scieee Open visual document viewer

Urany-Less Low Voltage Transmission Electron Microscopy: A Powerful Tool for Ultrastructural Studying of Cyanobacterial Cells

Mrázová, Kateřina; Bačovský, Jaromír; Kroupová, Zuzana; Slaninová, Eva; Obruča, Stanislav; Fritz, Ines; Krzyžánek, Vladislav

Abstract

Sample preparation protocols for conventional high voltage transmission electron microscopy (TEM) heavily rely on the usage of staining agents containing various heavy metals, most commonly uranyl acetate and lead citrate. However high toxicity, rising legal regulations, and problematic waste disposal of uranyl acetate have increased calls for the reduction or even complete replacement of this staining agent. One of the strategies for uranyless imaging is the employment of low-voltage transmission electron microscopy. To investigate the influence of different imaging and staining strategies on the final image of cyanobacterial cells, samples stained by uranyl acetate with lead citrate, as well as unstained samples, were observed using TEM and accelerating voltages of 200 kV or 25 kV. Moreover, to examine the possibilities of reducing chromatic aberration, which often causes issues when imaging using electrons of lower energies, samples were also imaged using a scanning transmission electron microscopy at 15 kV accelerating voltages. The results of this study demonstrate that low-voltage electron microscopy offers great potential for uranyless electron microscopy.

Full text

Ci a ion: M azo a, K.; Baco sky, J.; Sed lo a, Z.; Slanino a, E.; Ob uca, S.; F i z, I.; K zyzanek, V. U any-Less Low Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy: A Powe ul Tool o Ul as uc u al S udying o Cyanobac e ial Cells. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888. h ps://doi.o g/ 10.3390/mic oo ganisms11040888 Academic Edi o : Juan M. Gonzalez Recei ed: 7 Ma ch 2023 Re ised: 27 Ma ch 2023 Accep ed: 28 Ma ch 2023 Published: 29 Ma ch 2023 Copy igh : © 2023 by he au ho s. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Swi ze land. This a icle is an open access a icle dis ibu ed unde he e ms and condi ions o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion (CC BY) license (h ps:// c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/ 4.0/). mic oo ganisms A icle U any-Less Low Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy: A Powe ul Tool o Ul as uc u al S udying o Cyanobac e ial Cells Ka e ina M azo a 1, Ja omi Baco sky 2, Zuzana Sed lo a 3, E a Slanino a 3, S anisla Ob uca 3, Ines F i z 4 and Vladisla K zyzanek 1,* 1Ins i u e o Scien i ic Ins umen s o he Czech Academy o Sciences, . .i., K alo opolska 147, 612 64 B no, Czech Republic; [email p o ec ed] 2Delong Ins umen s a.s., Palackeho T ida 3019/153 b, 612 00 B no, Czech Republic; ja omi [email p o ec ed] 3Depa men o Food Chemis y and Bio echnology, Facul y o Chemis y, B no Uni e si y o Technology, Pu kyno a 118, 612 00 B no, Czech Republic; [email p o ec ed] (Z.S.); [email p o ec ed] (E.S.); [email p o ec ed] (S.O.) 4 Ins i u e o En i onmen al Bio echnology, Depa men o Ag obio echnology, IFA-Tulln, Uni e si y o Na u al Resou ces and Li e Sciences, Kon ad-Lo enz-S ase 20, 3430 Tulln an de Donau, Aus ia; [email p o ec ed] *Co espondence: [email p o ec ed] Abs ac : Sample p epa a ion p o ocols o con en ional high ol age ansmission elec on mi- c oscopy (TEM) hea ily ely on he usage o s aining agen s con aining a ious hea y me als, mos commonly u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Howe e high oxici y, ising legal egula ions, and p oblema ic was e disposal o u anyl ace a e ha e inc eased calls o he educ ion o e en comple e eplacemen o his s aining agen . One o he s a egies o u anyless imaging is he employmen o low- ol age ansmission elec on mic oscopy. To in es iga e he in luence o di e en imaging and s aining s a egies on he inal image o cyanobac e ial cells, samples s ained by u anyl ace a e wi h lead ci a e, as well as uns ained samples, we e obse ed using TEM and accele a ing ol ages o 200 kV o 25 kV. Mo eo e , o examine he possibili ies o educing ch oma ic abe a ion, which o en causes issues when imaging using elec ons o lowe ene gies, samples we e also imaged using a scanning ansmission elec on mic oscopy a 15 kV accele a ing ol ages. The esul s o his s udy demons a e ha low- ol age elec on mic oscopy o e s g ea po en ial o u anyless elec on mic oscopy. Keywo