Full text
Ci a ion: Cal o-Iglesias, E.; Epi anio,
I. Re isi ing Male Allies in Ma hema ics
and Physics Th oughou His o y: Role
Models o Men in STEM Educa ion.
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535. h ps://
doi.o g/10.3390/educsci14050535
Academic Edi o : Ambe Simpson
Recei ed: 7 Ap il 2024
Re ised: 12 May 2024
Accep ed: 13 May 2024
Published: 16 May 2024
Copy igh : © 2024 by he au ho s.
Licensee MDPI, Basel, Swi ze land.
This a icle is an open access a icle
dis ibu ed unde he e ms and
condi ions o he C ea i e Commons
A ibu ion (CC BY) license (h ps://
c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/
4.0/).
educa ion
sciences
Essay
Re isi ing Male Allies in Ma hema ics and Physics Th oughou
His o y: Role Models o Men in STEM Educa ion
Encina Cal o-Iglesias 1and I ene Epi anio 2,*
1
Depa men o Applied Physics, Uni e si y o San iago de Compos ela, 15782 San iago de Compos ela, Spain;
[email p o ec ed]
2Depa men o Ma hema ics-IF, Jaume I Uni e si y, 12071 Cas elló de la Plana, Spain
*Co espondence: [email p o ec ed]
Abs ac : In he academic wo ld, he e a e also gende inequali ies, which a e especially isible in
ce ain masculinized STEM a eas, such as physics and ma hema ics. An essen ial ac o in co ec ing
hese inequali ies is he in ol emen o men, who should ac as “allies” in he uni e si y se ing.
Likewise, as he li e a u e shows us, we mus o e models wi h gende -incong uen oles o b eak
down s e eo ypes and p omo e non- adi ional beha io s. Howe e , o da e, hese ac ions ha e been
especially di ec ed owa d women, who gene ally do no hold powe and he e o e ha e less possibil-
i y o p omo ing change. Fo he i s ime, his wo k compiles, in a single documen , impo an male
physicis s and ma hema icians who ac ed as allies o women h oughou his o y. These examples can
be p esen ed o p o ide male e e ences in he eaching o physics and ma hema ics a uni e si y (and
high school). Wi h his ini ia i e, we in end o con ibu e o inco po a ing he gende pe spec i e in
uni e si y eaching, since, in p ac ice, uni e si y p o esso s a e unawa e o e e ences o al e na i e
masculini ies in he academic wo ld. We hope ha his a icle will be he seed o eco e hidden
male allies in hese and o he scien i ic ields. This can help b eak down s e eo ypes, and con a y o
p e ious ac ions, his wo k is especially di ec ed owa d men.
Keywo ds: ma hema ics educa ion; physics educa ion; STEM eaching; ma hema ics his o y; physics
his o y; gende equali y; male ad oca es; masculini ies; s e eo ypes
MSC: 97C60; 01A70; 97U99; 00A05; 00A79
1. In oduc ion
Gende inequali ies pe sis e en in coun ies wi h high a es o gende equali y. Fo
example, in ecen yea s, di e en laws ha e been app o ed in Spain ha ha e made i one
o he mos ad anced coun ies wi h espec o gende equali y. In ac , acco ding o a epo
om he Eu opean Ins i u e o Gende Equali y (EIGE), Spain is he ou h coun y in he
Eu opean Union (EU) on he gende equali y index o 2021 [
1
]. Bu despi e hese ad ances
in equali y policies, he e is s ill a gende wage gap in Spain and low co- esponsibili y, and
in ecen mon hs, a wo ying up ick in gende iolence has been obse ed [2].
These p oblems also a ec ins i u ions such as uni e si ies, which could be he engine
o change in ou socie y, bu which can ha dly be so i he glass ceiling [
3
] and he gende
wage gap [
4
,
5
] pe sis and si ua ions o sexual ha assmen and gende -based ha assmen
occu [
6
]. Simila ly, Moss-Racusin e al.
[7]
e ealed ha scien is s a e biased in hi ing
and encou aging men o e women. Sugimo o and La i iè e
[8]
also e ealed a gap in
ci a ions a o ing men-led pape s in mos coun ies, in e ms o bo h i s au ho ship and
las au ho ship. This si ua ion a o s e ical seg ega ion ha s ill pe sis s in uni e si ies
and public esea ch o ganiza ions. In Spain, he epo Cien í icas en ci as 2023 (Female
scien is s in igu es 2023) [
9
] shows ha in he ea ly s ages o esea ch ca ee s, women and
men a e equally ep esen ed, bu emale alen is p og essi ely being los , un il we ind ha
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/educsci14050535 h ps://www.mdpi.com/jou nal/educa ion
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 2 o 21
women a e unde - ep esen ed a he highes posi ions, only 25.6% [
9
]. This ac con ibu es
o a 12.7% pay gap in uni e si ies [
4
]. In addi ion, he epo ci ed abo e shows ha women
ob ain less unding, e.g., “in 2020, g an s o he implemen a ion o scien i ic esea ch and
echnological de elopmen o p oposals gene a ed by women we e a o al amoun o EUR
254.9 million, compa ed o EUR 420.7 million awa ded o p oposals gene a ed by men. The
amoun awa ded o women ep esen s 37.7% o he o al amoun , which is much lowe han
he pe cen age ob ained by men (62.3%)” [
9
] (p. 91). Fu he mo e, Cabe o and Epi anio
[10]
laid ba e he gende gap in childca e wi h Spanish academic s a . The e was a di e ence
o 30 h pe week, on a e age, be ween emale and male academic s a o ca e du ing he
pe iod o pa en ing. The e o e, gende oles con inue o be p esen wi h Spanish academic
s a , and his con i ms he need o eal changes in ou ins i u ions.
Ha ing a legisla i e amewo k ha a o s gende equali y is a g ea ad ance, bu
i is no enough. Fo example, a ecen e iew o he s udy plans and eaching guides o
he P ima y Educa ion Deg ee highligh s ha “ he Teaching Guides, o he mos pa , use
language ha encou ages he in isibili y o women, hey lack coeduca ional compe encies,
con en , objec i es and esou ces and ha e an unequal dis ibu ion be ween women and
men p esen in he bibliog aphy” [
11
] (p. 255). Likewise, he epo Cien í icas en ci as 2023
(Female scien is s in igu es 2023) emphasizes ha “ he in eg a ion o sex/gende analysis
in he con en o eaching is one o he un esol ed issues ha has no been achie ed in all
uni e si ies, since only wo hi ds o public uni e si ies and hal o p i a e uni e si ies
claim o ha e ca ied ou ac ions aimed a p omo ing he inco po a ion o he gende
dimension in class ooms in 2022” [
9
] (p. 117), and his inac ion is also con i med by he
epo Las polí icas de igualdad uni e si a ias (Uni e si y equali y policies) p epa ed by he
Spanish Ne wo k o Equali y Uni s o Gende o Uni e si y Excellence [
12
] and Epi anio
and Cal o-Iglesias
[13]
, who analyzed he ac ions o gende equali y in scien i ic– echnical
a eas in Spanish uni e si ies.
To unde s and his low mains eaming o he gende pe spec i e, we mus ake in o
accoun ha , in ecen yea s, neolibe al measu es ha e been adop ed in he uni e si y con-
ex ha ha e encou aged eache s o p io i ize esea ch o e eaching, bo h o consolida e
hei ca ee s and in o de o gain access o a pe manen posi ion [
14
,
15
]. These measu es
ha e especially a ec ed young women wi h childca e esponsibili ies, because ca ing o
amily membe s o s uden s con inues o be a woman’s ask [
16
]. Fu he mo e, he da a
om he Cien í icas en Ci as epo con i m low male pa icipa ion, a ound 25%, in aining
ac ions on gende equali y in uni e si ies and public esea ch o ganiza ions. This gende
imbalance in pa icipa ion in equali y aining cou ses is wo ying o wo easons. On
he one hand, men con inue o hold powe in hese ins i u ions and monopolize he mos
impo an posi ions [
17
]. On he o he hand, he e a e highly masculinized a eas such as
enginee ing, especially hose ela ed o compu e science [
18
], physics, o ma hema ics,
whe e i is necessa y o in oduce he gende pe spec i e o end gende biases ha can
a ec he de elopmen o echnological p oduc s, as we can see in he de elopmen o
AI [
19
], o in he de ec ion o diseases ha cos money and e en li es [
20
]. By “masculinized
a eas” we mean ha hey a e masculinized in e ms o hei pe cep ion and in e ms o
hei p ac i ione s. As Gonsal es e al.
[21]
indica ed, “ he discipline o physics is no only
domina ed by men, bu also is laden wi h masculine conno a ions on a symbolical le el,
and ha his limi ed and limi ing cons uc ion o physics has made i di icul o many
women o ind a place in he discipline”. Le us also ecall ha a ew yea s ago, S umia,
a male pa icle physicis , s a ed ha “Physics was in en ed and buil by men, i is no by
in i a ion” [22].
The e o e, o ensu e g ea e equali y, we need o inc ease he pa icipa ion o men
who ac as allies o eminism wi hin he uni e si y. And i is necessa y o know wha
d i es hem o abandon hei p i ileges in o de o a ac mo e men o hese al e na i e
masculini ies [
23
]. In his pape , we will show he impo ance o p o iding masculine
e e ences wi hin he amewo k o new masculini ies o non-hegemonic masculini ies and
how we could inco po a e hem in he eaching o subjec s such as physics o ma hema ics.
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 3 o 21
To he bes o ou knowledge, his is he i s wo k ha compiles male allies h oughou
his o y in hese ields.
1.1. Egali a ian o Al e na i e Masculini ies
In e es in egali a ian o al e na i e masculini ies has inc eased in ecen yea s in
Spain. And al hough esea ch on his opic is s ill sca ce [
24
], al eady, “I is beginning
o be conside ed ha , wi hou a change in men, i will no be possible o achie e gende
equali y” [
25
] (p. 60). Thus, se e al pos g adua e cou ses on masculini ies and equali y
ha e been launched, such as he one a Uni e sidad Miguel He nández; con e ences ha e
been held; and aining is beginning o be p o ided o eache s and s uden s on his opic.
