scieee AI-readable full text Open interactive document viewer

Regularity results and new perspectives for degenerate Kolmogorov equations

Rebucci, Annalaura

Abstract

In this thesis, we are concerned with the regularity theory of strongly degenerate Kolmogorov equations and we also study a relativistic generalization of such equations. We divide this dissertation into three parts. In the first part, we present some results which lie in the classical regularity theory of Kolmogorov-type operators with regular coefficients. In particular, we here discuss some Schauder estimates for classical solutions to Kolmogorov equations in non-divergence form with Dini-continuous coefficients and right-hand side. Furthermore, we show new pointwise regularity results and a Taylor-type expansion up to second order with estimate of the rest in L^p norm. The second part focuses on the weak regularity theory of degenerate Kolmogorov equations with discontinuous coefficients, which is nowadays the main focus of the research community. More precisely, we present a Harnack inequality and the Hölder continuity for weak solutions to the Kolmogorov equation with measurable coefficients, integrable lower order terms and nonzero source term. We subsequently prove the existence of a fundamental solution associated to the Kolmogorov operator, together with Gaussian lower and upper bounds. Finally, in the last part of this thesis, we address a possible generalization of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation, which is in accordance with the theory of special relativity. In particular, we explain why the operator proposed is the suitable relativistic generalization of the Fokker-Planck operator and we describe it as a Hörmander operator which is invariant with respect to Lorentz transformations.

Full text

UNIVERSIT` A DEGLI STUDI DI PARMA DOTTORATO DI RICERCA IN MATEMATICA CICLO XXXV Regularity results and new perspectives for degenerate Kolmogorov equations Coordinatore: Prof.ssa Alessandra Lunardi Tutore: Prof. Sergio Polidoro Dottoranda: Annalaura Rebucci Anni Accademici 2019/2020 - 2021/2022 Abstract In this work, we are concerned with the regularity theory of strongly degenerate Kolmogorov equations and we also study a relativistic generalization of such equations. The Kolmogorov equation was first introduced by Kolmogorov in 1934 to study the time evolution of the density of a Brownian test particle in the phase space. It is a linear strongly degenerate second order PDE whose diffusion part is governed by the Laplace operator in a subset of the variables (velocity variables) coupled with a transport term that contains the directions of missing ellipticity (position variables). Such a drift term makes the equation non-symmetric, but at the same time it is responsible for the hypoelliptic properties of the operator. The first part of this thesis is devoted to the investigation of Kolmogorov-type operators with regular coefficients. In Chapter 1, we revise some results on the classical regularity theory for Kolmogorov operators with constant or continuous coefficients, with a particular emphasis on their connection to H¨ormander’s theory of hypoellipticity. In Chapters 2and 3, the regularity theory introduced in Chapter 1is developed in two unexplored directions. On one hand, in Chapter 2we extend a fundamental result of the classical regularity theory, namely Schauder estimates. More precisely, we prove that, if the operator satisfies H¨ormander’s hypoellipticity condition, and the right-hand side and the diffusion coefficients are Dini continuous, then the second order derivatives of the solution are Dini continuous as well. Additionally, we establish a new Taylor formula for classical solutions under minimal regularity assumptions. On the other hand, Chapter 3is devoted to the proof of new pointwise regularity results for solutions to degenerate second order partial differential equations with constant coefficients. The second part of this dissertation focuses on the weak regularity theory of degenerate Kolmogorov equations with discontinuous coefficients, which is nowadays the main focus of the research community. As the most recent developments in this framework have been established in the particular case of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation, the aim of Chapter 4is to extend some of these results to the ultraparabolic setting. More precisely, in Chapter 4we prove a Harnack inequality and the H¨older continuity for weak solutions to the Kolmogorov equation with measurable coefficients, integrable lower order terms and nonzero source term. We then introduce a functional space, suitable for the study of weak solutions to Kolmogorov-type equations, that allows us to prove a new (weak) Poincar´e inequality. The Harnack inequality contained in Chapter 4is also crucial in Chapter 5, where we prove the existence of a fundamental solution Γ associated to the Kolmogorov operator, together with Gaussian upper and lower bounds for Γ. Finally, in the last part of this work, we address a possible generalization of the kinetic Kolmogorov- Fokker-Planck equation, which is in accordance with the theory of special relativity. In particular, we explain why the operator proposed is the suitable relativistic generalization of the Fokker-Planck operator and we describe it as a H¨ormander operator which is invariant with respect to Lorentz transformations. We subsequently start its systematic study in its appropriate framework of PDE and H¨ormander’s theory. The main results of this part are a Lorentz-invariant Harnack-type inequality and accurate asymptotic lower bounds for positive solutions to the equation. As a consequence, we finally obtain a lower bound for the density of the stochastic process associated to the relativistic operator. Riassunto In questa tesi ci concentriamo sulla teoria della regolarit`a di equazioni di Kolmogorov degeneri e studiamo una possibile generalizzazione relativistica di tali equazioni. L’equazione di Kolmogorov `e stata introdotta da Kolmogorov nel 1934 per studiare l’evoluzione temporale della densit`a di una particella Browniana nello spazio delle fasi. Si tratta di una equazione differenziale alle derivate parziali lineare e fortemente degenere la cui diffusione `e governata dal Laplaciano in un insieme di variabili (le cosiddette variabili velocit`a) accoppiato con un termine di trasporto che contiene le direzioni non ipoellittiche (le cosiddette variabili posizione). Tale termine di trasporto rende l’equazione non simmetrica ma `e allo stesso tempo responsabile dell’ipoellitticit`a dell’operatore. La prima parte di questo elaborato si concentra sullo studio di equazioni di tipo Kolmogorov con coefficienti regolari. Nel Capitolo 1, richiamiamo alcuni risultati riguardanti la teoria della regolarit`a classica di equazioni di Kolmogorov con coefficienti costanti o continui, con particolare enfasi sulla loro connessione alla teoria dell’ipoellitticit`a di H¨ormander. In questa tesi, sviluppiamo tale teoria della regolarit`a in due direzioni inesplorate. Nel Capitolo 2, estendiamo un risultato fondamentale della teoria della regolarit`a classica, ossia le stime di Schauder. Pi`u precisamente, dimostriamo che, se l’operatore verifica la condizione di ipoellitticit`a di H¨ormander, e il membro di destra e i coefficienti di diffusione sono Dini continui, allora le derivate seconde della soluzione sono anch’esse Dini continue. Stabiliamo inoltre una nuova formula di Taylor per soluzioni classiche nelle ipotesi di regolarit`a minime. Il Capitolo 3`e invece dedicato alla dimostrazione di nuove stime di regolarit`a puntuale per soluzioni di equazioni di Kolmogorov con coefficienti di diffusione costanti. La seconda parte di questa tesi si concentra sulla teoria della regolarit`a debole per equazioni di Kolmogorov con coefficienti discontinui, teoria che `e al centro della ricerca attuale. Poich´e i principali sviluppi in questo ambito riguardano il caso particolare dell’equazione di Fokker-Planck, l’obiettivo del Capitolo 4`e estendere tali risultati al caso dell’equazioni ultraparaboliche. In particolare, nel quarto capitolo, dimostriamo una disuguaglianza di Harnack e l’H¨olderianit`a delle soluzioni deboli dell’equazione di Kolmgorov con coefficienti misurabili, termini del primo ordine integrabili e membro di destra non nullo. Successivamente, introduciamo uno spazio funzionale, appropriato per lo studio di soluzioni deboli di equazioni di tipo Kolmogorov, che ci permette di dimostrare una nuova disuguaglianza di Poincar`e debole. La disuguaglianza di Harnack dimostrata nel Capitolo 4si rivela cruciale anche nel capitolo successivo, dove dimostriamo l’esistenza di una soluzione fondamentale Γ associata all’operatore di Kolmogorov, insieme a stime gaussiane dal basso e dall’alto per Γ. Nell’ultima parte di questo elaborato, studiamo infine una possibile generalizzazione dell’equazione di Fokker-Planck, che `e in accordo con la teoria della relativit`a speciale. In particolare, speghiamo perch´e l’operatore proposto rappresenta l’appropriata controparte relativistica dell’operatore di Fokker-Planck e lo descriviamo come un operatore di H¨ormander che risulta essere invariante rispetto alle trasformazioni di Lorentz. Successivamente cominciamo lo studio sistematico di tale operatore nel contesto appropriato della teoria delle equazioni differenziali alle derivate parziali. I risultati principali di questa ultima parte sono una disuguaglianza di Harnack e un’accurata stima dal basso per soluzioni positive dell’equazione. Come conseguenza, otteniamo una stima dal basso per la densit`a del processo stocastico associato all’operatore relativistico. Acknowledgements First and foremost, I would like to express my gratitude to my supervisor Prof. Dr. Sergio Polidoro for supporting me and believing in me all these years. Moreover, I would like to thank him for suggesting many interesting projects and for guiding me, by sharing some of his ideas and insights with me. I also thank my collaborator Prof. Dr. Bianca Stroffolini for the proposal of interesting problems and for the joint discussions. Moreover, I express my gratitude to Dr. Francesca Anceschi, for the numerous collaborations and for all the beautiful travels we shared. Most importantly, I would like to thank her for all personal and academic advice. My sincere thanks goes also to the professors, scientific staff and students of the Department of Mathematics at the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia. In particular, I would to thank Prof. Dr. Federica Sani for her understanding and constant encouragement in the last months. Thanks should also go to Prof. Dr. Jessica Guerand for inviting me, Francesca Anceschi and Amelie Loher to Montpellier to work on a project together. In addition, I would like to express my deepest appreciation to all the students and scientists I met at conferences, who inspired me through many interesting and fruitful discussions. Finally, I would like to thank Prof. Dr. Cl´ement Mouhot and Dr. Giulio Tralli for agreeing to examine this thesis. Apart from the academic support, I would like to thank the people who helped me on a personal level. First of all, I thank my mother, Morena, my father, Giulio, and my brother, Francesco, who supported me patiently since school. I also thank my friends for their constant understanding and for giving me inspiration. In regard to this thesis, a special thanks goes to Alice, Bea, Chiara and Sofia. A last special thanks goes to the two people who tolerated me and supported me the most in the last three years. First, I thank my partner, Lukas, for always believing in me and for helping me in so many ways. Secondly, my deepest gratitude goes to my friend Erica, with whom I started this journey many years ago and without whom I would not be here today. Contents Introduction 1 I Regular coefficients 9 1 Kolmogorov-type operators: an overview and some classical results 12 1.1 Kolmogorov-type operators with constant coefficients .............. 14 1.1.1 Lie Group Invariance ............................ 15 1.1.2 Principal part operator ........................... 20 1.1.3 Fundamental Solution ........................... 21 1.2 Kolmogorov operators with H¨older continuous coefficients ............ 23 1.3 Applications of Kolmogorov equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 2 Schauder-type estimates 31 2.1 Statement of the problem ............................. 31 2.1.1 Assumptions ................................. 31 2.1.2 Main results ................................. 32 2.1.3 Comparison with existing results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 2.1.4 Idea of the proof .............................. 37 2.1.5 Outline of the chapter ........................... 37 2.2 Preliminary results ................................. 38 2.3 Taylor formula ................................... 49 2.4 Proof of Theorem 2.1.4 .............................. 56 2.5 Dini continuous coefficients ............................ 62 3 Pointwise estimates for Kolmogorov equations 64 3.1 Statement of the problem ............................. 64 3.1.1 Assumptions and mathematical preliminaries ............... 64 3.1.2 Main results ................................. 65 3.1.3 Comparison with existing results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 3.1.4 Outline of the chapter ........................... 69 3.2 Preliminary results ................................. 69 3.3 Pointwise estimates for the Kolmogorov equation ................ 72 iv INTRODUCTION Moreover, the forward Kolmogorov operator Kfof (Xt)t≥0is the adjoint K∗ bof Kb, that is Kfv(x, t) = −∂tv(x, t) + N X i,j=1 aij∂2 xixjv(x, t) + N X i,j=1 bijxi∂xjv(x, t) + tr(B)v(x, t), for sufficiently regular functions v. Note that Kfoperator agrees with Lin (8) up to a multiplication of the solution by exp(ttr(B)). The regularity theory for classical solutions to Kolmogorov equations with regular coefficients like the one in (8) had been widely developed during the years, starting from the work by Lanconelli and Polidoro in [73]. In this thesis, we develop such a regularity theory in two unexplored directions. On one hand, in Chapter 2, we deal for the first time with Dini continuous diffusion coefficients and Dini continuous right-hand side. In this setting, we derive Schauder estimates that extend the classical ones, where intrinsic H¨older continuous functions are considered. Moreover, we establish an instrinsic Taylor formula for solutions to Lu=f, which, besides being a key step in proving our Schauder estimates, is of independent interest, since it is derived under minimal regularity assumptions on u. In particular, we show that, in order to be approximated by its intrinsic Taylor polynomial of degree 2, uneeds to satisfy the following requirements. Space C2 L(Ω).Let Ωbe an open subset of RN+1. We say that a function ubelongs to C2 L(Ω) if u, its derivatives ∂xiu, ∂xixju(i, j = 1, . . . , m) and the Lie derivative Y u defined in (1.1.5)are continuous functions in Ω. We also require, for i= 1, . . . , m, that lim s→0 ∂xiu(exp(sB)x, t −s)−∂xiu(x, t) |s|1/2= 0,(9) uniformly for every (x, t)∈K, where Kis a compact set K⊂Ω. We remark that (9) can be interpreted as a condition on the second order mixed derivative of the form Y1/2∂xiu, since, mirroring the uniformly parabolic case, we regard the time derivative, here generalized by the Lie derivative Y, as a second order operator. It is clear that, if the derivative Y ∂xiuexists, then the fractional derivative Y ∂1/2 xiuis equal to 0. Besides their intrinsic interest, the regularity estimates presented in Chapter 2will also play a crucial role in proving the existence of a weak fundamental solution in the second part of this work. Finally, we remark that the results contained in Chapter 2were presented for the first time by the author, Stroffolini and Polidoro in the paper [105]. On the other hand, in Chapter 3we establish new pointwise regularity results for solutions to equation (8) in the case where the diffusion term is simply the Laplacian in velocity, following the recent paper [62] by the author and Ipocoana. In particular, for the first time in the ultraparabolic literature, we introduce a pointwise modulus of mean oscillation and we show that if the modulus of Lp-mean oscillation of Luat a point z∈RN+1 is Dini, then zis a Lebesgue point of continuity in Lpaverage for the second order derivatives 4 INTRODUCTION ∂2 xixju, i, j = 1, . . . , m, and the Lie derivative Y u. The method we follow in Chapter 3has the advantage of being quite flexible, as shown in [77,86], where it was applied to study new regularity results for obtacle problem for the Laplace equation and the heat equation. The obstacle problem associated to (8) is not only fascinating for theoretical purposes but also for multiple applications. For example, this comes as an interest in mathematical finance to determine the arbitrage free price of options of American-type (see [96]). In recent years, many attempts have been made to study the existence and regularity of solutions to the obstacle problem in the framework of PDE (see [92] and the references therein). However, in the promising aforementioned results, they could only deal with classical solutions and continuous obstacles. For this reason, the results established in Chapter 3aim at constituting a first step towards developing the weak regularity theory for solutions to the obstacle problem associated to Kolmogorov-type equations. Besides its interesting mathematical structure and its connection to H¨ormander’s theory, operator (1) is also important as it serves as a prototype for a family of evolution equations arising in the kinetic theory of gases which take the following general form m X j=1 pj∂yju(p, y, t) + ∂tu(p, y, t) =: Y u(p, y, t) = J(u).(10) In this case, Y u is the so called total derivative with respect to time in the phase space and J(u) is the collision operator, which can be either linear or non-linear. For instance, in the usual Fokker-Planck equation (cf. [37]) we have a linear collision operator of the form J(u) = m X i,j=1 aij(p, y, t)∂2 pi,pju(p, y, t) + m X i=1 bi(p, y, t)∂piu(p, y, t) + c(p, y, t)u(p, y, t).(11) In the second part of my thesis, which consists of Chapters 4-5, we focus on more general Kolmogorov operators which also include the usual Fokker-Planck equation, i.e. the collision operator (11). Specifically, we study Kolmogorov equations of the form Lu(x, t) : = m X i,j=1 ∂xiaij(x, t)∂xju(x, t)+ N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t) + m X i=1 bi(x, t)∂xiu(x, t) + c(x, t)u(x, t) = f(x, t), (12) where z= (x, t) = (x1, . . . , xN, t)∈RN+1 and 1 ≤m≤N. We remark that we recover the Fokker-Planck equation from (12) by choosing N= 2mand B= O O −ImO!. 5 INTRODUCTION Another step, with which we further generalize the setting of the first part of this dissertation, is that we consider weak solutions to equation (12) in the sense of the following definition. Weak solution. We denote by x(0) the hypoelliptic variables and we let Ω = Ωm× ΩN−m+1 ⊂RN+1, where Ωmis a bounded Lipschitz domain of Rmand ΩN−m+1 is a bounded Lipschitz domain of RN−m+1. We define H1 x(0) as the Sobolev space of functions u∈L2(Ωm) with distribution gradient Dmulying in (L2(Ωm))m, i.e. H1 x(0) := u∈L2(Ωm) : Dmu∈(L2(Ωm))m, and we let Wdenote the closure of C∞(Ω) in the norm kuk2 W=kuk2 L2ΩN−m0+1;H1 x(0) +kY uk2 L2ΩN−m0+1;H−1 x(0) .