El informe de transparencia de las firmas de auditoría. La experiencia española
Abstract
[ES] Primero se analiza el concepto de auditoría, después nos centraremos en las firmas que están obligadas a la transparencia en España, en la tercera parte del trabajo se evaluará la información divulgada en el informe de transparencia y para finalizar se estudiará el aspecto de la calidad en la auditoría y sus procesos.
Full text
!"!#$%&'%()"*+ "!,$-%.#(+"!,$'%(&)! /&'%+'!*# 0$(!1'& 2 234536 2-5 237 326 326 2 -4827 33 49 $:(!&!&'%(#&!$)# /%&'%* $&; %$"!/%'!$*%%("+%&*!#$ !#'%++ %$<=#"> ?6@99 AB6 =B C5B9 2 B7 9 7 72 B D7 7 AA77
6 =36 B 6 7 36 6 E?@ E%&+/%$'%(&)! /&'%+'!*# 0 E !"!#$%&)"*+ "!,$)! /&'%+'!*# 07 E%&+/%$;+$*+"!#$%&+%&*!#$ !#&++ %$<=#">?6@6 E?@FG E+%&*!#$ !#&++ %$<=#">?6@ H H A H = H C52 H 2 H 2B H H DB H AA7 H 6 H 9 H H EB H 26 H 2B H 4-4D599 H 45 H B2 H 72 H 62 H 3
E2$)# /%&'%* $&; %$"!6? ">!.#&3@ = C5 D AA E 4-4D5 45 3
3 3!I+ &2 3!I+ &826 3!I+ &3?@22 3!I+ &3?@29 3!I+ &2D36 3!I+ &933 3!I+ &37 3!I+ &B3AB 3!I+ &73=B9 3!I+ &63C5B7 3!I+ &37 3!I+ &37 3!I+ &37 3!I+ &3D77 3!I+ &23A6 3!I+ &93=36
! " # !$% #$& %$' &' ' $$' &() &()'" *% "$# !$*$+!! #$##
!"#"$!$%$&'((()"$$*#+%# , -&"$$*)./, 0 1 1 , 0 ,2 ,1 34)34"5 !"#"$!$ !56 7 890:"$!!; 7 13
< ,( 7890:"$!!; )0 < 70 0 +!6=,< "$!!"$!$ !"$!$ !-#!->> 14 +$'((()"$$*#+%# , !+ , ,20 0 3!"#"$!$ 66)!5!?#"$!,(3 74 ,2 1
0 0 1 @)6,2:,AA((; BC 1 BC3D< E . 6 , !> . !--5F D, 3 01 4E 7 71 F GFH< , < H2000 1 D E
/ ' 1 /I,) ! F D, 0 E 2FD,<2 < J 4 !-#!->> 1FD 3 K 1 3 0 31 0E LFD1 3 M10< E !" #$! !% & !