In ac , he Uni e si a Au ònoma de Ba celona has launched he Masculini y Wo kspace,
wi h which i aims o p o ide a suppo se ice aimed a men who wan o e hink hei
way o ela ing om a non-sexis pe spec i e. These cou ses and hese spaces a e impo an
since, as López Ramos and Ci e
[23]
(p. 292) poin ed ou , “ he change owa ds egali a ian
masculini ies equi es a e lec i e and p ac ical e o o he men who pe pe ua e i . An
e o ha canno be achie ed wi hou some ype o impulse om he social en i onmen ”.
The p omo ion o equali y wi hin he uni e si y en i onmen is essen ial in masculin-
ized disciplines such as physics, ma hema ics, and enginee ing o pu an end o he sexis
no ms ha s ill pe sis in hese disciplines and ha p e en women om ad ancing. The
s udy by Dancy and Hoda i
[26]
showed us how men in he ield o physics who suppo ed
he discou se o equali y in hei usual p ac ices main ained sexis no ms ha in alida ed
hose discou ses. And as Sugimo o and La i iè e
[8]
(p. 1) poin ed ou , gende dispa i ies
in science a e seen as a hing o he pas . The same goes o o he ypes o disc imina ion,
such as acism [27].
The e o e, people who occupy posi ions o powe in hese disciplines should pa ici-
pa e and ge in ol ed in ac ions ha a o equali y, s a ing wi h aining, because oday,
we should all know wha he scisso g aph ep esen s in he e olu ion o eaching and
esea ch s a . This g aph shows he e olu ion o women and men in hei academic ca ee s.
As he ajec o y p og esses, be o e ob aining a doc o a e and up o becoming a esea ch
p o esso , he pe cen age o women dec eases and ha o men inc eases. A he beginning,
he e a e sligh ly mo e women han men (excep in physics, enginee ing, and compu e
science (PECS) a eas), so he wo lines c oss. This is why i is called a scisso g aph.
Un o una ely, his is no he case [
28
], and we mus assume he consequences o doing
no hing, since i we a e no pa o he solu ion, we a e pa o he p oblem. In ac , ecen ly, in
Spain, uling 134/2021, o 24 Feb ua y, issued by he con en ious adminis a i e Chambe o
he Supe io Cou o Jus ice o he Valencian Communi y [
29
], ecognizes ha disc imina ion
can occu h ough omission, ha is, by no ac ing when he e is disc imina ion.
In ecen yea s, equali y measu es in scien i ic and echnical ields ha e ocused mainly
on women and gi ls and, mo e ecen ly, on LGTBIQ+ people, o ge ing ha i is he g oups
wi h p i ilege ha can a o change. Wi hou abandoning hese equali y measu es, we
need o he measu es ha allow us o inco po a e mo e men because, as bell hooks
[30]
(p. XVII) s a ed “I is no ue ha men a e unwilling o change. I is ue ha many men
a e a aid o change” .
And o his, i is necessa y o acili a e he knowledge and isibili y o al e na i e
and egali a ian models o men. These models a e no new, and as Bace e
[31]
(p. 30)
highligh ed, “dissidence, also in he male sphe e, has always been p esen , al hough i s
di e en exp essions ha e eached ou days wi h di icul y, because he na a i e o he
s o ies o dissiden men, as wi h ha o women, i is also biased, condi ioned and impac ed
by sexism”. And h oughou his o y he e ha e been
men such as Nicolas de Condo ce , Cha les Fou ie , William Thompson, John
S ua Mill, Léon Riche , Jin Tianhe and Taha Haddad ha e suppo ed he
emancipa ion o women. They de ended women’s physical in eg i y, libe y o
mo emen , and in ellec ual, ci il and poli ical equali y. They demanded ha
women ha e he igh o lea n, wo k, o e, lo e and be au onomous. [32] (p. X)
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 4 o 21
In scien i ic and echnical ields, we can also ind examples o dissiden men who ha e
suppo ed hei emale colleagues o disciples a wo k and in li e. And we need o in eg a e
hem in o ou explana ions and o e hem as models o ollow, as we will show in he
nex sec ion.
1.2. Fai Men, Also in Science?
The ision o science and echnology ha con inues o be ansmi ed in he class ooms
is posi i is . In gene al, he disas ous consequences ha ce ain disco e ies ha e had, such
as hose ha led o he a omic bomb, o he consequences o humani y o his indus ial
capi alism ha deple es na u al esou ces and endange s ou su i al on he plane , a e
no analyzed. The ac ha women we e e ased om he his o y o science and he scan
ecogni ion o hei con ibu ions is no ques ioned ei he . I con inues o be hough ha
science is neu al and objec i e, o ge ing ha i is made by people and can he e o e be
a ec ed in any way by hei biases. E en hough ex books con inue o ansmi o us an
and ocen ic ision o scien i ic knowledge, p og ess has been made, as e lec ed by he
la ge numbe o books abou emale scien is s aimed a child en and young people.
In he na a i e ha con inues o be sha ed abou science, scien is s con inue o be
p esen ed as he oes o he oines, and hei con ibu ions a e a ely ques ioned. No only
his, bu we ha e ecen ly seen how he p emie e o he ilm Oppenheime was celeb a ed.
Howe e , he e en i depic s should be seen as he bigges ailu e in he his o y o science
and echnology due o he des uc ion ha i caused. Fu he mo e, i should lead us o
analyze he alliance be ween science and echnology, and enginee ing and wa h oughou
his o y. And he ilm igno es he ole o Lise Mei ne , whom he No h Ame ican p ess
labeled he mo he o he nuclea bomb, in he disco e y o nuclea ission [
33
]. In hese
imes o ene gy and clima e c ises, su ounded by wa s, we need o he ypes o s o ies,
whe e e hics and human alues, like hose shown by Lise Mei ne who e used o pa icipa e
in he Manha an p ojec , help us build a ai e wo ld. This also conce ns he ision
o science ha we each in he class oom, whe e we mus ecognize no only scien i ic
achie emen s bu also he alue hey ha e had o socie y, including suppo o women in
he ield o science. In addi ion, i is necessa y o change he app oach o knowledge and
me hodology o Wes e n science o ien ed owa d he dominance o na u e [
34
]. We need o
do away wi h he masculinis app oach ha ocuses on he use o echnology o o e come
his c isis and inco po a e emale and excluded oices, as well as social and gende jus ice
conce ns abou he impac o clima e change on women and ulne able popula ions [34].
The his o y o science could be used as a eaching esou ce in his sense “since i allows
us o ex ac om i he mos signi ican p oblems ha esea ch had o ace a he ime,
in addi ion o o e ing a sample o he con o e sial na u e o scien i ic esea ch, which is
he esul o he wo k o nume ous people, mos ly men, and igno ing he con ibu ions
o women scien is s” [
35
] (p. 22). Thus, einse ing women in o scien i ic his o y and e-
claiming hei knowledge and ha o o he adi ionally excluded g oups will con ibu e o
ending he sexism, and ocen ism, and colonialism ha s ill pe mea e scien i ic knowledge.
We would like o emphasize ha we ind i e y in e es ing o use his o ical en ichmen as
a p oposal o decolonize he cu iculum [
36
]. Bu ou p oposal is ocused on cha ac e s o
he XIX and XX cen u ies ha buil he physics and ma hema ics ha we mainly each in
uni e si y cou ses on physics and ma hema ics.
Since Enheduanna (2300 BCE), who is conside ed he i s emale au ho and also he
i s emale scien is in his o y, he e ha e been many women who ha e con ibu ed o he
ad ancemen o science, mos ly women om he uppe classes o belonging o amilies o
scien is s, as is he case o many as onome s. As Sugimo o and La i iè e [8] (p. 17) said,
Be o e he wen ie h cen u y, science was associa ed wi h ama eu ism, which
allowed weal hy women and hose who ma ied scien is s o pa icipa e in sci-
en i ic ac i i ies. Beginning in he 1870s, women inc eased hei membe ship in
scien i ic o ganiza ions and began ob aining employmen in museums and obse -
a o ies. By he end o he nine een h cen u y, howe e , science began a p ocess o
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 5 o 21
p o essionaliza ion ha se ed o dec ease women’s access o schola ship. When
science became codi ied as a p o essional—and he e o e masculine—domain,
women we e u he isola ed om pa icipa ion.
Un il ecen ly, we did no know hei names, bu oday, hanks o books such as
Hypa ia’s He i age by Alic
[37]
, which has inspi ed many o he s, we a e al eady eco e ing
hem. And in addi ion o eco e ing hei names and hei legacy, we should also ecognize
he men who suppo ed hem, such as Py hago as (490 BCE), known as “ he philosophe
iend o women”, and Gös a Mi ag-Le le (1846–1927), a de ende o women’s access o
academic posi ions ha hey we e p ohibi ed om holding. We need ole models o men
who do no app op ia e he disco e ies o hei emale colleagues and who ecognize hei
wo h, as Pie e Cu ie did when he claimed he Nobel P ize o Ma ie Cu ie, as well as
men who help and ecognize emale alen , such as William He schel and F ied ich Pockels,
who helped hei sis e s Ca oline He schel (1750–1848) and Agnes Pockels
(1862–1935)
de elop hei scien i ic alen . Al hough i is ue ha in he case o W. He schel and
o he s, his suppo could be in e p e ed as ha ing been p o ided o his own bene i , as
Donald [38] (p. 21)
ema ked, “Ca oline He schel was able o be an ou lie , o midable
al hough he con ibu ions we e, by i ue o he ci cles which she was able o pene a e
h ough he b o he ”. Simila ly, we wan male p o esso s who alue he abili ies o hei
emale s uden s, such as Ka l Weie s aß (1815–1897) and Max Planck (1858–1947) wi h So ia
Ko alé skaya (1850–1891) and Lise Mei ne (1878–1968), espec i ely, al hough nei he o
hem we e, in p inciple, a o able o he admission o women o uni e si ies, and Geo ge
Gamow (194–1968), who made i possible o Ve a Rubin (1928–2016) o ca y ou he
hesis. Mo eo e , i is impo an ha , in ou p esen a ions, ou i ual class ooms, and
ou eachings, when making hese women scien is s isible, we highligh he alue o he
male allies who helped hem de elop hei alen . Because i is no ai ha women, “as
Glo ia S einem would say, (...) om he momen we en e kinde ga en un il we inish
he doc o a e, (...) we dedica e ou sel es i elessly o s udying ou own absence” [
39
]
(p. 19), o ha men do no ha e equal mi o s in which o look a hemsel es. We ag ee
wi h Gonsal es e al.