ds: low ol age elec on mic oscopy; u anyl ace a e; con as ing agen s; ansmission elec on mic oscopy; Synechocys is; polyhyd oxyalkanoa es 1. In oduc ion To da e, ansmission elec on mic oscopy (TEM) is commonly he numbe one me hod used o obse ing bo h he shape and in acellula space o cells [ 1 , 2 ]. The cu en mi- c oscopes ha e e ealed specimen de ails igh down o he a omic s uc u e [ 3 , 4 ], ye he esolu ion is no he only pa ame e used o e alua e image quali y. The second pa ame e , which is o equal impo ance as he spa ial esolu ion, is image con as . This pa ame e s a s o be highly c ucial, especially when imaging biological sec ions o o he specimens composed o ligh elemen s. B ie ly, he inciden elec ons in he ansmission elec on mic oscope ha in e ac wi h he sample a e dependen on he hickness and chemical composi ion o he ma e [ 5 , 6 ]. Since biological samples a e composed o ligh elemen s and a e also embedded in ca bon- based esins, he in e ac ions be ween he p ima y elec on beam and he sample a e no su icien o p o ide sa is ac o y con as s [6]. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/mic oo ganisms11040888 h ps://www.mdpi.com/jou nal/mic oo ganisms Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 2 o 13 The e a e se e al ways o deal wi h low image con as . Con en ional imaging o biological samples equi es specimen s aining. [ 7 , 8 ]. Howe e , such sample p epa a ion o TEM includes he use o a ious oxic subs ances, namely osmium e oxide, o o ganic sal s o hea y me als, such as u anium and lead, which a e used as pos ixa ion o con- as ing agen s [ 7 , 9 ]. Speci ically high oxici y, oge he wi h ising legal egula ions and p oblema ic was e disposal o u anyl ace a e, is egula ly used as a con as ing agen o ul a hin sec ions alongside a nega i e s aining agen , ha e aised he need o changes in con en ional biological sample p epa a ion p ocedu es o TEM [10,11]. Se e al s a egies on how o eplace u anyl ace a e a e being es ed. Sal s o he lan hanoid se ies o elemen s pose as he mos equen ly sui able subs i u es [ 11 – 13 ]. In e es ingly, some publica ions also sugges oolong ea ex ac as a s aining agen o ul a hin sec ions [14–16]. A di e en app oach, how o inc ease he con as o he image wi hou hea y me al s aining, is o al e he imaging echnique i sel . I can be ealized by cons uc ion imp o emen s o elec on op ics, such as a mic oscope ha can be equipped wi h a phase pla e [ 17 , 18 ], o ano he s a egy is o lowe he accele a ing ol age o he p ima y elec on beam [19,20]. To explain he o igin o he image con as , he p e iously men ioned elec on in e ac- ions wi h he sample ha e o be conside ed. The e a e se e al mechanisms in ol ed in he con as o ma ion o TEM images, connec ed o he a ious scena ios o he inciden elec- on beam in e ac ion wi h he sample. Elec ons can be elas ically o inelas ically sca e ed o hey can go h ough he sample wi hou any in e ac ion, while all o hese phenomena mani es di e en ly in he inal image. Elec ons ansmi ed h ough he sample wi hou any in e ac ion con ibu e o he b igh backg ound o he image. Elas ically sca e ed elec ons a e il e ed by he ape u es and, hus, inc ease he image con as . The mos p oblema ic a e inelas ically sca e ed elec ons, which lose some ene gy in e ac ing wi h he sample, because hey b oaden he ene gy spec um and, hus, b ing an addi ional con i- bu ion o he ch oma ic abe a ion. The p obabili y o each kind o in e ac ion is dependen on he alue o he c oss-sec ion, which is speci ic o a pa icula ype o in e ac ion, sample composi ion, and elec on ene gy [5,6]. Fo con en ional ansmission elec on mic oscopes ha use accele a ing ol ages be ween 60 and 300 kV [ 6 , 19 ], phase con as is essen ial [ 6 ]. Howe e , going o he lowe beam ene gy, phase con as is no longe as necessa y and he sca e ing con as becomes he mos impo an componen o he con as . Reducing he elec on beam ene gy leads o highe sca e ing and, hus, o highe image con as s. In o he wo ds, he in ensi y o he elec on in e ac ion wi h he sample is dependen on he hickness and chemical composi ion o he ma e [6,20,21]. The dependence o he con as o he esul ing image on he accele a ing ol age o he p ima y elec on beam in Figu e 1shows ha he con as o he image dec eases wi h highe elec on ene gies, while he esolu ion inc eases [ 20 ]. As was desc ibed o a ious laye s o polyme s and polyme blends, imaging using lowe ene gies p o ides