(13) A function u∈ W is a weak solution to (12)with source term f∈L2(Ω) if for every nonnegative test function ϕ∈C∞ c(Ω), we have ZΩ−hADu, Dϕi−uY ϕ +hb, Duiϕ+cuϕ =ZΩ fϕ, where the operator Lis written in its compact form, given that •the matrix A(x, t) = (aij(x, t))1≤i,j≤Nhas real measurable entries, where aij, for every i, j = 1, . . . , m, are the coefficients appearing in (12), while aij ≡0whenever i > m or j > m; •the vector b(x, t) := (b1(x, t), . . . , bm(x, t),0,...,0) contains the coefficients appearing in front of one of the lower order terms and the drift is defined as above, namely Y= PN i,j=1 bijxj∂xi−∂t. The analysis of the regularity theory of degenerate Kolmogorov equations in divergence form with discontinuous coefficients has been an open problem for decades and is nowadays the main focus of the research community. The most recent developments in this framework have been established in the particular case of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation. The aim of Chapter 4is to extend some of these results to the ultraparabolic setting. In particular, following the results presented by the author and Anceschi in [11], we prove a Harnack inequality and the H¨older continuity for weak solutions to the Kolmogorov equation (12) with measurable coefficients, integrable lower order terms and nonzero source term. To the best of our knowledge, the Harnack inequality contained in Chapter 4is the first result of this kind available for weak solutions to (12). We then introduce a suitable functional space W (see (13)), which mirrors the classical H1space for uniformly elliptic equations and therefore seems to be the most natural framework for studying the weak regularity theory for operator L. In particular, we extend the functional setting first formally proposed by Armstrong and Mourrat in [3] for the study of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation. To be 6 INTRODUCTION more precise, we show that it is sufficient to require that the drift term Y u belongs to the space L2 y,tH−1 x(0) to derive a new (weak) Poincar´e inequality. Here x(0) denotes, as above, the hypoelliptic variables, while ydescribes the directions of missing hypoellipticity. In this sense, we extend the classical ultraparabolic literature, where the drift Y u was always assumed to be in L2. Another motivation behind our studies is the need to determine which are the lowest possible integrability assumptions for c, b and fthat allow us to prove L2−L∞estimates and a Harnack inequality for weak solutions. Indeed, it is still an open problem in the ultraparabolic literature whether the optimal regularity for c, b and fis the hypoelliptic counterpart of the parabolic homogeneous dimension N 2, namely Q+2 2where Qis defined in (1.1.17). In particular, our attention is focused on the behavior of the term b, which plays an important role in some applications, such as the Mean Field Games theory. Indeed, a Harnack inequality for weak solutions is the fundamental ingredient in the analysis of the maximal Lp regularity and well-posedness theory for Mean Field systems with degenerate diffusion, which were studied in the parabolic setting [34] and only very recently there has been a first attempt to consider the ultraparabolic setting [44]. Harnack inequalities are also important due to their connection to Gaussian lower bounds for the fundamental solution. Indeed, since the work of Moser [87], it became clear that the proof of the lower bound relies on the repeated application of the Harnack inequality. In Chapter 5, we therefore take advantage of the Harnack inequality established in Chapter 4 to prove Gaussian lower bounds for a fundamental solution Γ associated to operator L. Following then Aronson’s method [14], we establish the corresponding Gaussian upper bound. Finally, we conclude Chapter 5by proving the existence of a weak fundamental solution relevant to operator (12). Our approach is based on a limiting procedure whose convergence is ensured by the Schauder types estimates obtained in Chapter 2. The results are obtained by the author in collaboration with Anceschi and are contained in the recent paper [12]. Finally, in the last part of this work, namely Chapter 6, we address a possible relativistic generalization of equation (1), namely Lu(p, y, t) = p|p|2+ 1 divp(DDpu)−hp, Dyui−p|p|2+ 1 ∂tu= 0,(14) where (p, y, t)∈R2m+1 and Dis the relativistic diffusion matrix given by D=1 p|p|2+ 1 (Im+p⊗p). Here and in the following, Imdenotes the m×midentity matrix and p⊗p= (pipj)i,j=1,...,m. Indeed, a questionable feature of (1) is that its diffusion term ∆puoperates with infinite velocity, as in classical mechanics the velocity is proportional to the momentum. In this case, if the initial distribution u(p, y, 0) is compactly supported in y, there would be instantaneously a 7 INTRODUCTION non-zero probability to find particles everywhere in space. This feature is clearly incompatible with the law that prevents particles from moving faster than light. We believe that the operator introduced in (14) is the suitable generalization of (1) in view of its invariance properties. Indeed, mirroring the invariance of the non-relativistic operator with respect to Galilean transformations (5), operator Lin (14) is invariant with respect to the equivalent relativistic transformations, namely the Lorentz transformations. As a complete mathematical characterization of the operator in (14) is not yet available, Chapter 6is dedicated to its systematic study in the appropriate framework of PDE theory. In particular, we place for the first time operator (14) in H¨ormander’s theory and construct its invariance group. Relying on classical results for operator (1), we are then able to derive asymptotic bounds for the fundamental solution associated to (14). Those results are presented by the author, Anceschi and Polidoro in the recent preprint [10]. 8 Part I Regular coefficients 9 The first part of this thesis addresses the study of Kolmogorov operators of the form Lu:= m X i,j=1 aij(x, t)∂2 xixju(x, t) + N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t),(I.1) where z= (x, t) = (x1, . . . , xN, t)∈RN+1 and 1 ≤m≤N,B:= (bij)i,j=1,...,N has real constant entries and the coefficients aij’s are regular, meaning that they are at least Dini continuous. Moreover, we always assume that Btakes a suitable block form (see equation (1.1.2)) that ensures that the first order part of Linduces a strong regularizing property, namely that Lis hypoelliptic. When the right-hand side of (I.1) is continuous, the solutions to Lu=fare called classical because their degree of regularity corresponds to the one imposed by the equation. The study of the classical regularity theory of the class of operators (I.1) was investigated in depth over the years. In Chapter 1, we revise some known results about operators of the form (I.1) that will be useful in the forthcoming chapters. In particular, we explain how to write the operators in (I.1) with constant coefficients as H¨ormander’s operators (3) and we construct their invariance group. Finally, Section 1.2 of Chapter 1collects some classical results about Kolmogorov-type operators in the more general case where the coefficients aij(x, t) are assumed to be H¨older continuous. As in the parabolic setting, the classical regularity theory was developed for coefficients belonging to suitable H¨older spaces (see Definition 1.2.1 below). In Chapter 2, we relax the regularity assumptions on the second order coefficients, by introducing a new definition of Dini continuity naturally associated to the Lie Group structure that leaves operator (I.1) invariant. Under these assumptions, we extend a fundamental result of the classical regularity theory, namely Schauder estimates. To be more precise, we prove that, if operator Lsatisfies H¨ormander’s hypoellipticity condition, and fand aij’s are Dini continuous functions, then the second order derivatives of the solution uto the equation Lu=fare Dini continuous functions as well. Additionally, we establish a new Taylor formula for classical solutions to Lu=funder minimal regularity assumptions on u. These results are the outcome of a scientific collaboration that started in 2020 between the author, Polidoro and Stroffolini and are published in [105]. In Chapter 3, we present some regularity results obtained in collaboration with Ipocoana. In contrast to Chapter 2, we assume the coefficients to be constant but we relax the regularity of the right-hand side, allowing it to be in Lp. More precisely, we establish new pointwise regularity results for solutions to degenerate second order partial differential equations of the form (I.1), when Ais the identity matrix. In particular, we show that if the modulus of Lpmean oscillation of Luat the origin is Dini, then the origin is a Lebesgue point of continuity in Lpaverage for the second order derivatives ∂2 xixju,i, j = 1, . . . , m, and the Lie derivative PN i,j=1 bijxj∂xi−∂tu. Moreover, we provide a Taylor-type expansion up to second order 10 with an estimate of the rest in Lpnorm. We observe that, although we consider the regularity problem for weak solutions to Kolmogorov operators in the framework of the Sobolev spaces, our procedure is basically pointwise and our approach follows the lines of regularity theory for classical solutions rather than the ones for weak solutions. We finally remark that the results of Chapter 3are presented in the paper [62]. 11 Chapter 1 Kolmogorov-type operators: an overview and some classical results This introductory chapter collects some known results about degenerate Kolmogorov-type equations and provides an insight into their applications. Moreover, we explain the importance of Kolmogorov-type operators in connection to H¨ormander’s theory of hypoellipticity. Throughout this chapter, we mainly focus on Kolmogorov operators with constant diffusion coefficients. Indeed, such operators, together with their invariant Lie group structure, are the starting point to study operators with variables coefficients, which will be the content of the forthcoming chapters. Finally, we recall some known results about Kolmogorov-type operators with H¨older continuous coefficients. The simplest Kolmogorov equation was introduced by Kolmogorov [67] in 1934 as follows 1 2σ2∂2u ∂p2(p, y, t) = p∂u ∂y (p, y, t) + ∂u ∂t (p, y, t),(p, y, t)∈R3,(1.0.1) and it is strongly degenerate as the second order derivative is only taken with respect to the momentum variable. In the Introduction of this work, we have already introduced equation (1.0.1) for σ=√2 and discussed its link to kinetic theory of gases. We here explain in more detail its physical meaning and its connection to Langevin processes. From the physical point of view, Fokker-Planck equations like the one in (1.0.1) provide a continuous description of the dynamics of the distribution of Brownian test particles immersed in a fluid in thermodynamical equilibrium. More precisely, the distribution function uof a test particle evolves according to the linear Fokker-Planck equation defined in (1.0.1), provided that the test particle is much heavier than the molecules of the fluid and that there is no friction. In particular, equation (1.0.1) is the backward Kolmogorov equation of the Langevin process, i.e. the particle whose 12 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS location in the phase space is (Pt, Yt) evolves as      Pt=p0+σWt, Yt=y0+ t R0 P(s)ds, (1.0.2) where (Wt)t≥0denotes a 1−dimensional Wiener process. We recall that (1.0.2) is usually referred to as time-integrated Brownian motion. In his seminal paper [67], Kolmogorov provided us with the explicit expression of the density Π = Π(t, p, y, p0, y0) of (1.0.1) Π(t, p, y, p0, y0) = √3 2πt2exp −(p−p0)2 t−3(p−p0)(y−y0−tp0) t2−3(y−y0−ty0)2 t3t > 0,(1.0.3) and pointed out that it is a smooth function despite the strong degeneracy of equation (1.0.1). As suggested by the smoothness of the density Π, operator Lassociated to equation (1.0.1) L:= 1 2σ2∂vv −v∂y−∂t,(1.0.4) is hypoelliptic, in the sense of the following definition, that we state for a general second order differential operator Lacting on an open subset Ω of RN. Definition 1.0.1 (Hypoellipticity).An operator Lis hypoelliptic if, for every distributional solution u∈L1 loc(Ω) to equation Lu=f, we have that f∈C∞(Ω) ⇒u∈C∞(Ω).(1.0.5) H¨ormander considered the operator Ldefined in (1.0.4) as a prototype for the family of hypoelliptic operators studied in his seminal work [54]. Specifically, the operators considered by H¨ormander are the ones that can be written in form (3), i.e. as a sum of squares of smooth vector fields plus a drift term. As already mentioned in the Introduction of this work, in [54] H¨ormander studied a sufficient condition for the hypoellipticity of L. We here recall its precise statement, which requires some notation. Given two vector fields Z1, Z2, the commutator of Z1and Z2is the vector field: [Z1, Z2] = Z1Z2−Z2Z1. Moreover, we recall that Lie(X1, . . . , Xm, Y ) is the Lie algebra generated by the vector fields X1, . . . , Xm, Y and their commutators. H¨ ormander’s Rank Condition. Suppose that rank Lie(X1, . . . , Xm, Y )(z) = N+ 1 for every z∈Ω.(1.0.6) 13 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS In this setting, the Lie group introduced in (1.1.6) has a quite natural intepretation, as the composition law (1.1.6) agrees with the Galilean change of variables (5). Moreover, the matrix Bin (1.1.25) is in the form (1.1.12) and therefore Kis invariant with respect to the dilation δr(v, y, t) := (rp, r3y, r2t) in (7). We remark that the dilation acts as the usual parabolic scaling with respect to the variable pand t. 1.1.2 Principal part operator In this subsection, we show that dilation-invariant operators are the blow-up limit of operators satisfying assumption [H.1]. This technique will be fundamental in the forthcoming Chapter 2, where we consider a general operator Lsatisfying [H.1]. Here and in the sequel, we denote by L0the principal part operator of L, obtained from Lby replacing its matrix Bwith B0in (1.1.12). As stated in Subsection 1.1.1 above, L0 satisfies (1.1.11). As in the proof of the main result of Chapter 2we rely on a blow-up argument, we will also apply dilation (1.1.13) to the general operator Lsatisfying [H.1]. Specifically, we define Lras the scaled operator of Lin terms of (δr)r>0as follows Lr:= r2(δr◦L◦δ1 r),(1.1.26) and we write its explicit expression in terms of the matrix Band (δr) as Lr= m X i,j=1 aij∂2 xixj+Yr, r ∈(0,1] (1.1.27) where Yr:= hBrx, Di−∂t(1.1.28) and Br:= r2δrBδ1 r, i.e., Br=         r2B0,0r4B0,1. . . r2κB0,κ−1r2κ+2B0,κ B1r2B1,1. . . r2κ−2B1,κ−1r2κB1,κ OB2. . . r2κ−4B2,κ−1r2κ−2B2,κ . . .. . ..... . .. . . O O . . . Bκr2Bκ,κ         .(1.1.29) Clearly, Lr=Lfor every r > 0 if and only if B=B0, and the principal part operator L0 is obtained as the limit of (1.1.26) as r→0. Setting Er(t) = exp(−tBr), we define the translation group related to Lras (x, t)◦r(ξ, τ) = (ξ+Er(τ)x, t +τ),(x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN+1.(1.1.30) 20 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS Remark 1.1.8. As it will be useful in the blow-up limit procedure in Chapter 2, we point out that the composition law defined in (1.1.30) depends continuously on r∈(0,1]. Moreover, taking r= 0 in (1.1.29) we find the matrix B0and “ ◦r ” in (1.1.30) simply becomes the composition law related to the dilation-invariant operator L0. Thus, “ ◦r ” is a continuous function on the compact set [0,1]. 1.1.3 Fundamental Solution In this subsection, we collect some known results concerning the fundamental solution Γ of L. First, we recall that, under the hypothesis of hypoellipticity, H¨ormander in [54] constructed the fundamental solution of Las Γ(z, ζ) = Γ(ζ−1◦z, 0),∀z, ζ ∈RN+1, z 6=ζ, where Γ((x, t),(0,0)) =    (4π)−N 2 √detC(t)exp −1 4hC−1(t)x, xi−t tr(B),if t > 0, 0,if t < 0, (1.1.31) and C(t) = Zt 0 E(s) AO O O!ET(s)ds. (1.1.32) We recall that assumption [H.1] implies that C(t) is strictly positive for every t > 0 (see [73, Proposition A.1]) and therefore Γ in (1.1.31) is well-defined. As a fundamental solution to L, the following representation formula holds true: for every u∈C∞ 0(RN+1) we have u(z) = −ZRN+1 [Γ(z, ·)L(u)](ζ)dζ. (1.1.33) In order to state another crucial property of the fundamental solution, we recall the following definition. Definition 1.1.9 (Homogeneous function).We say that a function udefined on RN+1 is homogeneous of degree α∈Rif u(δr(z)) = rαu(z) for every z∈RN+1. A differential operator Xwill be called homogeneous of degree β∈Rwith respect to (δr)r≥0 if Xu(δr(z)) = rβ(Xu) (δr(z)) for every z∈RN+1, and for every sufficiently smooth function u. Note that, if uis homogeneous of degree αand 21 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS Xis homogeneous of degree β, then Xu is homogeneous of degree α−β. As far as we are concerned with the vector fields of the Kolmogorov operator L0under the invariance assumption (1.1.11), we have that X1, . . . , Xmare homogeneous of degree 1 and Yis homogeneous of degree 2 with respect to (δr)r≥0. In particular, L0=Pm j=1 X2 j+Y is homogeneous of degree 2, and its fundamental solution Γ0is a homogeneous function of degree −Q, that is Γ0(δr(z)) = r−QΓ0(z),for every z∈RN+1 \{0},r > 0.(1.1.34) As a direct consequence, the estimate Γ0(z, ζ)≤c kζ−1◦zkQ K holds for every z, ζ ∈RN+1, with z6=ζ. Analogous bounds hold for the first order and second order derivatives of Γ0, as they are homogeneous of degree −Q−1 and −Q−2, respectively. Concerning the fundamental solution Γ of the non-dilation-invariant operator L, we recall the following estimates (see [41, Proposition 2.7]). We assume that all the eigenvalues of the matrix Abelong to some interval [λ, Λ] ⊂R+. Then for every T > 0, there exists a positive constant c, only depending on T, λ, Λ and on the matrix B, such that the following bounds hold Γ(z, ζ)≤c kζ−1◦zkQ K ,(1.1.35) |∂xjΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+1 K ,|∂ξjΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+1 K , |∂xixjΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+2 K ,|∂ξiξjΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+2 K ,(1.1.36) |YΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+2 K ,|Y∗Γ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+2 K , for every i, j = 1, . . . , m,z, ζ ∈RN×[−T, T] with z6=ζ. Here Y∗denotes the transposed operator of Y, defined as follows ZRN+1 ϕ(x, t)Y∗ψ(x, t)dxdt =ZRN+1 ψ(x, t)Y ϕ(x, t)dxdt, for every ψ,ϕ∈C∞ 0(RN+1). A similar result holds for the derivatives ∂xjΓ(z, ζ) and ∂ξjΓ(z, ζ) for j=m+ 1, . . . , N. These functions need to be considered as derivatives of order αj, where the integer αjhas been introduced in (1.1.18). We have |∂xjΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+αj K ,|∂ξkΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+αk K , |∂xj∂ξkΓ(z, ζ)| ≤ c kζ−1◦zkQ+αj+αk K , (1.1.37) 22 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS for every j, k = 1, . . . , N,z, ζ ∈RN×[−T, T] with z6=ζ. Note that, as α1=··· =αm= 1, the bounds in the first line of (1.1.37) agree with the first line of (1.1.36). The proof of (1.1.37) directly follows from the bound (2.59) and (2.60) in [41]. 1.2 Kolmogorov operators with H¨older continuous coefficients In this section, we show how to take advantage of the Lie Group structure introduced in Subsection 1.1.1 to study more general Kolmogorov-type operators. In particular, we consider Kolmogorov operators in trace form in RN+1 L= m X i,j=1 aij(x, t)∂2 xixj+ m X j=1 bj(x, t)∂xj+hBx, Di− ∂t,for (x, t)∈RN+1 (1.2.1) with variable coefficients aij’s and bj’s. As in the parabolic case, the classical theory for degenerate Kolmogorov operators is developed for spaces of H¨older continuous functions. As we rely on the non-Euclidean structure defined in Subsection 1.1.1, we need to consider functions which are H¨older continuous with respect to the quasi-distance in (1.1.21), i.e. functions which are H¨older continuous intrinsically. More precisely, here and in the sequel we rely on the following definition. Definition 1.2.1 (Intrinsic H¨older continuous functions).Let αbe a positive constant, α≤1, and let Ω be an open subset of RN+1. We say that a function f: Ω −→ Ris H¨older continuous with exponent αin Ω with respect to the group K= (RN+1,◦), defined in (1.1.6), (in short: H¨older continuous with exponent α) if there exists a positive constant M > 0 such that |f(z)−f(ζ)| ≤ M dK(z, ζ)αfor every z, ζ ∈Ω,(1.2.2) where dKis the distance defined in (1.1.21). If a function fsatisfies (1.2.2) we write f∈ Cα L(Ω), where the subscript Lrefers to the fact that we deal with functions which are H¨older continuous with respect to the group law that leaves operator Linvariant. To every bounded function f∈Cα L(Ω) we associate the semi-norm [f]Cα(Ω) = sup z,ζ∈Ω z6=ζ |f(z)−f(ζ)| dK(z, ζ)α. Moreover, we say a function fis locally H¨older continuous, and we write f∈Cα L,loc(Ω), if f∈Cα L(Ω0) for every compact subset Ω0of Ω. We remark that Definition 1.2.1 relies on the Lie group Kin (1.1.6), that is an invariant structure for the constant-coefficients operators. Even though the non-constant-coefficients operator in (1.2.1) is not invariant with respect to K, we rely on the Lie group invariance of 23 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS the model operator ∆m+Y= m X j=1 ∂2 xj+hBx, Di− ∂t,(1.2.3) associated to L. Indeed, this is a standard procedure in the study of uniformly parabolic operators. We observe that, in the uniformly parabolic setting, the model operator (1.2.3) is replaced by the heat operator and we have that dK(ξ, τ),(x, t)=|ξ−x|+|τ−t|1/2, so that we are considering the parabolic modulus of continuity. In this section, we always rely on the following assumption. (C) We always assume that hypothesis [H.1] holds. In addition, we assume that the matrix Asatisfies the following uniform ellipticity condition: there exist two positive constants λand Λ such that λ m X i=1 |ξi|2≤ m X i,j=1 aij(z)ξiξj≤Λ m X i=1 |ξi|2 for every (ξ1, . . . , ξm)∈Rmand z∈RN+1. Finally, we require that the coefficients aij’s and bj’s belong to the space Cα Lintroduced in Definition 1.2.1, for every i, j = 1, . . . , m. We now introduce the definition of classical solutions to equation Lu= 0. Definition 1.2.2. A function uis a classical solution to equation Lu= 0 in a domain Ω of RN+1 under assumption (C) if the derivatives ∂xiu, ∂2 xixju, for i, j = 1, . . . , m, and the Lie derivative Y u exist as continuous functions in Ω, and the equation Lu(x, t) = 0 is satisfied at any point (x, t)∈Ω. Finally, we say that uis a classical super-solution to Lu= 0 if Lu≤0. We say that uis a classical sub-solution if −uis a classical supersolution. The natural functional setting to study classical solutions to equation Lu= 0, with L as in (1.2.1), is the space C2,α L(Ω) = nu∈Cα L(Ω) |∂xiu, ∂2 xixju, Y u ∈Cα L(Ω),for i, j = 1, . . . , mo,(1.2.4) where Cα L(Ω) is given in Definition 1.2.1. Moreover, if u∈C2,α L(Ω), we define the norm |u|2+α,Ω:= |u|α,Ω+ m X i=1 |∂xiu|α,Ω+ m X i,j=1 |∂2 xixju|α,Ω+|Y u|α,Ω.