[40]
on he u ili y o s o y-based me hodologies o explo ing he
di e en pa hs ollowed o s ay and belong in physics.
In seconda y school, i is impo an o o e o he s o ies abou science [
41
] ha can
a ac mo e women o mino ized g oups [
42
] o his discipline who do no iden i y wi h
his supe masculini y ha seems o domina e physics and o he STEM a eas.
2. Male Allies in Ma hema ics and Physics
A na a i e e iew is conside ed. Unlike sys ema ic e iews ha a e guided by
p ocedu es such as PRISMA (P e e ed Repo ing I ems o Sys ema ic Re iews and Me a-
Analyses), he e a e no es ablished p ocedu es o na a i e e iews. We ollow he guide-
lines o na a i e e iews sugges ed by Sukhe a
[43]
, which a e as ollows: (1) a ionale
o a na a i e e iew; (2) cla i y o bounda ies, scope, and de ini ions; (3) jus i ica ion o
inclusion and exclusion c i e ia; (4) e lexi i y and a sa u a ion/su iciency s a emen ; and
(5) de ails on analysis and in e p e a ion. Rega ding he i s poin , we chose a na a i e
e iew because his opic is unde - esea ched, which is a si ua ion whe e a na a i e e iew
is use ul o educa o s [
43
]. We compiled e idence om mul iple sou ces in o one accessi-
ble and usable documen . Some o hose sou ces a e “neu al”, i.e., hey limi hemsel es
o s a ing ce ain ac s. Howe e , we conside ed a gende egali a ianism poin o iew
(poin 5). The e o e, his is also a c i ical e iew om he gende equali y pe spec i e. As
ega ds poin (4), na a i e e iews do no aim o be inclusi e o all li e a u e abou he
opic. The e o e, o he sake o b e i y, we p io i ized including mo e scien is s using a
limi ed numbe o e e ences pe scien is han including many e e ences o ew scien is s.
Conce ning poin s 2 and 3, hey a e speci ied as ollows.
In his sec ion, we will e iew male physicis s and ma hema icians who ac ed as
allies o he emale physics and ma hema ics (poin 3) who usually appea in he syllabi o
undamen al physics and ma hema ics subjec s in Spain (poin 2), no only in physics and
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 6 o 21
ma hema ics deg ees, bu also in mos science and enginee ing deg ees; so, hey would
se e o STEM deg ees in gene al. We will also poin ou he male ma hema icians and
physicis s who no only we e no allies bu also ac ually ac ed agains hem in o de o be
especially ca e ul and no use hem as e e ences (poin 3). In addi ion o STEM deg ees,
ma hema ics, and especially s a is ics, is augh in deg ees in he ields o heal h and social
sciences. Consequen ly, he scope o applica ion is no es ic ed only o STEM (poin 2).
2.1. Ma hema ics and S a is ics
Fi s ly, we will use some espec ed igu es ha appea in a basic s a is ics subjec as a
common h ead, combining his wi h he in oduc ion o espec ed igu es in o he a eas
o ma hema ics.
2.1.1. Desc ip i e S a is ics
In he ield o desc ip i e s a is ics, Flo ence Nigh ingale (1820–1910) [
44
] is a no able
name as she was a pionee in using s a is ical g aphs o achie e changes in he s a egies
o au ho i ies [
45
]. She had James Joseph Syl es e (1814–1897) as a u o , known among
o he hings o his con ibu ions in he ield o ma ices. Syl es e was a iend o ano he
illus ious ma hema ician, A hu Cayley (1821–1895), who suppo ed uni e si y educa ion
o women. In he ea ly days o Gi on College, Camb idge’s i s women’s college, Cayley
assis ed in eaching. Addi ionally, he was chai man o he council o Newnham College,
Camb idge’s second women’s college. Cha lo e Angas Sco ’s (1858–1931) [
46
] hesis was
di ec ed by Cayley, who ecommended ha she mo e o B yn Maw College (USA) so
she could wo k he e. In his way, Sco was able o supe ise he doc o a es o a leas
eigh emale ma hema icians, many o whom s udied wi h Felix Klein (1849–1925) a he
Uni e si y o Gö ingen.
Among Flo ence Nigh ingale’s allies, wi h whom she wo ked and co esponded
ex ensi ely, a e he s a is icians William Fa (1807–1883) and Lambe Adolphe Que ele
(1796–1874), ecognized as one o he a he s o mode n s a is ics. Toge he wi h F ancis
Gal on (1822–1911) (a s a is ician ecognized o a ious con ibu ions, such as s anda d
de ia ion, coining he e ms pe cen ile and co ela ion), he collabo a ed o c ea e a new
Chai o S a is ics a Ox o d, wi hou success. Howe e , we mus be cau ious wi h bo h
Gal on and o he amous s a is icians such as Ka l Pea son (1857–1936) and Ronald Fishe
(1890–1962), who had deep ies o eugenics and acial and class p ejudices, and no use hem
as e e ences, i.e., no be conside ed exempla s o be emula ed. Ins ead, hei his o y can be
shown o e lec on he ole o s a is ics in he wo ld [
47
], i.e., b inging hese igu es up in
he class oom could be use ul. This ecommenda ion conce ns no only hese pa icula
s a is icians; we mus be wa y mo e b oadly, and we ad ise no o be blindly suppo i e o
a pa icula scien is .
Gal on’s beha io was also sexis . He c ea ed a “beau y map” o he women o G ea
B i ain based on he sec e obse a ion o women om di e en egions, whom he a ed on
a scale as a ac i e, indi e en , o epulsi e, indica ing his opinions on a piece o pape in
he shape o a c oss. His cousin, Cha les Da win (1809–1882), de ended he in e io i y o
women o men. The ollowing is an ex ac om a le e he w o e o Lady Ca oline Kenna d
(1827–1907), a leading igu e in he eminis mo emen o he ime:
I ce ainly hink ha women hough gene ally supe io o men [in] mo al quali ies
a e in e io in ellec ually; and he e seems o me o be a g ea di icul y om he
laws o inhe i ance, (i I unde s and hese laws co ec ly) in hei becoming he
in ellec ual equals o man. [48] (p. 14).
No only did Da win conside women in e io , bu he also added ha women should
no aspi e o a li e ou side he home, since ha would be de imen al o he happiness o
child en and homes [48].
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 7 o 21
2.1.2. P obabili y
Con inuing wi h he concep s ha appea in basic s a is ics subjec s, in he ield o
p obabili y, Bo elian algeb a is shown, in hono o Emile Bo el (1871–1956). Bo el suppo ed
he wo k o his wi e Ma gue i e Appell (1883–1969), known as Camille Ma bo, a enowned
F ench eminis w i e , and hey bo h ounded he scien i ic and li e a y magazine Re ue du
Mois. In 1911, he and Ma bo hos ed Ma ie Cu ie (1867–1934) in hei home when Cu ie,
hen a widow, was a acked o he a ai wi h Paul Lange in (1872–1946) (de ails can be
ound in he physics sec ion), despi e p essu e om he F ench go e nmen o no accep
he . Bo el and Lange in we e ac i e in he de ense o human igh s. Bo el p oposed a law o
gua an ee he ep esen a ion o women in municipal councils [
49
]. His social commi men
also led him o be a membe o he F ench Resis ance du ing Wo ld Wa II.
Mo e han a hund ed yea s ea lie , ano he ma hema ician, Nicolas de Condo ce
(1743–1794), had been e y ac i e in de ending women’s igh s, being in a o o he emale
o e, which was no achie ed in F ance un il 1945.
In Bo el’s academic amily, we ind ano he ally, his hesis supe iso , he illus ious
Jean Gas on Da boux (1842–1917), who was in ol ed in ounding he École no male
supé ieu e de jeunes illes in 1880. Howe e , his academic g andson, Lau en Schwa z
(1915–2002), winne o a Field Medal in 1950, al hough poli ically ac i e (he was a T o skyis
and an i-colonialis , signing he Mani es o o he 121 on he Alge ian Wa , o which his
igh o each was suspended om 1961 o 1963) [
50
], did no ac i ely suppo his wi e,
ma hema ician Ma ie-Hélène Schwa z (1913–2013), daugh e o ma hema ician Paul Lé y
(1886–1971), wi h no ma hema ical exchanges ound be ween he couple [51].
Lé y was supe ised by Jacques Salomon Hadama d (1865–1963) and Vi o Vol e a
(1860–1940). Vol e a was ano he dis inguished ma hema ician, ac i ely engaged in an i-
ascism. He was one o 12 p o esso s ou o 1250 who e used o ake he obliga o y oa h o
loyal y o he ascis go e nmen o Beni o Mussolini in 1931. Consequen ly, he was expelled
om his posi ion a he uni e si y and om his membe ship o I alian scien i ic academies,
li ing ab oad o much o he nex ew yea s and only e u ning o Rome jus be o e his
dea h in 1940. Vol e a was an ally. In 1906, he p oposed he ounding o he Socie à I aliana
pe il P og esso delle Scienze (SIPS), a whose inaugu al cong ess he was elec ed p esiden
and whose inno a i e s a u es made i possible o women scien is s o join he socie y.