he possibili y o e en dis inguish a eas o di e en composi ions in ca bon-based samples [20,22,23]. S udies employing low- ol age ansmission elec on mic oscopy o he examina ion o biological samples ha e al eady p o en he bene i s o imaging a an accele a ing ol age o 5 kV [ 19 , 24 ]. Howe e , using such low ene gies comes oge he wi h he need o e en hinne samples han he con en ional ~70 nm. Speci ically, o obse e he panc ea ic issue o a a , Bendayan e al. chemically ixed he samples using glu a aldehyde wi hou any pos ixa ion p ocedu e, while o compa ison osmi ica ed samples we e also p epa ed. Samples embedded in Epon esin we e cu o ul a hin sec ions o 30–40 nm hickness. Obse a ion using a low ol age elec on mic oscope (LVEM) e ealed ha imaging using a 5 kV elec on beam p o ided su icien con as o he esul ing image and was able o expose s uc u es, which we e o he wise co e ed by osmium o o he hea y me als. [ 24 ] Ne e heless, he p epa a ion o sec ions 30–40 nm hin is qui e challenging o common use s o ul amic o ome, e en when using a diamond kni e [ 25 ]. Howe e , using mode - Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 3 o 13 a ely highe accele a ing ol ages o 25 kV, he elec ons o he p ima y elec on beam had su icien ene gy o pene a e he hicke common sec ions o 70 nm [26]. Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 3 o 14 me als. [24] Ne e heless, he p epa a ion o sec ions 30–40 nm hin is qui e challenging o common use s o ul amic o ome, e en when using a diamond kni e [25]. Howe e , using mode a ely highe accele a ing ol ages o 25 kV, he elec ons o he p ima y elec- on beam had sufficien ene gy o pene a e he hicke common sec ions o 70 nm [26]. Figu e 1. The dependence o con as and esolu ion on he accele a ing ol age o he p ima y elec on beam o TEM imaging o 20 nm ca bon laye s [20,27]. The model o ganism o choice, wi h well-desc ibed in acellula s uc u es o ou s udy, was he unicellula cyanobac e ium o PHA-p oducing s ain Synechocys is sp., PCC 6803. Cyanobac e ia belong o o ganisms signi ican in bo h he ields o science and indus y. They a e capable o g owing in di e se en i onmen s and can adap o a ious ad e se g ow h condi ions (e.g., hype saline en i onmen [28], high o low empe a u es [29,30], UV i adia ion [31], e c.). Mo eo e , many cyanobac e ial s ains pose as p oduc- e s o bio echnologically aluable subs ances [32–34]. Speci ically, membe s o he genus Synechocys is a e, along wi h some he e o ophic mic oo ganisms, capable o p oducing polyhyd oxyalkanoa es (PHAs), which a e polyes e s o hyd oxy acids ha o m g anules inside a ious mic obial cells [35–37]. In addi ion o se ing as s o age o ca bon and ene gy, PHAs ha e a signi ican ole in he enhanced obus ness o cells and, he e o e, in he capabili y o he cells o su i e ha sh en i onmen al condi ions [38,39]. The abili y o cope wi h un a o able en i onmen al condi ions o en comes oge he wi h he possibili y o mo phological changes o he cells, as was p e iously p o en o bo h he e o ophic bac e ia and cyanobac e ia. Fo a ious mic oo ganisms, he obse ed changes in he shape and size o cells, as well as he o ma ion o p ecipi a es and o he changes in he cy oplasm we e ela ed o exposu e o a ious s ess condi ions [40–42]. In ou s udy, we aimed o p o e ha an elec on beam o 15–25 kV was s ill capable o p o iding high con as o ligh e elemen s and, he e o e, i was possible o obse e biological samples wi hou he necessi y o hea y me als s aining. Samples we e ixed us- ing he high-p essu e eezing me hod, ollowed by eeze subs i u ion. Then, samples we e obse ed using TEMs ope a ing a 200 kV and 25 kV accele a ing ol ages. Bo h mi- c oscopes we e used o he analysis o he samples s ained using sal s o u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e alongside samples wi hou s aining wi h hea y me als. To demons a e he possibili y o how o minimize ch oma ic abe a ion a lowe accele a ing ol ages, imaging wi h a scanning ansmission elec on mic oscope (STEM) mode was also pe - o med. Figu e 1. The dependence o con as and esolu ion on he accele a ing ol age o he p ima y elec on beam o TEM imaging o 20 nm ca bon laye s [20,27]. The model o ganism o choice, wi h well-desc ibed in acellula s uc u es o ou s udy, was he unicellula cyanobac e ium o PHA-p oducing s ain Synechocys is sp., PCC 6803. Cyanobac e ia belong o o ganisms signi ican in bo h he ields o science and indus y. They a e