(1.2.5) Clearly, the definition of C2,α L,loc(Ω) follows straightforwardly from the definition of Cα L,loc(Ω). A definition of the space Ck,α L(Ω) for every positive integer kis given and discussed in the work [93] by Pagliarani, Pascucci and Pignotti, where a proof of the Taylor expansion for Ck,α L(Ω) functions is given. It is worth noting that the authors of [93] require weaker regularity assumptions for the definition of the space C2,α Lthan the ones considered here in (1.2.4). Finally, we recall that a complete characterization of the intrinsic H¨older spaces is provided 24 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS by Pagliarani, Pascucci and Pignotti in [93]. As in the uniformly elliptic and parabolic case, Schauder estimates constitute a fundamental result in the classical regularity theory. As Schauder-type estimates will be one of the main results of Chapter 2, we here revise the current literature on this subject. In particular, we recall that Schauder estimates for the dilation-invariant Kolmogorov operator (i.e. where the matrix B=B0) with H¨older continuous coefficients were proved by Manfredini in [82, Theorem 1.4]. Manfredini’s result was then extended by Di Francesco and Polidoro in [41, Theorem 1.3] to the non-dilation invariant case as follows. Theorem 1.2.3. Let us consider an operator Lof the type (1.2.1)satisfying assumption (C) with α < 1. Let Ωbe an open subset of RN+1,f∈Cα L,loc(Ω) and let ube a classical solution to Lu=fin Ω. Then for every Ω0⊂⊂ Ω00 ⊂⊂ Ωthere exists a positive constant C, depending only on the constants λ, Λ, on the H¨older-norm of the coefficients of Land on the diameter of Ω, such that |u|2+α,Ω0≤CsupΩ00 |u|+|f|α,Ω00 . A more precise estimate taking into account the distance between the point and the boundary of the set Ω can be found in [82, Theorem 1.4] for the dilation invariant case. We omit here this statement because it requires the introduction of further notation. We also recall that Schauder estimates in the framework of semigroup theory have been proved by Lunardi [81], Lorenzi [79], Priola [106]. We also quote analogous results obtained in the framework of stochastic theory (see Menozzi [84] and its bibliography). Schauder estimates for linear kinetic Fokker–Planck equations were obtained by Imbert and Mouhot in [56] and by Henderson and Snelson in [53], while the Boltzmann fractional framework was recently studied by Imbert and Silvestre in [60]. For a comparison between the different types of H¨older spaces considered in literature we refer the reader to [60,93]. We now present some known results concerning the fundamental solution of operator L in (1.2.1) with the additional term c, namely L= m X i,j=1 aij(x, t)∂2 xixj+ m X j=1 bj(x, t)∂xj+c(x, t) + hBx, Di− ∂t,for (x, t)∈RN+1. (1.2.6) These results will be useful in Chapter 5, when dealing with the weak fundamental solution associated to operators of the form (1.2.6) with measurable coefficients. We recall that, in some particular cases, variable-coefficients Kolmogorov operators were first studied by Weber [120], Il’In [55] and Sonin [111], who used the parametrix method to construct a fundamental solution. However, the authors of the aforementioned papers worked under unnecessary restrictive conditions, i.e. they required an Euclidean regularity on the 25 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS coefficients aij’s, bj’s and c. Later on, Polidoro applied in [102] the Levi parametrix method for the dilation-invariant operator L(i.e. under the additional assumption that Bhas the form (1.1.12)), then Di Francesco and Pascucci and Di Francesco and Polidoro removed this last assumption in [40,41]. The Levi’s parametrix method is a constructive argument to prove existence and bounds for the fundamental solution (see [75]). For every ζ∈RN+1, the parametrix Z(·, ζ) is the fundamental solution, with pole at ζ, of the following operator Lζ= m X i,j=1 aij(ζ)∂2 xixj+hBx, Di − ∂t. The method is based on the following property: if the coefficients aij’s are continuous and the coefficiens bj’s are bounded, then Zis a good approximation of the fundamental solution of Lat least as zis close to the pole ζ, since LZ(z, ζ) = m X i,j=1 (aij(z)−aij(ζ)) ∂2 xixjZ(z, ζ) + m X j=1 bj(z)∂xjZ(z, ζ). We look for the fundamental solution Γ as a solution of the following Volterra equation Γ(x, t, ξ, τ) = Z(x, t, ξ, τ) + Zt τZRN Z(x, t, y, s)G(y, s, ξ, τ)dy ds, where the unknown function Gis obtained by a fixed point argument. It turns out that G(z, ζ) = +∞ X k=1 (LZ)k(z, ζ), where (LZ)1(z, ζ) = LZ(z, ζ) and, for every k∈N, (LZ)k+1(x, t, ξ, τ) = Zt τZRN LZ(x, t, y, s)(LZ)k(y, s, ξ, τ)dy ds. We conclude this section stating the existence result for a classical fundamental solution for an operator Lof the form (1.2.6) proved in [40, Theorem 1.4-1.5]. The upcoming Theorem also provides us with an equivalent result for the fundamental solution Γ∗associated to the adjoint operator of (1.2.6). To this end, we recall that the formal adjoint of operator Lin (1.2.6) is defined as L∗v(ξ, τ) = m X i,j=1 ∂ξiaij(ξ, τ)∂ξjv(ξ, τ)− m X i=1 ∂ξi(bi(ξ, τ)v(ξ, τ)) (1.2.7) + (c−Tr(B))v(ξ, τ) + Y∗v(ξ, τ) 26 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS where Y∗v(ξ, τ) := − N X i,j=1 bijξj∂ξiv(ξ, τ) + ∂τv(ξ, τ). We are now in a position to recall the following fundamental result. Theorem 1.2.4. Let us consider an operator Lof the form (1.2.6)under assumption (C). Then there exists a fundamental solution Γ : RN+1 ×RN+1 →Rfor Lwith the following properties: 1. Γ(·,·;ξ, τ)∈L1 loc(RN+1)∩C(RN+1 \{(ξ, τ)}for every (ξ, τ)∈RN+1; 2. Γ(·,·;ξ, τ)is a classical solution of Lu= 0 in RN+1 \{(ξ, τ)}for every (ξ, τ)∈RN+1 in the sense of Definition 1.2.2; 3. let ϕ∈C(RN)such that for some positive constant c0we have |ϕ(x)| ≤ c0ec0|x|2for every x∈RN,(1.2.8) then there exists lim (x,t)→(x0,τ) t>τ Z RN Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)ϕ(ξ)dξ =ϕ(x0)for every x0∈RN; 4. let ϕ∈C(RN)satisfying (1.2.8). Then, for every positive 0< T0< T1, there exists T∈(T0, T1]such that the function u(x, t) = ZRN Γ(x, t;ξ, T0)ϕ(ξ)dξ dτ (1.2.9) is a classical solution to the Cauchy problem    Lu= 0 in ST0,T , u(·, T0) = ϕin RN;(1.2.10) 5. the reproduction property holds. Indeed, for every x, ξ ∈RNand t, τ ∈Rwith τ < s < t: Γ(x, t;ξ, τ) = Z RN Γ(x, t;y, s) Γ(y, s;ξ, τ)dy; 6. for every (x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN+1 with t≤τwe have that Γ(x, t;ξ, τ) = 0; 7. if c(x, t) = cis constant, then Z RN Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)dξ =e−c(t−τ),∀x∈RN, τ < t; 27 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS 8. for every λ+> λ and for every positive 0< T0< T1, there exists a constant C+, only dependent on λ,Band Tsuch that Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)≤C+Γ+(x, t;ξ, τ) (1.2.11) |∂xiΓ(x, t;ξ, τ)| ≤ C+ √t−τΓ+(x, t;ξ, τ) |∂2 xixjΓ(x, t;ξ, τ)| ≤ C+ t−τΓ+(x, t;ξ, τ) |YΓ(x, t;ξ, τ)| ≤ C+ t−τΓ+(x, t;ξ, τ) for any i, j = 1, . . . , m and (x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN×(T0, T1), and where Γ+denotes the fundamental solution of Lλ+, defined as follows Lλ+u(x, t) := λ+ 2 m0 X i=1 ∂2 xiu(x, t) + N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t). Owing to (1.1.31), it is clear that the explicit expression of Γ+is given by Γ+((x, t); (ξ, τ)) = Γ+((ξ, τ)−1◦(x, t); 0,0), for every (x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN+1, with (x, t)6= (ξ, τ)and Γ+(x, t; 0,0) =    (2πλ+)−N 2 √detC(t)exp −1 2λhC−1(t)x, xi−ttr(B),if t > 0, 0,if t≤0. (1.2.12) Moreover, there exists a fundamental solution Γ∗to L∗(1.2.7)satisfying the dual properties of this statement and such that Γ∗(x, t;ξ, τ) = Γ(ξ, τ;x, t)for every (x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN+1, (x, t)6= (ξ, τ). 1.3 Applications of Kolmogorov equations We conclude this chapter discussing some applications of Kolmogorov-type equations. First of all, as mentioned in the Introduction, the process (1.0.2) is the solution to the Langevin equation    dVt=dWt dYt=Vtdt, and therefore Kolmogorov equations are connected to every stochastic process satisfying Langevin equation. In particular, several mathematical models involving linear and non linear Kolmogorov-type equations have also appeared in finance [5], [15] and [38]. Indeed, equations of the form (1.0.1) appear in various models for pricing of path-dependent financial 28 CHAPTER 1. KOLMOGOROV-TYPE OPERATORS: AN OVERVIEW AND SOME CLASSICAL RESULTS instruments (cf., for instance, [16]). For example the equation ∂tP+1 2σ2S2∂2 SP+ (log S)∂AP+r(S∂SP−P) = 0, S > 0, A, t ∈R(1.3.1) arises in the Black and Scholes option pricing problem    dSt=µStdt +σStdWt dAt=Stdt, where σis the volatility of the stock price S,ris the interest rate of a riskless bond and P=P(S, A, t) is the price of the Asian option depending on the price of the stock S, the geometric average Aof the past price and the time to maturity t. For the applications of operators in the form Lto finance and to the stochastic theory we refer to the monograph [97] by Pascucci. Moreover, as already mentioned in the introduction of this work, the Kolmogorov equation is the prototype for a family of evolution equations arising in kinetic theory of gases of the form ∂tu+hp, Dyui=J(u).(1.3.2) Beside the collision operator (11) already considered in the introduction, J(u) can also occur in divergence form J(u) = n X i,j=1 ∂pi(aij ∂pju+biu) + n X i=1 ai∂piu+au. In particular, we mention the following nonlinear kinetic Fokker-Planck equation ∂tu+hp, Dyui=ρ[u]divp(Dpu+p u),(1.3.3) with periodic condition with respect to the space variable and where ρ[u] := RRmu(p, y, t)dp. We refer the reader to [49,56] for a recent treatment of the nonlinear operator in (1.3.3), in particular in connection to the linear Fokker-Planck operator. Equation (1.3.3) plays an important role in kinetic theory as it shares some similarities with the equation introduced by Landau [74] in 1936 to describe plasmas made up of ions and electrons which interact by Coulombian forces. In the case of the Landau equation, the collision operator J(u) in (1.3.2) takes the following form J(u) = divp(A[u]Dpu+B[u]u), 29 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES Schauder estimates As we rely on less regular coefficients, we now compare our regularity results with the current literature on this subject, which was revised in Chapter 1, Section 1.2. In particular, as a direct consequence of Theorem 2.1.5 we have the following corollary. Corollary 2.1.6. Let u∈C2 L(Q1(0,0)) be a classical solution to f Lu=f. Suppose that f and the coefficients aij,i, j = 1, . . . , m, belong to C0,α L(Q1(0,0)). Then for any points (x, t) and (ξ, τ)∈ Q1 2(0,0) the following holds: |∂2u(x, t)−∂2u(ξ, τ)| ≤c dαsup Q1(0,0) |u|+kfkCα L(Q1(0,0)) α(1 −α) + m X i,j=1 sup Q1(0,0) |∂2 xixju|kakCα L(Q1(0,0)) α(1 −α),if α < 1, |∂2u(x, t)−∂2u(ξ, τ)| ≤c dsup Q1(0,0) |u|+kfkC0,1 L(Q1(0,0))|log d| +m X i,j=1 sup Q1(0,0) |∂2 xixju|kakC0,1 L(Q1(0,0))|log d|,if α= 1. We observe that, for α < 1, Corollary 2.1.6 recovers the Schauder estimates contained in Theorem 1.2.3. Note that, in this case, an interpolation inequality allows us to state a bound for the Cα Lnorm of the derivatives ∂2uin terms of kakCα L(Q1(0,0)),kfkCα L(Q1(0,0)), and supQ1(0,0) |u|only. Theorems 2.1.4 and 2.1.5 improve Theorem 1.2.3 and the results presented in Section 1.2 in two directions. First of all, we weaken the regularity assumption on fand on the coefficients aij’s. Second, we are able to establish Schauder estimates for α= 1, extending the results of the aforementioned articles, where α < 1. Moreover, in the case of one commutator and H¨older continuous coefficients and righthand side, Imbert and Mouhot prove in [56] Schauder estimates for linear kinetic Fokker– Planck equations, as well as well for a toy nonlinear kinetic model. Schauder estimates for kinetic equations (and in particular for linear kinetic Fokker-Planck equations in trace-form) are also obtained by Henderson and Snelson in [53], where they are crucial in proving that weak solutions of the inhomogeneous Landau equation immediately become smooth. Finally, we recall the following results. Wei, Jiang, and Wu adapt in [121] the method introduced by Wang [119] and prove Schauder estimates for hypoelliptic degenerate operators on the Heisenberg group. The Taylor formula used in [121] is proved by Arena, Caruso and Causa in [13]. In a different framework, Wang’s method has been used by Bucur and Karakhanyan [26] in the study of fractional operators. 36 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES 2.1.4 Idea of the proof The proof of our main results is based on the method introduced by Safonov in [108] for the parabolic case, explained in Krylov’s book [69]. The core idea of Safonov’s argument was adopted by Wang [119] for the study of the Poisson equation with Dini continuous right-hand side and by Imbert and Mouhot for the study of kinetic Fokker–Planck equations with H¨oder continuous coefficients. As we also work under the assumption of Dini continuity, we briefly sketch the proof contained in [119]. Spefically, Wang considers in [119] a solution uto the equation ∆u=fin some open set Ω. Without loss of generality, he assumes that the unit ball B1(0) is contained in Ω and considers a sequence of Dirichlet problems as follows. Let Brk(0) be the Euclidean ball centered at the origin and of radius rk=1 2k, and let ukbe the solution to the Dirichlet problem ∆uk=f(0),in Brk(0), uk=uin ∂Brk(0). Quantitative information on the derivatives of every solution ukis obtained by using only the elementary properties of the Laplace equation, namely the weak maximum principle, and the standard a priori estimates of the derivatives, that are obtained in [119] via mean value formulas. The bounds for the derivatives of uare obtained as the limit of the analogous bounds for uk. The Taylor expansion in this step is fundamental to conclude the proof. More precisely, following Safonov’s argument, it is crucial to show that the oscillation of the remainder of the second-order Taylor polynomial of the solution decays at rate r2 kin a ball of radius rk. In this chapter, we apply the method described above to degenerate Kolmogorov operators L, by adapting Wang’s approach to the non-Euclidean structure defined in (1.1.6). In particular, the ball Brk(0) is replaced by the box Qrk(0,0) defined through the dilation δrk introduced in (1.1.13). Concerning the Taylor expansion, we recall the results due to Bonfiglioli [18] and the ones proved by Pagliarani, Pascucci and Pignotti [93]. We emphasize that the authors of the above articles assume that the second order derivatives of the function u are H¨older continuous, while we only require that ubelongs to the space C2 L(Ω) introduced in Definition 2.1.1. As the regularity of the second order derivatives of uis the very subject of this chapter, we do not assume extra conditions on them and we prove in Theorem 2.1.2 the Taylor approximation under the minimal requirement that u∈C2 L(Ω). 2.1.5 Outline of the chapter This chapter is structured as follows. In Section 2.2 we prove some preliminary results. In particular, we obtain some a priori estimates of the derivatives of the solutions uto Lu= 0 in terms of the L∞norm of u. We subsequently prove a mean-value formula for u. In Section 2.3 we prove our main result on the Taylor approximation of any function u∈C2 L(Ω). Section 2.4 contains the proof of Theorem 2.1.4, while Section 2.5 contains the proof of Theorem 2.1.5. 37 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES 2.2 Preliminary results In this section we list some preliminary facts, which are useful in proving our main results. As a first step, we prove a corollary of estimates (1.1.35), (1.1.36) and (1.1.37), which will be useful in the sequel. Secondly, we prove a priori estimates for the derivatives of usolution to the Kolmogorov equation with right-hand side equal to 0. To this end, we represent solutions to Lu= 0 as convolutions with the fundamental solution Γ of Land its derivatives ∂x1Γ, ..., ∂xNΓ. We then prove a mean-value formula for u, which is based on the Euclidean mean-value theorem and on the homogeneity of the fundamental solution. As the estimates in (1.1.35), (1.1.36) and (1.1.37) play a crucial role in the proof of the forthcoming Lemma 2.2.2, we briefly explain how to obtain them and we refer the reader to [41, Proposition 2.7] and [40, Theorems 1.4-1.5] for further details. We firstly observe that the estimate in (1.1.35) holds true in virtue of the homogeneity of the fundamental solution Γ0, see (1.1.34). Indeed, as already explained in Subsection 1.1.2, homogeneous operators provide a good approximation of the non-homogeneous ones. In particular, the following result holds true. Theorem 2.2.1. Let Lbe an operator of the form (1.1.1)and let L0be its principal part (see Subsection 1.1.2). As above, we denote by Γ(resp. Γ0) the fundamental solution with pole at the origin of L(resp. L0). Then for every b > 0, there exists a positive constant a such that 1 aΓ0(z)≤Γ(z)≤aΓ0(z) (2.2.1) for every z∈RN+1 such that Γ0(z)≥b. Moreover, a=a(b)→1as b→+∞. Proof. Let C(t) and C0(t) be the matrix defined in (1.1.32) corresponding to Land L0, respectively. Then, by [73, Equation (3.14)], we have det C(t) = det C0(t)(1 + tO(1)),as t→0+,(2.2.2) where O(1) denotes a bounded function on RN×(0,1]. On the other hand, (see [73, Lemma 3.3]), there holds exp −1 4hC−1(t)x, xi= exp −1 4hC−1 0(t)x, xiexp thC−1(t)x, xiO(1).(2.2.3) Thus, if Γ0(z)≥b, we get hC−1 0(t)x, xi ≤ 2Qlog cN b2/Q 1 t,(2.2.4) where cN= (4π)−N/2(det C(1))−1/2. The thesis follows at once from (1.1.31), (2.2.2), (2.2.3) and (2.2.4). 38 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES We now focus on the first estimate in (1.1.36) that involves the first derivatives of Γ. The other estimates in (1.1.36) can be obtained in a similar way and the detailed computations can be found in [41, Proposition 2.7]. As a first step, we set ζ= (ξ, τ) = w−1◦zso that Γ(z, w) = Γ(ξ, τ) and we compute ∂xjΓ(ξ, τ) = −1 2C−1(τ)ξjΓ(ξ, τ), j = 1, . . . N. (2.2.5) We now claim that C−1(τ)ξj≤c ταj/2δ0 1/τ (ξ)j= 1, . . . N, (2.2.6) where the numbers αjwere defined in (1.1.18) and the constant conly depends on Tand on the matrix B. Indeed, we have C−1(τ)ξj≤(C−1(τ)−C−1 0(τ))ξj+C−1 0(τ)ξj =1 ταj/2δ0 √τC−1(τ)−C−1 0(τ)δ0 √τδ0 √1/τ (ξ)j +1 ταj/2δ0 √τC−1 0(τ)δ0 √τδ0 √1/τ (ξ)j ≤1 ταj/2δ0 √τC−1(τ)−C−1 0(τ)δ0 √τδ0 √1/τ (ξ)+1 ταj/2C−1 0(1)δ0 √1/τ (ξ). (2.2.7) Moreover, we recall that, by [73, Remark 2.1], for any given T > 0, there exists a positive constant cTsuch that δ0 √1/τ C−1(τ)−C−1 0(τ)δ0 √1/τ ≤cTτkC0(1)k.(2.2.8) Hence, combining (2.2.7) and (2.2.8), we infer C−1(τ)ξj≤1 + cTτ ταj/2C−1 0(1)δ0 √1/τ (ξ), which yields (2.2.6). On the other hand, in virue of the homogeneity of the norm k·kK, we have k(ξ, τ)kK=√τk(δ0 √1/τ (ξ),1)kK≤c√τ|δ0 √1/τ (ξ)|K+ 1, where cis a constant that only depends on B. Combining the previous inequality with (2.2.6), we obtain k(ξ, τ)kαj KC−1(τ)ξj≤c|δ0 √1/τ (ξ)|K+ 1αj+1 ,(2.2.9) 39 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES where cis a constant that only depends on B. Then, taking advantage of (1.2.11), we get k(ξ, τ)kαj K∂xjΓ(ξ, τ)≤cΓ+(ξ, τ), j = 1, . . . , N, where Γ+was defined in (1.2.12). In particular, for j= 1, . . . , m, we can rewrite the previous estimate as follows k(ξ, τ)kK∂xjΓ(ξ, τ)≤cΓ+(ξ, τ), j = 1, . . . , m. The desired estimate in (1.1.36) finally follows from (1.1.35). We are now in a position to state and prove the following result. Lemma 2.2.2. Assume that all the eigenvalues of the matrix Abelong to some interval [λ, Λ] ⊂R+. Then there exist two positive constants C, only depending on λ, Λand on the matrix B, such that the following holds true. For every R∈(0,1] we have that sup nΓ(z, ζ) : z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o≤C RQ.(2.2.10) Moreover sup n∂xj∂ξkΓ(z, ζ):z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o≤C RQ+αj+αk.(2.2.11) and sup n|Y ∂ξkΓ(z, ζ)|:z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o≤C RQ+2+αk.(2.2.12) for every j, k = 1, . . . , N. Proof. We want to apply (1.1.35), (1.1.36) for two points z, ζ ∈ QR0(0), where R0>0 is a constant such that kζ−1◦zkK≤R0whenever z∈ Q1 2(0), and ζ∈ Q1(0). The existence of such a positive number R0follows from the pseudo-triangular inequality (1.1.20). With this choice of R0, we apply (1.1.35), and we find sup nΓ(z, ζ) : z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o≤ cinf nkζ−1◦zkK:z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o−Q. (2.2.13) We therefore need to estimate the infimum of kζ−1◦zkKfor z∈ QR 2(0) and ζ∈ QR(0) \ Q3R 4(0). We first consider the points ¯z:= δ1 R(z) and ¯ ζ:= δ1 R(ζ) which belong to Q1 2(0) and Q1(0) \ Q3 4(0), respectively. We now define the function g(¯z, ¯ ζ) := k¯ ζ−1◦R¯zkK, which is continuous on the compact set E:= Q1 2(0) ×Q1(0) \Q3 4(0) ×[0,1], as observed in Remark 1.1.8. Thus, by Weierstrass’s Theorem, gattains a minimum mon E, i.e., k¯ ζ−1◦R¯zkK≥m, ∀¯z∈ Q1 2(0),∀¯ ζ∈Q1(0) \Q3 4(0),∀R∈[0,1]. 40 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES Going back to the box of radius R, i.e. applying dilation δRto the points ¯zand ¯ ζyields kζ−1◦zkK≥mR, z ∈QR 2(0), ζ ∈QR(0) \Q3R 4(0),(2.2.14) and therefore (2.2.13) becomes sup nΓ(z, ζ) : z∈ QR 2(0), ζ ∈ QR(0) \Q3R 4(0)o≤c mQRQ=: C RQ(2.2.15) where the constant Cdoes not depend on R. To obtain (2.2.11) and (2.2.12), we use the bounds for the derivatives of Γ in (1.1.36) and apply the same arguments as above. In order to state our next result, we recall the notation introduced in (1.1.18), that is δr= diag(rα1, . . . , rαN, r2). In the sequel we assume that all the eigenvalues of the constant matrix Abelong to some interval [λ, Λ] ⊂R+. We are now in position to state our result. Proposition 2.2.3. Let ube a solution to Lu= 0 in QR(z0), with R∈]0,1]. Then |∂xju|(z)≤C RαjkukL∞(QR(z0)),for every z∈ QR 2(z0), j = 1, . . . , N, for some positive constant Conly depending on λ, Λand on the matrix B. Proof. Without loss of generality, we can assume z0= 0. Let ηR∈C∞ 0(RN+1) be a cut-off function such that ηR(x, t) = χ(k(x, t)kK),(2.2.16) where χ∈C∞([0,+∞),[0,1]) is such that χ(s) = 1 if s≤3R 4,χ(s) = 0 if s≥Rand |χ0| ≤ c R, |χ00| ≤ c R2. Then, for every z∈ QR(0) and for i= 1, . . . , N, there exists a constant c, only depending on B, such that |∂xiηR(z)| ≤ c Rαi,|∂tηR(z)| ≤ c R2.(2.2.17) Consequently, for every z∈ QR(0) and i, j = 1, . . . , m, we have |∂2 xixjηR(z)| ≤ c R2and therefore we obtain a bound for the second order part of |LηR(z)|. Since ηR≡1 in ∈ Q3R 4(0), for every z∈ QR 2(0) we represent a solution uto Lu= 0 as follows u(z) = (ηRu)(z) = −ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)L(ηRu)](ζ)dζ. (2.2.18) 41 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES Since L= div(ADm) + Yand Lu= 0 by assumption, (2.2.18) can be rewritten as u(z) = (ηRu)(z) = −ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)div(ADm(ηR))u](ζ)dζ −ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)Y(ηR)u](ζ)dζ −2ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)hDmu, ADmηRi](ζ)dζ. (2.2.19) Integrating by parts the last integral in (2.2.19), we obtain, for every z∈ QR 2(0) u(z) = (ηRu)(z) = ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)div(ADm(ηR))u](ζ)dζ −ZQR(0) [Γ(z, ·)Y(ηR)u](ζ)dζ + 2 ZQR(0) [hDζ mΓ(z, ·), ADmηRiu](ζ)dζ, (2.2.20) where Dmis the gradient with respect to x1, . . . , xmand the superscript in Dζ mindicates that we are differentiating w.r.t the variable ζ. Since z∈ QR 2(0) and ∂xiηR, Y (ηR) = 0 (i= 1, . . . , m) in Q3R 4(0), after differentiating under the integral sign (2.2.20), we find ∂xju(z) = ∂xj(ηRu)(z) = ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [∂xjΓ(z, ·)div(ADm(ηR))u](ζ)dζ −ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [∂xjΓ(z, ·)Y(ηR)u](ζ)dζ + 2 ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [h∂xjDζ mΓ(z, ·), ADmηRiu](ζ)dζ, for every j= 1, ..., N. Thus, we obtain |∂xju(z)|=|∂xj(ηRu)(z)| ≤ ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [∂xjΓ(z, ·)div(ADm(ηR))u](ζ)dζ +ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [∂xjΓ(z, ·)Y(ηR)u](ζ)dζ + 2 ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) [h∂xjDζ mΓ(z, ·), ADmηRiu](ζ)dζ =: e I1(z) + e I2(z) + e I3(z), 42 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES We estimate e I1(z) and e I2(z), for z∈ QR 2(0). We have e I1(z)≤ kukL∞(QR(0)) sup QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) |div(ADm(ηR))|meas(QR(0)) sup z∈QR 2(0), ζ∈QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) ∂xjΓ(z, ζ), e I2(z)≤ kukL∞(QR(0)) sup QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) |Y(ηR)|meas(QR(0)) sup z∈QR 2(0), ζ∈QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) ∂xjΓ(z, ζ). We now apply Lemma 2.2.2 and obtain sup z∈QR 2(0), ζ∈QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) ∂xjΓ(z, ζ)≤e C RQ+αj.