBjI AZ $tRsI Ys Yk IR{$A R$Zs$BtR $t s bsk Ys RZjR $t RZ{{RRPZj {B88Zt${s$Bt Abt jstZs ZRR RB Ys Y jstZs ZR {$%T $t Y8 ZtIRstIR Y ZR Ak bYB8 Yk s 8$I _B}BR$$BtR IB tB Ys% B {BtRZ{ sj$k sY Yk {BtRZ{ s ZRPZj RZA`{$% ZtIRstI$t BP sj$k yt Y$R {Bt- s YBk BP ZY 8ZR s, $tB s{{BZt Ys Y ZYT%sjZ BP s }B}BR$$Bt $R tB $tI}tIt BP Y stR ZR$t $ B Y R$Zs$Bt $t bY${Y $ $R ZRI Ys $ 8sk {Yst $t $8 Ys }B}BR$$BtR 8ZR A %sjZsI `ZR sR Yk s $t sj jstZs b$YBZ stk sjs$Bt BP Y$ j-${Bt stI Ys $ $R s Ps{ Ys 8BR tsZsj jstZs }B}BR$$BtR $t{jZI bBIR BP $8}{$R 8st$t yt BI$tsk {B88Zt${s$Bt Y s tB $tI}tIt ZYR AZ Z Rtt{ Zst{R }PB8I Ak }s${Zjs $tI$%$IZsjR yt Ps{ $t Y RB{$sj {Bt- BP {B88Zt$$R BP R}{$sj$RR $t }s${Zjs RZA`{ 8sR Y s$AZ$Bt BP ZY B s }B}BR$$Bt I}tIR 8B Bt Y j$tZ$R${ {B88Zt$k Yst Bt $R $tI$%$IZsj 88AR R$t{ $ $R tsjjk Y {B88Zt$k Ys RsAj$RYR Ak $tR$Z$Btsj 8{Yst$R8R bYs Y {B{ ZR BP s Rk8ABj B R$t BP Rk8ABjR $R stI bY${Y BP $R 88AR s {B8}t T stI $t bYs I T B RsAj$RY ZY s RB8 }s${Zjs $8 yt %kIsk jstZs Zst{R ZRZsjjk P B R$Zs$BtR Ys s tB }j${sAj {sttB A -s8$tI Ak BYR stI {sttB %t A T-s8$tI Ak Y R}s, R$t{ Y $R tB {s$tk Ys bB I$&t -}$t{R s $tRst{R BP Y Rs8 R$Zs$Bt yt Y sARt{ BP }j${sR sjj Ys {st A Rs$I $R Ys sRR$BtR {st A 8sI b$Y I$&t IR BP RZ{{RR $t %s$BZR I$8tR$BtR {st h Y Ps{R 8B B jRR jBBRjk stI $t I$&t bskR Bt I$&t B{{sR$BtR stI b$Y I$&t $ttR stI }Z}BRR >EH qY Zt$%R BP ZY %sjZR {sttB A j$8$I B XZ" stI XPsjR" VR tBI sAB% PZ99k jB${ s}}sR B JZ$ s RB{$sj Iht$$Bt BP ZY 7$t{ $ $R {Bt{tI b$Y sRBt$t Ys $R $8}{$R j$, %kIsk sRBt$t $t BI$tsk jstZs $ BZY B s, $tB s{{BZt Y stR $t%Bj%I $8 {Bt- stI Y -$Rt{ BP %sZ }I${sR <Bb% {Bt$$Bt BP Y RB{$sj tsZ BP ZY }B%$IR tB {$$Bt BP YBb B ZR Y$R {Bt{} sY $ s}}sR B $8}jk Ys A{sZR BP Y %s$k stI stR$t{ BP RB{$sj }YtB8ts tB RZ{Y {$$Bt $R }BRR$Aj qYZR sjYBZY $ $R tB $88I$sjk {js YBb Y qTR{Y8s 8sk A s}}j$I B tsZsj B R{$t$h{ jstZs t$Y $R $ {js Ys Y $R tB tI B s}}jk $ Vtk R{$t$h{ hjI R,R BA`{$%$k $t{jZI$t Y s8}R b$Y$t Y hjI BP PZ99k jB${ B RsAj$RY s PB8sj B $tPB8sj