(IL= ( :T7; T < 1 (( T R @3, 01 ,,00 !-?> + W ) /, 0 0 7!->%?W) >W)!->+ /, , !-?? :(O ; 3 4 @ ( & , 4 2 (O !5- !"+ <"5(O D EDE )(O 3 (@8:(@8; :I(;K % ( :(@;,(@8"$$" ($:(78;
,25$ 01 /':!->?;F 6#$* #($*% $# 61+%$*'%%&+(*'#& 6%M* ;#("!,$ 0 T T @ :!-->; 0F 3!(#&#)0$*!I+3 M 3!(#&#)0/#'% $
, 2 ,2 100 AA I 6(1 (0 3 0, , 0 0 0 1 7 0 ),2 < 6 )!>+> &7 !>5? )T
, !-!" D( 74 ,2E , !-"? 3 ( D &8E1 'R8D( & ,2E < ,2D @ . RE ,!*!-+5 ,D( & ,2E)T 7R ( , 1DTE D )E D 7E , 1R,G, 2!--5?#-5"!T 2 D & 2E )074 V ( M
' 7 ,2@!-5! 23,!$>0 @ 73TR <F( & K X, 3 R1< 11 1<J:@!-5!F !$>!; D E 3 1 1 , 4 76)?#*+%$6 8!5$*#*?%$& D& @ 8E 3 D( & EV1 1< 1
9 &@< 13D( ,2E02!-?% 1 <0D( & E < 7 00 < 0 < O20 2 < < < ,2 0113,2/,3 <<2 < , !-?? 6 ) >?!#?? "* D, 7,77RE,+ D :M;:M; < E 11 2 !->" D6 , E :6,; 131D TE D )E DTE D E D 3E 1
6 I6) ,:6,T;8 1 D ,2 ,E:, ;2!-?-, 0 1 <1 03 4 < 1 4 <0 (00 00)0 148 0 3,O,2 00 0 , , 3,2 ,,, !->*1 06!-5? R0 !--" , )/, 00 ,2 7 @ R ' ( ( M 7 T
, 00 ,2F %<7N7BB'%'%+(!#- !"#"$!$%$& ,D( E 1 R ,GD(7 E6 1 D6. E 0 3 )074 /, %<7N7B7-'%2'%+$!#-6R T 0 %(%" %*#%I!&(*!.#29N7B7-"") <6@ %( %" %*# 27N7B7 '% '% !"!%/K %- 66R %(%" %*#99N776-'%6'%!"!%/K %-6 %(%" %*#7N776-'%6'%!"!%/K %-7 T
/ %( %" %*# B2N77- '% 6 '% !"!%/K %- %< N772- '% '% 1#- @ 6 @ %(%" %*#BN779-'%7'%+(!#-6 6R %<N66'%/%'!'&'% %)# /'%(&!&*%/)!$$"!% # ,06!"#"$!$ 11 %(%" %*#B6N66-'%'%3%K % #-6)!*%*#!--$"$ ) %(%" %*#29N662-'%6'%%;*!%/K %-6)!*%*#!--$ "$) %<N66 %M*# %)+$'!'#: !-#!->>!"&;<$+%.#%I(/%$*#"$!! ,'!I# '% #/% "!# ; #K'# %( '% I#&*# '% BB2 < %I(/%$*#'%(%I!&* #% "$*!(; #K'#;# %(BN779-'%7 '%J+(!#,F
0 X1 6 < 1 6R 36J:66R !--*F"; %M*# %)+$'!'# '% ( %< '% #"!%''%& $,$!/&- ; #K'# ;# %( %" %*#%I!&(*!.#29N7B7-'%'%'!"!%/K %, 1
6 @A;;J:B ? ? ? ? "$> 0' ,' "= J# ' ' #- , ' #( !& 6 % 9 #! & 90 9 3 6 , #-* ' $8" &$ 0 99 9 '0/ J# K# 8 0/ @ =". '0 6 ### / ' @ !#" ' $! / 6 @$8" / ' 0 6 K! ' 9 , K. 6 , #! 0 & ( 90 ' "& 66 6 &##% 6 # - ! ' $& 6 / & $.4 9/ $ # / 8" 0 , %"( 6/ , ## , 0 $! 6 , " ' ;" ', , 8" 99 / ; , ' $# ;$ # = / 6 "#" 0 ;$1L.!" 60 ? #! ' 6 D$# 0 / ? ## "# 9 D$! / 6 ?.! ) 9/ # @ # /9 9' I -" 9 6 : 3 6 0 I 8". 00 6 ' 6' ,-&&. &&%
, , 0 0 2 "$$- 00%$"$!$, " : 00/ MD:C00/ 6 0H A ,6 A 0 G 0 60H A 9' A /6 / 00H A57 : 6/ 0H A 9/ A '90 99 ,H A 0' A 9 : /09 H A '9 A '60 00H 57DAM0 :00 ,-&&. &&%
/ ,0 6. 0 6. 0 ! ; MD?: 9' , , ,-&&.$ 1 1 , 2 "$$- 0!%>!% 1 -$Y 0 6. "!"
