scieee Open visual document viewer

Pseudo-Differential Filter Design Using Novel Adjustable Floating Inductance Simulator with Electronically Controllable Current Conveyors

Šotner, Roman; Herencsár, Norbert; Jeřábek, Jan; Kartci, Aslihan; Koton, Jaroslav; Dostál, Tomáš

Abstract

This paper presents new floating inductance simulator based on three electronically controllable current conveyors (ECCIIs) and differential voltage buffer (DVB). The inductance simulator offers simple electronic control of inductance value as well as simple control of losses by change of parameters of active elements. Based on this floating inductance simulator, example of reconnection-less reconfigurable pseudo-differential first-order filter, allowing change of transfer function between high-pass and inverting all-pass response, is discussed and studied. Moreover, the proposed structure can be easily extended to a pseudo-differential second-order band-bass filter. Behaviour of presented solutions is verified by PSpice simulations and also experimentally in frequency band up to 10 MHz. Obtained results confirmed expected features.

Full text

ELEKTRONIKA IR ELEKTROTECHNIKA,ISSN 1392-1215,VOL.23,NO.2,2017 1Abs ac —This pape p esen s new loa ing induc ance simula o based on h ee elec onically con ollable cu en con eyo s (ECCIIs) and di e en ial ol age bu e (DVB). The induc ance simula o o e s simple elec onic con ol o induc ance alue as well as simple con ol o losses by change o pa ame e s o ac i e elemen s. Based on his loa ing induc ance simula o , example o econnec ion-less econ igu able pseudo- di e en ial i s -o de il e , allowing change o ans e unc ion be ween high-pass and in e ing all-pass esponse, is discussed and s udied. Mo eo e , he p oposed s uc u e can be easily ex ended o a pseudo-di e en ial second-o de band-bass il e . Beha iou o p esen ed solu ions is e i ied by PSpice simula ions and also expe imen ally in equency band up o 10 MHz. Ob ained esul s con i med expec ed ea u es. Index Te ms—Di e en ial ac i e il e ; di e en ial mode; pseudo-di e en ial-mode; elec onic con ol; induc ance simula o ; econ igu abili y. I. INTRODUCTION In gene al, ully-di e en ial (symme ical) ci cui s ha e many applica ions due o speci ic ea u es hey o e , i.e. a enua ion o common-mode noise as well as be e ejec ion o signals incoming om powe supply sou ces and possibly also be e dynamics in compa ison o single-ended ci cui ies [1]–[4]. Howe e , inc eased complexi y o ci cui y is cos o hese bene i s. Elec onic con ollabili y o pa ame e s o analogue and mixed-mode ci cui s is use ul in single-ended as well as in case o di e en ial-mode ope a ion. The e o e, ci cui solu ions allowing hese ea u es a e subjec s o in e es o many esea che s [4]. Digi al con ol o impo an pa ame e s o he di e en ial- Manusc ip ecei ed 23 Decembe , 2016; accep ed 18 Ma ch, 2017. Resea ch desc ibed in his pape was inanced by Czech Minis y o Educa ion in ame o Na ional Sus ainabili y P og am unde g an LO1401. Fo esea ch, in as uc u e o he SIX Cen e was used. Resea ch desc ibed in he pape was suppo ed by Czech Science Founda ion p ojec s unde No. 16-11460Y. il e was also in es iga ed in he pas [5]. Di ision o di e en ial sys ems ( o example see [1]–[8]) o uly-di e en ial and so-called pseudo-di e en ial-mode o ope a ion, is pe ec ly explained in [8] which b ings new insigh in o his esea ch opic. No e ha complexi y o pseudo-di e en ial-mode ci cui s is signi