(2.2.21) Moreover, by our choice of the cut-off function ηR, we have |div(ADm(ηR))| ≤ Λc R2in QR(0),(2.2.22) where Λ is the largest eigenvalue of A. Finally, combining inequalities (2.2.21) and (2.2.22) with meas(QR(0)) = RQ+2meas(Q1(0)), we obtain e I1(z)≤C RαjkukL∞(QR(0)), z ∈ QR 2(0),(2.2.23) We now estimate |Y(ηR)| ≤ |hBx, DηRi| +|∂tηR|in QR(0) \ Q3R 4(0). The bound for the derivative with respect to time of ηRis obtained using (2.2.17). Moreover |hBx, DηR(ζ)i| ≤ N X i,k=1 |bik||xk||∂xiηR(ζ)| ≤ c N X i,k=1 |bik|Rαk−αi,(2.2.24) where ζ∈ QR(0)\Q3R 4(0). Notice that in sum (2.2.24) the exponent αk−αiis always greater or equal to −2, because of the form of the matrix B. Since by assumption R≤1, we estimate (2.2.24) as follows |hBx, DηRi| ≤ C0 R2,in QR(0) \Q3R 4(0),(2.2.25) where C0is a constant that only depends on the matrix Band on the constant cin (2.2.17). Finally, using again meas(QR(0)) = RQ+2meas(Q1(0)), together with (2.2.21) and (2.2.25), we obtain e I2(z)≤C RαjkukL∞(QR(0)), z ∈ QR 2(0),(2.2.26) where Cdepends only on the constants cand e Cin (2.2.17) and (2.2.21) and on the matrix 43 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES B. By the same argument we prove that, for a point z∈ QR 2(0), we have e I3(z)≤ kukL∞(QR(0)) c Rmeas(QR(0)) sup z∈QR 2(0), ζ∈QR(0)\Q3R 4(0) ∂xjDζ mΓ(z, ζ)≤C RαjkukL∞(QR(0)). where Cdenotes once again a constant depending only on c,e Cand B. Combining the inequality above with (2.2.23) and (2.2.26), we finally obtain k∂xjukL∞(QR 2(0)) ≤C RαjkukL∞(QR(0)), j = 1, ..., N. We state a result analogous to Proposition 2.2.3, written in terms of the vector fields X1, . . . , Xm, Y introduced in (1.1.4). Proposition 2.2.4. Let ube a solution to Lu= 0 in QR(0), for R∈]0,1[, then for any Xi, Xj∈ {X1, ..., Xm}, there exists a constant C, only depending on λ, Λand on the matrix B, such that |Xiu|(z)≤C RkukL∞(QR(0)), z ∈ QR 2(0), |XiXju|(z)≤C R2kukL∞(QR(0)), z ∈ QR 2(0). Similarly, we have that |Y u|(z)≤C R2kukL∞(QR(0)), z ∈ QR 2(0). Proof. The estimate of X1, . . . , Xmhas been proved in Proposition 2.2.3. The proof of the remaining estimates is obtained by reasoning as in Proposition 2.2.3, and using estimates (2.2.11) and (2.2.12), respectively. We omit the details here. In the sequel, we will need to estimate the second order derivatives of a solution to Lu=g, where gis a polynomial of degree at most two. To this end, we let g1(z) = hv, xi, g2(z) = hMx, xi,(2.2.27) be two polynomial functions, where vand Mdenote a constant vector of RNand a N×N constant matrix, respectively. Lemma 2.2.5. Let ηRbe the cut-off function introduced in (2.2.16)and let g1and g2be the functions defined in (2.2.27). Then there exists a positive constant C, only depending on λ, Λ 44 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES and on the matrix B, such that ∂2 xixjZQR(0) Γ(z, ζ)ηR(ζ)dζ≤C, (2.2.28) ∂2 xixjZQR(0) Γ(z, ζ)ηR(ζ)g1(ζ)dζ≤CR, (2.2.29) ∂2 xixjZQR(0) Γ(z, ζ)ηR(ζ)g2(ζ)dζ≤CR2,(2.2.30) for every z∈ QR 2(0),R∈]0,1] and for any i, j = 1, . . . , m. Proof. Reasoning as in the proof of Proposition 2.11 in [41], we write the right-hand side of (2.2.28) as ∂2 xixjZQR(0) Γ(ζ−1◦z)ηR(ζ)dζ = lim ε→0ZQR(0)∩{kζ−1◦zkK≥ε} ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z)ηR(ζ)dζ +ηR(z)ZkζkK=1 ∂xiΓ0(ζ)νjdσ(ζ) =: lim ε→0I0 1(ε, z) + I0 2(z). (2.2.31) We rewrite I0 1(ε, z) as I0 1(ε, z) = ZQR(0)∩{kζ−1◦zkK≥ε} ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z) (ηR(ζ)−ηR(z)) dζ +ηR(z)ZQR(0)∩{kζ−1◦zkK≥ε} ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z)dζ. (2.2.32) By the definition of ηR, we have 0≤ηR≤1, ηR(ζ)−ηR(z) = 0,for any ζ∈ Q3R 4(0), z∈ QR 2(0).(2.2.33) Thus, taking advantage of Lemma 2.2.2, we infer ZQR(0)∩{kζ−1◦zkK≥ε} ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z) (ηR(ζ)−ηR(z)) dζ =ZQR(0)\Q3R 4(0) ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z) (ηR(ζ)−ηR(z)) dζ≤C RQ+2 RQ+2 =C (2.2.34) Thus we find I0 2(z) + lim ε→0ηR(z)ZQR(0)∩{kζ−1◦zkK≥ε} ∂2 xixjΓ(ζ−1◦z)dζ =C. (2.2.35) Combining estimates (2.2.34) and (2.2.35) we conclude the proof of (2.2.28). 45 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES Indeed, in this case the trajectory (γ(n) v,s (z)) may affect the components x[0] +···+x[n−1], as the following example shows. Example 2.3.2. We consider the degenerate Kolmogorov operator K:= ∂2 xx +x∂y+x∂x−∂t.(2.3.5) In this case, Btakes the form B= 1 0 1 0!. and therefore the operator Kis not dilation-invariant. Let us emphasize the differences with the dilation-invariant case studied in Example 2.3.1. We denote again the points in R3by z= (x, y, t) and consider ζ= (0,0,0). The first two steps of the procedure used in Example 2.3.1 allow us to move from zto some point z1= (x1, y1,0), then to some other point z2= (0, y2,0). The difference with the homogeneous case arises in the third step, i.e. when we are dealing with the y-variable. Let us suppose we want to move from any point z= (0, y, 0) ∈V1to the origin (0,0,0). If we reproduce the same construction as in (2.3.4), we find: z1=esX(z) = (s, y, 0), z2=es2Y(z1) = (ses2,−s+ses2+y, −s2), z3=e−sX(z2) = (ses2−s, −s+ses2+y, −s2), z4=e−s2Y(z3) = (s(1 −e−s2), s(1 −e−s2) + y, 0). (2.3.6) If we choose ssuch that s(1 −e−s2) = −y, we obtain z4= (−y, 0,0), so that its second component is zero but, in constrast with the previous Example 2.3.1, we have that z4doesn’t agree with our target point ζ= (0,0,0). In order to reach the point ζ= (0,0,0) also in the case of not dilation-invariant operators, we rely on the method introduced by Pagliarani and Pignotti in [94] and by Pignotti in [101]. In the case of the operator Kin (2.3.5) it is sufficient to use once more the integral curve of the vector field X=∂x. In the case of more general operators a further topological argument is needed to conclude the construction. We refer to [94,101] for a detailed description of this construction. This step is needed as the invariance properties of operator Lare related to the structure of the matrix Bin (1.1.2). For this reason, to generalize the proof of Theorem 2.1.2 to the not dilation-invariant case is necessary also when treating the constant-coefficients operator L(and thus Theorem 2.1.4). We are now ready to prove our result. Proof of Theorem 2.1.2.Let z= (x, t), ζ = (ξ, τ) be two given points of Ω. As explained above, the proof relies on a finite sequence of integral paths of the vector fields X1, . . . , Xmand Yconnecting zto ζ. We use the construction made by Pagliarani, Pascucci and Pignotti [93] 52 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES for a dilation-invariant operator L. In this case the trajectories (γ(n) v,s (z))n=0,...,κ defined in (2.3.3) are explicitly given and we prove that (2.1.4) holds. We then discuss the modifications needed to deal with any not dilation-invariant operator L, as introduced by Pagliarani and Pignotti in [94] and by Pignotti in [101]. As a preliminary result, we prove our claim (2.1.4) under the assumption that the points z= (x, t) and ζ= (ξ, τ) have the same temporal component t=τ, by a finite iteration on n= 0, . . . , κ. We remove this assumption in the last part of the proof. Base case n= 0. In this case, we are only changing the variables xi, for i= 1, . . . , m, moving along the direction es0Xv0where v0= (v0,1, . . . , v0,m,0. . . , 0) is a suitable unit vector in V0. Thus, equation (2.1.3), with z= (x, t) and ζ= (x+s0v0, t), rewrites as T2 zu(ζ) = u(x, t) + m X i=1 ∂xiu(x, t)s0v0,i +s2 0 2 m X i,j=1 ∂2 xi,xju(x, t)v0,iv0,j.(2.3.7) We observe that kz−1◦ζk2 K=|s0|2and therefore we want to show that u(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ) = o(|s0|2) as s0→0.(2.3.8) By the multidimensional Euclidean mean-value theorem, there exist (¯vi,j)1≤i,j≤m, with ¯vi,j ∈span{e1, . . . , em}and |¯vi,j|≤|v0|such that u(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ) = s2 0 2 m X i,j=1 (∂2 xi,xju(x+s0¯vi,j, t)v0,iv0,j −∂2 xi,xju(x, t))v0,iv0,j =o(|s0|2)as s0→0, (2.3.9) where we have used the continuity of the second order derivatives of u. Thus, we have proved (2.3.8) and we are done. Let us remark that we do not need the dilation-invariance property for Y, as we do not make use of the vector field Yin this part of the construction. Inductive step. Suppose that the thesis is true for a given nonnegative n < κ. We prove it for n+ 1. For every z, ζ ∈RN+1 we set e T2 zu(ζ) := T2 zu(ζ)−u(z).(2.3.10) We define the points z= (x, t), z1=γ(n) v,s (z), z2=es2Y(z1) z3=γ(n) v,−s(z2), z4=e−s2Y(z3) = γ(n+1) v,s (z) where vis the unique unitary vector in V0,n+1 ⊂V0, defined as v=w |w|, where wis the vector 53 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES in V0,n+1 such that Bn+1w=ζ[n+1] −z[n+1] and s=|w|1 2(n+1)+1 . We aim to prove that u(z4)−T2 zu(z4) = o(kz−1◦z4k2 K) = o(|s|2) as s→0.(2.3.11) We now rewrite (2.3.11) by using the notation (2.3.10) as follows u(z4)−T2 zu(z4) = u(z4)−u(z3)(1) +u(z3)−u(z2)−e T2 z2u(z3)(2) +u(z2)−u(z1)(3) +e T2 z1u(z) + u(z1)−u(z)(4) +e T2 z2u(z3)−e T2 z1u(z)(5) −e T2 zu(z4)(6).(2.3.12) By the inductive hypothesis, the second and the forth difference are o(|s|2) as s→0. Moreover, recalling (2.1.3), we have that e T2 zu(z4)≡0, being x[0] 4=x[0] and t4=t. We next apply definition (2.1.3) to the fifth difference, and we find e T2 z2u(z3)−e T2 z1u(z) = −s m X i=1 (∂xiu(z2)−∂xiu(z1))vi −s2 2 m X i,j=1 (∂2 xixju(z2)−∂2 xixju(z1))vivj. (2.3.13) As an immediate consequence of condition (2.1.2), we obtain the following equation ∂xiu(z2)−∂xiu(z1) = ∂xiu(es2Y(z1)) −∂xiu(z1) = o(|s|).(2.3.14) Using the previous equation and the continuity of second order derivatives of u, we find that (2.3.13) is equal to o(|s|2). We now observe that u(z4)−u(z3) = u(e−s2Y(z3)) −u(z3). By applying the mean value theorem along the direction of the drift, we find that there exists ¯ssuch that u(e−s2Y(z3)) −u(z3) = −s2Y u(e¯sY (z3)), 54 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES where |¯s| ≤ |s|. Similarly we obtain that u(z2)−u(z1) = s2Y u(eesY (z1)), where again esverifies |es| ≤ |s|. By letting s→0, we find that ¯s, es→0, and therefore, using the continuity of Y u, we have shown that the sum of the first and the third difference in (2.3.12) is again equal to o(|s|2) as s→0. This proves (2.3.11) and therefore concludes the proof of the inductive step. As already pointed out, the construction of the trajectories in the case of not dilationinvariant operators requires the adjustments introduced in [94,101], to deal with the fact that the term e T2 zu(z4) in (2.3.12) fails to vanish. Indeed, with the notation (2.3.1), xwrites as x=x[0] +x[1] +···+x[κ], and we have e T2 zu(z4)6= 0 whenever x[0] 46=x[0]. To overcome this problem, we define a new point z5= (x5, t5) as follows: x[0] 5=x[0], x[1] 5=x[1] 4, . . . , x[κ] 5=x[κ] 4, t5=t4. Note that in [94,101] it is proved that x[0] −x[0] 4≤Ckz−1◦ζkK, for some positive constant Conly depending on the matrix B. Then u(z5)−u(z4) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as ζ→z. (2.3.15) With this modification, expression (2.3.12) is replaced by u(z5)−T2 zu(z5) = u(z5)−u(z4)−e T2 zu(z5) + o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as ζ→z. Moreover, x[0] 5=x[0] and t5=tyield e T2 zu(z5) = 0. From (2.3.15) it then follows that u(z5)−T2 zu(z5) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as ζ→z. We are now in position to prove (2.1.4). We first consider the point ¯z=e(t−τ)Y(z) = (e(t−τ)Bx, τ) and write u(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ) = u(ζ)−T2 ¯zu(ζ) + T2 ¯zu(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ).(2.3.16) Thanks to the previous steps, the first difference is o(k¯z−1◦ζk2 K) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as kz−1◦ζk2 K→0, since ζand ¯zhave the same temporal component τ. At the same time, the second difference in (2.3.16) can be rewritten as 55 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES T2 ¯zu(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ) = u(¯z)−u(z) + m X i=1 (∂xiu(¯z)−∂xiu(z)) (ξi−xi) +1 2 m X i,j=1 ∂2 xixju(¯z)−∂2 xixju(z)(ξi−xi)(ξj−xj) + Y u(z)(τ−t). (2.3.17) Using the mean value theorem along the drift, we can rewrite difference u(¯z)−u(z) in (2.3.17) as u(e(t−τ)Y(z)) −u(z) = (t−τ)Y u(eδY (z)),(2.3.18) where δis such that |δ| ≤ |t−τ|. Hence, we obtain u(¯z)−u(z)−Y(z)(t−τ) = (t−τ)(Y u(eδY (z)) −Y(z)),(2.3.19) which is o(|t−τ|) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as kz−1◦ζk2 K→0, thanks to the continuity of Y u. We observe that we can apply condition (2.1.2) to the point z, which is not fixed, thanks to the fact that such a condition holds locally uniformly. Hence, using the aforemention condition (2.1.2), together with the continuity of the second derivatives of u, we obtain that the second and third difference in (2.3.17) are also o(|t−τ|) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as kz−1◦ζk2 K→0. Combining all the previous estimates, we obtain T2 ¯zu(ζ)−T2 zu(ζ) = o(kz−1◦ζk2 K),as kz−1◦ζk2 K→0.(2.3.20) and therefore (2.3.16) is equal to o(kz−1◦ζk2 K) as kz−1◦ζk2 K→0. This concludes the proof. 2.4 Proof of Theorem 2.1.4 We first prove a preliminary lemma, which is a straightforward consequence of the maximum principle. Lemma 2.4.1. Given ϕ∈C(∂QR(z0)) and g∈Cb(QR(z0)), we assume that vsolves the following Dirichlet problem (Lv=g, in QR(z0), v=ϕ, in ∂QR(z0). Then, the following holds kvkL∞(QR(z0)) ≤ kϕkL∞(QR(z0)) + (t0−t1)kgkL∞(QR(z0)),(2.4.1) 56 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES where t1=t0−R2is the time coordinate of the basis of the cylinder QR(z0). Proof. We introduce the function w(x, t) := (t−t1)kgkL∞(QR(z0)) +kϕkL∞(QR(z0)) and we let u:= v−w. Clearly, usatisfies Lu=g+kgkL∞(QR(z0)) ≥0 in QR(z0). Moreover, as v≡ϕ on the boundary of QR(z0), we have u=ϕ−(t−t1)kgkL∞(QR(z0)) − kϕkL∞(QR(z0)) ≤0 in ∂QR(z0). By the strong maximum principle, it follows that u(x, t)≤0 in QR(z0). Replacing vby −v, estimate (2.4.1) follows at once. Proof of Theorem 2.1.4.We first prove assertion (ii). We denote Qk=Q%k(0), %=1 2and we consider the following sequence of Dirichlet problems: (Luk=f(0),in Qk uk=u, in ∂Qk (2.4.2) For any point z= (x, t) satisfying kzkK≤1 2, we want to estimate the quantity I(z) := |∂2u(z)−∂2u(0)|, where ∂2u(z) stands for either ∂2 xixju(z), with i, j = 1, . . . , m, or Y u(z). To this end, we write Ias the sum of three terms: I(z)≤ |∂2uk(z)−∂2uk(0)|+|∂2uk(0) −∂2u(0)|+ +|∂2u(z)−∂2uk(z)|=: I1(z) + I2(z) + I3(z). We first estimate I2. Following [119], we prove that ∂2uk(0)k∈Nis a Cauchy sequence and that its limit agrees with ∂2u(0). The same assertion holds for I3of course. First, we let vk:= u−ukand we observe that vksatisfies the Dirichlet boundary value problem (Lvk=f−f(0),in Qk vk= 0,in ∂Qk (2.4.3) From Lemma 2.4.1 it follows that kvkk∞≤4%2kkf−f(0)k∞≤4%2kωf(%k).(2.4.4) Moreover, since L(uk−uk+1) = 0 in Qk+1, we apply Proposition 2.2.4 and Lemma 2.4.1, and we find k∂xi(uk−uk+1)kL∞(Qk+2)≤C%−k−2sup Qk+1 |uk−uk+1| ≤C%−ksup Qk+1 |vk|+ sup Qk+1 |vk+1| ≤C%−k%2kωf(%k) = C%kωf(%k),(2.4.5) 57 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES for any i= 1, . . . , m. In the same way, we obtain k∂2 xixj(uk−uk+1)kL∞(Qk+2)≤C%−2k−4sup Qk+1 |uk−uk+1| ≤C%−2k%2kωf(%k) = Cωf(%k) (2.4.6) for i, j = 1, . . . , m, and kY(uk−uk+1)kL∞(Qk+2)≤C%−2k−4sup Qk+1 |uk−uk+1| ≤C%−2k%2kωf(%k) = Cωf(%k).(2.4.7) Let k≥1 such that %k+4 ≤ kzkK≤%k+3 , then we have: ∞ X l=k|∂2ul(0) −∂2ul+1(0)| ≤ C∞ X l=k ωf(%l)≤CZkzkK 0 ωf(r) rdr. (2.4.8) We next identify the sum of the series P∞ l=k∂2ul(0) −∂2ul+1(0)as ∞ X l=k∂2ul(0) −∂2ul+1(0)=∂2uk(0) −∂2u(0).(2.4.9) To this end, we first consider the derivative ∂2 xixjukand we prove that lim k→+∞∂2 xixjuk(0) = ∂2 xixjT2 0u(0),(2.4.10) where T2 0u(ζ) is the second-order Taylor polynomial of uaround the origin, computed at some point ζ= (ξ, τ)∈ Qk: T2 0u(ζ) = u(0) + m X i=1 ∂xiu(0)ξi+1 2 m X i,j=1 ∂2 xixju(0)ξiξj−Y u(0)τ. Thus, by applying Theorem 2.1.2 to u∈C2 L(Q1(0)), we obtain from (2.4.10) that lim k→+∞∂2 xixjuk(0) = ∂2 xixju(0).(2.4.11) We compute LT2 0uin ζ= (ξ, τ) as LT2 0u(ζ) = m X i,j=1 aij∂2 ξiζju(0) −∂tu(0) + N X j=1m X i=1 bij∂ξiu(0)ξj+ N X l,j=1 m X i=1 bil∂2 ξjξiu(0)ξlξj = m X i,j=1 aij∂2 ξiζju(0) −∂tu(0) + hv, ξi+hMξ, ξi, 58 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES where v= (vj)j=1,...,N = (Pm i=1 bij∂ξiu(0))j=1,...,N is a constant vector of RNand M= (mlj)l,j=1,...,N =Pm i=1 bil∂2 ξjξiu(0)l,j=1,...,N is a N×Nconstant matrix. In addition, as Lu=fin Qk, we have that m X i,j=1 aij∂2 ξiζju(0) −∂tu(0) = L0u(0) = Lu(0) = f(0) (2.4.12) and thus LT2 0u(ζ) = f(0) + hv, ξi+hMξ, ξi.(2.4.13) Thus, the definition of ukin (2.4.2) gives us LT2 0u−uk(ζ) = hv, ξi+hMξ, ξi, ζ ∈ Qk.(2.4.14) We now apply Lemma 2.2.6 to T2 0u−ukfor R=%kand infer |∂2 xixj(uk−T2 0u)(0)| ≤ C%−2ksup Qk|uk−T2 0u|+O(%k).(2.4.15) Moreover, since T2 0uis the second-order Taylor polynomial of u, we have u(ζ) = T2 0u(ζ) + o(kζk2 K). It follows that sup ζ∈Qk|u−T2 0u|=o(%2k) (2.4.16) Thus, from estimates (2.4.16) and (2.4.4), we obtain sup Qk|uk−T2 0u| ≤ sup Qk|vk|+ sup Qk|u−T2 0u| ≤ 4ωf(%k)%2k+o(%2k)≤o(%2k).(2.4.17) Estimates (2.4.15) and (2.4.17) finally yield |∂2 xixj(uk−T2 0u)(0)| ≤ C%−2ksup Qk|uk−T2 0u|+O(%k)≤C%−2ko(%2k) + O(%k)≤o(1), where, as usual, the indexes iand jrange from 1 to m. Thus, for any i, j = 1, . . . , m we have showed that (2.4.10) holds true. Repeating the same argument for the vector field Y, and using again Theorem 2.1.2, we obtain: lim k→+∞Y uk(0) = Y T2 0u(0) = Y u(0). In conclusion, using (2.4.8), we obtain: I2≤∞ X l=k|∂2ul(0) −∂2ul+1(0)| ≤ CZkzkK 0 ωf(r) rdr, (2.4.18) 59 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES for k≥1 such that %k+4 ≤ kzkK≤%k+3. Similarly, we can estimate I3through the solution of Lv=f(z) in Qj(z) and v=uon ∂Qj(z) and obtain I3≤∞ X l=k|∂2ul(z)−∂2ul+1(z)| ≤ CZkzkK 0 ωf(r) rdr. (2.4.19) Finally, let us estimate I1. Since hk=uk−uk+1 ∈C∞(Qk+2), we can apply Proposition 2.2.7 to the functions ∂2 xixjhkand Y hk: |∂2 xixjhk(z)−∂2 xixjhk(0)| ≤ C %kkzkKk∂2 xixjhkkL∞(Qk+1) and |Y hk(z)−Y hk(0)| ≤ C %kkzkKkY hkkL∞(Qk+1), for i, j = 1, . . . , m. We can now apply once again (2.4.6) to obtain |∂2 xixjhk(z)−∂2 xixjhk(0)| ≤ C %kkzkKk∂2 xixjhkkL∞(Qk+1)≤CkzkK%−kωf(%k). In addition, thanks to (2.4.7), we infer |Y hk(z)−Y hk(0)| ≤ C %kkzkKkY hkkL∞(Qk+1)≤CkzkK%−kωf(%k). Hence, since uk(z)−uk(0) = u0(z)−u0(0) + Pk−1 j=0 (hj(0) −hj(z)), we have I1≤ |∂2u0(z)−∂2u0(0)|+ k−1 X j=0 |∂2hj(z)−∂2hj(0)| ≤CkzkKku0kL∞(Q0)+C k−1 X j=0 %−jωf(%j) ≤CkzkKkukL∞(Q1(0)) +kfkL∞(Q1(0)) +CZ1 kzkK ωf(r) r2. Combining the above estimate with (2.4.18) and (2.4.19), we complete the proof of (ii). We now prove assertion (i). We consider u1solution to the following Dirichlet problem (Lu1=f(0),in Q1/2(0) u1=u, in ∂Q1/2(0) Then, we have |∂2u(0)|≤|∂2u(0) −∂2u1(0)|+|∂2u1(0)|.(2.4.20) 60 CHAPTER 2. SCHAUDER-TYPE ESTIMATES Thanks to (2.4.18), we can estimate the first term in (2.4.20) as |∂2u(0) −∂2u1(0)| ≤ CZ1 0 ωf(r) rdr. (2.4.21) To estimate the second term in (2.4.20), we consider the function v(z) := u1(z)η1/2(z), where η1/2is the cut-off function introduced in (2.2.16) with R=1 2. Reasoning as in the proof of Proposition 2.2.3, we obtain u(z) = v(z) = ZQ1 2(0) [Γ(z, ·)div(ADm(η1/2))u1](ζ)dζ −ZQ1 2(0) [Γ(z, ·)Y(η1/2)u1](ζ)dζ −ZQ1 2(0) [Γ(z, ·)η1/2L(u1)](ζ)dζ + 2 ZQ1 2(0) [hDζ mΓ(z, ·), ADmη1/2iu1](ζ)dζ, where z∈ Q1 4(0). Thanks to Lemma 2.4.1, we estimate sup Q1 2(0) |u1| ≤ sup Q1 2(0) |u|+ 4|f(0)|. As the derivatives of η1/2vanish in Q3/8(0), for any i, j = 1, . . . , m, we obtain |∂2 xixju1(z)| ≤ ZQ1 2(0)\Q3 8(0) [∂2 xixjΓ(z, ·)div(ADm(η1/2))u1](ζ)dζ +ZQ1 2(0)\Q3 8(0) [∂2 xixjΓ(z, ·)Y(η1/2)u1](ζ)dζ + 2 ZQ1 2(0)\Q3 8(0) [h∂2 xixjDζ mΓ(z, ·), ADmη1/2iu1](ζ)dζ (2.4.22) +f(0)h∂2 xixjZQ1 2(0) [Γ(z, ·)η1/2](ζ)dζi =: I1(z) + I2(z) + I3(z) + I4(z). Moreover, as the derivatives of η1/2are bounded, we estimate the first and second integral in (2.4.22) as I1(z)≤Csup Q1 2(0) |u|+ 4|f(0)|, I2(z)≤Csup Q1 2(0) |u|+ 4|f(0)|, 61 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS The proof of Theorem 3.1.2 is non-constructive and it is based on decay estimates, which we achieve by contradiction, blow-up and compactness results. We observe that from Theorem 3.1.2 iv) (inequality (3.1.16)), the next result follows straightforwardly. Corollary 3.1.3. If the modulus of Lp-mean oscillation of L0uat the origin is Dini, then the origin is a Lebesgue point of continuity in Lpaverage for the second order derivatives ∂2 xixju, i, j = 1, . . . , m, and the Lie derivative Y u. We observe that a simple consequence of Theorem 3.1.2 is that the second order derivatives ∂2 xixju,i, j = 1, . . . , m, and the Lie derivative Y u are H¨older continuous in some open set Ω⊂RN+1, when L0uis H¨older continuous with respect to the distance introduced in (1.1.21). Moreover, let us remark that Theorem 3.1.2 provides us with a Taylor-type expansion up to second order with an estimate of the rest in Lpnorm. We finally emphasize that, although we consider the regularity problem for weak solutions to Kolmogorov operators in the framework of the Sobolev spaces, our procedure is basically pointwise. Indeed, we consider some Lp norm of the function u−P0on a cylinder of radius rand we obtain our result by letting r going to zero. Thus, this approach follows the lines of regularity theory for classical solutions rather than the ones for weak solutions, which does not seem to be usual when dealing with Kolmogorov-type operators. 