opinion Politicalerosiondismantlestheconservationnetworkexisting intheCanaryIslands JoséMaríaFernández‐PalaciosandLeadeNascimento IslandEcologyandBiogeographyGroup,InstitutoUniversitariodeEnfermedadesTropicalesySalud PúblicadeCanarias(IUETSPC),UniversidaddeLaLaguna(ULL),Avda.AstrofísicoFranciscoSánchezs/n, 38206,LaLaguna,(Tenerife),Spain e‐mail:
[email protected];http://webpages.ull.es/users/jmferpal ISSN1948‐6596 opinion and perspectives RecentlytheCanarianParliamenthasapproveda newversionoftheCanariancatalogueofprotectedspecies(seeBox1)thatreducessubstantiallyboththenumberofspeciesincluded(from 466speciesinthe2001listto361speciesinthe 2010list)andtheprotectionafforded(from381 threatenedspeciesto160,andfrom85protected speciesto18).Thesereductionshavebeenwidely criticizedbyenvironmentalNGOsandthelocal scientificcommunity1,mainlyduetotheabsence ofarigorousscientificprocessinitsdevelopment. Althoughcertainlythefirstversionofthecataloguecouldbeimproved,themainreasonsbehindthenewrevisionswerenotconservationissuesbutratherstrictlypolitical.Thereasonsmay include,forinstance,thedevelopmentoflarge infrastructures,suchasindustrialharboursand golfcourses,whichuntiltherevisionswereforbiddenduetotheirimpactsonprotectedspeciesincludedintheoriginalversionoftheCanariancatalogue. Changesintheenvironmentallegislationof theCanaryIslandsentailaseriousthreattothe natureofthisregionofbiogeographicalinterest (Francisco‐Ortegaet al.,2000;Juanet al.,2000; Fernández‐Palacios&Whittaker,2008).Thus,we believeitisimportanttoshareourappraisalof thecurrentsituationwiththeinternationalscientificcommunity. Withinthenewrevisedcatalogueacompletelynewcriterionforprotectionhasemerged “especiesdeinterésparalosecosistemascanarios”(literally:“speciesofinterestforCanarianecosystems”),comprising152species(seeBox1).The phraseispoorlychosen.Itissupposedtoapply onlytoendangeredspecies,consequentlythefrequentandabundantspecieswhichusuallystructureanddominatetheecosystemsareexplicitly notlisted,leadingtoacuriousparadox:theCanarianpine(Pinuscanariensis)isnotaspeciesof interestfortheCanarianpineforest,the MacaronesianLaurel(Laurusnovocanariensis)is Abstract.TheoutstandingnatureoftheCanaryIslandshasbeenrecognizedbyEuropean,nationaland regionaladministrationssincethearrivalofdemocracyinSpain.Forty‐fivepercentofitsemergedterritoryhasbeendeclaredasNaturalProtectedAreas,fourCanarianNationalParkswereincludedwithinthe Spanishnetwork,morethan200endemicswerelistedintheSpanishcatalogueofendangeredspecies, and450specieswerelistedintheCanariancatalogueofprotectedspecies.However,inrecentyears,politicaldecisionshavestarteddismantlingthissplendidconservationnetwork,whichimpedesconstruction oflargeinfrastructure,golfcoursesandresorts,despitetheadviceofthescientificcommunity.Canarian natureisnowfacingtwothreats:delistinganddowngradingofnumerousendangeredspecies,andtransferofthemanagementofCanarianNationalParkstotheregionaladministration. Keywords:Biodiversityloss,endangeredspecies,NationalParks,naturalprotectedareas,politicalcorruption,scientificcommunity,speciesdelisting 1.Seedifferentreactionsathttp://www.nodescatalogacion.com,http://www.wwf.es,http://www.greenpeace.org, http://www.atan.org,http://www.ecologistasenaccion.org,http://especiesamenazadascanarias.blogspot.com, http://ecooceanos.blogspot.com,http://www.seo.org,. 106©2011theauthors;journalcompilation©2011TheInternationalBiogeographySociety—frontiersofbiogeography3.3,2011