YBk BP %sZtRR PB stkBt b$RY$t B tIBb Y jB${sj stsjkR$R BP $8}{$R jstZs b$Y BA`{$%$k Y qTR{Y8s $R st $tRZ8t Ys {sttB A B%jBB,I 1n yIsj ZY stI 8Zj$}jT%sjZI ZY V{{BI$t B _Zts8 >d(H $ $R }BRR$Aj B PB8Zjs s qTR{Y8s PB jstZsR b$Y %sZ }I${sR AZ Btjk s s }${U Y $tBIZ{$Bt BP %sZtRR $t Y 8sT jstZs qY$R $R $jjZRsI Ak Y PBjjBb$t ZY sAj $t bY${Y Xy" }RtR stk I BP ZY Abt q stI 3 qZY stI =$j$k $t 3Z99k NB${ dn 7 $R Z $& w  D } q q q 3 q 3 y q y yt BY bBIR Y jB${ BP Y 8sjstZs $R $t4Zt{I Ak Y jB${ BP Y BA`{ jstZsU $P Bt bstR B }R% Y JZ$%sjt{ -}RRI $t Y qT R{Y8s Yt %sZtRR {sttB A {BthtI B Y BA`{ jstZs stI $tR}{I PB8 Y %sts }B$t BP s {$R} 8sjstZs T Y 8sjstZs BB 8ZR sjjBb %sZtRR 3ZY8B Y 8ZR %t A 8sRtt{R }I${s$t ZY Ys Ys% ZY %sjZR BY Yst q stI 3 RB Ys Y }I${s XZ" 8ZR t{RRs$jk A sR $8}{$R sR Y %sZ }I${sR BP Y BA`{ jstZsU $P Y qTR{Y8s $R }R%I B st $8}{$R 7 Y 8ZR {BR}BtI st $8}{$R } stI B Y $8}{$R } st $8}{$R X7 $R Z" yt RYB _Zts8:R sZ8tR RYBb Ys $P Y 8sjstZs $R B {BtPB8 B {jsRR${sj jB${ Yt Y BA`{ jstZs 8ZR A Zjs$9I RB sR B j$8$ts %sZtRR bY$j $P %sZ }I${sR s B A sI8$I $t Y BA`{ jstZs sR RZR{}$Aj BP jB${sj stsjkR$R Yt {jsRR${sj jB${ 8ZR A }js{I Ak s 8Zj$}jT%sjZI jB${ $t ABY Y BA`{ jstZs stI Y 8sjstZs e%t $P Y qTR{Y8s {st s s }${ A tsj$9I PB8 }{$R B $8}{$R jstZsR Y sAB% tsj$9s$Bt bBZjI s}}s B JZ$ Ys bYs% I BP ZY s Rtt{ 8sk Ys% Ys I BP ZY A Zt$JZ I$R$tZ$RYsAj stI $tI}tIt BP Y tsZ BP stR stI R$Zs$BtR yR Y$R RB $t jstZsR b$Y %sZ }I${sR2 qY {Btsk $R RZRI Ak Y }ssIBBP 7B$RU $P RB8Bt b$Y `ZR s Pb Ys$R Bt Y$ YsI z Rsk $R AsjI Yt RB8Bt b$Y z Ld Ys$R $R sjRB AsjI stI RB Bt RB %kBt $R AsjI tB 8s YBb 8stk Ys$R Yk Ys% Bt Y$ YsI < s }stjk PsjR {Bt{jZR$Bt $R s$%I s YBZY Y sARt{ BP s YBj$R${ %$b BP Y }BAj8 stI Y ZR BP sRBt$t Ys 8s$ts$tR ZtsjI s s{Y R} Y RtY b$Y bY${Y Y }I${s XAsjI" $R s}}j$I qY$R }ssIB- YZR Y$Yj$YR bYs s}}sR B A st $t{B8}s$A$j$k Abt $BBZR s}}j${s$Bt BP Y ZjR BP jB${ stI Y {B88Bt RtR%sjZs$Bt BP ZY $t %kIsk R$Zs$BtRU $ $R sARZI B {Bt{jZI Ys %t Y Ys$$R BP YsIR $R AsjI AZ $ $R tB