Vol e a suppo ed his emale disciples, helping hem o pu sue ca ee s, in con as o he
hinking held by some men acco ding o which women could no each he high sphe es o
ma hema ics [
52
]. Vol e a wo ked wi h he ollowing emale ma hema icians: Co nelia
Fab i (1869–1915), Elena F eda (1890–1978) and he sis e Eleono a F eda, Giudi a G aziani
(18??–?), Cesi a O landi (1881–?), Pie ina Quin ili (~1880–?), Emma Sciole e (1886–?), and
Gina Zanoni (~1890–?).
Con inuing wi h p obabili y, ano he ele an name is Pa nu y Chebyshe (1821–1894),
who go he illus ious So ia Ko alé skaya (1850–1891) o be named an hono a y membe o
he Sain Pe e sbu g Academy o Sciences [
53
]. Howe e , among Ko alé skaya’s allies, we
also ind enowned physicis s and ma hema icians om o he a eas o ma hema ics apa
om p obabili y, such as he amous physicis Gus a Ki chho (1824–1887), who allowed
he o a end his classes. A special men ion should be made o he amous ma hema ician,
Ka l Weie s aß (1815–1897), conside ed he a he o mode n analysis, who was he men o .
Since she was no allowed o a end classes, Weie s aß u o ed he , gi ing he p i a e
lessons o ee o ou yea s. Weie s aß made use o one o his o me s uden s, he
ma hema ician Laza us Fuchs (1833–1902) a he Uni e si y o Gö ingen, and h ough
him and wi h a g ea deal o e o , in 1874, he managed o ha e Ko alé skaya awa ded
a doc o a e wi hou an o al exam, based only on he wo k she submi ed. Ano he o
Ko alé skaya’s g ea allies was Gös a Mi ag-Le le (1846–1927), who ga e he a posi ion
as a p o esso a S ockholm Uni e si y in 1883, al hough he i s yea was wi hou any
sala y (he s uden s paid he ), and she was appoin ed p o esso o li e in 1889.
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 8 o 21
2.1.3. P obabili y Dis ibu ions
In p obabili y dis ibu ions, many names o illus ious ma hema icians appea , some
allies and o he s no , as will be explained, pi o ing a ound he eminen ma hema ician
Sophie Ge main (1776–1831). Sophie Ge main was a sel - augh ma hema ician since she
was no allowed o access o mal aining [
54
]. The École Poly echnique, ounded in 1794,
did no admi women un il 1972, a he end o he 20 h cen u y. The e o e, Ge main ob ained
he no es o he amous ma hema ician Joseph Louis Lag ange (1736–1813) h ough a
amily iend, An oine-Augus e Le Blanc, and submi ed he wo k unde his name. When
Lag ange, who admi ed he wo k, me he , he encou aged he o con inue, in i ing he
o he ma hema ical ga he ings ha he o ganized [
55
]. Ano he no able ma hema ician
and ally was Ad ien-Ma ie Legend e (1752–1833), wi h whom Ge main collabo a ed on
an equal oo ing. Bap is e Joseph Fou ie (1768–1830) was also an ally. A e being elec ed
Pe manen Sec e a y o he Academy o Sciences, Fou ie allowed he o a end sessions,
being he i s woman who was no he wi e o an academic o do so. Among Ge main’s
allies, Ka l F ied ich Gauss (1777–1855) s ands ou : he p o usely p aised Ge main’s alen ,
poin ing ou he p ejudices and obs acles she su e ed o being a woman, bu as Mackinnon
(1990) highligh ed, i is no jus he ex bu also he ma hema ics included in he le e s
ha indica e ha Gauss dedica ed ime o he . Gauss’s public commi men o Ge main is
also shown in he pos humous g an ing o he i le o hono a y doc o by he Uni e si y o
Gö ingen in 1831 due o he p essu e he had o exe , since Gauss’s eques had al eady
been ejec ed in 1830.
Among hose who should no be included as e e ence igu es a e Pie e Simon
Laplace (1749–1827) and his p o égé Siméon Denis Poisson (1781–1840). Laplace o ganized
a compe i ion on he ma hema ical heo y o elas ic su aces, hinking ha he p ize could
go o Poisson, whom he also included on he ju y (in his case, he e we e no only no
obs acles bu also “gi s”). A e h ee anonymous a emp s by Ge main and some une hical
maneu e s by Poisson, he Ex ao dina y P ize o Ma hema ical Sciences o he Pa is
Academy o Sciences wen o Ge main. Poisson, who we emembe was also on he ju y,
was p esen ed wi h he p ize wi h he equa ion p e iously in oduced by Ge main bu
using alse ma hema ical simpli ica ions. Poisson publicly igno ed Ge main and was also
unwilling o discuss ma hema ics wi h he . Poisson’s esponse o a le e om Ge main, in
which she asked o his opinion on a se ies o ma hema ical easonings, consis ed simply
o sending he his epo , which symbolizes his con emp o Ge main.
2.1.4. Ma hema icians om he Uni e si y o Gö ingen
The Uni e si y o Gö ingen has been men ioned p e iously. One o i s p o esso s, he
dis inguished ma hema ician Felix Klein (1849–1925), could be conside ed he a che ype o
an ally, as he was one o he main ad oca es o women being able o s udy ma hema ics.
This ole as an ally was ans e ed o many o his s uden s, who became he i s male
ma hema icians o supe ise doc o al heses by emale ma hema icians a hei espec i e
uni e si ies [
56
]. A Gö ingen, women we e able o a end he classes o Klein and o he
ecognized ma hema icians, such as Da id Hilbe (1862–1943), Ca l Runge (1856–1927),
and He mann Minkowski (1864–1909) [
57
]. Klein changed his usual class g ee ing om
“Gen lemen!” o “Lis ene s!” o be mo e inclusi e, and i he e e go con used, he would
ec i y i wi h a smile [58] (p. 192).
Le us e iew some o he ac ions ca ied ou by Klein in a o o women in ma h-
ema ics. In 1891, he Ku a o o he Uni e si y o Gö ingen denied he eques o wo
emale ma hema icians o a end Klein’s classes. To ge a ound his e usal, in 1893, a
he eques o Ma y F ances Wins on (1869–1959) h ough he eache s Hein ich Maschke
(1853–1908) and Oska Bolza (1857–1942), Klein a oided he Ku a o and communica ed on
se e al occasions wi h he P ussian Minis e o Educa ion, who was mo e open o women
s udying. The minis e app o ed he applica ions (in six days) o ma hema ician G ace
Chisholm Wins on (1868–1944) and physicis Ma ga e Eliza Mal by (1860–1944). A e
ha , he Ku a o esigned. In la e yea s, Klein again asked he minis e o pe mission
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 9 o 21
o o he emale ma hema icians, such as Annie Louise MacKinnon (1868–1940) and Isabel
Maddison (1869–1950). In 1895, he e we e nine emale ma hema icians a Gö ingen, who
o med wha could be conside ed he i s “associa ion” o emale ma hema icians.
Da id Hilbe a i ed a Gö ingen in 1895 and was also a de ende o women’s
igh s o s udy. He supe ised he doc o al heses o six emale ma hema icians, h ee o
whom came om he Bes uzhe Cou ses in Sain Pe e sbu g, he main ins i u ion o highe
educa ion o women in Russia and whose eache s included he amous chemis Dmi i
Mendelee (1834–1907), who abandoned his posi ion a he uni e si y in de ense o he
s uden s. One o hem was Ve a Lebede a (1880–1970), who was able o become a p o esso
a he Uni e si y o Ia
s
,
i in Romania, a he same ime as he husband, he ma hema ician
Alexande Mylle (1879–1965), which would no ha e been possible elsewhe e a ha ime.
Klein a gued in Pa liamen and o he ins i u ions ha women we e jus as capable as
men and highligh ed he obs acles hey aced. In 1908, P ussia enac ed new laws allowing
he o icial en ollmen o women in uni e si ies and he es ablishmen o new seconda y
schools o gi ls. The educa ional e o m, known as he Klein Re o m, led o an inc ease
in emale s uden s and he opening o p o essional oppo uni ies o women: hus, one
o Klein’s daugh e s was p incipal o a seconda y school o gi ls eaching ma hema ics
and physics, while ano he daugh e o Runge was an indus ial ma hema ician a OSRAM
and Tele unke.
Howe e , laws con inued o exclude women om uni e si y eaching posi ions in
P ussia un il 1920. In 1915, he illus ious ma hema ician Emmy Noe he (1882–1935)
was endo sed in he Habili a ion, a equi emen o eaching, by Hilbe , Klein, Runge,
and Cons an in Ca a héodo y (1873–1950), among o he s [
59
,
60
]. Hilbe was especially
in ol ed, a guing o hose who opposed ha “I do no see ha he sex o he candida e
is an a gumen agains he admission. We a e a uni e si y, no a ba hhouse” [
61
] (p. 126).
Howe e , i was no un il 1919 ha Noe he ob ained he Habili a ion, a e Klein con ac ed
he Minis e o Cul u e again. Ne e heless, Noe he ’s posi ions a he uni e si y we e
e y p eca ious, and she was ne e able o ob ain a p o esso ship in P ussia. In 1923, he
amous ma hema ician Richa d Cou an (1888–1972) managed, h ough adminis a i e
sub e uge, o pay Noe he , e en i modes ly. In 1930, he enowned ma hema ician
He mann Weyl
(1885–1955)
ied o imp o e Noe he ’s employmen si ua ion h ough he
Minis y, wi hou success.
Many sexis commen s ha e been p ese ed in ela ion o Noe he , abou he physique
o clo hing, which is no he case wi h male scien is s. Fo example, Edwa d James McShane
(1904–1989) made he ollowing sexis ema k o Albe Tucke (1905–1995): “You know
how you can ell a penguin om Emmy Noe he ? A penguin doesn’ ha e a b ie case” [
62
]
(PMC6-8). Tucke ound such a “desc ip ion” o Noe he i ing [
62
]. Allies mus in e ene
in hese kinds o si ua ions.