notaspeciesofconcernfortheLaurelforest,and soon.Thisisnottosaythatthemostcommon structuringspeciesoftheCanarianecosystems havetobeincludedinthecatalogue,butwe wouldliketodrawattentiontotheinadequacyof theconcept. Butthisconceptualshortcomingpalesin comparisonwiththerealrepercussionofthenew criterion,whichisthatthosespecieslistedhere areonlyprotectedifpresentinanalreadydesignatedNaturalProtectedArea(NPA).(IntheCanaries,thatmeansineithertheCanarianNetwork ofNPAsortheEuropeanUnionNatura2000Network,whichoverlapextensively).Ifalistedspecies,forinstancethewoodcock(Scolopaxrusticola)orthecoot(Fulicaatra)whicharebothincludedunderthenewcriterion,dwellswithinthe limitsoftheprotectedareatheyaresafe;butif anybirdscrossthoselimits(whicharenotthat obvioustobirds,unfamiliarastheyarewithGIS), theycanbeshotlegallybyhunters.Thesameinconsistencyaffects,forinstance,ca.10endemic speciesofsealavenders(Limoniumspp.)protectedincertainravines,butnotinothers. Thenewlawcouldhavenegativeimplicationsforconservationbiogeography,andthiscan beillustratedwithsomeexamplesoftheCanarian floraandfauna.TheendemiclegumeCicercanariensis,previouslyconsideredasvulnerablein the2001Canariancatalogue,isnowincludedunderthecriterionspeciesofinterest.Fromits12 locations(teninLaPalmaandtwoinTenerife), thesixpopulationsintheNorthofLaPalma2are outsideNPAsandthereforeunprotectedaccordingtothenewlaw.Metapopulationdynamicsin thisspeciescouldbeaffectedbythisnewcriterion ifsourcepopulationswithinthesenorthernlocationsarethreatened,endangeringsinkpopulationsincludedinNPAs.Thesamecouldapplyto theAbaloneorCanarianclam(Haliotistuberculata ssp.coccinea)ortheSeaHorse(Hippocampushippocampus).Botharemarinespecieswithsparse populationsinthemeso‐andinfra‐littoral,which donotalwayscoincidewiththegeographicallocationofthemarineSpecialAreasforConservation, whichoccupymainlyleewardfringesontheArchipelago’scoasts.Collectionandcaptureofboth speciesisprohibitedbytheRegulationoftheFish‐ JoséMaríaFernández‐PalaciosandLeadeNascimento 2.AccordingtotheevaluationofthisspeciesbytheCanarianGovernment(ServiciodeBiodiversidad2009),there aresixpopulationnucleiintheNorthofLaPalma,distributedinthreelocationsmorethan10kmdistantonefrom eachother. Box1 Law4/2010,June4,oftheCanarianCatalogueofProtectedSpecies(seetheoriginalSpanishtextat http://www.gobiernodecanarias.org/boc/2010/112/) Article3.Canarianprotectedspecies 2)SpeciesofinterestforCanarianecosystems TheCanarianCatalogueofProtectedSpecieswillalsoinclude“speciesofinterestforCanarianecosystems"whicharethosethat,withoutbeinglistedinthethreateningsituationsabove(endangeredorvulnerable),areworthyofparticularattentionforitsecologicalsignificanceinareasoftheCanarianNetwork ofNaturalProtectedAreasorNatura2000network. 