capable o g owing in di e se en i onmen s and can adap o a ious ad e se g ow h condi ions (e.g., hype saline en i onmen [ 28 ], high o low em- pe a u es [ 29 , 30 ], UV i adia ion [ 31 ], e c.). Mo eo e , many cyanobac e ial s ains pose as p oduce s o bio echnologically aluable subs ances [ 32 – 34 ]. Speci ically, membe s o he genus Synechocys is a e, along wi h some he e o ophic mic oo ganisms, capable o p oducing polyhyd oxyalkanoa es (PHAs), which a e polyes e s o hyd oxy acids ha o m g anules inside a ious mic obial cells [ 35 – 37 ]. In addi ion o se ing as s o age o ca bon and ene gy, PHAs ha e a signi ican ole in he enhanced obus ness o cells and, he e o e, in he capabili y o he cells o su i e ha sh en i onmen al condi ions [38,39]. The abili y o cope wi h un a o able en i onmen al condi ions o en comes oge he wi h he possibili y o mo phological changes o he cells, as was p e iously p o en o bo h he e o ophic bac e ia and cyanobac e ia. Fo a ious mic oo ganisms, he obse ed changes in he shape and size o cells, as well as he o ma ion o p ecipi a es and o he changes in he cy oplasm we e ela ed o exposu e o a ious s ess condi ions [40–42]. In ou s udy, we aimed o p o e ha an elec on beam o 15–25 kV was s ill capable o p o iding high con as o ligh e elemen s and, he e o e, i was possible o obse e biological samples wi hou he necessi y o hea y me als s aining. Samples we e ixed using he high-p essu e eezing me hod, ollowed by eeze subs i u ion. Then, samples we e obse ed using TEMs ope a ing a 200 kV and 25 kV accele a ing ol ages. Bo h mic oscopes we e used o he analysis o he samples s ained using sal s o u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e alongside samples wi hou s aining wi h hea y me als. To demons a e he possibili y o how o minimize ch oma ic abe a ion a lowe accele a ing ol ages, imaging wi h a scanning ansmission elec on mic oscope (STEM) mode was also pe o med. 2. Ma e ials and Me hods 2.1. Mic oo ganisms and Thei Cul i a ion In his s udy cul u es o he cyanobac e ium Synechocys is sp., PCC 6803, we e ob ained om he Pas eu cul u e collec ion (Pa is, F ance) and used. Cul u es we e cul i a ed in a mine al medium based on BG-11 [ 43 , 44 ]. The con en o ni ogen and phospho us Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 4 o 13 was adjus ed o enable ea ly g ow h o biomass ollowed by s a a ion o ni ogen and phospho us o induce PHA p oduc ion. Cul u es in E lenmeye lasks we e cul i a ed in a anspa en box wi h con olled ai low, empe a u e, and dayligh illumina ion simula ion using a 16/8 h day/nigh cycle o illumina ion. 2.2. Sample P epa a ion o Elec on Mic oscopy Cyanobac e ial cul u es we e cen i uged o 4 min a 4000 pm and p ocessed using c yogenic me hods o sample p epa a ion. The cell pelle was pipe ed on 3 mm Au/Cu ca ie s ype A wi h 1% solu ion o soy leci hin in chlo o o m and co e ed wi h he la side o 3 mm Au/Cu ca ie ype B. Samples we e ixed using high-p essu e eezing (EM ICE, Leica Mic osys ems, Vienna, Aus ia), ollowed by eeze subs i u ion (EM AFS2, Leica Mic osys ems, Vienna, Aus ia). The subs i u ion solu ion con ained 1.5% OsO 4 in ace one and he p ocedu e was se o − 90 ◦ C o 72 h, hen, he samples we e wa med up o − 20 ◦ C o 24 h and he p ocedu e inished, wi h he inal phase a 4 ◦ C o 18 h, as p e iously desc ibed [ 45 ]. Fixed samples we e in il a ed wi h epoxy esin (Epoxy Embedding Medium ki , Sigma Ald ich, Da ms ad , Ge many ) and cu ed o 48 h a 62 ◦ C. Embedded samples we e cu in o ul a hin sec ions (~75 nm) using a diamond kni e (Ul a 45 ◦ , DiATOME, Nidau, Swi ze land) and ul amic o ome (EM UC7, Leica Mic osys ems, Vienna, Aus ia). Hal o he sec ions we e obse ed wi hou any pos s aining p ocedu es, while he o he hal we e s ained using con en ional s aining agen s: u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. 