ican ly educed in compa ison o ully-di e en ial-mode solu ions due o pa ially g ounded subpa s o di e en ial sys ems, i.e. inpu and ou pu po s a e di e en ial whe eas hei inne ci cui y consis s o g ounded (analog g ound) passi e componen s and e minals. Many om p e iously epo ed pseudo- di e en ial ci cui solu ions we e ocused on biquad a ic (second-o de ) ac i e il e s, [6]–[9] o ins ance. Elec onic con ollabili y [6] as well as mul i- unc ionali y (p o iding se e al ans e esponses) [7] we e also s udied in he pas . In his pape we a e in oducing a no el solu ion o loa ing induc ance simula o allowing ea u es no epo ed in p e ious wo ks. These ea u es a e bene icial especially in elec onic econ igu a ion o ans e unc ion and elec onic con ol o pseudo-di e en ial-mode il e pa ame e s. He e p oposed il e ing applica ions can be di ided o wo g oups: (i) i s -o de econ igu able il e , (ii) second-o de band- pass il e . Compa ison o selec ed solu ions o i s -o de ac i e il e s in single-ended, ully-di e en ial, o pseudo- di e en ial o m [10]–[14] is a ailable in Table I. In gene al, many o hese ha e mul i unc ional ea u es, howe e , ea u es such as econnec ion-less econ igu abili y (possible o ob ain a ious ans e esponses wi hou change o inpu /ou pu e minal) we e s udied only in single-ended il e ing solu ions (see o example [15]). To he bes o au ho s’ knowledge, ci cui s allowing econ igu a ion o ans e esponses, i.e. ce ain mul i- unc ionali y o he il e be ween a leas wo di e en ypes o ully-di e en ial o pseudo-di e en ial il e s we e no epo ed in he open li e a u e ye . He e p esen ed s uc u e o loa ing induc ance simula o allows such elec onic econ igu a ion, i i s Pseudo-Di e en ial Fil e Design Using No el Adjus able Floa ing Induc ance Simula o wi h Elec onically Con ollable Cu en Con eyo s Roman So ne 1,2, No be He encsa 2, Jan Je abek2, Aslihan Ka ci1,2, Ja osla Ko on2, Tomas Dos al3 1Depa men o Radio Elec onics, Facul y o Elec ical Enginee ing and Communica ion, B no Uni e si y o Technology, Technicka 12, B no, 616 00, Czech Republic 2Depa men o Telecommunica ions, Facul y o Elec ical Enginee ing and Communica ion, B no Uni e si y o Technology, Technicka 12, B no, 616 00, Czech Republic 3Depa men o Technical S udies, College o Poly echnics Jihla a, Tols eho 16, Jihla a 586 01, Czech Republic [email p o ec ed].cz h p://dx.doi.o g/10.5755/j01.eie.23.2.17996 31 ELEKTRONIKA IR ELEKTROTECHNIKA,ISSN 1392-1215,VOL.23,NO.2,2017 implemen a ion is app op ia e, as i is shown in his pape . TABLE I. COMPARISON OF REPORTED PSEUDO/FULLY- DIFFERENTIAL FIRST-ORDER MULTIFUNCTIONAL FILTERS. Wo k No. o pas./ac . elemen s A ailable unc ions T ans e esponse con igu abili y [10] 4-6/1 AP, BR No [11] 2-6/1-2 LP, HP, AP No [12] 4/1 AP No [13] 4/2 AP, LP No [14] 1/3 AP No Fig. 3 2(6)/1(4) HP, iAP Yes No e: (i) DT – (in e ing) di ec ans e ; (i) AP – (in e ing) all-pass; LP – low-pass; (i) HP – (in e ing) high-pass; BR – band ejec . II. DESCRIPTION OF FLOATING INDUCTANCE SIMULATOR P oposed loa ing induc ance simula o shown in Fig. 1 employs h ee elec onically adjus able cu en con eyo s o second gene a ion (ECCIIs) [16] desc ibed by he ollowing in e - e minal ans e s: IZ=B.IX,VX=VY,IY= 0 and one di e en ial ol age bu e (DVB) [16] p o iding he ollowing ope a ion: V+V=Vou . No e ha he cu en gain Bo each ECCII is con ollable linea ly by DC ol age (BVSET_B). Comme cially a ailable de ices EL2082 and AD830 a e examples o p e iously