2.EffectsofinclusionintheCatalogue b)Thelegalregimeforprotectionof“speciesofinterestforCanarianecosystems"willbeapplicableonly intheterritoryoftheCanarianNetworkofNaturalProtectedAreasorNatura2000Network.Tothisend, applicablemeasuresshallbeprovidedbythemanagementplansofNaturalProtectedAreasandHabitats oftheNatura2000Networkinwhichtheyarelocated.Suchplansshallincludethedeterminations,controlandmonitoringtoensureeffectivenessofprotection,orwhereapplicable,thejustificationthatthere isnoneedforplans.(...)Inthecaseofactionspromotedbyreasonsofpublicinterestandpriorityaffectingthe“speciesofinterestforCanarianecosystems"theseactionscouldbepossibleaslongastheydo notaffecttheecosystemsubstantially,underthetermsinparagraphs4to7oftheArticle45oftheLaw 42/2007,December13,ofNaturalHeritageandBiodiversity. 107frontiersofbiogeography3.3,2011—©2011theauthors;journalcompilation©2011TheInternationalBiogeographySociety
Canarianconservationnetworkdismantled eriesLawoftheCanaryIslands,buttheirinclusion inthenewcriterionmayleadtoconfusiononthe fishingbaninpopulationsoutsideofthereserve networks. ThecaseoftheseagrassCymodocea nodosaisofparticularinterestfortworeasons; thisspeciesstructuresacommunity(“sebadales”), consideredasNaturalHabitatofCommunityInterestbytheHabitatsDirective,anditspresence inthelittoralzoneisoneofthemainobstaclesto theconstructionorenlargementofharbours.The mostrecentisthePuertodeGranadilla,where conservationofaEuropeanpriorityecosystem comesintoconflictwithEuropeanfundingofa largeinfrastructure.Thesebadalesareakeycommunityfromanecologicalpointofviewasthey playanimportantroleinthecarboncycle,stabilizesandysoils,exportbiomassandactasafish nurseryarea(Barberáetal.2005).Thelattercharacteristicisalsoveryimportantforthesustainabilityoflocalfisheries.Also,themarinemeadowsof C.nodosaintheCanaryIslandsandMauritania arethemostextensiveexamplesatthespecies’ southernlimitandcompromisingthemmaythereforeleadtorangecontraction.Theconstructionof PuertodeGranadillawillseverelydamageoneof themostgeneticallydiversepatchesofsebadales intheArchipelago(Albertoetal.2008).In2009, asaprecautionarymeasure,theSuperiorCourtof JusticeoftheCanaryIslandssuspendedtheproposalsubmittedbytheCanarianGovernment,the PortAuthorityandtheCanarianCompanyofGas Transportation,todelistC.nodosa3.Currently,the EuropeanCourtshavedeclaredadmissiblethe complaintfiledbytheNGOEcologistasenAcción askingforthepublicreleaseofdocumentsthat includedalternativestotheconstructionofthe harbour(includingarenewaloftheinfrastructuresofalreadyexistingharbours),thatwerehiddenfromtheEuropeanCommissionbySpain’s NationalGovernment. Thiscontroversialcriterion—especiesde interésparalosecosistemascanaries—isanadaptationofthecriterion“speciessusceptibleto habitatdisturbance”,fromthepreviouscatalogue. Infact,manyofthespeciesofinterestcomefrom theformerlistofsusceptiblespeciesoraredowngradedthreatenedspecies.Howeverintheformer criteriontherewerenorestrictionsintheprotection,suchasthelocationornotinaNPA,andthe mainconsiderationtoincludeaspecieswasthat itshabitatwasthreatened,inregression,fragmentedorlimited.Thepreviouscriterionforprotectionwasmuchmoreappropriateifwethink aboutthedesignoftheCanarianNetworkof NPAs.UnfortunatelytheCanarianNetworkwas notbasedonathoroughanalysisofmetapopulationdynamics,geneticdiversityorviabilityof populations,butsimplyinprotectinglessdegradedremnantsofcommunitiesthatwerestill