0 # ; MD?: 9' , , ; ,0 ,'6 ; /6 /'9 ,-&&.$ 11 1!$$ ?!%!? $5Y@55Y
% ; N N 0 ' 0 6 ' ' /, 9 0 , 0 0 6 0'' '0 9' ' 00 ' ' K 00 6 99/ 6 /'9 ,-&&.$' , G 442 1 -$Y , 0 "$$> "$$- 1 1 & A 00/ H ?C0/ < 0,H 00, H ?C0, < 06H O 9'66, /H < H 9609090 /H H ? O '966 ,H < 6H 90669 ,H < H 6,,/ 00H < H 60'9 00H 00/ H ?C0/ < 0,H 00, H ?C0, < 06H D /6,0,0 /H < H //,6 /0H H ? D /6 6/,0 /H < ,H 0996 0H < H 06'/090 00H < H 0//// 00H /H ,-&&.'
702"$$-"$$> 02"$$50"$$> 3 ,"$$>"$$? 2"$$-"$$> , ,2"$$? 1 , 2 ,3 %+*%$Z55%5-$Z M00/ M00/ 9' 'H 57 ,6 /0H57 ? '966 ? 9'66, A 90 A '''/0 57@: 00/507 57 @ 00/567 ,-&&. 74 @*?>*!2"$$- D1E1:5>Y; !Y11 "%Y, 1
74!+Y3 +Y @:GJ@; /09 '6+9 H F+;+??A+ /96 + H G IA '0 0+6H @:J? '9'6 + H @: ; + :I; B @ '' 0+,H @:;; 69/ +H B;P@ '0' 0+6H @: , +6H 96,9 00H ,-&&.$$'
!"!#$%& '% ( )"*+ "!,$- %.#(+"!,$ '% (& )! /& '% +'!*# 0 $(!1'& 1 ,2 3 0 1 3 6= ,< 2"$!$"$5"?-"!Y1 23 01 )7U 97RT0 !$4= 1!>"Y00 O[,) 4 1 79O 5$5Y 1 !+ "%5? 6=!5 0(!+779O 000<0 500""!?!Y ?"5$%M#
' ,+!""10 !>000!$100 F ?AH50/ < 07 Q &0 ; RR %0% #0% !0 @ 0 0! ; D "0 "0 @M 0 ,-$$.&() ,D8(T+E
9 6!$10 1 ,\LD8+EF ?AH50/ < 07 R 1 # 0 J 1 %0# 1 %0 1 %0 ? 1 %0 1 "0% 23 1 "0 ; 1 0 ;@F GB G 10 1 0! ,-$$.&()'
0 J , I ( ( @ F (@ ?$$ !# 9 %+3,'7:#*( - # +/, # # ; # # ( +''',8 % <=> "+/, % ?== ( %7+''', -#@#+(#>A+(,,#- ( # ( ( ((+(#>A+,,%#'8' 'I3T !%"7 +''',- -- ## 8'61 0 0 M!%5 1 - * ) :"$$$; D:M; 0 0 1
0 1 0 70 7 0@ !W @"W6 0< 0<0 >% 1 01 3 0 , ,1 1 1 0 0 , 1 1 1
' , 1 1 1 1 <D>74 ,$$. 00 0 0
9 %<N663 )F < ( 0 1 0 D ) "$$*#+%# , 3 !5 !?E 0 1D 0K K K:M; ( K E
6 ) @:"$$>;3 #0 ( , 1 @,<0 :@, ;,@,<0 :@, ;:"$!!;0F+''', 0 -0 10 3 4 @341 < 3 4 3 4 2 --. ./ 4 31 ,!* 4 7200 DE0DE > !"#"$!$ D 1
, 1 3>%!"#"$!$E !"!<6 "$!! ,2 F " & " " 1 > ! < !) ) C00 < ) C00 ,>5=85- $ ' 94E ><4 9=89F =<G574<AA9?:>85=45A5A7<A. 4 0 ,
/ 2 3 D, ( 1E1 1D IE@< ,1 ,<1 001 1 , 1 13 I3
'0 3 3 ,3 .( '(.@ .:"$$-; ('71 D)"$$*#+%# , 341< E / 1 43 0 < 1 4 7 3 3 <D>74 ,-'/0H3)0$&&!7?9=<I6<J=A59475K><4<894A5>A<897< 5D-=>5G68G<7568<G$78<A95$LD4!1"%.