jRR sARZI B k B $It$Pk s Iht$ tZ8A BP Ys$R }BRRRR$Bt BP bY${Y {BtR$ZR Y ABIj$t Abt AsjItRR stI tBtTAsjItRR GYs Y }ssIBBP 7B$R sjjk Y$Yj$YR $R s I$&t{ Abt Y BAT `{$%R BP XjB${BT8sY8s${sj" sRBt$t stI Y BA`{$%R BP {B88Bt RtR sRBt$t XNB${BT8sY8s${sj" sRBt$t $R s}}B}$s stI &{$% $t }B%T $t }B}BR$$BtR b$Y $88ZsAj ZY %sjZR bYsR {B88Bt RtR sRBt$t {Bt{tR Y sRR$t8t BP ZY %sjZR PB R}{$h{ ZRPZj }Z}BRR $t R}{$h{ {B8T 8Zt${s$% R$Zs$BtR V Y$R }B$t j ZR {sjj Ys $t PZ99k jB${ XI BP ZY" $R ZRZsjjk $tT }I $Y sR X}s$sj ZY" B sR XZRPZj ZY" 3B8 Y }B$t BP %$b BP Z$j$k $ b$jj $t RB8 {sRR A $j%st bYY s $%t Rtt{ $R sRR$tI sR $R ZY %sjZ (ME( B (MEd YR bB %sjZR b$jj A $tI$R$tZ$RYsAj sR sIR Y RZ{{RR BP Y {B88Zt${s$Bt $t bY${Y Yk s ZRI stI Y IR$sA$j$k B BYb$R BP Y$ {BtRJZt{R <Bb% $t}I sR 8sRZR BP }s$sj ZY d; V 7BA$tB sR {BjsR BP sj$k w }Ys}R s %sZ BA`{ D  (ME( $R RRt$sjjk I$R$t{ PB8 (MEd $tII sRR$t8t BP Y ZY %sjZ (ME( {BZjI A sI sR ts$t sRR$t8t BP Y %sjZ (MEd qYZR PB s }B}BR$$Bt IR$ts$t $R j$tZ$R${ {Bjs s8A$%sjtjk Y qTR{Y8s $R tB Rs$RhI s jsR PB Bt BP Y %sjZR V}}j${s$Bt BP Y qTR{Y8s B Rtt{R Ys {st Btjk A 8BIjjI R8st$T {sjjk ZR$t IR BP ZY YPB jsIR $t%$sAjk B ZtIR$sAj {Bt{jZR$BtR yP Y $t}s$Bt BP Y tB$Bt BP I BP ZY $R jB${sj Y BZY B A s RYs} ABIj$t Abt s %sZ }I${s stI $R ts$Bt RB sR B s%B$I 7B$RTk} }ssIB-R AZ Y $R tB RYs} ABIj$t yP Bt Y BY YstI Y $t}s$Bt $R AsRI Bt Z$j$k Yt Y s {$$s PB Isb$t Y ABIT j$t AZ Y ABIj$t Isbt $R Ys9k stI 8ZsAj I}tI$t Bt {Bt-Zsj stI -sj$tZ$R${ Ps{BR qY$R I$j88s Abt ZRjRR BA`{$%$k stI RZA`{$% Z$j$k $R {Yss{$R${ BP Y RsZR BP Y tB$Bt BP ZY $t PZ99k jB${ yt bYs PBjjBbR y I$R{ZRR RB8 sR}{R BP Y$R n qZY stI Z$j$k $t PZ99k jB${ 3Z99k jB${ $R s jB${ BP %sZ }I${sR V PJZtjk ZRI }ssI$8 BP s %sZ }I${s $R Xsjj" y $R {B88Bt B Rsk Ys Y$R }I${s $R BAR%s$Btsj $ $ AjBtR B Ys {jsRR BP }I${sR Ys PB tB}BR$$%$RR s RRt$sj {B8}BttR BP Y }B}BR$$BtR b$Y bY${Y R{$t{ $R {BtRZ{I yt R}$ BP Y$R -sjI PZt{$Bt b {sttB AZ {Bt$9 Ys %sZ BAR%s$Btsj }I${sR {st A ZRI $t bskR Ys s {BtsI${Bk w $t Y {jsRR${sj RtR BP {BtsI${$Bt D B s jsR 8ZZsjjk I$R$t{ yP b bstI Y {Bt{} B Ys% s R$tj %sjZs$Bt b bBZjI Ys% B -}RR $ b$Y s }{$R$Bt V {B88Bt bsk BP RYs}t$t Y 8st$t BP s %sZ }I${s $R Ak Pt{ B $tRZ8tR Ys s8}j$Pk B ht BAR%s$Bt s&BI$t s 8B Is$jI %$b BP Y BA`{R stI %tR BAR%I Z $tRZ8tR Ys% Y$ j$8$R _s$,Y:R YB8 TPB 8B Is$jR R >EHT RYBbR Ys PB  T{Btt{I R}s{R $tRZ8tR BP BAR%s$Bt B 8sRZ8t {sttB {js$Pk Y -tR$Bt BP s %sZ }I${sU sjj BAR%s$BtR YBb% ht Ys% Y$ b$j$Y 9Bt VtBY bsk BP RYs}t$t s %sZ }I${s RZ{Y sR Xsjj" $R B s $ sR -}RR$t s js$%$R${ {Bt{} {B8}s$t PB -s8}j Y Y$Y BP Bt $tI$T %$IZsj b$Y Ys BP stBY yt Y$R {sR Y R8st${R BP Y %sZ }I${s $R tB }RtI Ak s I BP ZY AZ Ak st BII R BP %sjZR Z R$t{ Y }I${s A$t %sZ sI8$R 8B Yst Bt $tRst$s$Bt {s$t AsR BP %sZ }I${sR b$Y I$&t Y$YR {sttB A 8ZZsjjk I$R{$8$tsI B I$R$tT Z$RYI Ak 8stR BP Y }I${s Xsjj" yt BY bBIR Yk s tB 8ZZsjjk {B8}ssAj yt %$b BP YR I$^{Zj$R b 8sk Pj 8}I B bBtI bYs s sjj $tI$%$IZsj sjjk $R y bBZjI A Yj}PZj B k B stRb Y$R JZR$Bt $t 8R BP s }{$R 8sRZ PB -s8}j Ak s,$t s Zj stI ZR$t $ B 8sRZ st s}}B}$s $tI$%$IZsj 7Z}}BR Ys Y RZj $R s Y$Y BP dM;( {8 yP Y $tI$%$IZsj b Ys% 8sRZI s}}sR B A Zjk sjj b 8$Y Rsk Ys s sjj $tI$%$IZsj $R RB8Bt bYB 8sRZR dM;( {8 Z Y$R IBR tB stRb Y B$$tsj JZR$Bt qZY stI =$j$k $t 3Z99k NB${ dx s 8BR $ stRbR Y JZR$Bt XGYs $R $ B 8sRZ dM;( {82" bY${Y $R JZ$ I$R$t{ s jsR $t YBk PB8 Y JZR$Bt XGYs $R $ B 8sRZ dM;d {82" y bBZjI YZR R8 I{$IIjk I$^{Zj B I8$t }{$Rjk bYs sjjtRR $R $t R}$ BP BZ sjj ,tBb$t YBb B 8}jBk Y bBI Xsjj" $t BZ RB{$sj Isj$tR 7B s R{$t$h{ Iht$$Bt BP Xsjj" IBR tB {B$t{$I b$Y s }ZAj${ Iht$$Bt stI %${ %Rs  qB Rsk BP RB8Bt Ys Yk s sjj $R s {ZjZsj sRR$Bt AZ R{$t{ $R s j$8$I B R}{$sj PB8 BP {ZjZ $t%Bj%$t s R}{$h{ s}}t${RY$} ZtIs,t $t R${I s{sI8${ JZsR stI }s${Zjs {B88Zt$$R WsZsj jstZs Bt Y BY YstI $R Y PZ$ BP %BjZ$Bt stI }s BP BZ Bst${ stI RB{$sj I%jB}8t VtkBt YBZY 8jk j$%$t $t {B88Zt$k jstR Y 8st$t BP Xsjj" sjYBZY s{Y $tI$%$IZsj $t}R $ $t Y$R B Y Bbt 8R VR +Z$t >ddH }B$tI BZ Y ZRZsj 8stR Ak bY${Y