available.Asinmanypartsoftheworld,reserves werenotdesignedtomeettheprinciplesofsystematicconservationplanningneededtoachieve representativenessandpersistenceofbiodiversity (MargulesandPressey2000).ThesituationfurtherworsensintheCanarieswhendata,trends andviabilityofpopulationsarealmostunknown. TheCanarianNetworkislargelyprotecting speciesfrommarginalpopulations.Moreover,the protectionofspeciespresentonlyinthecurrent ReserveNetworkinhibitsre‐establishmentof originaldistributions.Agoodexampleisthelaurel forestinAnagaRuralPark,whichnowadaysisthe bestrepresentationofthisforesttypeinTenerife yetstillanimpoverishedfractionofitspastdistributionthroughoutthewindwardslopeoftheisland.Fromthepointofviewofmitigatingtheeffectsofglobalchange,vulnerabilityofcertainspeciesoutsidetheNetworkwouldhinderaltitudinal migration,especiallywhenecologicalcorridorsare notincludedinthedesignofNPAs. ThepracticeofprotectingtaxaonlyinNPAs isalreadyworkinginCatalonia(theonlyprecedentinSpain).TheCatalonianPlanofAreasof NaturalInterestincludesspeciesoffloraand faunastrictlyprotectedindesignatedareas.To ourknowledgenocasesofthefailureofthese practicesorpublicdisapprovalhavebeenreportedthere,butwesuspectthatthespecieswith restrictedprotectionintheCatalonianNPANet‐ 108©2011theauthors;journalcompilation©2011TheInternationalBiogeographySociety—frontiersofbiogeography3.3,2011 3.Seenewsinhttp://www.laprovincia.es. 4.Seehttp://www.laopinion.es,http://www.ecologistasenacción.org.
JoséMaríaFernández‐PalaciosandLeadeNascimento workwerenotdemotedfromhigherprotection. Intheory,themainaimoftheexistenceofregionalcataloguesisensuringtheprotectionof particularspeciesthatarenotconsideredbythe NationalCatalogue.Ontheotherhandseveral authorshavequestionedandanalysedtheeffectivenessofNPAsNetworksinbiodiversityconservation(Jaffreetal.1998,Rodriguesetal.2004) andconcludedthatreservenetworksaregeographicallyandtaxonomicallyunbalancedleaving abigproportionofendemicandthreatenedspeciesunprotected. Thiswayofthinkingmayfunctionwell whenprotectingaresource,forinstancemarine sanctuariesareintendedtoincreasecatchin neighbouringareasoutside,andthisworkscompetentlyintheCanaries’MarineReserveswith FisheryInterest,butisnonsensicalwhentheaim ofthedeclarationistoprotectathreatenedspecies.IfaspeciesisprotectedwhenwithinaNPA, butunprotectedwhenbeyondthearea,whatis reallyachievedintermsofprotection?Mightitbe toocynicaltosuggestthegreatestachievement wouldbethepoliticalgoalofinflatingthenumber ofspeciesincludedinthecataloguethusreducing thenumberofcriticsofdelisting?Despitenumerouspublicprotestsandtheclearoppositionofthe majorityoftheCanarianscientificcommunity,the newcataloguewaspresentedbytheleadingpoliticalforceintheRegionalParliament.These kindsofconflictsarenotexclusivetotheCanary Islandsandarenowadaystakingplaceindifferent regionsoftheworld(Possinghametal.2010, Metzgeretal.2011). Ifthedelistingitselfisnotofsufficientconcern,othernewsmakestheoutlookevenbleaker. TheCanariesharbourfourofthe13National Parks(NPs)inSpain–CañadasdelTeide (Tenerife),CalderadeTaburiente(LaPalma),Timanfaya(Lanzarote)andGarajonay(LaGomera) –despiterepresentingonly1.5%ofthecountry’s