discussed elemen s (ECCII, DVB) wi h well- i ing beha iou up o se e al ens o MHz. Assuming Rx1 =Rx2 =R3a e equal and designa ed as RL_in , he admi ance desc ip ion (based on me hod o unknown nodal ol ages: I=Y×V) o he ci cui in Fig. 1 p esen s se o equa ions: 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 , inp inp Inp inp I V a B a B I V a B a B                                (1) whe e   2 _ in _ in 3 _ in 2 L L L a sC R B R   . Then, assuming B1=B2=B1,2, impedance o equi alen induc ance emula o has he ollowing heo e ical o m   _ in _ in 2 _ in _ in 3 _ in 1,2 1,2 ( ) 2, eq eq s L L L L s sL R sC R B R B B       (2) whe e CL_in and RL_in a e passi e elemen s o he induc ance simula o and i is clea ha he p oposed ci cui beha es as lossy induc ance. Howe e , he lossy pa Rs_in in (1) can be easily elimina ed by selec ing cu en gain B3(ECCII3) equal o 2, losses a e nega i e o B3> 2. Ne e heless, lossy pa o he p oposed induc ance simula o can be also bene icial o applica ion as in oduced la e . Mo eo e , i is ob ious ha alue o Leq_in can be con olled elec onically by B1and B2. P oposed induc ance simula o in Fig. 1 was designed o u he implemen a ions wi h he ollowing alues o in e nal elemen s: RL_in = 560 ,CL_in = 470 pF as a pa icula example. The PSpice simula ion esul s o he induc ance simula o in g ounded o m a e shown in Fig. 2. Induc ance alue Leq was changed om 2.63 H o 0.13 H by VSET_B1,2 be ween 0.1 and 2 V, i.e. gains B1and B2a e be ween 0.1 and 2. III. INDUCTANCE SIMULATOR IMPLEMENTATION IN PSEUDO- DIFFERENTIAL FILTERING APPLICATIONS Bene i s o he p oposed solu ion we e e i ied in se e al il e ing applica ions shown in he ollowing sec ions. Induc ance simula o is used as loa ing elemen in RL o RLC ladde s uc u es. Theo e ical expec a ions a e suppo ed by simula ion esul s and also by labo a o y expe imen s. Fig. 1. P oposed loa ing induc ance simula o based on ECCIIs and DVB including desc ip ion o beha iou o ac i e elemen s (b own colou ). Fig. 2. Simula ion esul s o impedance cha ac e is ics (magni ude) o p oposed induc ance simula o (Fig. 1) in lossless mode while uning B1,2. A. Recon igu able Fi s -O de High-Pass/In e ing All- Pass Fil e P oposed ci cui in Fig. 3 has a pseudo-di e en ial con igu a ion, which, in acco dance o [8], means ha i has di e en ial inpu /ou pu e minals, bu inne ci cui i sel is no ully symme ical. Special ea u es o he in oduced induc ance simula o in Fig. 1 a e e y use ul o econnec ion-less econ igu abili y o ans e unc ion in pseudo-di e en ial i s -o de high-pass/in e ing all-pass (HP/iAP) il e . These ea u es a e no a ailable i any s anda d solu ion o simula o o lossless induc ance is employed as Leq in s uc u e shown in Fig. 3. Fig. 3. Implemen a ion o he loa ing induc ance simula o in pseudo- di e en ial-mode econ igu able i s -o de HP/iAP il e (Vinp/ou _s – symme ical inpu /ou pu ol age). Di e en ial-mode ans e unc ion ( ull desc ip ion (1) 32 ELEKTRONIKA IR ELEKTROTECHNIKA,ISSN 1392-1215,VOL.23,NO.2,2017 applied) o he ci cui in Fig. 3 has symbolical o m     _ _ _ 3 _ in _ in _ in 3 1 2 2 _ in _ in ( ) 2 2 . 2 ou s HP iAP inp s L L L L L V K s V B s C R R B R B B s C R                 (3) T ans e unc ion (3) o e s high-pass (HP) esponse, i B3= 2   1 2 2 _ in _ in ( ) 2 , HP L L s K s R B B s C R   (4) whe e cu -o (pole) equency is de ined by   1 2 12_ in _ in . p L L R B B R C    (5) The easies example o in e ing all-pass (iAP) esponse is a ailable o R=RL_in ,B1=B2=B1,2 = 1, B3= 3, om (3) we ob ained simpli ied o m o ans e _ in _ in 1/ ( ) ( ) 2 . 