' .( ':.( ';1 3 (.@ . (0 % , 33 (.@ . T ) T H E R0 @ 0 = / H H 703 1 1
' 2 71 4 1 H H 1 3 0 0 @ 7 / , H ) "$$*#+%# , 7, :>W)0; & :!-+>; 4 & 674: 78;"!" 1 , / ( (# $ :7 .8;0 ) 3
'/ ,1 -48 )"$$*#+%# ,!? , (3 74 ( +$ 7 2 )!"#"$!$!"+#!->>!" &1!+:"* < 6 ; , 0 11 1<3 1( +" , 0 < 1 !*%=; 6 "$$>#%*"# , 1 3 0 34 !?!; 1,(3740 31 0,00) ) 0 1
90 1 <1 D6 2E2D 302 34 00 , 2 < 34 F ; 3 38,2 I R')T@O7 ; 424
9 , 6 !5 ; 0 !5$ 0 ( ; ;0 5$$ 0 ; 1 0 "$$$$$$$$!$$$ ; 1 " ; ; ; 1 3 4 0 0 , 1 3440 ; ;;
9 601 8,2 I R')T@O7 000 1 1 00 3 # 1##3 )0 ; )"$$*#+%# ,3 1 , 01 1 /101 040 )%- , 0 0 D7)< 340 334 E > , ?K-($#")$&"* $&
9 )0 ) <2 3 0 <0 , > 0 342 027 1 ? 2 3431 00 1 310 5$"$$" %$20 3 414 2( )01%2 1*2 1 3 3 3 1<0!5 !?
9 3 3 4 , ) 0=_E890:"$!!; )0 /, 0<F )2,890:"$!!; 0 @ 0 2 0 ,, 1 3< M V12 24 M 6,01 0M <#
9' @,1 890:"$!!;0 3 , < 2( 1 1 , (3 74 , <, 0 34 ,,1 <@ 0 1 0 3 6 1 0
99 1 ,4 ) $:(!&!& '% (#& !$)# /%& '% * $&; %$"! /%'!$*% %( "+%&*!#$ !# '% ++ %$<=#">?6@ , 0 F !WF84146. +!6= "W F 6 ( 0 :"$!$"$!!; %W F 1 ( 890:"$!!; O%*;P&Q+%''%(&;:I!$&'%!$*% $%*<$P/% #'% %I!&* #%$%( '%(&)! /&'%+'!*# 0'%($R!$I 01 01[ 1[ 01[+!O6= ,<1,20 4<1[
96 1 [ 0 0 0$%M#6 , 1[,@:,; !*6=01 [06. 4 1 R 3 1 = 0 < .04 6. 07Q@@,@@.6@!- >??"$$>3 1[0,1 # O %*; %"#;!("!,$'%*#'#& (#& $)# /%& '% $&; %$"!Q+% >< %(!1'#"')! /'%&'%%(!$!"!#'%((%I!&("!,$?66H6@ 1[4 6. = 40 1 1 [ 0 03 0(, !$ , T6@R?-, 16. 4@$?%%
9, 1[ 0 T 6@R 6=,4 @$!5> 4 4 1[, %$Y!*Y < " <2 0 O "!:@$"$*;2 !"Y8,"+:@!%$$; 55Y83R"?:@$!??;"$Y, %5:@$*>$;+?Y&)%*:@$+"+; !5Y O[ %> :@!">?; !>"Y 1 4 :@$"!%; ->Y / )), 0 1 6. 4@!!-- 1[ !!6= %$>* $-Y ,0 2"$!$20, +! ,2 0 3 00 034 6
6' % , 0 01 ) +5Y +%Y 4 <0 0 <%8 90:"$!!;V + ,)D8+E>>Y 020 !$$Y ,30"#% 04 ,2( )3 11 1 5- (0( 00
69 5 ,(374 ,0 10 347 1< 34 37 ) 1