2.3. Elec on Mic oscopy Cyanobac e ial cells we e obse ed using a ious ypes o elec on mic oscopes. As p e iously men ioned, he con en ional ansmission elec on mic oscope ope a es wi hin he ange o 60–300 kV accele a ing ol ages o he elec on beam [ 6 , 19 ]. In ou s udy, we compa ed wo di e en ansmission elec on mic oscopes using di e en accele a ing ol ages o he elec on beam: Talos F200C ope a ing a 200 kV and LVEM 25 ope a ing a 25 kV. Mo eo e , con en ional TEM imaging equi es s aining o ul a hin sec ions commonly using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e [ 7 , 8 ], which should no be necessa y o low- ol age imaging [ 24 ]. Thus, o p o ide a ho ough s udy o he in luence o a ious imaging condi ions we compa ed no only imaging using di e en elec on beam ene gies bu also imaging o samples pos s ained using only osmium e oxide, p esen in he eeze subs i u ion solu ion, and also con en ionally s ained samples, using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Con en ional high- ol age imaging was ca ied ou on a ansmission elec on mic o- scope Talos F200C (The mo Fishe Scien i ic, Wal ham, MA, USA), equipped wi h a Ce a-D Came a, using an elec on beam ol age o 200 kV. Low- ol age images we e ob ained using a ansmission elec on mic oscope LVEM 25 (Delong Ins umen s, B no, Czech Republic) equipped wi h an sCMOS came a BSI Teledyne o TEM mode, using a ol age o 25 kV. Mo eo e , o explo e he possibili ies o educing he ch oma ic abe a ion when imaging using low ene gies o he elec on beam, he STEM mode o LVEM 25, using a YAG sc een, ollowed by a pho omul iplie o egis e STEM signal a 15 kV elec on beam ol age, was employed as well as imaging a he same ol age using a scanning elec on mic oscope Helios G4 HP (The moFishe Scien i ic, Wal ham, MA, USA) equipped wi h a STEM3+ de ec o , while he b igh ield segmen o he de ec o was selec ed o bo h mic oscopes. 3. Resul s 3.1. High Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy The in luence o he s aining p ocedu e on con en ional TEM imaging was subs an ial. As seen in Figu e 2A, e en hough he OsO 4 p o ided sub le con as in he in acellula Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 5 o 13 s uc u es o he cyanobac e ial cells, compa ed o he s ained sample in Figu e 2B, he ul as uc u e is almos indis inguishable. Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 o 14 3. Resul s 3.1. High Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy The in luence o he s aining p ocedu e on con en ional TEM imaging was subs an- ial. As seen in Figu e 2A, e en hough he OsO4 p o ided sub le con as in he in acel- lula s uc u es o he cyanobac e ial cells, compa ed o he s ained sample in Figu e 2B, he ul as uc u e is almos indis inguishable. Figu e 2. Compa ison o he in luence o diffe en s aining p ocedu es and ene gies o he elec on beam in he inal TEM image on cyanobac e ial cells. (A) A 200 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam wi hou s aining, (B) 200 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam and s aining wi h u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e, (C) 25 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam wi hou s aining, (D) 25 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam and s aining wi h u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Scale ba : 1 µm. Figu e 2. Compa ison o he in luence o di e en s aining p ocedu es and ene gies o he elec on beam in he inal TEM image on cyanobac e ial cells. ( A ) A 200 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam wi hou s aining, ( B ) 200 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam and s aining wi h u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e, ( C ) 25 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam wi hou s aining, ( D ) 25 kV accele a ing ol age o elec on beam and s aining wi h u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Scale ba : 1µm. E en he mo e de ailed images o he uns ained sample obse ed using a 200 kV elec on beam p o ided minimal con as wi h which o ecognize he in acellula s uc- u es. As shown in Figu e 3, he hylakoid memb anes o he cyanobac e ial cell a e ha dly dis inguishable wi hin he in acellula space and could e en be conside ed ‘noise’ in he image, while o he s uc u es, possibly occu ing in he cyanobac e ial cells, a e mos ly un ecognizable. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 6 o 13 Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 o 14 E en he mo e de ailed images o he uns ained sample obse ed using a 200 kV elec- on beam p o ided minimal con as wi h which o ecognize he in acellula s uc u es. As shown in Figu e 3, he hylakoid memb anes o he cyanobac e ial cell a e ha dly dis- inguishable wi hin he in acellula space and could e en be conside ed ‘noise’ in he image, while o he s uc u es, possibly occu ing in he cyanobac e ial cells, a e mos ly un ecognizable. Figu e 3. TEM image o uns ained cyanobac e ial cells ob ained using a 200 kV elec on beam. Thylakoid memb anes ma ked by a ow. Scale ba : 500 nm. On he o he hand, when ollowing he con en ional p ocedu e, he de ailed images o he s ained sample, obse ed using a 200 kV elec on beam (Figu e 4A), p o ide us wi h balanced con as and, he e o e, he in acellula s uc u es such as hylakoid memb anes (ma ked by a ow), ca boxysome (ma ked by iangle), glycogen g anules (ma ked by “gg”) a e easily dis inguishable, while i is e en possible o ecognize he diffe ence be- ween he elec on-lucen PHA g anules (ma ked by a owhead) and he holes in he spec- imen owing o he emains o he washed-away g anules (ma ked by c oss) [46]. Figu e 3. TEM image o uns ained cyanobac e ial cells ob ained using a 200 kV elec on beam. Thylakoid memb anes ma ked by a ow. Scale ba : 500 nm. On he o he hand, when ollowing he con en ional p ocedu e, he de ailed images o he s ained sample, obse ed using a 200 kV elec on beam (Figu e 4A), p o ide us wi h balanced con as and, he e o e, he in acellula s uc u es such as hylakoid memb anes (ma ked by a ow), ca boxysome (ma ked by iangle), glycogen g anules (ma ked by “gg”) a e easily dis inguishable, while i is e en possible o ecognize he di e ence be ween he elec on-lucen PHA g anules (ma ked by a owhead) and he holes in he specimen owing o he emains o he washed-away g anules (ma ked by c oss) [46]. Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 o 14 Figu e 4. In acellula s uc u es o cyanobac e ial cells we e acqui ed using diffe en imaging condi ions. (A) Sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged using a 200 kV elec- on beam, (B) sample wi hou s aining imaged using a 25 kV elec on beam. In acellula s uc- u es ma ked by an a ow: hylakoid memb anes; a owhead: PHA g anules; iangle: ca boxy- some; c oss: washed-ou g anule; gg: glycogen g anule. Scale ba : 500 nm. 3.2. Low Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy As shown in he p e ious sec ion, o ob ain sa is ac o y con as s in he images ac- qui ed by a high ol age ansmission elec on mic oscope, i is necessa y o use con- as ing agen s, mos commonly using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e o s ain ul a hin sec ions on he g id. Howe e , i he accele a ing ol age o he elec on beam is lowe ed, he uns ained sample (Figu e 2C) p o ides an easily ecognizable ul as uc u e o he s udied cells, which is, on he o he hand, in e es ingly a he co e ed by he s aining agen s (Figu e 2D), esul ing in e y da k images o he cells wi h ha dly any dis inguish- able in acellula s uc u es. Fu he mo e, as seen in Figu e 4B, he de ailed image o an uns ained sample ob- se ed using a 25 kV elec on beam p o ides clea ly ecognizable in acellula s uc u es, and in addi ion, when ocusing on he esin su ounding he cells, he low ol age image p o ides minimum noise, whe eby only he lines le by he kni e du ing sec ioning a e sligh ly isible, while he glycogen g anules a e easily dis inguishable om he ‘noise’. 3.3. Low Vol age Scanning T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy In scanning ansmission elec on mic oscopes (STEMs), he elec on beam is ocused on a e y small p obe and is scanned o e he sample; o each posi ion (pixel) ansmi ed elec ons a e eco ded by a sui able STEM de ec o . Mos TEM and scanning elec on mi- c oscopes (SEMs), i hey a e equipped wi h he necessa y ha dwa e, can also enable STEM image eco ding. This echnique is also e y use ul o imaging ul a hin sec ions o biological samples [47,48]. As shown in Figu e 5C, he low- ol age STEM p o ides a sha p image o he ul as uc u e o he cyanobac e ial cells wi h a sa is ac o y con as . Simila ly o he low- ol age TEM, he s ained sec ions o he samples p o ided a highe con as han he uns ained samples (Figu e 5D). Howe e , in he STEM images, i is s ill possible o ecognize he elemen al s uc u es o he cells. Figu e 4. In acellula s uc u es o cyanobac e ial cells we e acqui ed using di e en imaging condi ions. ( A ) Sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged using a 200 kV elec on beam, ( B ) sample wi hou s aining imaged using a 25 kV elec on beam. In acellula s uc u es ma ked by an a ow: hylakoid memb anes; a owhead: PHA g anules; iangle: ca boxysome; c oss: washed-ou g anule; gg: glycogen g anule. Scale ba : 500 nm. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 7 o 13 3.2. Low Vol age T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy As shown in he p e ious sec ion, o ob ain sa is ac o y con as s in he images ac- qui ed by a high ol age ansmission elec on mic oscope, i is necessa y o use con as ing agen s, mos commonly using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e o s ain ul a hin sec ions on he g id. Howe e , i he accele a ing ol age o he elec on beam is lowe ed, he uns ained sample (Figu e 2C) p o ides an easily ecognizable ul as uc u e o he s udied cells, which is, on he o he hand, in e es ingly a he co e ed by he s aining agen s (Figu e 2D), esul ing in e y da k images o he cells wi h ha dly any dis inguishable in acellula s uc u es. Fu he mo e, as seen in Figu e 4B, he de ailed image o an uns ained sample obse ed using a 25 kV elec on beam p o ides clea ly ecognizable in acellula s uc u es, and in addi ion, when ocusing on he esin su ounding he cells, he low ol age image p o ides minimum noise, whe eby only he lines le by he kni e du ing sec ioning a e sligh ly isible, while he glycogen g anules a e easily dis inguishable om he ‘noise’. 3.3. Low Vol age Scanning T ansmission Elec on Mic oscopy In scanning ansmission elec on mic oscopes (STEMs), he elec on beam is ocused on a e y small p obe and is scanned o e he sample; o each posi ion (pixel) ansmi ed elec ons a e eco ded by a sui able STEM de ec o . Mos TEM and scanning elec on mic oscopes (SEMs), i hey a e equipped wi h he necessa y ha dwa e, can also enable STEM image eco ding. This echnique is also e y use ul o imaging ul a hin sec ions o biological samples [ 47 , 48 ]. As shown in Figu e 5C, he low- ol age STEM p o ides a sha p image o he ul as uc u e o he cyanobac e ial cells wi h a sa is ac o y con as . Simila ly o he low- ol age TEM, he s ained sec ions o he samples p o ided a highe con as han he uns ained samples (Figu e 5D). Howe e , in he STEM images, i is s ill possible o ecognize he elemen al s uc u es o he cells. To p o e ha he use ulness o he low- ol age imaging is no bound solely h ough he specialized low- ol age TEM, he same samples we e also imaged using a SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o also ope a ing a a 15 kV accele a ing ol age. As seen in Figu e 6A, he o e all con as o he uns ained sample is compa able o bo h mic oscopes, while he specialized low- ol age TEM p o ided sha pe images. Howe e , he image o he s ained sample (Figu e 6B) shows mo e a balanced con as han in he specialized low- ol age TEM, while he image is also sha pe han in he uns ained sample imaged by a SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o , which is demons a ed by he s uc u e o glycogen g anules. Ne e heless, he p oblem o possible con amina ion o he sample by p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s also emains o STEM imaging, simila o he isk o con en ional TEM imaging. In Figu e 7B, he impu i ies caused by he p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s a e clea ly isible, as well as he impu i ies in Figu e 7A, whe e he esidual osmium e oxide om he eeze subs i u ion solu ion could ha e c ys alized and le he elec on-dense impu i ies in he sample. Howe e , he ex en o he con amina ion by he impu i ies is sub- s an ially highe o he con en ional s aining p ocedu e han o he osmium-only s aining. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 8 o 13 Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 o 14 Figu e 5. Compa ison o he images o cyanobac e ial cells ob ained using a low ol age ansmis- sion elec on mic oscope in diffe en imaging modes. (A) Uns ained sample imaged in TEM mode using a 25 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, (B) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged in TEM mode using a 25 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, (C) uns ained sam- ple imaged in STEM mode using a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, (D) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged in TEM mode using a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec- on beam. Scale ba : 1 µm. To p o e ha he use ulness o he low- ol age imaging is no bound solely h ough he specialized low- ol age TEM, he same samples we e also imaged using a SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o also ope a ing a a 15 kV accele a ing ol age. As seen in Figu e 6A, he o e all con as o he uns ained sample is compa able o bo h mic o- scopes, while he specialized low- ol age TEM p o ided sha pe images. Howe e , he Figu