2.1.5. O he Ma hema icians as Allies
Ano he amous ma hema ician who suppo ed emale ma hema icians wi h his co -
dial ea men was He mann Schwa z (1843–1921). In 1872, a Eidgenössische Technis-
che Hochschule Zü ich, Schwa z had he ma hema ician Eliza e a Fedo o na Li ino a
(1845–1919)
as a s uden (she was he only woman a he ins i u ion). Schwa z u o ed
he in some cases a his house, and he also in i ed he o ha e ea o spend an e ening
wi h his
amily [63]
. Li ino a’s doc o al hesis was supe ised in 1879 by ano he amous
ma hema ician, Ludwig Schlä li (1814–1895). La e , Schwa z had he illus ious Hilda
Hudson (1881–1965) as a s uden a he Uni e si y o Be lin. Hudson was he i s emale
ma hema ician o pa icipa e (Lau a Pisa i had p e iously been in i ed, bu agically died
in 1908, be o e he cong ess) in an In e na ional Cong ess o Ma hema icians (ICM) in 1912.
She ea ned he O de o he B i ish Empi e [64].
Examples o an i-disc imina o y ac ions by a ious male ma hema icians o scien-
is s/ echnologis s in de ense o women o some emale ma hema ician a e summa ized
as ollows. (a) The eminen John S ua Mill (1806–1873) asked he memo able ma he-
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 16 o 21
addi ion, o al e na i ely, hey need eache s, iends, colleagues o pa ne s who
suppo hem as equals. In o he wo ds, women need o be admi ed in o ha
selec ci cle ha he ounde s o he Royal Socie y called he “in isible college”.
...I you a e no accep ed in o ha college o ne wo k—which is always pe sonal,
ins i u ional, and poli ical a he same ime—i is impossible o make science
and/o ha e a place in i s his o y.
As Go oni sugges ed, o suppo equal oppo uni ies in science and ma hema ics, we
ha e o begin by s eng hening he image o science as cul u e and, secondly, “ o wo k
much mo e on boys and men han on gi ls and women” [
115
] (p. 311). And his is wha
we in ended in his wo k, o e ie e posi i e e e ences ha we can show o ou s uden s,
among which we could also include physicis s Tomas B age [
116
], p o esso o physics
and expe in gende equi y and equal oppo uni ies, and Paolo Gio dano, he au ho o
Tasmania [117], a no el whe e sexism in physics is also discussed.
3. Conclusions
Th oughou his pape , he impo ance o suppo and denuncia ion om he g oup
wi h powe , he p i ileged g oup, in his case, whi e he e osexual men [
118
], in elimina ing
obs acles o emale physicis s and ma hema icians was demons a ed. Likewise, he
signi icance o co- esponsibili y was e ealed, om which we a e s ill a away oday
wi hin he academic wo ld [
10
]. Examples o male allies we e also shown, including no able
physicis s and ma hema icians who can be used in classes as coun e -s e eo ypical gende
ole models, ha is, wi h gende -incong uen oles, in o de o b eak down s e eo ypes and
p omo e non- adi ional beha io s [
119
], especially in men in STEM subjec s. Howe e , i
is ad isable o ha e models o close allies, especially among eaching s a .
Un o una ely, gende s e eo ypes a e s ill in o ce in science and a e ansmi ed e en
in p ima y ma hema ics ex books [
120
]. To change his si ua ion, he in ol emen o he
scien i ic communi y is necessa y, especially hose who hold powe and he e o e ha e a
mo e in luen ial oice and g ea e s eng h o oppose disc imina ion [
26
]. Fu he mo e,
he messenge is key, as he e a e men who a e no willing o lis en o he message o
gende equali y i i comes om women bu who a e willing o lis en o i i ano he man
is he messenge [
121
]. The e o e, i is impo an o p omo e spaces and mee ings whe e
con e sa ions can be held abou he inequali y p esen in he scien i ic communi y, bo h
o gene a e empa hy and inc ease awa eness and o lea n abou he successes o o he
de ende s o equali y [
122
]. These mee ings would also se e o keep allies engaged, since
hey mus belie e ha hei e o s a e impo an [
123
], which is why in some uni e si ies,
he e a e p og ams such as Ad oca es and Allies a No h Dako a S a e Uni e si y [
124
].
No e ha becoming an ally is a li elong p ocess, wi h i e a i e cycles o unde s andings
and ac ion [
125
]. We also wan o highligh ha he pe cep ions be ween men and women
on he suppo needed o achie e equali y a e di e en ; men belie e ha hey a e g ea
allies in he wo kplace, while women disag ee [
126
]. Consequen ly, as indica ed by he
Associa ion o Women in Science, i is ad isable o a good ally o lis en o women [
127
].
Mo e ecommenda ions o men a e a ailable in [
128
,
129
], which highligh he impo ance
o he ac i e pa icipa ion o (cis-whi e) men as allies in changing he cu en cul u e, in
bo h day- o-day se ings and he big pic u e. Some ac s o allyship commen ed in his
pape we e suppo i e o many women, bu o he s we e suppo i e o jus one woman,
who pe haps was seen as an “excep ion” o gene alized s e eo ypes. The e o e, we mus
be cau ious so ha male s uden s do no hink ha indi idualized ac ions a e enough, o
ha hey a e doing enough by helping he women in hei immedia e o bi , a he han
ocusing on ins i u ional change.
Al hough we ocused on uni e si ies, ou con ibu ion can also be implemen ed in
high schools. No e ha using he his o y o science p o ides a iche con ex o lea n no
only science bu also he in e ac ions be ween socie y and science and scien is s [130].
Rega ding how o inco po a e his o ical igu es oge he wi h ac ual and close ole
models in ma hema ics and physics, di e en ways can be conside ed. Fo example, we
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 17 o 21
can in oduce he biog aphy o he igu e who is an expe in each ield be o e wo king in
ha ield, as p oposed by Figuei as e al.
[58]
, o use Wikipedia asks [
131
]. Mo e p oposals
a e explained by Epi anio e al.
[132]
, such as using quo es o he igu es a he beginning
o a uni o ini ia e a sho discussion, o include hem in p oblems, o in es iga e di e en
igu es as asks o o use gami ica ion, such as h ough digi al escape ooms [
133
]. Fo
esou ces abou emale ma hema icians and physicis s, you can see [
134
,
135
], espec i ely.
As many male igu es appea in hese disciplines h ough laws, ules, heo ems, esul s,
e c., we hink i is ecommendable o include mo e women and o he mino ized g oups
han male allies o balancing. Ne e heless, including he con ibu ions o women and
o he mino ized g oups oge he wi h male allies should no be an isola ed ac nei he
in e ms o ime (i should no cons i u e he ac ion o a single isola ed day) no as a
unique ac ion, i.e., ou eaching should ake in o accoun di e si y in all ace s, such as
class oom managemen , con en s, e alua ion, e c. The guides o mains eaming gende in
uni e si y eaching in physics [
135
] and ma hema ics [
134
] con ain ecommenda ions on
hose aspec s.
As u u e wo k, he impac o p esen ing hese male allies as e e ences in uni e si y
class ooms could be analyzed. This wo k cons i u ed he i s bu essen ial s ep, which is
he compila ion o allies in physics and ma hema ics since hey a e unknown o he as
majo i y o eache s in hese ields. This was demons a ed by he esul o a su ey ca ied
ou among uni e si y p o esso s in hese ields du ing a aining cou se on eaching wi h
a gende pe spec i e in ma hema ics a Jaume I Uni e si y in Janua y 2024, in which he
pa icipan s we e unable o p o ide any names. I should be no ed ha he compila ion
ca ied ou he e is no exhaus i e, bu i was in ended as a s a ing poin o eco e ing
hidden male allies in hese and o he scien i ic ields.
Au ho Con ibu ions: All au ho s con ibu ed equally o his wo k. All au ho s ha e ead and
ag eed o he published e sion o he manusc ip .
Funding: This esea ch was unded by Uni e si a Jaume I g an numbe TRANSUJI/2023/6.
Ins i u ional Re iew Boa d S a emen : No applicable.
In o med Consen S a emen : No applicable.
Da a A ailabili y S a emen : No new da a we e c ea ed o analyzed in his s udy. Da a sha ing is
no applicable o his a icle.
Con lic s o In e es : The au ho s decla e no con lic s o in e es . The unde s had no ole in he design
o he s udy; in he collec ion, analyses, o in e p e a ion o da a; in he w i ing o he manusc ip ; o
in he decision o publish he esul s.
Re e ences
1.
Eu opean Ins i u e o Gende Equali y. Gende Equali y Index 2023. 2023. A ailable online: h ps://eige.eu opa.eu/gende -
equali y-index/2023 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
2.
Ga cía-Viana, P. ¿Po qué han Aumen ado los Asesina os po Violencia de Géne o en 2023? 2023. A ailable online: h ps:
//www. e.es/no icias/20231123/25n-podcas -asesina os-machis as-muje es/2461614.sh ml (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
3.
Sego ia Saiz, C.; B iones Vozmediano, E.; Ma eos, J.T.; González Ma ía, E.; Gea Sánchez, M. El echo de c is al de las muje es
in es igado as en Ciencias de la Salud en España. Feminismo/s 2023,42, 385–412. [C ossRe ]
4.
De la Cal, M.L.; E xeza e a, A.; ND Galbe e, A.; Ma ínez, E. Es udio B echa Sala ial de Géne o en las Uni e sidades Públicas
Españolas. 2023. A ailable online: h ps://www.obse a o ioigualdadyempleo.es/download/es udio-b echa-sala ial-de-
gene o-en-las-uni e sidades-publicas-espanolas/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
5.
Jabbaz, M.; Sampe -G as, T.; Díaz, C. La b echa sala ial de géne o en las ins i uciones cien í icas. Es udio de caso. Con e g. Re .
Cienc. Soc. 2019,26, 1–27. [C ossRe ]
6.
Paniello-Cas illo, B.; González-Rojo, E.; González-Capella, T.; Ci i , N.R.; Be nal-T i iño, A.; Legido-Quigley, H.; Gea-Sánchez, M.