66 ! FP@ &M R &&M Q; &M SB &M @ &M ;D &M &&M I &M DRD &M D &M Q &M @ &M &M &&M &&M F+FIBG &M &&M ;@FGBG &M &&M &&M &M J 00H 9 H ,-$$.$$* $
6, 010 1< 0 5$Y7 0 5$Y 34<R < < 340 0<0 8 90:"$!!;<+ * , ,0 31) 00< 1 ? 6 V) !%Y 3 0 ""Y, ,)< 0 <10
6/ > ( @ ) 2 0<$%1 1 0 10 0 3 ,0) F <D>74! ,-$$.$
,0 A ! )2 7>>Y 40 0&7 1 2<5%1 "? " , , 7U 3 *5Y5$Y7 4 01 0 2 < 00 177)K7U <1 13
, % 6 , 1I 1 1)< D8+E , %5Y+%Y + ) ) 7 3 1 1<% *5Y*>Y ) 6G << 2 M , 00 0 &D 3-
, 5 , !$ , 00 V 7 66GG0 0 0 * 6 < I1)"$Y ""Y ? ( < ) 0 !" 2$ # 1 & " 4& & &3 1L(#!" E " $-" $ L!" 1 & "
, 0F <D>74# ,-$$.$$N = ,97RT3 (1 [1< ! )2F ,7U >>Y 44 &0@,2I 2 0
, " , 70 1 !! ,4 M % 6 , +?Y ++Y,0 1 6< ,0 T 97RT1 BC"'%(BC" ( C" ' + ,97RT?*Y 13 0 @ 04 ,2( 100
/ 5 , V,\L0 0 * 6 001 ,4 110 # ,0 <D>74 ,-$$.$
/ 9 )1T0 5>Y179O ! )2F ,3 8).0< 00 ?5Y " , T ?>Y I 4 <1 ,3 < 3 0 7 <
/ % 6 ,4*5Y, 1 1 4 4301 111 5$Y + , 0 ( 166GG 2 5 , , 3 40 * 6 6 3 R @ <
/ 1 0 < ,T0< HHR <D>74 ,-$$.$)
/' , %%Y !$$Y ,(374 ! )2 V *%Y *>Y 72 " , ,"*Y5$Y0, @<3 1 M % 6 V 44 M
/9 + 7 @<1 ) 3 I 1 M 7T0 66GG2 5 , , 34 0 * 6 ,< 1 0
/6 <D>74 ,-$$.$ B D ! )2F R1< 2 <, 10! "$!! " , ,+%Y 1,2 < M 1 4
/, % 6 , *$Y 4 ,< ( 4 3 /R(R,2% + , < 01 66GG 2 5 , 8). ,\L 0 0<
// <D>74 ,-$$.$/ 7 AA ,15 5+Y ! )2 ,>>Y2 4 " , M 3
00 1 % 6 4*$Y, 3 0I + ,1 *5Y166GG 2 5 6 ) 0 ,
06 7 3 6/)(.6,@T6./7@7:"$!!;?=>=D?=>>B, Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; R,)c,Q8:"$$$;IE4!$??* >% ,@ @,6'( (.@ ,R76,@6(,@ @ :"$!!; ?=>>B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; /)( /)(.6,@ @ :"$!!; ?=>> B, Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; /)(A(@ /)(.6,@ @7 :"$!!; ) ?=>>'B,Ca0F[[[<b: F"$!"; /)6( /)(.6( L .I@/.6( @7 :"$!!; ( ?=>>B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; /6,I @,6'( (.