e 5. Compa ison o he images o cyanobac e ial cells ob ained using a low ol age ansmission elec on mic oscope in di e en imaging modes. ( A ) Uns ained sample imaged in TEM mode using a 25 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, ( B ) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged in TEM mode using a 25 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, ( C ) uns ained sample imaged in STEM mode using a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam, ( D ) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e imaged in TEM mode using a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam. Scale ba : 1 µm. Mic oo ganisms 2023,11, 888 9 o 13 Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 o 14 image o he s ained sample (Figu e 6B) shows mo e a balanced con as han in he spe- cialized low- ol age TEM, while he image is also sha pe han in he uns ained sample imaged by a SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o , which is demons a ed by he s uc u e o glycogen g anules. Figu e 6. Cyanobac e ial cells we e imaged using SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o wi h a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam. (A) Uns ained sample, (B) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Glycogen g anules ma ked by “gg”. Scale ba : 1 µm. Ne e heless, he p oblem o possible con amina ion o he sample by p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s also emains o STEM imaging, simila o he isk o con en ional TEM imaging. In Figu e 7B, he impu i ies caused by he p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s a e clea ly isible, as well as he impu i ies in Figu e 7A, whe e he esidual osmium e- oxide om he eeze subs i u ion solu ion could ha e c ys alized and le he elec on- dense impu i ies in he sample. Howe e , he ex en o he con amina ion by he impu i- ies is subs an ially highe o he con en ional s aining p ocedu e han o he osmium- only s aining. Figu e 6. Cyanobac e ial cells we e imaged using SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o wi h a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam. ( A ) Uns ained sample, ( B ) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Glycogen g anules ma ked by “gg”. Scale ba : 1 µm. Mic oo ganisms 2023, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 o 14 image o he s ained sample (Figu e 6B) shows mo e a balanced con as han in he spe- cialized low- ol age TEM, while he image is also sha pe han in he uns ained sample imaged by a SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o , which is demons a ed by he s uc u e o glycogen g anules. Figu e 6. Cyanobac e ial cells we e imaged using SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o wi h a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam. (A) Uns ained sample, (B) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Glycogen g anules ma ked by “gg”. Scale ba : 1 µm. Ne e heless, he p oblem o possible con amina ion o he sample by p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s also emains o STEM imaging, simila o he isk o con en ional TEM imaging. In Figu e 7B, he impu i ies caused by he p ecipi a ed con as ing agen s a e clea ly isible, as well as he impu i ies in Figu e 7A, whe e he esidual osmium e- oxide om he eeze subs i u ion solu ion could ha e c ys alized and le he elec on- dense impu i ies in he sample. Howe e , he ex en o he con amina ion by he impu i- ies is subs an ially highe o he con en ional s aining p ocedu e han o he osmium- only s aining. Figu e 7. Cyanobac e ial cells we e imaged using SEM equipped wi h a STEM de ec o wi h a 15 kV accele a ing ol age elec on beam. ( A ) Uns ained sample, ( B ) sample s ained using u anyl ace a e and lead ci a e. Impu i ies ma ked by a ow. Scale ba : 1 µm. 4. Discussion The compa ison be ween he impac o he s aining p ocedu e and he accele a ing ol age o he elec on beam used o imaging he cyanobac e ial cells shows subs an ial di e ences o each echnique. The clea di e ence is al eady obse ed in he lowe magni ica ion images. As p e iously men ioned, he uns ained samples obse ed using he 200 kV elec on beam show almos no con as ; he e o e, he ul as uc u e o he cells is ha dly isible. On he o he hand, imaging he same uns ained sample using low accele a ing ol ages o he elec on beam p o ided a balanced con as and, he e o e, easily ecognizable in acellula s uc u es.