Y 8st$t BP BAR%s$Btsj }I${sR $R s{JZ$I $R BRtR$Bt RB tBABIk {st A RZ Ys bYs s bBI 8stR PB Y8 {B$t{$IR -s{jk b$Y bYs $ 8stR PB RB8Bt jR %t YBZY Yk s {BthIt BP BRR {B$t{$It{ w sR $R RYBbt Ak Y Ps$jZ BP {B88Zt${s$Bt B As, IBbt bYt% b ZR YR }I${sR D  ]BsR 8st$t $R YZR s {Yss{$R${ BP {s$t bBIR $t BI$tsk jstZs VjYBZY dM;( {8 $R }P{jk I$R$tZ$RYsAj PB8 dM;d {8 b bBZjI sjj s Ys $P RB8Bt Rs$I B 8sRZ dM;( {8 b {jsRR$hI sR sjj Y$R {jsRR$h{s$Bt bBZjI tB A sjI $P Yk ZtI BZ B 8sRZ dM;d {8 e%t $P %s$s$Bt BP j$tZ$R${ {Bt%t$BtR PB8 Bt {B88Zt$k B stBY s $tBI st $tI$%$IZsj:R A$t sjj $R sR $ b tB s }Rts$% BP RB8Y$t Zt$JZ AZ BP s {Bjj{T $Bt BP $tRst{R h$t Y IR{$}$Bt $%t Ak Y }I${s qY {Bt%t$BtR B%t$t }I${s$Bt BP sjjtRR s ZRPZj stI {s}Z Y bBjI AZ IB tB tI B A $88ZsAj Yk {st {Yst $P Y$ ZRR RB b$RY qY$R $R tB Y {sR BP _kYsBsR: qYB8 s 8sY8s${sj }B}BR$$Bt {BtR$II B A Zt$%Rsj stI $8jRR s jsR $t Y s}}B}$s YB${sj Ps8bB, 3B %sZ }I${sR Y {BtRtRZR BP Y {B88Zt$k $R -8jk $8}Bst $t s$AZ$t 8st$t >H yt BI B A sAj B ,tBb Ys Y {s $t PBt $R As,$t Y 8ZR A s8t Ys I $R I %t YBZY Y 8sRZI bs%jtYR BP Y As,$t j$YR BP stk bB {sR Rj{I s stIB8 bBZjI IBZAjRR sj8BR $t%s$sAjk A I$&t GYs $R tII $R s }s8s${ YBk BP Y ZR BP Y bBI XI" tB st $Isj YBk BP $ w bY${Y $R sjsIk s%s$jsAj D  _s$,Y >MH YsR I%$RI s %k s} $jjZRs$Bt BP Y Z$j$k BP s }s8s${ YBk BP Y ZR BP BAR%s$Btsj 8R y BR j$, Y$R Vtt stI FBYt s{Y $t Y Rs8 R{YBBj stI RYs s 4s !t Isk Vtt }YBtR FBYt PB8 R{YBBj B Rsk Ys RY YsR jP s YB8 s ABB, Bt jB${ RY tIR PB Y t- {jsRR stI {st Y }jsR htI $ stI s, $ B Y 7$t{ FBYt IBR tB ,tBb bYs Y ABB, jBB,R j$, Y sR,R Y bYs {BjBZ $ $R Vtt }j$R b$Y s %sZ BAR%s$Btsj }I${sU XI" qY }BAj8 $R Ys Vtt YsR d((( ABB,R BP bY${Y 1x( s I PB Vtt w R w  D D  n(( I PB FBYt w R w O D D stI Btjk 11x I PB ABY 1x s I PB Vtt AZ tB PB FBYt x I PB FBYt AZ tB PB Vtt stI Ex I PB t$Y BP Y8 qY$R R$Zs$Bt $R }RtI $t Y PBjjBb$t hZ dE V 7BA$tB qY s d(( ABB,R B bY${Y Vtt stI FBYt sRR$t I$&t {BjBZR AZ $ $R sRRZ8I Ys t$Y BP Y8 $R sbs BP Y$R bYt Vtt 8s,R Y