3.1.3 Comparison with existing results The results contained in Theorem 3.1.2 may be seen as a generalization of [86] and [77], where this kind of results are obtained for elliptic and parabolic equations, respectively. However, up to our knowledge, the case of Kolmogorov-type operators has not been investigated. The main difficulty with respect to the previous literature lies in the fact that the regularity properties of the Kolmogorov equations on RN+1 depend strongly on the geometric Lie group structure introduced in (1.1.6). In particular, this reflects on the family of dilations we consider. Furthermore, according to (3.1.2), we here take into account also the case where m < N and therefore L0is strongly degenerate. We emphasize that when m=Nand B≡O, our result recovers the one contained in [77]. Regarding the classical regularity theory of Kolmogorov operators, we recall the Schauder type estimates listed in Chapter 1, Section 1.2. Moreover, in [99] and then in [32], a pointwise estimate for weak solutions to Kolmogorov equations with right-hand side equal to zero was proved. In order to do so, the authors adapted the Moser iterative method to the non-Euclidean framework of the (homogeneous and non-homogeneous, respectively) Lie groups. Finally, the regularity of strong solutions to the Cauchy-Dirichlet and obstacle problem for a class of Kolmogorov-type operators was studied in [64] using a blow-up technique. 68 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS 3.1.4 Outline of the chapter The structure of the chapter is the following. Some general control results are contained in Section 3.2, some from the literature and a Caccioppoli-type estimate we prove ad hoc for our problem. Finally, Section 3.3 is devoted to proving our main result Theorem 3.1.2. In particular, for sake of semplicity, we first derive some preliminary estimates in Subsection 3.3.1 in order to finally give a shorter proof of Theorem 3.1.2 in Subsection 3.3.2. 3.2 Preliminary results We here list some general ultraparabolic estimates. Some of them are well-know from the literature, so for their proofs we will refer to source. First, for Ω open set in RN+1,p∈(1,+∞), we define the Sobolev space Sp(Ω) = {u∈Lp(Ω) : ∂xiu, ∂2 xixju, Y u ∈Lp(Ω), i, j = 1, . . . , m}. If we set kukp Sp(Ω) =kukp Lp(Ω) + m X i=1 k∂xiukp Lp(Ω) + m X i,j=1 k∂2 xixjukp Lp(Ω) +kY ukp Lp(Ω) we have the following local a priori estimates in Sp(Ω) for solutions to L0u=f(see [24]). Theorem 3.2.1. (Ultraparabolic interior Lp-estimates) Assume [H] holds and let ube a solution to L0u=fin Ω, where Ωis now a bounded open set in RN+1. If Ω1⊂⊂ Ω, then we can find a constant c, only depending on B,p,Ωand Ω1, such that kukSp(Ω1)≤c(kfkLp(Ω) +kukLp(Ω)).(3.2.1) We now state a general compactness result proved in [27]. Theorem 3.2.2. Let Ωbe an open set of RN+1 and let u∈Sp(Ω) be a weak solution to L0u=fin Ωwith f∈Lp loc(Ω). Then, for every z0∈Ωand ρ, σ > 0such that Q− ρ(z0)is contained in Ωand σ < ρ 2cH, with cHdefined in (1.1.20), we have that if 1< p < Q + 2 and p < q < p∗then there exists a positive constant e Cp,q such that ku(·◦h)−ukLq(Q− σ(z0)) ≤e Cp,q(kukLp(Q− ρ(z0)) +kfkLp(Q− ρ(z0)))khk(Q+2)( 1 q−1 p∗) where 1 p∗=1 p−1 Q+ 2. As a preliminary result, we state and prove the following Caccioppoli-type estimate which we obtain ad hoc for our problem. 69 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS Lemma 3.2.3. (Caccioppoli-type estimate) Let P∈ Pcrand let ube a solution to (3.1.1)in Q− r. Let p∈(1,+∞)and let ρ, r such that 1≤ρ < r. Then, for W:= (u−P)|u−P|p 2−1, the following estimate holds: 2(p−1) p2ZQ− ρ|DmW|2 ≤2 (p−1) c2 2 (r−ρ)2+2 pc1 r2κ+1 r−ρZQ− r W2+eω(f;r)|Q− r|1 |Q− r|ZQ− r η2p0W21 p0, where c1,c2are dimensional constants, p0is such that 1 p+1 p0= 1 and Dmdenotes the partial gradient in the first mvariables, that is Dm:= (∂x1, . . . , ∂xm). Proof. On the past cylinder Q− r, we have −L0u+f= 0,and −L0P+cr= 0,(3.2.2) since uis a solution to (3.1.1) and P∈ Pcr. We set ϕ:= η2w|w|p−2, where w:= u−Pand ηis a C∞−function with compact support, to be chosen later. Taking the difference of the two equations in (3.2.2) and multiplying it by ϕ, we obtain −ZQ− r η2w|w|p−2L0w=−ZQ− r η2w|w|p−2(f(x)−cr).(3.2.3) An integration by parts shows that −ZQ− r η2w|w|p−2L0w=ZQ− rhADmw, Dm(η2w|w|p−2)i−ZQ− r η2w|w|p−2Y(w) =: I1+I2, (3.2.4) where Dmdenotes the gradient with respect to x1, . . . , xm. We now observe that Dmϕ= 2ηDmη w|w|p−2+η2(p−1)|w|p−2Dmw and therefore we can rewrite the term I1on the right-hand side of (3.2.4) as I1= 2 ZQ− rhADmw, Dmηiηw|w|p−2+ (p−1) ZQ− r η2|w|p−2hADmw, Dmwi. Taking advantage of DmW=p 2|w|p 2−1Dmw, for W=w|w|p 2−1, the previous equation rewrites as I1=4(p−1) p2ZQ− r η2hADmW, DmWi+4 pZQ− r ηW hADmW, Dmηi.(3.2.5) 70 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS We now take care of the term I2in (3.2.4). We first notice that Y(W) = p 2|w|p 2−1Y(w), which, together with the divergence theorem and the identity Y(W2η2) = 2ηW2Y(η) + 2η2WY (W), yields I2=2 pZQ− r ηW2Y(η).(3.2.6) Thus, combining (3.2.5) and (3.2.6), we can rewrite identity (3.2.3) as 0 = 4(p−1) p2ZQ− r η2hADmW, DmWi+4 pZQ− r ηW hADmW, Dmηi +2 pZQ− r ηW2Y(η) + ZQ− r η2w|w|p−2(f(x)−cr). Now, setting ε=p−1 2pand using the estimate η|W||hADmW, Dmηi| ≤ εη2hADmW, DmWi+W2 4εhADmη, Dmηi, we finally obtain 2(p−1) p2ZQ− r η2hADmW, DmWi ≤2 (p−1) ZQ− r W2hADmη, Dmηi+2 pZQ− r W2η|Y(η)|+ZQ− r|f−cr|η2|W|2(p−1) p ≤2 (p−1) ZQ− r W2hADmη, Dmηi+2 pZQ− r W2η|Y(η)| +|Q− r|eω(f;r)1 |Q− r|ZQ− r η2p0|W|2p0(p−1) p1 p0 ≤2 (p−1) ZQ− r W2hADmη, Dmηi+2 pZQ− r W2η|Y(η)| +|Q− r|eω(f;r)1 |Q− r|ZQ− r η2p0|W|21 p0. (3.2.7) where p0is such that 1 p+1 p0= 1. The thesis follows by making a suitable choice of the function ηin (3.2.7). More precisely, we set η(x, t) = χ(k(x, 0)kK)χt(t) 71 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS where χ∈C∞([0,+∞)) is the cut-off function defined by χ(s) = (0,if s≥r, 1,if 0 ≤s≤ρ, |χ0| ≤ 2 r−ρ, and χt∈C∞((−∞,0] is defined by χt(s) = (0,if s≤ −r2, 1,if −ρ2≤s≤0,|χ0 t| ≤ 2 r−ρ, with r 2≤ρ < r. We observe that |Y η| ≤ c1 r2κ+1 r−ρ,|∂xjη| ≤ c2 r−ρfor j= 1, . . . , m0, where c1and c2are dimensional constants. Then, accordingly to (3.2.7), we finally obtain 2(p−1) p2ZQ− ρ|DmW|2 ≤2 (p−1) c2 2 (r−ρ)2ZQ− r W2+2 pc1 r2κ+1 r−ρZQ− r W2 +|Q− r|eω(f;r)1 |Q− r|ZQ− r η2p0|W|21 p0 and this concludes the proof. 3.3 Pointwise estimates for the Kolmogorov equation This section is the core of the chapter and it is devoted to prove our main result, Theorem 3.1.2. Since the proof is rather convoluted, we have decomposed it in intermediate results proved in Subsection 3.3.1, which will be combined in Subsection 3.3.2 in order to give a simpler proof of Theorem 3.1.2. 3.3.1 Preliminary estimates The following result is a useful tool in order to prove Lemma 3.3.3 below, as it allows us to rescale the Lp-norm of a given polynomial from a cylider of radius r(for a large r) to a unit cylider. Lemma 3.3.1 (Larger cylider/smaller cylider).The following statements hold: (i) there exists a constant C2=C2(p, Q)>0s.t. for every polynomial P∈e P, for any 72 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS r≥1it holds 1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|P|p1 p ≤C2 ZQ− 1|P|p!1 p ; (ii) there exists a constant e C2=e C2(p, Q)>0s.t. for every polynomial P∈e P, for any r < 1it holds ZQ− 1|P|p!1 p ≤e C21 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|P|p1 p . Proof. We only carry out the proof of assertion (i), since case (ii) is totally analogous. We start by writing the polynomial Pas P(x, t) = a+hb, xi+1 2hcx, xi+d t, where bis a vector in RNsuch that bj= 0 when j > m and cis a N×Nmatrix such that cij = 0 when i > m∨j > m. We moreover recall that Q− r=Br×(−r2,0), where Br={x∈RN:|x|K≤r}, with |·|Kas defined in (1.1.23). Then, owing to k(x, t)kK=|x|K+|t|1/2with in particular |xi| ≤ rfor i= 1 . . . m and |t| ≤ r2, there exists a constant C > 0 s.t. 1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|P|p1 p ≤C|a| r2+|b| r+|c|+|d|.(3.3.1) On the other hand it is possible to show by contradiction that |a|+|b|+|c|+|d| ≤ C ZQ− 1|P|p!1 p .(3.3.2) In order to prove (3.3.2), we first observe that, for a given polynomial P(x, t) = a+hb, xi+ 1 2hcx, xi+d t, it is not restrictive to assume that |a|+|b|+|c|+|d|= 1.(3.3.3) Indeed, if (3.3.3) is not satisfied, it is sufficient to observe that, for a given r > 0, we have ZQ− 1|ra +hrb, xi+1 2hrcx, xi+d rt|p!1 p =r ZQ− 1|a+hb, xi+1 2hcx, xi+d t|p!1 p . (3.3.4) Then the proof for general coefficients (a, b, c, d)6= (0,0,0,0) which do not satisfy (3.3.3) immediately follows by setting r=1 |a|+|b|+|c|+|d|. We are now in a position to prove (3.3.2) by contradiction. Indeed, if (3.3.2) is false, we have that, for every constant K > 0, there exists a polynomial PKwith coefficients 73 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS (aK, bK, cK, dK), that, without loss of generality satisfy (3.3.3), such that 1 = |aK|+|bK|+|cK|+|dK|>1 K ZQ− 1|PK|p!1 p .(3.3.5) Therefore, for K→0+, it follows that while the right hand side of (3.3.5) goes to infinity, the left hand side remains constant. This implies a contradiction, as the sum of the norms of the coefficients of PKwould be both a constant and infinity. The thesis follows by the combination of (3.3.1) and (3.3.2), with r≥1. Remark 3.3.2. We propose an alternative proof of inequality (3.3.2) which does not require a contradiction argument. As a first step, we fix 1 < p < ∞and we observe that the function (a, b, c, d)7→ ZQ− 1|P|p!1 p =: F(a, b, c, d) is continuous and strictly positive in R×RN×RN×N×R. Then, in virtue of Weierstrass’ theorem, Fadmits a strictly positive minimum on the compact set A:= {(a, b, c, d)∈R×RN×RN×N×R:|a|+|b|+|c|+|d|= 1}. The proof for the general case of (a, b, c, d)6= (0,0,0,0) that do not satisfy (3.3.3) follows reasoning as in the proof of Lemma 3.3.1. In particular, (3.3.4) yields F(ra, rb, rc, rd) = rF(a, b, c, d) and we just need to choose r=1 |a|+|b|+|c|+|d|. We now prove the following Lemma. Lemma 3.3.3. (Estimates on larger cylinders) Let ube solution of L0u=fin Q− Rfor R > 2. Then for any ρ∈[1, R/2], there exists a positive constant C1=C1(p, Q)s.t. 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|u−P1|pdx dt1 p≤C1Z4ρ 1 ˆ N(u, f;s) + eω(f;s) sds, (3.3.6) where P1∈ P1is the polynomial realizing the infimum in definition (3.1.9)at level one. Proof. We start working on the left hand side of (3.3.6). Namely, for any ρ≥1 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|u−P1|p1 p ≤1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|u−Pρ|p1 p+1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|Pρ−P1|p1 p=ˆ N(u, f;ρ) + I1.(3.3.7) where in the last line we recalled (3.1.9), and Pρ∈f Pcρis a polynomial realizing the infimum 74 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS in the definition of ˆ N(u, f;·) at the level ρ. We now estimate I1as follows I1≤1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|Pr−P1|p1 p+ k X j=1 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|P2jr−P2j−1r|p1 p=: I2+I3,(3.3.8) where we have written ρ≥1 as ρ= 2krfor an integer k≥1 and r∈[1/2,1). In order to control I2and I3we need to achieve a more general estimate. For an arbitrary γ > 1, for any α∈[1, γ] we have that 1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|Pαr −Pr|p1 p ≤1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|u−Pr|p1 p+1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|u−Pαr|p1 p ≤1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|u−Pr|p1 p+αQ+2+2p p1 (αr)Q+2+2pZQ− αr |u−Pαr|p1 p ≤αQ+2+2p p(ˆ N(u, f;r) + ˆ N(u, f;αr)) ≤γQ+2+2p p(ˆ N(u, f;r) + ˆ N(u, f;αr)).(3.3.9) We take care of I2choosing αr = 1, for r∈h1 γ,1in (3.3.9). Namely, applying both case (i) and (ii) from Lemma 3.3.1, we get I2:= 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|Pr−P1|p1 p≤C2ZQ− 1|P1−Pr|p1 p ≤C1 rQ+2+2pZQ− r|P1−Pr|p1 p≤γQ+2+2p p(ˆ N(u, f;r) + ˆ N(u, f; 1)).(3.3.10) Exploiting again (3.3.9) together with case (i) from Lemma 3.3.1, we infer that for every ρ≥1, which we write as ρ= 2krwith r∈h1 γ,1, there holds I3≤C k X j=1 ˆ N(u, f; 2jr).(3.3.11) Now, collecting bounds (3.3.8), (3.3.10) and (3.3.11), we have that (3.3.7) reads 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|u−P1|p1 p ≤C ˆ N(u, f; 1) + ˆ N(u, f;r) + k X j=1 ˆ N(u, f; 2jr) ,(3.3.12) where C=C(p, Q, γ) is a positive constant. We now want to estimate the right hand side of 75 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS (3.3.12), in particular for any γ > 1 and for α∈[1, γ] it follows that ˆ N(u, f;αr)≤1 (αr)Q+2+2pZQ− αr |u−Pαr|p1 p ≤1 (γr)Q+2+2pZQ− γr |u−Pγr|p1 pγ αQ+2+2p p +1 (αr)Q+2+2pZQ− αr |Pγr −Pαr|p1 p ≤γQ+2+2p pˆ N(u, f;γr) + C2|cαr −cγr| ZQ− 1|P∗|p!1 p (3.3.13) where in the last line we used case (i) of Lemma 3.3.1 and we introduced P∗as a solution to equation L0P∗= 1. In particular, from (3.1.8), we obtain |cαr −cγr|=1 |Q− αr|ZQ− αr |cαr −cγr|p1 p ≤1 |Q− αr|ZQ− αr |f−cαr|p1 p +γQ+2 p 1 |Q− γr|ZQ− γr |f−cγr|p!1 p ≤eω(f;αr) + γQ+2 peω(f;γr)≤2γQ+2 peω(f;γr).(3.3.14) Thus, combining (3.3.14) with (3.3.13) we infer that for any γ > 1 there esists a positive constant Cγ=Cγ(p, Q, γ) s.t. for any α∈[1, γ] it holds ˆ N(u, f;αr)≤Cγˆ N(u, f;γr) + eω(f;γr), eω(f;αr)≤Cγeω(f;γr).(3.3.15) Eventually, putting together (3.3.12) and (3.3.15) and choosing γ= 2 we finally obtain 1 ρQ+2+2pZQ− ρ|u−P1|p1 p≤3C k X j=1 ˆ N(u, f; 2j+1r) + eω(f; 2j+1r) ≤6C k X j=1 ˆ N(u, f; 2j+1r) + eω(f; 2j+1r) 2j+1 2j+2r−2j+1r ≤6CZ4ρ 1 ˆ N(u, f;s) + eω(f;s) sds. As a consequence, we can prove the decay estimate below. Proposition 3.3.4. (Basic decay estimate) Given p∈(1,+∞), there exist constants C0=C0(p, Q)>0and λ=λ(p, Q), µ =µ(p, Q)∈ 76 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS (0,1) such that for every function uand fsatisfying (3.1.1),∀r∈(0,1], the following estimates hold ˆ N(u, f;λ2r, λr)< µ ˆ N(u, f;λr, r)orˆ N(u, f;λ2r, λr)< C0eω(f;λ2r, r).(3.3.16) Proof. The proof is carried out by contradiction. Namely, if (3.3.16) is not true, we can find the sequences Ck→ ∞, rk∈(0,1], λk→0 and µk→1 such that ˆ N(uk, fk;λ2 krk, λkrk)≥µkˆ N(uk, fk;λkrk, rk) (3.3.17) ˆ N(uk, fk;λ2 krk, λkrk)≥Ckeω(fk;λ2 krk, rk),(3.3.18) where (fk)kand (uk)ksatisfy (3.1.1). Let us consider ρk∈[λ2 krk, λkrk] such that, according to (3.1.10) ˆ N(uk, fk;λ2 krk, λkrk) = ˆ N(uk, fk;ρk) =: εk.(3.3.19) Moreover, owing to (1.1.13), we define the rescaled functions vk(x, t) = uk(δρk(x, t)) ρ2 k and wk(x, t) = uk(δρk(x, t)) −Pk(δρk(x, t)) εkρ2 k (3.3.20) where Pk∈ Pcρkis the homogeneous polynomial realizing the infimum at the level ρk. Now we want to control wkin order to pass to the limit. We first notice that inf P∈P ZQ− 1|wk−P|p1 p= 1.(3.3.21) Indeed, first exploiting the definition of wkin (3.3.20) and then using the change of variables y=δ0 ρk(x), s =ρ2 kt, owing to (1.1.14), we infer inf P∈P ZQ− 1|wk−P|p1 p = inf P∈P ZQ− 1 uk(δ0 ρk(x), ρ2 kt)−Pk(δ0 ρk(x), ρ2 kt)−εkρ2 kP(x, t) εkρ2 k p dx dt1/p =1 εk inf P∈P 1 ρQ+2+2p kZQ− ρkuk(y, s)−Pk(y, s)−εkρ2 kPδ0 1 ρk (y),1 ρ2 k s p dy ds1/p. Now, since L0(Pk+εkρ2 kP) = L0Pk+εkρ2 kL0P=cρkby (3.1.4) and (3.1.5), the identity (3.3.21) follows from (3.3.19). 77 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS Remark 3.3.10. We observe that Proposition 3.3.9 holds, more generally, for two functions Nand ωsatisfying the assumptions of Proposition 3.3.5. 3.3.2 Proof of Theorem 3.1.2 (i) We first observe that from definitions (3.1.9) and (3.1.7), it holds that e N(u;r)≤ˆ N(u, f;r).(3.3.42) The right hand side of (3.3.42) can be estimated combining (3.3.31) with (3.3.32), which yields for r∈(0, λ] N(r)≤C N(1) + 1 µsup ρ∈(0,1] ω(ρ)!, where we recall that Nand ωwere defined respectively in (3.1.12) and (3.1.13). Moreover owing to the motonicity-type estimate (3.3.15) for γ=1 λand r∈(0,1] ˆ N(u, f;r)≤C ˆ N(u, f; 1) + sup ρ∈(0,1] eω(f;ρ)!, with C=C(λ, µ, p, Q). On the other hand, from definition (3.1.9) we get ˆ N(u, f; 1) ≤CkukLp(Q− 1)+kfkLp(Q− 1). Therefore, combining the estimates above, we conclude the proof of statement (i). (ii) Assertion (ii) follows directly from estimate (3.3.31). (iii) We observe that Proposition 3.3.5 with N≡ˆ Nand ω≡eωyields statement (iii). (iv) We recall that we have already proved estimate (3.1.16) in the case where P0∈e P, according to Proposition 3.3.9 and namely to (3.3.41). Furthermore, we notice that the coefficients of P0are bounded by choosing ρ=λ 4in (3.3.41). Therefore it is only left to show that P0belongs in particular to P, i.e. P0satisfies equation L0P0= 0. To this end, we define the function uε(x, t) = u(δε(x, t)) −P0(δε(x, t)) ε2 which converges in Lpto a function v≡0 by (3.3.41) for ε→0. Moreover from L0(uε) = ε2L0u(δε(x, t)) ε2−ε2L0P0(δε(x, t)) ε2 =f(δε(x, t)) −L0P0(δε(x, t)) 84 CHAPTER 3. POINTWISE ESTIMATES FOR KOLMOGOROV EQUATIONS and according to (3.2.1), it follows that for ε→0, 0 = L0v=f(0) −L0P0. Since by assumption f(0) = 0, then we have showed that P0satisfies equation L0P0= 0. This concludes the proof. 85 Part II Rough coefficients 86 The second part of this dissertation is devoted to the study of the regularity of weak solutions to Kolmogorov-type equations with rough coefficients. The study of the regularity theory of degenerate Kolmogorov equations in divergence form with discontinuous coefficients has been an open problem for decades. Indeed, such an investigation started only at the end of the 1990s with [24,83,103,104] and is nowadays the main focus of the research community. Starting from the aforementioned papers, where vanishing-mean-oscillations (VMO) diffusion coefficients were considered, the weak regularity theory for Kolmogorov operators was developed in at least the following four directions. Moser iteration. As far as rough coefficients aij’s are concerned, Pascucci and Polidoro proved in [99] that weak (sub)-solutions are locally bounded from above. Later on, Cinti, Pascucci and Polidoro extended this result to the non-dilation invariant case (see [32]). The non-dilation invariant case with lower order coefficients and positive divergence was eventually addressed by Anceschi, Polidoro and Ragusa in [9]). Poincar´e inequality and H¨older regularity. A weak Poincar´e inequality and the H¨older continuity of weak solutions were proved by Wang and Zhang in [117] for the dilationinvariant case and in [116] for the non-dilation invariant one. Related results have been recently proved in a rather new functional setting by Armstrong and Mourrat (see [3]) for the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation ∆pu(p, y, t) = hp, Dyu(p, y, t)i+∂tu(p, y, t),(II.1) where u:Rm×Rm×R→R. Very recently, Litsgard and Nystrom in [78] took advantage of the same functional setting of [3] to prove existence and uniqueness of solutions to the Cauchy Dirichlet problem associated to equation (II.1) with rough coefficients. Harnack inequality. Prior to this dissertation, the only results in this weak framework have been established in the particular case of the kinetic Fokker-Planck operator (II.1). In particular, Golse, Imbert, Mouhot and Vasseur proved the H¨older continuity and a Harnack inequality for weak solutions to the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation (see [49]). The Harnack inequality established in [49] is quite a remarkable result as it comes more than sixty years after the analogous one for uniformly parabolic equations. The reason for this delay lies in the fact that we the classical regularity techniques cannot be applied to degenerate equations like the one in (II.1). To overcome this technical difficulty, the authors of [49] adopted an approach based on velocity averaging method. Based on the results of [49], Anceschi, Eleuteri and Polidoro established a geometric statement for the Harnack inequality (see [6]). More recently, a weak Harnack inequality for kinetic Fokker-Planck equations with essentially bounded coefficients was proved by Guerand and Imbert in [51]. Moreover, in [52], Guerand and Mouhot gave new proofs of weak Harnack and Harnack inequalities, as 87 well as the De Giorgi intermediate-value lemma. Finally, it is worth mentioning the recent preprint [42], where a weak Harnack inequality for hypoelliptic equations including (II.1) was derived. Gaussian bounds for the fundamental solution. An upper bound for the fundamental solution of Kolmogorov-type operators with measurable bounded coefficients is obtained by Pascucci and Polidoro in [98] and by Lanconelli and Pascucci [71] adapting Aronson’s method. Moreover, starting from the invariant Harnack inequality in [49], Lanconelli, Pascucci and Polidoro proved Gaussian bounds for the fundamental solution of (II.1). In the next chapters, we aim at developing the study of the weak regularity theory for Kolmogorov operators even further. The results we present here are part of a project which started in 2021. The project emerged from the scientific collaboration with Anceschi. The final aim of the project was to provide a complete characterization of the De Giorgi-Nash- Moser weak regularity theory in a suitable functional space for very general Kolmogorov equations of the form Lu(x, t) : = m0 X i,j=1 ∂xiaij(x, t)∂xju(x, t)+ N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t) + m0 X i=1 bi(x, t)∂iu(x, t) + c(x, t)u(x, t) = f(x, t), (II.2) where z= (x, t) = (x1, . . . , xN, t)∈RN+1 and 1 ≤m0≤N. More precisely, in Chapter 4, we prove a Harnack inequality and the H¨older continuity for weak solutions to the Kolmogorov equation (II.2) with measurable coefficients, integrable lower order terms and nonzero source term. We then introduce a functional space W, suitable for the study of weak solutions to Lu=f, that allows us to prove a weak Poincar´e inequality. Our analysis is based on a weak Harnack inequality, a weak Poincar´e inequality combined with an L2−L∞estimate and a classical covering argument (Ink-Spots Theorem). The results we present in Chapter 4are contained in the paper [11]. As a second step, we then prove the existence of a fundamental solution associated to the Kolmogorov equation Lu=f, with bounded measurable coefficients. Finally, we prove Gaussian upper and lower bounds for the fundamental solution, and other related properties. These results will be presented in Chapter 5and are the content of the recent paper [12]. 