1/ ( ) L iAP L s C R K s s C R   (6) The ollowing ela ion mus be alid o B3i iAP esponse is eques ed 1 2 32 . 2 B B B   (7) Fig. 4. Magni ude esponses o he pseudo-di e en ial-mode econ igu able HP/iAP il e econ igu ed by con ol o Vse _B3 and se e al examples o uning o he cu -o equency o HP esponse by Vse _B1,2. Bo h pole/ze o equency has simple o m  p1 = 1/RCL_in . Also no e ha pole equency can be con olled elec onically by Vse _B1,2 and ype o ans e unc ion is econ igu ed by loss pa o induc o simula o (B3gain). Figu e 4 includes compa ison o expe imen al and simula ed esul s o he il e om Fig. 3, when wo king esis o was se R= 1 k. Resul ing aces we e ob ained o ideal cu -o equency equal o 216 kHz (simula ed 226 kHz, measu ed 227 kHz) ob ained by Vse _B1,2 = 0.1 V, Vse _B3 = 1.95 V (HP esponse) o 2.15 V in case o iAP esponse ((7) o B3). The example o  p1 uning in case o he HP esponse by con ol o B1,2 can be obse ed also in Fig. 4. In measu emen s he change o Vse _B1,2 be ween 0.1 and 0.5 V ensu es adjus men o p1 om 227 kHz o 959 kHz, espec i ely. B. Pseudo-Di e en ial-Mode Second-O de Band-Pass Fil e This applica ion is easily a ailable by adding a capaci ance be ween ou pu e minals as shown in Fig. 5. T ans e unc ion o ideal RLC ladde s uc u e employing lossless Leq conside ed in ully-di e en ial o m (1) is de ined as 2 1 ( ) . 1 1 2 BP eq sRC K s s s RC L C    (8) R R Leq CDVB 1 RL Ro 50 Ω 50 Ω OPAMP RI AD8138 AD830 DUT ne wo k analyze E5071C Fig. 5. Implemen a ion o he induc ance simula o in second-o de RLC ladde di e en ial band-pass il e . Schema ic includes expe imen al se up (Vinp/ou _as – asymme ical ol age; Vinp/ou _s – symme ical ol age). Conside ing he implemen a ion o lossless Leq_in (i.e. B3= 2), ans e unc ion (8) changes o 21 2 2_ in _ in 1 ( ) , 1 22 BP L L sRC K s B B s s RC R C C    (9) whe e cen e (pole) equency and quali y ac o ha e he ollowing exp essions: 1 2 1,2 1 2 2 2 _ in _ in 1,2 _ in _ in 1 2 1, p p B B B L L L L B B C C R B C C R          (10)   1 2 1,2 1 2 _ in _ in 1,2 _ in _ in 2 2 2. B B B L L L L B B C R Q Q R C B C R R C        (11) No e ha his second-o de BP il e allows uning o he pole equency wi h heo e ically no e ec on bandwid h, because BW [Hz] = 1/(4RC), and also change o quali y 33 ELEKTRONIKA IR ELEKTROTECHNIKA,ISSN 1392-1215,VOL.23,NO.2,2017 ac o wi hou change o gain du ing he uning p ocess. No e ha bo h il e s (Fig. 3 and Fig. 5) ha e +6 dB pass- band gain (see cons . 2 in (3) and (9)). Howe e , expe imen al se up (ou pu di ide ROand RLo ne wo k analyse ) pe o ms di ision by 2, he e o e, ideal pass-band gain o he whole sys em is 0 dB. Fig. 6. Magni ude esponses o he di e en ial-mode second-o de BP il e du ing uning o he cen e equency. Compa ison o expe imen al esul s, simula ions, and heo e ical aces o magni ude and phase esponses o he pseudo-di e en ial-mode BP il e is gi en in Fig. 6. Passi e componen alues and ac i e pa ame e s we e se as ollows: RL_in = 560 ,CL_in =C= 470 pF, R= 1 k,B3= 0 and B1=B2=B1,2 = 1 (Vse _B1,2 = 1 V). Theo e ical, expe imen ally es ed, and simula ed BP achie ed p2 = {605, 606, and 596} kHz, wi h BW = {169, 163, and 163} kHz and Q= {3.6, 3.8, and 3.7} espec i ely. Tuning p ocess (adjus men o B1,2) can be also obse ed in Fig. 6. In measu emen s, adjus ing o Vse _B1,2 be ween 0.1 V and 2 V o e s ange o p2 uning om 199 kHz o 880 kHz. All de ails