“Enough is Enough”: Tackling sexism, sexual ha assmen , and powe abuse in Spain’s academia and heal hca e sec o . Lance Reg.
Heal h Eu . 2023,34, 1–3. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
7.
Moss-Racusin, C.A.; Do idio, J.F.; B escoll, V.L.; G aham, M.J.; Handelsman, J. Science acul y’s sub le gende biases a o male
s uden s. P oc. Na l. Acad. Sci. USA 2012,109, 16474–16479. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 18 o 21
8.
Sugimo o, C.R.; La i iè e, V. Equi y o Women in Science: Disman ling Sys emic Ba ie s o Ad ancemen ; Ha a d Uni e si y P ess:
Camb idge, UK, 2023.
9.
Unidad de Muje es y Ciencia. Cien í icas en Ci as 2023. Minis e io de Ciencia e Inno ación, 2023. A ailable online:
h ps://hdl.handle.ne /11162/243043 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
10.
Cabe o, I.; Epi anio, I. A da a science analysis o academic s a wo kload p o iles in Spanish uni e si ies: Gende gap laid ba e.
Educ. Sci. 2021,11, 317. [C ossRe ]
11.
Resa Ocio, A. Igualdad de géne o y o mación inicial del p o eso ado en España: En e la u opía y la ealidad. P o . Re . Cu ic.
Fo m. P o . 2023,27, 255–275. [C ossRe ]
12.
Aguayo, E.; Fe nández-Cendón, M.; Pé ez-T oya, A.; Menéndez, R.; Ceb ián, I.; Cal o, G.; Gay án, S.; Ala cón, M.J. Docencia y
Fo mación con Pe spec i a de Géne o. In Las Polí icas de Igualdad Uni e si a ias: Diagnós ico de los G upos de T abajo; In o me de la
Red de Unidades de Igualdad de Géne o pa a la Excelencia Uni e si a ia, 2022. A ailable online: h ps:// edined.educacion.gob.
es/xmlui/handle/11162/242904 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
13.
Epi anio, I.; Cal o-Iglesias, E. Ac ions o gende equali y in scien i ic- echnical a eas in Spanish uni e si ies. Educ. XX1 2024,27.
[C ossRe ]
14.
González-Cal o, G.; A ias-Ca ballal, M. E ec s om audi cul u e and neolibe alism on uni e si y eaching: An au oe hnog aphic
pe spec i e. E hnog . Educ. 2018,13, 413–427. [C ossRe ]
15.
Ange all, P. The academic ca ee : A s udy o subjec i i y, gende and mo emen among women uni e si y lec u e s. Gend.
Educ. 2018,30, 105–118. [C ossRe ]
16.
Cabe o, I.; Epi anio, I.; Gual-A nau, X. Analysis o A che ypes o De e mine Time Use and Wo kload P o iles o Spanish
Uni e si y P o esso s. Educ. Sci. 2023,13, 295. [C ossRe ]
17.
Cas año, C.; Vázquez-Cupei o, S.; Ma ínez-Can os, J.L. Gende ed managemen in Spanish uni e si ies: Func ional seg ega ion
among ice- ec o s. Gend. Educ. 2019,31, 966–985. [C ossRe ]
18.
Global Educa ion Moni o ing Repo (UNESCO). Gende Repo : Technology on He Te ms, 2024. A ailable online:
h ps://unesdoc.unesco.o g/a k:/48223/p 0000389406 (accessed on 9 May 2024) [C ossRe ]
19.
Aa ik, K.; Collinson, D.L.; Hall, M.; Hea n, J.; Thym, A. The Impac o Men’s Domina ion o AI and Deep ake Technology. 2024.
A ailable online: h ps://www. ou ledge.com/blog/a icle/open-ai-ano he -case-o -men-masculini ies-gende ed-o ganizing
(accessed on 9 May 2024).
20.
Schiebinge , L.; Klinge, I. Gende ed Inno a ions 2: How Inclusi e Analysis Con ibu es o Resea ch and Inno a ion; Publica ions O ice
o he Eu opean Union: Luxembou g, 2020.
21.
Gonsal es, A.J.; Danielsson, A.; Pe e sson, H. Masculini ies and expe imen al p ac ices in physics: The iew om h ee case
s udies. Phys. Re . Phys. Educ. Res. 2016,12, 020120. [C ossRe ]
22.
Ghosh, P. CERN Scien is : ’Physics Buil by Men—No by In i a ion’. 2018. A ailable online: h ps://www.bbc.com/news/
wo ld-eu ope-45703700 (accessed on 9 May 2024).
23.
López Ramos, A.; Ci e, E. Los homb es y la Agenda Feminis a, ¿po qué los homb es se in e esan po la igualdad de géne o? Un
es udio cuali a i o con pe sonas expe as sob e las azones que mo i an al cambio en las masculinidades. Cues . Géne o Igual.
Di e . 2023,18, 275–297. [C ossRe ]
24.
Quiles Bailén, M. Polí icas de o mación e in es igación en géne o en la uni e sidad española: Es udios de masculinidades. In
Masculinidades Iguali a ias y Al e na i as: P ocesos, A ances y Reacciones; Ti an Humanidades: Valencia, Spain, 2019; pp. 299–322.
25.
Alonso Fe nández de A ilés, B. Análisis de la inco po ación de los homb es y las masculinidades en los planes es a égicos de
igualdad en España. Ex Aequo 2021,43, 49–68.
26.
Dancy, M.; Hoda i, A.K. How well-in en ioned whi e male physicis s main ain igno ance o inequi y and jus i y inac ion. In . J.
STEM Educ. 2023,10, 45. [C ossRe ]
27.
Genao, S.; Me cedes, Y. All We Need Is One Mic: A Call o An i- acis Solida i y o Decons uc An i-Black Racism in Educa ional
Leade ship. J. Sch. Leade sh. 2021,31, 127–141. [C ossRe ]
28.
Gómez-F ías, I.; Pascual-Sole , M.; Ga cía-Be bén, A.; F ías-Na a o, D. P o eso ado uni e si a io: Conocimien os y o mación
en pe spec i a de géne o (ODS 4 y ODS5). In P oceedings o he Ac as V Cong eso In e nacional Ciencia, Feminismo y
Masculinidades (CICFEM), Valencia, Spain, 3–4 Ma ch 2023; pp. 56–59.
29.
Sen encia del T ibunal Supe io de Jus icia de la Comuni a Valenciana, 134/2021, de 24 de Feb e o de 2021, de la Sala de lo
Con encioso-Adminis a i o. 2021. A ailable online: h ps://www.pode judicial.es/po al/si e/cgpj/ iewDocumen ?ECLI=
ECLI:ES:TSJCV:2021:66 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
30. bell hooks. The Will o Change: Men, Masculini y, and Lo e; Washing on Squa e P ess: New Yo k, NY, USA, 2004.
31. Bace e, R. Nue os Homb es Buenos; Ediciones Península: Ba celona, Spain, 2017.
32. Jablonka, I. Homb es Jus os. Del Pa ia cado a las Nue as Masculinidades; Anag ama: Ba celona, Spain, 2020.
33.
Mille , K. Why he ‘Mo he o he A omic Bomb’ Ne e Won a Nobel P ize. 2023. A ailable online: h ps://www.ny imes.com/
2023/10/02/science/lise-mei ne - ission-nobel.h ml (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
34.
Pease, B. Rec ea ing men’s ela ionship wi h na u e: Towa d a p o eminis en i onmen alism. Men Masculini ies 2019,22, 113–123.
[C ossRe ]
35.
Domínguez Sales, M.C. Imp on as emeninas en la ciencia de la iloso ía g iega a la alquimia. To e Del Vi ey Re . Es ud. Cul .
2019,25, 8–30.
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 19 o 21
36. Bo o ik, A. “Decoloniza ion” o he Cu icula. Ma h. In ell. 2023,45, 144–149. [C ossRe ]
37.
Alic, M. El legado de Hipa ia: His o ia de las Muje es en la Ciencia Desde la An igüedad Has a Fines del Siglo XIX; Siglo XXI: Mad id,
Spain, 2005.
38. Donald, A. No Jus o he Boys: Why We Need Mo e Women in Science; Ox o d Uni e si y P ess: Ox o d, UK, 2023.
39. Oño o, C. Las que Fal aban: Una His o ia del Mundo Di e en e; Tau us: Ba celona, Spain, 2022.
40.
Gonsal es, A.J.; Danielsson, A.T.; A aamidou, L.; Nys öm, A.S.; Esqui el, R. Using s o y-based me hodologies o explo e
physics iden i ies: How do momen s add up o a li e in physics? Phys. Re . Phys. Educ. Res. 2023,19, 020106. [C ossRe ]
41.
Johansson, A.; Nys öm, A.S.; Gonsal es, A.J.; Danielsson, A.T. Pe o ming legi ima e choice na a i es in physics: Possibili ies
o unde - ep esen ed physics s uden s. Cul . S ud. Sci. Educ. 2023,18, 1255–1283. [C ossRe ]
42.
Ba es Spezza, S.; Va elas, M.; Ashley, M.V.; Ba is a, D. “ I’ e el ou o place some imes in STEM bu my cul u al oo s say
o he wise:” La ina college s uden s’ iden i y conund ums and oppo uni ies in a science esea ch in e nship. Cul . S ud. Sci.
Educ. 2023,18, 1223–1253. [C ossRe ]
43. Sukhe a, J. Na a i e e iews: Flexible, igo ous, and p ac ical. J. G ad. Med Educ. 2022,14, 414–417. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
44.
Lo enzo-A ibas, A.; Cachei o, P. Flo ence Nigh ingale’s ne wo k: Women, powe , and scien i ic collabo a ion. Signi icance 2020,
17, 22–25. [C ossRe ]
45. Small, H. Flo ence Nigh ingale: A enging Angel; Cons able and Co.: London, UK, 1998.
46.