geographicalarea.Afterdecentralizationofthe SpanishStatewiththearrivalofthedemocracy, theNPsweresimultaneouslyco‐managedbythe CentralGovernment(Madrid)andtheRegional Governments.However,theSpanishConstitutionalCourtnowhasdeterminedthatNPsmanagementisexclusivelyamatterfortheRegional Governments.ConsequentlytheCentralGovernmenthastransferredallmanagementtotheregions.InthecaseoftheCanarianarchipelago,this managementwasintendedtobesubsequently delegatedtotherespectiveislandCouncils (“Cabildos”)in2012,althoughrecentlythenew deputyofEnvironmentoftheCanarianGovernmentexpressedherintentiontodiscussagainthis transferandtolimitthemanagementoftheislandCouncilsintheNPs. Thetransfertoregionsisnotinherently bad,andforinstancewouldworkexceptionally wellinNorthernEuropeancountries.Theproblem isnotthelawbuthowitisdevelopedwhenthe mainpoliticalpartiesthatgovernintheCanary Islandsshownointerestsinconservation,andan alarmingnumberofitspoliticians,includingsome whohavesignificantresponsibilitiesinconservation,havebeenchargedwithenvironmental crimes5.Althoughsomeimplicationsofdecentralizationshouldbepositive,forinstancethecreation ofregionallistsandplansconsideringtheparticularsofeachNPortheproximitytolocalspecialists andtechnicianswithawiderknowledgeofthe region,theresultisexactlyopposite.Withthe proximityofthemanagementcentrestotheNPs, thelikelihoodofpatronageandcorruptionseems likelytoincreasewhileunificationofconservation criteriaacrossthearchipelago’sfourNPsseems destinedtodecrease,especiallyifthedifferent islandCouncilsaregovernedbydifferentpolitical parties,whichiscurrentlythecase.Inaddition, jointmanagementoftheNPsandtheotherNPAs ineachislandwoulddilutetherigorandresources 5.Seepressreferencesinhttp://www.abc.es/20100322/canarias‐canarias/tres‐imputados‐coronan‐nueva‐ 20100322.html(lastaccessedAugust/2011);http://www.canarias‐semanal.com/elhierro.html(lastaccessedAugust/2011);http://www.eldia.es/2011‐04‐13/CANARIAS/5‐Es‐frecuente‐alcaldes‐esten‐imputados‐delitos‐ urbanisticos.html(lastaccessedAugust/2011);http://www.elpais.com/articulo/espana/corrupcion/presenta/ elecciones/elpepiesp/20110410elpepinac_1/Tes(lastaccessedAugust/2011);http://www.europapress.es/islascanarias/noticia‐imputados‐canarias‐logran‐mantenerse‐instituciones‐20110524094822.html(lastaccessedAugust/2011). 109frontiersofbiogeography3.3,2011—©2011theauthors;journalcompilation©2011TheInternationalBiogeographySociety
dedicatedtoNPs.Consideringthatbudgetsare notfixedthiswouldimplythatfundingtomanage theNPscouldeventuallybeusedinothertasks, moreconsistentwiththe"needsofthemoment". ArecentlycreatedCommissionofCanarianNPs, constitutedmainlyofpoliticiansandwithonlytwo advocatesforenvironmentalissues,leftasidethe presentdirectorsandconservatorsoftheNPs.It couldalsohappenthatoncetransferredtothe Councils,theelectionofnewdirectorswillnot considerthebalancebetweenconservationand managementskillsthatsuchpositionrequires. TheislandCouncilsarealreadyinchargeof themanagementoftheCanarianNetworkof NPAs.Whilesomeoftheseareashavebeenactivelymanagedotherslackanytypeofcontrol. ThesituationofsimilarNPAsvariesamongislands andformosttheactionplanshavebeenpartially orbarelyfulfilled,sothatnowadays(morethan