a e no ed in igu es. P esen ed expe imen al esul s in Fig. 4 and Fig. 6 we e ca ied ou using ec o ne wo k analyse E5071C wi h es se up gi en in Fig. 5. Figu e 7 shows he ab ica ed p o o ype including con e e s om single-ended o di e en ial mode and ice e sa se ing o pe o med expe imen al es s. Fig. 7. Fab ica ed expe imen al p o o ype o pseudo-di e en ial il e . IV. DISCUSSION AND SUMMARIZATION OF RESULTS Analysis o discussed induc ance simula o e ealed ollowing ad an ages: a) possible implemen a ion in di e en ial applica ions ( loa ing elemen ), b) pseudo- di e en ial cha ac e o ci cui y (inne g ounded capaci o ), c) simple elec onic con ollabili y o induc ance alue and losses including special o m o losses (2) ha allows in e es ing applica ions. No e ha hese ea u es a e no simul aneously a ailable in many s anda d solu ions. The alue o designed induc ance simula o was es ed om 2.63 H o 0.13 H (Vse _B1,2 adjus ed om 0.1 V up o 2.0 V), i.e. unabili y a io is app oxima ely 1:20. In acco dance o he s a e-o - he-a discussed in Table I, he i s applica ion example o he designed special induc ance implemen a ion ( econ igu able i s -o de il e ) ep esen s unique de ice, because up o now (pseudo)di e en ial-mode econ igu able il e s ha e no been widely in es iga ed. Ope a ion o he HP/iAP was e i ied by change o Vse _B3 om 1.95 V o 2.15 V (HP→iAP). Tuning ange o he pole equency yields alues om 227 kHz o 959 kHz (Vse _B1,2 se om 0.1 V o 0.5 V). The second example o applica ion, he pseudo- di e en ial second-o de BP was es ed in equency ange om 199 kHz o 880 kHz (Vse _B1,2 se om 0.1 V o 2.0 V) wi h almos cons an bandwid h app oxima ely equal o 165 kHz. V. CONCLUSIONS P esen ed loa ing induc ance simula o was es ed in wo no el applica ions namely pseudo-di e en ial-mode econ igu able i s -o de HP/iAP il e and second-o de BP il e de i ed om passi e p o o ypes. Due o limi a ions o comme cially a ailable de ices used in induc ance simula o , a ge ed equency ange was in hund eds o kHz. Expe imen al esul s a e in good ag eemen wi h simula ions and heo y. P oposed induc ance simula o o e s in e es ing ea u es in gi en applica ions and special o m o i s losses (in lossy mode o ope a ion) b ings use ul implemen a ions also in pseudo-di e en ial-mode oscilla o s. Fu u e po en ial o di e en ial-mode ci cui s is unde g ea in e es s o many esea che s. The e o e, we expec u he de elopmen o hese ci cui s especially wi h econnec ion-less econ igu a ions. REFERENCES [1] O. Casas, R. Pallas-A eny, “Basics o analog di e en ial il e s”, IEEE T ans. Ins umen a ion and Measu emen , ol. 45, no. 1, pp. 977–985, 1996. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/ 19.481347 [2] A. A. El-Adawy, A. M. Soliman, H. O. Elwan, “A no el ully di e en ial cu en con eyo and applica ions o analog VLSI”, IEEE T ans. Ci cui s and Sys ems – II: Analog and Digi al Signal P ocessing, ol. 47, no. 4, pp. 306–313, 2000. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/82.839666 [3] S. M. Al-Shah ani, “Fully di e en ial second o de il e ”, in P oc. 47 h IEEE In . Midwes Symposium on Ci cui s and Sys ems (MWSCAS), Hi oshima, Japan, 2004, pp. 299–301. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/MWSCAS.2004.1354353 [4] P. Beg, I. A. Khan, S. Maheshwa i, M. A. Siddiqi, “Digi ally p og ammable ully di e en ial il e ”, Radioenginee ing, ol. 20, no. 4, pp. 917–925, 2011. [5] R. Beg, S. Maheshwa i, M. A. Siddigi, “Digi ally con olled ully di e en ial ol age- and ansadmi ance-mode biquad a ic il e ”, IET Ci cui s, De ices and Sys ems, ol. 7, no. 4, pp. 193–203, 2013. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1049/ie -cds.2012.0244 [6] M. A. Ib ahim, H. Kun man, “A no el high CMRR high inpu impedance di e en ial ol age-mode KHN-biquad employing DO- DDCCs”, AEU – In e na ional Jou nal o Elec onics and Communica ions, ol. 58, no. 6, pp. 429–433, 2004. [Online]. 34 ELEKTRONIKA IR ELEKTROTECHNIKA,ISSN 1392-1215,VOL.23,NO.2,2017 A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1078/1434-8411-54100266 [7] A. K. Singh, P. Kuma , “A no el ully di e en ial cu en mode uni e sal il e ”, in P oc. 57 h In . Midwes Symposium on Ci cui s and Sys ems (MWSCAS), Texas, USA, 2014, pp. 579–582. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/MWSCAS.2014.6908481 [8] J. Ko on, N. He encsa , O. Sladok, J-W. Ho ng, “Pseudo-di e en ial second-o de band- ejec il e using cu en con eyo s”, AEU - In e na ional Jou nal o Elec onics and Communica ions, ol. 70, no. 6, pp. 814–821, 2016. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/ 10.1016/j.aeue.2016.03.009 [9] J. Ko on, N. He encsa , J. W. Ho ng, “Di e en ial second-o de ol age-mode all-pass il e using cu en con eyo s”, Elek onika i Elek o echnika, ol. 22, no. 5, pp. 52–57, 2016. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.5755/j01.eie.22.5.16344 [10] M. A. Ib ahim, S. Minaei, H. Kun man, “DVCC based di e en ial- mode all-pass and no ch il e s wi h high CMRR”, In . Jou nal o Elec onics, ol. 93, no. 4, pp. 231–240, 2006. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1080/00207210600562181 [11] M. S. Ansa i, G. S. Soni, “Digi ally-p og ammable ully-di e en ial cu en -mode i s -o de LP, HP and AP il e sec ions”, in P oc. In . Con . Signal P opaga ion and Compu e Technology (ICSPCT), Ajme , India, 2014, pp. 524–528. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/ICSPCT.2014.6884963 [12] J. W. Ho ng, C. M. Wu, N. He encsa , “Fully di e en ial i s -o de allpass il e s using a DDCC”, Indian J Eng Ma e Sci, ol. 21, no. 4, pp. 345–350, 2014. [13] I. A. Khan, M. I. Masud, S. A. Moiz, “Recon igu able ully di e en ial i s o de all pass il e using digi ally con olled CMOS DVCC”, in P oc. 8 h IEEE GCC Con . and exhibi ion (GCCCE), Musca , Oman, 2015, pp. 1–5. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/IEEEGCC.2015.7060082 [14] N. He encsa , J. Je abek, J. Ko on, K. V ba, S. Minaei, I. C. Gokna , “Pole equency and pass-band gain unable no el ully-di e en ial cu en -mode all-pass il e ”, in P oc. IEEE In . Symposium on Ci cui s and Sys ems (ISCAS), Lisbon, Po ugal, 2015, pp. 2668– 2671. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1109/ISCAS. 2015.7169235 [15] R. So ne , J. Je abek, N. He encsa , T. Zak, W. Jaikla, K. V ba, “Modi ied cu en di e encing uni and i s applica ion o elec onically econ igu able simple i s -o de ans e unc ion”, Ad ances in Elec ical and Compu e Enginee ing, ol. 15, no. 1, pp. 3–10, 2015. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.4316 /AECE.2015.01001 [16] R. So ne , J. Je abek, L. Langhamme , J. Polak, N. He encsa , R. P okop, J. Pe zela, W. Jaikla, “Compa ison o wo solu ions o quad a u e oscilla o s wi h linea con ol o equency o oscilla ion employing mode n comme cially a ailable de ices”, Ci cui s, Sys ems and Signal P ocessing, ol. 34, no. 11, pp. 3449–3469, 2015. [Online]. A ailable: h p://dx.doi.o g/10.1007/s00034-015- 0015-7 35