JZR FBYt $R B htI Y ABB, Vtt bstR b$Y Y RsI {BjBZ sR Y$R Btjk -tsj {jZ w Y YsR B jBB, s Y $j }s B 8s, RZ Y YsR Y $Y I ABB, D y$R $tRZ{$% B {sj{Zjs Y s%s tZ8A BP ABB,R Y YsR B B}t $t I$&t {${Z8Rst{R s D yt Y sARt{ BP stk $tPB8s$Bt s sjj sABZ Y -tsj s}}sst{ BP Y ABB, $P Y $R jZ{,k $ b$jj A Y hR Bt Y B}tR BYb$R $ b$jj A Y jsR !t s%s Yt Y b$jj Ys% B B}t x((x ABB,R A D yP FBYt:R {Bt{} BP I {B$t{$IR b$Y  Yt Ak stsjBBZR sRBt$t Y b$jj Ys% B B}t Bt s%s d1xx ABB,R R$t{ Y$R Rs{Y b$jj A j$8$I B 1x( ABB,R { D yP Vtt:R stI FBYt:R {Bt{}R BP I B%js} sR $R Y {sR j ZR RZ}}BR Ys Vtt Aj$%R Y ABB, B A $t  b$Y }BAsA$j$k ( stI FBYt Aj$%R $ B A $t O b$Y Y Rs8 }BAsA$j$k FBYt b$jj hR Rs{Y O stI Yt $P Y Rs{Y $R ZtRZ{{RRPZj Y {B8}j8t BP O < b$jj YPB hR jBB, s st s%s dx(x ABB,R b$Y }BAsA$j$k ( stI Yt $P Y jBB,R s sjj n(( $t  b$YBZ htI$t $ s st s%s nx( 8B b$Y }BAsA$j$k (d 8s,$t st B%sjj s%s BP ( dx( L (d w n(( L nx( D ) 1(( ABB,R qB RZ8 Z} FBYt $R Yj}I B tB R8sjj -t Ak Vtt:R jj$t Y$8 Y {BjBZ B }BAsAj {BjBZ BP Y ABB, %t YBZY Y$ {Bt{}R BP I IB tB -s{jk {B$t{$I yt BY bBIR $P Y %sZ }I${s $R ZRI $ tIBbR Vtt:R 8RRs b$Y s }BAsA$j$k BP RZ{{RR Yst $P $ $R tB ZRIU Y Rs{Y $8 T s }s8s${ 8sRZ j%st B Y Z$j$k BP Y 8RRs T $R R$t$h{stjk IZ{I Yst,R B Y $tPB8s$Bt {$%I qY sAB% -s8}j RYBbR Ys Y RZ{{RR BP Vtt:R 8RRs IBR tB I}tI Bt Y stI FBYt ABY ,tBb$t }{$Rjk YBb Yk ZR Y bBI XI" tB Bt Y$ ZRs A$t Y Rs8 $t I$&t R$Zs$BtR 3B htI$t Y JZRI BA`{ $ $R RZ^{$t PB Y8 B RYs }s BP Y Pt$sj 8st$t BP Y bBI qZY stI =$j$k $t 3Z99k NB${ d qYZR $t R}$ BP %sZ }I${sR Ys%$t I$&t %sjZR Y$ ZR IBR tB jsI B Y I$RsR PBBjI Ak Y {jsRR${sj {BtsI${$BtR w sjYBZY $ IBR jsI B I$^T {Zj$R {Bt{t$t Y }B}ss$Bt BP IR BP ZY YBZY sRBt$t }B{RRR y RYsjj tB Ibjj Bt Y$R $8}Bst }B$t D  qY$ 8sRR$% ZR $t jstZs $R st -s8}j BP %BjZ$Btsk sIs}$% j$tZ$R${ AYs%$BZ $tPB{I Ak Y AthR s&BII Ak Y s{Y$%8t BP ZtIRstI$t s8Bt I$&t }B}j bYt Y $R j$tZ$R${ {BB}s$Bt ]BB}s$Bt $t%Bj%R {BtRtRZR AZ {BtRtRZR }%tR Y Isb$t BP s RYs} ZtsjsAj j$t Abt {sRR B bY${Y Y %sZ }I${s $R