Lo ena , J. “Ac ual accomplishmen s in his wo ld”: The o he s uden s o Cha lo e Angas Sco . Ma h. In ell. 2020,42, 56–65.
[C ossRe ]
47.
Kennedy-Sha e , L. Teaching he Di icul Pas o S a is ics o Imp o e he Fu u e. J. S a . Da a Sci. Educ. 2024,32, 108–119.
[C ossRe ]
48. Saini, A. In e io : The T ue Powe o Women and he Science ha Shows I ; Fou h Es a e: London, UK, 2018.
49.
Faudue , S. Émile Bo el 1871–1956: L’espace e le emps d’une ie su deux siècles. Re . Pou L’his oi e CNRS 2000,3, 1–3. [C ossRe ]
50.
López Pellice , M. Lau en Schwa z (1915–2002). Resumen de su ida y ob a ma emá ica. Re . Real Acad. Cienc. Exac as FÍsicas
Na . 2018,109, 51–60.
51.
Paumie , A.S. Lau en Schwa z (1915–2002) e la ie Collec i e des Ma héma iques. Ph.D. Thesis, Uni e si é Pie e e Ma ie
Cu ie-Pa is VI, Pa is, F ance, 2014.
52. Lingue i, S. Un Ma ema ico un Po’speciale: Vi o Vol e a e le sue Allie e; Pend agon: Bologna, Spain, 2010.
53. Mole o, M.; Sal ado , A. Sonia Ko ale skaya; O o: Mad id, UK, 2002.
54.
Mole o, M.; Sal ado , A. Sophie Ge main (1776–1831). 2017. A ailable online: h ps://muje esconciencia.com/2017/09/19
/sophie-ge main-1776-1831/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
55.
Bolí a , J. Cien í icas: La Apasionan e His o ia de las Muje es De ás de los G andes Descub imien os de la Ciencia; Guadalmazán: Có doba,
Spain, 2022.
56.
Tobies, R. In e na ionalism and Women Ma hema icians a he Uni e si y o Gö ingen. In The Palg a e Handbook o Women and
Science Since 1660; Sp inge In e na ional Publishing: Cham, Swi ze land, 2022; pp. 223–243.
57.
Tobies, R. In e na ionali y: Women in Felix Klein’s Cou ses a he Uni e si y o Gö ingen (1893–1920). In Agains All Odds:
Women’s Ways o Ma hema ical Resea ch Since 1800; Sp inge In e na ional Publishing: Cham, Swi ze land, 2020; pp. 9–38.
58. Figuei as, L.; Mole o, M.; Sal ado , A.; Zuas i, N. Géne o y Ma emá icas; Sín esis: Mad id, Spain, 1998.
59.
Tollmien, C. “Sind wi doch de Meinung, dass ein weibliche Kop nu ganz ausnahmsweise in de Ma hema ik schöp e isch
ä ig sein kann” Emmy Noe he 1882–1935. Gö inge Jah b. 1990,38, 153–219. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
60.
Ih inge , F. Emmy Noe he ’s Habili a ion. 2019. A ailable online: h p://ma h.ih inge .o g/da a/noe he _ 05.pd (accessed on
2 Ma ch 2024).
61. Blanco Lase na, D. Emmy Noe he : Una Ma emá ica Ideal; Ni ola: Mad id, Spain, 2011.
62.
P incen on Uni e si y. Depa men o Ma hema ics O al His o y P ojec Reco ds. Leon W. Cohen (wi h Albe Tucke ). 2023.
A ailable online: h ps://web.ma h.p ince on.edu/o al-his o y/c6.pd (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
63.
Macho, M. Eliza e a Fedo o na Li ino a, la Ma emá ica Rusa que Desobedeció un Dec e o del za pa a Es udia . 2021. A ailable
online: h ps://muje esconciencia.com/2021/08/05/eliza e a- edo o na-li ino a-la-ma ema ica- usa-que-desobedecio-un-
dec e o-del-za / (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
64.
Royle, T. The impac o he women o he Technical Sec ion o he Admi al y Ai Depa men on he s uc u al in eg i y o ai c a
du ing Wo ld Wa One. His . Ma h. 2017,44, 342–366. [C ossRe ]
65. S enhouse, B. Mis e Ma y Some ille: Husband and sec e a y. Ma h. In ell. 2021,43, 7–18. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
66. an Del , D. Paul Eh en es ’s inal yea s. Phys. Today 2014,67, 41–47. [C ossRe ]
67.
Eden, A.; I zik, G. Ge man ma hema icians in exile in Tu key: Richa d on Mises, William P age , Hilda Gei inge , and hei
impac on Tu kish ma hema ics. His . Ma h. 2012,39, 432–459. [C ossRe ]
68.
Macho, M. Josiane Se e, la Química que Ayudó a sus Alumnas a P og esa en el Mundo Académico. 2023. A ailable
online: h ps://muje esconciencia.com/2023/12/21/josiane-se e-la-quimica-que-ayudo-a-sus-alumnas-a-p og esa -en-el-
mundo-academico/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
69.
Uni e sidad Ca los III de Mad id. Consejo de Gobie no. Medidas de Apoyo a la In es igación pa a la Igualdad E ec i a En e
Muje es y Homb es en la Uni e sidad Ca los III de Mad id, Ap obadas po el Consejo de Gobie no en Sesión de 12 de Julio de
2007. 2007. A ailable online: h ps://e-a chi o.uc3m.es/handle/10016/15460 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 20 o 21
70.
Ga cía, L. El Minis o Ped o Duque Cancela su Pa icipación en unas Jo nadas de la UIMP po la Desp opo ción de sus Ponen es:
17 Homb es F en e a dos Muje es. 2020. A ailable online: h ps://www.eldia io.es/can ab ia/ul imas-no icias/minis o-ped o-
duque-cancela-pa icipacion-jo nadas-uimp-desp opo cion-ponen es-homb es_1_6441175.h ml (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
71.
Pa k, A. NIH Di ec o F ancis Collins Has a Plan o Help Elimina e “Manels”. 2019. A ailable online: h ps:// ime.com/561114
2/manels-nih-di ec o - ancis-collins/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
72.
Pe kel, J. Jus Say “No” o Manels. The e’s an App o Tha . 2020. A ailable online: h ps://www.na u e.com/na u e-index/
news/say-no- o-manels-all-male-panels- esea ch-science-con e ence (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
73.
By ne, D. Science Di e si ied: The Men Who Say No o Manels. 2021. A ailable online: h ps://www.na u e.com/a icles/d415
86-021-00165-1 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
74.
Do ce, C. His o y o ma hema ics (and ma hema ics) wi h gende pe spec i e: Towa ds a social his o y o ma hema ics. In . J.
Ma h. Educ. Sci. Technol. 2023, 1–19. [C ossRe ]
75.
González Fe nández, N. Gende Pe spec i e in he Subjec s o he Chemis y Deg ee o he Uni e si y o Ba celona: Con ibu ion
o Women o he Cu iculum o he Deg ee. Bachelo ’s Thesis, Uni e si y o Ba celona, Ba celona, Spain, 2021. A ailable online:
h p://hdl.handle.ne /2445/179519 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
76. Roqué, X. Relee a Cu ie. In Ma ie Cu ie. Esc i os Biog á icos; Edicions UAB: Bella e a, Spain, 2022; pp. 9–33.
77. Mon e o, R. La Ridícula Idea de no Vol e a Ve e; Seix-Ba al: Ba celona, Spain, 2013.
78. Muñoz Páez, A. Ma ie Cu ie; Deba e: Mad id, Spain, 2020.
79.
Goldsmi h, B. Ma ie Cu ie. Genio Obsesi o: La P ime a Muje en Recibi el P emio Nobel y la única que lo Recibió dos Veces; An oni
Bosch edi o : Ba celona, Spain, 2022.
80. Me le-Bé al, H. 17 Muje es P emios Nobel de Ciencia; Pla a o ma: Ba celona, Spain, 2018.
81.
Ren e zi, M. Gende , poli ics, and adioac i i y esea ch in in e wa Vienna: The case o he Ins i u e o Radium Resea ch. Isis
2004,95, 359–393. [C ossRe ]
82.
Ren e zi, M. T a icking Ma e ials and Gende ed Expe imen al P ac ices: Radium Resea ch in Ea ly 20 h Cen u y Vienna; Columbia
Uni e si y P ess: New Yo k, NY, USA, 2008.
83.
Espma k, K.; No dlund, C. Ma ied o Science, Di o ced o Lo e: Success and Failu e in he Collabo a ion Be ween As id
Cle e and Hans on Eule -Chelpin. In Fo Be e o Fo Wo se? Collabo a i e Couples in he Sciences; Sp inge : Basel, Swi ze land,
2022; pp. 81–102.
84. F iedman, R.M. P oyec o Mei ne . Una His o ia de Ciencia y T aición; Alga Edi o ial: Alzi a, Spain, 2021.
85. Al schule , D.R.; Balles e os, F. Las Muje es de la Luna; Nex Doo Publishe s: Ba celona, Spain, 2016.
86. Mo ón, L. Lise Mei ne , una ísica que nunca pe dió su humanidad. Re . Española F´sica 2018,32, 55–64.
87. Sime, R.L. L Lise Mei ne . In Wissen Mach Geschlech ; Edi ion Open Access: Be lin, Ge many, 2016; pp. 67–70.
88. Sime, R.L. Lise Mei ne : A Li e in Physics; Uni e si y o Cali o nia P ess: Be keley, CA, USA, 1996.
89.
Beikü ne , K.; Reichenbe ge , A. Women and Logic: Wha Can Women’s S udies Con ibu e o he His o y o Fo mal Logic?
T ans e sal In . J. His . Sci. 2019,58, 6–14. [C ossRe ]
90.
Ca nei o de Lima, I.P. Lise Mei ne e a Fissão Nuclea : Caminhos pa a uma Na a i a Feminis a. Ph.D. Thesis, Uni e sidade Fede al
da Bahia, Sal ado , B azil, 2020. A ailable online: h ps:// eposi o io.u ba.b /handle/ i/31996 (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
91.