88 Chapter 4 De Giorgi-Nash regularity theory 4.1 Motivation This chapter is devoted to the study of the De Giorgi-Nash-Moser regularity theory for weak solutions to the second order partial differential equation of Kolmogorov-type of the form Lu(x, t) : = m0 X i,j=1 ∂xiaij(x, t)∂xju(x, t)+ N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t) + m0 X i=1 bi(x, t)∂iu(x, t) + c(x, t)u(x, t) = f(x, t), (4.1.1) where z= (x, t) = (x1, . . . , xN, t)∈RN+1 and 1 ≤m0≤N. In particular, following the lines of [11], we prove a Harnack inequality and the H¨older continuity for weak solutions to equation (4.1.1) under the hypotheses (H1)-(H2)-(H3) listed below. First of all, we require that the matrices A0= (aij(x, t))i,j=1,...,m0and B= (bij)i,j=1,...,N satisfy the following structural assumption. (H1) The matrix A0is symmetric with real measurable entries. Moreover, there exist two positive constants λand Λ such that λ|ξ|2≤ m0 X i,j=1 aij(x, t)ξiξj≤Λ|ξ|2(4.1.2) for every (x, t)∈RN+1 and ξ∈Rm0. The matrix B has constant entries. In order to state assumption (H2), let us consider the principal part operator L0u(x, t) := m0 X i=1 ∂2 xiu(x, t) + N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t) = ∆m0u(x, t) + Y u(x, t), (4.1.3) 89 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY where (x, t)∈RN+1 and, as usual, Y u denotes the Lie derivative introduced in (1.1.5). Operator L0in (4.1.3) belongs to the class of constant-coefficients operators we introduced in Chapter 1, Section 1.1. In particular, it is known that, if the matrix Btakes the block form (1.1.12), then L0is hypoelliptic and invariant with respect to a certain family of dilations. In the sequel, we will therefore rely on the following assumption. (H2) The principal part operator L0of Lis hypoelliptic and homogeneous of degree 2 with respect to the family of dilations (δr)r>0introduced in (1.1.13). In the following of this chapter, we will therefore assume that Bhas the canonical form (1.1.12) and we will also make use of the following notation, which allows us to introduce a compact formulation for operator L. More precisely, here and in the sequel D= (∂x1, . . . , ∂xN),h·,·i,div respectively denote the gradient, the inner product and the divergence in RN. In addition, Dm0= (∂x1, . . . , ∂xm0),divm0 denote as usual the partial gradient and the partial divergence in the first m0components, respectively. Moreover, we introduce the matrix A(x, t) = (aij(x, t))1≤i,j≤N, where aij, for every i, j = 1, . . . , m0, are the coefficients appearing in (4.1.1), while aij ≡0 whenever i > m0or j > m0, and we let b(x, t) := (b1(x, t), . . . , bm0(x, t),0,...,0) .(4.1.4) Now, we are able to rewrite operator Lin the following compact form Lu= div(ADu) + Y u +hb, Dui+cu. (4.1.5) We are now in a position to state our assumption on the integrability of b,cand of the source term fin terms of the homogeneous dimension defined in (1.1.17). (H3) c, f ∈Lq loc(Ω), with q > Q+2 2, and b∈(L∞ loc(Ω))m0. 4.1.1 Main results In order to expose our main results, we first need to introduce some preliminary notation. From now on, we consider a set Ω = Ωm0×ΩN−m0+1 of RN+1, where Ωm0is a bounded Lipschitz domain of Rm0and ΩN−m0+1 is a bounded Lipschitz domain of RN−m0+1. This 90 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY is not restrictive since the cylinders Qthat we consider in our local analysis (see (4.1.12)) satisfy the Lipschitz boundary assumption. Then we split the coordinate x∈RNas x=x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), x(0) ∈Rm0, x(j)∈Rmj, j ∈ {1, . . . , κ},(4.1.6) where we have that in accordance with the scaling of the differential equation (see (1.1.13)) every mjis a positive integer such that κ X j=1 mj=Nand N≥m0≥m1≥. . . ≥mκ≥1. We denote by D(Ω) the set of C∞functions compactly supported in Ω and by D0(Ω) the set of distributions in Ω. From now on, H1 x(0) denotes the Sobolev space of functions u∈L2(Ωm0) with distribution gradient Dm0ulying in (L2(Ωm0))m0, i.e. H1 x(0) := u∈L2(Ωm0) : Dm0u∈(L2(Ωm0))m0, and we set kuk2 H1 x(0) := kuk2 L2(Ωm0)+kDm0uk2 L2(Ωm0). We let H1 0denote the closure of C∞ c(Ωm0) in the norm of H1 x(0) and we recall that C∞ c(Ωm0) is dense in H1 x(0) since Ωm0is a bounded Lipschitz domain by assumption. Moreover, H1 0is a reflexive Hilbert space and thus we may consider its dual space H1 0∗=H−1 x(0) and H−1 x(0) ∗=H1 0, where the notation we consider is the classical one. Hence, from now on we denote by H−1 x(0) the dual of H1 0acting on functions in H1 0through the duality pairing h·,·i := h·,·iH1 x(0) ,H1 0. In a standard manner, see for instance [3,78], we let Wdenote the closure of C∞(Ω) in the norm kuk2 W=kuk2 L2ΩN−m0+1;H1 x(0) +kY uk2 L2ΩN−m0+1;H−1 x(0) ,(4.1.7) where the previous norm can be explicitly computed as follows: kuk2 W=ZΩN−m0+1 ku(·, y, t)k2 H1 x(0) dy dt +ZΩN−m0+1 kY u(·, y, t)k2 H−1 x(0) dy dt, where y= (x(1), . . . , x(κ)). In particular, Wis a Banach space and we remark that the dual of L2(ΩN−m0+1;H1 0) satisfies L2(ΩN−m0+1;H1 0)∗=L2(ΩN−m0+1;H−1 0) and L2(ΩN−m0+1;H−1 0)∗=L2(ΩN−m0+1;H1 0). 91 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY From now on, we consider the shorthand notation L2H−1to denote L2ΩN−m0+1;H−1 0. The space of functions Wis the most natural framework for the study of the weak regularity theory for operator L. Still, to the best of our knowledge it has never been considered in literature in the ultraparabolic setting. In particular, it is an extension of the functional setting firstly formally proposed by Armstrong and Mourrat in [3] for the study of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation, that can be recovered from (4.1.1) by choosing N= 2d, κ= 1, m0=m1=dand c≡0. We refer the reader to Subsection 4.1.2 for an overview on the existing literature. We refer to [78, Section 2] for some properties of the space W. Lastly, we remark that the major issue when dealing with the space Wis that it requires to handle the duality pairing between L2H1and L2H−1. To this end, we take advantage of the following remark, see [65, Chapter 4]. Remark 4.1.1. For every open subset A⊂Rnand for every function g∈H−1(A) there exist two functions H0,H1∈L2(A) such that g= divm0H1+H0and kH0kL2(A)+kH1kL2(A)≤2kgkH−1(A). Now, we introduce the definition of weak solutions we consider in this dissertation. Definition 4.1.2. A function u∈ W is a weak solution to (4.1.1) with source term f∈L2(Ω) if for every non-negative test function ϕ∈ D(Ω), we have ZΩ−hADu, Dϕi−uY ϕ +hb, Duiϕ+cuϕ =ZΩ fϕ. (4.1.8) In the sequel, we will also consider weak sub-solutions to (4.1.1), namely functions u∈ W that satisfy the following inequality ZΩ−hADu, Dϕi−uY ϕ +hb, Duiϕ+cuϕ (≤) ≥ZΩ fϕ, (4.1.9) for every non-negative test function ϕ∈ D(Ω). A function uis a super-solution to (4.1.1) if it satisfies (4.1.9) with (≤). As mentioned above, the aim of this chapter is to prove the local H¨older continuity and a Harnack inequality for solutions to (4.1.1) in the sense of Definition 4.1.2. Our method is based on the combination of three fundamental ingredients - boundedness of weak solutions, weak Poincar´e inequality and Log-transformation - in the same spirit of the recent paper [51] for the Fokker-Planck equation. First, we carry out a local study with Q0at unit scale. For some reasons we expose below in Section 4.5,Q0takes the form BR0×BR0×. . .×BR0×(−1,0] for some large constant R0only depending on the dimension Qand on the ellipticity constants λ, Λ in (H1). 92 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY As we rely on the Lie group structure associated to operator L0in (4.1.3), the suitable geometry when dealing with operator Lis given by the non-Euclidean structure defined in (1.1.6). Our results naturally reflect this non-Euclidean setting. Here and in the following of the chapter, we denote by Q1and e Q1the unit past cylinders Q1:= B1×B1×. . . ×B1×(−1,0), e Q1:= B1×B1×. . . ×B1×(−1,0],(4.1.10) defined through the open balls B1={x(j)∈Rmj:|x| ≤ 1},(4.1.11) where j= 0, . . . , κ and |·|denotes the euclidean norm in Rmj. Now, for every z0∈RN+1 and r > 0, we set Qr(z0) := z0◦(δr(Q1)) = {z∈RN+1 :z=z0◦δr(ζ), ζ ∈ Q1},(4.1.12) where “◦00 denote the composition law introduced in (1.1.6) and (δr)r>0the family of dilations defined in (1.1.13). Moreover, we introduce Q+=δωe Q1=Bω×Bω3×. . . ×Bω2κ+1 ×(−ω2,0] and e Q−= (0,...,0,−1 + 2ρ2)◦δρ(Q1) = Bρ×Bρ3×. . . ×Bρ2κ+1 ×(−1 + ρ2,−1 + 2ρ2). We are now in a position to state one of our main results, namely the following Harnack inequality. Figure 4.1: Geometric setting of the Harnack inequality for the degenerate kinetic Kolmogorov operator. The radius ωis small enough to ensure that, when stacking cylinders over a small one contained in Q−, the future cylinder Q+is captured, see Lemma 4.B.1 and Figure 4.B. On the other hand, the radius R0of Q0is large enough to allow us to apply Lemma 4.5.8 to every stacked cylinder. 93 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY 4.2.2. Since we have b∈(Lq(Ω))m0and v∈L2(Ω), we get |Γ(z, ·)||ϕ||b||Dv| ∈ L2α(Ω), where α=α(q) = q(Q+ 2) q(Q−2) + 2(Q+ 2) >1 if and only if q > Q+ 2 2. Hence, |hb, D (Γ(z, ·)ϕψε(z, ·))iv| ≤ |hb, D (Γ(z, ·)ϕ)iv| ∈ L1(Ω). Thus, the Lebesgue convergence theorem yields lim ε→0+I4,ε(z) = lim ε→0+−ZΩ [hb, D (Γ(z, ·)ϕψε(z, ·))iv](ζ)dζ =ZΩ [hb, DΓ(z, ·)ϕiv](ζ)dζ. Similarly, we can estimate the term I5,ε noting that |c||v||Γ(z, ·)||ϕ| ∈ L2α(Ω) with αas above. As a consequence, we have |cvΓ(z, ·)ϕψε(z, ·)| ≤ |cvΓ(z, ·)ϕ| ∈ L1(Ω),thus lim ε→0+I5,ε(z) = ZΩ [cvΓ(z, ·)ϕ](ζ)dζ. Now, we are left with the estimate of term I6,ε, which is again a Γ-potential such that |Γ(z, ·)||ϕ||f| ∈ L2κ(Ω), where κ=Q+2 Q−2. Thus, we infer |Γ(z, ·)ϕψε(z, ·)f| ≤ |Γ(z, ·)ϕf| ∈ L1(Ω). Therefore we conclude the proof by applying the dominated convergence theorem to I6,ε(z). We conclude this section by recalling the following lemma, for the proof of which we refer to [32, Lemma 6]. Lemma 4.2.4. There exists a positive constant c∈(0,1) such that z◦Qc(r−ρ)⊆ Qr,for every 0< ρ < r ≤1and z∈ Qρ.(4.2.6) Remark 4.2.5. We recall that for every cylinder Qr(z0) defined in (4.1.12) there exists a positive constant c[117, equation (21)] such that Br1(x(0) 0)×Br3 1(x(1) 0)×. . . ×Br2κ+1 1(x(κ) 0)×(t0−r2 1, t0] ⊂ Qr(z0)⊂Br2(x(0) 0)×Br3 2(x(1) 0)×. . . ×Br2κ+1 2(x(κ) 0)×(t0−r2 2, t0], where r1=r/cand r2=cr. From now on, by abuse of notation we will sometimes consider the newly introduced ball representation instead of the definition of cylinder in (4.1.12). 100 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY 4.3 Local boundedness for weak solutions to Lu=f This section is devoted to the proof of the local boundedness of weak solutions to (4.1.1). As pointed out in Section 4.1, we provide the reader with the full computations because the functional framework considered here is weaker than the one proposed in the already existing literature, see [9,32,99,118]. The procedure we follow here was first introduced by Moser in [88] and it is based on the iterative combination of a Caccioppoli and a Sobolev inequality. When dealing with the classical uniformly elliptic and parabolic settings, the Caccioppoli inequality provides us with an a priori estimate for the L2norm of the complete gradient of the solution in terms of the L2norm of the solution. This allows us to consider the classical Sobolev embedding to obtain a gain of integrability for the solution. This is not the case when dealing with operator (4.1.1). Indeed, the degeneracy of the diffusion part allows us to estimate only the partial gradient Dm0uof the solution to Lu=f (see Theorem 4.3.4). In addition, according to our definition of weak solution, udoes not lie in a classical Sobolev space. In order to overcome these issues, we adopt a technique based on the representation of a solution uto Lu=fin terms of the fundamental solution Γ (see (1.1.31)) of the principal part operator L0. Indeed, following the idea presented for the first time in [99] and later on applied in [9,32,118], we have that if uis a solution to Lu=f, then L0u= (L0−L)u+f= divm0((Im0−A)Dm0u) + f. (4.3.1) Hence, as pointed out at [99, p. 396], it seems quite natural to consider a representation formula in terms of the fundamental solution of the principal part operator L0”[...] since the classical Sobolev inequality can be proved by representing any function u∈H1as a convolution with the fundamental solution of the Laplace operator.” Theorem 4.3.1. Let z0∈Ωand 0<r 2≤ρ < r ≤1, be such that Qr(z0)⊆Ω. Let ube a nonnegative weak solution to Lu=fin Ωunder assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(M). Then for every p≥1there exists two positive constants C=Cp, λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr(z0)),kckLq(Qr(z0)), such that sup Qρ(z0) up l≤C (r−ρ)Q+2 βkup lkLβ(Qr(z0)), where β=q q−1,qintroduced in (M) and ul:= u+kfkLq(QR). The same statement holds true if uis a non-negative weak sub-solution to (4.1.1)for p≥1; if uis a non-negative weak super-solution to (4.1.1)for 0< p < 1 2. In particular, by choosing p= 1, for every sub-solution to (4.1.1)it holds sup Qρ(z0) u≤C (r−ρ)Q+2 βkukLβ(Qr(z0)) +kfkLq(Qr), In literature, we find various proofs of the Moser’s iterative scheme for a Kolmogorov 101 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY operator of the type L, see for instance [32,99,118]. Nevertheless, the functional framework proposed in those works is stronger than ours. Remark 4.3.2. Theorem 4.3.1 holds true under the assumptions of [118], see Subsection 4.1.2. In particular, in this case, the constant αis replaced by α= 1 + 2 Q, that was firstly obtained in [99]. This is due the fact that the Sobolev inequality, Theorem 4.3.3, holds true with a greater exponent if we assume more integrability for the coefficient b. Thus, this allows us to obtain the local boundedness for weak solutions to Lu=fwith lower integrability for cand f, i.e. c, f ∈Lq(Ω), with q > Q+2 2. Finally, Theorem 4.3.1 holds true also for weak sub and super solutions, but not for the same values of the exponent p. This is due to the technique adopted for the proof of the Caccioppoli-type inequality (Theorem 4.3.4), see also [99, Remark 1.3], and it is a classical feature of all the local boundedness results appearing in the existing literature, see for instance [99,118]. 4.3.1 Sobolev-type Inequality This subsection is devoted to the proof of a Sobolev-type inequality for weak solutions to Lu=f. Our approach is inspired by the paper [99] and allows us to construct an “ad hoc” Sobolev embedding for weak solutions to Lu=fby overcoming the difficulties due to the degeneracy of the second order part of L. However, the disadvantage of this method is that we are forced to lower the Sobolev exponent, that in our case depends on qand it is defined as α:= q(Q+ 2) q(Q−2) + 2(Q+ 2).(4.3.2) We remark that the following statement holds true under lower integrability assumption than the one required in (H3). Theorem 4.3.3. Let (H1)-(H2) hold. Let c∈Lq(Ω),b∈(Lq(Ω))m0for some q > Q+2 2with div b≥0and let f∈L2(Ω). Let vbe a non-negative weak sub-solution of Lv=fin Q1. Then there exists a constant C=C(Q, λ, Λ) >0such that v∈L2α(Q1), and the following inequality holds kvkL2α(Qρ(z0))≤CkbkLq(Qr(z0)) +r−ρ+ 1 r−ρkDm0vkL2(Qr(z0)) + +CkckLq(Qr(z0)) +ρ+ 1 ρ(r−ρ)kvkL2(Qr(z0)) +CkfkL2(Qr(z0)) for every ρ, r with 1 2≤ρ < r ≤1and for every z0∈Ω, where α=α(q)is defined as (4.3.2). The same statement holds for non-negative super-solutions. Proof. Let vbe a non-negative weak sub-solution to Lv=f. We represent vin terms of the fundamental solution Γ. To this end, we consider the cut-off function χρ,r defined in (4.2.5) 102 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY for 1 2≤ρ < r ≤1. Then, if we consider the test function ψ(x, t) = χρ,r(k(x, t)k),(4.3.3) the following estimates hold true |Y ψ| ≤ c0 ρ(r−ρ),|∂xjψ| ≤ c1 r−ρfor j= 1, . . . , m0(4.3.4) where c0,c1are dimensional constants. For every z∈ Qρ, we have v(z) = vψ(z) = ZQr [hIm0D(vψ), DΓ(z, ·)i−Γ(z, ·)Y(vψ)] (ζ)d(ζ) (4.3.5) =I0(z) + I1(z) + I2(z) + I3(z) where I0(z) = ZQr [hb, DviΓ(z, ·)ψ] (ζ)dζ +ZQr [cvΓ(z, ·)ψ] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [Γ(z, ·)ψf](ζ)dζ I1(z) = ZQr [hIm0Dψ, DΓ(z, ·)iv] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [Γ(z, ·)vY ψ] (ζ)dζ =I0 1+I00 1, I2(z) = ZQr [h(Im0−A)Dv, DΓ(z, ·)iψ] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [Γ(z, ·)hADv, Dψi] (ζ)dζ I3(z) = ZQr [hADv, D(Γ(z, ·)ψ)i] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [(Γ(z, ·)ψ)Y v] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [hb, DviΓ(z, ·)ψ] (ζ)dζ −ZQr [cvΓ(z, ·)ψ] (ζ)dζ +ZQr [Γ(z, ·)ψf](ζ)dζ. Since vis a non-negative weak sub-solution to Lv=f, it follows from Lemma 4.2.3 that I3≤0, then 0≤v(z)≤I0(z) + I1(z) + I2(z) for a.e. z∈ Qρ. To prove our claim is sufficient to estimate vby a sum of Γ−potentials. We start by estimating I0. In order to do so, we recall that hb, Dvi, cv ∈L2q q+2 for b, c ∈Lq, q > Q+ 2 2and v∈L2. Thus by Corollary 4.2.2 we get Γ∗hb, Dvi,Γ∗(cv)∈L2α, where α=α(q) is defined in (4.3.2). In addition, for f∈L2, we have Γ∗f∈L2κ, κ =Q+ 2 Q−2. 103 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY Observing that κ > α, we obtain that Γ ∗f∈L2αand therefore kI0(ζ)kL2α(Qr)≤Γ∗(hb, Dm0viψ) + Γ ∗(cvψ)kL2α(Qr)+kΓ∗fkL2α(Qr) ≤C·kbkLq(Qr)kDm0vkL2(Qr)+kckLq(Qr)kvkL2(Qr)+kfkL2(Qr). We now deal with the I1.I0 1can be estimated by (4.2.3) of Corollary 4.2.2 as follows kI0 1kL2α(Qρ)≤CkI0 1kL2∗(Qρ)≤CkvDm0ψkL2(RN+1)≤C r−ρkvkL2(Qr), where the last inequality follows from (4.3.4). To estimate I00 1we use (4.2.2) kI00 1kL2α(Qρ)≤CkI00 1kL2∗(Qρ)≤meas(Qρ)2/Q kI00 1kL2∗∗(Qr) ≤CkvY ψ kL2(RN+1)≤C ρ(r−ρ)kvkL2(Qr). We can use the same technique to prove that kI2kL2α(Qρ)≤C1 + 1 r−ρkDv kL2(Qρ), for some constant C=C(Q, λ, Λ). A similar argument proves the thesis when vis a supersolution to Lv=f. In this case we introduce the following auxiliary operator L0= ∆m0+e Y , e Y≡ −hx, BDi−∂t.(4.3.6) Then we proceed analogously as in [99], Section 3, proof of Theorem 3.3. 4.3.2 Caccioppoli-type inequality As a second step, we prove a Caccioppoli-type inequality for powers of non-negative subsolutions to Lu=f. In order to introduce the auxiliary function ulthat will play a relevant role in the proof of the Moser’s iterative scheme, we hereby report the complete proof of this result, which can also be found with zero right-hand side in [9,32,99]. Theorem 4.3.4. Let (H1)-(H2)-(M) hold and ube a non-negative weak sub-solution to Lu=fin Qr, with 0< ρ < r ≤1. For any p∈(1 2,+∞)such that up∈L2(Qr)the following estimate holds 2p−1 pλkDm0up lk2 L2(Qρ)≤c1 (r−ρ)2 p 2p−1 Λ λ+c0 ρ(r−ρ)kup lk2 L2(Qr) +c0 r−ρkbk2 Lq(Qr)+pkck2 Lq(Qr)+pkup lk2 L2β(Qr) where ul=u+kfkLq(Qr),β=β(q) = q q−1, and c0, c1are defined in (4.3.4). 104 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY Proof. Let us consider 0 < ρ < r ≤1 and the test function ψintroduced in (4.3.3). The idea is to test the definition of weak sub-solution (4.1.9) against the test function ϕ=pψ2u2p−1 l,with p≥1 2,and ul:= u+l, where l > 0 is chosen such that l=kfkLq(Qr). For the sake of clarity, from now on we assume uis a bounded weak sub-solution to (4.1.1) such that u∈C∞ c(Qr). This assumption is not restrictive thanks to the definition of the space Wand if uwhere not bounded, then we would consider the test function ϕ=pψ2u2p−1 l,M ,where ul,M = min{ul, M}and let Mgo to infinity. Hence, we test (4.1.9) against ϕas defined above: ZQrhADu, DϕiA≤ − ZQr uY ϕ Y +ZQrhb, Duiϕ B +ZQr cuϕ C−ZQr fϕ F .(4.3.7) We begin estimating the boxed term A: ZQrhADu, Dϕi=p(2p−1) ZQrhADu, Duliu2p−2 lψ2+ 2pZQrhADu, Dψiu2p−1 lψ =2p−1 pZQrhADup l, Dup liψ2+ 2 ZQrhADup l, Dψiup lψ ≥2p−1 pλZQr|Dm0up l|2ψ2−2ZQr|hADup l, Dψi|up lψ ≥2p−1 pλZQr|Dm0up l|2ψ2−Λε1ZQr|Dm0up l|2ψ−1 ε1ZQr|Dm0ψ|2|up l|2ψ where in the first line we considered Dul=Du; in the third line we applied (H1); in the last line we employed Young inequality with ε1>0 that will be chosen later on. Next, we proceed by estimating the boxed term Y: −ZQr uY ϕ Y =−pZQr uY (u2p−1 lψ2) = 1 2ZQr Y u2p lψ2 =−ZQr u2p lY ψ ψ ≤c0 ρ(r−ρ)kup lk2 L2(Qr) where we integrated by parts and we applied estimate (4.3.4) for the derivatives of the function ψ. As far as we are concerned with the term B: ZQrhb, Duiϕ B =pZQrhb, Duliψ2u2p−1 l=1 2ZQrhb, Du2p liψ2 =−1 2ZQr divb u2p lψ2−ZQrhb, Dψiu2p lψ 105 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY ≤ −ZQrhb, Dψiu2p lψ≤c0 (r−ρ)kbkLq(Qr)kup lk2 L2β(Qr) where we applied assumption (M), H¨older’s inequality and we defined β:= q q−1. Lastly, we are left with he estimates of the terms Cand F: ZQr cuϕ C≤pZQr|c||u|ψ2u2p−1 l≤pZQr|c|u2p lψ2≤pkckLq(Qr)kup lk2 L2β(Qr) −ZQr fϕ F≤pZQr|f|u2p−1 lψ2=pZQrCfu2p lψ2≤pkCfkLq(Qr)kup lk2 L2β(Qr)≤pkup lk2 L2β(Qr), where we set Cf=|f| kfkLq(Qr)so that we have |f| ul≤ Cfand kCfkLq(Qr)≤1. By choosing ε1=2p−1 2p2λ Λ, we conclude the proof. 4.3.3 Proof of Theorem 4.3.1 First of all, we consider a weak solution uto (4.1.1) and without loss of generality we assume z0= 0. As in Theorem 4.3.4, we set ul:= u+l=u+kfkLq(Qr)and we remark from now on, lneeds to be regarded as a constant. Our aim is to show there exists a positive constant c only depending on q,Q,λand Λ such that sup Qρ up l≤C (r−ρ)Q+2 βkup lkLβ(Qr).(4.3.8) To this end, we show that it is sufficient to prove that sup Q1 2 up l≤c1kup lkLβ(Q1),(4.3.9) where c1is a constant not depending on r. We briefly explain how to infer (4.3.9) from (4.3.8) and we refer to [32] for further details. Indeed, by Lemma 4.2.4, if we set θ=C(r−ρ) we obtain that (4.3.8) is equivalent to sup Qθ 2 vp≤cQ+2 β θQ+2 βkvpkLβ(Qθ).