@ 76.O,@(.I,@ 'IQ).@ @ :"$!!; ?=>>'B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; 8). /)(.6,@ @ :"$!!; $E ?=>> B, C a0F[[[b: F"$!"; 8,)6)&K&.GI@.I,9K@R(G,K:"$!$;-' (#' (''+4! !" !- @@ 6,/@ 6KT@@d'(O6I &RK@.6(@,I)6 :!-->; RF , ( L & ,2+W,
0, .6V@7V6,L\ c/)(.6,@@7:"$!!;?=>> F'B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; ),.(, @ :"$!!; ?=>>' B, C a0F[[[b: F"$!"; )/6SI), :!->"; 2 1 ( ) 4!$!"-%5: F"$!"; )/6,I),QTdR,QT/(RdI:"$$!,'2)51 G )/R ,6I@ \ L./IT @ :"$!!; ?=>>' B, C a0F[[[b: F"$!"; O(@ /)(.6,@ @ :"$!!; ?=>> B, C a0F[[[b: F"$!"; T8(I,,V I( .),/)(.6cL .I@/.6c@:"$!!,' ?=>>'B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; T.I@Q.IT/.&K%!)22H%IG )'+?=>=,'"$!$ ')4""+""55 T6I G.6I.I @7 :"$!!; ?=>> B, C a0F[[[0b: F"$!"; G.6UG /)(.6,@ ,@7e @ :"$!!; ?=>>B,Ca0F[[[[0[0b : F"$!";
0/ (8,6/)(R6R/)( .I@/(I@7:"$!!; ?=>=J?=>>' B, C a0F[[[b : F "$!"; (O :"$$*; )# +)# %$,'B,Ca0F[[[b: F "$!"; (I@(/.), .I8(())L/)(.6c), /,I@:"$!$;@ ,2"$$-$4>">- -? &IV 8.I, & :!--%; 3 K )/8 &7I 7 :"$$?; B, C a0F##[[[##[#$"bB !$#$>#"$!"C 97RT /)(.6,@ @ :"$!!; ?=>>' B, CF a0F[[[=b: F"$!"; 66(8 )(QQ.66( :"$$-,' +>, RF ,O!W, ,L!-#!->>),!"),&/(.),/)(.6c), /,I@ /R,I, R.)(O( )7.6,L!"#"$!$),%$),&/I(. ,L!-#!->-),"5),&/I(. ,L++#"$$"),R,)()@),6,O.6R),@(@,RO(II (,6. .767V6,QA:!--?;3)' )/8
0 d7,Q @/@.:"$$%;) "@ I,4!?! d7,Q @/@. :!--5; I ')K) R6cI,QT/IKL/8,6.G,6R.@7:"$$?; F.)'E4 !>* 5**- RQ6@/)(.6,@@7:"$!!;?=>=D?=>>) FB0F[[[C: F"$!"; R..6,@,7G,I))',6(@/)(.6,@L .I@/.6,@@7 :"$!!; ?=>>' B, C a0F[[[0 b .( '(.@ . , I( .RR(,, .O G, (I,6I(.I .6TI(Q(.I.O@, /6((,@ .RR(@@(.I@ :"$$-;! #' 6BC .(/@ [email protected]@ L :"$!$; E,04""+!!> !"5 7,6,)@(Tf,IQ&R:!--!;"RF , ,6@ 7V6,Q d7,Q &K d7,Q T'(6 R6 :"$$+; D EEN!55?*>?