Li es, M.Á.; Angós, T.N.; Rod iguez, U.P. U ilización didác ica de la his o ia de las ciencias: Muje es en ciencia nuclea . Tecné
Epis em. Didaxis TED 2006,20, 42–61. [C ossRe ]
92. Rayne -Canham, M.F.; Rayne -Canham, G.W. Pionee women in nuclea science. Am. J. Phys. 1990,58, 1036–1043. [C ossRe ]
93.
G eens ein, G. SCIENCE: The Ladies o Obse a o y Hill: Annie Jump Cannon and Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin. Am. Sch. 1993,
62, 437–446.
94. Po olés, C.M. Químicas españolas en la Edad de Pla a. An. Química RSEQ 2011,107, 94.
95. López, A.I.M. Hacia la igualdad de géne o en la his o ia del sis ema pe iódico. An. QuíMica RSEQ 2019,115, 227–234.
96.
Mo ón, L. Ma ia Goeppe -Maye : La belleza de Gö ingen. 2015. A ailable online: h ps://muje esconciencia.com/2015/02/02
/ma ia-goeppe -maye -la-belleza-de-go ingen/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
97.
Focaccia, M. No Jus Boys a Via Panispe na: Women a he Royal Physics Ins i u e in Rome. Phys. Pe spec . 2022,24, 154–177.
[C ossRe ]
98.
D esselhaus, M. A con e sa ion wi h P o . Mild ed D esselhaus: A ca ee in ca bon nanoma e ials. In e iew by Paul S Weiss.
ACS Nano 2009,3, 2434–2440. [PubMed]
99. Na a o, J. Ma ia Goeppe Maye . Re . Española Física 2019,33, 53–61.
100. Maye , J.E.; Maye , M.G. S a is ical Mechanics; John Wiley & Sons: New Yo k, NY, USA, 1940.
101.
B u on, E. The li e and ma e ial cul u e o He ha Ma ks Ay on (1854–1923): Su age e, physicis , ma hema ician and in en o .
Sci. Mus. G oup J. 2018,10, 1–22. [C ossRe ] [PubMed]
102. Ba e , A. Women a Impe ial College; Pas , P esen and Fu u e; Wo ld Scien i ic: London, UK, 2017.
103.
Del Río, U.R. COVID-19 y desigualdades de géne o: Los e ec os de la pandemia sob e las in es igado as y cien í icas. In es ig.
Fem. 2022,13, 3–12. [C ossRe ]
104.
Ha gi ai, M. Why Did He ha Ay on No Become he Fi s Female Fellow o he Royal Socie y? Ma h. In ell. 2023,45, 7. [C ossRe ]
105.
Mason, J. He ha Ay on (1854–1923) and he admission o women o he Royal Socie y o London. No es Rec. R. Soc. Lond. 1991,
45, 201–220.
Educ. Sci. 2024,14, 535 21 o 21
106.
Huggins, W.; Huggins, M.L. An A las o Rep esen a i e S ella Spec a om Lambda 4870 o Lambda 3300: Toge he wi h a Discussion o
he E olu ional O de o he S a s, and he In e p e a ion o Thei Spec a. P eceded by a Sho His o y o he Obse a o y and I s Wo k;
Wesley: London, UK, 1899.
107. Schiebinge , L. Has Feminism Changed Science? Ha a d Uni e si y P ess: Camb idge, UK, 1999.
108.
Sobel, D. The Glass Uni e se: How he Ladies o he Ha a d Obse a o y Took he Measu e o he S a s; Penguin: New Yo k, NY, USA, 2017.
109. Rubin, V.C. An in e es ing oyage. Annu. Re . As on. As ophys. 2011,49, 1–28. [C ossRe ]
110.
Gil Casano a, S. Ve a Rubin, la as ónoma que nos hizo eplan ea nos de qué es á hecho el uni e so. Re . Española Física 2019,
33, 49–55.
111. Mi on, J.; Mi on, S. Ve a Rubin: Una ida; Shackle on Books: Ba celona, Spain, 2022.
112.
Kelle , E.F. The anomaly o a woman in physics. In Women, Science, and Technology: A Reade in Feminis Science S udies; Rou ledge:
New Yo k, NY, USA, 2001; pp. 9–16.
113. Pé ez Sedeño, E. El sexo de las me á o as. A bo 2011,187, 99–108. [C ossRe ]
114.
Es adé, S. Muje es en ísica: Iden idad p o esional y pe sis encia de la anomalía. Cues . Géne o Igual. Di e . 2022,17, 183–191. [C ossRe ]
115.
Go oni, P. Hea say, No -So-Big Da a and Choice: Unde s anding Science and Ma hs Th ough he Li es o Men Who Suppo ed
Women. In Agains All Odds: Women’s Ways o Ma hema ical Resea ch Since 1800; Sp inge : Cham, Swi ze land, 2020; pp. 281–314.
116. B age, T. Wha Does Gende Ha e o Do wi h Physics? Op . Pho onics News 2019,30, 18–20.
117. Gio dano, P. Tasmania; Tusque s: Ba celona, Spain, 2023.
118.
Cech, E.A. The in e sec ional p i ilege o whi e able-bodied he e osexual men in STEM. Sci. Ad . 2022,8, eabo1558. [C ossRe ]
[PubMed]
119.
González-Pé ez, S.; Ma eos de Cabo, R.; Sáinz, M. Gi ls in STEM: Is i a emale ole-model hing? F on . Psychol. 2020,11, 2204.
[C ossRe ] [PubMed]
120.
Guicho -Reina, V.; De la To e-Sie a, A. The Rep esen a ion o Gende S e eo ypes in Spanish Ma hema ics Tex books o
Elemen a y Educa ion. Sex. Cul . 2023,27, 1481–1503. [C ossRe ]
121.
Williams, T.; Tes a, P.F.; B i zman, K.; Hibbing, M.V. Messenge s Ma e : Why Ad ancing Gende Equi y Requi es Male Allies.
PS Poli ical Sci. Poli ics 2021,54, 512–513. [C ossRe ]
122.
DuBow, W.M.; Ashc a , C. Male allies: Mo i a ions and ba ie s o pa icipa ing in di e si y ini ia i es in he echnology
wo kplace. In . J. Gende Sci. Technol. 2016,8, 160–180.
123.
Nash, M.; G an , R.; Moo e, R.; Winzenbe g, T. Male allyship in ins i u ional STEMM gende equi y ini ia i es. PLoS ONE 2021,
16, e0248373. [C ossRe ]
124.
McGeo ge, C.R.; Bilen-G een, C. Engaging men as allies o gende equi y in highe educa ion: An explo a ion o an Ad oca es
and Allies P og am. J. Women Mino . Sci. Eng. 2021,27, 25–59. [C ossRe ]
125.
Suyemo o, K.L.; Hochman, A.L. “Taking he empa hy o an ac i is s a e”: Ally de elopmen as con inuous cycles o c i ical
unde s anding and ac ion. Res. Hum. De . 2021,18, 105–148. [C ossRe ]
126.
Wa en, M.A. Men Think They A e S ong Wo kplace Allies. Women Disag ee. 2023. A ailable online: h ps://www.
scien i icame ican.com/a icle/men- hink- hey-a e-s ong-wo kplace-allies-women-disag ee/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
127.
Russell, A. A en ion Men: How o Become an Ally o Women’s Righ s. 2018. A ailable online: h ps://awis.o g/a en ion-men-
ally/ (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
128.
Flood, M. Men’s Posi i e Roles as Allies o Gende Equi y in Science. 2024. A ailable online: h ps://comunicacioncien i ica.
ecy .es/ac ualidad/mens-posi i e- oles-allies-gende -equi y-science (accessed on 2 Ma ch 2024).
129. Feldman, H.A. Being an ally. AIP Con . P oc. 2023,3040, 060011.
130.
Klop e , L.E.; Aikenhead, G.S. Humanis ic science educa ion: The his o y o science and o he ele an con ex s. Sci. Educ. 2022,
106, 490–504. [C ossRe ]
131.
Cal o-Iglesias, E. P epa ing biog aphies o STEM women in he Wikipedia o ma , a eaching expe ience. IEEE Re . Ibe oam.
Tecnol. Del Ap endiz. 2020,15, 211–214.
132.
Epi anio, I.; Fe ando, L.; Ma ínez-Ga cía, M. Mains eaming gende in ma hema ics uni e si y eaching and an assessmen
om s uden s and eache s. In P oceedings o he 2021 XI In e na ional Con e ence on Vi ual Campus (JICV), Salamanca, Spain,
30 Sep embe –1 Oc obe 2021; pp. 1–4. [C ossRe ]
133.
Fe ando, L.; Epi anio, I. Visibilización de muje es ma emá icas median e una escape oom i ual. In En o nos Vi uales Pa a la
Educación en Tiempos de Pandemia: Pe spec i as Me odológicas; Dykinson: Mad id, Spain, 2021; pp. 559–579.
134.
Epi anio, I. Guides o Mains eaming Gende in Uni e si y Teaching. Ma hema ics; Xa xa Vi es d’Uni e si a s: Cas elló de la Plana,
Spain, 2022. A ailable online: h p://hdl.handle.ne /10234/190009 (accessed on 9 May 2024).
135.
Cal o-Iglesias, E. Guides o Mains eaming Gende in Uni e si y Teaching. Physics; Xa xa Vi es d’Uni e si a s: Cas elló de la Plana,
Spain, 2021. A ailable online: h ps://www. i es.o g/book/guide-o -physics- o-mains eaming-gende -in-uni e si y- eaching/
(accessed on 9 May 2024).
Disclaime /Publishe ’s No e: The s a emen s, opinions and da a con ained in all publica ions a e solely hose o he indi idual
au ho (s) and con ibu o (s) and no o MDPI and/o he edi o (s). MDPI and/o he edi o (s) disclaim esponsibili y o any inju y o
people o p ope y esul ing om any ideas, me hods, ins uc ions o p oduc s e e ed o in he con en .