(4.3.10) Then, we recall that if uθis a solution to Lul= (f+cl) and θ > 0, then we have that v:= u◦δθ+lsolves Lθv=fθ+cθlin Q1, see [32], where Lθv:= Lθu(δθ(z)) = div(AθDu) + hBθx, Dui−∂tu+θhbθ, Dui+θ2cu(z), with Aθ(z) = A(δθ(z)), Bθ=θ2DθBD1 θ,bθ(z) = θb(δθ(z)) , cθ(z) = θ2c(δθ(z)), fθ(z) = θ2f(δθ(z)). Hence, by performing the change of variable w(ζ) = v(z◦δθ(ζ)), with ζ∈ Q1, we 106 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY imply (4.3.9). We are now in a position to address the proof of (4.3.8). First of all, if we set 1 2=ρand r= 1, the following estimates hold 1 (ρ(r−ρ))1 2(r−ρ)≤1 (r−ρ)2,1 ρ(r−ρ)≤1 (r−ρ)2, 1 (ρ(r−ρ))2≤1 (r−ρ)2, r2≤1 (r−ρ)2. (4.3.11) Combining Theorems 4.3.3 and 4.3.4 for a non-negative sub-solution u, we obtain the following estimate. If s > 1, δ > 0 verify the condition s−1 2≥δ, then we have kus lkL2α(Qρ)≤e Cs, λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr)kus lkL2β(Qr),(4.3.12) where e Cis a positive constant that we estimate as follows e C(s, λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr))≤K(λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr))√s (r−ρ)2,(4.3.13) thanks to (4.3.11). Then we set v=u p 2 l. Fixed a suitable δ > 0, that we will specify later on, and a suitable p≥1 such that p 2α βn −1 2≥2δ, ∀n∈N∪{0},(4.3.14) we iterate inequality (4.3.12) by choosing ρn=1 21 + 1 2n, pn=α βnp 2, n ∈N∪{0}. Thus, by combining (4.3.12) and (4.3.13), for every n∈N∪{0}the following holds kv(α β)nkL2α(Qρn+1)≤K(λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr))√p (ρn−ρn+1)2kv(α β)nkL2β(Qρn). From now on we denote K=K(p, λ, Λ, Q, kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr)). Since kv(α β)n kL2κ=kvkL2α(α β)n(α β)n and kv(α β)n kL2β=kvkL2β(α β)n(α β)n 107 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY we are able to rewrite the previous estimate in the following form for every n∈N∪{0} kvkL2α(α β)n (Qρn+1 )≤K√p (ρn−ρn+1)2(β α)n kvkL2β(α β)n (Qρn). Iterating this inequality and letting ngo to infinity, we get sup Qρ v≤e KkvkL2β(Qr),where e K= +∞ Y j=0 hK√p22(j+2)i(β α)j is a finite constant, since the product over jcorresponds to a converging series, only depending on universal quantities Q, and q. This proves inequality (4.3.9) for psatisfying condition (4.3.14). We now make a suitable choice of δ > 0, only dependent on the homogeneous dimension Q, and on qin order to show that (4.3.14) holds for every p≥1. We notice that, if pis a number of the form pm=1 2α βmα β+ 1, m ∈Z, then (4.3.14) is satisfied with the following choice of δfor every m∈Z δ=α−β 8β. Therefore (4.3.9) holds for such a choice of p, with e Konly dependent on Q, q, λ, Λ and kbkLq(Qr),kckLq(Qr). On the other hand, if pis an arbitrary positive number, we consider m∈Zsuch that pm≤p < pm+1 and conclude the proof thanks to the monotonicity of the Lpmeans, see for instance [99]. Hence, the proof is complete.  4.4 Weak Poincar´e inequality This section is devoted to the proof of a weak Poincar´e inequality (see Theorem 4.4.1) for functions u∈ W. As one immediately understands, this Poincar´e inequality is independent of the equation Lu=fand only relies on the structure of the space W. Its importance lies in the fact that it is a crucial tool in the proof of the Harnack inequality (see Theorem 4.1.3) and of the local H¨older continuity (see Theorem 4.1.4) of a solution uto (4.1.1). In order to state our result, we first need to introduce the following sets Qzero ={(x, t) : |xj| ≤ ηαj, j = 1, . . . , N, −1−η2< t ≤ −1},(4.4.1) Qext ={(x, t) : |xj| ≤ 2αjR, j = 1, . . . , N, −1−η2< t ≤0}, 108 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY where R > 1, η∈(0,1) and the exponents αj, for j= 1, . . . , N, are defined in (1.1.18). Thanks to Remark 4.2.5,Qzero and Qext are completely equivalent to (4.1.12), but in this form they are more convenient for the construction of the cut-off function ψ1introduced in Lemma 4.4.3. Now, we state our weak Poincar´e inequality. Theorem 4.4.1 (Weak Poincar´e inequality).Let η∈(0,1) and let Qzero and Qext be defined as in (4.4.1). Then there exist R > 1and ϑ0∈(0,1), that only depend on Qand η, such that for any non-negative function u∈ W such that u≤Min Q1=B1×B1×. . . ×B1×(−1,0) for a positive constant Mand |{u= 0}∩Qzero| ≥ 1 4|Qzero|,(4.4.2) we have k(u−ϑ0M)+kL2(Q1)≤CPkDm0ukL2(Qext)+kY ukL2H−1(Qext),(4.4.3) where C > 0is a constant only depending on Q. Figure 4.2: Geometric setting of the Poincar´e inequality (in the kinetic case). The notation we consider here needs to be understood in the sense of (4.1.7). In particular, we have that L2H−1(Qext) is short for L2(B23R×. . . ×B22κ+1R×(−1−η2,0], H−1 x(0) (B2R)),(4.4.4) where we split x=x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ)according to (4.1.6). A Poincar´e inequality was already introduced by Wang and Zhang specifically for strong weak sub-solutions of ultraparabolic equations, i.e. u∈L2H1and Y u ∈L2, in the preprint [116, Lemmata 3.3 and Lemma 3.4] and the corresponding lemmata in [117]. This statement differs from our weak Poincar´e inequality in three substantial aspects. First, the result we present here holds true for function ubelonging to the space W, and thus does not require the additional assumption for uto be a weak sub-solution to (4.1.1). Secondly, in our setting the transport operator Y u is merely assumed to be in L2H−1. Finally, the proof we propose here differs from the ones in [116,117], as we avoid using repeatedly the exact form of the 109 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY As Q1⊂RN×(−1−η2,0), the previous inequality implies in particular that P≤PRin Q1. Owing to (4.4.23), we represent Pusing the fundamental solution e Γ of f L0. More precisely, there exists −1−η2≤T0<0 such that P(x, t) = Z0 tZRNe Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)IZ(ξ, τ)dξdτ, for every (x, t)∈RN×(T0,0). In particular, for every (x, t)∈ Q1, there holds P(x, t) = Z0 tZRNe Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)IZ(ξ, τ)dξ dτ =ZZe Γ(x, t;ξ, τ)dξd τ ≥min Q1×Qzero ∩{t≤−1−T}e ΓZZ dξ dτ = min Q1×Qzero ∩{t≤−1−T}e Γ|Qzero ∩{t≤ −1−T}∩{u= 0}| ≥1 8min Q1×Qzero ∩{t≤−1−T}e Γ|Qzero|:= δ0, where in the last line we have used inequality (4.4.19). We remark that the fundamental solution e Γ is bounded from above and below by Gaussian bounds, see for instance [8, Theorem 1.6]. As a consequence, PR≥P≥δ0,in Q1(4.4.24) and claim (4.4.21) is now proved. Using estimates (4.4.22) and (4.4.24) in (4.4.20), we finally obtain h≤1−δ0+C0 R2,in Q1. We now observe that for Rlarge enough we have C0/R2≤δ0/2. Thus, setting ϑ0= 1−δ0/2< 1, we get the desired inequality (4.4.18). We remark that the proof (and therefore the statement) of Lemma 4.4.4 remains unchanged if we replace (4.4.17) with the less restrictive assumption |{u= 0}∩Qzero| ≥ γ0|Qzero| for some constant γ0such that 0 < γ0<1. Proof of Theorem 4.4.1.The proof follows immediately combining Lemmata 4.4.2 and 4.4.4.  4.5 Weak Harnack inequality This section is devoted to the proof of a weak Harnack inequality, an intermediate result necessary to prove Theorem 4.1.3. The approach we present here is an extension of the 116 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY classical method proposed in [68] for the elliptic and parabolic setting, and later on followed by Guerand and Imbert in [51] for the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation. This approach is very convenient for the study of the weak regularity theory, since it only relies on the functional structure of the space Wand on the non-Euclidean geometrical setting presented in Section 4.2. Theorem 4.5.1 (Weak Harnack inequality).Let R0and ωbe two given positive constants. Let Q0=BR0×BR0×. . .×BR0×(−1,0] and let ube a non-negative weak solution to Lu=f in Ω⊃ Q0under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3). Then we have ZQ− up1 p ≤Cinf Q+ u+kfkLq(Q0),(4.5.1) where Q+=Bω×Bω3×. . .×Bω2κ+1 ×(−ω2,0] and Q−=Bω×Bω3×. . .×Bω2κ+1 ×(−1,−1+ω2]. Moreover, the constants C,p,ωand R0only depend on the homogeneous dimension Qdefined in (1.1.17),qand on the ellipticity constants λand Λin (4.1.2). Additionally, if the term c is of positive sign, the statement holds true also for non-negative super-solutions to (4.1.1). Remark 4.5.2. As in [51], the radius ωis small enough so that when “stacking cylinders” over a small initial one contained in Q−, the cylinder Q+is captured, see Lemma 4.B.1. As far as we are concerned with R0, it is large enough so that it is possible to apply the expansion of positivity lemma (see Lemma 4.5.8) to every stacked cylinder. Finally, in order to carry out the proof of Theorem 4.5.1, we also require that the quantity R0/ω is large enough. This condition is due to the fact that we want to apply the expansion of positivity Lemma 4.5.10 to cylinders which are contained in Q−and therefore are of radius smaller than ω. To this end, we need to impose that R0≥Cω, where Cis a constant that only depends on Q, λ and Λ and is explicitly computed in (4.5.16). Remark 4.5.3. Differently from the weak Harnack inequality presented in [51], our statement holds true in general for weak solutions and not for weak super-solutions, hence the claim “Such a weak Harnack inequality can be generalized to the ultraparabolic equations with rough coefficients” stated in [51, Remark 4, p.2] is only partially true. This discrepancy is due to the presence of the lower order term cu in our analysis, which wasn’t considered by the authors of [51]. Indeed, when c≥0 we exactly recover the statement proposed in [51], but if we only consider assumption (H3) we are forced to restrict ourselves to the case of weak solutions. This is mainly due to the methodology we follow to prove the expansion of positivity, Lemma 4.5.8, which is based on our local boundedness result Theorem 4.3.1, that holds true when the right-hand side is in Lq loc, with q > (Q+2) 2. The extension of this result to weak super-solutions to (4.1.1) without any sign assumption on the term cwill be the content of a forthcoming paper. The proof of the weak Harnack inequality is obtained combining the fact that supersolutions to (4.1.1) expand positivity along times (Lemma 4.5.8) with the covering argument presented in Appendix 4.B. 117 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY We observe that, in contrast with parabolic equations, it is not possible to apply a classical Poincar´e inequality in the spirit of [87]. Indeed, in our case there is a positive quantity replacing the average in the usual Poincar´e inequality (see the statement of Theorem 4.4.1). Moreover, the lower order term involving cpresents additional difficulties to the ones already addressed in [51], see Remark 4.5.3 above. We circumvent these difficulties by establishing a weak expansion of positivity result for solutions (respectively, for super-solutions when c≥0) to (4.1.1). More precisely, given a small cylider Qpos lying in the past of Q1(see Definition (4.5.6)), we show that the positivity of a non-negative (super-)solution ulying above 1 in a “big” part of Qpos is spread to the whole Q1(see Lemma 4.5.8). In other words, a positivity in measure in a smaller cylinder Qpos is transformed into a pointwise positivity in a bigger cylinder Q1. First of all, we introduce a convex function whose properties parallel the ones of the less regular function max(0,−ln). Such a function was first constructed by Kruzhkov in [68] and later used in [51,118]. For a proof of its existence we refer the reader to [118, Lemma 5.1]. Definition 4.5.4. Let G: (0,+∞)→(0,+∞) be a non-increasing and C2convex function such that •G00 ≥(G0)2and G0≤0 in (0,+∞), •Gis supported in (0,1], •G(t)∼ −ln tas t→0+, •−G0(t)≤1 tfor t∈(0,1 4], •G(t) = 0 for t≥1. Our first aim is to show that, given a non-negative weak super-solution uto (4.1.1), the function Gtransforms it into a non-negative weak sub-solution to a suitably defined equation. Lemma 4.5.5. Let ε∈0,1 4and ube a non-negative weak super-solution to (4.1.1)under the assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3) in a cylindrical shaped open set Qext =BR0×BR1×. . .× BRκ×(t0, T]⊂Ω, where Ri>0for i= 0, . . . , κ. Then g:= G(u+εγ), for γ > 0, is a non-negative weak-sub-solution to the following equation: div(ADg) + Y g +hb, Dgi−λ|Dm0g|2=−ε−γ|cu −f|.(4.5.2) Proof. We consider g=G(u+εγ), where Gis the convex function defined above. In particular, we have that |G0(u+εγ)|≤|G0(εγ)| ≤ ε−γas uis non-negative and G0(u+εγ)≤0 by assumption. For this reason, we test the definition of super-solution uagainst the function ϕ=−G0(u+εγ)ψ, where ψis a non-negative test function belonging to D(Ω): Z Qext hADu, D(G0(u+εγ)ψ)i−Y u(G0(u+εγ)ψ) 118 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY −hb, Dui(G0(u+εγ)ψ)−cu(G0(u+εγ)ψ) ≤ − Z Qext f(G0(u+εγ)ψ). Now, owing to Dm0g=G0(u+εγ)Dm0uand Y g =G0(u+εγ)Y u, we can rewrite the previous inequality as follows: Z Qext hADg, Dψi−Y g ψ −hb, Dgiψ+Z Qext hADu, DuiG00(u+εγ)ψ ≤Z Qext cuG0(u+εγ)ψ−Z Qext fG0(u+εγ)ψ. Hence, we are left with the estimate of the terms appearing on the right-hand side. Let us begin with the first one: Z Qext hADu, DuiG00(u+εγ)ψ≥λZ Qext hDm0u, Dm0ui(G0(u+εγ))2ψ=λZ Qext |Dm0g|2ψ, where we employed assumption (H1) and G00(u+εγ)≥(G0(u+εγ))2. As far as we are concerned with the second and third term, we observe that Z Qext cuG0(u+εγ)ψ−Z Qext fG0(u+εγ)ψ≤Z Qext |cu −f||G0(u+εγ)|ψ≤ε−γZ Qext |cu −f|ψ, where the right-hand side is well-posed, since by definition of super-solution u∈ W and by assumption (H3) the term c∈Lq loc, with q > (Q+2) 2. Eventually, the function gsatisfies the following inequality Z Qext −hADg, Dψi+Y g ψ +hb, Dgiψ−λ|Dm0g|2ψ≥ −ε−γZ Qext |cu −f|ψ, (4.5.3) hence gis a non-negative weak-sub-solution to (4.5.2). We are now in a position to provide an estimate of the L2-norm of the gradient Dm0g. Lemma 4.5.6. Let Qext =BR0×BR1×. . . ×BRκ×(t0, T0]⊂Ωand Qint =Br0×Br1× . . . ×Brκ×(t1, T1], where 0< ri< Rifor every i= 0, . . . , κ and t0< t1< T1< T0. Let gbe a non-negative weak sub-solution to (4.5.2)under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3), then λ 2Z Qint |Dm0g|2≤CGZ Qext g+ε−γkckL2(Qext)kukL2(Qext)+kfkL1(Qext),(4.5.4) where CG=CG(kbkL∞(Qext),Λ, Q, C1, C2)is a positive constant and C1, C2are defined in 119 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY (4.5.5). Proof. Let us consider a test function ψ∈C∞ 0valued in [0,1], supported in Qext and equal to 1 in Qint. Moreover, we assume that the following estimates hold |Dm0ψ| ≤ C1,|Y ψ| ≤ C2(4.5.5) for two non-negative constants C1, C2. Now, we may test (4.5.3) against ψ2: Z Qext hADg, Dψ2i−Y g ψ2−hb, Dgiψ2+λ|Dm0g|2ψ2≤ε−γZ Qext |cu −f|ψ2. Let us begin by estimating the term involving the matrix Athrough the Young’s inequality: −Z Qext 2ψhADg, Dψi ≤ εZ Qext |hADg, Dgi|ψ+1 εZ Qext |hADψ, Dψi|ψ ≤εΛZ Qext |Dm0g|2ψ+Λ εZ Qext |Dm0ψ|2ψ. Now, let us address the term involving c,uand f: ε−γZ Qext |cu −f|ψ2≤ε−γZ Qext |c||u|ψ2+ε−γZ Qext |f|ψ2 ≤ε−γkckL2(Qext)kukL2(Qext)+ε−γkfkL1(Qext). As far as we are concerned with the term b, we integrate by parts and by assumption (H3) we have: Z Qext hb, Dgiψ2=−Z Qext divb gψ2−2Z Qext bgψDψ ≤2Z Qext |b||g||Dm0ψ|ψ ≤2C1kbkL∞(Qext)Z Qext g. Lastly, the term involving the transport operator can be treated as Z Qext Y g ψ2≤2Z Qext g|Y ψ|ψ≤2C2Z Qext g. Hence, by combining the above estimates we obtain (λ−εΛ) Z Qint |Dm0g|2≤Λ εZ Qext |Dm0ψ|2ψ+ε−γkckL2(Qext)kukL2(Qext)+ε−γkfkL1(Qext) 120 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY +C1Z Qext g+ 2C2Z Qext g. By choosing ε=λ/(2Λ) we get the desired estimate. We observe that assumption b∈(L∞ loc(Ω))m0was necessary to obtain the L1-norm of gon the right-hand side of inequality (4.5.4). The presence of such a norm in the aforementioned inequality plays a crucial role in the proof of the upcoming Lemma 4.5.8. Remark 4.5.7. A cut-off function satisfying the requirements stated in (4.5.5) exists. Indeed, we may for example consider a family of cut-off functions of the form χi ri,Ri(s) = (0,if s≥Ri, 1,if 0 ≤s≤ri,|χ0 ri,Ri| ≤ 2 Ri−ri , i = 1, . . . , κ, χt0,t1(s) = (0,if s≤t0, or t≥T0, 1,if t1≤s≤T1,|χ0 t0,t1| ≤ max 2 t1−t0 ,2 T0−T1, with 0 < ri< Rifor every i= 1, . . . , κ and t0< t1< T1< T0. Then, we define ψ(x, t) = χt0,t1(t) κ Y i=0 χi ri,Ri(kx(i)k), where the norm we consider is the Euclidean one. Eventually, the following estimates hold: |∂xjψ| ≤ c0 R0−r0 for j= 1, . . . , m0|Y ψ| ≤ κ X i=0 ci Ri−ri + max 2 t1−t0 ,2 T0−T1. Now, we are in a position to study how equation (4.1.1) spreads positivity of (super- )solutions. More precisely, we state the upcoming Lemma 4.5.8 in terms of the cylinders Qpos =Bθ×Bθ3×. . . ×Bθ2κ+1 ×(−1−θ2,−1],(4.5.6) e Qext =B3R×B33R×. . . ×B32κ+1R×(−1−θ2,0], where R=R(θ, Q, λ, Λ) is the constant given by Lemma 4.4.4 and θ∈(0,1] is a parameter we will choose later on. In particular, θwill be chosen such that the stacked cylinder Qm pos (see definition (4.A.1)) is contained in Q1. To stress the dependence of Ron θ, we will sometimes write Rθinstead of R. Lemma 4.5.8. Let θ∈(0,1] and Qpos,e Qext be the cylinders defined in (4.5.6). Then there exist a small positive constant η0=η0(θ, Q, λ, Λ) ∈(0,1) such that for any non-negative weak solution uof (4.1.1)under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3) in some cylindrical open set Ω⊃e Qext such that |{u≥1}∩Qpos| ≥ 1 2|Qpos|,(4.5.7) 121 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY we have u≥η0in Q1. If, additionally, c≥0the statement holds true for non-negative weak super-solutions to (4.1.1). Proof. Let us consider g=G(u+εγ) for ε∈0,1 4and γ=1 8. By Definition 4.5.4,gis non-negative and a sub-solution to (4.5.2). Since Gis non-increasing and ε∈0,1 4we also have g≤G(ε1 8)≤G(ε). Now, let us introduce two parameters η∈(0,θ 2) and ι > 0, both depending on a parameter θwe will choose later on. The idea of the proof is to apply Theorem 4.3.1 to the function g(with Q1as the small cylinder and Q1+ιas the big cylinder with an accurate choice of ι) combined with Theorem 4.4.1 scaled on the cylinder Q1+ι=δ1+ι(Qext). Finally, we estimate the L2-norm of the diffusive gradient of gvia the square root of the square of its mass on a larger cylinder. First of all, we need to show that we can choose ιsmall enough such that Qext ⊂ Q1+ι⊂ δ(1+ι)2Qext ⊂e Qext, where Qext is defined in (4.4.1). In particular, ιneeds to be chosen such that (1 + ι)4(1 + η2)≤1 + θ2and 22j+1(1 + ι)2(2j+1) ≤32j+1 for j= 1, . . . , κ, where the above inequalities take into consideration the scaling introduced in (1.1.13), (4.4.1) and (4.5.6). In particular, this holds true if we assume ι= min n4(1+θ2) 4+θ2−1,3 21 2−1o. Moreover, by recalling the definition of Qzero, see (4.4.1), we then pick η∈(0,1) such that |Qpos \δ(1+ι)(Qzero)| ≥ 1 4|δ(1+ι)(Qzero)|. Thanks to the geometry underlying operator L, it is enough to pick η= (2κ+ 1)−1/(2κ+1) (1+ ι)−1θ. Combining this fact with our assumption (4.5.7) we obtain |{u≥1}∩δ(1+ι)(Qzero)| ≥ 1 4|δ(1+ι)(Qzero)|.(4.5.8) Now, we want to check if we retrieve enough information on the function g. In particular, the set in which g= 0 needs to be at least of the same measure of the set where the function u≥1, i.e. we want to show that the inclusion {u≥1} ⊂ {g= 0}(4.5.9) holds true. The function g=G(u+ε1 8), by definition, is equal to zero if u+ε1 8>1⇐⇒ u > 1−ε1 8. Inclusion (4.5.9) follows immediately from the previous inequality observing that 1 −ε1 8<1 122 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY for every ε∈]0,1 4]. Hence, equation (4.5.8) and inclusion (4.5.9) imply that |{g= 0}∩δ(1+ι)(Qzero)| ≥ |{u≥1}∩δ(1+ι)(Qzero)| ≥ 1 4|δ(1+ι)(Qzero)|(4.5.10) Thus, the function gsatisfies inequality (4.4.3) with δ(1+ι)(Qzero) taking the role of Qzero and we are therefore allowed to apply Theorem 4.4.1. Now, our aim is to estimate g−θ0G(ε), where θ0∈(0,1) is the constant given in Theorem 4.4.1 only depending on ηand θ(since the dimension of the cylinders involved in our analysis depends on them). We now want to apply Theorem 4.3.1 to (g−θ0G(ε))+. To this end, we first observe (g−θ0G(ε))+is still a non-negative sub-solution to (4.5.2) and g−θ0G(ε)≤(g−θ0G(ε))+≤sup Q1 (g−θ0G(ε))+. We are not yet in a position to apply Theorem 4.3.1 to (g−θ0G(ε))+, as this result was derived for non-negative weak solutions to equation (4.1.1), where in particular the term −λ|Dm0u|2 does not appear. For this reason, we briefly explain how to take care of the additional term in the proof of the Sobolev-type and Caccioppoli-type inequalities presented in Section 4.3. In particular, in the proof of Theorem 4.3.3, we have additionally λZQr [hDm0v, Dm0viΓ(z, ·)ψ](ζ)dζ, which clearly satisfies λZQr [hDm0v, Dm0viΓ(z, ·)ψ](ζ)dζ ≤CkDm0vk2 L2(Qr), and can be treated like I2. On the other hand, in the proof of Theorem 4.3.4, we get an additionally term of the form λ pZQr|Dm0up l|2ψ2 on the left-hand side of (4.3.7). By choosing ε1= 2λ/Λ, we get exactly the inequality stated in Theorem 4.3.4. Eventually, we are able to provide the following chain of estimates sup Q1 (g−θ0G(ε))+≤CιCMk(g−θ0G(ε))+kLβ(Q1+ι) +CιCMε−1 8kcu −fkLq(Q1+ι)Theorem 4.3.1 ≤CιCMk(g−θ0G(ε))+kL2(Q1+ι) +CιCMε−1 8kcu −fkLq(Q1+ι)β:= q q−1<2 ≤CPCιCMkDm0(g−θ0G(ε))+kL2(Qext)Theorem 4.4.1 +CPCιCMkY(g−θ0G(ε))+kL2H−1(Qext) 123 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY +CιCMε−1 8kcu −fkLq(Q1+ι) ≤C(CPCιCMCG)1 2 Z Qext g  1 2 Lemma 4.5.6 +C(CPCιCMCG)1 2ε−1 16 kckL2(Qext)kukL2(Qext)+kfkL1(Qext)1 2 +CιCMε−1 8kcu −fkLq(Q1+ι) ≤C1pG(ε) + C2ε−1 8Gis non-increasing where Cιis a constant due to the scaling on the cylinder Q(1+ι)and, as C1,C2, only depends on Q, Λ, λ,kbkL∞(Qext),kck2 L2(Qext),kfkLq(Qext)and ιand we used inequality ε−1 16 ≤ε−1 8for εsufficiently small. Thus, we obtain the following inequality G(u+ε1 8)−θ0G(ε)≤C1pG(ε) + C2ε−1 8in Q1. As G(ε)∼ −ln(ε) as ε→0+and ε−1 8≤p−ln(ε) for every εsufficiently small (for instance, ε∈]0,1 5]), we have G(u+ε1 8)≤θ0G(ε) + CpG(ε),(4.5.11) where C=C(C1, C2) is a constant that does not depend on ε. Since G(ε)→+∞as ε→0+, there exists ¯ε∈]0,1 5] such that for every ε∈]0,¯ε] we have θ0G(ε) + CpG(ε)≤1 + 7θ0 8G(ε).(4.5.12) Indeed, we can rewrite (4.5.12) as follows CpG(ε)≤1−θ0 8G(ε).(4.5.13) As both sides of (4.5.13) are positive, we can raise the square and get C2G(ε)≤1−θ0 82 (G(ε))2. Hence, dividing by G(ε), we infer C2≤1−θ0 82 G(ε). 