s}}j${sAj stI {sRR B bY${Y $ $R tB s}}j${sAj 7{$t{ t%YjRR sR}$R B }B%$I BA`{$% ,tBbjI stI RB BB IBR s PB8sj YBk BP }B}BR$$BtR b$Y %sZ 8st$tR RZ{Y sR PZ99k jB${ <Bb {st ts,I ZY bY${Y B&R BA`{$%$k A {Bt{$jI b$Y Z$j$k bY${Y RRRR Y $8}Bst{ BP %sZtRR $t {B88Zt${s$Bt2 y RYsjj tBb s8} B {B88t Y$R JZR$Bt ; 3$tsj 4-$BtR pB$t As{, B 7B$R bYs bBZjI `ZR$Pk s Rtt{ A$t sRR$tI Bt I BP ZY stI tB stBY sj8BR $tI$R$tZ$RYsAj PB8 Y hR2 VR tBI sAB% $ {BZjI A sZI Ys Y {YB${ BP Y PB8 I BP ZY YsR }B%I ZRPZj PB Y JZ$I }Z}BRR stI tB IZ{$Bt $t Z$j$k bBZjI RZj PB8 }js{$t $ Ak Y js Vt s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Z$j$k sjjBbR Y %sjZ BP s Rtt{ B A }RtI $t 8Zj$}j bskR s Y st:R {Bt%t$t{ b$YBZ Y $t%$sAjk s$R$t s {BtsI${$Bt Ys sABR {B88Zt${s$Bt sR bBZjI B{{Z $P Y %sjZ b sI sR Y ts$Bt BP s 8$t$8sjjk I$&t Bt Vt $t}s$Bt BP Y R8st${R BP PZ99k jB${ $t 8R BP Z$j$k YZR s&BIR Y YB$R RB8 PIB8 $t 8BIjj$t }BAj8R stI Y$R sIs}sA$j$k B R}{$h{ {Bt-R $R Bt BP Y ,k Ps{BR $t $R RZ{{RR >xH Z s Y Rs8 $8 $ 8sk A st -{ZR PB s%B$I$t }BRR$Aj PZs$BtR 7$t{ s&s$R s Isj b$Y $t }s$sj RZA`{$% R{ts$BR $t 8stk {sRR $ $R I$^{Zj B jj bYY s }B}BRsj $R Y AR RBjZ$Bt B %t s BBI Bt yt RB8 {sRR Y }BAj8 8sk tB Ys% At 8BIjjI sR bjj sR $ 8$Y YBZY Y {Bt-Zsj$k 8s,R $ I$^{Zj B }B% Y {Btsk 3j-$A$j$k $R ZtIBZAIjk ZRPZj AZ s}}sR B A $t{B8}s$Aj b$Y Y $BZ Ys PB8sj jstZsR s RZ}}BRI B }BRRRR y bBZjI YPB A IR$sAj B R, s {s$t BA`{$%$k $t Y ZtIt$sAj Z$j$k B&I Ak PZ99k jB${ ZtIRBBI sR s jB${ BP sRR$BtR qY$R BA`{$%$k $R ZRZsjjk }B%$II Ak s jB${sj {$$Bt y Ys% sjsIk tBI Ys $P Y ZR b$RYR B Ys% s jB${sj AsR$R PB Y ZR BP IR BP ZY Y$ sRR$t8t 8ZR A Zt$JZ stI {Bt{t Zt$JZ PtR yt Y$R {sR w stI js%$t B Bt R$I Y I$^{Zjk BP {BtRZ{$t s j$R BP Rtt{R D  $ bBZjI A }B} B {js$8 Y %sj$I$k BP Y qTR{Y8s PB s %sZ tsZsj jstT Zs Z $P Ys b RB Y JZ$%sjt{ Ys Y qTR{Y8s JZ$R Abt 8sjstZs stI BA`{ jstZs {BZjI Btjk A RZARst$sI Ak {js$Pk$t Y Rs BP Y$tR PI B Ak s Rtt{ {Bts$t$t %sZ }I${sR $ Ak jZ{$T Is$t Y tB$Bt BP %sZ BA`{ yP Ys b s{Y$%I b bBZjI Ys% s }{$R