7(e,6.),7QQ.6(.T6(R:"$!!;, F E 4 "%* %*+? 7,/)(.6,@@7:"$!!; ?=>>B,C a0F[[[b: F"$!"; 7.876.O,@@(.I.',6@(TG8.6):"$!$; ! ( ' 6[!!* 7.8 76.O,@@(.I .',6@(TG 8.6) :"$$>K"$!$; I( + I, 7..T66().O:"$!$;/ ' I )5 )4-$%* 7.I R,@6,@ \ /)(.6,@ @. ().@ @ :"$!!;' B,Ca0F[[[b: F"$!"; 76( ,U,6G./@, ..7,6@ @ :"$!!;' ?=>> B, Ca0F[[[[b: F"$!"; 6,),86,.,T(@('.!5*+#!->-),""),)( (,R86, <6@ 6,), 6,.!*%*#!--$),"$),)( (,R86,6 6, .R,I) (dI), .R(@(dI :"$$"; G)1I4!>?%
@I G,QO,6ISI),Q),')66R&:"$!$;' E4""%!$!" @/`/(./), :"$$>, ' ,F L& @ @, /6((,@I),A GIT, .RR(@@(.I:@, ;:"$!!;I # 9 I- B, C a0F##[[[###%%?-!-0bB !"#$?#"$!"C G, .I@/(', .RR(,,.O ./II L8.)(,@:"$$-; & /6c@'(,I,&:!->?; RF,3O /L66,I ).,:"$!!;0 0+,'E4%"+>+-* 'I8//6,I&7K9. G9 :"$!!;E (-#MN',!%% '((()(6, ('), .I@,&.>+#"5%# ,, '( .6G,6ISI),QR:"$$?; <'I)%O((4* U(I)Rg,6 6 :"$$$;F 6!# M 6' 0 ,6[-F+*%-*+" Q.6(.T6(RKT6 (8,6I/RKI.',6&6`/, (',6&:"$!$; !$7'E4""5 !"!-
6 E?@ E6%&+/%$'%(&)! /&'%+'!*# 0 3 A 3 3 [[[ 0F##[[[##) @#Y"$#)# IY"$O#hh hh"$!! "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, @$*-" 7 A [[[[ 0F##[[[[#h## ##h"$!!h " "$!! 6,(Q /I (IO.6R, ,I"$!$ 7,6.I. /R7, .@ 6,`/(@( .@ 76 @,6), 6I@7 6,I ( @$"+" 7 = [[[= # 0F##[[[=#,@## I#7 #7#( "$!!< "$!! ,6 ,6 (IO.6R, ), 6I@7 6, ( @$?$" 7 C5 [[[ 0F##[[[#,@##@06 _ijj \0hih "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, @$5%$ 7 [[[ 0F##[[[###!>?#) <_R(i!"$%\ R6i!!%*\(8(i5+5 "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, @!"?% @$?+! 7 , @7 [[[0 0F##[[[0#h h0 "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, @$"%! 7
3 [[[ I.7/8( @$?%% 2 [[[ 0F##[[[### #7##-+ "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, @$?*5 @$"?% @!>"" @"$$* @!5!> @$"?> @!"*? @!"$! @$-"" @!>?> @$-$% @$5"! @$"!$ 6. @ 7 @ I 6. [[[ I.7/8( @$!5> I D [[[ 0F##[[[#7 #I#I 7#) #( "$!$"$!! "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, K"$!$ "$!! @!!>- 7 [[[ I.7/8( @!!-- ( A [[[[0 [0 0F##[[[[0[0# #0##(Y"$Y"$ Y"$"$!!Y"$[0[0 Y"$h"h "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, I6 7
' [[[ 0 0F##[[[0 #h 0 "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, @$?-- ) 1 4 =3 [[[ 0F##[[[#7#O0 <_(Ri%+!!-+% -->$5>!>"??" "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, ), 6I@7 6,I ( @$+"> 7 ,@ @ , @79O ( [[[ 0F##[[[# 0_i% "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, K"$!$ "$!! @!*$+ 7 (R6R @7 I. )(@7.I, ),7ST(I I.@,. (Q I6 1 R , @ E [[[< I.7/8( @$*?% %6,T(@6.@ ,I,6. 5 H 35C [[[0 I.7/8( @!-!! 7 /GL D [[[ I.7/8( I6 1 1[
9 3 AA [[[ I.7/8( @$%"! @$??* 7 (TO U.6)U(), ( ( 3S [[[ I.7/8( @$"$* 7 , (1 [ 42 = E [[[< 0F##[[[<###( hhhh"$!!h < "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, @$?++ [[[ 0F##[[[# < "$!! 76(R,6 (IO.6R, K"$!$ "$!! @!">$ 7 6 6 T [[[ I.7/8( @!%$$ [[[ 0F##[[[## # "$!! @,T/I) . (IO.6R, K @,6/)( @"!+* 7 @7 I,A( (