124 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY In order to obtain (4.5.12), it is therefore sufficient to choose εsmall enough such that G(ε)≥8C 1−θ02 . Combining (4.5.11) and (4.5.12), we finally get g=G(u+ε1 8)≤1 + 7θ0 8G(ε). Taking advantage again of G(ε)∼ −ln(ε) for ε→0+, for every εsufficiently small the previous inequality implies ln(u+ε1 8)≥1 + 7θ0 8ln(ε). Hence, we for every εsufficiently small we infer u+ε1 8≥ε1+7θ0 8=⇒u≥ε1+7θ0 8−ε1 8=: η0. We remark that η0>0 for every εsufficiently small, since 1+7θ0 8<1 8for θ0∈(0,1). This concludes the proof. Remark 4.5.9. We observe that our function g=G(u+ε1 8) differs from the one considered in [51,118]. This is due to the fact that in the proof of the weak Harnack inequality below we cannot reduce to the case where the right-hand side is equal to zero. This condition is imposed by our weaker integrability assumption on the right-hand side and lower order coefficients, namely c, f ∈Lqwith qpossibly less than +∞. As a straightforward consequence of Lemma 4.5.8 we have the following result, which is the extension of [51, Lemma 4.2] to our case. Lemma 4.5.10. Let m≥3and let Rbe the constant given in Lemma 4.5.8 for θ=m−1/2. Then there exists a constant M=M(m, Q, λ, Λ) >1such that for any non-negative solution u to (4.1.1)under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3) satisfying |{u≥M}∩Q1| ≥ 1 2|Q1|, we have u≥1in Qm 1(see (4.A.1)). If, additionally, c≥0the statement holds true for non-negative weak super-solutions to (4.1.1). Proof. Since θ=m−1/2, we have that Qm 1⊂Bθ−1×Bθ−3×. . .×Bθ−2κ−1×(0, θ−2], see (4.A.1). We observe that u/M is a non-negative weak solution to (4.1.1) with right-hand side equal to f/M and satisfying assumption (4.5.7). Therefore we are in a position to apply Lemma 4.5.8 to this function. In this case Q1and Bθ−1×Bθ−3×. . . ×Bθ−2κ−1×(0, θ−2] take the roles of the cylinders Qpos and Q1, thanks to a rescaling argument. Hence, we obtain inequality u≥η0Min Bθ−1×Bθ−3×. . . ×Bθ−2κ−1×(0, θ−2] and therefore in Qm 1. Thus, to conclude the proof it is sufficient to choose M= 1/η0>1. 125 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY for some integer k. Thus, we get kfkL1(Ω) ≥Z Ω∩∪iQji |f| ≥ λ 2 ∞ X i=1 |Qji∩Ω|=λ 2kQ+2 ∞ [ i=1 kQji∩Ω≥λ 2kQ+2 {Mf < λ}∩Ω. Thus, the claim is proved when C= 2kQ+2. The following generalized version of the Lebesgue differentiation theorem holds. Theorem 4.A.7 (Genaralized Lebesgue Differentiation Theorem).Let f∈L1(Ω, dx ⊗dt), where Ωis an open subset of RN+1. Then for a.e. (x, t)∈Ω lim r→0+ 1 |Qr(x, t)|Z Qr(x,t) |f(y, s)−f(x, t)|dy ds = 0. Theorem 4.A.7 is obtained from the following Lemma 4.A.6 exactly as in [57, Theorem 2.5.1] by considering Lemma 4.A.6. 4.A.3 Ink Spots theorem without time delay Lemma 4.A.8. Let E⊂F⊂ Q1be two bounded measurable sets. We make the following assumptions for some constant µ∈(0,1): •E < (1 −µ)|Q1|; •if for any cylinder Q ⊂ Q1such that |Q∩E| ≥ (1 −µ)|Q|, then Q ⊂ F. Then |E| ≤ (1 −cµ)|F|for some universal constant conly depending on N. Proof. Thanks to Theorem 4.A.7, for almost all points z∈Ethere is some cylinder Qz containing zsuch that |Qz∩E| ≥ (1−µ)|Qz|. Thus, for all Lebesgue points z∈Ewe choose a maximal cylinder Qz⊂ Q1that contains zand such that |Qz∩E| ≥ (1 −µ)|Qz|. Here Qz=Qr(x, t) for some r > 0 and (x, t)∈ Q1. In particular, we have that Qzdiffers from Q1 and Qz⊂Fby our assumption. First of all we prove that |Qz∩E|= (1 −µ)|Qz|. By contradiction, let us suppose that is not true. Then there exists δ > 0 small enough and Qsuch that Qz⊂ Q ⊂ (1 + δ)Qz, Q ⊂ Q1and |Q∩E|>(1 −µ)|Qz|, and this contradicts the maximality of the choice of Qz. Then we recall that the family of cylinders {Qz}z∈Ecovers the set E. Thanks to Lemma 4.A.5 and considering that Eis a bounded set, we can extract a finite subfamily of non overlapping cylinders Qj:= Qzjsuch that E⊂ ∪n j=1kQj. Since Qj⊂Fand |Qj∩E|= (1 −µ)|Qj|, we have that |Qj∩F\E|=µ|Qz|. Therefore, |F\E| ≥ n X j=1 |Qj∩F\E| ≥ n X j=1 µ|Qj|=k−(Q+2)µ n X j=1 |kQj| ≥ k−(Q+2)µ|E|. 132 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY Thus, we get that |F| ≥ (1 + cµ)|E|, with c=k−(Q+2). Since cµ ∈(0,1), we complete the proof by choosing c=c/2. 4.A.4 Proof of Theorem 4.A.1 and Corollary 4.A.3 In order to proceed with the proof of the Ink Spots Theorem, we first need to recall two preliminary results. Lemma 4.A.9. Consider a (possibly infinite) sequence of intervals (aj−hk, aj]. Then [ k (ak, ak+mhk]≥m m+ 1[ k (ak−hk, ak]. The proof of Lemma 4.A.9 can be found in [59, Lemma 10.8]. Here, we only report the proof of the following lemma, that is an extension of Lemma 10.9 [59]. Lemma 4.A.10. Let {Qj}be a collection of slanted cylinders and let Qm jbe the corresponding versions as in (4.A.1). Then [ jQm j≥m m+ 1[ jQj. Proof. Because of Fubini’s Theorem we know that for any set Ω ⊂RN+1 |Ω|=Z|{(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈Ω}|dx(0). Therefore, in order to prove our statement it is sufficient to show that for every x(0) ∈Rm0 n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈[ jQm jo ≥m m+ 1n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈[ jQjo. From now on, let us consider a fixed x∈Rm0. Any cylinder Qjis a cylinder with center (x(0) j, x(1) j, . . . , x(κ) j, tj)∈RN+1 and radius rj>0. Qm jis its delayed version (4.A.1), that thanks to Remark 4.2.5 can equivalently be represented as follows Qm j= (t0, t0+mr2 j]×Br(x(0) j)×B(m+2)r3 j(x(1) j)×. . . ×B(mκ+2 Pκ i=0 mi)r2κ+1 j(x(κ) j). On one hand, when |x−x(0) j| ≥ rjthe set n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈Qm jois empty. 133 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY On the other hand, when |x−x(0) j|< rjwe have that n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x, x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈ Qm jo ⊃e Qj:= (tj, tj+mr2 j]×B2r3 j(x(1) j)×. . . ×B2Pκ−1 i=0 mir2κ+1 j(x(κ) j). Based on these last observations, we have that n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈[ jQm jo≥[ j:|x−x(0) j|<rje Qj. Now, thanks to Fubini’s Theorem and Lemma 4.A.9 we have n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x(0), x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈[ jQm jo ≥m m+ 1[ j:|x−x(0) j|<rj (tj−r2 j,0] ×B2r3 j(x(1) j)×. . . ×B2Pκ−1 i=0 mir2κ+1 j(x(κ) j) ≥m m+ 1[ j:|x−x(0) j|<rj (tj−r2 j,0] ×Br3 j(x(1) j)×. . . ×Br2κ+1 j(x(κ) j) =m m+ 1n(x(1), . . . , x(κ), t) : (x, x(1), . . . , x(κ), t)∈[ jQjo. Combining all of the above results, the proof is complete. Proof of Theorem 4.A.1.Let Qbe the collection of all cylinders Q ⊂ Q1such that |Q ∩ E| ≥ (1 −µ)|Q|. Let G:= ∪Q∈QQ. By construction, the sets Eand Gsatisfy the assumptions of Lemma 4.A.8. Therefore (1 −cisµ)|G|≥|E|. Combining the assumptions of the theorem with Lemma 4.A.10 we conclude the proof.  Proof of Corollary 4.A.3.The condition |E| ≤ (1 −δ)|Q1|is implied by the second assumption when r0<1. Moreover, the result is trivial when r0≥1 choosing Csufficiently large. Let Qbe the collection of all cylinders Q ⊂ Q1such that |Q ∩ E| ≥ (1 −µ)|Q|. Let G:= ∪Q∈QQm. From Theorem 4.A.1 we have that |E| ≤ m m+1(1 −cµ)|G|. Moreover, our assumptions tell us G⊂F. In order to conclude the proof is sufficient to estimate the measure G\Q1by considering that each cylinder Q=Qr(x, t)⊂ Q1has radius bounded by r0(see [59, Corollary 10.2]).  4.B Stacked cylinders In addition to the paper [59], a covering argument was already proposed in [1] for the case of the Fokker-Planck equation in trace form with Cordes-Landis assumptions. For the sake of completeness, we here state the stacking cylinders lemma for our operator L, that is a 134 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY generalization of the one proposed in [59]. Such a result is used when applying the Ink-Spots Theorem in the proof of the weak Harnack inequality, Theorem 4.5.1. Lemma 4.B.1. Let ω < 1 102and ρ= ((3κ+ 1)ω)1 2κ+1 . We consider any non-empty cylinder Qr(z0)⊂ Q−and we set Tk=Pk j=1(2kr)2. Let N≥1such that TN≤ −t0< TN+1 and let Qr[k] := Q2kr(zk), k = 1, . . . , N QRN+1 [N+ 1] := QRN+1 (zN+1), where zk=z0◦(0,...,0, Tk)and R=|t0+TN|1 2,RN+1 = max(R, ρ), and zN+1 =(zN◦(0,...,0, R2),if R≥ρ (0,0),if R < ρ These cylinders satisfy Q+⊂ QRN+1 [N+ 1],∪N+1 k=1 Qr[k]⊂(−1,0] ×B2,e Q[N]⊂ Qr[N], where e Q[N] = QRN+1/2zN+1 ◦(0,...,0,−R2 N+1). Figure 4.3: Stacking cylinders above an initial one contained in Q− Proof. As our derivation of the previous lemma follows very closely the one contained in [51, Appendix C], we here simply sketch the proof. Indeed, the proof of the result is merely geometric and the main difference with [51] lies in the fact that in our case we exploit the more general composition law and dilations defined in (1.1.6) and in (1.1.13), respectively. This explains why here the constants ωand ρdiffer from the ones in [51]. We first check that the sequence of cylinders we consider is well-defined whenever ω < 1 102. As, by definition, r≤ω, we have that t0+T1≤ −1 + ω2+ 4r2<0; moreover, there exists N≥1 such that TN<−t0≤TN+1. 135 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY We now check that Q+⊂ QRN+1 [N+ 1]. We first observe that, if R < ρ, then RN+1 =ρ and therefore the desidered inclusion simply follows from the inequality ω≤ρ. If, on the other hand, R≥ρ, we have that RN+1 =Rand we can rewrite the desidered inclusion as Qω(z−1 N+1)⊂ QR. In this case, in virtue of the definition of zN+1 and of the group law (1.1.6), we have zN+1 = (E(R2+TN)x0, t0+TN+R2) = (E(R2+TN)x0,0), since R2=|t0+TN|= −t0−TN. Hence, owing to (1.1.8), we obtain z−1 N+1 = (E(R2+TN)x0,0)−1= (−E(t0)x0,0) and for every z∈ Qω, we have z−1 N+1 ◦z= (x−E(t+t0)x0, t)∈ QR whenever 2ω≤R, 4ω3≤R3,...,(3κ+ 1)ω2κ+1 ≤R2κ+1 and ω2≤R2. The previous inequalities are clearly satisfied if (3κ+ 1)ω≤R2κ+1, i.e. if ρ≤R. We now show that the inclusion Qr[k]⊂B2×. . . B2×(−1,0] holds true for every k∈ {1, . . . , N +1}. As far as QRN+1 [N+1] is concerned, i.e. as far as k=N+1, we take advantage of the inequalities R=|t0+TN| ≤ 1 and ρ= ((3κ+ 1)ω)1 2κ+1 ≤1 to infer RN+1 ≤1. In addition, zN+1 ∈ Q1and therefore QRN+1 [N+1] ⊂B2×. . . B2×(−1,0]. We now address the case k≤N. To this end, we observe that TN≤ −t0≤1 as t0∈(−1,−1 + ω2] with ω≤1. As a consequence, by construction (2Nr)2≤TN≤1 and therefore 2Nr≤1. Moreover, if ¯zk= (xk, tk), then there exists (x, t)∈ Q1such that ¯zk= (x0, t0)◦(0, Tk)◦(δ0 2kr(x),(2kr)2t), where (δ0 r)r>0denotes the family of spatial dilations introduced in (1.1.14). In particular, this implies that xk,i =PN j=1(E((2kr)2t+Tk))ijx0,j + (2kr)2i+1xiand therefore x(0) k≤x(0) 0+2krx(0)≤ω+ 1 ≤2, x(1) k≤x(1) 0+ 2 ((2kr)2t+Tk)x(0) 0+(2kr)3x(1)≤ω3+ 2ω+ 1 ≤3ω+ 1 ≤2 . . . x(κ) k≤x(κ) 0+ 2κ((2kr)2t+Tk)ω+(2kr)2κ+1x(κ)≤ω2κ+1 + 2κω + 1 ≤2 (4.B.1) where we split x= (x(0), . . . , x(κ)), x0= (x(0) 0, . . . , x(κ) 0), xk= (x(0) k, . . . , x(κ) k) according to (4.1.6). We remark inequalities (4.B.1) hold true in virtue of the assumption ρ2κ+1 = (3κ+ 1)ω≤1, which in turn implies that 3ω≤1,...,(2κ+ 1)ω≤1. In addition, in the above inequalities, we made use of (2kr)2j+1x(j)≤1 as (2kr)2j+1 ≤2kr≤2Nr≤1 for every k∈ {1, . . . , N + 1}and x(j)∈B1. Finally, we observe that inequalities (4.B.1) implies Qr[k]⊂B2×. . . B2×(−1,0] for every k≤N. We are now left with proving e Q[N]⊂ Qr[N], to conclude the proof of our lemma. If R≥ρ, then the conclusion simply follows from R/2≤2Nr. On the other hand, if R≤ρ, we want to show that Qρ/2(¯z)⊂ Q2Nr,(4.B.2) where ¯z= (0,−TN)◦(x0, t0)−1◦(0,−ρ2). In order to prove inclusion (4.B.2), we first estimate the quantity 2Nrfrom below. From t0+TN+1 >0 and −t0≥1−ω2, we obtain that 136 CHAPTER 4. DE GIORGI-NASH REGULARITY THEORY 4 34N+1 −1r2≥1−ω2, which implies 4Nr2≥1 43 4−7 4ω2≥1 8. As a consequence, we infer that 2Nr≥1 2√2.(4.B.3) We now observe that, by definition, ¯z= (−E(−ρ2−t0)x0,−TN−t0−ρ2) = (−E(−ρ2− t0)x0, R2−ρ2). Thus, for every z∈ Qρ/2, we compute ¯z◦z= (x−E(−ρ2−t0+t)x0, R2−ρ2+t) and we observe that x−E(−ρ2−t0+t)x0(i)≤ω2i+1 +(2i+1)ω+(ρ/2)2i+1 ≤(3κ+1)ω+ (ρ/2)2i+1 =ρ2κ+1 + (ρ/2)2i+1 ≤ρ2i+1 + (ρ/2)2i+1 ≤2ρ2i+1 ≤(2ρ)2i+1, for every i= 0, . . . , κ. Moreover, we have −(2ρ)2≤ −2ρ2< R2−ρ2−t0and therefore ¯z◦z∈ Q2ρ. Hence, owing to (4.B.3), it is sufficient to choose ωsuch that ρ≤1 2√2(i.e. ω≤1 102) to get the desidered inclusion (4.B.2). 137 Chapter 5 Weak fundamental solution 5.1 Statement of the problem In this chapter, we take advantage of the Schauder estimates contained in Chapter 2to prove the existence of a fundamental solution associated to the Kolmogorov equation (4.1.1). Moreover, thanks to Moser’s estimate and to the Harnack inequality established in the previous Chapter 4, we are able to prove Gaussian upper and lower bounds for the fundamental solution. We eventually remark that these results are published in [12]. In the following of this chapter, we therefore deal with weak solutions to equation (4.1.1) in the sense of Definition 4.1.2. Moreover, we always assume that hypothesis (H1)-(H2) of Chapter 4hold true. Concerning the regularity of the coefficients aij,biand c, for i, j = 1, . . . , N, we mainly rely on assumption (H3-ii) below. In order to expose the main results of this chapter, we first need to give the definition of weak fundamental solution for operator L. To this end, we recall that the formal adjoint of operator Lin (4.1.1) is defined as in (1.2.7). Definition 5.1.1. Aweak fundamental solution for Lis a continuous positive function Γ L= Γ L(x, t;ξ, τ) defined for t∈R, 0 ≤T0< τ < t < T1and any x, ξ ∈RNsuch that: 1. Γ L= Γ L(·,·;ξ, τ) is a weak solution to Lu= 0 in RN×(τ, T1) and Γ L= Γ L(x, t;·,·) is a weak solution of L∗v= 0 in RN×(T0, t); 2. for any bounded function ϕ∈C(RN) and any x, ξ ∈RNwe have      Lu(x, t) = 0 (x, t)∈RN×(τ, T1), lim (x,t)→(ξ,τ) t>τ u(x, t) = ϕ(ξ)ξ∈RN,(5.1.1)      L∗v(ξ, τ) = 0 (ξ, τ)∈RN×(T0, t), lim (ξ,τ)→(x,t) t>τ v(ξ, τ) = ϕ(x)x∈RN, 138 CHAPTER 5. WEAK FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTION where the above equations need to be satisfied in the weak sense and u(x, t) := ZRN Γ L(x, t;ξ, τ)ϕ(ξ)dξ, v(ξ, τ) := ZRN Γ L(x, t;ξ, τ)ϕ(x)dx. We remark that Definition 5.1.1 was first introduced by Lanconelli, Pascucci and Polidoro in [72, Definition 2.2]. Now, we are in a position to state our main results. First, we address and give answer to [72, Remark 2.3] by proving the existence of a weak fundamental solution for operator L in the sense of Definition 5.1.1 under the following assumptions on the coefficients of L. (H3-ii) The coefficients aij,bi,c∈L1(ST0T1)∩L∞ loc(ST0T1) for i, j, k = 1, . . . , N, i.e. for any given compact subset Kof ST0T1there exists a positive constant Msuch that |aij(x, t)|,|bi(x, t)|,|c(x, t)| ≤ M, ∀(x, t)∈K, ∀i, j = 1, . . . , N. Moreover, the diffusion coefficients aij are such that divAj 0= 0 ∀j= 1, . . . , m0in the distributional sense, where Aj 0denotes the jth-column of the matrix A0introduced in assumption (H1). Note that the divergence free assumption on the columns of the matrix A0is required to address technical issues arising in the proof of the forthcoming Theorem 5.1.2. Indeed, the existence of the weak fundamental solution is achieved by combining a regularization procedure with a diagonal argument. In particular, we perform a regularizing procedure on the coefficients aij,bi,cand we then prove that the newly defined coefficients are Dini continuous. This allows us to apply Theorem 2.1.5 to the constructed regularized operator Lεunder the following assumption (C’) The matrix A0satisfies assumption (H1), while the matrix Bhas constant entries. The principal part operator L0satisfies assumption (H2). Finally, the coefficients aij,bi, c, and ∂xkaij, for i, j, k = 1, . . . , N, are bounded and H¨older continuous of exponent α∈(0,1] in the sense of Definition 1.2.1. The proof of the existence of a fundamental solution associated to operator (4.1.1) finally follows from Theorem 1.2.4. Hence, the reason why we work under assumption (C’) is that we want to take advantage of Theorem 1.2.4, which, as discussed in Section 1.2, holds true under hypothesis (C). The only difference between assumption (C) of Section 1.2 and our assumption (C’) is that we here require the H¨older continuity of the derivatives of aij,i, j = 1, . . . , N. This additional requirement is simply due to the fact that the operator we consider in (4.1.1) is in divergence 139 CHAPTER 5. WEAK FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTION form, whereas Theorem 1.2.4 is proved for a trace form Kolmogorov operator, namely operator (1.2.6). It is our belief that this additional assumption can be dropped by considering more refined analytical techniques, such as the ones recently proposed in the preprint [80] for the case of measurable in time and H¨older continuous in space diffusion coefficients. Finally, we point out that it is possible to replace the diverge free assumption on the diffusion coefficients with the following, more restrictive, one: the coefficients aij are measurable, doubly (weakly) differentiable with respect to the first m0components and such that ∂2 lkaij ∈L∞ loc(ST0T1), for every l, k = 2, . . . , m0. Indeed, this last assumption is enough to ensure that also the first order derivatives ∂kaij are Lipschitz continuous on ST0T1, with a uniform modulus of continuity not depending on the set we are considering. Theorem 5.1.2 (Existence of the weak fundamental solution).Let us consider operator L under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3-ii). Then there exists a fundamental solution Γ Lof L in the sense of Definition 5.1.1 and the following reproduction property holds. Indeed, for every x, ξ ∈RNand every t, τ ∈Rwith τ < s < t such that τ, t ∈(T0, T1): Γ L(x, t;ξ, τ) = Z RN Γ L(x, t;y, s) Γ L(y, s;ξ, τ)dy. Moreover, the function Γ L ∗(x, t;ξ, τ) = Γ L(ξ, τ;x, t)is the fundamental solution of L∗and verifies the dual properties of this statement. The existence of a classical fundamental solution is a problem that has been thoroughly addressed over the years. In particular, we refer to the works by H¨ormander [54] and Kolmogorov [67] for the analysis of the case with constant, or smooth coefficients. Among others, we recall the paper [102] for the proof of the existence of a classical fundamental solution through the Levi parametrix method (see [75]) and we refer to the last part of Section 1.2 for further reference. To our knowledge, Theorem 5.1.2 is the first existence result available for the weak fundamental solution to (4.1.1) in the sense of Definition 5.1.1. The proof we propose here is based on a limiting procedure combined with Schauder type estimates and a diagonal argument. This procedure was first proposed in [7] to prove the existence of a classical fundamental solution when the coefficients of (4.1.1) are locally H¨older continuous. The main difficulties we encounter when adapting this argument to the weak case are given by the low regularity of the coefficients, hence a new regularizing procedure is introduced in Section 5.3. We emphasize that the PDE approach adopted in this work improves the previously known results in that it allows us to consider differential operators with bounded measurable coefficients in both time and space, which is a milder assumption than the ones considered in the most recent literature. Indeed, on the one hand, in [25] the authors considered the case of bounded measurable time-depending coefficients, with a proof that is based on explicit 140 CHAPTER 5. WEAK FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTION computations involving the fundamental solution. On the other hand, in [80] the case of H¨older continuous in space and bounded measurable in time coefficients was addressed. As a second issue, we extend [72, Theorem 1.3] providing Gaussian upper and lower bounds for the weak fundamental solution Γ of Lunder assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3-ii). As far as Gaussian upper bounds are concerned for the fundamental solution Γ associated to Lwith H¨older continuous coefficients, a first result dates back to [102], where the author proves Gaussian upper bounds depending on the H¨older norm of the coefficients a,band c. Later on, Di Francesco and Pascucci [40], Di Francesco and Polidoro [41] proved upper and lower bounds for the classical fundamental solution, where also in this case the involved constants depend on the H¨older norm of the coefficients. A first result regarding Gaussian upper bounds independent of the H¨older norm of the coefficients is due to Pascucci and Polidoro, who studied operator (4.1.1) with b=c= 0 (see [98, Theorem 1.1]). Later on, Lanconelli, Pascucci [71] and Lanconelli, Pascucci, Polidoro [72] extended Nash upper bounds to non-homogeneous operators of the form (4.1.1) with bounded measurable coefficients. On the other hand, if we consider Gaussian lower bounds independent of the H¨older norm of the coefficients, a first result is due to Lanconelli, Pascucci and Polidoro [72, Theorem 1.3] for the particular case of the kinetic Kolmogorov-Fokker-Planck equation. The proof of this result is based on the construction of a Harnack chain, alongside with the study of the control problem associated to the principal part operator L0. The authors of [72] already suggested this type of result could be extended to the general non-homogeneous Kolmogorov operator of step κin (4.1.1), once a suitable Harnack inequality is established. The present work is a first step in this direction as it handles the homogeneous case, the only one for which a Harnack inequality is available, see Theorem 4.1.3. Theorem 5.1.3 (Gaussian bounds).Let Lbe an operator of the form (4.1.1)under assumptions (H1)-(H2)-(H3-ii). Let I= (T0, T1)be a bounded interval, then there exist four positive constants λ+,λ−,C+,C−such that C−Γ K λ−(x, t;ξ, τ)≤Γ L(x, t;ξ, τ)≤C+Γ K λ+(x, t;ξ, τ) (5.1.2) for every (x, t),(ξ, τ)∈RN×(T0, T1)with τ < t. The constants λ+,λ−,C+,C−only depend on B,(T1−T0),M. Note that Γ K λ−and Γ K λ+denote the fundamental solution of Lλ− 0and Lλ+ 0, where Lλ 0u(x, t) := λ 2 m0 X i=1 ∂2 xiu(x, t) + N X i,j=1 bijxj∂xiu(x, t)−∂tu(x, t),(5.1.3) and the explicit expression of Γ K λ±is given by Γ K λ((x, t); (ξ, τ)) = Γ K λ((ξ, τ)−1◦(x, t); 0,0), 141