tenyearsafteritsdeclaration)itisstilleasytofind dumps,illegalconstructions,invasivespecies,togetherwithotherpotentialemergingthreats.Despitethecapacityandgoodworkofenvironmentaltechnicians,whostrugglewithbudgetcuts everyyear,theCouncilshavedemonstratedatrajectoryofinefficiencyandlackofcommitmentto themanagementofNPAs.WithinthenewCanarianNPsframework,therabbitswillreceivethe responsibilityoftakingcareofthelettuces. Acknowledgements WewouldliketothankRafaelLoyolaandthree anonymousreviewersfortheircommentsonthe manuscript.Wearealsogratefultotheeditorial boardofFrontiersinBiogeographyfortheirhelp improvingthispaper. References Alberto,F.,Massa,S.,Manent,P.,Diaz‐Almela,E.,Arnaud‐Haond,S.,Duarte,C.M.&Serrão,E.A. (2008)Geneticdifferentiationandsecondary contactzoneintheseagrassCymodoceanodosa acrosstheMediterranean–Atlantictransition region.JournalofBiogeography,35,1279–1294. Barberá,C.,TuyaF.,BoyraC.,Sanchez‐JerezP.,Blanch I.&HarounR.J.(2005)Spatialvariationinthe structuralparametersofCymodoceanodosa seagrassmeadowsintheCanaryIslands:amultiscaledapproach.BotanicaMarina,48,122– 126. Fernández‐Palacios,J.M.&Whittaker,R.(2008)Canaries.Animportantbiogeographicalmeeting place.JournalofBiogeography,35,379–387. Francisco‐Ortega,J.,Santos‐Guerra,A.,Kim,S.C.& Crawford,D.(2000)Plantgeneticdiversityinthe CanaryIslands:Aconservationperspective. AmericanJournalofBotany,87,909–919. Jaffre,T.,Bouchet,P.,Veillon,J.M.(1998)Threatened plantsofNewCaledonia:Isthesystemofprotectedareasadequate?BiodiversityandConservation,7,109–135. Juan,C.,Emerson,B.C.,Oromí,P.&Hewitt,G.M. (2000)Colonizationanddiversification:towards aphylogeneticsynthesisfortheCanaryIslands. TrendsinEcologyandEvolution,15,104–109. Margules,C.R.&Pressey,R.L.(2000)Systematicconservationplanning.Nature,405,243–253. Metzger,J.P.,Lewinsohn,T.M.,Joly,C.A.,Verdade, L.M.,Martinelli,L.A.,Rodrigues,R.R.(2011)BrazilianLaw:FullSpeedinReverse?Science,329, 276–277. Possingham,H.P.etal.(2010)OpenlettertothePrime MinisterandLeaderoftheOpposition,Science supportingmarineprotectedareas,signedby 152Australianscientists.Availablefromhttp:// www.ecology.uq.edu.au/docs/Marine% 20Reserve%20Scientist%20Ltr% 2018Aug2010.pdf(lastaccessedOctober/2011) Rodrigues,A.S.L.,Andelman,S.J.,Bakarr,M.I.,etal. (2004)Effectivenessoftheglobalprotectedarea networkinrepresentingspeciesdiversity.Nature,428,640–643. ServiciodeBiodiversidad(2009).EvaluacióndeespeciescatalogadasdeCanarias:Cicercanariensis [Ciccan06/2009].ConsejeríadeMedioAmbienteyOrdenaciónTerritorial,GobiernodeCanarias,LasPalmasdeGranCanaria.Availableat http://www.gobcan.es/cmayot/ medioambiente/medionatural/biodiversidad/ especies/especies_protegidas_amenazadas/ EditedbyJoaquínHortal&MichaelNDawson YoucanfindinformationabouttheInternationalBiogeographySocietyathttp:// www.biogeography.org/,andcontactwithotherbiogeographersattheIBSblog(http:// biogeography.blogspot.com/),theIBSfacebookgroup(http://www.facebook.com/group.php? gid=6908354463)andtheIBStwitterchannel(https://twitter.com/biogeography). 110©2011theauthors;journalcompilation©2011TheInternationalBiogeographySociety—frontiersofbiogeography3.3,2011 Canarianconservationnetworkdismantled